1 00:00:05,736 --> 00:00:08,306 ALL RIGHT, AND GOOD MORNING 2 00:00:08,306 --> 00:00:10,508 EVERYONE EMPLOY I'M DEBORAH, 3 00:00:10,508 --> 00:00:12,643 DIRECTOR OF DIRECTOR OF THE 4 00:00:12,643 --> 00:00:13,611 NATIONAL EN--STRATEGIESITUTE OF 5 00:00:13,611 --> 00:00:15,179 DEAF AND OTHER DISORDERS. 6 00:00:15,179 --> 00:00:16,380 THANK YOU TO ALL OF YOU IN THE 7 00:00:16,380 --> 00:00:18,049 ROOM AND WELCOME TO ALL WHO ARE 8 00:00:18,049 --> 00:00:19,450 JOINING US BY VIDEOCAST. 9 00:00:19,450 --> 00:00:21,986 FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE VIEWING 10 00:00:21,986 --> 00:00:23,621 ON NIH VIEDMAN KRE TINS CAST, 11 00:00:23,621 --> 00:00:25,323 PLOAZ BE ADVISED THAT TO TURN ON 12 00:00:25,323 --> 00:00:27,258 THE CAPTIONS, IF YOU WANT TO DO 13 00:00:27,258 --> 00:00:30,127 SO, FOR TODAY'S PRESENTATION YOU 14 00:00:30,127 --> 00:00:31,696 CAN CLICK THE CC BUTTON AT THE 15 00:00:31,696 --> 00:00:34,699 BOTTOM OF THE SCREEN. 16 00:00:34,699 --> 00:00:36,567 SO I'M PLEASED TO WELCOME 17 00:00:36,567 --> 00:00:40,238 EVERYONE JOINING US TODAY FOR 18 00:00:40,238 --> 00:00:41,472 THE NIDCD'S DIRECTOR'S SEMINAR 19 00:00:41,472 --> 00:00:43,307 SERIES, ADVANCING THE SCIENCE OF 20 00:00:43,307 --> 00:00:45,776 COMMUNICATION TO IMPROVE LIVES 21 00:00:45,776 --> 00:00:47,845 EMPLOY THIS ANNUAL SEMINAR 22 00:00:47,845 --> 00:00:49,847 SERIES IS DESIGNED TO ALIGN WITH 23 00:00:49,847 --> 00:01:00,391 THE THEMES AND PRIORITIES OF THE 24 00:01:02,126 --> 00:01:03,628 NIH 2023--2027 STRATEGIC PLAN, 25 00:01:03,628 --> 00:01:07,164 THE GOAL IS TO BALANCE, VOICE, 26 00:01:07,164 --> 00:01:08,099 SPEECH, TASTE, SMELL AND 27 00:01:08,099 --> 00:01:08,566 LANGUAGE. 28 00:01:08,566 --> 00:01:15,106 TODAY I AM DELIGHTED TO ANNOUNCE 29 00:01:15,106 --> 00:01:18,376 DR. ADAM RESNICK, HE WITH THE 30 00:01:18,376 --> 00:01:19,677 CATADRIVEN DORPHY IN BIOMEDICINE 31 00:01:19,677 --> 00:01:22,346 AT THE CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL AT 32 00:01:22,346 --> 00:01:22,680 PHILADELPHIA. 33 00:01:22,680 --> 00:01:24,348 DR. RESNICK IS RESPONSIBLE FOR 34 00:01:24,348 --> 00:01:25,950 LEADING A MULTIDISCIPLINARY TEAM 35 00:01:25,950 --> 00:01:30,187 TO BUILD AND SUPPORT A SCALABLE 36 00:01:30,187 --> 00:01:33,024 PATIENT-FOCUSED HEALTHCARE AND 37 00:01:33,024 --> 00:01:35,092 EDUCATIONAL ECOSYSTEM TO 38 00:01:35,092 --> 00:01:36,260 ACCELERATE DISCOVERY AND 39 00:01:36,260 --> 00:01:38,296 CLINICAL TRANSLATION FOR ALL 40 00:01:38,296 --> 00:01:38,796 CHILDREN. 41 00:01:38,796 --> 00:01:40,965 HE ALSO LEADS THE ONGOING 42 00:01:40,965 --> 00:01:42,233 DEVELOPMENT OF PLATFORMS 43 00:01:42,233 --> 00:01:45,303 SUPPORTING LARGE SCALE DATA 44 00:01:45,303 --> 00:01:46,003 SHARING AND COLLABORATIVE 45 00:01:46,003 --> 00:01:49,240 DISCOVERY IN THE AREAS OF 46 00:01:49,240 --> 00:01:50,808 PEDIATRIC CANCERS, STRUCTURAL 47 00:01:50,808 --> 00:01:52,777 BIRTH DEFECTS AND DOWNS 48 00:01:52,777 --> 00:01:53,044 SYNDROME. 49 00:01:53,044 --> 00:01:55,279 AND THESE INCLUDE THE GABRIELA 50 00:01:55,279 --> 00:01:57,081 MILLER, KIDS FIRST, DATA 51 00:01:57,081 --> 00:01:58,282 RESEARCH CENTER, WHICH IS 52 00:01:58,282 --> 00:02:02,253 SUPPORTED BY THE NIH COMMON 53 00:02:02,253 --> 00:02:04,121 FUND, AND THE ENCLUED PROJECTS 54 00:02:04,121 --> 00:02:07,458 DATA HUB AND INCLUDE STANDS FOR 55 00:02:07,458 --> 00:02:08,526 INVESTIGATION OF CO-OCCURRING 56 00:02:08,526 --> 00:02:11,762 CONDITIONS ACROSS THE LIFE SPAN 57 00:02:11,762 --> 00:02:12,797 TO UNDERSTAND DOWNS SYNDROME AND 58 00:02:12,797 --> 00:02:16,200 THIS IS A PROGRAM THAT NIDCD 59 00:02:16,200 --> 00:02:18,736 DOES PARTICIPATE IN. 60 00:02:18,736 --> 00:02:19,970 DR. RESNICK'S PRESENTATION WILL 61 00:02:19,970 --> 00:02:20,538 ADDRESS FUNDAMENTAL ISSUES 62 00:02:20,538 --> 00:02:22,940 RELATED TO HOW DATA ARE USED AND 63 00:02:22,940 --> 00:02:25,309 ACCESSED IN BOTH BASIC AND 64 00:02:25,309 --> 00:02:28,012 CLINICAL RESEARCH AND IN 65 00:02:28,012 --> 00:02:30,014 DECISION SUPPORT AND PRECISION 66 00:02:30,014 --> 00:02:30,314 BASED CARE. 67 00:02:30,314 --> 00:02:32,683 HE WILL REVIEW LESSONS LEARNED 68 00:02:32,683 --> 00:02:35,653 THROUGH NIH WIDE INITIATIVES, 69 00:02:35,653 --> 00:02:39,223 AND HE WILL DISCUSS UPCOMING 70 00:02:39,223 --> 00:02:40,324 ADVANCEMENTS IN MACHINE LEARNING 71 00:02:40,324 --> 00:02:41,726 AND ART FECIAL INTELLIGENCE TO 72 00:02:41,726 --> 00:02:44,662 SUPPORT AND IMPROVE PERSONALIZED 73 00:02:44,662 --> 00:02:46,797 CARE EMPLOY AFTER DR. RESNICK'S 74 00:02:46,797 --> 00:02:48,432 REMARKS, I HAVE INVITED 3 75 00:02:48,432 --> 00:02:51,202 NETWORK IH SCIENTISTS TO JOIN US 76 00:02:51,202 --> 00:02:52,703 FOR A PANEL DISCUSSION AND A 77 00:02:52,703 --> 00:02:54,772 FURTHER DISCUSSION OF THESE 78 00:02:54,772 --> 00:02:59,377 THEMES AND I WILL INTRODUCE OUR 79 00:02:59,377 --> 00:02:59,744 PANELISTS LATER. 80 00:02:59,744 --> 00:03:02,213 SO NOW I WILL TURN IT OVER TO 81 00:03:02,213 --> 00:03:03,714 DR. RESNICK FOR HIS REMARKS AND 82 00:03:03,714 --> 00:03:14,058 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR BEING WITH 83 00:03:14,058 --> 00:03:14,325 US TODAY. 84 00:03:14,325 --> 00:03:14,625 [ APPLAUSE ] 85 00:03:14,625 --> 00:03:17,094 >> YOU KNOW WHEN I GOT INVITED I 86 00:03:17,094 --> 00:03:18,062 WASENTIOUS SPECIALLY EXCITED 87 00:03:18,062 --> 00:03:21,198 AFTER READING THE STRATEGIC PLAN 88 00:03:21,198 --> 00:03:22,166 THAT WAS BRIEFLY DEVELOPED. 89 00:03:22,166 --> 00:03:23,868 AT THE SAME TIME I WAS MORE 90 00:03:23,868 --> 00:03:26,370 NERVOUS THAN USUAL TO COME IN 91 00:03:26,370 --> 00:03:29,807 PART BECAUSE WITH ANY 92 00:03:29,807 --> 00:03:30,875 ORGANIZATION, TAKES ANY 93 00:03:30,875 --> 00:03:33,611 DIRECTIVE ON INITTIAIVE ITS, 94 00:03:33,611 --> 00:03:35,579 IT'S VERY VULNERABLE AND 95 00:03:35,579 --> 00:03:37,314 OPPORTUNISTIC TIME SO I WANTED 96 00:03:37,314 --> 00:03:39,183 TO PROVIDE AS MUCH ENCOURAGEMENT 97 00:03:39,183 --> 00:03:41,919 AND SUPPORT FOR THOSE EFFORTS, 98 00:03:41,919 --> 00:03:43,220 YOU KNOW THROUGH THIS 99 00:03:43,220 --> 00:03:44,889 PRESENTATION AND SO, AS I 100 00:03:44,889 --> 00:03:47,291 MENTIONED, MY GOAL IS TO REALLY 101 00:03:47,291 --> 00:03:50,161 SHARE EXPERIENCES AND LESSONS 102 00:03:50,161 --> 00:03:51,295 LEARNED DEFINITELY NOT CONVEY 103 00:03:51,295 --> 00:03:52,730 THAT ALL PROBLEMS ARE SOLVED AND 104 00:03:52,730 --> 00:03:56,267 THAT SOMEHOW I HAVE THOSE 105 00:03:56,267 --> 00:03:56,901 SOLUTIONS FOR YOU. 106 00:03:56,901 --> 00:03:58,335 BUT YOU KNOW WE'VE BEEN DOING 107 00:03:58,335 --> 00:04:01,005 THIS FOR SOMETIME IN WAYS THAT I 108 00:04:01,005 --> 00:04:03,841 THINK I CAN PROVIDE SOME 109 00:04:03,841 --> 00:04:07,478 EXPERIENCES THROUGH BOTH OUR 110 00:04:07,478 --> 00:04:09,013 PEDIATRIC CONSORTIA BASED 111 00:04:09,013 --> 00:04:09,847 INITIATIVES THAT FOCUS DATA 112 00:04:09,847 --> 00:04:12,183 SHARING ASK COORDINATION AS WELL 113 00:04:12,183 --> 00:04:13,717 AS NIH-BASED EFFORTS IN WAYS 114 00:04:13,717 --> 00:04:18,456 THAT ARE NOW POSITIONED WITH A 115 00:04:18,456 --> 00:04:20,324 VERY UNIQUE CONTEXT AS NEW 116 00:04:20,324 --> 00:04:21,258 TECHNOLOGIES ARE EAMERICANNING 117 00:04:21,258 --> 00:04:24,562 AND HEALTHCARE SYSTEMS ARE 118 00:04:24,562 --> 00:04:26,230 ORIENTING TOWARDS DATA ORIENTED 119 00:04:26,230 --> 00:04:27,264 NETWORKS FOR PRECISION CARE. 120 00:04:27,264 --> 00:04:31,135 WHEN I CAME ACROSS THIS BOX IN 121 00:04:31,135 --> 00:04:33,204 THE STRATEGIC PLAN, I HAD A 122 00:04:33,204 --> 00:04:35,072 MOMENT WHERE MY HEART JUMPED FOR 123 00:04:35,072 --> 00:04:41,212 A SECOND AND THE REASON IT 124 00:04:41,212 --> 00:04:43,547 JUMPED IS BECAUSE THERE'S A 125 00:04:43,547 --> 00:04:46,183 METAFRAMEWORK FOR THE VISION FOR 126 00:04:46,183 --> 00:04:47,918 NIDCD AND I'LL SPEND AND INDULGE 127 00:04:47,918 --> 00:04:51,388 IN 5 MINUTES FOR THAT 128 00:04:51,388 --> 00:04:54,024 METAFRAMEWORK TO ALIGN HOPEFULLY 129 00:04:54,024 --> 00:04:55,226 A RE14 YOU WILL SEE THROUGH THE 130 00:04:55,226 --> 00:04:56,260 REST OF THE TALK. 131 00:04:56,260 --> 00:04:58,696 SO ADVANCING THE SCIENCE OF 132 00:04:58,696 --> 00:05:02,032 EDUCATION TO IMPROVE LIVES. 133 00:05:02,032 --> 00:05:02,967 --COMMUNICATION TO IMPROVE 134 00:05:02,967 --> 00:05:03,167 LIVES. 135 00:05:03,167 --> 00:05:04,201 WHENEVER I WORK ON 136 00:05:04,201 --> 00:05:04,969 COMMUNICATIONS, THE FIRST THING 137 00:05:04,969 --> 00:05:08,973 THAT COMES TO MY MIND AND THIS 138 00:05:08,973 --> 00:05:12,376 TRANSFORMATIVE PAPER FROM 1948 139 00:05:12,376 --> 00:05:14,311 FROM CLAUDE CHANEN, ESSENTIALLY 140 00:05:14,311 --> 00:05:17,081 INVENTED THE MODERN FRAMEWORK 141 00:05:17,081 --> 00:05:18,849 FOR INFORMATION THEORY AND 142 00:05:18,849 --> 00:05:19,884 ESSENTIALLY INVENTED WHAT WAS IS 143 00:05:19,884 --> 00:05:21,552 CALLED A BIT IN THE CONTEXT AND 144 00:05:21,552 --> 00:05:26,090 THE WAY THAT HE FRAMED 145 00:05:26,090 --> 00:05:29,994 INFORMATION THEORY IS IN THE 146 00:05:29,994 --> 00:05:33,297 CONTEXT OF COMMUNICATION, RIGHT? 147 00:05:33,297 --> 00:05:35,599 SO THE PAPER AND ANY SORT OF 148 00:05:35,599 --> 00:05:37,201 DATA [INDISCERNIBLE] WILL ALERT 149 00:05:37,201 --> 00:05:40,070 AND KNOW THIS TITLE BY HEART AND 150 00:05:40,070 --> 00:05:44,508 THAT MABLGHTMATICAL THEORY OF 151 00:05:44,508 --> 00:05:45,809 COMMUNICATION AND AND 152 00:05:45,809 --> 00:05:46,810 CONTEXTUALIZED 1 OF THE 153 00:05:46,810 --> 00:05:49,146 COMMUNICATION FROM BASIC HUMAN 154 00:05:49,146 --> 00:05:51,849 NEEDS FROM SMOKE SIGNALS TO 155 00:05:51,849 --> 00:05:53,717 PIGEONS TO TELEVISION, BUT THE 156 00:05:53,717 --> 00:05:54,985 AT TIME THE ENGINEERING OF 157 00:05:54,985 --> 00:05:56,287 ENGINEERING SYSTEMS IS ALWAYS 158 00:05:56,287 --> 00:06:01,592 TIED TO THE SPECIFIC AND BESPOKE 159 00:06:01,592 --> 00:06:04,428 FRAMEWORKS AND WHAT CLAUDE 160 00:06:04,428 --> 00:06:06,830 SHANNON DID WAS DEVELOP A 161 00:06:06,830 --> 00:06:09,099 EXTRACTION AND THEORY FOR 162 00:06:09,099 --> 00:06:11,168 COMMUNICATION INFORMATION 163 00:06:11,168 --> 00:06:12,469 THEORY. 164 00:06:12,469 --> 00:06:14,104 THAT INFORMATION IS OFTEN DRIVEN 165 00:06:14,104 --> 00:06:15,839 FROM THIS MANUSCRIPT IN THIS 166 00:06:15,839 --> 00:06:17,908 WAY, THAT ESSENTIALLY SIGNALS 167 00:06:17,908 --> 00:06:20,244 START AT A SOURCE, A MESSAGE IS 168 00:06:20,244 --> 00:06:23,814 CONVEYED, THAT SIGNAL HAS TO BE 169 00:06:23,814 --> 00:06:26,216 PROCESSED AND RECEIVED, AND THEN 170 00:06:26,216 --> 00:06:28,852 ENTERPRETINAL LOCATIONED BY 171 00:06:28,852 --> 00:06:30,054 DESTINATION. 172 00:06:30,054 --> 00:06:33,123 AND IT'S HUMANLY IMPOSSIBLE TO 173 00:06:33,123 --> 00:06:35,192 AVOID WHAT CLAUDE SHANNON CALLED 174 00:06:35,192 --> 00:06:35,793 NOISE, RIGHT? 175 00:06:35,793 --> 00:06:39,330 THAT THERE'S NO WAY TO GET TRUE 176 00:06:39,330 --> 00:06:40,898 FIDELITY WHEN THEIR MESSAGE IS 177 00:06:40,898 --> 00:06:42,232 SENT AND RECEIVED, WHETHER 178 00:06:42,232 --> 00:06:43,767 THAT'S OVER A PHONE LINE OR ME 179 00:06:43,767 --> 00:06:47,905 SPEAKING TO YOU IN FRONT. 180 00:06:47,905 --> 00:06:49,673 AND AS YOU BEGAN THINKING ABOUT 181 00:06:49,673 --> 00:06:52,443 THIS IS WHERE HE REALLY BEGAN 182 00:06:52,443 --> 00:06:53,711 DEFINING THE MATHEMATICAL 183 00:06:53,711 --> 00:06:57,414 FRAMEWORK FOR WHAT MOST OF US 184 00:06:57,414 --> 00:07:00,150 THINK OF TODAY OF BITS OF 185 00:07:00,150 --> 00:07:02,920 STORAGE UNITS RIGHT, LIKE HOW 186 00:07:02,920 --> 00:07:03,654 MANY MEGABITS OR ANYTHING ALONG 187 00:07:03,654 --> 00:07:04,822 THOSE NUMBERS THAT YOU THINK 188 00:07:04,822 --> 00:07:06,357 ABOUT FOR YOUR PHONE'S 189 00:07:06,357 --> 00:07:09,560 COMMUNICATION, SPEEDS OR STORAGE 190 00:07:09,560 --> 00:07:09,827 VARIABLES. 191 00:07:09,827 --> 00:07:12,529 BUT HE REALLY FUNDAMENTALLY 192 00:07:12,529 --> 00:07:14,732 DEFEIGNED 0 AND 1 AS THE ONLY 193 00:07:14,732 --> 00:07:19,803 WAY TO STORE AND COMMUNICATE 194 00:07:19,803 --> 00:07:20,771 DATA THROUGH TECHNOLOGY. 195 00:07:20,771 --> 00:07:23,107 AND IMPORTANTLY, HE WAS THE 196 00:07:23,107 --> 00:07:25,509 FIRST 1 THAT THEN TOOK THE NEXT 197 00:07:25,509 --> 00:07:29,446 STEP AND SAID YOU CAN ACTUALLY 198 00:07:29,446 --> 00:07:29,880 MEASURE INFORMATION. 199 00:07:29,880 --> 00:07:31,248 BITS ARE ACTUALLY UNITS OF 200 00:07:31,248 --> 00:07:31,482 MEASURE. 201 00:07:31,482 --> 00:07:32,650 PRIOR TO CLAUDE SHANNON THERE 202 00:07:32,650 --> 00:07:34,685 WAS NO UNIT OF MEASURE FOR HOW 203 00:07:34,685 --> 00:07:37,688 MUCH INFORMATION EXISTS IN ANY 204 00:07:37,688 --> 00:07:37,921 CONTEXT. 205 00:07:37,921 --> 00:07:39,957 AND HOPEFULLY CAN YOU SEE THAT 206 00:07:39,957 --> 00:07:42,359 THAT LAYS THE FOUNDATION FOR 207 00:07:42,359 --> 00:07:45,062 WHAT THEN EXPLODED INTO A 208 00:07:45,062 --> 00:07:46,130 COMMUNICATION FRAMEWORK, 209 00:07:46,130 --> 00:07:52,002 ADVANCEMENT OF COMPUTER 210 00:07:52,002 --> 00:07:53,470 TECHNOLOGIES AND WHAT INVARIABLY 211 00:07:53,470 --> 00:07:57,207 SEEPED INTO THE LANGUAGE OF 212 00:07:57,207 --> 00:07:57,741 BIOLOGY, RIGHT? 213 00:07:57,741 --> 00:08:00,711 SO IT'S NOT A CO INCIDENCE THAT 214 00:08:00,711 --> 00:08:03,380 WE TALK ABOUT A DNA CODE, THAT 215 00:08:03,380 --> 00:08:06,116 WE TALK ABOUT TRANSCRIPTION AND 216 00:08:06,116 --> 00:08:07,785 TRANSLATION AND DNA AND RNA, 217 00:08:07,785 --> 00:08:14,191 THAT THERE'S THIS NOTION OF 218 00:08:14,191 --> 00:08:15,926 MESSENGER RNA, AND EPIGENETICS 219 00:08:15,926 --> 00:08:20,998 WE TALK ABOUT READERS, WRITERS 220 00:08:20,998 --> 00:08:22,232 AND ERASERS, THAT'S CODE AS 221 00:08:22,232 --> 00:08:24,902 PROXIMAL TO CODE AND TECHNOLOGY 222 00:08:24,902 --> 00:08:26,503 BEGAN SEEPING EVERYWHERE AFTER 223 00:08:26,503 --> 00:08:30,074 CLAUDE SHANNON DEVELOPED HIS 224 00:08:30,074 --> 00:08:30,541 MATHEMATICAL FORMULA. 225 00:08:30,541 --> 00:08:34,144 AND PART OF MY HOPE TODAY IS TO 226 00:08:34,144 --> 00:08:35,879 REALLY FRAME THE ARC FROM CLAUDE 227 00:08:35,879 --> 00:08:37,648 SHANNON TO WHERE WE ARE TODAY IN 228 00:08:37,648 --> 00:08:40,551 A WAY THAT'S INCREDIBLY 229 00:08:40,551 --> 00:08:40,818 PRESCIENT. 230 00:08:40,818 --> 00:08:43,120 FOR THOSE THAT ARE GOING HOME 231 00:08:43,120 --> 00:08:44,254 AND READ HIS MANUSCRIPT, WHEN 232 00:08:44,254 --> 00:08:47,391 YOU WILL FIND IS THAT HALFWAY 233 00:08:47,391 --> 00:08:49,927 THROUGH HE STARTS THINKING ABOUT 234 00:08:49,927 --> 00:08:55,833 LANGUAGE AS A MODEL FOR 235 00:08:55,833 --> 00:08:57,000 MEASURING INFORMATIONAL CONTENT 236 00:08:57,000 --> 00:08:58,469 AND HOW LANGUAGE ITSELF 237 00:08:58,469 --> 00:08:59,303 STRUCTURES AND CONSTRAINS 238 00:08:59,303 --> 00:09:02,005 INFORMATION AND HE DOES THIS 239 00:09:02,005 --> 00:09:04,341 EXPERIMENT OF IF YOU--HOW MUCH 240 00:09:04,341 --> 00:09:06,376 INFORMATION IS ENCODED IN THE 241 00:09:06,376 --> 00:09:07,778 STRUCTURE OF LANGUAGE THAT YOU 242 00:09:07,778 --> 00:09:09,379 CAN BRING IN, RIGHT? 243 00:09:09,379 --> 00:09:11,482 SO IF YOU START UNDERSTANDING 244 00:09:11,482 --> 00:09:15,686 THE FREQUENCY OF LETTERS ACROSS 245 00:09:15,686 --> 00:09:17,387 LANGUAGE, THE POSITION OF 2 246 00:09:17,387 --> 00:09:18,689 LETTERS NEXT TO EACH XRGT HOW 247 00:09:18,689 --> 00:09:20,124 OFTEN THAT HAPPENS YOU CAN START 248 00:09:20,124 --> 00:09:22,960 MAKING PREDICTION ANDS IF YOU 249 00:09:22,960 --> 00:09:25,863 JUST RANDOMLY IMPLEMENT THOSE 250 00:09:25,863 --> 00:09:26,930 RULES, RANDOM LETTERS START 251 00:09:26,930 --> 00:09:28,198 LOOKING MORE AND MORE LIKE 252 00:09:28,198 --> 00:09:29,533 SENTENCES OR YOU CAN SEE THIS 253 00:09:29,533 --> 00:09:31,635 HAPPENING ALL THE WAY FROM 1-5. 254 00:09:31,635 --> 00:09:34,638 BY NUMBER 5, RANDOM CODE 255 00:09:34,638 --> 00:09:37,040 ESSENTIALLY STARTS CREATING 256 00:09:37,040 --> 00:09:39,343 LANGUAGE LOOKING THINGS IF YOU 257 00:09:39,343 --> 00:09:43,447 JUST IMPLEMENT THESE RULES FOR 258 00:09:43,447 --> 00:09:44,414 COMMUNICATION AND HOW LANGUAGE 259 00:09:44,414 --> 00:09:48,051 STRUCTURES THROUGH CODE IN THAT 260 00:09:48,051 --> 00:09:49,019 SETTING, REMARKABLY IT TOOK 261 00:09:49,019 --> 00:09:51,522 ALMOST 75 YEARS FOR THAT TO COME 262 00:09:51,522 --> 00:09:52,589 FULL CIRCLE, IN WHAT I'M SURE 263 00:09:52,589 --> 00:09:56,260 ALL OF YOU KNOW OF AS CHAT GPT. 264 00:09:56,260 --> 00:10:02,432 SO CHAT GPT, ESSENTIALLY IS 265 00:10:02,432 --> 00:10:03,066 ASTRONOMICALLY MORE ADVANCED 266 00:10:03,066 --> 00:10:05,669 VERSION OF THAT PREDICTIVE 267 00:10:05,669 --> 00:10:07,471 ALGORITHM, FOR THESE LARGE 268 00:10:07,471 --> 00:10:09,473 LANGUAGE MODELS ESSENTIALLY 269 00:10:09,473 --> 00:10:12,109 PREDICT THE NEXT WORD IN THE 270 00:10:12,109 --> 00:10:15,946 SENTENCE AND BY JUST DOING THAT 271 00:10:15,946 --> 00:10:18,048 BASING ALL OTHER MATERIAL ON THE 272 00:10:18,048 --> 00:10:19,683 WEB, KNOWLEDGE ACTUALLY GETS 273 00:10:19,683 --> 00:10:20,284 CREATED, RIGHT? 274 00:10:20,284 --> 00:10:22,886 THE STRUCTURE OF LANGUAGE AND 275 00:10:22,886 --> 00:10:24,021 KNOWLEDGE ARE JUXTAPOSED RIGHT 276 00:10:24,021 --> 00:10:25,789 AGAINST EACH OTHER IN WAYS THAT 277 00:10:25,789 --> 00:10:28,625 SEEM ALMOST HUMAN RIGHT IN THE 278 00:10:28,625 --> 00:10:31,728 CONTEXT OF INTERACTION OF 279 00:10:31,728 --> 00:10:32,095 CHATGPT. 280 00:10:32,095 --> 00:10:34,064 THAT WAS MY PRIVATE INDULGENCE 281 00:10:34,064 --> 00:10:36,700 BECAUSE AS YOU CAN TELL I'M A 282 00:10:36,700 --> 00:10:38,735 CLAUDE SHANNON FANATIC BUT FOR 283 00:10:38,735 --> 00:10:43,106 ME IT WAS SUCH AN UNCANNY 284 00:10:43,106 --> 00:10:47,644 STATEMENT, RIGHT, YOUR MISSION 285 00:10:47,644 --> 00:10:49,713 ARK ROUND COMMUNICATION AND 286 00:10:49,713 --> 00:10:51,281 COMMUNICATION AND FOUNDATION FOR 287 00:10:51,281 --> 00:10:53,584 ALL WE DO AS A LAYER IN DATA 288 00:10:53,584 --> 00:10:57,187 SCIENCE AS A COMMON EXCHANGE 289 00:10:57,187 --> 00:10:57,888 ESSENTIALLY FOR HAVE VISION 290 00:10:57,888 --> 00:10:59,823 MOVING FORWARD AND WHEN WE 291 00:10:59,823 --> 00:11:02,259 STARTED OUR ARC TO DEVELOP 292 00:11:02,259 --> 00:11:03,760 PLATFORMS AND RESOURCES, I KNEW 293 00:11:03,760 --> 00:11:04,795 OF CLAUDE SHANNON BUT I 294 00:11:04,795 --> 00:11:06,763 DEPARTMENT KNOW HOW TO BUILD OR 295 00:11:06,763 --> 00:11:09,633 MAKE THINGS WORK ON BEHALF OF 296 00:11:09,633 --> 00:11:12,169 SHARING DATA, AND OUR FIRST 297 00:11:12,169 --> 00:11:13,003 PROJECT REALLY BEGAN AROUND 298 00:11:13,003 --> 00:11:15,906 WHAT'S STILL THE LEADING CAUSE 299 00:11:15,906 --> 00:11:17,407 IS EASILY RELATED TO DEATH IN 300 00:11:17,407 --> 00:11:20,510 CHILDREN ASK THAT WAS A YOUNG 301 00:11:20,510 --> 00:11:22,246 FACULTY AT CHOP AND MY GOAL WAS 302 00:11:22,246 --> 00:11:23,647 TO START COLLECTING AND 303 00:11:23,647 --> 00:11:25,515 GENERATING MOLECULAR DAT SETS 304 00:11:25,515 --> 00:11:31,588 FOR PEDIATRIC BRAIN TUMORS. 305 00:11:31,588 --> 00:11:33,190 AND THE REASON FOR THAT WAS 306 00:11:33,190 --> 00:11:34,925 BECAUSE WE AND MANY OF AND YOU 307 00:11:34,925 --> 00:11:35,792 MANY OTHERS HAD ADOPTED THE 308 00:11:35,792 --> 00:11:38,929 MODEL FOR WHAT IT TAKES TO 309 00:11:38,929 --> 00:11:40,464 DEVELOP NEW THERAPEUTICS FOR ANY 310 00:11:40,464 --> 00:11:41,598 CONDITION, RIGHT? 311 00:11:41,598 --> 00:11:45,002 THERE'S A FAIRLY STANDARDIZED 312 00:11:45,002 --> 00:11:46,937 RECAPITULATED FRAMEWORK THAT YOU 313 00:11:46,937 --> 00:11:49,506 SEE HERE THAT SORT OF CREATES A 314 00:11:49,506 --> 00:11:51,775 CHEVRON CHAIN OF PREDISCOVERY, 315 00:11:51,775 --> 00:11:53,744 DRUG DISCOVERY, PRECLINICAL 316 00:11:53,744 --> 00:11:55,512 DEVELOPMENT, CLINICAL TRIAL 317 00:11:55,512 --> 00:11:56,780 FRAMEWORK, FDA APPROVAL AND THEN 318 00:11:56,780 --> 00:12:00,684 POST MARKETING AND OTHER 319 00:12:00,684 --> 00:12:00,984 ACTIVITIES. 