1 00:00:06,273 --> 00:00:08,575 >> GOOD MORNING. 2 00:00:08,575 --> 00:00:15,716 THIS PRESENTATION IS BEING 3 00:00:15,716 --> 00:00:21,922 RECORDED. 4 00:00:21,922 --> 00:00:24,091 USE Q&A TO DIRECT QUESTIONS TO 5 00:00:24,091 --> 00:00:25,626 SPEAKERS INCLUDING THE NAME OF 6 00:00:25,626 --> 00:00:26,493 PERSON YOU'RE DIRECTING YOUR 7 00:00:26,493 --> 00:00:27,060 QUESTION TO. 8 00:00:27,060 --> 00:00:29,029 THIS TOOL CAN BE USED DURING THE 9 00:00:29,029 --> 00:00:30,330 SESSION Q&As TO ASK THE 10 00:00:30,330 --> 00:00:31,331 SPEAKERS A QUESTION. 11 00:00:31,331 --> 00:00:33,300 QUESTIONS WILL BE CAPTURED FOR 12 00:00:33,300 --> 00:00:36,370 REVIEW BY THE WORKSHOP SPONSORS. 13 00:00:36,370 --> 00:00:38,038 IF YOU'RE NOT SPEAKING STAY OFF 14 00:00:38,038 --> 00:00:39,773 MUTE AND OFF CAMERA. 15 00:00:39,773 --> 00:00:48,215 THANK YOU. 16 00:00:48,215 --> 00:00:56,790 17 00:00:56,790 --> 00:01:00,160 18 00:01:00,160 --> 00:01:01,528 >> GOOD MORNING, AFTERNOON, OR 19 00:01:01,528 --> 00:01:02,796 EVENING, DEPENDING WHERE IN THE 20 00:01:02,796 --> 00:01:05,732 WORLD YOU'RE JOINING FROM. 21 00:01:05,732 --> 00:01:06,967 I'M DR. FERNANDO BRUNO, PROGRAM 22 00:01:06,967 --> 00:01:10,003 OFFICER AT THE CENTER FOR 23 00:01:10,003 --> 00:01:14,508 TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH AND 24 00:01:14,508 --> 00:01:15,609 IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE CTRIS. 25 00:01:15,609 --> 00:01:19,513 IT'S MY PLEASURE TO WELCOME YOU 26 00:01:19,513 --> 00:01:20,414 TO OUR VIRTUAL WORKSHOP 27 00:01:20,414 --> 00:01:22,115 IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH AND NEXT 28 00:01:22,115 --> 00:01:30,390 STEPS IN DIRECT TO CONSUMER 29 00:01:30,390 --> 00:01:30,691 TELEHEALTH. 30 00:01:30,691 --> 00:01:33,961 UNDERSTANDINGLESSONS LEARNED. 31 00:01:33,961 --> 00:01:37,831 THE HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONALS 32 00:01:37,831 --> 00:01:41,001 WERE USING E-MAILS, EARLY 33 00:01:41,001 --> 00:01:46,039 VERSIONS OF VIDEO CONFERRING TO 34 00:01:46,039 --> 00:01:47,341 CONNECT, THE LAST DECADE 35 00:01:47,341 --> 00:01:48,976 WITNESSED ADVANCES IN TECHNOLOGY 36 00:01:48,976 --> 00:01:52,179 THAT TRANSFORMED TELEHEALTH INTO 37 00:01:52,179 --> 00:01:55,349 AN ESSENTIAL TOOL IN MODERN 38 00:01:55,349 --> 00:01:56,216 HEALTH CARE, UNDENIABLE 39 00:01:56,216 --> 00:01:58,418 HARDSHIPS BROAD BY THE COVID-19 40 00:01:58,418 --> 00:02:01,154 PANDEMIC ACCELERATED THIS 41 00:02:01,154 --> 00:02:01,655 TRANSFORMATION. 42 00:02:01,655 --> 00:02:03,590 WE WERE FORCED TO INNOVATE, 43 00:02:03,590 --> 00:02:06,526 ADAPT, EMBRACE METHODS OF CARE 44 00:02:06,526 --> 00:02:08,095 DELIVERY. 45 00:02:08,095 --> 00:02:09,696 BARRIERS THAT ONCE LIMITED 46 00:02:09,696 --> 00:02:13,100 TELEHEALTH SUCH AS RESTRICTIVE 47 00:02:13,100 --> 00:02:14,167 POLICIES, CROSS--STATE LICENSURE 48 00:02:14,167 --> 00:02:15,369 CHALLENGES WERE TEMPORARILY 49 00:02:15,369 --> 00:02:18,005 LIFTED, IN SOME CASES TORN DOWN 50 00:02:18,005 --> 00:02:23,510 ENTIRELY, PAVING THE WAIT FOR 51 00:02:23,510 --> 00:02:25,912 WIDESPREAD ADOPTION. 52 00:02:25,912 --> 00:02:28,949 VIRTUAL CONSULTATIONS BECAME 53 00:02:28,949 --> 00:02:30,050 COMMONPLACE, REIMBURSEMENT 54 00:02:30,050 --> 00:02:34,855 MODELS EVOLVED AND TECHNOLOGICAL 55 00:02:34,855 --> 00:02:35,255 LITERARIES SURGED. 56 00:02:35,255 --> 00:02:38,725 THIS LAID THE FOUNDATION FOR 57 00:02:38,725 --> 00:02:39,760 LASTING INTEGRATION INTO 58 00:02:39,760 --> 00:02:41,995 HEALTHCARE SYSTEMS WORD WIDE. 59 00:02:41,995 --> 00:02:43,997 HERE WE ARE STANDING ON TOP OF 60 00:02:43,997 --> 00:02:46,066 SHOULDERS OF SUCH LEGACY. 61 00:02:46,066 --> 00:02:49,136 HUMANS HAVE AN INNATE DESIRE TO 62 00:02:49,136 --> 00:02:49,903 CONNECT. 63 00:02:49,903 --> 00:02:51,972 WHEN WE FACED WITH ADVERSITY WE 64 00:02:51,972 --> 00:02:55,809 CREATE NEW WAYS OF DOING THAT. 65 00:02:55,809 --> 00:02:57,911 JUST LIKE THAT, IT WAS NO LONGER 66 00:02:57,911 --> 00:02:58,979 OPTIONAL, IT WAS ESSENTIAL. 67 00:02:58,979 --> 00:03:02,049 TODAY WE LIVE IN A WORLD WHERE 68 00:03:02,049 --> 00:03:07,988 PATIENTS CAN CONNECT WITH HEALTH 69 00:03:07,988 --> 00:03:14,995 HEALTHCARE TEAMS USING DEVICES, 70 00:03:14,995 --> 00:03:18,165 WE TRACK DATA, STEPS, EKGs, 71 00:03:18,165 --> 00:03:24,738 GLUCOSE AND MORE FEEDING REAL 72 00:03:24,738 --> 00:03:26,039 DATA, ENABLING TRANSFORMATIVE 73 00:03:26,039 --> 00:03:32,412 AND GROUNDBREAKING RESEARCH AND 74 00:03:32,412 --> 00:03:33,480 A.I.-DRIVEN INSIGHTS 75 00:03:33,480 --> 00:03:35,549 REVOLUTIONIZING CARE, YET THIS 76 00:03:35,549 --> 00:03:36,883 BRINGS CHALLENGES. 77 00:03:36,883 --> 00:03:37,751 HEALTH POLICIES OFTEN STRUGGLE 78 00:03:37,751 --> 00:03:40,654 TO KEEP PACE WITH THE 79 00:03:40,654 --> 00:03:41,588 TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENTS AND 80 00:03:41,588 --> 00:03:46,226 AT TIMES SO DOES RESEARCH. 81 00:03:46,226 --> 00:03:47,594 RESEARCH MUST ADDRESS 82 00:03:47,594 --> 00:03:48,495 INFRASTRUCTURE GAPS, 83 00:03:48,495 --> 00:03:50,664 PARTICULARLY IN UNDERSERVED AND 84 00:03:50,664 --> 00:03:54,501 RURAL AREAS, TO ENSURE EQUITABLE 85 00:03:54,501 --> 00:03:54,734 ACCESS. 86 00:03:54,734 --> 00:03:56,036 UNDERSTANDING USER BEHAVIOR AND 87 00:03:56,036 --> 00:03:58,004 GIVING VOICE TO ALL STAKEHOLDERS 88 00:03:58,004 --> 00:03:59,306 IS ALSO PARAMOUNT. 89 00:03:59,306 --> 00:04:02,576 WE MUST FOCUS ON IMPROVING 90 00:04:02,576 --> 00:04:07,180 LITERACY OF PATIENTS AND 91 00:04:07,180 --> 00:04:09,049 PROVIDERS, TO ENSURE TOOLS ARE 92 00:04:09,049 --> 00:04:10,851 USED EFFECTIVELY AND NO ONE IS 93 00:04:10,851 --> 00:04:11,218 LEFT BEHIND. 94 00:04:11,218 --> 00:04:17,457 THIS IS WHERE I AM 95 00:04:17,457 --> 00:04:19,326 IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE PLAYS A 96 00:04:19,326 --> 00:04:20,327 CRITICAL CONTROL WHEN WHAT WORKS 97 00:04:20,327 --> 00:04:21,628 AND WHAT WE'RE DOING IN 98 00:04:21,628 --> 00:04:21,995 PRACTICE. 99 00:04:21,995 --> 00:04:24,164 WE NEED RESEARCH AND NEED IT NOW 100 00:04:24,164 --> 00:04:27,534 TO HELP CLOSE THIS GAP, 101 00:04:27,534 --> 00:04:28,602 UNCOVERING LESSONS LEARNED, 102 00:04:28,602 --> 00:04:29,736 TACKLE CHALLENGES AND SEIZE 103 00:04:29,736 --> 00:04:31,605 OPPORTUNITIES TO MAKE TOOLS 104 00:04:31,605 --> 00:04:32,572 ACCESSIBLE TO THOSE WHO NEED 105 00:04:32,572 --> 00:04:34,407 THEM MOST. 106 00:04:34,407 --> 00:04:37,511 THIS WORKSHOP IS A CRITICAL STEP 107 00:04:37,511 --> 00:04:39,679 TOWARDS THIS JOURNEY. 108 00:04:39,679 --> 00:04:41,515 TODAY WE'RE EXPLORING CURRENT 109 00:04:41,515 --> 00:04:45,585 STATE OF DIRECT TO CONSUMER 110 00:04:45,585 --> 00:04:47,454 TELEHEALTH, IDENTIFY KNOWLEDGE 111 00:04:47,454 --> 00:04:48,455 GAPS AND UNCOVER OPPORTUNITIES 112 00:04:48,455 --> 00:04:49,956 TO ADVANCE RESEARCH AND 113 00:04:49,956 --> 00:04:50,657 PRACTICE. 114 00:04:50,657 --> 00:04:55,428 WE'RE FORTUNATE TO HAVE THIS 115 00:04:55,428 --> 00:04:57,097 LINEUP OF SPEAKERS WHO WILL 116 00:04:57,097 --> 00:05:01,034 GUIDE US TO A RICH EXPLORATION 117 00:05:01,034 --> 00:05:02,569 OF TELEHEALTH LANDSCAPE. 118 00:05:02,569 --> 00:05:04,905 AT THE CENTER OF OF TODAY'S 119 00:05:04,905 --> 00:05:07,174 DISCUSSIONS, WE HAVE RESEARCH AS 120 00:05:07,174 --> 00:05:08,275 OUR GUIDING FRAMEWORK, AND AS 121 00:05:08,275 --> 00:05:10,877 THE BEST PART OF TODAY'S 122 00:05:10,877 --> 00:05:12,445 WORKSHOP IS YOU. 123 00:05:12,445 --> 00:05:15,182 THIS WORKSHOP IS A CONVERSATION. 124 00:05:15,182 --> 00:05:17,017 AND THE PERSPECTIVE AND 125 00:05:17,017 --> 00:05:18,451 QUESTIONS ARE KEY FOR ITS 126 00:05:18,451 --> 00:05:18,752 SUCCESS. 127 00:05:18,752 --> 00:05:21,855 SO WE ENCOURAGE YOU TO ENGAGE 128 00:05:21,855 --> 00:05:23,256 FULLY, ASK QUESTIONS, SHARE 129 00:05:23,256 --> 00:05:26,326 INSIGHTS, CONNECT WITH YOUR 130 00:05:26,326 --> 00:05:26,826 PEERS. 131 00:05:26,826 --> 00:05:31,031 YOU ARE A DIVERSE AUDIENCE OF 132 00:05:31,031 --> 00:05:31,665 RESEARCH, HEALTHCARE PROVIDERSE 133 00:05:31,665 --> 00:05:32,799 POLICYMAKERS, TECHNOLOGIST AND 134 00:05:32,799 --> 00:05:33,567 COMMUNITY LEADERS. 135 00:05:33,567 --> 00:05:36,069 ALL UNITED BY THE SHARED 136 00:05:36,069 --> 00:05:37,938 COMMITMENT TO IMPROVING 137 00:05:37,938 --> 00:05:38,805 TELEHEALTH AND HEALTHCARE 138 00:05:38,805 --> 00:05:39,472 DELIVERY. 139 00:05:39,472 --> 00:05:41,875 SO THANK YOU FOR JOINING US AT 140 00:05:41,875 --> 00:05:43,076 THIS IMPORTANT CONVERSATION. 141 00:05:43,076 --> 00:05:46,580 TOGETHER WE CAN CHART A FUTURE 142 00:05:46,580 --> 00:05:51,484 FOR TELEHEALTH AND ITS 143 00:05:51,484 --> 00:05:54,588 TRANSFORMATIVE POE ESSENTIAL. 144 00:05:54,588 --> 00:06:05,031 I'M PLEASED TO INVOLVE THE 145 00:06:05,498 --> 00:06:06,633 DIRECTOR OF CTRIS. 146 00:06:06,633 --> 00:06:07,834 TAKE IT AWAY. 147 00:06:07,834 --> 00:06:12,005 >> GOOD MORNING, GOOD AFTERNOON, 148 00:06:12,005 --> 00:06:14,507 GOOD EVENING, I'M DELIGHTED TO 149 00:06:14,507 --> 00:06:16,042 WORK YOU TO THE WORKSHOP. 150 00:06:16,042 --> 00:06:17,677 IT'S A GREAT PRIVILEGE TO EXTEND 151 00:06:17,677 --> 00:06:20,413 THIS WARM WELCOME TO YOU ON 152 00:06:20,413 --> 00:06:22,716 BEHALF OF OUR LEADERSHIP AND 153 00:06:22,716 --> 00:06:23,149 STAFF. 154 00:06:23,149 --> 00:06:24,251 SPECIAL THANKS TO ORGANIZING 155 00:06:24,251 --> 00:06:25,986 COMMITTEE AND SUPPORT STAFF WHO 156 00:06:25,986 --> 00:06:26,987 MADE THIS POSSIBLE. 157 00:06:26,987 --> 00:06:29,089 I ALSO WANT TO THANK THE MANY 158 00:06:29,089 --> 00:06:31,157 PANELISTS AND EXPERTS WHO WILL 159 00:06:31,157 --> 00:06:32,459 BE SHARING INSIGHTS AND 160 00:06:32,459 --> 00:06:42,535 CHALLENGES AND SUCCESSES OF 161 00:06:42,535 --> 00:06:43,236 SUPPORTING TELEHEALTH-FOCUSED 162 00:06:43,236 --> 00:06:44,404 IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH TO 163 00:06:44,404 --> 00:06:46,806 IMPROVE HEALTHCARE ACCESS AND 164 00:06:46,806 --> 00:06:47,073 OUTCOMES. 165 00:06:47,073 --> 00:06:49,409 IT'S AN HONOR TO SEE SUCH A 166 00:06:49,409 --> 00:06:51,811 DIVERSE AND ESTEEMED GROUP OF 167 00:06:51,811 --> 00:06:52,379 PROFESSIONALS, RESEARCHERS, 168 00:06:52,379 --> 00:06:53,380 PRACTITIONERS AND THE PUBLIC 169 00:06:53,380 --> 00:06:54,581 GATHERED HERE TODAY. 170 00:06:54,581 --> 00:06:57,284 AND THIS BRINGS ME TO THANKING 171 00:06:57,284 --> 00:06:57,951 YOU, ATTENDEES. 172 00:06:57,951 --> 00:07:00,687 WE KNOW YOU'RE VERY BUSY WITH 173 00:07:00,687 --> 00:07:02,322 MULTIPLE COMPETING PRIORITIES, 174 00:07:02,322 --> 00:07:05,925 SO IT DOES MEAN A LOT TO THE 175 00:07:05,925 --> 00:07:07,427 NHLBI AND CTRIS YOU AGREED TO 176 00:07:07,427 --> 00:07:08,228 JOIN US. 177 00:07:08,228 --> 00:07:08,895 THANK YOU. 178 00:07:08,895 --> 00:07:10,997 I'M EXCITED TO LEARN FROM YOU 179 00:07:10,997 --> 00:07:11,831 ALL TODAY. 180 00:07:11,831 --> 00:07:13,099 BEFORE WE JUMP IN TO THE 181 00:07:13,099 --> 00:07:15,068 WORKSHOP I WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT 182 00:07:15,068 --> 00:07:17,871 TO SHARE HOW THE WORKSHOP LINKS 183 00:07:17,871 --> 00:07:24,644 TO THE NHLBI STRATEGIC VISION. 184 00:07:24,644 --> 00:07:26,513 NHLBI TURNED 75 YEARS OLD LAST 185 00:07:26,513 --> 00:07:29,115 YEAR AND ENGAGED PUBLIC AND 186 00:07:29,115 --> 00:07:29,883 STAFF TO REFRESH STRATEGIC 187 00:07:29,883 --> 00:07:30,116 VISION. 188 00:07:30,116 --> 00:07:33,853 THE WAY I SEE IT, TELEHEALTH 189 00:07:33,853 --> 00:07:34,721 PRESENTS AN IMPORTANT VEHICLE 190 00:07:34,721 --> 00:07:36,790 FOR ADVANCING FOUR OF THE SIX 191 00:07:36,790 --> 00:07:38,425 FOCUS AREAS THAT WERE 192 00:07:38,425 --> 00:07:40,293 ARTICULATED THROUGH THIS 193 00:07:40,293 --> 00:07:41,494 STRATEGIC VISION REFRESH 194 00:07:41,494 --> 00:07:42,062 PROCESS. 195 00:07:42,062 --> 00:07:43,363 I'LL NAME THEM BRIEFLY. 196 00:07:43,363 --> 00:07:45,765 HARNESSING DATA SCIENCE AND NEW 197 00:07:45,765 --> 00:07:47,300 TECHNOLOGIES TO DRIVE SCIENTIFIC 198 00:07:47,300 --> 00:07:50,036 DISCOVERY AND PRECISION HEALTH. 199 00:07:50,036 --> 00:07:51,671 USING NOVEL APPROACHES FOR 200 00:07:51,671 --> 00:07:54,274 ADDRESSING HEALTH DISPARITIES 201 00:07:54,274 --> 00:07:56,042 AND TACKLING BIOLOGICAL 202 00:07:56,042 --> 00:07:58,111 UNDERPINNINGS FOR HEART, LUNG, 203 00:07:58,111 --> 00:08:00,613 BLOOD DISORDERS, LEVERAGING 204 00:08:00,613 --> 00:08:06,653 POWER OF COMMUNITY ENGAGING, 205 00:08:06,653 --> 00:08:08,855 REDUCING IMPACT OF GEOGRAPHY ON 206 00:08:08,855 --> 00:08:10,590 HEART, LUNG, BLOOD AND SLEEP 207 00:08:10,590 --> 00:08:12,559 HEALTH. 208 00:08:12,559 --> 00:08:14,627 AS DR. BRUNO INDICATED, 209 00:08:14,627 --> 00:08:15,228 TELEHEALTH HAS MATURED RAPIDLY 210 00:08:15,228 --> 00:08:20,767 OVER THE LAST TWO DECADES FROM A 211 00:08:20,767 --> 00:08:23,636 CONCEPTUAL IDEA TO A CRUCIAL 212 00:08:23,636 --> 00:08:27,140 COMPONENT AND WE WOULD BE REMISS 213 00:08:27,140 --> 00:08:33,913 IF WE DIDN'T ADMIT THE ROLE OF 214 00:08:33,913 --> 00:08:34,781 PROJECT ECHO, ECHO-TRAINED 215 00:08:34,781 --> 00:08:35,648 CLINICIANS PROVED TELEHEALTH 216 00:08:35,648 --> 00:08:37,717 CARE CAN LEAD TO OUTCOMES 217 00:08:37,717 --> 00:08:39,719 COMPARABLE TO CARE DELIVERED IN 218 00:08:39,719 --> 00:08:41,254 ACADEMIC HEALTH CENTERS FOR 219 00:08:41,254 --> 00:08:42,856 PATIENTS WITH HEPATITIS C LIVING 220 00:08:42,856 --> 00:08:44,090 IN RURAL AREAS. 221 00:08:44,090 --> 00:08:48,328 SINCE THEN AS WE HAVE SEEN, THE 222 00:08:48,328 --> 00:08:49,429 PANDEMIC ACCELERATED TELEHEALTH 223 00:08:49,429 --> 00:08:51,197 PROLIFERATION, AS NECESSITY WITH 224 00:08:51,197 --> 00:08:52,732 UTILIZATION RATES REMAINING 225 00:08:52,732 --> 00:08:54,901 HIGHER THAN PRE-PANDEMIC LEVELS. 226 00:08:54,901 --> 00:08:56,336 INDEED TELEHEALTH HAS BECOME 227 00:08:56,336 --> 00:08:58,304 INTEGRAL TO HEALTH CARE, 228 00:08:58,304 --> 00:08:59,506 ADDRESSING NEEDS AND 229 00:08:59,506 --> 00:09:01,374 TRADITIONALLY UNDERSERVED AREAS, 230 00:09:01,374 --> 00:09:02,242 WITH PATIENTS AND POPULATIONS 231 00:09:02,242 --> 00:09:04,210 EXPERIENCING SOCIAL RISK SUCH AS 232 00:09:04,210 --> 00:09:06,279 SOCIAL ISOLATION AS WELL AS 233 00:09:06,279 --> 00:09:08,148 CHILD CARE AND TRANSPORTATION 234 00:09:08,148 --> 00:09:10,884 CHALLENGES, FOR EXAMPLE. 235 00:09:10,884 --> 00:09:13,052 SO, TO OPTIMIZE HEALTH USE AND 236 00:09:13,052 --> 00:09:15,789 INTEGRATION FOR THINGS LIKE 237 00:09:15,789 --> 00:09:18,858 REACH, EQUITY, AFFORDABILITY, 238 00:09:18,858 --> 00:09:22,262 FEASIBILITY, IMPACT AND 239 00:09:22,262 --> 00:09:23,363 SUSTAINABILITY IT REQUIRES 240 00:09:23,363 --> 00:09:24,364 ADDRESSING QUESTIONS OF 241 00:09:24,364 --> 00:09:26,433 IMPLEMENTATION AND USE METHODS 242 00:09:26,433 --> 00:09:30,069 AND MEASURES FROM IMPLEMENTATION 243 00:09:30,069 --> 00:09:30,737 SCIENCE. 244 00:09:30,737 --> 00:09:31,905 INDEED TELEHEALTH RAPID 245 00:09:31,905 --> 00:09:35,442 EXPANSION INTO NEW SETTINGS 246 00:09:35,442 --> 00:09:36,543 NECESSITATED NIMBLE RESEARCH 247 00:09:36,543 --> 00:09:38,044 APPROACHES TO KEEP PACE. 248 00:09:38,044 --> 00:09:38,912 BECAUSE IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH 249 00:09:38,912 --> 00:09:41,981 CAN BE COMBINED WITH 250 00:09:41,981 --> 00:09:42,949 EFFECTIVENESS RESEARCH 251 00:09:42,949 --> 00:09:43,950 APPROACHES, THROUGH HYBRID STUDY 252 00:09:43,950 --> 00:09:46,052 TYPES AS AN EXAMPLE UNIQUE 253 00:09:46,052 --> 00:09:48,755 INSIGHTS CAN BE MADE TO 254 00:09:48,755 --> 00:09:49,289 ACCELERATE TRANSLATION OF 255 00:09:49,289 --> 00:09:54,661 EVIDENCE TO ACTION, AND 256 00:09:54,661 --> 00:09:55,762 OFFERINGS FRAMEWORKS, THOUGHTS 257 00:09:55,762 --> 00:09:57,397 AND TOOLS TO ELUCIDATE WHEN, 258 00:09:57,397 --> 00:10:00,500 WHERE, WHY AND HOW AND WITH WHOM 259 00:10:00,500 --> 00:10:03,303 TO LEVERAGE OR INCORPORATE 260 00:10:03,303 --> 00:10:03,970 TELEHEALTH. 261 00:10:03,970 --> 00:10:05,071 MOREOVER, EFFECTIVE TELEHEALTH 262 00:10:05,071 --> 00:10:06,372 IMPLEMENTATION REQUIRES 263 00:10:06,372 --> 00:10:08,541 INTEGRATION WITH EXISTING 264 00:10:08,541 --> 00:10:09,642 HEALTHCARE POLICIES, PROCESSES, 265 00:10:09,642 --> 00:10:12,512 PRACTICES, AND THIS EMPHASIZES 266 00:10:12,512 --> 00:10:14,113 THE NEED FOR CONTEXT-SPECIFIC 267 00:10:14,113 --> 00:10:15,815 STRATEGIES AND APPROACHES, AND 268 00:10:15,815 --> 00:10:18,318 SUCCESS DEPENDS ON COLLABORATION 269 00:10:18,318 --> 00:10:20,286 ACROSS DIVERSE STAKEHOLDERS 270 00:10:20,286 --> 00:10:21,187 INCLUDING CLINICIANS, 271 00:10:21,187 --> 00:10:23,323 RESEARCHERS, AND PATIENTS, FOR 272 00:10:23,323 --> 00:10:24,123 INSTANCE, PARAMOUNT IN 273 00:10:24,123 --> 00:10:26,993 IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH. 274 00:10:26,993 --> 00:10:32,365 I'LL MENTION ALSO THE MEDICAL 275 00:10:32,365 --> 00:10:35,068 UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CAROLINA 276 00:10:35,068 --> 00:10:37,370 TO AID IN RESEARCH, GUIDANCE 277 00:10:37,370 --> 00:10:40,473 INCLUDES THINGS LIKE REFINING 278 00:10:40,473 --> 00:10:42,509 RESEARCH QUESTIONS, DETERMINING 279 00:10:42,509 --> 00:10:47,347 STUDY DESIGNS, DEFINING 280 00:10:47,347 --> 00:10:48,982 IMPLEMENTATION OUTCOMES, 281 00:10:48,982 --> 00:10:50,283 SELECTING GUIDING FRAMEWORKS, 282 00:10:50,283 --> 00:10:52,452 DEVELOPING DATA COLLECTION TOOLS 283 00:10:52,452 --> 00:10:54,754 THAT THEY MIGHT TAILOR, AND 284 00:10:54,754 --> 00:10:55,788 SELECTING IMPLEMENTATION 285 00:10:55,788 --> 00:10:56,523 STRATEGIES. 286 00:10:56,523 --> 00:10:58,591 THAT'S A RESOURCE AVAILABLE 287 00:10:58,591 --> 00:10:58,825 ONLINE. 288 00:10:58,825 --> 00:11:00,360 EVEN WITH THIS GUIDANCE THERE 289 00:11:00,360 --> 00:11:02,128 ARE SO MANY EMPIRICAL QUESTIONS 290 00:11:02,128 --> 00:11:04,330 THAT REMAIN. 291 00:11:04,330 --> 00:11:07,800 WE SEE VARIABILITY IN ADOPTION 292 00:11:07,800 --> 00:11:09,135 AND RATES ACROSS SETTINGS THAT 293 00:11:09,135 --> 00:11:12,405 POSE CHALLENGES FOR EQUITABLE 294 00:11:12,405 --> 00:11:14,274 ACCESS, EVEN WITH TELEHEALTH, 295 00:11:14,274 --> 00:11:16,643 RESOURCE LIMITATIONS ARE A 296 00:11:16,643 --> 00:11:18,578 DIRECT THREAT TO TELEHEALTH 297 00:11:18,578 --> 00:11:19,479 SPREAD, WHEREBY LIMITED 298 00:11:19,479 --> 00:11:21,781 RESOURCES CONTINUE TO EXIST AND 299 00:11:21,781 --> 00:11:27,820 TELEHEALTH INTEGRATION WITH 300 00:11:27,820 --> 00:11:30,590 EXISTING IN-PERSON WORK FLOWS 301 00:11:30,590 --> 00:11:32,859 REMAIN COMPLICATED, EMPHASIZING 302 00:11:32,859 --> 00:11:34,627 NEED FOR EFFECTIVE CARE 303 00:11:34,627 --> 00:11:35,595 MANAGEMENT STRATEGIES AND 304 00:11:35,595 --> 00:11:36,563 APPROPRIATE PAYMENT MODELS, AND 305 00:11:36,563 --> 00:11:39,198 FUTURE POLICIES WILL BE CRUCIAL 306 00:11:39,198 --> 00:11:40,400 TO SUSTAIN TELEHEALTH, 307 00:11:40,400 --> 00:11:43,036 PARTICULARLY WITH RESPECT TO 308 00:11:43,036 --> 00:11:45,004 AUDIO/VISUAL SERVICES. 309 00:11:45,004 --> 00:11:46,306 SO EVEN WITH THESE CHALLENGES 310 00:11:46,306 --> 00:11:48,841 THE OPPORTUNITIES ARE PROFOUND. 311 00:11:48,841 --> 00:11:50,243 TELEHEALTH SIGNIFICANTLY 312 00:11:50,243 --> 00:11:53,012 ENHANCES ACCESS, ESPECIALLY IN 313 00:11:53,012 --> 00:11:54,981 UNDERSERVED AREAS, RESEARCH CAN 314 00:11:54,981 --> 00:11:56,816 PROVIDE DATA-DRIVEN INSIGHT INTO 315 00:11:56,816 --> 00:11:59,018 OPTIMIZING TELEHEALTH DELIVERY 316 00:11:59,018 --> 00:12:00,787 WITH ONGOING TECHNOLOGICAL 317 00:12:00,787 --> 00:12:01,688 INNOVATIONS OFFERING NEW 318 00:12:01,688 --> 00:12:02,755 POSSIBILITIES AND ARTIFICIAL 319 00:12:02,755 --> 00:12:03,723 INTELLIGENCE AND MACHINE 320 00:12:03,723 --> 00:12:04,591 LEARNING TECHNOLOGIES ARE 321 00:12:04,591 --> 00:12:06,793 EXPECTED TO PLAY AN EVEN LARGER 322 00:12:06,793 --> 00:12:09,729 ROLE, OFFERING NEW SOLUTIONS FOR 323 00:12:09,729 --> 00:12:11,364 PERSONALIZATION AND EFFICIENCY. 324 00:12:11,364 --> 00:12:13,900 SO, AS WE EMBARK ON THIS JOURNEY 325 00:12:13,900 --> 00:12:16,002 TODAY, I ENCOURAGE YOU TO 326 00:12:16,002 --> 00:12:19,272 ACTIVELY PARTICIPATE, SHARE YOUR 327 00:12:19,272 --> 00:12:20,406 EXPERIENCES, AND CHALLENGE 328 00:12:20,406 --> 00:12:20,940 CONVENTIONAL THINKING TO 329 00:12:20,940 --> 00:12:22,342 IDENTIFY GAPS AND OPPORTUNITIES 330 00:12:22,342 --> 00:12:23,443 FOR FUTURE RESEARCH. 331 00:12:23,443 --> 00:12:25,511 LET'S USE THIS PLATFORM TO 332 00:12:25,511 --> 00:12:27,480 INSPIRE AND BE INSPIRED TO 333 00:12:27,480 --> 00:12:28,581 INNOVATE AND TO MAKE TANGIBLE 334 00:12:28,581 --> 00:12:29,782 DIFFERENCE IN THE LIVES OF 335 00:12:29,782 --> 00:12:30,984 PATIENTS AND THEIR FAMILIES 336 00:12:30,984 --> 00:12:32,085 AROUND THE WORLD. 337 00:12:32,085 --> 00:12:34,621 SO WE'RE ASKING YOU TO USE THE 338 00:12:34,621 --> 00:12:36,990 DIVERSE EXPERTISE IN THE ROOM TO 339 00:12:36,990 --> 00:12:39,626 HELP US IDENTIFY OPPORTUNITIES 340 00:12:39,626 --> 00:12:40,560 FOR ENHANCING IMPLEMENTATION 341 00:12:40,560 --> 00:12:42,695 RESEARCH THAT EXPLORES THE USE 342 00:12:42,695 --> 00:12:43,997 OF TELEHEALTH FOR HEART, LUNG, 343 00:12:43,997 --> 00:12:46,633 BLOOD AND SLEEP CONDITIONS. 344 00:12:46,633 --> 00:12:48,601 INDEED THE NHLBI STRONGLY IS 345 00:12:48,601 --> 00:12:51,237 COMMITTED TO ADVANCING RESEARCH 346 00:12:51,237 --> 00:12:53,439 THAT ACCELERATES TURNING 347 00:12:53,439 --> 00:12:55,742 DISCOVERS INTO REAL WORLD HEALTH 348 00:12:55,742 --> 00:12:57,677 IMPACTS, AND CTRIS IS THE FOCAL 349 00:12:57,677 --> 00:12:57,877 POINT. 350 00:12:57,877 --> 00:13:00,213 LET ME REMIND YOU UNDER THE 351 00:13:00,213 --> 00:13:02,515 FEDERAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE ACT, 352 00:13:02,515 --> 00:13:05,018 FACA, SIGNED INTO LAW IN 1972, 353 00:13:05,018 --> 00:13:06,452 OUR WORKSHOPS ARE NOT 354 00:13:06,452 --> 00:13:08,755 CONSTITUTED FOR YOU TO ADVISE 355 00:13:08,755 --> 00:13:11,424 NHLBI OR TO MAKE RECOMMENDATIONS 356 00:13:11,424 --> 00:13:12,692 TO NHLBI OR NIH. 357 00:13:12,692 --> 00:13:13,793 PLEASE DO FRAME YOUR INSIGHTS 358 00:13:13,793 --> 00:13:16,429 THAT YOU SHARE WITH US AS 359 00:13:16,429 --> 00:13:18,698 CHALLENGES THAT YOU'RE AWARE OF, 360 00:13:18,698 --> 00:13:21,334 AS OPPORTUNITIES FOR NHLBI TO 361 00:13:21,334 --> 00:13:22,402 EXPLORE, NOT AS RECOMMENDATIONS. 362 00:13:22,402 --> 00:13:28,107 LET'S FOCUS ON CHALLENGES OR 363 00:13:28,107 --> 00:13:29,409 OPPORTUNITIES FOR IMPLEMENTING 364 00:13:29,409 --> 00:13:30,176 TELEHEALTH RESEARCH. 365 00:13:30,176 --> 00:13:31,844 OPPORTUNITIES YOU IDENTIFY WILL 366 00:13:31,844 --> 00:13:34,747 PLAY A ROLE AS THE STRATEGIC 367 00:13:34,747 --> 00:13:36,015 VISION IS IMPLEMENTED, AS YOU 368 00:13:36,015 --> 00:13:40,286 CAN SEE BY MY BACKGROUND, CTRIS 369 00:13:40,286 --> 00:13:41,254 IS CELEBRATING 10th 370 00:13:41,254 --> 00:13:42,055 ANNIVERSARY THIS YEAR, EAGER TO 371 00:13:42,055 --> 00:13:44,357 LEARN FROM YOU AS WE PLAN OUR 372 00:13:44,357 --> 00:13:46,759 NEXT DECADE AS A STRATEGIC FOCAL 373 00:13:46,759 --> 00:13:47,860 POINT FOR IMPLEMENTATION 374 00:13:47,860 --> 00:13:49,162 RESEARCH, COMMUNITY ENGAGED 375 00:13:49,162 --> 00:13:50,596 RESEARCH, GLOBAL HEALTH 376 00:13:50,596 --> 00:13:51,931 RESEARCH, AND HEALTH DISPARITIES 377 00:13:51,931 --> 00:13:53,533 RESEARCH, ON THIS NOTE IF YOU'D 378 00:13:53,533 --> 00:13:56,302 LIKE TO JOIN CTRIS IN 379 00:13:56,302 --> 00:13:57,270 CELEBRATION PLEASE REGISTER NOW 380 00:13:57,270 --> 00:13:59,272 OR LATER TODAY OR TOMORROW FOR 381 00:13:59,272 --> 00:14:01,207 OUR HALF-DAY EVENT THAT'S TAKING 382 00:14:01,207 --> 00:14:02,475 PLACE ON DECEMBER 11th FROM 2 383 00:14:02,475 --> 00:14:07,146 TO 6 P.M., THE LINK IS IN THE 384 00:14:07,146 --> 00:14:09,315 CHAT AND WILL POP UP A QR CODE 385 00:14:09,315 --> 00:14:10,083 AT SOME POINT. 386 00:14:10,083 --> 00:14:14,220 ONCE AGAIN, WELCOME TO THIS 387 00:14:14,220 --> 00:14:14,854 IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH-FOCUSED 388 00:14:14,854 --> 00:14:17,356 WORKSHOP TO ADVANCE TELEHEALTH 389 00:14:17,356 --> 00:14:18,725 AND ITS IMPACT ON ACCESS FOR 390 00:14:18,725 --> 00:14:19,492 HEALTH CARE. 391 00:14:19,492 --> 00:14:21,260 I LOOK FORWARD TO THE RICH 392 00:14:21,260 --> 00:14:22,228 DISCUSSIONS AND MEANINGFUL 393 00:14:22,228 --> 00:14:23,229 CONNECTIONS THAT WILL EMERGE 394 00:14:23,229 --> 00:14:24,363 FROM OUR TIME TOGETHER. 395 00:14:24,363 --> 00:14:26,099 THANK YOU FOR YOUR COMMITMENT TO 396 00:14:26,099 --> 00:14:27,934 THIS IMPORTANT VEHICLE FOR 397 00:14:27,934 --> 00:14:29,769 ENHANCING HEALTHCARE ACCESS AND 398 00:14:29,769 --> 00:14:30,002 IMPACT. 399 00:14:30,002 --> 00:14:31,104 LET'S GET STARTED ON WHAT 400 00:14:31,104 --> 00:14:35,708 PROMISES TO BE AN ENLIGHTENING 401 00:14:35,708 --> 00:14:37,076 AND IMPACTFUL WORKSHOP. 402 00:14:37,076 --> 00:14:38,344 >> THANK YOU, DR. LEWIS, TO GET 403 00:14:38,344 --> 00:14:39,445 US STARTED FOR TODAY. 404 00:14:39,445 --> 00:14:44,484 AND NOW IT'S MY HONOR TO INVITE 405 00:14:44,484 --> 00:14:45,485 OUR KEYNOTE SPEAKER. 406 00:14:45,485 --> 00:14:46,686 JUST WAITING FOR THE SLIDES TO 407 00:14:46,686 --> 00:14:49,622 MOVE ON. 408 00:14:49,622 --> 00:14:52,592 HERE WE ARE. 409 00:14:52,592 --> 00:14:56,796 TODAY WE HAVE DR. GARTH GRAYHAN, 410 00:14:56,796 --> 00:14:58,598 DIRECTOR OF HEALTH CARE AND 411 00:14:58,598 --> 00:15:01,033 PUBLIC HEALTH AT GOOGLE GUIDE US 412 00:15:01,033 --> 00:15:03,669 ON THE REFLECTION OF LESSONS 413 00:15:03,669 --> 00:15:05,004 FROM THE PANDEMIC. 414 00:15:05,004 --> 00:15:06,272 DR. GRAHAM, A PLEASURE TO HOST 415 00:15:06,272 --> 00:15:08,040 YOU TODAY. 416 00:15:08,040 --> 00:15:08,708 PLEASE TAKE IT AWAY. 417 00:15:08,708 --> 00:15:09,609 >> THANK YOU. 418 00:15:09,609 --> 00:15:12,345 THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME. 419 00:15:12,345 --> 00:15:14,747 I AM GOING TO HOPEFULLY GO OVER 420 00:15:14,747 --> 00:15:17,583 SOME POINTS, NOT JUST FROM THE 421 00:15:17,583 --> 00:15:20,853 PERSPECTIVE FROM SOMEONE WORKING 422 00:15:20,853 --> 00:15:23,389 IN TECH-RELATED ISSUES BUT ALSO 423 00:15:23,389 --> 00:15:25,992 A CARDIOLOGIST PRACTICING DURING 424 00:15:25,992 --> 00:15:26,826 THE PANDEMIC. 425 00:15:26,826 --> 00:15:30,596 AND WENTZ THROUGH KIND OF -- 426 00:15:30,596 --> 00:15:31,998 WENT THROUGH MY OWN PERSONAL 427 00:15:31,998 --> 00:15:38,037 JOURNEY IN TERMS OF 428 00:15:38,037 --> 00:15:38,704 TELEMEDICINE, TELEHEALTH, 429 00:15:38,704 --> 00:15:40,006 INTRODUCING THAT INTO MY OWN 430 00:15:40,006 --> 00:15:41,874 PRACTICE IN TERMS OF TAKING CARE 431 00:15:41,874 --> 00:15:43,943 OF PATIENTS AS WELL. 432 00:15:43,943 --> 00:15:47,680 AND TALK ABOUT THE HISTORY OF 433 00:15:47,680 --> 00:15:49,649 TELEHEALTH, TELEMEDICINE USING 434 00:15:49,649 --> 00:15:50,950 THE TERMS INTERCHANGEABLE AND 435 00:15:50,950 --> 00:15:54,453 HOW THINGS EVOLVED FROM THE PAST 436 00:15:54,453 --> 00:15:56,989 INTO HOPEFULLY WHAT WILL BE 437 00:15:56,989 --> 00:15:57,623 POTENTIALLY OPPORTUNITIES FOR 438 00:15:57,623 --> 00:15:58,624 THE FUTURE. 439 00:15:58,624 --> 00:16:03,129 I'LL SPEND THE FIRST 7 OR 8 440 00:16:03,129 --> 00:16:03,763 MINUTES GROUNDING UP 441 00:16:03,763 --> 00:16:05,298 OPPORTUNITIES, CHALLENGES IN 442 00:16:05,298 --> 00:16:06,499 TERMS OF DISPARITIES IN 443 00:16:06,499 --> 00:16:07,700 UNDERSERVED COMMUNITIES. 444 00:16:07,700 --> 00:16:11,537 KIME 445 00:16:11,537 --> 00:16:13,406 I COME FROM THAT BACKGROUND, 446 00:16:13,406 --> 00:16:14,841 CHIEF OF HEALTH SERVICES 447 00:16:14,841 --> 00:16:18,377 RESEARCH AT AN ACTIVE 448 00:16:18,377 --> 00:16:19,979 INSTITUTION, AND AS A RESULT 449 00:16:19,979 --> 00:16:21,514 MINORITY HEALTH IN THE FEDERAL 450 00:16:21,514 --> 00:16:21,814 GOVERNMENT. 451 00:16:21,814 --> 00:16:23,916 SO COME WITH A LOT OF BACKGROUND 452 00:16:23,916 --> 00:16:27,787 AROUND ISSUES RELATED TO 453 00:16:27,787 --> 00:16:28,855 DISPARITIES, AND HEALTH EQUITY, 454 00:16:28,855 --> 00:16:29,956 AS REALLY THE FOUNDATION FOR 455 00:16:29,956 --> 00:16:34,160 WHAT I THINK ARE SOME OF THE 456 00:16:34,160 --> 00:16:36,996 OPPORTUNITIES WITH TELEHEALTH 457 00:16:36,996 --> 00:16:38,097 AND TELEMEDICINE, THE FIRST 6 OR 458 00:16:38,097 --> 00:16:40,499 7 MINUTES TALKING ABOUT THAT AND 459 00:16:40,499 --> 00:16:42,235 HISTORY OF TELEHEALTH, AND THEN 460 00:16:42,235 --> 00:16:46,205 CLOSE WITH WHAT I THINK WERE 461 00:16:46,205 --> 00:16:47,840 LESSONS FROM THE PANDEMIC, AND 462 00:16:47,840 --> 00:16:49,375 GOING THROUGH RESEARCH AND 463 00:16:49,375 --> 00:16:54,413 STUDIES THERE. 464 00:16:54,413 --> 00:16:55,281 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 465 00:16:55,281 --> 00:17:01,087 SO WHAT I SET THIS UP -- NEXT 466 00:17:01,087 --> 00:17:03,589 SLIDE PLEASE. 467 00:17:03,589 --> 00:17:07,093 WHEN I THINK OF THE EVOLUTION OF 468 00:17:07,093 --> 00:17:09,629 TELEHEALTH, I THINK ABOUT AGAIN 469 00:17:09,629 --> 00:17:11,898 WHERE WE START WITH FROM A 470 00:17:11,898 --> 00:17:16,202 PATIENT POPULATION PERSPECTIVE. 471 00:17:16,202 --> 00:17:16,969 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 472 00:17:16,969 --> 00:17:19,372 A LOT OF TALK ABOUT THE POLICY 473 00:17:19,372 --> 00:17:20,473 AND IMPLICATIONS, I'LL TALK A 474 00:17:20,473 --> 00:17:21,874 LITTLE BIT ABOUT, THAT REALLY 475 00:17:21,874 --> 00:17:23,509 LET'S START WITH CONVERSATIONS 476 00:17:23,509 --> 00:17:24,543 ABOUT THE COMMUNITY. 477 00:17:24,543 --> 00:17:25,745 AND WHAT ARE THE OPPORTUNITIES 478 00:17:25,745 --> 00:17:28,247 REALLY HERE WHEN WE THINK OF 479 00:17:28,247 --> 00:17:29,382 TELEHEALTH AND TELEMEDICINE. 480 00:17:29,382 --> 00:17:31,984 SO I ALWAYS THINK ABOUT THIS 481 00:17:31,984 --> 00:17:36,155 IDEA, NEIGHBORHOODS MATTER FOR 482 00:17:36,155 --> 00:17:36,389 HEALTH. 483 00:17:36,389 --> 00:17:37,590 THIS IS ONE OF THE MANY POINTS 484 00:17:37,590 --> 00:17:41,360 OF DATA THAT MANY OF YOU HAVE 485 00:17:41,360 --> 00:17:43,629 SEEN IN TERMS OF OVERUSED TERM, 486 00:17:43,629 --> 00:17:45,264 YOUR ZIP CODE MATTERING MORE 487 00:17:45,264 --> 00:17:46,232 THAN GENETICS, THE IDEA THAT 488 00:17:46,232 --> 00:17:48,301 WHERE WE LIVE IN THE UNITED 489 00:17:48,301 --> 00:17:49,302 STATES SO ESSENTIALLY DEFINES 490 00:17:49,302 --> 00:17:51,370 HOW LONG WE LIVE AND THIS IS MY 491 00:17:51,370 --> 00:17:53,806 NEIGHBORHOOD THAT I GREW UP WITH 492 00:17:53,806 --> 00:17:56,842 AFTER I MOVED FROM JAMAICA, IN 493 00:17:56,842 --> 00:18:00,913 MIAMI, SHOWING WHERE WE LIVED IN 494 00:18:00,913 --> 00:18:04,517 MIAMI, THE ZIP CODE DIFFERENCE 495 00:18:04,517 --> 00:18:06,686 FROM DRIVING 15 MINUTES MORE 496 00:18:06,686 --> 00:18:08,287 INTO MORE AFFLUENT AREAS AND 497 00:18:08,287 --> 00:18:10,089 15-YEAR GAP IN TERMS OF LIFE 498 00:18:10,089 --> 00:18:11,057 EXPECTANCY. 499 00:18:11,057 --> 00:18:12,825 WHEN WE THINK ABOUT THE KINDS OF 500 00:18:12,825 --> 00:18:15,261 THINGS THAT WE CAN ADVANCE 501 00:18:15,261 --> 00:18:16,228 AROUND TELEHEALTH AND 502 00:18:16,228 --> 00:18:17,763 TELEMEDICINE THE NEXT COUPLE 503 00:18:17,763 --> 00:18:23,235 SLIDES ARE MEANT TO ENCAPSULATE 504 00:18:23,235 --> 00:18:24,003 THE CHALLENGES, UNDERSTANDING 505 00:18:24,003 --> 00:18:26,305 GEOGRAPHIC ISOLATION THAT DRIVES 506 00:18:26,305 --> 00:18:28,274 HEALTH DISPARITIES, BUT ALSO 507 00:18:28,274 --> 00:18:29,175 UNDERSTANDING HOW THAT, AGAIN, 508 00:18:29,175 --> 00:18:35,915 IMPACTS HEALTH OUTCOMES. 509 00:18:35,915 --> 00:18:36,816 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 510 00:18:36,816 --> 00:18:38,985 I SPENT TIME IN RESEARCH. 511 00:18:38,985 --> 00:18:42,621 THIS IS A PAPER THAT ME AND MY 512 00:18:42,621 --> 00:18:46,225 TEAM PUBLISHED IN JAMA EARLIER 513 00:18:46,225 --> 00:18:47,193 ON, PRE-PANDEMIC ACTUALLY. 514 00:18:47,193 --> 00:18:49,028 AND WE WERE LOOKING AT WHAT WERE 515 00:18:49,028 --> 00:18:52,131 SOME OF THE FACTORS THAT REALLY 516 00:18:52,131 --> 00:18:55,735 DROVE THE DEATH RATE FROM ACUTE 517 00:18:55,735 --> 00:18:56,936 MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION TO ONE 518 00:18:56,936 --> 00:18:58,070 YEAR AND FIVE-YEAR DEATH RATES 519 00:18:58,070 --> 00:19:00,439 IN TERMS OF THE DIFFERENCES 520 00:19:00,439 --> 00:19:03,075 BETWEEN A BLACK AND WHITE 521 00:19:03,075 --> 00:19:04,944 POPULATION. 522 00:19:04,944 --> 00:19:08,347 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 523 00:19:08,347 --> 00:19:12,952 WE SHOWED PREDOMINANTLY WHEN YOU 524 00:19:12,952 --> 00:19:14,253 PULL ASIDE ISSUES RELATED TO -- 525 00:19:14,253 --> 00:19:16,222 WHEN YOU STARTED TO SCORE IN 526 00:19:16,222 --> 00:19:17,556 TERMS OF PROPENSITY SCORES TO 527 00:19:17,556 --> 00:19:19,392 LOOK AT PARTICULARLY BLACK 528 00:19:19,392 --> 00:19:21,494 POPULATIONS AND THEN LOOK AT 529 00:19:21,494 --> 00:19:23,462 WHITE POPULATIONS, START TO 530 00:19:23,462 --> 00:19:26,899 AGGREGATE IN TERMS OF CONCEPTS 531 00:19:26,899 --> 00:19:28,234 AND DRIVERS DRIVING MORBIDITY 532 00:19:28,234 --> 00:19:29,602 AND MORTALITY, ISSUES WHEN YOU 533 00:19:29,602 --> 00:19:33,339 CONTROLLED FOR OTHER FACTORS, 534 00:19:33,339 --> 00:19:36,609 ISSUES SUCH AS HEALTH STATUS, 535 00:19:36,609 --> 00:19:37,243 CLINICAL PRESENTATION, LIFESTYLE 536 00:19:37,243 --> 00:19:39,445 FACTORS LESS OF A COMPONENT FOR 537 00:19:39,445 --> 00:19:40,646 DRIVING HEALTH OUTCOMES, 538 00:19:40,646 --> 00:19:42,381 COMPARED TO THE CONCEPT OF 539 00:19:42,381 --> 00:19:44,483 SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS. 540 00:19:44,483 --> 00:19:47,219 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 541 00:19:47,219 --> 00:19:48,187 SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS WAS REALLY 542 00:19:48,187 --> 00:19:50,823 A PROXY FOR THIS CONCEPT OF 543 00:19:50,823 --> 00:19:52,058 GEOGRAPHY AND ACCESS. 544 00:19:52,058 --> 00:19:55,528 WHAT WE SHOWED HERE IN THIS 545 00:19:55,528 --> 00:19:56,729 SLIDE WAS THAT YOUR PROBABILITY 546 00:19:56,729 --> 00:20:00,699 OF DYING FROM A HEART ATTACK IF 547 00:20:00,699 --> 00:20:03,836 YOU GO FROM LEFT TO RIGHT IN 548 00:20:03,836 --> 00:20:05,471 TERMS OF PROPENSITY SCORE AND 549 00:20:05,471 --> 00:20:10,443 PROBABILITY BEING ON THE Y-AXIS 550 00:20:10,443 --> 00:20:11,744 AND PROPENSITY SCORE BLACK AND 551 00:20:11,744 --> 00:20:14,480 WHITE ON THE X-AXIS, IF YOU WENT 552 00:20:14,480 --> 00:20:16,115 TO LOOKING AT PROPENSITY SCORING 553 00:20:16,115 --> 00:20:18,751 FOR POPULATIONS MORE LIKELY THAT 554 00:20:18,751 --> 00:20:23,889 YOU'RE BLACK OR WHITE, YOU SEE A 555 00:20:23,889 --> 00:20:25,858 PROBABILITY FIVE-YEAR INCREASING 556 00:20:25,858 --> 00:20:29,829 FROM .15 UP TO .45, A THREE-FOLD 557 00:20:29,829 --> 00:20:30,796 INCREASE IN PROPENSITY SCORE 558 00:20:30,796 --> 00:20:31,897 FROM FIVE-YEAR MORTALITY 559 00:20:31,897 --> 00:20:33,532 COMPARED TO BLACK OR WHITE 560 00:20:33,532 --> 00:20:33,799 PATIENTS. 561 00:20:33,799 --> 00:20:35,701 BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE P-VALUE 562 00:20:35,701 --> 00:20:40,406 FOR THAT YOU NOTICE THE P-VALUE 563 00:20:40,406 --> 00:20:41,740 IS INSIGNIFICANT, 0.20. 564 00:20:41,740 --> 00:20:45,244 THIS ISSUE OF WHETHER YOU DIED 565 00:20:45,244 --> 00:20:46,979 FROM A HEART ATTACK, WHETHER 566 00:20:46,979 --> 00:20:48,948 BLACK OR WHITE, WAS NOT SO MUCH 567 00:20:48,948 --> 00:20:50,950 RELATED TO YOUR ACTUAL RACE OF 568 00:20:50,950 --> 00:20:52,451 BEING BLACK OR WHITE, THAT'S WHY 569 00:20:52,451 --> 00:20:54,553 THE P-VALUE IS NOT SIGNIFICANT, 570 00:20:54,553 --> 00:20:57,356 THAT EARLIER SLIDE IN TERMS OF 571 00:20:57,356 --> 00:20:59,792 THE SOCIOECONOMIC AND ACCESS 572 00:20:59,792 --> 00:21:00,526 FACTORS THAT DROVE THOSE 573 00:21:00,526 --> 00:21:02,328 DYNAMICS, SO IF YOU MOVE BLACK 574 00:21:02,328 --> 00:21:04,830 PATIENTS INTO A WHITE COMMUNITY, 575 00:21:04,830 --> 00:21:06,932 YOU START TO SEE SIMILAR 576 00:21:06,932 --> 00:21:10,202 MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY FROM 577 00:21:10,202 --> 00:21:12,371 M.I.s, AND SIMILARLY VICE 578 00:21:12,371 --> 00:21:16,108 VERSE A BETWEEN BLACK AND WHITE 579 00:21:16,108 --> 00:21:20,746 THE SO THIS CONCEPT OF GEOGRAPHY 580 00:21:20,746 --> 00:21:22,481 AND ACCESS WAS DRIVING HEART 581 00:21:22,481 --> 00:21:23,816 DISEASE AND MORTALITY. 582 00:21:23,816 --> 00:21:26,318 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 583 00:21:26,318 --> 00:21:28,287 THIS CONCEPT IS NOT SOLELY 584 00:21:28,287 --> 00:21:30,456 RELATED TO JUST ISSUE THE BLACK 585 00:21:30,456 --> 00:21:31,357 OR WHITE. 586 00:21:31,357 --> 00:21:32,758 THIS IS VERY MUCH INTERPRETED 587 00:21:32,758 --> 00:21:37,363 WHAT YOU SEE IN TERMS OF RURAL 588 00:21:37,363 --> 00:21:38,998 GEOGRAPHY, INCREASED MORBIDITY 589 00:21:38,998 --> 00:21:39,331 AND MORTALITY. 590 00:21:39,331 --> 00:21:43,369 THIS IS SOME DATA FROM THE FOLKS 591 00:21:43,369 --> 00:21:44,503 IN VIRGINIA. 592 00:21:44,503 --> 00:21:46,639 AND I'M SHOWING THIS VERY SHARP 593 00:21:46,639 --> 00:21:47,640 INCREASE IN MORBIDITY AND 594 00:21:47,640 --> 00:21:48,741 MORTALITY, WHEN YOU START TO 595 00:21:48,741 --> 00:21:50,576 LOOK AT CONCEPT OF GEOGRAPHY. 596 00:21:50,576 --> 00:21:53,679 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 597 00:21:53,679 --> 00:21:57,816 AND THEN MORE IMPORTANTLY, THIS 598 00:21:57,816 --> 00:22:00,119 IS ANOTHER SLIDE FROM DR. WILSON 599 00:22:00,119 --> 00:22:02,221 IN VIRGINIA, LOOKING AGAIN OVER 600 00:22:02,221 --> 00:22:04,523 THE PAST COUPLE YEARS IN TERMS 601 00:22:04,523 --> 00:22:07,126 OF LIFE EXPECTANCY THIS HUGE GAP 602 00:22:07,126 --> 00:22:09,328 BETWEEN, YOU KNOW, FOLKS LIVING 603 00:22:09,328 --> 00:22:12,064 IN ONE OF THE TWO ZIP CODES 604 00:22:12,064 --> 00:22:13,566 VERSUS THE CONCEPT OF LIVING IN 605 00:22:13,566 --> 00:22:15,434 THE MIDDLE PART OF AMERICA. 606 00:22:15,434 --> 00:22:17,836 WHAT THIS HOPEFULLY SETS UP FOR 607 00:22:17,836 --> 00:22:20,906 YOU, THIS CONCEPT OF BOTH THIS 608 00:22:20,906 --> 00:22:22,775 IDEA OF BOTH GEOGRAPHY, 609 00:22:22,775 --> 00:22:24,376 SOCIOECONOMIC STATUS, AND 610 00:22:24,376 --> 00:22:29,682 ACCESS, AND WHERE THE PROMISE OF 611 00:22:29,682 --> 00:22:30,649 TOOLS LIKE TELEMEDICINE, 612 00:22:30,649 --> 00:22:32,284 TELEHEALTH AS WE GO THROUGH 613 00:22:32,284 --> 00:22:33,719 TODAY, YOU KNOW, AND THE 614 00:22:33,719 --> 00:22:36,021 CONVERSATIONS WE'RE GOING TO 615 00:22:36,021 --> 00:22:38,090 HAVE, THINK THROUGH AGAIN THESE 616 00:22:38,090 --> 00:22:39,959 IDEAS MORE ABOUT HOW AND WHERE 617 00:22:39,959 --> 00:22:41,927 THE TOOLS THAT WE TALK ABOUT CAN 618 00:22:41,927 --> 00:22:43,662 HELP TO KIND OF BRIDGE THESE 619 00:22:43,662 --> 00:22:45,064 GAPS IN TERMS OF MORBIDITY AND 620 00:22:45,064 --> 00:22:46,398 MORTALITY. 621 00:22:46,398 --> 00:22:47,566 SO STARTING NOT WITH TECHNOLOGY 622 00:22:47,566 --> 00:22:50,236 OFT THAN WE DO BUT MORE STARTING 623 00:22:50,236 --> 00:22:53,739 WITH THE PEOPLE AND THE 624 00:22:53,739 --> 00:22:55,808 COMMUNITIES AND THE MORTALITY 625 00:22:55,808 --> 00:22:57,209 DRIVEN IN THESE COMMUNITIES 626 00:22:57,209 --> 00:23:04,450 WHETHER BLACK VERSUS WHITE, 627 00:23:04,450 --> 00:23:05,317 URBAN VERSUS RURAL, AND THOSE 628 00:23:05,317 --> 00:23:07,519 ARE THE OPPORTUNITIES. 629 00:23:07,519 --> 00:23:09,788 THESE ARE THE IDEAS OF 630 00:23:09,788 --> 00:23:10,422 PATIENT-CENTRIC CARE, REACHING 631 00:23:10,422 --> 00:23:12,458 PATIENTS WHERE THEY ARE. 632 00:23:12,458 --> 00:23:13,425 AGAIN, THINKING ABOUT THIS 633 00:23:13,425 --> 00:23:17,029 OPPORTUNITY THAT WE HAVE WHEN WE 634 00:23:17,029 --> 00:23:19,231 THINK ABOUT CONCEPTS AROUND 635 00:23:19,231 --> 00:23:24,003 TELEMEDICINE AND TELEHEALTH. 636 00:23:24,003 --> 00:23:25,771 THAT HAS DRIVEN MY INTEREST AREA 637 00:23:25,771 --> 00:23:28,407 IN THE FIELD, BUT ALSO AS I HAVE 638 00:23:28,407 --> 00:23:31,143 PRACTICED, AND I PRACTICE 639 00:23:31,143 --> 00:23:33,445 PRIMARILY AS A TELEMEDICINE 640 00:23:33,445 --> 00:23:36,749 CLINICIAN, IN ADDITION TO MY 641 00:23:36,749 --> 00:23:37,549 ROLE AT GOOGLE, YouTube, 642 00:23:37,549 --> 00:23:40,686 WHAT WE'RE DOING IN TERMS OF 643 00:23:40,686 --> 00:23:43,522 GETTING AROUND THE TECHNOLOGY 644 00:23:43,522 --> 00:23:45,824 AND GETTING PEOPLE TO ACCESS 645 00:23:45,824 --> 00:23:46,792 QUALITY HEALTH INFORMATION, I'VE 646 00:23:46,792 --> 00:23:53,132 BEEN OBSESSED WITH THE IDEA OF 647 00:23:53,132 --> 00:23:54,233 OVERARCHING PROMISE OF 648 00:23:54,233 --> 00:23:57,503 TELEMEDICINE, THIS CAPTURES 649 00:23:57,503 --> 00:24:02,975 THINKING ABOUT HOW WE CAN BRIDGE 650 00:24:02,975 --> 00:24:05,744 GAPS IN TERMS OF MORBIDITY AND 651 00:24:05,744 --> 00:24:07,079 MORTALITY IN COMMUNITIES IN 652 00:24:07,079 --> 00:24:09,048 TERMS OF RURAL COMMUNITIES, BUT 653 00:24:09,048 --> 00:24:09,581 UNDERSTANDING, AGAIN, THE 654 00:24:09,581 --> 00:24:11,650 CONCEPT IN TERMS OF WHAT'S 655 00:24:11,650 --> 00:24:12,985 HAPPENING BETWEEN DISPARITIES IN 656 00:24:12,985 --> 00:24:13,952 DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES. 657 00:24:13,952 --> 00:24:17,690 AND THIS IS WHERE WE START TO 658 00:24:17,690 --> 00:24:21,393 THINK THROUGH WHAT ARE SOME 659 00:24:21,393 --> 00:24:22,928 OPPORTUNITIES, AND REALLY IN 660 00:24:22,928 --> 00:24:25,030 PARTICULAR THE FOCUS AROUND 661 00:24:25,030 --> 00:24:27,733 PATIENT OPPORTUNITIES AND 662 00:24:27,733 --> 00:24:28,834 THINKING THROUGH, AGAIN, HOW 663 00:24:28,834 --> 00:24:30,135 TELEMEDICINE, TELEHEALTH CAN 664 00:24:30,135 --> 00:24:31,136 KIND OF TRANSFORM THAT 665 00:24:31,136 --> 00:24:31,670 LANDSCAPE. 666 00:24:31,670 --> 00:24:33,339 A LOT OF YOU HERE HAVE BEEN 667 00:24:33,339 --> 00:24:36,709 WORKING IN THIS FIELD FOR A LONG 668 00:24:36,709 --> 00:24:37,042 TIME. 669 00:24:37,042 --> 00:24:39,445 NOT ONLY ON THE GOVERNMENT 670 00:24:39,445 --> 00:24:42,514 SECTOR AND PRIVATE SECTOR BUT 671 00:24:42,514 --> 00:24:46,452 ALSO RESEARCH, REALLY, AGAIN, I 672 00:24:46,452 --> 00:24:47,653 START WITH COMMUNITIES PROBLEM 673 00:24:47,653 --> 00:24:49,621 FIRST AND THINKING THROUGH 674 00:24:49,621 --> 00:24:50,022 TECHNOLOGY. 675 00:24:50,022 --> 00:24:51,357 THIS CAPTURES I THINK THIS IDEA 676 00:24:51,357 --> 00:24:54,326 WHAT IS A PROMISE, WHAT ARE THE 677 00:24:54,326 --> 00:24:57,363 OPPORTUNITIES IN FRONT OF US, 678 00:24:57,363 --> 00:25:00,232 WHEN WE THINK THROUGH 679 00:25:00,232 --> 00:25:01,333 OVERARCHING PROMISE OF 680 00:25:01,333 --> 00:25:01,767 TELEMEDICINE. 681 00:25:01,767 --> 00:25:07,005 I ALLUDED TO THE CONCEPT OF LIKE 682 00:25:07,005 --> 00:25:07,806 TACKLING DISPARITIES AS AN 683 00:25:07,806 --> 00:25:10,642 ULTIMATE GOAL, IF NOT ONE OF THE 684 00:25:10,642 --> 00:25:12,177 MANY GOALS, AND ONE OF THE 685 00:25:12,177 --> 00:25:15,114 OPPORTUNITIES WE SEE IS AS 686 00:25:15,114 --> 00:25:19,151 BROADBAND ACCESS HAS CONTINUED 687 00:25:19,151 --> 00:25:22,087 TO BE MORE AVAILABLE TO 688 00:25:22,087 --> 00:25:25,023 COMMUNITIES, BOTH COMMUNITIES IN 689 00:25:25,023 --> 00:25:26,558 TERMS OF GEOGRAPHY, BUT 690 00:25:26,558 --> 00:25:27,960 COMMUNITIES IN TERMS OF RACE, 691 00:25:27,960 --> 00:25:30,062 AND YOU SEE MORE CHALLENGES IN 692 00:25:30,062 --> 00:25:31,697 TERMS OF ECONOMIC SIDE OF 693 00:25:31,697 --> 00:25:32,464 BROADBAND ACCESS, THAT'S AGAIN 694 00:25:32,464 --> 00:25:35,834 WHERE YOU START TO SEE THIS 695 00:25:35,834 --> 00:25:37,169 ASPECT OF THE PROMISE AND 696 00:25:37,169 --> 00:25:39,438 OPPORTUNITIES IN TERMS OF 697 00:25:39,438 --> 00:25:42,241 TELEMEDICINE, TELEHEALTH. 