1 00:00:05,969 --> 00:00:09,439 IF EVERYBODY CAN GET SEATED 2 00:00:09,439 --> 00:00:10,473 WE'LL START THE MULTISCALE 3 00:00:10,473 --> 00:00:12,342 MODELING PAST AND FUTURE 4 00:00:12,342 --> 00:00:21,151 MEETING. 5 00:00:21,151 --> 00:00:23,153 ALL RIGHT, I WILL PASS IT TO 6 00:00:23,153 --> 00:00:25,122 BRUCE LEE. 7 00:00:25,122 --> 00:00:26,523 THANK YOU, EVERYONE. 8 00:00:26,523 --> 00:00:31,228 HOPE ALL OF YOU ENJOYED 9 00:00:31,228 --> 00:00:31,995 YESTERDAY. 10 00:00:31,995 --> 00:00:34,164 THANKS TO DENISE AND HERBERT FOR 11 00:00:34,164 --> 00:00:35,065 CO-CHAIRING THE FIRST DAY. 12 00:00:35,065 --> 00:00:36,633 THE FIRST DAY WAS FOCUSSED ON 13 00:00:36,633 --> 00:00:37,901 THE PAST AND WHAT WE'VE LEARNED 14 00:00:37,901 --> 00:00:41,104 FROM THE PAST AND HOW THAT 15 00:00:41,104 --> 00:00:41,705 ACTUALLY TRANSLATES TO THE 16 00:00:41,705 --> 00:00:42,039 FUTURE. 17 00:00:42,039 --> 00:00:46,510 WE ESSENTIALLY WENT THROUGH SOME 18 00:00:46,510 --> 00:00:49,680 OF THE ORIGINAL MSM AWARDEES AND 19 00:00:49,680 --> 00:00:51,215 REFLECTIONS AND GAVE TRIBUTE TO 20 00:00:51,215 --> 00:00:52,349 KEY MEMBERS OF THE CONSORTIUM. 21 00:00:52,349 --> 00:00:59,156 WE LISTENED TO A GREAT FANTASTIC 22 00:00:59,156 --> 00:01:01,491 KEYNOTE SPEAK FROM OUR CO-CHAIR, 23 00:01:01,491 --> 00:01:03,660 DENISE, NOW WE'RE READY TO MOVE 24 00:01:03,660 --> 00:01:05,495 TO THE SECOND DAY. 25 00:01:05,495 --> 00:01:07,297 THE SECOND DAY IS FOCUSSED ON 26 00:01:07,297 --> 00:01:07,931 THE FUTURE. 27 00:01:07,931 --> 00:01:09,633 WE'LL LOOK AT HOW DO WE MOVE 28 00:01:09,633 --> 00:01:12,569 FORWARD AS A CONSORTIUM. 29 00:01:12,569 --> 00:01:13,370 HOW DOES MULTISCALE MODELING 30 00:01:13,370 --> 00:01:15,739 MOVE FORWARD IN GENERAL. 31 00:01:15,739 --> 00:01:18,809 WE'RE GOING TO START WITH A 32 00:01:18,809 --> 00:01:22,179 KEYNOTE SPEAK FROM PETER HUNTER 33 00:01:22,179 --> 00:01:23,513 WHO GRACE WILL INTRODUCE. 34 00:01:23,513 --> 00:01:27,184 THEN WE'LL GO THROUGH A PLENARY 35 00:01:27,184 --> 00:01:30,053 SESSION 2.1 WHICH IS THE CURRENT 36 00:01:30,053 --> 00:01:31,655 IMAG INITIATIVE ROUNDTABLE. 37 00:01:31,655 --> 00:01:33,957 THIS WILL BE AN OPPORTUNITY TO 38 00:01:33,957 --> 00:01:34,691 REALLY COVER DIFFERENT 39 00:01:34,691 --> 00:01:39,596 INITIATIVES THAT ARE RELATED TO 40 00:01:39,596 --> 00:01:40,264 MULTISCALE MODELING IN DIFFERENT 41 00:01:40,264 --> 00:01:41,298 WAYS. 42 00:01:41,298 --> 00:01:42,532 A.I. DRIVEN AND MECHANISTIC 43 00:01:42,532 --> 00:01:44,034 DRIVEN INITIATIVES, ETCETERA. 44 00:01:44,034 --> 00:01:45,435 WE WANT TO ENCOURAGE EACH OF YOU 45 00:01:45,435 --> 00:01:48,739 TO LOOK AT THE WIKI, TO LOOK AT 46 00:01:48,739 --> 00:01:50,440 SOME OF THESE INITIATIVES LISTED 47 00:01:50,440 --> 00:01:50,641 THERE. 48 00:01:50,641 --> 00:01:52,609 THE ROUNDTABLE IS NOT GOING TO 49 00:01:52,609 --> 00:01:55,846 GO THROUGH EACH IN DETAIL SO IF 50 00:01:55,846 --> 00:01:57,014 YOU CAN LOOK THROUGH THE WIKI 51 00:01:57,014 --> 00:02:00,250 FIRST TO GET AN IDEA OF WHAT THE 52 00:02:00,250 --> 00:02:02,486 INITIATIVES ARE AND WE'LL 53 00:02:02,486 --> 00:02:04,354 DISCUSS THEM AND HOW MULTISCALE 54 00:02:04,354 --> 00:02:05,555 MODELING CAN FIT INTO THOSE. 55 00:02:05,555 --> 00:02:08,458 THEN WE'LL HAVE A COFFEE/TEA 56 00:02:08,458 --> 00:02:11,561 BREAK AT 10:00 A.M. THEN HAVE 57 00:02:11,561 --> 00:02:13,697 THE PLENARY SESSION 2.2 WHICH 58 00:02:13,697 --> 00:02:14,298 JASON WILL SUMMARIZE IN A 59 00:02:14,298 --> 00:02:16,600 SECOND. 60 00:02:16,600 --> 00:02:19,569 THEN WE'LL MOVE TO PLENARY 61 00:02:19,569 --> 00:02:21,605 SESSION 2.3, SYNERGIZING MSM 62 00:02:21,605 --> 00:02:22,239 WITH THE FUTURE. 63 00:02:22,239 --> 00:02:26,943 WE'LL GO THROUGH OUR MISSION 64 00:02:26,943 --> 00:02:28,979 STATEMENT THEN HAVE THE 65 00:02:28,979 --> 00:02:29,546 INTRODUCTION FOR THE FIVE 66 00:02:29,546 --> 00:02:33,216 DIFFERENT BREAKOUT SESSIONS SO 67 00:02:33,216 --> 00:02:34,851 WE WANT TO ENCOURAGE YOU TO SIGN 68 00:02:34,851 --> 00:02:36,453 UP FOR THEM IF YOU CAN. 69 00:02:36,453 --> 00:02:40,557 IT WILL TAKE US THROUGH LUNCH, 70 00:02:40,557 --> 00:02:43,627 12:15 TO 1:00 P.M. WILL BE THE 71 00:02:43,627 --> 00:02:44,428 FIRST ROUND AND SECOND ROUND 72 00:02:44,428 --> 00:02:45,829 RIGHT AFTER THAT AND THEN 73 00:02:45,829 --> 00:02:49,900 RECONVENE TO HAVE REPORT OUTS 74 00:02:49,900 --> 00:02:52,069 FOR EACH OF THE BREAKOUT 75 00:02:52,069 --> 00:02:55,105 SESSIONS -- POSTER SESSION, 76 00:02:55,105 --> 00:02:57,708 SORRY, 2:15 FOR ALL MSM 77 00:02:57,708 --> 00:03:00,911 INVESTIGATORS AND A SUMMARY OF 78 00:03:00,911 --> 00:03:03,146 BREAKOUTS AFTER THAT AND WRAP UP 79 00:03:03,146 --> 00:03:03,447 SESSION. 80 00:03:03,447 --> 00:03:05,315 THAT'S HOW OUR DAY IS GOING TO 81 00:03:05,315 --> 00:03:07,250 GO. 82 00:03:07,250 --> 00:03:08,952 JASON, DO YOU WANT TO MENTION 83 00:03:08,952 --> 00:03:09,886 THE DISPARITIES PANEL. 84 00:03:09,886 --> 00:03:12,122 >> YEAH, SESSION 2.2 WILL BE 85 00:03:12,122 --> 00:03:14,091 AFTER THE COFFEE AND TEA BREAK 86 00:03:14,091 --> 00:03:18,295 AND I'M EXCITED ABOUT THIS 87 00:03:18,295 --> 00:03:20,997 SESSION FOCUSSED ON HEALTH 88 00:03:20,997 --> 00:03:21,865 DISPARITIES AND MOVING TOWARDS 89 00:03:21,865 --> 00:03:22,999 HEALTH EQUITY. 90 00:03:22,999 --> 00:03:28,405 THIS WAS THE BRAIN CHILD OF TWO 91 00:03:28,405 --> 00:03:37,280 EARLY INVESTIGATORS, ELSJE 92 00:03:37,280 --> 00:03:41,118 PIENAAR OTHERS. 93 00:03:41,118 --> 00:03:45,622 >> WE'RE USING THE HASHTAG IMAG, 94 00:03:45,622 --> 00:03:52,295 PAST, THE NUMBER "2" FUTURE AND 95 00:03:52,295 --> 00:03:54,331 WE HAVE SOME POSTS BUT IF YOU 96 00:03:54,331 --> 00:03:55,999 CAN ADD TO THAT. 97 00:03:55,999 --> 00:03:57,167 >> WELCOME BACK, EVERYONE. 98 00:03:57,167 --> 00:03:59,035 I HOPE YOU ENJOYED THE FIRST DAY 99 00:03:59,035 --> 00:04:01,905 AND THE SECOND DAY SHOULD BE 100 00:04:01,905 --> 00:04:06,276 TWICE AS FUN. 101 00:04:06,276 --> 00:04:09,913 ANY WAY, WE WERE FORTUNATE TO 102 00:04:09,913 --> 00:04:12,416 PROVIDE FOR REFRESHMENTS FROM 103 00:04:12,416 --> 00:04:13,717 THE SOCIETY OF MATHEMATICAL 104 00:04:13,717 --> 00:04:13,950 BIOLOGY. 105 00:04:13,950 --> 00:04:14,851 WE'LL DO THE SAME THING AFTER 106 00:04:14,851 --> 00:04:16,520 THE MORNING SESSION. 107 00:04:16,520 --> 00:04:18,121 WE'LL HAVE SOME COFFEE AND TEA 108 00:04:18,121 --> 00:04:21,825 AND DURING THE POSTERS THIS 109 00:04:21,825 --> 00:04:22,793 AFTERNOON THERE'LL BE SOME 110 00:04:22,793 --> 00:04:23,026 SNACKS. 111 00:04:23,026 --> 00:04:29,332 PLEASE EAT THEM UP,EN JOY AND 112 00:04:29,332 --> 00:04:30,667 LUNCH THE SAME AS WELL. 113 00:04:30,667 --> 00:04:33,437 WHEN IT'S TIME TO PICK UP YOUR 114 00:04:33,437 --> 00:04:34,404 BOX LUNCH THIS TIME HOWEVER, 115 00:04:34,404 --> 00:04:37,674 YOU'LL TAKE IT TO THE BREAKOUT 116 00:04:37,674 --> 00:04:39,476 ROOM YOU SIGNED UP FOR SO A 117 00:04:39,476 --> 00:04:41,912 BREAKOUT/LUNCH TODAY. 118 00:04:41,912 --> 00:04:42,379 THANKS. 119 00:04:42,379 --> 00:04:44,047 >> AND REED, I THINK YOU HAVE 120 00:04:44,047 --> 00:04:46,283 LOGISTICS WITH THE BREAKOUT 121 00:04:46,283 --> 00:04:46,550 SESSIONS. 122 00:04:46,550 --> 00:04:47,384 >> YES. 123 00:04:47,384 --> 00:04:49,152 ALL RIGHT, SO I'M EXCITED ABOUT 124 00:04:49,152 --> 00:04:50,587 THESE BREAKOUT SESSIONS. 125 00:04:50,587 --> 00:04:51,555 A LOT OF FOLKS HAVE PUT A LOT OF 126 00:04:51,555 --> 00:04:53,390 WORK INTO THEM AND IT WILL BE A 127 00:04:53,390 --> 00:04:55,926 GREAT WAY TO INTERACT. 128 00:04:55,926 --> 00:04:57,093 OUTSIDE, OUT FRONT THERE'S A 129 00:04:57,093 --> 00:04:59,996 PLACE TO SIGN UP FOR YOUR 130 00:04:59,996 --> 00:05:00,597 BREAKOUT SESSION YOU'RE 131 00:05:00,597 --> 00:05:01,932 INTERESTED IN. 132 00:05:01,932 --> 00:05:06,770 THAT WILL HELP US ORGANIZE. 133 00:05:06,770 --> 00:05:09,172 I THINK THERE'S TWO ROUNDS SO 134 00:05:09,172 --> 00:05:11,274 YOU CAN SIGN UP FOR -- IF YOU 135 00:05:11,274 --> 00:05:13,477 KNOW, FOR ROUND ONE YOU CAN SIGN 136 00:05:13,477 --> 00:05:15,111 UP FOR DIGITAL TWINS AND ROUND 137 00:05:15,111 --> 00:05:16,746 TWO YOU CAN SIGN UP FOR HEALTH 138 00:05:16,746 --> 00:05:18,448 DISPARITIES OR ANOTHER ONE. 139 00:05:18,448 --> 00:05:20,250 PLEASE, MAKE SURE YOU SIGN UP 140 00:05:20,250 --> 00:05:21,518 MAYBE DURING THE COFFEE BREAK 141 00:05:21,518 --> 00:05:24,087 AND DON'T FORGET TO POST IN THE 142 00:05:24,087 --> 00:05:24,387 WIKI. 143 00:05:24,387 --> 00:05:27,591 POST YOUR QUESTIONS ON OUR SLACK 144 00:05:27,591 --> 00:05:28,058 CHANNEL. 145 00:05:28,058 --> 00:05:31,761 SORRY. 146 00:05:31,761 --> 00:05:35,732 AND ON EACH OF THE PAGES. 147 00:05:35,732 --> 00:05:37,400 IF YOU GO TO THE WIKI YOU CAN 148 00:05:37,400 --> 00:05:40,670 FIND OUT MORE ABOUT THE BREAKOUT 149 00:05:40,670 --> 00:05:42,105 ROOMS ON THE WIKI. 150 00:05:42,105 --> 00:05:44,040 DETAILS ABOUT THEM SO YOU CAN 151 00:05:44,040 --> 00:05:45,609 SCROLL THROUGH THAT NOW IF 152 00:05:45,609 --> 00:05:47,978 YOU'RE UNDECIDED ABOUT WHICH 153 00:05:47,978 --> 00:05:48,912 BREAKOUT YOU WANT TO CHOOSE. 154 00:05:48,912 --> 00:05:54,184 I LOOK FORWARD TO DAY TWO. 155 00:05:54,184 --> 00:05:58,421 >> AND EMPHASIS, ROUND TWO WILL 156 00:05:58,421 --> 00:06:00,857 BUILD ON ROUND ONE FOR THE 157 00:06:00,857 --> 00:06:01,558 BREAKOUT SESSION. 158 00:06:01,558 --> 00:06:03,560 ROUND ONE WILL DISCUSS THE 159 00:06:03,560 --> 00:06:04,361 DIFFERENT POSSIBLE NEXT STEPS 160 00:06:04,361 --> 00:06:06,963 FOR THAT TOPIC AREA AND ROUND 161 00:06:06,963 --> 00:06:09,199 TWO WILL REALLY BE COMING UP 162 00:06:09,199 --> 00:06:10,267 WITH CONCRETE NEXT STEPS. 163 00:06:10,267 --> 00:06:16,172 WE WANT TO BREAK OUT SESSIONS TO 164 00:06:16,172 --> 00:06:18,408 BE NEXT STEPS FOR OUR 165 00:06:18,408 --> 00:06:18,842 CONSORTIUM. 166 00:06:18,842 --> 00:06:20,544 I THINK WITH THAT, GRACE, YOU 167 00:06:20,544 --> 00:06:21,778 HAVE OTHER LOGISTICS? 168 00:06:21,778 --> 00:06:25,482 >> YEAH, FINALLY, TAKE A PICTURE 169 00:06:25,482 --> 00:06:27,183 OF THE QR CODE AND MAKE SURE YOU 170 00:06:27,183 --> 00:06:27,984 COME TO THE WIKI. 171 00:06:27,984 --> 00:06:31,821 ONCE YOU GET TO THE WIKI, YOU'LL 172 00:06:31,821 --> 00:06:33,390 GET TO THE PAGES. 173 00:06:33,390 --> 00:06:34,791 I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU IF YOU 174 00:06:34,791 --> 00:06:36,426 HAVEN'T DONE IT YET TO DO THE 175 00:06:36,426 --> 00:06:37,327 WORD CLOUD EXERCISE. 176 00:06:37,327 --> 00:06:38,795 GO TO THE LOGISTICS PAGE AND 177 00:06:38,795 --> 00:06:42,432 CLICK ON IT. 178 00:06:42,432 --> 00:06:46,536 WE DON'T HAVE MANY METHODS, 179 00:06:46,536 --> 00:06:47,737 APPLICATIONS. 180 00:06:47,737 --> 00:06:49,606 PLEASE POST YOUR FAVORITE 181 00:06:49,606 --> 00:06:51,374 MULTISCALE MODELING METHOD 182 00:06:51,374 --> 00:06:52,342 APPROACH HERE AND YOUR FAVORITE 183 00:06:52,342 --> 00:06:53,910 PROBLEM HERE AND ANY PICTURES 184 00:06:53,910 --> 00:07:04,187 YOU MIGHT HAVE. 185 00:07:04,788 --> 00:07:07,090 AND IN TERMS OF THE AGENDA FOR 186 00:07:07,090 --> 00:07:08,592 TODAY WE'RE GOING TO BE HAVING 187 00:07:08,592 --> 00:07:12,429 THE IMAG ROUNDTABLE AND THEN 188 00:07:12,429 --> 00:07:13,730 AFTER THAT RIGHT BEFORE WE BREAK 189 00:07:13,730 --> 00:07:17,100 FOR THE MORNING BREAK OUR 190 00:07:17,100 --> 00:07:18,535 PHOTOGRAPHER WILL BE HERE TO 191 00:07:18,535 --> 00:07:20,103 TAKE OUR PICTURE. 192 00:07:20,103 --> 00:07:21,671 SO STAY PUT AND YOU'LL BE 193 00:07:21,671 --> 00:07:23,106 DIRECTED TO COME FORWARD TO THE 194 00:07:23,106 --> 00:07:29,279 FRONT TO TAKE A PICTURE. 195 00:07:29,279 --> 00:07:31,247 AS WELL, MAKE SURE AS BRUCE JUST 196 00:07:31,247 --> 00:07:34,985 MENTIONED, PLEASE LOOK AT THE 197 00:07:34,985 --> 00:07:37,320 WIKI PAGES AND CLICK ON ALL THE 198 00:07:37,320 --> 00:07:38,722 SESSION PAGES AND ESPECIALLY WE 199 00:07:38,722 --> 00:07:40,123 ASKED YESTERDAY FOR YOU TO THINK 200 00:07:40,123 --> 00:07:42,325 ABOUT THE FUTURE, RIGHT. 201 00:07:42,325 --> 00:07:44,027 IF YOU HAVE IDEAS FOR THE 202 00:07:44,027 --> 00:07:46,296 FUTURE, CLICK ON THE LAST 203 00:07:46,296 --> 00:07:47,731 SESSION, FUTURE OF THE MSM 204 00:07:47,731 --> 00:07:48,898 CONSORTIUM ESPECIALLY IF YOU 205 00:07:48,898 --> 00:07:50,333 NEED TO LEAVE EARLY TODAY. 206 00:07:50,333 --> 00:07:51,768 WE WANT YOUR COMMENTS HERE. 207 00:07:51,768 --> 00:07:52,969 ADD YOUR COMMENTS HERE 208 00:07:52,969 --> 00:07:55,505 ESPECIALLY IF YOU WANT TO DO 209 00:07:55,505 --> 00:07:56,673 SOMETHING IN THE NEXT YEAR 210 00:07:56,673 --> 00:07:57,774 PERHAPS EVEN ORGANIZE THE NEXT 211 00:07:57,774 --> 00:07:58,441 MEETING. 212 00:07:58,441 --> 00:08:08,852 PUT YOUR POSTINGS THERE. 213 00:08:12,622 --> 00:08:13,657 >> GOOD MORNING. 214 00:08:13,657 --> 00:08:15,725 I WANT TO REMIND YOU ALL THE 215 00:08:15,725 --> 00:08:17,894 TALKS FROM YESTERDAY AND TODAY 216 00:08:17,894 --> 00:08:18,795 WILL BE THERE IN THE WIKI UNDER 217 00:08:18,795 --> 00:08:20,930 THE SESSIONS IF YOU WANT TO 218 00:08:20,930 --> 00:08:22,532 ACCESS THEM. 219 00:08:22,532 --> 00:08:23,833 ALSO, THERE WAS GREAT Q&A 220 00:08:23,833 --> 00:08:25,435 DISCUSSION SO YOU IF YOU WERE IN 221 00:08:25,435 --> 00:08:27,137 THOSE GO IN AND TRY TO RESPOND 222 00:08:27,137 --> 00:08:29,539 TO THE QUERIES AND IF YOU HAVE 223 00:08:29,539 --> 00:08:31,675 MORE QUESTIONS YOU THOUGHT ABOUT 224 00:08:31,675 --> 00:08:32,876 POST THEM THERE AND WE'LL 225 00:08:32,876 --> 00:08:33,910 CONTINUE THE INTERACTIVE 226 00:08:33,910 --> 00:08:35,178 DISCUSSION AND THAT WILL HAPPEN 227 00:08:35,178 --> 00:08:36,012 AGAIN TODAY. 228 00:08:36,012 --> 00:08:37,313 ALSO, AFTER THE BREAKOUT 229 00:08:37,313 --> 00:08:38,648 SESSIONS THERE'S GOING TO BE A 230 00:08:38,648 --> 00:08:40,250 SUMMARY SO ALL THE LEADS WILL 231 00:08:40,250 --> 00:08:43,353 PRESENT A TIGHT SUMMARY OF SOME 232 00:08:43,353 --> 00:08:45,422 OF THE CONCRETE DECISIONS AND 233 00:08:45,422 --> 00:08:47,357 SUGGESTIONS THAT ARE MADE. 234 00:08:47,357 --> 00:08:48,525 THAT'S GOING TO BE REALLY GREAT 235 00:08:48,525 --> 00:08:50,627 AND THAT WILL HAPPEN AFTER THE 236 00:08:50,627 --> 00:08:50,927 SUMMARY. 237 00:08:50,927 --> 00:08:52,529 EVEN IF YOU MISS ATTENDING THE 238 00:08:52,529 --> 00:08:54,564 OTHER SESSIONS YOU'LL HEAR A BIG 239 00:08:54,564 --> 00:08:55,699 SUMMARY OF WHAT HAPPENED. 240 00:08:55,699 --> 00:08:57,167 >> AND ONE FINAL THING, THE 241 00:08:57,167 --> 00:08:58,768 SECOND POSTER SESSION TODAY IS 242 00:08:58,768 --> 00:09:00,303 FOR ALL THE INVESTIGATORS BUT 243 00:09:00,303 --> 00:09:02,272 THE IMAG FOLKS, IF YOU ARE IN 244 00:09:02,272 --> 00:09:04,074 THIS ROOM, PLEASE STAND UP RIGHT 245 00:09:04,074 --> 00:09:09,245 NOW SO EVERYBODY CAN SEE YOU. 246 00:09:09,245 --> 00:09:11,147 WAVE, IMAG FOLKS. 247 00:09:11,147 --> 00:09:11,948 ALL RIGHT. 248 00:09:11,948 --> 00:09:16,386 WE'RE CELEBRATING IMAG FOLKS AND 249 00:09:16,386 --> 00:09:19,155 THEY'LL BE AT THE IMAG TABLE 250 00:09:19,155 --> 00:09:20,690 DURING THE POSTER SESSION. 251 00:09:20,690 --> 00:09:23,526 LOOK FOR THE BLUE STICKER ON 252 00:09:23,526 --> 00:09:25,495 THEIR NAME TAG AND FIND THEM AND 253 00:09:25,495 --> 00:09:26,029 ASK THEM ABOUT GOVERNMENT 254 00:09:26,029 --> 00:09:36,206 QUESTIONS. 255 00:09:36,873 --> 00:09:39,676 SO WE WILL BEGIN WITH THE 256 00:09:39,676 --> 00:09:40,477 KEYNOTE FOR TODAY. 257 00:09:40,477 --> 00:09:43,513 SO AS I MENTIONED DURING THE 258 00:09:43,513 --> 00:09:49,619 OPENING YESTERDAY, ONE OF THE 259 00:09:49,619 --> 00:09:52,021 INSPIRATIONS FOR OUR EXISTENCE 260 00:09:52,021 --> 00:09:59,596 IS PETER HUNTER'S PAPER FROM 261 00:09:59,596 --> 00:10:02,532 2003 WHERE ME INTRODUCED THE 262 00:10:02,532 --> 00:10:05,602 SCALES OF THE HUMAN BODY AND 263 00:10:05,602 --> 00:10:06,269 MULTISCALE MODELING AND I ASKED 264 00:10:06,269 --> 00:10:08,037 HIM TO DO THE KEYNOTE TO PRESENT 265 00:10:08,037 --> 00:10:09,506 THE VISION FOR THE FUTURE SINCE 266 00:10:09,506 --> 00:10:11,608 HE SORT OF PRESENTED FOR IT THE 267 00:10:11,608 --> 00:10:14,010 LAST 20 YEARS TO ASK PETER TO 268 00:10:14,010 --> 00:10:17,714 THINK ABOUT THE NEXT 20 YEARS. 269 00:10:17,714 --> 00:10:21,918 SO WITHOUT ANY FURTHER ADO, I'LL 270 00:10:21,918 --> 00:10:23,987 HAVE PETER COME UP AND PRESENT 271 00:10:23,987 --> 00:10:34,230 THE KEY NOTE. 272 00:10:48,378 --> 00:10:49,913 >> THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING ME TO 273 00:10:49,913 --> 00:10:51,147 TALK ABOUT THE FUTURE. 274 00:10:51,147 --> 00:10:56,486 I HAVE TO QUICKLY GIVE A 275 00:10:56,486 --> 00:11:05,261 PERSPECTIVE ON HOW THE PHYSIOME 276 00:11:05,261 --> 00:11:10,099 PROJECT GOT START AND IT STARTED 277 00:11:10,099 --> 00:11:16,673 WITH DENNIS AND THEN IN 1997 278 00:11:16,673 --> 00:11:19,576 THEY ASKED ME TO CHAIR THE FIRST 279 00:11:19,576 --> 00:11:22,345 WORKING GROUP OF COMMITTEE OF 280 00:11:22,345 --> 00:11:22,846 THAT. 281 00:11:22,846 --> 00:11:25,348 IT WAS ALWAYS FAIRLY QUICKLY 282 00:11:25,348 --> 00:11:28,117 TIED UP WITH THE EUROPEAN UNION 283 00:11:28,117 --> 00:11:29,552 AND THE PLANS THE EUROPEAN 284 00:11:29,552 --> 00:11:32,021 COMMISSION HAD FOR CREATING WHAT 285 00:11:32,021 --> 00:11:42,565 BECAME THE PHYSIOME PROJECT AND 286 00:11:50,106 --> 00:11:52,175 THE WELCOME TRUST AND AT THE 287 00:11:52,175 --> 00:11:58,548 SAME TIME GRACE BEGAN THE NIH 288 00:11:58,548 --> 00:11:59,749 INSTITUTES IMAG PROGRAM. 289 00:11:59,749 --> 00:12:02,051 WHAT WE WERE FOCUSSING ON WITH 290 00:12:02,051 --> 00:12:05,421 THE PHYSIOME PROJECT WAS REALLY 291 00:12:05,421 --> 00:12:08,958 THE ISSUE OF STANDARDS BEING 292 00:12:08,958 --> 00:12:10,927 ABLE TO ENSURE REPRODUCIBILITY 293 00:12:10,927 --> 00:12:12,428 IN MODELS BECAUSE WE WERE 294 00:12:12,428 --> 00:12:13,496 FINDING A LOT OF THE MODELS WE 295 00:12:13,496 --> 00:12:15,098 WERE TRYING TO ACCESS FROM THE 296 00:12:15,098 --> 00:12:17,700 LITERATURE WERE NOT 297 00:12:17,700 --> 00:12:20,203 REPRODUCIBLE. 298 00:12:20,203 --> 00:12:24,307 WE DEVELOPED CEL ML AND SOFTWARE 299 00:12:24,307 --> 00:12:32,181 AND AT ABOUT THE SAME TIME AS 300 00:12:32,181 --> 00:12:39,489 YOU HAD HEARD YESTERDAY SBML GOT 301 00:12:39,489 --> 00:12:44,027 GOING AND LEADING TO THE MARK UP 302 00:12:44,027 --> 00:12:45,828 LANGUAGE AROUND THE SOLUTION 303 00:12:45,828 --> 00:12:47,497 PROCESS FOR THE MODELS. 