1 00:07:08,114 --> 00:07:08,548 >> CHRIS SEYMOUR. 2 00:07:08,548 --> 00:07:11,150 GOOD MORNING EVERYONE I AM AN 3 00:07:11,150 --> 00:07:12,752 INTENSIVITY AND ASSOCIATE 4 00:07:12,752 --> 00:07:15,955 PROFESSOR AT THE UNIVERSITY OF 5 00:07:15,955 --> 00:07:17,023 PITTSBURGH CLINICAL TRANSLATION 6 00:07:17,023 --> 00:07:18,024 SCIENTIST SCIENTIST FOR SEPSIS, 7 00:07:18,024 --> 00:07:21,694 THANKS FOR HAVING ME. 8 00:07:21,694 --> 00:07:22,829 >> NEXT IN. 9 00:07:22,829 --> 00:07:25,331 >> HI, EVERYONE A PROFESSOR AT 10 00:07:25,331 --> 00:07:25,798 HARVARD UNIVERSITY, 11 00:07:25,798 --> 00:07:26,566 DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY UOF THE 12 00:07:26,566 --> 00:07:28,167 AND WE STUDY REGENERATION AND 13 00:07:28,167 --> 00:07:31,371 STEM CELL BIOLOGY. 14 00:07:31,371 --> 00:07:33,072 >> THANK YOU. 15 00:07:33,072 --> 00:07:35,108 AARON THOMAS? 16 00:07:35,108 --> 00:07:37,277 >> YEAH, AARON THOMAS, CHEMISTRY 17 00:07:37,277 --> 00:07:39,145 PROFESSOR AT THE UNIVERSITY OF 18 00:07:39,145 --> 00:07:41,214 MONTANA AND OVERSEE INDIGENOUS 19 00:07:41,214 --> 00:07:44,951 RESEARCH IN STEM EDUCATION. 20 00:07:44,951 --> 00:07:45,451 >> GREAT. 21 00:07:45,451 --> 00:07:45,718 YOAN? 22 00:07:45,718 --> 00:07:47,453 >> GOOD MORNING, CAN YOU HEAR 23 00:07:47,453 --> 00:07:47,820 ME. 24 00:07:47,820 --> 00:07:51,858 >> OKAY, GOOD MORNING EVERYBODY, 25 00:07:51,858 --> 00:07:53,426 JOANNE TREJO, FROM UNIVERSITY OF 26 00:07:53,426 --> 00:07:54,927 CALIFORNIA SAN DIEGO, DEPARTMENT 27 00:07:54,927 --> 00:07:56,562 OF PHARMACOLOGY AND SCHOOL OF 28 00:07:56,562 --> 00:07:59,399 MEDICINE AND MY LAB STUDIES CELL 29 00:07:59,399 --> 00:08:02,035 SIGNALING, THE CONTEXT OF 30 00:08:02,035 --> 00:08:03,803 VASCULAR INFLAMMATION AND BREAST 31 00:08:03,803 --> 00:08:04,804 CANCER PROGRESSION. 32 00:08:04,804 --> 00:08:07,807 >> THANK YOU. 33 00:08:07,807 --> 00:08:08,641 OSCAR? 34 00:08:08,641 --> 00:08:10,176 >> HI, EVERYONE, OSCAR VIVAS, I 35 00:08:10,176 --> 00:08:12,312 WORK AT THE UNIVERSITY OF 36 00:08:12,312 --> 00:08:13,046 WASHINGTON. 37 00:08:13,046 --> 00:08:14,247 I STUDY ORGANIZATION OF ION 38 00:08:14,247 --> 00:08:17,984 CHANNELS AND HOW THAT INFLUENCE 39 00:08:17,984 --> 00:08:19,952 EXCITABILITY OF AUTONOMIC 40 00:08:19,952 --> 00:08:20,753 NEURONS. 41 00:08:20,753 --> 00:08:21,054 >> GREAT. 42 00:08:21,054 --> 00:08:22,889 ANN WEST? 43 00:08:22,889 --> 00:08:23,990 >> GOOD MORNING EVERYONE, ANN 44 00:08:23,990 --> 00:08:25,725 WEST, AMOLOL A PROFESSOR OF 45 00:08:25,725 --> 00:08:27,460 CHEMISTRY AND BIOCHEMIST RADIOY 46 00:08:27,460 --> 00:08:28,928 AT THE UNIVERSITY OF OKLAHOMA 47 00:08:28,928 --> 00:08:29,996 AND I'M AN ASSOCIATE VICE 48 00:08:29,996 --> 00:08:32,632 PRESIDENT FOR RESEARCH AND 49 00:08:32,632 --> 00:08:33,199 PARTNERSHIPS. 50 00:08:33,199 --> 00:08:35,268 MY RESEARCH INTERESTS ARE IN 51 00:08:35,268 --> 00:08:37,603 STRUCTURE FUNCTION STUDIES OF 52 00:08:37,603 --> 00:08:39,339 BACTERIAL SIGNAL TRANSDUCTION 53 00:08:39,339 --> 00:08:40,306 PATHWAYS. 54 00:08:40,306 --> 00:08:43,776 NTHANK YOU ANN. 55 00:08:43,776 --> 00:08:45,778 >> RON, ARE YOU THERE? 56 00:08:45,778 --> 00:08:47,880 >> YEAH, I AM HERE, GOOD TO SEE 57 00:08:47,880 --> 00:08:49,982 YOU JON, I'M RON, I'M DIRECTOR 58 00:08:49,982 --> 00:08:52,352 OF GENOMIC MEDICINE FOR THE 59 00:08:52,352 --> 00:08:53,720 DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRS, 60 00:08:53,720 --> 00:08:55,121 BY TRADE I'M A PATHOLOGIST. 61 00:08:55,121 --> 00:08:56,756 GOOD TO SEE YOU ALL. 62 00:08:56,756 --> 00:08:59,025 >> GOOD TO SEE YOU. 63 00:08:59,025 --> 00:08:59,792 >> ERICA BROWN? 64 00:08:59,792 --> 00:09:01,194 >> GOOD MORNING I'M ERICA BROWN 65 00:09:01,194 --> 00:09:03,329 THE DIRECTOR OF THE DIVISION OF 66 00:09:03,329 --> 00:09:04,831 EXTRAMURAL ACTIVITIES AT 67 00:09:04,831 --> 00:09:06,399 NCIALTION AGMS AND THE EXECUTIVE 68 00:09:06,399 --> 00:09:10,403 SECRETARY OF THIS COUNCIL. 69 00:09:10,403 --> 00:09:11,003 >> DOREET. 70 00:09:11,003 --> 00:09:16,142 >> I'M HERE, I'M DOREET, DEPUTY 71 00:09:16,142 --> 00:09:19,078 DIRECTOR OF NAGMS. 72 00:09:19,078 --> 00:09:19,412 >> ARIEL? 73 00:09:19,412 --> 00:09:20,947 SNSHES HI, I'M AERIAL, DEPUTY 74 00:09:20,947 --> 00:09:24,350 DIRECTOR OF THE DIVISION OF 75 00:09:24,350 --> 00:09:25,451 EXTRAMURAL ACTIVITIES. 76 00:09:25,451 --> 00:09:27,954 >> AND FINALLY LATASHA, YOU WANT 77 00:09:27,954 --> 00:09:30,656 TO INTRODUCE YOURSELF? 78 00:09:30,656 --> 00:09:32,592 >> HELLO, EVERYONE, I'M ACTING 79 00:09:32,592 --> 00:09:35,027 DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF THE DIVISION 80 00:09:35,027 --> 00:09:35,795 EVER EXTRAMURAL ACTIVITIES. 81 00:09:35,795 --> 00:09:36,896 NICE TO SEE YOU ALL. 82 00:09:36,896 --> 00:09:37,764 >> GREAT. 83 00:09:37,764 --> 00:09:38,331 WELL, THAT DID IT. 84 00:09:38,331 --> 00:09:41,033 A LOT OF PEOPLE BUT THANK YOU 85 00:09:41,033 --> 00:09:42,101 ALL AGAIN FOR ATTENDING. 86 00:09:42,101 --> 00:09:43,269 WE REALLY APPRECIATE YOUR HARD 87 00:09:43,269 --> 00:09:47,673 WORK ON BEHALF OF THE 88 00:09:47,673 --> 00:09:48,341 INSTITUTES. 89 00:09:48,341 --> 00:09:49,442 FEW ORDERS OF BUSINESS, NOW I 90 00:09:49,442 --> 00:09:51,878 NEED TO READ THE CONFLICT OF 91 00:09:51,878 --> 00:09:56,616 INTEREST STATEMENT TO YOU ALL. 92 00:09:56,616 --> 00:09:57,216 OKAY. 93 00:09:57,216 --> 00:09:57,950 IN THE ELECTRONIC COUNCIL BOOK, 94 00:09:57,950 --> 00:09:59,585 YOU WILL FIND A CONFLICT OF 95 00:09:59,585 --> 00:10:00,887 INTEREST FORM THAT MUST BE 96 00:10:00,887 --> 00:10:03,189 SIGNED AT THE BEGINNING OF EACH 97 00:10:03,189 --> 00:10:03,656 COUNCIL MEETING. 98 00:10:03,656 --> 00:10:05,291 PLEASE SIGN IT AS I READ THE 99 00:10:05,291 --> 00:10:07,393 CONFLICT OF INTEREST STATEMENT, 100 00:10:07,393 --> 00:10:08,561 AND ELECTRONIC SIGNATURE WILL 101 00:10:08,561 --> 00:10:11,264 SUFFICE AND THEN RETURN IT VIA 102 00:10:11,264 --> 00:10:21,240 E-MAIL TO ANASTTASIA SOLIS, 103 00:10:21,240 --> 00:10:22,975 COUNCIL MEMBERS MAY NOT 104 00:10:22,975 --> 00:10:24,043 PARTICIPATE IN ANYIZATION WHERE 105 00:10:24,043 --> 00:10:25,144 CONFLICT OF LAW OR REGULATION 106 00:10:25,144 --> 00:10:26,345 SAYS MAY OCCUR. 107 00:10:26,345 --> 00:10:27,346 STAFF WILL INSURE THAT A 108 00:10:27,346 --> 00:10:28,648 COMMITTEE MEMBER DOES FOCUS ON 109 00:10:28,648 --> 00:10:30,316 THE PARTICIPATE IN AND IS NOT 110 00:10:30,316 --> 00:10:31,851 PRESENT DURING REVIEW OF 111 00:10:31,851 --> 00:10:33,920 APPLICATIONS AND PROGECS TO 112 00:10:33,920 --> 00:10:34,954 WHICH THE MEMBERS KNOWLEDGE, ANY 113 00:10:34,954 --> 00:10:37,790 OF THE FOLLOWING AS A FINANCIAL 114 00:10:37,790 --> 00:10:39,759 INTEREST, THE MEMBER, HIS OR HER 115 00:10:39,759 --> 00:10:41,461 SPOUSE, MINOR CHILD, PARTNER, 116 00:10:41,461 --> 00:10:42,995 INCLUDING CLOSE PROFESSIONAL 117 00:10:42,995 --> 00:10:45,598 ASSOCIATES, OR AN ORGANIZATION 118 00:10:45,598 --> 00:10:47,233 WITH WHICH THE MEMBER IS 119 00:10:47,233 --> 00:10:47,767 CONNECTED. 120 00:10:47,767 --> 00:10:48,501 IN ADDITION CONFLICTS OF 121 00:10:48,501 --> 00:10:50,970 INTEREST MAY OCCUR BECAUSE OF 122 00:10:50,970 --> 00:10:52,338 OTHER PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS 123 00:10:52,338 --> 00:10:55,475 SUCH AS WITH RECENT STUDENTS, 124 00:10:55,475 --> 00:10:56,309 COLLABORATORS, PERSONAL FRIENDS, 125 00:10:56,309 --> 00:10:57,944 OR SCIENTISTS WITH WHOM THE 126 00:10:57,944 --> 00:10:59,846 MEMBER HAS HAD LONG STANDING 127 00:10:59,846 --> 00:11:02,415 SCIENTIFIC OR PERSONAL 128 00:11:02,415 --> 00:11:02,715 DIFFERENCES. 129 00:11:02,715 --> 00:11:05,384 TO INSURE THAT A MEMBER DOES NOT 130 00:11:05,384 --> 00:11:06,819 PARTICIPATE IN THE DISCUSSION OF 131 00:11:06,819 --> 00:11:08,287 OR VOTE ON AN APPLICATION IN 132 00:11:08,287 --> 00:11:10,890 WHICH HE OR SHE IS IN CONFLICT, 133 00:11:10,890 --> 00:11:12,158 A WRITTEN CERTIFICATION IS 134 00:11:12,158 --> 00:11:12,458 REQUIRED. 135 00:11:12,458 --> 00:11:13,693 THIS STATEMENT WILL BECOME PART 136 00:11:13,693 --> 00:11:16,329 OF A MEETING FILE. 137 00:11:16,329 --> 00:11:18,331 THE OFFICE OF GOVERNMENT ETHICS 138 00:11:18,331 --> 00:11:20,366 PROVIDED A WAIVER FOR FEDERAL 139 00:11:20,366 --> 00:11:21,634 ADVISORY COMMITTEE MEMBERS 140 00:11:21,634 --> 00:11:23,870 EMPLOYED AT 1 UNIVERSITY OF A 141 00:11:23,870 --> 00:11:25,505 STATE, MULTIUNIVERSITY SYSTEM TO 142 00:11:25,505 --> 00:11:27,073 REVIEW APPLICATIONS FROM A 143 00:11:27,073 --> 00:11:28,708 SEPARATE UNIVERSITY OF THE SAME 144 00:11:28,708 --> 00:11:31,143 SYSTEM PROVIDED THE MEMBER HAS 145 00:11:31,143 --> 00:11:33,880 NO CONFLICTING INSTITUTIONAL 146 00:11:33,880 --> 00:11:34,313 RERESPONSIBILITIES. 147 00:11:34,313 --> 00:11:35,681 IN ADDITION, A FEDERAL ADVISORY 148 00:11:35,681 --> 00:11:38,050 COMMITTEE MEMBER WHO IS EMPLOYED 149 00:11:38,050 --> 00:11:39,051 BY PRIVATE INSTITUTION, FOR A 150 00:11:39,051 --> 00:11:41,053 PRIVATE INSTITUTION AND AT 1 OF 151 00:11:41,053 --> 00:11:42,355 ITS AFFILIATES AND THEY 152 00:11:42,355 --> 00:11:44,457 PARTICIPATE IN THE REVIEW OF A 153 00:11:44,457 --> 00:11:46,058 GRANT APPLICATION SUBMITTED BY 154 00:11:46,058 --> 00:11:47,894 ANOTHER AFFILIATE OF THE PRIVATE 155 00:11:47,894 --> 00:11:49,529 INSTITUTION, IF HE OR SHE DOES 156 00:11:49,529 --> 00:11:51,430 NOT HOLD THE JOINT APPOINTMENT 157 00:11:51,430 --> 00:11:53,566 WITH THE AFFILIATE AND SUBMITTED 158 00:11:53,566 --> 00:11:55,301 THE APPLICATION, DOES NOT HAVE 159 00:11:55,301 --> 00:11:56,302 AFFILIATED WITH RESPONSIBILITIES 160 00:11:56,302 --> 00:12:00,072 ASK HAVE A WAIVER TO DO SO. 161 00:12:00,072 --> 00:12:02,508 WE AT NAGMS KEEP TRACK OF THE 162 00:12:02,508 --> 00:12:03,209 EASILY IDENTIFIABLE CONFLICTS 163 00:12:03,209 --> 00:12:03,743 FOR YOU. 164 00:12:03,743 --> 00:12:06,345 WE RELY ON YOU TO IDENTIFY OTHER 165 00:12:06,345 --> 00:12:07,380 TYPES OF CONFLIBS SUCH AS THOSE 166 00:12:07,380 --> 00:12:11,050 THAT WE ARE UNLIKELY TO KNOW 167 00:12:11,050 --> 00:12:12,985 ABOUT, RECENT STUDENTS, PERSONAL 168 00:12:12,985 --> 00:12:13,786 FRIENDS, ET CETERA. 169 00:12:13,786 --> 00:12:14,654 PLEASE DON'T HESITATE TO LET US 170 00:12:14,654 --> 00:12:17,089 KNOW IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS ABOUT 171 00:12:17,089 --> 00:12:17,390 A CONFLICT. 172 00:12:17,390 --> 00:12:23,629 ANY QUESTIONS WITH THAT? 173 00:12:23,629 --> 00:12:24,564 OKAY, NOT SEEING ANY. 174 00:12:24,564 --> 00:12:26,599 IF DURING THE COURSE OF OUR 175 00:12:26,599 --> 00:12:29,068 PROCEEDINGS EITHER IN THE OPEN 176 00:12:29,068 --> 00:12:30,336 SESSION OR THE CLOSED SESSIONS, 177 00:12:30,336 --> 00:12:32,572 YOU REALIZE YOU ARE IN CONFLICT 178 00:12:32,572 --> 00:12:34,407 WITH SOMETHING, JUST SEND AN 179 00:12:34,407 --> 00:12:37,376 E-MAIL TO ERICA OR ARIEL OR 180 00:12:37,376 --> 00:12:38,544 LATASHA AND 1 OF THEM WILL BE 181 00:12:38,544 --> 00:12:41,414 ABLE TO DEAL WITH IT FOR YOU. 182 00:12:41,414 --> 00:12:44,183 THE OKAY. 183 00:12:44,183 --> 00:12:46,285 NOW, A FEW THINGS WE FLEED TO 184 00:12:46,285 --> 00:12:47,386 ACTUALLY TAKE VOTES ON. 185 00:12:47,386 --> 00:12:50,122 THE FIRST ARE THE MINUTES FROM 186 00:12:50,122 --> 00:12:51,524 OUR LAST ADVISORY COUNCIL 187 00:12:51,524 --> 00:12:54,493 MEETING WHICH WAS THE SEPTEMBER 188 00:12:54,493 --> 00:12:54,827 MEETING. 189 00:12:54,827 --> 00:12:56,329 DOES ANYONE HAVE ANY OBJECTIONS 190 00:12:56,329 --> 00:13:02,735 OR AMENDMENTS TO THE MINUTES? 191 00:13:02,735 --> 00:13:07,039 OKAY, ERICA YOU WANT TO ACHE A 192 00:13:07,039 --> 00:13:07,506 FORMAL POLL? 193 00:13:07,506 --> 00:13:09,075 >> I WILL DO A QUICK VOTE COUNT. 194 00:13:09,075 --> 00:13:11,544 I WILL MOVE THAT WE APPROVE THE 195 00:13:11,544 --> 00:13:14,180 MEETING MINUTES FROM THE 196 00:13:14,180 --> 00:13:17,550 SEPTEMBER COUNCIL MEETING, ANY 197 00:13:17,550 --> 00:13:18,084 OPPOSED? 198 00:13:18,084 --> 00:13:20,186 OKAY, THE MOTION'S APPROVED. 199 00:13:20,186 --> 00:13:21,320 >> THANK YOU. 200 00:13:21,320 --> 00:13:22,722 SAME FOR OPERATING PROCEDURES, 201 00:13:22,722 --> 00:13:32,031 OUR OPERATING PROCEDURES WERE 202 00:13:32,031 --> 00:13:32,665 ANNOUNCED PREVENTIVELY AND 203 00:13:32,665 --> 00:13:33,666 COUNCIL NEEDS TO APPROVE THOSE. 204 00:13:33,666 --> 00:13:35,968 >> I WILL MOVE THAT WE APPROVE 205 00:13:35,968 --> 00:13:37,803 THE COUNCIL OPERATING 206 00:13:37,803 --> 00:13:39,338 PROCEDURES, ARE ANY OPPOSED? 207 00:13:39,338 --> 00:13:41,540 THE MOTION IS APPROVED. 208 00:13:41,540 --> 00:13:46,012 >> AND THEN WE NEED TO VOTE ON 209 00:13:46,012 --> 00:13:46,512 OUR TRIENNIAL REPORT. 210 00:13:46,512 --> 00:13:50,950 WHICH RELATES TO HUMAN SUBJECTS 211 00:13:50,950 --> 00:13:51,384 RESEARCH, I BELIEVE. 212 00:13:51,384 --> 00:13:56,355 ARE THERE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT 213 00:13:56,355 --> 00:13:57,089 THAT, ERICA? 214 00:13:57,089 --> 00:13:57,957 >> OKAY, THANK YOU. 215 00:13:57,957 --> 00:14:02,628 I MOVE THAT WE APPROVE THE 216 00:14:02,628 --> 00:14:04,196 TRIENNIAL REPORT. 217 00:14:04,196 --> 00:14:05,297 ARE ANY OPPOSED. 218 00:14:05,297 --> 00:14:08,000 >> OKAY, THE MOTION'S APPROVED. 219 00:14:08,000 --> 00:14:08,300 THANK YOU. 220 00:14:08,300 --> 00:14:10,803 >> AND THEN WE NEED TO CONTINUE 221 00:14:10,803 --> 00:14:12,872 COUNCIL MEETING DATES AND THEY 222 00:14:12,872 --> 00:14:15,207 ARE THURSDAY SEPTEMBER 11th 223 00:14:15,207 --> 00:14:18,511 2025 VIRTUAL MEETING, THURSDAY 224 00:14:18,511 --> 00:14:19,879 FEBRUARY 5th, 2025I ALSO A 225 00:14:19,879 --> 00:14:22,882 VIRTUAL MEETING AND THURSDAY MAY 226 00:14:22,882 --> 00:14:24,016 21st, 2026, WHICH WE HAVE 227 00:14:24,016 --> 00:14:25,851 PLANNED AS AN IN-PERSON MEETING. 228 00:14:25,851 --> 00:14:30,056 ARE THERE ANY OBLIGATIONS JEK -- 229 00:14:30,056 --> 00:14:30,856 OBJECTIONS TO THOSE? 230 00:14:30,856 --> 00:14:32,558 OKAY, THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 231 00:14:32,558 --> 00:14:35,327 WITH THAT, WE WILL MOVE ON TO MY 232 00:14:35,327 --> 00:14:36,762 DIRECTOR'S REPORT AND GIVE YOU 233 00:14:36,762 --> 00:14:38,531 AN UPDATE ON SOME THINGS THAT 234 00:14:38,531 --> 00:14:40,866 HAVE BEEN GOING ON AT NAGMS, WE 235 00:14:40,866 --> 00:14:42,535 WILL HAVE TIME FOR QUESTIONS AND 236 00:14:42,535 --> 00:14:43,569 DISCUSSION AND WE WILL TAKE A 237 00:14:43,569 --> 00:14:48,908 BREAK AND THEN WE WILL DO A FEW 238 00:14:48,908 --> 00:14:49,375 MORE THINGS. 239 00:14:49,375 --> 00:14:52,178 IF I COULD HAVE MY SLIDES 240 00:14:52,178 --> 00:14:53,245 PLEASE, EXCELLENT. 241 00:14:53,245 --> 00:14:55,748 >> SORRY, JON, AS YOU'RE 242 00:14:55,748 --> 00:14:57,283 STARTING -- I WANT TO MAKE SURE 243 00:14:57,283 --> 00:14:59,018 EVERYONE HAS THEIR CAMERAS OFF. 244 00:14:59,018 --> 00:14:59,285 THANK YOU. 245 00:14:59,285 --> 00:15:00,252 >> GREAT AND WE WILL TURN THEM 246 00:15:00,252 --> 00:15:02,088 BACK ON WHEN WE HAVE THE 247 00:15:02,088 --> 00:15:02,388 DISCUSSION. 248 00:15:02,388 --> 00:15:03,622 AGAIN, I WANT TO THANK EVERYONE 249 00:15:03,622 --> 00:15:05,091 FOR TAKING THE TIME TO 250 00:15:05,091 --> 00:15:06,058 PARTICIPATE IN THIS COUNCIL. 251 00:15:06,058 --> 00:15:07,293 IT'S A VERY IMPORTANT WAY THAT 252 00:15:07,293 --> 00:15:09,995 WE GET FEEDBACK FROM THE 253 00:15:09,995 --> 00:15:12,298 COMMUNITY AND ALSO ALLOWS US TO 254 00:15:12,298 --> 00:15:15,201 DISSEMINATE INFORMATION TO THE 255 00:15:15,201 --> 00:15:18,804 COMMUNITY. 256 00:15:18,804 --> 00:15:19,472 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 257 00:15:19,472 --> 00:15:22,808 SO I WANT TO THANK SOME OUTGOING 258 00:15:22,808 --> 00:15:24,610 MEMBERS OF THE COUNCIL FIRST RON 259 00:15:24,610 --> 00:15:26,245 KING, WHO INTRODUCED HIMSELF 260 00:15:26,245 --> 00:15:31,450 REFIOUSLY AS WELL AS TERRY KINSY 261 00:15:31,450 --> 00:15:32,051 WHO INTRODUCED HERSELF. 262 00:15:32,051 --> 00:15:35,187 NEXT SLIDE. 263 00:15:35,187 --> 00:15:36,722 AND DAVE MATHEWS, THESE 3 264 00:15:36,722 --> 00:15:38,591 MEMBERS HAVE BEEN TREMENDOUS 265 00:15:38,591 --> 00:15:40,559 ASSETS TO OUR COUNCIL AND HAVE 266 00:15:40,559 --> 00:15:42,228 PROVIDED A LOT OF IMPORTANT 267 00:15:42,228 --> 00:15:48,334 INSIGHTS AND GUIDANCE TO THE 268 00:15:48,334 --> 00:15:49,268 INSTITUTE. 269 00:15:49,268 --> 00:15:50,302 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE, AS WE ALWAYS 270 00:15:50,302 --> 00:15:52,705 DO WE HAVE EARLY CAREER 271 00:15:52,705 --> 00:15:53,372 INVESTIGATORS PARTICIPATING AS 272 00:15:53,372 --> 00:15:56,008 ADHOC MEMBERS OF OUR COUNCIL, 273 00:15:56,008 --> 00:15:58,043 CHRISTINA AND P A ULO JUST 274 00:15:58,043 --> 00:16:00,346 INTRODUCED THEMSELVES TO YOU. 275 00:16:00,346 --> 00:16:01,147 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 276 00:16:01,147 --> 00:16:05,484 AND LIDDIA AND OSCAR AS WELL. 277 00:16:05,484 --> 00:16:07,019 WE BRING EARLY CAREER 278 00:16:07,019 --> 00:16:08,354 INVESTIGATORS ON AS ADHOCS SO 279 00:16:08,354 --> 00:16:09,688 THAT FIRST WE CAN GET THE 280 00:16:09,688 --> 00:16:11,023 FEEDBACK AND INPUT OF EARLY 281 00:16:11,023 --> 00:16:11,924 CAREER INVESTIGATORS WHICH WE 282 00:16:11,924 --> 00:16:14,126 FIND TO BE VITALLY IMPORTANT TO 283 00:16:14,126 --> 00:16:16,595 THE INSTITUTE TO GET THEIR 284 00:16:16,595 --> 00:16:16,929 PERSPECTIVES. 285 00:16:16,929 --> 00:16:19,431 WE ALSO DO IT SO THAT THEY CAN 286 00:16:19,431 --> 00:16:20,366 HELP DISSEMINATE THE INFORMATION 287 00:16:20,366 --> 00:16:22,668 ABOUT WHAT'S GOING ON AT NAGMS 288 00:16:22,668 --> 00:16:23,936 AS WELL AS WHAT HAPPENS ON 289 00:16:23,936 --> 00:16:27,339 COUNCIL WHEN I THINK IS OFTEN A 290 00:16:27,339 --> 00:16:30,242 LITTLE MYSTERIOUS TO EXTERNAL 291 00:16:30,242 --> 00:16:33,712 PEOPLE AND SO THEY CAN HELP US 292 00:16:33,712 --> 00:16:34,647 GIVE THAT INFORMATION. 293 00:16:34,647 --> 00:16:37,783 SOME SAD NEWS FOR ME, BUT HAPPY 294 00:16:37,783 --> 00:16:42,421 NEWS FOR HER, IS THAT DOREET 295 00:16:42,421 --> 00:16:43,522 ZOOCH, OUR LONG-TERM DEPUTY 296 00:16:43,522 --> 00:16:46,225 DIRECTOR WILL BE RETIRING AT THE 297 00:16:46,225 --> 00:16:46,525 END OF JUNE. 298 00:16:46,525 --> 00:16:50,563 I AM CERTAINLY GOING TO MISS HER 299 00:16:50,563 --> 00:16:52,264 TREMENDOUSLY MENDOUSLY ISSUES 300 00:16:52,264 --> 00:16:54,466 SHE'S BEEN AN INCREDIBLE ASSET 301 00:16:54,466 --> 00:16:56,168 TO THE INSTITUTE, ALMOST EVERY 302 00:16:56,168 --> 00:16:57,503 ASPECT OF THE OPERATION HE'S 303 00:16:57,503 --> 00:16:59,371 BEEN INVOLVE WIDE OPTIMIZING, 304 00:16:59,371 --> 00:17:00,739 COMING UP WITH CREATIVE NEW 305 00:17:00,739 --> 00:17:01,707 SOLUTIONS TO PROBLEMS AND MAKING 306 00:17:01,707 --> 00:17:03,742 SURE THE INSTITUTE RUNS 307 00:17:03,742 --> 00:17:05,077 OPTIMALLY AND SMOOTHLY, SO I 308 00:17:05,077 --> 00:17:07,012 THINK YOU WILL JOIN ME IN 309 00:17:07,012 --> 00:17:09,715 WISHING HER THE BEST IN 310 00:17:09,715 --> 00:17:11,517 RETIREMENT AND THANKING HER FOR 311 00:17:11,517 --> 00:17:12,351 HER INCREDIBLE SERVICE TO THE 312 00:17:12,351 --> 00:17:16,355 COUNTRY CAN TO NIH. 313 00:17:16,355 --> 00:17:21,894 NEXT, SLIDE PLEASE. 314 00:17:21,894 --> 00:17:23,662 ALSO, NEW NEWS, I THINK YOU KNOW 315 00:17:23,662 --> 00:17:25,531 IT, NIH AS A NEW DIRECTOR 316 00:17:25,531 --> 00:17:28,801 APPOINTED BY THE PRESIDENT AND 317 00:17:28,801 --> 00:17:37,710 CONFIRMED BY THE SENATE. 318 00:17:37,710 --> 00:17:38,577 JAY BHATTACHARYA, REPLACING 319 00:17:38,577 --> 00:17:41,747 MONICA BERTAGNOLLI WHO WAS THE 320 00:17:41,747 --> 00:17:43,382 DIRECTOR OF JANUARY 2023-25, JAY 321 00:17:43,382 --> 00:17:46,485 WAS A PREVIOUSLY TENURED 322 00:17:46,485 --> 00:17:48,287 PROFESSOR IN THE MEDICAL SCHOOL 323 00:17:48,287 --> 00:17:49,655 AT STANFORD UNIVERSITY, HIS WORK 324 00:17:49,655 --> 00:17:52,224 AS A HEALTH ECONOMIST FOCUSES ON 325 00:17:52,224 --> 00:17:53,592 RESEARCH ON POPULATION AGING AND 326 00:17:53,592 --> 00:17:54,727 CHRONIC DISEASE, PARTICULAR LE 327 00:17:54,727 --> 00:17:58,898 ON THE HEALTH AND WELL BEING OF 328 00:17:58,898 --> 00:17:59,465 VELLENERRABLE POPULATIONS. 329 00:17:59,465 --> 00:18:00,766 AND IT'S BEEN A PLEASURE SO FAR 330 00:18:00,766 --> 00:18:03,369 TO WORK WITH JAY AND I LOOK 331 00:18:03,369 --> 00:18:05,070 FORWARD TO WORKING WITH HIM AS 332 00:18:05,070 --> 00:18:08,574 WE MOVE FORWARD. 333 00:18:08,574 --> 00:18:09,842 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 334 00:18:09,842 --> 00:18:11,410 SOME OTHER ANNOUNCEMENTS, THESE 335 00:18:11,410 --> 00:18:14,380 ARE A LITTLE DELAYED NOW, BUT I 336 00:18:14,380 --> 00:18:19,251 THINK STILL WORTH TALKING ABOUT, 337 00:18:19,251 --> 00:18:21,220 SEVERAL NAGMS GRANTEES RECEIVED 338 00:18:21,220 --> 00:18:22,488 NOBEL PRIZES IN 2024 FOR WORK 339 00:18:22,488 --> 00:18:27,459 THAT WAS SUPPORTED BY NAGMS. 340 00:18:27,459 --> 00:18:30,829 VECTOR AMROSE AND GARY RUVKURKS 341 00:18:30,829 --> 00:18:34,033 UN WERE AWARDED THE NOBEL PRIZE 342 00:18:34,033 --> 00:18:36,302 FOR PHYSIOLOGY OR MEDICINE FOR 343 00:18:36,302 --> 00:18:38,037 THE DISCOVERY OF MRNA, AND ITS 344 00:18:38,037 --> 00:18:44,610 ROLE IN POST TRANSCRIPTIONAL 345 00:18:44,610 --> 00:18:46,845 JEEP REGULATION, AMBROSS HAS 346 00:18:46,845 --> 00:18:52,151 BEEN A GRANTEE SINCE 1985 AND 347 00:18:52,151 --> 00:18:55,521 GARY SINCE 1991, I GOT TO HAVE A 348 00:18:55,521 --> 00:18:57,489 RING SIDE SEAT TO WATCH, NOT 349 00:18:57,489 --> 00:19:00,192 INVOLVED IN ANY WAY BUT WATCH 350 00:19:00,192 --> 00:19:02,828 THE DISCOVERY OF MICRORNAs IN 351 00:19:02,828 --> 00:19:04,763 HIS LAB, AND REALLY QUITE 352 00:19:04,763 --> 00:19:06,632 EXCITING TO SEE THAT WORK FROM 353 00:19:06,632 --> 00:19:08,133 ALL THAT TIME AGO WAS RECOGNIZED 354 00:19:08,133 --> 00:19:10,069 IN THIS WAY, AND IT'S VERY 355 00:19:10,069 --> 00:19:11,570 IMPORTANT WORK AS I'M SURE YOU 356 00:19:11,570 --> 00:19:15,074 ALL KNOW, NEW PARADIGM IN HOW 357 00:19:15,074 --> 00:19:17,009 GENE EXPRESSION IS REGULATED 358 00:19:17,009 --> 00:19:20,079 WITH MANY IMPLICATIONS FOR BOTH 359 00:19:20,079 --> 00:19:20,946 BIOLOGY AND FOR MEDICINE. 360 00:19:20,946 --> 00:19:23,182 SO CONGRATULATIONS TO BOTH OF 361 00:19:23,182 --> 00:19:25,217 THEM AND 2 ABSOLUTELY WONDERFUL 362 00:19:25,217 --> 00:19:26,218 MEMBERS OF THE COMMUNITY AS 363 00:19:26,218 --> 00:19:29,321 WELL, WITH OUR CONTRIBUTIONS OF 364 00:19:29,321 --> 00:19:31,323 VARIOUS WAYS INCLUDING GOING 365 00:19:31,323 --> 00:19:39,765 ABOVE THEIR SCIENCE. 366 00:19:39,765 --> 00:19:41,734 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 367 00:19:41,734 --> 00:19:47,272 >> WE ARE ALSO EXCITED TO 368 00:19:47,272 --> 00:19:56,215 WELCOME DAVID BAKER, HE WAS A 369 00:19:56,215 --> 00:19:57,616 GRAPTUE FROM 1995-2005 AND 370 00:19:57,616 --> 00:19:59,585 AWARDED THE NOBEL PRIZE IN 371 00:19:59,585 --> 00:20:02,921 CHEMISTRY FOR COMPUTATIONAL 372 00:20:02,921 --> 00:20:04,590 PROTEIN DESIGN. 