320 00:12:00,984 --> 00:12:03,153 THE REALITY IS THAT THIS IS NOT 321 00:12:03,153 --> 00:12:07,891 THE REALITY, NOTHING IS LINEAR 322 00:12:07,891 --> 00:12:09,826 IN THIS PROCESS, AND I THOUGHT 323 00:12:09,826 --> 00:12:10,994 THAT THOSE COLLEAGUES DID A 324 00:12:10,994 --> 00:12:14,097 REALLY GREAT JOB A COUPLE YEARS 325 00:12:14,097 --> 00:12:15,599 AGO CONVERTING THAT LINEAR 326 00:12:15,599 --> 00:12:19,236 FRAMEWORK AND WHAT THEY CALL 327 00:12:19,236 --> 00:12:19,736 PRECISION MEDICINE MAP. 328 00:12:19,736 --> 00:12:20,904 I DON'T EXPECT YOU TO LOOK AT IT 329 00:12:20,904 --> 00:12:24,107 AND BE ABLE TO READ EVERY SINGLE 330 00:12:24,107 --> 00:12:26,376 PIECE BUT WHAT YOU CAN SEE IT'S 331 00:12:26,376 --> 00:12:27,778 A COMPLEX RECURSIVE FRAMEWORK 332 00:12:27,778 --> 00:12:30,814 THAT HAS KEY ELEMENTS THAT ARE 333 00:12:30,814 --> 00:12:31,949 REQUIRED ESSENTIALLY TO GO 334 00:12:31,949 --> 00:12:34,117 END-TO-END AND THEY GO ALL THE 335 00:12:34,117 --> 00:12:38,622 WAY AND START AT BASIC RESEARCH 336 00:12:38,622 --> 00:12:40,123 AND TARGET IDEBTIFICATION TO 337 00:12:40,123 --> 00:12:42,926 TARGET FROM ECOLOGY OR BIOMARKER 338 00:12:42,926 --> 00:12:44,294 DEVELOPMENT, 1 WILL THINK 339 00:12:44,294 --> 00:12:45,996 TRANSLATING THAT RESEARCH INTO 340 00:12:45,996 --> 00:12:48,065 SOMETHING YOU CAN MEASURE AND 341 00:12:48,065 --> 00:12:48,432 ACT ON. 342 00:12:48,432 --> 00:12:52,069 THEN YOU DEVELOP A LEAD 343 00:12:52,069 --> 00:12:52,736 IDENTIFICATION AND YOU LAUNCH 344 00:12:52,736 --> 00:12:54,738 CLINICAL TRIAL ANDS YOU GO 345 00:12:54,738 --> 00:12:56,606 THROUGH FDA REVIEW, AND OTHER 346 00:12:56,606 --> 00:12:57,874 ACTIVITIES BUT THE FIRST 4 347 00:12:57,874 --> 00:13:01,078 STEPS, RIGHT OF BASIC RESEARCH, 348 00:13:01,078 --> 00:13:01,812 UNDERSTANDING THE BIOLOGY, 349 00:13:01,812 --> 00:13:08,852 DEVELOPING WAYS TO MEASURE IT, 350 00:13:08,852 --> 00:13:10,520 AND THEN IMP LEMMING THE 351 00:13:10,520 --> 00:13:11,788 FRAMEWORKS ARE KEY, SO HERE IN 352 00:13:11,788 --> 00:13:12,756 THE TOP LEFT CORNER BECAUSE THIS 353 00:13:12,756 --> 00:13:14,958 IS THE AREA OF UNMET NEEDS 354 00:13:14,958 --> 00:13:17,561 ACROSS ANY DEC SETTING OR 355 00:13:17,561 --> 00:13:20,097 CONDITION IF YOU WANT TO ADVANCE 356 00:13:20,097 --> 00:13:21,164 A PRECISION MEDICINE FRAMEWORK, 357 00:13:21,164 --> 00:13:24,668 YOU HAVE TO HAVE THESE PIECES IN 358 00:13:24,668 --> 00:13:26,570 PLACE, RIGHT IN YOU HAVE TO 359 00:13:26,570 --> 00:13:27,537 THINK ABOUT REPOSITORY, DATA 360 00:13:27,537 --> 00:13:31,274 MINING, ABOUT I O MEDICAL 361 00:13:31,274 --> 00:13:32,776 INFORMATICS, HYPOTHESIS 362 00:13:32,776 --> 00:13:34,678 GENERATION, GENO TYPES, CLINICAL 363 00:13:34,678 --> 00:13:36,013 TRIAL INN ROLLMENT OF SUBJECTS, 364 00:13:36,013 --> 00:13:39,182 ALL OF THESE BOXES YOU HAVE TO 365 00:13:39,182 --> 00:13:39,916 CREATE NO MATTER WHICH DISEASE 366 00:13:39,916 --> 00:13:42,686 YOU TAKE EMPLOY SO WE WERE IN 367 00:13:42,686 --> 00:13:43,120 PEDIATRIC CANCER. 368 00:13:43,120 --> 00:13:45,555 WE KNEW WE HAD TO DO THIS AND 369 00:13:45,555 --> 00:13:47,858 THE LEFT-HAND SIDE IS THE PILLAR 370 00:13:47,858 --> 00:13:50,160 THAT ANY COMMUNITY HAS TO 371 00:13:50,160 --> 00:13:50,460 UNDERTAKE. 372 00:13:50,460 --> 00:13:52,729 SO OUR MODEL WAS TO SAY HOW DO 373 00:13:52,729 --> 00:13:55,132 WE SOLVE THIS AS A COMMUNITY? 374 00:13:55,132 --> 00:13:58,402 AND SO WE TRANSFORM THAT INTO 375 00:13:58,402 --> 00:13:59,503 THIS METHODOLOGY AS A FRAMEWORK 376 00:13:59,503 --> 00:14:03,874 WHICH IS WE WILL TART WITH 377 00:14:03,874 --> 00:14:05,675 COLLECTING ANNOTATED SAMPLES 378 00:14:05,675 --> 00:14:06,576 CLINICALLY ANNOTATED SAMPLES. 379 00:14:06,576 --> 00:14:08,578 WE WILL TRANSFORM THEM INTO DATA 380 00:14:08,578 --> 00:14:10,347 MEANING YOU MIGHT SEQUENCE THOSE 381 00:14:10,347 --> 00:14:11,214 SAMPLES, CHARACTERIZE THEM, NOT 382 00:14:11,214 --> 00:14:13,283 JUST WHAT COMES OFF THE MACHINE, 383 00:14:13,283 --> 00:14:14,117 THAT'S NOT A SUBTRAIT FOR 384 00:14:14,117 --> 00:14:15,752 DISCOVERY BECAUSE YOU HAVE TO 385 00:14:15,752 --> 00:14:17,054 THEN STRUCTURE AND HARMONIZE AND 386 00:14:17,054 --> 00:14:19,723 CONNECK THAT DATA TO OTHER DATA 387 00:14:19,723 --> 00:14:21,091 SETS, THAT'S THAT INFORMATION 388 00:14:21,091 --> 00:14:22,859 LAYER AND THEN ONLY WHEN YOU 389 00:14:22,859 --> 00:14:25,896 UNDERSTAND THAT INFORMATION 390 00:14:25,896 --> 00:14:27,264 LAYER AND CAN ACTUALLY AND ACT 391 00:14:27,264 --> 00:14:31,601 ON IT AND BECOME KNOWLEDGE THAT 392 00:14:31,601 --> 00:14:34,604 THEY CAN TRANSLATE THAT AND THE 393 00:14:34,604 --> 00:14:36,339 HYPOTHESIS WAS THAT IN RARE 394 00:14:36,339 --> 00:14:37,441 DISEASE SETTING OF PEDIATRIC 395 00:14:37,441 --> 00:14:38,375 CANCER WE WILL HAVE TO LAY 396 00:14:38,375 --> 00:14:39,309 THERAPY AND WORK FLOW WITH 397 00:14:39,309 --> 00:14:40,077 INFRANCIS COLLINS STRUCKURE AND 398 00:14:40,077 --> 00:14:40,610 THAT'S WHAT YOU SEE THE 399 00:14:40,610 --> 00:14:42,679 CONTROLLER OF BANKS ON THE TOP 400 00:14:42,679 --> 00:14:44,881 AND BELOW, RIGHT? 401 00:14:44,881 --> 00:14:47,484 WE WANTED TO--THESE ARE AMBITION 402 00:14:47,484 --> 00:14:48,685 SPACES, PLATFORMS CREATED TO 403 00:14:48,685 --> 00:14:50,420 OTHER PLATFORMS ISSUES CREATE 404 00:14:50,420 --> 00:14:53,290 REALTIME DYNAMIC EXCHANGE OF 405 00:14:53,290 --> 00:14:54,925 DATA BETWEEN INSTITUTIONS THAT 406 00:14:54,925 --> 00:14:56,793 HARNESSED HARMONIZED DATA SETS 407 00:14:56,793 --> 00:14:59,329 THAT ALLOWED ANYBODY TO ITERATE 408 00:14:59,329 --> 00:15:00,764 THE HYPOTHESIS AROUND THE DAILY 409 00:15:00,764 --> 00:15:02,165 BASIS DATA BECAUSE WE RECOGNIZE 410 00:15:02,165 --> 00:15:03,800 THAT NO SINGLE INSTITUTION WOULD 411 00:15:03,800 --> 00:15:06,036 HAVE ENOUGH SAMPLES OR ENOUGH 412 00:15:06,036 --> 00:15:09,039 RESEARCHERS TO ACTUALLY PERFORM 413 00:15:09,039 --> 00:15:10,040 RESEARCH THAT'S REQUIRED. 414 00:15:10,040 --> 00:15:11,942 SO WE STARTED WITH 4 415 00:15:11,942 --> 00:15:13,977 INSTITUTIONS AND WE STAYED AT 4 416 00:15:13,977 --> 00:15:16,279 FOR A WHILE AND UNTIL WE STARTED 417 00:15:16,279 --> 00:15:18,248 GENERATING LARGE ENOUGH COHORTS 418 00:15:18,248 --> 00:15:19,749 WAS A VALUE PROPOSITION WAS THAT 419 00:15:19,749 --> 00:15:22,119 BY JOINING THE COHORT, YOU 420 00:15:22,119 --> 00:15:23,186 ACTUALLY EMPOWERED YOUR OWN 421 00:15:23,186 --> 00:15:26,823 DATA, THIS IS A KEY SORT OF 422 00:15:26,823 --> 00:15:27,324 SHIFT, RIGHT? 423 00:15:27,324 --> 00:15:28,859 THE MINUTE YOU HAVE A 424 00:15:28,859 --> 00:15:38,635 FOUNDATIONAL LAYER OF A RESOURCE 425 00:15:38,635 --> 00:15:41,304 WHERE ANY ENTITIAADS VALUE TO 426 00:15:41,304 --> 00:15:42,239 THE RESOURCE, YOU PASSED THE 427 00:15:42,239 --> 00:15:44,474 MILESTONE BECAUSE THE ECONOMICS 428 00:15:44,474 --> 00:15:46,443 OF HUMAN BEHAVIOR AND DORPHY 429 00:15:46,443 --> 00:15:50,547 START ALIGNING, RIGHT, IT'S THE 430 00:15:50,547 --> 00:15:52,182 TRADITIONAL COMPETITIVE OR 431 00:15:52,182 --> 00:15:53,483 SILOED APPROACHES ARE ACTUALLY 432 00:15:53,483 --> 00:15:55,085 DETRIMENTAL TO THOSE WHO MIGHT 433 00:15:55,085 --> 00:15:56,786 NOT SHARE BECAUSE THE COMMUNITY 434 00:15:56,786 --> 00:15:58,655 HAS ALREADY CREATED A LARGER 435 00:15:58,655 --> 00:16:00,090 RESOURCE THAN THEY HAVE ON THEIR 436 00:16:00,090 --> 00:16:00,524 OWN, RIGHT? 437 00:16:00,524 --> 00:16:02,159 SO WE KNEW THAT HAD TO BE THE 438 00:16:02,159 --> 00:16:02,359 CASE. 439 00:16:02,359 --> 00:16:04,528 WE KNEW THAT WOULD BE THE 440 00:16:04,528 --> 00:16:06,496 FULCRUM SHIFT, THE MINUTE WE HAD 441 00:16:06,496 --> 00:16:08,365 MORE SAMPLES AND DATA THAT ANY 442 00:16:08,365 --> 00:16:09,065 SINGLE INSTITUTION WOULD HAVE 443 00:16:09,065 --> 00:16:11,168 WOULD BE AT THEIR ADVANTAGE TO 444 00:16:11,168 --> 00:16:12,936 CONNECT AND THEN SUDDENLY ALL 445 00:16:12,936 --> 00:16:15,305 THE SITES MARCHED ALONG AND WE 446 00:16:15,305 --> 00:16:16,473 GREW THE OTHER SITES. 447 00:16:16,473 --> 00:16:19,809 TODAY THEY'RE ARE MORE THAN 5000 448 00:16:19,809 --> 00:16:22,112 ENROLLED PARTICIPANTS EMPLOY THE 449 00:16:22,112 --> 00:16:25,015 LARGEST PEDIATRIC BRAIN TUMOR 450 00:16:25,015 --> 00:16:26,716 STUDY EVER CREATED ACROSS 451 00:16:26,716 --> 00:16:29,352 SAMPLES, DATA SETS, MODELS. 452 00:16:29,352 --> 00:16:30,754 THE PROJECTS IN THIS CONTEXT ARE 453 00:16:30,754 --> 00:16:31,888 ALSO VERY LARGE AND IMPORTANTLY 454 00:16:31,888 --> 00:16:34,424 WE TOOK A COUPLE STEPS THAT I 455 00:16:34,424 --> 00:16:34,891 THINK WERE KEY. 456 00:16:34,891 --> 00:16:36,059 ONE YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE A 457 00:16:36,059 --> 00:16:38,395 MEMBER OF THE CONSORTIUM TO 458 00:16:38,395 --> 00:16:40,130 ACCESS DATA OR THE SAMPLES. 459 00:16:40,130 --> 00:16:42,799 AGAIN, YOU HAVE TO ALIGN TO THIS 460 00:16:42,799 --> 00:16:44,401 MENTAL MODEL, ANYBODY WHO CAN 461 00:16:44,401 --> 00:16:45,168 CONTRIBUTE TO THE DISCOVERY 462 00:16:45,168 --> 00:16:47,604 PROCESS SHOULD BE ABLE TO DO 463 00:16:47,604 --> 00:16:48,205 THIS. 464 00:16:48,205 --> 00:16:50,840 NOW THAT'S AN ANTITHETICAL 465 00:16:50,840 --> 00:16:53,276 POSITION TO MOST INSTITUTIONS 466 00:16:53,276 --> 00:16:53,877 AND INVESTIGATORS. 467 00:16:53,877 --> 00:16:56,613 THE WAY WE ACCOMPLISH THAT IS 468 00:16:56,613 --> 00:16:57,681 THROUGH PARTNERSHIPS WITH 469 00:16:57,681 --> 00:16:58,982 PATIENT ADVOCATES. 470 00:16:58,982 --> 00:17:01,284 SO THE PATIENT ADVOCATES, RIGHT, 471 00:17:01,284 --> 00:17:02,686 WHAT'S THEIR NUMBER 1 GOAL. 472 00:17:02,686 --> 00:17:04,921 THEIR NUMBER 1 GOAL IS 473 00:17:04,921 --> 00:17:07,257 ACCELERATE DISCOVERY. 474 00:17:07,257 --> 00:17:08,158 THEY VERY RAPIDLY UNDERSTAND 475 00:17:08,158 --> 00:17:10,060 THAT THE MORE PEOPLE WHO WORK ON 476 00:17:10,060 --> 00:17:11,461 THEIR SAMPLES, THE MORE PEOPLE 477 00:17:11,461 --> 00:17:13,129 WHO HAVE ACCESS TO THEIR DATA, 478 00:17:13,129 --> 00:17:16,099 THE MORE LIKELY WE ARE IN THE 479 00:17:16,099 --> 00:17:17,367 COMMUNITY TO DEVELOP CURES. 480 00:17:17,367 --> 00:17:22,372 AND SO, WE EMPOWERED PATES AND 481 00:17:22,372 --> 00:17:25,108 THEIR FELLOWS TO ASK WHY ISN'T 482 00:17:25,108 --> 00:17:26,276 SOMETHING HAPPENING? 483 00:17:26,276 --> 00:17:27,978 AND IT WOULD NEVER BE SUFFICIENT 484 00:17:27,978 --> 00:17:30,080 TO SAY WELL I WANTED TO MAKE MY 485 00:17:30,080 --> 00:17:31,548 POST DOC HAD A JOB, AND THE 486 00:17:31,548 --> 00:17:33,483 FAMILY WOULD SAY, I WANT TO MAKE 487 00:17:33,483 --> 00:17:35,051 SURE MY KID GETS BETTER SO AS A 488 00:17:35,051 --> 00:17:36,052 COMMUNITY YOU HAVE TO GO THROUGH 489 00:17:36,052 --> 00:17:37,287 THE FRAMEWORK OF HOW DO YOU 490 00:17:37,287 --> 00:17:37,621 ADDRESS THAT? 491 00:17:37,621 --> 00:17:41,124 HOW DO YOU TART TO ALIEP THESE 492 00:17:41,124 --> 00:17:43,126 PROCESSES OF BASIC RESEARCH, 493 00:17:43,126 --> 00:17:43,927 STANDARD ACADEMEC PROCESS WITH 494 00:17:43,927 --> 00:17:46,096 COMMUNITY BUILDING AND 495 00:17:46,096 --> 00:17:47,030 ENGAGEMENT? 496 00:17:47,030 --> 00:17:49,899 AGAIN THE SECRET IS RADICAL 497 00:17:49,899 --> 00:17:52,269 TRANSPARENCY AROUND PROCESSES, 498 00:17:52,269 --> 00:17:54,371 SO THAT'S REPUTATIONAL FRAMEWORK 499 00:17:54,371 --> 00:17:55,171 SORE PARTNERSHIP OVERRIDES 500 00:17:55,171 --> 00:17:57,140 SELF-INTEREST AND IT'S MORE 501 00:17:57,140 --> 00:17:58,708 ADVANTAGEOUS FOR ANYONE TO 502 00:17:58,708 --> 00:18:00,076 COLLABORATE THAN TO OPERATE ON 503 00:18:00,076 --> 00:18:02,412 THEIR OWN. 504 00:18:02,412 --> 00:18:04,748 NOW, I WAS TREANED AS A 505 00:18:04,748 --> 00:18:05,682 NEUROSCIENTIST, I WORKED MY 506 00:18:05,682 --> 00:18:08,418 FIRST LAB WAS REALLY JUST A 507 00:18:08,418 --> 00:18:10,620 LABORATORY ENVIRONMENT. 508 00:18:10,620 --> 00:18:11,788 HERE SUDDENLY I WAS THRUST INTO 509 00:18:11,788 --> 00:18:13,823 THIS ENVIRONMENT OF SAYING, 510 00:18:13,823 --> 00:18:15,225 OKAY, --I HAVE ALL THESE PEOPLE 511 00:18:15,225 --> 00:18:16,993 TO AGREE TO SHARE SAMPLES, OR 512 00:18:16,993 --> 00:18:18,094 GENERATING ALL THIS DAT ANNOT 513 00:18:18,094 --> 00:18:21,097 ALL OF THEM HAVE 514 00:18:21,097 --> 00:18:22,299 BIOINFORMATICIANS, AND DATA 515 00:18:22,299 --> 00:18:24,334 SCIENTISTS AT THEIR SITES, IT'S 516 00:18:24,334 --> 00:18:27,804 A RIPE ENVIRONMENT FOR DESPERATE 517 00:18:27,804 --> 00:18:28,638 RESOURCES, SUDDENLY AGAIN 518 00:18:28,638 --> 00:18:30,840 EMERGING, IF 1 OF THOSE 519 00:18:30,840 --> 00:18:31,808 INSTITUTIONS CAN HARNESS DATA 520 00:18:31,808 --> 00:18:34,144 FASTER THAN ANOTHER INSTITUTION, 521 00:18:34,144 --> 00:18:35,779 YOU CREATE DISPARITIES, RATES OF 522 00:18:35,779 --> 00:18:36,179 EXCHANGE. 523 00:18:36,179 --> 00:18:37,480 SO WE THOUGHT ABOUT HOW DO WE 524 00:18:37,480 --> 00:18:39,382 CREATE THE NEXT LAYER ON TOP OF 525 00:18:39,382 --> 00:18:42,252 THE ANALOGUE LAYER OF SAMPLES 526 00:18:42,252 --> 00:18:45,622 AND DATA SETS, HOW DO WE CREATE 527 00:18:45,622 --> 00:18:46,489 SHARING PLATFORMS, ANALYTIC 528 00:18:46,489 --> 00:18:48,391 PLATFORMS THAT CAN BEA ACCESSED 529 00:18:48,391 --> 00:18:49,426 BY ANYONE EMPLOY AND SEVERAL 530 00:18:49,426 --> 00:18:50,527 THINGS HAPPEN THAT WE HAVEN'T 531 00:18:50,527 --> 00:18:51,995 FULLY SOLVED SO I PROMISE MYSELF 532 00:18:51,995 --> 00:18:53,630 I WILL TELL YOU A THINK THIS WE 533 00:18:53,630 --> 00:18:55,065 HAVEN'T SOLVED. 534 00:18:55,065 --> 00:18:59,035 VERY EARLY ON, WE GOTS LIKE THE 535 00:18:59,035 --> 00:19:00,403 FOLLOWING, IF YOU ARE GOING TO 536 00:19:00,403 --> 00:19:02,472 CARRY A PLATFORM ISSUES I WANT A 537 00:19:02,472 --> 00:19:04,240 PLATFORM FOR MY DISEASE AND WE 538 00:19:04,240 --> 00:19:06,609 WOULD GET ANOTHER PERSON WHO 539 00:19:06,609 --> 00:19:09,512 WOULD SAY I WANT A PLATFORM FOR 540 00:19:09,512 --> 00:19:10,513 THEIR BRAIN DISEASE. 541 00:19:10,513 --> 00:19:12,148 EVERYBODY WANTED THEIR OWN 542 00:19:12,148 --> 00:19:12,482 PLATFORM. 543 00:19:12,482 --> 00:19:16,052 AND IN MANY WAYS THE INSTINCT IS 544 00:19:16,052 --> 00:19:18,588 TO ORIENT AROUND YOUR COMMUNITY 545 00:19:18,588 --> 00:19:19,956 INTEREST, RIGHT, BRING PEOPLE 546 00:19:19,956 --> 00:19:20,390 TOGETHER. 547 00:19:20,390 --> 00:19:22,926 BUT THE REALITY IS IT'S 548 00:19:22,926 --> 00:19:23,493 IMPOSSIBLE FINANCIALLY AND 549 00:19:23,493 --> 00:19:25,362 RESOURCE WISE TO HAVE A HUNDRED 550 00:19:25,362 --> 00:19:28,098 DIFFERENT PLATFORMS FOR EACH 551 00:19:28,098 --> 00:19:30,166 INDIVIDUAL ENTITY, WE EVEN GOT 552 00:19:30,166 --> 00:19:31,668 PEOPLE WITHIN A SINGLE ENTITY 553 00:19:31,668 --> 00:19:33,336 SAY I WILL LIKE MY SUBTYPE TO 554 00:19:33,336 --> 00:19:35,472 HAVE MY OWN VERSION OF A 555 00:19:35,472 --> 00:19:36,573 PLATFORM AND I THINK PART OF IT 556 00:19:36,573 --> 00:19:40,043 HAS TO DO WITH THE FACT THAT YOU 557 00:19:40,043 --> 00:19:43,213 KNOW THEIR NETWORK RIGHT, IS SO 558 00:19:43,213 --> 00:19:45,615 TIGHT, THERE'S SUCH IDENTITY TO 559 00:19:45,615 --> 00:19:49,152 COORDINATION ACROSS PATIENTS AND 560 00:19:49,152 --> 00:19:50,553 RESEARCHERS, THAT'S THE INTINCT. 561 00:19:50,553 --> 00:19:52,222 OUR ARGUMENT WAS THAT ACTUALLY 562 00:19:52,222 --> 00:19:56,459 IF WE CREATED 1A PLATFORM YOU 563 00:19:56,459 --> 00:19:58,762 MIGHT ACTUALLY LEARN FROM EACH 564 00:19:58,762 --> 00:20:00,797 OTHER, CREATE PARTNERSHIPS YOU 565 00:20:00,797 --> 00:20:02,065 DEPARTMENT HAVE BEFORE, MAYBE 566 00:20:02,065 --> 00:20:03,700 CREATE SOMETHING FOR GENE X, 567 00:20:03,700 --> 00:20:04,434 THAT'S PLAGUING YOUR DISEASE 568 00:20:04,434 --> 00:20:07,570 EMPLOY IT WASN'T A MESSAGE THAT 569 00:20:07,570 --> 00:20:08,037 WAS IMMEDIATELY SOLD. 570 00:20:08,037 --> 00:20:09,272 IT'S STILL A MESSAGE WE'RE 571 00:20:09,272 --> 00:20:11,875 DEVELOPING BUT IT DID END UP 572 00:20:11,875 --> 00:20:13,877 BEING A REALITY IN MANY WAYS. 573 00:20:13,877 --> 00:20:17,213 AND SO I STILL FEEL LIKE WE 574 00:20:17,213 --> 00:20:18,314 HAVEN'T FOUND THAT PERFECT 575 00:20:18,314 --> 00:20:22,685 BALANCE OF CREATING A PLATFORM 576 00:20:22,685 --> 00:20:24,487 THAT'S CENTRALIZED AND COVERS A 577 00:20:24,487 --> 00:20:25,688 LARGE NUMBER OF DISEASE 578 00:20:25,688 --> 00:20:28,124 SETTINGS, CONTEXT CAN CONDITIONS 579 00:20:28,124 --> 00:20:29,426 THAT EMPOWERS COLLABORATION, BUT 580 00:20:29,426 --> 00:20:30,927 IN WAYS THAT SUFFICIENTLY 581 00:20:30,927 --> 00:20:32,662 ENGAGING FOR SOMEONE TO COME AND 582 00:20:32,662 --> 00:20:35,999 SAY, THAT'S MY PLATFORM, RIGHT, 583 00:20:35,999 --> 00:20:37,434 THE HUMAN LAYER OF IDENTITY IS 584 00:20:37,434 --> 00:20:43,907 STILL A CHALLENGE FOR US. 585 00:20:43,907 --> 00:20:46,543 WITH THAT IDEA THAT YOU CAN 586 00:20:46,543 --> 00:20:48,077 INTERSECT ACROSS DECS WAS ALSO 587 00:20:48,077 --> 00:20:49,512 SHARED BY NIH AND IN 2018 WE 588 00:20:49,512 --> 00:20:51,047 WERE FORTUNATE ENOUGH TO TAKE 589 00:20:51,047 --> 00:20:53,383 THOSE LESSONS LEARNED THROUGH 590 00:20:53,383 --> 00:20:54,651 THE GABRIELA MILLER 591 00:20:54,651 --> 00:20:56,719 [INDISCERNIBLE] FIRST DATA 592 00:20:56,719 --> 00:20:57,454 RESOURCE. 593 00:20:57,454 --> 00:20:58,922 GAB RIALLIA WAS A CHILD THAT HAD 594 00:20:58,922 --> 00:21:00,824 A BREAN TUMOR AND SUCCUMBED TO 595 00:21:00,824 --> 00:21:04,461 IT AND INIA A VIDEO CHALLENGED 596 00:21:04,461 --> 00:21:06,095 THE COMMUNITY AT LARMING TO STOP 597 00:21:06,095 --> 00:21:07,697 TALKING AND START DOING AND I 598 00:21:07,697 --> 00:21:10,233 THINK IF IF YOUR 10 YEAR-OLD 599 00:21:10,233 --> 00:21:13,803 WITH A BRAIN TUMOR, YOU CAN ALSO 600 00:21:13,803 --> 00:21:15,171 CURSE ON CAMERA WHICH SHE DID, 601 00:21:15,171 --> 00:21:20,944 AND THEY TOOK IT TO THE NEXT 602 00:21:20,944 --> 00:21:21,311 LEVEL. 603 00:21:21,311 --> 00:21:24,113 NOT ONLY ARE YOU GOING TO WORK 604 00:21:24,113 --> 00:21:25,215 ACROSS ALL PEDIATRIC CANCER, WE 605 00:21:25,215 --> 00:21:29,385 WILL BRING IN STRUCTURAL DEFECT 606 00:21:29,385 --> 00:21:30,320 ANDS CONGENITAL ABNORMALITIES. 607 00:21:30,320 --> 00:21:31,588 I REMEMBER THE FIRST MEETING WE 608 00:21:31,588 --> 00:21:33,256 HELD FOR THE INITIAL AWARDEES OF 609 00:21:33,256 --> 00:21:36,559 SOME OF THE RESOURCES AT THE END 610 00:21:36,559 --> 00:21:37,594 OF THE MEETING, 2 PROMINENT 611 00:21:37,594 --> 00:21:40,129 PEOPLE CAME UP TO ME, BY CHANCE 612 00:21:40,129 --> 00:21:41,531 FROM THE RESPECTIVE SIDES AND 613 00:21:41,531 --> 00:21:44,200 THEY SAID ADAM FOR THE NEXT 614 00:21:44,200 --> 00:21:45,535 MEETING CAN WE HAVE THE CANCER 615 00:21:45,535 --> 00:21:48,271 PEOPLE HAVE THEIR MEETING AND 616 00:21:48,271 --> 00:21:51,074 THE STRUCTURAL BIRTH DEFECTS 617 00:21:51,074 --> 00:21:52,108 HAVE THEIR MEETING, IT DOESN'T 618 00:21:52,108 --> 00:21:54,177 MAKE SENSE TO HAVE US IN THE 619 00:21:54,177 --> 00:21:54,577 SAME ROOM. 620 00:21:54,577 --> 00:21:56,346 THEY DON'T KNOW WHAT THEY'RE 621 00:21:56,346 --> 00:21:56,946 TALKING ABOUT, LITERALLY THEY 622 00:21:56,946 --> 00:21:59,716 SAID THAT, IT WAS A BIAS, CANCER 623 00:21:59,716 --> 00:22:03,319 PEOPLE WERE FOCUSED ON SOMATIC 624 00:22:03,319 --> 00:22:05,588 OPERATIONS. 625 00:22:05,588 --> 00:22:06,956 AND THE STRUCTURAL 1S WERE 626 00:22:06,956 --> 00:22:08,825 TALKING ABOUT GERM LINE 627 00:22:08,825 --> 00:22:09,359 ALTERATIONS. 628 00:22:09,359 --> 00:22:10,560 IT WAS 2 DIFFERENT CONTEXT. 629 00:22:10,560 --> 00:22:12,462 IT TOOK US TIME TO BUILD THE 630 00:22:12,462 --> 00:22:14,464 NEXT ITERATION OF INFRASTRUCTURE 631 00:22:14,464 --> 00:22:15,498 THAT CROSS-EMPOWERED THAT 632 00:22:15,498 --> 00:22:16,099 DISCOVERY, RIGHT? 633 00:22:16,099 --> 00:22:19,269 WHERE SOMEONE WHO NORMALLY 634 00:22:19,269 --> 00:22:21,371 WOULDN'T LOOK AT A SOMATIC 635 00:22:21,371 --> 00:22:22,772 ALTERATION IN CANCER WILL 636 00:22:22,772 --> 00:22:23,973 SUDDENLY DISCOVER, HEY, A YEN 637 00:22:23,973 --> 00:22:26,075 THAT CAUSES CANCER IS ALSO A 638 00:22:26,075 --> 00:22:28,611 GERM LINE IMPLICATED YEEP, 639 00:22:28,611 --> 00:22:30,446 PERHAPS IN OPPOSITE DIRECTION 640 00:22:30,446 --> 00:22:32,682 AND SUDDENLY THAT REALITY OF A 641 00:22:32,682 --> 00:22:35,618 COMMON INFRASTRUCTURE THAT 642 00:22:35,618 --> 00:22:40,723 SUPPORTS SHARED QUERY-ABILITY 643 00:22:40,723 --> 00:22:41,891 ACROSS RESOURCES EMERGED. 644 00:22:41,891 --> 00:22:43,560 THIS WILL NEVER HAVE HAPPENED IF 645 00:22:43,560 --> 00:22:45,895 IT WASN'T FOR THE NIH-BASED 646 00:22:45,895 --> 00:22:46,129 VISION. 