304 00:12:47,497 --> 00:12:54,070 RECENTLY ON THE BOTTOM LEFT WE 305 00:12:54,070 --> 00:12:56,239 STARTED AT A LOW -ACCESS JOURNAL 306 00:12:56,239 --> 00:12:58,541 AS A SECONDARY JOURNAL SO PEOPLE 307 00:12:58,541 --> 00:13:02,545 CAN PUT AFTER THEIR PUBLIC THEIR 308 00:13:02,545 --> 00:13:05,048 PRIMARY PAPER CAN PUT EXTRA 309 00:13:05,048 --> 00:13:07,150 EFFORT INTO DOCUMENTATION OF A 310 00:13:07,150 --> 00:13:12,355 MODEL AND PUBLISH THAT AS THE 311 00:13:12,355 --> 00:13:13,222 PHYSIOME JOURNAL AND THAT'S UP 312 00:13:13,222 --> 00:13:15,358 AND GOING AND HAS BEEN UP AND 313 00:13:15,358 --> 00:13:17,927 GOING ABOUT A YEAR. 314 00:13:17,927 --> 00:13:19,796 THE PHYSIOME MODEL REPOSITORY 315 00:13:19,796 --> 00:13:21,731 BUILT UP OVER MANY YEARS HAS 316 00:13:21,731 --> 00:13:28,204 ABOUT 1500 CURATED MODELS. 317 00:13:28,204 --> 00:13:34,177 THE CELLML STANDARD WAS AIMED AT 318 00:13:34,177 --> 00:13:38,381 THE COMMUNITY AND A LOT OF THESE 319 00:13:38,381 --> 00:13:40,450 MODELS OVER MANY YEARS WE FOUND 320 00:13:40,450 --> 00:13:42,518 NEARLY ALL PUBLISHED MODELS 321 00:13:42,518 --> 00:13:44,287 DON'T WHEN YOU GO TO THE PAPER 322 00:13:44,287 --> 00:13:46,289 YOU DON'T GET WHAT THE MODEL IS 323 00:13:46,289 --> 00:13:49,859 INTENDING TO DO. 324 00:13:49,859 --> 00:13:51,060 IT'S JUST IMPOSSIBLE TO WRITE 325 00:13:51,060 --> 00:13:53,296 THE MODELS WITHOUT TYPO 326 00:13:53,296 --> 00:13:53,796 GRAPHICAL ERRORS. 327 00:13:53,796 --> 00:13:55,832 SO WHAT WE WERE TRYING TO DO WAS 328 00:13:55,832 --> 00:14:01,904 WORK WITH THE AUTHORS TO MAKE 329 00:14:01,904 --> 00:14:05,908 THE MODEL TO THE COMMUNITY IN A 330 00:14:05,908 --> 00:14:07,477 CURATED STANDARDIZED FORM AND 331 00:14:07,477 --> 00:14:09,112 THAT'S HELPFUL BECAUSE PEOPLE 332 00:14:09,112 --> 00:14:11,547 ARE KEEN TO HELP. 333 00:14:11,547 --> 00:14:13,616 THESE MODELS SOME SHOWN HERE 334 00:14:13,616 --> 00:14:15,351 COME FROM RIGHT ACROSS THE 335 00:14:15,351 --> 00:14:17,920 SPECTRUM OF BIOLOGICAL MODELLING 336 00:14:17,920 --> 00:14:20,523 AND FROM GROUPS ALL AROUND THE 337 00:14:20,523 --> 00:14:26,362 WORLD BASED ON PUBLISHED PAPERS. 338 00:14:26,362 --> 00:14:28,898 AS WE DID THIS MORE WE FOUND 339 00:14:28,898 --> 00:14:30,600 WHILE THE MODELS ARE 340 00:14:30,600 --> 00:14:32,702 REPRODUCIBLE THEY DIDN'T OBEY 341 00:14:32,702 --> 00:14:33,870 THE LAWS OF PHYSICS. 342 00:14:33,870 --> 00:14:38,708 WHEN YOU WENT TO USE THEM IN A 343 00:14:38,708 --> 00:14:41,511 MULTISCALE SENSE IT WAS HARD TO 344 00:14:41,511 --> 00:14:43,713 ENSURE THEY CONSERVED ENERGY AND 345 00:14:43,713 --> 00:14:44,714 WE WENT BACK TO THE DRAWING 346 00:14:44,714 --> 00:14:51,487 BOARD AND THOUGHT HOW DO WE 347 00:14:51,487 --> 00:14:52,555 PROVIDE INFRASTRUCTURE FOR 348 00:14:52,555 --> 00:14:54,957 HANDLING THE PHYSICS OF A LOT OF 349 00:14:54,957 --> 00:14:56,726 THESE MODELS MORE ROBUSTLY THAN 350 00:14:56,726 --> 00:15:04,067 DONE BEFORE. 351 00:15:04,067 --> 00:15:06,702 THAT WAS PARTLY THE MOTIVATION 352 00:15:06,702 --> 00:15:14,010 FOR THE PHYSIOME JOURNAL AND TO 353 00:15:14,010 --> 00:15:16,813 CREATE LIBRARIES OF REUSABLE 354 00:15:16,813 --> 00:15:17,447 COMPONENT WHICH IS ARE 355 00:15:17,447 --> 00:15:19,916 GUARANTEED TO SOLVE THE PHYSICS 356 00:15:19,916 --> 00:15:20,516 AT THEIR APPROPRIATE SPATIAL 357 00:15:20,516 --> 00:15:24,754 SCALE. 358 00:15:24,754 --> 00:15:27,023 AND I'LL TALK ABOUT MODELS AND 359 00:15:27,023 --> 00:15:29,459 TALK ABOUT DISTRIBUTED AND 360 00:15:29,459 --> 00:15:33,029 SPATIAL PE MODELS AND THE IDEA 361 00:15:33,029 --> 00:15:35,398 OF THE PHYSIOME JOURNAL IS TO BE 362 00:15:35,398 --> 00:15:40,470 INTERACTIVE TO INTERACT WITH THE 363 00:15:40,470 --> 00:15:42,305 MODELS AND SOME OF THE PAPERS 364 00:15:42,305 --> 00:15:42,738 PUBLISHED BELOW. 365 00:15:42,738 --> 00:15:47,944 I THINK WE NEED A MASS PHYSICS 366 00:15:47,944 --> 00:15:49,979 FRAMEWORK TO LINK THEM ACROSS 367 00:15:49,979 --> 00:15:53,449 ALL SCALES AND A FRAMEWORK FOR 368 00:15:53,449 --> 00:15:59,489 THE MASS, CHARGE, ENERGY, 369 00:15:59,489 --> 00:15:59,755 ETCETERA. 370 00:15:59,755 --> 00:16:06,762 HERE'S THE FRAMEWORK DOES EXIST 371 00:16:06,762 --> 00:16:13,836 AND IT'S ZERO DIMENSIONAL AND 372 00:16:13,836 --> 00:16:17,907 BONE GRAPH -- BOND GRAPHS AND 373 00:16:17,907 --> 00:16:20,276 IT'S THE LOGICAL WAY TO ENSURE 374 00:16:20,276 --> 00:16:27,283 THE PHYSICS ARE SOLVED. 375 00:16:27,283 --> 00:16:29,485 THEN I WANT IT TALK ABOUT BONE 376 00:16:29,485 --> 00:16:33,055 GRAPH MODELS AND TAKE A MUCH 377 00:16:33,055 --> 00:16:34,757 MORE SYSTEMATIC APPROACH TO MAKE 378 00:16:34,757 --> 00:16:37,426 SURE WE HAVE ALL PROTEINS 379 00:16:37,426 --> 00:16:39,228 DEFINED IN THE FORM WITH THE 380 00:16:39,228 --> 00:16:42,165 PHYSICS IS DEFINED AND PROPERLY 381 00:16:42,165 --> 00:16:45,067 UNDERSTOOD AND LINK IT TO FOR 382 00:16:45,067 --> 00:16:49,238 EXAMPLE THE REACTOME AND THEN I 383 00:16:49,238 --> 00:16:52,108 WANT TO TALK HOW YOU MOVE 384 00:16:52,108 --> 00:16:54,510 UPSCALES TO FUNCTIONAL TISSUE 385 00:16:54,510 --> 00:16:56,379 UNITS I'LL EXPLAIN THAT AND 386 00:16:56,379 --> 00:16:59,015 FUNCTIONAL CONNECTIVITY AND TO 387 00:16:59,015 --> 00:17:00,983 THE WORLD OF PARTIAL EQUATIONS 388 00:17:00,983 --> 00:17:03,052 AND ORGAN SCAFFOLDS AND I'LL 389 00:17:03,052 --> 00:17:05,922 EXPLAIN THAT AND WHOLE BODY 390 00:17:05,922 --> 00:17:08,024 MODELS. 391 00:17:08,024 --> 00:17:10,960 A.I. REDUCING MODELS IN THEIR 392 00:17:10,960 --> 00:17:13,062 COMPLEXITY USING PHYSICS 393 00:17:13,062 --> 00:17:14,230 CONSTRAINED A.I. IS CRUCIAL TO 394 00:17:14,230 --> 00:17:15,965 THE SURROGATE MODELS. 395 00:17:15,965 --> 00:17:24,307 WE DO THIS AND OTHER OF COURSE 396 00:17:24,307 --> 00:17:27,610 AND SYSTEMS PHYSIOLOGY PLAYS A 397 00:17:27,610 --> 00:17:30,413 HUGE ROLE IN HOMEOSTASIS AND 398 00:17:30,413 --> 00:17:31,747 BOND GRAPHS HAVE A BIG ROLE IT 399 00:17:31,747 --> 00:17:32,048 PLAY THERE. 400 00:17:32,048 --> 00:17:33,916 THEN I THINK WE NEED TO CONFRONT 401 00:17:33,916 --> 00:17:37,587 THE ISSUE OF A SINGLE KNOWLEDGE 402 00:17:37,587 --> 00:17:42,358 BASE PROBABLY AGENTS AS PROPOSED 403 00:17:42,358 --> 00:17:44,227 BUT IT'S REALLY CRUCIAL THAT 404 00:17:44,227 --> 00:17:49,031 THINGS ARE PROPERLY LABELLED AND 405 00:17:49,031 --> 00:17:53,469 REPRODUCIBLE AND AVAILABLE, 406 00:17:53,469 --> 00:17:53,903 ACCESSIBLE. 407 00:17:53,903 --> 00:17:58,241 ALL THIS IS GOING TO REQUIRE 408 00:17:58,241 --> 00:17:59,642 SUBSTANTIAL INVESTMENT IN NEW 409 00:17:59,642 --> 00:18:01,911 INSTRUMENTATION AND NEW SOFTWARE 410 00:18:01,911 --> 00:18:04,547 ENGINEERING APPROACHES. 411 00:18:04,547 --> 00:18:06,015 YOU ALWAYS START AND NEW SCIENCE 412 00:18:06,015 --> 00:18:07,149 STARTS WITH INSTRUMENTS AND 413 00:18:07,149 --> 00:18:08,851 DEVELOPING A NEW INSTRUMENT AND 414 00:18:08,851 --> 00:18:10,886 YOU NEED THE MODEL TO DEAL WITH 415 00:18:10,886 --> 00:18:12,121 THE COMPLEXITY OF THE DATA 416 00:18:12,121 --> 00:18:13,589 COMING FROM THE EXPERIMENTS BUT 417 00:18:13,589 --> 00:18:15,691 THE STARTING POINT IS OFTEN THE 418 00:18:15,691 --> 00:18:16,659 INSTRUMENTS. 419 00:18:16,659 --> 00:18:19,795 I WANT TO TALK ABOUT BONE 420 00:18:19,795 --> 00:18:21,631 GRAPHS. 421 00:18:21,631 --> 00:18:25,067 AND IT STARTED WITH HANK PAINTER 422 00:18:25,067 --> 00:18:29,605 AT MIT IN THE '50s AND '60s, A 423 00:18:29,605 --> 00:18:31,574 MEMBER OF SEVERAL MIT 424 00:18:31,574 --> 00:18:34,310 DEPARTMENTS AND WANTED TO TALK 425 00:18:34,310 --> 00:18:36,979 HIS COLLEAGUES ACROSS THE 426 00:18:36,979 --> 00:18:37,280 DEPARTMENTS. 427 00:18:37,280 --> 00:18:39,782 YOU LOOK AT ENERGY AND POWER AND 428 00:18:39,782 --> 00:18:41,584 POWER IS CONSERVED. 429 00:18:41,584 --> 00:18:43,753 SO IF YOU HAVE BONDS THE 430 00:18:43,753 --> 00:18:45,254 MECHANISM FOR TRANSMITTING 431 00:18:45,254 --> 00:18:46,989 ENERGY, THE TWO VARIABLES YOU 432 00:18:46,989 --> 00:18:48,524 WANT TO ASSOCIATE WITH THE BOND 433 00:18:48,524 --> 00:18:53,362 ARE THE POTENTIAL, THE VOLTAGE 434 00:18:53,362 --> 00:18:57,633 AND THE FLOW OF SOME SUBSTANCE 435 00:18:57,633 --> 00:19:00,736 THE CURRENT OR COULD BE A 436 00:19:00,736 --> 00:19:01,904 MOVEMENT OR FLUID FLOW IN 437 00:19:01,904 --> 00:19:05,641 MECHANICS OR MOLD FLOW IN A 438 00:19:05,641 --> 00:19:06,809 CHEMICAL CASE. 439 00:19:06,809 --> 00:19:09,478 SO YOU ALWAYS HAVE A DRIVING 440 00:19:09,478 --> 00:19:12,081 FORD AND FLOW I SPOT IN THE RED 441 00:19:12,081 --> 00:19:12,381 COLOR. 442 00:19:12,381 --> 00:19:14,317 FOR THE DISCREET CASE, EACH BOND 443 00:19:14,317 --> 00:19:16,152 WILL CARRY ITS INDEPENDENT 444 00:19:16,152 --> 00:19:19,188 VALUES FOR THOSE QUALITIES. 445 00:19:19,188 --> 00:19:21,991 OFTEN YOU HAVE A COLUMN VOLTAGE 446 00:19:21,991 --> 00:19:23,459 FORCE, CHEMICAL POTENTIAL, 447 00:19:23,459 --> 00:19:24,126 WHATEVER IT IS. 448 00:19:24,126 --> 00:19:25,961 HAVE YOU A COMMON ONE AT THE 449 00:19:25,961 --> 00:19:28,597 CENTER OF THOSE CONNECTING 450 00:19:28,597 --> 00:19:28,864 BONDS. 451 00:19:28,864 --> 00:19:31,834 SO IF YOU TAKE THE U OUT OF THAT 452 00:19:31,834 --> 00:19:37,073 POWER EXPRESSION YOU'RE THEN 453 00:19:37,073 --> 00:19:43,546 GOING TO GET YOU TAKE THE U OUT 454 00:19:43,546 --> 00:19:49,385 SIDE THE SUMMATION OF MASS OR 455 00:19:49,385 --> 00:19:51,287 CONSERVATION OF CHARGE AND IF 456 00:19:51,287 --> 00:19:53,923 YOU HAVE A ONE NODE AND TAKE THE 457 00:19:53,923 --> 00:19:55,958 V OUT THE FRONT AND THEN THAT 458 00:19:55,958 --> 00:19:57,893 REDUCES YOU TO A CONSERVATION OF 459 00:19:57,893 --> 00:19:59,195 ENERGY STATEMENT. 460 00:19:59,195 --> 00:20:00,796 SO IN THE SINGLE POWER 461 00:20:00,796 --> 00:20:02,431 EXPRESSION YOU'VE GOT ALL THE 462 00:20:02,431 --> 00:20:05,935 CONSERVATION LAWS OF PHYSICS 463 00:20:05,935 --> 00:20:07,703 DEPENDING ON THE QUANTITY YOU'RE 464 00:20:07,703 --> 00:20:08,738 DEALING WITH. 465 00:20:08,738 --> 00:20:13,909 SO IF YOU THINK ABOUT THE 466 00:20:13,909 --> 00:20:24,620 QUANTITYIES AND YOU GET MOLS PE 467 00:20:30,860 --> 00:20:31,026 SECOND. 468 00:20:31,026 --> 00:20:32,628 AND WHEN YOU LOOK AT ENERGY 469 00:20:32,628 --> 00:20:34,930 STORAGE ALL THE STORAGE 470 00:20:34,930 --> 00:20:36,632 MECHANISMS ARE ALMOST THE SAME. 471 00:20:36,632 --> 00:20:41,337 YOU EITHER HAVE MECHANICAL 472 00:20:41,337 --> 00:20:46,108 STRING OR CHEMICAL SOLUTE 473 00:20:46,108 --> 00:20:46,876 THEY'RE ALL STORING THE ENERGY 474 00:20:46,876 --> 00:20:49,912 IN A SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT FORM BUT 475 00:20:49,912 --> 00:21:01,056 ESSENTIALLY OBEYI II IING THE 476 00:21:03,726 --> 00:21:05,928 RELATIONSHIP AND HAVE SIMILAR 477 00:21:05,928 --> 00:21:07,363 CHARACTERISTICS EXCEPT FOR 478 00:21:07,363 --> 00:21:08,030 CHEMICAL. 479 00:21:08,030 --> 00:21:08,864 ONE OF THE EXAMPLES AND THE LAST 480 00:21:08,864 --> 00:21:12,601 EXAMPLE TO USE FOR THIS IS A 481 00:21:12,601 --> 00:21:14,970 LOUD SPEAKER SYSTEM. 482 00:21:14,970 --> 00:21:16,672 IF YOU COUPLE A SYSTEM THE BOND 483 00:21:16,672 --> 00:21:18,941 GRAPH IS EXTREMELY SIMPLE. 484 00:21:18,941 --> 00:21:20,709 YOU HAVE A FLOW NODE RESPOND OF 485 00:21:20,709 --> 00:21:23,012 REPRESENTING THE ROLE FOR THE 486 00:21:23,012 --> 00:21:26,549 ELECTRICAL SYSTEM IN THE CASE OF 487 00:21:26,549 --> 00:21:28,050 MECHANICS THE ONE NODE BECOMES 488 00:21:28,050 --> 00:21:31,053 FORCE BALANCE AND THE COUPLING 489 00:21:31,053 --> 00:21:33,155 BETWEEN THEM USES SOMETHING 490 00:21:33,155 --> 00:21:40,095 CALLED A TRANSFORMING FACTOR AND 491 00:21:40,095 --> 00:21:46,869 OUT POP AN YOU GET THE FORCE FOR 492 00:21:46,869 --> 00:21:49,472 THE ACTUATOR. 493 00:21:49,472 --> 00:21:52,775 SO IT'S A BEAUTIFUL WAY OF VERY 494 00:21:52,775 --> 00:21:54,343 SIMPLY CAPTURING ENERGY FLOWS 495 00:21:54,343 --> 00:21:57,079 BETWEEN DIFFERENT MECHANISMS. 496 00:21:57,079 --> 00:21:59,648 AND PHYSIOLOGY IS CHARACTERIZED 497 00:21:59,648 --> 00:22:01,884 BY HAVING ALL MECHANISMS 498 00:22:01,884 --> 00:22:02,418 AVAILABLE TO NATURE. 499 00:22:02,418 --> 00:22:04,053 EVERY PROBLEM YOU LOOK AT. 500 00:22:04,053 --> 00:22:07,156 IF YOU'RE LOOKING AT CARDIAC 501 00:22:07,156 --> 00:22:09,658 MECHANICS OR TISSUE, RATHER, YOU 502 00:22:09,658 --> 00:22:11,494 HAVE ELECTRICAL CURRENT FLOW 503 00:22:11,494 --> 00:22:13,095 BECAUSE IT'S CHARGED AND 504 00:22:13,095 --> 00:22:13,929 ACTIVATION OF THE TISSUE AND YOU 505 00:22:13,929 --> 00:22:17,032 HAVE MECHANICS AND THE ENERGY 506 00:22:17,032 --> 00:22:19,668 CONSUMPTION AND BIO CHEMISTRY, 507 00:22:19,668 --> 00:22:19,935 ETCETERA. 508 00:22:19,935 --> 00:22:24,039 EAT -- HEAT GENERATION. 509 00:22:24,039 --> 00:22:25,641 YOU HAVE ALL THE AREAS OF 510 00:22:25,641 --> 00:22:29,912 PHYSPHYSIC 511 00:22:29,912 --> 00:22:32,214 S ENERGY PRESENT IN EVERY 512 00:22:32,214 --> 00:22:33,883 PHYSIOLOGICAL PROCESS AND NEED 513 00:22:33,883 --> 00:22:35,184 TO THINK OF ENERGY FLOW BETWEEN 514 00:22:35,184 --> 00:22:38,354 THE PROCESSES AND BOND GRAPH IS 515 00:22:38,354 --> 00:22:39,688 AN OBVIOUS AND SIMPLE WAY OF 516 00:22:39,688 --> 00:22:41,056 DOING IT. 517 00:22:41,056 --> 00:22:45,494 IN THE CASE OF THE ENZYME 518 00:22:45,494 --> 00:22:46,829 CATALITE 3 ACTION THERE'S A 519 00:22:46,829 --> 00:22:48,797 SLIGHT CHANGE IN THE REACTION A 520 00:22:48,797 --> 00:22:50,232 2 NODE ELEMENT BECAUSE THEY 521 00:22:50,232 --> 00:22:51,667 DEPEND SEPARATELY ON THE 522 00:22:51,667 --> 00:22:53,035 CHEMICAL POTENTIALS AT EACH END 523 00:22:53,035 --> 00:22:55,137 OF THAT REACTION BUT YOU CAN 524 00:22:55,137 --> 00:22:58,641 EASILY SHOW WITH THE ASSUMPTIONS 525 00:22:58,641 --> 00:23:04,013 IMPLICIT THIS DROPS DOWN TO 526 00:23:04,013 --> 00:23:07,716 MECHANO AND THE PROPER WAY OF 527 00:23:07,716 --> 00:23:09,919 FORMULATING THE CATALYZE 528 00:23:09,919 --> 00:23:12,288 MECHANISM IS WITH BOND GRAPHS IN 529 00:23:12,288 --> 00:23:13,188 APPROXIMATION. 530 00:23:13,188 --> 00:23:14,924 IF YOU GO TO THE CONTINUUM 531 00:23:14,924 --> 00:23:16,926 PROBLEM THE SAME THING HAPPENS 532 00:23:16,926 --> 00:23:20,863 BUT NOW WITH WHAT A CALL PORT 533 00:23:20,863 --> 00:23:23,299 HAMILTONIANS AND IT'S THE ZERO 534 00:23:23,299 --> 00:23:25,367 VERSION OF THIS AND YOU NEED ONE 535 00:23:25,367 --> 00:23:29,171 OTHER CONCEPT WHEN YOU GO TO THE 536 00:23:29,171 --> 00:23:32,508 CONTINUUM CASE THE SKEWED MATRIX 537 00:23:32,508 --> 00:23:34,410 AND YOU GET BEAUTIFUL 538 00:23:34,410 --> 00:23:35,311 RELATIONSHIPS POPPING UP THAT 539 00:23:35,311 --> 00:23:37,913 ALLOW YOU TO DEAL WITH THE WHOLE 540 00:23:37,913 --> 00:23:38,981 WORLD OF CONTINUUM MECHANICS 541 00:23:38,981 --> 00:23:43,085 DIVIDED INTO THE THREE AREAS OF 542 00:23:43,085 --> 00:23:48,324 MECHANICS FLOW AND ENTROPY AND 543 00:23:48,324 --> 00:23:49,825 MOLES FOR HEAT FLOW REACTION 544 00:23:49,825 --> 00:23:52,761 DIFFUSION OR ELECTROMAGNETICS 545 00:23:52,761 --> 00:24:03,172 WITH A SMALL NUMBER OF 546 00:24:12,548 --> 00:24:15,417 CONSTITUTIVE WORLD AND THERE WAS 547 00:24:15,417 --> 00:24:17,920 WORK DONE THAT SHOWS A COUPLE 548 00:24:17,920 --> 00:24:20,022 PORT HAMILTONIANS AND BOND GRAPH 549 00:24:20,022 --> 00:24:29,898 MODELS. 550 00:24:29,898 --> 00:24:31,433 AND WE HAVE WORKED ON THE BOND 551 00:24:31,433 --> 00:24:32,601 GRAPH TO MAKE SURE THEY WERE 552 00:24:32,601 --> 00:24:35,204 SATISFIED AND WE LOOKED AT THE 553 00:24:35,204 --> 00:24:40,909 GLUCOSE TRANSPORTERS, PH 554 00:24:40,909 --> 00:24:49,418 CONTROL, RENAL TUBULE RECEPTORS 555 00:24:49,418 --> 00:24:52,154 AND TRANSPORTERS AND IT'S FAIRLY 556 00:24:52,154 --> 00:24:52,788 STRAIGHTFORWARD TO GO THROUGH 557 00:24:52,788 --> 00:24:57,026 THE MODELS AN POP THEM IN A FORM 558 00:24:57,026 --> 00:24:57,993 WHERE YOU'RE GUARANTEED TO 559 00:24:57,993 --> 00:25:00,663 SATISFY THE LAWS OF PHYSICS. 560 00:25:00,663 --> 00:25:05,501 I WANT TO ILLUSTRATE THIS AND 561 00:25:05,501 --> 00:25:06,535 WE'RE WORKING WITH THE WESTERN 562 00:25:06,535 --> 00:25:11,874 GROUP ON TRANSPORTERS OF ABOUT 563 00:25:11,874 --> 00:25:14,076 158 GENES IN 65 FAMILIES AND 564 00:25:14,076 --> 00:25:16,745 THEY DEPEND ON 30 OR 40 565 00:25:16,745 --> 00:25:17,212 TRANSPORTER MECHANISM. 566 00:25:17,212 --> 00:25:21,917 WE CAN CHARACTERIZE ALL THE 567 00:25:21,917 --> 00:25:23,919 MECHANISMS IN BOND GRAPHS AND WE 568 00:25:23,919 --> 00:25:26,622 CAN APPLY WITH THE APPROPRIATE 569 00:25:26,622 --> 00:25:28,457 LIGAND TO THE TRANSPORTER 570 00:25:28,457 --> 00:25:28,691 FAMILY. 571 00:25:28,691 --> 00:25:30,192 WHAT WE'RE DOING IS MODELLING 572 00:25:30,192 --> 00:25:35,064 THE BOND GRAPH IN THIS CASE FOR 573 00:25:35,064 --> 00:25:39,401 THE SCLA21 TRANSPORTER AND 574 00:25:39,401 --> 00:25:40,469 GETTING THE REDUCED MODEL AND 575 00:25:40,469 --> 00:25:42,137 PLUGGING IT IN TO THE CELL MODEL 576 00:25:42,137 --> 00:25:47,176 I'LL TALK ABOUT IN A SECOND BUT 577 00:25:47,176 --> 00:25:51,647 ALSO DEALING WITH CITY STATE 578 00:25:51,647 --> 00:26:00,456 FLUX CONDITIONS AND CAN FIND THE 579 00:26:00,456 --> 00:26:03,659 STEADY STATE AND PLUG IT IN THE 580 00:26:03,659 --> 00:26:04,727 TRANSPORTSER AND IF WE CAN 581 00:26:04,727 --> 00:26:07,996 CREATE THE TRANSPORTER PROTEINS 582 00:26:07,996 --> 00:26:10,199 AND NOW THANKS TO ALPHA WE HAVE 583 00:26:10,199 --> 00:26:12,101 THREE WHY DON'T WE DOWNLOAD THE 584 00:26:12,101 --> 00:26:13,969 3-D STRUCTURE OF THE PROTEINS 585 00:26:13,969 --> 00:26:16,638 AND DO MOLECULAR MODELLING TO 586 00:26:16,638 --> 00:26:18,407 FIND STEADY STATE CONDITIONS AND 587 00:26:18,407 --> 00:26:20,609 THIS IS USING A TECHNIQUE CALLED 588 00:26:20,609 --> 00:26:22,678 UMBRELLA SAMPLING AND THIS IS ON 589 00:26:22,678 --> 00:26:25,547 THE RIGHT HAS BEEN DONE BY ONE 590 00:26:25,547 --> 00:26:30,919 OF MY POSTDOCS AND SHOWS THE 591 00:26:30,919 --> 00:26:32,855 GLUCOSE MOLECULE IN VARIOUS 592 00:26:32,855 --> 00:26:34,890 STAGES AND THEY'RE JIGGLING 593 00:26:34,890 --> 00:26:37,926 AROUND AND TAKING SHOTS AS IT 594 00:26:37,926 --> 00:26:41,897 MOVES THROUGH THE CHANNEL. 595 00:26:41,897 --> 00:26:44,466 AND CAN WE IN FACT USE MOLECULAR 596 00:26:44,466 --> 00:26:45,901 MODELLING TO DEFINE THE 597 00:26:45,901 --> 00:26:47,069 PARAMETERS UNDER THE STEADY 598 00:26:47,069 --> 00:26:52,374 STATE CONDITIONS SO WE DON'T 599 00:26:52,374 --> 00:26:56,879 HAVE TO DO ALL THE AS MUCH 600 00:26:56,879 --> 00:26:57,980 EXPERIMENTAL ON THE PROTEINS AND 601 00:26:57,980 --> 00:27:00,983 IF YOU CAN DO THAT YOU HAVE THE 602 00:27:00,983 --> 00:27:04,353 GENETICS OF THAT'S BEEN USED TO 603 00:27:04,353 --> 00:27:06,021 PREDICT THE FOLD IN THE ALPHA 604 00:27:06,021 --> 00:27:08,023 FOLD PROCESS. 