373 00:20:04,590 --> 00:20:06,692 I THINK WE'RE JUST AT THE 374 00:20:06,692 --> 00:20:08,160 BEGINNING OF UNDERSTANDING WHAT 375 00:20:08,160 --> 00:20:10,562 WE CAN DO WITH TECHNOLOGIES THAT 376 00:20:10,562 --> 00:20:13,532 DAVID'S LAB HAS DEVELOPED. 377 00:20:13,532 --> 00:20:15,167 THEY WILL TRANSFORM MEDICINE AND 378 00:20:15,167 --> 00:20:17,836 PROBABLY MANY OTHER FIELDS AS 379 00:20:17,836 --> 00:20:19,038 WELL BUT CONGRATULATIONS TO HIM 380 00:20:19,038 --> 00:20:23,108 AS WELL FOR THIS INCREDIBLE 381 00:20:23,108 --> 00:20:24,476 WORK. 382 00:20:24,476 --> 00:20:25,077 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 383 00:20:25,077 --> 00:20:27,513 SO I WANTED TO GIVE YOU A LITTLE 384 00:20:27,513 --> 00:20:31,583 SORT OF OVERVIEW OF A COUPLE OF 385 00:20:31,583 --> 00:20:33,318 REALLY FLAGSHIP NAGMS PROGRAMS 386 00:20:33,318 --> 00:20:38,057 AS WE MOVE INTO A NEW ERA, THE 387 00:20:38,057 --> 00:20:41,627 FIRST IS OUR R35 MAXIMIZING 388 00:20:41,627 --> 00:20:44,329 INVESTIGATORS RESEARCH AWARD OR 389 00:20:44,329 --> 00:20:45,831 MIRA PROGRAM. 390 00:20:45,831 --> 00:20:50,636 THIS HAS BECOME NIGMS'S FLAGSHIP 391 00:20:50,636 --> 00:20:52,337 FOR FUNDING INVESTIGATOR 392 00:20:52,337 --> 00:20:53,272 INITIATED FUNDAMENTAL RESEARCH. 393 00:20:53,272 --> 00:20:56,108 THE PROGRAM PROVIDES SUPPORT FOR 394 00:20:56,108 --> 00:20:58,110 INDIVIDUAL INVESTIGATORS FOR 395 00:20:58,110 --> 00:20:59,678 THEIR NIGMS RELATED PROGRAMS OF 396 00:20:59,678 --> 00:21:01,447 RESEARCH IN THEIR LABORATORY. 397 00:21:01,447 --> 00:21:03,649 SO THE WORK IN THEIR LABORATORY 398 00:21:03,649 --> 00:21:10,856 THAT IS RELEVANT TO NIGMS' 399 00:21:10,856 --> 00:21:12,491 MISSION, THE MIRA GRANT PROVIDES 400 00:21:12,491 --> 00:21:14,159 SUPPORT FOR THAT WHOLE PROGRAM. 401 00:21:14,159 --> 00:21:18,564 THE ADVANTAGES OF THE MIRA GRANT 402 00:21:18,564 --> 00:21:19,565 OVER TRADITIONAL RO-1S ARE 403 00:21:19,565 --> 00:21:21,400 MULTIPLE FOLD BUT THEY INCLUDE 404 00:21:21,400 --> 00:21:25,471 THE FACT THAT MIRA INVESTIGATORS 405 00:21:25,471 --> 00:21:27,539 HAVE MUCH GREATER SCIENTIFIC 406 00:21:27,539 --> 00:21:28,340 FLEXIBILITY IN TERMS OF BEING 407 00:21:28,340 --> 00:21:31,143 ABLE TO FOLLOW NEW IDEAS, NEW 408 00:21:31,143 --> 00:21:34,179 OBSERVATIONS, AS THOSE IDEAS OR 409 00:21:34,179 --> 00:21:35,147 OBSERVATIONS ARISE, NOT BEING 410 00:21:35,147 --> 00:21:36,782 TIED TO SPECIFIC AIMS THE WAY 411 00:21:36,782 --> 00:21:39,084 THEY ARE IN RO-1S, THEY ALSO 412 00:21:39,084 --> 00:21:40,853 HAVE CONSIDERABLY MORE FUNDING 413 00:21:40,853 --> 00:21:43,322 STABILITY AS WELL AS REDUCED 414 00:21:43,322 --> 00:21:44,323 ADMINISTRATIVE BURDEN AND ALL OF 415 00:21:44,323 --> 00:21:45,858 THESE THINGS WE THINK ALLOWS 416 00:21:45,858 --> 00:21:48,794 THEM TO TAKE ON MUCH MORE 417 00:21:48,794 --> 00:21:51,230 AMBITIOUS AND CREATIVE RESEARCH 418 00:21:51,230 --> 00:21:56,001 THAN THEY COULD DO THROUGH 419 00:21:56,001 --> 00:21:56,401 TRADITIONAL RO-1S. 420 00:21:56,401 --> 00:21:58,237 THE WAY THE MIRA WORKS IS 421 00:21:58,237 --> 00:22:02,441 INSTEAD OF BEING ABLE TO GET 422 00:22:02,441 --> 00:22:04,176 MULTIPLE GRANTS, THE WAY THEY 423 00:22:04,176 --> 00:22:06,011 INVEST WITH RO-1S, THE MIRA 424 00:22:06,011 --> 00:22:08,380 GRANT IS THE NIGMS FUNDING FOR 425 00:22:08,380 --> 00:22:09,114 THAT LAB'S RESEARCH AND ONCE 426 00:22:09,114 --> 00:22:11,650 THEY HAVE THE MIRA GRANT, THAT 427 00:22:11,650 --> 00:22:13,785 IS THE ONLY NIGMS RESEARCH 428 00:22:13,785 --> 00:22:15,454 FUNDING THAT THEY CAN HAVE. 429 00:22:15,454 --> 00:22:16,722 BECAUSE OF THIS THE PERIODS OF 430 00:22:16,722 --> 00:22:18,123 SUPPORT ARE LONGER AND THE 431 00:22:18,123 --> 00:22:22,427 BUDGET'S LARGER ON AVERAGE THAN 432 00:22:22,427 --> 00:22:23,395 COMPARABLE NIGMS RO-1S, SO 433 00:22:23,395 --> 00:22:25,631 THEY'RE 5 YEARS ENSTED OF 4. 434 00:22:25,631 --> 00:22:27,900 WE ARE SHOOTING NOW TO HAVE THE 435 00:22:27,900 --> 00:22:33,739 MEDIAN MODE OF DIRECT COSTS BE 436 00:22:33,739 --> 00:22:35,274 $275,000 PER YEAR. 437 00:22:35,274 --> 00:22:36,775 SO THAT'S CONSIDERABLY LARGER 438 00:22:36,775 --> 00:22:39,211 THAN WHAT AN INVESTIGATOR WOULD 439 00:22:39,211 --> 00:22:49,721 GET WITH A SINGLE NIGM S RO-1. 440 00:22:50,756 --> 00:22:55,827 WE HAVE 2 PROGRAMS, THESE ARE 441 00:22:55,827 --> 00:22:56,929 REVIEWED INDEPENDENTLY OF 1 442 00:22:56,929 --> 00:22:58,463 ANOTHER IN THE REVIEW PANELS SO 443 00:22:58,463 --> 00:23:00,332 THAT THE EARLY STAGE 444 00:23:00,332 --> 00:23:01,400 INVESTIGATORS ARE NOT BEING 445 00:23:01,400 --> 00:23:02,768 COMPARED TO THE MORE SENIOR 446 00:23:02,768 --> 00:23:04,336 ESTABLISHED INVESTIGATORS AND I 447 00:23:04,336 --> 00:23:06,638 THINK THAT'S ANOTHER IMPORTANT 448 00:23:06,638 --> 00:23:09,908 ASPECT OF THIS PROGRAM AND IN 449 00:23:09,908 --> 00:23:13,111 FACT, THRAW THE NIGMS EARLY 450 00:23:13,111 --> 00:23:14,279 INVESTIGATOR STAGE PROGRAM, 451 00:23:14,279 --> 00:23:17,216 SINCE 2013, THE INSTITUTE HAS 452 00:23:17,216 --> 00:23:19,885 ACTUALLY TRIPLED THE NUMBER OF 453 00:23:19,885 --> 00:23:23,622 EARLY STAGE INVESTIGATORS IT 454 00:23:23,622 --> 00:23:26,258 SUPPORTS PER YEAR, WHICH IS 455 00:23:26,258 --> 00:23:27,292 REALLY QUITE ASTOUNDING IF YOU 456 00:23:27,292 --> 00:23:29,661 THINK ABOUT IT, THAT SOMETHING 457 00:23:29,661 --> 00:23:31,396 TRIPLED IN ABOUT 10 YEARS AND 458 00:23:31,396 --> 00:23:34,466 THIS REALLY IS LARGELY 459 00:23:34,466 --> 00:23:36,468 ATTRIBUTABLE TO THE ESI MIRA, 460 00:23:36,468 --> 00:23:38,036 AND AT THIS POINT ALMOST ALL THE 461 00:23:38,036 --> 00:23:39,871 EARLY STAGE INVESTIGATORS PUT 462 00:23:39,871 --> 00:23:41,673 THE INSTITUTE FUNDS ARE 463 00:23:41,673 --> 00:23:45,143 SUPPORTED THROUGH MIRA AND NOT 464 00:23:45,143 --> 00:23:45,477 THROUGH RO-1S. 465 00:23:45,477 --> 00:23:48,981 AND GOING ALONG WITH IT AS OF 466 00:23:48,981 --> 00:23:54,186 FISCAL YEAR 2024, 2/3RDS ALMOST 467 00:23:54,186 --> 00:23:57,389 OF NIGMS'S RO-1 EQUIVALENTS WERE 468 00:23:57,389 --> 00:23:58,423 FUNDED THROUGH MIRAs INSTEAD 469 00:23:58,423 --> 00:24:02,427 OF OTHER MECHANISMS SUCH AS 470 00:24:02,427 --> 00:24:02,628 RO-1S. 471 00:24:02,628 --> 00:24:04,296 AT THE END OF THIS FISCAL YEAR 472 00:24:04,296 --> 00:24:05,731 THAT WOULD BE OVER 70%. 473 00:24:05,731 --> 00:24:07,566 THAT WAS A STRATEGIC TARGET WE 474 00:24:07,566 --> 00:24:10,769 HAD WAS TO REACH 60% BY 2025. 475 00:24:10,769 --> 00:24:11,903 WE EXCEEDED THAT, ALREADY IN 476 00:24:11,903 --> 00:24:13,705 2024 AND WE WILL GET 477 00:24:13,705 --> 00:24:14,906 CONSIDERABLY BEYOND THAT TARGET 478 00:24:14,906 --> 00:24:17,109 BY THE END OF THIS YEAR. 479 00:24:17,109 --> 00:24:20,545 SO THAT JUST SHOWS THE 480 00:24:20,545 --> 00:24:22,581 IMPORTANCE OF THIS PROGRAM TO 481 00:24:22,581 --> 00:24:26,451 THE INSTITUTE, THIS NEW PARADIGM 482 00:24:26,451 --> 00:24:28,020 AND 1 POINT I WANTED TO MAKE WAS 483 00:24:28,020 --> 00:24:30,555 TAKEN--THEY NIH IS SOMETIMES 484 00:24:30,555 --> 00:24:32,224 CRIT SIZED FOR BEING SLOW AND 485 00:24:32,224 --> 00:24:34,359 FOR SORT OF CLINGING TO THE PAST 486 00:24:34,359 --> 00:24:35,627 AND NOT MAKING CHANGES, HERE'S A 487 00:24:35,627 --> 00:24:39,498 CASE WHERE WE TOOK AN IDEA IN 488 00:24:39,498 --> 00:24:41,199 2015, 2016 WHEN THE PROGRAM 489 00:24:41,199 --> 00:24:43,402 STARTED AS A PILOT, IT WAS JUST 490 00:24:43,402 --> 00:24:46,238 AN IDEA IN HOW WE MIGHT MORE 491 00:24:46,238 --> 00:24:47,773 EFFECTIVELY AND MORE EFFICIENTLY 492 00:24:47,773 --> 00:24:49,207 SUPPORT FUNDAMENTAL RESEARCH AND 493 00:24:49,207 --> 00:24:51,476 WE TRIED IT OUT AND IT WAS 494 00:24:51,476 --> 00:24:53,478 SUCCESSFUL AND WE HAVE GROWN IT 495 00:24:53,478 --> 00:24:54,946 TO THIS POINT WHERE IT IS THE 496 00:24:54,946 --> 00:24:59,651 LARGE MAIORITY OF FUNDING FOR 497 00:24:59,651 --> 00:25:00,252 NIGMS' RESEARCH INVESTIGATORS. 498 00:25:00,252 --> 00:25:02,287 SO I THINK THAT SHOWS CERTAINLY 499 00:25:02,287 --> 00:25:06,391 THE ABILITY TO TRY NEW IDEAS AND 500 00:25:06,391 --> 00:25:07,359 TO ACTUALLY REPLACE THE OLD 501 00:25:07,359 --> 00:25:11,196 SYSTEM WITH NEW IDEAS WHEN THEY 502 00:25:11,196 --> 00:25:12,698 WORK. 503 00:25:12,698 --> 00:25:13,165 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 504 00:25:13,165 --> 00:25:15,467 I WILL GIVE YOU JUST A QUICK 505 00:25:15,467 --> 00:25:18,904 PORTRAIT OF 1 EARLY STAGE 506 00:25:18,904 --> 00:25:22,074 INVESTIGATOR, MIRA GRANTEE AND 507 00:25:22,074 --> 00:25:23,375 THAT'S SHANNON NEWFELT, SHE IS 508 00:25:23,375 --> 00:25:26,178 AT MONTANA STATE UNIVERSITY, SHE 509 00:25:26,178 --> 00:25:28,947 RECEIVED HER ESI MIRA IN TBENT 510 00:25:28,947 --> 00:25:35,454 20, HER RESEARCH USES ORGANIC 511 00:25:35,454 --> 00:25:37,656 AND ORGAN O METALLIC CHEMISTRY, 512 00:25:37,656 --> 00:25:40,459 TO OPTIMIZE AND UNDERSTAND 513 00:25:40,459 --> 00:25:44,062 CATALYTIC SYSTEMS FOR MOLECULAR 514 00:25:44,062 --> 00:25:45,731 SYNTHESIS, AND THIS WORK IS 515 00:25:45,731 --> 00:25:47,366 CRITICAL FOR US BEING ABLE TO 516 00:25:47,366 --> 00:25:50,969 MAKE NEW DRUGS AS WELL AS NEW 517 00:25:50,969 --> 00:25:51,403 MEDICAL MATERIALS. 518 00:25:51,403 --> 00:25:54,005 SO SHE STARTED HER LAB IN 2020, 519 00:25:54,005 --> 00:25:54,973 SHE'S ALREADY PUBLISHED 23 520 00:25:54,973 --> 00:25:56,842 PAPERS, THIS WAS ACTUALLY AS A 521 00:25:56,842 --> 00:25:58,543 FEW MONTHS AGO, I SUSPECT IT'S 522 00:25:58,543 --> 00:26:01,446 MORE THAN THAT AT THIS POINT. 523 00:26:01,446 --> 00:26:04,716 SO OFF TO JUST A TREMENDOUS 524 00:26:04,716 --> 00:26:06,451 START, HAVING A BIG IMPACT ON 525 00:26:06,451 --> 00:26:07,352 THIS FIELD ALREADY AND GOING 526 00:26:07,352 --> 00:26:08,987 ALONG WITH THAT SHE WAS A 527 00:26:08,987 --> 00:26:10,522 RECIPIENT OF THE PRESIDENTIAL 528 00:26:10,522 --> 00:26:12,324 EARLY CAREER AWARD FOR 529 00:26:12,324 --> 00:26:14,159 SCIENTISTS AND ENGINEERS A FEW 530 00:26:14,159 --> 00:26:14,459 MONTHS AGO. 531 00:26:14,459 --> 00:26:15,394 SO REALLY PROUD OF THE WORK 532 00:26:15,394 --> 00:26:19,731 SHE'S DOING AT MONTANA STATE 533 00:26:19,731 --> 00:26:21,433 WITH THE MIRA AND LOOK FORWARD 534 00:26:21,433 --> 00:26:24,736 TO SEEING WHAT SHE DOES IN THE 535 00:26:24,736 --> 00:26:25,370 FUTURE. 536 00:26:25,370 --> 00:26:26,037 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 537 00:26:26,037 --> 00:26:30,008 NOW THE OTHER FLAGSHIP PROGRAM I 538 00:26:30,008 --> 00:26:31,243 WANTED TO TO JUST BRING UP AND 539 00:26:31,243 --> 00:26:33,345 GO OVER A LITTLE BIT WITH YOU IS 540 00:26:33,345 --> 00:26:36,114 THE IDEA PROGRAM, THE 541 00:26:36,114 --> 00:26:36,882 INSTIEWTIONZAL DEVELOPMENT AWARD 542 00:26:36,882 --> 00:26:37,315 PROGRAM. 543 00:26:37,315 --> 00:26:39,384 THIS IS A RESEARCH CAPACITY 544 00:26:39,384 --> 00:26:41,520 BUILDING PROGRAM THAT TARGETS 545 00:26:41,520 --> 00:26:42,788 STATES THAT HISTORICALLY HAVE 546 00:26:42,788 --> 00:26:46,191 NOT RECEIVED HIGH LEVELS OF NIH 547 00:26:46,191 --> 00:26:46,691 FUNDING. 548 00:26:46,691 --> 00:26:48,260 IT WAS ESTABLISHED BY CONGRESS 549 00:26:48,260 --> 00:26:51,129 IN 1993 WITH A MISSION TO 550 00:26:51,129 --> 00:26:52,764 ENHANCE THE RESEARCH 551 00:26:52,764 --> 00:26:54,533 COMPETITIVENESS OF INSTITUTIONS 552 00:26:54,533 --> 00:26:55,133 IN STATES THAT HISTORICALLY 553 00:26:55,133 --> 00:26:58,970 RECEIVE LOW LEVELS OF NIH 554 00:26:58,970 --> 00:26:59,404 RESEARCH FUNDING. 555 00:26:59,404 --> 00:27:02,841 IN 2011 WITH THE DISSOLLULATION 556 00:27:02,841 --> 00:27:04,342 OF THE CENTER FOR NATURAL 557 00:27:04,342 --> 00:27:06,111 RESOURCES, IT WAS MOVED TO 558 00:27:06,111 --> 00:27:06,545 NIGMS. 559 00:27:06,545 --> 00:27:08,947 IT'S A LINE ITEM IN OUR 560 00:27:08,947 --> 00:27:10,515 APPROPRIATIONS AND IN FISCAL 561 00:27:10,515 --> 00:27:13,985 YEAR 24, IT WAS $431 MILLION. 562 00:27:13,985 --> 00:27:16,421 IT SUPPORTS BASIC TRANSLATIONAL 563 00:27:16,421 --> 00:27:16,955 CLENICAL AND BEHAVIORIAL 564 00:27:16,955 --> 00:27:20,692 RESEARCH AS WELL AS RESEARCH 565 00:27:20,692 --> 00:27:22,394 WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT AND 566 00:27:22,394 --> 00:27:23,662 INFRASTRUCTURE ENHANCE WANTS IN 567 00:27:23,662 --> 00:27:24,296 THE IDEA STATES. 568 00:27:24,296 --> 00:27:26,164 AND THE IDEA STATES ARE SHOWN ON 569 00:27:26,164 --> 00:27:28,934 THE MAP COLOR INDEED BLUE, 23 570 00:27:28,934 --> 00:27:34,239 STATES PLUS PUERTO RICO. 571 00:27:34,239 --> 00:27:34,739 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 572 00:27:34,739 --> 00:27:36,741 NOW YOU COULD ASK WHY DO WE HAVE 573 00:27:36,741 --> 00:27:39,744 AN IDEA PROGRAM, WHY DO WE WANT 574 00:27:39,744 --> 00:27:40,645 TO BUILD RESEARCH CAPACITY AT 575 00:27:40,645 --> 00:27:40,812 ALL? 576 00:27:40,812 --> 00:27:42,280 AND I THINK THERE ARE REALLY A 577 00:27:42,280 --> 00:27:46,384 NUMBER OF REASONS WHY THIS IS 578 00:27:46,384 --> 00:27:47,252 EXTREMELY COMPELLING FOR THE 579 00:27:47,252 --> 00:27:49,287 COUNTRY AND IMPORTANT USE AND 580 00:27:49,287 --> 00:27:52,257 IMPORTANT INVESTMENT OF TAXPAYER 581 00:27:52,257 --> 00:27:52,457 FUNDS. 582 00:27:52,457 --> 00:27:54,392 THE 1 I FIND THE MOST COMPETING 583 00:27:54,392 --> 00:27:56,595 AND IF I WERE TO ONLY SAY 1 IT 584 00:27:56,595 --> 00:28:00,932 WOULD BE UNTAPPED SCIENCE 585 00:28:00,932 --> 00:28:02,100 TALENT. 586 00:28:02,100 --> 00:28:02,834 THERE IS TREMENDOUSTALINENT 587 00:28:02,834 --> 00:28:04,336 EVERY STATE IN THE COUNTRY BUT 588 00:28:04,336 --> 00:28:05,837 IF FUNDAMENTAL OR OTHER RESEARCH 589 00:28:05,837 --> 00:28:07,439 WAS ONLY GOING ON IN JUST SAY 590 00:28:07,439 --> 00:28:09,307 HALF THE STATES, WE WOULD LOSE 591 00:28:09,307 --> 00:28:11,109 THE TALENTS IN THE OTHER HALF OF 592 00:28:11,109 --> 00:28:12,577 THE STATES BECAUSE THOSE 593 00:28:12,577 --> 00:28:13,478 STUDENTS, THOSE YOUNG PEOPLE 594 00:28:13,478 --> 00:28:17,616 WOULD NOT HAVE ACCESS TO TRYING 595 00:28:17,616 --> 00:28:18,383 OUT DOING BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH, 596 00:28:18,383 --> 00:28:21,152 THEY WOULDN'T LEARN THEY HAD A 597 00:28:21,152 --> 00:28:22,821 PASSION AND A TALENT FOR IT AND 598 00:28:22,821 --> 00:28:24,155 THEY WOULD DO SOMETHING ELSE 599 00:28:24,155 --> 00:28:24,489 INSTEAD. 600 00:28:24,489 --> 00:28:27,092 SO IT IS ESSENTIAL IN MY VIEW 601 00:28:27,092 --> 00:28:29,327 THAT WE HAVE CUTTING EMG 602 00:28:29,327 --> 00:28:30,495 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH GOING ON IN 603 00:28:30,495 --> 00:28:33,164 ALL 50 STATES AND IN TERRITORIES 604 00:28:33,164 --> 00:28:36,034 SO THAT WE CAN TAP INTO THAT 605 00:28:36,034 --> 00:28:36,735 INCREDIBLE SCIENTIFIC TALENT 606 00:28:36,735 --> 00:28:38,203 THAT EXISTS THROUGHOUT THE 607 00:28:38,203 --> 00:28:40,338 COUNTRY AND MAKE SURE THAT THE 608 00:28:40,338 --> 00:28:41,907 SCIENTISTS OF THE FUTURE ARE 609 00:28:41,907 --> 00:28:43,508 DRAWING FROM THIS ENTIRE TALENT 610 00:28:43,508 --> 00:28:43,975 POOL. 611 00:28:43,975 --> 00:28:45,544 IT'S SORT OF WHAT'S OFTEN BEEN 612 00:28:45,544 --> 00:28:47,178 DESCRIBED AS OR AS BEEN 613 00:28:47,178 --> 00:28:49,414 DESCRIBED IN THE PAST AS THE 614 00:28:49,414 --> 00:28:56,755 LOST EINSTEIN EFFECT. 615 00:28:56,755 --> 00:28:58,223 AGAIN, IF FUNDAMENTAL SCIENCE 616 00:28:58,223 --> 00:29:00,525 WAS BEING DONE IN HALF THE 617 00:29:00,525 --> 00:29:01,526 STATES, WE WOULD LOSE THOSE 618 00:29:01,526 --> 00:29:04,229 PEOPLE I JUST TALKED ABOUT A 619 00:29:04,229 --> 00:29:05,664 COUPLE MINUTES AGO. 620 00:29:05,664 --> 00:29:06,865 THERE ARE COMPELLING REASONS 621 00:29:06,865 --> 00:29:08,733 THOUGH, THERE ARE SPECIFIC 622 00:29:08,733 --> 00:29:10,168 REGION HEALTH CHALLENGES AND 623 00:29:10,168 --> 00:29:11,269 PRIORITIES. 624 00:29:11,269 --> 00:29:15,807 SO THE HEALTH CHALLENGES IN 625 00:29:15,807 --> 00:29:17,275 STATES DIFFER FROM 1 TO ANOTHER 626 00:29:17,275 --> 00:29:19,544 AND DIFFERENT REGIONS AS WELL. 627 00:29:19,544 --> 00:29:21,079 EXAMPLES OF THIS WOULD BE VALLEY 628 00:29:21,079 --> 00:29:26,184 FEVER THAT OCCURS IN DRY ARID 629 00:29:26,184 --> 00:29:27,385 STATES BUT NOT IN OTHER STATES 630 00:29:27,385 --> 00:29:30,922 THAT HAVE MORE HUMID CONDITIONS. 631 00:29:30,922 --> 00:29:33,224 IF RESEARCH WASN'T GOING ON IN 632 00:29:33,224 --> 00:29:34,626 STATES SAY ON THE COAST, THEN 633 00:29:34,626 --> 00:29:36,328 STATES THAT HAVE VALLEY FEVER 634 00:29:36,328 --> 00:29:38,363 WOULD BE MUCH LESS LIKELY TO GET 635 00:29:38,363 --> 00:29:40,732 THAT HEALTH CONDITION ADDRESSED 636 00:29:40,732 --> 00:29:43,134 THROUGH CUTTING EDGE RESEARCH. 637 00:29:43,134 --> 00:29:45,337 AND SO BEING ABLE TO ADDRESS THE 638 00:29:45,337 --> 00:29:47,305 REGION SPECIFIC HEALTH 639 00:29:47,305 --> 00:29:48,340 CHALLENGES, OF EVERY STATE, I 640 00:29:48,340 --> 00:29:51,009 THINK IS A CRITICAL REASON THAT 641 00:29:51,009 --> 00:29:53,211 WE HAVE TO BUILD RESEARCH 642 00:29:53,211 --> 00:29:55,180 CAPACITY THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE 643 00:29:55,180 --> 00:29:55,413 COUNTRY. 644 00:29:55,413 --> 00:29:58,717 IN ADDITION, WE WANT TO SEE 645 00:29:58,717 --> 00:29:59,918 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SPURRED 646 00:29:59,918 --> 00:30:02,020 THROUGH BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH 647 00:30:02,020 --> 00:30:03,955 THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE COUNTRY. 648 00:30:03,955 --> 00:30:05,690 THE BIOTECH SECTOR IS A VERY 649 00:30:05,690 --> 00:30:07,058 FAST GROWING AND IMPORTANT 650 00:30:07,058 --> 00:30:09,427 SECTOR OF THE ECONOMY, BUT 651 00:30:09,427 --> 00:30:10,895 CURRENTLY, IT REALLY EXISTS IN 652 00:30:10,895 --> 00:30:12,797 ONLY A SMALL SUBSET OF REGIONS, 653 00:30:12,797 --> 00:30:15,033 AND SO 1 OF THE GOALS IS TO 654 00:30:15,033 --> 00:30:17,836 ALLOW OTHER REGIONS AND STATES 655 00:30:17,836 --> 00:30:20,271 TO TAP INTO THIS GROWTH ENGINE 656 00:30:20,271 --> 00:30:22,774 FOR THEIR ECONOMIES AS WELL. 657 00:30:22,774 --> 00:30:24,609 AND THEN FINALLY, IF RESEARCH IS 658 00:30:24,609 --> 00:30:27,178 ONLY GOING ON IN SAY, A SUBSET 659 00:30:27,178 --> 00:30:30,081 OF THE STATES, THE BENEFITS OF 660 00:30:30,081 --> 00:30:32,350 THAT BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH AND AN 661 00:30:32,350 --> 00:30:33,985 UNDERSTANDING OF THE REASONS FOR 662 00:30:33,985 --> 00:30:34,619 DOING THAT BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH 663 00:30:34,619 --> 00:30:36,755 ARE NOT GOING TO BE DISTRIBUTED 664 00:30:36,755 --> 00:30:38,356 EVENLY ACROSS THE STATES BUT BY 665 00:30:38,356 --> 00:30:40,058 HAVING RESEARCH GOING ON IN 666 00:30:40,058 --> 00:30:41,826 EVERY STATE, THE STATE VS VESTED 667 00:30:41,826 --> 00:30:44,095 INTEREST IN THE RESEARCH, THEY 668 00:30:44,095 --> 00:30:46,798 CAN GUIDE THE RESEARCH IN WAYS 669 00:30:46,798 --> 00:30:49,601 THAT ARE APPROPRIATE FOR THEIR 670 00:30:49,601 --> 00:30:51,202 POPULATIONS AND THEIR PEOPLE AND 671 00:30:51,202 --> 00:30:52,570 YOU KNOW THAT ALLOWS EVERYONE IN 672 00:30:52,570 --> 00:30:55,373 THE COUNTRY TO BENEFIT FROM 673 00:30:55,373 --> 00:31:02,947 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH, NOT JUST 674 00:31:02,947 --> 00:31:03,581 SUBGROUPS OF PEOPLE. 675 00:31:03,581 --> 00:31:04,482 THOSE ARE SOME OF THE REASONS 676 00:31:04,482 --> 00:31:06,918 BUT I THINK THEY'RE INCREDIBLY 677 00:31:06,918 --> 00:31:10,889 COMPELLING AS TO WHY WE DO 678 00:31:10,889 --> 00:31:11,756 CAPACITY BUILDING AND WHY IN 679 00:31:11,756 --> 00:31:12,791 PARTICULAR WE HAVE THE PROGRAM. 680 00:31:12,791 --> 00:31:13,291 NEXT SLIDE. 681 00:31:13,291 --> 00:31:16,227 SO THE IDEA PROGRAM HAS 5 682 00:31:16,227 --> 00:31:18,329 PRINCIPAL COMPONENTS, THEY'RE 683 00:31:18,329 --> 00:31:20,131 THE CENTERS FOR BIOMEDICAL 684 00:31:20,131 --> 00:31:22,500 RESEARCH EXCELLENCE OR THE 685 00:31:22,500 --> 00:31:24,002 COBREs, THEY ARE CENTERS THAT 686 00:31:24,002 --> 00:31:25,737 ALLOW INSTITUTIONS OR GROUPS OF 687 00:31:25,737 --> 00:31:28,707 INSTITUTIONS TO BUILD RESEARCH 688 00:31:28,707 --> 00:31:30,341 CAPACITY IN PARTICULAR 689 00:31:30,341 --> 00:31:30,942 SCIENTIFIC AREAS OF STRATEGIC 690 00:31:30,942 --> 00:31:33,044 IMPORTANCE TO THAT INSTITUTE. 691 00:31:33,044 --> 00:31:36,181 SO THIS COULD BE -- COULD YOU GO 692 00:31:36,181 --> 00:31:36,548 FORWARD, PLEASE? 693 00:31:36,548 --> 00:31:38,516 THANK YOU. 694 00:31:38,516 --> 00:31:41,252 SO THESE COULD BE AREAS SUCH AS 695 00:31:41,252 --> 00:31:43,588 BASIC RESEARCH AREAS, STRUCTURAL 696 00:31:43,588 --> 00:31:46,291 BIOLOGY, ANN WEST WHO'S HERE HAS 697 00:31:46,291 --> 00:31:48,126 A REALLY SUCCESSFUL COBRE AT THE 698 00:31:48,126 --> 00:31:51,629 UNIVERSITY OF OKLAHOMA IN 699 00:31:51,629 --> 00:31:52,063 STRUCTURAL BIOLOGY. 700 00:31:52,063 --> 00:31:54,265 IT COULD BE SOMETHING LIKE 701 00:31:54,265 --> 00:32:01,673 BIOMEDICAL DATA SCIENCE TO BUILD 702 00:32:01,673 --> 00:32:03,775 THAT CAPACITY, IT COULD BE AREAS 703 00:32:03,775 --> 00:32:04,843 FOR BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH, 704 00:32:04,843 --> 00:32:07,078 INSTITUTES THAT DON'T HAVE A 705 00:32:07,078 --> 00:32:09,147 STRENGTH IN BUT ARE STRATEGIC 706 00:32:09,147 --> 00:32:11,850 IMPORTANT FOR GROWTH, THE COBRE 707 00:32:11,850 --> 00:32:13,218 CENTER ALLOWS THEM TO SUPPORT 708 00:32:13,218 --> 00:32:14,519 THOSE HIRES, THE URINE FACULTY 709 00:32:14,519 --> 00:32:16,221 ONCE THEY GET THERE WITH FUNDING 710 00:32:16,221 --> 00:32:19,524 AND MENTORING AS WELL AS 711 00:32:19,524 --> 00:32:20,959 RESOURCE INFRASTRUCTURE, CORE 712 00:32:20,959 --> 00:32:22,827 FACAS SIGNATURESSITYS, IMPROVE 713 00:32:22,827 --> 00:32:24,395 WANTS TO LAB FACILITIES, ET 714 00:32:24,395 --> 00:32:24,996 CETERA. 715 00:32:24,996 --> 00:32:28,566 CURRENTLY THERE ARE ABOUT ALMOST 716 00:32:28,566 --> 00:32:30,201 150 COBREs ACROSS THE COUNTRY 717 00:32:30,201 --> 00:32:33,338 IN A VAST ARRAY OF DIFFERENT 718 00:32:33,338 --> 00:32:34,005 AREAS. 719 00:32:34,005 --> 00:32:35,607 EACH IDEA STATE HAS WHAT WE CALL 720 00:32:35,607 --> 00:32:39,077 AN IDEA NETWORK OF BIOMEDICAL 721 00:32:39,077 --> 00:32:41,713 RESEARCH EXCELLENCE OR INBRE, 722 00:32:41,713 --> 00:32:44,048 THESE ARE STATEWIDE NETWORKS 723 00:32:44,048 --> 00:32:46,818 THAT LINK 1 OR MORE RESEARCH 724 00:32:46,818 --> 00:32:49,154 INSTITUTION TO THE STATE TO THE 725 00:32:49,154 --> 00:32:49,621 PRIMARY UNDERGRADUATE 726 00:32:49,621 --> 00:32:50,221 INSTITUTIONS OF THE STATE AND 727 00:32:50,221 --> 00:32:53,625 THEY FORM A PATHWAY THROUGH 728 00:32:53,625 --> 00:32:56,161 WHICH THE UNDERGRADUATE 729 00:32:56,161 --> 00:32:57,028 INSTITUTIONS CAN GET RESEARCH 730 00:32:57,028 --> 00:32:58,363 EXPERIENCE AT THEIR OWN 731 00:32:58,363 --> 00:33:01,633 INSTITUTION OR AT THE RESEARCH 732 00:33:01,633 --> 00:33:02,333 INTENSIVE INSTITUTIONS. 