698 00:25:42,241 --> 00:25:45,544 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 699 00:25:45,544 --> 00:25:47,479 AND SO EVOLUTIONS, IT'S KIND OF 700 00:25:47,479 --> 00:25:47,913 INTERESTING. 701 00:25:47,913 --> 00:25:50,115 AND, YOU KNOW, PART OF TODAY'S 702 00:25:50,115 --> 00:25:53,285 LOOKING BACK IN TERMS OF THE 703 00:25:53,285 --> 00:25:54,186 PANDEMIC AND PRIOR TO THAT, AND 704 00:25:54,186 --> 00:25:57,890 THEN IN TERMS OF EVEN THINKING 705 00:25:57,890 --> 00:25:58,957 THROUGH AND LOOKING FORWARD, 706 00:25:58,957 --> 00:26:02,027 THIS IS A SLIDE I CAPTURED FROM 707 00:26:02,027 --> 00:26:06,098 ONE OF -- FROM THE ATA, MAKES 708 00:26:06,098 --> 00:26:08,500 YOU THINK ABOUT HOW TELEMEDICINE 709 00:26:08,500 --> 00:26:11,437 AND TELEHEALTH EVOLVED, PRIOR TO 710 00:26:11,437 --> 00:26:17,242 EVEN GETTING TO WHERE WE WERE 711 00:26:17,242 --> 00:26:19,645 WITH THE PANDEMIC WHERE YOU ARE 712 00:26:19,645 --> 00:26:23,248 EARLY INNOVATORS, EARLY 713 00:26:23,248 --> 00:26:24,583 ADOPTERS, INDIVIDUALS WHO 714 00:26:24,583 --> 00:26:26,285 STARTED TELEMEDICINE AND 715 00:26:26,285 --> 00:26:29,188 TELEHEALTH PROGRAMS, DR. SANDERS 716 00:26:29,188 --> 00:26:34,326 BACK IN THE 1980s, AND OTHERS, 717 00:26:34,326 --> 00:26:36,395 BUILDING SOME OF THOSE BUILDING 718 00:26:36,395 --> 00:26:38,831 BLOCKS AND PROGRAMS. 719 00:26:38,831 --> 00:26:41,333 BUT THE REAL RATE-LIMITING 720 00:26:41,333 --> 00:26:43,635 FACTORS, ADVANCEMENTS IN 721 00:26:43,635 --> 00:26:44,269 TELEMEDICINE AND TELEHEALTH, HAS 722 00:26:44,269 --> 00:26:47,039 CONTINUED TO BE CHALLENGES 723 00:26:47,039 --> 00:26:48,373 AROUND POLICY, PAYMENT, AND 724 00:26:48,373 --> 00:26:49,208 INFRASTRUCTURE. 725 00:26:49,208 --> 00:26:50,676 WE'RE GOING TO TALK MORE ABOUT 726 00:26:50,676 --> 00:26:53,378 THAT, HOW THAT EVOLVED DURING 727 00:26:53,378 --> 00:26:54,546 THE PANDEMIC. 728 00:26:54,546 --> 00:27:01,920 THERE WERE SOME INITIAL FUNDING 729 00:27:01,920 --> 00:27:04,790 OPPORTUNITIES, YOU KNOW, WITH 730 00:27:04,790 --> 00:27:05,991 THE RECOVERY AND INVESTMENT ACT 731 00:27:05,991 --> 00:27:09,261 PUMPING MONEY INTO THE SYSTEM 732 00:27:09,261 --> 00:27:11,430 AROUND POLICY AND INNOVATION BUT 733 00:27:11,430 --> 00:27:12,664 BECAUSE POLICY LEVERS WEREN'T 734 00:27:12,664 --> 00:27:15,701 BEING PULLED SOME FUNDING 735 00:27:15,701 --> 00:27:17,669 DYNAMIC, THOUGH ADVANCING 736 00:27:17,669 --> 00:27:20,739 RESEARCH, DIDN'T REALLY ADVANCE 737 00:27:20,739 --> 00:27:22,875 THE PRACTICE OF TELEMEDICINE AND 738 00:27:22,875 --> 00:27:23,809 TELEHEALTH OVERALL. 739 00:27:23,809 --> 00:27:25,878 A LOT OF THAT HAPPENED DURING 740 00:27:25,878 --> 00:27:28,714 THE PANDEMIC AND I'LL HOPEFULLY 741 00:27:28,714 --> 00:27:32,017 ELUCIDATE SOME KEY ONES AND HOW 742 00:27:32,017 --> 00:27:32,684 THAT INFLUENCED BEHAVIOR 743 00:27:32,684 --> 00:27:33,318 PATTERNS AS WELL. 744 00:27:33,318 --> 00:27:37,155 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 745 00:27:37,155 --> 00:27:39,625 SO, PANDEMIC HIT. 746 00:27:39,625 --> 00:27:44,863 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 747 00:27:44,863 --> 00:27:47,366 AND THEN AS ALLUDED TO BEFORE A 748 00:27:47,366 --> 00:27:48,300 NUMBER OF THINGS HAPPENED 749 00:27:48,300 --> 00:27:49,468 SIMULTANEOUSLY ON THE POLICY 750 00:27:49,468 --> 00:27:49,668 FRONT. 751 00:27:49,668 --> 00:27:54,406 I'M SORRY, NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 752 00:27:54,406 --> 00:27:57,910 AND A KEY TO THOSE RAPID CHANGES 753 00:27:57,910 --> 00:28:00,746 AT THE ONSET OF THE PANDEMIC WAS 754 00:28:00,746 --> 00:28:02,481 IMPROVED REIMBURSEMENT FROM 755 00:28:02,481 --> 00:28:06,985 INSURERS BUT ALSO KEY ACTIVITIES 756 00:28:06,985 --> 00:28:09,521 FROM LOOSENING OF PRIVACY AND 757 00:28:09,521 --> 00:28:12,558 HIPAA REQUIREMENTS FROM OCR. 758 00:28:12,558 --> 00:28:15,527 I WOULD ALSO -- REQUIREMENTS FOR 759 00:28:15,527 --> 00:28:16,428 TELEHEALTH AND MEDICARE PROGRAM 760 00:28:16,428 --> 00:28:19,231 ALLOWING MORE ACCESS IN TERMS OF 761 00:28:19,231 --> 00:28:21,300 PAYMENT FROM GEOGRAPHIC 762 00:28:21,300 --> 00:28:22,734 LOCATIONS, EXPANDED ACCESS TO 763 00:28:22,734 --> 00:28:24,836 TELEHEALTH, AND A LOT AROUND 764 00:28:24,836 --> 00:28:27,739 THIS CONCEPT OF WHAT HAPPENED 765 00:28:27,739 --> 00:28:29,841 WITH PROVIDER LICENSE AND 766 00:28:29,841 --> 00:28:31,276 ON-LINE PRESCRIBING AND WRITTEN 767 00:28:31,276 --> 00:28:31,510 CONSENT. 768 00:28:31,510 --> 00:28:32,811 IT'S INTERESTING WHEN YOU PEEL 769 00:28:32,811 --> 00:28:34,980 BACK WHAT HAPPENED IN TERMS OF 770 00:28:34,980 --> 00:28:36,415 PRACTICE PATTERNS, GOING IN 771 00:28:36,415 --> 00:28:37,849 PARTICULAR THROUGH WHAT HAPPENED 772 00:28:37,849 --> 00:28:38,917 IN FAMILY PRACTICE GROUPS AND 773 00:28:38,917 --> 00:28:40,485 THEN OTHERS IN TERMS OF DATA 774 00:28:40,485 --> 00:28:43,322 THAT WAS BEING COLLECTED IN REAL 775 00:28:43,322 --> 00:28:43,789 TIME. 776 00:28:43,789 --> 00:28:45,524 BUT INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH, YOU 777 00:28:45,524 --> 00:28:47,259 KNOW, YOU SAW THE PRIVATE 778 00:28:47,259 --> 00:28:47,859 EXPANSION. 779 00:28:47,859 --> 00:28:49,361 IN A COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTER 780 00:28:49,361 --> 00:28:57,336 PROGRAM FOR INSTANCE WHERE YOU 781 00:28:57,336 --> 00:28:58,537 INITIALLY SAW TELEMEDICINE 782 00:28:58,537 --> 00:29:02,040 TELEHEALTH RATES IN 15%, GETTING 783 00:29:02,040 --> 00:29:07,846 INTO THE 90s PER CENT DURING 784 00:29:07,846 --> 00:29:09,247 THE PANDEMIC, AS CLINICIANS 785 00:29:09,247 --> 00:29:12,017 STARTED TO LEARN, GRASP, GAIN 786 00:29:12,017 --> 00:29:12,784 MORE COMFORT WITH 787 00:29:12,784 --> 00:29:16,088 INFRASTRUCTURE, YOU STARTED TO 788 00:29:16,088 --> 00:29:18,557 SEE WHERE A LOT OF PRACTICE 789 00:29:18,557 --> 00:29:23,161 PATTERNS CHANGED, BUT AS THE 790 00:29:23,161 --> 00:29:24,363 PAYMENTS AND POLICY CONTINUED TO 791 00:29:24,363 --> 00:29:27,532 BE A BARRIER, DESPITE THE MANY 792 00:29:27,532 --> 00:29:28,967 CHANGES, WE'LL TALK ABOUT THAT 793 00:29:28,967 --> 00:29:29,701 AS WELL. 794 00:29:29,701 --> 00:29:32,771 SO RAPID CHANGES IN TERMS OF 795 00:29:32,771 --> 00:29:34,640 PAYMENT AND POLICY REALLY PULLED 796 00:29:34,640 --> 00:29:39,144 ON THOSE LEVERS THAT MOVED 797 00:29:39,144 --> 00:29:40,245 FORWARD A LOT DURING THE 798 00:29:40,245 --> 00:29:44,616 PANDEMIC AS WELL. 799 00:29:44,616 --> 00:29:45,617 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 800 00:29:45,617 --> 00:29:46,918 AND THERE'S SOME INTERESTING 801 00:29:46,918 --> 00:29:48,120 DATA THAT CAME OUT. 802 00:29:48,120 --> 00:29:52,691 I CAPTURED A LOT FROM A REALLY 803 00:29:52,691 --> 00:29:53,358 WELL-DONE REVIEW FROM 804 00:29:53,358 --> 00:29:56,528 IMMUNOLOGIST WHO WROTE A LOT 805 00:29:56,528 --> 00:29:58,497 ABOUT JUST REVIEW GROUP, WHO 806 00:29:58,497 --> 00:30:00,265 WROTE A LOT ABOUT SOME OF THE 807 00:30:00,265 --> 00:30:01,700 DYNAMICS THAT REALLY KIND OF 808 00:30:01,700 --> 00:30:02,167 CHANGED. 809 00:30:02,167 --> 00:30:03,869 ONE OF THOSE INTERESTING THINGS 810 00:30:03,869 --> 00:30:07,606 WAS INITIALLY IN THE PANDEMIC, 811 00:30:07,606 --> 00:30:10,108 PATIENT SATISFACTION WAS SIMILAR 812 00:30:10,108 --> 00:30:11,643 WITH IN-PERSON AND TELEPHONE 813 00:30:11,643 --> 00:30:13,712 ENCOUNTERS, PARTICULARLY DURING 814 00:30:13,712 --> 00:30:14,046 THE PANDEMIC. 815 00:30:14,046 --> 00:30:18,216 AND MAYBE SOME OF THIS WAS 816 00:30:18,216 --> 00:30:19,451 RELATED TO EXPECTATIONS THAT 817 00:30:19,451 --> 00:30:21,420 PEOPLE WERE DEALING WITH THEIR 818 00:30:21,420 --> 00:30:25,357 OWN FEARS IN TERMS OF VIRAL 819 00:30:25,357 --> 00:30:27,893 EXPOSURE, BUT YOU SAW A LOT OF 820 00:30:27,893 --> 00:30:31,530 EQUAL DYNAMICS IN TERMS OF 821 00:30:31,530 --> 00:30:32,731 IN-PERSON VIDEO, TELEPHONE 822 00:30:32,731 --> 00:30:37,102 ENCOUNTERS, INITIALLY DURING THE 823 00:30:37,102 --> 00:30:38,537 PANDEMIC, AROUND THOSE AND 824 00:30:38,537 --> 00:30:40,839 PATIENT SATISFACTION AND THOSE 825 00:30:40,839 --> 00:30:42,708 RELATED TO REAL-LIFE -- IN 826 00:30:42,708 --> 00:30:48,280 REAL-LIFE ENCOUNTERS AS WELL. 827 00:30:48,280 --> 00:30:48,914 SIMILARLY, PHYSICIAN 828 00:30:48,914 --> 00:30:49,815 SATISFACTION WAS EVOLVED OVER 829 00:30:49,815 --> 00:30:52,317 TIME WITH A LOT OF PROVIDERS 830 00:30:52,317 --> 00:30:54,186 EXPRESSING MORE POSITIVE 831 00:30:54,186 --> 00:30:55,153 ATTITUDES AROUND ADOPTION OF 832 00:30:55,153 --> 00:30:55,721 TELEMEDICINE. 833 00:30:55,721 --> 00:30:56,722 I'LL GO INTO THAT SPECIFICALLY 834 00:30:56,722 --> 00:30:57,789 IN A SECOND AS WELL. 835 00:30:57,789 --> 00:30:59,658 THERE ARE A LOT OF CHALLENGES 836 00:30:59,658 --> 00:31:01,693 WITH INTEGRATION OF WORK FLOW, 837 00:31:01,693 --> 00:31:06,098 AND THEN A LOT OF CHALLENGES IN 838 00:31:06,098 --> 00:31:07,866 TERMS OF HOW TO REPLICATE 839 00:31:07,866 --> 00:31:09,601 COLLECTING CLINICAL INFORMATION 840 00:31:09,601 --> 00:31:11,236 AT HOME, LIKE BLOOD PRESSURE, OR 841 00:31:11,236 --> 00:31:13,538 OTHER KINDS OF THINGS YOU WOULD 842 00:31:13,538 --> 00:31:15,073 NORMALLY COLLECT WITHIN THE 843 00:31:15,073 --> 00:31:16,942 CLINICAL CONTEXT IN A VISIT, AND 844 00:31:16,942 --> 00:31:18,577 A LOT OF CHALLENGES WITH THAT. 845 00:31:18,577 --> 00:31:20,345 IT WAS INTERESTING WATCHING THE 846 00:31:20,345 --> 00:31:21,880 SYSTEM EVOLVE IN REAL TIME. 847 00:31:21,880 --> 00:31:25,517 I'LL SHOW YOU SOME DATA FROM 848 00:31:25,517 --> 00:31:26,685 FAMILY MEDICINE, CLINICIANS 849 00:31:26,685 --> 00:31:28,019 SHOWING HOW CLINICIANS WERE 850 00:31:28,019 --> 00:31:30,989 EVOLVING IN REAL TIME AND THEN 851 00:31:30,989 --> 00:31:31,857 EEVOLVEDDED BACK. 852 00:31:31,857 --> 00:31:35,694 INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH, A LOT OF 853 00:31:35,694 --> 00:31:38,296 STUDIES SHOWED PARTICULAR 854 00:31:38,296 --> 00:31:39,631 BENEFIT AROUND VIRTUAL VISITS 855 00:31:39,631 --> 00:31:40,966 AROUND SPECIALTY CARE, AND 856 00:31:40,966 --> 00:31:44,469 THAT'S WHERE I THINK WE'LL 857 00:31:44,469 --> 00:31:47,873 CONTINUE TO POTENTIALLY SEE SOME 858 00:31:47,873 --> 00:31:50,275 LONG LASTING IMPACT AND 859 00:31:50,275 --> 00:31:51,910 BETTER -- GOOD DATA AROUND 860 00:31:51,910 --> 00:31:54,079 IMPACTS BUT REALLY AGAIN 861 00:31:54,079 --> 00:31:58,450 SPECIALTY CARE WAS WHERE YOU SAW 862 00:31:58,450 --> 00:32:03,155 SOME OF THE MOST -- A LOT MORE 863 00:32:03,155 --> 00:32:04,156 LONG-LASTING BENEFITS IN TERMS 864 00:32:04,156 --> 00:32:05,690 OF PATIENT AND PROVIDER. 865 00:32:05,690 --> 00:32:07,325 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 866 00:32:07,325 --> 00:32:12,264 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 867 00:32:12,264 --> 00:32:14,566 AND SO, INTERESTING -- GO ONE 868 00:32:14,566 --> 00:32:15,100 SLIDE BACK. 869 00:32:15,100 --> 00:32:17,335 INTERESTING IS, YOU KNOW, HOW 870 00:32:17,335 --> 00:32:24,442 THE KIND THIS CHANGE OF MEDICINE 871 00:32:24,442 --> 00:32:25,911 EVOLVED, STATE LICENSURE WAS A 872 00:32:25,911 --> 00:32:27,145 LIMITING FACTOR. 873 00:32:27,145 --> 00:32:29,481 THIS IDEA OF STATE LICENSE AND 874 00:32:29,481 --> 00:32:32,083 BEING ABLE TO PRACTICE AND 875 00:32:32,083 --> 00:32:33,151 PROVIDE CARE ACROSS STATE LINES 876 00:32:33,151 --> 00:32:35,287 HAS AN CONTINUES TO BE KIND OF 877 00:32:35,287 --> 00:32:39,424 ONE OF THOSE RATE-LIMITING 878 00:32:39,424 --> 00:32:39,825 FACTORS. 879 00:32:39,825 --> 00:32:43,695 SO YOU SAW, YOU KNOW, 12 STATE 880 00:32:43,695 --> 00:32:45,463 BOARDS THAT ALLOWED LICENSE TO 881 00:32:45,463 --> 00:32:48,400 PRACTICE ACROSS STATE LINES BUT 882 00:32:48,400 --> 00:32:51,670 STILL THIS ISSUE OF STATE 883 00:32:51,670 --> 00:32:52,737 LICENSURE BEING A CONSTANT 884 00:32:52,737 --> 00:32:56,608 CONCEPT EVEN THOUGH SOME OF THAT 885 00:32:56,608 --> 00:32:59,244 EVOLVED DURING THE PANDEMIC, BUT 886 00:32:59,244 --> 00:33:05,250 EVEN SO STILL BEING -- AS A 887 00:33:05,250 --> 00:33:05,884 CLINICIAN WHO PRACTICES 888 00:33:05,884 --> 00:33:08,086 TELEMEDICINE, CARDIOLOGY, YOU 889 00:33:08,086 --> 00:33:12,257 SEE THAT IN REAL TIME AS YOU ARE 890 00:33:12,257 --> 00:33:14,326 LOOKING AT DIFFERENT 891 00:33:14,326 --> 00:33:16,261 TELEMEDICINE-RELATED PROGRAMS, 892 00:33:16,261 --> 00:33:16,628 IN GENERAL. 893 00:33:16,628 --> 00:33:20,665 I HAVE BEEN ONE OF THE CLINICIAN 894 00:33:20,665 --> 00:33:22,634 LEADERS OF ECHO PROGRAM IN 895 00:33:22,634 --> 00:33:24,402 MISSOURI ACROSS THE STATE OF 896 00:33:24,402 --> 00:33:25,804 MISSOURI, UNIVERSITY OF 897 00:33:25,804 --> 00:33:26,171 MISSOURI. 898 00:33:26,171 --> 00:33:27,439 AND IT'S BEEN INTERESTING HOW 899 00:33:27,439 --> 00:33:34,479 WE'VE ALSO BEEN ABLE TO LEVERAGE 900 00:33:34,479 --> 00:33:37,549 THERE THE CONCEPTS AROUND NOT 901 00:33:37,549 --> 00:33:39,417 JUST LICENSE BUT ALSO THIS IDEA 902 00:33:39,417 --> 00:33:40,619 OF UTILIZING COMMUNITY HEALTH 903 00:33:40,619 --> 00:33:43,255 WORKERS AND OTHER KINDS OF CARE 904 00:33:43,255 --> 00:33:45,991 EXTENDERS, IN TERMS OF REACHING 905 00:33:45,991 --> 00:33:46,391 COMMUNITIES. 906 00:33:46,391 --> 00:33:48,159 SO AS WE WORK THROUGH ISSUES OF 907 00:33:48,159 --> 00:33:50,829 LICENSURE I THINK ALSO THINKING 908 00:33:50,829 --> 00:33:51,897 THROUGH OTHER COMPONENTS IN 909 00:33:51,897 --> 00:33:53,331 TERMS OF EXTENSION OF CARE AS 910 00:33:53,331 --> 00:33:55,066 WELL. 911 00:33:55,066 --> 00:33:57,769 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 912 00:33:57,769 --> 00:34:01,539 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 913 00:34:01,539 --> 00:34:05,777 SO, INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH INITIAL 914 00:34:05,777 --> 00:34:07,445 GROWTH OF TELEMEDICINE OFFSET 915 00:34:07,445 --> 00:34:17,055 2/3 OF DECLINE OF IN IN-PERSON 916 00:34:17,055 --> 00:34:18,823 VISITS, PEAKED AROUND APRIL 15 917 00:34:18,823 --> 00:34:22,761 BEFORE DECLINING BUT CAP TOWARD 918 00:34:22,761 --> 00:34:24,529 WHAT WAS OCCURRING IN REAL TIME, 919 00:34:24,529 --> 00:34:27,165 ABLE TO MAKE UP FOR A LOT OF 920 00:34:27,165 --> 00:34:29,434 WHERE PEOPLE WERE LOSING ACCESS 921 00:34:29,434 --> 00:34:30,869 TO CARE, TELEMEDICINE WAS ABLE 922 00:34:30,869 --> 00:34:31,636 TO STEP IN. 923 00:34:31,636 --> 00:34:33,271 I WANT YOU TO THINK ABOUT THAT 924 00:34:33,271 --> 00:34:34,806 IN TERMS OF SOME EARLIER SLIDES 925 00:34:34,806 --> 00:34:38,977 I PRESENTED WHEN I WAS TALKING 926 00:34:38,977 --> 00:34:40,946 ABOUT HEART DISEASE OUTCOMES AND 927 00:34:40,946 --> 00:34:42,580 MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY FROM OUR 928 00:34:42,580 --> 00:34:44,549 HEART DISEASE, AND OPPORTUNITIES 929 00:34:44,549 --> 00:34:46,051 WE HAD WITH TELEMEDICINE OF 930 00:34:46,051 --> 00:34:48,053 BEING ABLE TO GET BETTER ACCESS 931 00:34:48,053 --> 00:34:52,190 IF WE CAN GET THROUGH SOME 932 00:34:52,190 --> 00:34:54,059 STRUCTURAL CONCEPTS THAT LIMIT 933 00:34:54,059 --> 00:34:55,727 BOTH MINORITY AND RURAL 934 00:34:55,727 --> 00:34:57,329 COMMUNITIES. 935 00:34:57,329 --> 00:35:00,231 BUT THIS SLIDE CAPTURES HOW 936 00:35:00,231 --> 00:35:02,701 PARTICULARLY IN FAMILY MEDICINE 937 00:35:02,701 --> 00:35:07,105 HOW THE KIND OF USE BUMPED UP 938 00:35:07,105 --> 00:35:09,407 OVER TIME, KIND OF WENT UP AND 939 00:35:09,407 --> 00:35:12,577 DOWN IN RELATION TO VIRAL 940 00:35:12,577 --> 00:35:14,446 PANDEMICS, WHEN THE VIRUS WAS 941 00:35:14,446 --> 00:35:16,648 PARTICULARLY EMERGING AND MORE 942 00:35:16,648 --> 00:35:17,515 LETHAL AND MORE PROMINENT YOU 943 00:35:17,515 --> 00:35:19,918 SAW THE SPIKE IN VISITS, AND 944 00:35:19,918 --> 00:35:21,753 SPIKE GOING BACK DOWN. 945 00:35:21,753 --> 00:35:24,723 AND SO A LOT TO TEASE APART 946 00:35:24,723 --> 00:35:27,258 HERE, THERE'S A COUPLE THINGS 947 00:35:27,258 --> 00:35:28,860 THAT WE'LL CAPTURE IN THE NEXT 948 00:35:28,860 --> 00:35:31,596 SLIDE AS WELL. 949 00:35:31,596 --> 00:35:32,697 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 950 00:35:32,697 --> 00:35:39,504 AND THEN WHAT YOU ALSO SAW WAS 951 00:35:39,504 --> 00:35:41,806 THAT PROVIDERS WERE GENERALLY 952 00:35:41,806 --> 00:35:44,309 VERY POSITIVE IN TERMS OF THEIR 953 00:35:44,309 --> 00:35:45,643 CAPACITY TO SEE PATIENTS, ET 954 00:35:45,643 --> 00:35:47,612 CETERA. 955 00:35:47,612 --> 00:35:50,148 A LOT OF BENEFITS SEEN IN THE 956 00:35:50,148 --> 00:35:52,117 HEALTH ARENA, YOU START TO SEE A 957 00:35:52,117 --> 00:35:56,955 LOT CONTINUE TO EVOLVE. 958 00:35:56,955 --> 00:35:59,157 STILL SOME DISCOMFORT AROUND 959 00:35:59,157 --> 00:36:03,261 SOME TREATMENT, BUT YOU START TO 960 00:36:03,261 --> 00:36:05,463 SEE A LOT OF POSITIVES AROUND 961 00:36:05,463 --> 00:36:09,100 BEHAVIOR AND MENTAL HEALTH. 962 00:36:09,100 --> 00:36:09,834 INTERESTINGLY ENOUGH POPULATION 963 00:36:09,834 --> 00:36:12,837 THAT YOU START TO SEE THE MOST 964 00:36:12,837 --> 00:36:15,006 BENEFIT WERE NOT SOME MINORITY 965 00:36:15,006 --> 00:36:16,074 AND UNDERSERVED POPULATIONS 966 00:36:16,074 --> 00:36:19,811 WHERE YOU HAVE THE MOST 967 00:36:19,811 --> 00:36:20,912 OPPORTUNITY BUT OTHER 968 00:36:20,912 --> 00:36:21,813 POPULATIONS WHO MAY HAVE HAD 969 00:36:21,813 --> 00:36:23,114 ACCESS IN OTHER WAYS WHERE THIS 970 00:36:23,114 --> 00:36:25,617 WAS A MORE CONVENIENT FORM OF 971 00:36:25,617 --> 00:36:25,850 ACCESS. 972 00:36:25,850 --> 00:36:32,957 AGAIN, KEEPING IN MIND HOW DO WE 973 00:36:32,957 --> 00:36:33,625 THINK THROUGH EXPANDING 974 00:36:33,625 --> 00:36:34,592 INFRASTRUCTURE AND TOOLS WE CAN 975 00:36:34,592 --> 00:36:37,462 DO HERE AND HOW DO WE THEN BRING 976 00:36:37,462 --> 00:36:39,864 THAT MORE TO MINORITY AND 977 00:36:39,864 --> 00:36:41,933 UNDERSERVED POPULATIONS. 978 00:36:41,933 --> 00:36:42,700 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 979 00:36:42,700 --> 00:36:46,438 AND THIS IS KIND OF INTERESTING 980 00:36:46,438 --> 00:36:49,274 WHEN WE LOOK AT HOW CLINICIANS 981 00:36:49,274 --> 00:36:51,242 FELT LATER ON AROUND 982 00:36:51,242 --> 00:36:55,847 TELEMEDICINE AND TELEHEALTH. 983 00:36:55,847 --> 00:36:57,348 SO POSITIVE OVERALL IN A VARIETY 984 00:36:57,348 --> 00:36:58,450 OF WAYS. 985 00:36:58,450 --> 00:37:00,518 WHAT YOU DID START TO SEE WAS 986 00:37:00,518 --> 00:37:05,557 TWO THINGS THAT HAVE KIND OF LED 987 00:37:05,557 --> 00:37:08,193 TO THE OVERALL DECLINE, A LOT 988 00:37:08,193 --> 00:37:09,794 RELATED TO REIMBURSEMENT. 989 00:37:09,794 --> 00:37:13,465 STARTED TO GET MORE ENTANGLED, 990 00:37:13,465 --> 00:37:14,566 FURTHER REIMBURSEMENT DYNAMICS, 991 00:37:14,566 --> 00:37:21,239 YOU STARTED TO SEE A LOT OF 992 00:37:21,239 --> 00:37:22,006 THESE PERCEPTIONS, CONCEPTS, 993 00:37:22,006 --> 00:37:23,208 PRACTICES REVERT AND KIND OF 994 00:37:23,208 --> 00:37:25,844 CHANGE BACK TO THE WAY THINGS 995 00:37:25,844 --> 00:37:26,277 WERE BEFORE. 996 00:37:26,277 --> 00:37:32,317 SO A LOT OF RECOGNITION FROM 997 00:37:32,317 --> 00:37:35,253 CLINICIANS THAT THE PRACTICE OF 998 00:37:35,253 --> 00:37:36,221 TELEMEDICINE, THE WAY THEY 999 00:37:36,221 --> 00:37:38,656 INTEGRATED TELEHEALTH INTO THEIR 1000 00:37:38,656 --> 00:37:40,291 PRACTICES THOUGH CHALLENGING 1001 00:37:40,291 --> 00:37:42,594 INITIALLY, EVOLVING OVER TIME, 1002 00:37:42,594 --> 00:37:45,196 OF NET BENEFIT IN GENERAL. 1003 00:37:45,196 --> 00:37:47,832 BUT WHAT YOU STARTED TO SEE IN 1004 00:37:47,832 --> 00:37:51,436 THE LAST SLIDE WAS A LOT OF 1005 00:37:51,436 --> 00:37:52,470 REGRESSION, PRACTICE PATTERNS, 1006 00:37:52,470 --> 00:38:00,345 RELATED PRIMARILY A LOT TO 1007 00:38:00,345 --> 00:38:00,945 REIMBURSEMENT, AND COMMERCIAL 1008 00:38:00,945 --> 00:38:05,583 REIMBURSEMENT, MADE IT MORE 1009 00:38:05,583 --> 00:38:06,651 CHALLENGING, TELEMEDICINE AND 1010 00:38:06,651 --> 00:38:08,319 TELEHEALTH, BUT A LOT OF THIS 1011 00:38:08,319 --> 00:38:15,560 RELATED TO NOT JUST -- NOT SO 1012 00:38:15,560 --> 00:38:17,061 MUCH THE FEELINGS OF CLINICIANS 1013 00:38:17,061 --> 00:38:18,263 BUT THE QUALITY IN GENERAL. 1014 00:38:18,263 --> 00:38:20,899 GOING BACK TO THE HISTORY OF 1015 00:38:20,899 --> 00:38:22,200 TELEMEDICINE, TELEHEALTH, A LOT 1016 00:38:22,200 --> 00:38:23,868 BOTH IN PANDEMIC AND 1017 00:38:23,868 --> 00:38:27,071 PRE-PANDEMIC, A LOT OF 1018 00:38:27,071 --> 00:38:28,439 RATE-LIMITING FACTORS BEING 1019 00:38:28,439 --> 00:38:31,309 DRIVEN BY POLICY AND PAYMENT 1020 00:38:31,309 --> 00:38:33,745 DYNAMICS, IN THE INSURER, 1021 00:38:33,745 --> 00:38:37,015 PRIVATE INSURER, BUT ALSO IN THE 1022 00:38:37,015 --> 00:38:40,919 BROADER THEME OF PUBLIC POLICY. 1023 00:38:40,919 --> 00:38:43,121 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 1024 00:38:43,121 --> 00:38:44,122 SO, HOSPITALS, IT'S AN 1025 00:38:44,122 --> 00:38:46,958 INTERESTING THING WHEN YOU LOOK 1026 00:38:46,958 --> 00:38:53,531 AT WHO WERE ABLE TO ADOPT, YOU 1027 00:38:53,531 --> 00:38:54,732 KNOW, TELEHEALTH AND 1028 00:38:54,732 --> 00:38:55,934 TELEMEDICINE PRACTICES. 1029 00:38:55,934 --> 00:38:58,102 IN HOSPITALS THAT WERE 1030 00:38:58,102 --> 00:39:02,941 AFFILIATED WITH -- HOSPITALS 1031 00:39:02,941 --> 00:39:04,375 AFFILIATED WITH LARGE SYSTEMS, 1032 00:39:04,375 --> 00:39:07,412 YOU KNOW, THOSE WERE THE ONES 1033 00:39:07,412 --> 00:39:11,149 THAT WERE MORE LIKELY. 1034 00:39:11,149 --> 00:39:12,016 MAJOR TEACHING HOSPITALS MORE 1035 00:39:12,016 --> 00:39:13,885 LIKELY TO ADOPT TELEHEALTH. 1036 00:39:13,885 --> 00:39:15,720 THE ONES MORE CHALLENGED WERE IN 1037 00:39:15,720 --> 00:39:18,690 RURAL AREAS, OR THOSE THAT WERE 1038 00:39:18,690 --> 00:39:20,225 INVESTOR-OWNED OR THOSE THAT 1039 00:39:20,225 --> 00:39:21,759 WERE UNAFFILIATED WITH A 1040 00:39:21,759 --> 00:39:26,130 HOSPITAL SYSTEM, HUGE 1041 00:39:26,130 --> 00:39:30,768 DISPARITIES IN TERMS OF HOSPITAL 1042 00:39:30,768 --> 00:39:34,872 DYNAMICS AND INFRASTRUCTURE WAS 1043 00:39:34,872 --> 00:39:36,741 THOUGHT TO PLAY A MAJOR ROLE, 1044 00:39:36,741 --> 00:39:38,276 AND BROADBAND ACCESS, NOT JUST 1045 00:39:38,276 --> 00:39:40,144 OF PATIENTS, WHAT'S OCCURRING IN 1046 00:39:40,144 --> 00:39:41,212 THESE COMMUNITIES. 1047 00:39:41,212 --> 00:39:42,413 SO VERY BIG DIFFERENCES IN THE 1048 00:39:42,413 --> 00:39:45,383 PANDEMIC OF THE HOSPITAL SYSTEMS 1049 00:39:45,383 --> 00:39:50,288 ABLE TO ENGAGE AND NOT ENGAGE, 1050 00:39:50,288 --> 00:39:54,292 RELATED TO ABILITY TO TAP INTO A 1051 00:39:54,292 --> 00:39:56,594 LARGER POOL AND LARGER 1052 00:39:56,594 --> 00:39:57,095 INFRASTRUCTURE OVERALL. 1053 00:39:57,095 --> 00:39:59,764 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 1054 00:39:59,764 --> 00:40:00,965 SO -- NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 1055 00:40:00,965 --> 00:40:03,368 SO WHEN WE KIND OF THINK THROUGH 1056 00:40:03,368 --> 00:40:07,171 A LOT OF THIS, LET ME CLOSE WITH 1057 00:40:07,171 --> 00:40:08,973 A COUPLE TAKEHOME MESSAGES. 1058 00:40:08,973 --> 00:40:11,709 TELEMEDICINE IS NOT GOING TO 1059 00:40:11,709 --> 00:40:15,780 REPLACE IN-PERSON CARE, BUT IS 1060 00:40:15,780 --> 00:40:17,081 REALLY AN ADJUNCT NOT JUST IN 1061 00:40:17,081 --> 00:40:18,116 PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCIES HERE 1062 00:40:18,116 --> 00:40:22,787 BUT ALSO IN TERMS OF THAT MACRO 1063 00:40:22,787 --> 00:40:26,791 CHALLENGE I WAS ARTICULATING 1064 00:40:26,791 --> 00:40:29,560 BEFORE, AROUND, YOU KNOW, HOW WE 1065 00:40:29,560 --> 00:40:31,129 CAN REACH UNDERSERVED 1066 00:40:31,129 --> 00:40:34,532 POPULATIONS. 1067 00:40:34,532 --> 00:40:37,368 CERTAINLY IN MY WORLD, GOOGLE 1068 00:40:37,368 --> 00:40:38,803 AND RELATED PLACES, THERE ARE 1069 00:40:38,803 --> 00:40:44,375 ADDITIONAL A.I. OTHER TOOLS. 1070 00:40:44,375 --> 00:40:44,976 FOR THE CONVERSATIONS TODAY, 1071 00:40:44,976 --> 00:40:49,080 THERE'S A LOT TO UNDERSTAND IN 1072 00:40:49,080 --> 00:40:52,784 TERMS OF WHAT THE ROLE IS, 1073 00:40:52,784 --> 00:40:53,451 TELEMEDICINE, TELEHEALTH CAN 1074 00:40:53,451 --> 00:40:54,018 PLAY IN GENERAL. 1075 00:40:54,018 --> 00:40:56,721 I WANT TO TAKE A SECOND TO TALK 1076 00:40:56,721 --> 00:41:00,458 THROUGH THIS ISSUE OF BARRIERS. 1077 00:41:00,458 --> 00:41:03,728 THERE'S A LOT PUBLISHED AROUND, 1078 00:41:03,728 --> 00:41:04,929 YOU KNOW, BARRIERS TO 1079 00:41:04,929 --> 00:41:07,231 TELEMEDICINE, TELEHEALTH, WHAT 1080 00:41:07,231 --> 00:41:09,767 IT MEANS FOR MINORITY AND 1081 00:41:09,767 --> 00:41:10,068 UNDERSERVED. 1082 00:41:10,068 --> 00:41:12,837 AT THE BEGINNING, THOSE WERE THE 1083 00:41:12,837 --> 00:41:15,173 BEST AND BIGGEST OPPORTUNITIES, 1084 00:41:15,173 --> 00:41:15,773 JUST BECAUSE OF THE MORBIDITY 1085 00:41:15,773 --> 00:41:17,775 AND MORTALITY GAP AND HOW SO 1086 00:41:17,775 --> 00:41:22,146 MANY OF THE ACCESS DYNAMICS ARE 1087 00:41:22,146 --> 00:41:23,448 DRIVING MORTALITY, HOPING TO 1088 00:41:23,448 --> 00:41:29,153 SHOW YOU IN THAT PAPER THAT WE 1089 00:41:29,153 --> 00:41:31,322 PUBLISHED IN JAMA ON HEART 1090 00:41:31,322 --> 00:41:32,290 DISEASE AND MORTALITY. 1091 00:41:32,290 --> 00:41:33,658 INFRASTRUCTURE DYNAMICS ARE AT 1092 00:41:33,658 --> 00:41:35,193 PLAY, A LOT OF PRACTICE PATTERN 1093 00:41:35,193 --> 00:41:36,694 DYNAMICS AT PLAY AS WELL IN 1094 00:41:36,694 --> 00:41:40,098 TERMS OF ACCESS FOR RURAL AND 1095 00:41:40,098 --> 00:41:40,932 MINORITY POPULATIONS. 1096 00:41:40,932 --> 00:41:43,501 AND EVEN WHEN YOU LOOK PAST DATA 1097 00:41:43,501 --> 00:41:45,470 IN TERMS OF WHERE SOME 1098 00:41:45,470 --> 00:41:47,004 INFRASTRUCTURE HAS EVOLVED, YOU 1099 00:41:47,004 --> 00:41:50,174 SEE YOU STILL START TO SEE A LOT 1100 00:41:50,174 --> 00:41:53,811 OF CHALLENGES PARTICULARLY 1101 00:41:53,811 --> 00:41:54,912 AROUND WHERE TELEMEDICINE 1102 00:41:54,912 --> 00:41:56,881 OPTIONS ARE OFFERED, ALSO 1103 00:41:56,881 --> 00:42:02,120 LANGUAGE ACCESS AND HOW WE THINK 1104 00:42:02,120 --> 00:42:04,155 THROUGH LANGUAGE BARRIERS. 1105 00:42:04,155 --> 00:42:07,291 EARLIEST TELEMEDICINE PROGRAMS 1106 00:42:07,291 --> 00:42:12,130 IN THE 1970s PIONEERED IN IHS 1107 00:42:12,130 --> 00:42:14,098 AND IN THE NEEDS OF NATIVE 1108 00:42:14,098 --> 00:42:15,833 AMERICAN POPULATION, JUST 1109 00:42:15,833 --> 00:42:18,035 BECAUSE THAT WAS WHERE THE 1110 00:42:18,035 --> 00:42:18,469 OPPORTUNITIES WERE. 1111 00:42:18,469 --> 00:42:21,105 YOU CAN START TO SEE WHEREAS 1112 00:42:21,105 --> 00:42:23,174 TECHNOLOGIES EVOLVED WE NEED TO 1113 00:42:23,174 --> 00:42:24,308 APPLY THAT IN TERMS OF 1114 00:42:24,308 --> 00:42:24,842 OPPORTUNITIES. 1115 00:42:24,842 --> 00:42:27,779 THE LAST THING I'LL SAY,JUST TO 1116 00:42:27,779 --> 00:42:32,950 FINISH EXACTLY ON TIME, IS THAT, 1117 00:42:32,950 --> 00:42:35,353 YOU KNOW, OVERARCHINGLY THE 1118 00:42:35,353 --> 00:42:38,423 POLICY AND TEAM DYNAMICS IS WHAT 1119 00:42:38,423 --> 00:42:45,096 HAS BEEN DRIVING ADOPTION 1120 00:42:45,096 --> 00:42:45,963 PRE-PANDEMIC, INTRAPANDEMIC, AND 1121 00:42:45,963 --> 00:42:47,064 POST-PANDEMIC. 1122 00:42:47,064 --> 00:42:50,368 TEAMS ARE WORKING ON ADDITIONAL 1123 00:42:50,368 --> 00:42:52,303 TECHNOLOGIC TOOLS TO ADD ON AND 1124 00:42:52,303 --> 00:42:53,871 SERVE AS ADJUNCT FOR PATIENT 1125 00:42:53,871 --> 00:42:55,473 CARE, GET PATIENTS ACCESS TO 1126 00:42:55,473 --> 00:42:57,341 CARE, THE MACRO CONCEPTS ARE 1127 00:42:57,341 --> 00:43:00,745 STILL GOING TO BE DRIVEN IN THE 1128 00:43:00,745 --> 00:43:02,513 PUBLIC POLICY SPHERE AROUND -- 1129 00:43:02,513 --> 00:43:04,916 THERE'S A LOT OF LEGISLATIVE 1130 00:43:04,916 --> 00:43:07,151 ADVANCES AND REGRESSION AND 1131 00:43:07,151 --> 00:43:09,620 ADVANCES, ESPECIALLY WHEN YOU 1132 00:43:09,620 --> 00:43:12,790 THINK ABOUT LEGISLATIVE PARITY 1133 00:43:12,790 --> 00:43:13,658 AROUND TELEMEDICINE AND 1134 00:43:13,658 --> 00:43:13,958 TELEHEALTH. 1135 00:43:13,958 --> 00:43:15,526 SPOKE ABOUT A LOT OF DIFFERENT 1136 00:43:15,526 --> 00:43:17,061 THINGS HERE BUT THE CONCEPTS I 1137 00:43:17,061 --> 00:43:20,398 WOULD SAY KEEP IN MIND IS THAT, 1138 00:43:20,398 --> 00:43:23,401 YOU KNOW, THERE'S -- THERE ARE 1139 00:43:23,401 --> 00:43:26,270 AND CONTINUE TO BE 1140 00:43:26,270 --> 00:43:26,938 OPPORTUNITIES. 1141 00:43:26,938 --> 00:43:31,943 THERE ARE, YOU KNOW, SIGNIFICANT 1142 00:43:31,943 --> 00:43:32,243 CHALLENGES. 1143 00:43:32,243 --> 00:43:32,810 YOU SAW SUCH RAPID EVOLUTION 1144 00:43:32,810 --> 00:43:35,346 DURING THE PANDEMIC. 1145 00:43:35,346 --> 00:43:36,647 AND THEN SOME REGRESSION. 1146 00:43:36,647 --> 00:43:39,951 YOU CAN START TO SEE WHERE THE 1147 00:43:39,951 --> 00:43:42,220 OPPORTUNITIES HAVE THE ABILITY 1148 00:43:42,220 --> 00:43:43,888 TO BE ADDRESSED, IN GENERAL. 1149 00:43:43,888 --> 00:43:45,857 SO I WILL STOP THERE. 1150 00:43:45,857 --> 00:43:49,894 AND HOPEFULLY DID NOT GO OVER MY 1151 00:43:49,894 --> 00:43:51,095 TIME AS ALLOTTED. 1152 00:43:51,095 --> 00:43:52,396 THANK YOU. 1153 00:43:52,396 --> 00:43:55,566 >> NOT AT ALL FOR YOUR TIME, DR. 1154 00:43:55,566 --> 00:43:55,900 GRAHAM. 1155 00:43:55,900 --> 00:43:58,302 AGAIN, THANK YOU FOR AGREEING TO 1156 00:43:58,302 --> 00:44:00,071 BE HERE WITH US TODAY AND GUIDE 1157 00:44:00,071 --> 00:44:03,774 US, SETTING THE STAGE FOR OUR 1158 00:44:03,774 --> 00:44:04,041 WORKSHOP. 1159 00:44:04,041 --> 00:44:05,710 I PARTICULARLY LIKE HOW YOU SAID 1160 00:44:05,710 --> 00:44:07,745 THAT THE IDEA OF TELEHEALTH IS 1161 00:44:07,745 --> 00:44:10,147 TO SERVE AS AN ADJUNCT. 1162 00:44:10,147 --> 00:44:11,449 NOT A REPLACEMENT. 1163 00:44:11,449 --> 00:44:12,884 BECAUSE SOMETIMES THERE'S A LOT 1164 00:44:12,884 --> 00:44:16,354 OF CONFUSION WHERE WE'RE GOING 1165 00:44:16,354 --> 00:44:18,222 THROUGH TELEHEALTH BUT IF YOU 1166 00:44:18,222 --> 00:44:19,790 ASK ANY HEALTHCARE PROVIDER THEY 1167 00:44:19,790 --> 00:44:21,192 WILL TALK ABOUT PHYSICAL 1168 00:44:21,192 --> 00:44:24,295 EXAMINATION, CONTACT WITH THE 1169 00:44:24,295 --> 00:44:25,730 PATIENT, THAT'S SOMETHING 1170 00:44:25,730 --> 00:44:26,063 UNREPLACEABLE. 1171 00:44:26,063 --> 00:44:31,502 PERHAPS 100 YEARS FROM NOW, TEN 1172 00:44:31,502 --> 00:44:32,837 YEARS FROM NOW, ADVANCEMENTS, 1173 00:44:32,837 --> 00:44:34,238 PERHAPS A HOLOGRAM IN THE SHORT 1174 00:44:34,238 --> 00:44:35,973 FUTURE THAT I'M NOT FORESEEING 1175 00:44:35,973 --> 00:44:37,742 AND PEOPLE WILL LOOK BACK AT 1176 00:44:37,742 --> 00:44:40,144 THIS VIDEO AND THINK WHAT WAS HE 1177 00:44:40,144 --> 00:44:41,779 THINKING ABOUT? 1178 00:44:41,779 --> 00:44:43,648 WASN'T HOLOGRAMS THAT YOU CAN 1179 00:44:43,648 --> 00:44:45,182 TOUCH AND EXAMINE HERE, 1180 00:44:45,182 --> 00:44:45,983 SOMETHING SO STRAIGHTFORWARD? 1181 00:44:45,983 --> 00:44:50,121 I AGREE WITH YOU, TELEMEDICINE 1182 00:44:50,121 --> 00:44:52,623 IS A GREAT ADJUNCT AND CAN SERVE 1183 00:44:52,623 --> 00:44:56,994 AS A TOOL FOR DEALING WITH 1184 00:44:56,994 --> 00:44:58,863 UNDERSERVED WHEN THEY DON'T HAVE 1185 00:44:58,863 --> 00:45:02,133 ACCESS TO CARE, NOW YOU'RE 1186 00:45:02,133 --> 00:45:03,901 ENABLING ACCESS, PARTICULARLY 1187 00:45:03,901 --> 00:45:05,102 PROVIDERS NOT AVAILABLE IN THE 1188 00:45:05,102 --> 00:45:05,970 REGION. 1189 00:45:05,970 --> 00:45:09,473 AS YOU POINTED OUT, IF THERE'S 1190 00:45:09,473 --> 00:45:10,374 NO INTERNET, NO INFRASTRUCTURE 1191 00:45:10,374 --> 00:45:12,310 TO GO HAND IN HAND WITH THE GOAL 1192 00:45:12,310 --> 00:45:13,511 OF THE TECHNOLOGY, IT WON'T 1193 00:45:13,511 --> 00:45:13,945 WORK. 1194 00:45:13,945 --> 00:45:18,349 THE SAME THING GOES FOR THE 1195 00:45:18,349 --> 00:45:20,618 POLICIES AND THE FINANCING WHICH 1196 00:45:20,618 --> 00:45:22,386 SHOW A LOT OF PROBLEMS HAPPENS. 1197 00:45:22,386 --> 00:45:23,387 THERE WERE POLICIES LIFTED 1198 00:45:23,387 --> 00:45:24,922 DURING THE PANDEMIC AND NOW ARE 1199 00:45:24,922 --> 00:45:27,124 BACK INTO PLACE, AND PEOPLE ARE 1200 00:45:27,124 --> 00:45:28,693 STILL TRYING TO GO BACK AND 1201 00:45:28,693 --> 00:45:32,797 UNDERSTAND HOW TO DEAL WITH THE 1202 00:45:32,797 --> 00:45:34,098 CROSS-STATE LICENSOR, WHAT IS 1203 00:45:34,098 --> 00:45:35,967 ELIGIBLE FOR REPLACEMENT OR NOT, 1204 00:45:35,967 --> 00:45:38,703 DEALING WITH BURNOUT FROM 1205 00:45:38,703 --> 00:45:39,470 HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS BECAUSE NOW 1206 00:45:39,470 --> 00:45:42,306 THEY GET A LOT MORE MESSAGES, A 1207 00:45:42,306 --> 00:45:43,608 LOT MORE PORTALS, COMMUNICATIONS 1208 00:45:43,608 --> 00:45:44,175 THAN BEFORE. 1209 00:45:44,175 --> 00:45:45,276 SO ALL GREAT POINTS, DR. GRAHAM. 1210 00:45:45,276 --> 00:45:48,646 I DON'T KNOW IF YOU WANT TO GIVE 1211 00:45:48,646 --> 00:45:50,281 A LAST STATEMENT SINCE I MADE 1212 00:45:50,281 --> 00:45:51,949 SOME COMMENTS BEFORE WE GO TO 1213 00:45:51,949 --> 00:45:52,817 OUR BREAK. 1214 00:45:52,817 --> 00:45:57,421 >> NO, NO I'LL JUST SAY THAT AS 1215 00:45:57,421 --> 00:46:00,891 A PRACTITIONER, AGAIN, I WORK 1216 00:46:00,891 --> 00:46:04,962 WITH TECHNOLOGY, BUT AS A 1217 00:46:04,962 --> 00:46:06,364 PRACTITIONER YOU SEE THE 1218 00:46:06,364 --> 00:46:07,465 DIFFERENCE, WHEREAS A SPECIALIST 1219 00:46:07,465 --> 00:46:09,000 BEING ABLE TO CONNECT WITH 1220 00:46:09,000 --> 00:46:10,101 PEOPLE IN RURAL COMMUNITIES, AND 1221 00:46:10,101 --> 00:46:13,404 EVEN IN THAT ONE VISIT WE SEE 1222 00:46:13,404 --> 00:46:13,804 DIFFERENCE. 1223 00:46:13,804 --> 00:46:16,007 FOR ME WHAT WE CAN DO HERE IS 1224 00:46:16,007 --> 00:46:16,207 GREAT. 1225 00:46:16,207 --> 00:46:21,946 AS I WORK ON THE TECH PART AND 1226 00:46:21,946 --> 00:46:23,447 FROM ANOTHER VIEWPOINT, TO WHAT 1227 00:46:23,447 --> 00:46:27,385 YOU JUST SAID AND HOPEFULLY TO 1228 00:46:27,385 --> 00:46:29,687 KEEP US APART IN THE 1229 00:46:29,687 --> 00:46:30,321 CONVERSATION WE'RE TALKING ABOUT 1230 00:46:30,321 --> 00:46:35,860 SOMETHING VERY REAL IN PEOPLE'S 1231 00:46:35,860 --> 00:46:36,227 LIVES. 1232 00:46:36,227 --> 00:46:39,263 A PATIENT I SAW A COUPLE MONTHS 1233 00:46:39,263 --> 00:46:40,331 AGO, YOU TALK ABOUT SOMETHING 1234 00:46:40,331 --> 00:46:47,371 THAT CHANGES A LIVE -- LIFE IF 1235 00:46:47,371 --> 00:46:49,006 THEY DIDN'T HAVE THAT ENCOUNTER, 1236 00:46:49,006 --> 00:46:50,641 FOR SOME THE MOST IMPORTANT 1237 00:46:50,641 --> 00:46:52,743 THING IN TERMS OF THEIR CHANCE 1238 00:46:52,743 --> 00:46:53,811 TO GUESS BETTER WITH HEALTH 1239 00:46:53,811 --> 00:46:55,613 CARE, A LOT OF REAL FACTORS IN 1240 00:46:55,613 --> 00:46:56,480 THE WORKSHOP TODAY. 1241 00:46:56,480 --> 00:46:57,882 >> THANK YOU FOR SETTING THE 1242 00:46:57,882 --> 00:46:59,850 STAGE, DR. GRAHAM, AND JOINING 1243 00:46:59,850 --> 00:47:00,117 US TODAY. 1244 00:47:00,117 --> 00:47:04,255 WE'LL GO INTO A SHORT BREAK, AND 1245 00:47:04,255 --> 00:47:07,358 WE'LL BE BACK AT 11:55 IN 1246 00:47:07,358 --> 00:47:08,826 EASTERN STANDARD TIME HERE IN 1247 00:47:08,826 --> 00:47:09,360 BETHESDA. 1248 00:47:09,360 --> 00:47:10,161 THANK YOU, EVERYONE. 1249 00:47:10,161 --> 00:47:10,194 STAY TUNED. 1250 00:47:12,650 --> 00:47:15,887 >> WELCOME BACK. 1251 00:47:15,887 --> 00:47:18,022 IN THE BETHESDA AREA IT IS 1252 00:47:18,022 --> 00:47:19,657 11:55, TIME TO COME BACK TO OUR 1253 00:47:19,657 --> 00:47:20,758 FIRST SESSION. 1254 00:47:20,758 --> 00:47:22,927 THE IDEA AGAIN TODAY OF THE 1255 00:47:22,927 --> 00:47:24,729 WORKSHOP IS TO FOCUS ON THE 1256 00:47:24,729 --> 00:47:26,030 DIRECT TO CONSUMER, DIRECT TO 1257 00:47:26,030 --> 00:47:27,098 PATIENT TELEHEALTH. 1258 00:47:27,098 --> 00:47:29,734 SO FOCUS IS NOT SO MUCH THE 1259 00:47:29,734 --> 00:47:31,135 PROVIDER-TO-PROVIDER COVERED IN 1260 00:47:31,135 --> 00:47:31,569 PREVIOUS WORKSHOPS. 1261 00:47:31,569 --> 00:47:34,238 AND IT IS MY PLEASURE TO 1262 00:47:34,238 --> 00:47:35,773 INTRODUCE THIS FIRST SESSION OF 1263 00:47:35,773 --> 00:47:37,408 BEYOND THE SCREEN, BEST 1264 00:47:37,408 --> 00:47:38,943 PRACTICES IN TELEHEALTH AND 1265 00:47:38,943 --> 00:47:43,214 IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH FOR 1266 00:47:43,214 --> 00:47:43,781 LASTING IMPACT. 1267 00:47:43,781 --> 00:47:47,285 MODERATOR IS DR. MEGAN MAHONEY, 1268 00:47:47,285 --> 00:47:50,788 FAMILY ENDOWED PROFESSOR AND 1269 00:47:50,788 --> 00:47:51,289 CHAIR, DEPARTMENT OF THE 1270 00:47:51,289 --> 00:47:51,990 UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN 1271 00:47:51,990 --> 00:47:52,490 FRANCISCO. 1272 00:47:52,490 --> 00:47:56,494 WE ALSO HAVE OUR THREE 1273 00:47:56,494 --> 00:47:57,428 PANELISTS, PROFESSOR AND CHAIR 1274 00:47:57,428 --> 00:47:59,864 OF THE DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH 1275 00:47:59,864 --> 00:48:01,866 SERVICES POLICY AND PRACTICE AT 1276 00:48:01,866 --> 00:48:03,801 BROWN UNIVERSITY, WE HAVE DR. 1277 00:48:03,801 --> 00:48:05,503 CHRISTINE RAY, ASSOCIATE 1278 00:48:05,503 --> 00:48:07,105 PROFESSOR OF PEDIATRICS, 1279 00:48:07,105 --> 00:48:08,006 UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH SCHOOL 1280 00:48:08,006 --> 00:48:14,579 OF MEDICINE, DIRECTOR OF HEALTH 1281 00:48:14,579 --> 00:48:18,282 SYSTEMS IMPROVEMENT AT UPNC 1282 00:48:18,282 --> 00:48:20,018 CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL, PITTSBURGH, 1283 00:48:20,018 --> 00:48:21,452 ALSO DR. JUDD HOLLANDER, SENIOR 1284 00:48:21,452 --> 00:48:24,889 VICE PRESIDENT FOR HEALTH CARE 1285 00:48:24,889 --> 00:48:27,792 DELIVERY AND INNOVATION, 1286 00:48:27,792 --> 00:48:29,327 DEPARTMENT OF EMERGENCY 1287 00:48:29,327 --> 00:48:30,428 MEDICINE, AND SYDNEY KIMMEL 1288 00:48:30,428 --> 00:48:32,163 MEDICAL COLLEGE OF THOMAS 1289 00:48:32,163 --> 00:48:34,032 JEFFERSON UNIVERSITY. 1290 00:48:34,032 --> 00:48:37,101 DR. MAHONEY, PLEASE TAKE IT 1291 00:48:37,101 --> 00:48:38,636 AWAY, A PLEASURE HAVING YOU 1292 00:48:38,636 --> 00:48:38,836 HERE. 1293 00:48:38,836 --> 00:48:40,271 >> IT'S A REAL PLEASURE TO BE 1294 00:48:40,271 --> 00:48:41,906 WITH YOU ALL TODAY. 1295 00:48:41,906 --> 00:48:43,875 THANK YOU, DR. BRUNO. 1296 00:48:43,875 --> 00:48:46,944 I KNOW THAT THIS PROMISES TO BE 1297 00:48:46,944 --> 00:48:48,780 A VERY ILLUMINATING 1298 00:48:48,780 --> 00:48:49,113 CONVERSATION. 1299 00:48:49,113 --> 00:48:50,982 I'M LOOKING FORWARD TO 1300 00:48:50,982 --> 00:48:52,850 MODERATING THIS DISCUSSION. 1301 00:48:52,850 --> 00:48:55,253 DURING THIS SESSION, WE WILL BE 1302 00:48:55,253 --> 00:48:57,989 EXPLORING AND IDENTIFYING BEST 1303 00:48:57,989 --> 00:49:03,861 PRACTICES IN TELEHEALTH, AND 1304 00:49:03,861 --> 00:49:06,631 WE'LL EXAMINE IDEAL UTILIZATION 1305 00:49:06,631 --> 00:49:08,066 SCENARIOS, LESSON LEARNED, 1306 00:49:08,066 --> 00:49:09,467 SUSTAINABLE CHANGES IN 1307 00:49:09,467 --> 00:49:11,436 HEALTHCARE DELIVERY, SHIFT IN 1308 00:49:11,436 --> 00:49:13,538 PATIENT AND CLINICIAN 1309 00:49:13,538 --> 00:49:15,173 DEMOGRAPHICS, EFFECTIVENESS OF 1310 00:49:15,173 --> 00:49:16,607 VARIOUS TELEHEALTH DELIVERY 1311 00:49:16,607 --> 00:49:16,974 SERVICES. 1312 00:49:16,974 --> 00:49:20,411 I AM REALLY HONORED TO SERVE AS 1313 00:49:20,411 --> 00:49:22,447 MODERATOR FOR THIS ESTEEMED 1314 00:49:22,447 --> 00:49:22,714 PANEL. 1315 00:49:22,714 --> 00:49:24,716 I HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY OF 1316 00:49:24,716 --> 00:49:26,884 REVIEWING A NUMBER OF THE 1317 00:49:26,884 --> 00:49:28,886 PUBLICATIONS, AND I KNOW WE'LL 1318 00:49:28,886 --> 00:49:31,622 HAVE A GREAT DISCUSSION TODAY. 1319 00:49:31,622 --> 00:49:38,229 WE'LL HAVE ABOUT 50 MINUTES. 1320 00:49:38,229 --> 00:49:40,465 I ENCOURAGE YOU TO USE THE Q&A 1321 00:49:40,465 --> 00:49:42,233 TOOL TO CONTRIBUTE YOUR 1322 00:49:42,233 --> 00:49:46,938 QUESTIONS. 1323 00:49:46,938 --> 00:49:52,410 I INVITE DR. HAL ANDER, RAY AND 1324 00:49:52,410 --> 00:49:55,379 MEHROTA TO JOIN AND WE'LL GET 1325 00:49:55,379 --> 00:50:05,723 INTO THE QUESTIONS. 1326 00:50:17,769 --> 00:50:18,002 >> WELCOME. 1327 00:50:18,002 --> 00:50:20,338 >> THE FIRST QUESTION FOR YOU IS 1328 00:50:20,338 --> 00:50:23,074 WHAT ARE THE BEST METRICS AFTER 1329 00:50:23,074 --> 00:50:26,144 HEARING FROM DR. GRAHAM'S 1330 00:50:26,144 --> 00:50:28,646 WONDERFUL PRESENTATION; HOW ARE 1331 00:50:28,646 --> 00:50:30,148 YOU THINKING ABOUT EVALUATING 1332 00:50:30,148 --> 00:50:31,282 TELEHEALTH EFFECTIVENESS? 1333 00:50:31,282 --> 00:50:36,320 WHAT ARE THE IDEAL SCENARIOS FOR 1334 00:50:36,320 --> 00:50:37,288 TELEHEALTH UTILIZATION, VERSUS 1335 00:50:37,288 --> 00:50:38,289 INPATIENT CARE? 1336 00:50:38,289 --> 00:50:41,125 AND I WILL GO AHEAD AND INVITE 1337 00:50:41,125 --> 00:50:44,629 DR. RAY TO GET US KICKED OFF. 1338 00:50:44,629 --> 00:50:45,396 >> THANKS SO MUCH. 1339 00:50:45,396 --> 00:50:48,332 IT'S A PLEASURE TO BE HERE WITH 1340 00:50:48,332 --> 00:50:49,333 THIS GROUP. 1341 00:50:49,333 --> 00:50:53,805 I THINK IN TERMS OF BEST METRICS 1342 00:50:53,805 --> 00:50:54,405 FOR EVALUATING TELEHEALTH 1343 00:50:54,405 --> 00:50:55,773 EFFECTIVENESS, I THINK AT ONE 1344 00:50:55,773 --> 00:50:58,976 LEVEL WHEN WE'RE THINKING ABOUT 1345 00:50:58,976 --> 00:51:00,044 INDIVIDUAL CLINICAL SCENARIOS, 1346 00:51:00,044 --> 00:51:00,778 HIGH-QUALITY CARE IS 1347 00:51:00,778 --> 00:51:01,913 HIGH-QUALITY CARE. 1348 00:51:01,913 --> 00:51:03,881 AND SO WHETHER IT'S OCCURRING IN 1349 00:51:03,881 --> 00:51:05,416 PERSON OR VIRTUALLY, WE WANT TO 1350 00:51:05,416 --> 00:51:06,517 MEET THOSE SAME STANDARDS. 1351 00:51:06,517 --> 00:51:11,422 AND SO WHEN WE'RE THINKING ABOUT 1352 00:51:11,422 --> 00:51:14,358 EXISTING METRICS, BEST CARE FOR 1353 00:51:14,358 --> 00:51:21,833 YOU A CUTE RESPIRATORY CARE 1354 00:51:21,833 --> 00:51:24,535 INFECTION, THEY REMAIN IMPORTANT 1355 00:51:24,535 --> 00:51:25,670 AND ESSENTIAL. 1356 00:51:25,670 --> 00:51:26,771 WE KNOW WHAT HIGH-QUALITY CARE 1357 00:51:26,771 --> 00:51:29,307 IS AND CAN START WITH THE SAME 1358 00:51:29,307 --> 00:51:29,607 METRICS. 1359 00:51:29,607 --> 00:51:34,011 I THINK THERE'S ANOTHER LEVEL 1360 00:51:34,011 --> 00:51:35,446 WHERE BECAUSE TELEHEALTH SHIFTS 1361 00:51:35,446 --> 00:51:38,149 ACCESSIBILITY OF CARE AS WE'VE 1362 00:51:38,149 --> 00:51:38,916 BEEN HEARING, THERE IS SOME 1363 00:51:38,916 --> 00:51:40,451 OPPORTUNITY TO THINK ABOUT THE 1364 00:51:40,451 --> 00:51:41,853 BALANCE OF ACCESSIBILITY AND 1365 00:51:41,853 --> 00:51:43,287 EFFECTIVENESS OF CARE. 1366 00:51:43,287 --> 00:51:45,389 AND IF WE'RE DOING -- IF WE'RE 1367 00:51:45,389 --> 00:51:46,457 REACHING A BROADER POPULATION, 1368 00:51:46,457 --> 00:51:48,226 AND WE'RE REACHING INTO 1369 00:51:48,226 --> 00:51:51,295 POPULATIONS THAT OTHERWISE WOULD 1370 00:51:51,295 --> 00:51:53,364 NOT HAVE RECEIVED CARE, THE 1371 00:51:53,364 --> 00:51:54,665 BALANCE OF REACHING THEM AND 1372 00:51:54,665 --> 00:51:56,734 ENHANCING THE QUALITY OF CARE 1373 00:51:56,734 --> 00:51:58,703 MAY LOOK DIFFERENT. 