605 00:27:08,023 --> 00:27:13,362 SO HERE'S THE PLAN FOR THAT 606 00:27:13,362 --> 00:27:15,831 NIDDK PROJECT WITH CASE WESTERN 607 00:27:15,831 --> 00:27:18,000 AND UCSD AND WE WOULD LIKE TO 608 00:27:18,000 --> 00:27:23,305 SEE IF WE CONDITAN BRING IN SAM 609 00:27:23,305 --> 00:27:25,240 METHODS TO PREDICT THE BONE 610 00:27:25,240 --> 00:27:27,509 GRAPH MODELS FROM GOING BACK TO 611 00:27:27,509 --> 00:27:27,976 GENE SEQUENCE. 612 00:27:27,976 --> 00:27:29,378 WHETHER THAT WILL BE POSSIBLE 613 00:27:29,378 --> 00:27:30,112 I'M NOT SURE BUT IT'S WORTH A 614 00:27:30,112 --> 00:27:31,780 TRY. 615 00:27:31,780 --> 00:27:33,982 SO THEN I WANT TO MOVE TO WHOLE 616 00:27:33,982 --> 00:27:35,250 CELL MODELLING. 617 00:27:35,250 --> 00:27:36,752 ONCE HAVE YOU ALL THESE BOND 618 00:27:36,752 --> 00:27:39,888 GRAPHS FOR ALL THE PROCESSES 619 00:27:39,888 --> 00:27:43,258 THAT GARNER THE CELL WHY WOULD 620 00:27:43,258 --> 00:27:48,030 YOU COUPLE THEM SEMANTICALLY AND 621 00:27:48,030 --> 00:27:50,866 INTO A WHOLE CELL MODEL THAT 622 00:27:50,866 --> 00:27:52,601 APPLIES TO ANY CELL, ANY TISSUE 623 00:27:52,601 --> 00:27:54,703 TYPE AND YOU PULL OUT WHAT YOU 624 00:27:54,703 --> 00:27:57,506 NEED FOR THAT PARTICULAR TISSUE 625 00:27:57,506 --> 00:27:59,741 CELL TYPE BASED ON SEMANTICS. 626 00:27:59,741 --> 00:28:00,676 THAT'S WHAT WE'RE NOW TRYING TO 627 00:28:00,676 --> 00:28:06,114 DO AND USING THE IDEA THAT THE 628 00:28:06,114 --> 00:28:07,649 BOND GRAPH FRAMEWORK GIVES A 629 00:28:07,649 --> 00:28:13,021 NICE WAY OF CHARACTERIZING THE 630 00:28:13,021 --> 00:28:17,893 VARIOUS EQUATIONS THAT DEAL WITH 631 00:28:17,893 --> 00:28:28,437 THE MOBILE SUBSTANCES SOLUTE AS 632 00:28:31,673 --> 00:28:33,609 YOU BUILD THE WHOLE CELL MODEL 633 00:28:33,609 --> 00:28:34,776 YOU WANT. 634 00:28:34,776 --> 00:28:36,678 THE BOND GRAPH LENDS ITSELF WELL 635 00:28:36,678 --> 00:28:38,814 TO AUTOMATE THE PROCESS OF 636 00:28:38,814 --> 00:28:41,917 CONSTRUCTING WHATEVER MODEL YOU 637 00:28:41,917 --> 00:28:44,219 NEED FOR A PARTICULAR WHOLE SELL 638 00:28:44,219 --> 00:28:46,922 MODEL AND SOLVING THOSE BUT IT 639 00:28:46,922 --> 00:28:48,523 NEEDS TO BE LINKED WITH REACTOME 640 00:28:48,523 --> 00:28:50,592 TO MAKE SURE THERE'S A GOOD 641 00:28:50,592 --> 00:28:51,693 CONNECTION WITH THE BIOLOGICAL 642 00:28:51,693 --> 00:28:53,896 WORLD OF WHAT'S GOING ON IN 643 00:28:53,896 --> 00:29:03,138 THOSE CELLS. 644 00:29:03,138 --> 00:29:05,908 WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE BIGGER 645 00:29:05,908 --> 00:29:07,542 ORGAN CELLS AND THE FUNCTIONAL 646 00:29:07,542 --> 00:29:07,910 TISSUE UNIT. 647 00:29:07,910 --> 00:29:10,913 WE WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE BOND 648 00:29:10,913 --> 00:29:13,181 GRAPH CELL MODELS AND KNOW WE 649 00:29:13,181 --> 00:29:15,584 CAN DO MODELLING OF ORGANS FOR 650 00:29:15,584 --> 00:29:17,953 THEIR PHYSICS FOR A WHOLE ORGAN 651 00:29:17,953 --> 00:29:19,922 BUT WE NEED TO BE FOCUSSED, I 652 00:29:19,922 --> 00:29:23,292 THINK, ON WHAT IS REALLY THE 653 00:29:23,292 --> 00:29:24,927 HARDEST PROBLEM AND THAT IS THE 654 00:29:24,927 --> 00:29:27,396 DEFINITION OF THE FUNCTIONAL 655 00:29:27,396 --> 00:29:29,431 TISSUE UNITS THAT CHARACTERIZE 656 00:29:29,431 --> 00:29:32,501 PHYSIOLOGY WHERE IT EMERGES FROM 657 00:29:32,501 --> 00:29:36,672 CELL BIOLOGY AT THE SUB 658 00:29:36,672 --> 00:29:38,740 MILLIMETER SCALE. 659 00:29:38,740 --> 00:29:41,910 OSTEOIN THE BONE AND IN THE 660 00:29:41,910 --> 00:29:44,046 KID 661 00:29:44,046 --> 00:29:49,918 KIDDY NEPHRONETS AND WE NEED A 662 00:29:49,918 --> 00:29:51,420 METHOD TO DEAL WITH THE CELL 663 00:29:51,420 --> 00:29:54,523 TYPES THAT EXIST IN THE 664 00:29:54,523 --> 00:29:58,493 STRUCTURES BECAUSE THE ORGAN IS 665 00:29:58,493 --> 00:30:00,495 SCALING UP IF YOU'RE A KIDNEY IN 666 00:30:00,495 --> 00:30:11,039 A MOUSE YOU HAVE 100,000 NEPHRON 667 00:30:11,707 --> 00:30:14,409 AND WE HAVE TO HAVE THEM WELL 668 00:30:14,409 --> 00:30:17,913 DEFINED AND LINKED TO CELLULAR, 669 00:30:17,913 --> 00:30:20,215 MOLECULAR BIOLOGY AND CAN SCALE 670 00:30:20,215 --> 00:30:23,585 THEM UP UNDER WELL UNDERSTAND 671 00:30:23,585 --> 00:30:25,153 TECHNIQUES TO PUT IN THE CONTEXT 672 00:30:25,153 --> 00:30:27,022 OF WHOLE ORGANS AND TO THE WHOLE 673 00:30:27,022 --> 00:30:27,289 BODY. 674 00:30:27,289 --> 00:30:29,958 SO ONE OF THE PROJECTS I'M 675 00:30:29,958 --> 00:30:33,261 INVOLVED WITH IS THE NIH SPARK 676 00:30:33,261 --> 00:30:39,067 PROJECT A COMMON FUND PROJECT 677 00:30:39,067 --> 00:30:49,644 AND A GROUP AT UCSD AND PENN AND 678 00:30:51,446 --> 00:30:53,148 A GROUP IN SWITZERLAND AND US 679 00:30:53,148 --> 00:30:54,649 DOING THE MAPPING WORK. 680 00:30:54,649 --> 00:30:56,485 IT'S BEEN AN EFFECTIVE WAY OF 681 00:30:56,485 --> 00:31:00,355 BRINGING THE GROUPS TOGETHER TO 682 00:31:00,355 --> 00:31:08,063 FOCUS ON THE AUTONOMIC NERVOUS 683 00:31:08,063 --> 00:31:10,499 SYSTEM AND WE LOOKED AT THE 684 00:31:10,499 --> 00:31:11,433 ORGANS FOR A VARIETY OF SPECIES 685 00:31:11,433 --> 00:31:14,469 DEALING WITH THE DETAILED 686 00:31:14,469 --> 00:31:17,472 ANATOMY OF THE NEURAL PATHS AND 687 00:31:17,472 --> 00:31:19,408 DEALING WITH THE PROCESS OF 688 00:31:19,408 --> 00:31:22,677 PUTTING THOSE NEURONS WHERE WE 689 00:31:22,677 --> 00:31:25,914 HAVE DATA ON THE NEURONS IN 690 00:31:25,914 --> 00:31:27,649 TISSUE SUCH AS CARDIAC ONE SHOWN 691 00:31:27,649 --> 00:31:27,849 HERE. 692 00:31:27,849 --> 00:31:36,491 WE CAN EMBED THEM TO 3-D 693 00:31:36,491 --> 00:31:36,992 ENVIRONMENTS. 694 00:31:36,992 --> 00:31:39,194 PART OF WHAT WE NEEDED TO DO IS 695 00:31:39,194 --> 00:31:40,629 CREATE A FUNCTIONAL CONNECTIVITY 696 00:31:40,629 --> 00:31:42,330 MAP WHERE WE ALLOW THE ORGAN 697 00:31:42,330 --> 00:31:44,466 SYSTEMS OF THE BODY, ALL 12 698 00:31:44,466 --> 00:31:46,435 ORGAN SYSTEMS, WE DEFINED ALL 699 00:31:46,435 --> 00:31:48,537 THE ORGANS WITHIN THE ORGAN 700 00:31:48,537 --> 00:31:50,305 SYSTEMS AND DEFINE THOSE FTUs 701 00:31:50,305 --> 00:31:52,374 THAT ARE RELEVANT FOR THAT ORGAN 702 00:31:52,374 --> 00:31:57,079 AND DEFINE ALL OF THEM IN A 703 00:31:57,079 --> 00:31:58,213 SINGLE ZOOMABLE STREET MAPS TYPE 704 00:31:58,213 --> 00:32:02,117 ENVIRONMENT TO LAY ON THE SEM 705 00:32:02,117 --> 00:32:02,551 ANTAN 706 00:32:02,851 --> 00:32:09,091 ANTIC -- SEMANTICS AND LAY THE 707 00:32:09,091 --> 00:32:12,027 OTHER SYSTEMS LIKE LYMPHATIC AND 708 00:32:12,027 --> 00:32:13,328 SOMATIC MUSCLE CONTROL BUT HAVE 709 00:32:13,328 --> 00:32:14,429 ONE ENVIRONMENT THAT JUST 710 00:32:14,429 --> 00:32:17,899 DEFINES ALL THE SEMANTICS AND 711 00:32:17,899 --> 00:32:19,434 CONNECTIVITY THAT CAN BE LINKED 712 00:32:19,434 --> 00:32:23,872 OUT TO DATABASES AND USED FOR 713 00:32:23,872 --> 00:32:24,506 THEN AUTOMATICALLY RENDERING TO 714 00:32:24,506 --> 00:32:27,242 DIFFERENT ENVIRONMENTS. 715 00:32:27,242 --> 00:32:28,810 AND SO HERE'S THE OTHER PART OF 716 00:32:28,810 --> 00:32:31,680 THIS IS THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE 717 00:32:31,680 --> 00:32:33,381 3-D SCAFFOLDS FOR EMBEDDING 718 00:32:33,381 --> 00:32:37,018 NEURONS TO ORGANS. 719 00:32:37,018 --> 00:32:40,055 WE DEVELOPED HIGH SCAFFOLDS OF 720 00:32:40,055 --> 00:32:42,858 HEART, LUNGS, OTHER ORGANS. 721 00:32:42,858 --> 00:32:44,893 OFTEN THEY'RE BUILT ON SUB 722 00:32:44,893 --> 00:32:47,562 STRUCTURES AND THERE'S A COLON 723 00:32:47,562 --> 00:32:49,131 STRUCTURE THAT WORKS ACROSS 724 00:32:49,131 --> 00:32:51,299 SPECIES AND YOU DEFINE THE 725 00:32:51,299 --> 00:32:53,902 CENTER LINE OF THE SPECIES AND 726 00:32:53,902 --> 00:32:56,972 YOU THEN RECONSTRUCT THE FULL 727 00:32:56,972 --> 00:33:03,879 SCAFFOLD FOR A GIVEN SPECIES 728 00:33:03,879 --> 00:33:06,948 WITH COMMON UNDERLYING SCAFFOLDS 729 00:33:06,948 --> 00:33:09,217 AND HAVE WORKED WITHOTHERS TO 730 00:33:09,217 --> 00:33:10,218 REGISTER THE DATA FOR MULTIPLE 731 00:33:10,218 --> 00:33:11,953 SPECIES INTO A SINGLE 732 00:33:11,953 --> 00:33:14,823 ENVIRONMENT FOR VARIOUS ORGANS. 733 00:33:14,823 --> 00:33:17,859 AND LOOKING AT THE SAME THING 734 00:33:17,859 --> 00:33:23,865 FOR THE WHOLE BODY. 735 00:33:23,865 --> 00:33:25,300 I'VE BEEN ABLE TO DEFINE 736 00:33:25,300 --> 00:33:27,569 SCAFFOLDS FOR THE ORGANS OF THE 737 00:33:27,569 --> 00:33:30,739 BODY AND BY HAVING A 3-D 738 00:33:30,739 --> 00:33:32,474 COORDINATE SYSTEM BEING ABLE TO 739 00:33:32,474 --> 00:33:34,843 POSITION THE SCAFFOLDS 740 00:33:34,843 --> 00:33:37,746 AUTOMATICALLY IN THE APPROPRIATE 741 00:33:37,746 --> 00:33:43,952 PART OF THE BODY ALGORITHMICALLY 742 00:33:43,952 --> 00:33:44,819 TIED TO THE COORDINATES. 743 00:33:44,819 --> 00:33:47,756 IT'S GOT A LONG WAY TO GO BUT 744 00:33:47,756 --> 00:33:50,392 IT'S STARTING TO GET QUITE A BIT 745 00:33:50,392 --> 00:33:54,329 OF THE ANATOMY OF THE BODY. 746 00:33:54,329 --> 00:34:00,735 AND THEN WE CAN USE THE FC MAPS 747 00:34:00,735 --> 00:34:05,373 FOR EXAMPLE FOR LAYING OUT THE 748 00:34:05,373 --> 00:34:06,775 VASCULATURE AND WE CAN CREATE 749 00:34:06,775 --> 00:34:08,977 THE BONE GRAPH MODELS FOR 750 00:34:08,977 --> 00:34:12,013 SOLVING THE FLUID EQUATIONS FOR 751 00:34:12,013 --> 00:34:13,848 THE CIRCULATION. 752 00:34:13,848 --> 00:34:16,284 THEN BE ABLE TO VISUALIZE 753 00:34:16,284 --> 00:34:17,586 PRESSURES AND FLOWS IN ANY 754 00:34:17,586 --> 00:34:18,119 POSITION. 755 00:34:18,119 --> 00:34:19,921 THESE ARE REAL-TIME MODELS. 756 00:34:19,921 --> 00:34:22,490 THEY'RE NOT AS ACCURATE AS A 757 00:34:22,490 --> 00:34:23,725 FULL 3-D SOLUTION BUT THEY GET 758 00:34:23,725 --> 00:34:28,129 PRETTY CLOSE FROM A PRACTICAL 759 00:34:28,129 --> 00:34:28,763 CLINICAL POINT OF VIEW THEY'RE 760 00:34:28,763 --> 00:34:30,198 GIVING US GOOD COMPARISONS FOR 761 00:34:30,198 --> 00:34:35,170 3-D ANALYSES. 762 00:34:35,170 --> 00:34:37,038 I WANT TO INDICATE WHERE I THINK 763 00:34:37,038 --> 00:34:38,039 THIS IS HITTING. 764 00:34:38,039 --> 00:34:40,775 IN A SENSE IT'S THE PHYSIOME 765 00:34:40,775 --> 00:34:43,278 MORPHING INTO A VIRTUAL DIGITAL 766 00:34:43,278 --> 00:34:47,215 TWIN OR VIRTUAL DIGITAL HUMAN 767 00:34:47,215 --> 00:34:50,252 TWIN YOU WANT A WHOLE BODY MODEL 768 00:34:50,252 --> 00:34:53,922 AND WANT IT TO BE PHYSICS BASED 769 00:34:53,922 --> 00:34:57,492 AND NEED MECHANISM IN THERE BUT 770 00:34:57,492 --> 00:34:58,860 A.I. IS CRUCIAL OFTEN FOR 771 00:34:58,860 --> 00:35:01,863 SURROGATE MODELS BUT IT MEANS 772 00:35:01,863 --> 00:35:04,399 AND YOU FOR THE VIRTUAL HUMAN 773 00:35:04,399 --> 00:35:05,667 TWIN YOU'RE TRYING TO 774 00:35:05,667 --> 00:35:07,569 PERSONALIZE IT AND WANT THE 775 00:35:07,569 --> 00:35:09,604 WHOLE BODY MODEL TO BE FILLED 776 00:35:09,604 --> 00:35:12,440 WITH PARAMETERS FROM A GIVEN 777 00:35:12,440 --> 00:35:14,009 INDIVIDUAL AS WELL AS BUILDING 778 00:35:14,009 --> 00:35:17,445 UP POPULATIONS OF VIRTUAL 779 00:35:17,445 --> 00:35:17,779 MODELS. 780 00:35:17,779 --> 00:35:19,681 THE FRAMEWORK WE'RE TRYING TO 781 00:35:19,681 --> 00:35:22,050 DEVELOP AND IT NEEDS A MAJOR 782 00:35:22,050 --> 00:35:25,920 INTERNATIONAL EFFORT AROUND 783 00:35:25,920 --> 00:35:26,288 THOSE. 784 00:35:26,288 --> 00:35:30,492 BUT IT'S TO SAY YOU USE ENERGY 785 00:35:30,492 --> 00:35:31,926 PRESERVING METHODS ALL THE WAY 786 00:35:31,926 --> 00:35:35,363 THROUGH AND BOND GRAPHS AT THE 787 00:35:35,363 --> 00:35:36,197 BOTTOM, DEVELOP GENERAL 788 00:35:36,197 --> 00:35:37,165 WHOLESALE MODELS THAT EXPLOIT 789 00:35:37,165 --> 00:35:38,933 THAT AND THE ABILITY TO CREATE 790 00:35:38,933 --> 00:35:40,502 THESE AND THE HARDEST PROBLEM OF 791 00:35:40,502 --> 00:35:46,975 ALL IS THE FTUs TO FIND WHERE 792 00:35:46,975 --> 00:35:49,511 MOLECULAR CELL BIOLOGY REDUCE TO 793 00:35:49,511 --> 00:35:50,578 CELL BIOLOGY AND THE TECHNIQUES 794 00:35:50,578 --> 00:35:56,017 IS OFTEN ASSOCIATED WITH A 795 00:35:56,017 --> 00:35:57,285 CONSTITUTIVE MODEL AND THEN WHAT 796 00:35:57,285 --> 00:35:59,421 YOU'RE DOING IS BRINGING DATA IN 797 00:35:59,421 --> 00:36:03,191 AT DIFFERENT LEVELS FROM A 798 00:36:03,191 --> 00:36:03,858 MEDICAL PERSPECTIVE YOU'RE ABLE 799 00:36:03,858 --> 00:36:07,362 TO BRING GENETIC CELL BIOMARKERS 800 00:36:07,362 --> 00:36:09,898 AND BIOMARKERS, FOR EXAMPLE. 801 00:36:09,898 --> 00:36:11,733 IT'S NOT UNREASONABLE TO ASSUME 802 00:36:11,733 --> 00:36:13,535 WE'LL HAVE ALL THE BLOOD 803 00:36:13,535 --> 00:36:15,303 COMPONENTS BEFORE TOO LONG. 804 00:36:15,303 --> 00:36:17,672 THERE'S ALL SORTS OF TECHNIQUES 805 00:36:17,672 --> 00:36:20,709 BEING DEVELOPED TO BE ABLE TO 806 00:36:20,709 --> 00:36:23,812 SAMPLE BLOOD AND GIVE A MORE 807 00:36:23,812 --> 00:36:25,480 REALISTIC PICTURE OF WHAT'S 808 00:36:25,480 --> 00:36:26,648 GOING ON IN A CLINICAL SETTING 809 00:36:26,648 --> 00:36:28,650 AND WE NEED TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF 810 00:36:28,650 --> 00:36:31,886 THE HIGH-SCALE DATA AND USE 811 00:36:31,886 --> 00:36:33,888 MODELS THAT PROPERLY 812 00:36:33,888 --> 00:36:34,956 PARAMETERIZE FOR AN INDIVIDUAL 813 00:36:34,956 --> 00:36:37,525 THE DATA THAT'S GOING TO BE 814 00:36:37,525 --> 00:36:38,660 AVAILABLE FOR INDIVIDUALS. 815 00:36:38,660 --> 00:36:41,696 BUT WITHIN A FRAMEWORK WHERE YOU 816 00:36:41,696 --> 00:36:43,898 CAN REALLY HAVE CONFIDENCE THAT 817 00:36:43,898 --> 00:36:46,634 YOU'RE CORRECTLY SOLVING THE 818 00:36:46,634 --> 00:36:47,502 PHYSICS RIGHT UP THROUGH THESE 819 00:36:47,502 --> 00:36:49,704 SCALES INCLUDING UP TO THE LEVEL 820 00:36:49,704 --> 00:36:53,141 OF INTERPRETING CLINICAL IMAGES 821 00:36:53,141 --> 00:36:57,145 OF THE SCALE AND ALSO 822 00:36:57,145 --> 00:36:57,946 PHYSIOLOGICAL FUNCTION TESTS YOU 823 00:36:57,946 --> 00:37:00,148 WANT TO DO AS WELL AND ALL THIS 824 00:37:00,148 --> 00:37:01,516 HAS TO PLUG INTO CLINICAL WORK 825 00:37:01,516 --> 00:37:03,518 FLOWS OF COURSE. 826 00:37:03,518 --> 00:37:05,520 THERE'S A COLLABORATION GOING ON 827 00:37:05,520 --> 00:37:07,088 TO FIND WHAT THE CLINICAL WORK 828 00:37:07,088 --> 00:37:09,924 FLOWS WOULD LOOK LIKE IF YOU'RE 829 00:37:09,924 --> 00:37:12,494 BRAIN MODELS INTO THAT CLINICAL 830 00:37:12,494 --> 00:37:14,529 DECISION MAKING AND THERAPEUTIC 831 00:37:14,529 --> 00:37:14,796 FRAMEWORK. 832 00:37:14,796 --> 00:37:15,997 SO THE WORK I'VE TALKED ABOUT I 833 00:37:15,997 --> 00:37:17,899 WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE LOTS OF 834 00:37:17,899 --> 00:37:21,870 PEOPLE AT ABI IN AUCKLAND AND 835 00:37:21,870 --> 00:37:24,038 THE PEOPLE SHOWN HERE AND DAVID 836 00:37:24,038 --> 00:37:26,341 NICKERSON WHO IS ALWAYS A KEY 837 00:37:26,341 --> 00:37:29,544 PERSON FOR TYING A LOT OF THIS 838 00:37:29,544 --> 00:37:31,713 TOGETHER AND THANKS TO FUNDING 839 00:37:31,713 --> 00:37:37,919 THE NEW ZEALAND GOVERNMENT HAS 840 00:37:37,919 --> 00:37:44,359 THE 12 LABORS PROJECT AND THE 841 00:37:44,359 --> 00:37:49,864 SPARC PROJECT THAT FUNDS US IN 842 00:37:49,864 --> 00:37:52,867 AUCKLAND. 843 00:37:52,867 --> 00:37:54,669 AND THE NIDDK FAIR DOs PROJECT. 844 00:37:54,669 --> 00:38:04,846 THANK YOU. 845 00:38:08,183 --> 00:38:09,918 >> WELL, THANK YOU, PETER FOR 846 00:38:09,918 --> 00:38:13,154 THE VERY THOUGHT PROVOKING WAY 847 00:38:13,154 --> 00:38:14,823 TO START OUR SECOND DAY. 848 00:38:14,823 --> 00:38:17,425 AGAIN, TODAY'S FOCUSSED ON THE 849 00:38:17,425 --> 00:38:18,893 FUTURE I THINK THAT WAS A GREAT 850 00:38:18,893 --> 00:38:21,596 TALK TO GET US STARTED. 851 00:38:21,596 --> 00:38:23,698 SO FOR THE NEXT SESSION, WHICH 852 00:38:23,698 --> 00:38:26,868 IS THE IMAG ROUNDTABLE WE WOULD 853 00:38:26,868 --> 00:38:29,103 LIKE EVERYONE WHO WILL BE 854 00:38:29,103 --> 00:38:30,872 PARTICIPATING TO COME ON UP AND 855 00:38:30,872 --> 00:38:40,915 WHAT WE'LL HAVE IS EACH OF YOU 856 00:38:40,915 --> 00:38:44,819 WILL HAVE ABOUT A MINUTE TO TALK 857 00:38:44,819 --> 00:38:46,154 ABOUT YOUR INITIATIVE AND WE'LL 858 00:38:46,154 --> 00:38:47,922 FLASH YOUR SLIDE SO COME FORWARD 859 00:38:47,922 --> 00:38:48,857 AND WE HAVE FOLKS JOINING 860 00:38:48,857 --> 00:38:57,131 REMOTELY AS WELL. 861 00:38:57,131 --> 00:38:59,033 FOR EVERYONE ELSE, PLEASE CHECK 862 00:38:59,033 --> 00:39:03,438 THE WIKI, WILL -- WHICH WILL 863 00:39:03,438 --> 00:39:06,474 HAVE DETAILS ON EACH OF THESE 864 00:39:06,474 --> 00:39:06,774 INITIATIVES. 865 00:39:06,774 --> 00:39:08,676 WE'LL HAVE EACH PERSON BRIEFLY 866 00:39:08,676 --> 00:39:09,244 PRESENT THE INITIATIVE. 867 00:39:09,244 --> 00:39:14,082 THE GOAL AGAIN IS NOT TO BE 868 00:39:14,082 --> 00:39:15,016 EXHAUSTIVE BUT JUST TO INTRODUCE 869 00:39:15,016 --> 00:39:17,719 YOU TO THE INITIATIVES AND THEN 870 00:39:17,719 --> 00:39:18,186 WE'LL HAVE ROUNDTABLE 871 00:39:18,186 --> 00:39:28,396 DISCUSSION. 872 00:39:48,616 --> 00:39:48,950 FIRST WENDY. 873 00:39:48,950 --> 00:39:59,494 >> CAN EVERYBODY SEE THE ORDER? 874 00:40:09,837 --> 00:40:14,008 WE'RE GOING TO LIMIT EACH PERSON 875 00:40:14,008 --> 00:40:17,045 TO A MINUTE SO WE'LL RING THE 876 00:40:17,045 --> 00:40:18,379 BELL. 877 00:40:18,379 --> 00:40:25,053 >> I'LL STAY HERE AND MAURICIO 878 00:40:25,053 --> 00:40:35,597 IS NEXT AND EMILY IS ON REMOTE. 879 00:40:40,768 --> 00:40:45,540 >> I'LL MENTION THE MPH AND THEN 880 00:40:45,540 --> 00:40:46,741 WE'LL HAVE STEPHANIE AFTER THAT 881 00:40:46,741 --> 00:40:49,944 AND THEN WE HAVE SOFTWARE DRIVEN 882 00:40:49,944 --> 00:40:50,945 INITIATIVES, WE'VE GOT JOSH 883 00:40:50,945 --> 00:40:53,915 GOING TO BE REMOTE AND EMILY 884 00:40:53,915 --> 00:40:56,017 REMOTE AND STEPHANIE. 885 00:40:56,017 --> 00:40:59,954 WE HAVE LAY NA. 886 00:40:59,954 --> 00:41:05,026 AFTER THAT, DAVE AND 887 00:41:05,026 --> 00:41:05,693 EXPERIMENTAL-DRIVEN INITIATIVES 888 00:41:05,693 --> 00:41:06,928 WILL BE REED AND THEN DAVE. 889 00:41:06,928 --> 00:41:17,305 DO WE HAVE THE ORDER? 890 00:41:17,672 --> 00:41:20,208 >> REED IS IN THE BACK ROOM SO 891 00:41:20,208 --> 00:41:23,544 WE WON'T SEE HIS FACE BUT YOU 892 00:41:23,544 --> 00:41:25,913 CAN SHARE YOUR COMPUTER AND WE 893 00:41:25,913 --> 00:41:36,290 CAN SEE YOU ON SCREEN. 894 00:41:36,491 --> 00:41:38,993 THE DECK IS ON THE WIKI AND YOU 895 00:41:38,993 --> 00:41:40,461 CAN PULL UP THE DECK EVERYONE'S 896 00:41:40,461 --> 00:41:43,731 PRESENTING FROM AND ALL THE 897 00:41:43,731 --> 00:41:44,666 EXTRA INFORMATION IS THERE AS 898 00:41:44,666 --> 00:41:45,900 BRUCE SAID. 899 00:41:45,900 --> 00:41:48,436 EVERYBODY IS BASICALLY 900 00:41:48,436 --> 00:41:49,404 PRESENTING ONE SOUND BITE TO GET 901 00:41:49,404 --> 00:41:50,705 YOU TO LOOK AT THE INITIATIVE IN 902 00:41:50,705 --> 00:41:53,908 THE WIKI AND POST QUESTIONS ON 903 00:41:53,908 --> 00:41:54,709 THE WIKI PAGE. 904 00:41:54,709 --> 00:41:56,177 GO TO SESSION 2.1 AND POST YOUR 905 00:41:56,177 --> 00:42:06,554 QUESTIONS HERE BELOW. 