733 00:33:02,333 --> 00:33:04,135 THEY PROVIDE SUPPORT FOR THE 734 00:33:04,135 --> 00:33:05,904 STUDENTS TO WORK EITHER DURING 735 00:33:05,904 --> 00:33:07,605 THE SCHOOL YEAR OR IN THE SUMMER 736 00:33:07,605 --> 00:33:10,909 IN LABS, DOING RESEARCH, THEY 737 00:33:10,909 --> 00:33:14,012 PROVIDE INFRASTRUCTURE FOR CORE 738 00:33:14,012 --> 00:33:16,080 FACILITIES, THEY PROVIDE 739 00:33:16,080 --> 00:33:17,282 RENOVATION EXPENSES TO UPGRADE 740 00:33:17,282 --> 00:33:20,451 THE FACILITIES AND THE PRIMARILY 741 00:33:20,451 --> 00:33:21,386 UNDERGRADUATE INSTITUTIONS AND 742 00:33:21,386 --> 00:33:23,755 ALSO SUPPORT FOR FACULTY TO 743 00:33:23,755 --> 00:33:26,624 START RESEARCH PROJECTS TO BRING 744 00:33:26,624 --> 00:33:28,927 THE RESEARCH CAPACITY OF THOSE 745 00:33:28,927 --> 00:33:30,094 PRIMARILY UNDERGRADUATE 746 00:33:30,094 --> 00:33:31,229 INSTITUTIONS HIGHER. 747 00:33:31,229 --> 00:33:34,799 AND THAT BUILDS A PIPELINE OR A 748 00:33:34,799 --> 00:33:37,101 PATHWAY IN THE STATE FROM THE 749 00:33:37,101 --> 00:33:38,536 YOUNG PEOPLE, THE UNDERGRADUATES 750 00:33:38,536 --> 00:33:40,371 TO GET THEM EXPERIENCED TO GET 751 00:33:40,371 --> 00:33:42,240 THEM EXCITED ABOUT RESEARCH AND 752 00:33:42,240 --> 00:33:44,309 THEN GOING INTO LABS AT THE 753 00:33:44,309 --> 00:33:46,477 PRIMARILY -- THE RESEARCH 754 00:33:46,477 --> 00:33:49,581 INTENSIVE INSTITUTIONS IN THOSE 755 00:33:49,581 --> 00:33:49,814 STATES. 756 00:33:49,814 --> 00:33:52,016 WE ALSO ARE A PROGRAM CALLED THE 757 00:33:52,016 --> 00:33:53,218 CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL 758 00:33:53,218 --> 00:33:56,020 RESEARCH AWARDS PROGRAM. 759 00:33:56,020 --> 00:33:57,522 THIS IS DESIGNED TO BUILD 760 00:33:57,522 --> 00:33:59,290 RESEARCH CAPACITY IN CLINICAL 761 00:33:59,290 --> 00:34:00,959 AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH 762 00:34:00,959 --> 00:34:03,728 WITHIN INSTITUTIONS IN THOSE 763 00:34:03,728 --> 00:34:03,962 STATES. 764 00:34:03,962 --> 00:34:06,064 THEY ARE SIMILAR TO THE CTSAs 765 00:34:06,064 --> 00:34:09,067 THAT ARE SUPPORTED BY NCATS, BUT 766 00:34:09,067 --> 00:34:11,135 THEY ARE SPECIFIC TO THE IDEA 767 00:34:11,135 --> 00:34:13,538 STATES, AND HAVE SOME SPECIAL 768 00:34:13,538 --> 00:34:15,273 FEATURES FOR THE IDEA STATES 769 00:34:15,273 --> 00:34:19,110 THAT ALLOW THEM TO TARGET, AGAIN 770 00:34:19,110 --> 00:34:20,111 THOSE HEALTH BURDENS AND HEALTH 771 00:34:20,111 --> 00:34:22,580 AREAS OF NEED THAT ARE SPECIFIC 772 00:34:22,580 --> 00:34:27,252 TO THE PARTICULAR STATE IN WHICH 773 00:34:27,252 --> 00:34:37,528 THE CTRs EXIST. 774 00:34:44,335 --> 00:34:46,771 THESE CURRENTLY THESE REGIONS 775 00:34:46,771 --> 00:34:49,574 THEY DEVELOP UNDERSTANDING AND 776 00:34:49,574 --> 00:34:50,708 SKILLS AMONGST FACULTY, POST 777 00:34:50,708 --> 00:34:52,777 DOCS AND STUDENTS IN HOW TO 778 00:34:52,777 --> 00:34:54,612 COMMERCIALIZE FINDINGS FROM THE 779 00:34:54,612 --> 00:34:58,182 LAB AND MOVE THEM INTO ACTUAL 780 00:34:58,182 --> 00:34:59,217 PRODUCTS EVENTUALLY. 781 00:34:59,217 --> 00:35:00,919 WE ARE GOING TO RETOOL THIS 782 00:35:00,919 --> 00:35:02,287 PROGRAM, WE THINK WE WILL 783 00:35:02,287 --> 00:35:04,155 PROBABLY EXPAND IT SO THAT IT'S 784 00:35:04,155 --> 00:35:06,591 MORE THAN JUST 1 IN EACH OF THE 785 00:35:06,591 --> 00:35:08,326 4 IDEA REGIONS, THAT WAS A LOT 786 00:35:08,326 --> 00:35:10,395 EACH OF THOSE CENTERS TO TAKE 787 00:35:10,395 --> 00:35:15,199 ON, AND MAYBE MAKE IT MORE 788 00:35:15,199 --> 00:35:18,803 TARGETED AT INDIVIDUAL STATES OR 789 00:35:18,803 --> 00:35:19,604 NEIGHBORING STATES AND THEN 790 00:35:19,604 --> 00:35:21,239 FINALLY WE HAVE THE IDEA CO 791 00:35:21,239 --> 00:35:22,840 FUNDING PROGRAM. 792 00:35:22,840 --> 00:35:26,878 THE IDEA PROGRAM WILL SUPPORT 793 00:35:26,878 --> 00:35:29,113 RESEARCH GRANTS AT OTHER NIH 794 00:35:29,113 --> 00:35:30,048 INSTITUTES AND CENTERS THAT 795 00:35:30,048 --> 00:35:33,217 SCORE WELL IN REVIEW THAT WERE 796 00:35:33,217 --> 00:35:34,953 MERITORIOUS BUT WEREN'T QUITE 797 00:35:34,953 --> 00:35:36,654 GOOD ENOUGH IN TERMS OF THEIR 798 00:35:36,654 --> 00:35:38,823 SCORES TO GET FUNDED AT THOSE 799 00:35:38,823 --> 00:35:40,558 NIH INSTITUTES AND CENTERS, THE 800 00:35:40,558 --> 00:35:43,061 IDEA PROGRAM WILL FUND THE FIRST 801 00:35:43,061 --> 00:35:45,229 2 YEARS OF THOSE GRANTS, WHICH 802 00:35:45,229 --> 00:35:46,597 ALLOWS THEM TO GET FUNDED AND 803 00:35:46,597 --> 00:35:48,166 THEN THOSE INSTITUTES AND 804 00:35:48,166 --> 00:35:49,834 CENTERS PICK UP THE OUT YEARS 805 00:35:49,834 --> 00:35:52,170 AFTER THOSE FIRST 2 YEARS AND WE 806 00:35:52,170 --> 00:35:54,605 FIND ABOUT 30 RESEARCH GRANTS A 807 00:35:54,605 --> 00:35:56,941 YEAR THROUGH THIS CO FUNDING 808 00:35:56,941 --> 00:35:58,843 PROGRAM SO THAT'S GETTING A FAIR 809 00:35:58,843 --> 00:36:00,011 NUMBER OF GRANTS FUNDED THAT 810 00:36:00,011 --> 00:36:01,279 WOULD OTHERWISE NOT HAVE BEEN 811 00:36:01,279 --> 00:36:02,981 FUND INDEED IDEA STATES. 812 00:36:02,981 --> 00:36:07,251 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 813 00:36:07,251 --> 00:36:10,755 SO JUST A FEW EXAMPLES OF THE 814 00:36:10,755 --> 00:36:13,091 COBREs THAT EXIST AROUND THE 815 00:36:13,091 --> 00:36:14,258 COUNTRY THESE ARE JUST PICKED TO 816 00:36:14,258 --> 00:36:16,094 GIVE YOU A FLAVOR OF THE 817 00:36:16,094 --> 00:36:18,296 DIFFERENT KINDS OF THINGS THAT 818 00:36:18,296 --> 00:36:20,732 ARE BEING SUPPORTED IN IDAHO 819 00:36:20,732 --> 00:36:23,801 THERE'S A COBRE ON NUTRITION AND 820 00:36:23,801 --> 00:36:26,471 WOMEN'S HEALTH AND MONTANA 821 00:36:26,471 --> 00:36:28,206 THERE'S INTEGRATED BIOMEDICAL 822 00:36:28,206 --> 00:36:32,410 AND RESEARCH WORLD HEALTH COBRE, 823 00:36:32,410 --> 00:36:34,078 IN MAINE THERE'S ACUTE CARE AND 824 00:36:34,078 --> 00:36:35,213 RESEARCH IN RURAL DISPARITIES, 825 00:36:35,213 --> 00:36:38,249 IN KENTUCKY THERE'S A COBRE IN 826 00:36:38,249 --> 00:36:39,283 PHARMACEUTICAL RESEARCH AND 827 00:36:39,283 --> 00:36:40,284 INNOVATION AND IN MISSISSIPPI 828 00:36:40,284 --> 00:36:41,886 THERE'S A TBLIEK O SCIENCE 829 00:36:41,886 --> 00:36:42,720 CENTER OF RESEARCH EXCELLENCE 830 00:36:42,720 --> 00:36:44,822 AND IN KANSAS THERE'S A 831 00:36:44,822 --> 00:36:46,958 MOLECULAR ANALYSIS OF DISEASE 832 00:36:46,958 --> 00:36:47,225 PATHWAYS. 833 00:36:47,225 --> 00:36:49,527 SO THOSE ARE JUST A FLAVOR FROM 834 00:36:49,527 --> 00:36:52,196 BASIC SCIENCE ALL THE WAY TO 835 00:36:52,196 --> 00:36:54,632 POPULATION HEALTH STUDIES. 836 00:36:54,632 --> 00:36:56,768 A VARIETY OF EXTERNAL STUDIES 837 00:36:56,768 --> 00:36:58,069 CONDUCTED BY INDEPENDENT 838 00:36:58,069 --> 00:36:59,937 INVESTIGATORS, HAS SHOWN THAT 839 00:36:59,937 --> 00:37:01,406 CON, BREs ARE EXTREMELY 840 00:37:01,406 --> 00:37:04,809 SUCCESSFUL AT LEAST IN 841 00:37:04,809 --> 00:37:05,476 PARTICULAR CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHAT 842 00:37:05,476 --> 00:37:08,279 I TALKED ABOUT IN BUILDING THE 843 00:37:08,279 --> 00:37:10,048 BASE OF JUNIOR INVESTIGATORS AND 844 00:37:10,048 --> 00:37:12,016 GETTING THEM TO FUNDING 845 00:37:12,016 --> 00:37:13,418 INDEPENDENCE AND SUCCESS. 846 00:37:13,418 --> 00:37:16,354 SO, A PAPER PUBLISHED ABOUT THE 847 00:37:16,354 --> 00:37:19,190 COBREs IN NEVADA, SHOWED THAT 848 00:37:19,190 --> 00:37:21,025 THEY INCREASE THE SUCCESS RATE 849 00:37:21,025 --> 00:37:24,362 OF JUNIOR FACULTY IN RECEIVING 850 00:37:24,362 --> 00:37:26,497 FUNDING, BY APPROXIMATELY 3 FOLD 851 00:37:26,497 --> 00:37:29,467 FROM 15% TO 47% RELATIVE TO 852 00:37:29,467 --> 00:37:31,803 MATCHED PIs WHO DID NOT 853 00:37:31,803 --> 00:37:33,471 PARTICIPATE IN COBREs, SO 854 00:37:33,471 --> 00:37:34,405 THAT'S REALLY QUITE IMPRESSIVE 855 00:37:34,405 --> 00:37:35,740 AND OTHER STUDY VS SHOWN SIMILAR 856 00:37:35,740 --> 00:37:37,575 THINGS AND YOU WILL HEAR THAT WE 857 00:37:37,575 --> 00:37:39,944 ARE LAUNCHING OUR OWN MORE 858 00:37:39,944 --> 00:37:41,312 GLOBAL EVALUATION OF THE COBE 859 00:37:41,312 --> 00:37:43,481 PROGRAM AS WELL, WE WILL ASK 860 00:37:43,481 --> 00:37:45,349 YOUR PERMISSION TO MOVE 861 00:37:45,349 --> 00:37:47,185 FORWARD WITH THAT IN A FEW 862 00:37:47,185 --> 00:37:53,257 MINUTES. 863 00:37:53,257 --> 00:37:54,258 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 864 00:37:54,258 --> 00:37:56,461 JUST A COUPLE SUCCESS STORIES OF 865 00:37:56,461 --> 00:37:57,095 THOSE JUNIOR INVESTIGATORS WHO 866 00:37:57,095 --> 00:38:00,098 HAVE COME OUT OF CON, BREs, 2 867 00:38:00,098 --> 00:38:02,600 INVESTIGATORS OUT OF THE KANSAS 868 00:38:02,600 --> 00:38:05,503 COBRE I MENTIONED, THE CENTER 869 00:38:05,503 --> 00:38:06,771 FOR MOLECULAR DISEASE PATHWAYS 870 00:38:06,771 --> 00:38:10,942 HAVE GONE ON TO RECEIVE THE MI 871 00:38:10,942 --> 00:38:14,679 RA AWARDS I TOLD YOU ABOUT 872 00:38:14,679 --> 00:38:15,113 BEFORE. 873 00:38:15,113 --> 00:38:16,714 JENNIFER ROBINSON RECEIVED A 874 00:38:16,714 --> 00:38:22,620 MIRA TO CONTINUE HER RESEARCH ON 875 00:38:22,620 --> 00:38:24,322 OSTEOARTHRITIS AND JING XIN WANG 876 00:38:24,322 --> 00:38:25,957 RECEIVED A MIEE, AUDIENCE RA 877 00:38:25,957 --> 00:38:27,692 AWARD TO FURTHER EXPLORE RNA 878 00:38:27,692 --> 00:38:28,059 SPLICING. 879 00:38:28,059 --> 00:38:31,629 WE SEE MORE OF THESE RECEIVING 880 00:38:31,629 --> 00:38:33,297 MIRAs THROUGH INITIAL SUPPORT 881 00:38:33,297 --> 00:38:35,733 THEY RECEIVE THROUGH COBRE 882 00:38:35,733 --> 00:38:38,769 GRANTS OR IN SOME CASES FROM 883 00:38:38,769 --> 00:38:40,138 INBRE GRANTS. 884 00:38:40,138 --> 00:38:40,605 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 885 00:38:40,605 --> 00:38:43,241 NOW I WANT TO HONE IN ON JUST 1 886 00:38:43,241 --> 00:38:45,877 IDEA STATE, JUST TO GIVE YOU A 887 00:38:45,877 --> 00:38:46,677 FLAVOR OF SOME OF THE THINGS 888 00:38:46,677 --> 00:38:48,646 THAT ARE GOING ON IN 1 889 00:38:48,646 --> 00:38:51,415 PARTICULAR STATE AND I JUST -- 890 00:38:51,415 --> 00:38:55,086 ARBTRARLY AT SOME LEVEL PICKED 891 00:38:55,086 --> 00:38:55,419 OKLAHOMA. 892 00:38:55,419 --> 00:38:58,122 JUST GIVES YOU A MAP OF THE 893 00:38:58,122 --> 00:39:00,958 ACADEMIC INSTITUTIONS IN 894 00:39:00,958 --> 00:39:01,792 OKLAHOMA. 895 00:39:01,792 --> 00:39:04,695 THERE ARE 29 4-YEAR 896 00:39:04,695 --> 00:39:06,597 INSTITUTIONS, 20 2-YEAR 897 00:39:06,597 --> 00:39:07,865 INSTITUTIONS INCLUDING 1 TRIBAL 898 00:39:07,865 --> 00:39:09,767 COLLEGE AND 3 NONDEGREE GRANTING 899 00:39:09,767 --> 00:39:11,369 RESEARCH INSTITUTIONS AND THEY 900 00:39:11,369 --> 00:39:12,336 ARE BASICALLY SPREAD THROUGHOUT 901 00:39:12,336 --> 00:39:13,437 THE STATE. 902 00:39:13,437 --> 00:39:18,442 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 903 00:39:18,442 --> 00:39:20,044 SOME OVERALL STATISTICS, THE 904 00:39:20,044 --> 00:39:22,113 TOTAL NIH FUNDING FOR OKLAHOMA 905 00:39:22,113 --> 00:39:25,316 AND FISCAL YEAR 2024 WAS A 906 00:39:25,316 --> 00:39:26,317 LITTLE OVER $151 MILLION. 907 00:39:26,317 --> 00:39:30,688 THE TOTAL FUNDING THAT CAME JUST 908 00:39:30,688 --> 00:39:32,023 FROM NIGMS WAS ALMOST 909 00:39:32,023 --> 00:39:34,625 $41 MILLION, SO YOU CAN SEE A 910 00:39:34,625 --> 00:39:35,693 VERY SUBSTANTIAL FRACTION OF THE 911 00:39:35,693 --> 00:39:38,996 TOTAL FUNDING FOR THE STATE OF 912 00:39:38,996 --> 00:39:41,365 OKLAHOMA FROM NIH CAME JUST FROM 913 00:39:41,365 --> 00:39:42,833 NIGMS EVEN THOUGH WE'RE JUST 1 914 00:39:42,833 --> 00:39:44,769 OF 24 INSTITUTES AND CENTERS 915 00:39:44,769 --> 00:39:47,104 THAT GIVES GRANT AWARDS. 916 00:39:47,104 --> 00:39:51,042 THE TOTAL IDEA FUNDING FROM -- 917 00:39:51,042 --> 00:39:54,545 FOR THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA WAS 918 00:39:54,545 --> 00:39:55,112 $28 MILLION, A LITTLE OVER 919 00:39:55,112 --> 00:39:56,514 $28 MILLION, SO THE PERCENTAGE 920 00:39:56,514 --> 00:40:01,285 OF NIH FUNDING FROM NIGMS OVER 921 00:40:01,285 --> 00:40:03,221 ALL, PERCENTAGE OF NIH FUNDING 922 00:40:03,221 --> 00:40:05,189 THAT WAS FROM NIGMS TO OKLAHOMA 923 00:40:05,189 --> 00:40:05,623 WAS 27%. 924 00:40:05,623 --> 00:40:10,161 SO OVER A QUARTER OF THE ENTIRE 925 00:40:10,161 --> 00:40:12,930 STATE'S FUNDING FROM NIH COME 926 00:40:12,930 --> 00:40:14,966 JUST FROM NIGMS AND CONTRAST 927 00:40:14,966 --> 00:40:17,835 THAT THE FACT THAT NIGMS'S 928 00:40:17,835 --> 00:40:19,904 BUNLET AND LESS THAN 7% OF THE 929 00:40:19,904 --> 00:40:22,740 TOTAL NIH BUDGET SO IF WE WERE 930 00:40:22,740 --> 00:40:24,275 GOING ON BUNLET ALLOCATION, THAT 931 00:40:24,275 --> 00:40:26,244 WOULD BE 7% BUT YOU CAN SEE IT'S 932 00:40:26,244 --> 00:40:27,245 ALMOST 4 TIMES THAT LEVEL. 933 00:40:27,245 --> 00:40:28,579 SO THAT SHOWS BOTH THE 934 00:40:28,579 --> 00:40:31,482 IMPORTANCE OF THE IDEA PROGRAM, 935 00:40:31,482 --> 00:40:34,151 BUT ALSO I THINK THAT NIGMS 936 00:40:34,151 --> 00:40:36,320 OVERALL IS PUNCHING ABOVE ITS 937 00:40:36,320 --> 00:40:39,657 WEIGHT IN SUPPORTING STATES SUCH 938 00:40:39,657 --> 00:40:40,558 AS OKLAHOMA. 939 00:40:40,558 --> 00:40:42,627 THE NUMBER OF MIRA GRANTS SO FAR 940 00:40:42,627 --> 00:40:45,429 IN OKLAHOMA AS OF FISCAL YEAR 941 00:40:45,429 --> 00:40:47,198 2024 WAS 16 WHICH IS -- IS GOOD 942 00:40:47,198 --> 00:40:50,568 BUT I THINK WE HAVE CERTAINLY A 943 00:40:50,568 --> 00:40:51,869 FAIR AMOUNT OF ROOM WE COULD 944 00:40:51,869 --> 00:40:54,171 MOVE AND GROW IN THAT REGARD FOR 945 00:40:54,171 --> 00:40:55,606 OKLAHOMA AND THE OTHER IDEA 946 00:40:55,606 --> 00:40:56,207 STATES AS WELL. 947 00:40:56,207 --> 00:40:58,843 SO THAT'S GOING TO BE A 948 00:40:58,843 --> 00:41:01,646 STRATEGIC GOAL OF NIGMS FOR THE 949 00:41:01,646 --> 00:41:02,647 NEXT 5 YEARS. 950 00:41:02,647 --> 00:41:06,350 THE NUMBER OF NIGMS R15 AREA 951 00:41:06,350 --> 00:41:08,586 GRANTS, THESE ARE GRANTS THAT 952 00:41:08,586 --> 00:41:10,521 SUPPORT THOSE PRIMARILY 953 00:41:10,521 --> 00:41:11,155 UNDERGRADUATE INSTITUTIONS IN 954 00:41:11,155 --> 00:41:14,225 THE STATE THAT ARE PART OF THE 955 00:41:14,225 --> 00:41:18,929 INBRE THAT I MENTIONED, SO NOT 956 00:41:18,929 --> 00:41:22,366 BAD BUT ROOM TO GO. 957 00:41:22,366 --> 00:41:23,668 NO R16 SURE GRANTS WHICH ALSO 958 00:41:23,668 --> 00:41:25,236 SUPPORT A SIMILAR AND SUBSET OF 959 00:41:25,236 --> 00:41:26,370 INSTITUTIONS IN THE STATE SO 960 00:41:26,370 --> 00:41:27,705 THAT'S AN AREA THAT I THINK WE 961 00:41:27,705 --> 00:41:30,675 CAN WORK ON TRYING TO GET MORE 962 00:41:30,675 --> 00:41:33,944 OF THOSE IN OKLAHOMA AND 10 963 00:41:33,944 --> 00:41:34,745 COBREs CURRENTLY IN OKLAHOMA 964 00:41:34,745 --> 00:41:40,351 WHICH IS A GOOD NUMBER. 965 00:41:40,351 --> 00:41:41,018 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 966 00:41:41,018 --> 00:41:44,055 THIS JUST GIVES A LIST OF THE 967 00:41:44,055 --> 00:41:45,990 COBREs THAT CURRENTLY EXIST IN 968 00:41:45,990 --> 00:41:46,290 OKLAHOMA. 969 00:41:46,290 --> 00:41:48,693 THEY RANGE AGAIN FROM THE BASIC 970 00:41:48,693 --> 00:41:51,696 SCIENCE, ACROSS THE SPECTRUM ALL 971 00:41:51,696 --> 00:41:54,031 THE WAY TO THINGS THAT ARE MUCH 972 00:41:54,031 --> 00:41:55,866 MORE CLINICALLY AND POPULATION 973 00:41:55,866 --> 00:41:56,200 FOCUSED. 974 00:41:56,200 --> 00:41:58,736 AGAIN, I WILL JUST PARTICULARLY 975 00:41:58,736 --> 00:42:02,406 HIGHLIGHT ANN WEST'S STRUCTURAL 976 00:42:02,406 --> 00:42:05,576 BIOLOGY COBRE AT THE UNIVERSITY 977 00:42:05,576 --> 00:42:06,043 OF OKLAHOMA. 978 00:42:06,043 --> 00:42:07,912 I THINK THAT'S 1 I KEEP COMING 979 00:42:07,912 --> 00:42:09,847 BACK TO AND POINTING TO OVER AND 980 00:42:09,847 --> 00:42:12,316 OVER AGAIN AS A EXTREMELY 981 00:42:12,316 --> 00:42:12,717 SUCCESSFUL COBRE. 982 00:42:12,717 --> 00:42:14,285 THE KIND OF THING THAT WE'RE 983 00:42:14,285 --> 00:42:17,121 LOOKING FOR, A BROAD AREA OF 984 00:42:17,121 --> 00:42:19,657 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH THAT THE 985 00:42:19,657 --> 00:42:21,692 INSTITUTION DECIDED WAS OF 986 00:42:21,692 --> 00:42:23,461 STRATEGIC IMPORTANCE FOR IT TO 987 00:42:23,461 --> 00:42:25,863 GROW IN AND YOU KNOW HA ANN AND 988 00:42:25,863 --> 00:42:28,299 HER COLLEAGUES HAVE DONE THERE 989 00:42:28,299 --> 00:42:29,500 HAS BEEN REALLY IMPRESSIVE. 990 00:42:29,500 --> 00:42:32,303 MANY OTHER IMPORTANT COBREs, 991 00:42:32,303 --> 00:42:34,739 IN THE STATE DEVELOPMENTAL 992 00:42:34,739 --> 00:42:37,041 BIOLOGY, CELLULAR METABOLISM, 993 00:42:37,041 --> 00:42:38,509 CHILDHOOD INTEGRATIVE RESEARCH 994 00:42:38,509 --> 00:42:40,244 ON CHILDHOOD ADVERSITY SO AGAIN 995 00:42:40,244 --> 00:42:41,312 THAT WHOLE SPECTRUM FROM BASIC 996 00:42:41,312 --> 00:42:44,081 SCIENCE ALL THE WAY TO 997 00:42:44,081 --> 00:42:46,717 POPULATION STUDIES AND 998 00:42:46,717 --> 00:42:48,753 EVERYTHING IN BETWEEN. 999 00:42:48,753 --> 00:42:50,488 AND MAYBE ANN WILL HAVE 1000 00:42:50,488 --> 00:42:53,057 SOMETHING TO SAY ABOUT HER 1001 00:42:53,057 --> 00:42:55,626 EXPERIENCES LEADING THE 1002 00:42:55,626 --> 00:42:59,597 STRUCTURAL BIOLOGY OF COBRE AT 1003 00:42:59,597 --> 00:43:01,665 THE END OF THIS. 1004 00:43:01,665 --> 00:43:02,066 NEXT SLIDE. 1005 00:43:02,066 --> 00:43:04,802 I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT THE INBRE IN 1006 00:43:04,802 --> 00:43:05,870 OKLAHOMA AS WELL. 1007 00:43:05,870 --> 00:43:06,570 TWO RESEARCH INTENSIVE 1008 00:43:06,570 --> 00:43:08,773 INSTITUTIONS IN THE STATE SERVE 1009 00:43:08,773 --> 00:43:11,008 AS THE HUBS, THE UNIVERSITY OF 1010 00:43:11,008 --> 00:43:12,410 OKLAHOMA HELT SCIENCES CENTER AS 1011 00:43:12,410 --> 00:43:13,711 THE LEAD AND OKLAHOMA MEDICAL 1012 00:43:13,711 --> 00:43:15,613 RESEARCH FOUNDATION WHICH IS 1 1013 00:43:15,613 --> 00:43:17,081 OF THOSE RESEARCH INSTITUTES IN 1014 00:43:17,081 --> 00:43:20,885 THE STATE IS ALSO A PRIMARY 1015 00:43:20,885 --> 00:43:21,952 PARTICIPANT. 1016 00:43:21,952 --> 00:43:23,654 FIFTEEN PRIMARILY UNDERGRADUATE 1017 00:43:23,654 --> 00:43:24,688 INSTITUTIONS AND COMMUNITY AND 1018 00:43:24,688 --> 00:43:26,524 TRIBAL COLLEGES MAKE UP THE 1019 00:43:26,524 --> 00:43:28,893 SPOKES AND SO THOSE ARE THOSE 1020 00:43:28,893 --> 00:43:31,529 UNDERGRADUATE SCHOOLS I TALKED 1021 00:43:31,529 --> 00:43:31,729 ABOUT. 1022 00:43:31,729 --> 00:43:34,498 THEY SUPPORT FACULTY AND 1023 00:43:34,498 --> 00:43:35,900 STUDENTS RESEARCH PROJECTS, THEY 1024 00:43:35,900 --> 00:43:37,435 DO MENTORING OF BOTH THE 1025 00:43:37,435 --> 00:43:40,671 STUDENTS AND THE FACULTY AT THE 1026 00:43:40,671 --> 00:43:41,539 PRIMARILY UNDERGRAD 1027 00:43:41,539 --> 00:43:44,108 UTINSTITUTIONS, THEY SUPPORT 1028 00:43:44,108 --> 00:43:45,676 CORE FACILITIES PARTICULARLY IN 1029 00:43:45,676 --> 00:43:47,578 DATA SCIENCE SO EVERY INBRE IS 1030 00:43:47,578 --> 00:43:49,013 REQUIRED TO HAVE A DATA SCIENCE 1031 00:43:49,013 --> 00:43:50,414 CORE BECAUSE WE FELT IT WAS SUCH 1032 00:43:50,414 --> 00:43:52,917 AN IMPORTANT AREA FOR EVERY IDEA 1033 00:43:52,917 --> 00:43:55,386 STATE TO HAVE STRENGTH, GROWING 1034 00:43:55,386 --> 00:43:57,321 STRENGTHENED AND THEY ALSO HAVE 1035 00:43:57,321 --> 00:43:59,590 A VERY STRONG PROTEOMICS CORE AS 1036 00:43:59,590 --> 00:44:00,324 WELL. 1037 00:44:00,324 --> 00:44:02,793 THEY ALSO DO INFRASTRUCTURE AND 1038 00:44:02,793 --> 00:44:04,728 ENHANCEMENT SO FOR INSTANCE LAB 1039 00:44:04,728 --> 00:44:07,565 FACILITIES AT THE PRIMARILY 1040 00:44:07,565 --> 00:44:08,966 GRADUATE INSTITUTIONS CAN BE 1041 00:44:08,966 --> 00:44:10,501 RENOVATED AND MADE MORE MODERN 1042 00:44:10,501 --> 00:44:12,436 FROM THE FUNDS THROUGH INBREs, 1043 00:44:12,436 --> 00:44:14,805 AND 1 OF THE EXCITING THINGS I 1044 00:44:14,805 --> 00:44:17,408 THINK ABOUT THE INBRE IS THAT 1045 00:44:17,408 --> 00:44:18,275 THE FEDERAL INVESTMENT WAS 1046 00:44:18,275 --> 00:44:19,677 LEVERAGED BY THE STATE, SO THE 1047 00:44:19,677 --> 00:44:22,613 STATE OF OKLAHOMA CONTRIBUTES 1048 00:44:22,613 --> 00:44:24,482 ADDITIONAL FUNDING TO EXPAND THE 1049 00:44:24,482 --> 00:44:27,151 REACH OF THE INBRE, SO WE GET A 1050 00:44:27,151 --> 00:44:28,786 SINNER GESTIC EFFECT FROM THE 1051 00:44:28,786 --> 00:44:30,321 FEDERAL INVESTMENT IN,A DITION 1052 00:44:30,321 --> 00:44:31,188 TO THE STATE INVESTMENT AND I 1053 00:44:31,188 --> 00:44:32,389 THINK THAT'S KIND OF A HALLMARK 1054 00:44:32,389 --> 00:44:34,558 OF MANY OF THE IDEA PROGRAMS 1055 00:44:34,558 --> 00:44:37,862 THAT YOU SEE WHERE THE STATE 1056 00:44:37,862 --> 00:44:40,898 ALSO CONTRIBUTES ON TOP OF THIS 1057 00:44:40,898 --> 00:44:43,601 NIGMS AND NIH INVESTMENT BECAUSE 1058 00:44:43,601 --> 00:44:45,736 THEY SEE THE INCREDIBLE LOAMACYY 1059 00:44:45,736 --> 00:44:46,403 IMPORTANT WORK THAT'S BEING DONE 1060 00:44:46,403 --> 00:44:48,439 THROUGH THE PROGRAM AND THEY 1061 00:44:48,439 --> 00:44:49,907 REALIZE THEY CAN SYNERGIZE WITH 1062 00:44:49,907 --> 00:44:51,909 IT AND GET EVEN MORE FOR THEIR 1063 00:44:51,909 --> 00:44:57,114 INVESTMENTS ON TOP OF IT. 1064 00:44:57,114 --> 00:44:57,748 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 1065 00:44:57,748 --> 00:45:00,684 AND I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT 1 1066 00:45:00,684 --> 00:45:02,286 RESEARCHER FROM OKLAHOMA, 1067 00:45:02,286 --> 00:45:04,188 SUZANNEA RANKIN, AT THE OKLAHOMA 1068 00:45:04,188 --> 00:45:04,755 MEDICAL RESEARCH FOUNDATION. 1069 00:45:04,755 --> 00:45:07,458 HER WORK IS STUDYING THE WORLD 1070 00:45:07,458 --> 00:45:10,361 OF CO HESIN AND CO HESIN 1071 00:45:10,361 --> 00:45:12,329 REGULATING PROTEINS IN 1072 00:45:12,329 --> 00:45:14,198 CHROMASOME STRUCTURE AND 1073 00:45:14,198 --> 00:45:14,765 CHROMOSOME SEGGREEN 1074 00:45:14,765 --> 00:45:16,033 CELLSICATION, SO WHEN IT'S 1075 00:45:16,033 --> 00:45:16,800 DIVIDED DURING CELL DIVISION 1076 00:45:16,800 --> 00:45:20,471 WHAT IS THE ROLE OF COHESIN AND 1077 00:45:20,471 --> 00:45:22,339 ALLOWING THAT TO HAPPEN. 1078 00:45:22,339 --> 00:45:24,008 AND SEE USES BOTH FROG EGG 1079 00:45:24,008 --> 00:45:26,577 EXTRACTS AS WELL AS HUMAN CELLS 1080 00:45:26,577 --> 00:45:28,512 AS RESEARCH SYSTEMS. 1081 00:45:28,512 --> 00:45:31,048 SO I THINK QUITE NICE CROSSING 1082 00:45:31,048 --> 00:45:34,585 THE BOUNDARIES BETWEEN SPECIES 1083 00:45:34,585 --> 00:45:36,854 TO LEARN FUNDAMENTAL KNOWLEDGE 1084 00:45:36,854 --> 00:45:38,489 ABOUT HOW BIOLOGY WORKS THROUGH 1085 00:45:38,489 --> 00:45:40,324 HER WORK IN BOTH OF THESE 1086 00:45:40,324 --> 00:45:42,226 DIFFERENT SYSTEMS. 