647 00:22:46,129 --> 00:22:47,630 THE COMMUNITY ITSELF WILL NOT 648 00:22:47,630 --> 00:22:48,598 TAKE THOSE STEPS ON THEIR OWN 649 00:22:48,598 --> 00:22:50,166 AND I THINK THAT'S A REALLY 650 00:22:50,166 --> 00:22:54,470 UNIQUE CONTEXT THAT WAS A 651 00:22:54,470 --> 00:22:56,072 LEARNING EXPERIENCE FOR ME, THAT 652 00:22:56,072 --> 00:23:01,511 PLATFORMS NOT ONLY SUPPORT AND 653 00:23:01,511 --> 00:23:02,245 ENHANCE COORDINATION, BUT 654 00:23:02,245 --> 00:23:03,079 EXTREMELY POWERFUL TO BRENG 655 00:23:03,079 --> 00:23:04,347 TOGETHER PEOPLE WHO MAY NOT UPON 656 00:23:04,347 --> 00:23:06,983 EACH OTHER RIGHT IN THAT 657 00:23:06,983 --> 00:23:07,317 CONTEXT. 658 00:23:07,317 --> 00:23:16,459 YOU ARE TO ADDRESS A NUMBER OF 659 00:23:16,459 --> 00:23:17,727 SETTINGS, MOLECULAR DATA SETS, 660 00:23:17,727 --> 00:23:19,128 DISEASE CONTEXT AND DEC 661 00:23:19,128 --> 00:23:20,630 CONDITIONS THAT WERE NOT RELATED 662 00:23:20,630 --> 00:23:25,602 AND THEY CAN JOINTLY SHARE 663 00:23:25,602 --> 00:23:26,669 QUERIABLE BY COMMUNITY, SO TODAY 664 00:23:26,669 --> 00:23:29,539 WE HAVE MORE THAN 21,000 WHOLE 665 00:23:29,539 --> 00:23:32,375 GENOMES IN THIS PLATFORM ACROSS 666 00:23:32,375 --> 00:23:37,814 MORE THAN 6000 PHENOTYPES. 667 00:23:37,814 --> 00:23:40,083 MANY ARE PHENOTYPES THAT THIS 668 00:23:40,083 --> 00:23:42,619 AREA CARE ABOUT, AND VERY FEW 669 00:23:42,619 --> 00:23:44,487 PEOPLE HAVE QUERIES ABOUT THOSE 670 00:23:44,487 --> 00:23:46,089 DATA SETS, AND THEY INCLUDE 671 00:23:46,089 --> 00:23:48,091 CHANGES IN THE PLATFORM WHICH IS 672 00:23:48,091 --> 00:23:48,891 A PARTNERED ENVIRONMENT HERE. 673 00:23:48,891 --> 00:23:51,027 THIS IS 1 OF THE LARNLEST WHOLE 674 00:23:51,027 --> 00:23:52,595 GENOME AND MOLECULAR DATA SETS 675 00:23:52,595 --> 00:23:55,231 FOR PEDIATRIC CANCER AND 676 00:23:55,231 --> 00:23:56,899 STRUCTURAL BIRTH DEFECTS AND 677 00:23:56,899 --> 00:23:57,834 ADOPTS THE FOLLOWING PRINCIPLES 678 00:23:57,834 --> 00:23:59,202 THAT WE'RE STILL STRIVING TO 679 00:23:59,202 --> 00:24:00,003 ACCOMPLISH, SO AMOUNT OF 680 00:24:00,003 --> 00:24:00,703 EXPERIENCE BEING TRANSPARENT 681 00:24:00,703 --> 00:24:02,105 WITH YOU, THIS IS OUR REACH 682 00:24:02,105 --> 00:24:03,506 GOAL, WE HAVE NOT YET REACHED 683 00:24:03,506 --> 00:24:05,541 IT, BUT OUR LEARNED EXPERIENCES 684 00:24:05,541 --> 00:24:12,215 IF YOU DO THE FOLLOWING, RIGHT, 685 00:24:12,215 --> 00:24:16,052 YOU ENGENDER SCIENTIFIC WAYS YOU 686 00:24:16,052 --> 00:24:17,286 WOULDN'T HAVE EXPECTED. 687 00:24:17,286 --> 00:24:18,688 IT'S NONLOCAL, IT'S NOT ABOUT 688 00:24:18,688 --> 00:24:22,225 BEING IN THE SAME INSTITUTION OR 689 00:24:22,225 --> 00:24:22,959 SAME UNIVERSITY. 690 00:24:22,959 --> 00:24:25,928 YOU HAVE MACK MYSELF THE NUMBER 691 00:24:25,928 --> 00:24:27,096 OF INFORMATION USED FOR YOUR 692 00:24:27,096 --> 00:24:28,731 GOAL AS A PLATFORM OPERATOR 693 00:24:28,731 --> 00:24:29,999 SHOULD BE TO BRENG AS MANY 694 00:24:29,999 --> 00:24:33,803 DIFFERENT PEOPLE TO THE PLATFORM 695 00:24:33,803 --> 00:24:34,370 AS POSSIBLE. 696 00:24:34,370 --> 00:24:34,771 RIGHT? 697 00:24:34,771 --> 00:24:36,172 TYPICALLY THE OPPOSITE OF MOST 698 00:24:36,172 --> 00:24:38,374 DATA PLATFORMS THAT SAYS, OKAY, 699 00:24:38,374 --> 00:24:40,076 I'M GOING TO GATE KEEP THE DATA 700 00:24:40,076 --> 00:24:42,111 FOR A CERTAIN PURPOSE, RIGHT? 701 00:24:42,111 --> 00:24:44,180 YOU ACTUALLY MEASURE SUCCESS BY 702 00:24:44,180 --> 00:24:44,647 INCREASING THE NUMBER. 703 00:24:44,647 --> 00:24:45,748 AT THE SAME TIME THAT YOU'RE 704 00:24:45,748 --> 00:24:47,183 INCREASING THE NUMBER, YOU WANT 705 00:24:47,183 --> 00:24:48,785 TO INCREASE THE DIVERSITY, 706 00:24:48,785 --> 00:24:51,421 RIGHT, BECAUSE YOU ESSENTIALLY 707 00:24:51,421 --> 00:24:53,289 WANT TO ENGENDER DIFFERENT 708 00:24:53,289 --> 00:24:54,824 DISCIPLINES, WHERE I CAN TALK 709 00:24:54,824 --> 00:24:56,426 DIFFERENTLY ABOUT DATA AND USE 710 00:24:56,426 --> 00:24:57,527 DIFFERENT DATA DIFFERENTLY TO 711 00:24:57,527 --> 00:24:59,896 ACTUALLY BUMP INTO EACH OTHER IN 712 00:24:59,896 --> 00:25:02,031 THE VIRTUAL DOMAIN, THIS IS 1 OF 713 00:25:02,031 --> 00:25:02,965 THE HARDEST CHALLENGES, I THINK 714 00:25:02,965 --> 00:25:04,500 I WAS TALKING TO SOMEBODY 715 00:25:04,500 --> 00:25:08,271 EARLIER HERE TODAY WHO SAID 716 00:25:08,271 --> 00:25:09,772 THEY'RE WORKING ACROSS 717 00:25:09,772 --> 00:25:10,373 BIOINFORMATICIANS AND 718 00:25:10,373 --> 00:25:11,874 CLINICIANS, THEY SPEAK 719 00:25:11,874 --> 00:25:12,775 COMPLETELY DIFFERENT LANGUAGES, 720 00:25:12,775 --> 00:25:17,480 RIGHT, ABOUT THE EXACT SAME 721 00:25:17,480 --> 00:25:17,980 PATIENT, RIGHT? 722 00:25:17,980 --> 00:25:20,516 AND THEN TO DO THAT, YOU HAVE TO 723 00:25:20,516 --> 00:25:22,452 SUPPORT FRAMEWORKS THAT CONNECT 724 00:25:22,452 --> 00:25:24,687 NATURALLY BETWEEN THESE 725 00:25:24,687 --> 00:25:26,556 COMMUNITIES AND ACHIEVE AND THIS 726 00:25:26,556 --> 00:25:28,057 IS OUR GOAL FRICTIONLESS FLOW OF 727 00:25:28,057 --> 00:25:28,424 DATA. 728 00:25:28,424 --> 00:25:31,961 THE FLOW OF DATA MEANS A COUPLE 729 00:25:31,961 --> 00:25:33,162 DIFFERENT THINGS HERE, 1 CAN 730 00:25:33,162 --> 00:25:34,330 SOMEONE ACTUALLY FIND DATA AND 731 00:25:34,330 --> 00:25:35,698 KNOW IT'S THERE, USE IT, TOUCH 732 00:25:35,698 --> 00:25:39,969 IT, PLAY WITH IT, AND CAN PEOPLE 733 00:25:39,969 --> 00:25:40,770 DO THAT TOGETHER. 734 00:25:40,770 --> 00:25:42,405 SO THIS IS THE WORK FLOW WE 735 00:25:42,405 --> 00:25:43,339 STRIVE TO ACHIEVE AND BY AND 736 00:25:43,339 --> 00:25:45,341 LARNL YOU COULD DO THIS TODAY ON 737 00:25:45,341 --> 00:25:47,410 THE KIDS FIRST PLATFORM OR THE 738 00:25:47,410 --> 00:25:47,944 INCLUDE PLATFORM. 739 00:25:47,944 --> 00:25:50,213 ANYBODY CAN LOG ON AND FIND OUT 740 00:25:50,213 --> 00:25:52,048 WHEN'S IN THE DATA RESOURCE AND 741 00:25:52,048 --> 00:25:56,719 THEN THEY CAN NAVIGATE AND 742 00:25:56,719 --> 00:25:57,787 EXPLORE THE DATA ACCESS. 743 00:25:57,787 --> 00:25:59,222 MOST PEOPLE WANT TO DO IS FIGURE 744 00:25:59,222 --> 00:25:59,889 OUT WHAT'S THERE. 745 00:25:59,889 --> 00:26:01,224 THEY WANT TO CREATE COHORTS 746 00:26:01,224 --> 00:26:04,627 BASED ON WHAT THEY CARE ABOUT. 747 00:26:04,627 --> 00:26:05,561 OUR BIGGEST CHALLENGE IS THAT 748 00:26:05,561 --> 00:26:09,298 MOST PEOPLE DON'T KNOW WHAT 749 00:26:09,298 --> 00:26:11,534 QUESTIONS TO ASK RIGHT, IT'S AN 750 00:26:11,534 --> 00:26:12,468 ITERATIVE PROCESS, I DIDN'T KNOW 751 00:26:12,468 --> 00:26:14,771 YOU HAD THIS TOO, OR THAT. 752 00:26:14,771 --> 00:26:16,939 SO SEARCH SPACE FOR PEOPLE IS 753 00:26:16,939 --> 00:26:17,807 UNDEFINED, THATIA A CHAL ENK AND 754 00:26:17,807 --> 00:26:21,110 I WILL COME BACK TO THAT AT THE 755 00:26:21,110 --> 00:26:21,277 END. 756 00:26:21,277 --> 00:26:24,580 THE OTHER CHALLENGE A DATA CHEKS 757 00:26:24,580 --> 00:26:25,815 PROCESS IS VERY HETEROGENERATED 758 00:26:25,815 --> 00:26:27,784 A USE, SOME PEOPLE COLLECT FROM 759 00:26:27,784 --> 00:26:29,819 EHR, SOME PEOPLE HAVE 760 00:26:29,819 --> 00:26:31,287 INSTRUMENTS, CRFs THEY 761 00:26:31,287 --> 00:26:33,122 DESIGNED THEMSELVES, NOBODY 762 00:26:33,122 --> 00:26:34,624 ADOPTED A CENTRALIZED MODEL 763 00:26:34,624 --> 00:26:36,559 ACROSS ALL PEDIATRIC CANCERS AND 764 00:26:36,559 --> 00:26:38,261 STRUCTURAL BIRTH DEFECS SO WE 765 00:26:38,261 --> 00:26:39,562 HAD TO IMPLEMENT FRAMEWORKS THAT 766 00:26:39,562 --> 00:26:44,934 STILL ALLOWED A GENO TYPE TO 767 00:26:44,934 --> 00:26:45,334 PHENOTYPE CONNECK. 768 00:26:45,334 --> 00:26:47,136 YOU CAN IMAGINE SOMEONE LIKE ME 769 00:26:47,136 --> 00:26:48,671 WHO THINKS ABOUT BRAIN TUMORS, I 770 00:26:48,671 --> 00:26:50,106 NOTICE A KID HAS A BIRTH DEFECT 771 00:26:50,106 --> 00:26:54,210 IN THE HEART, I WILL SAY YEAH, A 772 00:26:54,210 --> 00:26:55,278 CARDIAC BIRTH DEFECT BUT A KID 773 00:26:55,278 --> 00:26:57,814 THAT MIGHT BE SEEN FOR A CARDIAC 774 00:26:57,814 --> 00:26:59,582 BERTH DEFECT WILL HAVE VERY WELL 775 00:26:59,582 --> 00:27:01,083 DEFINED WHICH PART OF THE HEART, 776 00:27:01,083 --> 00:27:04,821 WHAT TYPE OF DEFECT IT IS THOSE 777 00:27:04,821 --> 00:27:07,323 ARE DIFFERENT TERMINOLOGIES THAT 778 00:27:07,323 --> 00:27:07,924 WOULD NORMALLY INTERSECT BUT 779 00:27:07,924 --> 00:27:09,926 THEY WOULD HAVE THE SAME 780 00:27:09,926 --> 00:27:11,527 DPENETTIC BASIS AT THE GENOME 781 00:27:11,527 --> 00:27:14,330 LAYER SO YOU HAVE TO POWER THE 782 00:27:14,330 --> 00:27:14,864 CONNECTIVITY OF RESOURCES. 783 00:27:14,864 --> 00:27:16,232 AND WE DID THIS THROUGH 784 00:27:16,232 --> 00:27:19,435 LEVERAGING ONTOLOGIES IN WAYS 785 00:27:19,435 --> 00:27:21,237 THAT'S VERY VISIBLE. 786 00:27:21,237 --> 00:27:22,705 AND JUST FOR FUN I SAW I'M DOING 787 00:27:22,705 --> 00:27:25,641 THIS HERE, I WILL SHOW YOU AN 788 00:27:25,641 --> 00:27:30,112 EXAMPLE OF THIS, I THINK I'M 789 00:27:30,112 --> 00:27:33,149 LOGGING INTO THE INCLUDE 790 00:27:33,149 --> 00:27:34,350 PLATFORM HERE, I THINK? 791 00:27:34,350 --> 00:27:38,187 OKAY, HERE WE GO. 792 00:27:38,187 --> 00:27:40,823 SO I'LL DO A PHENOTYPIC SEARCH, 793 00:27:40,823 --> 00:27:42,225 I WILL CLICK ON PARTICIPANT AND 794 00:27:42,225 --> 00:27:44,727 I DO IT THROUGH A COUPLE 795 00:27:44,727 --> 00:27:46,295 DIFFERENT ONTOLOGIES, EITHER 796 00:27:46,295 --> 00:27:48,631 THROUGH DIAGNOSIS ONTOLOGY, 797 00:27:48,631 --> 00:27:50,800 CALLED MONDOOR, OR PHENOTYPIC 798 00:27:50,800 --> 00:27:56,539 ONTOLOGY, BUT LET'S JUST TRY 1, 799 00:27:56,539 --> 00:27:57,573 I CAN SEARCH FOR HEARING OTHERS 800 00:27:57,573 --> 00:27:57,773 RIGHT? 801 00:27:57,773 --> 00:27:59,609 SO YOU WILL SEE THIS TREE EXPAND 802 00:27:59,609 --> 00:28:02,612 AND WHAT YOU WILL SEE IS NUMBERS 803 00:28:02,612 --> 00:28:05,214 HERE ACROSS THIS, IS WHAT THIS 804 00:28:05,214 --> 00:28:06,749 MEANS ESSENTIALLY IS THAT ON THE 805 00:28:06,749 --> 00:28:08,618 LEFT HAND COLUMN, THAT'S THE 806 00:28:08,618 --> 00:28:10,720 EXACT WAY THAT SOMEONAN OITATED 807 00:28:10,720 --> 00:28:12,221 THAT PATIENT, RIGHT? 808 00:28:12,221 --> 00:28:14,557 THEY ACTUALLY ANNOTATED IT AT 809 00:28:14,557 --> 00:28:16,325 THAT LEVEL BUT AS YOU GO UP YOU 810 00:28:16,325 --> 00:28:17,693 WILL SEE THAT THE NUMBERS ON THE 811 00:28:17,693 --> 00:28:19,495 RIGHT GET BIGGER AND THAT'S 812 00:28:19,495 --> 00:28:23,299 BECAUSE WE'RE SUMMING UP, RIGHT, 813 00:28:23,299 --> 00:28:24,433 SPECIFIC PHENOTYPES WITH OUR 814 00:28:24,433 --> 00:28:26,369 LAST PHENOTYPES AND SOMEONE CAN 815 00:28:26,369 --> 00:28:31,707 TAKE THIS COHORT AND APPLY IT 816 00:28:31,707 --> 00:28:35,544 AND GET ALL 25, 2000 SUBJECTS IN 817 00:28:35,544 --> 00:28:36,512 THIS COHORT, BIOSPECIMENS THEY 818 00:28:36,512 --> 00:28:38,247 HAVE, WHAT DATA THEY HAVE AND 819 00:28:38,247 --> 00:28:41,350 THEN OPERATE ON THAT DATA MOVING 820 00:28:41,350 --> 00:28:42,585 FORWARD SO THEY CAN SELECT THIS 821 00:28:42,585 --> 00:28:45,755 DATA AND BRING IT INTO A CLOUD 822 00:28:45,755 --> 00:28:46,789 ENVIRONMENT AND ANALYZE IT I 823 00:28:46,789 --> 00:28:48,157 DON'T KNOW HOW MANY PEOPLE HERE 824 00:28:48,157 --> 00:28:50,960 HAVE EVER LOGGED ON TO A CLOUD 825 00:28:50,960 --> 00:28:53,262 TO ANALYZE GENOMIC DATA, 826 00:28:53,262 --> 00:28:55,464 HOPEFULLY SOME BUT IT TURNS OUT 827 00:28:55,464 --> 00:28:57,400 THAT'S NOT AS LARGE A GROUP OF 828 00:28:57,400 --> 00:28:59,201 PEOPLE AS PEOPLE WHO HAVE 829 00:28:59,201 --> 00:28:59,902 BENEFITS FROM SOMEONE WHO'S DONE 830 00:28:59,902 --> 00:29:01,404 THAT ALREADY AND CREATED AN 831 00:29:01,404 --> 00:29:04,040 EXCEL SHEET FOR THEM WITH ALL 832 00:29:04,040 --> 00:29:04,974 THE INFORMATION IN THERE. 833 00:29:04,974 --> 00:29:06,976 THE KEY PART IS YOU HAVE TO HAVE 834 00:29:06,976 --> 00:29:08,244 A CENTRALIZED ENVIRONMENT FOR 835 00:29:08,244 --> 00:29:13,683 ANALYSIS, IN ORDER TO MAKE 836 00:29:13,683 --> 00:29:15,117 SHAREABLE EXCEL SHEETS THAT 837 00:29:15,117 --> 00:29:15,751 INTEGRATE HARMONIZED DAILY BASIS 838 00:29:15,751 --> 00:29:19,422 THEA BECAUSE YOU WANT THE NEXT 839 00:29:19,422 --> 00:29:20,723 PERSON'S NOT INCLUDED TO ADD 840 00:29:20,723 --> 00:29:21,924 THEIR DATA INTO YOUR EXCEL SHEET 841 00:29:21,924 --> 00:29:23,459 ISSUES THE OHM WAY THEY CAN DO 842 00:29:23,459 --> 00:29:25,194 THAT IF THEY EARN THE SAME 843 00:29:25,194 --> 00:29:26,395 PIPELINE, WORK FLOWS TO 844 00:29:26,395 --> 00:29:27,096 INTERSECT. 845 00:29:27,096 --> 00:29:28,597 SO THE PLATFORM LEVERAGES TO 846 00:29:28,597 --> 00:29:31,667 CLOUD NOT JUST BECAUSE THE DATA 847 00:29:31,667 --> 00:29:33,402 ARE LARGE BUT BECAUSE A CLOUD IS 848 00:29:33,402 --> 00:29:35,938 A FRAMEWORK FOR HARMONIZATION 849 00:29:35,938 --> 00:29:37,340 AND INTEGRATION OF DATA EVEN IF 850 00:29:37,340 --> 00:29:39,208 THE DATA ARE SMALL, YOU CAN 851 00:29:39,208 --> 00:29:41,811 CONNECT TO AND BE CONTEXTUALIZED 852 00:29:41,811 --> 00:29:52,288 IN THE CONTEXT IN THE LONGER 853 00:29:56,926 --> 00:29:57,226 TERM. 854 00:29:57,226 --> 00:30:01,964 I PUT THIS SLY UP SO YOU CAN SEE 855 00:30:01,964 --> 00:30:03,532 THE CASE, YOU CAN ALSO DO THIS 856 00:30:03,532 --> 00:30:05,034 FROM THE GENOMIC SIDE AND THE 857 00:30:05,034 --> 00:30:06,435 GENOMIC SIDE IS A REAL EXCITING 858 00:30:06,435 --> 00:30:10,406 FRAIRM WORK BECAUSE IT TURNS OUT 859 00:30:10,406 --> 00:30:13,743 THAT IF YOU PUT A GENE OF 860 00:30:13,743 --> 00:30:15,711 INTEREST BECAUSE OF THE WAY THAT 861 00:30:15,711 --> 00:30:16,979 THE FRAMEWORK IS STRUCTURED, YOU 862 00:30:16,979 --> 00:30:18,647 WILL IMMEDIATELY FIND THAT THAT 863 00:30:18,647 --> 00:30:20,716 JEEP IS IMPLICATED POTENTIAL IN 864 00:30:20,716 --> 00:30:23,185 MANY OTHER CONTEXT YOU WERE NOT 865 00:30:23,185 --> 00:30:24,920 INTERESTED IN, RIGHT, BIOLOGY IS 866 00:30:24,920 --> 00:30:25,621 SUFFICIENTLY CONSERVATIVE THAT 867 00:30:25,621 --> 00:30:27,423 YOU WILL SEE THESE COMBINATIONS 868 00:30:27,423 --> 00:30:28,791 OF PHENOTYPES AND GENO TYPES 869 00:30:28,791 --> 00:30:30,292 THAT OVERLAP, AND THAT'S A 870 00:30:30,292 --> 00:30:34,330 POWERFUL FRAMEWORK TO BEGIN 871 00:30:34,330 --> 00:30:37,933 PRIORITIZING WHICH GENES MATTER 872 00:30:37,933 --> 00:30:41,370 FOR YOU OR SOMEBODY ELSE, IF 873 00:30:41,370 --> 00:30:44,040 SOMEONE WITH DOWNS SYNDROME HAS 874 00:30:44,040 --> 00:30:45,541 A CERTAIN PHENOTYPE, ANOTHER 1 875 00:30:45,541 --> 00:30:47,176 DOESN'T HAVE THAT CERTAIN 876 00:30:47,176 --> 00:30:47,810 PHENOTYPE, YOU AREN'T 877 00:30:47,810 --> 00:30:49,278 NECESSARILY THINKING ABOUT DOWNS 878 00:30:49,278 --> 00:30:50,846 SYNDROME BUT 1 OF THEM HAD 879 00:30:50,846 --> 00:30:54,250 HEARING LOSS OR DIDN'T ISSUES IT 880 00:30:54,250 --> 00:30:56,786 STARTS OVERLAPPING WITH YOUR 881 00:30:56,786 --> 00:30:59,388 SPECIFIC INTEREST IN THE 882 00:30:59,388 --> 00:31:00,689 PHENOTYPE GENETIC CONTEXT. 883 00:31:00,689 --> 00:31:04,226 GANNA, SHARE WITH YOU THE HARD 884 00:31:04,226 --> 00:31:04,427 PARTS. 885 00:31:04,427 --> 00:31:07,730 THE HARD PARTS ARE THAT THE 886 00:31:07,730 --> 00:31:10,433 OPPORTUNITY FOR DATA GENERATION 887 00:31:10,433 --> 00:31:11,667 HAVE EXPONENTIALLY GROWN SO WE 888 00:31:11,667 --> 00:31:19,442 CAN GENERATE DATA ON SAMPLES IN 889 00:31:19,442 --> 00:31:23,712 AN INCREASINGLY LONG RAINCHL, WE 890 00:31:23,712 --> 00:31:24,380 CAN SHORTEN, LEPGHTEN, CREATE 891 00:31:24,380 --> 00:31:26,849 EACH OF THOSE AND THEY EACH OF 892 00:31:26,849 --> 00:31:28,184 THOSE LAYERS HAS ANOTHER 5 OR 6 893 00:31:28,184 --> 00:31:30,319 LAYERS THAT THE GENOME CAN BE 894 00:31:30,319 --> 00:31:31,253 DUPLICATED OR TRANSLOCATED OR 895 00:31:31,253 --> 00:31:34,723 HAVE A SINGLE PULL MUTATION FOR 896 00:31:34,723 --> 00:31:35,791 THE EXPONENTIAL COMPLEXITY 897 00:31:35,791 --> 00:31:38,327 ACROSS EACH DATA MODALITY AND 898 00:31:38,327 --> 00:31:40,296 EACH LAYER OF INTERPRETATION, IT 899 00:31:40,296 --> 00:31:44,133 TURNS OUT THAT PROTEOMISTS, 900 00:31:44,133 --> 00:31:47,203 DON'T TYPICALLY STUDY GENOMES, 901 00:31:47,203 --> 00:31:49,705 AND GENOMISTS DON'T TYPICALLY 902 00:31:49,705 --> 00:31:51,073 STUDY PROTEOMES. 903 00:31:51,073 --> 00:31:55,744 EVEN IN GENOMICS SPACE PEOPLE 904 00:31:55,744 --> 00:31:58,214 STUDY RNASEQ VERSUS OTHER DATA 905 00:31:58,214 --> 00:31:59,014 MODALITIES AND HISTORICALLY 906 00:31:59,014 --> 00:31:59,982 THAT'S LED TO PLATFOR THE 907 00:31:59,982 --> 00:32:03,119 PURPOSES THAT ARE DATA MODALITY 908 00:32:03,119 --> 00:32:03,786 SPECIFIC. 909 00:32:03,786 --> 00:32:05,621 PREVENTING MULTIMODAL ANALYSIS 910 00:32:05,621 --> 00:32:08,924 FROM FULLY GETTING TO A WORK 911 00:32:08,924 --> 00:32:09,125 SPACE. 912 00:32:09,125 --> 00:32:11,393 EVEN WORSE IS WHEN YOU ADD THE 913 00:32:11,393 --> 00:32:12,661 DIVERSITY OF CLINICAL DATA AND 914 00:32:12,661 --> 00:32:13,729 EVEN WORSE IT TURNS OUT THERE 915 00:32:13,729 --> 00:32:18,100 ARE NOT A LOT OF NEUROSURGEONS 916 00:32:18,100 --> 00:32:20,169 WHO SPENT 17 YEARS TO BECOME A 917 00:32:20,169 --> 00:32:21,470 NURSE OR WHO ALSO SPENT 918 00:32:21,470 --> 00:32:24,540 ADDITIONAL YEARS TO BECOME A 919 00:32:24,540 --> 00:32:25,641 DIOINFORMATICIAN, SO THEY SPEAK 920 00:32:25,641 --> 00:32:26,575 COMPLETELY DIFFERENT LANGUAGES 921 00:32:26,575 --> 00:32:27,643 FROM THE CLENICAL END PUCTURE 922 00:32:27,643 --> 00:32:28,944 YOU'RE TRYING TO HELP AND THE 923 00:32:28,944 --> 00:32:31,213 DATA LANDSCAPE AND THEY ASK 924 00:32:31,213 --> 00:32:32,414 QUESTIONS VERY DIFFERENTLY, IT'S 925 00:32:32,414 --> 00:32:34,717 VERY CHALLENGING TO CREATE A 926 00:32:34,717 --> 00:32:36,018 FARM WORK THAT'S BOTH POINT AND 927 00:32:36,018 --> 00:32:39,522 CLICK FOR SOMEONE WHO'S NOT A 928 00:32:39,522 --> 00:32:40,456 DATA SCIENTIST AND, RIGHT, 929 00:32:40,456 --> 00:32:45,594 COMMAND LEAN AND USER INTERFACE 930 00:32:45,594 --> 00:32:46,262 FRIENDLY FOR BIOINFORMATICIANS. 931 00:32:46,262 --> 00:32:48,631 THIS IS STILL AN ONGOING PROCESS 932 00:32:48,631 --> 00:32:49,632 FOR US. 933 00:32:49,632 --> 00:32:53,169 LET ME GIVE YOU A COUPLE MORE 934 00:32:53,169 --> 00:32:55,137 ENDING SLIDES AS ADDITIONAL 935 00:32:55,137 --> 00:32:56,705 CONTEXT OF WHERE WE'RE TRYING TO 936 00:32:56,705 --> 00:33:00,676 HEAD. 937 00:33:00,676 --> 00:33:02,745 KIDS FIRST BEGAN WITH WITH 938 00:33:02,745 --> 00:33:05,514 COHORTS THAT HAD BEEN CREATED BY 939 00:33:05,514 --> 00:33:07,283 VERY LONGS, AND THE GOAL WAS TO 940 00:33:07,283 --> 00:33:09,285 CREATE A SINGLE POINT IN TIME 941 00:33:09,285 --> 00:33:10,886 OMIC DATABASE THAT'S LINKED TO 942 00:33:10,886 --> 00:33:12,922 THE EXISTING PHENOTYPES. 943 00:33:12,922 --> 00:33:16,325 IN REALITY, RIGHT, PHENOTYPES 944 00:33:16,325 --> 00:33:16,992 CHANGE ACROSS TIME. 945 00:33:16,992 --> 00:33:19,762 AND SO WE MIGHT HAVE GOTTEN A 946 00:33:19,762 --> 00:33:22,731 SNAPSHOT OF THAT PATIENT OF 947 00:33:22,731 --> 00:33:26,268 WHATEVER TIME THEY WERE, 948 00:33:26,268 --> 00:33:27,803 COLLECTED THE SESMLE AND 949 00:33:27,803 --> 00:33:29,872 ADJUDICATE FOR THIS PURPOSE BUT 950 00:33:29,872 --> 00:33:31,173 INVARIABLILY THE MINUTE SOMEONE 951 00:33:31,173 --> 00:33:32,141 HAS A FINDING, THE NEXT QUESTION 952 00:33:32,141 --> 00:33:34,543 THEY'RE GOING TO ASK IS WELL, 953 00:33:34,543 --> 00:33:35,244 WHAT HAPPENED INCOME ACCIDENT 954 00:33:35,244 --> 00:33:36,345 WHAT WERE THEY TREATED WITH, 955 00:33:36,345 --> 00:33:38,781 WHAT WERE THE OUTCOMES AND IT 956 00:33:38,781 --> 00:33:40,282 URNS OUT THESE COMMUNITIES ALSO 957 00:33:40,282 --> 00:33:41,483 ASK QUESTIONS IN VERY DIFFERENT 958 00:33:41,483 --> 00:33:45,721 WAYS, RIGHT IN THE PEOPLE WHO 959 00:33:45,721 --> 00:33:46,322 ARE CLINICAL INFORMATTISTICS, 960 00:33:46,322 --> 00:33:48,991 WHOSE BREAD AND BUTTER RIGHT, IS 961 00:33:48,991 --> 00:33:50,059 COLLECTING CLINICAL DATA FROM 962 00:33:50,059 --> 00:33:51,694 THE HEALTH RECORS AND CREATING 963 00:33:51,694 --> 00:33:52,895 THIS FRAMEWORK, THEY CREATE 964 00:33:52,895 --> 00:33:55,965 INFRASTRUCTURES THAT ARE 965 00:33:55,965 --> 00:33:57,733 TYPICALLY SEGREGATED FROM 966 00:33:57,733 --> 00:33:59,368 MOLECULAR DATA SETS, INTEGRATING 967 00:33:59,368 --> 00:34:01,136 THOSE INTO A COMMON CONTEXT IS 968 00:34:01,136 --> 00:34:02,638 STILL A NEW ENDEAVOR FOR MOST OF 969 00:34:02,638 --> 00:34:04,740 THE SCIENCE BECAUSE A GENOME 970 00:34:04,740 --> 00:34:06,709 CYSTS OF DATA AS POINT IF TIME, 971 00:34:06,709 --> 00:34:08,010 YOU ONLY HAVE 1 GENOME, YOU 972 00:34:08,010 --> 00:34:10,446 MIGHT GET LUCK EXPE HAVE 2 973 00:34:10,446 --> 00:34:11,614 SAMPLES COLLECTED IN TIME IF 974 00:34:11,614 --> 00:34:14,250 THERE WAS A RECURRENCE, WE MIGHT 975 00:34:14,250 --> 00:34:16,919 GET LUCKIER IF WE HAD A LIQUID 976 00:34:16,919 --> 00:34:18,554 DAILY BASIS THEA BIOPSY BUT IT'S 977 00:34:18,554 --> 00:34:20,055 NOT A TREME LIKE HEALTHCARE IS 978 00:34:20,055 --> 00:34:21,924 IN THE CONTEXT BUT THE MINUTE WE 979 00:34:21,924 --> 00:34:23,425 FIND ANYTHING, THE ONCOLOGIST 980 00:34:23,425 --> 00:34:24,927 ASKS WHAT WERE THEY TREATED 981 00:34:24,927 --> 00:34:26,262 WITH, FOR HOW LONG WERE THEY 982 00:34:26,262 --> 00:34:27,763 TREATED TOGETHER WITH THOSE 983 00:34:27,763 --> 00:34:28,597 SAMPLES SO WE'RE STARTING TO 984 00:34:28,597 --> 00:34:30,499 THINK ABOUT HOW TO CREATE THESE 985 00:34:30,499 --> 00:34:32,201 VIEWS, SO THIS IS A VIEW OF A 986 00:34:32,201 --> 00:34:35,571 PATIENT WHERE YOU'RE ANNOTATING 987 00:34:35,571 --> 00:34:36,405 SAMPLE COLLECTIONS ACROSS TIME 988 00:34:36,405 --> 00:34:38,140 BECAUSE THE PATIENT HAS 989 00:34:38,140 --> 00:34:39,208 RECURRENCE, WHICH DRUGS THEY 990 00:34:39,208 --> 00:34:41,176 WERE RECEIVING BECAUSE YOU 991 00:34:41,176 --> 00:34:41,910 SUSPECTED DRUGS INTERSECT WITH 992 00:34:41,910 --> 00:34:47,416 THE BIOLOGY OF THE TUMOR AND 993 00:34:47,416 --> 00:34:47,650 PATIENT. 