1374 00:51:58,703 --> 00:52:00,037 I'M THINKING ABOUT ADOLESCENTS, 1375 00:52:00,037 --> 00:52:02,340 IF WE CONSIDER REACHING OUT TO 1376 00:52:02,340 --> 00:52:05,610 THEM TO PROVIDE WELL CHILD CARE 1377 00:52:05,610 --> 00:52:06,611 THROUGH CHILD TELEHEALTH WILL 1378 00:52:06,611 --> 00:52:09,780 INCREASE NUMBER OF TEENS WHO GET 1379 00:52:09,780 --> 00:52:11,716 DEPRESSION SCREENING BUT MAY NOT 1380 00:52:11,716 --> 00:52:13,417 GET VISION SCREENING TO THE KIDS 1381 00:52:13,417 --> 00:52:15,286 AND HOW DO WE BALANCE THE 1382 00:52:15,286 --> 00:52:17,355 GREATER REACH WITH SOME 1383 00:52:17,355 --> 00:52:18,122 MODALITIES AND WHILE RECOGNIZING 1384 00:52:18,122 --> 00:52:19,423 OTHER THINGS MAY NOT OCCUR IN 1385 00:52:19,423 --> 00:52:21,058 THE SAME WAY. 1386 00:52:21,058 --> 00:52:24,896 SO I THINK FOR INDIVIDUAL 1387 00:52:24,896 --> 00:52:26,197 SCENARIOS, I THINK ABOUT THE 1388 00:52:26,197 --> 00:52:27,531 METRICS THAT WE ALREADY KNOW BUT 1389 00:52:27,531 --> 00:52:29,367 WHEN WE'RE THINKING ABOUT MORE 1390 00:52:29,367 --> 00:52:30,568 POPULATION HEALTH THERE'S A 1391 00:52:30,568 --> 00:52:34,405 LITTLE BIT MORE OF COMPLEXITY IN 1392 00:52:34,405 --> 00:52:36,707 THINKING OF TRADEOFFS BETWEEN 1393 00:52:36,707 --> 00:52:37,775 ACCESS AND EFFECTIVENESS AND 1394 00:52:37,775 --> 00:52:39,010 COUNTER BALANCE IF THAT PATIENT 1395 00:52:39,010 --> 00:52:40,511 HAD NOT GOTTEN THE TELEHEALTH 1396 00:52:40,511 --> 00:52:43,047 VISIT WOULD THEY HAVE GOTTEN NO 1397 00:52:43,047 --> 00:52:44,682 CARE OR AN IN-PERSON VISIT, WE 1398 00:52:44,682 --> 00:52:45,683 NEED TO RECOGNIZE AND 1399 00:52:45,683 --> 00:52:45,983 ACKNOWLEDGE. 1400 00:52:45,983 --> 00:52:47,351 I MIGHT PAUSE THERE AND COME 1401 00:52:47,351 --> 00:52:48,986 BACK TO THE IDEAL SCENARIO 1402 00:52:48,986 --> 00:52:55,960 QUESTION AFTER OTHERS HAVE A 1403 00:52:55,960 --> 00:52:59,096 CHANCE TO WEIGH IN. 1404 00:52:59,096 --> 00:53:00,898 >> WE NEED TO ASSERT THE SAME 1405 00:53:00,898 --> 00:53:09,440 STANDARDS OF OF CARE WITH QUALY 1406 00:53:09,440 --> 00:53:10,975 METRICS REACHING PARITY AND 1407 00:53:10,975 --> 00:53:12,510 TAILORING ACCESS METRIC 1408 00:53:12,510 --> 00:53:13,377 ACCORDING TO MODALITIES 1409 00:53:13,377 --> 00:53:16,013 TELEHEALTH VERSUS IN PERSON. 1410 00:53:16,013 --> 00:53:20,151 AND SO I'LL TRANSITION TO DR. 1411 00:53:20,151 --> 00:53:22,887 MEHROTRA IF YOU COULD WEIGH IN 1412 00:53:22,887 --> 00:53:24,522 AS WELL. 1413 00:53:24,522 --> 00:53:27,391 >> I'M IN AGREEMENT WITH DR. 1414 00:53:27,391 --> 00:53:27,558 RAY. 1415 00:53:27,558 --> 00:53:29,226 HOW DO I EVALUATE MY PROGRAM? 1416 00:53:29,226 --> 00:53:30,361 YOU'VE BEEN EVALUATING LOTS OF 1417 00:53:30,361 --> 00:53:32,730 PROGRAMS FOR A LONG TIME, DO THE 1418 00:53:32,730 --> 00:53:35,132 SAME METRICS FOR HEART DISEASE, 1419 00:53:35,132 --> 00:53:37,668 WE KNOW HOW TO TREAT HEART 1420 00:53:37,668 --> 00:53:37,902 DISEASE. 1421 00:53:37,902 --> 00:53:40,538 I WANT TO EMPHASIZE ALSO WHAT 1422 00:53:40,538 --> 00:53:45,676 DR. RAY SAID IT DOES RAISE 1423 00:53:45,676 --> 00:53:46,811 METRICS, EVALUATING FOR HEART 1424 00:53:46,811 --> 00:53:49,413 DISEASE WE DO NOT THINK ABOUT AS 1425 00:53:49,413 --> 00:53:52,450 OUTCOME TRAVEL TIME, BURDEN ON 1426 00:53:52,450 --> 00:53:53,451 CAREGIVERS, THOSE OUTCOMES. 1427 00:53:53,451 --> 00:53:57,254 I THINK THE GROWTH OF TELEHEALTH 1428 00:53:57,254 --> 00:53:59,056 PUSHES US IN THAT DIRECTION 1429 00:53:59,056 --> 00:53:59,790 THINKING OF PATIENT-CENTERED 1430 00:53:59,790 --> 00:54:00,057 CARE. 1431 00:54:00,057 --> 00:54:01,525 I WOULD WANT TO USE THE SAME 1432 00:54:01,525 --> 00:54:03,394 METRICS FOR ANY EVALUATION. 1433 00:54:03,394 --> 00:54:07,765 THAT WOULD BE -- I'M BASICALLY 1434 00:54:07,765 --> 00:54:14,505 ECHO WHAT DR. RAY SAID. 1435 00:54:14,505 --> 00:54:15,673 >> IT HELPS INTRODUCE NEW 1436 00:54:15,673 --> 00:54:19,310 METRICS THAT SHOULD HAVE BEEN 1437 00:54:19,310 --> 00:54:19,610 THERE. 1438 00:54:19,610 --> 00:54:20,244 DR. HOLLANDER? 1439 00:54:20,244 --> 00:54:22,680 >> IT'S WEIRD TO GO THIRD AND 1440 00:54:22,680 --> 00:54:23,881 NOT ARGUE WITH SOMETHING 1441 00:54:23,881 --> 00:54:25,383 SOMEBODY SAID ALREADY. 1442 00:54:25,383 --> 00:54:27,852 I AGREE 100% WITH ALL OF IT. 1443 00:54:27,852 --> 00:54:29,820 I'LL ADD A COUPLE COLOR 1444 00:54:29,820 --> 00:54:31,689 COMMENTARY STATEMENTS TO IT. 1445 00:54:31,689 --> 00:54:34,291 ONE IS NATIONAL QUALITY FORUM, 1446 00:54:34,291 --> 00:54:38,796 AMONG OTHER GROUPS, MEASURE 1447 00:54:38,796 --> 00:54:43,868 FRAMEWORKS AND MEASURE, AND IT'S 1448 00:54:43,868 --> 00:54:44,468 ACCESS, COST, EXPERIENCE, 1449 00:54:44,468 --> 00:54:46,670 EFFECTIVENESS AS THE OTHER 1450 00:54:46,670 --> 00:54:47,104 DOCTORS SAID. 1451 00:54:47,104 --> 00:54:49,306 IT'S THE SAME THING WE DO FOR 1452 00:54:49,306 --> 00:54:50,274 EVERYBODY ELSE, SHOULDN'T THINK 1453 00:54:50,274 --> 00:54:55,246 OF IT DIFFERENTLY. 1454 00:54:55,246 --> 00:54:57,214 ONE POINT ALREADY MADE, WE 1455 00:54:57,214 --> 00:54:58,949 CANNOT COMPARE TELEHEALTH TO 1456 00:54:58,949 --> 00:55:00,918 IN-PERSON CARE. 1457 00:55:00,918 --> 00:55:04,321 WE WANT TO COMPARE TELEHEALTH TO 1458 00:55:04,321 --> 00:55:05,723 THE ALTERNATIVE AVAILABLE. 1459 00:55:05,723 --> 00:55:07,258 IT'S NOT REALLY IMPORTANT TO 1460 00:55:07,258 --> 00:55:09,126 TAKE THAT DIABETIC AND SAY HOW 1461 00:55:09,126 --> 00:55:10,995 WAS THEIR VISIT ON MARCH 15, 1462 00:55:10,995 --> 00:55:13,064 IT'S MUCH MORE IMPORTANT TO SAY 1463 00:55:13,064 --> 00:55:14,265 HOW IS THEIR CARE. 1464 00:55:14,265 --> 00:55:16,567 SO IT'S REALLY ABOUT CARE 1465 00:55:16,567 --> 00:55:18,202 WITHOUT ANY TELEHEALTH VERSUS 1466 00:55:18,202 --> 00:55:21,272 WHAT WE OFTEN CALL HYBRID CARE, 1467 00:55:21,272 --> 00:55:22,039 CARE INCLUDING TELEHEALTH, SOME 1468 00:55:22,039 --> 00:55:23,707 OF THE TIME. 1469 00:55:23,707 --> 00:55:25,009 AND IT'S REALLY CRITICAL, WE 1470 00:55:25,009 --> 00:55:26,343 FUND STUDIES THAT LOOK AT IT 1471 00:55:26,343 --> 00:55:27,545 THAT WAY. 1472 00:55:27,545 --> 00:55:35,086 AND MY FINAL COMMENT, AND I DO 1473 00:55:35,086 --> 00:55:36,620 AGREE WITH WHAT ATEEV, NEW 1474 00:55:36,620 --> 00:55:38,789 OPPORTUNITY TO LOOK AT DIFFERENT 1475 00:55:38,789 --> 00:55:39,023 THINGS. 1476 00:55:39,023 --> 00:55:40,891 IF WE ANCHOR TO WHAT WE DO WE 1477 00:55:40,891 --> 00:55:42,526 LOSE THE ABILITY TO REINVENT 1478 00:55:42,526 --> 00:55:43,394 CARE. 1479 00:55:43,394 --> 00:55:46,564 CARE WE DELIVER RIGHT NOW ISN'T 1480 00:55:46,564 --> 00:55:47,865 CONSUMER-CENTRIC AND THERE ARE 1481 00:55:47,865 --> 00:55:49,834 THINGS WE SHOULD ABSOLUTELY DO 1482 00:55:49,834 --> 00:55:50,134 DIFFERENTLY. 1483 00:55:50,134 --> 00:55:52,002 SO I BELIEVE AND I'LL TAKE 1484 00:55:52,002 --> 00:55:55,306 PHYSICAL EXAM COMMENT MADE ON 1485 00:55:55,306 --> 00:55:56,841 THE EARLIER KEYNOTE, DO WE NEED 1486 00:55:56,841 --> 00:55:58,409 A PHYSICAL EXAM? 1487 00:55:58,409 --> 00:56:04,315 IF I ASK AUDIENCE FOR SHOW OF 1488 00:56:04,315 --> 00:56:07,284 HANDS, WHO HAS NOT TOUCHED IN AN 1489 00:56:07,284 --> 00:56:08,786 EXAM, 80% WOULD GO UP. 1490 00:56:08,786 --> 00:56:11,122 WE HAVE A FALLACY IN-PERSON CARE 1491 00:56:11,122 --> 00:56:12,890 IS WILDLY DIFFERENT BECAUSE OF A 1492 00:56:12,890 --> 00:56:14,825 PHYSICAL EXAM. 1493 00:56:14,825 --> 00:56:15,426 I CHALLENGE CARDIOLOGY 1494 00:56:15,426 --> 00:56:19,363 COLLEAGUES TO SAY ON A ROUTINE 1495 00:56:19,363 --> 00:56:19,997 SCHEDULED APPOINTMENT HOW MANY 1496 00:56:19,997 --> 00:56:21,432 TIMES HAVE YOU FOUND A NEW 1497 00:56:21,432 --> 00:56:22,766 MURMUR ON A PATIENT, THE ANSWER 1498 00:56:22,766 --> 00:56:24,468 IS NEVER ON EVERY WOULD BE. 1499 00:56:24,468 --> 00:56:27,671 WHAT IS IT WE NEED TO DO FOR 1500 00:56:27,671 --> 00:56:28,472 PATIENTS, NOT WHAT HAVE WE 1501 00:56:28,472 --> 00:56:30,307 ALWAYS DONE AND YOU WHO DO WE DO 1502 00:56:30,307 --> 00:56:32,042 IT WITH TELEMEDICINE. 1503 00:56:32,042 --> 00:56:33,244 MY FINAL THOUGHT, ANALOGY I USED 1504 00:56:33,244 --> 00:56:35,012 TO NOT LIKE THAT SOMEONE ELSE 1505 00:56:35,012 --> 00:56:37,648 MADE, THAT I NOW LOVE, 1506 00:56:37,648 --> 00:56:38,916 TELEMEDICINE IS THE ELEVATOR. 1507 00:56:38,916 --> 00:56:40,551 NOBODY ASKED HOW IS THE ELEVATOR 1508 00:56:40,551 --> 00:56:42,653 RIDE UP TO THE FIFTH FLOOR TO 1509 00:56:42,653 --> 00:56:44,955 GET TO MEDICAL CARE. 1510 00:56:44,955 --> 00:56:46,323 THE TELEMEDICINE PLATFORM SHOULD 1511 00:56:46,323 --> 00:56:48,726 BE SEAMLESS, SHOULD BE THE 1512 00:56:48,726 --> 00:56:48,993 ELEVATOR. 1513 00:56:48,993 --> 00:56:50,794 AND ECHOING THE COMMENTS OF THE 1514 00:56:50,794 --> 00:56:52,096 OTHER PANELISTS, IT'S ABOUT THE 1515 00:56:52,096 --> 00:56:56,033 CARE YOU'RE GETTING FOR THE 1516 00:56:56,033 --> 00:56:57,134 CONDITION YOU HAVE. 1517 00:56:57,134 --> 00:57:00,070 >> IF YOU DON'T MIND JUMPING IN, 1518 00:57:00,070 --> 00:57:01,305 WE'RE IN AGREEMENT. 1519 00:57:01,305 --> 00:57:02,740 ONE THING I WOULD HIGHLIGHT FOR 1520 00:57:02,740 --> 00:57:04,375 THE AUDIENCE IS A BIT OF A 1521 00:57:04,375 --> 00:57:04,708 PARADOX. 1522 00:57:04,708 --> 00:57:05,776 I'M WITH YOU. 1523 00:57:05,776 --> 00:57:07,811 HOW OFTEN DOES THE PHYSICAL 1524 00:57:07,811 --> 00:57:09,847 EXAM -- IS IT CRITICAL FOR 1525 00:57:09,847 --> 00:57:10,481 DIAGNOSIS AND MANAGEMENT? 1526 00:57:10,481 --> 00:57:12,349 I AGREE MOST OF THE TIME IT 1527 00:57:12,349 --> 00:57:12,583 ISN'T. 1528 00:57:12,583 --> 00:57:15,119 WHEN WE ASK PEOPLE IN NATIONAL 1529 00:57:15,119 --> 00:57:17,221 SURVEYS WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THE 1530 00:57:17,221 --> 00:57:18,355 TELEHEALTH VISIT, LIKE IT WAS 1531 00:57:18,355 --> 00:57:20,324 OKAY, BUT I DIDN'T GET A 1532 00:57:20,324 --> 00:57:21,659 PHYSICAL EXAM SO I'M NOT SURE I 1533 00:57:21,659 --> 00:57:24,595 GOT THE RIGHT QUALITY OF CARE. 1534 00:57:24,595 --> 00:57:25,996 THAT MIGHT CHANGE OVER TIME BUT 1535 00:57:25,996 --> 00:57:28,532 I DO WANT TO -- I'M WITH YOU BUT 1536 00:57:28,532 --> 00:57:29,867 WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE ALSO THE 1537 00:57:29,867 --> 00:57:32,803 AMERICAN PUBLIC MAY NOT AGREE 1538 00:57:32,803 --> 00:57:33,037 WITH US. 1539 00:57:33,037 --> 00:57:34,672 >> AND OF COURSE THERE'S ALSO 1540 00:57:34,672 --> 00:57:37,074 THE OPPORTUNITY FOR THE PATIENT 1541 00:57:37,074 --> 00:57:38,709 TO CONDUCT A SELF-EXAM DURING A 1542 00:57:38,709 --> 00:57:40,144 TELEHEALTH VISIT AS WELL. 1543 00:57:40,144 --> 00:57:41,779 SO WE CAN MAYBE STRIKE A BALANCE 1544 00:57:41,779 --> 00:57:44,615 WHERE WE HAVE THE BEST OF ALL 1545 00:57:44,615 --> 00:57:45,950 WORLDS. 1546 00:57:45,950 --> 00:57:46,317 >> ABSOLUTELY. 1547 00:57:46,317 --> 00:57:49,753 I MIGHT ADD WE CAN NARRATE THE 1548 00:57:49,753 --> 00:57:51,388 EXAM WE'RE SEEING AS WE SHALL 1549 00:57:51,388 --> 00:57:52,489 VISUALIZING A PATIENT, WE 1550 00:57:52,489 --> 00:57:55,659 ACTUALLY DO A LOT OF EXAMS, I 1551 00:57:55,659 --> 00:57:57,161 KNOW ALL OF THE PANELISTS AGREE 1552 00:57:57,161 --> 00:57:59,964 WE'RE DOING A LOT OF EXAM AS WE 1553 00:57:59,964 --> 00:58:01,065 ARE SEEING PEOPLE THROUGH 1554 00:58:01,065 --> 00:58:03,033 TELEHEALTH, BUT IT MAY NOT -- WE 1555 00:58:03,033 --> 00:58:04,568 MAY NEED TO MAKE IT MORE 1556 00:58:04,568 --> 00:58:06,403 APPARENT TO THE PATIENT THAT I 1557 00:58:06,403 --> 00:58:10,107 SEE THIS ABOUT YOUR EYES, THIS 1558 00:58:10,107 --> 00:58:13,010 ABOUT YOUR BREATHING, TO HELP 1559 00:58:13,010 --> 00:58:15,846 SATISFY THAT ISSUE THAT YOU 1560 00:58:15,846 --> 00:58:16,046 RAISE. 1561 00:58:16,046 --> 00:58:17,481 >> SINCE THIS PANEL IS ABOUT 1562 00:58:17,481 --> 00:58:19,350 RESEARCH, THIS IS A GREAT 1563 00:58:19,350 --> 00:58:23,887 OPPORTUNITY TO DO RESEARCH AND 1564 00:58:23,887 --> 00:58:25,055 TO WHAT COMPONENTS OF THE 1565 00:58:25,055 --> 00:58:26,023 PHYSICAL EXAM ARE IMPORTANT. 1566 00:58:26,023 --> 00:58:27,024 WHEN WE TALK ABOUT THIS 1567 00:58:27,024 --> 00:58:29,293 CLINICALLY I DON'T HAVE TO GET 1568 00:58:29,293 --> 00:58:31,161 THE DIAGNOSIS RIGHT, I'M AN E.R. 1569 00:58:31,161 --> 00:58:33,664 DOC, I CAN'T MISS SOMETHING BAD, 1570 00:58:33,664 --> 00:58:33,864 RIGHT? 1571 00:58:33,864 --> 00:58:36,066 AND SO WE TEND TO THINK IN 1572 00:58:36,066 --> 00:58:37,201 TELEMEDICINE IF I SEE SOMEBODY 1573 00:58:37,201 --> 00:58:38,602 AND NEED TO SENDS THEM TO THE 1574 00:58:38,602 --> 00:58:39,937 E.R. I HAVE FAILED. 1575 00:58:39,937 --> 00:58:40,704 THAT'S NOT TRUE. 1576 00:58:40,704 --> 00:58:41,905 I'VE ONLY FAILED IF I NEED TO 1577 00:58:41,905 --> 00:58:44,074 SEND THEM TO THE E.R. AND I 1578 00:58:44,074 --> 00:58:45,943 DON'T BECAUSE PRIMARY CARE 1579 00:58:45,943 --> 00:58:48,012 DOCTORS ALL THE TIME SEND PEOPLE 1580 00:58:48,012 --> 00:58:53,484 TO THE E.R., OUTOF ORDER 1581 00:58:53,484 --> 00:58:54,585 OUTPATIENT TESTS, THE RIGHT 1582 00:58:54,585 --> 00:59:05,062 THING IS GETTING TO THE NEXT 1583 00:59:06,630 --> 00:59:07,931 ACTIONABLE STEP, THE DIFFERENCE 1584 00:59:07,931 --> 00:59:08,866 BETWEEN BRONCHITIS AND SINUSITIS 1585 00:59:08,866 --> 00:59:10,334 MAY NOT MATTER TO THE PATIENT. 1586 00:59:10,334 --> 00:59:12,770 >> ONE LAST POINT AND WE'LL GET 1587 00:59:12,770 --> 00:59:14,471 TO THE NEXT QUESTION. 1588 00:59:14,471 --> 00:59:16,807 JUDD RAISED A POINT THAT I 1589 00:59:16,807 --> 00:59:18,876 WANTED TO EMPHASIZE WHICH IS 1590 00:59:18,876 --> 00:59:20,978 THAT -- I BUILD UPON, WHICH IS 1591 00:59:20,978 --> 00:59:22,579 THAT RIGHT NOW WE DO A LOT OF 1592 00:59:22,579 --> 00:59:25,683 WORK ON VIDEO AND PHONE VISITS 1593 00:59:25,683 --> 00:59:27,284 IN THE CONSTRUCT OF THE ZOOM 1594 00:59:27,284 --> 00:59:28,519 CALL RIGHT NOW. 1595 00:59:28,519 --> 00:59:29,687 THERE IS THIS BURGEONING 1596 00:59:29,687 --> 00:59:31,255 INDUSTRY OF A NUMBER OF DEVICES 1597 00:59:31,255 --> 00:59:32,556 PEOPLE CAN BRING TO THE HOME, 1598 00:59:32,556 --> 00:59:35,292 SOME WILL WORK, SOME WILL BE NOT 1599 00:59:35,292 --> 00:59:37,027 SO HOT. 1600 00:59:37,027 --> 00:59:39,797 BUT THAT QUESTION THAT JUDD 1601 00:59:39,797 --> 00:59:41,532 RAISED, WHICH IS THAT A 1602 00:59:41,532 --> 00:59:43,067 CARDIOLOGIST MAY FEEL VERY, VERY 1603 00:59:43,067 --> 00:59:44,468 UNCOMFORTABLE MANAGING A PATIENT 1604 00:59:44,468 --> 00:59:46,236 WITH HEART FAILURE IN A CURRENT 1605 00:59:46,236 --> 00:59:47,104 SITUATION WITH VIDEO VISIT. 1606 00:59:47,104 --> 00:59:50,607 BUT IF THERE WAS A PHYSICAL EXAM 1607 00:59:50,607 --> 00:59:52,676 OF JUST A ONE-LEAD TELLE THING 1608 00:59:52,676 --> 00:59:55,312 ON THE PHONE AND VISUAL 1609 00:59:55,312 --> 00:59:57,181 STETHOSCOPE, WHAT THEY JUDGE AND 1610 00:59:57,181 --> 00:59:59,149 WHAT THE PATIENT JUDGES TO BE 1611 00:59:59,149 --> 01:00:00,784 SUFFICIENT QUALITY MAY BE 1612 01:00:00,784 --> 01:00:01,452 EXTREMELY DIFFERENT. 1613 01:00:01,452 --> 01:00:09,193 SO WE HAVE TO THINK ABOUT 1614 01:00:09,193 --> 01:00:10,761 TELETODAY AND TELE IN A COUPLE 1615 01:00:10,761 --> 01:00:12,062 YEARS MAY BE DIFFERENT HOW WE 1616 01:00:12,062 --> 01:00:12,996 JUDGE THAT QUALITY. 1617 01:00:12,996 --> 01:00:16,633 >> THAT'S WHAT WE WANT TO 1618 01:00:16,633 --> 01:00:17,134 ENCOURAGE, CONVERSATION. 1619 01:00:17,134 --> 01:00:17,868 SO THIS IS GREAT. 1620 01:00:17,868 --> 01:00:19,803 I WANT TO LET YOU KNOW THERE ARE 1621 01:00:19,803 --> 01:00:21,472 ALREADY A NUMBER OF QUESTIONS 1622 01:00:21,472 --> 01:00:23,307 THAT ARE COMING IN, AND SO I'LL 1623 01:00:23,307 --> 01:00:25,142 PROBABLY JUST JUMP TO THAT AND 1624 01:00:25,142 --> 01:00:27,678 PICKING UP ON DR. HOLLANDER'S 1625 01:00:27,678 --> 01:00:30,114 AND EVERYBODY'S POINT AROUND 1626 01:00:30,114 --> 01:00:32,149 ELEVATOR BEING TELEMEDICINE JUST 1627 01:00:32,149 --> 01:00:35,018 ONE MODALITY, AND DR. HOLLANDER, 1628 01:00:35,018 --> 01:00:36,787 ONE OF OUR RECENT PUBLICATIONS 1629 01:00:36,787 --> 01:00:38,188 YOU HIGHLIGHT THERE'S AN ARRAY 1630 01:00:38,188 --> 01:00:40,057 OF MODALITIES THAT FALL WITHIN 1631 01:00:40,057 --> 01:00:41,358 THIS REALM. 1632 01:00:41,358 --> 01:00:46,063 WE HAVE LIVE AUDIO VIDEO, WE 1633 01:00:46,063 --> 01:00:48,265 HAVE ASYNCHRONOUS CARE, NEAR AND 1634 01:00:48,265 --> 01:00:54,371 DEAR TO ME IN PRIMARY CARE, AND 1635 01:00:54,371 --> 01:00:55,372 REMOTE PATIENT MONITORING WHICH 1636 01:00:55,372 --> 01:00:57,441 ATEEV MENTIONED AS WELL. 1637 01:00:57,441 --> 01:00:58,075 THE QUESTION FROM THE AUDIENCE 1638 01:00:58,075 --> 01:01:00,244 HOW DO YOU THINK THE 1639 01:01:00,244 --> 01:01:02,379 RELATIONSHIP WITH PATIENTS 1640 01:01:02,379 --> 01:01:04,681 SHOULD BE MANAGED, CONSIDERINGED 1641 01:01:04,681 --> 01:01:10,154 THESE MODALITIES, IS THERE 1642 01:01:10,154 --> 01:01:14,458 RELUCTANCE TO TELEHEALTH DUE TO 1643 01:01:14,458 --> 01:01:16,093 RUSHED IMPLEMENTATION AND WHAT 1644 01:01:16,093 --> 01:01:17,728 STRATEGIES CAN REENGAGE THOSE 1645 01:01:17,728 --> 01:01:19,596 WHO DO HAVE SOME MISTRUST OF 1646 01:01:19,596 --> 01:01:21,765 THESE MODALITIES AND HOW DO WE 1647 01:01:21,765 --> 01:01:24,501 GET THEM TO ENGAGE? 1648 01:01:24,501 --> 01:01:27,905 >> WELL, I THANK YOU FOR THAT 1649 01:01:27,905 --> 01:01:28,906 INCREDIBLY SIMPLE QUESTION. 1650 01:01:28,906 --> 01:01:31,175 I CAN SAY THIS, YOU KNOW, I HAVE 1651 01:01:31,175 --> 01:01:33,577 A UNIQUE EXPERIENCE BECAUSE WE 1652 01:01:33,577 --> 01:01:34,344 LAUNCHED OUR FIRST TELEMEDICINE 1653 01:01:34,344 --> 01:01:36,113 PROGRAM IN 2015, LONG BEFORE 1654 01:01:36,113 --> 01:01:36,613 COVID. 1655 01:01:36,613 --> 01:01:38,182 AND THEN BECAUSE JEFFERSON HAS 1656 01:01:38,182 --> 01:01:40,584 GROWN FROM ALMOST THREE 1657 01:01:40,584 --> 01:01:41,919 HOSPITALS INTO 32 NOW, I'VE HAD 1658 01:01:41,919 --> 01:01:44,855 THE EXTREME PLEASURE OF HAVING 1659 01:01:44,855 --> 01:01:48,459 TO RELAUNCH IT MULTIPLE TIMES AS 1660 01:01:48,459 --> 01:01:49,626 WE ADDED ADDITIONAL HOSPITALS 1661 01:01:49,626 --> 01:01:51,128 AND APPLY LEARNINGS FROM THE 1662 01:01:51,128 --> 01:01:53,530 FIRST TO THE SUBSEQUENT ONES. 1663 01:01:53,530 --> 01:01:57,034 A COUPLE PIECES OF TRUE DATA, WE 1664 01:01:57,034 --> 01:01:58,335 KNOW IN SCHEDULED VISITS BETWEEN 1665 01:01:58,335 --> 01:02:01,638 A PATIENT AND THEIR PRIMARY 1666 01:02:01,638 --> 01:02:03,607 PROVIDER ARE SPECIALIST, ABOUT 1667 01:02:03,607 --> 01:02:06,009 70% OF THE DECISION TO DO 1668 01:02:06,009 --> 01:02:08,078 TELEMEDICINE IS THE PROVIDER 1669 01:02:08,078 --> 01:02:09,947 SAYING YOUR NEXT VISIT CAN BE 1670 01:02:09,947 --> 01:02:10,714 TELEMEDICINE. 1671 01:02:10,714 --> 01:02:13,684 WE TALK A LOT ABOUT 1672 01:02:13,684 --> 01:02:15,786 PATIENT-CENTRIC CARE BUT A 1673 01:02:15,786 --> 01:02:18,388 TELEMEDICINE VISIT IS DRIVEN BY 1674 01:02:18,388 --> 01:02:20,691 THE PROVIDER WHO CAN CLEARLY SAY 1675 01:02:20,691 --> 01:02:21,458 GET YOUR HEMOGLOBIN A1 CROSS 1676 01:02:21,458 --> 01:02:24,394 COUNTRY CHECKED A1c 1677 01:02:24,394 --> 01:02:28,465 CHECKED AT THE LAB AND WE'LL 1678 01:02:28,465 --> 01:02:29,766 TALK VIA TELEMEDICINE. 1679 01:02:29,766 --> 01:02:34,171 THINK ABOUT OUR HEALTH SYSTEMS. 1680 01:02:34,171 --> 01:02:36,139 WE'RE AT CAPACITY, NOT A LOT OF 1681 01:02:36,139 --> 01:02:37,441 OPEN APPOINTMENTS FOR THE 1682 01:02:37,441 --> 01:02:40,210 RHEUMATOLOGIST TO SEE YOU TODAY. 1683 01:02:40,210 --> 01:02:41,745 HE SEES YOU ON YOUR SCHEDULED 1684 01:02:41,745 --> 01:02:43,580 VISIT WHEN YOU'RE WELL BUT NOT 1685 01:02:43,580 --> 01:02:45,782 WHEN YOU HAVE AN ACUTE FLARE. 1686 01:02:45,782 --> 01:02:47,751 WE NEED TO FIGURE OUT WHAT ARE 1687 01:02:47,751 --> 01:02:48,952 THE WAYS WE CAN ENGAGE PATIENTS 1688 01:02:48,952 --> 01:02:51,889 TO TAKE CARE OF THEIR ACUTE 1689 01:02:51,889 --> 01:02:53,790 PROBLEMS ON SYSTEM IF YOU 1690 01:02:53,790 --> 01:02:55,859 EXCLUDE E.R. URGENT CARE AND 1691 01:02:55,859 --> 01:02:59,663 RETAIL CLINICS IS LARGELY BUILT 1692 01:02:59,663 --> 01:03:00,797 ON CHRONIC CARE MODEL. 1693 01:03:00,797 --> 01:03:02,332 AND SO I'M NOT ONE OF THESE 1694 01:03:02,332 --> 01:03:05,536 PEOPLE BUT THE THREE OF YOU 1695 01:03:05,536 --> 01:03:06,169 PROBABLY HAVE IN-BOX 1696 01:03:06,169 --> 01:03:07,204 DIFFICULTIES, RIGHT? 1697 01:03:07,204 --> 01:03:08,572 WITH PATIENTS REACHING OUT TO 1698 01:03:08,572 --> 01:03:09,540 YOU. 1699 01:03:09,540 --> 01:03:11,875 SO IF WE HAVE GOOD ASYNCHRONOUS 1700 01:03:11,875 --> 01:03:13,176 WAYS OF COMMUNICATING WITH 1701 01:03:13,176 --> 01:03:14,711 PATIENTS, THAT COULD SAY, YES, I 1702 01:03:14,711 --> 01:03:16,346 NEED TO SEE YOU, NO, I DON'T 1703 01:03:16,346 --> 01:03:18,115 NEED TO SEE YOU, EVEN IF I DO 1704 01:03:18,115 --> 01:03:20,617 SEE YOU I'M LIKELY TO SEND YOU 1705 01:03:20,617 --> 01:03:22,352 TO URGENT CARE OR E.R. BECAUSE 1706 01:03:22,352 --> 01:03:24,021 YOU NEED LABS AND X-RAY, THAT 1707 01:03:24,021 --> 01:03:25,856 WOULD GO A LONG WAY. 1708 01:03:25,856 --> 01:03:28,725 I COME BACK TO CONCEPT OF 1709 01:03:28,725 --> 01:03:30,360 LEVERAGING TELEMEDICINE FOR 1710 01:03:30,360 --> 01:03:31,328 ACTIONABLE NEXT STEPS, AND 1711 01:03:31,328 --> 01:03:33,530 PEOPLE WILL CALL IT A.I. OR 1712 01:03:33,530 --> 01:03:34,731 PREDICTIVE ANALYTICS BUT WHERE 1713 01:03:34,731 --> 01:03:38,468 IS THE RIGHT SPOT FOR YOUR CARE 1714 01:03:38,468 --> 01:03:42,506 NOW AND THAT CAN BE DONE 1715 01:03:42,506 --> 01:03:43,106 ASYNCHRONOUSLY. 1716 01:03:43,106 --> 01:03:43,840 >> EXCELLENT ANSWER ON THE 1717 01:03:43,840 --> 01:03:44,608 PATIENT SIDE. 1718 01:03:44,608 --> 01:03:47,344 I WANT TO ADD ON THE PROVIDER 1719 01:03:47,344 --> 01:03:49,413 SIDE THAT QUESTION OF RELUCTANCE 1720 01:03:49,413 --> 01:03:50,948 AND REENGAGEMENT, WE HAVE -- I 1721 01:03:50,948 --> 01:03:53,784 WORK IN A PRIMARY CARE NETWORK, 1722 01:03:53,784 --> 01:03:55,886 55 PRACTICES THAT MADE THIS 1723 01:03:55,886 --> 01:03:57,654 RAPID TRANSITION TO TELEHEALTH, 1724 01:03:57,654 --> 01:04:00,190 AND THERE'S A SUBSET OF OUR 1725 01:04:00,190 --> 01:04:02,426 CLINICIANS WHERE I DO SEE WHAT I 1726 01:04:02,426 --> 01:04:04,428 THINK ARE TELEHEALTH WHIPLASH, 1727 01:04:04,428 --> 01:04:09,266 WHERE THEY WENT ALONG AND DID IT 1728 01:04:09,266 --> 01:04:12,769 BUT NOW THEY ARE NOT SO FEELING 1729 01:04:12,769 --> 01:04:13,470 POSITIVE TOWARDS TELEMEDICINE 1730 01:04:13,470 --> 01:04:16,073 NOW THAT THEY HAVE MORE OF A 1731 01:04:16,073 --> 01:04:16,740 CHOICE. 1732 01:04:16,740 --> 01:04:18,275 SOME IS IN IN RAPID TRANSITION, 1733 01:04:18,275 --> 01:04:26,416 IT WAS A RAPID TRANSITION, THE 1734 01:04:26,416 --> 01:04:27,284 STAY-AT-HOME PEOPLE WERE OFFERED 1735 01:04:27,284 --> 01:04:28,819 FOR TELEHEALTH THINGS WE 1736 01:04:28,819 --> 01:04:30,887 WOULDN'T NORMALLY OFFER, WE 1737 01:04:30,887 --> 01:04:33,857 DIDN'T HAVE ABILITY TO TRANSFER 1738 01:04:33,857 --> 01:04:35,859 TO IN-PERSON, WRAPPED IN 1739 01:04:35,859 --> 01:04:37,127 UNCERTAINTY AND ISOLATION OF THE 1740 01:04:37,127 --> 01:04:37,694 PANDEMIC. 1741 01:04:37,694 --> 01:04:40,831 AND SO I HEAR FROM SOME DOCS 1742 01:04:40,831 --> 01:04:43,467 THAT THEY DON'T LIKE TELEHEALTH 1743 01:04:43,467 --> 01:04:45,969 BECAUSE IT IS ISOLATING, AND I 1744 01:04:45,969 --> 01:04:46,870 FIND THE OPPOSITE. 1745 01:04:46,870 --> 01:04:48,271 BUT I THINK BECAUSE IT'S A GREAT 1746 01:04:48,271 --> 01:04:50,140 WAY TO CONNECT IN THE HOME, BUT 1747 01:04:50,140 --> 01:04:51,675 I THINK WE NEED TO LISTEN TO 1748 01:04:51,675 --> 01:04:54,745 THOSE DOCS AND MAKE SURE THAT WE 1749 01:04:54,745 --> 01:04:56,813 REENGAGE THEM AS WELL AS THE 1750 01:04:56,813 --> 01:04:57,814 QUESTION ABOUT REENGAGING 1751 01:04:57,814 --> 01:04:59,483 PATIENTS. 1752 01:04:59,483 --> 01:05:01,118 BUT THINKING ABOUT HOW WE MAKE 1753 01:05:01,118 --> 01:05:02,619 IT FEEL SAFE AND COMFORTABLE FOR 1754 01:05:02,619 --> 01:05:04,821 DOCS WHO MAY BE BURNED OUT ON 1755 01:05:04,821 --> 01:05:07,557 TELEHEALTH TO COME BACK AS WELL. 1756 01:05:07,557 --> 01:05:10,394 >> ONE THING I WANTED TO BUILD 1757 01:05:10,394 --> 01:05:13,664 UPON HERE WAS THE MODALITY IN 1758 01:05:13,664 --> 01:05:17,934 JUST THE SYNCHRONOUS VERSUS 1759 01:05:17,934 --> 01:05:18,402 ASYNCHRONOUS THING. 1760 01:05:18,402 --> 01:05:19,903 ONE OF THE THINGS THAT HAS 1761 01:05:19,903 --> 01:05:22,773 ALREADY COME UP IS THAT IN MANY 1762 01:05:22,773 --> 01:05:24,074 AREAS, CLINICAL CARE FROM 1763 01:05:24,074 --> 01:05:25,509 CARDIOLOGY TO RHEUMATOLOGY TO 1764 01:05:25,509 --> 01:05:26,510 MENTAL HEALTH PROFESSIONALS, 1765 01:05:26,510 --> 01:05:28,545 PRIMARY CARE, WE JUST DON'T HAVE 1766 01:05:28,545 --> 01:05:29,880 ENOUGH CLINICIANS. 1767 01:05:29,880 --> 01:05:32,616 AND SO WHEN WE ENGAGE THE DOCS, 1768 01:05:32,616 --> 01:05:35,352 I ALSO -- WHAT IS THE MODALITY? 1769 01:05:35,352 --> 01:05:36,920 BECAUSE THIS IS AN INHERENT 1770 01:05:36,920 --> 01:05:39,489 PROBLEM WITH VIDEO AND PHONE 1771 01:05:39,489 --> 01:05:39,723 VISITS. 1772 01:05:39,723 --> 01:05:42,359 I JUST -- OUR HEALTH SYSTEM, ALL 1773 01:05:42,359 --> 01:05:45,195 HEALTH SYSTEMS ARE NOT LIKE A 1774 01:05:45,195 --> 01:05:46,630 LOT OF CARDIOLOGISTS, SITTING 1775 01:05:46,630 --> 01:05:49,032 AROUND, YOU GOT ME MORE ACCESS, 1776 01:05:49,032 --> 01:05:51,234 I CAN TREAT PEOPLE IN -- YOU 1777 01:05:51,234 --> 01:05:53,503 KNOW, DR. GRAHAM IN HIS OPENING 1778 01:05:53,503 --> 01:05:55,605 PLENARY HIGHLIGHTED WHY I GET 1779 01:05:55,605 --> 01:05:56,873 EXCITED, IMAGINING THE PEOPLE ON 1780 01:05:56,873 --> 01:05:58,975 THE CALL GET EXCITED, I WANT TO 1781 01:05:58,975 --> 01:06:00,377 ACKNOWLEDGE THAT IF WE'RE GOING 1782 01:06:00,377 --> 01:06:03,046 TO IMPROVE ACCESS IN THE WAY WE 1783 01:06:03,046 --> 01:06:06,116 REALLY WANT TO, JUST DOING VIDEO 1784 01:06:06,116 --> 01:06:08,085 AND PHONE VISITS DOESN'T IMPROVE 1785 01:06:08,085 --> 01:06:09,519 PRODUCTIVITY OR EFFICIENCY. 1786 01:06:09,519 --> 01:06:13,457 SO WHEN I THINK ABOUT THE FUTURE 1787 01:06:13,457 --> 01:06:16,827 OF TELEHEALTH, WHAT GETS ME MOST 1788 01:06:16,827 --> 01:06:17,828 EXCITED ABOUT REALLY FULFILLING 1789 01:06:17,828 --> 01:06:20,330 THE PROMISE THAT WAS DR. 1790 01:06:20,330 --> 01:06:22,199 GRAHAM'S HIGHLIGHT, I GET A LOT 1791 01:06:22,199 --> 01:06:26,436 MORE EXCITED AND I'M REALLY 1792 01:06:26,436 --> 01:06:28,105 INTERESTED IN TELEHEALTH 1793 01:06:28,105 --> 01:06:28,772 MODALITIES, APPLICATIONS THAT 1794 01:06:28,772 --> 01:06:29,873 IMPROVE PRODUCTIVITY. 1795 01:06:29,873 --> 01:06:32,809 WHAT I MEAN BY THAT IS THAT 1796 01:06:32,809 --> 01:06:34,144 RHEUMATOLOGIST THAT JUDD 1797 01:06:34,144 --> 01:06:36,213 MENTIONED CAN NOW MANAGE MORE 1798 01:06:36,213 --> 01:06:37,748 PATIENTS AND THEREFORE HAVE IN 1799 01:06:37,748 --> 01:06:40,584 HER PANEL THE ABILITY TO REACH 1800 01:06:40,584 --> 01:06:43,019 THAT PATIENT IN THAT RURAL 1801 01:06:43,019 --> 01:06:45,856 COMMUNITY OR THE COMMUNITY IN 1802 01:06:45,856 --> 01:06:47,724 MIAMI WHERE ACCESS WAS DIFFICULT 1803 01:06:47,724 --> 01:06:48,158 BEFORE. 1804 01:06:48,158 --> 01:06:51,194 AND SO THAT MEANS THINGS THAT 1805 01:06:51,194 --> 01:06:52,429 ARE ASYNCHRONOUS WE CAN GO INTO 1806 01:06:52,429 --> 01:06:54,598 THOSE IF YOU WANT, HAPPY TO JUMP 1807 01:06:54,598 --> 01:06:56,333 IN, BUT WANTED TO MAKE THE 1808 01:06:56,333 --> 01:06:57,567 LARGER POINT AS WE THINK ABOUT 1809 01:06:57,567 --> 01:07:00,804 THE FUTURE OF TELEHEALTH 1810 01:07:00,804 --> 01:07:01,938 THINKING ABOUT PRODUCTIVITY AND 1811 01:07:01,938 --> 01:07:03,874 THOSE APPLICATIONS MAY ALLOW US 1812 01:07:03,874 --> 01:07:06,409 TO FULFILL THE GOALS THAT DR. 1813 01:07:06,409 --> 01:07:10,380 GRAHAM REALLY ARTICULATED SO 1814 01:07:10,380 --> 01:07:10,580 WELL. 1815 01:07:10,580 --> 01:07:12,482 >> ONE THING WE DIDN'T TOUCH ON 1816 01:07:12,482 --> 01:07:15,318 SINCE PART OF TODAY IS ABOUT 1817 01:07:15,318 --> 01:07:16,520 IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE, WE NEVER 1818 01:07:16,520 --> 01:07:23,960 IMPLEMENTED IN A WAY ANY 1819 01:07:23,960 --> 01:07:25,028 NORMAL 1820 01:07:25,028 --> 01:07:29,199 SYSTEM WOULD IMELEMENT. -- 1821 01:07:29,199 --> 01:07:30,400 IMPLEMENT HEALTH CARE. 1822 01:07:30,400 --> 01:07:32,469 WHEN I SHIFTED SEVEN YEARS AGO I 1823 01:07:32,469 --> 01:07:33,703 HAD TEN MINUTES OF ORIENTATION, 1824 01:07:33,703 --> 01:07:35,906 HOW DO I DO THIS, WRITE AN 1825 01:07:35,906 --> 01:07:36,940 ORDER, AT MY COMPUTER. 1826 01:07:36,940 --> 01:07:38,441 I KNOW HOW TO DO IT BECAUSE I 1827 01:07:38,441 --> 01:07:40,076 HAD PEOPLE NEXT TO ME WHO KNEW 1828 01:07:40,076 --> 01:07:42,412 HOW TO DO IT. 1829 01:07:42,412 --> 01:07:45,448 WHEN WE ALL STARTED DOING 1830 01:07:45,448 --> 01:07:47,083 TELEMEDICINE IN MARCH OF 2020, 1831 01:07:47,083 --> 01:07:49,419 WHAT WE DID NOT HAVE IS ANYBODY 1832 01:07:49,419 --> 01:07:51,922 NEXT TO US WHO KNEW HOW TO DO 1833 01:07:51,922 --> 01:07:52,355 IT. 1834 01:07:52,355 --> 01:07:54,324 NOR DID MOST INSTITUTIONS HAVE 1835 01:07:54,324 --> 01:07:55,659 ANY TRAINING PROGRAM WHO COULD 1836 01:07:55,659 --> 01:07:57,961 TEACH PEOPLE HOW TO DO IT. 1837 01:07:57,961 --> 01:07:58,829 THE OLDER PEOPLE, THEY DIDN'T 1838 01:07:58,829 --> 01:08:01,364 LIKE IT. 1839 01:08:01,364 --> 01:08:07,804 THEY MAY HAVE BEEN 1840 01:08:07,804 --> 01:08:08,405 TECHNI-PHOBES, YOUNGER PEOPLE 1841 01:08:08,405 --> 01:08:12,642 ARE NO CLINICAL EXPERIENCE AND 1842 01:08:12,642 --> 01:08:13,343 WERE UNCOMFORTABLE IN 1843 01:08:13,343 --> 01:08:14,811 TELEMEDICINE, AND PEOPLE IN THE 1844 01:08:14,811 --> 01:08:16,146 MIDDLE OF THEIR CAREER WHO WOULD 1845 01:08:16,146 --> 01:08:17,747 HAVE EXPERIENCE AND UNDERSTAND 1846 01:08:17,747 --> 01:08:19,316 HOW TO DO THINGS DIDN'T KNOW HOW 1847 01:08:19,316 --> 01:08:20,183 TO DO THINGS. 1848 01:08:20,183 --> 01:08:21,818 SO WHEN YOU ASK THE PERSON NEXT 1849 01:08:21,818 --> 01:08:25,121 TO YOU WHAT TO DO, THEY JUST 1850 01:08:25,121 --> 01:08:26,356 MADE UP SOMETHING AND WHEN THEY 1851 01:08:26,356 --> 01:08:31,027 COULD ONLY DO THE MADE-UP 1852 01:08:31,027 --> 01:08:32,028 SOMETHING, THEY WERE COMFORTABLE 1853 01:08:32,028 --> 01:08:33,563 BECAUSE THE ALTERNATIVE WAS 1854 01:08:33,563 --> 01:08:34,865 PLACING THE LIFE AT RISK BY 1855 01:08:34,865 --> 01:08:36,499 SEEING PEOPLE IN PERSON AND 1856 01:08:36,499 --> 01:08:37,767 NEVER LEARNED TO GET COMFORTABLE 1857 01:08:37,767 --> 01:08:39,369 AND LEARN THE RIGHT WAY TO DO 1858 01:08:39,369 --> 01:08:39,536 IT. 1859 01:08:39,536 --> 01:08:41,538 THERE ARE GOOD WAYS TO DO 1860 01:08:41,538 --> 01:08:43,640 PHYSICAL EXAMS ON TELEMEDICINE. 1861 01:08:43,640 --> 01:08:44,541 WE'VE TRAINED THOUSANDS OF 1862 01:08:44,541 --> 01:08:47,677 PEOPLE ON HOW TO DO BELLY EXAMS 1863 01:08:47,677 --> 01:08:49,112 FOR ACUTE ABDOMINAL PAIN AND 1864 01:08:49,112 --> 01:08:50,180 PICKED UP EVERYTHING YOU COULD 1865 01:08:50,180 --> 01:08:52,816 IMAGINE AND TO THE BEST OF MY 1866 01:08:52,816 --> 01:08:54,251 KNOWLEDGE HAVE MISSED NOTHING 1867 01:08:54,251 --> 01:08:56,019 THAT WE SHOULD HAVE FOUND OVER 1868 01:08:56,019 --> 01:08:57,420 TEN YEARS OF EXPERIENCE. 1869 01:08:57,420 --> 01:08:58,955 I'M SURE THERE'S ONE OR TWO IN 1870 01:08:58,955 --> 01:08:59,189 THERE. 1871 01:08:59,189 --> 01:09:01,057 WE DON'T KNOW ABOUT. 1872 01:09:01,057 --> 01:09:03,460 BUT WE'VE DONE REALLY WELL. 1873 01:09:03,460 --> 01:09:05,128 BUT PEOPLE DON'T HAVE THAT 1874 01:09:05,128 --> 01:09:05,395 TRAINING. 1875 01:09:05,395 --> 01:09:07,931 AND SO IF YOU TRAINED ON HOW TO 1876 01:09:07,931 --> 01:09:10,367 EXAMINE SOMEONE IN PERSON, IT'S 1877 01:09:10,367 --> 01:09:11,868 DIFFERENT ON VIDEO. 1878 01:09:11,868 --> 01:09:14,404 SO AN OPPORTUNITY FOR STUDY IS 1879 01:09:14,404 --> 01:09:17,140 HOW DO WE EXAMINE PEOPLE VIA 1880 01:09:17,140 --> 01:09:18,441 VIDEO TO GET ENOUGH INFORMATION 1881 01:09:18,441 --> 01:09:20,844 TO GET TO THE APPROPRIATE 1882 01:09:20,844 --> 01:09:22,846 ACTIONABLE NEXT STEP WITHOUT 1883 01:09:22,846 --> 01:09:28,084 PLACING QUALITY AT RISK. 1884 01:09:28,084 --> 01:09:30,253 >> KRISTIN, DID YOU HAVE A 1885 01:09:30,253 --> 01:09:30,487 COMMENT? 1886 01:09:30,487 --> 01:09:32,355 >> JUST AGREEING. 1887 01:09:32,355 --> 01:09:35,525 OH, ONE ON THE PREVIOUS POINT, 1888 01:09:35,525 --> 01:09:37,394 WHICH WAS ABOUT THE ASYNCHRONOUS 1889 01:09:37,394 --> 01:09:40,363 AND THE VALUE OF THOSE. 1890 01:09:40,363 --> 01:09:43,300 I 100% AGREE AND OFTEN SEE OR 1891 01:09:43,300 --> 01:09:45,702 HEAR CONVERSATIONS ABOUT USING 1892 01:09:45,702 --> 01:09:46,503 TELEHEALTH TO INCREASE 1893 01:09:46,503 --> 01:09:48,338 AVAILABILITY WHEN IT REALLY ONLY 1894 01:09:48,338 --> 01:09:49,105 INCREASES ACCESS. 1895 01:09:49,105 --> 01:09:51,708 IT DOESN'T CHANGE OUR CAPACITY. 1896 01:09:51,708 --> 01:09:55,545 AND SO I WANT TO SET THAT -- 1897 01:09:55,545 --> 01:09:59,482 EMPHASIZE THAT. 1898 01:09:59,482 --> 01:10:00,583 ALSO SHARE ENTHUSIASM THAT 1899 01:10:00,583 --> 01:10:02,352 THERE'S SO MANY MODELS, AND I 1900 01:10:02,352 --> 01:10:04,087 THINK OUR BEST FUTURE HEALTHCARE 1901 01:10:04,087 --> 01:10:05,522 SYSTEM WILL INVOLVE STITCHING 1902 01:10:05,522 --> 01:10:06,790 THOSE ALONG SO THE PATIENT, YOU 1903 01:10:06,790 --> 01:10:08,825 KNOW, ENTER AT THE DOOR THAT'S 1904 01:10:08,825 --> 01:10:10,093 MOST ACCESSIBLE TO THEM, ARE 1905 01:10:10,093 --> 01:10:12,862 HANDED UP TO THE LEVEL THAT THEY 1906 01:10:12,862 --> 01:10:15,732 MOST NEED BASED ON RECOGNITION 1907 01:10:15,732 --> 01:10:18,034 OF CLINICAL SCENARIOS AS DR. 1908 01:10:18,034 --> 01:10:18,668 HOLLANDER NOTED. 1909 01:10:18,668 --> 01:10:21,304 SO I THINK THAT IT'S NOT AN 1910 01:10:21,304 --> 01:10:22,839 EITHER/OR BUT THE SYSTEM WHERE 1911 01:10:22,839 --> 01:10:24,674 YOU USE THE LOWEST TOUCH 1912 01:10:24,674 --> 01:10:27,010 NECESSARY TO DELIVER THE HIGHEST 1913 01:10:27,010 --> 01:10:28,812 QUALITY CARE. 1914 01:10:28,812 --> 01:10:31,481 >> AND THAT GETS TO THE COMMENT 1915 01:10:31,481 --> 01:10:33,083 MADE EARLIER, JUDD, ABOUT THE 1916 01:10:33,083 --> 01:10:35,418 UNIT OF ANALYSIS SHOULD BE THE 1917 01:10:35,418 --> 01:10:39,055 CARE JOURNEY AND NOT JUST THE 1918 01:10:39,055 --> 01:10:39,589 ONE VISIT. 1919 01:10:39,589 --> 01:10:42,692 AND HOW A PATIENT IS ABLE TO 1920 01:10:42,692 --> 01:10:46,262 ACCESS CARE THEY ARE RECEIVING 1921 01:10:46,262 --> 01:10:48,131 WHEN IT PERTAINS TO DIABETES OR 1922 01:10:48,131 --> 01:10:49,199 HYPERTENSION OUTCOMES, ET 1923 01:10:49,199 --> 01:10:49,432 CETERA. 1924 01:10:49,432 --> 01:10:50,533 I'M GOING TO TRANSITION THE 1925 01:10:50,533 --> 01:10:51,835 CONVERSATION BECAUSE THERE ARE A 1926 01:10:51,835 --> 01:10:54,571 NUMBER OF QUESTIONS RELATED TO 1927 01:10:54,571 --> 01:10:55,438 IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE AND 1928 01:10:55,438 --> 01:10:56,039 IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH WHICH 1929 01:10:56,039 --> 01:10:58,308 REALLY IS THE THEME OF OUR PANEL 1930 01:10:58,308 --> 01:10:58,508 TODAY. 1931 01:10:58,508 --> 01:11:01,811 MAYBE WHAT WE SHOULD DO IS JUST 1932 01:11:01,811 --> 01:11:03,413 REVIEW WHAT ARE THE TELEHEALTH 1933 01:11:03,413 --> 01:11:05,648 DELIVERY METHODS THAT ARE PROVEN 1934 01:11:05,648 --> 01:11:09,886 TO BE EFFECTIVE, WHAT ARE BEST 1935 01:11:09,886 --> 01:11:11,187 PRACTICES, AND ATEEV WAS 1936 01:11:11,187 --> 01:11:13,690 POINTING TO THE NEED FOR WORK 1937 01:11:13,690 --> 01:11:19,629 FLOW TO ENSURE THESE ARE 1938 01:11:19,629 --> 01:11:21,398 IMPLEMENTED EFFECTIVELY ACROSS 1939 01:11:21,398 --> 01:11:21,831 MODALITIES. 1940 01:11:21,831 --> 01:11:23,233 WHAT SHOULD BE RETAINED OR NEED 1941 01:11:23,233 --> 01:11:26,770 TO BE DEVELOPED, WHAT NEEDS TO 1942 01:11:26,770 --> 01:11:34,978 BE IMPLEMENTED FOR FUTURE 1943 01:11:34,978 --> 01:11:36,279 HEALTHCARE DELIVERY? 1944 01:11:36,279 --> 01:11:36,479 ATEEV? 1945 01:11:36,479 --> 01:11:37,781 >> KRISTIN AND JUDD RUN A BIG 1946 01:11:37,781 --> 01:11:39,249 PROGRAM, I'M MORE ON THE 1947 01:11:39,249 --> 01:11:40,016 RESEARCH SIDE. 1948 01:11:40,016 --> 01:11:44,487 CAN I PASS THE BATON ON THAT 1949 01:11:44,487 --> 01:11:45,488 QUESTION? 1950 01:11:45,488 --> 01:11:47,223 >> SURE, DO YOU WANT TO TAKE IT? 1951 01:11:47,223 --> 01:11:48,458 >> YOU CAN GO FIRST. 1952 01:11:48,458 --> 01:11:50,627 I'M POINTING TO YOU. 1953 01:11:50,627 --> 01:11:53,563 >> I THINK ONE THING THAT IS 1954 01:11:53,563 --> 01:11:57,734 MOST IMPORTANT IN THINKING ABOUT 1955 01:11:57,734 --> 01:11:59,369 TELEHEALTH IS JUST HOW MANY 1956 01:11:59,369 --> 01:12:03,406 MODALITIES OF CARE FALL UNDER 1957 01:12:03,406 --> 01:12:05,375 THIS UMBRELLA, THERE IS 1958 01:12:05,375 --> 01:12:06,176 ASYNCHRONOUS AND SYNCHRONOUS, 1959 01:12:06,176 --> 01:12:08,211 AND YOU CAN GO INTO DETAIL ON 1960 01:12:08,211 --> 01:12:08,411 THOSE. 1961 01:12:08,411 --> 01:12:12,415 BUT I THINK EVEN WITHIN LIVE 1962 01:12:12,415 --> 01:12:14,684 INTERACTIVE TELEMEDICINE THERE'S 1963 01:12:14,684 --> 01:12:16,019 DIFFERENCES IN WHETHER 1964 01:12:16,019 --> 01:12:16,753 PERIPHERALS ARE AVAILABLE, 1965 01:12:16,753 --> 01:12:18,555 WHETHER IT'S HAPPENING IN THE 1966 01:12:18,555 --> 01:12:20,657 CONTEXT OF AN ONGOING CARE 1967 01:12:20,657 --> 01:12:23,026 RELATIONSHIP, WHETHER THERE IS 1968 01:12:23,026 --> 01:12:24,928 CONTINUITY OF RECORD AND PEOPLE 1969 01:12:24,928 --> 01:12:26,229 HAVE ACCESS TO EHR. 1970 01:12:26,229 --> 01:12:29,933 I THINK THAT WHEN WE'RE THINKING 1971 01:12:29,933 --> 01:12:31,868 ABOUT THE IMPLEMENTATION 1972 01:12:31,868 --> 01:12:33,369 QUESTION, IT'S NOT TELEHEALTH 1973 01:12:33,369 --> 01:12:35,305 YES/NO BUT TELEHEALTH IN THIS 1974 01:12:35,305 --> 01:12:36,206 CONTEXT, TELEHEALTH IN THAT 1975 01:12:36,206 --> 01:12:38,374 CONTEXT, THAT WE NEED TO BE 1976 01:12:38,374 --> 01:12:39,809 THINKING ABOUT TO IDENTIFY WHAT 1977 01:12:39,809 --> 01:12:41,544 THE BEST WAYS AND WHAT ARE THE 1978 01:12:41,544 --> 01:12:44,280 MODELS THAT ARE EMERGING THAT 1979 01:12:44,280 --> 01:12:47,283 ARE SHOWING IN THE MOST PROMISE 1980 01:12:47,283 --> 01:12:49,786 THAT WE CAN LIFT UP. 1981 01:12:49,786 --> 01:12:52,956 SOME KEY THINGS ARE -- THAT ARE 1982 01:12:52,956 --> 01:12:54,724 EMERGING ARE NOT NECESSARILY IN 1983 01:12:54,724 --> 01:12:56,693 THE TECHNOLOGY ITSELF. 1984 01:12:56,693 --> 01:12:59,095 I THINK COMMUNICATION SKILLS AND 1985 01:12:59,095 --> 01:13:00,597 THE EXAM SKILLS, THE TRAINING, 1986 01:13:00,597 --> 01:13:02,065 ALL OF THOSE I THINK ARE 1987 01:13:02,065 --> 01:13:04,601 ESSENTIAL THAT WE MAKE SURE 1988 01:13:04,601 --> 01:13:05,902 WE'RE UNDERSTANDING AND 1989 01:13:05,902 --> 01:13:07,437 ILLUMINATING BEST PRACTICES. 1990 01:13:07,437 --> 01:13:09,405 ONE EXAMPLE OF A STUDY I FOUND 1991 01:13:09,405 --> 01:13:10,807 REALLY POWERFUL THAT I THINK IS 1992 01:13:10,807 --> 01:13:12,775 THE TYPE OF WORK WE NEED IN 1993 01:13:12,775 --> 01:13:14,444 TELEHEALTH WAS A STUDY THAT CAME 1994 01:13:14,444 --> 01:13:15,745 OUT OF KAISER IN THE LAST YEAR 1995 01:13:15,745 --> 01:13:19,916 OR SO WHERE THEY WERE LOOKING AT 1996 01:13:19,916 --> 01:13:21,918 IMPACT OF VIRTUAL ROOMING 1997 01:13:21,918 --> 01:13:24,954 PROCESSES WHERE THEY HAD M.A. OR 1998 01:13:24,954 --> 01:13:30,460 R.N. ROOM PATIENT VIRTUALLY, 1999 01:13:30,460 --> 01:13:33,863 SCHEDULED APPOINTMENTS, NOT ONLY 2000 01:13:33,863 --> 01:13:36,366 THAT NO-SHOW RATE BUT REDUCED 2001 01:13:36,366 --> 01:13:39,335 NEW-SHOW RATE MORE FOR THOSE WHO 2002 01:13:39,335 --> 01:13:41,004 WERE DISADVANTAGED POPULATIONS, 2003 01:13:41,004 --> 01:13:46,442 WHETHER IT WAS LANGUAGE OR 2004 01:13:46,442 --> 01:13:49,279 MINORITIZED RACE AND ETHNICITY. 2005 01:13:49,279 --> 01:13:50,480 IDENTIFYING OPPORTUNITIES THAT 2006 01:13:50,480 --> 01:13:55,552 IMPROVE ACCESS OR EFFECTS E-- 2007 01:13:55,552 --> 01:13:56,619 EFFECTIVENESS FOR ALL BUT 2008 01:13:56,619 --> 01:13:58,821 ESPECIALLY THOSE NOT WELL SERVED 2009 01:13:58,821 --> 01:13:59,522 BY TRADITIONAL HEALTHCARE SYSTEM 2010 01:13:59,522 --> 01:14:03,293 IS ONE OF THE PLACES I GET MOST 2011 01:14:03,293 --> 01:14:04,494 EXCITED ABOUT. 2012 01:14:04,494 --> 01:14:06,930 >> SO I'M GOING TO ADD BUT BEGIN 2013 01:14:06,930 --> 01:14:08,731 WITH A COMMENT THAT WE SHOULDN'T 2014 01:14:08,731 --> 01:14:10,633 HOLD TELEMEDICINE TO A HIGHER 2015 01:14:10,633 --> 01:14:12,902 STANDARD OF CARE THAN IN-PERSON 2016 01:14:12,902 --> 01:14:13,369 CARE, RIGHT? 2017 01:14:13,369 --> 01:14:15,038 IT SHOULD BE ITS OWN THING. 2018 01:14:15,038 --> 01:14:16,372 I THINK THAT'S IMPORTANT. 2019 01:14:16,372 --> 01:14:18,575 AND THEN I THINK WE'VE FAILED 2020 01:14:18,575 --> 01:14:20,877 THE WORLD IN SHOWING 2021 01:14:20,877 --> 01:14:22,212 TELEMEDICINE'S EFFECTIVENESS 2022 01:14:22,212 --> 01:14:24,180 BECAUSE WE HAVEN'T DEMANDED THE 2023 01:14:24,180 --> 01:14:26,516 SAME THING WITH NEW DEVICES AND 2024 01:14:26,516 --> 01:14:30,420 NEW TOYS THAT WE DEMAND WITH NEW 2025 01:14:30,420 --> 01:14:30,753 DRUGS. 2026 01:14:30,753 --> 01:14:32,622 SO, IF, FOR EXAMPLE, YOU'RE A 2027 01:14:32,622 --> 01:14:34,357 START-UP PHARMA COMPANY AND YOU 2028 01:14:34,357 --> 01:14:36,526 HAVE A VERY PROMISING MOLECULE, 2029 01:14:36,526 --> 01:14:38,828 YOU DON'T GET TO SAY, HERE, 2030 01:14:38,828 --> 01:14:39,929 JUDD, USE THIS, WE THINK IT'S 2031 01:14:39,929 --> 01:14:41,231 COOL AND IT'S GOING HELP YOUR 2032 01:14:41,231 --> 01:14:44,100 PATIENTS AND HAVE A RETURN ON 2033 01:14:44,100 --> 01:14:44,400 INVESTMENT. 2034 01:14:44,400 --> 01:14:45,635 YOU HAVE TO PROVE IT. 2035 01:14:45,635 --> 01:14:47,937 IF YOU'RE A REMOTE PATIENT 2036 01:14:47,937 --> 01:14:49,138 MONITORING COMPANY, YOU COULD 2037 01:14:49,138 --> 01:14:50,039 SAY, YOU KNOW, BLOOD PRESSURE 2038 01:14:50,039 --> 01:14:51,541 EVERY ONCE IN A WHILE IS GOOD SO 2039 01:14:51,541 --> 01:14:52,976 WE'LL DO IT EVERY MINUTE OF THE 2040 01:14:52,976 --> 01:14:54,177 DAY AND HERE IS A DEVICE YOU 2041 01:14:54,177 --> 01:14:56,479 COULD DO IT EVERY MINUTE OF THE 2042 01:14:56,479 --> 01:14:58,748 DAY, WITH NO PROOF THAT IT 2043 01:14:58,748 --> 01:15:00,583 ACTUALLY GENERALLY CHANGES THE 2044 01:15:00,583 --> 01:15:03,353 OUTCOME FOR PATIENTS TO DO MORE 2045 01:15:03,353 --> 01:15:05,555 OF SOMETHING THAT WORKED LESS. 2046 01:15:05,555 --> 01:15:10,360 AND SO, I THINK THAT WE HAVE AN 2047 01:15:10,360 --> 01:15:12,862 OBLIGATION TO REQUIRE START-UPS 2048 01:15:12,862 --> 01:15:14,297 IN THE DEVICE TELEMEDICINE 2049 01:15:14,297 --> 01:15:20,503 INDUSTRY TO -- WHEN WHEN THEY E 2050 01:15:20,503 --> 01:15:22,272 RAISING MONEY ARE THE SAME 2051 01:15:22,272 --> 01:15:24,574 STANDARDS AND PHARMA, TO DO 2052 01:15:24,574 --> 01:15:26,342 CLINICAL TRIALS TO IMPROVE YOUR 2053 01:15:26,342 --> 01:15:28,645 TOY MAKES IMPACT ON PATIENTS. 2054 01:15:28,645 --> 01:15:30,313 HEALTH SYSTEMS DON'T HAVE BIG 2055 01:15:30,313 --> 01:15:30,680 MARGINS. 2056 01:15:30,680 --> 01:15:33,883 BUTTER 2057 01:15:33,883 --> 01:15:35,652 BUT -- BUT THERE ARE SOME 2058 01:15:35,652 --> 01:15:37,954 THINGS, I'LL GIVE AN EXAMPLE 2059 01:15:37,954 --> 01:15:39,389 SOMETHING WE LAUNCHED ALMOST BY 2060 01:15:39,389 --> 01:15:39,789 MISTAKE. 2061 01:15:39,789 --> 01:15:41,257 SOMETIMES YOU JUST GET LUCKY. 