1087 00:45:42,226 --> 00:45:44,395 SHE WAS SUPPORTED ACTUALLY PRIOR 1088 00:45:44,395 --> 00:45:48,198 TO GETTING INDEPENDENT FUNDING 1089 00:45:48,198 --> 00:45:51,468 THROUGH OKLAHOMA INBRE, AND SHE 1090 00:45:51,468 --> 00:45:55,573 NOW HAS AN NIGMS MIRA SUPPORT SO 1091 00:45:55,573 --> 00:45:58,909 REALLY GREAT FACT THAT SHE WENT 1092 00:45:58,909 --> 00:46:00,778 FROM SUPPORT FROM INBRE TO 1093 00:46:00,778 --> 00:46:02,513 GETTING AN NIGMS MIRA GRANT 1094 00:46:02,513 --> 00:46:03,480 SHOWING THAT THE PIPELINE WE ARE 1095 00:46:03,480 --> 00:46:05,549 TRYING TO BUILD HAS BEEN WORKING 1096 00:46:05,549 --> 00:46:14,224 SO FAR AND WE CAN EXPAND UPON 1097 00:46:14,224 --> 00:46:15,559 THAT. 1098 00:46:15,559 --> 00:46:16,694 NEXT SLIDE PLEASE. 1099 00:46:16,694 --> 00:46:18,195 AND FINALLY, I JUST WANT TO END 1100 00:46:18,195 --> 00:46:21,532 WITH HIGHLIGHTING 1 OF OUR 1101 00:46:21,532 --> 00:46:22,066 TRAINING PROGRAMS. 1102 00:46:22,066 --> 00:46:24,969 AS YOU KNOW NIGMS IS 1 OF THE 1103 00:46:24,969 --> 00:46:27,705 BIGGEST FUNDERS OF T32 1104 00:46:27,705 --> 00:46:28,572 INSTITUTIONAL PREDOCTORAL 1105 00:46:28,572 --> 00:46:29,673 TRAINING GRANTS, IS THE BIGGEST 1106 00:46:29,673 --> 00:46:33,477 LENDER OF THOSE AT NIH. 1107 00:46:33,477 --> 00:46:36,146 WE HAVE A NEW OR REVAMPED 1108 00:46:36,146 --> 00:46:38,349 SUBCATEGORY OF OUR T32, SO WE 1109 00:46:38,349 --> 00:46:40,584 HAVE DIFFERENT AREAS IN WHICH WE 1110 00:46:40,584 --> 00:46:43,454 GET T32S, THINGS LIKE CELL AND 1111 00:46:43,454 --> 00:46:45,422 MOLECULAR BIOLOGY, BEHAVIORIAL, 1112 00:46:45,422 --> 00:46:46,156 BASIC BEHAVIORIAL STUDIES, ET 1113 00:46:46,156 --> 00:46:47,257 CETERA, AND YOU CAN GO TO OUR 1114 00:46:47,257 --> 00:46:50,327 WEBSITE TO SEE WHAT THOSE ARE, 1115 00:46:50,327 --> 00:46:52,129 BUT WE'VE RECENTLY VASMED THE 1116 00:46:52,129 --> 00:46:52,763 TRANSDEPARTMENTMENTAL AREA, AND 1117 00:46:52,763 --> 00:46:55,432 THE GOAL OF THIS PROGRAM IS TO 1118 00:46:55,432 --> 00:46:58,769 BROADEN THE SCOPE OF OUR 1119 00:46:58,769 --> 00:47:00,037 INSTITUTIONAL T32 PREDOCTORAL 1120 00:47:00,037 --> 00:47:02,306 TRAINING GRANTS, IN TERMS OF 1121 00:47:02,306 --> 00:47:04,274 BOTH THE INSTITUTIONS THEY 1122 00:47:04,274 --> 00:47:07,111 SUPPORT AND THEIR GEOGRAPHIC 1123 00:47:07,111 --> 00:47:07,611 DISTRIBUTION. 1124 00:47:07,611 --> 00:47:10,781 WE ARE TRYING TO USE THESE TO 1125 00:47:10,781 --> 00:47:12,650 ENHANCE ORGANIZATIONAL CAPACITY 1126 00:47:12,650 --> 00:47:14,051 FOR BASIC BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH 1127 00:47:14,051 --> 00:47:15,986 TRAINING AND TO PROVIDE RESEARCH 1128 00:47:15,986 --> 00:47:17,588 TRAINING OPPORTUNITIES TO 1129 00:47:17,588 --> 00:47:19,923 STUDENTS FROM A WIDE BREDTH OF 1130 00:47:19,923 --> 00:47:23,594 BIOMEDICAL DISCIPLINES AT THE 1131 00:47:23,594 --> 00:47:25,796 PARTICIPATING ORGANIZATIONS. 1132 00:47:25,796 --> 00:47:27,831 THEY ARE ELIGIBLE FOR INTUITIONS 1133 00:47:27,831 --> 00:47:31,735 ARE ELIGIBLE TO APPLY FOR THIS 1134 00:47:31,735 --> 00:47:34,872 TRACK IF THEY HAVE NO PREVIOUS 1135 00:47:34,872 --> 00:47:37,408 NIH T32s, NO OTHER NIGMS 1136 00:47:37,408 --> 00:47:38,942 T32s WITH A COUPLE MINOR 1137 00:47:38,942 --> 00:47:41,578 EXCEPTIONS AND WE'RE STRONGLY 1138 00:47:41,578 --> 00:47:42,179 ENCOURAGING ORGANIZATIONS IN 1139 00:47:42,179 --> 00:47:43,047 IDEA STATES TO APPLY. 1140 00:47:43,047 --> 00:47:46,717 SO THIS IS NOT PART OF THE IDEA 1141 00:47:46,717 --> 00:47:48,485 PROGRAM, WE DON'T SUPPORT IT IN 1142 00:47:48,485 --> 00:47:50,320 GENERAL WITH THE IDEA 1143 00:47:50,320 --> 00:47:52,056 APPROPRIATIONS, BUT IT'S ANOTHER 1144 00:47:52,056 --> 00:47:53,590 WAY WE'RE LEVERAGING NIGMS FUNDS 1145 00:47:53,590 --> 00:47:55,125 TO TRY TO SUPPORT THE IDEA 1146 00:47:55,125 --> 00:47:55,359 STATES. 1147 00:47:55,359 --> 00:47:59,029 SO WE'RE TRYING TO GET MORE OF 1148 00:47:59,029 --> 00:48:01,298 OUR NRSA T32 PROGRAMS INTO IDEA 1149 00:48:01,298 --> 00:48:03,300 STATES TO FIND ANOTHER WAY TO 1150 00:48:03,300 --> 00:48:05,202 SUPPORT THEIR GRADUATE STUDENTS 1151 00:48:05,202 --> 00:48:07,771 IN THIS CASE, AND WE'RE GOING TO 1152 00:48:07,771 --> 00:48:12,242 USE THIS TRACK TO TRY TO DO 1153 00:48:12,242 --> 00:48:13,844 THAT. 1154 00:48:13,844 --> 00:48:14,845 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 1155 00:48:14,845 --> 00:48:16,146 AND THAT'S WHAT I HAD TO SAY. 1156 00:48:16,146 --> 00:48:18,382 THIS IS A PICTURE OF SOME OF THE 1157 00:48:18,382 --> 00:48:20,184 REALLY GREAT FOLKS AT NIGMS. 1158 00:48:20,184 --> 00:48:21,552 LET ME JUST END BY SAYING I KNOW 1159 00:48:21,552 --> 00:48:23,620 THERE ARE A LOT OF CHANGES GOING 1160 00:48:23,620 --> 00:48:27,391 ON AND THAT THE COMMUNITY IS 1161 00:48:27,391 --> 00:48:29,393 HAVING TO ADJUST TO CHANGES IN 1162 00:48:29,393 --> 00:48:32,262 PRIORITIES, CHANGES IN THE WAY 1163 00:48:32,262 --> 00:48:33,931 WE DO BUSINESS, AND CHANGE IS 1164 00:48:33,931 --> 00:48:35,566 ALWAYS HARD BUT LET ME ASSURE 1165 00:48:35,566 --> 00:48:39,503 YOU THAT THE STAFF AT NIGMS ARE 1166 00:48:39,503 --> 00:48:42,139 INCREDIBLY COMMITTED TO 1167 00:48:42,139 --> 00:48:45,175 SUPPORTING THE NIGMS RESEARCH, 1168 00:48:45,175 --> 00:48:46,343 TRAINING, CAPACITY BUILDING 1169 00:48:46,343 --> 00:48:50,247 COMMUNITIES, THEY ARE WORKING 1170 00:48:50,247 --> 00:48:52,149 JUST UNBELIEVABLY HARD TO ADAPT 1171 00:48:52,149 --> 00:48:54,251 TO AND MANAGE THE CHANGES THAT 1172 00:48:54,251 --> 00:48:55,652 ARE HAPPENING AND MAKE THEM ALL 1173 00:48:55,652 --> 00:48:57,955 WORK AS EFFICIENTLY AND 1174 00:48:57,955 --> 00:48:59,022 EFFECTIVELY AS POSSIBLE AND THEY 1175 00:48:59,022 --> 00:49:02,493 ARE DOING EVERYTHING THEY CAN TO 1176 00:49:02,493 --> 00:49:04,027 GET GRANTS AWARDED, SO THAT THE 1177 00:49:04,027 --> 00:49:06,163 COMMUNITY CAN KEEP DOING THE 1178 00:49:06,163 --> 00:49:07,998 REALLY IMPORTANT RESEARCH 1179 00:49:07,998 --> 00:49:09,967 TRAINING AND CAPACITY BUILDING 1180 00:49:09,967 --> 00:49:11,368 THAT IT DOES SOME OF WHICH I 1181 00:49:11,368 --> 00:49:12,169 JUST HIGHLIGHTED FOR YOU. 1182 00:49:12,169 --> 00:49:14,805 SO I WANT TO THANK THE STAFF FOR 1183 00:49:14,805 --> 00:49:16,940 THEIR INCREDIBLY HARD WORK AND 1184 00:49:16,940 --> 00:49:17,975 THEIR DEDICATION TO BIOMEDICAL 1185 00:49:17,975 --> 00:49:20,944 RESEARCH AND TO THE COMMUNITY 1186 00:49:20,944 --> 00:49:23,614 AND THANK YOU ALL AND HAPPY TO 1187 00:49:23,614 --> 00:49:25,048 TAKE SOME QUESTIONS. 1188 00:49:25,048 --> 00:49:27,284 IF YOU CAN TURN YOUR CAMERAS ON, 1189 00:49:27,284 --> 00:49:28,218 COUNCIL, THAT WOULD BE GREAT. 1190 00:49:28,218 --> 00:49:30,354 AND IF WE CAN MAYBE GO TO THE -- 1191 00:49:30,354 --> 00:49:33,957 YEAH, THAT VIEW IS GOOD. 1192 00:49:33,957 --> 00:49:35,125 MY FRIEND STEVEN CUTLER. 1193 00:49:35,125 --> 00:49:36,827 YOU HAD YOUR HAND UP. 1194 00:49:36,827 --> 00:49:38,095 >> YES, THANK YOU JON. 1195 00:49:38,095 --> 00:49:39,530 GREAT OVERVIEW, AND I REALLY 1196 00:49:39,530 --> 00:49:41,665 APPRECIATE YOU SPENDING TIME 1197 00:49:41,665 --> 00:49:43,333 TALKING ABOUT THE IDEA PROGRAM. 1198 00:49:43,333 --> 00:49:46,270 IT'S 1 OF THE BEST PROGRAMS THAT 1199 00:49:46,270 --> 00:49:47,805 NIH FUNDS AND SUPPORTS. 1200 00:49:47,805 --> 00:49:49,606 FOR THOSE WHO DON'T KNOW, I 1201 00:49:49,606 --> 00:49:53,877 SERVED AS A PI FOR COBRE FOR 2 1202 00:49:53,877 --> 00:49:55,245 PHASES, EARLY COMPETITIVE PHASE 1203 00:49:55,245 --> 00:49:56,680 FOR PHASE 3, THAT WAS FUNDED AS 1204 00:49:56,680 --> 00:49:58,182 I LEFT TO GO TO UNIVERSITY OF 1205 00:49:58,182 --> 00:49:59,683 SARK ARK AT THE TIME, IT WAS THE 1206 00:49:59,683 --> 00:50:00,651 UNIVERSITY OF MISSISSIPPI WHERE 1207 00:50:00,651 --> 00:50:02,886 I WAS FUNDED, IT WAS TO DO 1208 00:50:02,886 --> 00:50:04,955 RESEARCH ON CANNABIS AS THE ONLY 1209 00:50:04,955 --> 00:50:06,690 FEDERAL FACILITY IN THE COUNTRY 1210 00:50:06,690 --> 00:50:08,258 THAT CAN GROW CANNABIS AND 1211 00:50:08,258 --> 00:50:10,994 DURING THAT 10 YEAR PERIOD OF 1212 00:50:10,994 --> 00:50:12,596 TIME THAT COBRE REALLY HAD A 1213 00:50:12,596 --> 00:50:14,865 MAJOR IMPACT ON THE UNIVERSITY 1214 00:50:14,865 --> 00:50:16,366 OF MISSISSIPPI. 1215 00:50:16,366 --> 00:50:18,302 THE COMPETITIVENESS OF THE 1216 00:50:18,302 --> 00:50:20,571 APPLICATIONS WERE AT 34% WERE 1217 00:50:20,571 --> 00:50:23,240 FUNDED, I THINK THE AVERAGE FOR 1218 00:50:23,240 --> 00:50:26,076 NIH WAS CLOSER TO A SINGLE DIGIT 1219 00:50:26,076 --> 00:50:29,046 AND IN A 10 YEAR PERIOD OF TIME 1220 00:50:29,046 --> 00:50:31,915 WE QUADRUPLE FUNDED AT THE 1221 00:50:31,915 --> 00:50:33,717 UNIVERSITY OF MISSISSIPPI. 1222 00:50:33,717 --> 00:50:34,985 JUST A REMARKABLE PROGRAM. 1223 00:50:34,985 --> 00:50:37,454 JON, YOU MAY RECALL, I TOLD 1224 00:50:37,454 --> 00:50:38,255 FRANCIS COLLINS AT THE TIME 1225 00:50:38,255 --> 00:50:40,958 THIS, IS SOME OF THE BEST MONEY 1226 00:50:40,958 --> 00:50:42,860 THAT NIH IS SPENDING BECAUSE OF 1227 00:50:42,860 --> 00:50:45,395 THE 4 PILLARS YOU SHARED WITH US 1228 00:50:45,395 --> 00:50:46,396 ATY BEGINNING OF THE 1229 00:50:46,396 --> 00:50:47,631 PRESENTATION OF THE IDEA 1230 00:50:47,631 --> 00:50:47,865 PROGRAM. 1231 00:50:47,865 --> 00:50:49,266 THANK YOU FOR SUPPORTING IT. 1232 00:50:49,266 --> 00:50:49,766 >> THANK YOU STEVE. 1233 00:50:49,766 --> 00:50:52,236 WHEN I CAME TO NIGMS, I KNEW 1234 00:50:52,236 --> 00:50:53,937 NOTHING ABOUT THE IDEA PROGRAM 1235 00:50:53,937 --> 00:50:55,305 AND I THINK PROBABLY LITERALLY 1236 00:50:55,305 --> 00:50:56,940 THE FIRST THING I DID WAS GO 1237 00:50:56,940 --> 00:51:01,144 DOWN STAIRS STAIRS AND MEET WID 1238 00:51:01,144 --> 00:51:02,312 TAYLOR AND GET HIM TO EXPLAIN 1239 00:51:02,312 --> 00:51:04,314 THE PROGRAM AND I WAS A CONVERT 1240 00:51:04,314 --> 00:51:09,119 WITHIN AN HOUR AND I'M NOW THE 1241 00:51:09,119 --> 00:51:09,820 BIGGEST SUPPORTER 1242 00:51:09,820 --> 00:51:12,556 PROSELYTIZINGER FOR THAT PROGRAM 1243 00:51:12,556 --> 00:51:13,891 AROUND AND THANK YOU FOR THE 1244 00:51:13,891 --> 00:51:15,659 HARD WORK YOU'VE DONE AND 1245 00:51:15,659 --> 00:51:16,293 INCREDIBLE THINGS YOU'VE DONE 1246 00:51:16,293 --> 00:51:17,394 THAT YOU TALK ABOUT AT 1247 00:51:17,394 --> 00:51:18,829 MISSISSIPPI AND THAT YOU'RE NOW 1248 00:51:18,829 --> 00:51:21,031 DOING AT SOUTH CAROLINA. 1249 00:51:21,031 --> 00:51:21,832 SPEAKING OF INCREDIBLE, ANN WHAT 1250 00:51:21,832 --> 00:51:23,667 DO YOU HAVE TO SAY? 1251 00:51:23,667 --> 00:51:24,868 >> THANK YOU JON, I WANT TO SAY 1252 00:51:24,868 --> 00:51:26,904 THANK TO YOU ALL THE STAFF AT 1253 00:51:26,904 --> 00:51:29,006 NIGMS FOR EVERYTHING THAT YOU DO 1254 00:51:29,006 --> 00:51:30,240 AND ESPECIALLY DURING THE 1255 00:51:30,240 --> 00:51:32,709 DIFFICULT TIMES THAT WE FIND 1256 00:51:32,709 --> 00:51:33,043 OURSELVES IN. 1257 00:51:33,043 --> 00:51:34,978 BUT THANK YOU FOR SHINING A 1258 00:51:34,978 --> 00:51:37,180 SPOTLIGHT ON THE STATE OF 1259 00:51:37,180 --> 00:51:38,715 OKLAHOMA AND OUR COBRE IN 1260 00:51:38,715 --> 00:51:40,083 PARTICULAR, AND FOR THOSE WHO 1261 00:51:40,083 --> 00:51:41,785 AREN'T AS FAMILIAR WITH THESE 1262 00:51:41,785 --> 00:51:46,990 PROGRAMS, AS STEVE SAID, YOU 1263 00:51:46,990 --> 00:51:49,192 KNOW THE COBREs FOCUS AT LEAST 1264 00:51:49,192 --> 00:51:51,962 ON PHASE 1 AND 2 ON EARLY CAREER 1265 00:51:51,962 --> 00:51:52,896 FACULTY MEMBERS TO THE POINT 1266 00:51:52,896 --> 00:51:55,032 WHERE THEY GRADUATE FROM COBRE 1267 00:51:55,032 --> 00:51:56,333 FUNDING TO INDEPENDENT FUNDING 1268 00:51:56,333 --> 00:51:58,135 OF THEIR OWN SO IT'S REALLY A 1269 00:51:58,135 --> 00:51:59,636 WIN, WIN, SITUATION AND IT'S -- 1270 00:51:59,636 --> 00:52:02,739 YOU KNOW CAN BE TRANSFORMATIONAL 1271 00:52:02,739 --> 00:52:04,608 FOR AN INSTITUTION AND FOR 1272 00:52:04,608 --> 00:52:06,243 INDIVIDUALS INVOLVED IN PROGRAMS 1273 00:52:06,243 --> 00:52:06,877 SUCH AS THIS. 1274 00:52:06,877 --> 00:52:08,612 SO THANK YOU FOR YOUR SUPPORT 1275 00:52:08,612 --> 00:52:11,248 AND I APPRECIATE YOU WELCOMING 1276 00:52:11,248 --> 00:52:13,450 ME TO THE COUNCIL WITH THOSE 1277 00:52:13,450 --> 00:52:15,052 HIGHLIGHTS. 1278 00:52:15,052 --> 00:52:15,319 THANK YOU. 1279 00:52:15,319 --> 00:52:19,556 >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 1280 00:52:19,556 --> 00:52:19,756 ERIC? 1281 00:52:19,756 --> 00:52:22,092 NTHANK YOU JON, SO I WAS JUST 1282 00:52:22,092 --> 00:52:23,827 CURIOUS, WHEN YOU SAID 1283 00:52:23,827 --> 00:52:24,494 TRANSDEPARTMENTMENTAL, WHAT DO 1284 00:52:24,494 --> 00:52:25,862 YOU MEAN BY THAT? 1285 00:52:25,862 --> 00:52:27,731 I'M JUST SORT OF CURIOUS, IS IT 1286 00:52:27,731 --> 00:52:29,266 GOING TO BE -- I ASSUME WELL'S 1287 00:52:29,266 --> 00:52:30,701 GOING TO BE MORE DETAILS LATER 1288 00:52:30,701 --> 00:52:33,537 ON BUT I WAS JUST CURIOUS. 1289 00:52:33,537 --> 00:52:36,306 >> YEAH, CAN YOU CAN GO TO OUR 1290 00:52:36,306 --> 00:52:37,341 WEBSITE AND ANYONE'S INTERESTED 1291 00:52:37,341 --> 00:52:40,310 CAN LEARN MORE. 1292 00:52:40,310 --> 00:52:41,144 IT'S CALLED TRANSDEPARTMENTAL 1293 00:52:41,144 --> 00:52:42,713 BECAUSE WE WERE TRYING TO 1294 00:52:42,713 --> 00:52:46,450 BROADEN AND FOCUS ACROSS AN 1295 00:52:46,450 --> 00:52:46,883 ENTIRE INSTITUTION. 1296 00:52:46,883 --> 00:52:48,819 SO SOME OF THE OTHER 1S ARE THE 1297 00:52:48,819 --> 00:52:53,457 DEPARTMENT OF CELLULARY AND 1298 00:52:53,457 --> 00:52:55,025 MOLECULAR BIOLOGY IN CELLULAR 1299 00:52:55,025 --> 00:52:57,728 AND MOLEC BAR BIOLOGY, SO THIS 1300 00:52:57,728 --> 00:52:59,229 WAS SUPPOSED TO BE ABLE TO 1301 00:52:59,229 --> 00:53:01,198 SUPPORT INSTIEWPGZS THAT DON'T 1302 00:53:01,198 --> 00:53:02,466 CURRENTLY HAVE NIGMS TRAINING 1303 00:53:02,466 --> 00:53:03,900 SUPPORT BROADLY SO THEY COULD 1304 00:53:03,900 --> 00:53:05,736 HAVE 1 THAT SPANNED THE CHEMIST 1305 00:53:05,736 --> 00:53:06,536 RADIOY DEPARTMENT, BIOLOGY 1306 00:53:06,536 --> 00:53:08,638 DEPARTMENT AND YOU KNOW WHATEVER 1307 00:53:08,638 --> 00:53:09,539 STATISTICS DEPARTMENT, YOU KNOW 1308 00:53:09,539 --> 00:53:10,707 WHATEVER DEPARTMENTS THEY WANTED 1309 00:53:10,707 --> 00:53:13,977 TO FIT INTO THIS BROAD BASED 1310 00:53:13,977 --> 00:53:15,746 PROGRAM TO REALLY GET THEIR 1311 00:53:15,746 --> 00:53:17,147 GRADUATE TRAINING TO THE NEXT 1312 00:53:17,147 --> 00:53:19,649 LEVEL, BUT NOT JUST IN 1 1313 00:53:19,649 --> 00:53:20,183 SPECIFIC AREA. 1314 00:53:20,183 --> 00:53:24,421 SO THAT'S WHAT WE MEAN BY 1315 00:53:24,421 --> 00:53:28,291 TRANSDEPARTMENTAL, IT CAN CROSS 1316 00:53:28,291 --> 00:53:31,595 DEPARTMENTMENTAL BOUNDARIES 1317 00:53:31,595 --> 00:53:31,828 EASILY. 1318 00:53:31,828 --> 00:53:32,029 TERRY? 1319 00:53:32,029 --> 00:53:36,800 >> I JUST WANTED TO TAKE A 1320 00:53:36,800 --> 00:53:40,670 MOMENT AND THANK DR. ZUK TO HER 1321 00:53:40,670 --> 00:53:43,407 INCREDIBLE CONTRIBUTIONS TO 1322 00:53:43,407 --> 00:53:45,575 NIGMS, HER WORKSHOP SHE RAN ON 1323 00:53:45,575 --> 00:53:47,310 TRULY NONTRADITIONAL MODEL 1324 00:53:47,310 --> 00:53:49,279 SYSTEMS IN RESEARCH AND HOW 1325 00:53:49,279 --> 00:53:50,614 IMPORTANT THINGS LIKE THAT, THAT 1326 00:53:50,614 --> 00:53:53,250 SHE ALWAYS MADE SURE TO LIFT UP 1327 00:53:53,250 --> 00:53:55,485 THE IMPORTANT THINGS TO MOVE 1328 00:53:55,485 --> 00:53:57,120 SCIENCE FORWARD AND HAS A GREAT 1329 00:53:57,120 --> 00:53:58,555 SCIENTIST HERSELF, I WANT TO 1330 00:53:58,555 --> 00:54:00,290 APPLAUD HER FOR WHAT SHE DID AND 1331 00:54:00,290 --> 00:54:10,267 SHE WILL BE MISSED. 1332 00:54:10,267 --> 00:54:11,601 >> THANKS, TERRY. 1333 00:54:11,601 --> 00:54:13,303 >> I WILL CERTAINLY MISS HER, NO 1334 00:54:13,303 --> 00:54:14,204 DOUBT ABOUT THAT. 1335 00:54:14,204 --> 00:54:16,006 >> I WILL MISS YOU ALL, TOO, BUT 1336 00:54:16,006 --> 00:54:17,541 MAYBE NOT THAT MUCH. 1337 00:54:17,541 --> 00:54:22,345 >> YOU WILL HAVE TO SEND US HAIR 1338 00:54:22,345 --> 00:54:23,713 COLOR UPDATES FREQUENTLY. 1339 00:54:23,713 --> 00:54:24,714 >> OTHER QUESTIONS, THINGS 1340 00:54:24,714 --> 00:54:28,919 PEOPLE WOULD LIKE TO DISCUSS? 1341 00:54:28,919 --> 00:54:29,419 LET'S SEE, MAZI. 1342 00:54:29,419 --> 00:54:30,487 >> WE ARE JUST CONNECTING BACK 1343 00:54:30,487 --> 00:54:32,889 TO THE QUESTION ABOUT THE TRANSZ 1344 00:54:32,889 --> 00:54:34,257 DEPARTMENTAL PROGRAM, I THINK 1345 00:54:34,257 --> 00:54:39,162 THATIA A REALLY FANTASTIC IDEA. 1346 00:54:39,162 --> 00:54:41,531 YOU KNOW BIOLOGY, -- BIOMEDICAL 1347 00:54:41,531 --> 00:54:44,568 RESEARCH IS JUST INCREASINGLY 1348 00:54:44,568 --> 00:54:45,435 INTERDISCIPLINARY WHERE IT TAKES 1349 00:54:45,435 --> 00:54:47,404 THE TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES OF MANY 1350 00:54:47,404 --> 00:54:49,973 DIFFERENT FIELDS TO TRULY MAKE 1351 00:54:49,973 --> 00:54:51,341 PROGRESS SO, I THINK THAT'S 1352 00:54:51,341 --> 00:54:54,811 GOING TO BE A TREMENDOUS 1353 00:54:54,811 --> 00:54:55,045 SUCCESS. 1354 00:54:55,045 --> 00:54:56,279 >> YEAH, THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR 1355 00:54:56,279 --> 00:54:56,746 THAT. 1356 00:54:56,746 --> 00:54:59,716 I THINK YOU'RE RIGHT ON THE 1357 00:54:59,716 --> 00:55:00,417 MONEY THERE. 1358 00:55:00,417 --> 00:55:03,553 WE ALSO DO OFFER IT FOR 1359 00:55:03,553 --> 00:55:05,555 INSTITUTIONS THAT CURRENTLY HAVE 1360 00:55:05,555 --> 00:55:06,490 MULTIPLE TRAINING GRANTS IN 1361 00:55:06,490 --> 00:55:07,491 DIFFERENT AREAS BUT WOULD LIKE 1362 00:55:07,491 --> 00:55:09,559 TO COLLAPSE THEM INTO A SINGLE 1363 00:55:09,559 --> 00:55:10,227 BROAD PROGRAM, SO THAT'S ANOTHER 1364 00:55:10,227 --> 00:55:18,368 WAY IT CAN BE USED. 1365 00:55:18,368 --> 00:55:18,835 JOANNE? 1366 00:55:18,835 --> 00:55:21,905 >> YEAH, JON, AND ALL STAFF OF 1367 00:55:21,905 --> 00:55:22,772 THE NIGMS, REALLY 1368 00:55:22,772 --> 00:55:26,409 CONGRATULATIONS TO THE SUCCESS 1369 00:55:26,409 --> 00:55:27,511 OF THE MIRA PROGRAM, IT'S REALLY 1370 00:55:27,511 --> 00:55:30,180 GREAT TO SEE THE INCREASED 1371 00:55:30,180 --> 00:55:31,481 SUPPORT, PARTICULARLY FOR EARLY 1372 00:55:31,481 --> 00:55:34,351 STAGE INVESTIGATORS AND THE WAY 1373 00:55:34,351 --> 00:55:36,720 THE MECHANISM IS STRUCTURED IT 1374 00:55:36,720 --> 00:55:38,955 TRULY DOES PROVIDE MORE 1375 00:55:38,955 --> 00:55:39,823 STABILITY, MORE LONG-TERM 1376 00:55:39,823 --> 00:55:42,792 RESEARCH FUNDING AND REDUCES 1377 00:55:42,792 --> 00:55:43,994 ADMINISTRATIVE BURRED KNOW SO I 1378 00:55:43,994 --> 00:55:49,366 THINK THIS IS SOMETHING REAL 1379 00:55:49,366 --> 00:55:51,935 INNOVATIVE AND A PROGRAM I THINK 1380 00:55:51,935 --> 00:55:52,602 WILL HAVE SIGNIFICANT IMPACT SO 1381 00:55:52,602 --> 00:55:54,971 I WANT TO MAKE I SHOUT OUT TO 1382 00:55:54,971 --> 00:55:55,405 THAT. 1383 00:55:55,405 --> 00:55:55,772 >> THANK YOU. 1384 00:55:55,772 --> 00:55:56,306 REALLY APPRECIATE THAT. 1385 00:55:56,306 --> 00:55:58,008 AND WE DO HEAR THAT IN THE 1386 00:55:58,008 --> 00:56:00,143 COMMUNITY IN COMNL, SO THANK YOU 1387 00:56:00,143 --> 00:56:02,612 FOR HIGHLIGHTING THAT JOANNE. 1388 00:56:02,612 --> 00:56:05,315 , LET'S SEE, CHRISTINE? 1389 00:56:05,315 --> 00:56:08,151 >> AS SOMEONE WHO RECEIVED AN 1390 00:56:08,151 --> 00:56:09,986 EARLY STAGE MIRA AWARD AND WHO 1391 00:56:09,986 --> 00:56:11,254 HAD IT RENEWED EARLIER THIS 1392 00:56:11,254 --> 00:56:13,456 YEAR, I HAVE TO GIVE A SHOUT OUT 1393 00:56:13,456 --> 00:56:15,659 TO THAT AS WELL. 1394 00:56:15,659 --> 00:56:18,495 THE STABILITY AFFORDS THE 1395 00:56:18,495 --> 00:56:21,731 ABILITY TO GO OUT ON A LIMB AND 1396 00:56:21,731 --> 00:56:23,733 MAYBE DO THINGS YOU MIGHT NOT 1397 00:56:23,733 --> 00:56:24,734 OTHERWISE DO BECAUSE HAVE YOU 1398 00:56:24,734 --> 00:56:25,835 THE BACK STOP OF SUPPORT AND I 1399 00:56:25,835 --> 00:56:31,441 THINK IT HELPS TO ACTUALLY 1400 00:56:31,441 --> 00:56:33,276 PROMOTE MORE INVIGORATING 1401 00:56:33,276 --> 00:56:35,812 SCIENTIFIC FORAYS, AND 1402 00:56:35,812 --> 00:56:37,781 INTERDISCIPLINARY WORK. 1403 00:56:37,781 --> 00:56:38,515 >> THANK YOU. 1404 00:56:38,515 --> 00:56:40,750 REALLY GREAT TO GET THOSE 1405 00:56:40,750 --> 00:56:41,685 TESTIMONIALS, THAT WAS WHAT WE 1406 00:56:41,685 --> 00:56:43,119 WERE HOPING WHEN WE SET IT UP. 1407 00:56:43,119 --> 00:56:45,288 THANK YOU FOR THAT. 1408 00:56:45,288 --> 00:56:46,790 TERRY, DO YOU STILL HAVE YOUR 1409 00:56:46,790 --> 00:56:53,196 HAND UP OR IS THAT THE OLD 1? 1410 00:56:53,196 --> 00:56:53,563 LESLIE? 1411 00:56:53,563 --> 00:56:54,497 >> THANKS, MY HAND DOESN'T SEEM 1412 00:56:54,497 --> 00:56:57,267 TO BE GOING UP. 1413 00:56:57,267 --> 00:57:00,036 YEAH, SO, TUSTLY HAVE A 1414 00:57:00,036 --> 00:57:01,605 QUESTION/CONCERN, SO YEAH, I 1415 00:57:01,605 --> 00:57:04,474 THINK GENERALLY MY COLLEAGUES 1416 00:57:04,474 --> 00:57:08,111 ARE ENTHUSIASTIC ABOUT THE MIRA 1417 00:57:08,111 --> 00:57:09,746 PROGRAM, BUT THERE IS 1 CONCERN 1418 00:57:09,746 --> 00:57:13,016 THAT'S BEEN VOICED TO ME IS 1419 00:57:13,016 --> 00:57:15,352 ABOUT THE ELEDGIBILITY PERIOD. 1420 00:57:15,352 --> 00:57:16,853 SO, TO PUT THAT AS A QUESTION, 1421 00:57:16,853 --> 00:57:19,489 IS THERE ANY CHANCE OF 1422 00:57:19,489 --> 00:57:22,492 INCREASING THE ELIGIBLE PERIOD 1423 00:57:22,492 --> 00:57:23,893 BECAUSE FOR PEOPLE TRYING TO 1424 00:57:23,893 --> 00:57:27,364 CONVERT, IT SEEMS LIKE A SHORT 1425 00:57:27,364 --> 00:57:28,565 WINDOW OF TIME AND ESPECIALLY 1426 00:57:28,565 --> 00:57:30,600 RIGHT NOW WITH THE 2 DEADLINES 1427 00:57:30,600 --> 00:57:35,171 BEING SO CLOSE TOGETHER, IT 1428 00:57:35,171 --> 00:57:36,273 SEEMS LIKE THERE'S 1 SHOT AND 1429 00:57:36,273 --> 00:57:38,975 THEN IF YOU DON'T GET IT, ON THE 1430 00:57:38,975 --> 00:57:41,544 FIRST ROUND, YOU ARE GOING BACK 1431 00:57:41,544 --> 00:57:44,547 TO AN RO-1 POOL WHERE NOW THE 1432 00:57:44,547 --> 00:57:49,119 PAY LINE IS MUCH, MUCH LOWER. 1433 00:57:49,119 --> 00:57:51,321 AND MY DEPARTMENT CHAIR BROUGHT 1434 00:57:51,321 --> 00:57:53,490 THIS TO ME BECAUSE HE HEARD IT 1435 00:57:53,490 --> 00:57:55,325 FROM SOME OF HIS PEOPLE BUT ALSO 1436 00:57:55,325 --> 00:57:56,926 IN OTHER DEPARTMENTS THAT 1437 00:57:56,926 --> 00:57:58,094 THERE'S JUST WORRY ABOUT PEOPLE 1438 00:57:58,094 --> 00:57:59,362 FALLING THROUGH THE CRACKS 1439 00:57:59,362 --> 00:58:01,631 BASICALLY BECAUSE IF YOU DON'T 1440 00:58:01,631 --> 00:58:04,634 GET IN, YOU CANNOT REAPPLY FOR A 1441 00:58:04,634 --> 00:58:08,371 MIRA AFTER THAT 1 YEAR 1442 00:58:08,371 --> 00:58:08,938 ELIGIBILITY. 1443 00:58:08,938 --> 00:58:09,205 >> YEAH. 1444 00:58:09,205 --> 00:58:10,774 WE TAKE THAT BACK AND THANKS FOR 1445 00:58:10,774 --> 00:58:12,809 RAISING THAT AND LOOK AT IT. 1446 00:58:12,809 --> 00:58:16,146 I THINK THE WAY WE SET IT UP WAS 1447 00:58:16,146 --> 00:58:18,148 THAT THEY CAN APPLY EARLIER IN 1448 00:58:18,148 --> 00:58:21,217 THEIR RO-1 IF THEY WANT TO, 1449 00:58:21,217 --> 00:58:21,618 RIGHT? 