994 00:34:47,650 --> 00:34:50,853 AND OTHER ENCOUNTER EVENTS LIKE 995 00:34:50,853 --> 00:34:51,553 IMAGES, MRIs OR PATHOLOGY 996 00:34:51,553 --> 00:34:54,556 EVENTS AND YOU CAN SEE THAT THE 997 00:34:54,556 --> 00:34:56,058 DATA GETS MORE COMPLICATED RIGHT 998 00:34:56,058 --> 00:34:57,059 HERE, EACH OF THESE NUMBERS ON 999 00:34:57,059 --> 00:34:58,394 THE LEFT IS A SAMPLE AND IT 1000 00:34:58,394 --> 00:35:06,402 TURNS OUT THAT THE TUMOR CHANGES 1001 00:35:06,402 --> 00:35:08,470 ACROSS TIME YOU ONLY GET THE 1002 00:35:08,470 --> 00:35:11,507 MUTATION AND THE SAMPLE DOESN'T 1003 00:35:11,507 --> 00:35:13,409 EXIST ON TABLE 1, 2, OR 3, AND 1004 00:35:13,409 --> 00:35:15,611 WHAT DO YOU DO WITH THAT, MOST 1005 00:35:15,611 --> 00:35:17,913 CLINICAL PRACTICES DON'T HAVE AN 1006 00:35:17,913 --> 00:35:20,049 ANSWER FOR THAT CAN THAT'S THE 1007 00:35:20,049 --> 00:35:21,817 OTHER CHALLENGE. 1008 00:35:21,817 --> 00:35:25,120 OUR CAPACITY TO GENERATE AND 1009 00:35:25,120 --> 00:35:26,755 INTERPRET DATA HAS OUT STRIPPED 1010 00:35:26,755 --> 00:35:27,856 THE CLINICAL CAPACITY TO SAY IF 1011 00:35:27,856 --> 00:35:30,693 I HAVE THIS, I DO THAT. 1012 00:35:30,693 --> 00:35:32,528 HOSPITAL SYSTEMS BY AND LARNL 1013 00:35:32,528 --> 00:35:35,030 ARE BUILT AS A BINARY FRAMEWORK, 1014 00:35:35,030 --> 00:35:36,198 YOU'RE POSITIVE FOR SOMETHING, 1015 00:35:36,198 --> 00:35:37,299 YOU'RE NEGATIVE FOR SOMETHING, 1016 00:35:37,299 --> 00:35:40,002 IF THIS OCCURS, YOU GET THIS. 1017 00:35:40,002 --> 00:35:40,803 SUDDENLY BIOMEDICAL HEALTH AND 1018 00:35:40,803 --> 00:35:42,805 GENERATING DAILY BASIS THEA 1019 00:35:42,805 --> 00:35:44,440 THAT'S NOT BINARY IN THAT 1020 00:35:44,440 --> 00:35:49,611 CONTEXT, AND THIS IS WHAT WHERE 1021 00:35:49,611 --> 00:35:50,346 PRECISION MEDICINE THRIVES. 1022 00:35:50,346 --> 00:35:52,381 I HAVE NOT YET BEEN TO A SINGLE 1023 00:35:52,381 --> 00:35:58,620 HOSPITAL THAT CAN ASK THE 1024 00:35:58,620 --> 00:35:59,688 FOLLOWING QUESTION: LET'S TAKE 1025 00:35:59,688 --> 00:36:01,323 BRAIN TUMORS AS A CONTEXT. 1026 00:36:01,323 --> 00:36:03,058 SHOW ME ALL BRAIN TUMORS I HAVE 1027 00:36:03,058 --> 00:36:04,593 TREATED THROUGH MY EPIC 1028 00:36:04,593 --> 00:36:06,195 INTERFACE THAT LOOK LIKE THIS 1029 00:36:06,195 --> 00:36:06,562 PATIENT? 1030 00:36:06,562 --> 00:36:08,197 AND LOOK LIKE THIS PATIENT COULD 1031 00:36:08,197 --> 00:36:09,865 BE THEIR MRI LOOKS THE SAME, 1032 00:36:09,865 --> 00:36:11,433 OUTCOME WAS THE SAME, MOLECULAR 1033 00:36:11,433 --> 00:36:14,403 DATA SET WAS THE SAME, THIS IS 1034 00:36:14,403 --> 00:36:18,006 THE KEY CHALLENGE THAT PRECISION 1035 00:36:18,006 --> 00:36:18,674 MEDICINE'S TRANALATION REQUIRES 1036 00:36:18,674 --> 00:36:24,713 INFRANCIS 1037 00:36:24,713 --> 00:36:25,848 IN--INFRASTRUCTURE THAT'S 1038 00:36:25,848 --> 00:36:26,882 COMPUTATIONALLY LINKED. 1039 00:36:26,882 --> 00:36:29,118 RIGHT NOW IT'S OPERATIONALLY 1040 00:36:29,118 --> 00:36:30,953 DRIVEN, NOT ANALYTICALLY EMPLOY 1041 00:36:30,953 --> 00:36:32,287 THE ANALYSIS HAPPENS IN THE 1042 00:36:32,287 --> 00:36:33,522 DOCTOR'S HEAD BASED ON WHAT THEY 1043 00:36:33,522 --> 00:36:36,492 KNOW, REMEMBER AND EXPERIENCE. 1044 00:36:36,492 --> 00:36:37,860 PRECISION MEDICINE REQUIRES THAT 1045 00:36:37,860 --> 00:36:40,295 NEXT LAYER OF INTERACTIONS 1046 00:36:40,295 --> 00:36:41,163 BETWEEN THAT PATIENT'S DATA 1047 00:36:41,163 --> 00:36:43,232 WHICH SUDDEN LOAMACYY IS MORE 1048 00:36:43,232 --> 00:36:46,135 COMPLEX, PART OF IT'S NOT 1049 00:36:46,135 --> 00:36:47,169 INTERPRETTAABLE BUT MIGHT BE 1050 00:36:47,169 --> 00:36:47,936 TOMORROW WHEN THE NEXT PATIENT 1051 00:36:47,936 --> 00:36:51,140 COMES ALONG AND LOOKS LIKE THAT 1052 00:36:51,140 --> 00:36:52,808 PATIENT, YOU HAVE THE FRAMEWORK 1053 00:36:52,808 --> 00:36:54,410 OF ANALYSIS AROUND PATIENTS SO 1054 00:36:54,410 --> 00:36:55,310 THAT CLINICIANS CAN INTERPRET 1055 00:36:55,310 --> 00:36:59,148 THEM IN THAT SETTING. 1056 00:36:59,148 --> 00:37:00,516 BUT THAT'S AN EXCITING ENDEAVOR 1057 00:37:00,516 --> 00:37:02,317 TO THINK ABOUT THEPABILITY OF 1058 00:37:02,317 --> 00:37:05,320 LARGE SCALE DATA SETS AND 1059 00:37:05,320 --> 00:37:06,422 INFRASTRUCTURE CREATED FOR 1060 00:37:06,422 --> 00:37:07,055 RESEARCH BECOME PROXIMAL TO 1061 00:37:07,055 --> 00:37:07,256 CARE. 1062 00:37:07,256 --> 00:37:09,057 AND I THINK THAT'S 1 OF THE 1063 00:37:09,057 --> 00:37:10,292 HARDEST LESSONS I LEARNED. 1064 00:37:10,292 --> 00:37:16,698 IT TURNS OUT THAT IF YOU ASK ANY 1065 00:37:16,698 --> 00:37:18,534 PAIBT ON OUR CLINICAL TRIALS OR 1066 00:37:18,534 --> 00:37:20,769 FOR WHICH YOU COLLECT SAMPLES, 1067 00:37:20,769 --> 00:37:21,470 THEY'RE NOT DIFFERENTIATING 1068 00:37:21,470 --> 00:37:24,239 BETWEEN TUMOR RESEARCH AND CARE, 1069 00:37:24,239 --> 00:37:24,440 RIGHT? 1070 00:37:24,440 --> 00:37:27,476 A MOTHER WHO'S CHILD HAS A BRAIN 1071 00:37:27,476 --> 00:37:28,544 TUMOR, RIGHT, THE CONTRACT SHE 1072 00:37:28,544 --> 00:37:29,778 HAS WITH US AS SCIENTISTS IS, 1073 00:37:29,778 --> 00:37:32,448 YOU ARE DOING EVERYTHING THAT'S 1074 00:37:32,448 --> 00:37:37,453 POSSIBLE TO ADVANCE THE 1075 00:37:37,453 --> 00:37:38,887 POTENTIAL FOR NEW THERAPY, SO 1076 00:37:38,887 --> 00:37:40,155 SUDDENLY YOU GET THIS 1077 00:37:40,155 --> 00:37:42,024 REQUIREMENT FOR RESEARCH TO BE 1078 00:37:42,024 --> 00:37:43,725 EXTREMELY CLOSE AND PROXIMAL TO 1079 00:37:43,725 --> 00:37:46,628 CARE IN THE ABSENCE OF 1080 00:37:46,628 --> 00:37:47,196 POTENTIALLY ESTABLISHED 1081 00:37:47,196 --> 00:37:49,398 STANDARDS OF CARE, RIGHT FOR 1082 00:37:49,398 --> 00:37:50,699 MANY DISEASES, YOU DON'T HAVE A 1083 00:37:50,699 --> 00:37:53,101 STANDARD OF CARE, WE HAVE A 1084 00:37:53,101 --> 00:37:54,970 THERAPEUTIC OFF THE SHELF MENU. 1085 00:37:54,970 --> 00:37:56,839 EMPOWERING THAT IS WHAT PARENTS 1086 00:37:56,839 --> 00:37:57,806 AND PATIENTS WANT, THAT'S WHAT 1087 00:37:57,806 --> 00:38:01,043 WE HAVE TO BUILD ON BEHALF OF 1088 00:38:01,043 --> 00:38:01,677 THESE RESEARCH FRAMEWORKS, WHILE 1089 00:38:01,677 --> 00:38:12,187 AT THE SAME TIME WE'RE DRIVING 1090 00:38:13,589 --> 00:38:14,323 RESEARCH. 1091 00:38:14,323 --> 00:38:17,926 THE OTHER INCREDIBLY INFORMATIVE 1092 00:38:17,926 --> 00:38:20,863 PART OF MY STUDIES WAS THAT I 1093 00:38:20,863 --> 00:38:22,364 WILL HAVE IMAGES, FEATURES 1094 00:38:22,364 --> 00:38:24,666 ACCIDENT EACH COMMUNITY THINKS 1095 00:38:24,666 --> 00:38:25,834 ABOUT DATA DIFFERENTLY, HOW IT'S 1096 00:38:25,834 --> 00:38:26,502 STRUCTURED AND THE INFORMATION 1097 00:38:26,502 --> 00:38:28,337 THAT GOES INTO IT, I THOUGHT IT 1098 00:38:28,337 --> 00:38:29,304 WAS WORTH WHILE ESPECIALLY HERE 1099 00:38:29,304 --> 00:38:31,373 TO BRING A LAYER THAT'S ALMOST 1100 00:38:31,373 --> 00:38:36,144 ALWAYS ABSENT FROM THE DATA SETS 1101 00:38:36,144 --> 00:38:37,012 WE GET. 1102 00:38:37,012 --> 00:38:39,915 WHEN A RADIOLOGIST LOOKS AT AN 1103 00:38:39,915 --> 00:38:42,985 MRI OR A HISTOLOGIST LOOKS AT A 1104 00:38:42,985 --> 00:38:45,621 HISTOLOGY SLIDE, THEY BECOME 1105 00:38:45,621 --> 00:38:45,954 STORY TELLERS. 1106 00:38:45,954 --> 00:38:49,091 THEY WRITE THESE VERY LONG 1107 00:38:49,091 --> 00:38:49,391 NARRATIVES. 1108 00:38:49,391 --> 00:38:49,591 RIGHT? 1109 00:38:49,591 --> 00:38:50,759 WHEN AN ONCOLOGIST WRITES A PLAN 1110 00:38:50,759 --> 00:38:52,294 FOR A PEASHT'S CARE, THEY WRITE 1111 00:38:52,294 --> 00:39:00,536 A STORY FOR THAT PATIENT. 1112 00:39:00,536 --> 00:39:01,904 IT'S EMBEDDED IN THE CARE IS 1113 00:39:01,904 --> 00:39:04,239 ABSENT FOR MOST OF OUR DATA, MY 1114 00:39:04,239 --> 00:39:05,307 COORDINATOR WILL LOOK AT THIS, 1115 00:39:05,307 --> 00:39:07,576 PICK UP A COUPLE OF WORDS AND 1116 00:39:07,576 --> 00:39:10,479 PUT THEM INTO MY DATABASE THAT'S 1117 00:39:10,479 --> 00:39:14,049 MISSING THIS FROM THE DATA LET 1118 00:39:14,049 --> 00:39:21,690 ALONE WHEN WE FIRST STARTED 1119 00:39:21,690 --> 00:39:23,191 TRYING TO TAKE AND PUT IT IN THE 1120 00:39:23,191 --> 00:39:25,460 SAME PLACE FOR THE GENOMICS 1121 00:39:25,460 --> 00:39:26,662 DATA, NO RADIOLOGIST TOUCHED 1122 00:39:26,662 --> 00:39:27,095 THEM. 1123 00:39:27,095 --> 00:39:28,830 IT TURNS OUT THAT JUST EACH THE 1124 00:39:28,830 --> 00:39:31,166 WAY THE FILES ARE STRUCTURED, 1125 00:39:31,166 --> 00:39:33,168 HOW THEY'RE COMBINED, 1126 00:39:33,168 --> 00:39:34,836 RADIOLOGIST EXPECTS A SERIES OF 1127 00:39:34,836 --> 00:39:36,004 SESSIONS RIGHT WHICH SCAN DID 1128 00:39:36,004 --> 00:39:39,875 THEY GET ALL AT 1 TIME SO EACH 1129 00:39:39,875 --> 00:39:40,809 PATIENT FOR A SINGLE EXPERIMENT 1130 00:39:40,809 --> 00:39:49,785 MIGHT HAVE HUNDREDS OF SESSIONS 1131 00:39:49,785 --> 00:39:52,554 FILES A GENOMISTS XEBS TO SEE 2 1132 00:39:52,554 --> 00:39:54,656 OR 3. 1133 00:39:54,656 --> 00:39:56,158 A DENATIONAL LIBRARY OF MEDICINE 1134 00:39:56,158 --> 00:39:57,492 CYST WORKS ON THE FILE AND HOW 1135 00:39:57,492 --> 00:39:58,560 THEY'RE AVAILABLE FOR COMMUNITY 1136 00:39:58,560 --> 00:40:00,128 AND REQUIRES A COMMON SET OF 1137 00:40:00,128 --> 00:40:00,896 INFRASTRUCTURES TO WORK TOGETHER 1138 00:40:00,896 --> 00:40:05,400 AND SO WE STARTED CATERING TO 1139 00:40:05,400 --> 00:40:07,536 THAT AND SAYING WHICH PLATFORMS 1140 00:40:07,536 --> 00:40:08,937 HAVE RADIOLOGISTS HAVE THEM ON 1141 00:40:08,937 --> 00:40:10,606 THEM, LET'S BRENG THEM IN, BUT 1142 00:40:10,606 --> 00:40:11,974 WHETHER YOU LEARN THAT LESSON IN 1143 00:40:11,974 --> 00:40:13,842 THE PAST, WE DON'T WANT 1144 00:40:13,842 --> 00:40:14,443 THEERATEIOLOGYIST WORKS IN 1 1145 00:40:14,443 --> 00:40:16,078 PLACE AND THE GENTLEMEN WORKS IN 1146 00:40:16,078 --> 00:40:18,013 ANOTHER, THEY WILL MAKE THEIR 1147 00:40:18,013 --> 00:40:18,947 SEPARATE DISCOVERIES AND NEVER 1148 00:40:18,947 --> 00:40:19,147 TALK. 1149 00:40:19,147 --> 00:40:22,384 WE HAVE TO MAKE THE PLATFORMS 1150 00:40:22,384 --> 00:40:23,585 ACTUALLY HAVE NOTIONS OF 1151 00:40:23,585 --> 00:40:31,526 COMBINED PROGECS IN A COMMON 1152 00:40:31,526 --> 00:40:34,396 PLACE, CREATE WORK FLOWS, CREATE 1153 00:40:34,396 --> 00:40:37,399 GENERATED SETTIC DATA AND 1154 00:40:37,399 --> 00:40:38,533 ROUTING THAT ENTIRE DATA TO 1155 00:40:38,533 --> 00:40:46,375 CREATE THE SHARED PROJECT BUT 1156 00:40:46,375 --> 00:40:48,143 THE RESULTS CAN BE INTEGRATED 1157 00:40:48,143 --> 00:40:52,614 FOR ANALYSIS IN A COMMON WORK 1158 00:40:52,614 --> 00:40:52,814 SPACE. 1159 00:40:52,814 --> 00:40:56,184 I THOUGHT GENOMICS AND DATA 1160 00:40:56,184 --> 00:40:57,919 ANALYTICS WAS HARD, IT WASN'T 1161 00:40:57,919 --> 00:41:00,222 UNTIL WE TRIED EXPANDING OUR 1162 00:41:00,222 --> 00:41:01,657 FOOTPRINT ARK ROUND CLINICAL 1163 00:41:01,657 --> 00:41:04,326 DATA THAT WE REALIZED HOW HARD 1164 00:41:04,326 --> 00:41:06,628 CLINICAL VARIABLES ACTUALLY ARE, 1165 00:41:06,628 --> 00:41:08,463 I MENTIONED OUR GOAL WAS TO SAY 1166 00:41:08,463 --> 00:41:10,666 RECOGNIZING THE CLINICAL DATA IS 1167 00:41:10,666 --> 00:41:12,067 CONTINUOUS, A BRAIN TUMOR 1168 00:41:12,067 --> 00:41:21,510 PATIENT MIGHT HAVE SURGERY TWICE 1169 00:41:21,510 --> 00:41:22,244 AND CREATE THE FILE. 1170 00:41:22,244 --> 00:41:24,913 HOW DO WE CREATE THE REAL 1171 00:41:24,913 --> 00:41:26,515 FRAMEWORK OF DATA FLOW. 1172 00:41:26,515 --> 00:41:27,949 UP UNTIL NOW MOST PEOPLE DO IT 1173 00:41:27,949 --> 00:41:29,217 IN A HUMAN WAY. 1174 00:41:29,217 --> 00:41:31,520 WHAT I MEAN BY THAT IS LITERALLY 1175 00:41:31,520 --> 00:41:33,488 HUMAN, LOOKING AT THE EPIC OR 1176 00:41:33,488 --> 00:41:34,890 ELECTRONIC HELT RECORANDS 1177 00:41:34,890 --> 00:41:36,725 COPYING AND PASTING OR WRITING 1178 00:41:36,725 --> 00:41:38,660 INFORMATION THAT THEY SEE THERE 1179 00:41:38,660 --> 00:41:40,762 AND TURNINGS OUT HUMANS ARE 1180 00:41:40,762 --> 00:41:47,903 PRETTY CRAPY AT THAT AT SCALE, 1181 00:41:47,903 --> 00:41:48,403 HUMANS MAKE MISTAKES. 1182 00:41:48,403 --> 00:41:50,238 THE ONLY WAY TO COMBAT THAT IS 1183 00:41:50,238 --> 00:41:55,544 TO HAVE RECOLLECT HUMANS CHECK 1184 00:41:55,544 --> 00:41:57,179 THEIR ERRORS AND COMBAT THAT. 1185 00:41:57,179 --> 00:41:59,214 OVER THE PAST 10 YEARS 1186 00:41:59,214 --> 00:42:02,350 ESSENTIALLY BETWEEN THE 1187 00:42:02,350 --> 00:42:04,186 HIGH-TECH ACT OF 2009 AND UNDER 1188 00:42:04,186 --> 00:42:05,921 THE OBAMA ADMINISTRATION AND 1189 00:42:05,921 --> 00:42:07,456 LAST YEAR WITH THE NONBLOCKING 1190 00:42:07,456 --> 00:42:10,092 RULE OF THE NATIONAL OFFICE OF 1191 00:42:10,092 --> 00:42:11,727 THE CONTROLLER COORDINATOR 1192 00:42:11,727 --> 00:42:13,462 THERE'S BEEN A TRANSFORMATION IN 1193 00:42:13,462 --> 00:42:15,097 THINKING ABOUT HEALTHCARE DATA 1194 00:42:15,097 --> 00:42:17,265 IS STRUCTURED, MANY OF YOU MAY 1195 00:42:17,265 --> 00:42:18,667 HAVE YOUR IPHONES CONNEBBED TO 1196 00:42:18,667 --> 00:42:26,208 YOUR MY HEALTH APP, THAT'S 1197 00:42:26,208 --> 00:42:28,944 REQUIRED FOR THOSE STATEMENTS 1198 00:42:28,944 --> 00:42:32,280 AND DATA TO COME OUT IN AN 1199 00:42:32,280 --> 00:42:32,714 OVERQUAL FBIED WAY. 1200 00:42:32,714 --> 00:42:33,849 IT'S OVERSELLING IT, IT'S NOT 1201 00:42:33,849 --> 00:42:34,783 UNIFIED BUT IT'S AVAILABLE TO 1202 00:42:34,783 --> 00:42:38,553 PEOPLE WHO MAKE TOOLS THAT CAN 1203 00:42:38,553 --> 00:42:39,821 UNDERSTAND WHAT'S COMING OUT OF 1204 00:42:39,821 --> 00:42:42,491 THE ELECTRONIC HEALTH RECORD OR 1205 00:42:42,491 --> 00:42:47,362 THE EXCHANGE FORMAT WHICH IS 1206 00:42:47,362 --> 00:42:49,531 WHAT FHIR STANDS FOR. 1207 00:42:49,531 --> 00:42:51,099 SO WE'VE BEEN PILOTING THIS OVER 1208 00:42:51,099 --> 00:42:52,801 THE LAST 6 MONTHS THEN, SO CHOP 1209 00:42:52,801 --> 00:42:54,836 WILL GO TO SEATTLE AND UCSF, 1210 00:42:54,836 --> 00:42:57,439 WHAT DOES IT TAKE FOR DATA TO 1211 00:42:57,439 --> 00:43:00,842 JUST STREAM FROM THE ELECTRONIC 1212 00:43:00,842 --> 00:43:01,777 HEALTH TREATMENT AND THE 1213 00:43:01,777 --> 00:43:03,011 GOVERNMENT SAYS YOU HAVE TO DO 1214 00:43:03,011 --> 00:43:09,651 THIS AND IT TURNS OUT IT DOESN'T 1215 00:43:09,651 --> 00:43:11,386 REALLY HAPPEN FULLY WE HAVE TO 1216 00:43:11,386 --> 00:43:12,954 GO THROUGH HAYERS OF IMP 1217 00:43:12,954 --> 00:43:16,158 LEMMATION, ADDITIONAL TOOLS BUT 1218 00:43:16,158 --> 00:43:18,160 NOW WE CAN, WE'VE PROVEN WE CAN 1219 00:43:18,160 --> 00:43:19,761 CREATE FRAMEWORK FOR REALTIME 1220 00:43:19,761 --> 00:43:22,664 DATA EXCHANGE, THE PATIENT SHOWS 1221 00:43:22,664 --> 00:43:24,499 UP, THEY'RE CONSENTED, DATA 1222 00:43:24,499 --> 00:43:26,968 FLOWS, INSTEAD OF PULLING DATA, 1223 00:43:26,968 --> 00:43:29,538 DATA GETS PUSHED, GETS PUSHED ON 1224 00:43:29,538 --> 00:43:34,176 BEHALF OF PATES PATES--PATIENTS 1225 00:43:34,176 --> 00:43:35,043 CONSENTED AND WANT THAT 1226 00:43:35,043 --> 00:43:36,077 INTERNATIONAL CLASSIFICATION 1227 00:43:36,077 --> 00:43:36,344 IMRAITED. 1228 00:43:36,344 --> 00:43:39,181 THE NEXT LAYER TO LEVERAGE THE 1229 00:43:39,181 --> 00:43:39,915 SAME INTEROPERABILITY FRAMEWORK 1230 00:43:39,915 --> 00:43:41,416 TO BRING DATA BACK IN, RIGHT? 1231 00:43:41,416 --> 00:43:43,218 , CAN YOU IMAGINE DATA GOING 1232 00:43:43,218 --> 00:43:44,352 OUT, ANALYZED, ANSWERING 1233 00:43:44,352 --> 00:43:46,988 QUESTIONS, WHAT THE OTHER PATES 1234 00:43:46,988 --> 00:43:48,056 AT CHOP OR ANYWHERE ELSE THAT 1235 00:43:48,056 --> 00:43:50,158 LOOK LIKE THOSE PATIENTS EMPLOY 1236 00:43:50,158 --> 00:43:51,993 THOSE MRIs, FLOWING INTO A 1237 00:43:51,993 --> 00:43:55,330 FRAMEWORK WHERE THE SYSTEM 1238 00:43:55,330 --> 00:43:55,797 MEASURES BIOMETRICALLY 1239 00:43:55,797 --> 00:43:58,300 AUTOMATICALLY, THE SIZE OF THE 1240 00:43:58,300 --> 00:43:59,267 TUMOR, THINGS THE HUMAN MAY NOT 1241 00:43:59,267 --> 00:44:01,036 HAVE SEEN AND THAT ANALYSIS THEN 1242 00:44:01,036 --> 00:44:08,743 FLOWS BACK THROUGH THAT SAME 1243 00:44:08,743 --> 00:44:10,011 PIPE BECAUSE PIPE IS 1244 00:44:10,011 --> 00:44:12,514 BI-DIRECTIONAL AND THE SAME GOES 1245 00:44:12,514 --> 00:44:14,349 THROUGH THOSE DIRECTIONS, WHEN 1246 00:44:14,349 --> 00:44:19,187 CHAT GPT KEAM UP, I BECAME A 1247 00:44:19,187 --> 00:44:20,055 CHATGPT FANATIC, NOT THE LEAST 1248 00:44:20,055 --> 00:44:21,857 OF WHICH BECAUSE IT COULD WRITE 1249 00:44:21,857 --> 00:44:24,125 THINGS IN WHATEVER FORMAT I 1250 00:44:24,125 --> 00:44:25,894 WANTED SHAKES SPEAR OR OTHER 1251 00:44:25,894 --> 00:44:28,396 WISE OR BECAUSE MY KID 1252 00:44:28,396 --> 00:44:29,931 STARTEDUING IT FOR MANY 1253 00:44:29,931 --> 00:44:31,099 TEENAGERS WERE USING IT FOR THAT 1254 00:44:31,099 --> 00:44:32,500 THEY SHOULDN'T HAVE BUT BECAUSE 1255 00:44:32,500 --> 00:44:39,274 I SAW THE POTENTIAL FOR 1 OF OUR 1256 00:44:39,274 --> 00:44:40,942 BIGGEST BARRIERS AND I MENTIONED 1257 00:44:40,942 --> 00:44:42,477 IT EARLY ON, AS I GO TO THE 1258 00:44:42,477 --> 00:44:44,346 PORTALS YOU HAVE TO KNOW WHICH 1259 00:44:44,346 --> 00:44:46,648 BUTTON TO CLICK ON TO FIGURE OUT 1260 00:44:46,648 --> 00:44:47,582 THAT SEARCH SPACE, IF YOU'VE 1261 00:44:47,582 --> 00:44:49,584 DONE IT A FEW TIMES AND YOU LOST 1262 00:44:49,584 --> 00:44:50,785 A VIDEO, YOU LEARN HOW TO DO 1263 00:44:50,785 --> 00:44:52,954 THAT BUT WHAT A CLINICIAN REALLY 1264 00:44:52,954 --> 00:45:00,195 WANTS TO DO IS ASK THE QUESTION, 1265 00:45:00,195 --> 00:45:00,629 RIGHT? 1266 00:45:00,629 --> 00:45:02,264 WE'VE HAD THIS MUTATION, THEY'LL 1267 00:45:02,264 --> 00:45:05,233 SAVE IT IN THE ORDER, THEY WANT 1268 00:45:05,233 --> 00:45:15,343 TO COMMUNICATE WITH THE DATA 1269 00:45:15,343 --> 00:45:17,579 CHATGPT IS TAKEN THAT FRAMEWORK 1270 00:45:17,579 --> 00:45:18,947 OR PREDICTABILITY, LAYERED THAT 1271 00:45:18,947 --> 00:45:22,284 STRUCTURE ON DATA AND AS LONG AS 1272 00:45:22,284 --> 00:45:25,353 THERE'S STRUCTURE, THE SYSTEM 1273 00:45:25,353 --> 00:45:27,656 UNDERSTANDS IN FACT IF ANY OF 1274 00:45:27,656 --> 00:45:29,124 YOU HAVE EVER QUERIES A 1275 00:45:29,124 --> 00:45:31,159 DATABASE, YOU WOULD HAVE TO USE 1276 00:45:31,159 --> 00:45:32,294 SOMETHING LIKE SEQUEL OR 1277 00:45:32,294 --> 00:45:33,728 SOMETHING COMPLEX WHERE YOU 1278 00:45:33,728 --> 00:45:34,863 TRANALATE YOUR HUMAN LANGUAGE 1279 00:45:34,863 --> 00:45:39,401 INTO COMPUTER LANGUAGE TO IRPT 1280 00:45:39,401 --> 00:45:41,469 ACT WITH IT. 1281 00:45:41,469 --> 00:45:43,638 WHAT THE GPT DID IS IT CAN DO 1282 00:45:43,638 --> 00:45:46,241 THAT FOR YOU, IT UNDERSTANDS 1283 00:45:46,241 --> 00:45:47,642 FHIR, IT UNDERSTANDS READING 1284 00:45:47,642 --> 00:45:48,610 [INDISCERNIBLE] ON FILES, IT CAN 1285 00:45:48,610 --> 00:45:51,413 DO THE FOLLOWING, CAN YOU ASK 1286 00:45:51,413 --> 00:45:52,914 THAT QUESTION, SHOW ME ALL 1287 00:45:52,914 --> 00:45:54,282 PATIENTS THAT ARE SIMILAR TO 1288 00:45:54,282 --> 00:45:55,951 THIS AND THEY'LL ASK BACK, DO 1289 00:45:55,951 --> 00:46:02,290 YOU MEAN BY MRI AND DO YOU MEAN 1290 00:46:02,290 --> 00:46:05,093 GENOMEICALLY, LET'S DO BOTH 1291 00:46:05,093 --> 00:46:13,935 IT'LL HAVE THAT INTERACTION WITH 1292 00:46:13,935 --> 00:46:15,704 YOU BAGSED ON THE COMMUNICATION, 1293 00:46:15,704 --> 00:46:17,772 THE LAYER BETWEEN A QUERY AND A 1294 00:46:17,772 --> 00:46:20,842 DATA SET, IS THE LAST BARRIER TO 1295 00:46:20,842 --> 00:46:23,278 ENTRY FOR DISCOVERY, RIGHT? 