2062 01:15:41,257 --> 01:15:45,395 WE BUILT A BEAUTIFUL NEW 2063 01:15:45,395 --> 01:15:46,262 BUILDING, $800 MILLION, WHEN 2064 01:15:46,262 --> 01:15:48,698 THEY DESIGNED IT, I HATE TO 2065 01:15:48,698 --> 01:15:50,233 THINK THIS IS RECORDED, LET'S 2066 01:15:50,233 --> 01:15:52,302 SAY THEY RAN OUT OF SPACE TO PUT 2067 01:15:52,302 --> 01:15:53,970 PEOPLE WHO WOULD CHECK OUT THE 2068 01:15:53,970 --> 01:15:54,237 PATIENTS. 2069 01:15:54,237 --> 01:15:56,039 AND SO THEY SAID CAN YOU COME UP 2070 01:15:56,039 --> 01:15:57,440 WITH A SOLUTION? 2071 01:15:57,440 --> 01:15:59,375 AND A COUPLE TEAMS SAT TOGETHER 2072 01:15:59,375 --> 01:16:01,277 IN A ROOM, WHITE BOARDED IT, 2073 01:16:01,277 --> 01:16:03,146 CAME UP WITH A CONCEPT OF 2074 01:16:03,146 --> 01:16:04,047 VIRTUAL CHECKOUT. 2075 01:16:04,047 --> 01:16:05,882 NOW IN EVERY SINGLE ROOM THAT 2076 01:16:05,882 --> 01:16:13,656 YOU GO INTO, THE WORK FLOW FROM 2077 01:16:13,656 --> 01:16:14,891 THE KIOSK, TO THE PHYSICIAN, 2078 01:16:14,891 --> 01:16:16,092 THERE'S A WHITE BOARD, WHEN 2079 01:16:16,092 --> 01:16:20,697 YOU'RE READY TO GET DRESSED, 2080 01:16:20,697 --> 01:16:23,666 HIT 2081 01:16:23,666 --> 01:16:24,667 THE BUTTON, WE'VE DONE 70,000 2082 01:16:24,667 --> 01:16:26,402 THINGS APRIL, IT WASN'T 2083 01:16:26,402 --> 01:16:27,337 PRE-PLANNED, SOMEBODY MAKES THE 2084 01:16:27,337 --> 01:16:28,271 FOLLOW-UP APPOINTMENT ON THE 2085 01:16:28,271 --> 01:16:28,504 SCREEN. 2086 01:16:28,504 --> 01:16:31,341 NOT ONLY THAT, THIS WEEK IT'S 2087 01:16:31,341 --> 01:16:32,542 LAUNCHING PATIENT PREFERRED 2088 01:16:32,542 --> 01:16:35,578 LANGUAGE, SO OF THE 22 PEOPLE WE 2089 01:16:35,578 --> 01:16:38,014 HAVE DOING CHECKOUT FOR THE SIX, 2090 01:16:38,014 --> 01:16:39,649 SEVEN HUNDRED PATIENTS WE'RE 2091 01:16:39,649 --> 01:16:41,617 SEEING A DAY, THEY WILL KNOW 2092 01:16:41,617 --> 01:16:42,819 WHAT THEIR PRIMARY LANGUAGE IS 2093 01:16:42,819 --> 01:16:45,822 AND IF WE HAVE SOMEBODY WHO IS 2094 01:16:45,822 --> 01:16:46,956 BILINGUAL IN SPANISH THEY WILL 2095 01:16:46,956 --> 01:16:48,725 JUMP THAT PATIENT TO THE FRONT 2096 01:16:48,725 --> 01:16:51,127 OF THEIR QUEUE. 2097 01:16:51,127 --> 01:16:52,862 WE SAY TRANSLATORS, THEY CHECK 2098 01:16:52,862 --> 01:16:55,398 OUT BY SOMEBODY WHO SPEAKS THEIR 2099 01:16:55,398 --> 01:16:56,165 LANGUAGE, LOOKS LIKE THEM, MAKES 2100 01:16:56,165 --> 01:16:57,033 THEIR APPOINTMENT. 2101 01:16:57,033 --> 01:16:58,034 OUR DATA WHICH WE'RE BEGINNING 2102 01:16:58,034 --> 01:17:00,870 TO LOOK AT SHOWS AVERAGE TIME TO 2103 01:17:00,870 --> 01:17:02,839 APPOINTMENT BEING MADE IN THE 2104 01:17:02,839 --> 01:17:04,374 BUILDING WHETHER VIRTUAL 2105 01:17:04,374 --> 01:17:06,476 CHECKOUT OR NOT IS NOW ONE DAY, 2106 01:17:06,476 --> 01:17:07,543 AND IN OUR SYSTEM WHEN YOU GO 2107 01:17:07,543 --> 01:17:11,047 HOME AND WE SAY MAKE APPOINTMENT 2108 01:17:11,047 --> 01:17:12,382 WITH CARDIOLOGY OR WHOEVER, IT'S 2109 01:17:12,382 --> 01:17:15,318 15 DAYS WHICH WE KNOW CORRELATES 2110 01:17:15,318 --> 01:17:17,954 WITH NO-SHOW RATES AND THINGS OF 2111 01:17:17,954 --> 01:17:18,221 THE SUCH. 2112 01:17:18,221 --> 01:17:21,023 SO A REALLY SIMPLE THING THAT 2113 01:17:21,023 --> 01:17:22,225 WOULD NEVER GET MEASURED IN 2114 01:17:22,225 --> 01:17:25,094 TERMS OF IS THERE VALUE TO CARE 2115 01:17:25,094 --> 01:17:27,263 HAS CHANGED OUR IN-PERSON VISITS 2116 01:17:27,263 --> 01:17:28,798 BECAUSE WE FOUND A DIFFERENT WAY 2117 01:17:28,798 --> 01:17:31,334 TO DO HYBRID CARE. 2118 01:17:31,334 --> 01:17:34,504 I THINK, YOU KNOW, PATIENT 2119 01:17:34,504 --> 01:17:38,474 SATISFACTION IS THROUGH THE ROOF 2120 01:17:38,474 --> 01:17:39,876 WITH IT AND WASN'T EXPERIENCE. 2121 01:17:39,876 --> 01:17:41,644 >> WONDERFUL TO THINK ABOUT CARE 2122 01:17:41,644 --> 01:17:42,612 TRANSITION RELATED TO 2123 01:17:42,612 --> 01:17:43,713 INTERVENTION AND HEALTH EQUITY 2124 01:17:43,713 --> 01:17:44,714 ASPECT OF IT. 2125 01:17:44,714 --> 01:17:48,317 AND IT IS INTERESTING THAT IT 2126 01:17:48,317 --> 01:17:50,286 WASN'T DESIGNED IN ADVANCE, 2127 01:17:50,286 --> 01:17:51,320 PROACTIVELY, BUT ACTUALLY WAS 2128 01:17:51,320 --> 01:17:54,090 JUST A CONSEQUENCE OF THE 2129 01:17:54,090 --> 01:17:54,957 CONSTRAINTS BEING PRESENTED. 2130 01:17:54,957 --> 01:17:57,059 THAT RELATES TO THE NEXT 2131 01:17:57,059 --> 01:17:58,361 QUESTION COMING IN FROM ONE OF 2132 01:17:58,361 --> 01:18:00,463 THE MEMBERS OF OUR AUDIENCE 2133 01:18:00,463 --> 01:18:01,164 TODAY. 2134 01:18:01,164 --> 01:18:03,866 SO, IT SAYS THANKS FOR A GREAT 2135 01:18:03,866 --> 01:18:06,602 COMMENT, OUTLINING THE GOALS AND 2136 01:18:06,602 --> 01:18:10,306 PRACTICE BETWEEN RESEARCH AND 2137 01:18:10,306 --> 01:18:11,407 CLINICAL PRACTICE. 2138 01:18:11,407 --> 01:18:13,176 AND THEN THAT TELEHEALTH SHOULD 2139 01:18:13,176 --> 01:18:21,818 BE TAILORED TO MEET THE GOALS OF 2140 01:18:21,818 --> 01:18:22,685 ALL SETTINGS, AND KEEP 2141 01:18:22,685 --> 01:18:23,085 INTEROPERABILITY. 2142 01:18:23,085 --> 01:18:24,587 AND WHAT IS THE OPPORTUNITY TO 2143 01:18:24,587 --> 01:18:25,855 INTEGRATE RESEARCH INTO THE 2144 01:18:25,855 --> 01:18:27,723 DESIGN OF TELEHEALTH? 2145 01:18:27,723 --> 01:18:31,861 AND WHAT SHOULD WE CONSIDER AS 2146 01:18:31,861 --> 01:18:32,862 WE INTENTIONALLY INTEGRATE A 2147 01:18:32,862 --> 01:18:34,597 DESIGN FEATURE IN THE 2148 01:18:34,597 --> 01:18:36,899 IMPLEMENTATION OF TELEHEALTH AND 2149 01:18:36,899 --> 01:18:38,100 WHAT ARE THE CHALLENGES RELATED 2150 01:18:38,100 --> 01:18:39,302 TO THAT? 2151 01:18:39,302 --> 01:18:40,770 YOU GOT INTO THIS, JUDD, A 2152 01:18:40,770 --> 01:18:43,473 LITTLE BIT BUT I WANTED TO OPEN 2153 01:18:43,473 --> 01:18:46,309 TO THE ENTIRE PANEL. 2154 01:18:46,309 --> 01:18:49,278 >> ONE THING I WOULD JUST -- IN 2155 01:18:49,278 --> 01:18:50,046 TERMS OF IMPLEMENTATION SIDE, 2156 01:18:50,046 --> 01:18:51,914 BUILDING ON THE QUESTION, WE'VE 2157 01:18:51,914 --> 01:18:53,449 DONE WORK REMOTE PATIENT 2158 01:18:53,449 --> 01:18:56,385 MONITORING FOR HIGH BLOOD 2159 01:18:56,385 --> 01:18:56,652 PRESSURE. 2160 01:18:56,652 --> 01:18:58,588 THE QUESTION WAS WHAT ARE THINGS 2161 01:18:58,588 --> 01:18:59,789 YOU GET EXCITED ABOUT, THAT'S 2162 01:18:59,789 --> 01:18:59,956 ONE. 2163 01:18:59,956 --> 01:19:03,259 I THINK IT'S A REALLY GOOD 2164 01:19:03,259 --> 01:19:04,293 MODEL, BETTER MODEL MANAGING 2165 01:19:04,293 --> 01:19:05,261 HIGH BLOOD PRESSURE. 2166 01:19:05,261 --> 01:19:09,131 BUT I THINK WHEN I SAY THAT, I 2167 01:19:09,131 --> 01:19:11,200 HAVE TREPIDATION BECAUSE WHEN 2168 01:19:11,200 --> 01:19:13,936 YOU GO AND TALK AND SAY, HOW DO 2169 01:19:13,936 --> 01:19:15,338 YOU ACTUALLY DO THIS, LIKE WHO 2170 01:19:15,338 --> 01:19:18,274 THE HECK IS ACTUALLY GETTING THE 2171 01:19:18,274 --> 01:19:20,276 BLOOD PRESSURE MEASUREMENT, WHO 2172 01:19:20,276 --> 01:19:21,577 REACTS TO THAT INFORMATION, WHAT 2173 01:19:21,577 --> 01:19:22,578 HAPPENS IF IT'S REALLY HIGH 2174 01:19:22,578 --> 01:19:24,413 BLOOD PRESSURE IN THE MIDDLE OF 2175 01:19:24,413 --> 01:19:26,315 THE NIGHT, WHO RESPONDS? 2176 01:19:26,315 --> 01:19:28,251 OH MY GOSH, THERE'S SO MUCH 2177 01:19:28,251 --> 01:19:28,518 VARIATION. 2178 01:19:28,518 --> 01:19:31,320 AND SO WE THINK ABOUT 2179 01:19:31,320 --> 01:19:32,388 IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE RESEARCH, 2180 01:19:32,388 --> 01:19:35,458 THESE ARE THE KINDS OF 2181 01:19:35,458 --> 01:19:35,892 QUESTIONS. 2182 01:19:35,892 --> 01:19:37,226 THEY SOUND BORING BUT THEY ARE 2183 01:19:37,226 --> 01:19:37,760 REALLY IMPORTANT, OF 2184 01:19:37,760 --> 01:19:41,030 UNDERSTANDING WHAT IS THE 2185 01:19:41,030 --> 01:19:42,231 NUANCES, HOW DO YOU IMPLEMENT 2186 01:19:42,231 --> 01:19:44,534 SUCH A PROGRAM BECAUSE SMALL 2187 01:19:44,534 --> 01:19:45,868 CHANGES CAN MAKE BIG DIFFERENCE 2188 01:19:45,868 --> 01:19:48,170 IN IMPACT OF HIGH BLOOD 2189 01:19:48,170 --> 01:19:48,738 PRESSURE. 2190 01:19:48,738 --> 01:19:50,907 SO -- AND OUTCOMES WE LOOK AT. 2191 01:19:50,907 --> 01:19:54,510 SO, THAT WAS JUST ONE ASPECT OF 2192 01:19:54,510 --> 01:19:54,710 THAT. 2193 01:19:54,710 --> 01:19:59,348 ANOTHER THING THAT I WANTED TO 2194 01:19:59,348 --> 01:20:01,217 EMPHASIZE THE QUESTION MADE ME 2195 01:20:01,217 --> 01:20:02,852 THINK ABOUT WAS JUDD MADE THE 2196 01:20:02,852 --> 01:20:04,253 POINT ABOUT REMOTE PATIENT 2197 01:20:04,253 --> 01:20:05,354 MONITORING, YOU CAN JUST SORT OF 2198 01:20:05,354 --> 01:20:06,122 DO IT. 2199 01:20:06,122 --> 01:20:07,456 IT DRIVES ME CRAZY THAT YOU CAN 2200 01:20:07,456 --> 01:20:09,659 JUST DO SOMETHING LIKE THAT AS 2201 01:20:09,659 --> 01:20:13,930 OPPOSED TO A NEW MOLECULE. 2202 01:20:13,930 --> 01:20:15,698 THE TITLE OF THIS OVERALL THING 2203 01:20:15,698 --> 01:20:17,733 IS DIRECT TO CONSUMER. 2204 01:20:17,733 --> 01:20:19,402 ONE THING WE'VE NEGLECTED HERE A 2205 01:20:19,402 --> 01:20:21,804 BIT IS THAT BEYOND -- WE'VE BEEN 2206 01:20:21,804 --> 01:20:23,439 HEALTH SYSTEM FOCUSED GIVEN THE 2207 01:20:23,439 --> 01:20:26,509 NATURE OF THE PANEL OF WHAT'S 2208 01:20:26,509 --> 01:20:30,913 HAPPENED AT JEFFERSON, UPMC. 2209 01:20:30,913 --> 01:20:33,449 BUT THERE ARE HUNDREDS AND 2210 01:20:33,449 --> 01:20:35,751 HUNDREDS OF START-UPS OUT THERE 2211 01:20:35,751 --> 01:20:37,687 THAT DO A TELEMEDICINE-ONLY 2212 01:20:37,687 --> 01:20:38,921 MODEL, NOT WHAT FERNANDO WAS 2213 01:20:38,921 --> 01:20:40,423 TALKING ABOUT HYBRID OR ADJUNCT, 2214 01:20:40,423 --> 01:20:41,591 THIS IS A TELEMEDICINE-ONLY 2215 01:20:41,591 --> 01:20:43,292 MODEL. 2216 01:20:43,292 --> 01:20:46,028 AND THEY ARE PROVIDING CARE TO 2217 01:20:46,028 --> 01:20:46,729 PROBABLY MILLIONS OF PATIENTS, 2218 01:20:46,729 --> 01:20:48,331 AMERICANS IN THE UNITED STATES, 2219 01:20:48,331 --> 01:20:50,399 AND WE DON'T KNOW, WE DO NOT 2220 01:20:50,399 --> 01:20:55,538 HAVE GOOD DATA ON WHETHER THEIR 2221 01:20:55,538 --> 01:20:56,572 PARTICULAR MODEL IS HELPFUL, HOW 2222 01:20:56,572 --> 01:20:58,774 DOES IT BUILT WITH EXISTING 2223 01:20:58,774 --> 01:21:00,576 HEALTHCARE SYSTEM, WHICH ARE 2224 01:21:00,576 --> 01:21:01,577 WORKING AND NOT WORKING. 2225 01:21:01,577 --> 01:21:03,346 WE SHOULD NOT HAVE AN 2226 01:21:03,346 --> 01:21:04,780 EXPECTATION THE STARTUPS WILL 2227 01:21:04,780 --> 01:21:06,482 EVALUATE THEMSELVES. 2228 01:21:06,482 --> 01:21:07,850 THEY DON'T HAVE INCENTIVE, THEY 2229 01:21:07,850 --> 01:21:08,484 DON'T HAVE TO. 2230 01:21:08,484 --> 01:21:10,119 SO THIS IS ANOTHER AREA OF 2231 01:21:10,119 --> 01:21:12,521 RESEARCH THAT I'M REALLY 2232 01:21:12,521 --> 01:21:13,823 THINKING ABOUT WHICH IS WE MAY 2233 01:21:13,823 --> 01:21:16,025 LIKE 'EM, WE MAY NOT LIKE 'EM, 2234 01:21:16,025 --> 01:21:17,159 BUT WE NEED TO UNDERSTAND WHAT 2235 01:21:17,159 --> 01:21:19,128 IMPACT THEY ARE HAVING. 2236 01:21:19,128 --> 01:21:21,864 SO WANTED TO THROW OUT ANOTHER 2237 01:21:21,864 --> 01:21:22,932 AREA AND THINKING ABOUT WHAT 2238 01:21:22,932 --> 01:21:25,668 ROLE THEY HAVE IN THE OVERALL 2239 01:21:25,668 --> 01:21:28,537 CARE THAT PATIENTS ARE 2240 01:21:28,537 --> 01:21:30,072 RECEIVING. 2241 01:21:30,072 --> 01:21:32,141 >> AND THE IMPLEMENTATION 2242 01:21:32,141 --> 01:21:36,212 SCIENCE OPPORTUNITY AS WELL. 2243 01:21:36,212 --> 01:21:37,947 I'LL MOVE TO ANOTHER QUESTION 2244 01:21:37,947 --> 01:21:39,815 THAT IS VERY INTERESTING TO ME 2245 01:21:39,815 --> 01:21:42,118 AS WE THINK ABOUT OTHER 2246 01:21:42,118 --> 01:21:45,755 PROVIDERS, WE'VE BEEN TALKING 2247 01:21:45,755 --> 01:21:48,257 ABOUT PHYSICIANS, WHAT ABOUT THE 2248 01:21:48,257 --> 01:21:50,292 ADVANCED PRACTICE PROFESSIONALS, 2249 01:21:50,292 --> 01:21:51,661 NURSES, SOCIAL WORKERS, OTHER 2250 01:21:51,661 --> 01:21:54,930 MEMBERS OF THE CARE TEAM, AND 2251 01:21:54,930 --> 01:21:58,634 WHAT IS YOUR EXPERIENCE WITH THE 2252 01:21:58,634 --> 01:22:00,736 UPTAKE AND INTEREST AND 2253 01:22:00,736 --> 01:22:02,805 ENGAGEMENT IN TELEHEALTH 2254 01:22:02,805 --> 01:22:04,674 MODALITIES, AND THESE -- AMONG 2255 01:22:04,674 --> 01:22:06,542 THESE TEAM MEMBERS? 2256 01:22:06,542 --> 01:22:07,543 >> SO I HAVE PRETTY GOOD 2257 01:22:07,543 --> 01:22:08,844 EXPERIENCE WITH THAT. 2258 01:22:08,844 --> 01:22:09,545 I DON'T HAVE IMPLEMENTATION 2259 01:22:09,545 --> 01:22:11,681 SCIENCE ON IT BUT I DO HAVE 2260 01:22:11,681 --> 01:22:12,782 PATIENT SATISFACTION SCORES. 2261 01:22:12,782 --> 01:22:14,750 AND IT TURNS OUT WHEN WE FIRST 2262 01:22:14,750 --> 01:22:17,153 LAUNCHED OUR PROGRAM TEN YEARS 2263 01:22:17,153 --> 01:22:18,454 AGO, WE ACTUALLY WERE, YOU KNOW, 2264 01:22:18,454 --> 01:22:19,889 PROBABLY A LITTLE ARROGANT FOR 2265 01:22:19,889 --> 01:22:21,190 AN ACADEMIC HEALTH SYSTEM AND 2266 01:22:21,190 --> 01:22:22,291 THOUGHT EVERYBODY'S GOING TO 2267 01:22:22,291 --> 01:22:24,493 WANT TO SEE AN E.R. DOC WHO IS 2268 01:22:24,493 --> 01:22:25,695 WELL VERSED FROM AN ACADEMIC 2269 01:22:25,695 --> 01:22:26,128 MEDICAL CENTER. 2270 01:22:26,128 --> 01:22:27,663 UNTIL ONE OF OUR EARLY SURVEYS 2271 01:22:27,663 --> 01:22:30,933 WAS HOW MUCH DO YOU CARE IFS AN 2272 01:22:30,933 --> 01:22:33,569 E.R., PRIMARY CARE DOC OR NURSE 2273 01:22:33,569 --> 01:22:35,004 PRACTITIONER, WE ONLY CARE IF 2274 01:22:35,004 --> 01:22:37,506 SOMEBODY ANSWERS THE VIDEO RIGHT 2275 01:22:37,506 --> 01:22:37,873 AWAY. 2276 01:22:37,873 --> 01:22:38,808 WHAT'S THE IMPORTANCE OF 2277 01:22:38,808 --> 01:22:42,078 SOMEBODY ACADEMIC OR NOT, THE 2278 01:22:42,078 --> 01:22:43,412 IMPORTANCE WAS LIKE NOTHING. 2279 01:22:43,412 --> 01:22:45,347 AND SO WE LEARNED, OKAY, WE'RE 2280 01:22:45,347 --> 01:22:49,985 SPENDING A LOT OF MONEY ON E.R. 2281 01:22:49,985 --> 01:22:53,923 DOCS 24/7, MOST COMPLAINTS ARE 2282 01:22:53,923 --> 01:22:55,024 HANDLED BY NURSE PRACTITIONERS 2283 01:22:55,024 --> 01:22:59,962 ACROSS THE COUNTRY. 2284 01:22:59,962 --> 01:23:00,863 WE STARTED TRANSITIONING, 2285 01:23:00,863 --> 01:23:02,932 PATIENT SATISFACTION SCORES, WE 2286 01:23:02,932 --> 01:23:03,666 HAVE METRICS, ARE BASICALLY THE 2287 01:23:03,666 --> 01:23:05,000 SAME BETWEEN THE TWO GROUPS WITH 2288 01:23:05,000 --> 01:23:06,102 THE EXCEPTION OF COST. 2289 01:23:06,102 --> 01:23:08,437 SO I THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT 2290 01:23:08,437 --> 01:23:12,007 TO EXTEND IT TO NON-PHYSICIANS. 2291 01:23:12,007 --> 01:23:14,944 WE HAVE RECENTLY LAUNCHED 2292 01:23:14,944 --> 01:23:17,513 INPATIENT TELEMEDICINE, LARGELY 2293 01:23:17,513 --> 01:23:18,514 WITH VIRTUAL NURSING AND 2294 01:23:18,514 --> 01:23:21,150 TELESITTING, WE'VE HAD THAT FOR 2295 01:23:21,150 --> 01:23:21,684 A WHILE. 2296 01:23:21,684 --> 01:23:23,452 AND THIS IS REALLY IMPORTANT 2297 01:23:23,452 --> 01:23:26,388 WHEN YOU EVALUATE IT BECAUSE 2298 01:23:26,388 --> 01:23:30,025 THERE'S GOOD ROI MODELS FOR HARD 2299 01:23:30,025 --> 01:23:32,094 AND SOFT RELATED TO NURSING, WE 2300 01:23:32,094 --> 01:23:36,065 THINT -- DIDN'T SHOW THEM IN TE 2301 01:23:36,065 --> 01:23:37,700 PILOT PHASE BECAUSE EVERYBODY 2302 01:23:37,700 --> 01:23:39,535 WITH EXPERIENCE DOING VIRTUAL 2303 01:23:39,535 --> 01:23:40,736 NURSING SAID NURSES HAVE TO BE 2304 01:23:40,736 --> 01:23:43,038 OFF SITE AND NOT TIED, BEING 2305 01:23:43,038 --> 01:23:44,807 ABLE TO PULL TO THE UNIT. 2306 01:23:44,807 --> 01:23:46,876 WE THOUGHT, WELL, WHAT A GREAT 2307 01:23:46,876 --> 01:23:49,278 WAY TO BEGIN, IF NURSES KNOW THE 2308 01:23:49,278 --> 01:23:50,279 VIRTUAL NURSES, THEY WILL BE 2309 01:23:50,279 --> 01:23:50,946 MORE COMFORTABLE. 2310 01:23:50,946 --> 01:23:52,081 YOU KNOW WHAT THEY ARE? 2311 01:23:52,081 --> 01:23:53,949 HALF THE TIME PULLED BACK TO THE 2312 01:23:53,949 --> 01:23:55,684 UNIT BECAUSE SOMEBODY'S OUT 2313 01:23:55,684 --> 01:23:56,118 SICK. 2314 01:23:56,118 --> 01:23:58,420 AND SO VIRTUAL NURSE PROGRAM IS 2315 01:23:58,420 --> 01:24:00,689 AT RISK BECAUSE OUR INITIAL 2316 01:24:00,689 --> 01:24:02,958 ASSESSMENT WAS FLAWED BY THE WAY 2317 01:24:02,958 --> 01:24:03,626 WE IMPLEMENTED IT. 2318 01:24:03,626 --> 01:24:06,562 AND SO WE HAVE NOW DECIDED THAT 2319 01:24:06,562 --> 01:24:07,463 YES, YOU'RE RIGHT, IF WE'RE 2320 01:24:07,463 --> 01:24:08,998 GOING TO CONTINUE DOING IT THIS 2321 01:24:08,998 --> 01:24:10,566 WAY SHOULD GIVE UP THE PROGRAM. 2322 01:24:10,566 --> 01:24:12,034 BUT WE PROBABLY SHOULD HAVE DONE 2323 01:24:12,034 --> 01:24:13,369 IT THE WAY EVERYBODY IN THE 2324 01:24:13,369 --> 01:24:14,570 WORLD RECOMMENDED FROM THE 2325 01:24:14,570 --> 01:24:16,338 BEGINNING, RATHER THAN THINKING 2326 01:24:16,338 --> 01:24:18,174 WE'RE SMARTER THAN THEM. 2327 01:24:18,174 --> 01:24:21,110 AND SO I THINK THAT'S TRUE 2328 01:24:21,110 --> 01:24:23,345 IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE, RIGHT? 2329 01:24:23,345 --> 01:24:25,181 IF YOU DID A RANDOMIZED 2330 01:24:25,181 --> 01:24:26,182 CONTROLLED TRIAL HOW TO 2331 01:24:26,182 --> 01:24:27,149 IMPLEMENT IT MIGHT HAVE SAVED 2332 01:24:27,149 --> 01:24:30,586 THE TROUBLE OF DOING WHAT WE 2333 01:24:30,586 --> 01:24:31,854 DID. 2334 01:24:31,854 --> 01:24:32,154 >> GREAT. 2335 01:24:32,154 --> 01:24:34,156 KRISTIN, YOU HAVE EXPERIENCE 2336 01:24:34,156 --> 01:24:36,959 WITH ALLOWED HEALTH 2337 01:24:36,959 --> 01:24:37,526 PROFESSIONALS, PARTICULARLY 2338 01:24:37,526 --> 01:24:38,160 AROUND TELELACTATION, BUT 2339 01:24:38,160 --> 01:24:39,328 ANYTHING YOU WANT TO COMMENT ON? 2340 01:24:39,328 --> 01:24:41,831 >> I CAN SPEAK TO BOTH OF THOSE. 2341 01:24:41,831 --> 01:24:45,734 FIRST IN THE CLINICAL SETTING, 2342 01:24:45,734 --> 01:24:47,870 PRIMARY CARE WHERE I PRACTICE WE 2343 01:24:47,870 --> 01:24:48,704 HAVE TEAM-BASED CARE, WORKING 2344 01:24:48,704 --> 01:24:51,907 SIDE BY SIDE WITH PHYSICIANS AND 2345 01:24:51,907 --> 01:24:53,209 NURSE PRACTITIONERS AND PAS, 2346 01:24:53,209 --> 01:24:56,378 SOCIAL WORKERS IN PERSON. 2347 01:24:56,378 --> 01:24:57,913 WE FOUND THE SAME CLINICIANS, 2348 01:24:57,913 --> 01:25:01,083 EVERYONE IS HAPPY TO MEET OUR 2349 01:25:01,083 --> 01:25:03,052 PATIENTS' NEEDS AND ENGAGE 2350 01:25:03,052 --> 01:25:03,953 VIRTUALLY. 2351 01:25:03,953 --> 01:25:06,989 I THINK THAT MORE IMPORTANT THAN 2352 01:25:06,989 --> 01:25:09,859 THE DEGREE ON THE CLINICIAN SIDE 2353 01:25:09,859 --> 01:25:13,028 IS I THINK TELEHEALTH CAN BE 2354 01:25:13,028 --> 01:25:15,431 TRICKY AND ONE NEEDS TO BE 2355 01:25:15,431 --> 01:25:17,066 TRAINED AND COMFORTABLE WITH THE 2356 01:25:17,066 --> 01:25:21,770 UNCERTAINTY THAT COMES WITH NOT 2357 01:25:21,770 --> 01:25:25,407 HAVING THE PATIENT IN THE ROOM. 2358 01:25:25,407 --> 01:25:27,610 I THINK EXPERIENCE DOES MATTER, 2359 01:25:27,610 --> 01:25:28,310 EXPERIENCE OR TRAINING, OR 2360 01:25:28,310 --> 01:25:31,313 GETTING PEOPLE TO THE LEVEL 2361 01:25:31,313 --> 01:25:34,183 WHERE THEY FEEL YESTERDAY TO 2362 01:25:34,183 --> 01:25:35,584 MAKE THESE DIAGNOSIS AND DECIDE 2363 01:25:35,584 --> 01:25:37,219 WHEN THEY NEED TO ESCALATE CARE 2364 01:25:37,219 --> 01:25:41,624 BRINGING A PATIENT IN, IN 2365 01:25:41,624 --> 01:25:41,857 PERSON. 2366 01:25:41,857 --> 01:25:47,963 MORE THAN DEGREES THAT IS 2367 01:25:47,963 --> 01:25:48,731 IMPORTANT. 2368 01:25:48,731 --> 01:25:50,366 GOING BACK TO PROVIDING CARE 2369 01:25:50,366 --> 01:25:51,267 IMPORTANT FOR THAT CONDITION, IF 2370 01:25:51,267 --> 01:25:53,535 YOU WERE IN PERSON OR VIRTUALLY 2371 01:25:53,535 --> 01:25:55,304 DOING THE SAME SORT OF MANEUVERS 2372 01:25:55,304 --> 01:25:59,575 THAT ARE NECESSARY FOR THAT 2373 01:25:59,575 --> 01:26:01,410 DIAGNOSIS, I THINK SIMILARLY IF 2374 01:26:01,410 --> 01:26:02,645 SOMEONE IS NOT COMFORTABLE 2375 01:26:02,645 --> 01:26:05,381 CARING FOR THIS AGE GROUP OR 2376 01:26:05,381 --> 01:26:07,449 THIS CONDITION, IN PERSON, THEN 2377 01:26:07,449 --> 01:26:09,084 THEY MAYBE SHOULD ALSO PASS ON 2378 01:26:09,084 --> 01:26:11,820 THAT TELEHEALTH PATIENT. 2379 01:26:11,820 --> 01:26:16,692 SO I THINK IT'S THAT IN-PERSON 2380 01:26:16,692 --> 01:26:18,193 STANDARD APPLIES AND I THINK 2381 01:26:18,193 --> 01:26:20,796 EXPERIENCE MATTERS IN WHAT I'VE 2382 01:26:20,796 --> 01:26:23,198 SEEN BUT WE CAN ALSO TRAIN 2383 01:26:23,198 --> 01:26:25,634 PEOPLE AS DR. HOLLANDER HAS VAST 2384 01:26:25,634 --> 01:26:26,302 EXPERIENCE IN. 2385 01:26:26,302 --> 01:26:28,270 THE OTHER PIECE ABOUT OTHER 2386 01:26:28,270 --> 01:26:31,206 PROVIDERS, ON OUR SOCIAL WORK 2387 01:26:31,206 --> 01:26:32,641 AND CARE COORDINATOR SIDE, THE 2388 01:26:32,641 --> 01:26:35,144 BILLING MODEL IS NOT THERE 2389 01:26:35,144 --> 01:26:41,617 DEPENDENTING ON PAYMENT 2390 01:26:41,617 --> 01:26:43,919 STRUCTURE. 2391 01:26:43,919 --> 01:26:46,322 ON THE TELELACTATION SIDE, DR. 2392 01:26:46,322 --> 01:26:50,359 MEHOTRA WAS PART OF THIS, WE 2393 01:26:50,359 --> 01:26:51,794 LOOKED AT RANDOMIZING PATIENTS 2394 01:26:51,794 --> 01:26:55,764 TO HAVING ACCESS TO 2395 01:26:55,764 --> 01:26:57,599 TELELACTATION SERVICES. 2396 01:26:57,599 --> 01:27:00,769 AND HAVE FOUND PARENTS ARE -- 2397 01:27:00,769 --> 01:27:02,104 NURSING PEOPLE ARE HAPPY TO 2398 01:27:02,104 --> 01:27:03,739 CONNECT AND RECEIVE SERVICES, 2399 01:27:03,739 --> 01:27:05,374 NOT EVERYONE USES IT WHICH MAKES 2400 01:27:05,374 --> 01:27:08,344 SENSE BECAUSE NOT EVERYONE HAS A 2401 01:27:08,344 --> 01:27:10,212 NEED FOR LACTATION CONSULTANT, 2402 01:27:10,212 --> 01:27:11,947 AND MANY PEOPLE CAN RECEIVE 2403 01:27:11,947 --> 01:27:13,148 ACCESS IN PERSON. 2404 01:27:13,148 --> 01:27:15,751 SO, WE'RE FINDING AS AN 2405 01:27:15,751 --> 01:27:19,855 AUGMENTED OPTION IT IS SOMETHING 2406 01:27:19,855 --> 01:27:22,024 THAT CAN BE USEFUL FOR NURSING 2407 01:27:22,024 --> 01:27:23,325 PEOPLE AND LACTATION CONSULTANTS 2408 01:27:23,325 --> 01:27:24,526 IN GENERAL FEEL LIKE THEY CAN 2409 01:27:24,526 --> 01:27:26,595 PROVIDE THE CARE THAT THEY NEED 2410 01:27:26,595 --> 01:27:31,367 TO BE ABLE TO PROVIDE. 2411 01:27:31,367 --> 01:27:33,068 >> A NUMBER OF THINGS YOU 2412 01:27:33,068 --> 01:27:36,038 HIGHLIGHTED AROUND THE NEED FOR 2413 01:27:36,038 --> 01:27:38,073 TRAINING AND HOW THAT IS 2414 01:27:38,073 --> 01:27:41,276 DIFFERENT WHEN WE'RE TALKING 2415 01:27:41,276 --> 01:27:43,579 ABOUT TELEHEALTH PERHAPS, AND 2416 01:27:43,579 --> 01:27:46,181 THE NEED FOR POTENTIALLY THE 2417 01:27:46,181 --> 01:27:47,616 LIMITATION AND NUANCE AROUND 2418 01:27:47,616 --> 01:27:49,251 SUPERVISION IN THIS MODALITY 2419 01:27:49,251 --> 01:27:51,086 VERSUS IN PERSON THAT PRESENTS A 2420 01:27:51,086 --> 01:27:52,187 CHALLENGE AND PARTICULARLY 2421 01:27:52,187 --> 01:27:53,088 AROUND BILLING AND PAYMENT WHICH 2422 01:27:53,088 --> 01:27:54,923 THERE IS A QUESTION FROM THE 2423 01:27:54,923 --> 01:27:57,359 PANEL RELATED TO THAT SO I'D 2424 01:27:57,359 --> 01:28:00,295 LIKE TO GET TO THAT. 2425 01:28:00,295 --> 01:28:03,799 BEFORE THAT, ATEEV, DID YOU HAVE 2426 01:28:03,799 --> 01:28:04,900 A COMMENT? 2427 01:28:04,900 --> 01:28:05,768 >> THE QUESTIONER DIDN'T HAVE 2428 01:28:05,768 --> 01:28:07,169 THIS INTENT BUT IT HIT A PET 2429 01:28:07,169 --> 01:28:07,870 PEEVE OF MINE. 2430 01:28:07,870 --> 01:28:09,271 I HAD TO GET IT OUT. 2431 01:28:09,271 --> 01:28:12,341 I'LL PUT IT OUT, WHICH IS 2432 01:28:12,341 --> 01:28:14,610 THERE'S STILL THIS ONGOING 2433 01:28:14,610 --> 01:28:16,178 CONVERSATION ABOUT 2434 01:28:16,178 --> 01:28:17,179 NON-PHYSICIANS AND PHYSICIANS, 2435 01:28:17,179 --> 01:28:18,580 AND REALITY IS THAT RIGHT NOW IN 2436 01:28:18,580 --> 01:28:20,449 THE UNITED STATES A QUARTER OF 2437 01:28:20,449 --> 01:28:23,719 ALL VISITS ARE PROVIDED BY 2438 01:28:23,719 --> 01:28:24,086 NON-PHYSICIANS. 2439 01:28:24,086 --> 01:28:26,488 AND THAT RATE IS GROWING REALLY 2440 01:28:26,488 --> 01:28:28,891 RAPIDLY, IN THE NEXT 10 TO 20 2441 01:28:28,891 --> 01:28:30,626 YEARS MY SENSES LOOKING AT 2442 01:28:30,626 --> 01:28:31,827 WORKFORCE NUMBERS MAJORITY OF 2443 01:28:31,827 --> 01:28:33,162 OUTPATIENT VISITS WILL BE 2444 01:28:33,162 --> 01:28:33,996 PROVIDED BY NON-PHYSICIANS. 2445 01:28:33,996 --> 01:28:34,930 WE'RE ALREADY SEEING THAT IN 2446 01:28:34,930 --> 01:28:36,732 MANY RURAL COMMUNITIES IN THE 2447 01:28:36,732 --> 01:28:37,066 UNITED STATES. 2448 01:28:37,066 --> 01:28:40,035 SO THIS IS THE REALITY. 2449 01:28:40,035 --> 01:28:42,304 I DON'T THINK THERE'S THAT MUCH 2450 01:28:42,304 --> 01:28:44,406 OF A DIFFERENCE IN TERMS OF 2451 01:28:44,406 --> 01:28:45,941 TELEHEALTH AND I THINK WE JUST 2452 01:28:45,941 --> 01:28:50,079 HAVE TO THINK ABOUT THESE 2453 01:28:50,079 --> 01:28:52,714 TEAM-BASED MODELS AS KRISTIN 2454 01:28:52,714 --> 01:28:52,981 DESCRIBED. 2455 01:28:52,981 --> 01:28:54,383 THERE ARE SOME QUESTIONS WHAT 2456 01:28:54,383 --> 01:28:55,551 THE OPTIMAL STRUCTURE OF THOSE 2457 01:28:55,551 --> 01:28:57,853 TEAMS IS BUT IT'S GOING TO BE 2458 01:28:57,853 --> 01:29:00,722 TEAMS AND I REALLY GET THE PET 2459 01:29:00,722 --> 01:29:02,591 PEEVE WAS THE SORT OF THINKING 2460 01:29:02,591 --> 01:29:05,994 ABOUT A CAGE PHYSICIAN IN ONE 2461 01:29:05,994 --> 01:29:08,197 CORNER, PHYSICIAN IN ONE CORNER, 2462 01:29:08,197 --> 01:29:09,598 NURSE PRACTITIONER IN THE OTHER 2463 01:29:09,598 --> 01:29:10,365 AND I GET FRUSTRATED BECAUSE 2464 01:29:10,365 --> 01:29:12,134 IT'S GOING TO BE A TEAM-BASED 2465 01:29:12,134 --> 01:29:16,705 CARE AND IT'S ALREADY HAPPENING. 2466 01:29:16,705 --> 01:29:19,141 2467 01:29:19,141 --> 01:29:20,542 >> THAT RELATES TO NEXT 2468 01:29:20,542 --> 01:29:25,581 QUESTION, DRIVERS OF TELEHEALTH 2469 01:29:25,581 --> 01:29:26,615 IMPLEMENTATION, I WOULD ASK 2470 01:29:26,615 --> 01:29:31,620 INCLUDING LET'S SAY PHYSICAL 2471 01:29:31,620 --> 01:29:33,589 THERAPISTS OR OTHER SPECIALTIES, 2472 01:29:33,589 --> 01:29:34,990 DISCIPLINES WHERE REIMBURSEMENT 2473 01:29:34,990 --> 01:29:37,392 AND PAY PARITY ARE NOT ENTIRE IN 2474 01:29:37,392 --> 01:29:38,994 PLACE IS MY UNDERSTANDING. 2475 01:29:38,994 --> 01:29:41,230 BUT PLEASE CORRECT ME IF THAT'S 2476 01:29:41,230 --> 01:29:41,663 NOT CORRECT. 2477 01:29:41,663 --> 01:29:45,501 AND SO THE QUESTION IS, IS 2478 01:29:45,501 --> 01:29:53,041 INSURANCE PAYMENT DICTATING THE 2479 01:29:53,041 --> 01:29:57,012 EXPANSION OF TELEMEDICINE NOW? 2480 01:29:57,012 --> 01:29:57,546 >> YES. 2481 01:29:57,546 --> 01:29:59,948 I MEAN, MY SENSE -- GO AHEAD, 2482 01:29:59,948 --> 01:30:00,382 KRISTIN. 2483 01:30:00,382 --> 01:30:02,684 >> I WANT TO NAME ONE CHANGE 2484 01:30:02,684 --> 01:30:04,319 THAT WAS HUGE AND CONTINUES TO 2485 01:30:04,319 --> 01:30:05,754 BE HUGE FOR PRIMARY CARE TO 2486 01:30:05,754 --> 01:30:08,924 CONTINUE TO BE ABLE TO OFFER 2487 01:30:08,924 --> 01:30:09,224 TELEHEALTH. 2488 01:30:09,224 --> 01:30:11,693 AND THAT'S THE -- YOU KNOW, 2489 01:30:11,693 --> 01:30:13,629 MULTIPLE CHANGES HAPPENED WITH 2490 01:30:13,629 --> 01:30:16,031 PANDEMIC BUT ABILITY FOR PRIMARY 2491 01:30:16,031 --> 01:30:19,868 CARE PROVIDERS TO BILL MEDICAID 2492 01:30:19,868 --> 01:30:20,869 AND MEDICARE AND COMMERCIAL 2493 01:30:20,869 --> 01:30:23,372 INSURERS WHEN THE PATIENT IS AT 2494 01:30:23,372 --> 01:30:25,874 HOME WITHOUT RURAL LIMITATIONS 2495 01:30:25,874 --> 01:30:27,976 OR TRANSPORTATION BARRIERS IS 2496 01:30:27,976 --> 01:30:29,711 HUGE, ESPECIALLY IF SOMEONE 2497 01:30:29,711 --> 01:30:31,680 PRACTICES IN URBAN AREA WHERE 2498 01:30:31,680 --> 01:30:34,216 PATIENTS ARE GEOGRAPHICALLY 2499 01:30:34,216 --> 01:30:35,083 CLOSE BUT TEMPORALLY IT TAKES A 2500 01:30:35,083 --> 01:30:37,252 LONG TIME TO GET TO MY CLINIC SO 2501 01:30:37,252 --> 01:30:41,757 MAKING SURE WE PRESERVE THE 2502 01:30:41,757 --> 01:30:44,726 OPPORTUNITY FOR PEOPLE, I THINK 2503 01:30:44,726 --> 01:30:46,161 THAT THIS IS INCREASINGLY 2504 01:30:46,161 --> 01:30:47,863 SEEMING LIKE IT'S BECOMING BAKED 2505 01:30:47,863 --> 01:30:52,501 IN BUT I WANT TO NAME THAT'S SO 2506 01:30:52,501 --> 01:30:55,904 IMPORTANT, AND I THINK ONE THING 2507 01:30:55,904 --> 01:30:58,974 THAT CONTINUES TO -- THERE ARE 2508 01:30:58,974 --> 01:31:01,343 ADDITIONAL POLICY AND PAYMENT 2509 01:31:01,343 --> 01:31:02,344 ISSUES THAT ARE IMPORTANT AND 2510 01:31:02,344 --> 01:31:03,779 EVOLVING, I CAN LET OTHER PEOPLE 2511 01:31:03,779 --> 01:31:05,948 SPEAK TO THOSE BUT ALSO 2512 01:31:05,948 --> 01:31:06,982 UNCERTAINTY HOW WE GET 2513 01:31:06,982 --> 01:31:09,251 EXTENSIONS FOR A PERIOD OF TIME 2514 01:31:09,251 --> 01:31:11,553 SHIFTS HOW PEOPLE FEEL ABOUT 2515 01:31:11,553 --> 01:31:12,988 REALLY THINKING RESOURCES AND 2516 01:31:12,988 --> 01:31:14,957 SCHEDULES AND WORKFLOWS INTO 2517 01:31:14,957 --> 01:31:16,391 MORE TELEHEALTH SPACES. 2518 01:31:16,391 --> 01:31:19,561 SO THOSE ARE SOME FACTORS THAT 2519 01:31:19,561 --> 01:31:21,630 AS THEY EVOLVE OFFER 2520 01:31:21,630 --> 01:31:23,065 OPPORTUNITIES TO STUDY WHAT'S 2521 01:31:23,065 --> 01:31:24,600 THE IMPACT WHEN THESE CHANGES 2522 01:31:24,600 --> 01:31:26,768 HAPPEN, IF THEY ARE STATE 2523 01:31:26,768 --> 01:31:28,003 DEPENDENT, PLAN DEPENDENT, WE 2524 01:31:28,003 --> 01:31:31,740 CAN LEARN FROM NATURAL VARIATION 2525 01:31:31,740 --> 01:31:33,642 HAPPENING AS DIFFERENT PAYERS 2526 01:31:33,642 --> 01:31:36,478 AND STATES MAKE DIFFERENT 2527 01:31:36,478 --> 01:31:37,012 CHANGES. 2528 01:31:37,012 --> 01:31:38,747 >> NOW YOU HIT MY PET PEEVE. 2529 01:31:38,747 --> 01:31:40,282 I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING YOU 2530 01:31:40,282 --> 01:31:40,482 SAID. 2531 01:31:40,482 --> 01:31:42,184 KICKING THE CAN DOWN THE ROAD IS 2532 01:31:42,184 --> 01:31:44,486 A KILLER, I WILL SAY. 2533 01:31:44,486 --> 01:31:46,121 LIKE I CAN'T TELL YOU THE NUMBER 2534 01:31:46,121 --> 01:31:47,756 OF E-MAILS I GOT IN THE LAST 2535 01:31:47,756 --> 01:31:50,192 MONTH SAYING SHOULD I CANCEL ALL 2536 01:31:50,192 --> 01:31:52,461 MY JANUARY TELEHEALTH 2537 01:31:52,461 --> 01:31:52,794 APPOINTMENTS? 2538 01:31:52,794 --> 01:31:54,429 AND NOW OUR OFFICIAL STANCE IS 2539 01:31:54,429 --> 01:31:57,065 DO NOT TILL WE TELL YOU TO DO 2540 01:31:57,065 --> 01:31:57,766 SOMETHING BECAUSE EVERYBODY 2541 01:31:57,766 --> 01:32:00,235 HEARS FROM A FRIEND SOMETHING'S 2542 01:32:00,235 --> 01:32:02,337 GOING AWAY, AND IT'S CRAZY. 2543 01:32:02,337 --> 01:32:05,040 IT RESULTS IN A LOT OF WORK 2544 01:32:05,040 --> 01:32:06,141 THAT'S UNNECESSARY. 2545 01:32:06,141 --> 01:32:08,543 THE SECOND THING THAT'S REALLY 2546 01:32:08,543 --> 01:32:11,713 IMPORTANT IS GEOGRAPHY. 2547 01:32:11,713 --> 01:32:13,248 AND WE'VE HINTED. 2548 01:32:13,248 --> 01:32:14,916 IT'S SO RUTHLESSLY UNFAIR TO BE 2549 01:32:14,916 --> 01:32:16,451 FUNDING THINGS IN RURAL AREAS 2550 01:32:16,451 --> 01:32:18,086 AND NOT URBAN AREAS. 2551 01:32:18,086 --> 01:32:20,489 I KNOW MY FRIENDS FROM HRSA ARE 2552 01:32:20,489 --> 01:32:21,690 ATTENDING TODAY AND I UNDERSTAND 2553 01:32:21,690 --> 01:32:23,458 THAT'S THEIR MISSION AND THERE'S 2554 01:32:23,458 --> 01:32:25,727 NOTHING THEY CAN DO ABOUT IT, 2555 01:32:25,727 --> 01:32:27,596 BUT REALITY IS MANY, MANY MORE 2556 01:32:27,596 --> 01:32:29,464 PEOPLE LIVE IN URBAN AREAS AND 2557 01:32:29,464 --> 01:32:30,932 THEY HAVE THEIR OWN CHALLENGES. 2558 01:32:30,932 --> 01:32:32,434 THEY MAY NOT HAVE A CAR. 2559 01:32:32,434 --> 01:32:34,303 THE BUS MAY BE BROKEN DOWN IN 2560 01:32:34,303 --> 01:32:36,371 PHILADELPHIA, WE'RE ON THE EDGE 2561 01:32:36,371 --> 01:32:37,906 OF A STRIKE, CAN THEY GET THERE? 2562 01:32:37,906 --> 01:32:40,108 I LIKE TO SAY THERE'S FEWER 2563 01:32:40,108 --> 01:32:42,110 DOCTORS IN RURAL AREAS, NO 2564 01:32:42,110 --> 01:32:44,479 DOUBT, BUT THERE'S FEWER 2565 01:32:44,479 --> 01:32:45,714 APPOINTMENTS AVAILABLE IN URBAN 2566 01:32:45,714 --> 01:32:48,250 AREAS, NO DOUBT. 2567 01:32:48,250 --> 01:32:49,651 AND I KNOW IF NOTHING ELSE IN 2568 01:32:49,651 --> 01:32:51,620 THE WORLD OF MEDICINE THAT PICKS 2569 01:32:51,620 --> 01:32:53,488 GEOGRAPHY AS A CONDITION FOR 2570 01:32:53,488 --> 01:32:54,489 FUNDING OR EVER DID. 2571 01:32:54,489 --> 01:32:57,326 I THINK WE HAVE TO GET PAST 2572 01:32:57,326 --> 01:32:57,859 THAT. 2573 01:32:57,859 --> 01:33:00,295 AND, YOU KNOW, AGAIN NOT AGAINST 2574 01:33:00,295 --> 01:33:02,664 ANY ONE AGENCY BUT WE HAVE TO 2575 01:33:02,664 --> 01:33:06,301 LOOK BROADLY AND NOT HAVE THINGS 2576 01:33:06,301 --> 01:33:07,636 FIT INTO RURAL-ONLY FUNDING 2577 01:33:07,636 --> 01:33:11,006 OPPORTUNITIES OR WE'RE ACTUALLY 2578 01:33:11,006 --> 01:33:11,840 TOTALLY INEQUITABLE BY DEPRIVING 2579 01:33:11,840 --> 01:33:19,114 URBAN PATIENTS OF THE CARE. 2580 01:33:19,114 --> 01:33:20,515 >> JUDD, OKAY, I'M WITH YOU 2581 01:33:20,515 --> 01:33:22,084 ABOUT KICKING THE CAN. 2582 01:33:22,084 --> 01:33:24,386 IT'S DRIVING EVERYBODY CRAZY AND 2583 01:33:24,386 --> 01:33:25,153 NEGATIVELY IMPACTING TELEHEALTH. 2584 01:33:25,153 --> 01:33:26,788 WHERE I GET A BIT WORRIED ABOUT 2585 01:33:26,788 --> 01:33:28,857 WHAT YOU SAID IS I FULLY 2586 01:33:28,857 --> 01:33:30,492 ACKNOWLEDGE THE BARRIERS IN 2587 01:33:30,492 --> 01:33:33,795 URBAN AREAS. 2588 01:33:33,795 --> 01:33:36,965 BUT I WORRY ALSO ABOUT 2589 01:33:36,965 --> 01:33:39,668 ASSUMPTION THAT IF WE OFFER 2590 01:33:39,668 --> 01:33:41,336 TELEHEALTH TO EVERYBODY, AND 2591 01:33:41,336 --> 01:33:45,707 MAKE IT OPEN, IT'S GOING TO 2592 01:33:45,707 --> 01:33:46,842 ADDRESS THE DISPARITIES THAT DR. 2593 01:33:46,842 --> 01:33:50,412 GRAHAM AND SO MANY OTHERS HAVE 2594 01:33:50,412 --> 01:33:52,280 HIGHLIGHTED, LET'S JUST STICK 2595 01:33:52,280 --> 01:33:54,483 WITH RURAL/URBAN DIVIDE. 2596 01:33:54,483 --> 01:33:56,585 EVIDENCE THAT I SEE IF YOU JUST 2597 01:33:56,585 --> 01:33:57,753 OFFER IT TO EVERYBODY, MORE 2598 01:33:57,753 --> 01:33:59,421 PEOPLE WILL USE IT IN URBAN 2599 01:33:59,421 --> 01:34:04,793 AREAS AND WE'RE GOING TO WIDEN 2600 01:34:04,793 --> 01:34:06,762 DISPARITIES, NOT NARROW THEM. 2601 01:34:06,762 --> 01:34:10,031 AND THAT REALLY BOTHERS ME QUITE 2602 01:34:10,031 --> 01:34:10,799 A BIT. 2603 01:34:10,799 --> 01:34:12,300 IT BOTHERS ME A TON. 2604 01:34:12,300 --> 01:34:16,805 I THINK A LOT ABOUT THE NEED FOR 2605 01:34:16,805 --> 01:34:20,142 RESEARCH ON HOW DO YOU ENSURE -- 2606 01:34:20,142 --> 01:34:29,017 I'M NOT SAYING TAKE IT WITH A 2607 01:34:29,017 --> 01:34:34,923 TAKE IT AWAY FROM URBAN AREAS, 2608 01:34:34,923 --> 01:34:40,228 BUT I'M CONCERNED ABOUT WIDENING 2609 01:34:40,228 --> 01:34:40,529 DISPARITIES. 2610 01:34:40,529 --> 01:34:41,530 >> MY PUSHBACK, I AGREE WITH 2611 01:34:41,530 --> 01:34:43,064 YOU, WE SHOULD CHOICE THE GAP. 2612 01:34:43,064 --> 01:34:45,133 BUT THE ONE WAY WE SHOULDN'T 2613 01:34:45,133 --> 01:34:47,969 CLOSE THE GAP IS BY DEPRIVING 2614 01:34:47,969 --> 01:34:50,705 OPPORTUNITIES FOR TELEMEDICINE 2615 01:34:50,705 --> 01:34:54,009 CARE TO PEOPLE WHO ARE LESS 2616 01:34:54,009 --> 01:34:54,376 BIASED AGAINST. 2617 01:34:54,376 --> 01:34:56,511 SO, I WANT TO BE CAREFUL THAT 2618 01:34:56,511 --> 01:34:59,281 THE GOAL IS NOT GAP CLOSURE, THE 2619 01:34:59,281 --> 01:35:01,216 GOAL IS OPTIMAL CARE FOR BOTH 2620 01:35:01,216 --> 01:35:07,389 PATIENT POPULATIONS OR FOR ALL 2621 01:35:07,389 --> 01:35:07,656 PATIENTS. 2622 01:35:07,656 --> 01:35:10,892 >> I WORRY WHEN WE GROUP INTO 2623 01:35:10,892 --> 01:35:11,526 RURAL/URBAN. 2624 01:35:11,526 --> 01:35:13,428 THERE'S AN URBAN BUCKET WITH 2625 01:35:13,428 --> 01:35:14,930 SUBPOPULATIONS AND EXPERIENCES 2626 01:35:14,930 --> 01:35:16,798 IN THERE. 2627 01:35:16,798 --> 01:35:17,999 MORE INNER CITY URBAN 2628 01:35:17,999 --> 01:35:19,534 POPULATIONS ARE VERY DIFFERENT 2629 01:35:19,534 --> 01:35:21,036 FROM THE SUBURBAN RINGS THAT 2630 01:35:21,036 --> 01:35:23,371 OFTEN ARE IN THE SAME 2631 01:35:23,371 --> 01:35:23,672 POPULATION. 2632 01:35:23,672 --> 01:35:26,641 SO WHEN WE LOOK AT ACCESS TO 2633 01:35:26,641 --> 01:35:30,278 EMERGENCY ROOM VISITS OR PRIMARY 2634 01:35:30,278 --> 01:35:31,913 CARE VISITS, THERE'S OFTEN 2635 01:35:31,913 --> 01:35:32,781 VARIATION, LOW UTILIZATION IN 2636 01:35:32,781 --> 01:35:36,551 THE MIDDLE OF THE MOST URBAN 2637 01:35:36,551 --> 01:35:38,053 CORRIDORS, THINGS LIKE GREAT, 2638 01:35:38,053 --> 01:35:39,721 CARE GOES DOWN AGAIN, SO MAKING 2639 01:35:39,721 --> 01:35:41,790 SURE THAT WE'RE SENSITIVE TO 2640 01:35:41,790 --> 01:35:43,625 THOSE NUANCES I THINK IS REALLY 2641 01:35:43,625 --> 01:35:48,797 IMPORTANT AS WE'RE THINKING 2642 01:35:48,797 --> 01:35:49,631 ABOUT ACCESS THROUGH TELEHEALTH 2643 01:35:49,631 --> 01:35:51,967 >> IT'S LIKE WE MAKING THE 2644 01:35:51,967 --> 01:35:53,401 DIVISION BETWEEN RURAL AND URBAN 2645 01:35:53,401 --> 01:35:54,603 AS IF THERE'S A DIFFERENCE AS 2646 01:35:54,603 --> 01:35:57,572 FAR AS HEALTH EQUITY AND ACCESS 2647 01:35:57,572 --> 01:36:00,942 TO DIGITAL MEANS, WHEN TO YOUR 2648 01:36:00,942 --> 01:36:02,244 POINT, KRISTIN, THERE ARE 2649 01:36:02,244 --> 01:36:06,948 POCKETS OF LOW DIGITAL LITERACY 2650 01:36:06,948 --> 01:36:08,717 WITHIN URBAN ENVIRONMENTS, AND 2651 01:36:08,717 --> 01:36:10,552 OPPOSITE TRUE IN RURAL AREAS. 2652 01:36:10,552 --> 01:36:12,087 AS WE THINK ABOUT INDIVIDUALS 2653 01:36:12,087 --> 01:36:15,223 WHO HAVE LOW DIGITAL LITERACY OR 2654 01:36:15,223 --> 01:36:16,691 LIMITED ENGLISH PROFICIENCY, 2655 01:36:16,691 --> 01:36:18,660 SOME OF THESE GROUPS THAT ARE 2656 01:36:18,660 --> 01:36:20,562 POTENTIALLY BEING LEFT OUT IN 2657 01:36:20,562 --> 01:36:22,697 THE TELEHEALTH REVOLUTION, WHAT 2658 01:36:22,697 --> 01:36:25,901 ARE SOME OF THE STRATEGIES, 2659 01:36:25,901 --> 01:36:27,002 RECOMMENDATIONS, AND ALSO 2660 01:36:27,002 --> 01:36:29,604 OPPORTUNITIES AND OPPORTUNITIES 2661 01:36:29,604 --> 01:36:30,505 FOR IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH THAT 2662 01:36:30,505 --> 01:36:37,045 COME TO MIND TO THIS PANEL? 2663 01:36:37,045 --> 01:36:40,148 >> I'LL LAY THE STAGE AND WOULD 2664 01:36:40,148 --> 01:36:42,751 LOVE FOR KRISTIN AND JUDD TO 2665 01:36:42,751 --> 01:36:43,084 HIGHLIGHT. 2666 01:36:43,084 --> 01:36:44,853 WE ALL RECOGNIZE WE NEED TO 2667 01:36:44,853 --> 01:36:47,355 JUST, AGAIN, JUST OFFER TO 2668 01:36:47,355 --> 01:36:49,558 EVERYBODY, IT JUST DOESN'T WORK. 2669 01:36:49,558 --> 01:36:51,927 WE'LL HAVE TO ADDRESS SOME OF 2670 01:36:51,927 --> 01:36:53,461 THE DIGITAL LITERACY, AND MY 2671 01:36:53,461 --> 01:36:54,563 EXPERIENCE BOTH CLINICALLY AS 2672 01:36:54,563 --> 01:36:56,431 WELL AS LOOKING OUT THERE IS 2673 01:36:56,431 --> 01:36:58,700 THAT CLINICIANS ARE DOING WHAT 2674 01:36:58,700 --> 01:37:00,368 MAKES SENSE, COMMON SENSE. 2675 01:37:00,368 --> 01:37:02,470 LIKE, HEY, LET'S TRY A PILOT 2676 01:37:02,470 --> 01:37:02,904 VISIT. 2677 01:37:02,904 --> 01:37:04,973 HEY, LET ME HAVE A TELEHEALTH 2678 01:37:04,973 --> 01:37:06,508 COORDINATOR WHO CAN REACH OUT 2679 01:37:06,508 --> 01:37:07,576 AND SET THAT UP. 2680 01:37:07,576 --> 01:37:09,477 HEY, MAYBE I'LL GIVE YOU A 2681 01:37:09,477 --> 01:37:11,646 DEVICE TO HELP YOU DO THIS. 2682 01:37:11,646 --> 01:37:13,848 AND A VARIETY OF OTHER TOOLS. 2683 01:37:13,848 --> 01:37:15,417 AND ALL OF THOSE MAKE SENSE TO 2684 01:37:15,417 --> 01:37:17,018 ME, AND I THINK IF I WAS IN 2685 01:37:17,018 --> 01:37:18,753 THEIR SHOES I WOULD DO THAT. 2686 01:37:18,753 --> 01:37:22,290 I DON'T KNOW ABOUT A LOT OF 2687 01:37:22,290 --> 01:37:24,159 EVIDENCE THAT CAN SAY, HEY, THIS 2688 01:37:24,159 --> 01:37:25,794 THING WORKS BETTER THAN THIS 2689 01:37:25,794 --> 01:37:27,329 OTHER THING. 2690 01:37:27,329 --> 01:37:29,097 AND THAT DOES SEEM LIKE A 2691 01:37:29,097 --> 01:37:30,498 RESEARCH GAP. 2692 01:37:30,498 --> 01:37:32,033 I'D BE CURIOUS WHAT KRISTIN AND 2693 01:37:32,033 --> 01:37:33,702 JUDD, DO YOU AGREE OR DO YOU 2694 01:37:33,702 --> 01:37:35,136 FEEL LIKE WE HAVE THE EVIDENCE 2695 01:37:35,136 --> 01:37:36,738 TO KNOW TO INFORM A HEALTH 2696 01:37:36,738 --> 01:37:38,106 SYSTEM OTHER INDIVIDUAL PRACTICE 2697 01:37:38,106 --> 01:37:42,978 ON WHAT TO DO? 2698 01:37:42,978 --> 01:37:45,080 >> I THINK THERE IS SOME DATA IN 2699 01:37:45,080 --> 01:37:50,018 SOME OF THOSE SPACES, AND I 2700 01:37:50,018 --> 01:37:52,821 THINK THERE ARE -- THERE'S SOME 2701 01:37:52,821 --> 01:37:55,457 THINGS WE NEED TO DO BECAUSE -- 2702 01:37:55,457 --> 01:37:56,725 WE SHOULD ALWAYS HAVE 2703 01:37:56,725 --> 01:37:57,058 INTERPRETERS. 2704 01:37:57,058 --> 01:38:01,863 WE SHOULD HAVE ALL OUR 2705 01:38:01,863 --> 01:38:02,831 PATIENT-FACING PORTALS AND 2706 01:38:02,831 --> 01:38:03,698 SELF-SCHEDULING AVAILABLE IN 2707 01:38:03,698 --> 01:38:04,165 MULTIPLE LANGUAGES. 2708 01:38:04,165 --> 01:38:05,667 I KNOW WE'RE FAR FROM DOING 2709 01:38:05,667 --> 01:38:05,900 THAT. 2710 01:38:05,900 --> 01:38:07,435 BUT I DON'T THINK WE NEED DATA 2711 01:38:07,435 --> 01:38:09,204 TO PROVE THAT. 2712 01:38:09,204 --> 01:38:12,507 THE NEXT LEVEL OF -- I KNOW 2713 01:38:12,507 --> 01:38:14,242 WE'RE ALL AWARE WE NEED TO DO 2714 01:38:14,242 --> 01:38:15,210 THOSE THINGS. 2715 01:38:15,210 --> 01:38:22,917 THE NEXT LEVEL OF DIGITAL 2716 01:38:22,917 --> 01:38:23,818 NAVIGATORS AND THOSE 2717 01:38:23,818 --> 01:38:26,454 SELF-ROOMING PROCESSES, THERE IS 2718 01:38:26,454 --> 01:38:28,089 NEED FOR ADDITIONAL DATA, AND AS 2719 01:38:28,089 --> 01:38:29,924 I MENTIONED THERE'S SOME STUDIES 2720 01:38:29,924 --> 01:38:30,692 SHOWING THAT. 2721 01:38:30,692 --> 01:38:32,127 IT'S PROBABLY THE SORT OF THING 2722 01:38:32,127 --> 01:38:35,864 WE WANT TO SEE MULTIPLE STUDIES 2723 01:38:35,864 --> 01:38:36,965 ACROSS MULTIPLE SETTINGS BEFORE 2724 01:38:36,965 --> 01:38:38,400 EVERY HEALTH SYSTEM ELIMINATED 2725 01:38:38,400 --> 01:38:41,836 VESTS HUGE AMOUNT OF EXTRA 2726 01:38:41,836 --> 01:38:43,605 PERSONNEL IN BUT I THINK THOSE 2727 01:38:43,605 --> 01:38:44,706 ARE THE QUESTIONS WE SHOULD 2728 01:38:44,706 --> 01:38:50,178 PRIORITIZE IN TERMS OF LOOKING 2729 01:38:50,178 --> 01:38:52,180 AT REPLICABLE STRUCTURES AND 2730 01:38:52,180 --> 01:38:53,815 PROCESS THAT ALLOW FOR 2731 01:38:53,815 --> 01:38:54,582 SCHEDULING, ATTENDANCE, QUALITY 2732 01:38:54,582 --> 01:38:55,550 OF CARE DURING THE VISIT. 2733 01:38:55,550 --> 01:38:59,921 I THINK THE OTHER THING IS WE'RE 2734 01:38:59,921 --> 01:39:01,356 THINKING ABOUT EQUITY AND 2735 01:39:01,356 --> 01:39:02,557 TELEHEALTH BROADLY IS 2736 01:39:02,557 --> 01:39:03,958 REMEMBERING THAT EQUITY ISN'T 2737 01:39:03,958 --> 01:39:04,859 NECESSARILY EVERYONE GETTING THE 2738 01:39:04,859 --> 01:39:06,161 SAME BUT IT'S EVERYONE GETTING 2739 01:39:06,161 --> 01:39:07,462 WHAT THEY NEED. 2740 01:39:07,462 --> 01:39:08,797 SO FOR DIFFERENT POPULATIONS 2741 01:39:08,797 --> 01:39:10,065 THAT WILL LOOK DIFFERENT. 2742 01:39:10,065 --> 01:39:14,169 I THINK WE'RE KIND OF AT A 2743 01:39:14,169 --> 01:39:16,805 TELEHEALTH EQUITY 1.0, MAYBE 2.0 2744 01:39:16,805 --> 01:39:19,874 LOOKING AT IS USE OF THIS 2745 01:39:19,874 --> 01:39:20,809 MODALITY THE SAME ACROSS 2746 01:39:20,809 --> 01:39:23,111 POPULATIONS AND WE WANT TO LOOK 2747 01:39:23,111 --> 01:39:25,180 AT HOW IS THIS MODALITY LAYERING 2748 01:39:25,180 --> 01:39:26,915 ON TOP OF OTHER MODALITIES AND 2749 01:39:26,915 --> 01:39:28,450 ARE PEOPLE GETTING THE CARE THEY 2750 01:39:28,450 --> 01:39:29,017 NEED. 2751 01:39:29,017 --> 01:39:30,351 THAT'S A LOT HARDER. 