906 00:42:16,297 --> 00:42:16,764 WE'LL JUMP TO THE SLIDES. 907 00:42:16,764 --> 00:42:26,874 OKAY. 908 00:42:32,113 --> 00:42:34,449 >> WHO KNOWS HOW TO MAKE THE 909 00:42:34,449 --> 00:42:44,759 GOOGLE DOC BIGGER? 910 00:42:49,864 --> 00:42:50,465 JOSHUA, EMILY AND NICOLE CAN YOU 911 00:42:50,465 --> 00:43:00,608 HEAR US? 912 00:43:07,381 --> 00:43:09,584 ALL RIGHT, FIRST UP IS WENDY. 913 00:43:09,584 --> 00:43:13,921 YOU HAVE ONE MINUTE. 914 00:43:13,921 --> 00:43:15,490 ELEVATOR SPEECH. 915 00:43:15,490 --> 00:43:16,758 >> 916 00:43:16,758 --> 00:43:26,934 [OFF-MIC] 917 00:43:28,870 --> 00:43:30,772 >> OBVIOUSLY WE CARE ABOUT THE 918 00:43:30,772 --> 00:43:32,473 ISSUES IMAG COMES WITH AND 919 00:43:32,473 --> 00:43:33,908 THERE'S MANY INITIATIVES. 920 00:43:33,908 --> 00:43:36,144 I'LL TELL YOU ABOUT BUT NEITHER 921 00:43:36,144 --> 00:43:43,184 IS ACTIVE BUT STAY TUNED. 922 00:43:43,184 --> 00:43:44,786 THEY'RE BOTH IMPORTANT 923 00:43:44,786 --> 00:43:45,920 INITIATIVES. 924 00:43:45,920 --> 00:43:49,957 A.I. INSTITUTES. 925 00:43:49,957 --> 00:43:56,597 THESE ARE MODELLING SIMULATION. 926 00:43:56,597 --> 00:43:57,899 IT'S AN IMPORTANT INITIATIVE AND 927 00:43:57,899 --> 00:43:59,801 LARGE AWARDS OF $20 MILLION AND 928 00:43:59,801 --> 00:44:01,903 TRYING TO BECOME A NEXUS IN THIS 929 00:44:01,903 --> 00:44:02,103 AREA. 930 00:44:02,103 --> 00:44:07,975 IT'S ALL FUNDAMENTAL SCIENCE. 931 00:44:07,975 --> 00:44:10,645 THE GOAL IS TO REALLY BRING 932 00:44:10,645 --> 00:44:11,279 TOGETHER COMMUNITIES TO DRIVE 933 00:44:11,279 --> 00:44:17,919 THIS FORWARD TO THE NEXT STAGE. 934 00:44:17,919 --> 00:44:26,861 . 935 00:44:26,861 --> 00:44:37,405 >> MORE SLIDES ARE IN THE DECK? 936 00:44:37,972 --> 00:44:40,474 THE MORE IMPORTANT IS THE SMART 937 00:44:40,474 --> 00:44:45,913 HEALTH INITIATIVE LOOKING AT 938 00:44:45,913 --> 00:44:46,681 COLLABORATIVE TEAMS COMING 939 00:44:46,681 --> 00:44:48,749 TOGETHER AND WORK IN THIS 940 00:44:48,749 --> 00:44:49,817 COMPUTATIONAL AREA. 941 00:44:49,817 --> 00:44:50,985 IT'S AN EXCITING INITIATIVE AND 942 00:44:50,985 --> 00:44:52,553 NOT ACTIVE AT THE MOMENT BUT 943 00:44:52,553 --> 00:44:53,221 STAY TUNED. 944 00:44:53,221 --> 00:44:59,927 IT'S AN IMPORTANT INITIATIVE. 945 00:44:59,927 --> 00:45:02,063 >> I'M FROM THE NATIONAL SCIENCE 946 00:45:02,063 --> 00:45:05,900 FOUNDATION FROM THE DIVISION OF 947 00:45:05,900 --> 00:45:06,801 MATHEMATICAL SCIENCES. 948 00:45:06,801 --> 00:45:13,474 WE HAVE ALSO RIGHT NOW THE 949 00:45:13,474 --> 00:45:19,380 ACTIVE ON THE MATHEMATICAL 950 00:45:19,380 --> 00:45:20,548 FOUNDATION OF A.I. AND MACHINE 951 00:45:20,548 --> 00:45:21,582 LEARNING TECHNIQUES. 952 00:45:21,582 --> 00:45:24,185 >> GREAT. 953 00:45:24,185 --> 00:45:24,485 NEXT. 954 00:45:24,485 --> 00:45:25,853 >> I'M NEXT UP. 955 00:45:25,853 --> 00:45:28,089 I'M JUST SHOWING THE SLIDE ABOUT 956 00:45:28,089 --> 00:45:31,559 THE NIH BRIDGE TO A.I. PROGRAM. 957 00:45:31,559 --> 00:45:33,294 I WANTED TO HIGHLIGHT HOW BRIDGE 958 00:45:33,294 --> 00:45:35,997 TO A.I. FITS WITHIN THE 959 00:45:35,997 --> 00:45:36,797 DISCOVERY PIPELINE. 960 00:45:36,797 --> 00:45:38,933 THE BRIDGE TO A .I. IS ALL ABOUT 961 00:45:38,933 --> 00:45:39,901 DATA PREPARATION. 962 00:45:39,901 --> 00:45:45,439 IT'S NOT ABOUT MODEL DEVELOPMENT 963 00:45:45,439 --> 00:45:46,307 OR MODEL EVALUATION. 964 00:45:46,307 --> 00:45:48,943 IT'S USING THE ENTIRE PROGRAM TO 965 00:45:48,943 --> 00:45:49,911 CREATE ETHICALLY SOURCED DATA 966 00:45:49,911 --> 00:45:51,712 FROM DIVERSE SOURCES. 967 00:45:51,712 --> 00:45:53,247 WHAT'S THAT MEAN? 968 00:45:53,247 --> 00:45:54,515 WE HAVE APPROPRIATE TEAMING AND 969 00:45:54,515 --> 00:45:56,484 ETHICS AND STANDARDS AND TOOLS 970 00:45:56,484 --> 00:45:57,351 AS WELL AS DATA ACQUISITION. 971 00:45:57,351 --> 00:46:02,089 THE THREE PILLARS ARE PEOPLE, 972 00:46:02,089 --> 00:46:02,957 ETHICS AND DATA. 973 00:46:02,957 --> 00:46:05,059 I WANT YOU TO REMEMBER THOSE 974 00:46:05,059 --> 00:46:05,860 THREE THINGS. 975 00:46:05,860 --> 00:46:06,594 PEOPLE MEANS DIVERSITY. 976 00:46:06,594 --> 00:46:08,362 WE'RE DOING A CHALLENGE. 977 00:46:08,362 --> 00:46:11,299 IT'S A VERY CHALLENGING TO BE 978 00:46:11,299 --> 00:46:11,532 DIVERSE. 979 00:46:11,532 --> 00:46:13,968 IN OUR RESEARCH TEAMS, IN OUR 980 00:46:13,968 --> 00:46:16,570 RESEARCH COHORTS, IN OUR 981 00:46:16,570 --> 00:46:17,171 RESEARCH METHODOLOGIES AND 982 00:46:17,171 --> 00:46:19,640 TRYING TO DO TEAMING AS BEST WE 983 00:46:19,640 --> 00:46:22,209 CAN WITH THIS VERY COMPLICATED 984 00:46:22,209 --> 00:46:23,778 SOCIAL ORGANIZATION. 985 00:46:23,778 --> 00:46:25,379 ETHICS IS ANOTHER DIFFICULT 986 00:46:25,379 --> 00:46:26,814 CHALLENGE TO THINK ABOUT ETHICS 987 00:46:26,814 --> 00:46:33,654 IN THE SENSE OF CULTURE OF 988 00:46:33,654 --> 00:46:34,155 INQU 989 00:46:34,155 --> 00:46:34,789 INQU 990 00:46:34,789 --> 00:46:36,824 INQUIRING THE PROCESS AND HOW 991 00:46:36,824 --> 00:46:38,926 THE PROTOCOL INTENDS AND HOW YOU 992 00:46:38,926 --> 00:46:43,798 PUT IT INTO A DUMB MACHINE TO 993 00:46:43,798 --> 00:46:44,298 UNDERSTAND. 994 00:46:44,298 --> 00:46:45,433 HOW WOULD YOUR MACHINE LEARNING 995 00:46:45,433 --> 00:46:47,034 MODEL UNDERSTAND THE PARAMETERS 996 00:46:47,034 --> 00:46:48,669 INVOLVED IN THE PROTOCOLS 997 00:46:48,669 --> 00:46:49,570 ETHICALLY? 998 00:46:49,570 --> 00:46:51,172 AND FINALLY DATA IS ALL ABOUT 999 00:46:51,172 --> 00:46:53,107 CREATING NUTRITION LABELS FOR 1000 00:46:53,107 --> 00:46:53,908 THE DATA. 1001 00:46:53,908 --> 00:46:55,409 DATA SHEETS AND MODEL CARDS. 1002 00:46:55,409 --> 00:46:57,244 HOW IS THAT VERY DUMB MACHINE 1003 00:46:57,244 --> 00:47:00,348 GOING TO UNDERSTAND THE DATA AND 1004 00:47:00,348 --> 00:47:01,515 ULTIMATELY WE WANT TO HAVE THE 1005 00:47:01,515 --> 00:47:04,018 DATA MINED BY ALL OF YOU AS 1006 00:47:04,018 --> 00:47:04,285 MODELERS. 1007 00:47:04,285 --> 00:47:06,287 SO BRIDGE TO A.I. IS ALL ABOUT 1008 00:47:06,287 --> 00:47:06,887 DATA PREPARATION. 1009 00:47:06,887 --> 00:47:08,055 IF YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS, COME 1010 00:47:08,055 --> 00:47:18,165 TO ME. 1011 00:47:22,937 --> 00:47:25,039 >> MAURICIO. 1012 00:47:25,039 --> 00:47:26,540 >> HE'S NOT HERE I BELIEVE SO 1013 00:47:26,540 --> 00:47:28,676 I'LL SAY WHAT I KNOW BECAUSE I 1014 00:47:28,676 --> 00:47:30,244 COLLABORATE WITH HIM ON THE 1015 00:47:30,244 --> 00:47:35,549 BRAIN INITIATIVE AND KNOW HE'S 1016 00:47:35,549 --> 00:47:39,086 VERY INTERESTED IN EXPLAINABLE 1017 00:47:39,086 --> 00:47:40,988 A.I. AT THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE 1018 00:47:40,988 --> 00:47:43,991 OF HEALTH AND THEY PUT OUT THE 1019 00:47:43,991 --> 00:47:47,962 INITIATIVE AND HAVE A NOTICE ON 1020 00:47:47,962 --> 00:47:49,463 HAVING EXPLAINABLE ARTIFICIAL 1021 00:47:49,463 --> 00:47:49,797 INTELLIGENCE. 1022 00:47:49,797 --> 00:47:52,033 MAURICIO IS ONE OF THE BREAKOUT 1023 00:47:52,033 --> 00:47:55,403 SESSION LEADERS NUMBER 2 OR THE 1024 00:47:55,403 --> 00:47:56,037 MECHANISTIC MACHINE LEARNING 1025 00:47:56,037 --> 00:47:57,138 BREAKOUT SESSION. 1026 00:47:57,138 --> 00:47:58,873 SO IF YOU'RE INTERESTED IN 1027 00:47:58,873 --> 00:48:00,107 LEARNING MORE ABOUT THAT, I 1028 00:48:00,107 --> 00:48:01,675 WOULD ENCOURAGE TO GO TO 1029 00:48:01,675 --> 00:48:08,049 BREAKOUT SESSION 2 AND TALK TO 1030 00:48:08,049 --> 00:48:09,717 MAURICIO. 1031 00:48:09,717 --> 00:48:10,551 >> GOOD MORNING. 1032 00:48:10,551 --> 00:48:17,958 MY NAME IS ELANA GOLDBERG. 1033 00:48:17,958 --> 00:48:21,896 I AM A PROGRAM DIRECTOR -- 1034 00:48:21,896 --> 00:48:24,432 >> I APOLOGIZE. 1035 00:48:24,432 --> 00:48:28,035 I THOUGHT EMILY WAS UP NEXT. 1036 00:48:28,035 --> 00:48:29,904 >> I'M A PROGRAM DIRECTOR AT THE 1037 00:48:29,904 --> 00:48:33,908 NATIONAL HEART, LUNG AND BLOOD 1038 00:48:33,908 --> 00:48:36,243 INSTITUTE AND WE'RE HAVE AN 1039 00:48:36,243 --> 00:48:39,980 INTEREST GROUP AT THE IMAG WIKI 1040 00:48:39,980 --> 00:48:41,916 PAGE AND IT'S A.I. AND MACHINE 1041 00:48:41,916 --> 00:48:43,217 LEARNING FOR DIAGNOSTICS AND 1042 00:48:43,217 --> 00:48:43,684 DISEASES. 1043 00:48:43,684 --> 00:48:45,586 WHAT WE'RE HOPING TO DO IS GET A 1044 00:48:45,586 --> 00:48:47,621 BUNCH OF PEOPLE IN THE FIELD ON 1045 00:48:47,621 --> 00:48:49,657 TO THE WIKI, SHARE YOUR IDEAS, 1046 00:48:49,657 --> 00:48:51,392 SHARE THE PROJECTS YOU'RE 1047 00:48:51,392 --> 00:48:54,295 WORKING ON. 1048 00:48:54,295 --> 00:48:56,430 I KNOW WE HAVE A LOT GOING ON 1049 00:48:56,430 --> 00:48:57,331 RIGHT NOW IN THE FIELD BUT A LOT 1050 00:48:57,331 --> 00:49:00,634 OF ONE-OFF PROJECTS SO SOMEONE 1051 00:49:00,634 --> 00:49:02,570 IS DEVELOPING AN APP OR DOING 1052 00:49:02,570 --> 00:49:03,938 MACHINE LEARNING TO LOOK AT 1053 00:49:03,938 --> 00:49:05,372 BLOOD PHENOTYPING OVER HERE. 1054 00:49:05,372 --> 00:49:07,141 WHAT I'M HOPING WE CAN DO IS 1055 00:49:07,141 --> 00:49:08,042 JOIN TOGETHER AND COLLABORATE 1056 00:49:08,042 --> 00:49:09,810 AND SEE THE BIGGER PICTURE. 1057 00:49:09,810 --> 00:49:11,812 HOW CAN WE DEVELOP DATABASES OF 1058 00:49:11,812 --> 00:49:17,751 THIS TYPE OF DATA SO IT CAN THEN 1059 00:49:17,751 --> 00:49:20,721 BE USED FOR THE MACHINE LEARNING 1060 00:49:20,721 --> 00:49:21,922 TRAINING AS WELL AS THE 1061 00:49:21,922 --> 00:49:23,257 VALIDATION AND WE ARE USING 1062 00:49:23,257 --> 00:49:24,792 SAMPLES FROM ONE BLOOD BANK. 1063 00:49:24,792 --> 00:49:26,961 HAS IT EVER BEEN VALIDATED ON 1064 00:49:26,961 --> 00:49:28,262 SAMPLES FROM A SECOND BLOOD BANK 1065 00:49:28,262 --> 00:49:29,763 AND HOW CAN WE PUT IT ALL 1066 00:49:29,763 --> 00:49:31,765 TOGETHER AND TALK AND FORM AN 1067 00:49:31,765 --> 00:49:33,901 OVER ALL PICTURE FOR WHERE WE 1068 00:49:33,901 --> 00:49:38,973 WANT TO GO AND WHAT ARE STRATEGY 1069 00:49:38,973 --> 00:49:41,242 PROJECTIVES ARE FOR MACHINE 1070 00:49:41,242 --> 00:49:43,144 LEARNING AND BLOOD DISEASES AND 1071 00:49:43,144 --> 00:49:44,512 DIAGNOSTICS AND WE'LL TALK ABOUT 1072 00:49:44,512 --> 00:49:45,946 THIS FURTHER A BIT IN BREAKOUT 1073 00:49:45,946 --> 00:49:46,447 SESSION 2. 1074 00:49:46,447 --> 00:49:48,182 I HOPE YOU'LL COME AND JOIN THE 1075 00:49:48,182 --> 00:49:49,183 CONVERSATION AND JOIN THE 1076 00:49:49,183 --> 00:49:50,718 INTEREST GROUP ON THE IMAG WIKI. 1077 00:49:50,718 --> 00:49:51,152 THANK YOU. 1078 00:49:51,152 --> 00:49:54,822 >> YOU CAN FIND THE PAGE ON THE 1079 00:49:54,822 --> 00:49:58,826 IMAG WIKI UNDER THE ASK THE 1080 00:49:58,826 --> 00:49:59,827 STAFF. 1081 00:49:59,827 --> 00:50:00,661 >> THANK YOU. 1082 00:50:00,661 --> 00:50:00,861 EMILY. 1083 00:50:00,861 --> 00:50:06,901 I BELIEVE SHE'S ON THE ZOOM. 1084 00:50:06,901 --> 00:50:08,602 >> CAN YOU HEAR ME IN NATCHER? 1085 00:50:08,602 --> 00:50:14,008 >> YES, WE CAN HEAR YOU. 1086 00:50:14,008 --> 00:50:15,843 >> OKAY. 1087 00:50:15,843 --> 00:50:16,043 GREAT. 1088 00:50:16,043 --> 00:50:22,683 SO WHAT THIS INITIATIVE IS IS AN 1089 00:50:22,683 --> 00:50:24,952 OPPORTUNITY AT LOOKING AT CANCER 1090 00:50:24,952 --> 00:50:26,887 A.I. ACCELERATOR. 1091 00:50:26,887 --> 00:50:29,723 WE SEE IT AS AN OPPORTUNITY TO 1092 00:50:29,723 --> 00:50:32,226 BUILD TRANS DISCIPLINARY 1093 00:50:32,226 --> 00:50:33,594 COLLABORATION FOR APPROPRIATE 1094 00:50:33,594 --> 00:50:35,896 USE OF A.I. IN CANCER RESEARCH 1095 00:50:35,896 --> 00:50:42,937 AND WE HAVE ENVISIONED THIS NOT 1096 00:50:42,937 --> 00:50:48,008 AT A LARGE PROGRAM BUT NIMBLE 1097 00:50:48,008 --> 00:50:49,910 AND ADAPTIVE COOPERATION AMONG 1098 00:50:49,910 --> 00:50:51,212 INVESTIGATORS IN THIS 1099 00:50:51,212 --> 00:50:51,612 FAST-MOVING FIELD. 1100 00:50:51,612 --> 00:50:54,415 AS THE FIELD IS FAST-MOVING WE 1101 00:50:54,415 --> 00:50:58,619 ANTICIPATE THE ACCELERATOR NEEDS 1102 00:50:58,619 --> 00:51:00,221 TO BE CONSTANTLY BE CHANGING IN 1103 00:51:00,221 --> 00:51:02,890 GOALS AND ACTIVITIES AS WELL. 1104 00:51:02,890 --> 00:51:07,061 WE WOULD LIKE TO APPLY THIS TO 1105 00:51:07,061 --> 00:51:07,962 RESEARCH IN CLINICAL PRACTICE 1106 00:51:07,962 --> 00:51:10,864 AND ALSO HAVE THE ACCELERATOR 1107 00:51:10,864 --> 00:51:11,665 FOSTER INTERACTIONS WITH 1108 00:51:11,665 --> 00:51:13,801 RELEVANT ORGANIZATIONS AND 1109 00:51:13,801 --> 00:51:16,537 INITIATIVES BEYOND NCI AND 1110 00:51:16,537 --> 00:51:17,905 BEYOND CANCER. 1111 00:51:17,905 --> 00:51:28,048 THANKS. 1112 00:51:35,689 --> 00:51:37,658 >> I'M GOING TO BE TALKING 1113 00:51:37,658 --> 00:51:40,828 BRIEFLY ABOUT THE NIH NUTRITION 1114 00:51:40,828 --> 00:51:41,495 FOR PRECISION HEALTH. 1115 00:51:41,495 --> 00:51:45,966 WE'RE THE AIMING CENTER THE A.I. 1116 00:51:45,966 --> 00:51:49,837 CENTER FOR THIS MPH CONSORTIUM 1117 00:51:49,837 --> 00:51:52,339 INCLUDING 14 DIFFERENT AWARDS, A 1118 00:51:52,339 --> 00:51:54,275 VARIETY OF CLINICAL CENTERS AND 1119 00:51:54,275 --> 00:51:56,510 A METABOLOMIC CENTER AND DIETARY 1120 00:51:56,510 --> 00:51:59,280 CENTER AMONG OTHER THINGS. 1121 00:51:59,280 --> 00:52:01,515 WE'RE ISSUING AN RFA TO SEEK 1122 00:52:01,515 --> 00:52:04,218 PRODUCTS THAT USE A.I. AND OTHER 1123 00:52:04,218 --> 00:52:05,919 APPROACHES TO FACILITATE 1124 00:52:05,919 --> 00:52:06,587 NUTRITION. 1125 00:52:06,587 --> 00:52:09,156 THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO BE 1126 00:52:09,156 --> 00:52:10,991 AWARDED THE PILOT PROJECT SO 1127 00:52:10,991 --> 00:52:16,130 THAT YOU CAN PARTICIPATE IN THE 1128 00:52:16,130 --> 00:52:17,298 NUTRITION FOR PRECISION HEALTH 1129 00:52:17,298 --> 00:52:18,332 CONSORTIUM WORK. 1130 00:52:18,332 --> 00:52:20,100 ALL THE DETAILS ARE LISTED HERE. 1131 00:52:20,100 --> 00:52:23,203 THE DEADLINE IS OCTOBER 12, 1132 00:52:23,203 --> 00:52:24,104 2023. 1133 00:52:24,104 --> 00:52:25,973 AND YOU CAN SCAN THE QR CODE OR 1134 00:52:25,973 --> 00:52:29,910 GO TO THAT LINK TO GET MORE 1135 00:52:29,910 --> 00:52:36,417 DETAILS ON THE OPPORTUNITY. 1136 00:52:36,417 --> 00:52:38,986 THAT WRAPS UP OUR A.I. DRIVEN 1137 00:52:38,986 --> 00:52:41,488 INITIATIVES AND WE'RE MOVING ON 1138 00:52:41,488 --> 00:52:43,157 TO THE MECHANISM-DRIVEN 1139 00:52:43,157 --> 00:52:44,091 INITIATIVES. 1140 00:52:44,091 --> 00:52:48,762 THE FIRST OF COURSE IS IMAG AND 1141 00:52:48,762 --> 00:52:50,531 MSM AND YOU AND I PUT YOU HERE 1142 00:52:50,531 --> 00:52:51,732 BECAUSE I WANT YOU TO FOCUS ON 1143 00:52:51,732 --> 00:52:53,801 THE DIFFERENT CATEGORIES WE'RE 1144 00:52:53,801 --> 00:52:56,103 TALKING ABOUT AND SEE WHERE 1145 00:52:56,103 --> 00:53:00,841 IMAGO AND THE MSM CAN FIT. 1146 00:53:00,841 --> 00:53:02,309 WE ARE THE CONSORTIUM FOR 1147 00:53:02,309 --> 00:53:03,477 MECHANISTIC MODELS AND YOU'RE 1148 00:53:03,477 --> 00:53:06,680 ASKING ME WHERE IS THE NEXT MSM 1149 00:53:06,680 --> 00:53:07,348 INITIATIVE. 1150 00:53:07,348 --> 00:53:09,917 THESE ARE ALL IMAG INITIATIVES 1151 00:53:09,917 --> 00:53:12,152 YOU'RE LISTENING TO. 1152 00:53:12,152 --> 00:53:13,921 PAY ATTENTION AND POST YOUR 1153 00:53:13,921 --> 00:53:17,891 QUESTION IN THE WIKI. 1154 00:53:17,891 --> 00:53:19,560 >> OKAY. 1155 00:53:19,560 --> 00:53:21,895 NEXT UP IS SPARC. 1156 00:53:21,895 --> 00:53:25,065 [OFF-MIC] 1157 00:53:25,065 --> 00:53:27,000 >> A PROGRAM OFFICER AT NCCIH. 1158 00:53:27,000 --> 00:53:31,505 I HOPE YOU CAN HEAR ME. 1159 00:53:31,505 --> 00:53:33,607 SO STIMULATING PERIPHERAL 1160 00:53:33,607 --> 00:53:35,709 ACTIVITY TO RELIEF CONDITION IS 1161 00:53:35,709 --> 00:53:37,578 A COMMON FUND PROGRAM AND THE 1162 00:53:37,578 --> 00:53:45,452 GOAL IS TO ACCELERATE THE 1163 00:53:45,452 --> 00:53:49,890 ADOPTMENT OF IMPROVING 1164 00:53:49,890 --> 00:53:52,593 PERIPHERAL ORGAN FUNCTION. 1165 00:53:52,593 --> 00:53:54,428 RESEARCHERS DEVELOPED A TOOL TO 1166 00:53:54,428 --> 00:53:57,765 MAKE THE COMPLEX HIGHWAYS OF 1167 00:53:57,765 --> 00:53:59,233 NERVES THAT SEND SIGNALS THROUGH 1168 00:53:59,233 --> 00:54:01,835 ALL OF OUR BODIES. 1169 00:54:01,835 --> 00:54:08,275 AND NOW, THE SPARC PROGRAM 1170 00:54:08,275 --> 00:54:11,245 BEGINS PHASE 2 TO ADOPT THE 1171 00:54:11,245 --> 00:54:13,280 SUCCESS OF PHASE 1 TO DEVELOP 1172 00:54:13,280 --> 00:54:15,449 AND SHINE MORE DATA SETS ON 1173 00:54:15,449 --> 00:54:16,717 STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION OF 1174 00:54:16,717 --> 00:54:21,622 PERIPHERAL NEURAL SYSTEM. 1175 00:54:21,622 --> 00:54:25,726 AND TEST NEW THERAPIES TO TREAT 1176 00:54:25,726 --> 00:54:29,730 DISEASES SUCH AS HYPERTENSION, 1177 00:54:29,730 --> 00:54:32,099 CHRONIC PAIN AND 1178 00:54:32,099 --> 00:54:32,699 GASTROINTESTINAL ISSUES AND 1179 00:54:32,699 --> 00:54:38,505 PHASE 2 INTRODUCES THE THREE 1180 00:54:38,505 --> 00:54:42,209 INITIATIVES ON NERVE MAPPING AND 1181 00:54:42,209 --> 00:54:43,076 PHYSIOLOGY AND OPEN SOURCE 1182 00:54:43,076 --> 00:54:48,482 NEURAL MODULATION TECHNOLOGIES. 1183 00:54:48,482 --> 00:54:52,386 RIGHT NOW SPARC IS IDENTIFYING 1184 00:54:52,386 --> 00:54:57,057 THE AFFECT OF NERVE STIMULATION 1185 00:54:57,057 --> 00:55:03,897 ON THREE ORGAN SYSTEMS, 1186 00:55:03,897 --> 00:55:05,265 CARDIOVASCULAR AND COLLECT THE 1187 00:55:05,265 --> 00:55:09,903 DATA FOR 144 INDIVIDUALS. 1188 00:55:09,903 --> 00:55:11,505 SO PLEASE VISIT THE SPARC 1189 00:55:11,505 --> 00:55:11,738 PORTAL. 1190 00:55:11,738 --> 00:55:16,109 YOU CAN SEE OVER HERE THE 1191 00:55:16,109 --> 00:55:18,345 WEBSITE FOR THE CREATED DATA 1192 00:55:18,345 --> 00:55:20,848 SETS AND MAPS OF NEURAL ORGAN 1193 00:55:20,848 --> 00:55:23,116 INTERACTIONS AN COMPUTATIONAL 1194 00:55:23,116 --> 00:55:25,285 STUDIES AND MORE AND AVAILABLE 1195 00:55:25,285 --> 00:55:28,889 DATA FOR BOOT SCALE MODELLING 1196 00:55:28,889 --> 00:55:30,123 LATER ON. 1197 00:55:30,123 --> 00:55:35,662 RIGHT NOW SPARC WAS GENERATING 1198 00:55:35,662 --> 00:55:38,265 HUGE DATA INCLUDING DIFFERENT 1199 00:55:38,265 --> 00:55:42,469 PHYSIOLOGICAL ORGAN SYSTEMS. 1200 00:55:42,469 --> 00:55:52,846 >> NEXT UP IS NICOLE. 1201 00:55:54,515 --> 00:56:00,120 NICOLE'S REMOTE. 1202 00:56:00,120 --> 00:56:02,623 >> HI, HOPEFULLY EVERYONE CAN 1203 00:56:02,623 --> 00:56:05,058 HEAR ME. 1204 00:56:05,058 --> 00:56:08,095 SO, YEAH, THANKS FOR THE 1205 00:56:08,095 --> 00:56:10,664 OPPORTUNITY TO TALK ABOUT THE 1206 00:56:10,664 --> 00:56:15,035 ANIMAL TESTING IN THE TOXICOLOGY 1207 00:56:15,035 --> 00:56:15,469 SPACE. 