1296 00:46:23,278 --> 00:46:24,879 THAT'S THE PART, RIGHT THAT 1297 00:46:24,879 --> 00:46:29,584 WE'RE POSITIONING ALL THESE 1298 00:46:29,584 --> 00:46:31,653 RESOURCES FOR SO WE'RE DOING 1299 00:46:31,653 --> 00:46:33,154 THIS PILOT OF BRINGING THE DATA 1300 00:46:33,154 --> 00:46:34,356 OUT IN REALTIME BUT IT'S 1301 00:46:34,356 --> 00:46:38,326 ENTERING A PLACE WHERE A GPT 1302 00:46:38,326 --> 00:46:40,395 TRANSFORMER AND WE WILL PAIR 1303 00:46:40,395 --> 00:46:41,463 THIS, AND CAN DETERMINE 1304 00:46:41,463 --> 00:46:42,163 AUTOMATICALLY UNDERSTAND WHAT 1305 00:46:42,163 --> 00:46:43,598 DATA IS THERE AND WE WILL SEE IF 1306 00:46:43,598 --> 00:46:45,233 I CAN ASK A QUESTION OR YOU CAN 1307 00:46:45,233 --> 00:46:47,869 ASK A QUESTION, JUST ASKING THE 1308 00:46:47,869 --> 00:46:49,137 QUESTION, SO SUDDENLY THE 1309 00:46:49,137 --> 00:46:50,839 DASHBOARD OF ALL THESE BUTTONS 1310 00:46:50,839 --> 00:46:52,640 YOU HAVE TO CLIM, ALL THE 1311 00:46:52,640 --> 00:46:55,710 FACETTED SEARCH, MAYBE THEY GO 1312 00:46:55,710 --> 00:46:58,113 AWAY, OR MAYBE THEY GO TO THE 1313 00:46:58,113 --> 00:46:58,847 RECEIVING BACKGROUND AND YOU 1314 00:46:58,847 --> 00:47:00,181 JUST ASK YOUR QUESTION, HAVE YOU 1315 00:47:00,181 --> 00:47:03,518 A CONVERSATION WITH THE DATA. 1316 00:47:03,518 --> 00:47:04,953 I'M SURE MANY OF YOU HAVE HEARD 1317 00:47:04,953 --> 00:47:07,055 ABOUT THE DANGERS AND RISKS OF 1318 00:47:07,055 --> 00:47:09,691 THIS, I STARTED THIS HERE FOR MY 1319 00:47:09,691 --> 00:47:12,193 KID, MY KID HAS KNOWN I WORKED 1320 00:47:12,193 --> 00:47:14,529 FOR THE LAST 15 YEARS, HE NEVER 1321 00:47:14,529 --> 00:47:16,398 LOGGED ON TO ANY OF OUR PORTALS 1322 00:47:16,398 --> 00:47:17,599 EACH THOUGH I PROMISED HIM 1323 00:47:17,599 --> 00:47:20,802 THERE'S NO MATH ON IT, RIGHT? 1324 00:47:20,802 --> 00:47:24,005 YOU CAN IMAGINE THE CONVERSATION 1325 00:47:24,005 --> 00:47:24,839 EVEN MORE PERSONALIZED, RIGHT? 1326 00:47:24,839 --> 00:47:28,710 I CAN HAVE THE CHAT, LITERALLY A 1327 00:47:28,710 --> 00:47:30,812 CHAT VERSION CALLED GENZ-SPEAK 1328 00:47:30,812 --> 00:47:36,684 WHERE IT WILL TALK TO YOU IN 1329 00:47:36,684 --> 00:47:38,119 GEN-Z, MAYBE THAT WILL BE THE 1330 00:47:38,119 --> 00:47:39,988 NEXT BARRIER TO ACTUALLY GET A 1331 00:47:39,988 --> 00:47:42,090 TEENAGER TO LOG ON TO A PLATFORM 1332 00:47:42,090 --> 00:47:44,626 THAT'S OPEN, BUT THE PART THAT I 1333 00:47:44,626 --> 00:47:48,596 LOVE THE MOST IS THAT EVEN 1334 00:47:48,596 --> 00:47:51,966 THOUGH CHAT GPT OR OTHER CANS 1335 00:47:51,966 --> 00:47:52,801 HALLUCINATE BECAUSE ALL THEY'RE 1336 00:47:52,801 --> 00:47:54,169 DOING IS PREDIBTING WORDS WHAT 1337 00:47:54,169 --> 00:47:57,439 THEY CAN DO IS CONNECK TO THINGS 1338 00:47:57,439 --> 00:47:57,939 THAT DON'T HALLUCINATE. 1339 00:47:57,939 --> 00:48:01,810 SO CAN YOU TAKE A KNOWLEDGE 1340 00:48:01,810 --> 00:48:03,878 FRAMEWORK, A DATABASE AND ASK 1341 00:48:03,878 --> 00:48:06,147 THE QUESTION, NATURAL LANGUAGE 1342 00:48:06,147 --> 00:48:07,916 WISE, AND THE GPT TRANSFORMER 1343 00:48:07,916 --> 00:48:09,250 WILL UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU WANT TO 1344 00:48:09,250 --> 00:48:11,319 KNOW, WILL KNOW WHERE TO GO AND 1345 00:48:11,319 --> 00:48:14,322 IT WILL WRITE THE CODE TO GET IT 1346 00:48:14,322 --> 00:48:18,026 AND BRING IT BACK TO YOU. 1347 00:48:18,026 --> 00:48:18,960 THAT IRPT ACTION BETWEEN 1348 00:48:18,960 --> 00:48:21,162 KNOWLEDGE OR ACTUALLY 1349 00:48:21,162 --> 00:48:23,431 STRUCTURED, FRAMED, VETTED AND 1350 00:48:23,431 --> 00:48:25,767 THE LAYER OF LANGUAGE, YOU CAN 1351 00:48:25,767 --> 00:48:28,069 COMMUNICATE WITH IT AND THE 1352 00:48:28,069 --> 00:48:28,870 TRANSFORMATIVE MOMENT, RIGHT, 1353 00:48:28,870 --> 00:48:35,043 FOR SCIENTISTSA THE LARGE. 1354 00:48:35,043 --> 00:48:36,511 TRULY IDEALIZES THE CONTEXT IN 1355 00:48:36,511 --> 00:48:38,179 WAYS I AM SUPER EXCITED ABOUT. 1356 00:48:38,179 --> 00:48:40,849 AND IN FACT, LEAK WHEN I SHOWED 1357 00:48:40,849 --> 00:48:42,050 PORTAL TODAY TO YOU, RIGHT, 1358 00:48:42,050 --> 00:48:45,687 THERE'S A PART OF ME THAT HURTS 1359 00:48:45,687 --> 00:48:47,255 BECAUSE I KNOW IT'S ALREADY NOT 1360 00:48:47,255 --> 00:48:48,389 RELEVANT, RIGHT IN BECAUSE THIS 1361 00:48:48,389 --> 00:48:56,931 IS THE NEXT WAVE OF INTERACTING 1362 00:48:56,931 --> 00:48:58,600 WITH DATA IT'S AN AMAZING PORTAL 1363 00:48:58,600 --> 00:49:01,202 AND I DON'T WANT TO SAY 1364 00:49:01,202 --> 00:49:02,403 OTHERWISE, BUILT BY AN AMAZING 1365 00:49:02,403 --> 00:49:05,507 TEAM BUT YOU CAN ALREADY SEE THE 1366 00:49:05,507 --> 00:49:07,575 DYNAMIC INTERACTION BETWEEN DATA 1367 00:49:07,575 --> 00:49:08,776 SOURCES, HOW THEY INTERCONNECT, 1368 00:49:08,776 --> 00:49:11,212 WHO ASKS THE QUESTIONS AND THEY 1369 00:49:11,212 --> 00:49:12,013 GET COMPLETELY TRANSFORM. 1370 00:49:12,013 --> 00:49:16,551 FOR ME THAT'S ENTIRELY AMAZING 1371 00:49:16,551 --> 00:49:18,553 EMPLOY AND IT FULFILLS A PHRASE 1372 00:49:18,553 --> 00:49:20,622 I TRY TO SAY IN ALL MY TALKS 1373 00:49:20,622 --> 00:49:24,159 WHICH IS PROMISE WE GIVE TO 1374 00:49:24,159 --> 00:49:24,559 PATIENT FAMILIES. 1375 00:49:24,559 --> 00:49:26,294 THE 21st CENTURY PROMISE IS 1376 00:49:26,294 --> 00:49:27,862 THAT IF YOU CAN MEASURE IT, YOU 1377 00:49:27,862 --> 00:49:29,464 CAN UNDERSTAND IT, IF YOU CAN 1378 00:49:29,464 --> 00:49:30,698 UNDERSTAND IT, WE CAN INTERVENE 1379 00:49:30,698 --> 00:49:33,268 WITH IT. 1380 00:49:33,268 --> 00:49:36,337 THAT'S THE PROMISE AND IF THAT'S 1381 00:49:36,337 --> 00:49:38,173 TRUE, THEN OUR JOB IS TO 1382 00:49:38,173 --> 00:49:39,274 ACCELERATE THAT PROCESS THRIE 1383 00:49:39,274 --> 00:49:40,241 THROUGH TECHNOLOGY, IF YOU TAKE 1384 00:49:40,241 --> 00:49:41,509 THAT AS FACT, RIGHT, YOU CAN 1385 00:49:41,509 --> 00:49:42,710 MEASURE IT, YOU UNDERSTAND IT, 1386 00:49:42,710 --> 00:49:46,481 THEN YOU CAN CHANGE IT, BUT 1387 00:49:46,481 --> 00:49:47,515 THAT'S THE TRUISM, THEN 1388 00:49:47,515 --> 00:49:49,284 EVERYTHING SHOULD ORIENT TOWARDS 1389 00:49:49,284 --> 00:49:50,351 ACCELERATING THE FRAMEWORK AND 1390 00:49:50,351 --> 00:49:52,187 THE TECHNOLOGY FRAMEWORK THAT 1391 00:49:52,187 --> 00:49:54,822 DATA SCIENCE BRINGS IS AT OUR 1392 00:49:54,822 --> 00:49:55,056 HANDS. 1393 00:49:55,056 --> 00:49:56,324 IT TURNS OUT WE WEREN'T THE 1394 00:49:56,324 --> 00:49:58,092 FIRST PEOPLE TO TRY TO DO THAT, 1395 00:49:58,092 --> 00:50:02,230 I WILL FINISH WITH THIS 1 SLIDE. 1396 00:50:02,230 --> 00:50:05,633 GROWING UP I WAS AN AVIATION 1397 00:50:05,633 --> 00:50:08,069 ENTHUSIAST SO I TOOK PILOT'S 1398 00:50:08,069 --> 00:50:09,837 LESSONS WHEN I WAS 12. 1399 00:50:09,837 --> 00:50:13,141 YOU WOULD SHOW UP THE AIRPORT, 1400 00:50:13,141 --> 00:50:14,409 YOU WOULD GET THE WEATHER 1401 00:50:14,409 --> 00:50:16,477 REPORT, YOU WOULDN'T GET THE 1402 00:50:16,477 --> 00:50:18,446 WEATHER REPORT FOR MY AIRPORT, 1403 00:50:18,446 --> 00:50:20,615 YOU WOULD GET THE WEATHER FOR 1404 00:50:20,615 --> 00:50:23,051 WHEN WHERE YOU'RE HEADING, THIS 1405 00:50:23,051 --> 00:50:24,319 WAS IN 1992, PREINTERNET, THERE 1406 00:50:24,319 --> 00:50:25,620 WAS A COMMUNICATION FRAMEWORK 1407 00:50:25,620 --> 00:50:27,689 FOR THE WEATHER, IT TURNS OUT 1408 00:50:27,689 --> 00:50:29,424 WEATHER IS A MULTIMODAL 1409 00:50:29,424 --> 00:50:31,092 FRAMEWORK, THERE'S THE SHAPE OF 1410 00:50:31,092 --> 00:50:34,195 THE LANDSCAPE, THE TEMPERATURE, 1411 00:50:34,195 --> 00:50:39,467 THE OCEAN, THE GROUND HUMIDITY, 1412 00:50:39,467 --> 00:50:42,136 NUMBER OF WAYS TO MEASURE IT, 1413 00:50:42,136 --> 00:50:43,705 BALLOONS WHO GET SENT UP AND 1414 00:50:43,705 --> 00:50:46,941 DOWN 2 TIMES A DAY, AIRPLANES 1415 00:50:46,941 --> 00:50:48,376 FLYING INTO STORMS AND 1416 00:50:48,376 --> 00:50:50,245 COLLECTING DATA, THE NUMBER OF 1417 00:50:50,245 --> 00:50:52,213 IMAGES TAKEN AND INTEGRATE THE 1418 00:50:52,213 --> 00:50:53,348 WAVE LENGTH THE MULTIMODAL 1419 00:50:53,348 --> 00:50:55,283 FRAMEWORK BUT EVERY TIME A 1420 00:50:55,283 --> 00:50:58,419 HURRICANE COMES, RIGHT, WE SEE 1421 00:50:58,419 --> 00:51:01,089 THIS, WE SEE SEXER SENTIALLY 1422 00:51:01,089 --> 00:51:03,057 WHAT'S CALLED A SPAGHETTI PLOT, 1423 00:51:03,057 --> 00:51:05,360 CAN YOU SEE IT'S TIGHTLY 1424 00:51:05,360 --> 00:51:06,894 TOGETHER AT 2 OR 2 AND GETS 1425 00:51:06,894 --> 00:51:07,395 SPREAD APART. 1426 00:51:07,395 --> 00:51:09,464 WHY CAN'T WE DO THAT FOR 1427 00:51:09,464 --> 00:51:09,998 PATIENTS, RIGHT? 1428 00:51:09,998 --> 00:51:12,033 CAN WE CREATE A SPAGHETTI PLOT 1429 00:51:12,033 --> 00:51:12,533 FOR OUR PATIENTS? 1430 00:51:12,533 --> 00:51:14,669 I THINK WE CAN. 1431 00:51:14,669 --> 00:51:18,740 I THINK IT'S BEEN DONE BEFORE, 1432 00:51:18,740 --> 00:51:20,375 AND UNLIKE THE WEATHER, I THINK 1433 00:51:20,375 --> 00:51:21,909 WE CAN CHANGE IT SO THAT'S THE 1434 00:51:21,909 --> 00:51:24,178 VISION AND WE WILL SEE HOW THE 1435 00:51:24,178 --> 00:51:29,984 PANELISTS FEEL ABOUT THAT 1436 00:51:29,984 --> 00:51:30,285 VISION. 1437 00:51:30,285 --> 00:51:40,328 [ APPLAUSE ] 1438 00:51:40,328 --> 00:51:42,230 >> THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THAT 1439 00:51:42,230 --> 00:51:44,732 REALLY, REALLY WONDERFUL AND 1440 00:51:44,732 --> 00:51:45,233 THOUGHT-PROVOKING TALK. 1441 00:51:45,233 --> 00:51:47,101 SO NOW I WILL ASK THE PANELISTS 1442 00:51:47,101 --> 00:51:52,273 TO COME UP AND LEAD THE 1443 00:51:52,273 --> 00:51:55,543 DECUSHION, IT WILL BE LED BY OUR 1444 00:51:55,543 --> 00:51:57,378 CHIEF SCIENTIFIC OFFICER OF THE 1445 00:51:57,378 --> 00:52:01,582 ALL OF US PANEL AT THE NIH, WE 1446 00:52:01,582 --> 00:52:03,951 HAVE DR. FRAN CHESK O, WITH 1447 00:52:03,951 --> 00:52:05,987 NHGRI WHICH IS THE NATIONAL 1448 00:52:05,987 --> 00:52:08,456 HUMAN GENOME RESEARCH INSTITUTE 1449 00:52:08,456 --> 00:52:10,091 AND DR. JOSH LEVY IS THE 1450 00:52:10,091 --> 00:52:13,461 CLENICAL DIRECTOR FOR NIDCD, SO 1451 00:52:13,461 --> 00:52:14,896 DR. GINSBERG, PLEASE LEAD US 1452 00:52:14,896 --> 00:52:18,232 OFF. 1453 00:52:18,232 --> 00:52:18,533 NTHANK YOU. 1454 00:52:18,533 --> 00:52:18,800 THANK YOU. 1455 00:52:18,800 --> 00:52:26,774 THANK YOU VERY MUCH DR. RESNICK, 1456 00:52:26,774 --> 00:52:28,242 OR ADAM FOR AN INSPIRATIONAL 1457 00:52:28,242 --> 00:52:33,381 TALK, I WILL JUST SAVE SOMETHING 1458 00:52:33,381 --> 00:52:34,682 FOR A LATER DISCUSSION AFTER 1459 00:52:34,682 --> 00:52:37,719 THIS IS OVER IS THE CONVERGENCE 1460 00:52:37,719 --> 00:52:39,287 OF PHILOSOPHICAL INTENT OF THE 1461 00:52:39,287 --> 00:52:40,455 KIDS PLATFORM YOU BUILT AND ALL 1462 00:52:40,455 --> 00:52:41,656 OF US IS REMARKABLE AND WILL 1463 00:52:41,656 --> 00:52:44,092 PROBABLY HAVE A LOT TO LEARN 1464 00:52:44,092 --> 00:52:44,559 FROM EACH OTHER. 1465 00:52:44,559 --> 00:52:46,060 BUT LET ME TELL WHAT YOU WE'RE 1466 00:52:46,060 --> 00:52:49,764 GOING TO DO TODAY, SO THE THEME 1467 00:52:49,764 --> 00:52:50,898 IS PRECISION MEDICINE AND THIS 1468 00:52:50,898 --> 00:52:52,233 IS A STRAY JECTORY TEENLIC 1469 00:52:52,233 --> 00:52:54,268 PILLAR IN THE NIERK DCD 1470 00:52:54,268 --> 00:52:54,902 TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH TEEJIC 1471 00:52:54,902 --> 00:52:57,305 PLAN AS YOU KNOW, SO THE GOAL OF 1472 00:52:57,305 --> 00:52:58,706 THIS PART OF--ACTUALLY THE GOAL 1473 00:52:58,706 --> 00:53:00,975 OF THIS DAY, I THINK IS TO 1474 00:53:00,975 --> 00:53:02,310 PROVIDE NIDCD CAN SOME INSIGHTS 1475 00:53:02,310 --> 00:53:05,747 AS TO HOW TO ACTUALLY ENABLE 1476 00:53:05,747 --> 00:53:10,718 PRECISION MEDICINE TO BE PART OF 1477 00:53:10,718 --> 00:53:11,219 COMMUNICATION DISORDERS 1478 00:53:11,219 --> 00:53:11,486 RESEARCH. 1479 00:53:11,486 --> 00:53:12,587 SO THAT'S WHAT WE'RE GOING TO 1480 00:53:12,587 --> 00:53:14,722 TRY TO TAKE OUT OF THE 1481 00:53:14,722 --> 00:53:15,289 DISCUSSION TODAY. 1482 00:53:15,289 --> 00:53:18,126 THE AGENDA OF THIS NEXT PART IS 1483 00:53:18,126 --> 00:53:20,128 FIRST OF ALL, I WILL JUST SAY A 1484 00:53:20,128 --> 00:53:22,663 FEW WORDS ABOUT THE FIELD OF 1485 00:53:22,663 --> 00:53:24,866 PRECISION MEDICINE AND THEN 1486 00:53:24,866 --> 00:53:26,267 WE'VE DERIVED QUESTIONS, TO 1487 00:53:26,267 --> 00:53:27,101 PROVIDE STRUCTURE TO THE 1488 00:53:27,101 --> 00:53:28,569 SESSIONS SO THAT WE CAN OPTIMIZE 1489 00:53:28,569 --> 00:53:30,071 IN THE SHORT PERIOD OF TIME WE 1490 00:53:30,071 --> 00:53:31,606 HAVE THE KINDS OF INFORMATION 1491 00:53:31,606 --> 00:53:36,677 CONVEYED BY OUR EXPERTS TO THE 1492 00:53:36,677 --> 00:53:36,978 NIDCD GROUP. 1493 00:53:36,978 --> 00:53:39,781 I WILL ASK EACH OF MY COLLEAGUES 1494 00:53:39,781 --> 00:53:43,684 TO INTRODUCE THEMSELVES BEFORE 1495 00:53:43,684 --> 00:53:44,619 THEY ANSWER THE FIRST QUESTION. 1496 00:53:44,619 --> 00:53:46,487 SO LET ME START OFF AND TELL 1497 00:53:46,487 --> 00:53:48,256 YOU, JUST A COUPLE THINGS FIRST 1498 00:53:48,256 --> 00:53:49,857 ABOUT MYSELF, AND ABOUT 1499 00:53:49,857 --> 00:53:52,193 PRECISION MEDICINE, AT LEAST A 1500 00:53:52,193 --> 00:53:53,494 VANTAGE POINT TO THINK ABOUT. 1501 00:53:53,494 --> 00:53:57,632 I AM TRAINED AS A CLINICIAN 1502 00:53:57,632 --> 00:53:58,232 SCIENTIST, MOLECULAR, 1503 00:53:58,232 --> 00:53:59,500 CARDIOLOGIST AND GENETICS, I 1504 00:53:59,500 --> 00:54:02,336 HAVE HAD EXPERIENCE IN ACADEMIA 1505 00:54:02,336 --> 00:54:04,672 AND INDUSTRY AND WENT BACK TO 1506 00:54:04,672 --> 00:54:09,177 ACADEMIA AND I MET DEBAT DUKE 1507 00:54:09,177 --> 00:54:10,244 UNIVERSITY AS COLLEAGUES AND I 1508 00:54:10,244 --> 00:54:12,680 CAME TO NIH TO BE THE CHIEF OF 1509 00:54:12,680 --> 00:54:13,514 MEDICAL AND SCIENTIFIC OFFICER 1510 00:54:13,514 --> 00:54:18,152 FOR ALL OF US AND SO I'VE BEEN 1511 00:54:18,152 --> 00:54:19,020 IN THE PRECISION MEDICINE SPACE, 1512 00:54:19,020 --> 00:54:22,390 I WOULD SAY ALL OF MY CAREER. 1513 00:54:22,390 --> 00:54:24,125 AND IT'S INTERESTING THAT THIS 1514 00:54:24,125 --> 00:54:27,195 IS THE YEAR 2023 AND IT'S 20 1515 00:54:27,195 --> 00:54:29,464 YEARS SENSE THE SEQUENCING OF 1516 00:54:29,464 --> 00:54:32,099 THE HUMAN GENOME WHICH NIH WAS 1517 00:54:32,099 --> 00:54:34,802 INTIMATELY INVOLVED IN AND A 1518 00:54:34,802 --> 00:54:37,271 STRONG DRIVER OF. 1519 00:54:37,271 --> 00:54:46,481 DESPITE THE HIGH HYPERBOLE WE'D 1520 00:54:46,481 --> 00:54:48,483 IN THE LAST 20 YEARS, I WOULD 1521 00:54:48,483 --> 00:54:49,250 SAY IT'S REMARKABLE. 1522 00:54:49,250 --> 00:54:50,685 JUST THINK ABOUT CANCER, WE JUST 1523 00:54:50,685 --> 00:54:52,286 HEARD A LOT ABOUT THE POSSIBLES 1524 00:54:52,286 --> 00:54:54,956 OF CHILDHOOD CANCER BUT TODAY 1525 00:54:54,956 --> 00:54:57,859 THE ENTIRE ARC OF CARE OF CANCER 1526 00:54:57,859 --> 00:55:00,127 IS ENABLED BY PRECISION MEDICINE 1527 00:55:00,127 --> 00:55:02,296 IN THAT IT WASN'T FOR HUMAN 1528 00:55:02,296 --> 00:55:07,168 BENOAM, WE CAN PREDICT THE RESKS 1529 00:55:07,168 --> 00:55:08,669 OF SOMETHING DEVELOPING COLON 1530 00:55:08,669 --> 00:55:11,005 CANCER, BREAST CANCER AND OTHER 1531 00:55:11,005 --> 00:55:12,640 NUMEROUS VARIANTS THAT CAN BE 1532 00:55:12,640 --> 00:55:13,407 OBTAINED THROUGH GENOME 1533 00:55:13,407 --> 00:55:13,674 SEQUENCE. 1534 00:55:13,674 --> 00:55:16,811 WE CAN ALSO DO TESTING FOR EARLY 1535 00:55:16,811 --> 00:55:18,479 DETECTION THROUGH A NUMBER OF 1536 00:55:18,479 --> 00:55:19,914 ASSAYS OR LIQUID BIOPSIES FOR 1537 00:55:19,914 --> 00:55:21,282 DIAGNOSIS AND MOST OF THE 1538 00:55:21,282 --> 00:55:23,618 TREATMENTS OF CANCER NOW ARE 1539 00:55:23,618 --> 00:55:25,019 TARGETED THERAPIES GOING TO THE 1540 00:55:25,019 --> 00:55:29,323 ABILITY TO SEQUENCE THE TUMOR 1541 00:55:29,323 --> 00:55:30,758 GENOME, AND THRIVE DRUG TARGETS 1542 00:55:30,758 --> 00:55:31,726 AND ULTIMATELY MOLECULES THAT 1543 00:55:31,726 --> 00:55:32,994 WILL PREVENT THE GROWTH OF 1544 00:55:32,994 --> 00:55:35,229 TUMORS AND EVEN IN THE CARE OF A 1545 00:55:35,229 --> 00:55:37,999 PATIENT WITH CANCER, MANY OF THE 1546 00:55:37,999 --> 00:55:40,101 ANCILLARY DRUGS THAT ARE USED TO 1547 00:55:40,101 --> 00:55:42,069 CONTROL THEIR PAIN, OR NAUSEA 1548 00:55:42,069 --> 00:55:43,371 ARE SUBJECT TO PHARMA CO 1549 00:55:43,371 --> 00:55:44,338 GENETICS ROLE, SO THAT'S 1550 00:55:44,338 --> 00:55:45,973 SOMETHING THAT WAS JUST NOT, 1551 00:55:45,973 --> 00:55:49,143 PART OF A PATIENT'S CARE PLAN, 1552 00:55:49,143 --> 00:55:51,913 20 YEARS AGO, OR MAYBE EVEN 10 1553 00:55:51,913 --> 00:55:53,781 YEARS AGO AND PHARMA CO GENETICS 1554 00:55:53,781 --> 00:55:58,219 ITSELF IS A BROAD FIELD, IN THIS 1555 00:55:58,219 --> 00:56:01,422 ROOM, 95% OF US HARBOR A GENETIC 1556 00:56:01,422 --> 00:56:02,757 VARIANT AND GENES THAT CONTROL 1557 00:56:02,757 --> 00:56:04,792 DRUG METABOLISM FOR THE MOST 1558 00:56:04,792 --> 00:56:05,993 COMMONLY PRESCRIBED DRUGS IN IN 1559 00:56:05,993 --> 00:56:08,362 COUNTRY SO IF WE DON'T KNOW OUR 1560 00:56:08,362 --> 00:56:09,697 PHARMA CO GENETIC BACKGROUND 1561 00:56:09,697 --> 00:56:11,065 THEN IT'S LIKELY THAT 1 OF US OR 1562 00:56:11,065 --> 00:56:13,768 MORE OF US WILL ACTUALLY HAVE AN 1563 00:56:13,768 --> 00:56:15,036 UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCE OF A DRUG 1564 00:56:15,036 --> 00:56:16,504 OR MAYBE NOT GET OPTIMAL 1565 00:56:16,504 --> 00:56:17,371 THERAPY. 1566 00:56:17,371 --> 00:56:20,441 IF YOU THINK ABOUT RARE DISEASE, 1567 00:56:20,441 --> 00:56:23,844 WE CAN NOW SEE PEOPLE WITH 1568 00:56:23,844 --> 00:56:25,179 CYSTIC FIBROSIS, LIVING INTO 1569 00:56:25,179 --> 00:56:31,552 THEIR 60S WITH GREAT QUALITY OF 1570 00:56:31,552 --> 00:56:33,354 LIFE BECAUSE WE KNOW SOMETHING 1571 00:56:33,354 --> 00:56:34,989 ABOUT THE GENETIC VARIATIONS IN 1572 00:56:34,989 --> 00:56:38,726 THE CFTR, AND COMPANIES HAVE 1573 00:56:38,726 --> 00:56:40,261 RISEN TO THE CHALLENGES OF 1574 00:56:40,261 --> 00:56:42,330 TARGETING THOSE IN WAYS 1575 00:56:42,330 --> 00:56:43,965 UNBELIEVABLE 20 YEARS AGO AND 1576 00:56:43,965 --> 00:56:45,700 SICKLE CELL IS BEING CURED 1577 00:56:45,700 --> 00:56:47,401 THROUGH GENE EDITING SO RARE 1578 00:56:47,401 --> 00:56:51,639 DISEASES IS UNDERGOING A MAJOR 1579 00:56:51,639 --> 00:56:53,174 CONFORMATION, AS IS CHRONIC 1580 00:56:53,174 --> 00:56:56,277 DISEASES, WE'RE SEEING POLYGENIC 1581 00:56:56,277 --> 00:56:58,879 RISK SCORES DERIVED AND USE 1582 00:56:58,879 --> 00:57:00,748 INDEED CLINIC TO ENHANCE 1'S 1583 00:57:00,748 --> 00:57:02,383 ABILITY FOR THE ONSET OF DECS 1584 00:57:02,383 --> 00:57:04,251 AND THOSE ARE COMPLEMENTED BY 1585 00:57:04,251 --> 00:57:05,553 SOCIAL DETERMINANTS OF HEALTH 1586 00:57:05,553 --> 00:57:07,955 DATA OR ENVIRONMENTAL DATA GIVE 1587 00:57:07,955 --> 00:57:09,390 A FULLY WHOLISTIC VIEW OF RISK, 1588 00:57:09,390 --> 00:57:10,791 NOT JUST A GENOMIC VIEW OF RISK 1589 00:57:10,791 --> 00:57:17,999 AND I THINK ALL OF THESE COULD 1590 00:57:17,999 --> 00:57:20,901 BE PERTINENT TO THE NIDCD AGENDA 1591 00:57:20,901 --> 00:57:22,570 AND I WILL SAY 1 MORE THING 1592 00:57:22,570 --> 00:57:23,638 BEFORE WE GO INTO THE QUESTIONS 1593 00:57:23,638 --> 00:57:26,674 ABOUT ALL OF US, THE ALL OF US 1594 00:57:26,674 --> 00:57:31,245 RESEARCH PROGRAM, WE ARE NOW AT 1595 00:57:31,245 --> 00:57:31,946 ABOUT 700,000 PLUS INDIVIDUAL 1596 00:57:31,946 --> 00:57:35,316 WHO IS HAVE CONSENTED. 1597 00:57:35,316 --> 00:57:38,486 WE HAVE 500,000--AROUND 500,000 1598 00:57:38,486 --> 00:57:40,988 ELECTRONIC HEALTH RECORDS 1599 00:57:40,988 --> 00:57:41,856 ACQUIRED. 