1450 00:58:21,618 --> 00:58:24,154 AND SO, IT'S A QUESTION OF YOU 1451 00:58:24,154 --> 00:58:27,791 KNOW DO THEY WANT TO CONVERT AND 1452 00:58:27,791 --> 00:58:29,092 POTENTIALLY HAVE A YEAR LESS OF 1453 00:58:29,092 --> 00:58:31,494 THE RO-1, BUT NOW GET THE MIRA, 1454 00:58:31,494 --> 00:58:33,630 SO IT IS A TRADE-OFF, BUT WE 1455 00:58:33,630 --> 00:58:36,366 TRIED TO BUILD IT INTO THE 1456 00:58:36,366 --> 00:58:38,635 SYSTEM SO THAT, YOU KNOW THEY 1457 00:58:38,635 --> 00:58:39,969 HAD MULTIPLE SHOTS ON GOALS SO 1458 00:58:39,969 --> 00:58:43,907 TO SPEAK IF THEY WANTED TO DO 1459 00:58:43,907 --> 00:58:44,207 THAT. 1460 00:58:44,207 --> 00:58:45,241 >> RIGHT, I WOULD SAY GOING IN 1461 00:58:45,241 --> 00:58:47,777 EARLY, THOUGH, IF YOU ARE A 1462 00:58:47,777 --> 00:58:52,816 SINGLE SMALL RO-1 LAB, COULD BE 1463 00:58:52,816 --> 00:58:52,949 -- 1464 00:58:52,949 --> 00:58:53,416 >> YEAH, UNDERSTOOD. 1465 00:58:53,416 --> 00:58:57,420 WE WILL SEE IF THERE'S ANYWAY WE 1466 00:58:57,420 --> 00:59:00,390 CAN MODIFY THAT. 1467 00:59:00,390 --> 00:59:02,125 >> THANKS. 1468 00:59:02,125 --> 00:59:02,592 >> LET'S SEE, MONCI? 1469 00:59:02,592 --> 00:59:03,827 >> I ULS HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT 1470 00:59:03,827 --> 00:59:05,228 THE MIRA PROGRAM WHICH I'M A 1471 00:59:05,228 --> 00:59:07,297 HUGE FAN OF, YOU KNOW I 1472 00:59:07,297 --> 00:59:09,132 BENEFITED TREMENDOUSLY, I THINK 1473 00:59:09,132 --> 00:59:10,633 IT'S REALLY PROVIDED 1474 00:59:10,633 --> 00:59:12,902 OPPORTUNITIES FOR MANY OF US 1475 00:59:12,902 --> 00:59:17,040 DOING HIGHER RISK NONTRADITIONAL 1476 00:59:17,040 --> 00:59:19,209 MODEL ORGANISM WORK THIS DORIT 1477 00:59:19,209 --> 00:59:20,043 HAS BEEN CHAMPIONING EMPLOY SO 1478 00:59:20,043 --> 00:59:22,379 GIVEN THAT THE MIRA PROGRAM HAS 1479 00:59:22,379 --> 00:59:23,546 BEEN AROUND FOR A NUMBER OF 1480 00:59:23,546 --> 00:59:24,981 YEARS AT THIS POINT BUT IT HAS 1481 00:59:24,981 --> 00:59:27,283 PEOPLE COME NOTHING THROUGH 1482 00:59:27,283 --> 00:59:28,518 DIFFERENT ROUTES, SOME FOLKS 1483 00:59:28,518 --> 00:59:31,988 COMING IN BY COMBINING MULTIPLE 1484 00:59:31,988 --> 00:59:33,223 RO-1s THEN, ESI PROGRAM NOW 1485 00:59:33,223 --> 00:59:36,659 FOLK CANS CONVERT FROM SINGLE 1486 00:59:36,659 --> 00:59:40,663 RO-1S AND IT'S TRUE THAT OVERALL 1487 00:59:40,663 --> 00:59:43,733 THE BUDGETS ARE HIGHER THAN THE 1488 00:59:43,733 --> 00:59:45,001 BUDGETS OF RO-1S, BUT I'M 1489 00:59:45,001 --> 00:59:49,205 CURIOUS IF YOU'RE NOTICING ANY 1490 00:59:49,205 --> 00:59:52,375 DIFFERENCES IN OVERALL LEVEL OF 1491 00:59:52,375 --> 00:59:53,777 SUPPORT PER GRANT DEPENDING ON 1492 00:59:53,777 --> 00:59:57,614 WHAT THE INCOMING MECHANISM WAS? 1493 00:59:57,614 --> 01:00:00,383 AND IF SO, YOU ARE PUTTING ANY 1494 01:00:00,383 --> 01:00:02,018 NEW MECHANISMS IN PLACE TO MAKE 1495 01:00:02,018 --> 01:00:04,320 SURE THAT YOU KNOW EVERYBODY 1496 01:00:04,320 --> 01:00:05,955 DOING EQUIVALENT BOLD RESEARCH 1497 01:00:05,955 --> 01:00:10,126 IS GETTING EQUIVALENT SUPPORT? 1498 01:00:10,126 --> 01:00:11,428 >> EXCELLENT QUESTION. 1499 01:00:11,428 --> 01:00:12,462 SO THERE DEFINITELY WERE 1500 01:00:12,462 --> 01:00:13,530 DIFFERENCES BECAUSE THE PROGRAM 1501 01:00:13,530 --> 01:00:15,131 STARTED THAT WE STARTED AS A 1502 01:00:15,131 --> 01:00:19,002 PILOT AND IT WAS FOR PEOPLE WHO 1503 01:00:19,002 --> 01:00:20,403 HAD MULTIPLE GRANTS TO 1504 01:00:20,403 --> 01:00:22,505 CONSOLIDATE AND WE ACTUALLY CUT 1505 01:00:22,505 --> 01:00:23,740 THEIR BUDGETS WHEN THEY DID 1506 01:00:23,740 --> 01:00:25,108 THAT, SO WE TOOK SOME OF THE 1507 01:00:25,108 --> 01:00:26,609 MONEY FROM PEOPLE WHO HAD A LOT 1508 01:00:26,609 --> 01:00:28,511 OF MONEY AND PUT IT BACK INTO 1509 01:00:28,511 --> 01:00:31,247 THE POOL, SO WE -- THAT WAS 1 1510 01:00:31,247 --> 01:00:32,982 PLACE AT WHICH WE TRIED TO 1511 01:00:32,982 --> 01:00:34,384 NORMALIZE THINGS A LITTLE BIT 1512 01:00:34,384 --> 01:00:36,920 BUT THERE -- THERE WAS STILL 1513 01:00:36,920 --> 01:00:41,825 SOME PEOPLE HAD $600,000 AND 1514 01:00:41,825 --> 01:00:42,959 OTHER PEOPLE HAD 250. 1515 01:00:42,959 --> 01:00:45,762 WHAT WE'RE DOING NOW, AS I 1516 01:00:45,762 --> 01:00:48,131 ALLUDED TO WAS, WE'RE TRYING TO 1517 01:00:48,131 --> 01:00:49,966 INCREASE THE MEDIA AND THE MODE 1518 01:00:49,966 --> 01:00:51,701 BUDGET, YOU KNOW AND IT'S NOT -- 1519 01:00:51,701 --> 01:00:56,806 IT'S NOT GOING FROM 250 TO 500, 1520 01:00:56,806 --> 01:00:59,142 IT'S GOING FROM 250-275 BECAUSE 1521 01:00:59,142 --> 01:01:06,583 THERE'S A LIMITED POOL OF MONEY. 1522 01:01:06,583 --> 01:01:07,650 BUT THAT'S WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO 1523 01:01:07,650 --> 01:01:12,055 DO AND WHEN I FIRST ENVISIONED 1524 01:01:12,055 --> 01:01:13,623 THIS PROGRAM WAS A PROGRAM WHERE 1525 01:01:13,623 --> 01:01:14,357 EVERYBODY GOT -- I THINK THE 1526 01:01:14,357 --> 01:01:16,259 NUMBER I HAD IN MY HEAD AT THE 1527 01:01:16,259 --> 01:01:18,761 TIME WHICH WAS 12, 13 YEARS AGO 1528 01:01:18,761 --> 01:01:20,463 WAS 300 AND PIOF THE THOUSAND 1529 01:01:20,463 --> 01:01:22,899 DOLLARS, YOU KNOW -- IF EVERYONE 1530 01:01:22,899 --> 01:01:24,968 JUST GOT THAT, THEY COULD DO ALL 1531 01:01:24,968 --> 01:01:26,402 KINDS OF STUFF AND WE COULD FUND 1532 01:01:26,402 --> 01:01:28,004 A LOT MORE PEOPLE XI THINK WE 1533 01:01:28,004 --> 01:01:30,607 WOULD GET BETTER RESULTS. 1534 01:01:30,607 --> 01:01:32,876 THAT'S STILL KIND OF WHAT I LIKE 1535 01:01:32,876 --> 01:01:36,212 AS AN IDEA, BUT TO MOVE TO THAT 1536 01:01:36,212 --> 01:01:38,948 IS NOT SOMETHING YOU CAN DO ALL 1537 01:01:38,948 --> 01:01:39,649 AT ONCE, RIGHT? 1538 01:01:39,649 --> 01:01:43,586 WE HAVE TO GRADUALLY BUILD 1539 01:01:43,586 --> 01:01:46,089 TOWARDS THAT. 1540 01:01:46,089 --> 01:01:46,322 PETRA? 1541 01:01:46,322 --> 01:01:48,558 >> OKAY, LET'S SEE IF THE 1542 01:01:48,558 --> 01:01:51,094 MIC WORKS, YEAH, CAN YOU HEAR ME 1543 01:01:51,094 --> 01:01:51,261 IN. 1544 01:01:51,261 --> 01:01:51,628 >> YEAH. 1545 01:01:51,628 --> 01:01:52,328 >> YOU SHOULD INTRODUCE YOURSELF 1546 01:01:52,328 --> 01:01:54,030 BECAUSE YOU NEVER GOT A CHANCE 1547 01:01:54,030 --> 01:01:54,664 TO DO IT. 1548 01:01:54,664 --> 01:01:56,533 >> I'M FROM THE BIOLOGY 1549 01:01:56,533 --> 01:01:57,467 DEPARTMENT OF WASHINGTON 1550 01:01:57,467 --> 01:01:59,569 UNIVERSITY IN ST. LOUIS AND I 1551 01:01:59,569 --> 01:02:01,804 WORK ON BACTERIAL PHYSIOLOGY, 1552 01:02:01,804 --> 01:02:04,340 GROWTH, SIZE, SHAPE, SOME 1553 01:02:04,340 --> 01:02:04,707 ANTIBIOTIC WORK. 1554 01:02:04,707 --> 01:02:05,875 MY QUESTION ACTUALLY IS ALSO 1555 01:02:05,875 --> 01:02:07,844 ABOUT THE MIRA WHICH I LOVE THIS 1556 01:02:07,844 --> 01:02:09,579 PROGRAM VERY MUCH. 1557 01:02:09,579 --> 01:02:10,747 I GUESS MY MAIN QUESTION IS NOW 1558 01:02:10,747 --> 01:02:12,882 THAT THERE'S TOW MANY MIRAs 1559 01:02:12,882 --> 01:02:14,684 AND I'VE GONE THROUGH SO MANY 1560 01:02:14,684 --> 01:02:15,585 SUMMARY STATEMENTS ARE THEY 1561 01:02:15,585 --> 01:02:16,986 GOING TO START PERCENTILING THEM 1562 01:02:16,986 --> 01:02:18,788 TO HAVE MORE UNIFORMITY ACROSS 1563 01:02:18,788 --> 01:02:21,624 STUDY SECTIONS AS THEY ARE FOR 1564 01:02:21,624 --> 01:02:23,726 THE RO-1S BECAUSE, YEAH, THAT 1565 01:02:23,726 --> 01:02:24,460 WAS MY -- 1566 01:02:24,460 --> 01:02:26,129 >> YEAH, THAT IS A GOOD 1567 01:02:26,129 --> 01:02:26,396 QUESTION. 1568 01:02:26,396 --> 01:02:30,300 SOMETHING WE'VE THOUGHT ABOUT A 1569 01:02:30,300 --> 01:02:30,466 LOT. 1570 01:02:30,466 --> 01:02:32,969 I THINK 1 OF THE REASONS WE 1571 01:02:32,969 --> 01:02:35,805 HAVEN'T DONE IT YET IS, WELL, 1572 01:02:35,805 --> 01:02:38,575 FIRST OF ALL CSR'S BEEN A 1573 01:02:38,575 --> 01:02:39,542 TREMENDOUSLY GREAT PARTNER IN 1574 01:02:39,542 --> 01:02:41,678 THE MIRA AND THEY DO ALL THE 1575 01:02:41,678 --> 01:02:43,446 MIRA REVIEWS AND THEY HAVE STOOD 1576 01:02:43,446 --> 01:02:45,481 UP STANDING PANELS FROM MIRA AND 1577 01:02:45,481 --> 01:02:48,184 THEY EXPANDED THE NUMBER, BUT 1578 01:02:48,184 --> 01:02:50,553 THEY ALSO STILL USE A FAIR 1579 01:02:50,553 --> 01:02:51,454 AMOUNT OF SPECIAL EMPHASIS 1580 01:02:51,454 --> 01:02:53,089 PANELS AND THAT MAKES THE 1581 01:02:53,089 --> 01:02:55,725 PERCENTILE A LITTLE HARD BECAUSE 1582 01:02:55,725 --> 01:02:58,294 THEY KEEP CHANGING AND WHAT'S IN 1583 01:02:58,294 --> 01:02:59,862 THEM IS CHANGING, SO THAT'S 1 1584 01:02:59,862 --> 01:03:00,797 ISSUE, THE OTHER ISSUE IS 1585 01:03:00,797 --> 01:03:04,667 ALTHOUGH THE SCORE OF A GRANT IS 1586 01:03:04,667 --> 01:03:06,102 AN IMPORTANT FACTOR, WE DON'T 1587 01:03:06,102 --> 01:03:08,071 WANT TO OVEREMPHASIZE IT, 1588 01:03:08,071 --> 01:03:09,405 BECAUSE IT'S JUST 1 THING, 1589 01:03:09,405 --> 01:03:10,073 RIGHT? 1590 01:03:10,073 --> 01:03:13,076 AND WE LOOK VERY CLOSELY AT THE 1591 01:03:13,076 --> 01:03:13,710 REVIEWS THEMSELVES, BECAUSE YOU 1592 01:03:13,710 --> 01:03:17,981 CAN GET A CORE OF SAY, 30 WITH 1593 01:03:17,981 --> 01:03:22,852 ALL 3 REVOWERS, GIVING YOU A 3, 1594 01:03:22,852 --> 01:03:24,387 OR, YOU KNOW 1 GIVING YOU A 1, I 1595 01:03:24,387 --> 01:03:26,222 WON'T DO THE MATH IN MY HEAD BUT 1596 01:03:26,222 --> 01:03:28,625 1 GIVING YOU A 1, 1 GIVING AWE A 1597 01:03:28,625 --> 01:03:30,893 4 AND 1 GIVING YOU A 6 OR 1598 01:03:30,893 --> 01:03:32,795 WHATEVER THE AVERAGE IS, DID I 1599 01:03:32,795 --> 01:03:33,363 GET IT RIGHT? 1600 01:03:33,363 --> 01:03:34,130 PROBABLY NOT. 1601 01:03:34,130 --> 01:03:37,900 BUT THAT'S A VERY DIFFERENT 1602 01:03:37,900 --> 01:03:39,102 THING THAN EVERYONE SAYING THE 1603 01:03:39,102 --> 01:03:40,903 SAME SO WE DON'T FEEL WE CAN GO 1604 01:03:40,903 --> 01:03:42,372 ON SCORE ALONE AND SO WE DON'T 1605 01:03:42,372 --> 01:03:44,207 -- AS YOU KNOW WE DON'T USE PAY 1606 01:03:44,207 --> 01:03:47,143 LINES, WE LOOK AT MANY DIFFERENT 1607 01:03:47,143 --> 01:03:50,947 FACTORS WHEN MAKING FUNDING 1608 01:03:50,947 --> 01:03:52,448 DECISIONS AND SO, PERCENTILING 1609 01:03:52,448 --> 01:03:52,949 DID HAVE THE CENTER FOR 1610 01:03:52,949 --> 01:03:53,850 EXCELLENCE ON AGING OF SAYING 1611 01:03:53,850 --> 01:03:55,151 LIKE, IT'S ALL THE SCORES, 1612 01:03:55,151 --> 01:03:57,153 THAT'S THE ONLY THING THAT 1613 01:03:57,153 --> 01:03:58,321 MATTERS AS OPPOSE TO THE FACT 1614 01:03:58,321 --> 01:04:00,390 THAT THERE ARE MANY OTHER THINGS 1615 01:04:00,390 --> 01:04:02,859 TO LOOK AT. 1616 01:04:02,859 --> 01:04:04,060 SO, THAT'S, YOU KNOW, I WOULD 1617 01:04:04,060 --> 01:04:09,465 SAY THAT'S THE MAIN ISSUE. 1618 01:04:09,465 --> 01:04:12,735 WE DO HOWEVER, SINCE EACH PANEL 1619 01:04:12,735 --> 01:04:13,603 IS CALIBRATED DIFFERENTLY, EVERY 1620 01:04:13,603 --> 01:04:15,672 ROUND WE LOOK AT THE GRIEWKS OF 1621 01:04:15,672 --> 01:04:19,742 SCORES AND THE PANELS AND WE 1622 01:04:19,742 --> 01:04:20,777 ACTUALLY TRY TO NORMALIZE THE 1623 01:04:20,777 --> 01:04:25,081 FUNDING WE GIVE TO EACH -- THE 1624 01:04:25,081 --> 01:04:27,116 GRANTS COMING OUT OF EACH PANEL 1625 01:04:27,116 --> 01:04:28,518 TO MAKE SURE WE'RE TAKING INTO,A 1626 01:04:28,518 --> 01:04:31,354 COUNT THAT SOME ARE HARDER 1627 01:04:31,354 --> 01:04:34,257 GRADERS THAN OTHERS SO THEY'RE 1628 01:04:34,257 --> 01:04:35,525 NOT JUST DISADVANTAGED FROM 1629 01:04:35,525 --> 01:04:40,329 BEING IN A HARD GRADING PANEL. 1630 01:04:40,329 --> 01:04:40,830 YEAH. 1631 01:04:40,830 --> 01:04:41,764 NEIL? 1632 01:04:41,764 --> 01:04:44,100 >> HEY, JON, COUPLE COMMENTS AND 1633 01:04:44,100 --> 01:04:45,234 A QUESTION/SUGGESTION, FIRST OF 1634 01:04:45,234 --> 01:04:47,336 ALL, THANK YOU TO EVERYBODY AT 1635 01:04:47,336 --> 01:04:48,137 NIGMS FOR EVERYTHING YOU'RE 1636 01:04:48,137 --> 01:04:48,805 DOING. 1637 01:04:48,805 --> 01:04:49,539 WE APPRECIATE IT. 1638 01:04:49,539 --> 01:04:51,674 I WANT TO ALSO SAY THAT FOR THE 1639 01:04:51,674 --> 01:04:53,476 MIRA ISSUE I JUST THINK THAT'S 1640 01:04:53,476 --> 01:04:55,344 AN AWESOME PROGRAM FOR MANY OF 1641 01:04:55,344 --> 01:04:57,213 US, IT'S REALLY BEEN 1642 01:04:57,213 --> 01:04:57,547 INSTRUMENTAL. 1643 01:04:57,547 --> 01:04:58,681 IT'S BEEN HUGE FOR US AND I 1644 01:04:58,681 --> 01:05:01,250 REALLY HOPE IT CONTINUES AND I 1645 01:05:01,250 --> 01:05:01,851 APPRECIATED YOUR PRESENTATION. 1646 01:05:01,851 --> 01:05:03,920 THE SPECIFIC THAT I WOULD SAY IS 1647 01:05:03,920 --> 01:05:05,755 THAT'S BEEN MOST HELPFUL FOR ME 1648 01:05:05,755 --> 01:05:07,757 IS THE FLEXIBILITY IN TERMS OF 1649 01:05:07,757 --> 01:05:09,959 THE SCIENCE WE PURSUE, AND NOT 1650 01:05:09,959 --> 01:05:11,327 BEING TIED DOWN TO SPECIFIC 1651 01:05:11,327 --> 01:05:11,527 AIMS. 1652 01:05:11,527 --> 01:05:12,829 THAT'S BEEN THE BIGGEST 1653 01:05:12,829 --> 01:05:14,597 DIFFERENCE FOR ME GOING FROM THE 1654 01:05:14,597 --> 01:05:15,698 RO-1 TO THE R35, PLUS THE 1655 01:05:15,698 --> 01:05:16,432 FINANCIAL STABILITY AND WHAT NOT 1656 01:05:16,432 --> 01:05:18,634 BUT I WANT TO MENTION IT, THAT'S 1657 01:05:18,634 --> 01:05:20,103 BEEN IMPORTANT FOR GIVING US 1658 01:05:20,103 --> 01:05:22,905 FLEXIBILITY TO PURSUE WHATEVER'S 1659 01:05:22,905 --> 01:05:25,174 MOST EXCITING NOT WHAT WE 1660 01:05:25,174 --> 01:05:26,342 THOUGHT WAS EXCITINGA AT THE 1661 01:05:26,342 --> 01:05:29,212 TIME WE WROTE THE SPECIFIC AIMS. 1662 01:05:29,212 --> 01:05:31,681 I WANTED TO TALK A LITTLE BIT 1663 01:05:31,681 --> 01:05:35,985 ABOUT THE NEXT GENERATION OF 1664 01:05:35,985 --> 01:05:37,620 SCIENTISTS AND CONCERNS IN 1665 01:05:37,620 --> 01:05:38,988 ACADEMIA AND MOST INSTITUTIONS I 1666 01:05:38,988 --> 01:05:41,157 THINK STILL HAVE HIRING FREEZES 1667 01:05:41,157 --> 01:05:42,792 AND IT'S GOTTEN A LITTLE 1668 01:05:42,792 --> 01:05:45,328 COMPLICATED FOR THE YOUNGER 1669 01:05:45,328 --> 01:05:47,230 FOLKS AS THERE ARE DPRADUATE 1670 01:05:47,230 --> 01:05:49,766 STUDENTS OR POST DOCS THAT ARE 1671 01:05:49,766 --> 01:05:51,834 THINKING ABOUT ACADEMIA AND ON 1672 01:05:51,834 --> 01:05:53,469 TOP OF THAT THE NSF FELLOWSHIPS 1673 01:05:53,469 --> 01:05:55,004 HAVE BEEN CUT IN HALF. 1674 01:05:55,004 --> 01:05:58,307 COULD YOU SAY MORE ABOUT THAT? 1675 01:05:58,307 --> 01:05:59,876 I APPRECIATED YOUR COMMENTTHE 1676 01:05:59,876 --> 01:06:01,377 T32, ENCOURAGING COMMENTS AT THE 1677 01:06:01,377 --> 01:06:04,847 END COULD YOU SAY ANYTHING ABOUT 1678 01:06:04,847 --> 01:06:07,483 F31 OR F32, ANY HOPES OF BRINGS 1679 01:06:07,483 --> 01:06:09,285 BACK THOSE AND PUTTING FUNDING 1680 01:06:09,285 --> 01:06:10,887 INTO IT AND REGARDLESS I WANT TO 1681 01:06:10,887 --> 01:06:12,955 PUT IN A MR. UG FOR THAT AND 1682 01:06:12,955 --> 01:06:14,390 HOPE THAT'S SOMETHING THIS GROUP 1683 01:06:14,390 --> 01:06:18,261 IT CONSIDER AND TALK ABOUT IT 1684 01:06:18,261 --> 01:06:20,163 AND I WOULD LOVE TO HEAR OTHER 1685 01:06:20,163 --> 01:06:21,430 PEOPLE'S OPINIONS ON THIS FOR 1686 01:06:21,430 --> 01:06:23,065 THE FUTURE AND WHAT CAN CAN DO 1687 01:06:23,065 --> 01:06:25,668 TO HELP POST GRADUATES AND POST 1688 01:06:25,668 --> 01:06:27,069 DOCS. 1689 01:06:27,069 --> 01:06:27,870 NGREAT QUESTION. 1690 01:06:27,870 --> 01:06:32,275 SO GLOBALLY NIH WIDE, THE 1691 01:06:32,275 --> 01:06:33,910 F-FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES WE PLAN 1692 01:06:33,910 --> 01:06:35,611 TO BE REISSUING SOON. 1693 01:06:35,611 --> 01:06:37,013 YOU KNOW THEY EXPIRED. 1694 01:06:37,013 --> 01:06:39,182 THEY HAD TO HAVE THE REVIEW 1695 01:06:39,182 --> 01:06:42,518 CRITERIA UP DATED TO THE NEW 1696 01:06:42,518 --> 01:06:44,020 VERSIONS, SO THE PLAN IS THAT 1697 01:06:44,020 --> 01:06:46,022 THOSE SHOULD COME OUT AGAIN, SO, 1698 01:06:46,022 --> 01:06:49,125 IT'S NOT THAT NIH CANCELED THE 1699 01:06:49,125 --> 01:06:49,826 FELLOWSHIP PROGRAMS, THAT THEY 1700 01:06:49,826 --> 01:06:55,064 ARE SUPPOSED TO BE COMING OUT. 1701 01:06:55,064 --> 01:06:56,966 IN TERMS OF NIGMS, CERTAINLY WE 1702 01:06:56,966 --> 01:06:59,735 ARE THE LARGEST FUNDER OF 1703 01:06:59,735 --> 01:07:01,037 INSTITUTIONAL TRAINING GRANTS SO 1704 01:07:01,037 --> 01:07:02,004 THAT'S HISTORICALLY BEEN OUR 1705 01:07:02,004 --> 01:07:04,674 MAIN WAY TO SUPPORT GRADUATE 1706 01:07:04,674 --> 01:07:05,708 STUDENTS AND I ANTICIPATE WE 1707 01:07:05,708 --> 01:07:07,443 WILL PROBABLY CONTINUE THAT, THE 1708 01:07:07,443 --> 01:07:09,545 ADVANTAGES OF THE TRAINING 1709 01:07:09,545 --> 01:07:12,048 GRANTS ARE THAT THEY ARE SORT OF 1710 01:07:12,048 --> 01:07:14,550 THE LEVERAGING EFFECT WHERE 1711 01:07:14,550 --> 01:07:15,952 BECAUSE IT'S INSTITUTIONAL, THE 1712 01:07:15,952 --> 01:07:17,086 INSTITUTION ALSO PUTS SKIN IN 1713 01:07:17,086 --> 01:07:21,524 THE GAME FOR THOSE, WILL CHANGE 1714 01:07:21,524 --> 01:07:23,659 ITS CURRICULUM, WILL CHANGE THE 1715 01:07:23,659 --> 01:07:24,327 WAY MENTOR STUDENTS, ET CETERA 1716 01:07:24,327 --> 01:07:27,830 BASED ON THE REQUIREMENTS OF THE 1717 01:07:27,830 --> 01:07:29,565 PROGRAM, SO I THINK WE WILL 1718 01:07:29,565 --> 01:07:31,534 CONTINUE TO PROBABLY LEAN 1719 01:07:31,534 --> 01:07:34,403 HEAVILY ON THOSE BECAUSE OF 1720 01:07:34,403 --> 01:07:37,073 THOSE FACTORS. 1721 01:07:37,073 --> 01:07:38,140 INSTITUTIONS ALSO PUT THEIR OWN 1722 01:07:38,140 --> 01:07:39,542 MONEY IN TO FURTHER SUPPORT THE 1723 01:07:39,542 --> 01:07:42,144 PROGRAM SO AGAIN, THERE'S THAT 1724 01:07:42,144 --> 01:07:42,879 LEVERAGING EFFECT, FELLOWSHIPS, 1725 01:07:42,879 --> 01:07:46,115 I THINK CAN BE VERY VALUABLE IN 1726 01:07:46,115 --> 01:07:47,717 THE RIGHT CIRCUMSTANCES AND 1 1727 01:07:47,717 --> 01:07:51,921 THING WE ARE TALKING ABOUT MAY 1728 01:07:51,921 --> 01:07:56,893 BE GOING DOWN THE PATH IN THAT 1729 01:07:56,893 --> 01:07:58,160 REGARD IS THE F99 K00 CONCEPT 1730 01:07:58,160 --> 01:08:01,230 WHERE IT WOULD BE FOR LATER 1731 01:08:01,230 --> 01:08:02,632 STAGE GRADUATE STUDENTS TO 1732 01:08:02,632 --> 01:08:04,133 SUPPORT THEIR KIND OF TRANSITION 1733 01:08:04,133 --> 01:08:05,935 INTO A POST DOC, SO THE F99 IS 1734 01:08:05,935 --> 01:08:08,104 FOR THE END OF THEIR GRADUATE 1735 01:08:08,104 --> 01:08:11,841 CAREER, GETTING THEM FINISHED, 1736 01:08:11,841 --> 01:08:15,411 AND THEN THE F99-K00, THE K00 IS 1737 01:08:15,411 --> 01:08:17,046 TO SUPPORT THE EARLY STAGE OF 1738 01:08:17,046 --> 01:08:20,549 THEIR POST DOCTORAL WORK. 1739 01:08:20,549 --> 01:08:24,053 SO THAT I HOPE WE MAY BE ABLE TO 1740 01:08:24,053 --> 01:08:26,422 GET STARTED AND USE THAT. 1741 01:08:26,422 --> 01:08:31,093 I THINK -- I WILL JUST SAY THE 1742 01:08:31,093 --> 01:08:33,996 REASON THAT NIGMS STOPPED USING 1743 01:08:33,996 --> 01:08:35,731 THE F31 WAS BECAUSE WHEN WE 1744 01:08:35,731 --> 01:08:39,468 LOOKED AT IT, THEY WERE ALL 1745 01:08:39,468 --> 01:08:40,670 GOING TO A VERY SMALL NUMBER OF 1746 01:08:40,670 --> 01:08:43,739 LABS AND A VERY SMALL NUMBER OF 1747 01:08:43,739 --> 01:08:46,542 INSTITUTIONS AND LET'S GO BACK 1748 01:08:46,542 --> 01:08:47,877 TO PETRA'S QUESTION ABOUT 1749 01:08:47,877 --> 01:08:48,110 SCORES. 1750 01:08:48,110 --> 01:08:49,278 EVEN IF WE WANT TO SAY, YOU KNOW 1751 01:08:49,278 --> 01:08:52,882 WE WILL TRY TO PUT MORE OF THOSE 1752 01:08:52,882 --> 01:08:54,083 IN INSTITUTIONS SAYING IDEA 1753 01:08:54,083 --> 01:08:56,886 STATES WE COULDN'T DO IT BECAUSE 1754 01:08:56,886 --> 01:08:59,755 THE WAY THE SCORING DISTRIBUTION 1755 01:08:59,755 --> 01:09:01,657 WAS YOU WOULD HAVE TO SKIP 50 1756 01:09:01,657 --> 01:09:05,494 APPLICANTS TO GET TO THE 1 IN 1757 01:09:05,494 --> 01:09:09,799 THE IDEA STATE AND SO IT DID 1758 01:09:09,799 --> 01:09:10,366 SEEM VERY SKEWED. 1759 01:09:10,366 --> 01:09:13,436 NOW THE GREAT WORK OF ALLYSON 1760 01:09:13,436 --> 01:09:15,805 GAMMY IS OTHERS HAS CHANGED THE 1761 01:09:15,805 --> 01:09:17,673 WHOLE FRAMING OF THE NIH Fs 1762 01:09:17,673 --> 01:09:19,775 WHICH IS THE THING WE'RE TRYING 1763 01:09:19,775 --> 01:09:21,944 TO GET PUBLISHED SOON AND IS THE 1764 01:09:21,944 --> 01:09:26,415 REASON THAT THEY HAVE NOFOs 1765 01:09:26,415 --> 01:09:28,084 ARE AREN'T OUT, AND THAT MAY 1766 01:09:28,084 --> 01:09:30,186 HELP FIX THAT PROBLEM SO THAT 1767 01:09:30,186 --> 01:09:32,121 FIXES THAT PROBLEM AND ALLOWS A 1768 01:09:32,121 --> 01:09:33,055 BROADER DISTRIBUTION AND THE 1769 01:09:33,055 --> 01:09:34,890 AWARDS TO GO TO EMPLOYMENT 1770 01:09:34,890 --> 01:09:37,827 PROGRAMS WHO MIGHT NOT BE ABLE 1771 01:09:37,827 --> 01:09:38,894 TO COMPLETE THEIR GRADUATE 1772 01:09:38,894 --> 01:09:39,729 EDUCATION, THEN THAT WOULD BE A 1773 01:09:39,729 --> 01:09:40,463 GREAT THING. 1774 01:09:40,463 --> 01:09:42,898 IF IT'S JUST GOING TO LABS THAT 1775 01:09:42,898 --> 01:09:44,133 HAVE HHMI SUPPORT AND OTHER 1776 01:09:44,133 --> 01:09:46,202 THINGS LIKE THAT, IT'S JUST NOT 1777 01:09:46,202 --> 01:09:47,370 CLEAR WHAT -- YOU KNOW WHAT 1778 01:09:47,370 --> 01:09:50,940 WE'RE DOING AT THAT STAGE THAT'S 1779 01:09:50,940 --> 01:10:01,450 BENEFITING THE GREATER SYSTEM. 1780 01:10:02,251 --> 01:10:02,985 CHRIS? 1781 01:10:02,985 --> 01:10:04,020 YOU THERE CHRIS? 1782 01:10:04,020 --> 01:10:05,554 >> THANKS AGAIN, I HAD TO STEP 1783 01:10:05,554 --> 01:10:07,890 AWAY FOR A FEW MINUTES, I MAY 1784 01:10:07,890 --> 01:10:10,026 HAVE MISSED THIS BUT BEYOND FOR 1785 01:10:10,026 --> 01:10:11,494 THE MIRA PROGRAM, BEYOND JUST 1786 01:10:11,494 --> 01:10:12,828 THE PROPORTION OF APPLICATIONS 1787 01:10:12,828 --> 01:10:14,764 BEING FUNDED AS A METRIC, WHAT 1788 01:10:14,764 --> 01:10:16,732 OTHER METRICS ARE YOU LOOKING AT 1789 01:10:16,732 --> 01:10:20,169 THAT THIS IS A SUCCESS IS IT 1790 01:10:20,169 --> 01:10:22,438 THROUGH RENEWAL RATES OR THROUGH 1791 01:10:22,438 --> 01:10:23,606 PUBLICATION RATES, I'M CURIOUS 1792 01:10:23,606 --> 01:10:26,008 WHAT ARE THE OTHER ANCILLARY 1793 01:10:26,008 --> 01:10:26,742 THINGS YOU'RE MEASURING? 1794 01:10:26,742 --> 01:10:28,544 >> YEAH, WE LOOK AT LOTS OF 1795 01:10:28,544 --> 01:10:30,513 DIFFERENT THINGS AND I AS I SAID 1796 01:10:30,513 --> 01:10:32,481 THE MIRA PROGRAM IS THE MOST 1797 01:10:32,481 --> 01:10:33,549 HEAVILY EVALUATED PROGRAM WE'VE 1798 01:10:33,549 --> 01:10:34,950 HAD BECAUSE WE'VE BEEN 1799 01:10:34,950 --> 01:10:36,652 CONTINUALLY DOING IT ALL THE 1800 01:10:36,652 --> 01:10:38,888 TIME AS WE GO LOOKING AT ALL 1801 01:10:38,888 --> 01:10:41,090 KINDS OF DIFFERENT FACTORS, SO 1802 01:10:41,090 --> 01:10:42,491 WE DID DO ANALYSIS A FEW YEARS 1803 01:10:42,491 --> 01:10:45,594 AGO OF THE SORT OF EASY LYE 1804 01:10:45,594 --> 01:10:47,763 MEASURABLE THINGS IN TERMS OF 1805 01:10:47,763 --> 01:10:50,866 SCIENTIFIC PRODUCTIVITY LIKE 1806 01:10:50,866 --> 01:10:53,202 PAPERS, CITATIONS, AND MIRA WAS, 1807 01:10:53,202 --> 01:10:54,937 I THINK IT'S SAFE TO SAY IT WAS 1808 01:10:54,937 --> 01:10:59,308 AT LEAST AS GOOD AS RO-1S AND 1809 01:10:59,308 --> 01:11:01,310 SORT OF WAS TRENDING BETTER IN 1810 01:11:01,310 --> 01:11:02,978 THOSE THINGS BUT THOSE ARE, YOU 1811 01:11:02,978 --> 01:11:06,749 KNOW, THEY ARE LIMITED AND 1812 01:11:06,749 --> 01:11:08,918 NUMBERS IN OF THE TIME WE WILL 1813 01:11:08,918 --> 01:11:11,554 REDO THAT ANALYSIS SOON, THAT'S 1814 01:11:11,554 --> 01:11:13,355 AN IMPERFECT -- PAPERS, WELL 1815 01:11:13,355 --> 01:11:16,926 THAT'S 1 THING, CITATIONS, THOSE 1816 01:11:16,926 --> 01:11:19,228 AREN'T PERFECT, 1 WOULD LIKE TO 1817 01:11:19,228 --> 01:11:20,629 SEE THINGS LIKE THEY DIDN'T 1818 01:11:20,629 --> 01:11:22,631 ALLOW PEOPLE TO REALLY SWITCH 1819 01:11:22,631 --> 01:11:23,666 DIRECTIONS, IN THE RESEARCH LIKE 1820 01:11:23,666 --> 01:11:25,201 WE HEARD ABOUT, THAT'S MUCH 1821 01:11:25,201 --> 01:11:25,768 HARDER TO MEASURE. 