1208 00:56:15,469 --> 00:56:17,971 WE SUPPORT A CONGRESSIONALLY 1209 00:56:17,971 --> 00:56:21,208 MANDATED COMMITTEE INCLUDING THE 1210 00:56:21,208 --> 00:56:24,478 NHRCs AND EPA AND FDA AND PRETTY 1211 00:56:24,478 --> 00:56:25,546 MUCH EVERY REGULATORY AGENCY YOU 1212 00:56:25,546 --> 00:56:29,082 CAN THINK OF. 1213 00:56:29,082 --> 00:56:29,917 WE WORK IN THE DIFFERENT AREAS 1214 00:56:29,917 --> 00:56:33,921 YOU SEE LISTED ON THE SWLIED SO 1215 00:56:33,921 --> 00:56:36,757 IF YOU HAVE -- SLIDE AND IF YOU 1216 00:56:36,757 --> 00:56:39,226 HAVE AN INTEREST REACH OUT AND 1217 00:56:39,226 --> 00:56:40,294 THE CHEMICAL ENVIRONMENT IS A 1218 00:56:40,294 --> 00:56:41,895 RESOURCE THAT HAS A LARGE AMOUNT 1219 00:56:41,895 --> 00:56:44,831 OF HIGH-QUALITY CURATED DATA 1220 00:56:44,831 --> 00:56:47,568 BOTH FROM LEGACY AND ANIMAL 1221 00:56:47,568 --> 00:56:53,040 STUDIES AND ALSO FROM IN VITRO 1222 00:56:53,040 --> 00:56:53,273 STUDIES. 1223 00:56:53,273 --> 00:56:57,911 WE ANNOTATED THAT DATA TO 1224 00:56:57,911 --> 00:56:59,913 MECHANISTIC TARGETS AND 1225 00:56:59,913 --> 00:57:01,682 TOXICOLOGICAL MODES OF ACTION TO 1226 00:57:01,682 --> 00:57:04,585 SUPPORT BETTER MODELS. 1227 00:57:04,585 --> 00:57:06,153 THAT'S THE QR CODE ON THE SLIDE 1228 00:57:06,153 --> 00:57:08,355 AND YOU CAN FOLLOW ALONG ONLINE 1229 00:57:08,355 --> 00:57:09,656 AND CLICK ON THE LINK THERE AND 1230 00:57:09,656 --> 00:57:16,597 VISIT OUR WEBSITE AND OUR 1231 00:57:16,597 --> 00:57:24,671 DATABASE AND LOOK AT IN VIVO 1232 00:57:24,671 --> 00:57:25,072 EXTRAPOLATION OR 1233 00:57:25,072 --> 00:57:27,140 CHARACTERIZATION WORK FLOWS, 1234 00:57:27,140 --> 00:57:27,407 ETCETERA. 1235 00:57:27,407 --> 00:57:27,674 THAT'S IT. 1236 00:57:27,674 --> 00:57:33,547 THANKS. 1237 00:57:33,547 --> 00:57:35,582 >> I HAVE TO SAY NICOLE'S 1238 00:57:35,582 --> 00:57:39,653 PROGRAM IS WHAT WE'RE SHOOTING 1239 00:57:39,653 --> 00:57:44,891 FOR IN IMAG MSM BECAUSE SHE'S 1240 00:57:44,891 --> 00:57:46,560 TRANSLATED THE MODELS AND HAS A 1241 00:57:46,560 --> 00:57:50,464 CYCLE GOING FROM BIG DATA TO 1242 00:57:50,464 --> 00:57:51,598 EXPERIMENTATION. 1243 00:57:51,598 --> 00:57:52,799 CONGRATULATIONS, NICOLE. 1244 00:57:52,799 --> 00:57:53,066 THANK YOU. 1245 00:57:53,066 --> 00:57:54,334 >> THANKS, NICOLE. 1246 00:57:54,334 --> 00:58:00,107 NEXT UP WE HAVE STEPHANIE. 1247 00:58:00,107 --> 00:58:03,076 >> I'M STEPHANIE GEORGE AT THE 1248 00:58:03,076 --> 00:58:04,378 BIO MEDICAL SYSTEMS PROGRAM WITH 1249 00:58:04,378 --> 00:58:07,648 OUR ENVIRONMENTAL AND TRANSPORT 1250 00:58:07,648 --> 00:58:11,652 SYSTEMS DIVISION WITHIN THE 1251 00:58:11,652 --> 00:58:13,920 ENGINEERING DIRECTORATE AT NSN. 1252 00:58:13,920 --> 00:58:19,526 OUR CORE PROGRAMS ALSO WELCOME 1253 00:58:19,526 --> 00:58:20,327 MULTISCALE MODELING MECHANISTIC 1254 00:58:20,327 --> 00:58:23,063 AND YOU CAN SEE THE SLIDE DECK 1255 00:58:23,063 --> 00:58:24,865 FOR EXAMPLES INCLUDING MY 1256 00:58:24,865 --> 00:58:29,169 PROGRAM AND PROGRAMS LIKE BIO 1257 00:58:29,169 --> 00:58:35,375 MECHANICS AND UP HERE I HAVE OUR 1258 00:58:35,375 --> 00:58:35,976 COMPUTATIONAL SCIENCE AND 1259 00:58:35,976 --> 00:58:36,309 ENGINEERING. 1260 00:58:36,309 --> 00:58:38,311 THIS IS A METAPROGRAM YOU CAN 1261 00:58:38,311 --> 00:58:41,214 APPLY THESE PROJECTS TYPICALLY 1262 00:58:41,214 --> 00:58:43,350 HAVE A MUCH LARGER COMPUTATIONAL 1263 00:58:43,350 --> 00:58:44,117 COMPONENT THAN THOSE SUBMITTED 1264 00:58:44,117 --> 00:58:45,786 TO THE CORE PROGRAMS. 1265 00:58:45,786 --> 00:58:49,790 WE ALSO HAVE SOLICITATION FOR 1266 00:58:49,790 --> 00:58:52,459 CYBER INFRASTRUCTURE AND A 1267 00:58:52,459 --> 00:58:53,860 SPECIAL COMPUTATIONAL CRCNS FOR 1268 00:58:53,860 --> 00:58:54,761 NEUROSCIENCE YOU CAN SEE IN THE 1269 00:58:54,761 --> 00:58:55,062 SLIDE DECK. 1270 00:58:55,062 --> 00:58:57,330 THANK YOU. 1271 00:58:57,330 --> 00:59:03,670 >> THANKS, STEPHANIE. 1272 00:59:03,670 --> 00:59:09,876 NEXT UP WE HAVE FREDERICK. 1273 00:59:09,876 --> 00:59:12,679 >> I'M FREDERICK. 1274 00:59:12,679 --> 00:59:14,981 I RUN THE PROGRAM AT AIR FORCE 1275 00:59:14,981 --> 00:59:16,616 OFFICE OF SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH. 1276 00:59:16,616 --> 00:59:21,154 I'M A LITTLE BIT OF AN OUTLIER. 1277 00:59:21,154 --> 00:59:25,192 MY COLLEAGUE RUNS THE 1278 00:59:25,192 --> 00:59:25,759 COMPUTATIONAL MATHEMATICS 1279 00:59:25,759 --> 00:59:27,461 PROGRAM USUALLY COMES HERE AND 1280 00:59:27,461 --> 00:59:31,798 INVOLVE IN THE MATHEMATICS FOR 1281 00:59:31,798 --> 00:59:33,900 DIGITAL TWINS HOWEVER IN MY 1282 00:59:33,900 --> 00:59:36,570 PROGRAM I FUND THE ANALYSIS OF 1283 00:59:36,570 --> 00:59:43,810 COMPLEX TIMICAL SYSTEMS AND 1284 00:59:43,810 --> 00:59:45,612 MULTISCALE AND MULTIPHYSICS IS 1285 00:59:45,612 --> 00:59:48,014 IMPORTANT TO MY PROGRAM AND FUND 1286 00:59:48,014 --> 00:59:50,984 THE MATHEMATICAL DEVELOPMENT OF 1287 00:59:50,984 --> 00:59:52,285 CONTROL THEORY FOR COMPLEX 1288 00:59:52,285 --> 00:59:53,220 SYSTEMS. 1289 00:59:53,220 --> 00:59:56,056 IF THERE'S ANY QUESTIONS NOW OR 1290 00:59:56,056 --> 00:59:57,958 AFTER THIS PANEL, PLEASE LET ME 1291 00:59:57,958 --> 00:59:58,158 KNOW. 1292 00:59:58,158 --> 01:00:01,661 THANK YOU. 1293 01:00:01,661 --> 01:00:07,200 >> THANKS, FREDERICK. 1294 01:00:07,200 --> 01:00:11,671 NEXT UP WE HAVE REGINA. 1295 01:00:11,671 --> 01:00:13,840 >> I'M THE MATHEMATICS MANAGER 1296 01:00:13,840 --> 01:00:15,575 AT THE ARMY OFFICE AND WILL TALK 1297 01:00:15,575 --> 01:00:17,811 ABOUT MY PROGRAM AS WELL AS MY 1298 01:00:17,811 --> 01:00:21,014 COLLEAGUE WHO COULDN'T BE HERE 1299 01:00:21,014 --> 01:00:23,583 TODAY BECAUSE HE'S MOVING BACK 1300 01:00:23,583 --> 01:00:25,352 FROM CALIFORNIA TO NORTH 1301 01:00:25,352 --> 01:00:26,186 CAROLINA WHERE OUR OFFICES ARE 1302 01:00:26,186 --> 01:00:26,920 AS WE SPEAK. 1303 01:00:26,920 --> 01:00:29,823 I DO APOLOGIZE FOR THE SLIDES. 1304 01:00:29,823 --> 01:00:33,393 I HAD TO FIND SLIDES THAT WERE 1305 01:00:33,393 --> 01:00:35,395 ALREADY APPROVED AND PUBLICLY 1306 01:00:35,395 --> 01:00:37,898 RELEASABLE AND CHOSE THE BEST OF 1307 01:00:37,898 --> 01:00:39,099 WHAT I HAD. 1308 01:00:39,099 --> 01:00:42,068 SO OUR OVER ALL MISSION IS TO 1309 01:00:42,068 --> 01:00:47,374 FUND THE BEST BASIC HIGH-RISK, 1310 01:00:47,374 --> 01:00:49,276 HIGH-REWARD IN OUR VARIOUS 1311 01:00:49,276 --> 01:00:49,476 FIELD. 1312 01:00:49,476 --> 01:00:52,612 IN MY FIELD OF BIO MATHEMATICS 1313 01:00:52,612 --> 01:00:55,382 MY CURRENT AND ONGOING IN THE 1314 01:00:55,382 --> 01:01:01,421 PAST THIS IS PAST, CURRENT AND 1315 01:01:01,421 --> 01:01:02,088 FUTURE RESEARCH AREAS ARE 1316 01:01:02,088 --> 01:01:05,392 BIOLOGY, MULTISCALE MODELING AND 1317 01:01:05,392 --> 01:01:06,560 INVERSE MODELLING AND HYBRID 1318 01:01:06,560 --> 01:01:08,094 MODELLING. 1319 01:01:08,094 --> 01:01:11,097 THESE ARE SUPPOSED TO BE A FEW 1320 01:01:11,097 --> 01:01:13,567 FROM A TAB REVIEW WE DID IN 1321 01:01:13,567 --> 01:01:13,834 NOVEMBER. 1322 01:01:13,834 --> 01:01:16,036 THIS SHOWS THE BREADTH OF THE 1323 01:01:16,036 --> 01:01:17,470 DIFFERENT AREAS. 1324 01:01:17,470 --> 01:01:18,905 THE AREAS THAT MY PROGRAM WORKS 1325 01:01:18,905 --> 01:01:22,809 IN ARE ALL OVER THE MAP. 1326 01:01:22,809 --> 01:01:25,912 I DID NOT DECIDE TO FOCUS ON 1327 01:01:25,912 --> 01:01:27,447 SPECIFIC APPLICATION AREAS BUT 1328 01:01:27,447 --> 01:01:30,517 MORE ON THE FUNDAMENTALS OF BIO 1329 01:01:30,517 --> 01:01:41,027 MATHEMATICS AND THE MODELLING. 1330 01:01:47,701 --> 01:01:50,103 SO EDWARD GAVE ME INFORMATION. 1331 01:01:50,103 --> 01:01:52,639 HIS PROGRAM IS SOCIAL AND 1332 01:01:52,639 --> 01:01:53,740 COGNITIVE NETWORKS AND FUNDS 1333 01:01:53,740 --> 01:01:57,911 RESEARCH FOCUSSED ON COMMUNITY 1334 01:01:57,911 --> 01:02:00,647 COGNITIVE RESILIENCE. 1335 01:02:00,647 --> 01:02:05,919 HE FOLKS ON DEPRESSION, ANXIETY, 1336 01:02:05,919 --> 01:02:07,520 PTSD, SUICIDAL IDEATION AND PAIN 1337 01:02:07,520 --> 01:02:13,460 AND DISINFORMATION AND TPROGRAM 1338 01:02:13,460 --> 01:02:16,997 IS BASED ON SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH 1339 01:02:16,997 --> 01:02:22,602 AND FOCUSES ON MINDFULNESS AND 1340 01:02:22,602 --> 01:02:24,204 HYPNOTHERAPY AND LEVERAGES 1341 01:02:24,204 --> 01:02:25,171 METHODS TO EXPLORE AN 1342 01:02:25,171 --> 01:02:27,574 INDIVIDUAL'S IMPACT ON AND FROM 1343 01:02:27,574 --> 01:02:29,009 THE COMMUNITIES IN WHICH HE OR 1344 01:02:29,009 --> 01:02:29,910 SHE IS EMBEDDED. 1345 01:02:29,910 --> 01:02:31,878 I WANTED TO MENTION WE HAVE LOTS 1346 01:02:31,878 --> 01:02:33,079 OF OTHER PROGRAMS THAT MAY BE OF 1347 01:02:33,079 --> 01:02:34,581 INTEREST TO PEOPLE IN THIS 1348 01:02:34,581 --> 01:02:36,082 COMMUNITY AND IN PARTICULAR WE 1349 01:02:36,082 --> 01:02:37,918 HAVE A COUPLE DIFFERENT PROGRAMS 1350 01:02:37,918 --> 01:02:41,621 THAT DEAL WITH A .I. AND MACHINE 1351 01:02:41,621 --> 01:02:45,892 LEARNING AND DO LIKE TO WORK 1352 01:02:45,892 --> 01:02:47,761 ACROSS TO FUND ACROSS PROGRAMS 1353 01:02:47,761 --> 01:02:49,095 FOR INDIVIDUAL EFFORTS OR FOR 1354 01:02:49,095 --> 01:02:49,663 WORKSHOPS OR OTHER AREAS OF 1355 01:02:49,663 --> 01:02:54,200 INTEREST. 1356 01:02:54,200 --> 01:02:54,834 THANK YOU. 1357 01:02:54,834 --> 01:02:55,302 >> THANK YOU. 1358 01:02:55,302 --> 01:02:56,136 NOW TO THE SOFTWARE DRIVEN 1359 01:02:56,136 --> 01:03:03,410 INITIATIVES. 1360 01:03:03,410 --> 01:03:05,245 JOSH IS ON HIS REMOTE. 1361 01:03:05,245 --> 01:03:13,954 JOSHUA. 1362 01:03:13,954 --> 01:03:24,464 >> HI, I'M A PROGRAM MANAGER. 1363 01:03:43,350 --> 01:03:44,751 A PROGRAM I'VE BEEN DEVELOPING 1364 01:03:44,751 --> 01:03:46,786 SEVERAL YEARS AND HAVE A FEW 1365 01:03:46,786 --> 01:03:49,422 YEARS LEFT ON IT THEY WORKED 1366 01:03:49,422 --> 01:03:54,694 CLOSELY WITH THE IMAG COMMUNITY 1367 01:03:54,694 --> 01:03:59,299 AND FOLKS AUTOMATE IING MODELLI 1368 01:03:59,299 --> 01:04:02,402 AND GOES FROM KNOWLEDGE TO 1369 01:04:02,402 --> 01:04:07,540 MODELLING AND COMPUTER DESIGN TO 1370 01:04:07,540 --> 01:04:12,679 ENABLE MODELERS TO DESIGN 1371 01:04:12,679 --> 01:04:14,748 MULTISCALE MODELING AND DATA 1372 01:04:14,748 --> 01:04:20,020 WORK AND HAVING ACCESS TO THE 1373 01:04:20,020 --> 01:04:22,655 FULL PUBLICATION FROM ADVANCED 1374 01:04:22,655 --> 01:04:23,723 DATA AND ETCETERA. 1375 01:04:23,723 --> 01:04:28,028 WE'RE CURRENTLY WORKING THROUGH 1376 01:04:28,028 --> 01:04:32,132 OUR PHASE 1 RANGING FROM 1377 01:04:32,132 --> 01:04:35,402 EPIDEMIOLOGY OF COVID AND 1378 01:04:35,402 --> 01:04:38,538 LOOKING AT THE OCEAN AND 1379 01:04:38,538 --> 01:04:44,110 APPLYING INGS TO VISUAL POINT 1380 01:04:44,110 --> 01:04:48,148 APPLICATION WITH A FOCUS ON 1381 01:04:48,148 --> 01:04:55,955 PARTNERSHIP WITH NIH, NCI AND 1382 01:04:55,955 --> 01:04:56,456 ARP 1383 01:04:56,456 --> 01:04:56,689 ARPA-H. 1384 01:04:56,689 --> 01:05:01,895 I'LL LEAVE IT THERE. 1385 01:05:01,895 --> 01:05:08,268 >> NEXT ONE IS EMILY. 1386 01:05:08,268 --> 01:05:12,806 >> SO THIS SLIDE IS NATIONAL 1387 01:05:12,806 --> 01:05:14,574 ACADEMY OF SCIENCE, ENGINEERING 1388 01:05:14,574 --> 01:05:18,945 AND MEDICINE CONSENSUS STUDY. 1389 01:05:18,945 --> 01:05:21,781 THAT'S BEEN ONGOING FOR CLOSE TO 1390 01:05:21,781 --> 01:05:25,985 A YEAR NOW NINE OR 10 MONTH WE 1391 01:05:25,985 --> 01:05:28,154 FOUND FOUNDATIONAL GAPS AND 1392 01:05:28,154 --> 01:05:29,956 LOOKED AT DIGITAL TWINS. 1393 01:05:29,956 --> 01:05:31,858 WE HAVE SEVERAL IMAG MEMBERS WHO 1394 01:05:31,858 --> 01:05:35,929 ARE CO-SPONSORING THE STUDY FROM 1395 01:05:35,929 --> 01:05:40,467 NIH IS NIAID AND NCI, OFFICE OF 1396 01:05:40,467 --> 01:05:42,802 DATA SCIENCE STRATEGY AND NLM AS 1397 01:05:42,802 --> 01:05:49,909 WELL AS DOD, NSF AND DOD-DARPA. 1398 01:05:49,909 --> 01:05:53,680 THIS IS ACROSS THE MAIN STUDY. 1399 01:05:53,680 --> 01:05:54,614 WE'RE LOOKING AT DIFFERENT 1400 01:05:54,614 --> 01:05:56,116 SCIENTIFIC AND TECHNICAL DOMAINS 1401 01:05:56,116 --> 01:06:00,420 WHERE DIGITAL TWINS CAN BE 1402 01:06:00,420 --> 01:06:02,288 APPLIED INCLUDING BIO MEDICAL 1403 01:06:02,288 --> 01:06:04,324 SCIENCE AND EARTH SYSTEMS AND 1404 01:06:04,324 --> 01:06:05,892 AEROSPACE ENGINEERING. 1405 01:06:05,892 --> 01:06:09,696 THE OVER ALL GOALS OF THIS STUDY 1406 01:06:09,696 --> 01:06:13,766 ARE TO INVESTIGATE RIGOROUS 1407 01:06:13,766 --> 01:06:16,469 METHODS TO MAKE DIGITAL TWINS 1408 01:06:16,469 --> 01:06:16,736 SCALABLE. 1409 01:06:16,736 --> 01:06:19,706 IN OTHER WORDS, WE WANT TO 1410 01:06:19,706 --> 01:06:23,610 START THINKING ABOUT HOW DIGITAL 1411 01:06:23,610 --> 01:06:25,912 TWINS CAN BE MORE GENERALIZABLE 1412 01:06:25,912 --> 01:06:27,247 AND FOUNDATIONAL ACROSS 1413 01:06:27,247 --> 01:06:29,582 DIFFERENT USE CASES AND DOMAINS. 1414 01:06:29,582 --> 01:06:32,118 WE'RE ALSO LOOKING AT BEST 1415 01:06:32,118 --> 01:06:35,021 PRACTICES AND USE CASES AND 1416 01:06:35,021 --> 01:06:35,989 CHALLENGES FOR DEVELOPING 1417 01:06:35,989 --> 01:06:39,225 DIGITAL TWINS AT SCALE. 1418 01:06:39,225 --> 01:06:40,627 IN THE WINTER, THIS PAST WINTER 1419 01:06:40,627 --> 01:06:44,130 THERE WERE THREE WORKSHOPS HELD 1420 01:06:44,130 --> 01:06:46,299 IN THESE SPECIFIC DOMAIN AREAS. 1421 01:06:46,299 --> 01:06:51,070 ONE OF THE WORKSHOPS THE BIO 1422 01:06:51,070 --> 01:06:53,039 MEDICAL WORKSHOP HAS PROCEEDINGS 1423 01:06:53,039 --> 01:06:55,508 THAT HAVE RECENTLY BEEN 1424 01:06:55,508 --> 01:06:55,842 PUBLISHED. 1425 01:06:55,842 --> 01:06:57,610 I'D ENCOURAGE EVERYONE TO LOOK 1426 01:06:57,610 --> 01:07:00,880 AT THE STUDY, SORRY, AT THE 1427 01:07:00,880 --> 01:07:03,917 WORKSHOP PROCEEDINGS AT THIS 1428 01:07:03,917 --> 01:07:06,286 LINK AND AT THE BOTTOM AND THEN 1429 01:07:06,286 --> 01:07:08,121 IF YOU WANT TO LEARN MORE ABOUT 1430 01:07:08,121 --> 01:07:10,156 THE STUDY IT'S AT THE FIRST LINK 1431 01:07:10,156 --> 01:07:12,659 THERE. 1432 01:07:12,659 --> 01:07:14,027 AND THE OTHER WORKSHOP 1433 01:07:14,027 --> 01:07:17,030 PROCEEDINGS WILL BE PUBLISHED 1434 01:07:17,030 --> 01:07:20,900 THERE SOON AS WELL AS EVENTUALLY 1435 01:07:20,900 --> 01:07:22,936 THE FINAL CONSENSUS REPORT WILL 1436 01:07:22,936 --> 01:07:25,371 BE AVAILABLE THROUGH THE WEBSITE 1437 01:07:25,371 --> 01:07:25,672 AS WELL. 1438 01:07:25,672 --> 01:07:25,939 THANK YOU. 1439 01:07:25,939 --> 01:07:28,708 >> THANK YOU, EMILY. 1440 01:07:28,708 --> 01:07:31,711 >> YOU CAN SEE THE STUDY IS 1441 01:07:31,711 --> 01:07:37,884 SPONSORED BY THE FOLKS AT IMAGO 1442 01:07:37,884 --> 01:07:40,954 AND STEPHANIE, GEORGE AND I. 1443 01:07:40,954 --> 01:07:42,722 FRED, DID YOU WANT TO MAKE ANY 1444 01:07:42,722 --> 01:07:47,193 EXTRA COMMENTS? 1445 01:07:47,193 --> 01:07:49,896 >> THIS IS PROBABLY -- 1446 01:07:49,896 --> 01:07:56,436 >> THANK YOU, EMILY. 1447 01:07:56,436 --> 01:08:00,640 >> NEXT, ELANA. 1448 01:08:00,640 --> 01:08:02,642 >> I'M A STAFF FELLOW AT THE 1449 01:08:02,642 --> 01:08:05,912 DIVISION OF DIAGNOSTICS, IMAGING 1450 01:08:05,912 --> 01:08:08,715 AND RELIABILITY AT THE OFFICE OF 1451 01:08:08,715 --> 01:08:10,183 SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING LABS. 1452 01:08:10,183 --> 01:08:12,051 AS YOU HAVE HEARD PROBABLY FROM 1453 01:08:12,051 --> 01:08:13,853 THE MAJORITY OF THE INITIATIVES 1454 01:08:13,853 --> 01:08:18,324 IS THAT WE ALL WANT SAFE AND 1455 01:08:18,324 --> 01:08:19,492 EFFECTIVE A.I. THAT WOULD HELP 1456 01:08:19,492 --> 01:08:20,893 AND PUT IN MEDICAL DEVICES WE 1457 01:08:20,893 --> 01:08:24,664 WILL USE. 1458 01:08:24,664 --> 01:08:26,599 WE AT FDA SEE SUBMISSIONS THAT 1459 01:08:26,599 --> 01:08:28,868 COME IN. 1460 01:08:28,868 --> 01:08:32,138 ONE OF THE RECURRING ISSUES WE 1461 01:08:32,138 --> 01:08:34,407 SEE IS THE DEVICES THERE'S NOT 1462 01:08:34,407 --> 01:08:36,142 ENOUGH PATIENT DATA TO VALIDATE 1463 01:08:36,142 --> 01:08:37,910 THE DEVICES ON DIVERSE 1464 01:08:37,910 --> 01:08:41,047 POPULATIONS. 1465 01:08:41,047 --> 01:08:42,115 SO THE INITIATIVE I WANT TO 1466 01:08:42,115 --> 01:08:46,386 DESCRIBE IS WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO 1467 01:08:46,386 --> 01:08:47,854 EVALUATE DEVICES USING VIRTUAL 1468 01:08:47,854 --> 01:08:53,493 IN SILICO TOOLS SUCH AS MSM 1469 01:08:53,493 --> 01:08:54,761 TOOLS OR DIGITAL TOOLS OR 1470 01:08:54,761 --> 01:08:57,830 DIGITAL PHANTOMS. 1471 01:08:57,830 --> 01:08:59,666 WE HAVE PROJECTS IN 1472 01:08:59,666 --> 01:09:00,633 COLLABORATION START FROM 1473 01:09:00,633 --> 01:09:02,335 DEVELOPING DIGITAL PHANTOM WOULD 1474 01:09:02,335 --> 01:09:06,072 BE DIGITAL OR PHYSICAL PHANTOMS 1475 01:09:06,072 --> 01:09:08,308 USED FOR TESTING A.I. DEVICES 1476 01:09:08,308 --> 01:09:10,777 THAT WOULD BE USED BY SMALL 1477 01:09:10,777 --> 01:09:12,745 BUSINESSES AND COMPANIES TO 1478 01:09:12,745 --> 01:09:13,946 CALIBRATE THEM. 1479 01:09:13,946 --> 01:09:16,082 IN PARALLEL WE'RE ALSO 1480 01:09:16,082 --> 01:09:17,684 DEVELOPING COMPUTATIONAL TOOLS 1481 01:09:17,684 --> 01:09:19,319 FOR IN SILICO TRIALS. 1482 01:09:19,319 --> 01:09:20,153 ONE OF THE TOOLS THAT HAVE BEEN 1483 01:09:20,153 --> 01:09:23,656 DEVELOPED IN OUR GROUP IS THE 1484 01:09:23,656 --> 01:09:25,892 VIRTUAL IMAGING CLINICAL TRIAL 1485 01:09:25,892 --> 01:09:29,462 FOR VALIDATION SHOWING IT'S 1486 01:09:29,462 --> 01:09:31,164 POSSIBLE TO DO CLINICAL TRIAL 1487 01:09:31,164 --> 01:09:32,732 COMPLETELY IN SILICO AND MATCH 1488 01:09:32,732 --> 01:09:33,766 THE PATIENT DATA. 1489 01:09:33,766 --> 01:09:36,135 AN EMERGING APPLICATION AS WE 1490 01:09:36,135 --> 01:09:37,670 SEE A LOT OF THE DEVICES USE 1491 01:09:37,670 --> 01:09:39,005 A.I. 1492 01:09:39,005 --> 01:09:42,842 HOW CAN WE USE THESE IN SILICO 1493 01:09:42,842 --> 01:09:45,812 TOOLS TO MAKE DATA SO YOU DON'T 1494 01:09:45,812 --> 01:09:47,280 NEED TO COLLECT PATIENT DATA 1495 01:09:47,280 --> 01:09:48,848 INITIALLY TO TEST THEM. 1496 01:09:48,848 --> 01:09:51,851 YOU COULD SIMULATE DATA AND 1497 01:09:51,851 --> 01:09:53,019 PRETEST THEM WITHOUT HAVING TO 1498 01:09:53,019 --> 01:09:53,720 DIRECTLY GO TO PATIENTS FROM THE 1499 01:09:53,720 --> 01:10:01,861 START. 1500 01:10:01,861 --> 01:10:03,262 GIVEN THESE ACTIVITIES WE'RE 1501 01:10:03,262 --> 01:10:04,897 HERE AT IMAG. 1502 01:10:04,897 --> 01:10:08,868 WE WANT TO BUILD PARTNERSHIPS 1503 01:10:08,868 --> 01:10:11,137 WITH IMAGO AND MSM COMMUNITIES 1504 01:10:11,137 --> 01:10:12,438 TO FOSTER THE INNOVATIVE TOOLS 1505 01:10:12,438 --> 01:10:16,209 AND PUT THEM INTO PRACTICE AND 1506 01:10:16,209 --> 01:10:20,146 HELP DEVELOP SAFER DEVICES. 