2752 01:39:30,351 --> 01:39:32,420 SO IT MAKES SENSE THAT WE 2753 01:39:32,420 --> 01:39:34,055 DON'T -- WE CAN'T ALWAYS DO THAT 2754 01:39:34,055 --> 01:39:35,156 BUT SHOULD BE LAYERING DIFFERENT 2755 01:39:35,156 --> 01:39:39,828 STUDIES ON TOP OF EACH OTHER TO 2756 01:39:39,828 --> 01:39:40,729 UNDERSTAND GIVEN THAT PATIENTS 2757 01:39:40,729 --> 01:39:42,163 HAVE DIFFERENT NEEDS FOR 2758 01:39:42,163 --> 01:39:44,365 CLINICAL CARE BASED ON THEIR 2759 01:39:44,365 --> 01:39:45,533 DIFFERENT HEALTH CONDITIONS, AND 2760 01:39:45,533 --> 01:39:48,069 THAT THEY HAVE DIFFERENT ACCESS 2761 01:39:48,069 --> 01:39:50,572 TO IN-PERSON CARE, THEIR NEED 2762 01:39:50,572 --> 01:39:52,207 FOR SUBSPECIALTY CARE OR SORRY 2763 01:39:52,207 --> 01:39:53,374 FOR TELEHEALTH CARE MAY VARY AND 2764 01:39:53,374 --> 01:39:54,943 WE WANT TO MAKE SURE THEY ARE 2765 01:39:54,943 --> 01:39:55,910 GETTING WHAT THEY NEED. 2766 01:39:55,910 --> 01:39:57,979 AND I THINK WE NEED TO 2767 01:39:57,979 --> 01:40:00,815 PRIORITIZE A RANGE OF 2768 01:40:00,815 --> 01:40:02,884 POPULATIONS FOR THAT. 2769 01:40:02,884 --> 01:40:04,119 >> TO ATEEV'S POINT, THE SHORT 2770 01:40:04,119 --> 01:40:05,754 ANSWER TO YOUR QUESTION IS 2771 01:40:05,754 --> 01:40:06,755 ABSOLUTELY YES. 2772 01:40:06,755 --> 01:40:08,256 THERE'S A GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR 2773 01:40:08,256 --> 01:40:10,992 MORE RESEARCH IN THAT AREA. 2774 01:40:10,992 --> 01:40:12,961 I CAUTION, AND I KNOW THE 2775 01:40:12,961 --> 01:40:14,629 QUALITY OF YOUR STUDIES SO I 2776 01:40:14,629 --> 01:40:16,131 KNOW YOU KNOW THIS, NOT 2777 01:40:16,131 --> 01:40:17,232 EVERYBODY PATIENT IS GOING TO 2778 01:40:17,232 --> 01:40:19,334 GET THE SAME SOLUTION THAT WORKS 2779 01:40:19,334 --> 01:40:20,668 FOR THEM. 2780 01:40:20,668 --> 01:40:22,137 IT MAY BE PREDICTIVE ANALYTICS 2781 01:40:22,137 --> 01:40:23,905 WHETHER YOU NEED WHAT WE CALL A 2782 01:40:23,905 --> 01:40:24,672 TELEHEALTH COORDINATOR TO REACH 2783 01:40:24,672 --> 01:40:26,975 OUT AND DO A PRACTICE VISIT THE 2784 01:40:26,975 --> 01:40:31,212 DAY BEFORE OR JUST A FIRST VISIT 2785 01:40:31,212 --> 01:40:33,748 AND MAYBE A BOT COULD CALL AND 2786 01:40:33,748 --> 01:40:35,950 PROVE YOU CAN LOG ON AND DO YOUR 2787 01:40:35,950 --> 01:40:37,018 MICROPHONE AND AUDIO VISIT, OR 2788 01:40:37,018 --> 01:40:38,219 MAYBE INSTRUCTIONS WITHIN THE 2789 01:40:38,219 --> 01:40:39,320 PORTAL MESSAGE THAT COULD WORK 2790 01:40:39,320 --> 01:40:41,523 FOR SOME PATIENTS BECAUSE THEY 2791 01:40:41,523 --> 01:40:43,491 ARE SAVVY ENOUGH WITH SOME 2792 01:40:43,491 --> 01:40:43,825 INSTRUCTIONS. 2793 01:40:43,825 --> 01:40:47,428 I THINK THERE'S GOING TO BE -- 2794 01:40:47,428 --> 01:40:49,297 KRISTIN RISING HAS DONE A LOT OF 2795 01:40:49,297 --> 01:40:51,599 WORK AT JEFF, A PORTFOLIO OF 2796 01:40:51,599 --> 01:40:52,967 OPTIONS THAT WILL WORK FOR 2797 01:40:52,967 --> 01:40:53,401 DIFFERENT PATIENTS. 2798 01:40:53,401 --> 01:40:55,770 WHETHER OR NOT WE CAN BE SMART 2799 01:40:55,770 --> 01:40:57,505 ENOUGH TO PREDICT THAT, TO HAVE 2800 01:40:57,505 --> 01:40:59,240 A HIGHER LIKELIHOOD OF THE 2801 01:40:59,240 --> 01:41:01,543 OPTION THAT PATIENT A GETS, 2802 01:41:01,543 --> 01:41:03,077 BEING THE RIGHT OPTION, OR 2803 01:41:03,077 --> 01:41:05,480 GIVING A PORTFOLIO OF OPTIONS, I 2804 01:41:05,480 --> 01:41:07,348 THINK IS A TOTALLY RIPE 2805 01:41:07,348 --> 01:41:09,317 OPPORTUNITY FOR RESEARCH. 2806 01:41:09,317 --> 01:41:11,719 >> AND IF I COULD JUST -- I 2807 01:41:11,719 --> 01:41:12,720 SHOULD HAVE PROVIDED THE CONTEXT 2808 01:41:12,720 --> 01:41:15,890 IN WHICH I WAS THINKING ABOUT 2809 01:41:15,890 --> 01:41:16,691 THIS QUESTION. 2810 01:41:16,691 --> 01:41:19,060 THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AS PART 2811 01:41:19,060 --> 01:41:29,604 OF THE AFFORD AND CONNECTIVITY 2812 01:41:34,309 --> 01:41:35,043 PROGRAM PROVIDED LIKE $7 2813 01:41:35,043 --> 01:41:35,543 BILLION. 2814 01:41:35,543 --> 01:41:37,445 I WOULD HAVE BEEN SUPPORTIVE OF 2815 01:41:37,445 --> 01:41:41,282 IT, AT LEAST MY EVIDENCE, 2816 01:41:41,282 --> 01:41:43,351 UNFORTUNATELY I DON'T SEE AN 2817 01:41:43,351 --> 01:41:45,320 ASSOCIATION BETWEEN THAT PROGRAM 2818 01:41:45,320 --> 01:41:46,621 AND MORE TELEHEALTH USE. 2819 01:41:46,621 --> 01:41:48,289 SO THERE'S A LOT OF REASONS WE 2820 01:41:48,289 --> 01:41:48,923 HAD THAT PROGRAM. 2821 01:41:48,923 --> 01:41:50,592 I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT. 2822 01:41:50,592 --> 01:41:52,126 IF IT'S JUST ABOUT TELEHEALTH 2823 01:41:52,126 --> 01:41:55,063 IT'S ONE EXAMPLE WHERE I'VE NOT 2824 01:41:55,063 --> 01:41:57,232 SEEN EVIDENCE THAT'S THE KIND OF 2825 01:41:57,232 --> 01:41:58,333 PROGRAM THAT'S MOST EFFECTIVE. 2826 01:41:58,333 --> 01:42:00,301 THIS IS ONE EXAMPLE OF WHY THIS 2827 01:42:00,301 --> 01:42:01,502 TYPE OF RESEARCH IS NECESSARY 2828 01:42:01,502 --> 01:42:06,007 BECAUSE WE JUST SHOULDN'T MAKE 2829 01:42:06,007 --> 01:42:06,341 ASSUMPTIONS. 2830 01:42:06,341 --> 01:42:09,310 >> ABSOLUTELY. 2831 01:42:09,310 --> 01:42:09,677 >> EXCELLENT. 2832 01:42:09,677 --> 01:42:11,145 I THINK WE'RE WINDING DOWN AND 2833 01:42:11,145 --> 01:42:14,549 COMING TO THE END OF A LIVELY 2834 01:42:14,549 --> 01:42:17,518 DISCUSSION, THIS HAS BEEN 2835 01:42:17,518 --> 01:42:18,286 INSIGHTFUL AND STIMULATING. 2836 01:42:18,286 --> 01:42:22,757 I WANT TO CLOSE ALLOWING THE 2837 01:42:22,757 --> 01:42:24,392 PANELISTS TO GIVE FINAL THOUGHTS 2838 01:42:24,392 --> 01:42:25,960 WHAT YOU'RE EXCITED ABOUT IN THE 2839 01:42:25,960 --> 01:42:28,796 NEXT YEAR OR FIVE YEARS AS FAR 2840 01:42:28,796 --> 01:42:33,501 AS TELEHEALTH AND THE 2841 01:42:33,501 --> 01:42:35,603 OPPORTUNITIES OF IMPLEMENTATION 2842 01:42:35,603 --> 01:42:36,905 RESEARCH STARTING WITH ATEEV 2843 01:42:36,905 --> 01:42:37,105 FIRST. 2844 01:42:37,105 --> 01:42:39,007 >> YEAH, I THINK THE 2845 01:42:39,007 --> 01:42:40,642 INTERSECTION BETWEEN A.I. AND 2846 01:42:40,642 --> 01:42:42,710 TELEHEALTH IS REALLY AN 2847 01:42:42,710 --> 01:42:43,111 INTERESTING SPACE. 2848 01:42:43,111 --> 01:42:44,345 AGAIN, BUILDING OFF THAT IDEA OF 2849 01:42:44,345 --> 01:42:48,616 HOW DO WE USE TECHNOLOGY TO MAKE 2850 01:42:48,616 --> 01:42:49,918 OUR CLINICIANS MORE PRODUCTIVE, 2851 01:42:49,918 --> 01:42:50,752 THERE'S OPPORTUNITIES THERE, 2852 01:42:50,752 --> 01:42:52,620 THIS IS SOMETHING IN THE 2853 01:42:52,620 --> 01:42:54,355 AFTERNOON WE'LL DISCUSS MORE. 2854 01:42:54,355 --> 01:42:57,191 BUT THAT GETS ME EXCITED ABOUT 2855 01:42:57,191 --> 01:43:00,695 WHERE WE'RE HEADED. 2856 01:43:00,695 --> 01:43:02,463 >> THANK YOU. 2857 01:43:02,463 --> 01:43:05,099 >> I'M EXCITED ABOUT THINKING 2858 01:43:05,099 --> 01:43:06,401 ABOUT HOW WE UNDERSTAND THE 2859 01:43:06,401 --> 01:43:10,138 CONTINUUM OF CARE, HOW WE HAND 2860 01:43:10,138 --> 01:43:11,773 PATIENTS OFF FROM ASYNCHRONOUS 2861 01:43:11,773 --> 01:43:12,740 TO SYNCHRONOUS TO IN-PERSON CARE 2862 01:43:12,740 --> 01:43:16,044 AND DO THAT IN A WAY THAT MEETS 2863 01:43:16,044 --> 01:43:17,245 PATIENTS' NEEDS AS SEAMLESSLY AS 2864 01:43:17,245 --> 01:43:17,779 POSSIBLE. 2865 01:43:17,779 --> 01:43:20,081 I'M EXCITED ABOUT THINKING ABOUT 2866 01:43:20,081 --> 01:43:21,082 THE MORE LONGITUDINAL PATTERNS 2867 01:43:21,082 --> 01:43:23,718 OF CARE SO NOT THE TELEHEALTH 2868 01:43:23,718 --> 01:43:26,087 VERSUS IN-PERSON VISITS ON THEIR 2869 01:43:26,087 --> 01:43:28,890 OWN BUT OVERALL ONE OF MY 2870 01:43:28,890 --> 01:43:30,725 COLLEAGUES STATED LOOKING AT A 2871 01:43:30,725 --> 01:43:31,926 PRACTICE WHERE THERE IS 2872 01:43:31,926 --> 01:43:33,661 TELEHEALTH AND IN-PERSON CARE 2873 01:43:33,661 --> 01:43:34,862 VERSUS IN-PERSON ONLY AND HOW 2874 01:43:34,862 --> 01:43:36,831 DOES THAT CHANGE THE CARE THAT 2875 01:43:36,831 --> 01:43:38,466 PEOPLE RECEIVE. 2876 01:43:38,466 --> 01:43:40,568 AND THEN CONTINUING TO 2877 01:43:40,568 --> 01:43:41,869 PRIORITIZE SESSIONS OF EQUITY 2878 01:43:41,869 --> 01:43:43,771 AND AS WE'RE THINKING ABOUT 2879 01:43:43,771 --> 01:43:48,209 THESE QUESTIONS. 2880 01:43:48,209 --> 01:43:49,610 >> I'M A SIMPLE GUY, EXCITED THE 2881 01:43:49,610 --> 01:43:52,580 NIH IS HAVING A PANEL LIKE THIS. 2882 01:43:52,580 --> 01:43:54,115 I'VE SEEN WHAT RESEARCH IS 2883 01:43:54,115 --> 01:43:55,750 NECESSARY, AND TO ME THAT'S 2884 01:43:55,750 --> 01:43:58,386 ACTUALLY THE MOST EXCITING THING 2885 01:43:58,386 --> 01:43:59,821 THAT'S HAPPENED IN THE RECENT 2886 01:43:59,821 --> 01:44:01,356 PAST. 2887 01:44:01,356 --> 01:44:01,956 >> EXCELLENT. 2888 01:44:01,956 --> 01:44:02,991 WELL, THANK YOU ALL. 2889 01:44:02,991 --> 01:44:05,393 AND SINCE WE HAVE SOME TIME I'LL 2890 01:44:05,393 --> 01:44:08,796 SHARE WHAT I'M EXCITED ABOUT AS 2891 01:44:08,796 --> 01:44:11,866 A PRIMARY CARE DOCTOR, THINKING 2892 01:44:11,866 --> 01:44:16,204 ABOUT BURNOUT AND THE WORKFORCE, 2893 01:44:16,204 --> 01:44:16,771 EXCITED WHAT TELEHEALTH CAN 2894 01:44:16,771 --> 01:44:20,742 OFFERED FER OFFER TO THE FRONT 2895 01:44:20,742 --> 01:44:21,776 LINE CLINICIAN, TEAM-BASED 2896 01:44:21,776 --> 01:44:23,478 MODELS ACCESSIBLE TO PATIENTS, 2897 01:44:23,478 --> 01:44:25,346 GIVING OUR PATIENTS MORE 2898 01:44:25,346 --> 01:44:25,780 OPPORTUNITIES. 2899 01:44:25,780 --> 01:44:26,748 I'M CONCERNED ABOUT THOSE 2900 01:44:26,748 --> 01:44:27,749 PATIENTS WHO ARE FALLING THROUGH 2901 01:44:27,749 --> 01:44:30,718 THE CRACKS AS WE TALK ABOUT 2902 01:44:30,718 --> 01:44:32,587 LIMITED DIGITAL LITERACY, AND 2903 01:44:32,587 --> 01:44:33,654 LIMITED ENGLISH PROFICIENCY. 2904 01:44:33,654 --> 01:44:35,723 AND I THINK A LOT OF THOSE 2905 01:44:35,723 --> 01:44:37,258 SOLUTIONS HIGHLIGHTED IN THIS 2906 01:44:37,258 --> 01:44:40,528 PANEL ARE VERY PROMISING AREAS 2907 01:44:40,528 --> 01:44:42,697 TO INVESTIGATE WHEN WE THINK 2908 01:44:42,697 --> 01:44:43,798 ABOUT IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH. 2909 01:44:43,798 --> 01:44:45,767 SO WITH THAT, I JUST WANT TO 2910 01:44:45,767 --> 01:44:47,201 THANK THE PANEL. 2911 01:44:47,201 --> 01:44:48,102 THIS WAS GREAT. 2912 01:44:48,102 --> 01:44:51,806 AND I'LL TURN IT OVER TO OUR 2913 01:44:51,806 --> 01:44:53,441 FACILITATORS FOR THE NEXT STEPS. 2914 01:44:53,441 --> 01:44:54,876 THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 2915 01:44:54,876 --> 01:44:58,146 >> THANKS, ALL. 2916 01:44:58,146 --> 01:45:04,252 >> THANK YOU. 2917 01:45:04,252 --> 01:45:06,921 WE HAVE A LOT OF WORKSHOPS LIKE 2918 01:45:06,921 --> 01:45:07,688 THESE. 2919 01:45:07,688 --> 01:45:11,192 IT'S NOT JUST THIS ONE, DR. 2920 01:45:11,192 --> 01:45:11,526 HOLLANDER. 2921 01:45:11,526 --> 01:45:12,960 WHEN WE HAVE MORE ABOUT 2922 01:45:12,960 --> 01:45:14,929 TELEHEALTH AND OTHER TOPICS I'LL 2923 01:45:14,929 --> 01:45:17,098 START FORWARDING THEM TO YOU. 2924 01:45:17,098 --> 01:45:19,734 EVEN BACK IN 2022 WE HAD ALSO 2925 01:45:19,734 --> 01:45:21,069 THE FEDERAL PARTNERS PROGRAM 2926 01:45:21,069 --> 01:45:27,075 WHICH WAS A WORKSHOP ENGAGING 2927 01:45:27,075 --> 01:45:28,709 NIH AND HHS AND OTHER 2928 01:45:28,709 --> 01:45:31,879 DEPARTMENTS IN THE U.S. 2929 01:45:31,879 --> 01:45:32,780 GOVERNMENT DISCUSSING 2930 01:45:32,780 --> 01:45:33,414 PROVIDER-TO-PROVIDER TELEHEALTH 2931 01:45:33,414 --> 01:45:34,715 AND A LOT OF PUBLICATIONS THAT 2932 01:45:34,715 --> 01:45:35,817 CAME FROM THAT MEETING. 2933 01:45:35,817 --> 01:45:37,351 PERHAPS I'LL SHARE THOSE IN THE 2934 01:45:37,351 --> 01:45:38,686 CHAT COMING ALONG. 2935 01:45:38,686 --> 01:45:40,988 NOW WE HAVE A BRIEF BREAK, A 2936 01:45:40,988 --> 01:45:44,125 BREAK OF ABOUT 45 MINUTES OR SO 2937 01:45:44,125 --> 01:45:45,760 TO GET LUNCH. 2938 01:45:45,760 --> 01:45:47,895 ON THE WEST COAST, PERHAPS 2939 01:45:47,895 --> 01:45:49,730 MID-BREAKFAST, I'M NOT SURE. 2940 01:45:49,730 --> 01:45:51,466 WE'LL RETURN WITH THE SMALL 2941 01:45:51,466 --> 01:45:52,867 GROUP DISCUSSIONS. 2942 01:45:52,867 --> 01:45:56,037 SMALL GROUP DISCUSSIONS, 2943 01:45:56,037 --> 01:45:59,107 EVERYBODY WILL BE DIVIDED INTO 2944 01:45:59,107 --> 01:46:01,409 THE GROUP THEY CHOSE WHEN THEY 2945 01:46:01,409 --> 01:46:02,310 REGISTERED. 2946 01:46:02,310 --> 01:46:02,944 JOINING VERSUS VIDEOCAST YOU 2947 01:46:02,944 --> 01:46:05,346 WON'T BE ABLE TO JOIN THE SMALL 2948 01:46:05,346 --> 01:46:07,115 GROUPS, ONLY THOSE WHO 2949 01:46:07,115 --> 01:46:08,416 REGISTERED AND ARE JOINING VIA 2950 01:46:08,416 --> 01:46:09,050 ZOOM. 2951 01:46:09,050 --> 01:46:11,819 IF YOU ARE REGISTERED AND YOU'RE 2952 01:46:11,819 --> 01:46:13,121 WATCHING NOW VIA VIDEOCAST, IT'S 2953 01:46:13,121 --> 01:46:15,523 A GREAT MOMENT TO JOIN VIA ZOOM. 2954 01:46:15,523 --> 01:46:18,159 IF YOU ALREADY JOINED VIA ZOOM, 2955 01:46:18,159 --> 01:46:20,828 OUR SUPPORT TEAM IS GIVING US 2956 01:46:20,828 --> 01:46:22,997 ADVICE TO NOT LOG OFF, JUST STAY 2957 01:46:22,997 --> 01:46:25,199 MUTED WITH YOUR CAMERA TURNED 2958 01:46:25,199 --> 01:46:27,935 OFF AND WE'LL SEE EACH OTHER AT 2959 01:46:27,935 --> 01:46:29,270 1:40 P.M. EASTERN TIME. 2960 01:46:29,270 --> 01:46:31,085 SEE YOU IN A LITTLE BIT. 2961 01:47:31,089 --> 01:47:35,493 >> WE HAVE FOUR GROUPS LED BY 2962 01:47:35,493 --> 01:47:37,995 AMAZING PANELISTS AND MODERATORS 2963 01:47:37,995 --> 01:47:38,463 TODAY, TRANSFORMATIVE 2964 01:47:38,463 --> 01:47:40,198 TECHNOLOGIES, SHAPING THE FUTURE 2965 01:47:40,198 --> 01:47:44,135 OF REMOTE CARE, I'LL START WITH 2966 01:47:44,135 --> 01:47:44,669 YOU. 2967 01:47:44,669 --> 01:47:45,970 WE'LL START WITH THE OFFICE OF 2968 01:47:45,970 --> 01:47:46,504 DISEASE PREVENTION AT THE 2969 01:47:46,504 --> 01:47:47,538 NATIONAL INSTITUTES OF HEALTH. 2970 01:47:47,538 --> 01:47:50,308 SO, BOB, CAN YOU GIVE US A QUICK 2971 01:47:50,308 --> 01:47:52,543 SUMMARY OF WHAT WERE SOME HIGH 2972 01:47:52,543 --> 01:47:55,747 YIELD, IF ANYONE IN THE GROUP 2973 01:47:55,747 --> 01:47:57,081 ALSO WANTS TO ADD MORE COMMENTS 2974 01:47:57,081 --> 01:47:59,050 TO THE CHAT PLEASE GO AHEAD. 2975 01:47:59,050 --> 01:48:00,485 WE'LL CALL EACH GROUP, STARTING 2976 01:48:00,485 --> 01:48:01,919 WITH YOU, BOB. 2977 01:48:01,919 --> 01:48:03,554 >> THANK YOU, FERNANDO. 2978 01:48:03,554 --> 01:48:05,289 WHAT A GREAT GROUP FROM AROUND 2979 01:48:05,289 --> 01:48:06,190 THE WORLD, PEOPLE DOING ALL 2980 01:48:06,190 --> 01:48:10,795 KINDS OF WORK NOTE -- NOT JUST 2981 01:48:10,795 --> 01:48:12,096 HEALTH CARE BUT ANCILLARY 2982 01:48:12,096 --> 01:48:13,765 GROUPS, FOOD AND BEVERAGE 2983 01:48:13,765 --> 01:48:15,500 INDUSTRY, A BUNCH OF 2984 01:48:15,500 --> 01:48:17,168 PERSPECTIVES TO BRING TO BEAR. 2985 01:48:17,168 --> 01:48:18,369 FOR FOLKS TO KNOW THE MAIN 2986 01:48:18,369 --> 01:48:20,104 OBJECTIVE IN OUR GROUP WAS TO 2987 01:48:20,104 --> 01:48:22,607 TRY TO HIGHLIGHT RECENT AND 2988 01:48:22,607 --> 01:48:23,674 UPCOMING INNOVATIONS IN 2989 01:48:23,674 --> 01:48:27,111 TELEHEALTH SUCH AS A.I., REMOTE 2990 01:48:27,111 --> 01:48:29,647 MONITORING, AND INTEGRATION IN 2991 01:48:29,647 --> 01:48:30,515 EXISTING HEALTHCARE SYSTEMS. 2992 01:48:30,515 --> 01:48:32,150 OF COURSE WE TOUCHED A LOT ON 2993 01:48:32,150 --> 01:48:33,317 A.I. 2994 01:48:33,317 --> 01:48:35,553 A.I. CAME UP FREQUENTLY AS A 2995 01:48:35,553 --> 01:48:36,320 THEME. 2996 01:48:36,320 --> 01:48:37,855 AND ESPECIALLY WITH INTEGRATION 2997 01:48:37,855 --> 01:48:39,590 WITH TELEHEALTH. 2998 01:48:39,590 --> 01:48:43,094 HOW IT MIGHT DECREASE THE BURDEN 2999 01:48:43,094 --> 01:48:45,096 ON CLINICIANS, TOOLS AROUND 3000 01:48:45,096 --> 01:48:46,130 SUMMARIZING VISIT DATA OR 3001 01:48:46,130 --> 01:48:48,766 PUTTING NOTES IN THE EMRs, BUT 3002 01:48:48,766 --> 01:48:50,168 ALSO EMPOWERING PATIENTS, HAVING 3003 01:48:50,168 --> 01:48:51,202 THAT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 3004 01:48:51,202 --> 01:48:53,037 ABOUT PATIENTS TO TAKE CARE OF 3005 01:48:53,037 --> 01:48:54,005 THEMSELVES. 3006 01:48:54,005 --> 01:48:56,774 WE TALKED ABOUT WEARABLES, MANY 3007 01:48:56,774 --> 01:48:59,877 CAPACITIES, NOT JUST SMARTWATCH 3008 01:48:59,877 --> 01:49:03,815 BUT FOR SLEEP APNEA, PROMOTE 3009 01:49:03,815 --> 01:49:04,782 WOMEN'S HEALTH, UNDERSTAND 3010 01:49:04,782 --> 01:49:05,116 CONDITIONS. 3011 01:49:05,116 --> 01:49:06,951 ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I THINK A 3012 01:49:06,951 --> 01:49:08,920 THEME FOR ME THAT CAME UP 3013 01:49:08,920 --> 01:49:12,089 THROUGH ALL THESE CONVERSATIONS 3014 01:49:12,089 --> 01:49:15,393 AROUND HOW A.I. AND POTENTIALLY 3015 01:49:15,393 --> 01:49:17,161 WEARABLES, REMOTE PATIENT 3016 01:49:17,161 --> 01:49:19,330 MONITORING, AND OTHER TOOLS CAN 3017 01:49:19,330 --> 01:49:21,966 BE A CHALLENGE IS REALLY AROUND 3018 01:49:21,966 --> 01:49:24,936 THE QUESTION, IS MORE DATA 3019 01:49:24,936 --> 01:49:26,571 BETTER, AND WHETHER THAT DATA IS 3020 01:49:26,571 --> 01:49:27,438 GOING TO THE CLINICIANS, AND 3021 01:49:27,438 --> 01:49:29,173 THEY HAVE TO MAKE DECISIONS ON 3022 01:49:29,173 --> 01:49:31,509 WHETHER TO ACT ON IT OR NOT, OR 3023 01:49:31,509 --> 01:49:32,410 WHETHER THAT DATA IS GOING TO 3024 01:49:32,410 --> 01:49:33,678 PATIENTS AND THEY HAVE TO 3025 01:49:33,678 --> 01:49:34,479 UNDERSTAND WHETHER IT'S 3026 01:49:34,479 --> 01:49:36,214 MEANINGFUL OR NOT OR USEFUL. 3027 01:49:36,214 --> 01:49:38,950 SO REALLY THE THEME ABOUT MORE 3028 01:49:38,950 --> 01:49:40,618 DATA COULD BE COOL BUT WILL IT 3029 01:49:40,618 --> 01:49:43,221 ACTUALLY BE JUST INTERESTING OR 3030 01:49:43,221 --> 01:49:44,755 WILL IT BE USEFUL. 3031 01:49:44,755 --> 01:49:45,857 I THINK ONE INTERESTING MODEL 3032 01:49:45,857 --> 01:49:47,725 FOR HOW WE THINK ABOUT THAT WAS 3033 01:49:47,725 --> 01:49:50,995 WE HAD A BRIEF DISCUSSION ABOUT 3034 01:49:50,995 --> 01:49:55,399 PAIN AND HOW WE START TO SCALE A 3035 01:49:55,399 --> 01:49:57,368 PATIENT'S PAIN, ON A 1-10, AND 3036 01:49:57,368 --> 01:49:58,636 USUALLY AS ONE OF OUR 3037 01:49:58,636 --> 01:50:01,305 PARTICIPANTS SAID I CAN ALWAYS 3038 01:50:01,305 --> 01:50:02,273 ANTICIPATE THEY ARE COMING TO 3039 01:50:02,273 --> 01:50:04,942 SEE ME, PAIN IS A 7, 8, OR 9. 3040 01:50:04,942 --> 01:50:06,511 THE QUESTION WHAT DOES THAT MEAN 3041 01:50:06,511 --> 01:50:07,545 FOR THE INDIVIDUAL, PEOPLE WERE 3042 01:50:07,545 --> 01:50:09,747 ASKING WHAT'S A 7 OR 8? 3043 01:50:09,747 --> 01:50:11,682 IS THERE A WAY TO QUALIFY THAT A 3044 01:50:11,682 --> 01:50:11,983 LITTLE BIT? 3045 01:50:11,983 --> 01:50:14,886 AND PARTLY THIS WAS THE VALUE OF 3046 01:50:14,886 --> 01:50:16,854 IS THAT DATA USEFUL TO US, WHAT 3047 01:50:16,854 --> 01:50:19,257 DO WE DO TO ACT ON IT AND ARE 3048 01:50:19,257 --> 01:50:20,992 THERE WAYS TO QUALIFY, MAKE IT 3049 01:50:20,992 --> 01:50:26,597 MEANINGFUL AND PERSONAL, ALL 3050 01:50:26,597 --> 01:50:27,832 DATA ISN'T NECESSARILY BETTER, 3051 01:50:27,832 --> 01:50:29,000 IF IT'S ACTIONABLE, HELPS 3052 01:50:29,000 --> 01:50:31,202 IMPROVE THE CARE WE DELIVER AND 3053 01:50:31,202 --> 01:50:32,737 HELPS CONNECT PATIENTS BETTER TO 3054 01:50:32,737 --> 01:50:34,138 THE CARE THEY NEED. 3055 01:50:34,138 --> 01:50:37,742 SO THOSE ARE A FEW OF MY 3056 01:50:37,742 --> 01:50:38,009 TAKEAWAYS. 3057 01:50:38,009 --> 01:50:39,744 WE HAVE A COUPLE SLIDES, GREAT 3058 01:50:39,744 --> 01:50:41,178 CHAT, GOOD DISCUSSIONS ON A 3059 01:50:41,178 --> 01:50:42,613 VARIETY OF THINGS. 3060 01:50:42,613 --> 01:50:44,248 IS THERE ANYBODY FROM THE SMALL 3061 01:50:44,248 --> 01:50:45,583 GROUP WHO WANTED TO HARP ON A 3062 01:50:45,583 --> 01:50:47,518 POINT I MAY HAVE LEFT OUT? 3063 01:50:47,518 --> 01:50:50,922 I'D LOVE TO HEAR ANY OTHER 3064 01:50:50,922 --> 01:50:51,188 THINGS. 3065 01:50:51,188 --> 01:50:53,558 >> I WROTE DOWN IS MORE DATA 3066 01:50:53,558 --> 01:50:53,991 BETTER. 3067 01:50:53,991 --> 01:50:55,293 >> YEAH. 3068 01:50:55,293 --> 01:50:57,161 >> BECAUSE I THINK WE'RE ALL 3069 01:50:57,161 --> 01:50:58,029 GUILTY OF THAT. 3070 01:50:58,029 --> 01:51:00,665 I SEE SO MANY PEOPLE WE GO 3071 01:51:00,665 --> 01:51:01,499 CONFERENCES, TAKE PHOTOS EVEN OF 3072 01:51:01,499 --> 01:51:03,734 THE SLIDE OF THE SPEAKERS, OH, 3073 01:51:03,734 --> 01:51:05,169 THIS IS AMAZING, AND WE NEVER 3074 01:51:05,169 --> 01:51:06,304 LOOK AT THAT DATA AGAIN. 3075 01:51:06,304 --> 01:51:08,205 I THINK MANY TIMES WE COLLECT SO 3076 01:51:08,205 --> 01:51:10,074 MUCH DATA AND THAT GOES 3077 01:51:10,074 --> 01:51:10,341 UNNOTICED. 3078 01:51:10,341 --> 01:51:13,277 SO THIS QUESTION OF LIKE WHO IS 3079 01:51:13,277 --> 01:51:14,478 ACCESSING IT, THE PHYSICIAN, 3080 01:51:14,478 --> 01:51:18,516 MEDICAL TEAM, IS IT THE PATIENT, 3081 01:51:18,516 --> 01:51:19,617 YOU KNOW. 3082 01:51:19,617 --> 01:51:20,217 >> ABSOLUTELY. 3083 01:51:20,217 --> 01:51:21,485 I'LL JUST SAY WHILE WE'RE 3084 01:51:21,485 --> 01:51:23,788 WAITING, WE CAN MOVE ON TOO, 3085 01:51:23,788 --> 01:51:25,456 DOES THIS DATA HELP TO BRIDGE 3086 01:51:25,456 --> 01:51:26,624 THE EQUITY GAPS WE'VE BEEN 3087 01:51:26,624 --> 01:51:27,825 TALKING ABOUT SO MUCH. 3088 01:51:27,825 --> 01:51:29,894 IT WAS HIGHLIGHTED VERY NICELY 3089 01:51:29,894 --> 01:51:31,329 THAT EQUITY DOESN'T MEAN 3090 01:51:31,329 --> 01:51:32,663 EVERYBODY GETS THE SAME THING, 3091 01:51:32,663 --> 01:51:34,065 PEOPLE GET WHAT THEY NEED. 3092 01:51:34,065 --> 01:51:37,335 AND ARE THERE WAYS WE CAN -- 3093 01:51:37,335 --> 01:51:38,970 A.I., WEARABLES OR OTHER 3094 01:51:38,970 --> 01:51:41,405 TECHNOLOGIES CAN HELP GET THEM 3095 01:51:41,405 --> 01:51:41,806 THERE. 3096 01:51:41,806 --> 01:51:47,211 >> IT'S A QUESTION OF LIKE ARE 3097 01:51:47,211 --> 01:51:49,080 WE COLLECTING DATA BECAUSE WE 3098 01:51:49,080 --> 01:51:53,250 CAN OR IS THERE A PLAN FOR THAT 3099 01:51:53,250 --> 01:51:53,751 DATA? 3100 01:51:53,751 --> 01:51:55,419 >> DOES IT HAVE MEANING. 3101 01:51:55,419 --> 01:51:55,720 >> YEAH. 3102 01:51:55,720 --> 01:51:56,420 >> THANKS FOR THE OPPORTUNITY TO 3103 01:51:56,420 --> 01:51:57,421 REPORT OUT. 3104 01:51:57,421 --> 01:51:58,589 A GREAT WORKSHOP. 3105 01:51:58,589 --> 01:52:02,760 THANK YOU FOR THIS, FOR YOUR 3106 01:52:02,760 --> 01:52:03,427 WORK, FERNANDO. 3107 01:52:03,427 --> 01:52:05,396 >> MOVING ON NOW TO OUR SMALL 3108 01:52:05,396 --> 01:52:07,264 GROUP 2, TELEHEALTH POLICY AND 3109 01:52:07,264 --> 01:52:11,402 EQUITY, BRIDGING GAPS IN ACCESS 3110 01:52:11,402 --> 01:52:13,938 AND CARE, I CALL THE CHIEF FOR 3111 01:52:13,938 --> 01:52:14,905 HEALTH COMMUNICATION INFORMATICS 3112 01:52:14,905 --> 01:52:18,309 RESEARCH BRANCH HERE AT NCI OF 3113 01:52:18,309 --> 01:52:19,176 THE NIH. 3114 01:52:19,176 --> 01:52:19,844 ROBIN, WELCOME. 3115 01:52:19,844 --> 01:52:20,645 >> THANK YOU. 3116 01:52:20,645 --> 01:52:21,846 I'VE BEEN HAVING AUDIO ISSUES, 3117 01:52:21,846 --> 01:52:24,682 CAN YOU HEAR ME? 3118 01:52:24,682 --> 01:52:26,017 >> NO PROBLEMS. 3119 01:52:26,017 --> 01:52:28,085 IF THERE'S PROBLEM WE'LL LET YOU 3120 01:52:28,085 --> 01:52:29,220 KNOW. 3121 01:52:29,220 --> 01:52:30,354 >> GREAT. 3122 01:52:30,354 --> 01:52:31,589 QUICKLY, I THINK YOU CAN 3123 01:52:31,589 --> 01:52:33,457 IMAGINE, ALREADY KNOW MANY OF 3124 01:52:33,457 --> 01:52:38,796 THE SOCIAL DETERMINANTS OF 3125 01:52:38,796 --> 01:52:40,898 HEALTH THAT WOULD AFFECT ACCESS, 3126 01:52:40,898 --> 01:52:44,168 AND EQUITABLE ACCESS AT THAT TO 3127 01:52:44,168 --> 01:52:44,969 TELEHEALTH SERVICES. 3128 01:52:44,969 --> 01:52:48,439 AND SO WE CERTAINLY IDENTIFIED 3129 01:52:48,439 --> 01:52:49,874 EVERYTHING FROM TRANSPORTATION 3130 01:52:49,874 --> 01:52:53,277 AND EDUCATION AND FOOD 3131 01:52:53,277 --> 01:52:56,213 INSECURITY TO FINANCIAL 3132 01:52:56,213 --> 01:52:58,015 RESOURCES, FAMILY INCOME, 3133 01:52:58,015 --> 01:52:59,617 BROADBAND ACCESS, DEFINITELY WAS 3134 01:52:59,617 --> 01:53:02,586 PART OF OUR CONVERSATION. 3135 01:53:02,586 --> 01:53:04,555 BUT THEN I THINK, YOU KNOW, A 3136 01:53:04,555 --> 01:53:06,290 NEWER COMPONENT THAT WE THINK 3137 01:53:06,290 --> 01:53:09,260 ABOUT RELATED TO HEALTH LITERACY 3138 01:53:09,260 --> 01:53:13,964 IS DIGITAL LITERACY, RIGHT? 3139 01:53:13,964 --> 01:53:16,033 THINKING ABOUT HOW PATIENTS, YOU 3140 01:53:16,033 --> 01:53:17,568 KNOW, REALLY PERCEIVE THIS 3141 01:53:17,568 --> 01:53:19,670 TECHNOLOGY, ARE THEY ABLE TO USE 3142 01:53:19,670 --> 01:53:22,273 IT, DO THEY HAVE AN E-MAIL 3143 01:53:22,273 --> 01:53:23,507 ADDRESS THAT ALLOWS THEM, YOU 3144 01:53:23,507 --> 01:53:26,010 KNOW, TO EVEN GET THE LINK TO 3145 01:53:26,010 --> 01:53:27,411 LOG IN TO THE TELEHEALTH 3146 01:53:27,411 --> 01:53:28,512 ENCOUNTER, FOR EXAMPLE. 3147 01:53:28,512 --> 01:53:31,048 AND THEN MAKING SURE PATIENTS 3148 01:53:31,048 --> 01:53:34,318 HAVE ACCESS TO THE DEVICES, 3149 01:53:34,318 --> 01:53:36,954 SOFTWARE, EQUIPMENT, WHATEVER 3150 01:53:36,954 --> 01:53:40,658 TECHNOLOGY IS NEEDED TO ACCESS 3151 01:53:40,658 --> 01:53:41,425 THOSE TELEHEALTH SERVICES. 3152 01:53:41,425 --> 01:53:44,462 AND SO WE SPENT THE REST OF THE 3153 01:53:44,462 --> 01:53:46,664 TIME THINKING ABOUT OBVIOUSLY 3154 01:53:46,664 --> 01:53:51,368 WHAT STRATEGIES, WHAT RESEARCH, 3155 01:53:51,368 --> 01:53:53,571 WHAT COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIPS CAN 3156 01:53:53,571 --> 01:53:55,706 BE FACILITATE AND LEVERAGED TO 3157 01:53:55,706 --> 01:53:57,141 IMPROVE ACCESS TO TELEHEALTH 3158 01:53:57,141 --> 01:53:58,576 SERVICES, TO ADDRESS THESE 3159 01:53:58,576 --> 01:54:01,212 SOCIAL DETERMINANTS OF HEALTH. 3160 01:54:01,212 --> 01:54:03,814 AND OUR GROUP REALLY HAD LOT OF 3161 01:54:03,814 --> 01:54:05,015 THOUGHT AND INTERACTION, FOR 3162 01:54:05,015 --> 01:54:08,319 EXAMPLE, AROUND WORKING WITH 3163 01:54:08,319 --> 01:54:11,489 PUBLIC LIBRARIES OF THOSE BEING 3164 01:54:11,489 --> 01:54:13,457 REALLY STRONG COMMUNITY, YOU 3165 01:54:13,457 --> 01:54:15,993 KNOW, POINT OF CONTACT FOR FOLKS 3166 01:54:15,993 --> 01:54:18,395 TO COME IN AND ACCESS BOTH THE 3167 01:54:18,395 --> 01:54:20,464 INTERNET, TO ACCESS ACTUAL 3168 01:54:20,464 --> 01:54:22,233 COMPUTER SERVICES, BUT ALSO AS 3169 01:54:22,233 --> 01:54:24,301 YOU KNOW LIBRARIES CAN PROVIDE 3170 01:54:24,301 --> 01:54:26,036 TRAINING SERVICES AND CLASSES 3171 01:54:26,036 --> 01:54:27,805 ABOUT WHAT IS TELEHEALTH, WHAT 3172 01:54:27,805 --> 01:54:30,007 IS YOUR EHR PORTAL AND HOW DO 3173 01:54:30,007 --> 01:54:31,842 YOU ACCESS THAT. 3174 01:54:31,842 --> 01:54:36,380 WE TALKED ABOUT FAITH 3175 01:54:36,380 --> 01:54:37,648 ORGANIZATIONS, FAITH MINISTRIES, 3176 01:54:37,648 --> 01:54:40,417 SCHOOLS WHO OFTEN SERVE AGAIN AS 3177 01:54:40,417 --> 01:54:41,385 A RESOURCE HUB IN OUR 3178 01:54:41,385 --> 01:54:44,355 COMMUNITIES AND HOW THOSE COULD 3179 01:54:44,355 --> 01:54:46,657 BE LEVERAGED TO ACCESS 3180 01:54:46,657 --> 01:54:47,491 TELEHEALTH SERVICES. 3181 01:54:47,491 --> 01:54:51,362 WE ALSO TALKED A LOT ABOUT 3182 01:54:51,362 --> 01:54:52,263 TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE AND 3183 01:54:52,263 --> 01:54:54,331 TRAINING FOR PATIENTS AND THEIR 3184 01:54:54,331 --> 01:54:56,300 CAREGIVERS ON HOW TO JUST LEARN 3185 01:54:56,300 --> 01:54:57,835 HOW TO USE TELEHEALTH. 3186 01:54:57,835 --> 01:55:00,237 WHAT DOES THE EHR PORTAL OFFER 3187 01:55:00,237 --> 01:55:01,005 ME? 3188 01:55:01,005 --> 01:55:02,873 HOW DOES A TELEHEALTH ENCOUNTER 3189 01:55:02,873 --> 01:55:03,307 WORK? 3190 01:55:03,307 --> 01:55:05,743 CAN WE WORK THROUGH SOME OF THE 3191 01:55:05,743 --> 01:55:07,111 BUMPS AND BUGS OF GETTING FOLKS 3192 01:55:07,111 --> 01:55:10,214 LOGGED ON SO THEY ARE READY TO 3193 01:55:10,214 --> 01:55:12,516 GO WHEN THE PROVIDER IS PRESENT 3194 01:55:12,516 --> 01:55:14,251 IN THE VIRTUAL ROOM. 3195 01:55:14,251 --> 01:55:18,522 SO THINKING ABOUT TELEHEALTH 3196 01:55:18,522 --> 01:55:20,057 COORDINATORS, TELEHEALTH 3197 01:55:20,057 --> 01:55:20,591 NAVIGATORS. 3198 01:55:20,591 --> 01:55:22,259 AND THEN AGAIN UNDERSTANDING 3199 01:55:22,259 --> 01:55:24,094 PATIENT PREFERENCES AND 3200 01:55:24,094 --> 01:55:25,529 SATISFACTION WITH DIFFERENT 3201 01:55:25,529 --> 01:55:26,997 ROUTES OF DELIVERING TELEHEALTH, 3202 01:55:26,997 --> 01:55:29,033 WHETHER ON COMPUTER OR 3203 01:55:29,033 --> 01:55:30,334 SMARTPHONE OR AUDIO ONLY. 3204 01:55:30,334 --> 01:55:34,171 BUT THEN REALLY GETTING INTO 3205 01:55:34,171 --> 01:55:34,705 USABILITY, COMFORTABILITY, 3206 01:55:34,705 --> 01:55:35,906 SATISFACTION, YOU KNOW, SO WE 3207 01:55:35,906 --> 01:55:38,008 CAN MEET PATIENTS WHERE THEY 3208 01:55:38,008 --> 01:55:38,175 ARE. 3209 01:55:38,175 --> 01:55:39,977 AND I THINK, YOU KNOW, THEN 3210 01:55:39,977 --> 01:55:41,612 THINGS WE TALKED ABOUT THIS 3211 01:55:41,612 --> 01:55:45,015 MORNING RESONATED WITH US AROUND 3212 01:55:45,015 --> 01:55:47,318 FOCUSING ON OUTCOMES, HOW DOES 3213 01:55:47,318 --> 01:55:48,118 TELEHEALTH IMPROVE OUTCOMES 3214 01:55:48,118 --> 01:55:50,487 RELATED TO IMPROVEMENTS IN 3215 01:55:50,487 --> 01:55:52,690 NO-SHOW RATE, ACCESS IN 3216 01:55:52,690 --> 01:55:55,059 SPECIALTY CARE, HOW DOES IT COME 3217 01:55:55,059 --> 01:55:57,494 COMPLEMENT IN PATIENT OR 3218 01:55:57,494 --> 01:55:58,395 IN-PERSON SERVICES. 3219 01:55:58,395 --> 01:56:00,497 AND JUST DEEP DIVES IN THE DATA 3220 01:56:00,497 --> 01:56:02,099 TO HELP US UNDERSTAND 3221 01:56:02,099 --> 01:56:04,869 DISPARITIES, MAYBE WE NEED TO BE 3222 01:56:04,869 --> 01:56:11,275 WORKING WITH EHR COMPANIES AND 3223 01:56:11,275 --> 01:56:11,876 TELEHEALTH DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER 3224 01:56:11,876 --> 01:56:12,977 COMPANIES TO SEE WHO IS 3225 01:56:12,977 --> 01:56:15,045 ACCESSING TELEHEALTH AND WHO IS 3226 01:56:15,045 --> 01:56:17,114 NOT ACCESSING TELEHEALTH. 3227 01:56:17,114 --> 01:56:19,850 AND I THINK WITH THAT I'LL 3228 01:56:19,850 --> 01:56:21,151 PROBABLY -- OH, OF COURSE ONE OF 3229 01:56:21,151 --> 01:56:23,354 THE BIGGER POINTS WE TALKED 3230 01:56:23,354 --> 01:56:27,191 ABOUT IS HOW TO IMPROVE THE 3231 01:56:27,191 --> 01:56:28,592 CROSS--STATE-LINE ISSUES WE SEE 3232 01:56:28,592 --> 01:56:32,463 RIGHT NOW AND EVERYBODY CAME 3233 01:56:32,463 --> 01:56:34,965 BACK TO FLEXIBILITY, NATIONAL 3234 01:56:34,965 --> 01:56:40,804 POLICIES, DOING EDUCATION AND 3235 01:56:40,804 --> 01:56:44,174 OUTREACH TO POLICYMAKERS ARE 3236 01:56:44,174 --> 01:56:44,808 IMPORTANT, AND IMPROVING 3237 01:56:44,808 --> 01:56:47,912 REIMBURSEMENT AND WE HAD 3238 01:56:47,912 --> 01:56:50,447 DISCUSSIONS ABOUT IMPROVING OUR 3239 01:56:50,447 --> 01:56:51,749 OFFERING OF LANGUAGE TRANSLATION 3240 01:56:51,749 --> 01:56:52,716 SERVICES FOR TELEHEALTH USE AND 3241 01:56:52,716 --> 01:56:56,020 MAYBE HOW COULD YOU USE 3242 01:56:56,020 --> 01:56:57,021 TECHNOLOGY TO TRANSLATE IN REAL 3243 01:56:57,021 --> 01:56:57,221 TIME. 3244 01:56:57,221 --> 01:57:00,391 I KNOW THAT COULD BE PART OF OUR 3245 01:57:00,391 --> 01:57:02,359 CONVERSATION LATER THIS 3246 01:57:02,359 --> 01:57:02,626 AFTERNOON. 3247 01:57:02,626 --> 01:57:04,995 WITH THAT I WANT TO MOVE, I KNOW 3248 01:57:04,995 --> 01:57:06,864 WE'RE SHORT ON TIME BUT THOSE 3249 01:57:06,864 --> 01:57:08,165 WERE GREAT CONVERSATION STARTING 3250 01:57:08,165 --> 01:57:10,134 POINTS IN OUR GROUP. 3251 01:57:10,134 --> 01:57:12,002 >> THANK YOU, ROBIN AND GROUP 2. 3252 01:57:12,002 --> 01:57:14,405 I WAS ALSO THINKING HERE THAT 3253 01:57:14,405 --> 01:57:17,574 NOT ONLY THE HEALTHCARE 3254 01:57:17,574 --> 01:57:20,644 PROFESSIONALS ALSO HAVE THE 3255 01:57:20,644 --> 01:57:23,714 CHALLENGE WITH ELECTRONIC 3256 01:57:23,714 --> 01:57:27,084 MEDICAL RECORDS YET EXPECT 3257 01:57:27,084 --> 01:57:28,953 PATIENTS USING PLATFORMS TO 3258 01:57:28,953 --> 01:57:29,853 FULLY UNDERSTAND THEM WHEN EVEN 3259 01:57:29,853 --> 01:57:31,689 THOSE NOT USING THEM DAY, IT 3260 01:57:31,689 --> 01:57:34,091 SEEMS LIKE YOUR GROUP DISCUSSED 3261 01:57:34,091 --> 01:57:34,959 THIS PROCESS OF CAPACITY 3262 01:57:34,959 --> 01:57:35,225 BUILDING. 3263 01:57:35,225 --> 01:57:40,331 I LIKE WHAT YOU SAID ALSO 3264 01:57:40,331 --> 01:57:41,966 TAPPING INTO THE CAREGIVER, ARE 3265 01:57:41,966 --> 01:57:43,600 CARE GIVERS HELPING TRAIN AND 3266 01:57:43,600 --> 01:57:44,835 BRINGS TO MIND SOMETHING I 3267 01:57:44,835 --> 01:57:46,370 STARTED IN UNITED STATES 3268 01:57:46,370 --> 01:57:48,238 SCHOOLS, HERE IN VIRGINIA, WE 3269 01:57:48,238 --> 01:57:49,873 ALSO HAVE IT, WHICH IS DIGITAL 3270 01:57:49,873 --> 01:57:53,043 CITIZEN IS ONE OF THE COURSES 3271 01:57:53,043 --> 01:57:53,911 NOW THEY OFFER FOR CHILDREN, 3272 01:57:53,911 --> 01:57:57,314 WHEN THEY ARE IN FIFTH GRADE, 3273 01:57:57,314 --> 01:57:59,183 ABOUT TEACHING THESE FIFTH 3274 01:57:59,183 --> 01:58:04,989 GRADERS HOW THEY BECOME 3275 01:58:04,989 --> 01:58:07,725 PEOPLE -- THEY TALK ABOUT 3276 01:58:07,725 --> 01:58:09,493 PHISHING, SCAMS, PROFILES, 3277 01:58:09,493 --> 01:58:10,160 SHARING INFORMATION, PERHAPS 3278 01:58:10,160 --> 01:58:12,096 SOMETHING WE CAN FOCUS ON 3279 01:58:12,096 --> 01:58:14,198 CAPACITY BUILDING. 3280 01:58:14,198 --> 01:58:15,833 NOW GIVEN THE LAST QUESTION, 3281 01:58:15,833 --> 01:58:18,135 BACK TO YOU, ROBIN, WHEN WE 3282 01:58:18,135 --> 01:58:19,336 DISCUSSED THIS CHANGING POLICY 3283 01:58:19,336 --> 01:58:20,771 THAT YOU ARE PROPOSING OBVIOUSLY 3284 01:58:20,771 --> 01:58:22,840 ALL THESE CHALLENGES ARE 3285 01:58:22,840 --> 01:58:23,273 MULTI-FACTORIAL. 3286 01:58:23,273 --> 01:58:25,909 AND WE TALK ABOUT CHANGING 3287 01:58:25,909 --> 01:58:27,011 POLICIES, CREATING MORE 3288 01:58:27,011 --> 01:58:29,213 FLEXIBILITY OF THE POLICIES, HOW 3289 01:58:29,213 --> 01:58:31,215 CAN THE RESEARCH ACTUALLY INFORM 3290 01:58:31,215 --> 01:58:32,316 THESE POLICIES, WHAT WAS 3291 01:58:32,316 --> 01:58:34,284 DISCUSSED IN YOUR GROUP IN TERMS 3292 01:58:34,284 --> 01:58:37,287 OF NEXT STEPS IN RESEARCH? 3293 01:58:37,287 --> 01:58:39,223 >> YEAH, I THINK -- WELL, WE 3294 01:58:39,223 --> 01:58:42,793 RANGE ON A LOT OF TOPICS, 3295 01:58:42,793 --> 01:58:44,228 LEVERAGING DATA, USING DATA 3296 01:58:44,228 --> 01:58:45,529 THAT'S AVAILABLE SO THAT'S MAYBE 3297 01:58:45,529 --> 01:58:48,465 DATA WE HAVEN'T TAPPED INTO 3298 01:58:48,465 --> 01:58:49,900 FULLY YET TO REALLY UNDERSTAND 3299 01:58:49,900 --> 01:58:51,001 THE PROBLEM, RIGHT? 3300 01:58:51,001 --> 01:58:53,070 THAT'S ALWAYS AN IMPORTANT FIRST 3301 01:58:53,070 --> 01:58:53,837 STEP. 3302 01:58:53,837 --> 01:58:56,907 AND THEN I THINK THERE WAS THESE 3303 01:58:56,907 --> 01:58:58,108 PIECES AROUND DO WE STOP AND 3304 01:58:58,108 --> 01:59:01,745 REALLY DO MAYBE SOME OF THE 3305 01:59:01,745 --> 01:59:03,380 QUALITATIVE, IF YOU WILL, WORK 3306 01:59:03,380 --> 01:59:06,550 OR USABILITY WORK WITH PATIENTS 3307 01:59:06,550 --> 01:59:08,318 AND CAREGIVERS, AND PROVIDERS, 3308 01:59:08,318 --> 01:59:11,722 TO REALLY UNDERSTAND THEIR 3309 01:59:11,722 --> 01:59:13,123 PREFERENCES, THEIR SATISFACTION, 3310 01:59:13,123 --> 01:59:13,857 THEIR USABILITY. 3311 01:59:13,857 --> 01:59:15,859 YOU KNOW, REALLY THAT 3312 01:59:15,859 --> 01:59:16,493 PATIENT-CENTERED APPROACH TO 3313 01:59:16,493 --> 01:59:20,297 FIGURING OUT WHAT WORKS FOR THEM 3314 01:59:20,297 --> 01:59:22,733 AND DOING THE -- DELIVERING 3315 01:59:22,733 --> 01:59:23,500 TAILORED INTERVENTIONS AND 3316 01:59:23,500 --> 01:59:24,701 PROGRAMMING AFTER THAT. 3317 01:59:24,701 --> 01:59:26,003 CERTAINLY FOR THE LARGER POLICY 3318 01:59:26,003 --> 01:59:28,572 PIECE, I THINK WHERE WE CAN 3319 01:59:28,572 --> 01:59:32,142 COLLECT, FOR EXAMPLE, YOU KNOW, 3320 01:59:32,142 --> 01:59:33,877 USE DATA, QUALITY METRICS, YOU 3321 01:59:33,877 --> 01:59:35,879 KNOW, REALLY CHANGING I WOULD 3322 01:59:35,879 --> 01:59:38,182 ARGUE SOCIAL NORMS AROUND 3323 01:59:38,182 --> 01:59:40,250 TELEHEALTH, I THINK THAT FEEDS 3324 01:59:40,250 --> 01:59:43,220 TO WHAT POLICYMAKERS NEED AS THE 3325 01:59:43,220 --> 01:59:44,088 EVIDENCE THAT TELEHEALTH IS A 3326 01:59:44,088 --> 01:59:50,527 GOOD THING AND THAT WE NEED TO 3327 01:59:50,527 --> 01:59:52,830 CONTINUE IMPROVING THE 3328 01:59:52,830 --> 01:59:53,397 FLEXIBILITY'S REIMBURSEMENT, 3329 01:59:53,397 --> 01:59:55,065 LICENSURE ISSUE, ET CETERA, TO 3330 01:59:55,065 --> 01:59:57,367 MAKE THIS MORE WIDESPREAD, MORE 3331 01:59:57,367 --> 01:59:58,802 SCALABLE, MORE ACCESSIBLE. 3332 01:59:58,802 --> 01:59:59,136 >> PERFECT. 3333 01:59:59,136 --> 02:00:00,571 THANKS SO MUCH, ROBIN. 3334 02:00:00,571 --> 02:00:01,572 I APPRECIATE IT. 3335 02:00:01,572 --> 02:00:03,040 THANK YOU, GROUP 2. 3336 02:00:03,040 --> 02:00:08,078 NOW WE MOVE FOR THE REPORT FROM 3337 02:00:08,078 --> 02:00:09,513 GROUP 3, INFRASTRUCTURE AND 3338 02:00:09,513 --> 02:00:11,148 TECHNOLOGICAL CHALLENGES, PEOPLE 3339 02:00:11,148 --> 02:00:13,117 WERE HIGHLY ENGAGED, WE BARELY 3340 02:00:13,117 --> 02:00:14,218 FELT MOTIVATED TO COME BACK TO 3341 02:00:14,218 --> 02:00:15,452 THE MAIN ROOM BECAUSE WE WANTED 3342 02:00:15,452 --> 02:00:20,457 TO STAY THERE. 3343 02:00:20,457 --> 02:00:24,194 I INVITE DR. LOK SAMSON, HHS 3344 02:00:24,194 --> 02:00:26,430 OFFICE OF ASSISTANT SECRETARY 3345 02:00:26,430 --> 02:00:29,032 FOR PLANNING, PLEASE FEEL FREE 3346 02:00:29,032 --> 02:00:31,201 TO SHARE YOUR PERSPECTIVES. 3347 02:00:31,201 --> 02:00:33,937 >> OUR GROUP DUG INTO TELEHEALTH 3348 02:00:33,937 --> 02:00:34,705 INFRASTRUCTURE AND TECHNOLOGICAL 3349 02:00:34,705 --> 02:00:35,906 BARRIERS. 3350 02:00:35,906 --> 02:00:40,377 WE HAD A GOOD USE CASE FOR 3351 02:00:40,377 --> 02:00:42,913 PEDIATRIC TELEREHAB, THERE WAS 3352 02:00:42,913 --> 02:00:44,982 INFRASTRUCTURE VARIANTS IN TERMS 3353 02:00:44,982 --> 02:00:46,316 OF EQUIPMENT, EXERCISE 3354 02:00:46,316 --> 02:00:47,317 EQUIPMENT, AFFORDABILITY FOR 3355 02:00:47,317 --> 02:00:49,153 PATIENTS, BUT ALSO ESPECIALLY 3356 02:00:49,153 --> 02:00:52,089 FOR PEDIATRICS, ALL THE DEVICES 3357 02:00:52,089 --> 02:00:54,458 ARE NOT REALLY DESIGNED FOR 3358 02:00:54,458 --> 02:00:55,058 CHILDREN. 3359 02:00:55,058 --> 02:00:57,027 THERE ARE PRIVACY AND LIABILITY 3360 02:00:57,027 --> 02:01:00,564 ISSUES WITH HAVING CHILDREN 3361 02:01:00,564 --> 02:01:04,368 DIRECTLY USE THESE APPS, 3362 02:01:04,368 --> 02:01:07,204 CONNECTED TO EXERCISE EQUIPMENT, 3363 02:01:07,204 --> 02:01:09,606 AND WORK-AROUND USING PARENT'S 3364 02:01:09,606 --> 02:01:10,374 PHONE, PARENT'S ACCOUNTS, THIS 3365 02:01:10,374 --> 02:01:13,577 MIGHT BE A TEENAGER THAT HAS THE 3366 02:01:13,577 --> 02:01:14,978 EQUIPMENT, HAS A PHONE THAT 3367 02:01:14,978 --> 02:01:19,483 CAN'T USE THEIR OWN PHONE. 3368 02:01:19,483 --> 02:01:21,785 THERE WERE ALSO SPECIAL 3369 02:01:21,785 --> 02:01:23,987 POPULATIONS WHERE THERE MIGHT BE 3370 02:01:23,987 --> 02:01:27,157 HESITANCY TO USE INTERNET AND 3371 02:01:27,157 --> 02:01:29,560 OTHER TECHNOLOGIES, AND MIGHT 3372 02:01:29,560 --> 02:01:31,428 NEED SPECIAL EXEMPTIONS FROM 3373 02:01:31,428 --> 02:01:35,365 RELIGIOUS LEADERS TO USE THESE 3374 02:01:35,365 --> 02:01:36,900 KINDS OF TELEHEALTH 3375 02:01:36,900 --> 02:01:38,535 TECHNOLOGIES. 3376 02:01:38,535 --> 02:01:41,805 IN TERMS OF AFFORDABILITY SOME 3377 02:01:41,805 --> 02:01:42,573 WORKAROUNDS IN GETTING INTERNET 3378 02:01:42,573 --> 02:01:44,408 ACCESS AT LEAST FOR RESEARCHERS 3379 02:01:44,408 --> 02:01:47,945 WHO HAVE GRANTS MIGHT BE TO 3380 02:01:47,945 --> 02:01:49,780 OFFER A SIM CARD, ESPECIALLY IN 3381 02:01:49,780 --> 02:01:51,982 RURAL AREAS WHERE THERE'S NO 3382 02:01:51,982 --> 02:01:54,084 BROADBAND ACCESS. 3383 02:01:54,084 --> 02:01:57,454 SO THESE EXAMPLES GIVE A FLAVOR 3384 02:01:57,454 --> 02:01:58,555 OF THE ON-THE-GROUND BARRIERS 3385 02:01:58,555 --> 02:02:00,591 PATIENTS ARE FACING WHERE 3386 02:02:00,591 --> 02:02:01,758 TELEHEALTH COULD HAVE A LOT OF 3387 02:02:01,758 --> 02:02:04,494 IMPACT ESPECIALLY IN RURAL AREAS 3388 02:02:04,494 --> 02:02:07,097 WHERE PEOPLE DON'T HAVE THAT 3389 02:02:07,097 --> 02:02:11,001 BROADBAND ACCESS. 3390 02:02:11,001 --> 02:02:12,336 ADDITIONAL WORKAROUNDS EXAMPLES 3391 02:02:12,336 --> 02:02:14,705 INCLUDED PATIENTS GOING TO THE 3392 02:02:14,705 --> 02:02:17,207 SCHOOL TO ACCESS EQUIPMENT AND 3393 02:02:17,207 --> 02:02:18,041 THE INTERNET. 3394 02:02:18,041 --> 02:02:19,376 AND I GUESS THE QUESTION HERE 3395 02:02:19,376 --> 02:02:20,911 WAS FROM THE GROUP, WHAT KIND OF 3396 02:02:20,911 --> 02:02:23,347 RESEARCH DO WE NEED, WHO DOESN'T 3397 02:02:23,347 --> 02:02:26,216 HAVE ACCESS, WHAT DO WE REALLY 3398 02:02:26,216 --> 02:02:28,819 KNOW ABOUT THESE SPECIAL GROUPS. 3399 02:02:28,819 --> 02:02:31,788 THERE WAS ALSO POLICY 3400 02:02:31,788 --> 02:02:33,690 LIMITATIONS, ESPECIALLY IN TERMS 3401 02:02:33,690 --> 02:02:37,294 OF EQUIPMENT, OFTEN HALF THE 3402 02:02:37,294 --> 02:02:40,163 TOOLS USE A MULTI-PAYER APPROACH 3403 02:02:40,163 --> 02:02:42,232 TO THEIR RULES, AND THERE ARE 3404 02:02:42,232 --> 02:02:44,101 LIMITS ON WHAT AMOUNT OF GIFTS 3405 02:02:44,101 --> 02:02:46,069 PATIENTS CAN RECEIVE EVEN IN THE 3406 02:02:46,069 --> 02:02:47,804 FORM OF EQUIPMENT. 3407 02:02:47,804 --> 02:02:50,440 SO THIS SORT OF BRINGS SORT OF 3408 02:02:50,440 --> 02:02:54,811 TELEHEALTH AND THE INTERSECTION 3409 02:02:54,811 --> 02:02:56,013 WITH HEALTHCARE POLICIES 3410 02:02:56,013 --> 02:02:56,480 TOGETHER. 3411 02:02:56,480 --> 02:02:58,315 ONE THOUGHT ALSO WAS THAT IN 3412 02:02:58,315 --> 02:03:00,050 TERMS OF INTERNET ACCESS, WHAT 3413 02:03:00,050 --> 02:03:03,787 DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE IMPACT OF 3414 02:03:03,787 --> 02:03:05,222 THE BROADBAND AFFORDABILITY 3415 02:03:05,222 --> 02:03:06,757 CONNECTIVITY PROGRAM THAT 3416 02:03:06,757 --> 02:03:07,524 RECENTLY ENDED. 3417 02:03:07,524 --> 02:03:09,926 AND, YOU KNOW, ARE THERE -- IS 3418 02:03:09,926 --> 02:03:11,795 THERE RESEARCH THAT CAN TELL US 3419 02:03:11,795 --> 02:03:13,630 IF IT IMPROVED ACCESS OR IF 3420 02:03:13,630 --> 02:03:15,399 THERE'S STILL OPPORTUNITIES TO 3421 02:03:15,399 --> 02:03:19,136 IMPROVE ACCESS FOR SPECIAL 3422 02:03:19,136 --> 02:03:19,670 POPULATIONS. 3423 02:03:19,670 --> 02:03:24,041 IN TERMS OF THE SECOND QUESTION 3424 02:03:24,041 --> 02:03:27,144 WE EXPLORED INTEROPERABLE DATA 3425 02:03:27,144 --> 02:03:28,245 EXCHANGES, AN AREA WITH 3426 02:03:28,245 --> 02:03:31,181 DISCUSSION ABOUT LIMITED ACCESS 3427 02:03:31,181 --> 02:03:32,516 TO DATA FROM WEARABLES, 3428 02:03:32,516 --> 02:03:36,253 CHALLENGES IN PULLING DATA 3429 02:03:36,253 --> 02:03:38,889 ACROSS DIFFERENT VENDORS, 3430 02:03:38,889 --> 02:03:40,490 ESPECIALLY FOR RESEARCH, AND 3431 02:03:40,490 --> 02:03:41,825 WITH CHANGES IN TECHNOLOGY AS 3432 02:03:41,825 --> 02:03:43,360 THE MARKET CHANGES THERE'S 3433 02:03:43,360 --> 02:03:45,662 REALLY NO CENTRAL PLATFORM FOR 3434 02:03:45,662 --> 02:03:49,833 DATA SHARING, WHICH MAKES IT 3435 02:03:49,833 --> 02:03:52,102 CHALLENGING FOR RESEARCHERS AND 3436 02:03:52,102 --> 02:03:53,637 ALSO PARTICIPANTS WHO MAYBE 3437 02:03:53,637 --> 02:03:54,971 HAVING DIFFERENT DEVICES WANT TO 3438 02:03:54,971 --> 02:03:57,474 USE THE INFORMATION FOR THEIR 3439 02:03:57,474 --> 02:03:59,343 OWN CARE. 3440 02:03:59,343 --> 02:04:03,847 ONE AREA WE DISCUSSED WAS 3441 02:04:03,847 --> 02:04:04,648 ELIMINATING CONTEXT ESPECIALLY 3442 02:04:04,648 --> 02:04:06,383 WITH WEARABLE DATA. 3443 02:04:06,383 --> 02:04:08,018 IT'S DIFFICULT TO INTERPRET THE 3444 02:04:08,018 --> 02:04:09,753 MEANING OF THE WEARABLE 3445 02:04:09,753 --> 02:04:12,155 INFORMATION WITHOUT KNOWING WHAT 3446 02:04:12,155 --> 02:04:13,590 MEDICATIONS OR LIFESTYLE CHANGES 3447 02:04:13,590 --> 02:04:15,459 A PATIENT MIGHT BE UNDERTAKING. 