1822 01:11:25,768 --> 01:11:27,203 WE TRIED TO SOME INITIAL THINGS 1823 01:11:27,203 --> 01:11:30,172 TO LOOK AT THAT, BUT NOT TRIVIAL 1824 01:11:30,172 --> 01:11:31,474 TO MEASURE ABOUT WE WILL KEEP 1825 01:11:31,474 --> 01:11:33,742 TRYING TO MEASURE THINGS LIKE 1826 01:11:33,742 --> 01:11:34,009 THAT. 1827 01:11:34,009 --> 01:11:36,979 YOU KNOW, WE ALSO LOOK AT THINGS 1828 01:11:36,979 --> 01:11:38,981 LIKE RENEWAL RATES, THOSE ARE TO 1829 01:11:38,981 --> 01:11:42,017 AN EXTENT IN OUR CONTROL 1830 01:11:42,017 --> 01:11:42,618 ALTHOUGH NOT ENTIRELY, DEPENDS 1831 01:11:42,618 --> 01:11:44,220 ON THE BUDGET, BUT YOU KNOW ARE 1832 01:11:44,220 --> 01:11:46,055 WE MEETING OUR GOALS OF HAVING 1833 01:11:46,055 --> 01:11:49,992 HIGH RENEWAL RATES FOR MIRAs 1834 01:11:49,992 --> 01:11:52,061 SO A VARIETY OF THINGS WE WILL 1835 01:11:52,061 --> 01:11:53,762 LOOK AT, EVENTUALLY WE WILL LOOK 1836 01:11:53,762 --> 01:12:03,405 AT PATENTS, YOU KNOW, GOOD 1837 01:12:03,405 --> 01:12:03,672 QUESTIONS. 1838 01:12:03,672 --> 01:12:03,939 CHRISTINA? 1839 01:12:03,939 --> 01:12:06,275 >> HI, JOHN, I ALSO WANTED TO 1840 01:12:06,275 --> 01:12:08,744 ECHO OTHERS IN OUR THANKS TO YOU 1841 01:12:08,744 --> 01:12:10,779 AND THE NIGMS STAFF, IT'S VERY 1842 01:12:10,779 --> 01:12:12,548 MUCH APPRECIATED, ALL THE WORK 1843 01:12:12,548 --> 01:12:13,315 YOU'RE PUTTING IN. 1844 01:12:13,315 --> 01:12:15,217 I WANTED TO MAKE A SMALL FOLLOW 1845 01:12:15,217 --> 01:12:17,486 UP COMMENT ON LESLIE'S COMMENT 1846 01:12:17,486 --> 01:12:18,053 ABOUT TIMING. 1847 01:12:18,053 --> 01:12:19,655 SO I THINK, I'M NOT SURE WHAT 1848 01:12:19,655 --> 01:12:22,191 CAN BE DONE ABOUT TIMING BUT 1849 01:12:22,191 --> 01:12:24,026 THERE'S SOME CONCERNS, I KNOW 1850 01:12:24,026 --> 01:12:26,061 AMONG A NUMBER OF INVESTIGATORS 1851 01:12:26,061 --> 01:12:29,198 WITH THE BUMP IN STUDY SECTIONS, 1852 01:12:29,198 --> 01:12:30,866 SO, SOME OF THE MIRA, I DON'T 1853 01:12:30,866 --> 01:12:32,801 KNOW HOW MANY, BUT A BUNCH OF 1854 01:12:32,801 --> 01:12:33,903 MIRA ASHES WARDS THAT WERE 1855 01:12:33,903 --> 01:12:35,538 SUPPOSED TO BE REVIEWED THIS 1856 01:12:35,538 --> 01:12:36,972 JUNE ARE NOW BUMPED TO OCTOBER 1857 01:12:36,972 --> 01:12:39,341 AND I'M HEARING THAT EVEN THE 1858 01:12:39,341 --> 01:12:40,442 OCTOBER DATES HAVEN'T BEEN SENT 1859 01:12:40,442 --> 01:12:42,111 YET, SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT, YOU 1860 01:12:42,111 --> 01:12:44,246 KNOW AT LEAST A 4 MONTH DELAY. 1861 01:12:44,246 --> 01:12:47,416 SO I DON'T KNOW IF THERE'S EVEN 1862 01:12:47,416 --> 01:12:50,252 A TEMPORARY ADJUSTMENT IN TIMING 1863 01:12:50,252 --> 01:12:51,287 BUT WE COULD THINK ABOUT THAT 1864 01:12:51,287 --> 01:12:52,821 THAT WOULD BE APPRECIATED. 1865 01:12:52,821 --> 01:12:54,456 >> YEAH, YEAH, THERE ARE A LOT 1866 01:12:54,456 --> 01:12:57,092 OF CHALLENGES AND WE WILL KEEP 1867 01:12:57,092 --> 01:13:00,029 WORKING THROUGH THOSE WITH CSR. 1868 01:13:00,029 --> 01:13:02,665 CSR REVIEW IS BEING CONSOLIDATED 1869 01:13:02,665 --> 01:13:09,405 IN CSR WHICH I THINK ULTIMATE 1870 01:13:09,405 --> 01:13:10,139 ULTIMATELY 1871 01:13:10,139 --> 01:13:10,940 WILL HAVE BENEFITS BUT ANYTIME 1872 01:13:10,940 --> 01:13:12,474 YOU MAKE A BIG CHANGE IT WILL 1873 01:13:12,474 --> 01:13:13,542 CAUSE DISRUPTIONS ABOUT YOU WE 1874 01:13:13,542 --> 01:13:15,911 WILL KEEP TRYING TO FIND WAYS TO 1875 01:13:15,911 --> 01:13:18,581 MITIGATE THOSE PROBLEMS. 1876 01:13:18,581 --> 01:13:21,750 I SHOULD SAY THAT EARLY STAGE 1877 01:13:21,750 --> 01:13:22,651 INVESTIGATORS YOU KNOW WHOSE 1878 01:13:22,651 --> 01:13:23,485 EARLY STAGE INVESTIGATOR STATUS 1879 01:13:23,485 --> 01:13:27,022 IS GOING TO RUN OUT, CAN APPLY 1880 01:13:27,022 --> 01:13:28,958 FOR TENSIONS FOR VARIOUS 1881 01:13:28,958 --> 01:13:29,892 EXTENUATING CIRCUMSTANCES, SO 1882 01:13:29,892 --> 01:13:31,160 THAT'S SOMETHING TO MAKE 1883 01:13:31,160 --> 01:13:32,728 EVERYONE AWARE OF, THERE'S A 1884 01:13:32,728 --> 01:13:34,029 PORTAL THAT NIH HAS THAT CAN 1885 01:13:34,029 --> 01:13:35,431 EXPLAIN WHAT IT WAS THAT 1886 01:13:35,431 --> 01:13:37,600 HAPPENED, THE STUDY SECTION WAS 1887 01:13:37,600 --> 01:13:39,668 DELAYED FOR EXAMPLE, THINGS OF 1888 01:13:39,668 --> 01:13:40,836 THAT NATURE, SO, THAT SHOULD BE 1889 01:13:40,836 --> 01:13:42,538 ABLE TO BE TAKEN CARE OF, IF 1890 01:13:42,538 --> 01:13:46,175 IT'S AN ISSUE OF ESI 1891 01:13:46,175 --> 01:13:49,478 ELIGIBILITY, I THINK THAT SHOULD 1892 01:13:49,478 --> 01:13:50,412 BE ABLE -- 1893 01:13:50,412 --> 01:13:51,313 >> YEAH, THANK YOU. 1894 01:13:51,313 --> 01:13:52,781 NYEAH ISSUE WE WILL TAKE THE 1895 01:13:52,781 --> 01:13:53,749 LAST QUESTION FROM DAVE AND THEN 1896 01:13:53,749 --> 01:13:57,786 WE WILL TAKE A SHORT BREAK. 1897 01:13:57,786 --> 01:13:58,053 NHI, JON. 1898 01:13:58,053 --> 01:13:59,755 SO I'M WONDERING IF NOW MIGHT BE 1899 01:13:59,755 --> 01:14:01,624 A GOOD TIME TO HAVE A WORKING 1900 01:14:01,624 --> 01:14:02,891 GROUP EVALUATE THE MIRA PROGRAM 1901 01:14:02,891 --> 01:14:06,228 TO BRING IN SOME PERSPECTIVES 1902 01:14:06,228 --> 01:14:06,929 FROM THE COMMUNITY? 1903 01:14:06,929 --> 01:14:08,797 >> WE COULD THINK ABOUT THAT. 1904 01:14:08,797 --> 01:14:10,566 CERTAINLY AS I SAID WE'VE BEEN 1905 01:14:10,566 --> 01:14:12,635 DOING SOME INTERNAL EVALUATIONS 1906 01:14:12,635 --> 01:14:14,803 AS WE GO, BUT WE CAN DEFINITELY 1907 01:14:14,803 --> 01:14:20,142 ADD THAT TO THE LIST OF FORMAL 1908 01:14:20,142 --> 01:14:21,076 EVALUATIONS THAT WE MIGHT WANT 1909 01:14:21,076 --> 01:14:21,610 TO DO. 1910 01:14:21,610 --> 01:14:24,046 I THINK THAT'S A TOTALLY 1911 01:14:24,046 --> 01:14:25,047 REASONABLE IDEA. 1912 01:14:25,047 --> 01:14:26,115 >> I THINK NOW HAVING WORKED ON 1913 01:14:26,115 --> 01:14:28,684 1 OF THE WORKING GROUPS, I CAN 1914 01:14:28,684 --> 01:14:31,287 SEE HOW SOME OUTSIDE PERSPECTIVE 1915 01:14:31,287 --> 01:14:32,187 MIGHT BE HELPFUL. 1916 01:14:32,187 --> 01:14:33,389 >> OKAY, WE WILL TAKE THAT BACK, 1917 01:14:33,389 --> 01:14:34,923 THAT'S A GOOD IDEA. 1918 01:14:34,923 --> 01:14:36,792 ALL RIGHT, SO, WE'RE A LITTLE 1919 01:14:36,792 --> 01:14:38,427 BEHIND TIME, SO WHY DON'T WE 1920 01:14:38,427 --> 01:14:41,330 TAKE WHAT DO YOU THINK A 10 1921 01:14:41,330 --> 01:14:42,865 MINUTE BREAK, ERICA? 1922 01:14:42,865 --> 01:14:44,266 SHAVE OFF A LITTLE TIME IN. 1923 01:14:44,266 --> 01:14:46,302 >> YEAH, ABOUT 10 MINUTES WOULD 1924 01:14:46,302 --> 01:14:46,535 BE GOOD. 1925 01:14:46,535 --> 01:14:48,137 >> SO WHY DON'T WE ALL COME BACK 1926 01:14:48,137 --> 01:14:49,872 IN 10 MINUTES SO ABOUT 5 MINUTES 1927 01:14:49,872 --> 01:14:50,773 TO 11. 1928 01:14:50,773 --> 01:14:51,840 DID EMPLOY. 1929 01:14:51,840 --> 01:14:56,092 THANK YOU ALL. 1930 01:15:17,978 --> 01:15:19,480 >> ALL RIGHT. 1931 01:15:19,480 --> 01:15:25,986 LET'S GET STARTED AGAIN. 1932 01:15:25,986 --> 01:15:31,292 I WILL START WITH THE PLAN FOR 1933 01:15:31,292 --> 01:15:32,326 EVALUATING THE COBRE CENTERS I 1934 01:15:32,326 --> 01:15:33,561 TALKED ABOUT AND THEN WE WILL 1935 01:15:33,561 --> 01:15:35,329 ARE A REPORT ON AN ACTUAL 1936 01:15:35,329 --> 01:15:37,264 EVALUATION THAT DAVE MATTHEWS 1937 01:15:37,264 --> 01:15:39,099 AND MICHAEL CHAPMAN WILL LEAD. 1938 01:15:39,099 --> 01:15:41,569 SO IF I CAN HAVE THE SLIDE FOR 1939 01:15:41,569 --> 01:15:48,475 THE COBRE PART. 1940 01:15:48,475 --> 01:15:49,109 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 1941 01:15:49,109 --> 01:15:51,512 ALL RIGHT, SO I ALREADY GAVE THE 1942 01:15:51,512 --> 01:15:53,180 BACKGROUND ON IDEA, SO I WON'T 1943 01:15:53,180 --> 01:15:55,716 GO OVER THAT AGAIN, AND I TOLD 1944 01:15:55,716 --> 01:15:59,720 YOU ABOUT THE COBRE PROGRAM, BUT 1945 01:15:59,720 --> 01:16:00,988 JUST TO GIVE A LITTLE MORE 1946 01:16:00,988 --> 01:16:02,022 SPECIFICS, THERE ARE ACTUALLY 3 1947 01:16:02,022 --> 01:16:05,125 PHASES IN THE COBRE PROGRAM, THE 1948 01:16:05,125 --> 01:16:07,628 FIRST PHASE IS DOING THAT 1949 01:16:07,628 --> 01:16:09,496 CAPACITY BUILDING AND 1950 01:16:09,496 --> 01:16:11,765 INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT I 1951 01:16:11,765 --> 01:16:15,502 TALKED ABOUT, FOCUSING ON JUNIOR 1952 01:16:15,502 --> 01:16:16,870 INVESTIGATORS, THE SECOND PHASE 1953 01:16:16,870 --> 01:16:26,614 IS A RENEWAL SO THEY CAN 1954 01:16:26,614 --> 01:16:28,749 CONTINUE THAT WORK AND THEN PLAN 1955 01:16:28,749 --> 01:16:30,217 HOW THEY WILL MAKE THIS 1956 01:16:30,217 --> 01:16:31,719 SUSTAINABLE IN THE LONG RUN AND 1957 01:16:31,719 --> 01:16:34,588 THE THIRD PHASE IS THE 1958 01:16:34,588 --> 01:16:36,323 SOLIDIFYING PHASE, IF THEY WERE 1959 01:16:36,323 --> 01:16:37,291 SUCCESSFUL, NOW THEY GET TIME 1960 01:16:37,291 --> 01:16:40,561 AND FUNDING TO TREELLY TRY AND 1961 01:16:40,561 --> 01:16:45,165 SOLIDIFY THE GAMES AND TO MAKE 1962 01:16:45,165 --> 01:16:46,300 THEM FULLY CEMENTED INTO THE 1963 01:16:46,300 --> 01:16:50,904 SYSTEM. 1964 01:16:50,904 --> 01:16:51,438 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 1965 01:16:51,438 --> 01:16:52,806 IF YOU CAN JUST CLICK THE 1966 01:16:52,806 --> 01:16:57,244 BULLETS THAT WOULD BE GOOD. 1967 01:16:57,244 --> 01:16:59,947 SO THE WAY WE DO EVALUATIONS, 1968 01:16:59,947 --> 01:17:03,017 WHEN WE DO THEM FULL SCALE 1969 01:17:03,017 --> 01:17:06,186 FORMALLY IS WE DO A BIG DATA 1970 01:17:06,186 --> 01:17:11,058 COLLECTION IN-HOUSE THAT'S LED 1971 01:17:11,058 --> 01:17:13,360 BY RICHARD ARAGOM AND HIS DIMA 1972 01:17:13,360 --> 01:17:18,132 TEAMS AND YOU WILL SEE 1 OF 1973 01:17:18,132 --> 01:17:19,033 THOSE FROM THE DATA COLLECTION 1974 01:17:19,033 --> 01:17:20,501 EFFORTS IN JUST A MINUTE. 1975 01:17:20,501 --> 01:17:22,569 WE DISCUSSED THAT IN HOUSE QUITE 1976 01:17:22,569 --> 01:17:24,271 A BIT, ASK MORE QUESTIONS, GET 1977 01:17:24,271 --> 01:17:26,740 MORE DATA AND THEN ONCE THAT'S 1978 01:17:26,740 --> 01:17:27,875 COMPLETE WE EMPANEL A WORKING 1979 01:17:27,875 --> 01:17:29,543 GROUP OF COUNCIL WITH A FEW 1980 01:17:29,543 --> 01:17:31,245 COUNCIL MEMBERS AND THEN OTHERS 1981 01:17:31,245 --> 01:17:32,513 FROM OUTSIDE WITH APPROPRIATE 1982 01:17:32,513 --> 01:17:35,482 EXPERTISE WHO GO OVER ALL THOSE 1983 01:17:35,482 --> 01:17:37,184 DATA, THEY CAN ASK FOR 1984 01:17:37,184 --> 01:17:38,919 ADDITIONAL DATA, ASK ADDITIONAL 1985 01:17:38,919 --> 01:17:42,256 QUESTIONS, THEY HAVE A FULL DAY 1986 01:17:42,256 --> 01:17:43,891 MEETING, WHERE THEY SYNTHESIZE, 1987 01:17:43,891 --> 01:17:46,360 YOU KNOW THEIR IDEAS AND YOU 1988 01:17:46,360 --> 01:17:47,695 KNOW BASICALLY THEIR FINDINGS 1989 01:17:47,695 --> 01:17:51,932 ABOUT THE PROGRAM, INTO A REPORT 1990 01:17:51,932 --> 01:17:53,267 WITH RECOMMENDATIONS FOR YOU 1991 01:17:53,267 --> 01:18:00,040 KNOW CHANGES OR IMPROVEMENTS IN 1992 01:18:00,040 --> 01:18:00,407 THE PROGRAM. 1993 01:18:00,407 --> 01:18:03,243 SO THE WAY THEY DO THIS IS TO 1994 01:18:03,243 --> 01:18:04,778 ASK 4 OVERARCHING QUESTIONS: 1995 01:18:04,778 --> 01:18:06,347 HAS THE PROGRAM BEEN SUCCESSFUL 1996 01:18:06,347 --> 01:18:07,881 IN MEETING ITS STATED 1997 01:18:07,881 --> 01:18:08,415 OBJECTIVES? 1998 01:18:08,415 --> 01:18:09,483 ARE THE STATED OBLIGATIONS 1999 01:18:09,483 --> 01:18:11,218 YECTIVES APPROPRIATE FOR THE 2000 01:18:11,218 --> 01:18:13,387 PROGRAM AND ITS INTENDED IMPACT? 2001 01:18:13,387 --> 01:18:15,055 CAN CERTAIN AREAS OF THE PROGRAM 2002 01:18:15,055 --> 01:18:17,224 WITH BE OPTIMIZED, IMPROVED OR 2003 01:18:17,224 --> 01:18:18,759 STRENGTHENED IN AND WHAT KEY 2004 01:18:18,759 --> 01:18:19,593 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS CAN 2005 01:18:19,593 --> 01:18:21,462 BE MADE ABOUT THE PROGRAM? 2006 01:18:21,462 --> 01:18:25,065 EVERYTHING HAS HAPPENED IN THESE 2007 01:18:25,065 --> 01:18:26,367 EVALUATIONS FROM PROGRAMS 2008 01:18:26,367 --> 01:18:28,535 WORKING ERROR WELL, JUST NEEDS 2009 01:18:28,535 --> 01:18:30,738 MINOR TWEAKS TO IN A COUPLE 2010 01:18:30,738 --> 01:18:32,339 CASES, THE PROGRAM IS MOT 2011 01:18:32,339 --> 01:18:34,775 WORKING THE WAY IT'S SUPPOSED TO 2012 01:18:34,775 --> 01:18:37,478 AND SHOULD BE COMPLOATLY CHANGED 2013 01:18:37,478 --> 01:18:39,580 OR ELIMINATED AND REPLACED WITH 2014 01:18:39,580 --> 01:18:41,115 SOMETHING ELSE. 2015 01:18:41,115 --> 01:18:44,084 AS I MENTIONED, DIMA, ARE THE 1S 2016 01:18:44,084 --> 01:18:45,652 THAT DO THE DATA. 2017 01:18:45,652 --> 01:18:48,756 THEY LEAD THIS GROUP BUT THERE'S 2018 01:18:48,756 --> 01:18:53,460 A WORKING GROUP OF COUNCIL 2019 01:18:53,460 --> 01:18:54,762 THAT'S AN EVALUATIVE BODY. 2020 01:18:54,762 --> 01:18:55,662 NEXT SLIDE. 2021 01:18:55,662 --> 01:18:59,199 SO, YEAH, GO BACK 1 SLIDE. 2022 01:18:59,199 --> 01:19:00,968 SO THE WORKING GROUP ONCE 2023 01:19:00,968 --> 01:19:03,537 THEY'VE GOTTEN THEIR FINDINGS 2024 01:19:03,537 --> 01:19:06,874 SYNTHESIZED, THEY THEN PRESENTED 2025 01:19:06,874 --> 01:19:08,842 TO NIGMS COUNCIL, IT'S A 2026 01:19:08,842 --> 01:19:09,977 PRESENTATION TO THE COUNCIL. 2027 01:19:09,977 --> 01:19:13,213 THE COUNCIL HAS TO FORMALLY 2028 01:19:13,213 --> 01:19:14,648 ACCEPT THEIR REPORT. 2029 01:19:14,648 --> 01:19:18,051 FROM THEIR NIGMS LOOKS AT THE 2030 01:19:18,051 --> 01:19:18,652 RECOMMENDATIONS, DECIDES WHAT 2031 01:19:18,652 --> 01:19:19,887 CHANGES TO MAKE AND THEN WE 2032 01:19:19,887 --> 01:19:21,588 ACTUALLY COME BACK AND DO A 2033 01:19:21,588 --> 01:19:22,322 PRESENTATION TO COUNCIL SAYING 2034 01:19:22,322 --> 01:19:25,325 WHAT WE ARE GOING TO CHANGE 2035 01:19:25,325 --> 01:19:26,860 BASED ON THE RECOMMENDATION OF 2036 01:19:26,860 --> 01:19:28,128 THE WORKING GROUP THAT WAS 2037 01:19:28,128 --> 01:19:33,300 ACCEPTED BY OUR COUNCIL. 2038 01:19:33,300 --> 01:19:36,904 IN ORDER TO DO THIS WE HAVE TO 2039 01:19:36,904 --> 01:19:38,505 FORMALLY ASK COUNCIL TO DO THE 2040 01:19:38,505 --> 01:19:39,940 PANEL AND WE'RE HERE TO DO THAT 2041 01:19:39,940 --> 01:19:42,910 NOW IS TO ASK IF YOU ARE WILLING 2042 01:19:42,910 --> 01:19:44,611 TO LET US EMPANEL A WORKING 2043 01:19:44,611 --> 01:19:47,481 GROUP TO DO A FORMAL EVALUATION 2044 01:19:47,481 --> 01:19:51,218 OF THED COBRE PROGRAM. 2045 01:19:51,218 --> 01:20:00,961 SO ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THAT? 2046 01:20:00,961 --> 01:20:02,696 >> ERRATICCA, I WILL TAKE A VOTE 2047 01:20:02,696 --> 01:20:03,130 ON THAT. 2048 01:20:03,130 --> 01:20:06,533 I WILL MOVE THAT WE APPROVE TO 2049 01:20:06,533 --> 01:20:08,469 IMPANEL THIS WORKING GROUP, ARE 2050 01:20:08,469 --> 01:20:12,406 ANY OPPOSED IN OPPOSED? 2051 01:20:12,406 --> 01:20:13,707 , THE HOAGZ IS APPROVED. 2052 01:20:13,707 --> 01:20:14,007 >> GREAT. 2053 01:20:14,007 --> 01:20:16,510 WE WILL MOVE FORWARD WITH THAT 2054 01:20:16,510 --> 01:20:17,744 COBRE EVALUATION, NOW WE WILL 2055 01:20:17,744 --> 01:20:19,313 HEAR THE RESULTS OF A PREVIOUS 2056 01:20:19,313 --> 01:20:21,281 EVALUATION THAT IS CONCLUDING 2057 01:20:21,281 --> 01:20:22,349 WITH THIS PRESENTATION TO 2058 01:20:22,349 --> 01:20:26,687 COUNCIL, SO DAVE, I WILL LET YOU 2059 01:20:26,687 --> 01:20:30,724 TAKE IT AWAY AND IS MICHAEL HERE 2060 01:20:30,724 --> 01:20:32,192 AS WELL? 2061 01:20:32,192 --> 01:20:32,526 >> YES. 2062 01:20:32,526 --> 01:20:32,793 >> YEAH. 2063 01:20:32,793 --> 01:20:35,929 >> GREAT, I WILL LET YOU 2 TAKE 2064 01:20:35,929 --> 01:20:36,563 IT AWAY. 2065 01:20:36,563 --> 01:20:47,107 >> THANKS, CAN YOU PULL UP OUR 2066 01:20:50,811 --> 01:20:51,111 SLIDES. 2067 01:20:51,111 --> 01:20:53,647 SO I'M DAVID MATHEWS AND I'M CO 2068 01:20:53,647 --> 01:20:56,116 CHAIR ALONG WITH MICHAEL 2069 01:20:56,116 --> 01:20:57,284 CHAPMAN. 2070 01:20:57,284 --> 01:21:00,587 WE EVALUATED THE NIGMS 2071 01:21:00,587 --> 01:21:01,655 MSR PROGRAM, MATURE SINK ROUGH 2072 01:21:01,655 --> 01:21:03,257 ATOM TRON RESOURCES. 2073 01:21:03,257 --> 01:21:03,690 NEXT SLIDE. 2074 01:21:03,690 --> 01:21:07,427 OUR WORKING GROUP WAS COMPOSED 2075 01:21:07,427 --> 01:21:09,096 OF SARAH BOWMAN, UNIVERSITY OF 2076 01:21:09,096 --> 01:21:10,697 BUFFALO, MICHAEL CHAPMAN THE CO 2077 01:21:10,697 --> 01:21:15,769 CHAIR FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF 2078 01:21:15,769 --> 01:21:24,645 MISSOURI AT COLUMBI ATHE VADIM 2079 01:21:24,645 --> 01:21:31,952 CHEREZOV FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF 2080 01:21:31,952 --> 01:21:34,421 SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA, KRZYSZTOF 2081 01:21:34,421 --> 01:21:36,490 FIDELIS, FROM THE UNIVERSITY OF 2082 01:21:36,490 --> 01:21:38,258 CALIFORNIA DAVIS AND I WANT TO 2083 01:21:38,258 --> 01:21:40,694 THANK THE HELP OF NIGMS STAFF 2084 01:21:40,694 --> 01:21:43,297 FOR THE WORK THEY PROVIDED IN 2085 01:21:43,297 --> 01:21:43,664 GATHERING DATA. 2086 01:21:43,664 --> 01:21:49,770 IN PARTICULAR I WANT TO CALL OUT 2087 01:21:49,770 --> 01:21:51,471 ANDREW MIKLOS, WHO IS INVOLVED 2088 01:21:51,471 --> 01:21:53,774 WITH THE DATA INTEGRATION AT 2089 01:21:53,774 --> 01:21:53,974 NIGMS. 2090 01:21:53,974 --> 01:21:55,709 WE DID A GREAT JOB COLLECTING 2091 01:21:55,709 --> 01:21:57,678 DATA AND PRESENTING IT TO US AND 2092 01:21:57,678 --> 01:21:59,112 ALSO ORGANIZING OUR MEETINGS, I 2093 01:21:59,112 --> 01:22:08,255 ALSO WANT TO THANK RICHARD AR 2094 01:22:08,255 --> 01:22:11,525 AGON, DOROTHY DECKET, DAVID 2095 01:22:11,525 --> 01:22:12,726 BOTCHENER, THOMAS CHO, ANN, 2096 01:22:12,726 --> 01:22:15,462 PAULA, AND ADAPTED RUE AND KATIE 2097 01:22:15,462 --> 01:22:17,731 AND KAMILAH, AND TROY, THANKS 2098 01:22:17,731 --> 01:22:18,432 FOR THEIR HELP. 2099 01:22:18,432 --> 01:22:19,566 NEXT SLIDE. 2100 01:22:19,566 --> 01:22:21,201 IN THIS EVALUATION POINT, I WILL 2101 01:22:21,201 --> 01:22:22,302 START THE PRESENTATION, I WILL 2102 01:22:22,302 --> 01:22:24,605 GIVE BACKGROUND ON THE P30 MSR 2103 01:22:24,605 --> 01:22:26,573 PROGRAM, I WILL PRESENT OUR KEY 2104 01:22:26,573 --> 01:22:28,208 QUESTIONS AND FINDINGS, AND THEN 2105 01:22:28,208 --> 01:22:33,747 MICHAEL CHAPMAN WILL GET THE 2106 01:22:33,747 --> 01:22:34,748 WORKING GROUP RECOMMENDATIONS. 2107 01:22:34,748 --> 01:22:35,048 NEXT SLIDE. 2108 01:22:35,048 --> 01:22:39,987 SO THE P30 MSR OBLIGATIONS 2109 01:22:39,987 --> 01:22:41,989 YECTIVE IS TO INSURE THAT THE 2110 01:22:41,989 --> 01:22:43,090 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH ACTIVITY HAS 2111 01:22:43,090 --> 01:22:44,658 ACCESS TO STRAIGHT OF THE ART 2112 01:22:44,658 --> 01:22:47,828 BEAM LINE TECHNOLOGIES FOR 2113 01:22:47,828 --> 01:22:48,629 BIOLOGICAL RESEARCH 2114 01:22:48,629 --> 01:22:51,031 APPLICATIONS, IT ALSO HAS THE 2115 01:22:51,031 --> 01:22:54,368 SUBAIMS TO OBTAIN OR CREATE BEST 2116 01:22:54,368 --> 01:22:54,968 PRACTICES, ADVERTISE RESOURCE 2117 01:22:54,968 --> 01:22:56,236 CAPABILITIES AND AVAILABILITY TO 2118 01:22:56,236 --> 01:22:57,170 THE BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH 2119 01:22:57,170 --> 01:22:58,405 COMMUNITY THROUGH OUTREACH 2120 01:22:58,405 --> 01:22:59,640 ACTIVITIES, AND TO PROVIDE USER 2121 01:22:59,640 --> 01:23:01,475 TRAINING AND SUPPORT DATA 2122 01:23:01,475 --> 01:23:05,012 COLLECTION PROCESSING AND 2123 01:23:05,012 --> 01:23:06,113 ANALYSIS. 2124 01:23:06,113 --> 01:23:08,348 NEXT SLIDE. 2125 01:23:08,348 --> 01:23:11,151 THE MSR PROGRAM STRUCTURE IS 2126 01:23:11,151 --> 01:23:12,052 DESIGNED AROUND RESOURCE 2127 01:23:12,052 --> 01:23:13,220 FACILITIES, I WILL SHOW YOU ON 2128 01:23:13,220 --> 01:23:15,789 THE NEXT SLIDES THAT THERE ARE 8 2129 01:23:15,789 --> 01:23:17,758 OF THESE FACILITIES, EACH 2130 01:23:17,758 --> 01:23:19,826 FACILITY HAS 3 CORES, AN 2131 01:23:19,826 --> 01:23:21,294 ADMINISTRATIVE CORE, A USER 2132 01:23:21,294 --> 01:23:23,664 TRAINING AND OUTREACH CORE, AND 2133 01:23:23,664 --> 01:23:26,333 A TECHNOLOGY OPERATIONS CORE AND 2134 01:23:26,333 --> 01:23:28,001 THE INTENDED RESOURCE USERS ARE 2135 01:23:28,001 --> 01:23:28,735 THE BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH 2136 01:23:28,735 --> 01:23:33,874 COMMUNITY AT LARGE. 2137 01:23:33,874 --> 01:23:35,175 NEXT SLIDE. 2138 01:23:35,175 --> 01:23:36,743 THIS SLIDE ILLUSTRATES THE 2139 01:23:36,743 --> 01:23:37,878 TECHNIQUES THAT ARE SUPPORTED BY 2140 01:23:37,878 --> 01:23:38,578 THE PROGRAM. 2141 01:23:38,578 --> 01:23:41,114 THE FIGURE SHOWS STRUCTURAL 2142 01:23:41,114 --> 01:23:42,215 BIOLOGY TECHNIQUES IN GENERAL 2143 01:23:42,215 --> 01:23:46,386 STARTING ON THE LEFT WITH THOSE 2144 01:23:46,386 --> 01:23:47,487 WITH THE FINEST RESOLUTION TO 2145 01:23:47,487 --> 01:23:49,189 THE RIGHT THOSE THAT ARE 2146 01:23:49,189 --> 01:23:51,558 GRANDEST IN SCALE AND THEN IN 2147 01:23:51,558 --> 01:23:56,463 BLUE BOXES ARE THE NAMES OF THE 2148 01:23:56,463 --> 01:23:57,631 TECHNIQUES THAT ARE SINK ROUGH 2149 01:23:57,631 --> 01:24:01,101 ATOM TON TECHNIQUES SUPPORTED BY 2150 01:24:01,101 --> 01:24:07,841 NIGMS, THOSE INCLUDE MASS SPEC 2151 01:24:07,841 --> 01:24:08,475 ROMETRY, CRYSTALLOGRAPHY, SMALL 2152 01:24:08,475 --> 01:24:12,079 ANGLE AND NEUTRON SCATTERING, 2153 01:24:12,079 --> 01:24:14,414 SOFTXRAY TOMOGRAPHY, AND THEN 2154 01:24:14,414 --> 01:24:16,416 X-RAY FLUORESCENCE IMANNUALING, 2155 01:24:16,416 --> 01:24:20,987 MICROSPECTROSCOPY AND TOMOGRAPHY 2156 01:24:20,987 --> 01:24:21,822 . 2157 01:24:21,822 --> 01:24:22,322 NEXT SLIDE. 2158 01:24:22,322 --> 01:24:24,858 SO THIS PROVIDES AN OVERVIEW OF 2159 01:24:24,858 --> 01:24:26,626 THE SITES THAT ARE SUPPORTED BY 2160 01:24:26,626 --> 01:24:28,962 THE MSR PROGRAM BY LOCATION. 2161 01:24:28,962 --> 01:24:31,865 AND THE TABLE STARTS PRESENTING 2162 01:24:31,865 --> 01:24:33,934 THEM ROUGHLY FROM WEST TO EAST. 2163 01:24:33,934 --> 01:24:35,469 AND SO, THE ADVANCED LIGHT 2164 01:24:35,469 --> 01:24:39,339 SOURCE IS THE HOME OF 2 2165 01:24:39,339 --> 01:24:45,112 RESOURCES, ALS ENABLE WHICH IS 2166 01:24:45,112 --> 01:24:47,681 ADMINISTERED UC LAWRENCE BURKELY 2167 01:24:47,681 --> 01:24:51,518 LABS AND THEN ALS-NCXT, 2168 01:24:51,518 --> 01:24:54,454 ADMINISTERED BY UNIVERSITY OF 2169 01:24:54,454 --> 01:24:55,856 SAN FRANCISCO, THE SSRL IS THE 2170 01:24:55,856 --> 01:24:59,025 HOME OF 1 RESOURCE, WHICH IS 2171 01:24:59,025 --> 01:24:59,526 ADMINISTERED BY STANFORD 2172 01:24:59,526 --> 01:25:02,596 UNIVERSITY, AND THEN THERE ARE 3 2173 01:25:02,596 --> 01:25:04,598 DIFFERENT RESOURCES AT THE 2174 01:25:04,598 --> 01:25:08,635 ADVANCED PHOTON SOURCE OR APS IN 2175 01:25:08,635 --> 01:25:10,604 ILLINOIS. 