1507 01:10:20,146 --> 01:10:24,684 WE HAVE -- I'M JOINED BY DORNE 1508 01:10:24,684 --> 01:10:26,886 CARANZA THE DIRECTOR OF STRATEGY 1509 01:10:26,886 --> 01:10:28,087 PARTNERSHIPS AND WE ALSO HAVE A 1510 01:10:28,087 --> 01:10:29,355 BREAKOUT SESSION LATER IN THE 1511 01:10:29,355 --> 01:10:32,125 AFTERNOON AND WE WOULD LOVE TO 1512 01:10:32,125 --> 01:10:37,096 HEAR AND TALK TO YOU. 1513 01:10:37,096 --> 01:10:37,864 >> THANK YOU. 1514 01:10:37,864 --> 01:10:38,064 DAVE. 1515 01:10:38,064 --> 01:10:41,234 >> I'M DAVID MILLER A PROGRAM 1516 01:10:41,234 --> 01:10:42,635 DIRECTOR AT THE NATIONAL CANCER 1517 01:10:42,635 --> 01:10:44,637 INSTITUTE. 1518 01:10:44,637 --> 01:10:51,577 THIS PROGRAM I TCR SUPPORTS 1519 01:10:51,577 --> 01:10:53,913 INFORMATICS TECHNOLOGY 1520 01:10:53,913 --> 01:10:56,015 DEVELOPMENT SPANNING ALL ASPECTS 1521 01:10:56,015 --> 01:10:58,317 AND ALL EXTRAMURAL DIVISIONS 1522 01:10:58,317 --> 01:11:01,053 WORK, BASIC CANCER BIOLOGY 1523 01:11:01,053 --> 01:11:01,854 PREVENTION AND DIAGNOSIS AND 1524 01:11:01,854 --> 01:11:03,556 TREATMENT AND POPULATION 1525 01:11:03,556 --> 01:11:03,790 STUDIES. 1526 01:11:03,790 --> 01:11:06,426 DON'T BE DISMAYED AT THE 1527 01:11:06,426 --> 01:11:07,260 INFORMATICS NAME. 1528 01:11:07,260 --> 01:11:09,128 IT'S FUNDED MATHEMATICAL 1529 01:11:09,128 --> 01:11:10,563 MODELLING SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT 1530 01:11:10,563 --> 01:11:13,232 AT ALL STAGES OF THE SOFTWARE 1531 01:11:13,232 --> 01:11:15,501 DEVELOPMENT LIFE PSYCH FRAL 1532 01:11:15,501 --> 01:11:18,838 INITIAL ALGORITHMS TO WHOLE 1533 01:11:18,838 --> 01:11:19,806 MODELLING PLATFORMS WITH LARGE 1534 01:11:19,806 --> 01:11:20,206 USER COMMUNITIES. 1535 01:11:20,206 --> 01:11:23,176 CAN REACH OUT TO ME OR JULIE 1536 01:11:23,176 --> 01:11:25,511 CLEN WHO SHOULD BE ON THE SLIDE 1537 01:11:25,511 --> 01:11:27,280 HERE AND I'D ENCOURAGE TO YOU 1538 01:11:27,280 --> 01:11:28,714 CHECK OUT THE WEBSITE AND LOOK 1539 01:11:28,714 --> 01:11:30,583 AT THE HISTORY OF FUNDED 1540 01:11:30,583 --> 01:11:32,118 PROJECTS THAT HAVE COME UP 1541 01:11:32,118 --> 01:11:33,886 THROUGH THE PROGRAM. 1542 01:11:33,886 --> 01:11:37,290 >> THANKS, DAVE. 1543 01:11:37,290 --> 01:11:39,459 NOW ON TO THE NEXT CATEGORY, 1544 01:11:39,459 --> 01:11:43,463 EXPERIMENT DRIVEN INITIATIVES. 1545 01:11:43,463 --> 01:11:43,663 REED. 1546 01:11:43,663 --> 01:11:46,365 >> CAN YOU HEAR ME OKAY? 1547 01:11:46,365 --> 01:11:46,933 >> YEAH 1548 01:11:46,933 --> 01:11:49,469 >> I'M COMING TO YOU FROM THE 1549 01:11:49,469 --> 01:11:50,136 BACK OF THE ROOM. 1550 01:11:50,136 --> 01:11:51,904 NO NEED TO TURN AROUND. 1551 01:11:51,904 --> 01:11:54,207 I WANT TO BRIEFLY TALK ABOUT THE 1552 01:11:54,207 --> 01:11:55,908 NIAID SYSTEMS BIOLOGY FOR 1553 01:11:55,908 --> 01:11:57,743 INFECTIOUS DISEASE PROGRAM. 1554 01:11:57,743 --> 01:12:00,580 THIS IS A COMMUNITY INTEGRATING 1555 01:12:00,580 --> 01:12:02,048 EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY, 1556 01:12:02,048 --> 01:12:02,915 COMPUTATIONAL TOOLS AND 1557 01:12:02,915 --> 01:12:04,083 MODELLING ACROSS TIME AND SPACE 1558 01:12:04,083 --> 01:12:05,885 TO DEVELOP STRATEGIES THAT 1559 01:12:05,885 --> 01:12:08,521 PREDICT AND ALLEVIATE DISEASE 1560 01:12:08,521 --> 01:12:09,755 SEVERITY ACROSS HUMAN PATHOGENS. 1561 01:12:09,755 --> 01:12:11,691 YOU CAN GO TO THE WEBSITE ON THE 1562 01:12:11,691 --> 01:12:13,759 SCREEN TO LEARN ABOUT THE 1563 01:12:13,759 --> 01:12:14,494 CURRENTLY-FUNDED CENTERS. 1564 01:12:14,494 --> 01:12:16,162 THIS IS AN ONGOING PROGRAM BUT 1565 01:12:16,162 --> 01:12:17,497 WHAT I WANT TO HIGHLIGHT IS THAT 1566 01:12:17,497 --> 01:12:20,132 THEY ARE ALWAYS LOOKING FOR 1567 01:12:20,132 --> 01:12:20,466 COLLABORATORS. 1568 01:12:20,466 --> 01:12:21,501 YOU SHOULD REACH OUT TO THE 1569 01:12:21,501 --> 01:12:22,902 INDIVIDUALS ON THE WEBSITE AND 1570 01:12:22,902 --> 01:12:24,871 ASK ME ABOUT THE SYSTEMS BIOLOGY 1571 01:12:24,871 --> 01:12:27,640 CODEATHON IN CHICAGO ON 1572 01:12:27,640 --> 01:12:29,175 SEPTEMBER 25 WHERE WE'LL BE 1573 01:12:29,175 --> 01:12:31,244 INTEGRATING CLINICAL AND 1574 01:12:31,244 --> 01:12:33,913 SINGLE-SELL LUNG TRANSCRIPTOMIC 1575 01:12:33,913 --> 01:12:34,280 DATA. 1576 01:12:34,280 --> 01:12:36,015 THERE ARE WAYS TO HAVE TRAVEL 1577 01:12:36,015 --> 01:12:36,782 SPONSOR FOR INDIVIDUALS 1578 01:12:36,782 --> 01:12:37,049 SELECTED. 1579 01:12:37,049 --> 01:12:40,686 THANK YOU. 1580 01:12:40,686 --> 01:12:42,121 >> IF EVERYONE TURNS AROUND AND 1581 01:12:42,121 --> 01:12:43,089 WAVE TO REED HE'S THERE IN THE 1582 01:12:43,089 --> 01:12:49,896 BACK OF THE ROOM. 1583 01:12:49,896 --> 01:12:51,063 >> THANK YOU. 1584 01:12:51,063 --> 01:12:53,466 THEN WE HAVE HANNAH AND ERIC. 1585 01:12:53,466 --> 01:12:55,568 >> I'M GOING SPEAK FOR BOTH OF 1586 01:12:55,568 --> 01:12:55,968 THEM. 1587 01:12:55,968 --> 01:12:57,270 ME, DAVE, AGAIN. 1588 01:12:57,270 --> 01:12:59,438 FIRST UP ON THE LEFT SIDE THE 1589 01:12:59,438 --> 01:13:00,940 CANCER SYSTEMS BIOLOGY 1590 01:13:00,940 --> 01:13:02,542 CONSORTIUM OFFERS AN OPPORTUNITY 1591 01:13:02,542 --> 01:13:05,177 FOR ASSOCIATE MEMBERSHIP IN THE 1592 01:13:05,177 --> 01:13:06,112 CONSORTIUM TO ANYONE NOT 1593 01:13:06,112 --> 01:13:09,015 CURRENTLY FUNDED THROUGH A CSC 1594 01:13:09,015 --> 01:13:10,983 AWARD AND THERE'S ELIGIBILITY 1595 01:13:10,983 --> 01:13:12,385 CRITERIA AND EXPECTATIONS OF 1596 01:13:12,385 --> 01:13:13,786 MEMBERS AND APPLICATION FORM CAN 1597 01:13:13,786 --> 01:13:15,288 BE FOUND ON THE WEB PAGE LISTED 1598 01:13:15,288 --> 01:13:17,156 ON THE BOTTOM LEFT. 1599 01:13:17,156 --> 01:13:18,157 HANNAH IS THE PROGRAM CONTACT 1600 01:13:18,157 --> 01:13:20,326 FOR CSBC. 1601 01:13:20,326 --> 01:13:21,894 ON THE RIGHT SIDE THE GOAL OF 1602 01:13:21,894 --> 01:13:23,663 THE PHYSICAL SCIENCES ONCOLOGY 1603 01:13:23,663 --> 01:13:26,499 NETWORK IS TO PROMOTE A PHYSICAL 1604 01:13:26,499 --> 01:13:28,734 SCIENCES PERSPECTIVE AND FOSTER 1605 01:13:28,734 --> 01:13:29,936 PHYSICAL SCIENCE AND CANCER 1606 01:13:29,936 --> 01:13:31,971 RESEARCH BY FORMING TRANS 1607 01:13:31,971 --> 01:13:34,373 DISCIPLINARY TEAMS OF PHYSICAL 1608 01:13:34,373 --> 01:13:36,142 SCIENTISTS AND CANCER 1609 01:13:36,142 --> 01:13:37,643 RESEARCHERS WORKING CLOSELY 1610 01:13:37,643 --> 01:13:38,411 TOGETHER TO UNDERSTAND OUR 1611 01:13:38,411 --> 01:13:40,713 CANCER BIOLOGY AND ONCOLOGY. 1612 01:13:40,713 --> 01:13:43,649 MATH MODELLING AND THE 1613 01:13:43,649 --> 01:13:44,650 METHODOLOGIES ARE KEY COMPONENTS 1614 01:13:44,650 --> 01:13:46,919 TO ALL THESE AWARDS AND ERIC IS 1615 01:13:46,919 --> 01:13:49,322 THE CONTACT AND HE'S HERE IN THE 1616 01:13:49,322 --> 01:13:49,922 ROOM TODAY ON THE RIGHT SIDE 1617 01:13:49,922 --> 01:13:54,794 WITH HIS HAND UP. 1618 01:13:54,794 --> 01:13:56,128 >> ALL RIGHT. 1619 01:13:56,128 --> 01:14:05,905 THANKS, DAVID. 1620 01:14:05,905 --> 01:14:07,907 >> WENDY'S EXTRA SLIDE. 1621 01:14:07,907 --> 01:14:09,675 ALL THE EXTRA SLIDES ARE HERE. 1622 01:14:09,675 --> 01:14:16,015 YOU GUYS CAN GO TO THE WIKI. 1623 01:14:16,015 --> 01:14:17,316 >> WE'VE GOT LOTS OF EXTRA 1624 01:14:17,316 --> 01:14:18,050 INFORMATION ON THE WIKI. 1625 01:14:18,050 --> 01:14:20,119 ONCE AGAIN, CHECK THE WIKI FOR 1626 01:14:20,119 --> 01:14:23,489 ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. 1627 01:14:23,489 --> 01:14:26,759 SO, WE CAN SEGUE TO THE SECOND 1628 01:14:26,759 --> 01:14:28,461 PART OF OUR ROUNDTABLE WHICH IS 1629 01:14:28,461 --> 01:14:29,328 BASICALLY ASKING QUESTIONS AND 1630 01:14:29,328 --> 01:14:31,998 GENERATING DISCUSSION. 1631 01:14:31,998 --> 01:14:34,900 SO I WANTED TO START OFF BY 1632 01:14:34,900 --> 01:14:36,702 ASKING EVERYONE A GENERAL 1633 01:14:36,702 --> 01:14:36,969 QUESTION. 1634 01:14:36,969 --> 01:14:40,006 IT LOOKS LIKE THERE'S A MIXTURE 1635 01:14:40,006 --> 01:14:43,809 OF ACTIVE POSSIBILITIES WHERE 1636 01:14:43,809 --> 01:14:47,113 RFAs, CALL FOR APPLICATIONS AND 1637 01:14:47,113 --> 01:14:48,247 EXISTING PROGRAMS UNDERWAY. 1638 01:14:48,247 --> 01:14:50,716 I GUESS WHEN IT COMES TO THE 1639 01:14:50,716 --> 01:14:55,054 ACTIVE APPLICATIONS, ONE CONCERN 1640 01:14:55,054 --> 01:14:57,390 OFTEN WITH MULTISCALE MODELING 1641 01:14:57,390 --> 01:14:58,858 IS THE WORD OR TERM MULTISCALE 1642 01:14:58,858 --> 01:15:01,327 MODELING IS NOT ACTIVELY CALLED 1643 01:15:01,327 --> 01:15:04,063 OUT MANY TIMES IN THESE CALLS. 1644 01:15:04,063 --> 01:15:06,132 WHAT TYPES OF STRATEGIES SHOULD 1645 01:15:06,132 --> 01:15:09,635 WE USE IF SOMEONE IS A 1646 01:15:09,635 --> 01:15:11,704 MULTISCALE MODELER TO PUT 1647 01:15:11,704 --> 01:15:16,942 TOGETHER A PROPOSAL OR MAYBE 1648 01:15:16,942 --> 01:15:22,014 CONTACT THE PROGRAM OR THE 1649 01:15:22,014 --> 01:15:23,749 IMPORTANCE FOR NEED FOR 1650 01:15:23,749 --> 01:15:24,617 MULTISCALE NEED WITHIN THE 1651 01:15:24,617 --> 01:15:26,652 INITIATIVE AND WANT TO OPEN IT 1652 01:15:26,652 --> 01:15:30,656 UP TO ANYONE ON THE PANEL TO 1653 01:15:30,656 --> 01:15:31,857 OFFER ADVICE. 1654 01:15:31,857 --> 01:15:32,925 IF MULTISCALE MODELING IS NOT 1655 01:15:32,925 --> 01:15:34,260 ACTIVELY CALLED OUT IN YOUR 1656 01:15:34,260 --> 01:15:38,130 PROGRAM, HOW DOES ONE GET 1657 01:15:38,130 --> 01:15:48,007 INVOLVED? 1658 01:15:48,007 --> 01:15:51,744 >> SOME PATIENTS ARE SPECIFIED 1659 01:15:51,744 --> 01:15:55,915 WHEN WE LOOK FOR MONTHS AND 1660 01:15:55,915 --> 01:15:57,416 FOUNDATION OF MACHINE LEARNING 1661 01:15:57,416 --> 01:15:59,051 APPROACHES INCLUDING MULTISCALE 1662 01:15:59,051 --> 01:15:59,318 MODELING. 1663 01:15:59,318 --> 01:16:04,957 BUT FOCUS MORE ON THE BIOLOGICAL 1664 01:16:04,957 --> 01:16:05,324 SYSTEMS. 1665 01:16:05,324 --> 01:16:05,958 THOSE ARE IMPORTANT TOPICS FOR 1666 01:16:05,958 --> 01:16:16,168 OUR PROGRAM. 1667 01:16:17,970 --> 01:16:20,005 >> FOCUS ON THE SCIENCE AND IT 1668 01:16:20,005 --> 01:16:21,173 DOESN'T MATTER. 1669 01:16:21,173 --> 01:16:21,907 WE'LL HELP YOU FIND THE HOME FOR 1670 01:16:21,907 --> 01:16:27,646 IT. 1671 01:16:27,646 --> 01:16:29,415 >> I'LL SPEAK FOR NIH. 1672 01:16:29,415 --> 01:16:33,052 I'VE ALWAYS MENTIONED NIH IS 1673 01:16:33,052 --> 01:16:35,888 BASED ON A SUPPLY AND DEMAND 1674 01:16:35,888 --> 01:16:36,822 MECHANISM. 1675 01:16:36,822 --> 01:16:37,656 THE MORE MULTISCALE MODELING YOU 1676 01:16:37,656 --> 01:16:38,958 SUBMIT THE MORE THE STUDY 1677 01:16:38,958 --> 01:16:41,227 SECTIONS WILL HAVE TO BE CREATED 1678 01:16:41,227 --> 01:16:42,194 THE MORE THEY'LL RECRUIT YOU ALL 1679 01:16:42,194 --> 01:16:44,230 TO BE REVIEWERS AND THE MORE YOU 1680 01:16:44,230 --> 01:16:46,866 CAN MAKE MULTISCALE MODELING AT 1681 01:16:46,866 --> 01:16:47,933 THE NIH THE NATURAL WAY. 1682 01:16:47,933 --> 01:16:49,902 YOU DON'T HAVE TO RESPOND TO ANY 1683 01:16:49,902 --> 01:16:50,603 INITIATIVE. 1684 01:16:50,603 --> 01:16:53,072 YOU CAN JUST COME TO THE PARENT 1685 01:16:53,072 --> 01:16:54,306 ANNOUNCEMENTS AND JUST COME IN 1686 01:16:54,306 --> 01:16:58,043 AND THE MORE YOU COME IN THE 1687 01:16:58,043 --> 01:17:00,312 MORE IT WILL INCREASE THE 1688 01:17:00,312 --> 01:17:01,580 CULTURE OF MULTISCALE MODELING 1689 01:17:01,580 --> 01:17:02,648 AT THE NIH. 1690 01:17:02,648 --> 01:17:04,250 >> AND ALWAYS TALK TO YOUR 1691 01:17:04,250 --> 01:17:04,717 PROGRAM DIRECTOR. 1692 01:17:04,717 --> 01:17:06,986 THAT'S A MANTRA AT THE NIH. 1693 01:17:06,986 --> 01:17:08,521 YOU CAN TALK TO YOUR PROGRAM 1694 01:17:08,521 --> 01:17:11,023 DIRECTOR ABOUT ANY TOPIC. 1695 01:17:11,023 --> 01:17:12,424 SOME THINGS ARE CALLED DIFFERENT 1696 01:17:12,424 --> 01:17:12,658 THINGS. 1697 01:17:12,658 --> 01:17:15,528 I MENTIONED INFORMATICS 1698 01:17:15,528 --> 01:17:16,595 SPECIFICALLY BUT SOFTWARE 1699 01:17:16,595 --> 01:17:18,631 DEVELOPMENT WE HAVE A HISTORY OF 1700 01:17:18,631 --> 01:17:21,901 FUNDING MATHEMATICAL MODELS AND 1701 01:17:21,901 --> 01:17:24,170 PLATFORMS USED IN ANALYSIS OR 1702 01:17:24,170 --> 01:17:25,437 TREATMENT DIAGNOSIS. 1703 01:17:25,437 --> 01:17:26,939 SOMETIMES IT'S JUST A LANGUAGE 1704 01:17:26,939 --> 01:17:28,073 BARRIER AND ALWAYS WORTH TALKING 1705 01:17:28,073 --> 01:17:29,909 TO A PROGRAM DIRECTOR. 1706 01:17:29,909 --> 01:17:33,913 >> REACH OUT AND TALK TO YOUR 1707 01:17:33,913 --> 01:17:36,482 PROGRAM DIRECTORS. 1708 01:17:36,482 --> 01:17:38,617 THAT'S WHAT WE'RE HERE FOR AND 1709 01:17:38,617 --> 01:17:39,718 IF YOU WRITE A SPECIFIC AIMS 1710 01:17:39,718 --> 01:17:40,653 PAGE WE CAN HELP YOU OUT MORE 1711 01:17:40,653 --> 01:17:44,857 WITH THE WRITTEN WORDS . 1712 01:17:44,857 --> 01:17:46,992 >> WE DON'T EXPECT NOT TO GET 1713 01:17:46,992 --> 01:17:47,660 PROPOSALS FROM PEOPLE UNLESS WE 1714 01:17:47,660 --> 01:17:52,565 TALKED TO THEM. 1715 01:17:52,565 --> 01:17:56,335 IT WOULD COME OUT IN OUR 1716 01:17:56,335 --> 01:17:56,735 CONVERSATIONS. 1717 01:17:56,735 --> 01:17:59,004 I DON'T KNOW IF I CAN SPEAK FOR 1718 01:17:59,004 --> 01:18:00,439 FRED OR NOT. 1719 01:18:00,439 --> 01:18:06,045 >> I'LL REITERATE WHAT VIRGINIA 1720 01:18:06,045 --> 01:18:07,446 SAID WE DON'T LIKE SEEING 1721 01:18:07,446 --> 01:18:08,914 PROPOSALS WE DIDN'T EXPECT. 1722 01:18:08,914 --> 01:18:11,250 OUR PROGRAMS ARE WITHIN THE DOD. 1723 01:18:11,250 --> 01:18:13,919 WE'RE ESSENTIALLY SCIENCE 1724 01:18:13,919 --> 01:18:16,655 PROGRAMS WITHIN THE DOD SO WE 1725 01:18:16,655 --> 01:18:18,924 DON'T NECESSARILY FUND STRICTLY 1726 01:18:18,924 --> 01:18:20,059 MATHEMATICAL RESEARCH. 1727 01:18:20,059 --> 01:18:21,894 OUR PROGRAMS ARE DRIVEN TO BE 1728 01:18:21,894 --> 01:18:24,029 GENERAL BUT WITH AN EYE THAT 1729 01:18:24,029 --> 01:18:25,698 WOULD BE FUTURE DOD RELEVANT IN 1730 01:18:25,698 --> 01:18:32,705 15, 20 YEARS. 1731 01:18:32,705 --> 01:18:35,341 IF YOU HAVE AN IDEA FOR 1732 01:18:35,341 --> 01:18:36,876 MULTI-SCALE SYSTEMS IT'S 1733 01:18:36,876 --> 01:18:40,679 PROBABLY RELEVANT TO MY PROGRAM, 1734 01:18:40,679 --> 01:18:44,283 MY COLLEAGUE'S MATHEMATICAL 1735 01:18:44,283 --> 01:18:49,655 OPTION -- OPTIMIZATION PROGRAM 1736 01:18:49,655 --> 01:18:56,161 AND THE BEST WAY TO PITCH AN 1737 01:18:56,161 --> 01:18:58,898 IDEA IS A PARAGRAPH, MAYBE A 1738 01:18:58,898 --> 01:19:01,901 WHITE PAPER. 1739 01:19:01,901 --> 01:19:09,041 THANK YOU. 1740 01:19:09,041 --> 01:19:12,878 >> I ENCOURAGE APPLICANTS TO 1741 01:19:12,878 --> 01:19:18,150 REACH OUT TO DISCUSS IF THEY 1742 01:19:18,150 --> 01:19:20,920 FEEL THEY ARE IT DOESN'T FIT 1743 01:19:20,920 --> 01:19:25,324 WELL WITH THE STUDY SECTION. 1744 01:19:25,324 --> 01:19:27,793 YOU MAY DISCUSS THIS WITH YOUR 1745 01:19:27,793 --> 01:19:28,427 SCIENTIFIC REVIEW OFFICER AFTER 1746 01:19:28,427 --> 01:19:38,704 THE SUBMISSION. 1747 01:19:46,278 --> 01:19:49,081 IF YOU HAVE QUESTIONS RAISE YOUR 1748 01:19:49,081 --> 01:19:49,882 HAND. 1749 01:19:49,882 --> 01:19:52,017 THERE'S MICS IN THE AISLE. 1750 01:19:52,017 --> 01:19:53,385 WALK UP TO THE MIC AND FEEL FREE 1751 01:19:53,385 --> 01:20:03,696 TO ASK A QUESTION. 1752 01:20:08,233 --> 01:20:09,969 >> SOME OF THESE ARE TIGHTLY 1753 01:20:09,969 --> 01:20:20,512 FOCUSSED AT LEAST APPEAR TO BE. 1754 01:20:21,947 --> 01:20:24,883 ARE TE INITIATIVES APPROPRIATE 1755 01:20:24,883 --> 01:20:25,718 FOR MULTISCALE MODELING AND IF 1756 01:20:25,718 --> 01:20:28,187 SO HOW DOES ONE CONVINCE YOU'RE 1757 01:20:28,187 --> 01:20:30,155 FALLING WITHIN THE SCOPE AND 1758 01:20:30,155 --> 01:20:30,756 INTEGRATING OTHER ASPECTS AS 1759 01:20:30,756 --> 01:20:40,866 WELL. 1760 01:20:41,400 --> 01:20:44,069 >> I CAN SPEAK FOR VIRGINIA SHE 1761 01:20:44,069 --> 01:20:47,306 CAN CORRECT ME IF NOT AND OUR 1762 01:20:47,306 --> 01:20:48,807 CALLS ARE VAGUE ON PURPOSE. 1763 01:20:48,807 --> 01:20:50,075 DON'T ASK FOR ANYTHING SPECIFIC. 1764 01:20:50,075 --> 01:20:51,377 THERE'S MORE MONEY IN THE 1765 01:20:51,377 --> 01:20:52,678 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE THAT GOES 1766 01:20:52,678 --> 01:20:54,213 TO THINGS THAT ARE SPECIFIC. 1767 01:20:54,213 --> 01:20:56,148 WE GET A SMALL CHUNK FOR 1768 01:20:56,148 --> 01:21:03,922 SCIENCE. 1769 01:21:03,922 --> 01:21:05,891 WHAT I WOULD SAY IN MY PROGRAM 1770 01:21:05,891 --> 01:21:08,660 IS THAT I DON'T WANT SOMETHING 1771 01:21:08,660 --> 01:21:13,665 SPECIFIC BASED OFF SPECIFIC 1772 01:21:13,665 --> 01:21:13,966 APPLICATION. 1773 01:21:13,966 --> 01:21:15,000 I WANT SOMETHING THAT COWL BE 1774 01:21:15,000 --> 01:21:17,169 EXPANDED TO MANY APPLICATIONS. 1775 01:21:17,169 --> 01:21:20,139 I LOOK FOR WHY IS IT INTERESTING 1776 01:21:20,139 --> 01:21:21,673 MATHEMATICALLY, WHY IS IT HARD? 1777 01:21:21,673 --> 01:21:25,878 WHY CAN'T WE DO IT NOW? 1778 01:21:25,878 --> 01:21:29,882 WHAT ARE YOU BRINGING TO THE 1779 01:21:29,882 --> 01:21:31,583 TABLE THAT WILL ENABLE THINGS TO 1780 01:21:31,583 --> 01:21:33,886 BE DONE IN THE FUTURE. 1781 01:21:33,886 --> 01:21:36,255 THAT'S WHAT I'LL SAY. 1782 01:21:36,255 --> 01:21:37,790 >> AN INTERESTING AND RELEVANT 1783 01:21:37,790 --> 01:21:42,294 APPLICATION IS LIKE A PROOF OF 1784 01:21:42,294 --> 01:21:43,262 PRINCIPLE OF THE WORK IS A BONUS 1785 01:21:43,262 --> 01:21:51,070 FOR OUR PROGRAMS. 1786 01:21:51,070 --> 01:21:53,505 >> AT THE NIH OVER HALF THE 1787 01:21:53,505 --> 01:21:55,074 APPLICATIONS THAT COME IN GO TO 1788 01:21:55,074 --> 01:21:56,208 THE BROAD CALL WE HAVE WHERE 1789 01:21:56,208 --> 01:21:57,376 THERE IS NO SPECIFIC GUIDELINES 1790 01:21:57,376 --> 01:21:58,877 FOR WHAT COMES IN. 1791 01:21:58,877 --> 01:22:00,446 TALK TO YOUR PROGRAM DIRECTOR 1792 01:22:00,446 --> 01:22:01,914 AND IF WE DECIDE THAT YES, 1793 01:22:01,914 --> 01:22:02,648 YOU'RE NOT RIGHT FOR THIS 1794 01:22:02,648 --> 01:22:03,949 PROGRAM OR THIS PROGRAM BUT YOU 1795 01:22:03,949 --> 01:22:07,519 CAN COME IN AS AN 1796 01:22:07,519 --> 01:22:08,153 INVESTIGATOR-INITIATED RO1 OR 1797 01:22:08,153 --> 01:22:09,154 OTHER MECHANISMS AND YOU HAVE 1798 01:22:09,154 --> 01:22:11,023 THE VISION FOR YOUR SCIENCE AND 1799 01:22:11,023 --> 01:22:13,258 WHAT IT NEEDS TO BE AND IT WILL 1800 01:22:13,258 --> 01:22:14,426 GO TO OUR APPROPRIATE STUDY 1801 01:22:14,426 --> 01:22:23,502 SECTION FOR WHAT YOU SUBMITTED. 1802 01:22:23,502 --> 01:22:25,537 >> MY QUESTION IS FOR DAVID 1803 01:22:25,537 --> 01:22:26,138 MILLER. 1804 01:22:26,138 --> 01:22:29,208 YOU I SAW YOU HAD SOFTWARE 1805 01:22:29,208 --> 01:22:30,175 SUSTAINABILITY WHICH IS EXCITING 1806 01:22:30,175 --> 01:22:36,482 FOR THE TYPE OF WORK I'M 1807 01:22:36,482 --> 01:22:36,882 INTERESTED IN. 1808 01:22:36,882 --> 01:22:39,651 HOW DO YOU DECIDE OR WHAT IS 1809 01:22:39,651 --> 01:22:42,020 YOUR CRITERIA IN THE U24 FOR 1810 01:22:42,020 --> 01:22:43,989 THINGS YOU'D INVEST IN? 1811 01:22:43,989 --> 01:22:46,825 WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE GITHUB 1812 01:22:46,825 --> 01:22:47,259 ISSUES? 