3448 02:04:15,459 --> 02:04:18,962 AND THAT MAKES IT HARDER FOR 3449 02:04:18,962 --> 02:04:22,666 CLINICIANS TO USE THAT 3450 02:04:22,666 --> 02:04:24,868 INFORMATION. 3451 02:04:24,868 --> 02:04:25,535 LET'S SEE. 3452 02:04:25,535 --> 02:04:29,706 THERE ARE ALSO SORT OF 3453 02:04:29,706 --> 02:04:33,210 TECHNOLOGICAL LIMITATIONS, JUST 3454 02:04:33,210 --> 02:04:37,681 MAKING DATA USEFUL FOR PATIENTS, 3455 02:04:37,681 --> 02:04:39,216 PATIENTS REQUIRED TO WEAR THE 3456 02:04:39,216 --> 02:04:40,951 DEVICE FOR THREE DAYS TO 3457 02:04:40,951 --> 02:04:42,052 ESTABLISH A BASELINE SO SOME 3458 02:04:42,052 --> 02:04:44,054 QUESTIONS IS THERE A NEED FOR 3459 02:04:44,054 --> 02:04:46,556 TRIALS OF REMOTE PATIENT 3460 02:04:46,556 --> 02:04:48,325 MONITORING, WITH CURRENT TOOLS 3461 02:04:48,325 --> 02:04:49,960 ON THE MARKET MIGHT BE 3462 02:04:49,960 --> 02:04:50,861 INSUFFICIENT RIGHT NOW TO 3463 02:04:50,861 --> 02:04:52,696 DETERMINE WHAT REALLY WORKS. 3464 02:04:52,696 --> 02:04:54,264 BUT THERE ARE GROWING 3465 02:04:54,264 --> 02:04:55,265 OPPORTUNITIES, ESPECIALLY WITH 3466 02:04:55,265 --> 02:04:59,302 NEW DEVICES, SUCH AS BIOCHEMICAL 3467 02:04:59,302 --> 02:05:01,571 PATCHES FOR MONITORING THAT 3468 02:05:01,571 --> 02:05:04,641 WOULD BETTER SUPPORT CORRELATION 3469 02:05:04,641 --> 02:05:06,176 BETWEEN THE WEARABLE INFORMATION 3470 02:05:06,176 --> 02:05:11,181 AND OUTCOMES THAT THAT'S WHAT 3471 02:05:11,181 --> 02:05:12,082 CLINICIANS WANT. 3472 02:05:12,082 --> 02:05:12,883 >> THANK YOU. 3473 02:05:12,883 --> 02:05:14,050 I SEE SIMILARITIES ON WHAT 3474 02:05:14,050 --> 02:05:16,920 YOU'RE SAYING AND WHAT ROBIN 3475 02:05:16,920 --> 02:05:19,256 JUST SAID ALSO ABOUT THE 3476 02:05:19,256 --> 02:05:20,490 FLEXIBILITY OF POLICIES, A LOT 3477 02:05:20,490 --> 02:05:26,196 OF THINGS THAT BOB HAS SPOKEN 3478 02:05:26,196 --> 02:05:27,164 ABOUT HOW MUCH COLLECTION OF 3479 02:05:27,164 --> 02:05:28,598 DATA IS USEFUL. 3480 02:05:28,598 --> 02:05:29,933 FOR YOUR PARTICULAR SMALL GROUP 3481 02:05:29,933 --> 02:05:31,902 SESSION, A LOT OF THIS WILL BE A 3482 02:05:31,902 --> 02:05:34,738 SEGUE TO THE NEXT SESSION AFTER 3483 02:05:34,738 --> 02:05:36,473 WE FINISH THIS REPORT-BACK WHICH 3484 02:05:36,473 --> 02:05:38,575 WILL FOCUS ON mHEALTH AND 3485 02:05:38,575 --> 02:05:44,181 REMOTE MORE 3486 02:05:44,181 --> 02:05:45,382 REMOTE MONITORING AND DATA 3487 02:05:45,382 --> 02:05:46,917 ANALYSIS, ALSO WHEN DATA ARE 3488 02:05:46,917 --> 02:05:47,484 COLLECTED FROM MULTIPLE 3489 02:05:47,484 --> 02:05:51,221 PLATFORMS THAT DON'T SPEAK WITH 3490 02:05:51,221 --> 02:05:54,391 ONE ANOTHER HOW CAN WE 3491 02:05:54,391 --> 02:05:54,658 INTEGRATE. 3492 02:05:54,658 --> 02:05:56,259 WE APPRECIATE GROUP 3 FOR THE 3493 02:05:56,259 --> 02:05:56,526 FEEDBACK. 3494 02:05:56,526 --> 02:05:57,227 >> THANK YOU. 3495 02:05:57,227 --> 02:05:59,863 >> WE MOVE NOW TO OUR LAST 3496 02:05:59,863 --> 02:06:02,065 GROUP, SMALL GROUP 4, ENHANCING 3497 02:06:02,065 --> 02:06:06,436 PATIENT ENGAGEMENT AND 3498 02:06:06,436 --> 02:06:08,605 SATISFACTION THROUGH TELEHEALTH. 3499 02:06:08,605 --> 02:06:10,574 NOW THE DIRECTOR FOR PRACTICE 3500 02:06:10,574 --> 02:06:13,443 IMPROVEMENT, CENTER FOR EVIDENCE 3501 02:06:13,443 --> 02:06:17,047 AND PRACTICE IMPROVEMENT AT 3502 02:06:17,047 --> 02:06:19,349 AHRQ. 3503 02:06:19,349 --> 02:06:21,218 PLEASE TAKE IT AWAY. 3504 02:06:21,218 --> 02:06:24,321 >> WE HAVE A SMALL GROUP, 3505 02:06:24,321 --> 02:06:26,122 EVERYBODY REALLY ENGAGING WITH 3506 02:06:26,122 --> 02:06:27,924 DISCUSSIONS AND PLEASE CORRECT 3507 02:06:27,924 --> 02:06:29,993 ME, FEEL FREE TO JUMP IN IF I 3508 02:06:29,993 --> 02:06:31,828 MISSED ANYTHING. 3509 02:06:31,828 --> 02:06:35,165 OUR TARGET TO LOOK AT STRATEGY 3510 02:06:35,165 --> 02:06:36,099 FOR PATIENT ENGAGEMENT AND 3511 02:06:36,099 --> 02:06:39,636 SATISFACTION IN TELEHEALTH WHICH 3512 02:06:39,636 --> 02:06:43,340 WE ALL FEEL CRITICAL, ESSENTIAL 3513 02:06:43,340 --> 02:06:45,308 TO ENGAGING THE PROVIDERS, 3514 02:06:45,308 --> 02:06:46,042 HEALTHCARE SYSTEMS, ENGAGING 3515 02:06:46,042 --> 02:06:50,013 PATIENT AND COMMUNITY TO MAKING 3516 02:06:50,013 --> 02:06:51,781 SURE HOLISTIC APPROACH AND 3517 02:06:51,781 --> 02:06:54,284 PATIENT PERSON-CENTERED CARE FOR 3518 02:06:54,284 --> 02:06:57,587 THE PATIENT, WE LOOK AT THE 3519 02:06:57,587 --> 02:07:03,727 USING TELEHEALTH, ENHANCED 3520 02:07:03,727 --> 02:07:05,462 PATIENT ENGAGEMENT AND 3521 02:07:05,462 --> 02:07:06,096 SATISFACTION, INCLUDING 3522 02:07:06,096 --> 02:07:07,130 PATIENT-CENTERED ENGAGEMENT, WE 3523 02:07:07,130 --> 02:07:10,634 FEEL IS THE KEY, ALSO LEVERAGE 3524 02:07:10,634 --> 02:07:12,569 PARTNERSHIPS WITHOUT SIDE 3525 02:07:12,569 --> 02:07:13,303 SERVICES, PARTNERS, FOR EXAMPLE, 3526 02:07:13,303 --> 02:07:17,073 VIA 3527 02:07:17,073 --> 02:07:23,013 SEE -- V.A. HAS BEEN DOING TO 3528 02:07:23,013 --> 02:07:23,914 MAKE SURE BROADBAND INTERNET 3529 02:07:23,914 --> 02:07:25,749 ACCESS IS AVAILABLE TO THOSE 3530 02:07:25,749 --> 02:07:30,453 WITH CHALLENGES, DO NOT HAVE 3531 02:07:30,453 --> 02:07:32,556 RESOURCES TO ACCESS TELEMEDICINE 3532 02:07:32,556 --> 02:07:34,391 AND ENGAGE PARTNERS TO COLLECT 3533 02:07:34,391 --> 02:07:38,595 PATIENT SURVEYS, INTERVIEWS TO 3534 02:07:38,595 --> 02:07:40,096 GET PERSPECTIVES TO FIND METHODS 3535 02:07:40,096 --> 02:07:41,665 FOR CARE BEST FIT FOR PATIENT 3536 02:07:41,665 --> 02:07:46,369 AND POPULATION HAS BEEN 3537 02:07:46,369 --> 02:07:46,836 EVIDENCE. 3538 02:07:46,836 --> 02:07:49,239 WE ALSO GOT SUGGESTED USING 3539 02:07:49,239 --> 02:07:50,874 DIGITAL PLATFORM TO ADDRESS HIGH 3540 02:07:50,874 --> 02:07:56,279 PATIENT LOAD AND SOMETIMES LACK 3541 02:07:56,279 --> 02:07:58,648 OF PROVIDERS IN DIFFERENT AREAS, 3542 02:07:58,648 --> 02:08:03,253 LESSONS FROM INDIA SHARED, LOOK 3543 02:08:03,253 --> 02:08:04,054 AT DIGITAL INFRASTRUCTURE 3544 02:08:04,054 --> 02:08:07,390 LACKING IN NOT ONLY INDIA BUT 3545 02:08:07,390 --> 02:08:08,491 ALSO IN UNITED STATES, MANY 3546 02:08:08,491 --> 02:08:10,894 TIMES DESPITE A LOT OF 3547 02:08:10,894 --> 02:08:13,964 INVESTMENT ALREADY HAPPENING IN 3548 02:08:13,964 --> 02:08:16,399 THE FIELD. 3549 02:08:16,399 --> 02:08:18,234 WE LOOK AT QUESTIONS ABOUT 3550 02:08:18,234 --> 02:08:19,102 TELEHEALTH PLATFORMS, WHAT ARE 3551 02:08:19,102 --> 02:08:20,971 MOST AVAILABLE TO THE PATIENTS 3552 02:08:20,971 --> 02:08:25,342 AND HOW CAN THIS BE OPTIMIZED, 3553 02:08:25,342 --> 02:08:27,744 WE REALIZE V.A. HAD EXPERIENCE 3554 02:08:27,744 --> 02:08:33,717 WORKING WITH LOCAL COMMUNITY 3555 02:08:33,717 --> 02:08:36,052 ACCESS POINTS TO FACILITATE. 3556 02:08:36,052 --> 02:08:44,527 AGREEMENTS WITH LIBRARIES, 3557 02:08:44,527 --> 02:08:46,997 COMMUNITY CENTERS, TO 3558 02:08:46,997 --> 02:08:48,031 SYNCHRONIZE CONNECTIONS WITH 3559 02:08:48,031 --> 02:08:49,899 PROVIDERS ADDING SATISFACTION 3560 02:08:49,899 --> 02:08:53,303 AMONG VETERAN PATIENTS, REDUCING 3561 02:08:53,303 --> 02:08:57,340 TRAVEL BURDEN, AND WE FOUND 3562 02:08:57,340 --> 02:08:59,976 ONLINE PORTALS TO FACILITATE 3563 02:08:59,976 --> 02:09:02,479 MEDICATION RENEWS MAKING 3564 02:09:02,479 --> 02:09:05,649 APPOINTMENT, MESSAGING 3565 02:09:05,649 --> 02:09:07,951 PROVIDERS, EVEN SHARING IMAGES 3566 02:09:07,951 --> 02:09:09,319 AND HEALTH DATA HIGHLIGHTED BY 3567 02:09:09,319 --> 02:09:12,856 THE PATIENTS, WE NEED TO ALSO 3568 02:09:12,856 --> 02:09:19,663 OPTIMIZE APPROACHES FOR THESE 3569 02:09:19,663 --> 02:09:20,964 WITH DIAGNOSIS 3570 02:09:20,964 --> 02:09:23,166 MAKING SURE THEY GET TREATMENTS 3571 02:09:23,166 --> 02:09:25,335 THROUGH SYSTEM MAKING SURE WE 3572 02:09:25,335 --> 02:09:27,470 DON'T MISS ANY PATIENT, ADDING 3573 02:09:27,470 --> 02:09:28,204 PREVENTION COMPONENT. 3574 02:09:28,204 --> 02:09:32,942 AND ALSO HOW TO PROVIDE CARE TO 3575 02:09:32,942 --> 02:09:36,312 IMPROVE ACCESS TO CARE USING 3576 02:09:36,312 --> 02:09:37,514 TELEMEDICINE AND OTHER 3577 02:09:37,514 --> 02:09:38,948 TECHNOLOGIES, SOMETHING OUR 3578 02:09:38,948 --> 02:09:47,057 GROUP ALSO VERY INTERESTED TO 3579 02:09:47,057 --> 02:09:52,295 TALK ABOUT. 3580 02:09:52,295 --> 02:09:53,396 LEVERAGING TEAM-BASED APPROACH, 3581 02:09:53,396 --> 02:09:55,799 PRIMARY CARE PROVIDERS, OTHER 3582 02:09:55,799 --> 02:09:58,902 NURSE SPECIALTIES, AND OTHER 3583 02:09:58,902 --> 02:10:01,204 PROVIDERS IN ORDER TO HAVE 3584 02:10:01,204 --> 02:10:02,272 PROVIDER HOLISTIC APPROACH CARE 3585 02:10:02,272 --> 02:10:04,908 TO THE PATIENT, THAT'S ALSO 3586 02:10:04,908 --> 02:10:08,611 SOMETHING WE HAD SOME 3587 02:10:08,611 --> 02:10:09,179 DISCUSSIONS ABOUT. 3588 02:10:09,179 --> 02:10:12,615 NEXT WE TALKED ABOUT ADDITION TO 3589 02:10:12,615 --> 02:10:14,884 PROVIDER HOW THE SYSTEM CAN 3590 02:10:14,884 --> 02:10:16,753 TAILOR COMMUNICATIONS TO REACH 3591 02:10:16,753 --> 02:10:19,355 OUT DIVERSE PATIENTS, WE USED 3592 02:10:19,355 --> 02:10:22,425 EXAMPLES ALSO FROM V.A., THEY 3593 02:10:22,425 --> 02:10:23,960 HAD THE SOCIAL NEEDS SCREENING 3594 02:10:23,960 --> 02:10:25,495 WHICH HELPS ASKING THE PATIENTS 3595 02:10:25,495 --> 02:10:28,364 FIRST AND TRY TO IDENTIFY 3596 02:10:28,364 --> 02:10:30,166 DIFFERENT VETERANS, WHAT THEY 3597 02:10:30,166 --> 02:10:33,436 NEED, THEIR BARRIERS IN ORDER TO 3598 02:10:33,436 --> 02:10:35,939 OVERCOME THE DIGITAL DIVIDE, 3599 02:10:35,939 --> 02:10:41,111 THEN PROVIDE THEM WITH DIFFERENT 3600 02:10:41,111 --> 02:10:42,412 CONSULT FOR EDUCATION AND LOAN 3601 02:10:42,412 --> 02:10:44,914 DEVICE TO HAVE ACCESS TO CARE, 3602 02:10:44,914 --> 02:10:48,084 APPLICATION TO ACCESS HEALTH 3603 02:10:48,084 --> 02:10:50,520 CARE PORTALS BEST. 3604 02:10:50,520 --> 02:10:54,557 THERE ARE PILOT STUDIES FOR 3605 02:10:54,557 --> 02:10:55,859 DISABILITY AND APPROPRIATENESS 3606 02:10:55,859 --> 02:10:57,494 TO UNDERSTAND PATIENT STANDARD 3607 02:10:57,494 --> 02:11:04,400 FOCUS HAS BEEN IMPLEMENTED IN 3608 02:11:04,400 --> 02:11:06,269 V.A. AND IN OTHERS. 3609 02:11:06,269 --> 02:11:07,904 ONE PARTICIPANT MENTIONED IN 3610 02:11:07,904 --> 02:11:09,906 INDIA THERE ARE OVER 200 3611 02:11:09,906 --> 02:11:10,673 LANGUAGES SPOKEN SO MAKING IT 3612 02:11:10,673 --> 02:11:13,276 VERY IMPORTANT TO HAVE A DIGITAL 3613 02:11:13,276 --> 02:11:17,113 PLATFORM PROVIDE A LANGUAGE TO 3614 02:11:17,113 --> 02:11:19,182 EVERYBODY WHO CAN UNDERSTAND AND 3615 02:11:19,182 --> 02:11:20,183 ACCESS HEALTHCARE SERVICES IN 3616 02:11:20,183 --> 02:11:22,051 THIS CASE. 3617 02:11:22,051 --> 02:11:26,189 SOME OF THE TOOLS PROVIDED BY 3618 02:11:26,189 --> 02:11:31,461 V.A. INCLUDING HEALTH PORTAL, 3619 02:11:31,461 --> 02:11:34,864 ATLAS PROGRAM, INDIAN NATIONAL 3620 02:11:34,864 --> 02:11:36,733 PROGRAM, WHICH IS NATIONAL 3621 02:11:36,733 --> 02:11:40,236 PROGRAM SUPPORTED BY INDIAN 3622 02:11:40,236 --> 02:11:40,637 GOVERNMENT. 3623 02:11:40,637 --> 02:11:46,042 AND ALSO CURRENT APP USED IN 3624 02:11:46,042 --> 02:11:48,444 WAKE FOREST SO PATIENTS CAN 3625 02:11:48,444 --> 02:11:49,112 ACCESS THAT. 3626 02:11:49,112 --> 02:11:50,747 WE DISCUSSED THE ROLE OF 3627 02:11:50,747 --> 02:11:52,048 CAREGIVERS, V.A. HAVE GREAT 3628 02:11:52,048 --> 02:11:55,218 EXAMPLES IN THIS CASE, VERY 3629 02:11:55,218 --> 02:11:56,986 ENGAGING PROVIDERS, AND THEIR 3630 02:11:56,986 --> 02:11:58,054 CAREGIVERS OF THE PATIENTS, THEY 3631 02:11:58,054 --> 02:11:59,155 WILL BE INVOLVED IN THE 3632 02:11:59,155 --> 02:12:01,791 BEGINNING OF THE CARE AND TO 3633 02:12:01,791 --> 02:12:03,326 HELP WITH DIGITAL NAVIGATION OF 3634 02:12:03,326 --> 02:12:06,830 THE PATIENTS, WE ALSO DISCUSSED 3635 02:12:06,830 --> 02:12:08,565 ABOUT HIPAA ISSUES, MAKING SURE 3636 02:12:08,565 --> 02:12:09,766 PERMISSIONS AND CONSENT ARE 3637 02:12:09,766 --> 02:12:10,767 AVAILABLE FOR THE CAREGIVERS IN 3638 02:12:10,767 --> 02:12:13,436 ORDER TO BE PART OF THE 3639 02:12:13,436 --> 02:12:14,671 HEALTHCARE SYSTEM. 3640 02:12:14,671 --> 02:12:21,377 THERE ARE A LOT WE HAVE JOINED 3641 02:12:21,377 --> 02:12:25,849 IN DISCUSSION, LET ME KNOW. 3642 02:12:25,849 --> 02:12:27,817 >> THANK YOU, GROUP 4. 3643 02:12:27,817 --> 02:12:29,452 THIS WORKSHOP IS MEANT TO BE A 3644 02:12:29,452 --> 02:12:32,188 CONVERSATION TO HEAR ABOUT YOUR 3645 02:12:32,188 --> 02:12:32,822 CHALLENGES, OPPORTUNITIES OF 3646 02:12:32,822 --> 02:12:35,458 RESEARCH, I THINK THE SMALL 3647 02:12:35,458 --> 02:12:36,359 GROUP DISCUSSIONS WERE 3648 02:12:36,359 --> 02:12:37,660 PHENOMENAL TO ACHIEVE THAT GOAL. 3649 02:12:37,660 --> 02:12:40,964 THANKS TO ALL FOUR GROUPS. 3650 02:12:40,964 --> 02:12:42,265 WE ORIGINALLY HAD 15-MINUTE 3651 02:12:42,265 --> 02:12:43,366 BREAK HERE. 3652 02:12:43,366 --> 02:12:46,202 BECAUSE OF TECHNICAL CHALLENGES 3653 02:12:46,202 --> 02:12:48,071 DURING THE SPLIT OF THE SMALL 3654 02:12:48,071 --> 02:12:50,273 GROUPS, WE ARE GOING TO REDUCE 3655 02:12:50,273 --> 02:12:53,443 THIS TO FIVE MINUTES AND WE'LL 3656 02:12:53,443 --> 02:12:55,078 COME BACK AT 3:05 EASTERN TIME. 3657 02:12:55,078 --> 02:12:55,912 THANK YOU, EVERYONE. 3658 02:12:55,912 --> 02:12:57,847 SEE YOU IN FIVE MINUTES. 3659 02:12:57,847 --> 02:13:00,717 OR SIX ACTUALLY, YOU HAVE ONE 3660 02:13:00,717 --> 02:13:03,519 MORE MINUTE. 3661 02:13:03,519 --> 02:13:04,053 THANK YOU, MODERATORS. 3662 02:13:04,053 --> 02:13:06,556 APPRECIATE IT. 3663 02:13:06,556 --> 02:13:12,595 3664 02:13:12,595 --> 02:13:22,639 3665 02:19:37,513 --> 02:19:38,314 >> WELCOME BACK, EVERYONE. 3666 02:19:38,314 --> 02:19:41,284 IT'S TIME TO MOVE TO OUR SESSION 3667 02:19:41,284 --> 02:19:43,452 2, BUT THE DAY IS NOT OVER. 3668 02:19:43,452 --> 02:19:45,388 WE STILL HAVE MORE THINGS TO 3669 02:19:45,388 --> 02:19:48,190 SHARE AFTER SESSION 2 SO DON'T 3670 02:19:48,190 --> 02:19:51,027 GO AND LOG OFF AFTER THAT. 3671 02:19:51,027 --> 02:19:53,996 SESSION 2 IS mHEALTH, REMOTE 3672 02:19:53,996 --> 02:19:55,531 MONITORING, DATA ANALYSIS, 3673 02:19:55,531 --> 02:19:58,067 INNOVATIONS DRIVING TELEHEALTH 3674 02:19:58,067 --> 02:19:59,468 RESEARCH AND PATIENT OUTCOMES. 3675 02:19:59,468 --> 02:20:02,238 I'M WAITING FOR THE NEXT SLIDE 3676 02:20:02,238 --> 02:20:07,376 SO YOU GET TO SEE OUR WONDERFUL 3677 02:20:07,376 --> 02:20:09,578 PANELIST AND MODERATOR. 3678 02:20:09,578 --> 02:20:14,383 I INVITE DR. DAVID, VICE 3679 02:20:14,383 --> 02:20:16,218 PRESIDENT OF HEALTH CARE AT 3680 02:20:16,218 --> 02:20:18,287 MICROSOFT TO MODERATE THE 3681 02:20:18,287 --> 02:20:25,995 SESSION, AND JOINING HIM THREE 3682 02:20:25,995 --> 02:20:27,530 WONDERFUL PANELISTS, DR. 3683 02:20:27,530 --> 02:20:30,700 KHETEHROP, UNIVERSITY OF 3684 02:20:30,700 --> 02:20:34,403 MICHIGAN MEDICAL SCHOOL. 3685 02:20:34,403 --> 02:20:38,574 WE HAVE JOSEPH KVEDOR, EDITOR IN 3686 02:20:38,574 --> 02:20:42,011 CHIEF OF NPJ JOURNAL AND 3687 02:20:42,011 --> 02:20:42,545 PROFESSOR OF DERMATOLOGY, 3688 02:20:42,545 --> 02:20:44,714 HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL. 3689 02:20:44,714 --> 02:20:50,052 WE INVITE DR. LOK SAMSON, HEALTH 3690 02:20:50,052 --> 02:20:51,921 POLICY ANALYST, HHS OFFICE OF 3691 02:20:51,921 --> 02:20:54,156 THE ASSISTANT SECRETARY FOR 3692 02:20:54,156 --> 02:20:55,424 PLANNING AND EVALUATION, THANK 3693 02:20:55,424 --> 02:20:58,928 YOU VERY MUCH FOR JOINING US, 3694 02:20:58,928 --> 02:21:00,229 AND FOR THOSE WATCHING US, AND, 3695 02:21:00,229 --> 02:21:01,764 DAVID, PLEASE TAKE IT AWAY. 3696 02:21:01,764 --> 02:21:02,531 >> THANK YOU. 3697 02:21:02,531 --> 02:21:06,035 IT'S A PLEASURE TO BE HERE, TO 3698 02:21:06,035 --> 02:21:11,941 MODERATE THIS PANEL WITH SOME 3699 02:21:11,941 --> 02:21:13,409 ESTEEMED EXPERTS IN THE FIELD, 3700 02:21:13,409 --> 02:21:14,810 IN THE SPACE FOR QUITE SOME TIME 3701 02:21:14,810 --> 02:21:16,879 AND I'M GOING TO USE THE 3702 02:21:16,879 --> 02:21:18,080 OPPORTUNITY TO ASK SOME 3703 02:21:18,080 --> 02:21:21,150 QUESTIONS ABOUT SOME OF THEIR 3704 02:21:21,150 --> 02:21:23,252 EXPERIENCES AND OBSERVATIONS. 3705 02:21:23,252 --> 02:21:25,755 JOE, YOU'VE BEEN LOOKING A LOT 3706 02:21:25,755 --> 02:21:28,290 AT TECHNOLOGIES THAT WE'VE SEEN, 3707 02:21:28,290 --> 02:21:29,024 WEARABLES, PATCHES. 3708 02:21:29,024 --> 02:21:30,359 I'D LOVE TO GET YOUR TAKE IN 3709 02:21:30,359 --> 02:21:32,695 TERMS OF WHAT ARE WE SEEING OUT 3710 02:21:32,695 --> 02:21:35,164 THERE THAT'S NEW, THAT IS 3711 02:21:35,164 --> 02:21:37,700 PROMISING, WHAT ARE THINGS WE 3712 02:21:37,700 --> 02:21:38,467 ANTICIPATE? 3713 02:21:38,467 --> 02:21:42,972 WILL WE EVER HAVE NON-INVASIVE 3714 02:21:42,972 --> 02:21:43,539 GLUCOSE MEASUREMENTS WITH 3715 02:21:43,539 --> 02:21:45,174 WEARABLE, I'D LOVE TO GET YOUR 3716 02:21:45,174 --> 02:21:46,242 TAKE, WHAT'S POSSIBLE AND WHAT 3717 02:21:46,242 --> 02:21:50,746 COULD BE POSSIBLE? 3718 02:21:50,746 --> 02:21:52,281 >> WELL, THANK YOU TO THE FOLKS 3719 02:21:52,281 --> 02:21:54,250 FROM THE NIH FOR INVITING ME, 3720 02:21:54,250 --> 02:21:55,351 I'M DELIGHTED TO MEET YOU. 3721 02:21:55,351 --> 02:21:57,953 I DON'T KNOW THAT YOU HAVE AS 3722 02:21:57,953 --> 02:22:00,389 MUCH WISDOM TO IMPART HERE AS 3723 02:22:00,389 --> 02:22:01,991 YOU HAD HOPED. 3724 02:22:01,991 --> 02:22:04,193 I FIELD, IN MY OPINION, IS 3725 02:22:04,193 --> 02:22:04,427 STALLED. 3726 02:22:04,427 --> 02:22:08,831 WE DID NOW A GOOD 15 YEARS OF 3727 02:22:08,831 --> 02:22:12,635 MONITORING STEPS AND NOW WE'RE I 3728 02:22:12,635 --> 02:22:14,270 THINK STRUGGLING WITH SLEEP. 3729 02:22:14,270 --> 02:22:16,572 ONE THING THAT'S A BREAKTHROUGH, 3730 02:22:16,572 --> 02:22:18,541 IN MY OPINION, I'LL GIVE JUST A 3731 02:22:18,541 --> 02:22:22,044 QUICK ANECDOTE OF MY OWN HEALTH, 3732 02:22:22,044 --> 02:22:24,480 I HAD HEART VALVE REPAIR DONE IN 3733 02:22:24,480 --> 02:22:24,780 JUNE. 3734 02:22:24,780 --> 02:22:27,616 DURING THE POST-OP PERIOD I HAD 3735 02:22:27,616 --> 02:22:29,385 ATRIAL FIBRILLATION, NOW I'M ON 3736 02:22:29,385 --> 02:22:30,386 AN ANTICOAGULANT NOW. 3737 02:22:30,386 --> 02:22:32,221 MY DOCTOR SAID TO ME, WELL, IF 3738 02:22:32,221 --> 02:22:34,523 YOU GET YOURSELF A WATCH THAT 3739 02:22:34,523 --> 02:22:36,392 WILL TRIGGER WHEN YOU HAVE 3740 02:22:36,392 --> 02:22:37,359 ATRIAL FIBRILLATION WE MIGHT 3741 02:22:37,359 --> 02:22:40,563 TAKE YOU OFF THE ANTI-COAGULANT. 3742 02:22:40,563 --> 02:22:42,631 THAT'S MAINSTREAM FOR A 3743 02:22:42,631 --> 02:22:43,999 WEARABLE, CONSUMER DEVICE, TO BE 3744 02:22:43,999 --> 02:22:46,368 RECOMMENDED TO ME BY A 3745 02:22:46,368 --> 02:22:46,702 CARDIOLOGIST. 3746 02:22:46,702 --> 02:22:48,671 I THINK WE HAVE MADE SOME 3747 02:22:48,671 --> 02:22:51,841 STRIDES, THERE'S STILL THAT GAP 3748 02:22:51,841 --> 02:22:55,611 BETWEEN MEDICAL DEVICES, HARD 3749 02:22:55,611 --> 02:22:56,278 CORE AND CONSUMER WEARABLES, IT 3750 02:22:56,278 --> 02:22:59,982 WAS MENTIONED IN ONE OF THE 3751 02:22:59,982 --> 02:23:01,951 BREAKOUT GROUPS VAST SEA OF DATA 3752 02:23:01,951 --> 02:23:03,352 BUT NONE CONNECTS, I THINK 3753 02:23:03,352 --> 02:23:04,119 THAT'S A CHALLENGE. 3754 02:23:04,119 --> 02:23:05,554 BUT ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE DO 3755 02:23:05,554 --> 02:23:11,894 SEE A LOT OF NOW IN TERMS OF 3756 02:23:11,894 --> 02:23:14,396 SUBMISSIONS TO THE JOURNAL IS 3757 02:23:14,396 --> 02:23:15,130 MULTI-MODAL ARTIFICIAL 3758 02:23:15,130 --> 02:23:16,065 INTELLIGENCE, GETTING DIFFERENT 3759 02:23:16,065 --> 02:23:19,668 DATA STREAMS, COLLECTING THEM 3760 02:23:19,668 --> 02:23:21,437 AND GETTING MORE POWER IN THE 3761 02:23:21,437 --> 02:23:23,172 FINE TUNING OF THE MACHINE 3762 02:23:23,172 --> 02:23:24,573 LEARNING BECAUSE OF THE RICHNESS 3763 02:23:24,573 --> 02:23:25,374 OF THE DATA. 3764 02:23:25,374 --> 02:23:28,644 SO, I GUESS IT'S A BIT OF A TALE 3765 02:23:28,644 --> 02:23:29,879 OF TWO CITIES TYPE ANSWER. 3766 02:23:29,879 --> 02:23:31,280 I SEE A LOT OF PROMISE BUT A 3767 02:23:31,280 --> 02:23:33,349 LITTLE BIT OF STALLING IN THE 3768 02:23:33,349 --> 02:23:34,116 ACTUAL TECHNOLOGY. 3769 02:23:34,116 --> 02:23:37,419 >> YEAH, SO ON THE POINT OF THE 3770 02:23:37,419 --> 02:23:39,488 ATRIAL FIBRILLATION NOW WE HAVE 3771 02:23:39,488 --> 02:23:42,024 TECHNOLOGIES THAT CAN DETECT IT, 3772 02:23:42,024 --> 02:23:44,660 IN THE PAST MAYBE WE DIDN'T HAVE 3773 02:23:44,660 --> 02:23:47,129 THAT CAPABILITY. 3774 02:23:47,129 --> 02:23:48,697 ARE WE FINDING THIS IS -- THE 3775 02:23:48,697 --> 02:23:50,232 CONCERN AT THE TIME WAS THIS WAS 3776 02:23:50,232 --> 02:23:51,467 GOING TO FLOOD DOCTOR OFFICES 3777 02:23:51,467 --> 02:23:53,202 WITH INDIVIDUALS SAYING THIS IS 3778 02:23:53,202 --> 02:23:55,604 JUST, YOU KNOW, I'VE GOT A-FIB 3779 02:23:55,604 --> 02:23:57,139 OR I'VE GOT SOMETHING I'M 3780 02:23:57,139 --> 02:23:58,440 WORRIED ABOUT. 3781 02:23:58,440 --> 02:23:59,542 HAVE WE SEEN THAT? 3782 02:23:59,542 --> 02:24:01,610 OR WAS THAT CONCERN THAT WAS 3783 02:24:01,610 --> 02:24:03,045 JUST MAYBE A LITTLE OVERHYPED? 3784 02:24:03,045 --> 02:24:04,780 >> I THINK A LITTLE OVERHYPED. 3785 02:24:04,780 --> 02:24:05,781 THAT'S MY OPINION. 3786 02:24:05,781 --> 02:24:07,416 I DON'T HAVE DATA BUT I WILL 3787 02:24:07,416 --> 02:24:08,517 TELL YOU PEOPLE HAVE LIVES. 3788 02:24:08,517 --> 02:24:09,985 THEY ARE NOT SITTING AROUND JUST 3789 02:24:09,985 --> 02:24:11,253 WAITING FOR THEIR WATCH TO GO 3790 02:24:11,253 --> 02:24:11,687 OFF. 3791 02:24:11,687 --> 02:24:13,222 THEY GOT OTHER THINGS TO DO. 3792 02:24:13,222 --> 02:24:15,925 AGAIN, I JUST THOUGHT IT WAS 3793 02:24:15,925 --> 02:24:17,593 INTERESTING THAT MY OWN 3794 02:24:17,593 --> 02:24:19,562 PHYSICIAN WHO ISN'T PARTICULARLY 3795 02:24:19,562 --> 02:24:22,831 TECHY, SHE'S JUST A REGULAR GOOD 3796 02:24:22,831 --> 02:24:24,700 OLD CARDIOLOGIST, SAID THIS WAS 3797 02:24:24,700 --> 02:24:26,435 A TURNING POINT FOR HER. 3798 02:24:26,435 --> 02:24:32,374 I THOUGHT THAT WAS MEANINGFUL. 3799 02:24:32,374 --> 02:24:37,947 >> ANYTHING ON YOUR END, 3800 02:24:37,947 --> 02:24:39,248 SACHIN,LOK? 3801 02:24:39,248 --> 02:24:40,249 WE'LL START WITH SACHIN. 3802 02:24:40,249 --> 02:24:42,451 >> SURE, THANK YOU. 3803 02:24:42,451 --> 02:24:46,989 WE HAD SIMILAR EXPERIENCES AS 3804 02:24:46,989 --> 02:24:49,224 WHAT JOE IS MENTIONING, CONCERNS 3805 02:24:49,224 --> 02:24:51,527 ABOUT FOLKS BEING FLOODED WITH 3806 02:24:51,527 --> 02:24:53,596 FALSE ALARMS IS OVERSTATED. 3807 02:24:53,596 --> 02:24:55,464 IT'S ONE OF OUR RESEARCH 3808 02:24:55,464 --> 02:24:57,433 PROJECTS, 7,000 APPLE WATCHES 3809 02:24:57,433 --> 02:25:01,136 AND BLOOD PRESSURE CUFFS WENT TO 3810 02:25:01,136 --> 02:25:02,471 UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN PATIENTS, 3811 02:25:02,471 --> 02:25:04,440 WITH ENTIRE PROTOCOL SET UP, IF 3812 02:25:04,440 --> 02:25:06,508 I HAD ABNORMAL HEART RHYTHM 3813 02:25:06,508 --> 02:25:09,244 ALARM ON THE WATCH OR CUFF, WE 3814 02:25:09,244 --> 02:25:10,579 HAVE THIS PATHWAY. 3815 02:25:10,579 --> 02:25:13,749 WE FOUND, NUMBER ONE, PATIENTS 3816 02:25:13,749 --> 02:25:15,284 REALLY, NUMBER ONE, ENJOYED 3817 02:25:15,284 --> 02:25:15,851 UNDERSTANDING THEIR HEALTH 3818 02:25:15,851 --> 02:25:18,754 BETTER EVEN IF IT WAS A FALSE 3819 02:25:18,754 --> 02:25:19,421 ALARM. 3820 02:25:19,421 --> 02:25:21,190 I THINK THE VALUE OF A DEVICE 3821 02:25:21,190 --> 02:25:24,893 THAT DOES SOME RETURN OF 3822 02:25:24,893 --> 02:25:27,062 INFORMATION, ENGAGES THE 3823 02:25:27,062 --> 02:25:27,863 PATIENT'S HEALTH, POTENTIALLY 3824 02:25:27,863 --> 02:25:29,832 MUCH MORE IMPORTANT THAN THE 3825 02:25:29,832 --> 02:25:30,699 RISK OF OCCASIONALLY THOSE 3826 02:25:30,699 --> 02:25:31,934 PATIENTS GETTING A BIT ALARMED 3827 02:25:31,934 --> 02:25:34,003 BY IT AND GO SEE THEIR DOCTOR. 3828 02:25:34,003 --> 02:25:37,373 TURNS OUT THAT ACTUALLY IS 3829 02:25:37,373 --> 02:25:40,442 PROBABLY A GOOD INTERACTION 3830 02:25:40,442 --> 02:25:43,612 ANYWAY. 3831 02:25:43,612 --> 02:25:47,349 VERY FEW FALSE ALARMS -- WE 3832 02:25:47,349 --> 02:25:50,853 PUBLISHED THAT RATE, BUT I THINK 3833 02:25:50,853 --> 02:25:53,155 I WOULD SECOND THE EXPERIENCE 3834 02:25:53,155 --> 02:25:55,691 WHICH IS THE POSSIBLE BENEFIT OF 3835 02:25:55,691 --> 02:25:56,759 JUST BEING CONNECTED WITH YOUR 3836 02:25:56,759 --> 02:25:57,593 HEALTH IN AN OBJECTIVE WAY, 3837 02:25:57,593 --> 02:26:01,497 WHETHER OR NOT IT'S A CLINICALLY 3838 02:26:01,497 --> 02:26:04,233 MEANINGFUL OBJECTIVE OUTCOME, 3839 02:26:04,233 --> 02:26:08,270 FAR OUTWEIGHS POTENTIAL RISKS OF 3840 02:26:08,270 --> 02:26:10,039 FALSE ALARMS. 3841 02:26:10,039 --> 02:26:10,639 >> YEAH, LOK, YOUR THOUGHTS? 3842 02:26:10,639 --> 02:26:11,774 >> CAN YOU HEAR ME? 3843 02:26:11,774 --> 02:26:12,841 >> YES, WE CAN. 3844 02:26:12,841 --> 02:26:15,444 >> JUST THINKING IN TERMS OF THE 3845 02:26:15,444 --> 02:26:17,246 MEDICARE SPACE, SEEING A LOT OF 3846 02:26:17,246 --> 02:26:18,547 UPTAKE OF REMOTE PATIENT 3847 02:26:18,547 --> 02:26:19,548 MONITORING ESPECIALLY DURING THE 3848 02:26:19,548 --> 02:26:19,815 PANDEMIC. 3849 02:26:19,815 --> 02:26:23,352 I THINK THAT REALLY IS GOING TO 3850 02:26:23,352 --> 02:26:24,453 ACCELERATE PEOPLE'S INTEREST IN 3851 02:26:24,453 --> 02:26:26,889 PARTNERING WITH THEIR HEALTHCARE 3852 02:26:26,889 --> 02:26:31,794 PROVIDER, IN UNDERSTANDING THEIR 3853 02:26:31,794 --> 02:26:33,095 CLINICAL VITAL SIGNS. 3854 02:26:33,095 --> 02:26:34,096 SO I HAVEN'T DONE MUCH RESEARCH 3855 02:26:34,096 --> 02:26:36,699 IN THIS AREA BUT IT SOUNDS LIKE 3856 02:26:36,699 --> 02:26:41,336 THERE'S AT LEAST HEALTHCARE 3857 02:26:41,336 --> 02:26:41,670 INTEREST. 3858 02:26:41,670 --> 02:26:43,305 >> ONE THING I'M SEEING, 3859 02:26:43,305 --> 02:26:44,139 EXTRAORDINARY, WE'RE MAKING 3860 02:26:44,139 --> 02:26:45,607 SIGNIFICANT STRIDES IN TERMS OF 3861 02:26:45,607 --> 02:26:48,677 OUR ABILITY TO CAPTURE NEWER 3862 02:26:48,677 --> 02:26:51,513 TYPES OF INFORMATION AND WITH 3863 02:26:51,513 --> 02:26:56,218 THIS DIFFERENT SENSORS OUT THERE 3864 02:26:56,218 --> 02:26:56,952 BECOMING MORE NON-INVASIVE, WE 3865 02:26:56,952 --> 02:26:58,654 CAN IDENTIFY THINGS IN THE PAST 3866 02:26:58,654 --> 02:27:00,422 WE COULDN'T ENVISION SUCH AS 3867 02:27:00,422 --> 02:27:02,224 RIGHT NOW STARTING WITH GLUCOSE, 3868 02:27:02,224 --> 02:27:04,159 OF COURSE STARTING TO SEE THAT. 3869 02:27:04,159 --> 02:27:06,595 BUT ALSO THINGS SUCH AS SERUM 3870 02:27:06,595 --> 02:27:08,430 LACTATE, AND PERHAPS EVEN OTHER 3871 02:27:08,430 --> 02:27:09,765 TYPES OF BIOCHEMICALS WHICH 3872 02:27:09,765 --> 02:27:10,833 COULD REALLY CHANGE THEIR 3873 02:27:10,833 --> 02:27:12,034 PERCEPTION IN TERMS OF WHETHER 3874 02:27:12,034 --> 02:27:14,236 OR NOT WE CAN MONITOR PATIENTS 3875 02:27:14,236 --> 02:27:15,771 AT HOME, AND AS WE START 3876 02:27:15,771 --> 02:27:18,173 THINKING MORE ABOUT THIS CONCEPT 3877 02:27:18,173 --> 02:27:19,575 OF MONITORING PATIENTS AT HOME 3878 02:27:19,575 --> 02:27:22,878 WE'VE GOT PROGRAMS LIKE HOSPITAL 3879 02:27:22,878 --> 02:27:26,815 AT HOME, I'M CURIOUS, FROM YOUR 3880 02:27:26,815 --> 02:27:27,716 PERSPECTIVES, MAYBE YOU, SACHIN, 3881 02:27:27,716 --> 02:27:30,219 HAVE YOU SEEN THESE TYPE OF 3882 02:27:30,219 --> 02:27:31,086 PROGRAMS TAKING OFF MORE? 3883 02:27:31,086 --> 02:27:32,921 WHAT DO YOU SEE AS THE 3884 02:27:32,921 --> 02:27:34,623 CHALLENGES, WHAT ARE THE 3885 02:27:34,623 --> 02:27:36,325 ADVANTAGES, THE BENEFITS? 3886 02:27:36,325 --> 02:27:38,994 >> YOU KNOW, AS AN 3887 02:27:38,994 --> 02:27:41,296 ANESTHESIOLOGIST, I LOVE HAVING 3888 02:27:41,296 --> 02:27:42,231 ABOUT 40 PARAMETERS CONSTANTLY 3889 02:27:42,231 --> 02:27:43,599 ABOUT MY PATIENTS. 3890 02:27:43,599 --> 02:27:46,435 I DO LIVER TRANSPLANT 3891 02:27:46,435 --> 02:27:48,103 ANESTHESIA, IF I DON'T HAVE AN 3892 02:27:48,103 --> 02:27:49,171 ECHO PROGRAM I THINK I'M HANDS 3893 02:27:49,171 --> 02:27:51,373 OFF WHEN IT COMES TO MONITORING. 3894 02:27:51,373 --> 02:27:54,343 YOU'RE SEEING SOMEONE WHO IS 3895 02:27:54,343 --> 02:27:56,512 VERY, VERY DATA RICH FOCUSED. 3896 02:27:56,512 --> 02:27:57,279 THE HOSPITAL'S PROGRAMS WHAT 3897 02:27:57,279 --> 02:28:00,916 THEY HAVE DONE FOR IDENTIFY 3898 02:28:00,916 --> 02:28:03,418 IS -- THE UPTAKE IS DRIVEN BY 3899 02:28:03,418 --> 02:28:04,853 CAPACITY CONSTRAINTS ONLY. 3900 02:28:04,853 --> 02:28:12,961 IF YOU'RE IN AN ENVIRONMENT 3901 02:28:12,961 --> 02:28:14,129 WHERE FINANCIAL DRIVERS 3902 02:28:14,129 --> 02:28:16,999 ENCOURAGE US BECOMING FLEXIBLE 3903 02:28:16,999 --> 02:28:18,233 AS CLINICIANS AND OUR TENDENCY 3904 02:28:18,233 --> 02:28:19,501 TO OVERORDER TESTS EVEN IF 3905 02:28:19,501 --> 02:28:20,769 SOMEONE IS IN THE HOSPITAL 3906 02:28:20,769 --> 02:28:21,937 TRANSLATE TO LETTING THEM GO 3907 02:28:21,937 --> 02:28:25,808 HOME AND HAVE THE SAME THINGS. 3908 02:28:25,808 --> 02:28:27,876 CAPACITY CONSTRAINTS CAUSE 3909 02:28:27,876 --> 02:28:29,278 INNOVATION, WHAT WE'RE FINDING. 3910 02:28:29,278 --> 02:28:32,247 THE PANDEMIC WAS ONE EXAMPLE OF 3911 02:28:32,247 --> 02:28:32,581 IT. 3912 02:28:32,581 --> 02:28:34,116 IN THE POST-PANDEMIC WORLD WE 3913 02:28:34,116 --> 02:28:35,551 STILL SEE VALUES IN THE 3914 02:28:35,551 --> 02:28:37,519 OUTPATIENT SETTING BUT WE 3915 02:28:37,519 --> 02:28:38,153 OBVIOUSLY HAVE A 3916 02:28:38,153 --> 02:28:39,121 HOSPITAL-AT-HOME PROGRAM LIKE 3917 02:28:39,121 --> 02:28:45,727 EVERYBODY ELSE, AND IT'S RAMPING 3918 02:28:45,727 --> 02:28:47,396 UP, BECAUSE WE'VE GOT CAPACITY 3919 02:28:47,396 --> 02:28:48,730 CONSTRAINTS AT UNIVERSITY OF 3920 02:28:48,730 --> 02:28:50,866 MICHIGAN SO INVESTMENTS ON A 3921 02:28:50,866 --> 02:28:54,236 YIELDING VALUE, WHERE WE DON'T 3922 02:28:54,236 --> 02:29:01,810 SEE CONSTRAINTS DISCOMFORT 3923 02:29:01,810 --> 02:29:02,678 DOESN'T LEAVE ROOM. 3924 02:29:02,678 --> 02:29:04,112 FOR THE RURAL PATIENTS WE SEE A 3925 02:29:04,112 --> 02:29:06,181 FAIR AMOUNT OF VALUE THERE, THE 3926 02:29:06,181 --> 02:29:07,149 TREES BEHIND YOU REFLECT WHAT 3927 02:29:07,149 --> 02:29:09,451 MOST OF MICHIGAN IS LIKE, A LOT 3928 02:29:09,451 --> 02:29:10,752 OF PATIENTS ARE DRIVING FROM 3929 02:29:10,752 --> 02:29:12,187 THREE OR FOUR HOURS, AND THEY DO 3930 02:29:12,187 --> 02:29:13,956 FIND SOME VALUE IN MAYBE GETTING 3931 02:29:13,956 --> 02:29:15,891 DISCHARGED A DAY OR TWO, THE 3932 02:29:15,891 --> 02:29:17,860 ONLY PLACE WE'RE SEEING CAPACITY 3933 02:29:17,860 --> 02:29:19,962 CONSTRAINTS NOT DRIVING THAT 3934 02:29:19,962 --> 02:29:21,396 INNOVATION ADOPTION BECAUSE OF 3935 02:29:21,396 --> 02:29:23,465 OUR TENDENCY TO JUST NOT WANT TO 3936 02:29:23,465 --> 02:29:26,602 BE WITHOUT THE DATA THAT WE'RE 3937 02:29:26,602 --> 02:29:27,402 USED TO. 3938 02:29:27,402 --> 02:29:29,137 >> IN TERMS OF A NATIONAL 3939 02:29:29,137 --> 02:29:31,940 PICTURE, ARE YOU SEEING ANY 3940 02:29:31,940 --> 02:29:33,742 PATTERNS EMERGE RELATIVE TO 3941 02:29:33,742 --> 02:29:35,611 ADOPTION OF DIFFERENT PROGRAMS 3942 02:29:35,611 --> 02:29:38,013 WHETHER HOSPITAL AT HOME, REMOTE 3943 02:29:38,013 --> 02:29:39,548 MONITORING, TELEHEALTH, THINGS 3944 02:29:39,548 --> 02:29:41,516 LIKE THAT? 3945 02:29:41,516 --> 02:29:42,618 >> WE'VE MONITORED NATIONAL 3946 02:29:42,618 --> 02:29:45,354 TRENDS FOR MEDICARE TELEHEALTH. 3947 02:29:45,354 --> 02:29:47,489 IT'S DROPPED FROM THE PANDEMIC 3948 02:29:47,489 --> 02:29:49,858 HEIGHT, IT'S STILL A MUCH LARGER 3949 02:29:49,858 --> 02:29:51,260 USE OF TELEHEALTH THAN 3950 02:29:51,260 --> 02:29:51,827 PRE-PANDEMIC. 3951 02:29:51,827 --> 02:29:55,030 I THINK IT REALLY IS SHOWING 3952 02:29:55,030 --> 02:29:59,501 THERE'S INTEREST IN HAVING THIS 3953 02:29:59,501 --> 02:30:00,035 MODALITY. 3954 02:30:00,035 --> 02:30:01,036 HOSPITAL AT HOME PROGRAM HAS 3955 02:30:01,036 --> 02:30:02,571 BEEN WELL RECEIVED BY PATIENTS. 3956 02:30:02,571 --> 02:30:04,239 I THINK THERE'S INTEREST ON THE 3957 02:30:04,239 --> 02:30:06,174 HILL TO CONTINUE THE PROGRAM. 3958 02:30:06,174 --> 02:30:08,310 THE ISSUE ALWAYS WITH THE 3959 02:30:08,310 --> 02:30:08,877 MEDICARE-FUNDED PROGRAMS IS 3960 02:30:08,877 --> 02:30:11,413 WHETHER OR NOT IT'S GOING TO 3961 02:30:11,413 --> 02:30:12,047 INCREASE SPENDING. 3962 02:30:12,047 --> 02:30:14,182 SO I THINK THAT'S WHAT EVERYONE 3963 02:30:14,182 --> 02:30:17,352 IS TRYING TO UNDERSTAND IS THIS 3964 02:30:17,352 --> 02:30:19,321 IN THE NET SCHEME OF THINGS 3965 02:30:19,321 --> 02:30:21,290 GOING TO INDUCE MORE UTILIZATION 3966 02:30:21,290 --> 02:30:23,592 OR WILL IT LEAD TO DIFFERENT 3967 02:30:23,592 --> 02:30:25,694 WAYS IN WHICH PATIENTS ACCESS 3968 02:30:25,694 --> 02:30:26,895 THE HEALTHCARE SYSTEM. 3969 02:30:26,895 --> 02:30:28,196 >> YEAH, IT'S A GOOD POINT. 3970 02:30:28,196 --> 02:30:30,933 IN FACT, I THINK THERE ARE MANY 3971 02:30:30,933 --> 02:30:32,801 STUDIES THAT SHOW UTILIZATION 3972 02:30:32,801 --> 02:30:33,568 INCREASES, BUT THEN AGAIN THE 3973 02:30:33,568 --> 02:30:35,003 SAME POINT COULD BE MADE THAT A 3974 02:30:35,003 --> 02:30:36,972 LOT OF PEOPLE WANT TO SEE THEIR 3975 02:30:36,972 --> 02:30:37,639 DOCTORS NOT NECESSARILY FOR 3976 02:30:37,639 --> 02:30:40,142 HEALTH CARE BUT TO HAVE A 3977 02:30:40,142 --> 02:30:41,443 CONVERSATION, AND TO FEEL 3978 02:30:41,443 --> 02:30:42,744 CONNECTED WITH THEM. 3979 02:30:42,744 --> 02:30:45,347 SO I THINK THE QUESTION IS, IS 3980 02:30:45,347 --> 02:30:48,250 THIS SOMETHING THAT DO YOU FEEL 3981 02:30:48,250 --> 02:30:49,651 RIGHT NOW ECONOMICS ARE IN FAVOR 3982 02:30:49,651 --> 02:30:51,954 OF THESE TYPE OF PROGRAMS? 3983 02:30:51,954 --> 02:30:53,622 IS THE ROI THERE? 3984 02:30:53,622 --> 02:30:56,558 DO WE SEE A POSITIVE PATH 3985 02:30:56,558 --> 02:30:59,127 TOWARDS GREATER REIMBURSEMENTS 3986 02:30:59,127 --> 02:31:00,495 AROUND THESE CATEGORIES? 3987 02:31:00,495 --> 02:31:01,596 >> IT'S REALLY INTERESTING. 3988 02:31:01,596 --> 02:31:04,900 EVERY YEAR WE SEE DIFFERENT 3989 02:31:04,900 --> 02:31:06,401 STUDIES, SHOWING SLIGHTLY 3990 02:31:06,401 --> 02:31:07,469 DIFFERENT RESULTS. 3991 02:31:07,469 --> 02:31:09,938 MED PAC FOUND TELEHEALTH MIGHT 3992 02:31:09,938 --> 02:31:12,207 INCREASE SPENDING, BUT IN THEIR 3993 02:31:12,207 --> 02:31:13,408 MOST RECENT REVISED REPORT THEY 3994 02:31:13,408 --> 02:31:14,943 HAVE FOUND IT ACTUALLY REDUCES 3995 02:31:14,943 --> 02:31:16,044 SPENDING SOMEWHAT. 3996 02:31:16,044 --> 02:31:17,813 THERE'S BEEN OTHER STUDIES THAT 3997 02:31:17,813 --> 02:31:19,881 HAVE SHOWN SPENDING INCREASES 3998 02:31:19,881 --> 02:31:22,484 MIGHT BE BECAUSE PATIENTS ARE 3999 02:31:22,484 --> 02:31:23,285 ADHERING TO TREATMENT BETTER, 4000 02:31:23,285 --> 02:31:25,787 GETTING THE CARE THEY REALLY 4001 02:31:25,787 --> 02:31:27,322 NEEDED, AVOIDING SOME OF THE 4002 02:31:27,322 --> 02:31:27,990 E.D. VISITS. 4003 02:31:27,990 --> 02:31:31,026 I THINK IT'S ALL A MATTER OF 4004 02:31:31,026 --> 02:31:32,794 PERSPECTIVE, HOW YOU LOOK AT THE 4005 02:31:32,794 --> 02:31:33,762 PROBLEM, PERHAPS REFLECTING ALSO 4006 02:31:33,762 --> 02:31:36,198 A SHIFT IN HOW HEALTHCARE MIGHT 4007 02:31:36,198 --> 02:31:37,599 BE DELIVERED MOVING FROM IN 4008 02:31:37,599 --> 02:31:39,501 PERSON TO HYBRID MODEL OF CARE 4009 02:31:39,501 --> 02:31:41,703 WHICH MIGHT MAKE MORE SENSE 4010 02:31:41,703 --> 02:31:44,306 UNDER A VALUE-BASED CARE PAYMENT 4011 02:31:44,306 --> 02:31:44,606 ARRANGEMENT. 4012 02:31:44,606 --> 02:31:45,941 >> , YEAH ABSOLUTELY. 4013 02:31:45,941 --> 02:31:49,111 LOOKING AT THE OUTCOMES THAT 4014 02:31:49,111 --> 02:31:50,212 MATTER, READMISSIONS, MORTALITY, 4015 02:31:50,212 --> 02:31:52,147 AND REALLY FOCUSING ON THOSE AS 4016 02:31:52,147 --> 02:31:53,615 OPPOSED TO SIMPLY WHETHER OR NOT 4017 02:31:53,615 --> 02:31:55,751 YOU'RE HAVING MORE TELEHEALTH 4018 02:31:55,751 --> 02:31:57,786 VISITS MAKES A LOT OF SENSE. 4019 02:31:57,786 --> 02:31:59,654 JOE, YOU PROBABLY GET A LOT OF 4020 02:31:59,654 --> 02:32:00,856 PEOPLE SUBMITTING STUDIES IN 4021 02:32:00,856 --> 02:32:01,723 THIS AREA. 4022 02:32:01,723 --> 02:32:03,158 WHAT ARE YOU SEEING RELATIVE TO 4023 02:32:03,158 --> 02:32:04,359 THE TYPE OF RESEARCH THAT'S 4024 02:32:04,359 --> 02:32:06,328 BEING DONE IN THIS SPACE? 4025 02:32:06,328 --> 02:32:09,698 >> I WAS GOING TO COMMENT ON 4026 02:32:09,698 --> 02:32:13,201 JUST SORT OF UNDERSCORE WHAT 4027 02:32:13,201 --> 02:32:16,071 SACHIN SAID, I REMEMBER BEING AT 4028 02:32:16,071 --> 02:32:18,740 SOME SORT OF PANEL, INNOVATORS 4029 02:32:18,740 --> 02:32:19,741 SOMETHING OR OTHER, PROBABLY TEN 4030 02:32:19,741 --> 02:32:21,410 YEARS AGO WITH A FEW OF THE 4031 02:32:21,410 --> 02:32:24,179 EARLY, EARLY PIONEERS IN THE 4032 02:32:24,179 --> 02:32:24,880 HOSPITAL-AT-HOME ARENA. 4033 02:32:24,880 --> 02:32:27,516 THEY TRIED TO SELL IT ON 4034 02:32:27,516 --> 02:32:28,617 CAPACITY CHALLENGE, TRIED TO 4035 02:32:28,617 --> 02:32:32,220 SELL IT ON YOU WOULD USE FEWER 4036 02:32:32,220 --> 02:32:32,487 RESOURCES. 4037 02:32:32,487 --> 02:32:37,592 AND ALL IT REALLY TOOK OFF WE 4038 02:32:37,592 --> 02:32:38,393 STARTED REIMBURSING, A HUGE 4039 02:32:38,393 --> 02:32:39,928 DANGER OF GOING AWAY IF WE DON'T 4040 02:32:39,928 --> 02:32:40,896 CONTINUE TO REIMBURSE. 4041 02:32:40,896 --> 02:32:44,866 I JUST WOULD MAKE THAT COMMENT 4042 02:32:44,866 --> 02:32:46,968 BECAUSE THERE'S -- IF WE COULD 4043 02:32:46,968 --> 02:32:48,470 GET TO A VALUE-BASED MODEL 4044 02:32:48,470 --> 02:32:51,006 THAT'S A DIFFERENT CONVERSATION 4045 02:32:51,006 --> 02:32:51,973 BUT UNTIL WE DO, PEOPLE JUST 4046 02:32:51,973 --> 02:32:53,308 WANT TO BE PAID FOR WHAT THEY 4047 02:32:53,308 --> 02:32:53,575 DO. 4048 02:32:53,575 --> 02:32:55,477 I DON'T KNOW IF IT'S GOING TO 4049 02:32:55,477 --> 02:32:56,711 SAVE MONEY. 4050 02:32:56,711 --> 02:33:07,255 THE OTHER QUICK COMMENT ON THIS 4051 02:33:08,056 --> 02:33:09,624 AREA, A GOOD CASE THAT EVERY 4052 02:33:09,624 --> 02:33:11,726 OTHER INNOVATION THAT COMES INTO 4053 02:33:11,726 --> 02:33:13,361 HEALTH CARE WE DON'T ASK IF IT 4054 02:33:13,361 --> 02:33:17,299 PAYS MONEY, WE ASK IF IT'S WORTH 4055 02:33:17,299 --> 02:33:21,336 THE COST. 4056 02:33:21,336 --> 02:33:23,338 WE MIGHT BE PUSHING TELEHEALTH 4057 02:33:23,338 --> 02:33:25,841 TO TOO MUCH TO ASK IF IT SAVES 4058 02:33:25,841 --> 02:33:26,641 MONEY. 4059 02:33:26,641 --> 02:33:28,577 >> CAN WE SAY IT REDUCE COST, 4060 02:33:28,577 --> 02:33:31,413 WHAT DOES THE LITERATURE SAY? 4061 02:33:31,413 --> 02:33:34,049 >> AGAIN, THERE HAVE BEEN, AS 4062 02:33:34,049 --> 02:33:35,250 LOK SAID, THERE'S CONFLICTING 4063 02:33:35,250 --> 02:33:35,484 STUDIES. 4064 02:33:35,484 --> 02:33:38,220 I THINK IT DEPENDS WHAT YOU ASK. 4065 02:33:38,220 --> 02:33:40,889 THE ONE I USED TO CITE WAS ONE 4066 02:33:40,889 --> 02:33:42,257 THAT SHOWED DURING THE PANDEMIC, 4067 02:33:42,257 --> 02:33:44,793 AND THIS IS A LITTLE -- EVEN 4068 02:33:44,793 --> 02:33:47,429 THIS IS MAYBE A BACK-HANDED 4069 02:33:47,429 --> 02:33:54,669 CONCLUSION, BUT DURING THE 4070 02:33:54,669 --> 02:33:56,972 PANDEMIC PRIMARY CARE -- ACCESS 4071 02:33:56,972 --> 02:33:58,840 TO PRIMARY CARE DIDN'T INCREASE 4072 02:33:58,840 --> 02:33:59,708 BECAUSE PEOPLE WERE DOING MORE 4073 02:33:59,708 --> 02:34:00,142 TELEHEALTH. 4074 02:34:00,142 --> 02:34:01,910 IN OTHER WORDS, IT DIDN'T ADD TO 4075 02:34:01,910 --> 02:34:02,544 COST. 4076 02:34:02,544 --> 02:34:03,345 I DON'T KNOW. 4077 02:34:03,345 --> 02:34:07,249 I THINK, AGAIN, IT'S A VERY HARD 4078 02:34:07,249 --> 02:34:08,683 PROBLEM TO STUDY. 4079 02:34:08,683 --> 02:34:10,452 THERE'S NO RANDOMIZED TRIAL I'M 4080 02:34:10,452 --> 02:34:11,219 AWARE OF. 4081 02:34:11,219 --> 02:34:17,125 IT'S ALWAYS DONE ON AN 4082 02:34:17,125 --> 02:34:17,592 EPIDEMIOLOGIC BASIS. 4083 02:34:17,592 --> 02:34:19,761 >> DO YOU THINK THERE'S 4084 02:34:19,761 --> 02:34:21,396 SUBPOPULATIONS WE CAN SAY THIS 4085 02:34:21,396 --> 02:34:23,365 HAS BEEN BENEFICIAL, COST 4086 02:34:23,365 --> 02:34:24,799 EFFECTIVE, SAVING MONEY, 4087 02:34:24,799 --> 02:34:25,867 IMPROVING OUTCOMES, AND MAYBE 4088 02:34:25,867 --> 02:34:28,737 OVERALL IF WE LOOK AT IT, IT 4089 02:34:28,737 --> 02:34:33,675 MIGHT GET A MIXED BAG? 4090 02:34:33,675 --> 02:34:35,844 >> WELL, SO, MY ANSWER ISN'T 4091 02:34:35,844 --> 02:34:38,380 PARTICULARLY DATA DRIVEN, IT'S 4092 02:34:38,380 --> 02:34:40,348 MORE EXPERIENCE DRIVEN. 4093 02:34:40,348 --> 02:34:41,883 BUT THINGS THAT ARE RELATIVELY 4094 02:34:41,883 --> 02:34:42,984 TRANSACTIONAL, TELEHEALTH IS 4095 02:34:42,984 --> 02:34:46,254 GREAT FOR I NEED MY REFILL ON MY 4096 02:34:46,254 --> 02:34:51,526 MEDICINE, I SEE PATIENTS -- I'M 4097 02:34:51,526 --> 02:34:52,160 A DERMATOLOGIST, ACNE, 4098 02:34:52,160 --> 02:34:53,028 PSORIASIS, ECZEMA PATIENTS THAT 4099 02:34:53,028 --> 02:34:55,030 ARE STABLE AND NEED MED REFILLS. 4100 02:34:55,030 --> 02:34:57,199 THAT'S A GREAT USE FOR 4101 02:34:57,199 --> 02:34:58,333 TELEHEALTH. 4102 02:34:58,333 --> 02:35:05,273 SO THERE ARE WAYS TO CARVE OUT 4103 02:35:05,273 --> 02:35:05,774 HIGH-YIELD INTERACTIONS. 4104 02:35:05,774 --> 02:35:06,708 SOMEONE WHO HAS A BRAND-NEW 4105 02:35:06,708 --> 02:35:07,809 DIAGNOSIS OF CANCER I MIGHT WANT 4106 02:35:07,809 --> 02:35:09,244 TO SIT WITH THEM IN PERSON AND 4107 02:35:09,244 --> 02:35:11,112 TALK TO THEM ABOUT THAT. 4108 02:35:11,112 --> 02:35:14,716 SOMEONE WHO HAS A COMPLICATED -- 4109 02:35:14,716 --> 02:35:16,918 AGAIN, TRANSPLANT PATIENTS, ALL 4110 02:35:16,918 --> 02:35:17,686 THESE OTHER COMPLICATIONS MIGHT 4111 02:35:17,686 --> 02:35:19,421 MAKE MORE SENSE TO HAVE THEM 4112 02:35:19,421 --> 02:35:20,188 COME IN. 4113 02:35:20,188 --> 02:35:21,957 AGAIN, IT DEPEND HOW YOU ASK THE 4114 02:35:21,957 --> 02:35:22,224 QUESTION. 4115 02:35:22,224 --> 02:35:25,961 AND I'M NOT AWARE OF RESEARCH 4116 02:35:25,961 --> 02:35:28,296 THAT'S DONE THOSE CARVE-OUTS 4117 02:35:28,296 --> 02:35:29,164 EFFECTIVELY. 4118 02:35:29,164 --> 02:35:31,266 MAYBE THE OTHERS ARE. 4119 02:35:31,266 --> 02:35:34,336 >> GREAT COMMENTS THERE. 4120 02:35:34,336 --> 02:35:36,805 LARGELY, THIS IS ALL BASED ON 4121 02:35:36,805 --> 02:35:38,807 CAPTURING DATA, PRESENTING IT TO 4122 02:35:38,807 --> 02:35:40,775 A CLINICIAN, TO THE PATIENT, YOU 4123 02:35:40,775 --> 02:35:42,944 KNOW, EITHER THE CLINICIAN 4124 02:35:42,944 --> 02:35:44,045 MAKING A RECOMMENDATION TO 4125 02:35:44,045 --> 02:35:46,014 PATIENTS, THE PATIENT LOOKING AT 4126 02:35:46,014 --> 02:35:47,549 THAT INFORMATION AND RESPONDING 4127 02:35:47,549 --> 02:35:49,284 TO IT. 4128 02:35:49,284 --> 02:35:50,619 IT'S BEHAVIOR CHANGE. 4129 02:35:50,619 --> 02:35:54,556 BEHAVIOR CHANGE AT BOTH PATIENT 4130 02:35:54,556 --> 02:35:55,757 AND CLINICIAN LEVEL. 4131 02:35:55,757 --> 02:35:57,092 LET'S TALK FIRST ABOUT THE 4132 02:35:57,092 --> 02:35:57,525 PATIENT. 