2176 01:25:10,604 --> 01:25:12,305 THERE'S APS, GCMA, ISSUED BY 2177 01:25:12,305 --> 01:25:15,408 ARGON LABS AND THE UNIVERSITY OF 2178 01:25:15,408 --> 01:25:16,143 CHICAGO. 2179 01:25:16,143 --> 01:25:17,744 APS BIOCAT ADMINISTERED BY 2180 01:25:17,744 --> 01:25:20,647 ILLINOIS EN--STRATEGIESITUTE OF 2181 01:25:20,647 --> 01:25:23,350 TECHNOLOGY AND APS NE-CAT WHICH 2182 01:25:23,350 --> 01:25:30,624 IS ADMINISTERED AT CORNELL 2183 01:25:30,624 --> 01:25:32,726 UNIVERSITY, AT THE MACCHESS AND 2184 01:25:32,726 --> 01:25:36,530 THEN THE FARTHER IS THE 1 2185 01:25:36,530 --> 01:25:38,632 RESOURCE, THE NSLS 2 CBMS WHICH 2186 01:25:38,632 --> 01:25:41,802 IS ADMINISTERED BY BROOK HAVEN 2187 01:25:41,802 --> 01:25:45,238 NATIONAL LABS. 2188 01:25:45,238 --> 01:25:46,039 NEXT SLIDE. 2189 01:25:46,039 --> 01:25:48,108 THIS SLIDE GOES TO THE 2190 01:25:48,108 --> 01:25:49,576 INVESTMENT PROGRAM FROM NIGMS, 2191 01:25:49,576 --> 01:25:51,211 THE FIGURE SHOWS THE TOTAL 2192 01:25:51,211 --> 01:25:52,379 DOLLARS IN MILLIONS AS A 2193 01:25:52,379 --> 01:25:55,949 FUNCTION OF THE FISCAL YEAR. 2194 01:25:55,949 --> 01:25:57,450 PRIOR TO 2017, THE SINK ROUGH 2195 01:25:57,450 --> 01:26:00,687 ATOM TON RESOURCES WERE FUNDED 2196 01:26:00,687 --> 01:26:02,722 THROUGH NIGMS, THROUGH THE P41 2197 01:26:02,722 --> 01:26:08,028 MECHANISM OR INTERAGENCY 2198 01:26:08,028 --> 01:26:08,328 AGREEMENTS. 2199 01:26:08,328 --> 01:26:10,096 IN THE PERIOD OF TIME, THE 2200 01:26:10,096 --> 01:26:13,533 TRANSITION TO THE P31 PROGRAM 2201 01:26:13,533 --> 01:26:15,068 THAT WE EVALUATED AND THE NUMBER 2202 01:26:15,068 --> 01:26:18,104 OF RESOURCES HAS BEEN STABLE AT 2203 01:26:18,104 --> 01:26:19,639 8. 2204 01:26:19,639 --> 01:26:22,242 THE PTHERT HAS BEEN CONSTANT 2205 01:26:22,242 --> 01:26:23,810 SINCE FISCAL YEAR 2020 AND 2206 01:26:23,810 --> 01:26:27,347 AROUND $22 MILLION AWARDED PER 2207 01:26:27,347 --> 01:26:27,914 YEAR. 2208 01:26:27,914 --> 01:26:29,482 NEXT SLIDE. 2209 01:26:29,482 --> 01:26:32,118 THIS SLIDE ILLUSTRATES THE LINE 2210 01:26:32,118 --> 01:26:32,719 OF TECHNOLOGIES THAT ARE 2211 01:26:32,719 --> 01:26:33,553 SUPPORTED BY THE PROGRAM. 2212 01:26:33,553 --> 01:26:38,124 SO AS I MENTIONED THERE ARE 8 2213 01:26:38,124 --> 01:26:39,159 RESOURCES, THEY PROVIDE 36 BEAM 2214 01:26:39,159 --> 01:26:42,596 LINES TOTAL, MANY OF THESE BEAM 2215 01:26:42,596 --> 01:26:44,998 LINES ARE PARTIALLY SUPPORTED BY 2216 01:26:44,998 --> 01:26:47,400 NIGMS SO THERE ARE 21 EFFECTIVE 2217 01:26:47,400 --> 01:26:49,369 BEAM LINES SUPPORTED. 2218 01:26:49,369 --> 01:26:50,537 THE PIE CHARTOT RIGHT SHOWS THE 2219 01:26:50,537 --> 01:26:53,406 BREAK DOWN BY TECHNIQUE, THE 2220 01:26:53,406 --> 01:26:55,642 MAJORITY GOES TO CRYSTALLOGRAPHY 2221 01:26:55,642 --> 01:27:06,152 AT 52% OF THE BEAM LINES SMALL 2222 01:27:10,857 --> 01:27:13,326 SCATTERING AND ALTHOUGH SOME OF 2223 01:27:13,326 --> 01:27:14,794 THE SPECIFIC TECHNIQUES REQUIRE 2224 01:27:14,794 --> 01:27:25,071 ONSET ACCESS AND 2225 01:30:50,877 --> 01:30:52,645 -- THAN IN OTHER YEARS, THAT'S 2226 01:30:52,645 --> 01:30:58,118 BECAUSE OF COVID SHUT DOWNS, 2227 01:30:58,118 --> 01:30:59,652 OTHER RESOURCES HAD SAFETY SHUT 2228 01:30:59,652 --> 01:31:00,820 DOWNS THAT REDUCED AVAILABLE 2229 01:31:00,820 --> 01:31:01,754 TIME IN SPECIFIC YEARS BUT WE 2230 01:31:01,754 --> 01:31:04,057 CAN SEE THAT THE OTHER RESOURCES 2231 01:31:04,057 --> 01:31:05,158 HAVE INCREASED TO PICK UP SOME 2232 01:31:05,158 --> 01:31:15,401 OF THE SLACK. 2233 01:31:16,536 --> 01:31:17,904 NEXT SLIDE. 2234 01:31:17,904 --> 01:31:18,972 THIS SHOWS PROGRAMS TO BENEFITED 2235 01:31:18,972 --> 01:31:20,607 FROM THE PROGRAMS AND THIS SHOWS 2236 01:31:20,607 --> 01:31:22,509 THE UNIQUE USERS ON THE Y-AXIS 2237 01:31:22,509 --> 01:31:26,146 AND THE X-AXIS IS THE YEAR AND 2238 01:31:26,146 --> 01:31:27,881 THEN EACH RESOURCE IS PLOTTED IN 2239 01:31:27,881 --> 01:31:31,484 A DIFFERENT COLOR AND SO WE CAN 2240 01:31:31,484 --> 01:31:33,353 SEE THAT SAW DIFFERENT USERS IN 2241 01:31:33,353 --> 01:31:38,491 2020 ALMOST CERTAINLY BECAUSE OF 2242 01:31:38,491 --> 01:31:39,959 COVID-19 LOCK DOWNS THE NUMBER 2243 01:31:39,959 --> 01:31:44,297 OF USERS CONSISTENT OR INCREASED 2244 01:31:44,297 --> 01:31:46,266 WE DO SEE SOME AND WE SEE SOME 2245 01:31:46,266 --> 01:31:47,333 RESOURCES THIS IS ALMOST 2246 01:31:47,333 --> 01:31:50,036 CERTAINLY FROM DOWN TIME, EITHER 2247 01:31:50,036 --> 01:31:51,638 FOR SAFETY OR UPGRADE AND SO, 2248 01:31:51,638 --> 01:31:53,506 SOME OF THE THESE RESOURCES THAT 2249 01:31:53,506 --> 01:31:56,176 HAD PLANNED DOWN TIMES WERE ABLE 2250 01:31:56,176 --> 01:31:59,312 TO MAKE AGREEMENTS WITH OTHER 2251 01:31:59,312 --> 01:32:01,181 RESOURCES TO ABNORMALITIES 2252 01:32:01,181 --> 01:32:04,851 ABSORB USER REQUESTS! 2253 01:32:04,851 --> 01:32:05,451 NEXT SLIDE. 2254 01:32:05,451 --> 01:32:07,086 THIS SLIDE SHOWS THE NUMBER OF 2255 01:32:07,086 --> 01:32:08,588 PUBLICATIONS THAT WERE SUPPORTED 2256 01:32:08,588 --> 01:32:10,590 BY THE MSR PROGRAM, SO THE BAR 2257 01:32:10,590 --> 01:32:11,891 PLOT SHOWS THE NUMBER OF 2258 01:32:11,891 --> 01:32:14,360 PUBLICATIONS AS A NUMBER OF 2259 01:32:14,360 --> 01:32:15,195 PUBLICATION YEAR. 2260 01:32:15,195 --> 01:32:16,596 IN PARTICULAR, WE CAN SEE THAT 2261 01:32:16,596 --> 01:32:18,865 THIS HAS BEEN RELATIVELY 2262 01:32:18,865 --> 01:32:21,434 CONSTANT DURING THE P30 YEARS OF 2263 01:32:21,434 --> 01:32:23,403 SUPPORT, WE CAN SEE A BIG 2264 01:32:23,403 --> 01:32:25,138 INCREASE IN 2020 WHICH WAS 2265 01:32:25,138 --> 01:32:27,840 ALMOST CERTAINLY DURING THE 2266 01:32:27,840 --> 01:32:29,275 COVID LOCK DOWNS INVESTIGATORS 2267 01:32:29,275 --> 01:32:31,978 INSTEAD OF DOING STRUCTURAL 2268 01:32:31,978 --> 01:32:33,947 BIOLOGY RESEARCH, WERE WRITING 2269 01:32:33,947 --> 01:32:35,481 UP THE RESULTS FOR PUBLICATION, 2270 01:32:35,481 --> 01:32:38,785 AFTER THAT WE CAN SEE A VERY 2271 01:32:38,785 --> 01:32:40,486 SLIGHT DECLINE WHICH COULD 2272 01:32:40,486 --> 01:32:43,823 POSSIBLY BE A REPORTING LAG IN 2273 01:32:43,823 --> 01:32:44,157 PUBLICATIONS. 2274 01:32:44,157 --> 01:32:45,024 WE THINK ACTUALLY A LARGE PART 2275 01:32:45,024 --> 01:32:48,695 OF IT IS THE COVID-19 IMPACTS, 2276 01:32:48,695 --> 01:32:50,396 SO IN 2020 WHILE STRUCTURES WERE 2277 01:32:50,396 --> 01:32:52,732 BEING SOLVED WE CAN SEE THAT THE 2278 01:32:52,732 --> 01:32:54,934 NUMBER OF PAPERS REPORTING 2279 01:32:54,934 --> 01:33:02,609 RESULTINGS IS DECREASED. 2280 01:33:02,609 --> 01:33:03,409 NEXT SLIDE. 2281 01:33:03,409 --> 01:33:06,946 AND THIS SLIDE SHOWS THE NUMBER 2282 01:33:06,946 --> 01:33:09,015 OF PDB DEPOSITIONS SO ON THIS 2283 01:33:09,015 --> 01:33:10,550 SLIDE THE STRUCTURES IS ALONG 2284 01:33:10,550 --> 01:33:11,851 THE Y-AXIS AND IT'S IMPORTANT TO 2285 01:33:11,851 --> 01:33:14,420 NOTE THIS IS A LOGO RHYTHMIC 2286 01:33:14,420 --> 01:33:17,056 ACCESS AND THEN THE Y-AXIS IS 2287 01:33:17,056 --> 01:33:19,926 THE PDB RELEASE SHARE, SO WE CAN 2288 01:33:19,926 --> 01:33:22,295 SEE SINCE 1980 A NUMBER OF 2289 01:33:22,295 --> 01:33:23,229 DEPOSITIONS OF X-RAY STRUCTURE 2290 01:33:23,229 --> 01:33:25,565 SHOWN IN RED HAVE INCREASED 2291 01:33:25,565 --> 01:33:26,499 EXPONENTIALLY AND JUST STARTED 2292 01:33:26,499 --> 01:33:29,235 TO LEVEL OFF IN RECENT YEARS! 2293 01:33:29,235 --> 01:33:31,738 AT THE SAME TEE WE CAN SEE THAT 2294 01:33:31,738 --> 01:33:33,206 ELECTRON MICROSCOPY POTTED IN 2295 01:33:33,206 --> 01:33:35,074 BLACK HAS HAD AN EXPONENTIAL 2296 01:33:35,074 --> 01:33:38,144 INCREASE IN THE NUMBER OF 2297 01:33:38,144 --> 01:33:39,746 DEPOSITIONS FROM ABOUT 2010 TO 2298 01:33:39,746 --> 01:33:43,750 TODAY, BUT WE STILL SEE THAT THE 2299 01:33:43,750 --> 01:33:47,120 X-RAY CRYSTALLOGRAPHY IS STILL 2300 01:33:47,120 --> 01:33:53,326 THE NUMBER 1'S OF PDB 2301 01:33:53,326 --> 01:33:54,427 DEPOSITIONS. 2302 01:33:54,427 --> 01:33:55,028 NEXT SLIDE. 2303 01:33:55,028 --> 01:33:57,630 TWO AND 3 OF THE MSR PROGRAM ARE 2304 01:33:57,630 --> 01:33:58,264 ADVERTISING RESOURCE 2305 01:33:58,264 --> 01:34:00,233 CAPABILITIES AND AVAILABILITY 2306 01:34:00,233 --> 01:34:01,701 THROUGH OUTREACH ACTIVITIES 2307 01:34:01,701 --> 01:34:03,202 PROVIDING USER TRAINING AND 2308 01:34:03,202 --> 01:34:05,638 SUPPORTING DATA COLLECTION 2309 01:34:05,638 --> 01:34:07,073 PROCESSING AND ANALYSIS. 2310 01:34:07,073 --> 01:34:10,076 HERE WE HAVE LESS DATA TO SHOW 2311 01:34:10,076 --> 01:34:12,111 TO SUPPORT THE SUCCESS OF THIS 2312 01:34:12,111 --> 01:34:14,013 ALTHOUGH WE HAVE A LOT OF 2313 01:34:14,013 --> 01:34:16,316 ANECDOTA EVIDENCE THAT THE MSR 2314 01:34:16,316 --> 01:34:18,251 PROGRAM HAS BEEN SUCCESSFUL. 2315 01:34:18,251 --> 01:34:19,385 WE DO HAVE 1 PIECE OF DATA THAT 2316 01:34:19,385 --> 01:34:22,388 I WANT TO SHOW ON THE NEXT SLIDE 2317 01:34:22,388 --> 01:34:25,058 THAT SUPPORTS THIS. 2318 01:34:25,058 --> 01:34:25,525 NEXT SLIDE. 2319 01:34:25,525 --> 01:34:28,361 HERE WE SHOW A MAP OF THE UNITED 2320 01:34:28,361 --> 01:34:31,564 STATES WITH THE NUMBER OF USERS 2321 01:34:31,564 --> 01:34:36,235 OF THE MSR RESOURCES PLOTTED PER 2322 01:34:36,235 --> 01:34:38,171 STATE NORMALIZED BY THE NIH 2323 01:34:38,171 --> 01:34:41,274 FUNDING PER STATE IN MILLIONS OF 2324 01:34:41,274 --> 01:34:41,774 DOLLARS. 2325 01:34:41,774 --> 01:34:44,110 IN PARTICULAR WE ALSO HAVE THE 2326 01:34:44,110 --> 01:34:46,546 IDEA STATES THAT JOHN TALKED 2327 01:34:46,546 --> 01:34:48,348 ABOUT EARLIER SURROUNDED WITH A 2328 01:34:48,348 --> 01:34:49,215 YELLOW BORDER. 2329 01:34:49,215 --> 01:34:52,218 AND SO, THE MSR RESOURCES 2330 01:34:52,218 --> 01:34:54,287 ATTRACT USERS FLOABALLY, BUT A 2331 01:34:54,287 --> 01:34:55,788 MAJORITY OF THESE COME FROM THE 2332 01:34:55,788 --> 01:34:56,489 UNITED STATES. 2333 01:34:56,489 --> 01:34:59,392 NINETY% OF STATES HAVE USERS 2334 01:34:59,392 --> 01:35:01,761 ACCESSING THE MSR, AND IN 2335 01:35:01,761 --> 01:35:03,896 PARTICULAR 75% OF THE IDEA 2336 01:35:03,896 --> 01:35:06,032 STATES HAVE USERS UTILIZING THE 2337 01:35:06,032 --> 01:35:07,533 MSRS, SO THESE DATA SUPPORT THAT 2338 01:35:07,533 --> 01:35:11,738 THE OUTREACH HAS BEEN 2339 01:35:11,738 --> 01:35:12,939 SUCCESSFUL. 2340 01:35:12,939 --> 01:35:13,973 NEXT SLIDE. 2341 01:35:13,973 --> 01:35:15,708 NOW, MICHAEL CHAPMAN WILL 2342 01:35:15,708 --> 01:35:19,746 PRESENT THE RECOMMENDATIONS. 2343 01:35:19,746 --> 01:35:27,019 >> THANK YOU DAVE. 2344 01:35:27,019 --> 01:35:29,589 SO, NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE THE 2345 01:35:29,589 --> 01:35:30,990 WORKING GROUP CAME UP WITH 2346 01:35:30,990 --> 01:35:33,626 RECOMMENDATIONS AND THEY TART BY 2347 01:35:33,626 --> 01:35:36,162 NOTING THAT THE DIFFERENT BEAM 2348 01:35:36,162 --> 01:35:42,168 LINES NOW PROVIDING SIMILAR 2349 01:35:42,168 --> 01:35:44,170 SERVICES WITH WORK FLOWS AND 2350 01:35:44,170 --> 01:35:47,340 STAN ARDIZEATIONS THAT WOULD 2351 01:35:47,340 --> 01:35:48,708 IMPROVE EFFICIENCIES BY MAKING 2352 01:35:48,708 --> 01:35:50,576 IT EASIER FOR USERS TO SWITCH 2353 01:35:50,576 --> 01:35:53,679 BETWEEN DIFFERENT RESOURCES AND 2354 01:35:53,679 --> 01:35:55,081 THESE STANDARDIZATIONS COULD BE 2355 01:35:55,081 --> 01:35:56,916 -- COULD INVOLVE THE APPLICATION 2356 01:35:56,916 --> 01:36:00,620 PROCESS WITH COMMON FORMS, IT 2357 01:36:00,620 --> 01:36:02,922 COULD INCLUDE COMMON USER 2358 01:36:02,922 --> 01:36:04,424 INTERFACES TO CONTROLLING THE 2359 01:36:04,424 --> 01:36:07,126 BEAM LINES WHETHER THAT BE 2360 01:36:07,126 --> 01:36:12,131 ONSITE OR FOR REMOTE OPERATION. 2361 01:36:12,131 --> 01:36:13,733 AND SUCH STANDARDIZATIONS WOULD 2362 01:36:13,733 --> 01:36:18,237 BE A FOUNDATION FOR DEVELOPING 2363 01:36:18,237 --> 01:36:24,444 MODULINGS OF TRAINING, 2364 01:36:24,444 --> 01:36:25,711 CERTIFICATIONS OF COMPETENCIES 2365 01:36:25,711 --> 01:36:29,682 WHO COULD BE TRANSFERRED BETWEEN 2366 01:36:29,682 --> 01:36:31,150 DIFFERENT BEAM LINES. 2367 01:36:31,150 --> 01:36:32,952 NOW THESE RECOMMENDATIONS COME 2368 01:36:32,952 --> 01:36:36,289 FROM THE EXPERIENCE WITH THE 2369 01:36:36,289 --> 01:36:40,993 NATIONAL CRYOEM CENTERS, AND WE 2370 01:36:40,993 --> 01:36:51,604 KNOW FOR THE CINCH ROUGH SYNCHRN 2371 01:36:53,639 --> 01:37:00,146 RESOURCES BECAUSE SOME OF THESE 2372 01:37:00,146 --> 01:37:01,180 PROVIDING RESOURCES IN WHERE 2373 01:37:01,180 --> 01:37:03,816 THEY EXPECT SAT TUS TO BE AND 2374 01:37:03,816 --> 01:37:06,118 THEY ALSO ENCOMP PASS A WIDE 2375 01:37:06,118 --> 01:37:07,320 DIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGIES AND 2376 01:37:07,320 --> 01:37:09,255 THIS IT WOULD BE DIFFICULT TO 2377 01:37:09,255 --> 01:37:11,224 STANDARDIZE BETWEEN SAY SMALL 2378 01:37:11,224 --> 01:37:14,026 INGLE STATERRING AND X-RAY 2379 01:37:14,026 --> 01:37:14,827 CRYSTALLOGRAPHY. 2380 01:37:14,827 --> 01:37:17,897 NOW, THE CRYOEM CENTERS GOT TO 2381 01:37:17,897 --> 01:37:24,437 THIS POINT IN TERMS OF 2382 01:37:24,437 --> 01:37:25,137 STANDARDIZATION REALLY THROUGH 2383 01:37:25,137 --> 01:37:26,873 DISCUSSIONS THAT WERE HATCHED AT 2384 01:37:26,873 --> 01:37:31,043 ANNUAL MEETINGS BETWEEN THE 2385 01:37:31,043 --> 01:37:32,211 CENTERS MEETINGS THAT INVOLVE 2386 01:37:32,211 --> 01:37:34,814 THE KEY PERSONNEL AT EACH SITE 2387 01:37:34,814 --> 01:37:39,685 AND THAT WERE SPONSORED BY NIH 2388 01:37:39,685 --> 01:37:40,853 AND SO THE RECOMMENDATION FROM 2389 01:37:40,853 --> 01:37:44,123 THE WORKING GROUP IS THAT NIGMS 2390 01:37:44,123 --> 01:37:48,394 CONSIDER BUDGETING FUNDS SO THAT 2391 01:37:48,394 --> 01:37:50,463 AN ANNUAL MEETING COULD BE HOLD 2392 01:37:50,463 --> 01:37:52,698 BETWEEN THE MSRs SPONSORED BY 2393 01:37:52,698 --> 01:37:56,002 NIGMS AND HELD AT EACH MSR 2394 01:37:56,002 --> 01:37:59,605 INTERN. 2395 01:37:59,605 --> 01:38:09,949 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 2396 01:38:12,852 --> 01:38:23,329 SO, YEAH, THERE WERE SUGGESTIONS 2397 01:38:24,964 --> 01:38:27,233 ON TRAINING AND AGAIN THESE 2398 01:38:27,233 --> 01:38:33,940 INVOLVE IDEAS STOLEN FROM THE 2399 01:38:33,940 --> 01:38:36,142 CRYOEM CENTERS AND THAT 1 OF THE 2400 01:38:36,142 --> 01:38:41,314 CENTRAL IDEAS WAS TO THINK ABOUT 2401 01:38:41,314 --> 01:38:45,818 COMPETITIONS FOR SEPARATE 2402 01:38:45,818 --> 01:38:47,286 CURRICULUM DEVELOPMENT GRANTS 2403 01:38:47,286 --> 01:38:49,889 THAT HAVE HAD A SUBSTANTIAL 2404 01:38:49,889 --> 01:38:53,793 IMPACT ON THE CRYOEM SIDE, BY 2405 01:38:53,793 --> 01:38:57,897 COVERING ELEMENTS OF CORE 2406 01:38:57,897 --> 01:38:59,332 CURRICULUM, AND THE MODULES THAT 2407 01:38:59,332 --> 01:39:03,102 HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED OUT OF THESE 2408 01:39:03,102 --> 01:39:04,170 INITIATIVES HAVE BECOME PRERICK 2409 01:39:04,170 --> 01:39:07,340 WIZZITS FOR THE TRAINING THAT IS 2410 01:39:07,340 --> 01:39:10,409 REQUIRED TO USE EACH 1 OF THE 2411 01:39:10,409 --> 01:39:15,514 RESOURCES THAT EACH 1 OF THOSE 2412 01:39:15,514 --> 01:39:16,282 SITES. 2413 01:39:16,282 --> 01:39:17,817 THESE TRAINING PROGRAMS HAVE 2414 01:39:17,817 --> 01:39:20,553 CONSITUTED A PRETTY MODEST 2415 01:39:20,553 --> 01:39:21,821 INVESTMENT, IT'S JUST 3 PERCENT 2416 01:39:21,821 --> 01:39:24,290 OF THE OVERALL INVESTMENT IN THE 2417 01:39:24,290 --> 01:39:27,493 CRYOEM CENTERS BUT IT'S PRODUCED 2418 01:39:27,493 --> 01:39:28,294 A HIGH RETURN. 2419 01:39:28,294 --> 01:39:31,030 THE WORKING GROUP NOTED THAT 2420 01:39:31,030 --> 01:39:32,198 THIS WOULD SUBSTITUTE FOR ONLY A 2421 01:39:32,198 --> 01:39:34,567 SMALL PART OF THE TRAINING 2422 01:39:34,567 --> 01:39:36,402 ACTIVITIES OF THE SINK ROUGH 2423 01:39:36,402 --> 01:39:37,436 ATOM TRON RESOURCES BECAUSE WE 2424 01:39:37,436 --> 01:39:39,472 WOULD EXPECT THAT SIGNIFICANT 2425 01:39:39,472 --> 01:39:41,841 TRAINING WOULD ALSO HAVE TO 2426 01:39:41,841 --> 01:39:48,748 OCCUR AT EACH OF AT 2427 01:39:48,748 --> 01:39:52,318 EACH OF THE INDIVIDUAL SITES. 2428 01:39:52,318 --> 01:39:53,586 NOW ANOTHER RECOMMENDATION CAME 2429 01:39:53,586 --> 01:39:55,087 FROM CONSIDERATION THAT THERE 2430 01:39:55,087 --> 01:39:59,025 MAY COME A TIME WHEN DEMAND FOR 2431 01:39:59,025 --> 01:40:01,627 SOME OF THE SYNCHROTRON SERVICES 2432 01:40:01,627 --> 01:40:03,062 BEGINS TO SUFFER. 2433 01:40:03,062 --> 01:40:04,130 THERE'S NOT YET ANY EVIDENCE OF 2434 01:40:04,130 --> 01:40:05,665 THIS HAPPENING BUT THE WORKING 2435 01:40:05,665 --> 01:40:09,068 GROUP WAS CONCERNED THAT FUTURE 2436 01:40:09,068 --> 01:40:10,102 RECOMMENDATIONS WOULD BE BEST 2437 01:40:10,102 --> 01:40:12,638 MADE WITH KEY USAGE DATA THAT'S 2438 01:40:12,638 --> 01:40:14,540 NOT AVAILABLE NOW AND SO 2439 01:40:14,540 --> 01:40:15,975 COLLECTION OF SUCH DATA SHOULD 2440 01:40:15,975 --> 01:40:19,545 BE STARTED AS SOON AS PRACTICAL. 2441 01:40:19,545 --> 01:40:21,213 THE CRITICAL DATA THAT'S NEEDED 2442 01:40:21,213 --> 01:40:25,551 ARE THE NUMBER OF APPLICANTS, 2443 01:40:25,551 --> 01:40:26,552 THE SUCCESS RATES, THE TIMES 2444 01:40:26,552 --> 01:40:29,889 THAT YOU HAVE TO WAIT IN ORDER 2445 01:40:29,889 --> 01:40:35,795 TO SCHEDULE TIME AT A PARTICULAR 2446 01:40:35,795 --> 01:40:36,996 RESOURCE AND THESE DATA ARE 2447 01:40:36,996 --> 01:40:39,165 LIKELY AVAILABLE AT ALL OF THE 2448 01:40:39,165 --> 01:40:41,734 SITES BUT THEY REALLY NEED TO BE 2449 01:40:41,734 --> 01:40:48,774 COLLECTED IN A STANDARDIZED 2450 01:40:48,774 --> 01:40:49,141 FORM. 2451 01:40:49,141 --> 01:40:52,411 THERE WAS A SURVEY TO WHICH 2452 01:40:52,411 --> 01:40:54,046 INTERESTED MEMBERS OF THE 2453 01:40:54,046 --> 01:40:54,947 COMMUNITY WERE INVITED TO 2454 01:40:54,947 --> 01:40:57,249 RESPOND AND THERE WERE 2 2455 01:40:57,249 --> 01:40:59,018 MESSAGES THAT DOMINATED, THE 2456 01:40:59,018 --> 01:41:01,887 FIRST 1 WAS THAT THE MATURE 2457 01:41:01,887 --> 01:41:04,457 SYNCHROTRON RESOURCES ARE DOING 2458 01:41:04,457 --> 01:41:06,726 A GREAT SERVICE. 2459 01:41:06,726 --> 01:41:09,528 THE SECOND MESSAGE WAS THAT 2460 01:41:09,528 --> 01:41:13,899 THERE'S A NEED FOR FURTHER 2461 01:41:13,899 --> 01:41:18,537 RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT AND 2 2462 01:41:18,537 --> 01:41:19,605 PURPOSES WERE CITED 1 WAS FOR 2463 01:41:19,605 --> 01:41:22,575 IMPROVING THE QUALITY AND 2464 01:41:22,575 --> 01:41:24,777 THEENTIOUS FICIENCY OF THE BEAM 2465 01:41:24,777 --> 01:41:26,979 LINES, BUT IT'S ALSO A QUESTION 2466 01:41:26,979 --> 01:41:28,714 OF IMPROVING THE ENGAGEMENT OF 2467 01:41:28,714 --> 01:41:30,616 THE SCIENTIFIC SUPPORT STAFF AND 2468 01:41:30,616 --> 01:41:36,055 AS A MEANS TO THEIR RETENTION. 2469 01:41:36,055 --> 01:41:38,491 SO RESPONDENTS TO THE SURVEY 2470 01:41:38,491 --> 01:41:39,358 RECOMMENDED INCREASED SUPPORT OF 2471 01:41:39,358 --> 01:41:42,194 BEAM LINE R&D BEYOND THAT -- 2472 01:41:42,194 --> 01:41:44,964 >> SHOULD THE SLIDES BE 2473 01:41:44,964 --> 01:41:45,431 ADVANCED? 2474 01:41:45,431 --> 01:41:45,731 >> SORRY. 2475 01:41:45,731 --> 01:41:46,432 YES. 2476 01:41:46,432 --> 01:41:56,776 WE SHOULD BE ON 24. 2477 01:41:57,877 --> 01:41:59,411 I'M SORRY. 2478 01:41:59,411 --> 01:42:03,482 SO THIS PROMPTED DISCUSSION ON 2479 01:42:03,482 --> 01:42:04,350 SEVERAL FRONTS. 2480 01:42:04,350 --> 01:42:08,754 THERE WAS DISCUSSION OF WHETHER 2481 01:42:08,754 --> 01:42:10,923 THE CURRENT RESTRICTIONS ON R&D 2482 01:42:10,923 --> 01:42:14,360 AND THE P30 MECHANISM SHOULD BE 2483 01:42:14,360 --> 01:42:17,830 RELAXED, THERE WAS DISCUSSION OF 2484 01:42:17,830 --> 01:42:20,299 WHETHER COMPOSITION TR R-SERIES 2485 01:42:20,299 --> 01:42:22,034 GRANTS WAS THE APPROPRIATE WORK 2486 01:42:22,034 --> 01:42:24,570 FOR FUNDING TO BE FUNNELED TO 2487 01:42:24,570 --> 01:42:27,807 SUCH WORK, AND THERE WAS ALSO 2488 01:42:27,807 --> 01:42:30,376 DISCUSSION OF A PERCEIVED 2489 01:42:30,376 --> 01:42:33,245 DISADVANTAGE FOR PROPOSALS IN 2490 01:42:33,245 --> 01:42:35,514 THE AREA OF BEAM LINE TECHNOLOGY 2491 01:42:35,514 --> 01:42:44,423 DEVELOPMENT, SO NEXT SLIDE, 2492 01:42:44,423 --> 01:42:44,657 PLEASE. 2493 01:42:44,657 --> 01:42:46,525 SO THE WORKING GROUP WAS 2494 01:42:46,525 --> 01:42:50,362 PROVIDED WITH ADDITIONAL 2495 01:42:50,362 --> 01:42:53,265 RELEVANT DATA AND SO, THESE ARE 2496 01:42:53,265 --> 01:42:58,103 DATA ON TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT 2497 01:42:58,103 --> 01:42:58,537 GRANTS. 2498 01:42:58,537 --> 01:43:00,172 IT'S A SMALL SAMPLE SIZE SO I 2499 01:43:00,172 --> 01:43:03,242 WOULD CAUTION ABOUT READING TOO 2500 01:43:03,242 --> 01:43:06,478 MUCH INTO THIS BUT IF WE ADD 2501 01:43:06,478 --> 01:43:08,447 TOGETHER THESE 3 DIFFERENT 2502 01:43:08,447 --> 01:43:09,448 FUNDING MECHANISMS, AND I SHOULD 2503 01:43:09,448 --> 01:43:12,451 POINT OUT THAT THE DATA REFER TO 2504 01:43:12,451 --> 01:43:17,990 AN 8 YEAR PERIOD, EACH 2505 01:43:17,990 --> 01:43:20,893 MSR AVERAGED 1.1 SUCCESSFUL 2506 01:43:20,893 --> 01:43:22,795 APPLICATIONS FOR SEPARATE 2507 01:43:22,795 --> 01:43:25,965 FUNDING FOR BEAM LINE TECHNOLOGY 2508 01:43:25,965 --> 01:43:30,002 DEVELOPMENT AND WE CAN INFER 2509 01:43:30,002 --> 01:43:35,674 FROM THIS, THAT EACH OF THE 2510 01:43:35,674 --> 01:43:37,476 RESOURCES HAD R&D GRANT FOR 2511 01:43:37,476 --> 01:43:40,379 ABOUT HALF OF THE TIME. 2512 01:43:40,379 --> 01:43:42,982 NOW, YOU CAN ALSO LOOK AT THIS 2513 01:43:42,982 --> 01:43:47,253 DATA IN TERMS OF SUCCESS RATES 2514 01:43:47,253 --> 01:43:52,958 AND WE SEE THAT ABOUT 30% OF THE 2515 01:43:52,958 --> 01:43:54,994 INCOMING PROPOSALS ENDED UP 2516 01:43:54,994 --> 01:43:55,427 BEING FUNDED. 2517 01:43:55,427 --> 01:43:57,429 AND SO THIS IS ROUGHLY 2518 01:43:57,429 --> 01:44:00,799 COMMENSURATE WITH SUCCESS RATES 2519 01:44:00,799 --> 01:44:05,504 OVERALL AND SO, BOTH SIDES OF 2520 01:44:05,504 --> 01:44:08,374 THIS DISCUSSION COULD SEE DATA 2521 01:44:08,374 --> 01:44:11,343 TO SUPPORT THEIR POSITIONS OF 2522 01:44:11,343 --> 01:44:15,981 EITHER THE NEEDED TO BE A BETTER 2523 01:44:15,981 --> 01:44:18,284 MECHANISM FOR SUPPORTING R&D, 2524 01:44:18,284 --> 01:44:19,318 AND TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT AT 2525 01:44:19,318 --> 01:44:21,453 THE BEAM LINES OR THAT THE 2526 01:44:21,453 --> 01:44:25,357 EXISTING MECHANISMS WERE WORKING 2527 01:44:25,357 --> 01:44:35,467 FINE. 2528 01:44:38,170 --> 01:44:38,537 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 2529 01:44:38,537 --> 01:44:41,807 THERE WERE A COUPLE SUGGESTIONS 2530 01:44:41,807 --> 01:44:42,708 REGARDING OUTREACH. 