1600 00:57:41,856 --> 00:57:43,290 WE RELEASE 250,000 WHOLE GENOME 1601 00:57:43,290 --> 00:57:45,126 SEQUENCES ON TO OUR RESEARCHER 1602 00:57:45,126 --> 00:57:48,896 WORK BENCH AND THE--AND SO WE'VE 1603 00:57:48,896 --> 00:57:49,864 AMASSED JUST AS YOU'VE HEARD 1604 00:57:49,864 --> 00:57:52,867 FROM ADAM ON A SMALLER SCALE, AN 1605 00:57:52,867 --> 00:57:56,203 ARK MAZING DATA STORE THAT CAN 1606 00:57:56,203 --> 00:57:57,471 PROVIDE INSIGHTS INTO MANY 1607 00:57:57,471 --> 00:57:59,640 COMMON CHRONIC DISEASES AS WELL 1608 00:57:59,640 --> 00:58:01,175 AS RARE DISEASES IN WAYS THAT 1609 00:58:01,175 --> 00:58:03,044 WERE NEVER ACHIEVABLE BY HAVING 1610 00:58:03,044 --> 00:58:04,145 A FULLY ACCESSIBLE DATA PLATFORM 1611 00:58:04,145 --> 00:58:06,013 OF THE TYPE THAT WE'VE BEEN 1612 00:58:06,013 --> 00:58:09,183 BUILDING AND CONTINUED TO BUILD 1613 00:58:09,183 --> 00:58:09,383 OUT. 1614 00:58:09,383 --> 00:58:13,688 SO WITH THAT, I WILL LIKE TO 1615 00:58:13,688 --> 00:58:16,090 NOW, TURN IT OVER NOW TO OUR 1616 00:58:16,090 --> 00:58:19,493 PANELIST ANDS ASK THE FESTER 1617 00:58:19,493 --> 00:58:22,763 QUESTION ANDIME THINKING IN VERY 1618 00:58:22,763 --> 00:58:24,065 PRAGMATIC TERMS. 1619 00:58:24,065 --> 00:58:27,868 SO NIDCD WANTS TO BUILD, MAYBE 1620 00:58:27,868 --> 00:58:31,005 ACQUIRE OR PARTNER WITH GROUPS 1621 00:58:31,005 --> 00:58:31,872 THAT ARE DEVELOPING DIFFERENT 1622 00:58:31,872 --> 00:58:34,108 TYPES OF DATA TO ANSWER 1623 00:58:34,108 --> 00:58:36,143 PERTINENT AND SCIENTIFIC 1624 00:58:36,143 --> 00:58:37,311 QUESTIONS TO THIS INSTITUTE, ID 1625 00:58:37,311 --> 00:58:38,679 LIKE EACH OF YOU TO TELL US YOUR 1626 00:58:38,679 --> 00:58:40,247 DREAM FOR WHAT THAT DATA █STORE 1627 00:58:40,247 --> 00:58:43,684 SHOULD LOOK LIKE TO ENABLE NIDCD 1628 00:58:43,684 --> 00:58:45,086 TO ACHIEVE ITS VISION EMPLOY 1629 00:58:45,086 --> 00:58:46,954 WHAT ARE SOME--IT'S NOT--IT 1630 00:58:46,954 --> 00:58:48,556 SHOULDN'T IN MY MIND AT LEAST IT 1631 00:58:48,556 --> 00:58:50,157 SHOULD NOT BE JUST DATA FOR THE 1632 00:58:50,157 --> 00:58:51,325 SAKE OF COLLECTING DATA BUT DATA 1633 00:58:51,325 --> 00:58:53,294 IN THE CONTEXT OF WHAT 1634 00:58:53,294 --> 00:58:54,328 SCIENTIFIC QUESTIONS WILL THESE 1635 00:58:54,328 --> 00:58:58,666 DATA ENABLE US TO ANSWER THAT WE 1636 00:58:58,666 --> 00:58:59,100 CAN'T WITHOUT IT. 1637 00:58:59,100 --> 00:59:00,568 SO MAYBE I'LL START WITH YOSH 1638 00:59:00,568 --> 00:59:02,470 AND WE'LL COME THIS WAY, GIVE 1639 00:59:02,470 --> 00:59:04,872 ADAM A CHANCE TO REST FOR A 1640 00:59:04,872 --> 00:59:05,906 MOMENT. 1641 00:59:05,906 --> 00:59:06,340 >> ABSOLUTELY. 1642 00:59:06,340 --> 00:59:08,109 I'M JOSHUA LEV WHY, MY 1643 00:59:08,109 --> 00:59:18,152 BACKGROUND TRAINING IS IN 1644 00:59:18,152 --> 00:59:20,621 OTOLARYNG OLOGY, AND OTOWHINE O 1645 00:59:20,621 --> 00:59:22,523 INFLATION AND IT WAS A FANTASTIC 1646 00:59:22,523 --> 00:59:22,757 TALK. 1647 00:59:22,757 --> 00:59:29,764 I THINK A LOT OF THE--WHAT WE 1648 00:59:29,764 --> 00:59:31,932 ARK SPIRE TO AS A FEEL IN TERMS 1649 00:59:31,932 --> 00:59:34,168 OF DATA COLLECTION ARE THINGS 1650 00:59:34,168 --> 00:59:35,736 THAT ARE SCALABLE, UNIVERSAL, 1651 00:59:35,736 --> 00:59:37,037 BUT GROUNDED IN [INDISCERNIBLE] 1652 00:59:37,037 --> 00:59:39,974 WHICH IS SOMETHING I THINK CAN 1653 00:59:39,974 --> 00:59:41,142 OFTEN BE LOST PARTICULARLY AND 1654 00:59:41,142 --> 00:59:43,444 THIS IS THE BIG POINT THAT I 1655 00:59:43,444 --> 00:59:45,112 HOPE WE DIG INTO THE NEED FOR 1656 00:59:45,112 --> 00:59:50,751 DATA STABBED ARDS --STANDARDS AD 1657 00:59:50,751 --> 00:59:51,452 CLEAR REPORTING AND 1658 00:59:51,452 --> 00:59:52,386 UNDERSTANDABILITY OF WHAT I CALL 1659 00:59:52,386 --> 00:59:55,256 LOSS OF SMELL AT MY INSTITUTE 1660 00:59:55,256 --> 00:59:57,258 ALIGNS WITH THE SAME DIAGNOSIS, 1661 00:59:57,258 --> 00:59:59,326 THE SAME METRIC THAT'S MEASURED 1662 00:59:59,326 --> 01:00:08,769 AND REPORTED IN A COMMON 1663 01:00:08,769 --> 01:00:09,270 DATABASE. 1664 01:00:09,270 --> 01:00:18,712 >> YES, GOOD MORNING I'M 1665 01:00:18,712 --> 01:00:20,181 VALENTINA, FRANCESCA, LEADING 1666 01:00:20,181 --> 01:00:21,782 THE HUMAN GENOME RESEARCH 1667 01:00:21,782 --> 01:00:24,185 INSTITUTE, MY BACKGROUND IS 1668 01:00:24,185 --> 01:00:24,985 MATHEMATICS AND STATISTICS. 1669 01:00:24,985 --> 01:00:26,954 I CAME TO THE NIEKS H, I WAS 1670 01:00:26,954 --> 01:00:28,823 ALWAYS ABOUTED IN THE 1671 01:00:28,823 --> 01:00:30,825 APPLICATIONS OF MATHEMATICAL AND 1672 01:00:30,825 --> 01:00:32,660 STATISTICAL TOOLS TO REAL WORLD 1673 01:00:32,660 --> 01:00:33,994 CHALLENGES AND SO, I HAVE--IT 1674 01:00:33,994 --> 01:00:36,697 WAS LIKE ENOUGH TO COME TO THE 1675 01:00:36,697 --> 01:00:38,666 NIH TO DO A POST DOCTORAL 1676 01:00:38,666 --> 01:00:40,801 FELLOWSHIP, THAT'S HOW I STARTED 1677 01:00:40,801 --> 01:00:45,239 TO LEARN BIOLOGY, SO, AND I WAS 1678 01:00:45,239 --> 01:00:46,774 LUCKY ENOUGH TO GET INTO 1679 01:00:46,774 --> 01:00:48,542 GENOMICS AT THE VERY EARLY YEARS 1680 01:00:48,542 --> 01:00:50,945 FOR THE INSTITUTE GENOMIC 1681 01:00:50,945 --> 01:00:52,813 RESEARCH, GENOMICS, I WAS 1682 01:00:52,813 --> 01:00:54,014 INVOLVED IN THE HUMAN GENOME 1683 01:00:54,014 --> 01:00:56,984 PROJECT AND BASICALLY BECAME A 1684 01:00:56,984 --> 01:00:57,852 COMPUTATIONAL GENOMICS ALL THE 1685 01:00:57,852 --> 01:01:01,589 TIME AND THEN I CAME TO THE NIH 1686 01:01:01,589 --> 01:01:03,357 AS A PROGRAM OFFICER, ALWAYS 1687 01:01:03,357 --> 01:01:05,993 BEEN INVOLVED IN VARIOUS 1688 01:01:05,993 --> 01:01:08,662 PROGRAMS ABOUT DOING ANALYSIS OF 1689 01:01:08,662 --> 01:01:10,664 GENOMIC DATA, SO I'M VERY 1690 01:01:10,664 --> 01:01:12,900 COMMITTED AND INTERESTED IN ALL 1691 01:01:12,900 --> 01:01:15,069 THINGS ABOUT HOW TO EXTRACT 1692 01:01:15,069 --> 01:01:17,171 INFORMATION FROM THE DATA BEING 1693 01:01:17,171 --> 01:01:18,505 DPENERATED, HOW TO ANALYZE IT 1694 01:01:18,505 --> 01:01:20,975 AND CREATING THE ENVIRONMENT AND 1695 01:01:20,975 --> 01:01:23,177 RESOURCES THAT ADAM JUST TALKED 1696 01:01:23,177 --> 01:01:25,012 ABOUT BECAUSE IT'S A BIG 1697 01:01:25,012 --> 01:01:25,746 CHALLENGE. 1698 01:01:25,746 --> 01:01:27,815 IT'S OBVIOUS THAT BIOMEDICAL 1699 01:01:27,815 --> 01:01:29,950 RESEARCH IS TIGHTLY CONNECKED TO 1700 01:01:29,950 --> 01:01:32,219 THE PROGRESS OF DATA SCIENCE 1701 01:01:32,219 --> 01:01:34,889 TECHNOLOGIES AND SO, HOW TO MAKE 1702 01:01:34,889 --> 01:01:36,824 SURE THAT NIH VALUES INSTITUTES 1703 01:01:36,824 --> 01:01:39,994 ACROSS THE NIH HAVE THE TOOLS 1704 01:01:39,994 --> 01:01:44,031 AND THE TECHNOLOGIES TO DO 1705 01:01:44,031 --> 01:01:44,365 EXACTLY THAT. 1706 01:01:44,365 --> 01:01:45,633 BIG DATA HAS BEEN GENERATED AND 1707 01:01:45,633 --> 01:01:48,402 IT IS A WELL-KNOWN SECRET THAT 1708 01:01:48,402 --> 01:01:50,638 EVEN THOUGH WE ARE REALLY GOOD 1709 01:01:50,638 --> 01:01:52,172 AT GENERATING DATA AND NOT THAT 1710 01:01:52,172 --> 01:01:54,008 GOOD AT ANALYZING IT AND ALSO 1711 01:01:54,008 --> 01:01:55,109 NOT THAT GOOD ABOUT MAKING THE 1712 01:01:55,109 --> 01:01:56,777 TOOLS RABBLE TO THE CLINICIANS 1713 01:01:56,777 --> 01:01:58,145 AND TO BIOMEDICAL RESEARCHERS 1714 01:01:58,145 --> 01:02:01,448 THAT ACTUALLY NEED TO USE IT SO 1715 01:02:01,448 --> 01:02:03,918 HOW TO TRANSLATE ALL THIS WEALTH 1716 01:02:03,918 --> 01:02:06,453 OF INFORMATION INTO SOMETHING 1717 01:02:06,453 --> 01:02:07,554 THAT IS MANAGEABLE AND 1718 01:02:07,554 --> 01:02:08,489 UNDERSTANDABLE BY THE PEOPLE 1719 01:02:08,489 --> 01:02:10,824 THAT NEED TO USE IT NOT ONLY THE 1720 01:02:10,824 --> 01:02:13,694 CLINICIANS BUT ALSO PATIENTS 1721 01:02:13,694 --> 01:02:16,597 THAT IS REALLY A PASSION OF 1722 01:02:16,597 --> 01:02:17,298 MINE. 1723 01:02:17,298 --> 01:02:21,402 I AM LUCKY ENOUGH THAT I AM AT 1724 01:02:21,402 --> 01:02:22,903 NHGRI THAT IS AT THE FOREFRONT 1725 01:02:22,903 --> 01:02:24,238 OF THESE QUESTIONS SO FOR ME 1726 01:02:24,238 --> 01:02:28,909 IT'S FROM THE POINT OF VIEW AS 1727 01:02:28,909 --> 01:02:31,512 AN ADMINISTRATOR AT THE NIH, I 1728 01:02:31,512 --> 01:02:32,780 AM VERY GLAD WE ARE THAT 1729 01:02:32,780 --> 01:02:34,281 OPPORTUNITY FOR ME TO BE HERE SO 1730 01:02:34,281 --> 01:02:37,651 THAT WE CAN TRY TO ESTABLISH 1731 01:02:37,651 --> 01:02:39,186 COLLABORATIONS ON THIS VERY 1732 01:02:39,186 --> 01:02:41,322 IMPORTANT TOPICS WHERE WE ARE 1733 01:02:41,322 --> 01:02:42,623 DOING PROGRESS IN DIFFERENT WAYS 1734 01:02:42,623 --> 01:02:44,491 AND THERE'S A LOT OF KNOWLEDGE 1735 01:02:44,491 --> 01:02:50,497 THAT WE CAN SHARE, SO I WILL 1736 01:02:50,497 --> 01:02:51,332 STOP HERE. 1737 01:02:51,332 --> 01:02:53,167 >> SO I ALWAYS LIKE TO SHARE 1738 01:02:53,167 --> 01:03:01,508 MISTAKES WE'VE MADE AS CONTEXT. 1739 01:03:01,508 --> 01:03:04,044 AND SO YOU SAW OUR EFFORTS NOW, 1740 01:03:04,044 --> 01:03:06,180 SO WEY GANNA WITH GENERATED 1741 01:03:06,180 --> 01:03:07,614 RETIRING MOLECULAR DATA SETS, IN 1742 01:03:07,614 --> 01:03:09,416 PART BECAUSE WE BELIEVE IN 1743 01:03:09,416 --> 01:03:11,885 MOLECULAR DAILY BASIS THEA SETS 1744 01:03:11,885 --> 01:03:15,522 AS A CONDUIT FOR DRUGS, SPECIFIC 1745 01:03:15,522 --> 01:03:15,956 MUTATION OR CONTEXT. 1746 01:03:15,956 --> 01:03:19,393 THE MISTAKE WE MADE, I THINK 1747 01:03:19,393 --> 01:03:20,794 TIES TO YOUR CHARGE WHICH IS IF 1748 01:03:20,794 --> 01:03:26,900 YOU GO TO ANY ANY MOLECULAR TUR 1749 01:03:26,900 --> 01:03:28,369 BOARD AT ANY HOSPITAL, THE FIRST 1750 01:03:28,369 --> 01:03:31,372 THINK THIS THEY PULL UP IS THE 1751 01:03:31,372 --> 01:03:33,107 IN, RI, THE RADIOLOGY REPORT, 1752 01:03:33,107 --> 01:03:34,842 THE HISTOLOGY SLIDE AND THEN, 1753 01:03:34,842 --> 01:03:38,846 THEY'LL GET TO THE MOLECULAR 1754 01:03:38,846 --> 01:03:39,113 FEATURES. 1755 01:03:39,113 --> 01:03:40,948 SO THE PART I THINK WE MISS 1756 01:03:40,948 --> 01:03:45,119 EARLY ON IS NOT YOUR RECOGNIZED 1757 01:03:45,119 --> 01:03:46,720 THAT WE SHOULD ACTUALLY ANCHOR 1758 01:03:46,720 --> 01:03:52,826 INTO WHAT IS THE CLINICAL DATA 1759 01:03:52,826 --> 01:03:54,495 SET, RIGHT, THAT CLINICIANS ARE 1760 01:03:54,495 --> 01:03:56,497 ACTUALLY CURRENTLY USING IN THE 1761 01:03:56,497 --> 01:03:58,832 CONTEXT OF CARE, THAT WAVE FORM 1762 01:03:58,832 --> 01:03:59,867 DATA, IMAGING DATA, 1 OF THE 1763 01:03:59,867 --> 01:04:01,402 ASSAY THAIS ARE DOING CLINICALLY 1764 01:04:01,402 --> 01:04:03,737 AND HOW ARE THEY ASSEMBLING THAT 1765 01:04:03,737 --> 01:04:07,074 CAT ON BEHALF OF CARE, LIKELY 1766 01:04:07,074 --> 01:04:09,710 NOT THROUGH A DATABASE, RIGHT, 1767 01:04:09,710 --> 01:04:11,445 THEY'RE ASSEMBLING IN THEIR 1768 01:04:11,445 --> 01:04:11,945 MIND, RIGHT? 1769 01:04:11,945 --> 01:04:13,113 EACH 1 INDIVIDUALLY BUT 1770 01:04:13,113 --> 01:04:15,416 RECOGNIZING THAT WITHIN EACH 1771 01:04:15,416 --> 01:04:18,152 DOMAIN, THERE'S TYPICAL LYE A 1772 01:04:18,152 --> 01:04:19,787 SET, RIGHT, OF CLINICAL DAT THAT 1773 01:04:19,787 --> 01:04:22,523 COMES FROM TECH SPACE INTERFACE 1774 01:04:22,523 --> 01:04:24,058 PLUS SOME MODALITIES THAT ARE 1775 01:04:24,058 --> 01:04:25,192 BEING ASSAYS IN MEASUREMENTS 1776 01:04:25,192 --> 01:04:28,929 THAT ARE BEING TAKEN INTO 1777 01:04:28,929 --> 01:04:29,229 ACCOUNT. 1778 01:04:29,229 --> 01:04:33,600 RARELY, HAVE I SEEN AND MADE 1779 01:04:33,600 --> 01:04:35,002 THOSE MISTAKES, AS INFRANCIS 1780 01:04:35,002 --> 01:04:36,236 COLLINS STRUCKURE FOR PRECISION 1781 01:04:36,236 --> 01:04:37,438 MEDICINE BEEN BUILT THINKING 1782 01:04:37,438 --> 01:04:39,106 ABOUT THE COMBINATION OF DATA 1783 01:04:39,106 --> 01:04:41,608 THAT THE CLINICAL PEOPLE 1784 01:04:41,608 --> 01:04:44,778 ACTUALLY USE IN COMBINATION 1785 01:04:44,778 --> 01:04:46,513 RIGHT, FOR CARE, AS THE 1786 01:04:46,513 --> 01:04:48,515 FOUNDATION UPON WHICH YOU EXTEND 1787 01:04:48,515 --> 01:04:50,350 THE ADDITIONAL DATA MODALITIES, 1788 01:04:50,350 --> 01:04:52,119 MAKE SENSE, SO, YOU KNOW LIKE I 1789 01:04:52,119 --> 01:04:55,456 SAID, THE MINUTE WE STARTED 1790 01:04:55,456 --> 01:04:56,123 HAVING MOLECULAR FINDINGS, 1791 01:04:56,123 --> 01:04:58,058 PEOPLE SAY LET ME SEE THE MRI, 1792 01:04:58,058 --> 01:05:00,461 THEY'RE USED TO THAT, THAT'S HOW 1793 01:05:00,461 --> 01:05:04,364 THEY TREAT THEIR PATIENTS. 1794 01:05:04,364 --> 01:05:09,703 ONE OF THE DATA MODALITIES THE 1795 01:05:09,703 --> 01:05:11,638 CLENITION USES, BUT HOW CAN 1796 01:05:11,638 --> 01:05:16,243 THOSE BE EXPANDED THROUGH DATA 1797 01:05:16,243 --> 01:05:18,078 SCIENCE INFRASTRUCTURE IS AN 1798 01:05:18,078 --> 01:05:18,912 EXTREMELY UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY 1799 01:05:18,912 --> 01:05:20,514 THAT'S NOT ALWAYS BEEN DONE, IN 1800 01:05:20,514 --> 01:05:22,082 PART BECAUSE IT'S A CHALLENGE. 1801 01:05:22,082 --> 01:05:27,187 WAIT FOR DATA, HAS TO BE MANAGED 1802 01:05:27,187 --> 01:05:29,990 DIFFERENTLY THAN.COM DATA OR 1803 01:05:29,990 --> 01:05:32,126 TEXT-BASED DATA OR MOLECULAR 1804 01:05:32,126 --> 01:05:32,326 DATA. 1805 01:05:32,326 --> 01:05:34,394 BUT I THINK THAT COMMUNITIES 1806 01:05:34,394 --> 01:05:36,130 THAT START FRESH POTENTIALLY 1807 01:05:36,130 --> 01:05:40,534 HAVE A OPPORTUNITY TO LEAP FROG, 1808 01:05:40,534 --> 01:05:41,368 MAKE DECISIONS DIFFERENTLY THAN 1809 01:05:41,368 --> 01:05:43,170 THOSE OF US WHO GRIND OUR WAY 1810 01:05:43,170 --> 01:05:45,672 THROUGH IT EARLY ON. 1811 01:05:45,672 --> 01:05:46,140 >> THANKS. 1812 01:05:46,140 --> 01:05:47,741 I WOULD LIKE TO DRILL DOWN A 1813 01:05:47,741 --> 01:05:50,244 LITTLE BIT INTO SOME DETAILS, 1814 01:05:50,244 --> 01:05:51,512 BASED ON YOUR 3 RESPONSES AND 1815 01:05:51,512 --> 01:05:54,248 I'M GOING TO TAKE THE 1816 01:05:54,248 --> 01:05:56,483 PERSPECTIVE OF SOMEBODY WHO'S 1817 01:05:56,483 --> 01:05:59,153 HAD REQUESTS FROM THE RESEARCH 1818 01:05:59,153 --> 01:05:59,753 COMMUNITY, THE COMMUNICATIONS 1819 01:05:59,753 --> 01:06:00,587 RESEARCH COMMUNITY ABOUT ALL OF 1820 01:06:00,587 --> 01:06:03,690 US, WHERE IS THE AUDIOGRAM DATA, 1821 01:06:03,690 --> 01:06:07,794 WHERE IS THE SPEECH DATA, CAN WE 1822 01:06:07,794 --> 01:06:09,530 CAPTURE LINKAGES TO 1823 01:06:09,530 --> 01:06:12,065 ENVIRONMENTAL NOISE FEATURES AND 1824 01:06:12,065 --> 01:06:14,101 YOU KNOW MAKE--AND THROUGH 1825 01:06:14,101 --> 01:06:15,602 GEOCODING BE ABLE TO UNDERSTAND 1826 01:06:15,602 --> 01:06:21,074 THE ENVIRONMENT OF THE PERSON 1827 01:06:21,074 --> 01:06:22,809 EXPERIENCING SOME TYPE OF 1828 01:06:22,809 --> 01:06:23,377 HEALTH-DISEASE TRANSITION. 1829 01:06:23,377 --> 01:06:24,878 SO FIRST OF ALL I WOULD LIKE YOU 1830 01:06:24,878 --> 01:06:26,446 TO REAC TO THE KINDS OF DATA AT 1831 01:06:26,446 --> 01:06:29,516 THAT LEVEL THAT WILL BE CRITICAL 1832 01:06:29,516 --> 01:06:32,252 FOR NIDCD TO ACHIEVE PRECISION 1833 01:06:32,252 --> 01:06:35,589 MEDICINE IN THIS REGUARD AND 1834 01:06:35,589 --> 01:06:37,891 ALSO THINK ABOUT THE STANDARDS 1835 01:06:37,891 --> 01:06:39,893 AND MAKING IT INTEROPERABLE, 1836 01:06:39,893 --> 01:06:40,994 MAYBE DIFFERENT HEALTH SYSTEMS 1837 01:06:40,994 --> 01:06:43,263 HAVE DIFFERENT WAYS TO CAPTURE 1838 01:06:43,263 --> 01:06:44,531 AUDIOGRAM DATA, DO THEY ACTUALLY 1839 01:06:44,531 --> 01:06:46,033 COMMUNICATE WITH EACH OTHER, DO 1840 01:06:46,033 --> 01:06:48,335 RESEARCHERS ACTUALLY KNOW HOW TO 1841 01:06:48,335 --> 01:06:51,405 USE AND TRANSFORM THOSE DATA 1842 01:06:51,405 --> 01:06:52,506 INTO USEABLE FEATURES THAT THEY 1843 01:06:52,506 --> 01:06:55,409 CAN USE IN THE RESEARCH SO THE 1844 01:06:55,409 --> 01:06:57,578 TOOLS, PIECE AND THEN THE 1845 01:06:57,578 --> 01:06:58,612 COMBINATORIAL ASPECT, TOO, SO I 1846 01:06:58,612 --> 01:07:00,847 WOULD LIKE TO GET MORE INTO THE 1847 01:07:00,847 --> 01:07:03,450 DETAILS OF YOU KNOW THE DATA 1848 01:07:03,450 --> 01:07:05,886 TYPES AND WHAT THE CHALLENGES 1849 01:07:05,886 --> 01:07:06,386 MIGHT BE. 1850 01:07:06,386 --> 01:07:07,588 NYEAH, I LOVE THE QUESTION, I 1851 01:07:07,588 --> 01:07:12,192 WOULD LIKE TO ECHO, GIVE US THE 1852 01:07:12,192 --> 01:07:12,693 DATA. 1853 01:07:12,693 --> 01:07:14,194 IT'S AN EDUCATION THAT I'VE 1854 01:07:14,194 --> 01:07:16,463 RECENTLY HAD TRYING TO TACKLE 1855 01:07:16,463 --> 01:07:21,768 THIS QUESTION IN THAT AS A 1856 01:07:21,768 --> 01:07:23,437 CLINICIAN, OF COURSE IT'S EASY. 1857 01:07:23,437 --> 01:07:24,238 WE KNOW AUTOIMPORTANT AND WE CAN 1858 01:07:24,238 --> 01:07:26,073 GET THE DAILY BASIS THEA AND 1859 01:07:26,073 --> 01:07:27,608 STANDARDS ARE JUST THE DEFINED 1860 01:07:27,608 --> 01:07:29,176 DEFINITION OF WHAT WE VALUE BUT 1861 01:07:29,176 --> 01:07:30,644 IN PRACTICE, THE EDUCATION I'VE 1862 01:07:30,644 --> 01:07:32,179 HAD IS THAT IT'S INCREDIBLY 1863 01:07:32,179 --> 01:07:34,481 DIFFICULT AND I WANT TO 1864 01:07:34,481 --> 01:07:36,783 ACKNOWLEDGE KELLIE KENNING WHO'S 1865 01:07:36,783 --> 01:07:38,252 HELPED TO LEAD THIS EFFORT 1866 01:07:38,252 --> 01:07:40,120 WITHIN THE HEARING SPACE WHERE 1867 01:07:40,120 --> 01:07:42,055 WE'VE ACTUALLY PARTNERED WITH 1868 01:07:42,055 --> 01:07:45,259 THE NATIONAL ACADEMIES TO BRING 1869 01:07:45,259 --> 01:07:47,227 DIFFERENT STAKEHOLDERS TO 1 1870 01:07:47,227 --> 01:07:49,162 PLACE, DIFFERENT VALUES SO THAT 1871 01:07:49,162 --> 01:07:53,166 WE CAN ACCEPT AND ADOPT THESE 1872 01:07:53,166 --> 01:07:54,868 STANDARDS WHICH ARE THEN 1873 01:07:54,868 --> 01:07:56,703 INTEROPERABLE BECAUSE RIGHT NOW, 1874 01:07:56,703 --> 01:07:59,640 A PDF OF AN AUDIOGRAM AS YOU 1875 01:07:59,640 --> 01:08:08,181 MENTIONED, IS VERY LIMITED 1876 01:08:08,181 --> 01:08:09,383 EMPLOY SPHRKS I DON'T HAVE AN 1877 01:08:09,383 --> 01:08:10,651 SECOND WORLD WAR ARE TO THAT 1878 01:08:10,651 --> 01:08:12,953 QUESTION BUT I AM 1 THAT IS 1879 01:08:12,953 --> 01:08:14,621 WONDERING WHETHER WE CAN USE 1880 01:08:14,621 --> 01:08:16,056 LANGUAGE MODELS TO DEFINE 1881 01:08:16,056 --> 01:08:17,557 STANDARDS AND ENCOURAGE THE AX 1882 01:08:17,557 --> 01:08:21,061 DOPGZ OF STANDARDS BY 1883 01:08:21,061 --> 01:08:22,095 RESEARCHERS. 1884 01:08:22,095 --> 01:08:24,531 BECAUSE IT'S DIFFICULT, RIGHT, 1885 01:08:24,531 --> 01:08:26,233 IT'S REALLY DIFFICULT TO DEFINE 1886 01:08:26,233 --> 01:08:27,668 STANDARDS THAT WORK WITH 1887 01:08:27,668 --> 01:08:28,702 DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES ATA A HIGH 1888 01:08:28,702 --> 01:08:30,771 LEVEL AND IT'S ALSO VERY 1889 01:08:30,771 --> 01:08:33,407 DIFFICULT ONCE THE STANDARD IS 1890 01:08:33,407 --> 01:08:36,743 DEFINED TO REALLY IMPLEMENT IT 1891 01:08:36,743 --> 01:08:39,313 IN REAL CASE SITUATIONS SO TO 1892 01:08:39,313 --> 01:08:41,114 HAVE TOOLS AND LARGE LANGUAGE 1893 01:08:41,114 --> 01:08:43,617 MODELS HAVE DIFFERENT FEATURES, 1894 01:08:43,617 --> 01:08:46,119 THAT SEEM PROMISING THAT COULD 1895 01:08:46,119 --> 01:08:47,888 FACILITATE ONCE THE STANDARD IS 1896 01:08:47,888 --> 01:08:50,590 IN PLACE, COULD FACILITATE THE 1897 01:08:50,590 --> 01:08:52,259 ADOPTION OF THESE STANDARDS BY 1898 01:08:52,259 --> 01:08:59,433 THE RESEARCH COMMUNITY, JUST AN 1899 01:08:59,433 --> 01:08:59,766 IDEA. 1900 01:08:59,766 --> 01:09:00,834 >> HUNDRED PERCENT AGREE WITH 1901 01:09:00,834 --> 01:09:02,869 YOUR COMMENT. 1902 01:09:02,869 --> 01:09:05,939 WE EVEN SEE THIS IN FIELDS THAT 1903 01:09:05,939 --> 01:09:10,977 HAVE SOME ESTABLISHED LIKE 1904 01:09:10,977 --> 01:09:12,346 IMAGING FOR EXAMPLE. 1905 01:09:12,346 --> 01:09:13,647 I WAS ALWAYS REFLECT AND 1906 01:09:13,647 --> 01:09:15,649 CONTHECT IT TO GENOMICS, 1907 01:09:15,649 --> 01:09:16,983 GENOMICS YES THERE ARE DIFFERENT 1908 01:09:16,983 --> 01:09:18,919 PLATFORMS BUT AS A FIELD WE SORT 1909 01:09:18,919 --> 01:09:21,421 OF HAVE A HANDLE ON HOW TO MAKE 1910 01:09:21,421 --> 01:09:23,790 THEM EQUAL OR THAT CAN BE 1911 01:09:23,790 --> 01:09:24,124 EQUALIZED. 1912 01:09:24,124 --> 01:09:25,225 MANY OTHER MODALITIES WE DON'T 1913 01:09:25,225 --> 01:09:31,098 AS A CONTEXT AND SO I'VE OFTEN 1914 01:09:31,098 --> 01:09:34,301 WONDERED WHY STANDARDS EMERGE. 1915 01:09:34,301 --> 01:09:36,303 STANDARDS EMERGE BECAUSE OF 1916 01:09:36,303 --> 01:09:37,904 VALUE PROPOSITION FOR 1917 01:09:37,904 --> 01:09:38,538 IMPLEMENTATION OF STANDARDS FOR 1918 01:09:38,538 --> 01:09:41,408 THOSE WHO ARE FORCED TO CHANGE 1919 01:09:41,408 --> 01:09:41,775 PRACTICE, RIGHT? 