4133 02:35:57,525 --> 02:35:58,727 THERE WAS AN ORIGINAL FEELING 4134 02:35:58,727 --> 02:35:59,928 YOU COULD CAPTURE THE DATA AND 4135 02:35:59,928 --> 02:36:02,364 THEN PEOPLE COULD LOOK AT IT, 4136 02:36:02,364 --> 02:36:04,099 MOTIVATED TO WANT TO GET 4137 02:36:04,099 --> 02:36:04,699 IMPROVED HEALTH. 4138 02:36:04,699 --> 02:36:06,534 AND I'D LOVE TO GET YOUR 4139 02:36:06,534 --> 02:36:07,002 THOUGHTS. 4140 02:36:07,002 --> 02:36:08,470 HAS THAT COME TO BE TRUE? 4141 02:36:08,470 --> 02:36:10,005 IS IT NOT TRUE? 4142 02:36:10,005 --> 02:36:15,277 ARE WE SOMEWHERE IN THE MIDDLE? 4143 02:36:15,277 --> 02:36:16,711 >> CERTAINLY THAT'S BEEN THE 4144 02:36:16,711 --> 02:36:18,346 ANECDOTAL SUCCESS STORIES THAT 4145 02:36:18,346 --> 02:36:22,384 WE'VE ALL RUN PROJECTS OR WE'VE 4146 02:36:22,384 --> 02:36:23,485 PROVIDED DEVICES, YOU KNOW, 4147 02:36:23,485 --> 02:36:24,753 MENTIONING EARLY CONNECTED 4148 02:36:24,753 --> 02:36:26,888 PARTICIPANTS TO HEALTH, HUNDREDS 4149 02:36:26,888 --> 02:36:28,089 OF E-MAILS FROM PARTICIPANTS 4150 02:36:28,089 --> 02:36:30,525 SAYING THIS TRANSFORMED MY LIFE. 4151 02:36:30,525 --> 02:36:34,663 I WAS CONNECTED, NOW I'M DOING 4152 02:36:34,663 --> 02:36:36,331 THIS, DOING THAT. 4153 02:36:36,331 --> 02:36:37,999 THERE'S A SELECTION BIAS PROBLEM 4154 02:36:37,999 --> 02:36:41,036 IN THE COMMENTS, WHEN YOU LOOK 4155 02:36:41,036 --> 02:36:42,137 AT RIGOROUSLY DONE STUDIES WHEN 4156 02:36:42,137 --> 02:36:44,005 THEY PROVIDE HALF WITH DEVICE, 4157 02:36:44,005 --> 02:36:45,874 DON'T PROVIDE THE OTHER HALF 4158 02:36:45,874 --> 02:36:48,410 WITH THE DEVICE, CHANGING STEP 4159 02:36:48,410 --> 02:36:50,245 COUNTS, CHANGING ACTIVITY 4160 02:36:50,245 --> 02:36:52,113 LEVELS, CHANGING WEIGHTS ARE 4161 02:36:52,113 --> 02:36:54,849 NON-RESILIENT TO TIME. 4162 02:36:54,849 --> 02:36:57,352 I CONTINUE TO BE SADDENED BY THE 4163 02:36:57,352 --> 02:37:00,422 LACK OF CLARITY IN THAT MESSAGE. 4164 02:37:00,422 --> 02:37:03,825 I THINK OF PLACES WHERE WE'RE 4165 02:37:03,825 --> 02:37:06,428 SEEING VALUE IN THIS, WHERE 4166 02:37:06,428 --> 02:37:08,096 THERE'S CLEAR EFFICACY IN THE 4167 02:37:08,096 --> 02:37:12,467 INTENSE VERSION OF THAT CLINICAL 4168 02:37:12,467 --> 02:37:13,001 INTERACTION. 4169 02:37:13,001 --> 02:37:13,868 CARDIAC REHAB, PULMONARY REHAB, 4170 02:37:13,868 --> 02:37:16,938 AND DUE TO INCONVENIENCE OF THAT 4171 02:37:16,938 --> 02:37:20,008 INTENSE VERSION, DESPITE ITS 4172 02:37:20,008 --> 02:37:22,877 EFFICACY YOU DON'T SEE -- ACCESS 4173 02:37:22,877 --> 02:37:23,945 ISSUES, BOTH HAVE MASSIVE ACCESS 4174 02:37:23,945 --> 02:37:26,514 ISSUES, ALL THESE FORMS OF 4175 02:37:26,514 --> 02:37:26,981 REHAB. 4176 02:37:26,981 --> 02:37:28,783 AND BECAUSE OF JUST 4177 02:37:28,783 --> 02:37:30,118 INCONVENIENCE ISSUES, YOU KNOW, 4178 02:37:30,118 --> 02:37:33,822 DRIVING TO THE PLACE, YOU KNOW, 4179 02:37:33,822 --> 02:37:36,024 AFTER USUAL FOURTH VISIT, HAVING 4180 02:37:36,024 --> 02:37:37,559 THE PHYSIOLOGIST TELLING YOU 4181 02:37:37,559 --> 02:37:40,295 YOU'RE WALKING TOO FAST, PLACES 4182 02:37:40,295 --> 02:37:42,397 WE'VE SEEN LIKE WITH TECHNOLOGY 4183 02:37:42,397 --> 02:37:44,132 IN THE PAST IF YOUR COMPARATOR 4184 02:37:44,132 --> 02:37:45,367 IS NOTHING THESE TECHNOLOGIES DO 4185 02:37:45,367 --> 02:37:46,134 WELL. 4186 02:37:46,134 --> 02:37:49,170 AND LET'S BE HONEST, NOTHING IS 4187 02:37:49,170 --> 02:37:51,172 A VERY VALID COMPARATOR BECAUSE 4188 02:37:51,172 --> 02:37:53,041 THAT'S THE DEFAULT BEHAVIOR. 4189 02:37:53,041 --> 02:37:54,142 MY BACKGROUND IN ELECTRONIC 4190 02:37:54,142 --> 02:37:56,010 HEALTH RECORDS, WE USED TO -- 20 4191 02:37:56,010 --> 02:37:57,545 YEARS AGO WOULD SAY OUR 4192 02:37:57,545 --> 02:37:59,981 COMPETITOR ISN'T THIS COMPANY OR 4193 02:37:59,981 --> 02:38:02,250 THAT COMPANY, IT'S PAPER. 4194 02:38:02,250 --> 02:38:03,351 IT'S FORMIDABLE. 4195 02:38:03,351 --> 02:38:05,720 IT'S WINNING. 4196 02:38:05,720 --> 02:38:06,521 AND CLINICIANS ARE NATURALLY 4197 02:38:06,521 --> 02:38:07,522 THERE. 4198 02:38:07,522 --> 02:38:09,691 TELEHEALTH IS IN THE SAME SPOT 4199 02:38:09,691 --> 02:38:10,358 NOW. 4200 02:38:10,358 --> 02:38:11,793 WE KEEP TRYING TO CONFIRM 4201 02:38:11,793 --> 02:38:13,762 TELEHEALTH TO SEEING YOUR 4202 02:38:13,762 --> 02:38:14,329 CARDIOLOGIST. 4203 02:38:14,329 --> 02:38:15,830 THAT'S NOT VALID. 4204 02:38:15,830 --> 02:38:18,700 TELEHEALTH POTENTIALLY TO -- OR 4205 02:38:18,700 --> 02:38:20,235 REMOTE PATIENT MONITORING 4206 02:38:20,235 --> 02:38:22,103 OPTIONS COMPARING TO NOT GETTING 4207 02:38:22,103 --> 02:38:24,072 CARDIAC REHAB TYPICALLY DOES 4208 02:38:24,072 --> 02:38:25,173 WIN, WITH LOWER UTILIZATION 4209 02:38:25,173 --> 02:38:26,474 RATE, THAT'S A GREAT STORY WE 4210 02:38:26,474 --> 02:38:28,009 SHOULD BE TOUTING MORE 4211 02:38:28,009 --> 02:38:29,077 EFFECTIVELY, HOW HAVE KNOWN 4212 02:38:29,077 --> 02:38:30,645 INTERVENTIONS BUT BECAUSE OF 4213 02:38:30,645 --> 02:38:31,813 CHALLENGE IN GETTING THEM THEY 4214 02:38:31,813 --> 02:38:33,515 CAN'T GET THEM IN THE IN-PERSON 4215 02:38:33,515 --> 02:38:36,117 SETTING, AND THESE ARE VALID 4216 02:38:36,117 --> 02:38:36,651 OPTIONS. 4217 02:38:36,651 --> 02:38:38,186 THAT'S A NEW TYPE OF PATIENT 4218 02:38:38,186 --> 02:38:43,558 YOU'RE HELPING THAT YOU'RE NOT 4219 02:38:43,558 --> 02:38:44,259 HELP OTHERWISE. 4220 02:38:44,259 --> 02:38:45,894 >> YOUR POINTS ABOUT HAVING 4221 02:38:45,894 --> 02:38:46,628 THESE PROGRAMS WHICH INDIVIDUALS 4222 02:38:46,628 --> 02:38:48,830 ARE CONNECTED TO THE PROVIDERS 4223 02:38:48,830 --> 02:38:49,731 AND HAVING THAT MOTIVATION TO 4224 02:38:49,731 --> 02:38:52,667 ACT ON IT BECAUSE YOU KNOW YOUR 4225 02:38:52,667 --> 02:38:53,768 PROVIDER IS LOOKING AND 4226 02:38:53,768 --> 02:38:57,939 OVERSEEING WHAT YOU'RE DOING, 4227 02:38:57,939 --> 02:39:00,675 BEHAVIORAL ECONOMICS BEHIND IT, 4228 02:39:00,675 --> 02:39:04,078 CARDIAC AND PULMONARY REHAB ARE 4229 02:39:04,078 --> 02:39:04,846 EXCELLENT EXAMPLES. 4230 02:39:04,846 --> 02:39:07,682 LOK, HAVE YOU SEEN PROGRAMS LIKE 4231 02:39:07,682 --> 02:39:09,317 THIS HIGHLY EFFECTIVE, HIGHLY 4232 02:39:09,317 --> 02:39:10,318 ENGAGING, THINGS PATIENTS AND 4233 02:39:10,318 --> 02:39:12,053 CONSUMERS WHEN THEY SEE THE DATA 4234 02:39:12,053 --> 02:39:14,155 OR WHEN THEY ARE RESPONDING TO 4235 02:39:14,155 --> 02:39:16,758 WRITTEN MESSAGES THEY ARE MORE 4236 02:39:16,758 --> 02:39:18,193 LIKELY TO DO THE THINGS 4237 02:39:18,193 --> 02:39:22,030 NECESSARY TO GET TO BETTER 4238 02:39:22,030 --> 02:39:23,131 HEALTH? 4239 02:39:23,131 --> 02:39:25,967 >> I'M GOING TO PUNCH ON THAT 4240 02:39:25,967 --> 02:39:26,401 ONE. 4241 02:39:26,401 --> 02:39:27,969 >> MAYBE, JOE, YOU SEE STUDIES 4242 02:39:27,969 --> 02:39:30,672 OR PERSONAL EXPERIENCE. 4243 02:39:30,672 --> 02:39:31,773 >> YEAH, PERSONAL EXPERIENCE. 4244 02:39:31,773 --> 02:39:33,842 WE STUDY THIS PROBLEM TEN YEARS 4245 02:39:33,842 --> 02:39:34,209 AGO EXTENSIVELY. 4246 02:39:34,209 --> 02:39:37,445 TWO OR THREE KINDS OF INSIGHTS, 4247 02:39:37,445 --> 02:39:40,748 ONE IS THAT TO YOUR POINT, IF 4248 02:39:40,748 --> 02:39:42,283 PEOPLE ARE SELF-MOTIVATED BY 4249 02:39:42,283 --> 02:39:43,685 DATA, THEY DO REALLY WELL. 4250 02:39:43,685 --> 02:39:50,258 THIS WAS IN THE BEGINNING WE 4251 02:39:50,258 --> 02:39:51,359 CALLED THEM QUANTIFIED 4252 02:39:51,359 --> 02:39:53,194 SELF-PRESENTERS. 4253 02:39:53,194 --> 02:39:53,795 GET TOGETHER, HAVE MEETINGS, 4254 02:39:53,795 --> 02:39:55,196 TALK ABOUT THINGS THEY WERE 4255 02:39:55,196 --> 02:39:55,830 MEASURING. 4256 02:39:55,830 --> 02:39:57,265 THAT'S SUCH A NARROW SLICE OF 4257 02:39:57,265 --> 02:39:58,132 THE POPULATION. 4258 02:39:58,132 --> 02:39:58,967 USUALLY BECAUSE THEY CARE ABOUT 4259 02:39:58,967 --> 02:40:00,902 ALL KINDS OF OTHER THINGS ABOUT 4260 02:40:00,902 --> 02:40:06,374 THEIR HEALTH TOO. 4261 02:40:06,374 --> 02:40:07,308 SADLY, WEARABLES WORK WELL FOR 4262 02:40:07,308 --> 02:40:08,877 THEM BUT NOT THOSE OF US THAT 4263 02:40:08,877 --> 02:40:09,711 CARE ABOUT PATIENTS. 4264 02:40:09,711 --> 02:40:10,745 THE SECOND PHENOMENON WHEN WE 4265 02:40:10,745 --> 02:40:12,046 STARTED TO DO IT WITH 4266 02:40:12,046 --> 02:40:17,352 CLINICIANS, THIS IS EARLY DAYS, 4267 02:40:17,352 --> 02:40:22,290 IF THE PATIENT BOTHERED TO GET 4268 02:40:22,290 --> 02:40:26,861 ALL THIS INFORMATION COLLECTED, 4269 02:40:26,861 --> 02:40:28,963 AND THE DOCTOR DIDN'T KNOW OR 4270 02:40:28,963 --> 02:40:30,398 DIDN'T LOOK, IT WAS 4271 02:40:30,398 --> 02:40:30,732 DEMOTIVATING. 4272 02:40:30,732 --> 02:40:32,467 THEY CHECKED OUT AND WOULD TELL 4273 02:40:32,467 --> 02:40:34,636 US IN FOCUS GROUP WHY AM I 4274 02:40:34,636 --> 02:40:35,136 BOTHERING? 4275 02:40:35,136 --> 02:40:37,372 IT'S ABOUT THEIR HEALTH. 4276 02:40:37,372 --> 02:40:39,440 BUT THIS WAS GLUCOSE MONITORING, 4277 02:40:39,440 --> 02:40:41,309 PATIENTS WITH DIABETES. 4278 02:40:41,309 --> 02:40:42,977 THEY STILL WOULD SAY, THE DOCTOR 4279 02:40:42,977 --> 02:40:46,347 DOESN'T SEEM TO CARE, I'M OUT. 4280 02:40:46,347 --> 02:40:48,750 OR THE OTHER PHENOMENON, AND 4281 02:40:48,750 --> 02:40:52,287 THIS I'LL EXIT AFTER THIS, THE 4282 02:40:52,287 --> 02:40:53,688 OTHER PHENOMENON WAS IF PEOPLE 4283 02:40:53,688 --> 02:40:54,556 WOULD CHANGE BEHAVIOR BECAUSE 4284 02:40:54,556 --> 02:40:56,090 THEY KNEW SOMEONE IN THE 4285 02:40:56,090 --> 02:40:57,625 PRACTICE WAS LOOKING AT THE 4286 02:40:57,625 --> 02:41:01,029 DATA, SO YOU CALL IT THE 4287 02:41:01,029 --> 02:41:01,896 SENTINEL OR HAWTHORNE EFFECT, 4288 02:41:01,896 --> 02:41:04,532 THAT'S VERY REAL. 4289 02:41:04,532 --> 02:41:06,601 YOU CAN MOTIVATE CERTAIN COHORTS 4290 02:41:06,601 --> 02:41:09,003 OF INDIVIDUALS BY GIVING THEM A 4291 02:41:09,003 --> 02:41:10,271 DEVICES AND JUST HAVING -- 4292 02:41:10,271 --> 02:41:12,206 SENDING THEM A MESSAGE FROM THE 4293 02:41:12,206 --> 02:41:14,375 NURSE IN THE PRACTICE EVERY SO 4294 02:41:14,375 --> 02:41:17,211 OFTEN YOU'RE DOING GREAT OR YOU 4295 02:41:17,211 --> 02:41:19,414 COULD DO BETTER THEY ONE THEIR 4296 02:41:19,414 --> 02:41:19,647 GAME. 4297 02:41:19,647 --> 02:41:21,149 THESE THINGS HAVE A ROLE. 4298 02:41:21,149 --> 02:41:23,351 I THINK FINDING -- I DON'T KNOW 4299 02:41:23,351 --> 02:41:25,420 OF ANY KIND OF -- YOU HAVE TO 4300 02:41:25,420 --> 02:41:27,822 FILL OUT 10 OR 15 QUESTIONS LIKE 4301 02:41:27,822 --> 02:41:30,124 THE PHQ OR WHAT HAVE YOU, I 4302 02:41:30,124 --> 02:41:32,527 DON'T KNOW OF ANY SURVEY LIKE 4303 02:41:32,527 --> 02:41:34,596 THAT, TEN QUESTIONS LONG, THAT 4304 02:41:34,596 --> 02:41:36,264 WILL PUT YOU IN THE ONE OF THE 4305 02:41:36,264 --> 02:41:37,365 THREE GROUPS. 4306 02:41:37,365 --> 02:41:39,434 IF WE DID WE COULD FINE TUNE 4307 02:41:39,434 --> 02:41:40,535 THIS FROM A CLINICAL 4308 02:41:40,535 --> 02:41:41,069 PERSPECTIVE. 4309 02:41:41,069 --> 02:41:43,605 >> YEAH, IDENTIFICATION OF THE 4310 02:41:43,605 --> 02:41:45,473 RIGHT PATIENTS, YOU KNOW, 4311 02:41:45,473 --> 02:41:47,775 PATIENT ACTIVATION MEASURES, 4312 02:41:47,775 --> 02:41:49,310 THINGS LIKE THAT, YEAH, 4313 02:41:49,310 --> 02:41:50,178 OFTENTIMES IT'S DIFFICULT TO 4314 02:41:50,178 --> 02:41:52,347 KNOW WHO WILL RESPOND BEST. 4315 02:41:52,347 --> 02:41:54,682 WE SEE A SIMILAR STORY WITH 4316 02:41:54,682 --> 02:41:58,219 CLINICIANS, SUPER EAGER AND 4317 02:41:58,219 --> 02:42:00,288 ACTIVE, WANT TO PARTICIPATE, 4318 02:42:00,288 --> 02:42:02,056 OTHERS SAY IT'S TOO MUCH 4319 02:42:02,056 --> 02:42:03,458 INFORMATION, MAYBE TOO MUCH 4320 02:42:03,458 --> 02:42:03,725 LIABILITY. 4321 02:42:03,725 --> 02:42:05,093 CURIOUS WHAT YOUR THOUGHTS ARE, 4322 02:42:05,093 --> 02:42:06,961 OPEN TO THE GROUP. 4323 02:42:06,961 --> 02:42:09,030 WHAT ARE YOU SEEING, HAS THAT 4324 02:42:09,030 --> 02:42:09,263 CHANGED? 4325 02:42:09,263 --> 02:42:15,937 DO PEOPLE FEEL NOW WITH THE FACT 4326 02:42:15,937 --> 02:42:17,672 THESE ARE MORE UBIQUITOUS, OR 4327 02:42:17,672 --> 02:42:19,007 ARE THEY STILL FEELING THIS IS 4328 02:42:19,007 --> 02:42:26,114 NOISE AND MAYBE TOO MUCH EFFORT? 4329 02:42:26,114 --> 02:42:26,781 >> A BELL-SHAPED CURVED. 4330 02:42:26,781 --> 02:42:27,982 I POINT TO MY STORY. 4331 02:42:27,982 --> 02:42:29,617 TEN YEARS AGO I WOULD NOT HAVE 4332 02:42:29,617 --> 02:42:31,252 HAD A CARDIOLOGIST TELL ME TO 4333 02:42:31,252 --> 02:42:34,322 GET A SMART DEVICE, I'M SURE, 4334 02:42:34,322 --> 02:42:34,689 RIGHT? 4335 02:42:34,689 --> 02:42:35,990 WE'RE GETTING THERE. 4336 02:42:35,990 --> 02:42:40,795 BUT, YEAH, THERE'S A LOT OF 4337 02:42:40,795 --> 02:42:41,796 FOLKS AT CONFERENCES, 4338 02:42:41,796 --> 02:42:42,664 EVANGELIZING, I DON'T WANT TO 4339 02:42:42,664 --> 02:42:44,198 SEE ALL THAT INFORMATION. 4340 02:42:44,198 --> 02:42:45,867 I'M WORRIED ABOUT THE LIABILITY, 4341 02:42:45,867 --> 02:42:49,270 TOO BUSY, WHICH TO ME IS SAD 4342 02:42:49,270 --> 02:42:52,006 BECAUSE BEING A DOCTOR IS ABOUT 4343 02:42:52,006 --> 02:42:52,840 COLLECTING INFORMATION, ABOUT 4344 02:42:52,840 --> 02:42:53,741 YOUR PATIENT TO HELP THEM. 4345 02:42:53,741 --> 02:42:54,842 IF YOU CAN ONLY COLLECT IT WHEN 4346 02:42:54,842 --> 02:42:56,611 THEY ARE THERE AND YOU GET THAT 4347 02:42:56,611 --> 02:42:58,346 NARROW SLICE WHEN THEY ARE IN 4348 02:42:58,346 --> 02:42:59,781 THE OFFICE, THAT'S SUCH A NARROW 4349 02:42:59,781 --> 02:43:00,748 VIEW OF THEIR LIFE. 4350 02:43:00,748 --> 02:43:02,750 I THINK IT'S TOO BAD WE CAN'T 4351 02:43:02,750 --> 02:43:04,519 FIGURE OUT A WAY TO MAKE THIS 4352 02:43:04,519 --> 02:43:07,455 MORE ACTIONABLE SO THAT DOCTORS 4353 02:43:07,455 --> 02:43:08,556 DON'T FEEL SO OVERWHELMED BY 4354 02:43:08,556 --> 02:43:10,825 REAMS AND REAMS AND REAMS OF 4355 02:43:10,825 --> 02:43:12,060 NORMAL RESULTS AND SO FORTH. 4356 02:43:12,060 --> 02:43:13,261 >> YEAH, YEAH. 4357 02:43:13,261 --> 02:43:14,595 >> I THINK THERE'S LESSONS WE'VE 4358 02:43:14,595 --> 02:43:16,531 SEEN IN THE CLINICAL REALM THAT 4359 02:43:16,531 --> 02:43:18,866 WE HAVE TO LEARN HOW TO ADAPT TO 4360 02:43:18,866 --> 02:43:23,271 THE NEXT SET OF DATA STREAMS. 4361 02:43:23,271 --> 02:43:24,172 YOU KNOW, AMBULATORY BLOOD 4362 02:43:24,172 --> 02:43:26,307 PRESSURE MEASUREMENT USED TO BE 4363 02:43:26,307 --> 02:43:27,742 A CLINICAL INTERACTION, WE GIVE 4364 02:43:27,742 --> 02:43:29,811 YOU A PARTICULAR TYPE OF CUFF, 4365 02:43:29,811 --> 02:43:31,112 CYCLE FOUR TIMES A DAY. 4366 02:43:31,112 --> 02:43:32,113 THOSE DAYS ARE GONE NOW. 4367 02:43:32,113 --> 02:43:34,315 ARE YOU SEND PEOPLE HOME WITH A 4368 02:43:34,315 --> 02:43:36,484 BLOOD PRESSURE CUFF, THEY PICK 4369 02:43:36,484 --> 02:43:38,453 ONE UP, AND WHETHER THEY BRING A 4370 02:43:38,453 --> 02:43:40,955 PRINTOUT, SHARE THE APP WITH 4371 02:43:40,955 --> 02:43:42,857 YOU, CGMs ARE DOING THE SAME 4372 02:43:42,857 --> 02:43:43,624 THING, RIGHT? 4373 02:43:43,624 --> 02:43:45,259 PROVIDERS HAVE JUMPED ON THAT 4374 02:43:45,259 --> 02:43:48,863 TRAINEE EFFECTIVELY BECAUSE WE 4375 02:43:48,863 --> 02:43:55,036 RECOGNIZED DICHOTOMY BETWEEN TE 4376 02:43:55,036 --> 02:43:57,205 NARROW MOMENT, DIFFERENCE 4377 02:43:57,205 --> 02:43:57,972 BETWEEN HYPERTENSION TODAY, 4378 02:43:57,972 --> 02:43:59,841 WHITE COAT VERSUS AT HOME, SO 4379 02:43:59,841 --> 02:44:01,776 WE'VE GOT PHYSIOLOGY WE'VE 4380 02:44:01,776 --> 02:44:02,443 ESTABLISHED SCIENCE OF THE VALUE 4381 02:44:02,443 --> 02:44:03,778 OF THE HOME DATA. 4382 02:44:03,778 --> 02:44:06,080 SO WHAT'S MISSING RIGHT NOW IS 4383 02:44:06,080 --> 02:44:07,915 PROVIDING CLINICIANS WHAT'S THE 4384 02:44:07,915 --> 02:44:10,752 VALUE OF THAT HOME ACTIVITY, THE 4385 02:44:10,752 --> 02:44:13,187 VALUE OF THE HOME SLEEP HOUR, 4386 02:44:13,187 --> 02:44:15,923 WE'VE GOT MORE DATA POINTS. 4387 02:44:15,923 --> 02:44:17,558 WE HAVEN'T SAID COMPARED TO THIS 4388 02:44:17,558 --> 02:44:20,528 GOLD STANDARD IT MIGHT BE BETTER 4389 02:44:20,528 --> 02:44:23,030 THAN TAKING THE PATIENT'S BLOOD 4390 02:44:23,030 --> 02:44:24,732 PRESSURE THAT DAY, BETTER THAN 4391 02:44:24,732 --> 02:44:30,671 I'M MANAGING A HEART FAILURE 4392 02:44:30,671 --> 02:44:32,306 PATIENT. 4393 02:44:32,306 --> 02:44:33,441 IT'S A FINE ART. 4394 02:44:33,441 --> 02:44:34,575 WHERE WE'VE GIVEN THEM EVIDENCE 4395 02:44:34,575 --> 02:44:36,611 ON THE VALUE OF THE HOME DATA 4396 02:44:36,611 --> 02:44:37,912 STREAM, THAT MORE INTENSE DATA 4397 02:44:37,912 --> 02:44:39,213 STREAM, THEY HAVE ADOPTED AND 4398 02:44:39,213 --> 02:44:41,082 CHANGED PRACTICE ON THE CLINICAL 4399 02:44:41,082 --> 02:44:41,282 SIDE. 4400 02:44:41,282 --> 02:44:42,517 WE HAVEN'T GIVEN IT TO THEM FOR 4401 02:44:42,517 --> 02:44:43,951 THE OTHER STREAMS OUT THERE YET. 4402 02:44:43,951 --> 02:44:44,719 >> THAT'S FAIR. 4403 02:44:44,719 --> 02:44:46,687 >> ONE OF THE PROGRAMS WE'VE 4404 02:44:46,687 --> 02:44:48,890 SEEN WHERE IT'S BEEN SORT OF 4405 02:44:48,890 --> 02:44:51,959 UNDERVALUED AND PERHAPS MAYBE 4406 02:44:51,959 --> 02:44:54,595 OVERHYPED HAS BEEN TELEHEALTH. 4407 02:44:54,595 --> 02:44:55,363 SPECIFICALLY DURING THE PANDEMIC 4408 02:44:55,363 --> 02:44:57,131 A LOT OF INDIVIDUALS FELT THIS 4409 02:44:57,131 --> 02:44:59,767 WAS HERE TO STAY, WE'RE GOING TO 4410 02:44:59,767 --> 02:45:03,037 ACTUALLY NOW BE DOING MUCH MORE 4411 02:45:03,037 --> 02:45:05,673 HYBRID, BUT WE'VE SEEN A SHIFT 4412 02:45:05,673 --> 02:45:07,441 TO MORE IN-PERSON AND MAYBE 4413 02:45:07,441 --> 02:45:09,177 TELEHEALTH HAS BECOME LESS OF 4414 02:45:09,177 --> 02:45:10,611 THE CONVERSATION TOPIC. 4415 02:45:10,611 --> 02:45:15,850 AND LOK, FROM A NATIONAL 4416 02:45:15,850 --> 02:45:16,951 PERSPECTIVE CURIOUS, ARE YOU 4417 02:45:16,951 --> 02:45:18,052 SEEING TELEHEALTH SORT OF 4418 02:45:18,052 --> 02:45:19,587 STABILIZE WITH A CERTAIN NUMBER 4419 02:45:19,587 --> 02:45:21,355 OF SITES DOING IT CONSISTENTLY? 4420 02:45:21,355 --> 02:45:23,191 OR IS THERE A CONTINUOUS 4421 02:45:23,191 --> 02:45:23,524 DECLINE? 4422 02:45:23,524 --> 02:45:25,993 WHERE ARE WE AT IN TERMS OF 4423 02:45:25,993 --> 02:45:26,894 TELEHEALTH ADOPTION? 4424 02:45:26,894 --> 02:45:29,330 >> I THINK IN TERMS OF THE 4425 02:45:29,330 --> 02:45:30,731 ACTUAL UTILIZATION IT SEEMS TO 4426 02:45:30,731 --> 02:45:34,869 HAVE STABILIZED BUT WHAT'S 4427 02:45:34,869 --> 02:45:37,104 CONCERNING IS THE NUMBER OF 4428 02:45:37,104 --> 02:45:38,739 PROVIDERS WILLING TO OFFER, THE 4429 02:45:38,739 --> 02:45:39,407 DETERMINING FACTOR WHETHER 4430 02:45:39,407 --> 02:45:42,677 SOMEONE HAS A TELEHEALTH VISIT. 4431 02:45:42,677 --> 02:45:45,079 NOT THE PATIENT REQUESTING IT. 4432 02:45:45,079 --> 02:45:47,915 PROBABLY BECAUSE OF UNCERTAINTY 4433 02:45:47,915 --> 02:45:49,217 WITH THE TELEHEALTH FLEXIBILITY 4434 02:45:49,217 --> 02:45:49,884 CONTINUING, PROVIDERS NOT 4435 02:45:49,884 --> 02:45:52,420 WILLING TO INVEST IN CHANGING 4436 02:45:52,420 --> 02:45:53,855 THEIR CLINICAL WORKFLOW, 4437 02:45:53,855 --> 02:46:01,162 INVESTING IN VIRTUAL HEALTH 4438 02:46:01,162 --> 02:46:04,532 CLINICS, TO STAFF DIFFERENTLY, 4439 02:46:04,532 --> 02:46:06,067 THEY HAD TO DO IT IN THE 4440 02:46:06,067 --> 02:46:07,835 PANDEMIC FOR THEIR OWN SAFETY AS 4441 02:46:07,835 --> 02:46:08,236 WELL. 4442 02:46:08,236 --> 02:46:12,106 I'D LOVE TO HEAR, JOSEPH, YOUR 4443 02:46:12,106 --> 02:46:15,042 PERSPECTIVE ON THE GROUND. 4444 02:46:15,042 --> 02:46:15,943 >> I'LL GO. 4445 02:46:15,943 --> 02:46:20,882 SO I FOLLOW THE DATA SOURCE 4446 02:46:20,882 --> 02:46:26,420 CALLED FAIR HEALTH, THEY HAVE A 4447 02:46:26,420 --> 02:46:29,690 TELEHEALTH TRACKER. 4448 02:46:29,690 --> 02:46:30,057 FAIRHEALTH.ORG. 4449 02:46:30,057 --> 02:46:31,225 BEFORE THE PANDEMIC, THE TOTAL 4450 02:46:31,225 --> 02:46:35,396 PERCENTAGE OF CLAIMS COMING IN 4451 02:46:35,396 --> 02:46:38,499 TO THAT DATA SOURCE, 4452 02:46:38,499 --> 02:46:39,033 SELF-INSURANCE CLAIMS, FOR 4453 02:46:39,033 --> 02:46:41,969 TELEHEALTH, 0.19% OF ALL THEIR 4454 02:46:41,969 --> 02:46:42,203 CLAIMS. 4455 02:46:42,203 --> 02:46:45,039 THAT'S AUGUST OF 2019. 4456 02:46:45,039 --> 02:46:47,975 BY I THINK JUNE OR SO OF 2020, 4457 02:46:47,975 --> 02:46:50,645 IT WAS UP TO ABOUT 7%. 4458 02:46:50,645 --> 02:46:53,381 THAT'S THE SIZE IT GOT FROM THIS 4459 02:46:53,381 --> 02:46:54,248 PARTICULAR DATA STREAM. 4460 02:46:54,248 --> 02:46:58,719 AND THEN IT WENT DOWN IN JANUARY 4461 02:46:58,719 --> 02:47:05,960 OF 2021 TO ABOUT 4.5 OR 5%, 4462 02:47:05,960 --> 02:47:07,461 STABLE THERE, 80% IS BEHAVIORAL 4463 02:47:07,461 --> 02:47:08,262 HEALTH. 4464 02:47:08,262 --> 02:47:11,632 YOU CAN TAKE HOME THE REAL 4465 02:47:11,632 --> 02:47:16,570 WINNER FROM A PATIENT 4466 02:47:16,570 --> 02:47:19,073 PERSPECTIVE HAS BEEN BEHAVIORAL 4467 02:47:19,073 --> 02:47:19,874 HEALTH. 4468 02:47:19,874 --> 02:47:21,509 I TALKED TO PRACTITIONERS, MANY 4469 02:47:21,509 --> 02:47:24,345 DO A VERY LARGE CHUNK OF THEIR 4470 02:47:24,345 --> 02:47:25,446 PRACTICE THIS WAY. 4471 02:47:25,446 --> 02:47:29,850 AND I THINK IT'S EXTENDED ACCESS 4472 02:47:29,850 --> 02:47:31,686 BUT THERE'S STILL A SHORTAGE, 4473 02:47:31,686 --> 02:47:32,787 THERE'S STILL NEED, STILL ALL 4474 02:47:32,787 --> 02:47:35,856 KINDS OF CHALLENGES. 4475 02:47:35,856 --> 02:47:38,826 BY AND LARGE IT'S BEEN FOR THE 4476 02:47:38,826 --> 02:47:40,127 BEHAVIORAL HEALTH PATIENTS AS 4477 02:47:40,127 --> 02:47:40,461 WELL. 4478 02:47:40,461 --> 02:47:43,397 I THINK THAT'S THE STANDOUT 4479 02:47:43,397 --> 02:47:44,031 WINNER. 4480 02:47:44,031 --> 02:47:45,499 EVERYTHING ELSE IS NIBBLING 4481 02:47:45,499 --> 02:47:47,268 AROUND THE EDGES. 4482 02:47:47,268 --> 02:47:49,337 I LIKE -- I'LL UNDERSCORE THE 4483 02:47:49,337 --> 02:47:52,640 POINT YOU MADE, WHICH IS IF MY 4484 02:47:52,640 --> 02:47:53,407 INSTITUTION DOESN'T HAVE A LONG 4485 02:47:53,407 --> 02:47:54,809 RANGE GUARANTEE THAT WE'RE GOING 4486 02:47:54,809 --> 02:47:56,210 TO GET PAID FOR STUFF THEY ARE 4487 02:47:56,210 --> 02:47:57,545 NOT GOING TO MAKE A HUGE 4488 02:47:57,545 --> 02:47:59,080 INVESTMENT IN A NEW CHANNEL. 4489 02:47:59,080 --> 02:48:02,049 IT'S A WHOLE NEW CHANNEL. 4490 02:48:02,049 --> 02:48:03,784 IT'S NOT JUST ME DUCKING INTO AN 4491 02:48:03,784 --> 02:48:05,553 OFFICE TO DO A VIDEO VISIT 4492 02:48:05,553 --> 02:48:06,420 BETWEEN PATIENTS. 4493 02:48:06,420 --> 02:48:09,924 IT'S A NEW CHANNEL, IT HAS TO BE 4494 02:48:09,924 --> 02:48:10,891 MANAGED THAT WAY. 4495 02:48:10,891 --> 02:48:12,259 WE KNOW THAT'S COMING UP. 4496 02:48:12,259 --> 02:48:13,461 BIG DRUM ROLL. 4497 02:48:13,461 --> 02:48:15,196 BUT OUR FRIENDS IN CONGRESS HAVE 4498 02:48:15,196 --> 02:48:17,732 TOWARDS THE END OF THE YEAR HAVE 4499 02:48:17,732 --> 02:48:18,833 TO DO SOMETHING OTHER WE'LL FALL 4500 02:48:18,833 --> 02:48:25,306 BACK TO THE DAYS OF 1834, WHICH 4501 02:48:25,306 --> 02:48:26,741 IS VERY, VERY RESTRICTIVE. 4502 02:48:26,741 --> 02:48:28,376 >> HOW ABOUT ABILITY TO DO 4503 02:48:28,376 --> 02:48:29,243 TELEHEALTH ACROSS STATE 4504 02:48:29,243 --> 02:48:31,545 BOUNDARIES, IS THAT SOMETHING WE 4505 02:48:31,545 --> 02:48:32,913 ANTICIPATE IS GOING TO -- 4506 02:48:32,913 --> 02:48:33,514 >> NO. 4507 02:48:33,514 --> 02:48:35,683 >> WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN THERE? 4508 02:48:35,683 --> 02:48:38,319 >> NO, I DON'T THINK SO. 4509 02:48:38,319 --> 02:48:40,287 I JUST THINK THAT'S HOPELESS, 4510 02:48:40,287 --> 02:48:43,024 ALMOST HOPELESS. 4511 02:48:43,024 --> 02:48:46,861 STATE MEDICAL BOARDS ARE SO 4512 02:48:46,861 --> 02:48:48,262 ENTRENCHED, NOT INTERESTED, 4513 02:48:48,262 --> 02:48:49,263 DON'T SEE THE WORLD PERHAPS 4514 02:48:49,263 --> 02:48:51,432 OTHERS SEE THE WORLD. 4515 02:48:51,432 --> 02:48:52,533 AND THEY CONTROL OBVIOUSLY 4516 02:48:52,533 --> 02:48:53,868 WHETHER SOMEONE GETS TO PRACTICE 4517 02:48:53,868 --> 02:48:57,138 IN THEIR STATE. 4518 02:48:57,138 --> 02:49:00,441 >> I WANT TO POINT OUT A GROUP 4519 02:49:00,441 --> 02:49:02,076 THAT'S BENEFITED FROM 4520 02:49:02,076 --> 02:49:02,943 TELEHEALTH, THOSE WITH 4521 02:49:02,943 --> 02:49:05,446 DISABILITIES, 1 1/2 TO 2 TIMES 4522 02:49:05,446 --> 02:49:07,314 MORE LIKELY TO USE TELEHEALTH 4523 02:49:07,314 --> 02:49:08,315 THAN PEOPLE WITHOUT 4524 02:49:08,315 --> 02:49:09,183 DISABILITIES, A HIDDEN 4525 02:49:09,183 --> 02:49:09,617 POPULATION. 4526 02:49:09,617 --> 02:49:11,585 >> IT'S A WONDERFUL POINT, YEAH. 4527 02:49:11,585 --> 02:49:12,486 >> ARE THERE TECHNOLOGIES THAT 4528 02:49:12,486 --> 02:49:16,190 WE'RE SEEING THAT CAN HELP 4529 02:49:16,190 --> 02:49:17,725 INDIVIDUALS WITH DISABILITIES 4530 02:49:17,725 --> 02:49:20,795 THAT FOR INSTANCE THEY HAVE 4531 02:49:20,795 --> 02:49:21,896 VISUAL, HEARING, MOTOR, HOW IS 4532 02:49:21,896 --> 02:49:29,170 THE TELEHEALTH EXPERIENCE FOR 4533 02:49:29,170 --> 02:49:30,538 THOSE WITH DISABILITIES? 4534 02:49:30,538 --> 02:49:32,673 >> THERE ARE -- I THINK -- 4535 02:49:32,673 --> 02:49:34,141 YOU'RE RIGHT. 4536 02:49:34,141 --> 02:49:36,343 DISABILITY IS A BROAD SPECTRUM. 4537 02:49:36,343 --> 02:49:38,746 MY OWN CASE, MOST OF THE PEOPLE 4538 02:49:38,746 --> 02:49:40,381 THAT I SEE BENEFITING, THIS IS 4539 02:49:40,381 --> 02:49:44,819 MY OWN PRACTICE, ARE PEOPLE WHO 4540 02:49:44,819 --> 02:49:48,756 HAVE PHYSICAL DISABILITIES, HARD 4541 02:49:48,756 --> 02:49:50,324 TO GET OUT OF THEIR APARTMENT, 4542 02:49:50,324 --> 02:49:51,459 HARD TO GET IN. 4543 02:49:51,459 --> 02:49:53,527 ONE WOMAN JUST THANKED ME TEN 4544 02:49:53,527 --> 02:49:55,496 TIMES BECAUSE SHE HAS A SPECIAL 4545 02:49:55,496 --> 02:49:56,630 NEEDS CHILD, IT'S HARD FOR HER 4546 02:49:56,630 --> 02:49:57,498 TO GET OUT. 4547 02:49:57,498 --> 02:49:59,800 EVERY TIME THEY GO SOMEWHERE 4548 02:49:59,800 --> 02:50:04,071 THEY HAVE A WHOLE CAVALCADE OF 4549 02:50:04,071 --> 02:50:05,473 THINGS HAPPENING. 4550 02:50:05,473 --> 02:50:06,373 VISUAL AND AUDITORY, I'M NOT AS 4551 02:50:06,373 --> 02:50:09,410 UP TO DATE ON WHAT'S GOING ON. 4552 02:50:09,410 --> 02:50:11,178 MAYBE MY COLLEAGUES ARE. 4553 02:50:11,178 --> 02:50:11,779 >> YEAH. 4554 02:50:11,779 --> 02:50:13,714 I CAN SHARE THAT. 4555 02:50:13,714 --> 02:50:15,916 WE HAVE SEEN QUITE A BIT OF 4556 02:50:15,916 --> 02:50:17,785 ADVANCEMENT IN TERMS OF 4557 02:50:17,785 --> 02:50:19,386 TECHNOLOGIES TO HELP THOSE WITH 4558 02:50:19,386 --> 02:50:22,123 DISABILITIES ON ALL FRONTS FOR 4559 02:50:22,123 --> 02:50:22,790 CONNECTED CARE, EVERYTHING FROM 4560 02:50:22,790 --> 02:50:25,326 OF COURSE YOU HAVE THE ABILITY 4561 02:50:25,326 --> 02:50:27,061 TO HAVE THE VOICE TRANSCRIPTIONS 4562 02:50:27,061 --> 02:50:30,464 WHERE YOU CAN SEE THE WORDS, 4563 02:50:30,464 --> 02:50:32,433 TRANSLATED IN DIFFERENT 4564 02:50:32,433 --> 02:50:32,800 LANGUAGES. 4565 02:50:32,800 --> 02:50:35,002 LANGUAGES TRANSLATION IS 4566 02:50:35,002 --> 02:50:35,302 CHALLENGING. 4567 02:50:35,302 --> 02:50:36,637 IN MEDICAL TRANSLATION, NOT AS 4568 02:50:36,637 --> 02:50:39,974 ACCURATE, MAY NOT MEET THE 4569 02:50:39,974 --> 02:50:45,446 STANDARDS OF ACCEPTABILITY IN 4570 02:50:45,446 --> 02:50:45,746 TELEHEALTH. 4571 02:50:45,746 --> 02:50:47,414 IN ENGLISH THERE'S BEEN SOME. 4572 02:50:47,414 --> 02:50:51,552 THERE'S BEEN SOME WORK FOR THOSE 4573 02:50:51,552 --> 02:50:53,187 WITH VISUAL DISABILITIES, 4574 02:50:53,187 --> 02:50:54,522 DECREASED VISION, WE'VE EVEN 4575 02:50:54,522 --> 02:50:55,489 SEEN SOME SCENARIOS WHERE 4576 02:50:55,489 --> 02:50:59,026 INDIVIDUALS HAVE BEEN ABLE TO 4577 02:50:59,026 --> 02:51:02,630 HAVE INDIVIDUALS WITH SIGN 4578 02:51:02,630 --> 02:51:03,697 LANGUAGE TRANSLATORS, TELEHEALTH 4579 02:51:03,697 --> 02:51:07,368 IN, THERE HAVE BEEN OF COURSE 4580 02:51:07,368 --> 02:51:08,836 A.I.-BOTS THAT ARE NOW STARTING 4581 02:51:08,836 --> 02:51:10,971 TO BECOME HELPFUL AS WELL. 4582 02:51:10,971 --> 02:51:13,674 I THINK EVEN INDIVIDUALS WITH 4583 02:51:13,674 --> 02:51:15,242 DISABILITY, DUE TO STROKE, NOT 4584 02:51:15,242 --> 02:51:19,980 ABLE TO SPEAK AS WELL, CLEARLY, 4585 02:51:19,980 --> 02:51:21,482 THOSE CONNECTIONS WOULD BE 4586 02:51:21,482 --> 02:51:22,483 INTERPRETED SO INDIVIDUALS CAN 4587 02:51:22,483 --> 02:51:24,618 BETTER UNDERSTAND WHAT THEY ARE 4588 02:51:24,618 --> 02:51:26,387 SAYING. 4589 02:51:26,387 --> 02:51:29,056 SO A LOT OF MOVEMENT, HOPEFULLY 4590 02:51:29,056 --> 02:51:32,960 LYNN CREASE ACCESSIBILITY. 4591 02:51:32,960 --> 02:51:33,661 WE -- INCREASE ACCESSIBILITY. 4592 02:51:33,661 --> 02:51:35,129 LET'S GO TO THE CHAT. 4593 02:51:35,129 --> 02:51:37,531 A QUESTION FOR YOU, LOK, I'LL 4594 02:51:37,531 --> 02:51:38,432 READ IT. 4595 02:51:38,432 --> 02:51:40,701 YOU MENTIONED THAT THERE'S SOME 4596 02:51:40,701 --> 02:51:43,571 STUDIES THAT SHOW REDUCTION IN 4597 02:51:43,571 --> 02:51:44,438 SPENDING, OTHERS SUGGEST 4598 02:51:44,438 --> 02:51:45,940 INCREASE IN SPENDING. 4599 02:51:45,940 --> 02:51:47,808 WHAT'S YOUR ASSESSMENT WHETHER 4600 02:51:47,808 --> 02:51:51,345 TELEHEALTH HAS BEEN COST 4601 02:51:51,345 --> 02:51:53,747 BENEFICIAL OR COST EFFECTIVE IN 4602 02:51:53,747 --> 02:51:54,949 OTHER WORDS FROM SOCIETAL 4603 02:51:54,949 --> 02:51:56,383 PERSPECTIVE HAS THE VALUE BEEN 4604 02:51:56,383 --> 02:51:58,352 WORTH THE COST AND IN WHAT 4605 02:51:58,352 --> 02:51:58,786 SETTINGS? 4606 02:51:58,786 --> 02:52:01,322 >> I THINK THAT'S AN EXCELLENT 4607 02:52:01,322 --> 02:52:01,889 QUESTION. 4608 02:52:01,889 --> 02:52:03,390 AS A HEALTH SERVICES RESEARCHER 4609 02:52:03,390 --> 02:52:05,326 I THINK WE PROBABLY DON'T HAVE 4610 02:52:05,326 --> 02:52:06,894 THE RIGHT DATA TO ANSWER THAT 4611 02:52:06,894 --> 02:52:10,831 FULLY FROM A PATIENT PERSPECTIVE 4612 02:52:10,831 --> 02:52:13,033 BECAUSE THE PATIENT COST, THEIR 4613 02:52:13,033 --> 02:52:15,502 TIME, LOST OPPORTUNITIES FOR 4614 02:52:15,502 --> 02:52:16,737 WORK, HOSPITAL, ESPECIALLY IF 4615 02:52:16,737 --> 02:52:18,973 YOU HAVE DISABILITIES TO GET IN 4616 02:52:18,973 --> 02:52:20,474 AND OUT OF THE HOUSE. 4617 02:52:20,474 --> 02:52:24,612 AND I THINK WE TALKED EARLIER 4618 02:52:24,612 --> 02:52:26,146 ABOUT TELEHEALTH IS MEETING 4619 02:52:26,146 --> 02:52:27,348 POTENTIALLY UNMET NEED. 4620 02:52:27,348 --> 02:52:28,882 WE DON'T HAVE THAT DENOMINATOR 4621 02:52:28,882 --> 02:52:30,985 WHO ISN'T GETTING THE CARE THEY 4622 02:52:30,985 --> 02:52:32,620 NEED AND ARE NOW GETTING IT. 4623 02:52:32,620 --> 02:52:38,726 SO I THINK WE NEED TO HAVE THAT 4624 02:52:38,726 --> 02:52:39,827 BROADER SOCIETAL PERSPECTIVE TO 4625 02:52:39,827 --> 02:52:41,462 HELP US UNDERSTAND THE VALUE TO 4626 02:52:41,462 --> 02:52:44,665 SOCIETY, NOT JUST TO A PAYER. 4627 02:52:44,665 --> 02:52:46,100 >> FANTASTIC. 4628 02:52:46,100 --> 02:52:46,500 GREAT. 4629 02:52:46,500 --> 02:52:48,068 THANK YOU, LOK. 4630 02:52:48,068 --> 02:52:49,270 IF OTHERS HAVE QUESTIONS, PLEASE 4631 02:52:49,270 --> 02:52:51,438 FEEL FREE TO ENTER THEM INTO THE 4632 02:52:51,438 --> 02:52:53,641 CHAT Q&A AND I'LL GET TO THEM AS 4633 02:52:53,641 --> 02:52:55,376 WE GO THROUGH THE CONVERSATION. 4634 02:52:55,376 --> 02:52:58,112 I WANT TO SHIFT GEARS AND TALK 4635 02:52:58,112 --> 02:53:00,080 ABOUT SOME OF THE INFORMATION 4636 02:53:00,080 --> 02:53:02,383 THAT IS CAPTURED AND HOW 4637 02:53:02,383 --> 02:53:03,250 POTENTIALLY WE CAN BETTER 4638 02:53:03,250 --> 02:53:04,918 UNDERSTAND AND INTERPRET THIS. 4639 02:53:04,918 --> 02:53:06,520 JOE, YOU ALLUDED TO THIS WHEN 4640 02:53:06,520 --> 02:53:10,924 YOU TALKED ABOUT THE A.I. AND 4641 02:53:10,924 --> 02:53:11,225 MULTI-MODAL. 4642 02:53:11,225 --> 02:53:12,793 TELL US ABOUT WHAT YOU MEANT BY 4643 02:53:12,793 --> 02:53:12,993 THAT. 4644 02:53:12,993 --> 02:53:14,895 LIKE YOU SAID A.I. IS GOING TO 4645 02:53:14,895 --> 02:53:16,997 BE POTENTIALLY A VERY HELPFUL 4646 02:53:16,997 --> 02:53:18,432 TOOL IN THIS SPACE. 4647 02:53:18,432 --> 02:53:21,168 WHAT ARE YOU SEEING, WHERE DO 4648 02:53:21,168 --> 02:53:22,803 YOU SEE IT GOING? 4649 02:53:22,803 --> 02:53:24,872 >> WELL, I'LL TRY NOT TO 4650 02:53:24,872 --> 02:53:26,173 DOMINATE BECAUSE IT'S SUCH A FUN 4651 02:53:26,173 --> 02:53:27,474 TOPIC, SO MUCH GOING ON. 4652 02:53:27,474 --> 02:53:30,678 I'LL TRY TO BE SUCCINCT AND 4653 02:53:30,678 --> 02:53:31,011 THOUGHTFUL. 4654 02:53:31,011 --> 02:53:34,848 HARD FOR ME. 4655 02:53:34,848 --> 02:53:37,017 ANYWAY, IN 2015 I PUBLISHED A 4656 02:53:37,017 --> 02:53:44,024 BOOK "INTERNET OF HEALTHY 4657 02:53:44,024 --> 02:53:48,962 THINGS," FIRST CHAPTER IS MADE 4658 02:53:48,962 --> 02:53:52,066 UP, A VIRTUE CARE AGENT NAMED 4659 02:53:52,066 --> 02:53:55,669 SAM KNOWS ME, GUIDES ME AROUND, 4660 02:53:55,669 --> 02:53:57,771 KNOWS IF I'M TAKING A WALK AT 4661 02:53:57,771 --> 02:53:59,173 LUNCH BECAUSE OF MY SMART 4662 02:53:59,173 --> 02:54:00,407 PEDOMETER THAT I'M ALSO WALKING 4663 02:54:00,407 --> 02:54:02,176 TOWARDS A PLACE WHERE I NORMALLY 4664 02:54:02,176 --> 02:54:03,677 GET A COOKIE AND HE SAYS MAYBE 4665 02:54:03,677 --> 02:54:04,978 YOU DON'T WANT THAT COOKIE, 4666 02:54:04,978 --> 02:54:07,948 YOU'RE TRYING TO LOSE WEIGHT FOR 4667 02:54:07,948 --> 02:54:09,183 YOUR DAUGHTER'S WEDDING. 4668 02:54:09,183 --> 02:54:16,490 IT'S FANSFUL BUT -- FANCIFUL BT 4669 02:54:16,490 --> 02:54:17,891 IT'S NOW HAPPENING, TEN YEARS 4670 02:54:17,891 --> 02:54:19,660 SINCE I WROTE AND PUBLISHED. 4671 02:54:19,660 --> 02:54:21,495 SO MUCH HAS HAPPENED WHERE YOU 4672 02:54:21,495 --> 02:54:26,333 CAN TAKE MULTIPLE DATA STREAMS, 4673 02:54:26,333 --> 02:54:28,669 I'M NOT A COMPUTER OR DATA 4674 02:54:28,669 --> 02:54:29,536 SCIENTIST, BUT MAKE THEM MAKE 4675 02:54:29,536 --> 02:54:32,906 SENSE HOW THE ALGORITHMS WORK 4676 02:54:32,906 --> 02:54:34,675 AND YOU HOW THEY GENERATE 4677 02:54:34,675 --> 02:54:35,776 INSIGHTS AND PREDICTIONS ABOUT 4678 02:54:35,776 --> 02:54:38,045 THE FUTURE. 4679 02:54:38,045 --> 02:54:40,147 NOW WITH TEXT-TO-SPEECH AND ALL 4680 02:54:40,147 --> 02:54:41,648 OTHER THINGS, THIS CHARACTER I 4681 02:54:41,648 --> 02:54:43,751 ENVISIONED TEN YEARS AGO, SAM, 4682 02:54:43,751 --> 02:54:47,688 IT'S A REALITY FOR CERTAIN 4683 02:54:47,688 --> 02:54:48,989 PEOPLE, CERTAIN SITUATIONS. 4684 02:54:48,989 --> 02:54:50,858 SO TO ME THAT'S THE THING. 4685 02:54:50,858 --> 02:54:53,060 WHEN WE TALK ABOUT WEARABLES 4686 02:54:53,060 --> 02:54:55,229 BEING SCARY TO DOCTORS BECAUSE 4687 02:54:55,229 --> 02:54:58,065 OF NORMAL RESULTS OR MEANINGLESS 4688 02:54:58,065 --> 02:54:59,299 RESULTS, BUT FOR COMPUTERS 4689 02:54:59,299 --> 02:55:01,368 THAT'S A WONDERFUL THING. 4690 02:55:01,368 --> 02:55:03,437 THE MORE DATA, THE MERRIER. 4691 02:55:03,437 --> 02:55:05,506 THE MORE NUANCED DATA, THE 4692 02:55:05,506 --> 02:55:06,640 MERRIER. 4693 02:55:06,640 --> 02:55:07,808 AND I MEAN WEARABLES, MOBILE 4694 02:55:07,808 --> 02:55:10,444 PHONE DATA, WHERE YOU DID YOUR 4695 02:55:10,444 --> 02:55:11,545 PURCHASING, IF YOU USE A CREDIT 4696 02:55:11,545 --> 02:55:13,614 CARD FOR LUNCH AND YOU CAN MATCH 4697 02:55:13,614 --> 02:55:16,016 THAT AGAINST THE GEO TAGGING OF 4698 02:55:16,016 --> 02:55:18,952 YOUR PHONE, YOU THINK ABOUT THE 4699 02:55:18,952 --> 02:55:19,286 POSSIBILITIES. 4700 02:55:19,286 --> 02:55:24,024 AS I SAID, THIS IS HAPPENING 4701 02:55:24,024 --> 02:55:24,291 NOW. 4702 02:55:24,291 --> 02:55:25,426 IT'S PRETTY EXCITING. 4703 02:55:25,426 --> 02:55:26,760 THAT'S THE REALITY. 4704 02:55:26,760 --> 02:55:28,829 ON THE RESEARCH FRONT I'M NOT A 4705 02:55:28,829 --> 02:55:36,837 COMPUTER SCIENTIST. 4706 02:55:36,837 --> 02:55:38,906 SO MANY INVESTIGATORS ARE TRYING 4707 02:55:38,906 --> 02:55:41,408 TO MAKE THIS -- WHAT WE TALKED 4708 02:55:41,408 --> 02:55:43,610 ABOUT EARLIER, WHICH IS DATA 4709 02:55:43,610 --> 02:55:46,780 FROM A FITBIT DOESN'T EVEN 4710 02:55:46,780 --> 02:55:50,384 RECOGNIZE DATA FROM A 4711 02:55:50,384 --> 02:55:51,051 SMARTWATCH, SAMSUNG IS 4712 02:55:51,051 --> 02:55:53,320 DIFFERENT, ET CETERA, HOW TO 4713 02:55:53,320 --> 02:55:54,788 MARRY THOSE DATA STREAMS SO THEY 4714 02:55:54,788 --> 02:55:56,123 CAN BE COMPARED TO ONE ANOTHER. 4715 02:55:56,123 --> 02:56:01,562 I THINK THAT'S THE FRONTIER. 4716 02:56:01,562 --> 02:56:02,763 SOMETHING LIKE FHIR, SMART ON 4717 02:56:02,763 --> 02:56:03,964 FHIR FOR HEALTH DATA BUT WE 4718 02:56:03,964 --> 02:56:05,299 DON'T HAVE SOMETHING LIKE THAT, 4719 02:56:05,299 --> 02:56:08,068 THAT I'M AWARE OF ANYWAY, AT 4720 02:56:08,068 --> 02:56:11,672 LEAST IN WIDESPREAD USE FOR 4721 02:56:11,672 --> 02:56:12,539 WEARABLES DATA. 4722 02:56:12,539 --> 02:56:13,207 >> SACHIN? 4723 02:56:13,207 --> 02:56:15,709 >> IT'S INTERESTING, FROM A 4724 02:56:15,709 --> 02:56:16,810 PARTICIPANT PERSPECTIVE, WE'VE 4725 02:56:16,810 --> 02:56:19,012 SEEN THIS WHEN TRYING TO PROVIDE 4726 02:56:19,012 --> 02:56:21,615 DEVICES TO FOLKS. 4727 02:56:21,615 --> 02:56:24,852 I GOT A FITBIT, I DON'T WATCH A 4728 02:56:24,852 --> 02:56:27,087 WATCH, I DON'T WANT TO WEAR YOUR 4729 02:56:27,087 --> 02:56:31,191 FITBIT, A CALL TO ADJUST OUR 4730 02:56:31,191 --> 02:56:31,525 METHODOLOGIES. 4731 02:56:31,525 --> 02:56:35,863 I THINK WE -- YOU KNOW, EVERY 4732 02:56:35,863 --> 02:56:37,498 CLINICAL TRIAL TRIES TO CREATE 4733 02:56:37,498 --> 02:56:38,932 THE MOST HOMOGENOUS PATIENT 4734 02:56:38,932 --> 02:56:40,367 POPULATION OR OUTCOME TO MEASURE 4735 02:56:40,367 --> 02:56:44,538 THE EXACT SAME WAY, THAT SENSE 4736 02:56:44,538 --> 02:56:47,374 OF CONTROL BELIES REALITY OF 4737 02:56:47,374 --> 02:56:49,676 CLINICAL CARE, PARTICIPANT 4738 02:56:49,676 --> 02:56:50,978 EXPERIENCE, AND MOST IMPORTANTLY 4739 02:56:50,978 --> 02:56:56,650 PARTICIPANT PREFERENCE. 4740 02:56:56,650 --> 02:56:57,317 WE'LL CONTINUE MAKING STEP 4741 02:56:57,317 --> 02:57:00,287 COUNTS ON THE FITBIT LOOK THE 4742 02:57:00,287 --> 02:57:03,991 SAME AS APPLE WATCH, CONVERSION 4743 02:57:03,991 --> 02:57:06,793 FACTOR, BUT EXPERIENCE TAUGHT US 4744 02:57:06,793 --> 02:57:09,196 THAT'S AN ENDLESS PATH, 4745 02:57:09,196 --> 02:57:11,798 ASYMPTOTIC, STILL CHALLENGE TO 4746 02:57:11,798 --> 02:57:15,536 GET A CERTAIN RECORD TO LOOK 4747 02:57:15,536 --> 02:57:19,806 READABLE IN EPIC, DESPITE 4748 02:57:19,806 --> 02:57:21,675 STANDARDS, RIGHT? 4749 02:57:21,675 --> 02:57:25,078 WE'RE LOOKING FOR 4750 02:57:25,078 --> 02:57:25,946 PERTURBATIONS IN A PATIENT 4751 02:57:25,946 --> 02:57:28,348 EXPERIENCE, WE WANT TO USE 4752 02:57:28,348 --> 02:57:29,449 POPULATION NORMS COMPARING GROUP 4753 02:57:29,449 --> 02:57:33,487 TO GROUP FEED BUT WE SHOULD 4754 02:57:33,487 --> 02:57:35,055 FOCUS ON WITHIN PATIENT CHANGES, 4755 02:57:35,055 --> 02:57:37,524 YOUR CONTROL CHART, HERE IS A 4756 02:57:37,524 --> 02:57:39,092 CLEAR INFLECTION POINT, RESTING 4757 02:57:39,092 --> 02:57:41,595 HEART RATE HAS BEEN AT THIS 4758 02:57:41,595 --> 02:57:42,996 POINT, YOU'RE NOW OFF. 4759 02:57:42,996 --> 02:57:44,431 YOUR ACTIVITY LEVEL HAS BEEN 4760 02:57:44,431 --> 02:57:47,501 HERE, YOU'RE OFF THE BASELINE. 4761 02:57:47,501 --> 02:57:49,236 IT'S AN AREA OF METHODOLOGIC 4762 02:57:49,236 --> 02:57:50,904 APPROACH WHICH WE HAVEN'T 4763 02:57:50,904 --> 02:57:53,407 INVESTED ENOUGH ENERGY IN 4764 02:57:53,407 --> 02:57:54,374 VALIDATING FOR ADOPTING BECAUSE 4765 02:57:54,374 --> 02:57:56,577 IT REQUIRES US TO ADMIT THE 4766 02:57:56,577 --> 02:57:58,111 DIRTINESS OF THE WORLD BUT FAR 4767 02:57:58,111 --> 02:57:59,846 MORE REALISTIC IN TERMS OF 4768 02:57:59,846 --> 02:58:01,949 ADDING VALUE TO AN AVERAGE 4769 02:58:01,949 --> 02:58:03,016 CLINICIAN EVIDENCE BASE, FAR 4770 02:58:03,016 --> 02:58:04,351 MORE LIKELY TO BE WHAT PATIENTS 4771 02:58:04,351 --> 02:58:05,652 USE, BECAUSE THEY ARE GOING TO 4772 02:58:05,652 --> 02:58:06,787 KEEP THE DEVICE THEY WANT, THEY 4773 02:58:06,787 --> 02:58:10,257 HAVE A LOT OF REASONS TO WANT 4774 02:58:10,257 --> 02:58:10,791 IT. 4775 02:58:10,791 --> 02:58:13,060 IT'S OUR JOB AS SCIENTISTS TO 4776 02:58:13,060 --> 02:58:16,330 SAY BASED ON DATA EXTREMES FROM 4777 02:58:16,330 --> 02:58:17,664 YOUR DEVICE THESE SALIENT CHANGE 4778 02:58:17,664 --> 02:58:18,532 DEMONSTRATION SOMETHING IS ABOUT 4779 02:58:18,532 --> 02:58:19,833 TO HAPPEN AND THEREFORE WE DON'T 4780 02:58:19,833 --> 02:58:22,235 KNOW WHAT'S ABOUT TO HAPPEN BUT 4781 02:58:22,235 --> 02:58:23,670 SOMETHING'S UP, LET'S HAVE YOU 4782 02:58:23,670 --> 02:58:25,872 BRING -- LET'S BRING YOU IN. 4783 02:58:25,872 --> 02:58:28,575 THAT HETEROGENEITY OF DATA 4784 02:58:28,575 --> 02:58:32,312 SOURCES IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR 4785 02:58:32,312 --> 02:58:35,616 THE NIH TO REALLY EMBRACE THAT 4786 02:58:35,616 --> 02:58:37,718 HETEROGENEITY AND, YOU KNOW, 4787 02:58:37,718 --> 02:58:39,686 EVALUATE THE VALUE OF USING A 4788 02:58:39,686 --> 02:58:41,989 PATIENT AS THEIR OWN CONTROL 4789 02:58:41,989 --> 02:58:42,756 OVER TIME. 4790 02:58:42,756 --> 02:58:47,894 BECAUSE THAT'S -- WE ASK OUR 4791 02:58:47,894 --> 02:58:50,631 PATIENTS, HAVING DIFFICULTY, HOW 4792 02:58:50,631 --> 02:58:51,832 DIFFERENT IS THAT NOW? 4793 02:58:51,832 --> 02:58:59,072 I'VE GOT PATIENTS WITH A BMI 60 4794 02:58:59,072 --> 02:59:03,210 BARELY MOVING AND 18 WHO ARE 4795 02:59:03,210 --> 02:59:05,078 MARATHON RUNNERS, OUR PATIENTS 4796 02:59:05,078 --> 02:59:08,248 AREN'T DOING THE SAME ACTIVITY 4797 02:59:08,248 --> 02:59:08,515 LIFESTYLE. 4798 02:59:08,515 --> 02:59:10,350 THERE'S A METHODOLOGY AT WORK TO 4799 02:59:10,350 --> 02:59:11,318 MAKE US ADOPT WHAT THEY ARE 4800 02:59:11,318 --> 02:59:15,155 LIVING ON A DAILY BASIS. 4801 02:59:15,155 --> 02:59:16,256 >> YOU'RE TALKING, I MEAN, THE 4802 02:59:16,256 --> 02:59:18,792 END RESULT OF WHAT YOU'RE 4803 02:59:18,792 --> 02:59:19,960 TALKING ABOUT IS DIGITAL TWINS, 4804 02:59:19,960 --> 02:59:23,597 YOU CAN BE YOUR OWN CONTROL 4805 02:59:23,597 --> 02:59:24,798 GROUP FOR ANYTHING. 4806 02:59:24,798 --> 02:59:27,734 >> ONE OF THE THINGS THAT I 4807 02:59:27,734 --> 02:59:29,169 THINK I'VE SEEN OVER THE PAST 4808 02:59:29,169 --> 02:59:30,604 SEVERAL YEARS IS THAT THERE'S 4809 02:59:30,604 --> 02:59:32,005 BEEN A TRANSFORMATION IN TERMS 4810 02:59:32,005 --> 02:59:34,107 OF UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT A.I. 4811 02:59:34,107 --> 02:59:36,276 CAN AND CANNOT DO. 4812 02:59:36,276 --> 02:59:38,145 THE ORIGINAL THOUGHT FOR MANY 4813 02:59:38,145 --> 02:59:40,347 FOLKS IS THAT A.I. ARE A SERIES 4814 02:59:40,347 --> 02:59:42,315 OF ALGORITHMS THAT ARE JUST 4815 02:59:42,315 --> 02:59:43,884 SIMPLY APPLIED AT SCALE. 