1813 01:22:47,259 --> 01:22:50,162 HOW DO YOU DECIDE THIS IS 1814 01:22:50,162 --> 01:22:53,966 SOFTWARE THAT IS WORTH 1815 01:22:53,966 --> 01:22:55,968 CONTINUING ON? 1816 01:22:55,968 --> 01:22:59,471 SUSTAINABILITY AND I THINK THE 1817 01:22:59,471 --> 01:23:02,841 WAY A LOT OF SOFTWARE IS KEPT 1818 01:23:02,841 --> 01:23:05,177 ALIVE AND ADDING FEATURES OR 1819 01:23:05,177 --> 01:23:09,148 CLEANING OUT COBWEBS FROM 1820 01:23:09,148 --> 01:23:10,415 SOFTWARE THAT HAS BUILD INTO 1821 01:23:10,415 --> 01:23:12,384 MESSES OF THINGS OVER TIME AND 1822 01:23:12,384 --> 01:23:13,485 TRYING TO UNDERSTAND WHAT YOUR 1823 01:23:13,485 --> 01:23:14,586 THINKING IS AND A GOOD 1824 01:23:14,586 --> 01:23:17,022 APPLICATION AND THINGS YOU WANT 1825 01:23:17,022 --> 01:23:18,390 TO SEE HAPPEN? 1826 01:23:18,390 --> 01:23:19,992 >> THANKS, THIS IS A GOOD 1827 01:23:19,992 --> 01:23:21,193 EXAMPLE OF TALKING TO YOUR 1828 01:23:21,193 --> 01:23:24,296 PROGRAM DIRECTOR. 1829 01:23:24,296 --> 01:23:25,964 WITH 30 SECONDS WE DIDN'T HAVE 1830 01:23:25,964 --> 01:23:26,165 TIME. 1831 01:23:26,165 --> 01:23:29,034 THE U24 THE TITLE IS SOFTWARE 1832 01:23:29,034 --> 01:23:30,769 SUSTAINABILITY IS MEANT FOR 1833 01:23:30,769 --> 01:23:32,571 LARGE SOFTWARE TOOLS LIKE WE 1834 01:23:32,571 --> 01:23:35,974 FUNDED GALAXY AND IGB. 1835 01:23:35,974 --> 01:23:37,743 IF THE SOFTWARE WERE TO BE TAKEN 1836 01:23:37,743 --> 01:23:41,280 AWAY WOULD BE A DENT TO THE 1837 01:23:41,280 --> 01:23:41,547 COMMUNITY. 1838 01:23:41,547 --> 01:23:51,390 IT HAS THOUSANDS OF IF NOT TENS 1839 01:23:51,390 --> 01:23:53,892 OF THOUSANDS USERS. 1840 01:23:53,892 --> 01:23:57,563 IT'S A LARGE U24 FOR LARGE 1841 01:23:57,563 --> 01:23:57,863 TOOLS. 1842 01:23:57,863 --> 01:23:59,164 IF YOUR INTENT IS TO BRING 1843 01:23:59,164 --> 01:24:01,133 SOFTWARE UP TO DATE AND EXPAND 1844 01:24:01,133 --> 01:24:04,970 IT, IT'S MORE ABOUT THE STAGE 1845 01:24:04,970 --> 01:24:05,904 THE SOFTWARE WILL BE IN AND IF 1846 01:24:05,904 --> 01:24:08,173 YOU'RE TRYING TO BREAK INTO A 1847 01:24:08,173 --> 01:24:14,813 KNEW -- NEW COMMUNITY AND 1848 01:24:14,813 --> 01:24:15,847 THAT'S SOMETHING WE CAN WORK OUT 1849 01:24:15,847 --> 01:24:17,115 AND WHAT ARE YOUR GOALS FOR THE 1850 01:24:17,115 --> 01:24:17,883 SOFTWARE. 1851 01:24:17,883 --> 01:24:21,887 >> THANK YOU. 1852 01:24:21,887 --> 01:24:28,193 >> NEXT QUESTION. 1853 01:24:28,193 --> 01:24:30,596 >> YOU SEPARATED MECHANISTIC 1854 01:24:30,596 --> 01:24:31,630 MODELS FROM A.I. 1855 01:24:31,630 --> 01:24:34,333 IF YOU DIVE LOW ENOUGH TO THE 1856 01:24:34,333 --> 01:24:35,968 MATHEMATICS YOU'LL FIND THEY'RE 1857 01:24:35,968 --> 01:24:37,903 NOT THAT DIFFERENT EXCEPT FOR 1858 01:24:37,903 --> 01:24:39,204 COMPUTING POWER AND THINGS LIKE 1859 01:24:39,204 --> 01:24:41,907 THIS SO WHY DO YOU MAKE THE 1860 01:24:41,907 --> 01:24:51,717 SEPARATION? 1861 01:24:51,717 --> 01:24:52,584 >> YOUR QUESTION? 1862 01:24:52,584 --> 01:24:55,587 >> SEPARATING MECHANISTIC MODEL 1863 01:24:55,587 --> 01:24:57,889 FROM A.I. AND WHY THE 1864 01:24:57,889 --> 01:25:02,894 SEPARATION? 1865 01:25:02,894 --> 01:25:05,831 >> THE QUESTION IS WHY SEPARATE 1866 01:25:05,831 --> 01:25:08,467 A.I. FROM MECHANISTIC MODELS AND 1867 01:25:08,467 --> 01:25:13,672 I THINK THAT TIES INTO A 1868 01:25:13,672 --> 01:25:15,507 QUESTION ONLINE. 1869 01:25:15,507 --> 01:25:16,908 WHEN MECHANISTIC MODELS AREN'T 1870 01:25:16,908 --> 01:25:17,843 SPECIFICALLY CALLED OUT AND 1871 01:25:17,843 --> 01:25:22,614 THERE'S AN A.I. CALL. 1872 01:25:22,614 --> 01:25:26,918 HOW DOES ONE MELD THIS SEEMING 1873 01:25:26,918 --> 01:25:29,321 DIFFERENCE WHEN PEOPLE THINK OF 1874 01:25:29,321 --> 01:25:31,723 A.I. AND MECHANISTIC MODELS. 1875 01:25:31,723 --> 01:25:32,624 IS THERE THAT DISTINCTION WITH 1876 01:25:32,624 --> 01:25:37,896 EACH OF YOUR INITIATIVES AND IF 1877 01:25:37,896 --> 01:25:39,531 NOT HOW DOES ONE BRING 1878 01:25:39,531 --> 01:25:49,908 MECHANISTIC MODELLING INTO IT. 1879 01:25:49,908 --> 01:25:57,049 >> WE COMBINED THE MACHINE 1880 01:25:57,049 --> 01:26:02,154 LEARNING AND A.I. AND 1881 01:26:02,154 --> 01:26:03,622 COMMUNICATION. 1882 01:26:03,622 --> 01:26:06,625 THAT WOULD GO TO THE RELIABILITY 1883 01:26:06,625 --> 01:26:08,360 OF THE MIXED USE MODELS. 1884 01:26:08,360 --> 01:26:10,495 >> I WANT TO ADD IN NSF WE'RE 1885 01:26:10,495 --> 01:26:12,597 LOOKING AT A LOT OF THIS. 1886 01:26:12,597 --> 01:26:13,332 THIS IS AN INTERESTING 1887 01:26:13,332 --> 01:26:14,299 INTERSECTION FOR THE SCIENCE 1888 01:26:14,299 --> 01:26:15,767 WHERE A.I. AND MECHANISTIC 1889 01:26:15,767 --> 01:26:16,902 MODELS COME TOGETHER. 1890 01:26:16,902 --> 01:26:22,341 WE'RE NOT SPECIFYING EITHER. 1891 01:26:22,341 --> 01:26:24,009 >> FOR US WE CONSIDER FOR 1892 01:26:24,009 --> 01:26:25,811 EXAMPLE IF YOU'RE MECHANISTIC 1893 01:26:25,811 --> 01:26:27,779 MODEL IT MAY HAVE ADVANTAGES 1894 01:26:27,779 --> 01:26:29,948 OVER A.I. BECAUSE IT MAY BE 1895 01:26:29,948 --> 01:26:31,416 PHYSICS BASED AND MAY BE A LOT 1896 01:26:31,416 --> 01:26:33,885 OF KNOWLEDGE THAT WENT INTO IT 1897 01:26:33,885 --> 01:26:36,722 THAT A.I. MAY OR MAY NOT 1898 01:26:36,722 --> 01:26:36,955 CAPTURE. 1899 01:26:36,955 --> 01:26:39,758 IT'S AN AREA OF CONCERN FOR US 1900 01:26:39,758 --> 01:26:40,859 FOR WHICH MODEL DO WE SELECT AND 1901 01:26:40,859 --> 01:26:41,560 WHAT IS BEST FOR A PARTICULAR 1902 01:26:41,560 --> 01:26:46,798 THING. 1903 01:26:46,798 --> 01:26:49,267 >> IT SOUNDS LIKE THAT 1904 01:26:49,267 --> 01:26:50,602 DISTINCTION ISN'T BEING MADE 1905 01:26:50,602 --> 01:26:53,572 BETWEEN SOMETHING THAT'S A 1906 01:26:53,572 --> 01:26:55,073 NON-MECHANISTIC A.I. 1907 01:26:55,073 --> 01:26:56,575 ANOTHER QUESTION UP THERE. 1908 01:26:56,575 --> 01:26:57,843 >> ANY INTEREST IN THE 1909 01:26:57,843 --> 01:27:00,946 DEVELOPMENT OF METHODS FOR 1910 01:27:00,946 --> 01:27:02,647 GENERATING SYNTHETIC DATA TO 1911 01:27:02,647 --> 01:27:06,118 AUGMENT SOME OF THE A.I. 1912 01:27:06,118 --> 01:27:07,619 SYSTEMS? 1913 01:27:07,619 --> 01:27:13,759 USING MECHANISTIC MODELS? 1914 01:27:13,759 --> 01:27:15,260 I KNOW THERE'S BEEN DISPUTE 1915 01:27:15,260 --> 01:27:16,228 ABOUT THAT ACTIVITY. 1916 01:27:16,228 --> 01:27:17,896 >> WE'RE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT 1917 01:27:17,896 --> 01:27:19,498 WHICH MODELS CAN WE GENERATE 1918 01:27:19,498 --> 01:27:20,298 DATA AND HOW CREDIBLE THAT DATA 1919 01:27:20,298 --> 01:27:25,904 IS. 1920 01:27:25,904 --> 01:27:34,479 >> YES. 1921 01:27:34,479 --> 01:27:39,484 >> I WORK IN A.I. AND I GAVE A 1922 01:27:39,484 --> 01:27:41,353 TALK AT NIH A COUPLE YEARS AGO 1923 01:27:41,353 --> 01:27:42,854 AND ONE OF THE POINTS I WAS 1924 01:27:42,854 --> 01:27:47,192 TRYING TO MAKE PEOPLE AWARE 1925 01:27:47,192 --> 01:27:48,193 WHICH I THINK EVERYBODY'S AWARE 1926 01:27:48,193 --> 01:27:53,899 BUT DON'T TALK ABOUT IT AND I 1927 01:27:53,899 --> 01:27:58,537 SAW ONE OF THE LINK ON IMPERFECT 1928 01:27:58,537 --> 01:28:02,774 DATA AND THE PROBLEM IS FOR BIO 1929 01:28:02,774 --> 01:28:03,875 MEDICAL APPLICATIONS. 1930 01:28:03,875 --> 01:28:09,714 I DON'T SEE ANY ACTIVE RESEARCH 1931 01:28:09,714 --> 01:28:15,086 ON THAT FOR EXAMPLE, IF YOU WORK 1932 01:28:15,086 --> 01:28:21,760 ON PREDICTING HIPE -- 1933 01:28:21,760 --> 01:28:26,465 HYPOGLYCEMIA AND DIABETES BUT 1934 01:28:26,465 --> 01:28:28,934 THERE IS A HUGE DATA IMBALANCE. 1935 01:28:28,934 --> 01:28:30,836 PEOPLE IN COMPUTER SCIENCE ARE 1936 01:28:30,836 --> 01:28:34,940 USING SOME METHODS WHICH ARE 1937 01:28:34,940 --> 01:28:36,808 GOOD FOR IMAGE COMPUTER VISION 1938 01:28:36,808 --> 01:28:37,742 AND NOT NECESSARILY FOR THE 1939 01:28:37,742 --> 01:28:41,046 SYSTEMS WE'RE LOOKING AT. 1940 01:28:41,046 --> 01:28:42,647 THERE ARE SOME CLASSICAL METHODS 1941 01:28:42,647 --> 01:28:46,418 BUT NOT APPROPRIATE. 1942 01:28:46,418 --> 01:28:49,287 I DON'T KNOW IF -- OF COURSE YOU 1943 01:28:49,287 --> 01:28:50,155 NEED DATA. 1944 01:28:50,155 --> 01:28:55,293 I'M TALKING ABOUT WE'RE TRYING 1945 01:28:55,293 --> 01:28:56,862 TO FOCUS ON PATHOLOGY COMPARED 1946 01:28:56,862 --> 01:29:02,067 TO CONTROL IN ALL DISEASE ACROSS 1947 01:29:02,067 --> 01:29:04,703 INSTITUTES SHOULD BE INTERESTED. 1948 01:29:04,703 --> 01:29:07,205 THERE'S IMBALANCE IN DATA AND 1949 01:29:07,205 --> 01:29:09,708 GIMMICKS LIKE THAT OR SPRINKLING 1950 01:29:09,708 --> 01:29:12,310 NOISE OR SUB SAMPLING A MAJORITY 1951 01:29:12,310 --> 01:29:14,579 CLASS WILL NOT DO THE TRICK. 1952 01:29:14,579 --> 01:29:15,213 THERE'S HUGE BIAS. 1953 01:29:15,213 --> 01:29:17,849 I'D LIKE IT HEAR ABOUT THE 1954 01:29:17,849 --> 01:29:22,654 INITIATIVES OR ANY INITIATIVES 1955 01:29:22,654 --> 01:29:27,859 IN ALL THE METHODS. 1956 01:29:27,859 --> 01:29:32,097 >> BRIDGE TO A.I. IS ONE OF THE 1957 01:29:32,097 --> 01:29:35,634 CHALLENGES TO ADDRESS DATA 1958 01:29:35,634 --> 01:29:40,438 IMBALANCE AND WE USE GRAND 1959 01:29:40,438 --> 01:29:41,439 CHALLENGES TO MOTIVATE THE 1960 01:29:41,439 --> 01:29:42,908 DECISION TO CAPTURE WHICH DATA 1961 01:29:42,908 --> 01:29:45,176 BUT AS YOU SAID WE WANT THE DATA 1962 01:29:45,176 --> 01:29:47,546 TO BE AM LICKABLE BEYOND THE ONE 1963 01:29:47,546 --> 01:29:48,647 GRANT CHALLENGE AND SCALE 1964 01:29:48,647 --> 01:29:49,881 BETWEEN GRAND CHALLENGERS AND 1965 01:29:49,881 --> 01:29:50,482 HAVE DATA TYPES TALK TO EACH 1966 01:29:50,482 --> 01:29:54,719 OTHER. 1967 01:29:54,719 --> 01:29:56,154 WOULD BE WONDERFUL TO CONTRIBUTE 1968 01:29:56,154 --> 01:29:58,623 YOUR THOUGHTS ABOUT DATA 1969 01:29:58,623 --> 01:29:59,791 IMBALANCE TO OUR THOUGHT IN 1970 01:29:59,791 --> 01:30:01,426 BRIDGE TO A.I. WHEN HAVE YOU A 1971 01:30:01,426 --> 01:30:01,660 CHANCE. 1972 01:30:01,660 --> 01:30:03,628 IF YOU CAN POST IT ON THE WIKI 1973 01:30:03,628 --> 01:30:04,195 IT WOULD BE WRITTEN DOWN. 1974 01:30:04,195 --> 01:30:13,638 THANK YOU. 1975 01:30:13,638 --> 01:30:24,049 >> YOU WANT ME TO MUTE? 1976 01:30:31,790 --> 01:30:33,024 >> I CAN'T HEAR NATCHER SO I'LL 1977 01:30:33,024 --> 01:30:34,726 ASSUME IT'S A YES. 1978 01:30:34,726 --> 01:30:36,695 I WANTED TO MAKE A COUPLE 1979 01:30:36,695 --> 01:30:41,633 COMMENTS ABOUT ONE OF THE 1980 01:30:41,633 --> 01:30:44,135 QUESTIONS IN THE CHAT OR IN THE 1981 01:30:44,135 --> 01:30:44,736 WIKI AND THE DATA IMBALANCE 1982 01:30:44,736 --> 01:30:52,377 COMMENTS. 1983 01:30:52,377 --> 01:30:54,846 I DIDN'T HAVE A CHANCE TO TOUCH 1984 01:30:54,846 --> 01:30:56,581 ON THE NCI COLLABORATION WITH 1985 01:30:56,581 --> 01:30:57,382 THE DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY. 1986 01:30:57,382 --> 01:31:00,819 IT'S A LONG-STANDING STRATEGY 1987 01:31:00,819 --> 01:31:06,191 PARTNERSHIP THAT STARTED BACK IN 1988 01:31:06,191 --> 01:31:08,493 2016 AND TO HAVE A STABLE 1989 01:31:08,493 --> 01:31:14,165 PARTNERSHIP. 1990 01:31:14,165 --> 01:31:15,600 SURGE IN QUANTIFICATION HAS BEEN 1991 01:31:15,600 --> 01:31:20,472 CRITICAL TO THE PROJECTS WE'VE 1992 01:31:20,472 --> 01:31:25,910 BEEN PURSUING I'LL GIVE ONE 1993 01:31:25,910 --> 01:31:28,213 EXAMPLE. 1994 01:31:28,213 --> 01:31:33,718 ONE PROJECT LOOKS AT DEVELOPING 1995 01:31:33,718 --> 01:31:35,387 ALGORITHMS FOR EXTRACTING TEXT 1996 01:31:35,387 --> 01:31:36,955 FROM ELECTRONIC PATHOLOGY 1997 01:31:36,955 --> 01:31:40,792 REPORTS PART OF NCI PROGRAMS 1998 01:31:40,792 --> 01:31:41,893 SURVEILLANCE EPIDEMIOLOGY AND 1999 01:31:41,893 --> 01:31:49,234 RESULTS PROGRAM. 2000 01:31:49,234 --> 01:31:56,174 AND IT'S ON PAR WITH WHAT OTHERS 2001 01:31:56,174 --> 01:32:01,880 DO. 2002 01:32:01,880 --> 01:32:05,583 IN ORDER TO HAVE THEM DEPLOYED 2003 01:32:05,583 --> 01:32:07,085 QUANTIFICATION WAS CRITICAL TO 2004 01:32:07,085 --> 01:32:07,752 GIVE CONFIDENCE TO THE RESULT 2005 01:32:07,752 --> 01:32:10,855 AND THERE WAS A METHOD THEY CALL 2006 01:32:10,855 --> 01:32:12,757 DEEP ABSTAINING CLASSIFIER. 2007 01:32:12,757 --> 01:32:18,063 THERE'S A COUPLE PUBLICATIONS ON 2008 01:32:18,063 --> 01:32:25,904 THIS THE LINKS WILL TAKE TO YOU 2009 01:32:25,904 --> 01:32:27,572 THE COMPREHENSIVE PUBLICATIONS 2010 01:32:27,572 --> 01:32:34,679 AND YOU CAN READ MORE ABOUT THE 2011 01:32:34,679 --> 01:32:34,979 CLASSIFIER. 2012 01:32:34,979 --> 01:32:39,084 THIS ALLOWS RESEARCHERS TO 2013 01:32:39,084 --> 01:32:45,724 ABSTAIN OR NOT OBTAIN RESULTS 2014 01:32:45,724 --> 01:32:47,158 WHEN THE ANSWER IS UNCERTAIN AND 2015 01:32:47,158 --> 01:32:52,597 USING THIS CLASSIFIER THE TEAM 2016 01:32:52,597 --> 01:32:55,734 IS ABLE TO ACHIEVE 97% ACCURACY 2017 01:32:55,734 --> 01:33:06,211 ON ABOUT 20% OF THE REPORTS. 2018 01:33:07,312 --> 01:33:09,848 AND IF YOU WANT INFORMATION ON A 2019 01:33:09,848 --> 01:33:13,585 LARGER CORPUS OF DATA MAYBE YOU 2020 01:33:13,585 --> 01:33:18,423 SAY MY ACCURACY IS 95%. 2021 01:33:18,423 --> 01:33:22,861 THAT'S ONE EXAMPLE OF 2022 01:33:22,861 --> 01:33:24,763 COLLABORATION HOW QUANTIFICATION 2023 01:33:24,763 --> 01:33:26,197 HAS BEEN CRITICAL. 2024 01:33:26,197 --> 01:33:33,905 I WANTED TO TOUCH ON DATA 2025 01:33:33,905 --> 01:33:40,779 IMBALANCE AND CANCER DATA IS 2026 01:33:40,779 --> 01:33:43,448 HIGHLY IMBALANCED AND GETS EVEN 2027 01:33:43,448 --> 01:33:45,416 MORE IMBALANCED WHEN YOU THINK 2028 01:33:45,416 --> 01:33:51,489 AT ALL ABOUT RARE CANCER TYPES 2029 01:33:51,489 --> 01:33:53,291 FOR CERTAIN POPULATIONS OF 2030 01:33:53,291 --> 01:33:55,093 INDIVIDUALS WHERE THERE'S JUST 2031 01:33:55,093 --> 01:33:56,761 NOT A LOT OF DATA AND WILL NEVER 2032 01:33:56,761 --> 01:33:58,163 BE A LOT OF DATA. 2033 01:33:58,163 --> 01:34:04,202 IN APRIL WE HELD A VERY 2034 01:34:04,202 --> 01:34:08,072 SUCCESSFUL WORKSHOP ON NEW 2035 01:34:08,072 --> 01:34:18,316 METHODS WITH DATA IMBALANCES. 2036 01:34:18,316 --> 01:34:21,986 ONE OF THE MAIN AREAS OF THAT 2037 01:34:21,986 --> 01:34:24,589 IMPERFECT DATA WE'LL HAVE A 2038 01:34:24,589 --> 01:34:26,291 WHITE PAPER THAT WILL BE 2039 01:34:26,291 --> 01:34:29,894 DESCRIBING MORE ABOUT THE 2040 01:34:29,894 --> 01:34:32,697 ALGORITHMIC AND DATA METHODS 2041 01:34:32,697 --> 01:34:35,033 DISCUSSED AT THAT WORKSHOP. 2042 01:34:35,033 --> 01:34:37,669 WE ALSO HAVE AT NCI SOMETHING 2043 01:34:37,669 --> 01:34:39,404 CALLED THE CANCER RESEARCH DATA 2044 01:34:39,404 --> 01:34:41,005 COMMONS. 2045 01:34:41,005 --> 01:34:42,440 I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY PEOPLE IN 2046 01:34:42,440 --> 01:34:44,709 THE AUDIENCE MAY BE RESEARCH 2047 01:34:44,709 --> 01:34:49,881 WITH THIS BUT IT'S ONE OF THE 2048 01:34:49,881 --> 01:34:58,556 MAJOR DATA REPOSITORIES AT NIH. 2049 01:34:58,556 --> 01:35:03,361 IT HAS MULTIPLE GENOMICS AND 2050 01:35:03,361 --> 01:35:06,297 PROTEOMICS DATA AND DOING A DEEP 2051 01:35:06,297 --> 01:35:10,935 DIVE ASSESSMENT ON WHERE THERE'S 2052 01:35:10,935 --> 01:35:20,311 GAPS IN THESE COMMONS THAT MAY 2053 01:35:20,311 --> 01:35:22,247 DETRACT FROM THE QUOTE, A.I. 2054 01:35:22,247 --> 01:35:23,581 READINESS DATA AND LOOKING AT 2055 01:35:23,581 --> 01:35:25,683 DATA BALANCES IS A BIG PART OF 2056 01:35:25,683 --> 01:35:27,085 WHAT WE'RE UNDERTAKING IN THE 2057 01:35:27,085 --> 01:35:27,952 ASSESSMENT AS WELL. 2058 01:35:27,952 --> 01:35:28,319 I'LL STOP THERE. 2059 01:35:28,319 --> 01:35:33,892 THANKS. 2060 01:35:44,469 --> 01:35:46,204 >> THE ENVIRONMENT HAS BEEN A 2061 01:35:46,204 --> 01:35:49,774 GOOD RESOURCE FOR DATA AND WE 2062 01:35:49,774 --> 01:35:53,177 TRY TO OUT IN THE NEGATIVE AND 2063 01:35:53,177 --> 01:35:56,748 POSITIVE DATA THAT'S AVAILABLE 2064 01:35:56,748 --> 01:36:05,890 AND THE EPA DASHBOARD IS GOOD A 2065 01:36:05,890 --> 01:36:09,794 GOOD SOURCE FOR DATA. 2066 01:36:09,794 --> 01:36:13,932 WHAT I WANT TO EMPHASIZE IF YOU 2067 01:36:13,932 --> 01:36:19,070 GO TO SLIDE 28 THERE'S AN OPEN 2068 01:36:19,070 --> 01:36:24,375 RFA TO THE DIRECTOR WORKING 2069 01:36:24,375 --> 01:36:30,381 GROUP ON BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH. 2070 01:36:30,381 --> 01:36:38,856 IT'S TO USE OF THIS AND THEY'RE 2071 01:36:38,856 --> 01:36:42,961 REQUEST 2072 01:36:42,961 --> 01:36:45,964 REQUESTING THIS IS GOING TO 2073 01:36:45,964 --> 01:36:50,068 ENCOMPASS IN SILICO AND THE 2074 01:36:50,068 --> 01:36:54,439 CRITICAL PART OF THE METHOD 2075 01:36:54,439 --> 01:36:58,910 METHODOLOGIES FOR TRANSLATION 2076 01:36:58,910 --> 01:37:00,745 AND APPLICATION TO RELY 2077 01:37:00,745 --> 01:37:04,549 EXTREMELY HEAVILY ON THE USE OF 2078 01:37:04,549 --> 01:37:11,456 THE SYSTEMS MODEL AND MULTISCALE 2079 01:37:11,456 --> 01:37:18,463 MODELS. 2080 01:37:18,463 --> 01:37:21,899 IT'S OPEN TO AUGUST. 2081 01:37:21,899 --> 01:37:24,469 PLEASE RESPOND TO IT AND I 2082 01:37:24,469 --> 01:37:26,170 ASSURE YOU NIH WILL TAKE THE 2083 01:37:26,170 --> 01:37:28,039 INFORMATION SERIOUSLY AND ACT ON 2084 01:37:28,039 --> 01:37:28,473 IT. 2085 01:37:28,473 --> 01:37:31,943 >> THANK YOU, NICOLE. 2086 01:37:31,943 --> 01:37:37,882 DOES ANYONE ELSE REMOTE HAVE ANY 2087 01:37:37,882 --> 01:37:40,418 OTHER COMMENTS? 2088 01:37:40,418 --> 01:37:40,618 OKAY. 2089 01:37:40,618 --> 01:37:44,856 SO WE'RE RUNNING INTO OUR BREAK 2090 01:37:44,856 --> 01:37:46,224 BUT I GUESS WE HAVE TIME FOR A 2091 01:37:46,224 --> 01:37:49,160 COUPLE MORE QUESTIONS. 2092 01:37:49,160 --> 01:37:52,130 >> I'M NCI. 2093 01:37:52,130 --> 01:37:57,635 I HAVE A QUICK QUESTION. 2094 01:37:57,635 --> 01:38:03,508 HOW DO WE THINK ABOUT TAILORED 2095 01:38:03,508 --> 01:38:04,442 TRAININGS. 2096 01:38:04,442 --> 01:38:05,910 ONE IS FROM THE EXPERIMENTAL 2097 01:38:05,910 --> 01:38:12,517 SIDE BECAUSE THEY WANT TO KNOW 2098 01:38:12,517 --> 01:38:14,519 HOW OUR A.I. OR MACHINE LEARNING 2099 01:38:14,519 --> 01:38:17,255 MODEL CAN HELP THEM GAIN INSIGHT 2100 01:38:17,255 --> 01:38:19,357 ON BIOLOGICAL INFORMATION. 2101 01:38:19,357 --> 01:38:21,125 AND FROM THE EXPERIMENTAL 2102 01:38:21,125 --> 01:38:25,396 COMPUTATIONAL MODELLING WAYS WE 2103 01:38:25,396 --> 01:38:27,865 ALWAYS WANT IT ACHIEVE PAST DATA 2104 01:38:27,865 --> 01:38:28,099 QUALITY. 2105 01:38:28,099 --> 01:38:30,701 HOW WE ARE TAILORED OR GIVE 2106 01:38:30,701 --> 01:38:34,672 DIRECTIONS FOR THE EXPERIMENTAL 2107 01:38:34,672 --> 01:38:40,178 TO HAVE EXPERIMENTS ESPECIALLY 2108 01:38:40,178 --> 01:38:44,215 LIKE THE TECHNOLOGY CHALLENGES 2109 01:38:44,215 --> 01:38:47,452 OR COST CHALLENGES TO DO THE 2110 01:38:47,452 --> 01:38:49,153 ACTUAL EXPERIMENT TO GET 2111 01:38:49,153 --> 01:38:49,787 SUFFICIENT DATA FOR OUR MODEL 2112 01:38:49,787 --> 01:38:50,054 TRAININGS. 