1920 01:09:41,775 --> 01:09:42,442 DPE NATIONAL LIBRARY OF MEDICINE 1921 01:09:42,442 --> 01:09:43,110 INCREASE IN BODYS IT WAS CLEAR, 1922 01:09:43,110 --> 01:09:44,411 IF I WANT TO INTERPRET MY 1923 01:09:44,411 --> 01:09:46,380 GENOME, I HAVE TO INTERPRET MY 1924 01:09:46,380 --> 01:09:48,682 CONTEXT OF OTHER GENOMES, SO 1925 01:09:48,682 --> 01:09:50,417 THERE BETTER BE A STANDARD FOR 1926 01:09:50,417 --> 01:09:52,285 ME TO COMPARE THEM. 1927 01:09:52,285 --> 01:09:57,157 I THINK THAT THAT'S THE KEY, 1928 01:09:57,157 --> 01:09:59,559 RIGHT, IS THE GAP THAT I 1929 01:09:59,559 --> 01:10:00,627 MENTIONED IS UNTIL THE POINT 1930 01:10:00,627 --> 01:10:02,129 WHERE YOU CAN ACTUALLY ADD VALUE 1931 01:10:02,129 --> 01:10:05,599 TO THE CLINICIAN LOOKING AT THAT 1932 01:10:05,599 --> 01:10:12,172 PDF, IMPLEMENTS STANDARDS IS AN 1933 01:10:12,172 --> 01:10:13,473 OVERHEAD, VERY CHALLENGING. 1934 01:10:13,473 --> 01:10:15,976 OR ALTERNATIVELY IF THERE'S AN 1935 01:10:15,976 --> 01:10:17,711 NIH FUNDED PROJECT THE OTHER 1936 01:10:17,711 --> 01:10:19,646 INCENTIVE IS FINANCIAL OR 1937 01:10:19,646 --> 01:10:23,617 ACADEMIC SO I THINK THIS IS THE 1938 01:10:23,617 --> 01:10:25,419 PROMISE OF AN ANALYTIC FRAMEWORK 1939 01:10:25,419 --> 01:10:26,686 THAT'S LINKED TO HEALTHCARE. 1940 01:10:26,686 --> 01:10:28,955 THE MINUTE YOU ACTUALLY TART 1941 01:10:28,955 --> 01:10:30,891 EXTRACTING FEATURES AND 1942 01:10:30,891 --> 01:10:32,559 COMBINING THEM AND MAKING IT 1943 01:10:32,559 --> 01:10:35,595 MEANINGFUL TO A CLINICIAN OR 1944 01:10:35,595 --> 01:10:37,297 RESEARCHER AT A POINT OF 1945 01:10:37,297 --> 01:10:39,766 INTERFACE, WE SEE BEHAVIORS 1946 01:10:39,766 --> 01:10:40,000 CHANGE. 1947 01:10:40,000 --> 01:10:40,667 EVERYBODY COMPLAINS ABOUT 1948 01:10:40,667 --> 01:10:42,102 PUTTING DATA INTO EPIC, 1949 01:10:42,102 --> 01:10:44,371 CLINICIANS HATE IT ISSUES RIGHT, 1950 01:10:44,371 --> 01:10:45,572 BECAUSE THEY DON'T GET ANYTHING 1951 01:10:45,572 --> 01:10:46,239 BACK. 1952 01:10:46,239 --> 01:10:48,341 IMAGINE IF YOU CAN TELL A 1953 01:10:48,341 --> 01:10:49,643 CLINICIAN IF YOU PUT YOUR DATA 1954 01:10:49,643 --> 01:10:51,912 IN HERE THIS WAY, CAN YOU 1955 01:10:51,912 --> 01:10:53,647 IMMEDIATELY SEE YOUR PATIENT 1956 01:10:53,647 --> 01:10:55,148 CONTEXT OF ALL OTHER PATIENTS. 1957 01:10:55,148 --> 01:10:56,316 CLINICIANS WANT TO HELP THEM 1958 01:10:56,316 --> 01:10:58,718 PEASHTS ISSUES THE FEEDBACK LOOP 1959 01:10:58,718 --> 01:11:03,123 FOR ADOPTION IS MISSING AND 1960 01:11:03,123 --> 01:11:07,427 THAT'S 1 HYPOTHESIS THAT I SAY 1961 01:11:07,427 --> 01:11:12,065 WE'VE SEEN EMERGE. 1962 01:11:12,065 --> 01:11:13,633 >> YEAH, SURE, REACT. 1963 01:11:13,633 --> 01:11:15,168 >> I WANT TO COME BACK TO THE 1964 01:11:15,168 --> 01:11:18,438 FACT THAT GENOMICS IS QUITE 1965 01:11:18,438 --> 01:11:20,240 ADVANCED COMPARED TO OTHER 1966 01:11:20,240 --> 01:11:21,675 RESEARCH FIELDS FOR STANDARDS 1967 01:11:21,675 --> 01:11:23,143 THAT CAN BE USED IN BIOMEDICAL 1968 01:11:23,143 --> 01:11:26,112 RESEARCH SO I JUST WANT TO 1969 01:11:26,112 --> 01:11:29,249 MENTION PROBABLY 1 OF THE 1970 01:11:29,249 --> 01:11:30,717 STANDARDS, 1 OF THE RESEARCH 1971 01:11:30,717 --> 01:11:31,751 ORGANIZATIONS THAT REALLY, I 1972 01:11:31,751 --> 01:11:33,653 THINK WE'RE QUITE SUCCESSFUL IN 1973 01:11:33,653 --> 01:11:37,324 REALLY BRINGING THE COMMUNITY 1974 01:11:37,324 --> 01:11:41,828 TOGETHER IS THE GA FOR GH, 1975 01:11:41,828 --> 01:11:43,430 GOINGAL ALLIANCE FOR GENOMICS 1976 01:11:43,430 --> 01:11:44,030 AND HEALTH. 1977 01:11:44,030 --> 01:11:46,233 WHY WAS THAT SUCCESSFUL? 1978 01:11:46,233 --> 01:11:48,068 BECAUSE THEY CREATED A COMMUNITY 1979 01:11:48,068 --> 01:11:48,902 OF PARTIES THAT UNDERSTOOD THE 1980 01:11:48,902 --> 01:11:51,838 MISSION OF THE VALUE OF THE 1981 01:11:51,838 --> 01:11:54,274 STANDARDS AND COMMUNITY-DRIVEN 1982 01:11:54,274 --> 01:11:57,110 NOT MANDATES FROM THE NIH REALLY 1983 01:11:57,110 --> 01:11:58,011 ESTABLISHED THIS COMMUNITY OF 1984 01:11:58,011 --> 01:11:59,212 PEOPLE ACROSS THE WORLD THAT 1985 01:11:59,212 --> 01:12:01,348 WANTS TO COME TOGETHER TO 1986 01:12:01,348 --> 01:12:03,416 UNDERSTAND IMPORTANCE OF HAVING 1987 01:12:03,416 --> 01:12:05,952 STANDARDS FOR SHARING GENOMICS 1988 01:12:05,952 --> 01:12:08,555 DATA, ALSO FOR HEALTHCARE 1989 01:12:08,555 --> 01:12:08,889 PURPOSES. 1990 01:12:08,889 --> 01:12:10,657 SO YOU KNOW TO THE EXTENT THAT 1991 01:12:10,657 --> 01:12:13,693 SUCH A COMMUNITY CAN BE 1992 01:12:13,693 --> 01:12:14,461 ESTABLISHED FOR YOUR RESEARCH 1993 01:12:14,461 --> 01:12:16,029 COMMUNITY, I THINK THAT IS A 1994 01:12:16,029 --> 01:12:19,366 GREAT MODEL TO FOLLOW. 1995 01:12:19,366 --> 01:12:21,601 >> I WILL ADD 1 OTHER 1996 01:12:21,601 --> 01:12:22,269 COMMENT--NNO, NO, PLEASE. 1997 01:12:22,269 --> 01:12:25,772 NTHE 1998 01:12:25,772 --> 01:12:26,006 -- 1999 01:12:26,006 --> 01:12:28,308 >> THE OTHER THING YOU SEE IN 2000 01:12:28,308 --> 01:12:29,609 THE COMMERCIAL VENDORS PROVIDING 2001 01:12:29,609 --> 01:12:31,878 THOSE FRAMEWORK ANDS YOU KNOW 2002 01:12:31,878 --> 01:12:36,483 WE'VE SEEN IN WAYS THAT'S BEEN 2003 01:12:36,483 --> 01:12:37,951 REMARKABLE AROUND FHIR RESOURCE 2004 01:12:37,951 --> 01:12:40,921 IS THAT THE MINUTE THE FEDERAL 2005 01:12:40,921 --> 01:12:45,358 FRAMEWORK SAID THIS IS A 2006 01:12:45,358 --> 01:12:46,626 STANDARD, COMMERCIAL ENTITIES 2007 01:12:46,626 --> 01:12:49,062 BEGAN ADOPTING AND DEVELOPING 2008 01:12:49,062 --> 01:12:50,564 AGAINST IT MUCH, MUCH FASTER 2009 01:12:50,564 --> 01:12:52,299 THAN RESEARCH OR EACH HOSPITAL 2010 01:12:52,299 --> 01:12:55,068 SYSTEMS, LIKE AMAZON AND GOOGLE 2011 01:12:55,068 --> 01:12:57,571 AND MICROSOFT, SO THAT'S THE 2012 01:12:57,571 --> 01:13:03,810 OTHER ANGLE IS THAT I THINK AS 2013 01:13:03,810 --> 01:13:05,512 VALENTINA, MENTIONED, CAN YOU 2014 01:13:05,512 --> 01:13:08,081 PAIR ESSENTIALLY A BODY THAT HAS 2015 01:13:08,081 --> 01:13:10,550 SOME AUTHORITY AROUND RESOURCES 2016 01:13:10,550 --> 01:13:14,988 WITH COMMUNITY FEEDBACK LOOP OF 2017 01:13:14,988 --> 01:13:16,256 EMPOWERMENT. 2018 01:13:16,256 --> 01:13:19,859 THOSE CAN ACTUALLY DRIVE 2019 01:13:19,859 --> 01:13:20,293 PRACTICE. 2020 01:13:20,293 --> 01:13:21,261 >> MY COMMENT WAS RIGHT ALIGNED 2021 01:13:21,261 --> 01:13:23,096 WITH THAT AND I WAS NOT 2022 01:13:23,096 --> 01:13:25,999 ANTICIPATING TO HEAR ABOUT FHIR 2023 01:13:25,999 --> 01:13:27,233 TODAY BUT I'M REALLY FLAD THAT 2024 01:13:27,233 --> 01:13:31,972 YOU BROUGHT IT UP. 2025 01:13:31,972 --> 01:13:34,274 MY UNDERSTANDING OF FHIR IS THAT 2026 01:13:34,274 --> 01:13:38,678 IT'S A DATA STANDARD FOR THE 2027 01:13:38,678 --> 01:13:40,213 SHARING TRANSMISSION OF IN MY 2028 01:13:40,213 --> 01:13:41,147 EXPERIENCE AT LEAST, CLINICAL 2029 01:13:41,147 --> 01:13:43,350 DATA IF YOU HAVE AN AUDIOGRAM TO 2030 01:13:43,350 --> 01:13:45,185 SUBMIT THAT TO YOUR EPIC 2031 01:13:45,185 --> 01:13:48,054 DATABASE IT HAS TO FOLLOW A 2032 01:13:48,054 --> 01:13:50,757 FHRIERKS R PROTOCOL AND ADAM 2033 01:13:50,757 --> 01:13:52,258 PLEASE CORRECT, THE FRAME SHIFT 2034 01:13:52,258 --> 01:13:56,863 FOR ME IS VIEWING THAT STANDARD 2035 01:13:56,863 --> 01:13:59,733 IN THE RESEARCH FIELD, EXTENDING 2036 01:13:59,733 --> 01:14:01,067 IT BEYOND CLINICAL CARE, I THINK 2037 01:14:01,067 --> 01:14:03,103 THISIA A LOT OF OPPORTUNITIES. 2038 01:14:03,103 --> 01:14:06,172 NYEAH, THIS IS A KEY MOMENT IN 2039 01:14:06,172 --> 01:14:08,274 TIME, THEY ARE DEVELOPED FOR THE 2040 01:14:08,274 --> 01:14:09,776 CLINICAL FRAMEWORK, THE RESEARCH 2041 01:14:09,776 --> 01:14:11,645 COMMITTEE HAS HAD A VERY 2042 01:14:11,645 --> 01:14:15,582 EMPOWERED CONTEXT FOR CLENICAL 2043 01:14:15,582 --> 01:14:19,019 DATA MODELING THROUGH ODESSY OR 2044 01:14:19,019 --> 01:14:20,186 OMOP BASED REPRESENTATION OF 2045 01:14:20,186 --> 01:14:22,722 DATA, THE KEY PART HOW TO MARRY 2046 01:14:22,722 --> 01:14:23,790 THOSE 2 OPPORTUNITIES ISSUES THE 2047 01:14:23,790 --> 01:14:25,659 RESOURCES THAT ARE DEVELOPED FOR 2048 01:14:25,659 --> 01:14:27,160 RESEARCH, USE FOR CLINICAL DATA 2049 01:14:27,160 --> 01:14:30,163 HOW DO WE HARNESS THIS MOMENT IN 2050 01:14:30,163 --> 01:14:32,499 TIME WHERE THERE'S A MANDATE IN 2051 01:14:32,499 --> 01:14:34,000 TOOLING AND A KEY PART OF IT ARE 2052 01:14:34,000 --> 01:14:35,001 TO FRAME PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT 2053 01:14:35,001 --> 01:14:36,503 FAMILIAR WITH IT, THE MAIN 2054 01:14:36,503 --> 01:14:40,407 ADVANTAGE IS THAT THERE'S A 2055 01:14:40,407 --> 01:14:41,908 STANDARD SORT OF USB PORT THAT A 2056 01:14:41,908 --> 01:14:47,414 SYSTEM CAN CONNECT TO AND GET 2057 01:14:47,414 --> 01:14:49,249 THAT INFORMATION. 2058 01:14:49,249 --> 01:14:51,651 THERE'S AN ESTABLISHED 2059 01:14:51,651 --> 01:14:52,786 COMMUNICATION PORT ESSENTIALLY 2060 01:14:52,786 --> 01:14:55,288 INTO THE HEALTH DATA, DATA 2061 01:14:55,288 --> 01:14:56,856 ITSELF MAY STILL REQUIRE 2062 01:14:56,856 --> 01:14:58,124 ADDITIONAL MODELING OR OTHER 2063 01:14:58,124 --> 01:14:59,325 THINGS BUT AT LEAST YOU KNOW HOW 2064 01:14:59,325 --> 01:15:00,727 TO ASK FOR IT AND YOU KNOW WHAT 2065 01:15:00,727 --> 01:15:03,963 YOU'RE GOING TO GET, RIGHT AS A 2066 01:15:03,963 --> 01:15:06,700 FRAMEWORK AND THAT SEEMS SIMPLE, 2067 01:15:06,700 --> 01:15:08,468 BUT HALF THE TIME WITH WE GET 2068 01:15:08,468 --> 01:15:09,202 FILES FROM SOMEBODY, WE DON'T 2069 01:15:09,202 --> 01:15:10,704 KNOW WHAT THEY ARE, WE DON'T 2070 01:15:10,704 --> 01:15:12,572 KNOW WHAT'S IN THEM, RIGHT? 2071 01:15:12,572 --> 01:15:15,909 DID IT INCLUDE WHAT I ASKED FOR 2072 01:15:15,909 --> 01:15:17,677 IN THAT'S A REAL BIG BARRIER 2073 01:15:17,677 --> 01:15:21,414 INTO THAT CONTEXT. 2074 01:15:21,414 --> 01:15:22,682 >> I JUST CAN'T RESIST SAYING 2075 01:15:22,682 --> 01:15:23,783 THE GREAT THING ABOUT STANDARD 2076 01:15:23,783 --> 01:15:26,886 SYSTEM THAT THERE ARE SO MANY OF 2077 01:15:26,886 --> 01:15:27,520 THEM. 2078 01:15:27,520 --> 01:15:27,921 [LAUGHTER] 2079 01:15:27,921 --> 01:15:30,290 BUT THIS DISCUSSION, I THINK 2080 01:15:30,290 --> 01:15:32,659 CRYSTALLIZES AT LEAST 2081 01:15:32,659 --> 01:15:34,861 CONCEPTUALLY THAT SOMETHING THAT 2082 01:15:34,861 --> 01:15:36,830 NIDCD MIGHT DO ON ITS OWN OR 2083 01:15:36,830 --> 01:15:39,032 MAYBE IN PARTNERSHIP WITH OTHER 2084 01:15:39,032 --> 01:15:40,633 ORGANIZATIONS, I'M THINKING LIKE 2085 01:15:40,633 --> 01:15:42,135 THE NATIONAL ACADEMIES IS REALLY 2086 01:15:42,135 --> 01:15:44,571 TO HAVE IT CONVENING AROUND THIS 2087 01:15:44,571 --> 01:15:47,874 DATA STANDARDS TO FOSTER 2088 01:15:47,874 --> 01:15:48,708 INTEROPERATING GLOBALLY 2089 01:15:48,708 --> 01:15:49,909 RAIBILITY, FLUIDITY OF DATA TO 2090 01:15:49,909 --> 01:15:52,645 CLINICAL DATA I THINK THAT POINT 2091 01:15:52,645 --> 01:15:54,714 IS SPOT ON, JUST SOMETHING TO 2092 01:15:54,714 --> 01:15:56,382 CONSIDER AS WE MOVE ON HERE, SO 2093 01:15:56,382 --> 01:15:58,785 DID YOU WANT TO MAKE A COMMENT? 2094 01:15:58,785 --> 01:16:02,622 >> JUST ADD A LAYER HERE TO THE 2095 01:16:02,622 --> 01:16:03,123 OPPORTUNITY. 2096 01:16:03,123 --> 01:16:06,326 YOU KNOW ASSESS AI READINESS OF 2097 01:16:06,326 --> 01:16:08,027 DATA, RIGHT, HOW CAN THE DATA 2098 01:16:08,027 --> 01:16:10,697 YOU CARE ABOUT BE POSITIONED YOU 2099 01:16:10,697 --> 01:16:13,099 KNOW FOR HARNESSING THESE NEW 2100 01:16:13,099 --> 01:16:13,433 TECHNOLOGIES? 2101 01:16:13,433 --> 01:16:14,400 YOU DON'T WANT TO MISS THAT 2102 01:16:14,400 --> 01:16:18,838 MOMENT IN TIME ESSENTIALLY. 2103 01:16:18,838 --> 01:16:20,573 >> I WANTED TO SHIFT GEARS A BIT 2104 01:16:20,573 --> 01:16:22,675 AND THIS IS ALSO, YOU TOUCHED SO 2105 01:16:22,675 --> 01:16:23,843 MANY DIFFERENT TOPICS THAT ARE 2106 01:16:23,843 --> 01:16:26,479 RELEVANT TO THIS BUT 1 OF THE 2107 01:16:26,479 --> 01:16:27,680 TOPICS THAT WE ALL NEED TO THINK 2108 01:16:27,680 --> 01:16:31,785 ABOUT IS THE BIAS AND DATA, 2109 01:16:31,785 --> 01:16:34,254 BECAUSE ARE WE SEEING THE 2110 01:16:34,254 --> 01:16:35,688 DIVERSITY OF PATIENTS, 2111 01:16:35,688 --> 01:16:36,656 PARTICIPANTS CONTRIBUTING DATA 2112 01:16:36,656 --> 01:16:37,891 THAT WE 92 ED TO HAVE WHATEVER 2113 01:16:37,891 --> 01:16:40,293 WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HERE 2114 01:16:40,293 --> 01:16:42,762 APPLICABLE TO EVERYONE. 2115 01:16:42,762 --> 01:16:44,197 SO I WONDER IF ANY OF YOU WOULD 2116 01:16:44,197 --> 01:16:48,034 LIKE TO SPEAK TO SOME OF THE 2117 01:16:48,034 --> 01:16:50,370 CHALLENGES AND PARTICULARLY 2118 01:16:50,370 --> 01:16:51,638 IN--NOT JUST RACE ETHNICITY 2119 01:16:51,638 --> 01:16:53,840 CHALLENGES WHICH I'M SURE ARE 2120 01:16:53,840 --> 01:16:55,008 PARAMOUNT, BUT ALSO 2121 01:16:55,008 --> 01:16:56,276 DISABILITIES, AND MAKING SURE 2122 01:16:56,276 --> 01:16:58,044 THAT THOSE INDIVIDUALS ARE 2123 01:16:58,044 --> 01:17:01,414 REPRESENTED IN THE TYPES OF DATA 2124 01:17:01,414 --> 01:17:02,682 WE'RE TALKING ABOUT AND ANY 2125 01:17:02,682 --> 01:17:04,918 IDEAS ABOUT YOU HOW TO FOSTER 2126 01:17:04,918 --> 01:17:05,618 GREATER ENGAGEMENT WITH THE 2127 01:17:05,618 --> 01:17:07,987 COMMUNITIES THAT ARE LARGELY 2128 01:17:07,987 --> 01:17:11,891 ABSENT. 2129 01:17:11,891 --> 01:17:13,193 ANY THOUGHTS. 2130 01:17:13,193 --> 01:17:14,060 IT'S CRITICALLY IMPORTANT. 2131 01:17:14,060 --> 01:17:15,862 I THINK WE ALL RECOGNIZE THAT 2132 01:17:15,862 --> 01:17:16,963 DIVERSITY IN OUR CLINICAL TRIALS 2133 01:17:16,963 --> 01:17:20,500 BOTH FROM THE NIH AS WELL AS THE 2134 01:17:20,500 --> 01:17:22,902 EXTRAMURAL COMMUNITIES IS SORELY 2135 01:17:22,902 --> 01:17:24,637 LACKING CAN WHAT I FIND EVEN 2136 01:17:24,637 --> 01:17:26,706 MORE CONCERNING IS THAT THERE'S 2137 01:17:26,706 --> 01:17:31,911 NO CLEAR GUIDANCE ON HOW TO 2138 01:17:31,911 --> 01:17:33,546 IMPROVE WHAT IS DIVERSITY, WHAT 2139 01:17:33,546 --> 01:17:35,481 IS A REPRESENTATIVE POPULATION, 2140 01:17:35,481 --> 01:17:38,751 WHEN IS A RARE DISEASE 2141 01:17:38,751 --> 01:17:40,620 IDENTIFIABLE IN ITS OWN RIGHT? 2142 01:17:40,620 --> 01:17:41,888 THESE ARE ALL OPEN QUESTIONS 2143 01:17:41,888 --> 01:17:44,290 THAT ARE OFTEN TIMES DECIDED ON 2144 01:17:44,290 --> 01:17:46,492 A CASE BY CASE BASIS WHICH MAKE 2145 01:17:46,492 --> 01:17:47,794 ITS MUCH HARDER TO IMPROVE. 2146 01:17:47,794 --> 01:17:49,996 I WILL TAKE THE OPPORTUNITY TO 2147 01:17:49,996 --> 01:17:52,298 HIGHLIGHT A WORKSHOP THAT WILL 2148 01:17:52,298 --> 01:17:53,166 BE HOSTING AT THE CLINICAL 2149 01:17:53,166 --> 01:17:56,102 CENTER AND I WOULD LOVE EVERYONE 2150 01:17:56,102 --> 01:17:58,571 HERE ASK ONLINE TO JOIN SPEAKING 2151 01:17:58,571 --> 01:18:00,340 DIRECTLY TO THIS TOPIC ON 2152 01:18:00,340 --> 01:18:05,578 DIVERSITY CAN CLINICAL TRIALS 2153 01:18:05,578 --> 01:18:06,145 BECAUSE IT'S CRITICALLY 2154 01:18:06,145 --> 01:18:13,519 IMPORTANT BUT WE HAVE A LONG WAY 2155 01:18:13,519 --> 01:18:13,853 TO GO. 2156 01:18:13,853 --> 01:18:15,755 >> YEAH, I JUST WANT TO COMMENT 2157 01:18:15,755 --> 01:18:18,391 ON THE MEANING OF THE WORD 2158 01:18:18,391 --> 01:18:19,959 DIVERSITY, AND HOW DO WE DEFEIGN 2159 01:18:19,959 --> 01:18:22,962 AND HOW DO WE STRATIFY THE 2160 01:18:22,962 --> 01:18:25,798 POPULATION TO MAKE SURE THAT THE 2161 01:18:25,798 --> 01:18:28,868 CLINICAL TRIAL THAT WE'RE DOING 2162 01:18:28,868 --> 01:18:30,069 IS REALLY REFLECTIVE OF THE 2163 01:18:30,069 --> 01:18:33,239 PHENOTYPE THAT WE WANT TO STUDY, 2164 01:18:33,239 --> 01:18:33,706 RIGHT? 2165 01:18:33,706 --> 01:18:35,942 AND IT'S AN ENCOURAGEMENT TO GO 2166 01:18:35,942 --> 01:18:38,111 BEYOND THE SOCIAL CONSTRUCTS 2167 01:18:38,111 --> 01:18:39,779 THAT WE TYPICALLY TALK ABOUT, 2168 01:18:39,779 --> 01:18:42,315 THE MORE TRYING TO THINK ABOUT 2169 01:18:42,315 --> 01:18:44,617 OTHER WAYS THAT ARE A PHENOTYPIC 2170 01:18:44,617 --> 01:18:46,653 STRATIFICATION OF THE PATIENT 2171 01:18:46,653 --> 01:18:48,688 POPULATION, THAT MAY BE BASED ON 2172 01:18:48,688 --> 01:18:51,424 GENO TYPE AND OTHER 2173 01:18:51,424 --> 01:18:52,258 CHARACTERISTICS. 2174 01:18:52,258 --> 01:18:54,160 I THINK THAT FOR SIMPLICITY 2175 01:18:54,160 --> 01:18:58,932 SOMETIMES, WE JUST FOLLOW 2176 01:18:58,932 --> 01:18:59,732 UNCERTAIN CATEGORIES AND I 2177 01:18:59,732 --> 01:19:02,669 REALLY THINK WE SHOULD BE 2178 01:19:02,669 --> 01:19:03,670 ENCOURAGED BY THE BIOMEDICAL 2179 01:19:03,670 --> 01:19:06,205 RESEARCH COMMUNITY TO GO BEYOND 2180 01:19:06,205 --> 01:19:08,508 THOSE GROUPINGS AND TO REALLY GO 2181 01:19:08,508 --> 01:19:11,277 DEEPER WITH A PHENOTYPE OF A 2182 01:19:11,277 --> 01:19:13,613 POPULATION THATNYS TO BE 2183 01:19:13,613 --> 01:19:16,215 RECRUITED AND AND THROUGH THE 2184 01:19:16,215 --> 01:19:17,250 CLINICAL TRIAL EFFORT, THAT'S 2185 01:19:17,250 --> 01:19:22,422 ALL I WANTED TO SAY. 2186 01:19:22,422 --> 01:19:26,092 >> WE ALSO THINK ABOUT DIVERSITY 2187 01:19:26,092 --> 01:19:26,726 IN 2 FRAMEWORKS. 2188 01:19:26,726 --> 01:19:28,561 ONE WHICH IS NATURAL FOR US, I 2189 01:19:28,561 --> 01:19:31,531 THINK, THOSE OF US WHO ARE 2190 01:19:31,531 --> 01:19:34,400 STEEPED IN BIOLOGY AND MOLECULAR 2191 01:19:34,400 --> 01:19:37,070 CONTEXT WHICH HAS VALENTINA 2192 01:19:37,070 --> 01:19:38,938 MENTIONED HOW DO WE MAKE SURE 2193 01:19:38,938 --> 01:19:39,872 WE'RE ACTUALLY MEASURING THE 2194 01:19:39,872 --> 01:19:42,108 SPACE REQUIRED TO MEASURE TO 2195 01:19:42,108 --> 01:19:43,276 MAKE AN INTERPRETATION, LET 2196 01:19:43,276 --> 01:19:44,677 ALONE THE MORAL MANDATE OF 2197 01:19:44,677 --> 01:19:46,312 ADDRESSING THE NEED OF THOSE 2198 01:19:46,312 --> 01:19:48,214 REPRESENTED, BUT THE OTHER PART 2199 01:19:48,214 --> 01:19:50,817 WHICH I THINK WAS TRANSFORMATIVE 2200 01:19:50,817 --> 01:19:54,187 FOR ME, WAS WHEN I STARTED 2201 01:19:54,187 --> 01:19:56,956 READING PAPERS, THAT TREATED 2202 01:19:56,956 --> 01:19:58,458 OTHER VARIABLES OF THE 2203 01:19:58,458 --> 01:19:59,525 UNIVERSITY, FOR EXAMPLE, YOU 2204 01:19:59,525 --> 01:20:02,695 KNOW ACCESS TO HEALTHCARE, OR 2205 01:20:02,695 --> 01:20:06,833 SOCIOECONOMIC AT STATUS AND THE 2206 01:20:06,833 --> 01:20:07,667 OUTCOMES THESE KIDS MIGHT HAVE 2207 01:20:07,667 --> 01:20:10,903 IF YOU HAVE A BRAIN TUMOR, ARE 2208 01:20:10,903 --> 01:20:12,939 THE DIFFERENCES LIKE IF YOU 2209 01:20:12,939 --> 01:20:17,010 PLOTTED IT ON A CAP LANMIER 2210 01:20:17,010 --> 01:20:18,277 CURVE FOR EXAMPLE WERE MUCH 2211 01:20:18,277 --> 01:20:19,812 LARGER DIFFERENCES THAN ANY GENE 2212 01:20:19,812 --> 01:20:24,617 WE EVER DISCOVERED, RIGHT, THAT 2213 01:20:24,617 --> 01:20:25,918 CAUSE DIFFERENCES IN THE TUMOR. 2214 01:20:25,918 --> 01:20:27,020 SO THE UNDERSTANDING THAT YOU 2215 01:20:27,020 --> 01:20:29,055 CAN HAVE OUTCOME MEASURES WHICH 2216 01:20:29,055 --> 01:20:34,927 WHAT WE CARE ABOUT IMPACTED BY 2217 01:20:34,927 --> 01:20:36,562 VARIABLES THAT ACTUALLY ARE 2218 01:20:36,562 --> 01:20:37,497 POTENTIALLY ADDRESSABLE IN WAYS 2219 01:20:37,497 --> 01:20:41,734 THAT ARE EASIER FROM A--I KNOW 2220 01:20:41,734 --> 01:20:43,436 HOW TO FIX IT TYPE OF FRAMEWORK 2221 01:20:43,436 --> 01:20:45,204 THAN A MODEL CITIZEN LEAKULAR 1 2222 01:20:45,204 --> 01:20:46,906 WHERE WE HAVE TO DEVELOP A NEW 2223 01:20:46,906 --> 01:20:49,442 DRUG AND RECOGNIZING THAT THAT 2224 01:20:49,442 --> 01:20:52,912 SIGNAL TO NOISE EXISTS IN THAT 2225 01:20:52,912 --> 01:20:55,214 ANALYSIS, I THINK IS INKRE 2226 01:20:55,214 --> 01:20:57,817 TINSIBLELY IMPORTANT ESPECIALLY 2227 01:20:57,817 --> 01:20:59,886 AS YOUR PHENOTYPES BECOME MORE 2228 01:20:59,886 --> 01:21:05,425 COMPLEXLY INFORMED BY MULTIPLE 2229 01:21:05,425 --> 01:21:06,759 GENE AND ENVIRONMENTAL CONTEXT, 2230 01:21:06,759 --> 01:21:08,561 RIGHT, AS A SETTING AND SO, I 2231 01:21:08,561 --> 01:21:10,396 WILL COME BACK TO WHAT I FOUND 2232 01:21:10,396 --> 01:21:11,264 MYSELF HAVING TO REMIND MYSELF 2233 01:21:11,264 --> 01:21:13,199 AND PEOPLE I WORK WITH, THAT WE 2234 01:21:13,199 --> 01:21:15,068 CAN'T FIX SOMETHING WE DON'T 2235 01:21:15,068 --> 01:21:17,036 MEASURE, RIGHT IN SO YOU HAVE TO 2236 01:21:17,036 --> 01:21:21,674 MEASURE IT AND INCORPORATE IT 2237 01:21:21,674 --> 01:21:22,742 INTO THE SETTING, THAT'S THE 2238 01:21:22,742 --> 01:21:24,844 KEY, I THINK BUT THINKING ABOUT 2239 01:21:24,844 --> 01:21:27,947 DIVERSITY IN THE 2 LENSES, THE 2240 01:21:27,947 --> 01:21:29,348 BIOLOGIC REPRESENTATIONAL 1 BUT 2241 01:21:29,348 --> 01:21:30,716 ADVERSITY OF VARIABLES CAN 2242 01:21:30,716 --> 01:21:32,085 ACTUALLY IMPACT THE END POINTS 2243 01:21:32,085 --> 01:21:33,519 AND ARE ALREADY KNOWN THAT I 2244 01:21:33,519 --> 01:21:34,821 IGNORED BECAUSE OF WHAT YOU'RE 2245 01:21:34,821 --> 01:21:38,624 MEASURING, YOU KNOW IN THE 2246 01:21:38,624 --> 01:21:38,891 CONTEXT. 