4816 02:59:43,884 --> 02:59:45,052 AND WE'VE NOW RECOGNIZED THAT 4817 02:59:45,052 --> 02:59:47,621 A.I. CAN DO MUCH MORE THAN THAT, 4818 02:59:47,621 --> 02:59:49,489 SPECIFICALLY WHEN YOU 4819 02:59:49,489 --> 02:59:51,091 INCORPORATE MACHINE LEARNING TO 4820 02:59:51,091 --> 02:59:53,560 NOW BE ABLE TO TAKE UNSTRUCTURED 4821 02:59:53,560 --> 02:59:55,729 FORMS OF DATA AS WELL AS 4822 02:59:55,729 --> 02:59:56,396 STRUCTURED FORMS AND CONVERT 4823 02:59:56,396 --> 03:00:01,768 INTO THINGS THAT ARE 4824 03:00:01,768 --> 03:00:02,469 UNDERSTANDABLE, TEXT, VOICE, 4825 03:00:02,469 --> 03:00:05,505 IMAGE, VIDEO, AND OF COURSE WITH 4826 03:00:05,505 --> 03:00:06,807 THE VAST AMOUNT OF QUANTIFIABLE 4827 03:00:06,807 --> 03:00:09,443 DATA THAT'S COMING IN THROUGH 4828 03:00:09,443 --> 03:00:12,079 DEVICES, PUTTING THEM INTO SOME 4829 03:00:12,079 --> 03:00:12,779 MANNER THAT'S UNDERSTANDABLE, 4830 03:00:12,779 --> 03:00:14,014 BUT WHAT I THINK WHAT WE'RE ALSO 4831 03:00:14,014 --> 03:00:15,782 STARTING TO SEE IS THE NEED FOR 4832 03:00:15,782 --> 03:00:18,085 US TO CREATE DATA 4833 03:00:18,085 --> 03:00:18,952 INFRASTRUCTURES THAT SUPPORT 4834 03:00:18,952 --> 03:00:19,853 MULTI-MODAL DATA. 4835 03:00:19,853 --> 03:00:20,821 THAT MEANS THAT UNDERSTANDING 4836 03:00:20,821 --> 03:00:25,859 HOW YOU TAKE THE DATASETS FROM 4837 03:00:25,859 --> 03:00:27,928 THESE SOURCES AND CURATE THEM, 4838 03:00:27,928 --> 03:00:30,330 ANNOTATE THEM, AND ALLOW US TO 4839 03:00:30,330 --> 03:00:31,765 BE ABLE TO UNDERSTAND 4840 03:00:31,765 --> 03:00:34,167 LONGITUDINALLY HOW THEY ARE 4841 03:00:34,167 --> 03:00:35,368 ASSOCIATED WITH OUTCOMES, AND 4842 03:00:35,368 --> 03:00:37,571 THOSE TYPE OF DATASETS ONCE WE 4843 03:00:37,571 --> 03:00:39,973 ACTUALLY HAVE THEM BUILT, THAT 4844 03:00:39,973 --> 03:00:41,374 YOU HAVE POPULATED WITH THE 4845 03:00:41,374 --> 03:00:43,443 APPROPRIATE DATASETS CAN LEAD US 4846 03:00:43,443 --> 03:00:47,380 TO WAYS THAT WE CAN BE FAR MORE 4847 03:00:47,380 --> 03:00:48,281 PREDICTIVE, AND THERE ARE THREE 4848 03:00:48,281 --> 03:00:50,884 THINGS THAT CAN BE DONE ONCE YOU 4849 03:00:50,884 --> 03:00:53,320 HAVE THESE DATA INFRASTRUCTURES. 4850 03:00:53,320 --> 03:00:55,722 FIRST COULD BE WRIST 4851 03:00:55,722 --> 03:00:59,793 STRATIFICATION, TO IDENTIFY 4852 03:00:59,793 --> 03:01:03,697 HIGH, MEDIUM LOW STRATA. 4853 03:01:03,697 --> 03:01:05,265 SECOND IS COHORTING, LOOK 4854 03:01:05,265 --> 03:01:07,234 LONGITUDINALLY ACROSS A TIME 4855 03:01:07,234 --> 03:01:07,467 PERIOD. 4856 03:01:07,467 --> 03:01:09,302 THIRD IS PREDICTION, AND WE'RE 4857 03:01:09,302 --> 03:01:12,272 NOW STARTING TO SEE WITH THINGS 4858 03:01:12,272 --> 03:01:16,643 SUCH AS EKG HOW WE MIGHT BE ABLE 4859 03:01:16,643 --> 03:01:18,612 TO PREDICT FIVE-YEAR MORTALITY. 4860 03:01:18,612 --> 03:01:19,579 THESE ARE EXTRAORDINARY. 4861 03:01:19,579 --> 03:01:25,519 WE'RE NOT TALKING ABOUT EKG, 4862 03:01:25,519 --> 03:01:26,520 CARDIAC RISK FACTORS. 4863 03:01:26,520 --> 03:01:30,791 I'M SAYING A TAKE A LOOK AT YOUR 4864 03:01:30,791 --> 03:01:33,460 EKG AND FIGURE OUT YOUR 4865 03:01:33,460 --> 03:01:34,494 LONG-TERM MORTALITY, SHORT AND 4866 03:01:34,494 --> 03:01:34,828 LONG. 4867 03:01:34,828 --> 03:01:37,330 AS WE GET INTO POWER OF A.I., WE 4868 03:01:37,330 --> 03:01:39,599 CAN ENVISION HOW THIS COULD BE 4869 03:01:39,599 --> 03:01:40,834 APPLIED WITH WEARABLES DATA, 4870 03:01:40,834 --> 03:01:42,469 WITH THE FITNESS DATA, WITH 4871 03:01:42,469 --> 03:01:45,872 ACTIVITY, THE SLEEP, I MEAN, THE 4872 03:01:45,872 --> 03:01:46,673 GENERALIZABILITY AROUND YOUR 4873 03:01:46,673 --> 03:01:48,275 OVERALL HEALTH IN TERMS OF 4874 03:01:48,275 --> 03:01:50,143 INCORPORATING THAT INTO THIS 4875 03:01:50,143 --> 03:01:51,011 MAKES THE DATASETS FAR MORE 4876 03:01:51,011 --> 03:01:53,079 ROBUST BUT IT'S ALL DONE IN 4877 03:01:53,079 --> 03:01:54,214 CONTEXT OF NOT ONLY WHAT'S 4878 03:01:54,214 --> 03:01:56,283 HAPPENING AT THAT MOMENT BUT 4879 03:01:56,283 --> 03:01:57,551 ALSO OUTCOMES ASSOCIATED WITH 4880 03:01:57,551 --> 03:01:58,218 THAT LONGITUDINALLY. 4881 03:01:58,218 --> 03:01:59,719 AND I THINK THAT'S ONE OF THE 4882 03:01:59,719 --> 03:02:00,921 EXCITING THINGS BECAUSE WE'RE 4883 03:02:00,921 --> 03:02:02,889 NOW STARTING TO SEE SYSTEMS 4884 03:02:02,889 --> 03:02:05,192 BEING BUILT THAT ALLOW US TO 4885 03:02:05,192 --> 03:02:07,828 MAKE THESE LARGE 4886 03:02:07,828 --> 03:02:08,595 GENERALIZATIONS. 4887 03:02:08,595 --> 03:02:10,230 IT'S AN EXCITING TIME. 4888 03:02:10,230 --> 03:02:11,464 THE NEXT QUESTION ABOUT 4889 03:02:11,464 --> 03:02:13,066 RESEARCH, WHERE IS IT THAT WE'RE 4890 03:02:13,066 --> 03:02:14,601 HEADING IN TERMS OF RESEARCH? 4891 03:02:14,601 --> 03:02:15,702 WHAT IS THE OPPORTUNITY? 4892 03:02:15,702 --> 03:02:18,004 IS THE RESEARCH IN TERMS OF MORE 4893 03:02:18,004 --> 03:02:21,942 SENSORS, IN TERMS OF A.I., IS IT 4894 03:02:21,942 --> 03:02:23,310 IN TERMS OF MULTI-MODAL, 4895 03:02:23,310 --> 03:02:26,746 ENGAGEMENT, IS IT ALL OF THE 4896 03:02:26,746 --> 03:02:27,180 ABOVE? 4897 03:02:27,180 --> 03:02:28,081 YOU KNOW, DEMONSTRATING ROI? 4898 03:02:28,081 --> 03:02:30,250 MAYBE I'LL START WITH YOU, LOK, 4899 03:02:30,250 --> 03:02:32,118 I'D LOVE TO GET YOUR TAKE IN 4900 03:02:32,118 --> 03:02:35,589 TERMS WHERE DO YOU SEE RESEARCH 4901 03:02:35,589 --> 03:02:36,723 HEADING, WHAT ADVICE DO YOU HAVE 4902 03:02:36,723 --> 03:02:38,058 FOR RESEARCHERS IF THEY ARE 4903 03:02:38,058 --> 03:02:39,826 INTERESTED IN TAKING ADVANTAGE 4904 03:02:39,826 --> 03:02:40,894 OF ALL THIS OPPORTUNITY? 4905 03:02:40,894 --> 03:02:42,662 >> SO I WAS GOING TO SAY WITH 4906 03:02:42,662 --> 03:02:45,065 OPPORTUNITY COMES GREAT RISK AS 4907 03:02:45,065 --> 03:02:45,398 WELL. 4908 03:02:45,398 --> 03:02:47,701 USUALLY IT'S FLIPPED THE OTHER 4909 03:02:47,701 --> 03:02:48,134 WAY. 4910 03:02:48,134 --> 03:02:50,670 ONE OF THE CHALLENGES I THINK 4911 03:02:50,670 --> 03:02:52,038 ESPECIALLY WITH THE WEARABLE 4912 03:02:52,038 --> 03:02:54,641 DEVICE DATA IS THIS IS NOT A 4913 03:02:54,641 --> 03:02:55,642 REPRESENTATIVE POPULATION. 4914 03:02:55,642 --> 03:02:57,143 AND YOU WANT TO GENERATE 4915 03:02:57,143 --> 03:02:58,712 RESEARCH FINDINGS THAT COULD BE 4916 03:02:58,712 --> 03:03:02,282 APPLIED ESPECIALLY TO THE 4917 03:03:02,282 --> 03:03:03,183 UNDERSERVED, THOSE WITH SPECIAL 4918 03:03:03,183 --> 03:03:03,617 NEEDS. 4919 03:03:03,617 --> 03:03:04,651 I THINK THAT'S ONE OF THE 4920 03:03:04,651 --> 03:03:06,119 CHALLENGES WITH THE A.I. 4921 03:03:06,119 --> 03:03:07,654 APPLICATIONS, WE WANT TO MAKE 4922 03:03:07,654 --> 03:03:14,828 SURE WE'RE NOT CREATING BIAS 4923 03:03:14,828 --> 03:03:15,362 THROUGH MACHINE LEARNING 4924 03:03:15,362 --> 03:03:16,263 APPLICATIONS BECAUSE OF WHERE 4925 03:03:16,263 --> 03:03:18,798 THE DATA IS COMING FROM. 4926 03:03:18,798 --> 03:03:19,966 ALSO THINKING ABOUT THE 4927 03:03:19,966 --> 03:03:21,835 DIFFERENT TIMES OF DATA, 4928 03:03:21,835 --> 03:03:23,003 WEARABLE DATA CURRENTLY ISN'T 4929 03:03:23,003 --> 03:03:24,771 CONSIDERED HEALTH CARE DATA. 4930 03:03:24,771 --> 03:03:26,840 RESEARCHERS REALLY DON'T HAVE 4931 03:03:26,840 --> 03:03:30,777 ACCESS TO IT EXCEPT THROUGH 4932 03:03:30,777 --> 03:03:32,312 SCRAPING IN VARIOUS WAYS. 4933 03:03:32,312 --> 03:03:33,980 I DON'T WANT TO TALK ABOUT THOSE 4934 03:03:33,980 --> 03:03:35,382 DIFFERENT METHODS. 4935 03:03:35,382 --> 03:03:37,384 WE HAVE TO THINK HOW IS IT 4936 03:03:37,384 --> 03:03:38,785 PATIENTS WANT THIS DATA TO BE 4937 03:03:38,785 --> 03:03:42,822 USED FOR THEIR OWN HEALTH, FOR 4938 03:03:42,822 --> 03:03:43,490 PARTICIPATING POTENTIALLY IN 4939 03:03:43,490 --> 03:03:46,026 RESEARCH, AS WELL AS WHAT THEY 4940 03:03:46,026 --> 03:03:49,663 WANT TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE 4941 03:03:49,663 --> 03:03:50,397 HEALTHCARE ECOSYSTEM. 4942 03:03:50,397 --> 03:03:51,965 >> YEAH, YOU BRING UP A GOOD 4943 03:03:51,965 --> 03:03:52,165 POINT. 4944 03:03:52,165 --> 03:03:54,567 WE HAVEN'T TOUCHED ON THE WHOLE 4945 03:03:54,567 --> 03:03:57,437 CONCEPT OF BIAS IN THE DATASETS. 4946 03:03:57,437 --> 03:04:00,140 YOU KNOW, TO TRY TO CREATE THESE 4947 03:04:00,140 --> 03:04:03,743 MODELS WE DO NEED MORE 4948 03:04:03,743 --> 03:04:04,644 GENERALIZABILITY BUT WHO IS 4949 03:04:04,644 --> 03:04:06,379 PARTICIPATING IN HOW WE CAPTURE 4950 03:04:06,379 --> 03:04:09,115 THE DATA, AND WHAT CAN WE DO TO 4951 03:04:09,115 --> 03:04:10,450 ADDRESS THOSE ISSUES AROUND 4952 03:04:10,450 --> 03:04:14,487 BIAS? 4953 03:04:14,487 --> 03:04:15,188 LOK, YOUR THOUGHTS THERE? 4954 03:04:15,188 --> 03:04:17,557 >> I THINK THIS IS PROBABLY 4955 03:04:17,557 --> 03:04:18,658 WHERE THERE'S OPPORTUNITY FOR 4956 03:04:18,658 --> 03:04:20,060 RESEARCH WHERE YOU MIGHT WANT TO 4957 03:04:20,060 --> 03:04:22,929 DO A CLINICAL TRIAL IN AN 4958 03:04:22,929 --> 03:04:23,797 UNDERSERVED POPULATION, PEOPLE 4959 03:04:23,797 --> 03:04:27,334 WHO ARE CURRENTLY NOT WEARING 4960 03:04:27,334 --> 03:04:28,935 DEVICES, FIND OUT WHAT WORKS FOR 4961 03:04:28,935 --> 03:04:32,238 THEM, HOW DOES IT FIT INTO THEIR 4962 03:04:32,238 --> 03:04:32,505 LIFESTYLE. 4963 03:04:32,505 --> 03:04:34,107 IF I'M A CLEANER I'M RUNNING UP 4964 03:04:34,107 --> 03:04:35,175 AND DOWNSTAIRS ALL DAY, I DON'T 4965 03:04:35,175 --> 03:04:36,509 NEED TO COUNT MY STEPS. 4966 03:04:36,509 --> 03:04:41,648 BUT MIGHT HAVE SOME JOINT 4967 03:04:41,648 --> 03:04:42,515 ISSUES, CHOLESTEROL ISSUES, SO 4968 03:04:42,515 --> 03:04:44,384 WE'RE REALLY TRYING TO MAKE THE 4969 03:04:44,384 --> 03:04:50,090 DEVICES WORK NOT ONLY FOR 4970 03:04:50,090 --> 03:04:51,391 RESEARCHERS AND HEALTH CARE 4971 03:04:51,391 --> 03:04:53,560 SYSTEM BUT FOR THE PERSON TO 4972 03:04:53,560 --> 03:04:56,896 MOTIVATE THEIR BEHAVIOR CHANGE. 4973 03:04:56,896 --> 03:04:59,499 >> SACNIN, YOU DO A LOT OF 4974 03:04:59,499 --> 03:05:00,800 RESEARCH, WHAT ARE YOU SEEING 4975 03:05:00,800 --> 03:05:01,768 NOW AND AHEAD? 4976 03:05:01,768 --> 03:05:03,970 >> YOU KNOW, I THINK WE'RE 4977 03:05:03,970 --> 03:05:07,007 SEEING AN EVOLUTION HERE, 4978 03:05:07,007 --> 03:05:08,675 HISTORICAL PERCEPTIONS ON 4979 03:05:08,675 --> 03:05:10,410 UNDERSERVED POPULATIONS NOT 4980 03:05:10,410 --> 03:05:13,279 BEING INTERESTED OR ABLE TO 4981 03:05:13,279 --> 03:05:15,215 PARTICIPATE IN THESE TRIALS. 4982 03:05:15,215 --> 03:05:16,783 THOSE PERCEPTIONS HAVE BEEN 4983 03:05:16,783 --> 03:05:17,984 PROVEN TO BE INVALID. 4984 03:05:17,984 --> 03:05:20,954 THE NIH HAS DONE NEAT WORK, THE 4985 03:05:20,954 --> 03:05:23,356 RULE STUDY, NIH FUNDED THAT 4986 03:05:23,356 --> 03:05:25,658 STUDY IN CARDIOVASCULAR 4987 03:05:25,658 --> 03:05:26,493 MEDICINE, MOVING BEYOND LIKE 4988 03:05:26,493 --> 03:05:30,130 FRAMINGHAM HEART STUDY, A 4989 03:05:30,130 --> 03:05:31,331 CURATED HOMOGENOUS POPULATION 4990 03:05:31,331 --> 03:05:32,766 HANDING OUT DATA PLAN GIFT CARDS 4991 03:05:32,766 --> 03:05:33,633 TO FOLKS. 4992 03:05:33,633 --> 03:05:36,836 THE FOLKS THAT WERE IN THE 4993 03:05:36,836 --> 03:05:37,670 MISSING FROM THE HISTORICAL 4994 03:05:37,670 --> 03:05:38,905 STUDIES ARE NOW IN THERE. 4995 03:05:38,905 --> 03:05:42,742 IN OUR STUDY OF THOUSANDS OF 4996 03:05:42,742 --> 03:05:44,511 PARTICIPANTS THAT WE ENROLLED, 4997 03:05:44,511 --> 03:05:46,813 MICHIGAN HAS A RELATIVELY 4998 03:05:46,813 --> 03:05:48,114 NON-DIVERSE PATIENT POPULATION 4999 03:05:48,114 --> 03:05:52,385 SO WE ASKED MORE -- HAD SPECIFIC 5000 03:05:52,385 --> 03:05:54,921 ENROLLMENT TARGETS TO MAKE SURE 5001 03:05:54,921 --> 03:05:58,191 SAMPLE SIZES WERE ADEQUATE FOR 5002 03:05:58,191 --> 03:05:59,726 INFERENCE AT INDIVIDUAL LEVEL 5003 03:05:59,726 --> 03:06:02,228 AND SAW GREAT UPTAKE, GREAT 5004 03:06:02,228 --> 03:06:02,529 INVOLVEMENT. 5005 03:06:02,529 --> 03:06:05,532 BUT WHEN YOU ENGAGE COMMUNITY 5006 03:06:05,532 --> 03:06:07,600 PARTNERS, I THINK MISTRUST IS 5007 03:06:07,600 --> 03:06:07,934 THERE. 5008 03:06:07,934 --> 03:06:11,671 WHAT WE'RE AT NOW IS DATASETS 5009 03:06:11,671 --> 03:06:13,440 ARE OUT, THERE "ALL OF US" US 5010 03:06:13,440 --> 03:06:16,810 HAS TEN OR TWENTY THOUSAND 5011 03:06:16,810 --> 03:06:19,212 FOLKS, DIVERSE POPULATIONS. 5012 03:06:19,212 --> 03:06:20,947 I THINK OUR DIGITAL DIVIDE 5013 03:06:20,947 --> 03:06:24,350 CLOSURE IS MOVING FASTER THAN 5014 03:06:24,350 --> 03:06:26,119 OUR HEALTHCARE DIVIDE CLOSURE. 5015 03:06:26,119 --> 03:06:31,891 SO THE DISPARITIES IN HEALTHCARE 5016 03:06:31,891 --> 03:06:33,760 OUTCOMES BY RACE, 5017 03:06:33,760 --> 03:06:34,360 SOCIOSOCIOECONOMIC STATUS ARE 5018 03:06:34,360 --> 03:06:36,729 WIDE BUT GETTING DATA REGARDING 5019 03:06:36,729 --> 03:06:38,465 DIVERSE POPULATIONS, UNDERSERVED 5020 03:06:38,465 --> 03:06:43,937 POPULATIONS IS GETTING NARROW 5021 03:06:43,937 --> 03:06:45,805 RAPIDLY SO I'M QUITE OPTIMISTIC 5022 03:06:45,805 --> 03:06:48,408 BECAUSE I THINK WE'RE DOING 5023 03:06:48,408 --> 03:06:49,843 BETTER WITH RESEARCH THAN WITH 5024 03:06:49,843 --> 03:06:52,712 HEALTH CARE IN THIS AREA. 5025 03:06:52,712 --> 03:06:55,648 >> IF I'M A RESEARCHER, I WANT 5026 03:06:55,648 --> 03:06:57,383 TO EXPLORE AN UNADDRESSED 5027 03:06:57,383 --> 03:06:58,718 QUESTION, ONE THAT'S PRESSING, 5028 03:06:58,718 --> 03:06:59,686 IMPORTANT, WHAT WOULD YOUR 5029 03:06:59,686 --> 03:07:01,121 RECOMMENDATION BE? 5030 03:07:01,121 --> 03:07:01,855 WHERE SHOULD I FOCUS? 5031 03:07:01,855 --> 03:07:10,430 WHAT ARE SOME AREAS I SHOULD 5032 03:07:10,430 --> 03:07:11,297 LOOK AT? 5033 03:07:11,297 --> 03:07:13,066 >> START WITH JOE. 5034 03:07:13,066 --> 03:07:13,967 >> WHAT'S PUBLISHABLE? 5035 03:07:13,967 --> 03:07:16,603 >> THIS IS MY OWN BIAS, FOR 5036 03:07:16,603 --> 03:07:16,903 SURE. 5037 03:07:16,903 --> 03:07:18,838 ONE THOUGH I THINK THAT WE 5038 03:07:18,838 --> 03:07:20,540 TALKED ABOUT THIS SEVERAL TIMES, 5039 03:07:20,540 --> 03:07:21,841 WITH THE PSYCHOLOGY OF GETTING 5040 03:07:21,841 --> 03:07:25,378 PEOPLE TO ENGAGE WITH THEIR DATA 5041 03:07:25,378 --> 03:07:26,980 AND CHANGE THEIR BEHAVIORS. 5042 03:07:26,980 --> 03:07:28,982 IT'S STILL A BIG GOOSE EGG. 5043 03:07:28,982 --> 03:07:30,483 WE HAVEN'T FIGURED THAT OUT. 5044 03:07:30,483 --> 03:07:40,994 I LOVE IT WHEN I GET MULTI--- 5045 03:07:41,194 --> 03:07:44,430 DIFFERENT GROUPS TOGETHER DATA 5046 03:07:44,430 --> 03:07:45,298 SCIENTISTS, WEARABLE EXPERTS 5047 03:07:45,298 --> 03:07:46,399 TRYING TO SOLVE STUFF. 5048 03:07:46,399 --> 03:07:50,470 WE DIDN'T TALK ABOUT IT, BUT 5049 03:07:50,470 --> 03:07:51,337 JUST TO POINT AT LARGE LANGUAGE 5050 03:07:51,337 --> 03:07:53,206 MODEL IS THE THREE WORDS ON 5051 03:07:53,206 --> 03:07:56,176 EVERY SUBMISSION THESE DAYS. 5052 03:07:56,176 --> 03:08:06,719 IT'S BECAUSE PEOPLE SEE SO MANY 5053 03:08:08,154 --> 03:08:12,725 NICHE SETS, BUT THEY STILL HAVE 5054 03:08:12,725 --> 03:08:13,693 HALLUCINATIONSES, IF YOU CAN 5055 03:08:13,693 --> 03:08:15,895 SOLVE THAT THAT'S GOING TO MOVE 5056 03:08:15,895 --> 03:08:18,298 US A DECADE FORWARD QUICKLY. 5057 03:08:18,298 --> 03:08:19,732 THOSE ARE TWO AREAS THAT NEED A 5058 03:08:19,732 --> 03:08:20,833 LOT OF WORK. 5059 03:08:20,833 --> 03:08:24,771 MULTI-MODAL AS I SAID THAT'S A 5060 03:08:24,771 --> 03:08:26,172 BIG ONE. 5061 03:08:26,172 --> 03:08:28,508 RETRIEVAL, AUGMENTED GENERATION 5062 03:08:28,508 --> 03:08:28,942 IS THOUGHT. 5063 03:08:28,942 --> 03:08:31,144 AGENTIC A.I. IS HOT. 5064 03:08:31,144 --> 03:08:33,646 I DON'T MEAN TO BE BLABBERING 5065 03:08:33,646 --> 03:08:35,114 OFF JARGON BUT THOSE ARE THINGS 5066 03:08:35,114 --> 03:08:37,383 WE SEE A LOT OF. 5067 03:08:37,383 --> 03:08:39,886 >> WE'RE CLOSING ON TIME. 5068 03:08:39,886 --> 03:08:41,187 WE'VE GOT ANOTHER QUESTION HERE, 5069 03:08:41,187 --> 03:08:51,464 DO YOU THINK A.I. WILL HELP WITH 5070 03:08:51,464 --> 03:08:52,999 EHR SYNCHRONIZATION, NAVIGATING 5071 03:08:52,999 --> 03:08:54,934 VARIOUS EHRs ARE A NIGHTMARE 5072 03:08:54,934 --> 03:08:56,569 FOR PHYSICIANS, OPEN TO THE 5073 03:08:56,569 --> 03:08:56,936 GROUP. 5074 03:08:56,936 --> 03:08:58,304 WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS THERE? 5075 03:08:58,304 --> 03:08:59,505 >> I DON'T THINK IT'S A 5076 03:08:59,505 --> 03:09:00,173 TECHNOLOGY PROBLEM. 5077 03:09:00,173 --> 03:09:03,610 I THINK IT'S A BUSINESS MODEL 5078 03:09:03,610 --> 03:09:05,845 PROBLEM. 5079 03:09:05,845 --> 03:09:07,547 PEOPLE THAT ARE IN THAT BUSINESS 5080 03:09:07,547 --> 03:09:09,315 WANT TO BUILD WALLS SO YOU DON'T 5081 03:09:09,315 --> 03:09:10,516 SWITCH RECORD SYSTEMS AND SO 5082 03:09:10,516 --> 03:09:13,519 THEY DON'T TALK TO ONE ANOTHER. 5083 03:09:13,519 --> 03:09:18,825 >> DO WE FEEL THAT SOME OF THE 5084 03:09:18,825 --> 03:09:22,228 CURRENT WORK UNDERWAY AROUND 5085 03:09:22,228 --> 03:09:23,029 FHIR STANDARDS, STANDARDIZATION, 5086 03:09:23,029 --> 03:09:24,697 IS THAT GOING TO MAKE PROGRESS 5087 03:09:24,697 --> 03:09:29,002 OR IS IT -- 5088 03:09:29,002 --> 03:09:30,570 >> AT SOME POINT. 5089 03:09:30,570 --> 03:09:32,772 I REMEMBER WHEN DICOM WAS THERE, 5090 03:09:32,772 --> 03:09:34,407 IT DIDN'T WORK, NOW IT WORKS. 5091 03:09:34,407 --> 03:09:37,944 LIKE THE CHEESE MOVES. 5092 03:09:37,944 --> 03:09:41,514 RIGHT NOW, EPIC AND CERNER OF 5093 03:09:41,514 --> 03:09:44,150 THE WORLD DOESN'T WANT TO GIVE 5094 03:09:44,150 --> 03:09:47,253 AN INCH BUT MAYBE ZY SOMEDAY TY 5095 03:09:47,253 --> 03:09:48,121 WILL BE YESTERDAY'S THOUGHT, 5096 03:09:48,121 --> 03:09:50,623 SOMETHING ELSE THEY WILL FIGHT 5097 03:09:50,623 --> 03:09:50,857 OVER. 5098 03:09:50,857 --> 03:09:53,026 >> I'LL CLOSE WITH A TOPIC THAT 5099 03:09:53,026 --> 03:09:54,560 COULD BE ANOTHER THING WE COULD 5100 03:09:54,560 --> 03:09:58,865 SPEND AN HOUR ON. 5101 03:09:58,865 --> 03:10:04,203 MASS GENERAL BRIGHAM, WHERE JOE, 5102 03:10:04,203 --> 03:10:05,405 YOU WORK, SACHIN, MICHIGAN 5103 03:10:05,405 --> 03:10:08,241 MEDICINE, AND 48 OUR HEALTH 5104 03:10:08,241 --> 03:10:11,811 SYSTEMS ARE WORKING TOGETHER ON 5105 03:10:11,811 --> 03:10:13,379 THE TRUSTWORTHY RESPONSIBLE A.I. 5106 03:10:13,379 --> 03:10:14,580 NETWORK, TRAIN. 5107 03:10:14,580 --> 03:10:16,883 ONE OBJECTIVE IS TO HELP SYSTEMS 5108 03:10:16,883 --> 03:10:21,254 DEAL WITH THE AMOUNT OF A.I. 5109 03:10:21,254 --> 03:10:22,789 COMING THEIR WAY, TRY TO 5110 03:10:22,789 --> 03:10:24,223 DISTRIBUTE WORKLOAD BY WORKING 5111 03:10:24,223 --> 03:10:25,625 WITH OTHER SITES TO NOT ONLY 5112 03:10:25,625 --> 03:10:28,928 CHOOSE WHAT A.I. IS APPROPRIATE 5113 03:10:28,928 --> 03:10:31,531 TO MEASURE BUT ALSO STANDARDIZE 5114 03:10:31,531 --> 03:10:34,067 ON IMPLEMENTATION AND ON THE 5115 03:10:34,067 --> 03:10:34,400 MEASUREMENTS. 5116 03:10:34,400 --> 03:10:36,803 IF SITES COULD DO THAT, EACH 5117 03:10:36,803 --> 03:10:39,005 SITE DOING IT FOCUSED ON A 5118 03:10:39,005 --> 03:10:39,505 PARTICULAR QUESTION, OR 5119 03:10:39,505 --> 03:10:44,677 PARTICULAR A.I., WE MAY BE ABLE 5120 03:10:44,677 --> 03:10:46,079 TO CAPTURE THAT INFORMATION 5121 03:10:46,079 --> 03:10:48,281 WITHIN EACH SITE, AND THEN BE 5122 03:10:48,281 --> 03:10:51,384 ABLE TO CREATE FEDERATED A.I. 5123 03:10:51,384 --> 03:10:52,285 OUTCOMES REGISTRY. 5124 03:10:52,285 --> 03:10:57,090 SO THROWING TO THE GROUP, 5125 03:10:57,090 --> 03:10:59,625 BECAUSE OF THE FACT REGISTRIES 5126 03:10:59,625 --> 03:11:01,594 ARE A VALUABLE WAY TO STIMULATE 5127 03:11:01,594 --> 03:11:03,463 RESEARCH AND GATHER INFORMATION 5128 03:11:03,463 --> 03:11:06,399 IN A STANDARDIZED MANNER ACROSS 5129 03:11:06,399 --> 03:11:10,236 SYSTEMS WHILE MAINTAINING DATA 5130 03:11:10,236 --> 03:11:10,803 PROVENANCE THROUGH FEDERATED 5131 03:11:10,803 --> 03:11:12,505 MECHANISMS PERHAPS THAT COULD BE 5132 03:11:12,505 --> 03:11:14,841 ANOTHER AREA, AND SO FINAL 5133 03:11:14,841 --> 03:11:18,811 THOUGHTS ON THAT, DUMB IDEA, 5134 03:11:18,811 --> 03:11:25,351 SMART IDEA, INTERESTING IDEA? 5135 03:11:25,351 --> 03:11:32,058 >> I THINK IT'S A FABULOUS IDEA. 5136 03:11:32,058 --> 03:11:33,426 >> CERTAINLY A LOT OF 5137 03:11:33,426 --> 03:11:34,427 OPPORTUNITY FOR RESEARCHERS AS 5138 03:11:34,427 --> 03:11:36,496 WE LOOK INTO THIS SPACE. 5139 03:11:36,496 --> 03:11:39,665 I WANT TO MAYBE GIVE ONE FINAL 5140 03:11:39,665 --> 03:11:40,433 OPPORTUNITY, FINAL CLOSING 5141 03:11:40,433 --> 03:11:41,868 THOUGHTS, WHERE ARE WE HEADING 5142 03:11:41,868 --> 03:11:45,171 IN THE FUTURE, ANY 5143 03:11:45,171 --> 03:11:47,707 RECOMMENDATIONS, WE'LL GO LOK, 5144 03:11:47,707 --> 03:11:48,908 SACHIN, AND JOE. 5145 03:11:48,908 --> 03:11:51,411 >> JUST TO GO BACK TO THE POLICY 5146 03:11:51,411 --> 03:11:54,680 QUESTION, LOOKS LIKE THE HILL IS 5147 03:11:54,680 --> 03:11:55,548 CONTEMPLATING EXTENDING MEDICARE 5148 03:11:55,548 --> 03:11:56,783 TELEHEALTH FLEXIBILITY FOR 5149 03:11:56,783 --> 03:11:59,185 ANOTHER TWO YEARS, SO I GUESS 5150 03:11:59,185 --> 03:12:02,789 WE'RE PUNTING THIS ISSUE DOWN 5151 03:12:02,789 --> 03:12:06,526 THE ROAD. 5152 03:12:06,526 --> 03:12:06,993 >> OKAY. 5153 03:12:06,993 --> 03:12:09,862 POLICY-WISE, MORE PUNTING. 5154 03:12:09,862 --> 03:12:10,096 SACHIN? 5155 03:12:10,096 --> 03:12:13,866 >> CONTINUED EFFORTS IN 5156 03:12:13,866 --> 03:12:14,534 DECENTRALIZED AND NON-HEALTHCARE 5157 03:12:14,534 --> 03:12:17,804 SYSTEM BASED EFFORTS TO EVALUATE 5158 03:12:17,804 --> 03:12:19,238 THESE TECHNOLOGY, MEETING 5159 03:12:19,238 --> 03:12:20,106 PATIENTS WHERE THEY ARE, WHICH 5160 03:12:20,106 --> 03:12:22,375 DOESN'T HAVE TO WALK THROUGH OUR 5161 03:12:22,375 --> 03:12:24,076 ACADEMIC MEDICAL CENTER FRONT 5162 03:12:24,076 --> 03:12:26,813 WALL, FRONT DOOR IS THE KEY. 5163 03:12:26,813 --> 03:12:29,415 >> ABSOLUTELY. 5164 03:12:29,415 --> 03:12:29,582 JOE? 5165 03:12:29,582 --> 03:12:31,617 >> AGAIN THE IDEA OF OMNI 5166 03:12:31,617 --> 03:12:33,386 CHANNEL CARE, DEVELOPING IT OUT. 5167 03:12:33,386 --> 03:12:36,422 IT'S NOT UNLIKE WHAT SACHIN, 5168 03:12:36,422 --> 03:12:37,957 IT'S A DIGITAL FRONT-DOOR 5169 03:12:37,957 --> 03:12:38,191 CONCEPT. 5170 03:12:38,191 --> 03:12:40,159 WE'RE SO POOR AT THAT RIGHT NOW. 5171 03:12:40,159 --> 03:12:42,762 IT'S SAD, THERE'S SO MANY OTHER 5172 03:12:42,762 --> 03:12:43,996 INITIATIVES DOING SO MUCH BETTER 5173 03:12:43,996 --> 03:12:46,399 THAN WE ARE, I HOPE WE CAN GET 5174 03:12:46,399 --> 03:12:46,599 THERE. 5175 03:12:46,599 --> 03:12:48,134 >> IT'S BEEN A PLEASURE HAVING A 5176 03:12:48,134 --> 03:12:49,569 CONVERSATION WITH ALL THREE OF 5177 03:12:49,569 --> 03:12:49,969 YOU. 5178 03:12:49,969 --> 03:12:52,939 THANK YOU ALL FOR LISTENING IN. 5179 03:12:52,939 --> 03:12:54,373 WE'RE GOING TO CLOSE OUR PART OF 5180 03:12:54,373 --> 03:12:57,343 THE SESSION AND HAND IT BACK TO 5181 03:12:57,343 --> 03:12:58,044 THE FACILITATORS. 5182 03:12:58,044 --> 03:12:59,312 AND WE'RE BACK ON TIME. 5183 03:12:59,312 --> 03:13:01,514 SO THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR TIME 5184 03:13:01,514 --> 03:13:02,415 AND LOOKING FORWARD TO HEARING 5185 03:13:02,415 --> 03:13:05,618 THE REST OF THE PROGRAM. 5186 03:13:05,618 --> 03:13:06,652 >> THANK YOU. 5187 03:13:06,652 --> 03:13:08,421 >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR EVERY 5188 03:13:08,421 --> 03:13:10,056 ONE OF THESE SESSIONS, 5189 03:13:10,056 --> 03:13:11,324 PHENOMENAL DISCUSSION. 5190 03:13:11,324 --> 03:13:13,993 NOW WE MOVE FOR SOME CLOSING 5191 03:13:13,993 --> 03:13:14,961 REMARKS BY DR. MENSAH. 5192 03:13:14,961 --> 03:13:16,829 AGAIN, DON'T GO AWAY. 5193 03:13:16,829 --> 03:13:23,002 WE HAVE MORE. 5194 03:13:23,002 --> 03:13:23,836 >> ALL RIGHT. 5195 03:13:23,836 --> 03:13:26,973 THANK YOU, FERNANDO. 5196 03:13:26,973 --> 03:13:30,109 WHAT A REALLY FANTASTIC 5197 03:13:30,109 --> 03:13:31,611 PRACTICAL MEANINGFUL SUBSTANTIVE 5198 03:13:31,611 --> 03:13:32,011 WORKSHOP. 5199 03:13:32,011 --> 03:13:34,046 WE CAN'T THANK YOU ENOUGH. 5200 03:13:34,046 --> 03:13:38,084 BUT AS WE BRING THIS WORKSHOP TO 5201 03:13:38,084 --> 03:13:43,022 A CLOSE, I'D LIKE TO REFLECT ON 5202 03:13:43,022 --> 03:13:48,060 THE STIMULATING DISCUSSIONS, 5203 03:13:48,060 --> 03:13:49,028 INVALUABLE INSIGHTS, PRACTICAL 5204 03:13:49,028 --> 03:13:50,997 TAKEHOME MESSAGES AND UNIQUE 5205 03:13:50,997 --> 03:13:51,931 OPPORTUNITIES YOU HELPED US 5206 03:13:51,931 --> 03:13:54,700 IDENTIFY FOR US IN THE CENTER 5207 03:13:54,700 --> 03:13:56,469 FOR TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH AND 5208 03:13:56,469 --> 03:13:58,538 IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE, CTRIS, 5209 03:13:58,538 --> 03:14:00,840 AND EVEN MORE BROADLY FOR ALL OF 5210 03:14:00,840 --> 03:14:03,676 US AS COLLEAGUE OF NHLBI AND ALL 5211 03:14:03,676 --> 03:14:04,644 OF NIH. 5212 03:14:04,644 --> 03:14:07,046 SO FIRST, I WANT TO EXTEND MY 5213 03:14:07,046 --> 03:14:10,349 DEEPEST GRATITUDE TO EACH OF YOU 5214 03:14:10,349 --> 03:14:12,852 FOR YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS TO THIS 5215 03:14:12,852 --> 03:14:13,286 IMPORTANT WORKSHOP. 5216 03:14:13,286 --> 03:14:14,787 THIS IS A REALLY BUSY TIME OF 5217 03:14:14,787 --> 03:14:17,123 YEAR FOR ALL OF YOU. 5218 03:14:17,123 --> 03:14:19,325 SO WE REALLY, REALLY APPRECIATE 5219 03:14:19,325 --> 03:14:22,094 YOU TAKING THE TIME TO PREPARE, 5220 03:14:22,094 --> 03:14:25,598 AND TO CONTRIBUTE TO MAKING THIS 5221 03:14:25,598 --> 03:14:27,767 WORKSHOP SO SUCCESSFUL. 5222 03:14:27,767 --> 03:14:29,302 YOU KNOW, OUR JOURNEY INTO 5223 03:14:29,302 --> 03:14:34,006 UNDERSTAND THE CURRENT USE OF 5224 03:14:34,006 --> 03:14:34,607 DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER TELEHEALTH 5225 03:14:34,607 --> 03:14:36,876 AND LESSONS LEARNED, THAT 5226 03:14:36,876 --> 03:14:39,645 JOURNEY HAS BEEN ENLIGHTENING, 5227 03:14:39,645 --> 03:14:41,147 HAS BEEN INSPIRING, AND HAS EVEN 5228 03:14:41,147 --> 03:14:46,986 BEEN MADE MORE RICH BECAUSE OF 5229 03:14:46,986 --> 03:14:47,853 YOUR CONTRIBUTIONS. 5230 03:14:47,853 --> 03:14:49,488 THE CHALLENGES, ESPECIALLY THE 5231 03:14:49,488 --> 03:14:51,457 OPPORTUNITIES THAT YOU'VE HELPED 5232 03:14:51,457 --> 03:14:53,993 US IDENTIFY WILL GO A VERY, VERY 5233 03:14:53,993 --> 03:14:57,029 LONG WAY AS WE EXPLORE OVER THE 5234 03:14:57,029 --> 03:15:00,232 NEXT THREE TO FIVE YEARS AND 5235 03:15:00,232 --> 03:15:03,002 ESPECIALLY THE DECADE AHEAD, HOW 5236 03:15:03,002 --> 03:15:06,906 NHLBI CAN HELP LEVERAGE THE 5237 03:15:06,906 --> 03:15:08,774 TECHNOLOGICAL ADVANCEMENTS, 5238 03:15:08,774 --> 03:15:10,610 COUPLED WITH TRULY MEANINGFUL 5239 03:15:10,610 --> 03:15:12,345 ENGAGEMENT OF THE COMMUNITIES WE 5240 03:15:12,345 --> 03:15:15,982 SERVE, TO REALLY BEND THE CURVE 5241 03:15:15,982 --> 03:15:19,485 TOWARDS TRULY TRANSFORMATIVE 5242 03:15:19,485 --> 03:15:21,454 CHANGE IN DIRECT-TO CONSUMER 5243 03:15:21,454 --> 03:15:22,855 TELEHEALTH FOR ADVANCE ALSO 5244 03:15:22,855 --> 03:15:23,889 HEALTH FOR ALL. 5245 03:15:23,889 --> 03:15:26,993 DISCUSSIONS TODAY UNDERSCORED 5246 03:15:26,993 --> 03:15:29,128 THE CRITICAL IMPORTANCE OF 5247 03:15:29,128 --> 03:15:31,097 HEALTH EQUITY, PARTICULARLY IN 5248 03:15:31,097 --> 03:15:32,732 RURAL AND UNDERSERVED AREAS, AND 5249 03:15:32,732 --> 03:15:36,569 AS WE HEARD EVEN IN URBAN 5250 03:15:36,569 --> 03:15:38,204 CENTERS, THERE ARE UNDERSERVED 5251 03:15:38,204 --> 03:15:40,272 POPULATIONS FOR WHOM WE 5252 03:15:40,272 --> 03:15:41,807 SHOULDN'T FORGET. 5253 03:15:41,807 --> 03:15:44,443 IT'S CLEAR THAT WHILE TELEHEALTH 5254 03:15:44,443 --> 03:15:46,412 HOLDS TREMENDOUS PROMISE FOR 5255 03:15:46,412 --> 03:15:51,651 BRIDGING GAPS IN CARE, WE MUST 5256 03:15:51,651 --> 03:15:53,519 REMAIN VIGILANT ENSURING THESE 5257 03:15:53,519 --> 03:15:55,187 SOLUTIONS ARE INCLUSIVE AND 5258 03:15:55,187 --> 03:15:57,156 EQUITABLE FOR ALL COMMUNITIES, 5259 03:15:57,156 --> 03:15:59,592 THAT YOU WE DON'T NEED TO WIDEN 5260 03:15:59,592 --> 03:16:02,428 DISPARITIES THAT SEVERAL OF YOU 5261 03:16:02,428 --> 03:16:05,831 MENTIONED TODAY. 5262 03:16:05,831 --> 03:16:07,566 I'M VERY PARTICULARLY ENCOURAGED 5263 03:16:07,566 --> 03:16:09,568 BY INNOVATIVE IDEAS AND 5264 03:16:09,568 --> 03:16:12,071 POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS THAT EMERGED 5265 03:16:12,071 --> 03:16:12,738 FROM THE SESSIONS. 5266 03:16:12,738 --> 03:16:15,675 IN THE INTEREST OF TIME I WILL 5267 03:16:15,675 --> 03:16:18,077 NOT COMMENT ON SESSION 2 OR THE 5268 03:16:18,077 --> 03:16:20,746 REPORT-BACK FROM THE BREAKOUT 5269 03:16:20,746 --> 03:16:22,581 SESSIONS SINCE THOSE ARE FRESH 5270 03:16:22,581 --> 03:16:26,519 IN YOUR MIND SINCE WE JUST HAD 5271 03:16:26,519 --> 03:16:27,820 THOSE SESSIONS BUT I'LL COMMENT 5272 03:16:27,820 --> 03:16:29,221 ON A FEW THEMES FROM THE 5273 03:16:29,221 --> 03:16:29,455 MORNING. 5274 03:16:29,455 --> 03:16:32,625 WE BEGAN WITH DR. BRUNO AND DR. 5275 03:16:32,625 --> 03:16:34,593 LEWIS, WHO SHARED WITH US THE 5276 03:16:34,593 --> 03:16:36,696 REAL IMPORTANCE OF THIS WORKSHOP 5277 03:16:36,696 --> 03:16:38,764 WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF THE 5278 03:16:38,764 --> 03:16:42,702 STRATEGIC VISION GOALS AND 5279 03:16:42,702 --> 03:16:43,703 OBJECTIVES OF THE NATIONAL 5280 03:16:43,703 --> 03:16:49,575 HEART, LUNG AND BLOOD INSTITUTE 5281 03:16:49,575 --> 03:16:50,476 ESPECIALLY CENTER FOR 5282 03:16:50,476 --> 03:16:52,211 TRANSLATION RESEARCH. 5283 03:16:52,211 --> 03:16:53,879 WE JUST CELEBRATED OUR TENTH 5284 03:16:53,879 --> 03:16:56,382 ANNIVERSARY AND DR. LEWIS 5285 03:16:56,382 --> 03:16:58,350 INVITED YOU ON DECEMBER 11. 5286 03:16:58,350 --> 03:16:59,785 AFTER THAT CELEBRATION, AS WE 5287 03:16:59,785 --> 03:17:01,954 BEGIN TO CHART THE FUTURE OF THE 5288 03:17:01,954 --> 03:17:05,257 NEXT DECADE, WHAT WE'VE HEARD 5289 03:17:05,257 --> 03:17:07,660 FROM YOU TODAY IS GOING TO BE 5290 03:17:07,660 --> 03:17:07,893 CRUCIAL. 5291 03:17:07,893 --> 03:17:09,628 IN THE OPENING KEYNOTE 5292 03:17:09,628 --> 03:17:12,465 PRESENTATION WE HEARD FROM GARTH 5293 03:17:12,465 --> 03:17:14,967 GRAHAM WHO TOLD US NEIGHBORHOODS 5294 03:17:14,967 --> 03:17:17,069 MATTER FOR HEALTH. 5295 03:17:17,069 --> 03:17:19,271 MEANING WHERE WE LIVE HAS AN 5296 03:17:19,271 --> 03:17:23,642 IMPACT ON OUR HEALTH, AND THAT 5297 03:17:23,642 --> 03:17:24,844 TRUE PATIENT-CENTRIC CARE 5298 03:17:24,844 --> 03:17:28,013 REQUIRES REACHING PATIENTS WHERE 5299 03:17:28,013 --> 03:17:28,581 THEY ARE. 5300 03:17:28,581 --> 03:17:29,448 SO THERE ARE TREMENDOUS 5301 03:17:29,448 --> 03:17:31,083 OPPORTUNITIES FOR US. 5302 03:17:31,083 --> 03:17:33,285 HOW DO WE USE THE SEVEN DOMAINS 5303 03:17:33,285 --> 03:17:38,524 HE SHARED WITH US TO TRULY 5304 03:17:38,524 --> 03:17:44,563 TRANSFORM HEALTH OF PATIENTS AND 5305 03:17:44,563 --> 03:17:45,431 COMMUNITIES THROUGH 5306 03:17:45,431 --> 03:17:46,999 DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER TELEHEALTH 5307 03:17:46,999 --> 03:17:50,569 AND IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH. 5308 03:17:50,569 --> 03:17:52,538 HOW DO WE USE IMPLEMENTATION 5309 03:17:52,538 --> 03:17:54,473 STRATEGIES TO ENSURE OVERARCHING 5310 03:17:54,473 --> 03:17:55,741 PROMISE OF TELEMEDICINE IS MADE 5311 03:17:55,741 --> 03:17:57,143 REAL FOR PATIENTS OR PROVIDERS 5312 03:17:57,143 --> 03:17:59,345 AND ALSO FOR THE HEALTHCARE 5313 03:17:59,345 --> 03:18:01,013 SYSTEM AS A WHOLE. 5314 03:18:01,013 --> 03:18:05,284 HOW DO WE USE MULTI-CHANNEL 5315 03:18:05,284 --> 03:18:06,051 COMMUNICATION SCIENCE AND 5316 03:18:06,051 --> 03:18:07,253 DISSEMINATION RESEARCH TO ENSURE 5317 03:18:07,253 --> 03:18:11,624 THAT THE THREE TAKEHOME MESSAGES 5318 03:18:11,624 --> 03:18:14,260 HE SHARED REACH ALL AUDIENCES. 5319 03:18:14,260 --> 03:18:16,662 MANY EXAMPLES HE SHARED ABOUT 5320 03:18:16,662 --> 03:18:18,731 EVOLUTION OF TELEHEALTH AND 5321 03:18:18,731 --> 03:18:20,933 EXPERIENCES FROM MANY CLINICAL 5322 03:18:20,933 --> 03:18:24,737 PRACTICES DURING THE COVID 5323 03:18:24,737 --> 03:18:26,739 PANDEMIC, ESPECIALLY AROUND 5324 03:18:26,739 --> 03:18:27,573 PATIENT-PROVIDER RELATIONSHIPS, 5325 03:18:27,573 --> 03:18:29,341 THESE WILL ALL BE INVALUABLE AS 5326 03:18:29,341 --> 03:18:31,510 WE EXPLORE THE RESEARCH 5327 03:18:31,510 --> 03:18:31,844 OPPORTUNITIES. 5328 03:18:31,844 --> 03:18:34,079 SO WE THANK DR. GRAHAM FOR 5329 03:18:34,079 --> 03:18:35,815 GETTING US STARTED. 5330 03:18:35,815 --> 03:18:40,419 IN SESSION 1, AND RELATED SMALL 5331 03:18:40,419 --> 03:18:41,520 GROUP DISCUSSIONS, I THINK THEY 5332 03:18:41,520 --> 03:18:43,022 WERE FANTASTIC. 5333 03:18:43,022 --> 03:18:45,858 WE WENT BEYOND THE SCREEN AROUND 5334 03:18:45,858 --> 03:18:48,894 LEARNED ABOUT BEST PRACTICES IN 5335 03:18:48,894 --> 03:18:49,428 TELEHEALTH, IMPLEMENTATION 5336 03:18:49,428 --> 03:18:51,664 RESEARCH THAT CAN HAVE LASTING 5337 03:18:51,664 --> 03:18:51,897 IMPACT. 5338 03:18:51,897 --> 03:18:55,067 SO BIG THANK YOU TO MEGAN AND 5339 03:18:55,067 --> 03:18:58,003 KRISTIN AND THE TEAM AND JOHN 5340 03:18:58,003 --> 03:19:01,106 FOR THE WORK AND THE EXCITING 5341 03:19:01,106 --> 03:19:01,340 SESSION. 5342 03:19:01,340 --> 03:19:05,578 BUT REALLY WE HAD THE 5343 03:19:05,578 --> 03:19:07,213 OPPORTUNITY TO EXPLORE HOW WE 5344 03:19:07,213 --> 03:19:08,781 REINVENT CARE AND DO THINGS 5345 03:19:08,781 --> 03:19:09,949 DIFFERENTLY, NOT CONTINUE TO DO 5346 03:19:09,949 --> 03:19:12,017 THINGS THE SAME WAY. 5347 03:19:12,017 --> 03:19:14,320 WE HEARD THE CAVEAT THAT TO 5348 03:19:14,320 --> 03:19:16,088 THINK OF TELEHEALTH AS THE 5349 03:19:16,088 --> 03:19:17,790 ELEVATOR, FIRST TIME I HEARD 5350 03:19:17,790 --> 03:19:21,594 THAT EXPRESSION, BUT WHAT ARE 5351 03:19:21,594 --> 03:19:23,462 THE REAL PROMISING PRACTICES 5352 03:19:23,462 --> 03:19:26,198 AMONG THE TELEHEALTH MODALITIES 5353 03:19:26,198 --> 03:19:27,633 ESPECIALLY AS TELEHEALTH IS 5354 03:19:27,633 --> 03:19:31,437 LAUNCHED AND WE'RE LAUNCHED 5355 03:19:31,437 --> 03:19:32,638 MULTIPLE TIMES. 5356 03:19:32,638 --> 03:19:38,244 HOW DID WE ADDRESS ISSUES OF 5357 03:19:38,244 --> 03:19:39,445 RELUCTANCE, REENGAGEMENT, 5358 03:19:39,445 --> 03:19:40,446 TELEMEDICINE, WHAT STRATEGIES 5359 03:19:40,446 --> 03:19:43,582 CAN WE DEVELOP AND TEST TO 5360 03:19:43,582 --> 03:19:44,683 SUPPORT PROVIDERS? 5361 03:19:44,683 --> 03:19:46,752 IMPORTANTLY, HOW DO WE SUPPORT 5362 03:19:46,752 --> 03:19:48,053 TRAINING AND CAREER DEVELOPMENT 5363 03:19:48,053 --> 03:19:50,923 AND HOW WE BUILD THE FUTURE 5364 03:19:50,923 --> 03:19:52,124 GENERATION OF CLINICIANS, NOT 5365 03:19:52,124 --> 03:19:55,628 JUST PHYSICIANS BUT ALL 5366 03:19:55,628 --> 03:19:56,295 CLINICIANS, AND 5367 03:19:56,295 --> 03:19:58,397 CLINICIAN-SCIENTISTS, TO HAVE 5368 03:19:58,397 --> 03:20:00,332 EXPERTISE AND EXPERIENCE TO USE 5369 03:20:00,332 --> 03:20:01,567 TELEHEALTH APPROPRIATELY. 5370 03:20:01,567 --> 03:20:03,836 HOW DO WE SCALE UP THESE 5371 03:20:03,836 --> 03:20:04,803 PROBLEMS AND PRACTICES? 5372 03:20:04,803 --> 03:20:08,107 FOR EXAMPLE, WHAT WE HEARD 5373 03:20:08,107 --> 03:20:09,108 ABOUT, PATIENT CHECKOUT 5374 03:20:09,108 --> 03:20:10,409 ROUTINES, PATIENT PREFERRED 5375 03:20:10,409 --> 03:20:12,711 LANGUAGE SELECTION, AND OTHER 5376 03:20:12,711 --> 03:20:14,780 INNOVATIVE HYBRID ROUTINES ARE 5377 03:20:14,780 --> 03:20:16,782 IN CARE TRANSITIONS, HOW DO WE 5378 03:20:16,782 --> 03:20:19,818 BEST KNOW ABOUT THE REAL WORLD 5379 03:20:19,818 --> 03:20:20,586 DATA FROM STAND-ALONE 5380 03:20:20,586 --> 03:20:22,755 TELEHEALTH, AND IMPACT ON HEALTH 5381 03:20:22,755 --> 03:20:23,222 OUTCOMES. 5382 03:20:23,222 --> 03:20:25,424 I HAVE FIVE PAGES OF NOTES BUT 5383 03:20:25,424 --> 03:20:29,762 I'M GOING TO STOP AND SHARE MY 5384 03:20:29,762 --> 03:20:30,763 NOTES WITH FERNANDO, HONESTLY 5385 03:20:30,763 --> 03:20:37,336 THIS HAS BEEN A FANTASTIC 5386 03:20:37,336 --> 03:20:42,041 SESSION, SESSION, SINCERE 5387 03:20:42,041 --> 03:20:52,518 THANKS, BOB, ROBIN, LOK AND 5388 03:20:53,919 --> 03:20:55,587 SINCHAN, REALLY TERRIFIC. 5389 03:20:55,587 --> 03:20:56,121 EXPLORE OPPORTUNITIES IN 5390 03:20:56,121 --> 03:20:56,922 TELEHEALTH RESEARCH. 5391 03:20:56,922 --> 03:21:00,326 I HOPE WE ALL KEEP CHALLENGING 5392 03:21:00,326 --> 03:21:02,194 CONVENTIONAL THINKING AND WORK 5393 03:21:02,194 --> 03:21:04,263 TOWARDS TRANSLATING THE ADVANCES 5394 03:21:04,263 --> 03:21:07,666 WE'VE HEARD ABOUT TODAY INTO 5395 03:21:07,666 --> 03:21:08,968 TANGIBLE HEALTH IMPACTS THAT 5396 03:21:08,968 --> 03:21:11,170 WOULD ENABLE OUR COMMUNITIES TO 5397 03:21:11,170 --> 03:21:12,571 THRIVE. 5398 03:21:12,571 --> 03:21:15,441 ESPECIALLY WHEN IT COMES TO 5399 03:21:15,441 --> 03:21:19,278 IMPROVED ACCESS TO HIGH-QUALITY 5400 03:21:19,278 --> 03:21:20,245 HEALTH CARE THROUGH 5401 03:21:20,245 --> 03:21:21,547 DIRECT-TO-CONSUMER TELEHEALTH. 5402 03:21:21,547 --> 03:21:23,115 AGAIN, A TRULY WONDERFUL 5403 03:21:23,115 --> 03:21:23,382 WORKSHOP. 5404 03:21:23,382 --> 03:21:25,617 I'LL TURN IT OVER TO FERNANDO TO 5405 03:21:25,617 --> 03:21:28,554 THANK ALL OF YOU AND ESPECIALLY 5406 03:21:28,554 --> 03:21:31,523 THE ENTIRE TEAM THAT MADE THIS 5407 03:21:31,523 --> 03:21:32,992 WORKSHOP POSSIBLE, ALSO TO SHARE 5408 03:21:32,992 --> 03:21:35,461 WITH US SOME NEXT STEPS. 5409 03:21:35,461 --> 03:21:39,999 ON BEHALF OF NIH, NHLBI, AND OUR 5410 03:21:39,999 --> 03:21:42,701 CENTER, CTRIS, WE THANK YOU. 5411 03:21:42,701 --> 03:21:43,802 FERNANDO, I'LL TAG YOU. 5412 03:21:43,802 --> 03:21:47,172 >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH, GEORGE. 5413 03:21:47,172 --> 03:21:49,141 JUST WAITING FOR THE OPPORTUNITY 5414 03:21:49,141 --> 03:21:57,383 TO SHARE MY SCREEN, IF I CAN DO 5415 03:21:57,383 --> 03:21:58,884 THAT, SUPPORT TEAM. 5416 03:21:58,884 --> 03:22:04,023 I JUST ADDED MY SCREEN HERE SO I 5417 03:22:04,023 --> 03:22:08,093 CAN SHARE IT. 5418 03:22:08,093 --> 03:22:08,627 ALL RIGHT. 5419 03:22:08,627 --> 03:22:10,696 THIS BRINGS US TO A CLOSE, 5420 03:22:10,696 --> 03:22:13,232 NOTHING BETTER THAN HAVING OUR 5421 03:22:13,232 --> 03:22:16,001 DIRECTOR, DR. MENSAH, BRINGING 5422 03:22:16,001 --> 03:22:19,471 THESE WISE WORDS, SO MUCH RICH 5423 03:22:19,471 --> 03:22:20,239 CONVERSATION FOR TODAY. 5424 03:22:20,239 --> 03:22:21,607 IT WOULDN'T BE ENOUGH IF WE 5425 03:22:21,607 --> 03:22:24,076 DON'T THANK ALL OF YOU WHO 5426 03:22:24,076 --> 03:22:25,377 STAYED WITH US THROUGHOUT THIS 5427 03:22:25,377 --> 03:22:28,113 TIME, THOSE WHO MIGHT BE 5428 03:22:28,113 --> 03:22:29,081 WATCHING AFTER THIS WORKSHOP 5429 03:22:29,081 --> 03:22:31,850 TOOK PLACE BUT THOSE WHO MADE 5430 03:22:31,850 --> 03:22:33,585 THE WORKSHOP POSSIBLE. 5431 03:22:33,585 --> 03:22:35,354 I SEND MY GREAT THANK YOU AND 5432 03:22:35,354 --> 03:22:37,856 ACKNOWLEDGMENT TO THE NHLBI 5433 03:22:37,856 --> 03:22:38,857 WORKSHOP SUPPORT TEAM FOR THE 5434 03:22:38,857 --> 03:22:41,493 SAKE OF THE TIME I WON'T SAY 5435 03:22:41,493 --> 03:22:42,327 EVERYBODY'S NAME BUT THEY ARE 5436 03:22:42,327 --> 03:22:43,228 ALL HERE. 5437 03:22:43,228 --> 03:22:48,367 WITHOUT THEM THIS WOULD NOT HAVE 5438 03:22:48,367 --> 03:22:49,701 BEEN POSSIBLE. 5439 03:22:49,701 --> 03:22:50,469 ALSO, THE ADVERTISING AND 5440 03:22:50,469 --> 03:22:53,072 SPEAKING ABOUT THE EVENT AND 5441 03:22:53,072 --> 03:22:54,273 INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY TEAM AND 5442 03:22:54,273 --> 03:22:57,076 OBVIOUSLY TO ALL OF OUR SPEAKERS 5443 03:22:57,076 --> 03:22:59,111 AVAILABLE HERE TODAY, THANK YOU 5444 03:22:59,111 --> 03:23:00,746 FOR ACCEPTING OUR INVITATION, 5445 03:23:00,746 --> 03:23:02,281 FOR ENGAGING SUCH A RICH 5446 03:23:02,281 --> 03:23:02,981 CONVERSATION. 5447 03:23:02,981 --> 03:23:09,822 THANK YOU TO THE CTRIS 5448 03:23:09,822 --> 03:23:10,689 LEADERSHIP AND SHOUTING OUT, I 5449 03:23:10,689 --> 03:23:17,729 WANT TO GIVE THE SPOTLIGHT TO 5450 03:23:17,729 --> 03:23:19,598 PADMA WITHOUT WHOM I COULDN'T 5451 03:23:19,598 --> 03:23:21,767 SURVIVE THE PLANNING. 5452 03:23:21,767 --> 03:23:22,801 THANK YOU. 5453 03:23:22,801 --> 03:23:24,536 REGARDING NEXT STEPS, AS GEORGE 5454 03:23:24,536 --> 03:23:27,372 WAS MENTIONING THERE'S THE CTRIS 5455 03:23:27,372 --> 03:23:28,373 TEN-YEAR ANNIVERSARY WHICH WE 5456 03:23:28,373 --> 03:23:31,543 SHARED THE LINK FOR YOU TO 5457 03:23:31,543 --> 03:23:31,910 REGISTER. 5458 03:23:31,910 --> 03:23:33,512 TODAY ALSO MARKS THE END OF THE 5459 03:23:33,512 --> 03:23:35,914 WORKSHOP, TO US IT'S JUST THE 5460 03:23:35,914 --> 03:23:36,315 BEGINNING. 5461 03:23:36,315 --> 03:23:41,053 WE ARE GOING TO COMPILE THINGS 5462 03:23:41,053 --> 03:23:43,722 THAT HAPPENED TODAY INTO AN 5463 03:23:43,722 --> 03:23:44,923 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY AVAILABLE ON 5464 03:23:44,923 --> 03:23:46,758 THE WEBSITE WITHIN THE NEXT 5465 03:23:46,758 --> 03:23:47,092 MONTH. 5466 03:23:47,092 --> 03:23:48,060 HOPEFULLY SOME PUBLICATIONS ALSO 5467 03:23:48,060 --> 03:23:50,162 IN WHICH WE CAN COMMENT MORE 5468 03:23:50,162 --> 03:23:52,131 ABOUT WHAT WAS DISCUSSED TODAY. 5469 03:23:52,131 --> 03:23:54,733 AND BEFORE THE END, I WANT TO 5470 03:23:54,733 --> 03:23:57,369 ALSO SHARE SOMETHING CTRIS IS 5471 03:23:57,369 --> 03:24:00,772 ALREADY LEADING IN REGARDS TO 5472 03:24:00,772 --> 03:24:03,275 TELEHEALTH, WE'RE HAVING A 5473 03:24:03,275 --> 03:24:04,143 FUNDING OPPORTUNITY, DIFFERENCE 5474 03:24:04,143 --> 03:24:07,346 IN THE WORKSHOP FOCUS TODAY, 5475 03:24:07,346 --> 03:24:08,780 THIS ONE ON PROVIDER-TO-PROVIDER 5476 03:24:08,780 --> 03:24:09,615 TELEHEALTH, PARTICULARLY THOSE 5477 03:24:09,615 --> 03:24:10,849 IN NEED IN RURAL AREAS. 5478 03:24:10,849 --> 03:24:14,353 SO AS LONG AS YOU HAVE AN IDEA 5479 03:24:14,353 --> 03:24:18,490 FOR A PROJECT THAT DEALS WITH 5480 03:24:18,490 --> 03:24:20,359 RURAL AREAS BENEFITING, 5481 03:24:20,359 --> 03:24:22,861 PROVIDING COMMUNICATION, LIKELY 5482 03:24:22,861 --> 03:24:23,762 RESPONSIVE TO THIS NEWEST 5483 03:24:23,762 --> 03:24:24,530 OPPORTUNITY HERE. 5484 03:24:24,530 --> 03:24:28,133 HAVE YOU MY CONTACT THERE. 5485 03:24:28,133 --> 03:24:32,337 ALSO IMPORTANT HIGHLIGHT ROBIN 5486 03:24:32,337 --> 03:24:33,405 VANDERPOOL, SHE'S THE 5487 03:24:33,405 --> 03:24:34,006 REPRESENTATIVE FOR NCI, SO WE 5488 03:24:34,006 --> 03:24:40,312 CAN ALSO CONTACT HER. 5489 03:24:40,312 --> 03:24:42,147 SCAN THE QR CODE ABOUT THIS 5490 03:24:42,147 --> 03:24:43,916 NOTICE OF SPECIAL INTEREST ON 5491 03:24:43,916 --> 03:24:44,116 CTRIS. 5492 03:24:44,116 --> 03:24:47,186 BEYOND THIS IF YOU HAVE A 5493 03:24:47,186 --> 03:24:48,086 PARTICULAR PROJECT ON TELEHEALTH 5494 03:24:48,086 --> 03:24:51,690 OR SOMETHING THAT HAS TO DO WITH 5495 03:24:51,690 --> 03:24:54,092 IMPLEMENTATION RESEARCH REACH 5496 03:24:54,092 --> 03:24:54,393 OUT. 5497 03:24:54,393 --> 03:24:56,495 WE'RE OPEN TO HEAR YOUR IDEAS 5498 03:24:56,495 --> 03:24:57,496 AND HAVE TECHNICAL INFORMATION 5499 03:24:57,496 --> 03:24:59,998 CALLS WITH YOU, IN WHICH WE CAN 5500 03:24:59,998 --> 03:25:01,767 BETTER ASSIST WITH YOUR 5501 03:25:01,767 --> 03:25:02,034 RESEARCH. 5502 03:25:02,034 --> 03:25:03,302 AND WITH THAT I THINK THAT 5503 03:25:03,302 --> 03:25:05,137 BRINGS US TO THE ACTUAL CLOSE, 5504 03:25:05,137 --> 03:25:07,339 AND I WILL SHARE THIS SLIDE FROM 5505 03:25:07,339 --> 03:25:08,874 THE SUPPORT TEAM WHO IS ALSO 5506 03:25:08,874 --> 03:25:11,610 ASKING YOU TO PLEASE TAKE A 5507 03:25:11,610 --> 03:25:13,745 MINUTE AND RATE AND GIVE 5508 03:25:13,745 --> 03:25:14,947 FEEDBACK FOR THIS WORKSHOP. 5509 03:25:14,947 --> 03:25:16,081 IT'S BEEN WONDERFUL TO HOST ALL 5510 03:25:16,081 --> 03:25:16,682 OF YOU. 5511 03:25:16,682 --> 03:25:18,250 THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR STAYING 5512 03:25:18,250 --> 03:25:21,920 WITH US. 5513 03:25:21,920 --> 03:25:31,920 >> THANK YOU ALL.