2531 01:44:42,708 --> 01:44:45,678 ONE WAS TO SUGGEST INTERNSHIPS 2532 01:44:45,678 --> 01:44:48,213 AS A MECHANISM FOR BEAM LINE 2533 01:44:48,213 --> 01:44:49,381 WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT, THE 2534 01:44:49,381 --> 01:44:52,584 WORKING GROUP ALSO NOTED THAT 2535 01:44:52,584 --> 01:44:53,953 INVESTIGATORS AT RESOURCE 2536 01:44:53,953 --> 01:44:55,821 LIMITED INSTITUTIONS FACED 2537 01:44:55,821 --> 01:45:04,163 ADDITIONAL CHALLENGES IN 2538 01:45:04,163 --> 01:45:05,197 ACCESSING FOR DATA PROCESSING 2539 01:45:05,197 --> 01:45:06,865 THAT FOLLOWS THIS TO THE BEAM 2540 01:45:06,865 --> 01:45:08,400 LINES, AND THE WORKING GROUP 2541 01:45:08,400 --> 01:45:11,704 SUGGEST THAD THE NEXT RFA COULD 2542 01:45:11,704 --> 01:45:14,606 ALLOW PROPOSAL OF MODEST 2543 01:45:14,606 --> 01:45:25,084 COMPUTATIONAL RESOURCES FOR 2544 01:45:25,484 --> 01:45:27,019 SHARED ALLOCATION OF 2545 01:45:27,019 --> 01:45:28,287 INSTITUTIONS THAT COULD JUSTIFY 2546 01:45:28,287 --> 01:45:30,356 THE NEED AND A FAIRLY MODEST 2547 01:45:30,356 --> 01:45:31,457 INVESTMENT AND THE KEY BEING 2548 01:45:31,457 --> 01:45:35,728 THAT USERS WOULD HAVE TO 2549 01:45:35,728 --> 01:45:37,029 SPECIFICALLY REQUEST ACCESS 2550 01:45:37,029 --> 01:45:47,573 BASED UPON LIMITED RESOURCES AT 2551 01:45:57,916 --> 01:45:59,585 THEIR INSTITUTIONS. 2552 01:45:59,585 --> 01:46:01,787 AT THE WORKING GROUP, 2553 01:46:01,787 --> 01:46:05,391 DISCUSSIONS TRIED TO BALANCE THE 2554 01:46:05,391 --> 01:46:08,727 JUSTIFICATIONS FOR A CONSTANT 2555 01:46:08,727 --> 01:46:10,596 DOLLAR BUDGET WITH APPRECIATION 2556 01:46:10,596 --> 01:46:12,564 THAT NIGMS WAS LIKELY OFFERING 2557 01:46:12,564 --> 01:46:14,033 CONSIDERING REQUESTS TO EXPAND 2558 01:46:14,033 --> 01:46:15,134 SUPPORT FOR NEW TECHNOLOGIES AND 2559 01:46:15,134 --> 01:46:20,305 TRYING TO DO IT ALL WITHIN AN 2560 01:46:20,305 --> 01:46:22,708 NIGMS BUDGET THAT WAS 2561 01:46:22,708 --> 01:46:24,043 CONSTRAINED. 2562 01:46:24,043 --> 01:46:25,244 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. 2563 01:46:25,244 --> 01:46:27,579 AND SO, AGAIN, THE WORKING GROUP 2564 01:46:27,579 --> 01:46:31,850 WAS PROVIDED WITH ADDITIONAL 2565 01:46:31,850 --> 01:46:32,051 DATA. 2566 01:46:32,051 --> 01:46:38,190 ON THE LEFT WE SEE A GRAF 2567 01:46:38,190 --> 01:46:40,259 SHOWING THE LEVELS OF SUPPORT IN 2568 01:46:40,259 --> 01:46:41,760 CONSTANT DOLLARS, INFLATION 2569 01:46:41,760 --> 01:46:49,168 CORRECTED DOLLARS AND WE SEE 2570 01:46:49,168 --> 01:46:52,004 THAT THE FUNDING PEAKED AT ABOUT 2571 01:46:52,004 --> 01:46:54,206 2019 AT RIGHT THE TIME WHEN THE 2572 01:46:54,206 --> 01:46:57,142 P30 MECHANISM BECAME THE 2573 01:46:57,142 --> 01:47:00,512 PREDOMINANT FORM OF SUPPORT AND 2574 01:47:00,512 --> 01:47:02,614 IT'S DECLINED SOMEWHAT SINCE 2575 01:47:02,614 --> 01:47:04,917 THEN TO LEVELS THAT ARE ABOUT 2576 01:47:04,917 --> 01:47:06,785 COMMENSURATE WITH THE LEVELS OF 2577 01:47:06,785 --> 01:47:12,157 SUPPORT ABOUT A DECADE AGO. 2578 01:47:12,157 --> 01:47:15,894 NOW ON THE RIGHT IS SHOWN THE 2579 01:47:15,894 --> 01:47:17,596 SYNCHROTRON SUPPORT BUDGET AS A 2580 01:47:17,596 --> 01:47:21,700 FRACTION OF THE TOTAL NIGMS 2581 01:47:21,700 --> 01:47:22,668 BUDGET. 2582 01:47:22,668 --> 01:47:26,772 AND WE SEE THAT IT HAS REMAINED 2583 01:47:26,772 --> 01:47:29,074 ROUGHLY CONSTANT AT ABOUT 2584 01:47:29,074 --> 01:47:31,110 3-QUARTERS OF 1 PERCENT. 2585 01:47:31,110 --> 01:47:33,745 ASK SO IT WOULD BE A WORTHY GOAL 2586 01:47:33,745 --> 01:47:37,583 TO MAKE THE MSRs FULLY 2587 01:47:37,583 --> 01:47:41,420 SUSTAINABLE THRU RESTORATION OF 2588 01:47:41,420 --> 01:47:43,255 A LOST CONSTANT DOLLARS BUT IT'S 2589 01:47:43,255 --> 01:47:44,723 ALSO PERFECTLY REASONABLE TO 2590 01:47:44,723 --> 01:47:48,026 EXPECT THAT THE CHALLENGES, ARE 2591 01:47:48,026 --> 01:47:50,996 SHARED WITHIN THE NIGMS 2592 01:47:50,996 --> 01:47:52,131 PORTFOLIO. 2593 01:47:52,131 --> 01:47:53,432 AND THAT A CONSTANT FRACTION OF 2594 01:47:53,432 --> 01:47:57,970 THE OVERALL BUDGET IS A 2595 01:47:57,970 --> 01:47:58,537 REALISTIC EXPECTATION. 2596 01:47:58,537 --> 01:48:00,339 AND SO IN CONCLUSION, THE 2597 01:48:00,339 --> 01:48:04,309 WORKING GROUP WANTS TO EMPHASIZE 2598 01:48:04,309 --> 01:48:05,043 THAT THE MATURE SYNCHROTRON 2599 01:48:05,043 --> 01:48:06,712 RESOURCES ARE DOING A TERRIFIC 2600 01:48:06,712 --> 01:48:08,647 JOB PROVIDING A VALUED SERVICE 2601 01:48:08,647 --> 01:48:10,149 TO THE COMMUNITY THAT IS WELL 2602 01:48:10,149 --> 01:48:15,220 WORTHY OF THE SUPPORT THAT NIGMS 2603 01:48:15,220 --> 01:48:16,855 PROVIDES AND PERHAPS MORE WHEN 2604 01:48:16,855 --> 01:48:17,222 THAT'S POSSIBLE. 2605 01:48:17,222 --> 01:48:19,791 SO THANK YOU AND I THINK DAVE 2606 01:48:19,791 --> 01:48:22,394 AND I WILL BE HAPPY TO TRY TO 2607 01:48:22,394 --> 01:48:23,929 ADDRESS QUESTIONS. 2608 01:48:23,929 --> 01:48:24,296 NEXCELLENT. 2609 01:48:24,296 --> 01:48:25,731 THANK YOU FOR THAT GREAT 2610 01:48:25,731 --> 01:48:26,198 PRESENTATION. 2611 01:48:26,198 --> 01:48:27,799 THANKS TO THE ENTIRE WORKING 2612 01:48:27,799 --> 01:48:31,436 GROUP FOR ALL THE HARD WORK THEY 2613 01:48:31,436 --> 01:48:34,373 DID ON THIS. 2614 01:48:34,373 --> 01:48:35,774 VERY HELPFUL AND ILLUMINATING. 2615 01:48:35,774 --> 01:48:43,448 QUESTIONS FROM THE COMMITTEE? 2616 01:48:43,448 --> 01:48:45,484 ERIC IN. 2617 01:48:45,484 --> 01:48:48,487 >> SO I'M CURIOUS HAVE 2618 01:48:48,487 --> 01:48:49,121 ESSENTIALLY GEOGRAPHIC ISSUES, 2619 01:48:49,121 --> 01:48:50,789 -- IT LOOKS LIKE A LOT OF 2620 01:48:50,789 --> 01:48:52,057 CENTERS ARE FOCUSED IN SMALL 2621 01:48:52,057 --> 01:48:54,960 AREAS ACROSS THE COUNTRY SOIME 2622 01:48:54,960 --> 01:48:57,029 CURE QUOWS, ESSENTIALLY 2623 01:48:57,029 --> 01:48:57,996 GEOGRAPHIC ISSUES BEEN RESOLVED 2624 01:48:57,996 --> 01:49:00,632 BY A LOT OF REMOTE ACCESS AND 2625 01:49:00,632 --> 01:49:03,769 SAMPLES BEING SENT REMOTELY AND 2626 01:49:03,769 --> 01:49:05,504 I'M ALSO WONDERING CURIOUSLY HOW 2627 01:49:05,504 --> 01:49:08,507 MUCH HAVE THESE MATURE SOURCES 2628 01:49:08,507 --> 01:49:10,075 TRANSITIONED TO UNIQUE 2629 01:49:10,075 --> 01:49:11,243 METHODOLOGIES THAT CAN'T BE SEEN 2630 01:49:11,243 --> 01:49:13,478 BY OTHER METHODS SUCH AS CRYOEM, 2631 01:49:13,478 --> 01:49:16,615 SO FOR EXAMPLE, LOOKING AT 2632 01:49:16,615 --> 01:49:18,317 DYNAMIC STRUCTURES OVER TIME IN 2633 01:49:18,317 --> 01:49:25,324 ULTRA FAST SORT OF MEASUREMENT. 2634 01:49:25,324 --> 01:49:27,526 >> SO MAYBE I CAN TAKE A STAB AT 2635 01:49:27,526 --> 01:49:27,726 THAT. 2636 01:49:27,726 --> 01:49:30,329 SO WE DO THINK THAT THE REMOTE 2637 01:49:30,329 --> 01:49:31,263 DATA ACQUISITION HAS HELPED 2638 01:49:31,263 --> 01:49:41,807 QUITE A BIT WITH THE GEOGRAPHIC 2639 01:49:51,850 --> 01:49:53,185 KIND OF LOCALIZATION -- LOCATED 2640 01:49:53,185 --> 01:49:57,256 IN 1 PLACE AND USERS HAVE TO 2641 01:49:57,256 --> 01:49:57,856 TRAVEL THERE. 2642 01:49:57,856 --> 01:50:02,961 IN TERMS OF PROVIDING UNIQUE 2643 01:50:02,961 --> 01:50:07,532 SERVICES, I THINK CLEARLY THE 2644 01:50:07,532 --> 01:50:10,235 BEAM LINES FOR SMALL ANGLE X-RAY 2645 01:50:10,235 --> 01:50:12,404 SCATTERING AND FOR SOLVING 2646 01:50:12,404 --> 01:50:14,840 STRUCTURES BY X-RAY 2647 01:50:14,840 --> 01:50:16,541 CRYSTALLOGRAPHY ARE ESSENTIAL 2648 01:50:16,541 --> 01:50:22,247 FOR THE COMMUNITY AND SO, YOU 2649 01:50:22,247 --> 01:50:27,052 KNOW JUST PROVIDING THE HIGH 2650 01:50:27,052 --> 01:50:29,388 BRIGHT RESOURCES FOR EXTRA 2651 01:50:29,388 --> 01:50:38,530 CRYSTALLOGRAPHY IS CERTAINLY 2652 01:50:38,530 --> 01:50:39,097 UNIQUE. 2653 01:50:39,097 --> 01:50:41,800 >> THANKS, SUDA? 2654 01:50:41,800 --> 01:50:43,468 >> SORRY, THANKS, JON, MY RAISE 2655 01:50:43,468 --> 01:50:44,636 HAND WASN'T WORKING IN THE 2656 01:50:44,636 --> 01:50:47,572 PREVIOUS SESSION, SO THANK YOU. 2657 01:50:47,572 --> 01:50:49,641 THIS IS REALLY VERY USEFUL 2658 01:50:49,641 --> 01:50:51,176 INFORMATION, SO I WAS WONDERING, 2659 01:50:51,176 --> 01:50:54,279 I WANT TO PONENT OUT THAT 2660 01:50:54,279 --> 01:50:55,847 STANDARDIZING THE PROCEDURES AND 2661 01:50:55,847 --> 01:50:56,982 SHARING COMPETENCIES IS AN 2662 01:50:56,982 --> 01:50:57,716 EXCELLENT IDEA. 2663 01:50:57,716 --> 01:51:01,453 NICELY TAKEN FROM THE CRYOEM 2664 01:51:01,453 --> 01:51:02,888 NATIONAL CENTERS THAT HAS REALLY 2665 01:51:02,888 --> 01:51:04,656 HELPED SO I WAS WONDERING IN 2666 01:51:04,656 --> 01:51:07,392 TERPS OF THE MSR COLLABORATIONS 2667 01:51:07,392 --> 01:51:10,162 PER SE, LIKE, DO THEY FOR 2668 01:51:10,162 --> 01:51:11,963 EXAMPLE, ISSUES THAT THEY 2669 01:51:11,963 --> 01:51:13,965 ENCOUNTER WITH CERTAIN PROJECTS 2670 01:51:13,965 --> 01:51:16,768 OR CERTAIN TECHNOLOGIES, HOW DO 2671 01:51:16,768 --> 01:51:19,805 THEY SHARE INFORMATION ACROSS 2672 01:51:19,805 --> 01:51:28,046 THE DIFFERENT MSR CENTERS? 2673 01:51:28,046 --> 01:51:30,582 >> DO YOU WANT ME TO TAKE A STAB 2674 01:51:30,582 --> 01:51:31,483 AT THIS DAVE? 2675 01:51:31,483 --> 01:51:33,352 >> THAT WOULD BE GREAT, THANKS. 2676 01:51:33,352 --> 01:51:38,256 >> I THINK AT THE MOMENT IT'S 2677 01:51:38,256 --> 01:51:40,625 PRETTY INFORMAL AND I WOULD SAY 2678 01:51:40,625 --> 01:51:41,693 FRANKLY HIT AND MISS AS TO 2679 01:51:41,693 --> 01:51:46,832 WHETHER IT'S GOING TO HAPPEN. 2680 01:51:46,832 --> 01:51:49,735 AND I THINK THE EXPERIENCE FROM 2681 01:51:49,735 --> 01:51:52,404 THE CRYOEM CENTERS IS THAT WHEN 2682 01:51:52,404 --> 01:51:54,806 IT WAS A REQUIREMENT, THAT'S 2683 01:51:54,806 --> 01:52:01,546 WHAT REALLY GOT PEOPLE TALKING 2684 01:52:01,546 --> 01:52:02,581 TOGETHER AND THEN, YOU KNOW I 2685 01:52:02,581 --> 01:52:05,150 THINK IT WAS A SOCIAL 2686 01:52:05,150 --> 01:52:09,221 EXPERIMENT, RIGHT? 2687 01:52:09,221 --> 01:52:11,556 AND PEOPLE -- THE PERSONNEL AT 2688 01:52:11,556 --> 01:52:12,958 THE DIFFERENT SITES REALLY 2689 01:52:12,958 --> 01:52:14,059 STARTED WORKING WELL TOGETHER 2690 01:52:14,059 --> 01:52:16,161 WITH 1 ANOTHER AND OVERCOMING, 2691 01:52:16,161 --> 01:52:17,596 YOU KNOW THE SMALL BARRIERS THAT 2692 01:52:17,596 --> 01:52:24,569 THERE ARE TO THIS. 2693 01:52:24,569 --> 01:52:25,303 >> GREAT. 2694 01:52:25,303 --> 01:52:25,470 ANN? 2695 01:52:25,470 --> 01:52:26,938 >> HI, FIRST I JUST WANT TO SAY 2696 01:52:26,938 --> 01:52:31,743 THANK YOU TO BOTH MICHAEL AND 2697 01:52:31,743 --> 01:52:33,745 DAVID AND THE WORKING GROUP FOR 2698 01:52:33,745 --> 01:52:34,279 THEIR EXCELLENT REPORT. 2699 01:52:34,279 --> 01:52:37,282 I THINK THAT WAS REALLY 2700 01:52:37,282 --> 01:52:40,218 COMPREHENSIVE AND REFLECTIVE OF 2701 01:52:40,218 --> 01:52:40,852 THE STRUCTURAL BIOLOGY 2702 01:52:40,852 --> 01:52:41,119 COMMUNITY. 2703 01:52:41,119 --> 01:52:42,788 SO I HAVE A COMMENT AND A COUPLE 2704 01:52:42,788 --> 01:52:43,221 OF COMMENTS. 2705 01:52:43,221 --> 01:52:44,823 ONE IS THAT I'VE SEEN THIS SORT 2706 01:52:44,823 --> 01:52:48,026 OF COME FULL CIRCLE, YOU KNOW 2707 01:52:48,026 --> 01:52:49,561 THE EVOLUTION OF SYNCHROTRONS TO 2708 01:52:49,561 --> 01:52:52,497 A POINT WHERE NOW THEY'RE 2709 01:52:52,497 --> 01:52:54,733 CONSIDERED MATURE RESOURCES AND 2710 01:52:54,733 --> 01:52:56,601 THEN THE CRYOEM CENTERS THAT 2711 01:52:56,601 --> 01:52:58,003 HAVE CAP PALLIZED ON THAT LEVEL 2712 01:52:58,003 --> 01:52:59,838 OF MATURITY BECAUSE IESM 2713 01:52:59,838 --> 01:53:03,575 FAMILIAR WITH BOTH THE STANFORD 2714 01:53:03,575 --> 01:53:04,876 SLACK CRYO EM CENTER WHICH BASIC 2715 01:53:04,876 --> 01:53:09,714 LE ADOPTED A LOT OF THE 2716 01:53:09,714 --> 01:53:10,982 SSRL PROCEDURES AND PROCESSES, 2717 01:53:10,982 --> 01:53:14,419 AND THEN THE NCCAT WHICH HAS 2718 01:53:14,419 --> 01:53:17,856 WORKED WELL WITH THE NORTHEAST 2719 01:53:17,856 --> 01:53:19,157 CONSORTIUM ON STRUCTURAL BIOLOGY 2720 01:53:19,157 --> 01:53:21,793 AND I AGREE THAT THE CRYO EM 2721 01:53:21,793 --> 01:53:23,462 CENTERS HAVE DONE A TREMENDOUSLY 2722 01:53:23,462 --> 01:53:25,063 GOOD JOB IN EDUCATING THE 2723 01:53:25,063 --> 01:53:27,933 COMMUNITY AND A LOT ABOUT IT ARE 2724 01:53:27,933 --> 01:53:30,202 ONLINE RESOURCES IN ADDITION TO 2725 01:53:30,202 --> 01:53:34,272 OFFERING THE ONSET TRAINING 2726 01:53:34,272 --> 01:53:36,675 ESPECIALLY TO THE CORE FACILITY 2727 01:53:36,675 --> 01:53:37,943 DIRECTORS AND STUDENTS AND POST 2728 01:53:37,943 --> 01:53:39,778 DOCS SO IT'S INTERESTING YOU SEE 2729 01:53:39,778 --> 01:53:42,314 THIS COME FULL CIRCLE AND NOW 2730 01:53:42,314 --> 01:53:44,015 THE RECOMMENDATION FROM THE 2731 01:53:44,015 --> 01:53:45,851 SYNCHROTRON SIDE BEING ABLE TO 2732 01:53:45,851 --> 01:53:48,286 OFFER MORE TRAINING WHICH IS 2733 01:53:48,286 --> 01:53:49,387 KIND OF INTERESTING. 2734 01:53:49,387 --> 01:53:51,323 AND CERTAINLY THE REMOTE ACCESS 2735 01:53:51,323 --> 01:53:54,159 BEING ABLE TO SHIP SAMPLES, 2736 01:53:54,159 --> 01:53:56,027 REALLY MEANS THAT THE GEOGRAPHIC 2737 01:53:56,027 --> 01:53:58,497 LOCATIONS OF THESE RESOURCES ARE 2738 01:53:58,497 --> 01:54:02,868 PROBABLY NOT AN ISSUE AT ALL. 2739 01:54:02,868 --> 01:54:04,436 I THINK WHAT I'VE SEEN AT LEAST 2740 01:54:04,436 --> 01:54:06,538 FROM WORKING WITH A NUMBER OF 2741 01:54:06,538 --> 01:54:08,373 STRUCTURAL BIOLOGISTS IS THE 2742 01:54:08,373 --> 01:54:11,710 CHALLENGE IN RESOURCES ARE THE 2743 01:54:11,710 --> 01:54:13,278 DATA TRANSFER, RIGHT? 2744 01:54:13,278 --> 01:54:15,413 SO MOVING, YOU KNOW, HIGH 2745 01:54:15,413 --> 01:54:17,048 THROUGH PUT DATA FROM THESE 2746 01:54:17,048 --> 01:54:19,684 CENTERS TO THEIR HOME LOCATION, 2747 01:54:19,684 --> 01:54:21,152 HAVING TO PURCHASE SORT OF 2748 01:54:21,152 --> 01:54:25,357 HIGHER END, MUCH HIGHER END 2749 01:54:25,357 --> 01:54:26,758 DESKTOP COMPUTERS AND THEN 2750 01:54:26,758 --> 01:54:27,926 FINDING LOCAL RESOURCES FOR 2751 01:54:27,926 --> 01:54:31,563 STORING LARGE DATA SETS 2752 01:54:31,563 --> 01:54:32,497 ACCUMULATED OVER MANY YEARS AND 2753 01:54:32,497 --> 01:54:35,467 SO I THINK THAT'S WHERE WE 2754 01:54:35,467 --> 01:54:39,204 CURRENTLY FACE SOME CHALLENGES. 2755 01:54:39,204 --> 01:54:40,639 WITHOUT THE COBRE SUPPORT 2756 01:54:40,639 --> 01:54:41,439 CERTAINLY OUR STRUCTURAL BIOLOGY 2757 01:54:41,439 --> 01:54:42,440 CENTER WOULD NOT HAVE BEEN ABLE 2758 01:54:42,440 --> 01:54:45,243 TO BUILD THAT LEVEL OF 2759 01:54:45,243 --> 01:54:45,610 INFRASTRUCTURE. 2760 01:54:45,610 --> 01:54:47,479 I THINK WE'RE -- WE'RE GETTING 2761 01:54:47,479 --> 01:54:49,548 THERE, BUT IT'S -- YOU KNOW I 2762 01:54:49,548 --> 01:54:51,049 CAN'T IMAGINE A SINGLE 2763 01:54:51,049 --> 01:54:51,850 INVESTIGATOR LAB TRYING TO 2764 01:54:51,850 --> 01:54:54,286 FIGURE OUT HOW TO PROVIDE THEIR 2765 01:54:54,286 --> 01:55:03,228 OWN RESOURCES TO GET UP TO 2766 01:55:03,228 --> 01:55:05,163 SPEED. 2767 01:55:05,163 --> 01:55:06,464 >> GREAT, THANK YOU. 2768 01:55:06,464 --> 01:55:07,132 P A ULO? 2769 01:55:07,132 --> 01:55:11,636 >> YEAH, THAT IS CLEAR TO THE 2770 01:55:11,636 --> 01:55:12,871 WORKING GROUP, THAT ESPECIALLY 2771 01:55:12,871 --> 01:55:14,139 AT INSTITUTIONS WITH FEWER 2772 01:55:14,139 --> 01:55:16,641 RESOURCES THAT THE COMPUTING AND 2773 01:55:16,641 --> 01:55:18,209 STORAGE REQUIREMENTS CAN BE 2774 01:55:18,209 --> 01:55:20,211 ONEROUS, SO THAT WAS 1 OF THE 2775 01:55:20,211 --> 01:55:22,047 RECOMMENDATIONS THAT MICHAEL 2776 01:55:22,047 --> 01:55:25,116 PRESENTED WAS IN THE FUTURE, 2777 01:55:25,116 --> 01:55:26,651 MAYBE NIGMS COULD SUPPORT HAVING 2778 01:55:26,651 --> 01:55:27,919 SOME OF THAT COMPUTE POWER 2779 01:55:27,919 --> 01:55:32,991 AVAILABLE AT THE RESOURCES THAT 2780 01:55:32,991 --> 01:55:33,858 TARGETED FOR INSTITUTIONS THAT 2781 01:55:33,858 --> 01:55:38,496 DON'T ARE THOSE RESOURCES 2782 01:55:38,496 --> 01:55:39,130 AVAILABLE TO THEM. 2783 01:55:39,130 --> 01:55:41,933 NDO YOU THINK CLOUD IS A VIABLE 2784 01:55:41,933 --> 01:55:43,034 OPTION FOR THAT? 2785 01:55:43,034 --> 01:55:44,736 >> I DON'T THINK THAT SOLVES 2786 01:55:44,736 --> 01:55:48,173 EVERY PROBLEM BECAUSE OF THE 2787 01:55:48,173 --> 01:55:49,341 COST ASSOCIATED WITH USING THE 2788 01:55:49,341 --> 01:55:53,278 CLOUD, SO I THINK JUST SAYING 2789 01:55:53,278 --> 01:55:54,813 USING THE CLOUD HAS THE COST TO 2790 01:55:54,813 --> 01:55:55,413 INDIVIDUAL INVESTIGATORS THAT 2791 01:55:55,413 --> 01:55:58,316 MIGHT BE TOO MUCH. 2792 01:55:58,316 --> 01:56:00,785 >> I CAN COMMENT A LITTLE BIT 2793 01:56:00,785 --> 01:56:01,419 MORE ON THAT. 2794 01:56:01,419 --> 01:56:04,723 I DON'T KNOW WHETHER THE DATA 2795 01:56:04,723 --> 01:56:08,326 QUANTITIES WILL BE COMPATIBLE, 2796 01:56:08,326 --> 01:56:10,762 BUT A TYPICAL BM DATA SET, RAW 2797 01:56:10,762 --> 01:56:13,198 DATA SET IS OF THE ORDER OF 5 2798 01:56:13,198 --> 01:56:15,333 TERRA BYTES AT THIS POINT, SO 2799 01:56:15,333 --> 01:56:16,735 THAT'S A SIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF 2800 01:56:16,735 --> 01:56:18,303 DATA. 2801 01:56:18,303 --> 01:56:20,238 I SUSPECT THAT THE SYNCHROTRON 2802 01:56:20,238 --> 01:56:21,906 BEAM LINES CAN QUICKLY PROCESS 2803 01:56:21,906 --> 01:56:23,208 DOWN TO SMALLER DATA SETS AND SO 2804 01:56:23,208 --> 01:56:26,978 IT'S NOT QUITE AS SEVERE BUT 2805 01:56:26,978 --> 01:56:28,913 THERE'S BEEN A GROUP AT THE 2806 01:56:28,913 --> 01:56:30,949 UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN THAT HAVE 2807 01:56:30,949 --> 01:56:36,154 LOOKED AT THE USE OF CLOUD FOR 2808 01:56:36,154 --> 01:56:40,558 EM DATA PROCESSING AND IT REALLY 2809 01:56:40,558 --> 01:56:41,493 ISN'T ECONOMIC. 2810 01:56:41,493 --> 01:56:43,795 AND SO, YOU KNOW, IT MIGHT BE A 2811 01:56:43,795 --> 01:56:45,897 DIFFERENT QUESTION FOR THE 2812 01:56:45,897 --> 01:56:46,965 SYNCHROTRON BEAM LINES BUT 1 2813 01:56:46,965 --> 01:56:47,999 WOULD CERTAINLY WANT TO LOOK AT 2814 01:56:47,999 --> 01:56:49,534 IT AND NOT JUST ASSUME THAT IT'S 2815 01:56:49,534 --> 01:56:51,403 GOING TO BE AN EFFICIENT AND 2816 01:56:51,403 --> 01:57:01,846 ECONOMIC WAY OF DOING IT. 2817 01:57:02,113 --> 01:57:02,414 >> GREAT. 2818 01:57:02,414 --> 01:57:03,048 THANK YOU. 2819 01:57:03,048 --> 01:57:03,848 P A ULO? 2820 01:57:03,848 --> 01:57:07,185 NTHANK YOU FOR THE COMPREHENSIVE 2821 01:57:07,185 --> 01:57:09,688 OVERVIEW AND EXPLANATION, I WAS 2822 01:57:09,688 --> 01:57:14,259 WONDERING REFERRING TO THE 2823 01:57:14,259 --> 01:57:18,229 REPORT ON THE POSITION OF 2824 01:57:18,229 --> 01:57:21,299 DIFFERENT RESULTS AND LATER ON 2825 01:57:21,299 --> 01:57:22,534 THE PROTEIN DATA SEEM TO BE AN 2826 01:57:22,534 --> 01:57:24,269 INCREASE OF THAT, I THINK IT'S A 2827 01:57:24,269 --> 01:57:26,237 GREAT RESOURCE SO I WAS JUST 2828 01:57:26,237 --> 01:57:27,939 WONDERING IF THERE'S ANY METRIC 2829 01:57:27,939 --> 01:57:37,182 OF THE IMPACT OF THAT, TO HAVE 2830 01:57:37,182 --> 01:57:42,687 THIS OPEN RESOURCE HAVE IMPACT 2831 01:57:42,687 --> 01:57:44,089 THE RESEARCH COMMUNITY AS A 2832 01:57:44,089 --> 01:57:47,058 WHOLE, SO I JUST WONDER IF 2833 01:57:47,058 --> 01:57:48,126 THERE'S ANY MAGIC THAT THE 2834 01:57:48,126 --> 01:57:53,398 WORKING GROUP HAS CONSIDERED 2835 01:57:53,398 --> 01:57:55,433 REGARDING THAT. 2836 01:57:55,433 --> 01:57:57,635 >> SO I THINK THAT'S A GREAT 2837 01:57:57,635 --> 01:57:58,570 QUESTION, SO MAYBE 1 WAY WE 2838 01:57:58,570 --> 01:58:00,438 MIGHT HAVE TRIED TO ASSESS THAT 2839 01:58:00,438 --> 01:58:03,842 IS, YOU KNOW WHAT ARE THE 2840 01:58:03,842 --> 01:58:06,211 CITATIONS OF PAPERS THAT WERE 2841 01:58:06,211 --> 01:58:09,180 SUPPORTED BY THE P30 PROGRAM NOT 2842 01:58:09,180 --> 01:58:11,816 SURE THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN EASY 2843 01:58:11,816 --> 01:58:15,520 TO DO BUT, WE KIND OF CAME FROM 2844 01:58:15,520 --> 01:58:17,155 THE PERSPECTIVE OF THE 2845 01:58:17,155 --> 01:58:20,291 ASSUMPTION THAT STRUCTURAL 2846 01:58:20,291 --> 01:58:21,993 BIOLOGY IS FOUNDATIONAL ACROSS 2847 01:58:21,993 --> 01:58:23,928 THE BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH 2848 01:58:23,928 --> 01:58:25,396 ENTERPRISE IN GENERAL SO WE -- 2849 01:58:25,396 --> 01:58:35,774 WE DID NOT CHECK THAT. 2850 01:58:36,875 --> 01:58:42,514 >> OTHER QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? 2851 01:58:42,514 --> 01:58:43,548 ALL RIGHT, GREAT DISCUSSION 2852 01:58:43,548 --> 01:58:43,748 AGAIN. 2853 01:58:43,748 --> 01:58:44,849 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE HARD 2854 01:58:44,849 --> 01:58:47,218 WORK OF THIS COMMITTEE AND FOR 2855 01:58:47,218 --> 01:58:48,920 YOUR LEADERSHIP, DAVE AND 2856 01:58:48,920 --> 01:58:49,154 MICHAEL. 2857 01:58:49,154 --> 01:58:51,489 WE NEED TO FORMALLY HAVE COUNCIL 2858 01:58:51,489 --> 01:58:52,390 ACCEPT THIS REPORT. 2859 01:58:52,390 --> 01:58:54,425 SO ERICA, I WILL TURN IT OVER TO 2860 01:58:54,425 --> 01:58:56,494 YOU. 2861 01:58:56,494 --> 01:58:57,128 NTHANK 2862 01:58:57,128 --> 01:58:57,462 N-- 2863 01:58:57,462 --> 01:58:57,829 >> THANK YOU. 2864 01:58:57,829 --> 01:59:00,532 I MOVE THAT THE COUNCIL ACCEPT 2865 01:59:00,532 --> 01:59:02,267 THIS REPORT FROM THE WORKING 2866 01:59:02,267 --> 01:59:04,803 GROUP. 2867 01:59:04,803 --> 01:59:06,571 ARE ANY OPPOSED? 2868 01:59:06,571 --> 01:59:07,772 UNANIMOUSLY CONFIRMED. 2869 01:59:07,772 --> 01:59:09,140 THANK YOU, JON. 2870 01:59:09,140 --> 01:59:11,743 >> OKAY, THAT CONCLUDES THE OPEN 2871 01:59:11,743 --> 01:59:14,312 SESSION BUSINESS. 2872 01:59:14,312 --> 01:59:15,947 WE CERTAINLY ARE, ALWAYS EAGER 2873 01:59:15,947 --> 01:59:17,348 TO HEAR THINGS THAT YOU WOULD 2874 01:59:17,348 --> 01:59:19,884 LIKE TO DISCUSS AT FUTURE 2875 01:59:19,884 --> 01:59:21,986 MEETINGS, SO IF YOU HAVE ANY 2876 01:59:21,986 --> 01:59:23,087 TOPICS, YOU KNOW YOU WOULD LIKE 2877 01:59:23,087 --> 01:59:26,124 TO PUT ON THE POTENTIAL AGENDA, 2878 01:59:26,124 --> 01:59:27,458 YOU CAN EITHER TELL US NOW OR 2879 01:59:27,458 --> 01:59:33,364 SEND US AN E-MAIL AT ANY POINT. 2880 01:59:33,364 --> 01:59:36,401 ALWAYS HAPPY TO DISCUSS THINGS 2881 01:59:36,401 --> 01:59:37,902 THAT THE COUNCIL WOULD FIND 2882 01:59:37,902 --> 01:59:38,336 INTERESTING. 2883 01:59:38,336 --> 01:59:39,971 ALL RIGHT, WELL, WITH THAT WE 2884 01:59:39,971 --> 01:59:45,009 WILL CONCLUDE THE OPEN SESSION. 2885 01:59:45,009 --> 01:59:46,077 THE CLOSED SESSION PLEASE 2886 01:59:46,077 --> 01:59:49,280 CONSULT THE E-MAIL THAT HAVE YOU 2887 01:59:49,280 --> 01:59:51,115 GOTTEN REGARDING THE LYNCH, IT'S 2888 01:59:51,115 --> 01:59:52,317 NOT THE SAME LINK AS THIS AND 2889 01:59:52,317 --> 01:59:54,719 THE TIMING OF THAT SESSION, SO 2890 01:59:54,719 --> 01:59:57,121 MAKE SURE YOU KNOW THE TIME FOR 2891 01:59:57,121 --> 01:59:58,256 THE SESSION YOU'RE ATTENDING. 2892 01:59:58,256 --> 02:00:02,026 BUT WE WILL SEE YOU AT THOSE AND 2893 02:00:02,026 --> 02:00:03,661 AGAIN, THANK YOU EVERYONE FOR 2894 02:00:03,661 --> 02:00:04,729 YOUR PARTICIPATION AND IT WAS 2895 02:00:04,729 --> 02:00:09,300 GOOD TOEE -- SEE YOU HERE. 2896 02:00:09,300 --> 02:00:11,436 THANKS EVERYONE, SEE YOU AT THE 2897 02:00:11,436 --> 02:00:12,737 CLOSED SESSIONS. 2898 02:00:12,737 --> 02:00:23,047 >> THANKS MUCH.