2247 01:21:38,891 --> 01:21:42,662 >> LET ME FOLLOW UP ON THAT, 2248 01:21:42,662 --> 01:21:44,764 FIRST, IN THE--IF YOU NO MATTER 2249 01:21:44,764 --> 01:21:48,201 HOW WE DEFINE DIVERSITY, I AGREE 2250 01:21:48,201 --> 01:21:51,170 IT'S A CRITICAL DEFINITION. 2251 01:21:51,170 --> 01:21:52,672 WE HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY AS 2252 01:21:52,672 --> 01:21:54,740 YOU'RE POINTING OUT ADAM THAT WE 2253 01:21:54,740 --> 01:22:00,146 CAN MEASURE MANY DIMENSIONS OF 2254 01:22:00,146 --> 01:22:01,414 DATA OR POPULATION, YET THE 2255 01:22:01,414 --> 01:22:02,949 RESEARCH COMMUNITY IS PRETTY 2256 01:22:02,949 --> 01:22:06,085 MONODIMENSIONAL IN THE WAY THAT 2257 01:22:06,085 --> 01:22:08,387 THEY THINK ABOUT RESEARCH, 2258 01:22:08,387 --> 01:22:11,124 MEANING THAT MOST LABS MAY BE 2259 01:22:11,124 --> 01:22:13,059 USE 1 OR 2 DATA TYPES OF 2260 01:22:13,059 --> 01:22:13,993 CLINICAL GENETIC OR SOMETHING 2261 01:22:13,993 --> 01:22:19,065 LIKE THAT, BUT IT'S A RARE 2262 01:22:19,065 --> 01:22:19,866 LABORATORY INVESTIGATOR GROUP 2263 01:22:19,866 --> 01:22:21,300 THAT USES MORE DIMENSIONALITYS 2264 01:22:21,300 --> 01:22:23,035 OF THE DAY, SO THE QUESTION I'M 2265 01:22:23,035 --> 01:22:24,403 REALLY GETTING AT IS, IN ORDER 2266 01:22:24,403 --> 01:22:28,641 TO GET THE FULL PICTURE OF THE 2267 01:22:28,641 --> 01:22:30,176 INDIVIDUAL, THE TRAJECTORY, 2268 01:22:30,176 --> 01:22:31,344 PREDICTIVE MODELS, OUTCOMES AS 2269 01:22:31,344 --> 01:22:32,745 PRECISION MEDICINE WOULD LIKE US 2270 01:22:32,745 --> 01:22:34,714 TO DO, HOW DO WE PREPARE THE 2271 01:22:34,714 --> 01:22:38,251 WORKFORCE TO ACTUALLY BE ABLE TO 2272 01:22:38,251 --> 01:22:39,652 HANDLE THE DIFFERENT DATA 2273 01:22:39,652 --> 01:22:39,886 STREAMS. 2274 01:22:39,886 --> 01:22:44,490 ONE ANSWER YOU SAY WELL, USE 2275 01:22:44,490 --> 01:22:45,224 CHATGPT, I'M PEEKING DPLIBLY, 2276 01:22:45,224 --> 01:22:48,828 BUT I DO THINK THAT THE 2277 01:22:48,828 --> 01:22:49,762 WORKFORCE OF RESEARCHER 2278 01:22:49,762 --> 01:22:51,063 WORKFORCE TODAY MAY NOT BE 2279 01:22:51,063 --> 01:22:52,698 PREPARED TO USE THE DAILY BASIS 2280 01:22:52,698 --> 01:22:56,335 THEA TYPES WE'RE TALK HAD 2281 01:22:56,335 --> 01:22:57,837 THE--DATA TYPES WE'RE TALKING 2282 01:22:57,837 --> 01:22:58,471 ABOUT HERE. 2283 01:22:58,471 --> 01:23:00,640 >> I'M ASKING, IS THERE A WAY WE 2284 01:23:00,640 --> 01:23:00,873 CAN-- 2285 01:23:00,873 --> 01:23:03,743 >> HOW ARE WE TRYING TO DO THIS 2286 01:23:03,743 --> 01:23:05,545 AT LEAST. 2287 01:23:05,545 --> 01:23:09,248 YOU KNOW SO WE LEANED IN HEAVILY 2288 01:23:09,248 --> 01:23:09,916 INTO MULTIMOWAL FRAMEWORKS WITH 2289 01:23:09,916 --> 01:23:11,517 THE ARGUE AM WHICH I THINK IS 2290 01:23:11,517 --> 01:23:12,685 UNDERNEATH WHAT YOU'RE SAYING 2291 01:23:12,685 --> 01:23:18,691 WHICH IS RECOGNIZING THAT EACH 2292 01:23:18,691 --> 01:23:21,427 DATA LAYER ACTUALLY ADDS 2293 01:23:21,427 --> 01:23:23,162 INFORMATION TO THE ANALYSIS, I 2294 01:23:23,162 --> 01:23:26,566 THINK INVESTIGATORS DON'T KNOW 2295 01:23:26,566 --> 01:23:27,733 THAT FULLY AND DON'T HAVE THE 2296 01:23:27,733 --> 01:23:29,502 TOOLS TO ASSESS THAT FULLY. 2297 01:23:29,502 --> 01:23:32,205 THE MINUTE I SHOW A CLINICIAN, 2298 01:23:32,205 --> 01:23:37,443 THAT IF I CLUSTER THESE PATIENTS 2299 01:23:37,443 --> 01:23:39,478 USING 5 MODALITIES, AND 2, 2300 01:23:39,478 --> 01:23:42,548 SUDDENLY YOU HAVE 5 GROUPS OF 2301 01:23:42,548 --> 01:23:43,716 PATIENTS, THEY INTINCTUALLY 2302 01:23:43,716 --> 01:23:44,550 START ASKING QUESTIONS, WHAT'S 2303 01:23:44,550 --> 01:23:45,518 DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THIS GROUP 2304 01:23:45,518 --> 01:23:46,152 AND THAT GROUP. 2305 01:23:46,152 --> 01:23:48,421 HAVE I SEEN SOMETHING THAT I'VE 2306 01:23:48,421 --> 01:23:48,888 MISSED. 2307 01:23:48,888 --> 01:23:50,623 SO AGAIN, I THINK THERE'S A 2308 01:23:50,623 --> 01:23:51,891 FEEDBACK LOOP THAT YOU NEED TO 2309 01:23:51,891 --> 01:23:54,126 EMPOWER AND IT'S THE COMBINATION 2310 01:23:54,126 --> 01:23:57,997 OF TOOLING IN THAT SETTING, I'VE 2311 01:23:57,997 --> 01:23:58,965 SEEN MULTIMODAL DATA BEING 2312 01:23:58,965 --> 01:24:00,700 INTERSECT INDEED WAYS THAT 2313 01:24:00,700 --> 01:24:03,002 WASN'T MEANINGFUL SO THAT 2314 01:24:03,002 --> 01:24:04,704 ADOPTION FRAMEWORK AND 2315 01:24:04,704 --> 01:24:07,974 INCENTIVES ARE NOT THERE BUT THE 2316 01:24:07,974 --> 01:24:09,242 MINUTE YOU INCENTIVIZE 2317 01:24:09,242 --> 01:24:11,110 INTERPRETATION ASK MULTIMODAL 2318 01:24:11,110 --> 01:24:12,011 ANALYTICS AND UNVEILS SOMETHING 2319 01:24:12,011 --> 01:24:13,746 THAT'S DIFFERENT OR UNEXPECTED 2320 01:24:13,746 --> 01:24:15,881 OR EVEN CONFIRMS EVEN, YOU SEE 2321 01:24:15,881 --> 01:24:19,285 INTENSE INTEREST, YOU KNOW IN 2322 01:24:19,285 --> 01:24:20,753 THAT CONTEXT TO MOVE FORWARD, SO 2323 01:24:20,753 --> 01:24:22,688 PARTLY, I THINK IT'S TOOLING, 2324 01:24:22,688 --> 01:24:29,829 THE OTHER I THINK IS STILL IF 2325 01:24:29,829 --> 01:24:31,364 YOU MENTIONED AI 5 YEARS AGO, 2326 01:24:31,364 --> 01:24:33,099 PEOPLE WOULD ROLL THEIR EYES, 3 2327 01:24:33,099 --> 01:24:34,300 YEARS AGO, PEOPLE WOULD ROLL 2328 01:24:34,300 --> 01:24:38,571 THEIR EYES, I THINK NOW BECAUSE 2329 01:24:38,571 --> 01:24:41,007 IT'S A BIT MORE SPRENSIAL 2330 01:24:41,007 --> 01:24:42,375 BECAUSE PEOPLE HAVE GONE ON, 2331 01:24:42,375 --> 01:24:43,909 IT'S WEIRD AND DIFFERENT, THAT'S 2332 01:24:43,909 --> 01:24:45,077 THE OTHER OPPORTUNITY THAT'S 2333 01:24:45,077 --> 01:24:47,613 BEEN MISSING IS THAT, YOU FIGURE 2334 01:24:47,613 --> 01:24:52,518 THE PROMISE OF BIG DATA IN AI 2335 01:24:52,518 --> 01:24:54,387 AND ANALYTICS HAS NOT REALLY 2336 01:24:54,387 --> 01:24:57,123 COME TO HEALTHCARE YET. 2337 01:24:57,123 --> 01:25:00,826 AND IN MANY WAYS HEALTHCARE HAS 2338 01:25:00,826 --> 01:25:02,028 NOT RECOGNIZED, MOST HOSPITAL 2339 01:25:02,028 --> 01:25:03,996 SYSTEMS AND I SAY THIS FAIRLY 2340 01:25:03,996 --> 01:25:05,398 OFTEN, HAVE NOT RECOGNIZE THAD 2341 01:25:05,398 --> 01:25:06,766 THEY'RE BIG DATA COMPANIES AND 2342 01:25:06,766 --> 01:25:08,501 HOW TO THINK ABOUT THEIR 2343 01:25:08,501 --> 01:25:09,802 INFRASTRUCTURE OF A BIG DATA 2344 01:25:09,802 --> 01:25:11,904 COMPANY FROM AN ENGINEERING 2345 01:25:11,904 --> 01:25:12,772 PERSPECTIVE AND TOOLING 2346 01:25:12,772 --> 01:25:13,839 PERSPECTIVE AS CONTEXT. 2347 01:25:13,839 --> 01:25:15,308 DEFINITELY TOO HARD FOR A SINGLE 2348 01:25:15,308 --> 01:25:17,276 HUMAN TO THINK ABOUT. 2349 01:25:17,276 --> 01:25:18,744 >> I THINK JOSH WOULD DISAFRO 2350 01:25:18,744 --> 01:25:19,078 WITH YOU. 2351 01:25:19,078 --> 01:25:22,014 HE DOES THAT IN THE CLENNIC ALL 2352 01:25:22,014 --> 01:25:22,515 THE TIME. 2353 01:25:22,515 --> 01:25:23,949 SO I MEAN, I THINK THAT'S WHAT 2354 01:25:23,949 --> 01:25:26,285 YOU WERE SAYING EARLIER IS THAT 2355 01:25:26,285 --> 01:25:31,357 AS HUMANS WE GATHER INFORMATION 2356 01:25:31,357 --> 01:25:33,125 INTUITIVELY TO IN DEGREE AND 2357 01:25:33,125 --> 01:25:34,827 CREATE OUR OWN MODELS BUT 2358 01:25:34,827 --> 01:25:36,829 RESEARCHERS DON'T DO IT THAT 2359 01:25:36,829 --> 01:25:37,330 WAY. 2360 01:25:37,330 --> 01:25:38,431 >> MY FAVORITE NEUROSURGEON ASK 2361 01:25:38,431 --> 01:25:40,766 LOOK AT AN MRI AND SAY, I KNOW 2362 01:25:40,766 --> 01:25:44,370 I'VE SEEN THIS BEFORE. 2363 01:25:44,370 --> 01:25:45,171 >> YEAH. 2364 01:25:45,171 --> 01:25:52,178 DID YOU WANT TO ADDRESS IT? 2365 01:25:52,178 --> 01:25:54,113 >> YEAH, SO--THE PROBLEM OF 2366 01:25:54,113 --> 01:25:55,715 MULTIPLE MODALITY DATA AND HOW 2367 01:25:55,715 --> 01:25:56,749 TO EXTRACT INFORMATION FROM IT, 2368 01:25:56,749 --> 01:26:01,320 IT GOES BACK TO THE CLASSICAL 2369 01:26:01,320 --> 01:26:02,488 DATA INTEGRATION ISSUE WHICH YOU 2370 01:26:02,488 --> 01:26:06,859 KNOW DATA SCIENTISTS HAVE BEEN 2371 01:26:06,859 --> 01:26:09,161 DEALING WITH SINCE BIOMEDICAL 2372 01:26:09,161 --> 01:26:12,965 RESEARCH BECAME A BIG DATA 2373 01:26:12,965 --> 01:26:13,366 RESEARCH FIELD. 2374 01:26:13,366 --> 01:26:16,001 SO HOW TO DO THAT, CAN YOU DO IT 2375 01:26:16,001 --> 01:26:16,869 DIFFERENT LAYERS, RIGHT IN YOU 2376 01:26:16,869 --> 01:26:18,671 CAN JUST PUT THE DATA WITH 2377 01:26:18,671 --> 01:26:19,805 DIFFERENT DATA TYPES INTO THE 2378 01:26:19,805 --> 01:26:21,307 RESOURCE AND SAY IT'S INTEGRATED 2379 01:26:21,307 --> 01:26:22,508 WHICH WE KNOW IT'S NOT BUT AT 2380 01:26:22,508 --> 01:26:25,878 LEAST IT IS IN 1 PLACE. 2381 01:26:25,878 --> 01:26:28,948 OR CAN YOU BE LITTLE BIT MORE 2382 01:26:28,948 --> 01:26:31,517 SOPHISTICATED WHICH IS USE 2383 01:26:31,517 --> 01:26:32,451 STATISTICAL METHODS, AI, METHODS 2384 01:26:32,451 --> 01:26:35,788 AND SO ON, AND TRY TO EXTRACT 2385 01:26:35,788 --> 01:26:36,822 INFORMATION OUT OF IT. 2386 01:26:36,822 --> 01:26:38,591 SO IT DPZ BACK TO WORKFORCE 2387 01:26:38,591 --> 01:26:42,561 DEVELOPMENT, HOW DO YOU GET TO 2388 01:26:42,561 --> 01:26:44,797 THIS, YOU KNOW BIG ENOUGH 2389 01:26:44,797 --> 01:26:46,365 WORKFORCE OF COMPUTATIONAL 2390 01:26:46,365 --> 01:26:47,366 MODELERS, PEOPLE THAT KNOW HOW 2391 01:26:47,366 --> 01:26:54,206 TO TRAIN AND USE THIS AI MODELS 2392 01:26:54,206 --> 01:26:55,274 TO EXTRACT THE INFORMATION YOU 2393 01:26:55,274 --> 01:26:55,608 NEED. 2394 01:26:55,608 --> 01:26:58,577 SO IT GOES BACK TO HOW DO YOU 2395 01:26:58,577 --> 01:26:59,979 HAVE ENOUGH PEOPLE, THAT ARE 2396 01:26:59,979 --> 01:27:01,747 GOING TO STEM SCIENCES AND HOW 2397 01:27:01,747 --> 01:27:07,686 DO YOU CREATE ENOUGH PEOPLE EVEN 2398 01:27:07,686 --> 01:27:09,588 STARTING FROM K12 SCHOOL ENGEAJ 2399 01:27:09,588 --> 01:27:11,524 IN THIS TYPE OF ACTIVITY AND NOT 2400 01:27:11,524 --> 01:27:13,993 BE SCARED TO IT SO UNFORTUNATELY 2401 01:27:13,993 --> 01:27:16,128 THAT'S HOW--I THINK THE PROBLEM 2402 01:27:16,128 --> 01:27:17,296 STARTS MANY YEARS BEFORE IT, 2403 01:27:17,296 --> 01:27:23,169 PEOPLE GO TO MEDICAL SCHOOL. 2404 01:27:23,169 --> 01:27:24,136 >> ONE COMMENT ON THE SHARED 2405 01:27:24,136 --> 01:27:27,773 EXPERIENCE, WE DID KNOWA 2406 01:27:27,773 --> 01:27:28,841 EXPERIMENT OF HANDLING DATA TO 2407 01:27:28,841 --> 01:27:31,510 AMERICAN AIRLINES AND ENGINEERS, 2408 01:27:31,510 --> 01:27:33,779 THEY DIDN'T KNOW--THEY THEY HAD 2409 01:27:33,779 --> 01:27:36,549 FORGOTTEN ALL THEIR NIEJT GRADE 2410 01:27:36,549 --> 01:27:37,850 BIOLOGY, ALL WE DID WAS HAND 2411 01:27:37,850 --> 01:27:39,985 THEM SHEETS AND ROWS OF 2412 01:27:39,985 --> 01:27:40,820 MOLECULAR DATA. 2413 01:27:40,820 --> 01:27:41,420 THEY BROUGHT DIFFERENT 2414 01:27:41,420 --> 01:27:42,521 TECHNIQUES THAT THEY USE TO 2415 01:27:42,521 --> 01:27:44,123 PREDICT WHEN AN AIRPLANE'S GOING 2416 01:27:44,123 --> 01:27:45,324 TO BE A CERTAIN PLACE OR IT'S 2417 01:27:45,324 --> 01:27:47,026 GOING TO BE THERE, COMPLETELY 2418 01:27:47,026 --> 01:27:48,127 DNCH THAN WE WOULD HAVE EVER 2419 01:27:48,127 --> 01:27:50,396 THOUGHT OF BUT THEY COULD CREATE 2420 01:27:50,396 --> 01:27:52,031 THE EXACT SAME CLASSIFIED TUMOR 2421 01:27:52,031 --> 01:27:54,200 TYPES THAT WE HAD DONE. 2422 01:27:54,200 --> 01:27:56,836 SO I THINK THAT'S THE OTHER 2423 01:27:56,836 --> 01:27:59,171 OPPORTUNITY IS CROSS DISCIPLINE 2424 01:27:59,171 --> 01:27:59,538 ANALYTICS. 2425 01:27:59,538 --> 01:28:03,976 I MENTIONED WEATHER, RIGHT? 2426 01:28:03,976 --> 01:28:05,177 FINANCE IS AMAZING 3 GOOD AT 2427 01:28:05,177 --> 01:28:07,713 THIS, IF YOU WANT TO SEE 2428 01:28:07,713 --> 01:28:09,849 REALTIME ANALYTICS, FINANCE IS 2429 01:28:09,849 --> 01:28:11,383 WHERE YOU SEE REALTIME ANALYTICS 2430 01:28:11,383 --> 01:28:11,984 AT SCALE. 2431 01:28:11,984 --> 01:28:13,919 SO THAT'S THE OTHER OPPORTUNITY 2432 01:28:13,919 --> 01:28:18,824 TO THINK ABOUT IS, MULTIMODAL 2433 01:28:18,824 --> 01:28:24,096 ANALYTICS THAT HARNESS SHARED 2434 01:28:24,096 --> 01:28:24,396 APPROACHES. 2435 01:28:24,396 --> 01:28:25,598 >> I COMPLETELY AGROW AND I 2436 01:28:25,598 --> 01:28:27,333 WOULD JUST ADD THAT WE NEED TO 2437 01:28:27,333 --> 01:28:29,401 LOOK NOT ONLY OUTSIDE OF OUR OWN 2438 01:28:29,401 --> 01:28:31,637 FIELDS OUTSIDE OF HEALTHCARE BUT 2439 01:28:31,637 --> 01:28:33,439 WITHIN, AND CLINICALLY WE ARE 2440 01:28:33,439 --> 01:28:35,674 WAY TOO SILOED IN OUR OWN 2441 01:28:35,674 --> 01:28:37,409 SUBSPECIALTIES AND I THINK FROM 2442 01:28:37,409 --> 01:28:40,913 A DATA STANDPOINT THE SAME HOLDS 2443 01:28:40,913 --> 01:28:41,380 TRUE. 2444 01:28:41,380 --> 01:28:42,448 THE REPRESENTATION ON THIS PANEL 2445 01:28:42,448 --> 01:28:43,716 SPEAKS TO THE IMPORTANCE OF 2446 01:28:43,716 --> 01:28:45,784 BREAKING DOWN THESE BARRIERS. 2447 01:28:45,784 --> 01:28:51,390 WE DON'T NEED TO RECREATE DEN 2448 01:28:51,390 --> 01:28:52,691 DIFFERENT DATA SOLUTIONS, WE CAN 2449 01:28:52,691 --> 01:28:58,531 INTEGRATE AND LEARN FROM EACH 2450 01:28:58,531 --> 01:28:58,831 OTHER. 2451 01:28:58,831 --> 01:28:59,164 >> DPRAIT. 2452 01:28:59,164 --> 01:29:00,533 THAT WAS A FREIGHT RESPONSE TO 2453 01:29:00,533 --> 01:29:01,967 THAT LAST QUESTION EMPLOY I KNOW 2454 01:29:01,967 --> 01:29:04,770 WE'RE AT TIME, I WANT TO TAKE 2455 01:29:04,770 --> 01:29:06,772 60-SECONDS TO REFLECT ON SOME 2456 01:29:06,772 --> 01:29:08,240 HEAD LINES BECAUSE THAT'S ALL WE 2457 01:29:08,240 --> 01:29:09,875 HAVE TIME FOR, THINGS THAT I 2458 01:29:09,875 --> 01:29:12,077 HEARD BOTH THROUGH ADAM'S 2459 01:29:12,077 --> 01:29:12,912 PRESENTATION AND THE PANEL 2460 01:29:12,912 --> 01:29:13,946 DISCUSSION. 2461 01:29:13,946 --> 01:29:15,781 THE FIRST IS THAT WE SHOULD NOT 2462 01:29:15,781 --> 01:29:16,749 UNDERESTIMATE THE POWER OF 2463 01:29:16,749 --> 01:29:18,918 SHARING DATA AND LEVELS INCREASE 2464 01:29:18,918 --> 01:29:20,119 RAMMING THE INVESTMENTS THAT ANY 2465 01:29:20,119 --> 01:29:21,186 1 GROUP MAKES TO SHARE THEIR 2466 01:29:21,186 --> 01:29:24,156 DATA WITH THE OTHER AND THE 2467 01:29:24,156 --> 01:29:25,190 AMPLIFICATION THAT OCCURS IN 2468 01:29:25,190 --> 01:29:26,125 SCIENCE AND IN ORDER TO MAKE 2469 01:29:26,125 --> 01:29:29,461 THAT HAPPEN, WE HAVE TO BE 2470 01:29:29,461 --> 01:29:30,930 TRANSPARENT WITH OUR PARTICIPANT 2471 01:29:30,930 --> 01:29:33,332 AND PATIENT COMMUNITY SO THEY 2472 01:29:33,332 --> 01:29:35,935 UNDERSTAND HOW THEIR DATA IS 2473 01:29:35,935 --> 01:29:37,703 BEING USED AND CLEARLY THE 2474 01:29:37,703 --> 01:29:39,972 BENEFITS THAT BEING COME FROM 2475 01:29:39,972 --> 01:29:40,205 IT. 2476 01:29:40,205 --> 01:29:43,175 WE NEED TO AS A COMMUNITY I 2477 01:29:43,175 --> 01:29:44,476 THINK MAXIMIZE DIVERSITY NOT 2478 01:29:44,476 --> 01:29:46,078 ONLY OF OUR PARTICIPANT AND 2479 01:29:46,078 --> 01:29:47,179 PATIENT POPULATIONS THAT ARE 2480 01:29:47,179 --> 01:29:48,814 CONTRIBUTING THEIR DATA TO 2481 01:29:48,814 --> 01:29:50,950 RESEARCH, BUT THE DIVERSITY OF 2482 01:29:50,950 --> 01:29:52,151 THE LENSES OF EXPERT ANDS 2483 01:29:52,151 --> 01:29:53,252 RESEARCHERS THAT ARE LOOKING AT 2484 01:29:53,252 --> 01:29:55,220 THE DATA SO THAT WE CAN MACK 2485 01:29:55,220 --> 01:29:58,958 MYSELF THE QUESTIONS THAT 2486 01:29:58,958 --> 01:30:01,760 ARE--MAXIMIZE THE QUESTIONS THAT 2487 01:30:01,760 --> 01:30:04,763 ARE ASKED AND INFORMATION 2488 01:30:04,763 --> 01:30:05,030 ACHIEVED. 2489 01:30:05,030 --> 01:30:06,465 LONGITUDINALLITY IS IMPORTANT 2490 01:30:06,465 --> 01:30:11,837 AND TRAJECTORIES ARE GOING TO BE 2491 01:30:11,837 --> 01:30:15,074 PROYECTED SO THERE'S AN OBVIOUS 2492 01:30:15,074 --> 01:30:16,442 NEED FOR STANDARDS DISCUSSED ON 2493 01:30:16,442 --> 01:30:17,676 DIFFERENT LEVELSAs WELL AS 2494 01:30:17,676 --> 01:30:19,311 TOOLS TO MAKE THE DATA 2495 01:30:19,311 --> 01:30:20,713 APPROACHABLE BY EACH THE MOST 2496 01:30:20,713 --> 01:30:22,181 NOVICE OF RESEARCHERS, 2497 01:30:22,181 --> 01:30:25,017 COMMUNITY, PERHAPS GOING BACK TO 2498 01:30:25,017 --> 01:30:25,551 STEM. 2499 01:30:25,551 --> 01:30:27,152 EARLY, JUST EARLIER IN THE 2500 01:30:27,152 --> 01:30:28,988 EDUCATIONAL PROCESS, THE BETTER 2501 01:30:28,988 --> 01:30:31,490 OFF, THE FUTURE WORKFORCE WILL 2502 01:30:31,490 --> 01:30:34,159 BE AND THEN, NOT LASTLY BUT 2503 01:30:34,159 --> 01:30:35,361 CERTAINLY, 1 OF THE THEMES THAT 2504 01:30:35,361 --> 01:30:37,363 CAME UP JUST IN THE LAST FEW 2505 01:30:37,363 --> 01:30:38,664 MINUTES OF THIS DISCUSSION IS 2506 01:30:38,664 --> 01:30:40,933 THAT IT'S A TEAM SPORT, AND WHAT 2507 01:30:40,933 --> 01:30:43,035 THAT REALLY MEAN SYSTEM THAT 2508 01:30:43,035 --> 01:30:44,570 CROSS DISCIPLINARY TEAMS ARE 2509 01:30:44,570 --> 01:30:47,306 REALLY GOING TO ACCELERATE THE 2510 01:30:47,306 --> 01:30:48,374 RESEARCH AND 27 INSTITUTES AND 2511 01:30:48,374 --> 01:30:49,908 CENTERS HAVE TO FIGURE OUT HOW 2512 01:30:49,908 --> 01:30:52,511 TO BREAK DOWN THE SILOS TO MAKE 2513 01:30:52,511 --> 01:30:54,146 YOU KNOW PRECISION MEDICINE A 2514 01:30:54,146 --> 01:30:56,448 REALITY NOT ONLY FOR NIDCD BUT 2515 01:30:56,448 --> 01:30:57,883 FOR THE ENTIRETY OF NE H, SO 2516 01:30:57,883 --> 01:31:01,053 WITH THAT I WILL TURN IT BACK TO 2517 01:31:01,053 --> 01:31:01,587 DEB. 2518 01:31:01,587 --> 01:31:01,854 THANK YOU. 2519 01:31:01,854 --> 01:31:04,123 >> THANK YOU. 2520 01:31:04,123 --> 01:31:05,624 I WANT TO EXPRESS MY DEEP 2521 01:31:05,624 --> 01:31:07,393 APPRECIATION TO ADAM AND ALL OF 2522 01:31:07,393 --> 01:31:08,894 OUR PANELISTS FOR A RICH 2523 01:31:08,894 --> 01:31:09,895 DISCUSSION EMPLOY I COULDN'T 2524 01:31:09,895 --> 01:31:11,063 HAVE HOPED FOR MORE. 2525 01:31:11,063 --> 01:31:11,530 THAT WAS PERFECT. 2526 01:31:11,530 --> 01:31:13,065 I THINK WHEN I THINK OF A GRAND 2527 01:31:13,065 --> 01:31:15,067 VISION, WHAT I THINK OF AS 2528 01:31:15,067 --> 01:31:17,703 SOMEBODY WHO IS A CLINICIAN IS 2529 01:31:17,703 --> 01:31:20,205 REALLY THE INTEGRATION OF 2530 01:31:20,205 --> 01:31:21,473 RESEARCH INTO CLINICAL CARRY, I 2531 01:31:21,473 --> 01:31:23,308 THINK THAT'S THE END GAME THAT 2532 01:31:23,308 --> 01:31:26,345 WE'RE THINKING ABOUT IS THAT 2533 01:31:26,345 --> 01:31:28,147 RESEARCH IS A 2 WAY STREET SO 2534 01:31:28,147 --> 01:31:28,714 THE CLINICIAN PROVIDES 2535 01:31:28,714 --> 01:31:31,450 INFORMATION BUT THE CLINICIAN 2536 01:31:31,450 --> 01:31:32,618 ALSO GETS INFORMATION BACK ABOUT 2537 01:31:32,618 --> 01:31:34,820 HOW TO GUIDE THEIR CARE OF 2538 01:31:34,820 --> 01:31:35,220 PATIENTS. 2539 01:31:35,220 --> 01:31:38,691 SO, THAT IS THE GOAL THAT I KNOW 2540 01:31:38,691 --> 01:31:40,392 WE'RE ALL AIMING FOR. 2541 01:31:40,392 --> 01:31:42,661 SO I WILL WRAP UP THEN AND SAY 2542 01:31:42,661 --> 01:31:45,531 THAT IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO GIVE 2543 01:31:45,531 --> 01:31:47,833 FEEDBACK ON TODAY'S EVENT, THERE 2544 01:31:47,833 --> 01:31:49,668 SHOULD BE A SLIDE THAT WILL 2545 01:31:49,668 --> 01:31:51,937 APPEAR SHORTLY THAT HAS A QR 2546 01:31:51,937 --> 01:31:54,139 CODE THAT YOU CAN ACCESS TO 2547 01:31:54,139 --> 01:31:55,407 PROVIDE FEEDBACK AND WE WOULD 2548 01:31:55,407 --> 01:31:57,876 VERY MUCH APPRECIATE THAT. 2549 01:31:57,876 --> 01:31:59,812 FOR THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE HERE IN 2550 01:31:59,812 --> 01:32:02,181 PERSON, YOU'RE INVITED TO JOIN 2551 01:32:02,181 --> 01:32:03,749 US FOR COFFEE, DR. RESNICK WILL 2552 01:32:03,749 --> 01:32:07,119 STAY WITH US FOR A BIT AND CAN 2553 01:32:07,119 --> 01:32:09,254 CONTINUE THE DISCUSSION. 2554 01:32:09,254 --> 01:32:11,123 THE NEXT NIDCD'S DIRECTOR'S 2555 01:32:11,123 --> 01:32:13,692 SEMINAR SERIES WILL BE HELD NEXT 2556 01:32:13,692 --> 01:32:14,159 FALL. 2557 01:32:14,159 --> 01:32:16,595 PLEASE CHECK THE NIDCD EVENTS 2558 01:32:16,595 --> 01:32:18,597 PAGE OF OUR WEBSITE IN THE 2559 01:32:18,597 --> 01:32:19,631 COMING MONTHS FOR MORE 2560 01:32:19,631 --> 01:32:20,099 INFORMATION. 2561 01:32:20,099 --> 01:32:22,968 AND THIS CONCLUDES OUR 2562 01:32:22,968 --> 01:32:23,302 PRESENTATION. 2563 01:32:23,302 --> 01:32:25,170 THANK YOU ALL FOR COME XG THANK 2564 01:32:25,170 --> 01:32:27,573 YOU ADAM AND OUR PANELISTS. 2565 01:32:27,573 --> 01:32:37,816 [ APPLAUSE ]