2113 01:38:50,054 --> 01:38:55,693 THANK YOU. 2114 01:39:10,741 --> 01:39:11,008 >> 2115 01:39:11,008 --> 01:39:12,410 >> WE COULDN'T HEAR. 2116 01:39:12,410 --> 01:39:13,277 MAYBE IF YOU SUMMARIZE YOUR 2117 01:39:13,277 --> 01:39:16,481 QUESTION IN ONE LINE. 2118 01:39:16,481 --> 01:39:20,485 >> HOW TO GIVE THE DIRECTIONS 2119 01:39:20,485 --> 01:39:22,687 FOR THE EXPERIMENTALIST TAILORED 2120 01:39:22,687 --> 01:39:32,897 DATA FOR US TRAINEES? 2121 01:39:32,897 --> 01:39:37,902 CONSIDERING THE LIMITATIONS OF 2122 01:39:37,902 --> 01:39:40,571 THE COST AND TECHNICAL CHALLENGE 2123 01:39:40,571 --> 01:39:41,272 TO DO THE EXPERIMENT. 2124 01:39:41,272 --> 01:39:46,878 HOW ARE WE ABLE TO GIVE THE 2125 01:39:46,878 --> 01:39:48,579 GUIDANCE TO PRODUCE DATA FOR US 2126 01:39:48,579 --> 01:39:50,915 FOR THE TRAINEES AND GET THE 2127 01:39:50,915 --> 01:39:51,382 INSIGHT. 2128 01:39:51,382 --> 01:39:53,584 >> I THINK YOU'RE ASKING ABOUT 2129 01:39:53,584 --> 01:39:54,886 STANDARDIZING THE DATA FOR 2130 01:39:54,886 --> 01:39:55,853 BENCHMARKING THE EXPERIMENTAL 2131 01:39:55,853 --> 01:39:59,056 DATA SO THE MODELERS CAN USE, 2132 01:39:59,056 --> 01:39:59,390 CORRECT? 2133 01:39:59,390 --> 01:40:01,592 >> NO. 2134 01:40:01,592 --> 01:40:06,531 GIVE THE EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN SO 2135 01:40:06,531 --> 01:40:12,403 THAT BETTER INTEGRATED MODELS 2136 01:40:12,403 --> 01:40:13,804 AND THE EXPERIMENT TOGETHER? 2137 01:40:13,804 --> 01:40:14,672 >> DESIGN OF EXPERIMENT MODEL. 2138 01:40:14,672 --> 01:40:18,876 >> MAYBE I CAN ANSWER FOR NIH. 2139 01:40:18,876 --> 01:40:19,844 SOMETIMES THE DATA COLLECTION 2140 01:40:19,844 --> 01:40:21,245 PART IS EXPENSIVE. 2141 01:40:21,245 --> 01:40:24,048 THAT'S COMMON AT NIH, RIGHT. 2142 01:40:24,048 --> 01:40:25,816 WE'LL HAVE EXPENSIVE MOUSE 2143 01:40:25,816 --> 01:40:27,118 STUDIES AND TISSUE COLLECTION 2144 01:40:27,118 --> 01:40:29,253 STUDIES THAT ARE LARGE AND 2145 01:40:29,253 --> 01:40:29,587 EXPENSIVE. 2146 01:40:29,587 --> 01:40:33,591 IF THAT'S A KEY PIECE TO DO THE 2147 01:40:33,591 --> 01:40:34,292 COMPUTATIONAL COMPONENT YOU 2148 01:40:34,292 --> 01:40:35,326 INCLUDE THAT AS WELL. 2149 01:40:35,326 --> 01:40:36,394 HAVE YOU THE VISION FOR WHAT 2150 01:40:36,394 --> 01:40:37,061 YOU'RE SUBMITTING. 2151 01:40:37,061 --> 01:40:38,930 AM I ANSWERING YOUR QUESTION? 2152 01:40:38,930 --> 01:40:43,467 >> THE REASON IS I HAVE 2153 01:40:43,467 --> 01:40:45,903 CHALLENGES ON MY SIDE AND 2154 01:40:45,903 --> 01:40:47,572 WORKING WITH THE EXPERIMENTALIST 2155 01:40:47,572 --> 01:40:50,441 THEY WANT ME TO INPUT HOW WE ARE 2156 01:40:50,441 --> 01:40:54,612 PERFORMING TO DO THE SEQUENCING. 2157 01:40:54,612 --> 01:40:56,247 THE CHALLENGE IS THE DIFFERENT 2158 01:40:56,247 --> 01:40:58,683 WAY TO GO. 2159 01:40:58,683 --> 01:41:00,751 FOR ME IF WE TYPICALLY HAVE 2160 01:41:00,751 --> 01:41:02,353 DIFFERENT DATA WE HAVE DIFFERENT 2161 01:41:02,353 --> 01:41:06,224 STRATEGIES OR MODELS TO 2162 01:41:06,224 --> 01:41:10,795 IMPLEMENT BUT THE THING IS THAT 2163 01:41:10,795 --> 01:41:17,201 WE NEED TO -- THEY WANT TO KNOW 2164 01:41:17,201 --> 01:41:18,636 BECAUSE THE A.I. METHODS 2165 01:41:18,636 --> 01:41:21,906 MECHANISTIC MODELS GET THE 2166 01:41:21,906 --> 01:41:25,443 BETTER RESULT IN REGARD TO THE 2167 01:41:25,443 --> 01:41:26,043 BIOLOGIST. 2168 01:41:26,043 --> 01:41:29,880 HEY, HOW ARE WE PERFORMING THE 2169 01:41:29,880 --> 01:41:32,817 EXPERIMENT TO GET A BETTER 2170 01:41:32,817 --> 01:41:33,351 RESULT? 2171 01:41:33,351 --> 01:41:36,187 SO FOR ME THERE ARE A LOT OF 2172 01:41:36,187 --> 01:41:37,822 FACTORS TO CONSIDER. 2173 01:41:37,822 --> 01:41:45,329 JUST LIKE THE GEORGE MENTIONED 2174 01:41:45,329 --> 01:41:51,235 THE RESOURCE LIMITED AND IF WE 2175 01:41:51,235 --> 01:41:56,173 GO, FOR EXAMPLE, GATHER A LOT OF 2176 01:41:56,173 --> 01:41:58,976 THROUGHPUT WE MAY NOT GET ENOUGH 2177 01:41:58,976 --> 01:42:04,615 ACCURACY FOR EXAMPLE BUT FOR THE 2178 01:42:04,615 --> 01:42:09,887 LOW THROUGHPUT IT'S -- 2179 01:42:09,887 --> 01:42:13,924 >> I THINK I SEE. 2180 01:42:13,924 --> 01:42:15,459 BALANCING THOSE GO TO A 2181 01:42:15,459 --> 01:42:16,093 COMPELLING GRANT. 2182 01:42:16,093 --> 01:42:17,428 LET'S HAVE A CHAT AFTER. 2183 01:42:17,428 --> 01:42:18,929 >> SINCE WE'RE RUNNING UP 2184 01:42:18,929 --> 01:42:21,532 AGAINST THE COFFEE AND TEA 2185 01:42:21,532 --> 01:42:23,401 BREAK, WE PROBABLY SHOULD CLOSE 2186 01:42:23,401 --> 01:42:24,335 UP OUR PANEL BUT THIS SHOULD 2187 01:42:24,335 --> 01:42:26,837 JUST BE THE BEGINNING OF THE 2188 01:42:26,837 --> 01:42:27,271 DISCUSSION. 2189 01:42:27,271 --> 01:42:28,606 THE WAY WE'VE DESIGN THE DAY IS 2190 01:42:28,606 --> 01:42:29,840 WE ALSO HAVE A BREAKOUT SESSION 2191 01:42:29,840 --> 01:42:32,677 SO THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO 2192 01:42:32,677 --> 01:42:34,912 TAKE SOMEWHAT YOU'VE LEARNED 2193 01:42:34,912 --> 01:42:36,047 FROM THIS SESSION AND DISCUSS 2194 01:42:36,047 --> 01:42:38,716 THAT DURING THE BREAKOUT 2195 01:42:38,716 --> 01:42:41,452 SESSIONS TO PRESENT DIFFERENT 2196 01:42:41,452 --> 01:42:42,553 POSSIBILITIES YOU MIGHT FIND 2197 01:42:42,553 --> 01:42:44,155 THAT SOME OF THE ACTION ITEMS 2198 01:42:44,155 --> 01:42:46,857 MIGHT BE TO ENGAGE IN SOME OF 2199 01:42:46,857 --> 01:42:47,658 THESE PARTICULAR INITIATIVES OR 2200 01:42:47,658 --> 01:42:50,261 COME UP WITH PROJECTS THAT ARE 2201 01:42:50,261 --> 01:42:52,697 ALIGNED WITH THE INITIATIVES. 2202 01:42:52,697 --> 01:42:53,798 SO LET'S KEEP THIS CONVERSATION 2203 01:42:53,798 --> 01:42:55,933 GOING AND ONCE AGAIN THE WIKI'S 2204 01:42:55,933 --> 01:42:57,702 AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO THAT. 2205 01:42:57,702 --> 01:43:00,338 I WANTED TO THANK ALL OF OUR 2206 01:43:00,338 --> 01:43:01,906 PANELISTS FOR PUTTING TOGETHER 2207 01:43:01,906 --> 01:43:03,674 THE SLIDES AND GIVING US A 2208 01:43:03,674 --> 01:43:06,277 SUMMARY OF YOUR PROGRAMS. 2209 01:43:06,277 --> 01:43:10,514 THANK YOU. 2210 01:43:10,514 --> 01:43:12,216 IT'S REASONABLE TO SAY IF PEOPLE 2211 01:43:12,216 --> 01:43:13,384 HAVE QUESTIONS SPECIFIC 2212 01:43:13,384 --> 01:43:15,653 QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR INITIATIVES 2213 01:43:15,653 --> 01:43:18,322 THAT THERE'S CONTACT INFORMATION 2214 01:43:18,322 --> 01:43:20,791 IN EACH OF THE SLIDES SO PLEASE 2215 01:43:20,791 --> 01:43:21,392 REACH OUT AND KEEP THE 2216 01:43:21,392 --> 01:43:24,261 COMMUNICATIONS GOING. 2217 01:43:24,261 --> 01:43:25,896 AND HOPEFULLY THIS IS THE 2218 01:43:25,896 --> 01:43:29,066 BEGINNING OF MORE AND MORE 2219 01:43:29,066 --> 01:43:29,567 DISCUSSION. 2220 01:43:29,567 --> 01:43:29,900 GRACE. 2221 01:43:29,900 --> 01:43:31,569 >> BEFORE ANYONE LEAVES TO GO 2222 01:43:31,569 --> 01:43:34,739 OUT FOR BEVERAGES WE'RE GOING TO 2223 01:43:34,739 --> 01:43:35,639 TAKE PICTURES. 2224 01:43:35,639 --> 01:43:37,708 IMAG FOLKS STAND UP REALLY QUICK 2225 01:43:37,708 --> 01:43:39,777 AND WE'LL HAVE REMOTE FOLKS 2226 01:43:39,777 --> 01:43:43,180 BEHIND US AND IF THE REMOTE 2227 01:43:43,180 --> 01:43:45,883 FOLKS CAN SHARE THEIR SCREENS 2228 01:43:45,883 --> 01:43:49,253 AND WE CAN HAVE THEM AND IN THE 2229 01:43:49,253 --> 01:43:50,821 MEANTIME WHILE WE'RE TAKING 2230 01:43:50,821 --> 01:43:52,890 PICTURES, FOLKS IN THE 2231 01:43:52,890 --> 01:43:56,660 AUDITORIUM COME GATHER TOWARDS 2232 01:43:56,660 --> 01:43:57,828 THE FRONT AND THEN THEY'LL TAKE 2233 01:43:57,828 --> 01:44:08,305 THE PICTURE FROM THE STAGE. 2234 01:44:08,672 --> 01:44:09,407 >> IF YOU'RE A GOVERNMENT 2235 01:44:09,407 --> 01:44:11,175 PROGRAM PERSON AND YOU'RE 2236 01:44:11,175 --> 01:44:21,685 SEATED, COME UP TO THE STAGE. 2237 01:45:44,335 --> 01:45:45,536 KILL THE SPOTLIGHTS. 2238 01:45:45,536 --> 01:45:47,905 WHOEVER IS HANDLING THE 2239 01:45:47,905 --> 01:45:50,708 SPOTLIGHTS CAN YOU REMOVE THE 2240 01:45:50,708 --> 01:46:01,118 SPOTLIGHTS ON THE STAGE? 2241 01:46:08,626 --> 01:46:09,927 IS ANYONE IN THE CONTROL ROOM? 2242 01:46:09,927 --> 01:46:20,304 WE'VE BEEN ABANDONED. 2243 01:46:41,959 --> 01:46:52,102 BADGES OFF. 2244 02:12:26,469 --> 02:12:29,405 WE THINK THIS IS THE FUTURE OF 2245 02:12:29,405 --> 02:12:30,840 MULTISCALE MODELING BECAUSE WE 2246 02:12:30,840 --> 02:12:32,174 NEED THIS GROUP TO HELP ADVISE 2247 02:12:32,174 --> 02:12:36,545 WHERE WE SHOULD GO IN TERMS OF 2248 02:12:36,545 --> 02:12:37,880 HEALTH EQUITY MODELLING. 2249 02:12:37,880 --> 02:12:40,249 PAY ATTENTION AND POST YOUR 2250 02:12:40,249 --> 02:12:42,585 COMMENTS HERE IN THE WELCOME 2251 02:12:42,585 --> 02:12:46,522 BACK -- WIKI. 2252 02:12:46,522 --> 02:12:48,290 I CAN'T STRESS HOW IMPORTANT IT 2253 02:12:48,290 --> 02:12:49,191 IS TO POST BECAUSE PREVIOUS 2254 02:12:49,191 --> 02:12:50,626 SPEAKER ANSWERING QUESTIONS NOW. 2255 02:12:50,626 --> 02:12:56,065 IF YOU POSTED LOOK FOR ANSWERS 2256 02:12:56,065 --> 02:13:02,338 TO YOUR QUESTIONS AND THEY'RE 2257 02:13:02,338 --> 02:13:03,739 TRYING HARD TO ANSWER THE 2258 02:13:03,739 --> 02:13:05,875 QUESTIONS AND ORGANIZERS FOR THE 2259 02:13:05,875 --> 02:13:06,909 SESSION ARE HERE. 2260 02:13:06,909 --> 02:13:12,681 I'LL HAVE JASON ONE OF OUR 2261 02:13:12,681 --> 02:13:17,820 CO-CHAIRS INTRODUCE. 2262 02:13:17,820 --> 02:13:20,489 >> I'M HAPPY TO INTRODUCE THE 2263 02:13:20,489 --> 02:13:23,526 SESSION ON HEALTH EQUITIES AND 2264 02:13:23,526 --> 02:13:29,465 THIS IS THE BRAIN CHILD OF WHO 2265 02:13:29,465 --> 02:13:30,266 EARLY-CAREER INVESTIGATORS. 2266 02:13:30,266 --> 02:13:31,967 NONE OF US REALLY WORK IN THIS 2267 02:13:31,967 --> 02:13:34,069 AREA BUT WE THOUGHT THIS WAS A 2268 02:13:34,069 --> 02:13:36,872 GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR THE MSM 2269 02:13:36,872 --> 02:13:41,877 COMMUNITY TO UNDERSTAND WHAT THE 2270 02:13:41,877 --> 02:13:44,180 PROBLEMS ARE AND HOW WE AS A 2271 02:13:44,180 --> 02:13:46,315 COMMUNITY MIGHT CONTRIBUTE. 2272 02:13:46,315 --> 02:13:51,353 I'M HAPPY TO INTRODUCE OUR FIRST 2273 02:13:51,353 --> 02:13:57,893 SPEAKS TO PRESENT AN OVERVIEW OF 2274 02:13:57,893 --> 02:14:08,103 THIS TOPIC. 2275 02:14:25,354 --> 02:14:27,957 WE WANT TO PROVIDE AN OVERVIEW 2276 02:14:27,957 --> 02:14:30,092 OF INTERVENTIONS AND TALK ABOUT 2277 02:14:30,092 --> 02:14:32,294 PRINCIPLE AND MEANINGFUL 2278 02:14:32,294 --> 02:14:36,332 COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND WE HOPE 2279 02:14:36,332 --> 02:14:37,499 THOSE TWO DISCUSSION POINTS WILL 2280 02:14:37,499 --> 02:14:38,767 LAY THE FOUNDATION AND 2281 02:14:38,767 --> 02:14:39,735 OPPORTUNITIES AND CHALLENGES 2282 02:14:39,735 --> 02:14:45,874 EVALUATING THE TYPES OF 2283 02:14:45,874 --> 02:14:47,876 INTERVENTIONS. 2284 02:14:47,876 --> 02:14:48,877 LASTLY FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES 2285 02:14:48,877 --> 02:14:49,912 THAT MAY BE RIGHT FOR SIMILAR 2286 02:14:49,912 --> 02:14:51,614 TYPE OF WORK. 2287 02:14:51,614 --> 02:14:57,720 THE HEALTHY PEOPLE 2030 SDOH 2288 02:14:57,720 --> 02:15:00,289 DEFINITION IS PROBABLY THE MOST 2289 02:15:00,289 --> 02:15:01,190 WIDELY USED AND CONDITIONS IN 2290 02:15:01,190 --> 02:15:02,124 THE ENVIRONMENT WHERE PEOPLE ARE 2291 02:15:02,124 --> 02:15:03,726 BORN, LIVE, LEARN, WORK, PLAY, 2292 02:15:03,726 --> 02:15:14,003 WORSHIP AND AGE. 2293 02:15:15,504 --> 02:15:16,505 AFFECTS QUALITY OF LIFE AND RISK 2294 02:15:16,505 --> 02:15:19,141 AND THERE'S FIVE DOMAINS. 2295 02:15:19,141 --> 02:15:19,875 HEALTH CARE ACCESS AND QUALITY 2296 02:15:19,875 --> 02:15:21,877 WHICH YOU GUYS ARE PROBABLY MOST 2297 02:15:21,877 --> 02:15:24,013 USED TO, NEIGHBORHOOD AND BUILT 2298 02:15:24,013 --> 02:15:24,580 ENVIRONMENT. 2299 02:15:24,580 --> 02:15:29,652 THAT MAY ENCOMPASS THINGS LIKE 2300 02:15:29,652 --> 02:15:32,121 OPPORTUNITIES TO EXERCISE SAFELY 2301 02:15:32,121 --> 02:15:36,225 AND ACCESS TO HEALTHY AND 2302 02:15:36,225 --> 02:15:37,726 NUTRITION FOOD AND ECONOMIC 2303 02:15:37,726 --> 02:15:41,897 STABILITY WHICH MAY ENCOMPASS 2304 02:15:41,897 --> 02:15:45,301 THINGS SUCH AS HIGH QUALITY 2305 02:15:45,301 --> 02:15:47,269 EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES AND 2306 02:15:47,269 --> 02:15:49,138 EDUCATION ACCESS AND QUALITY. 2307 02:15:49,138 --> 02:15:49,972 THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION IS 2308 02:15:49,972 --> 02:15:54,977 ONE OF THE FIRST TO BUILD OUT A 2309 02:15:54,977 --> 02:15:56,478 CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK FOR SDOH 2310 02:15:56,478 --> 02:15:59,415 AND STRUCTURAL INTERVENTIONS. 2311 02:15:59,415 --> 02:16:00,516 YOU SEE THE WORLD HEALTH 2312 02:16:00,516 --> 02:16:02,284 ORGANIZATION EXTENDS HEALTHY 2313 02:16:02,284 --> 02:16:05,154 PEOPLE 2030 DEFINITION BY 2314 02:16:05,154 --> 02:16:06,488 INCORPORATING THE WIDER SET OF 2315 02:16:06,488 --> 02:16:08,324 FORCES AND SYSTEMS SHAPING THE 2316 02:16:08,324 --> 02:16:10,092 CONDITIONS OF DAILY LIFE. 2317 02:16:10,092 --> 02:16:11,660 THE COLUMN HERE THE FIRST COLUMN 2318 02:16:11,660 --> 02:16:14,830 TO YOUR LEFT REALLY DOES 2319 02:16:14,830 --> 02:16:17,866 REPRESENT THOSE HIGHER LEVEL 2320 02:16:17,866 --> 02:16:19,568 STRUCTURAL FACTORS. 2321 02:16:19,568 --> 02:16:22,237 SO MACRO ECONOMIC SYSTEMS, 2322 02:16:22,237 --> 02:16:23,972 SOCIAL POLICIES, PUBLIC 2323 02:16:23,972 --> 02:16:25,874 POLICIES, SCHOOL POLICIES, LABOR 2324 02:16:25,874 --> 02:16:29,878 POLICIES, ETCETERA. 2325 02:16:29,878 --> 02:16:31,447 AND THOSE FACTORS THEN IMPACT 2326 02:16:31,447 --> 02:16:33,615 THE CONDITIONS OF DAILY LIVING 2327 02:16:33,615 --> 02:16:34,416 OR THE ENVIRONMENT IN WHICH 2328 02:16:34,416 --> 02:16:35,918 PEOPLE LIVE WHICH IS WHAT I WENT 2329 02:16:35,918 --> 02:16:38,554 OVER WITH THE HEALTHY PEOPLE 2330 02:16:38,554 --> 02:16:39,755 2030 DEFINITION. 2331 02:16:39,755 --> 02:16:40,456 THAT IMPACTS WHAT INDIVIDUALS 2332 02:16:40,456 --> 02:16:45,594 AND FAMILIES HAVE ACCESS TO. 2333 02:16:45,594 --> 02:16:47,262 THEY'RE MATERIAL IN ECONOMIC 2334 02:16:47,262 --> 02:16:48,197 CIRCUMSTANCES THAT HAVE PROFOUND 2335 02:16:48,197 --> 02:16:49,798 AND SUSTAINED INFLUENCES ON THE 2336 02:16:49,798 --> 02:16:50,899 ABILITY OF INDIVIDUALS TO LIVE 2337 02:16:50,899 --> 02:16:59,675 HEALTHY LIVES. 2338 02:16:59,675 --> 02:17:01,076 WE KNOW WE MADE TREMENDOUS 2339 02:17:01,076 --> 02:17:02,010 PROGRESS IN REDUCING HEALTH 2340 02:17:02,010 --> 02:17:05,814 DISPARITIES BUT IN MANY CASES 2341 02:17:05,814 --> 02:17:08,050 THEY STILL EXIST, PERSIST AND 2342 02:17:08,050 --> 02:17:09,118 HAVE INCREASED ESPECIALLY OVER 2343 02:17:09,118 --> 02:17:10,619 THE COURSE OF THE PANDEMIC. 2344 02:17:10,619 --> 02:17:15,324 SO WE NEED TO THINK MORE BROADLY 2345 02:17:15,324 --> 02:17:16,492 ABOUT FACTORS THAT IMPACT HEALTH 2346 02:17:16,492 --> 02:17:17,993 BEYOND THE HEALTH CARE SYSTEM. 2347 02:17:17,993 --> 02:17:20,195 THINKING ABOUT THOSE STRUCTURAL 2348 02:17:20,195 --> 02:17:21,163 LEVEL FACTORS AND THOSE 2349 02:17:21,163 --> 02:17:25,367 CONDITIONS OF DAILY LIVING THAT 2350 02:17:25,367 --> 02:17:26,869 MAY NOT HAVE TRADITIONALLY BEEN 2351 02:17:26,869 --> 02:17:28,137 SITUATED IN THE HEALTH IMPACT 2352 02:17:28,137 --> 02:17:31,740 BUT WE KNOW IMPACTS HEALTH. 2353 02:17:31,740 --> 02:17:32,374 SOCIAL DETERMINATES OF HEALTH 2354 02:17:32,374 --> 02:17:34,743 ARE MAJOR CONTRIBUTORS TO HEALTH 2355 02:17:34,743 --> 02:17:35,144 DISPARITIES. 2356 02:17:35,144 --> 02:17:37,713 ARE SHAPED BY THE STRUCTURAL 2357 02:17:37,713 --> 02:17:38,380 FACTORS AND INFLUENCE INDIVIDUAL 2358 02:17:38,380 --> 02:17:41,784 AND FAMILY CIRCUMSTANCES. 2359 02:17:41,784 --> 02:17:44,019 WE BELIEVE IN THE CAMPUS PROGRAM 2360 02:17:44,019 --> 02:17:47,289 THE GREATEST OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE 2361 02:17:47,289 --> 02:17:47,956 SUSTAINED AND POWERFUL 2362 02:17:47,956 --> 02:17:53,162 INFLUENCES ON HEALTH IS TO MOVE 2363 02:17:53,162 --> 02:17:53,429 UPSTREAM. 2364 02:17:53,429 --> 02:17:56,298 SO OF COURSE ADDRESSING 2365 02:17:56,298 --> 02:17:57,399 INDIVIDUAL CIRCUMSTANCES ARE 2366 02:17:57,399 --> 02:17:58,934 IMPORTANT BUT THEY'RE 2367 02:17:58,934 --> 02:17:59,601 MANIFESTATIONS OF THE STRUCTURAL 2368 02:17:59,601 --> 02:18:01,870 AND SOCIAL FACTORS. 2369 02:18:01,870 --> 02:18:03,906 SO ADDRESSING THOSE FACTORS ARE 2370 02:18:03,906 --> 02:18:04,273 OPTIMAL. 2371 02:18:04,273 --> 02:18:05,874 SO WHAT ARE STRUCTURAL 2372 02:18:05,874 --> 02:18:07,609 INTERVEN 2373 02:18:07,609 --> 02:18:08,143 INTERVENTIONS? 2374 02:18:08,143 --> 02:18:09,411 THEY ATTEMPT TO CHANGE THE 2375 02:18:09,411 --> 02:18:12,047 SOCIAL, PHYSICAL, ECONOMIC OR 2376 02:18:12,047 --> 02:18:13,248 POLITICAL ENVIRONMENTS THAT MAY 2377 02:18:13,248 --> 02:18:14,783 SHAPE OR CONSTRAIN HEALTH 2378 02:18:14,783 --> 02:18:24,159 BEHAVIOR AND OUTCOMES. 2379 02:18:24,159 --> 02:18:27,129 I WON'T THROUGH THE WHOLE LIST 2380 02:18:27,129 --> 02:18:28,564 BUT MAY ENCOMPASS INCOME 2381 02:18:28,564 --> 02:18:30,165 POLICIES TO ADDRESS ISSUES OF 2382 02:18:30,165 --> 02:18:32,734 ECONOMIC STABILITY, INSTABILITY, 2383 02:18:32,734 --> 02:18:34,236 HIGH SPEED BROADBAND INTERNET 2384 02:18:34,236 --> 02:18:36,305 CONNECTION AND WE KNOW THIS WAS 2385 02:18:36,305 --> 02:18:37,739 PARTICULARLY RELEVANT DURING THE 2386 02:18:37,739 --> 02:18:39,374 COURSE OF THE PANDEMIC WHERE A 2387 02:18:39,374 --> 02:18:41,777 LOT OF CHILDREN MOVED FROM IN 2388 02:18:41,777 --> 02:18:47,182 PERSON TO ONLINE LEARNING. 2389 02:18:47,182 --> 02:18:48,250 IDENTIFYING OPPORTUNITIES TO 2390 02:18:48,250 --> 02:18:49,818 INCREASE BROADBAND ACCESS AND 2391 02:18:49,818 --> 02:18:54,890 COMMUNITIES AND HOUSEHOLDS THAT 2392 02:18:54,890 --> 02:18:59,528 DIDN'T HAVE IT WAS OF COMMUNITY 2393 02:18:59,528 --> 02:19:02,231 INTEREST AND ENHANCING 2394 02:19:02,231 --> 02:19:03,732 NEIGHBORHOOD AND COMMUNITY 2395 02:19:03,732 --> 02:19:05,868 RESOURCES AND FACILITATE 2396 02:19:05,868 --> 02:19:06,969 HEALTH-PROMOTING BEHAVIORS THAT 2397 02:19:06,969 --> 02:19:08,871 MAY INCLUDE THINKING ABOUT 2398 02:19:08,871 --> 02:19:10,973 OPPORTUNITIES TO BRING 2399 02:19:10,973 --> 02:19:13,175 FULL-SERVICE GROCERY STORES IN 2400 02:19:13,175 --> 02:19:15,043 COMMUNITIES, ADDING BIKE LANES, 2401 02:19:15,043 --> 02:19:17,513 ADDRESSING SAFETY CONCERNS TO 2402 02:19:17,513 --> 02:19:18,180 PROMOTE PHYSICAL ACTIVITY, 2403 02:19:18,180 --> 02:19:20,282 ETCETERA. 2404 02:19:20,282 --> 02:19:22,684 SO WHEN YOU ARE THINKING ABOUT 2405 02:19:22,684 --> 02:19:24,219 STRUCTURAL AND SOCIAL FACTORS, 2406 02:19:24,219 --> 02:19:26,288 AGAIN, YOU HAVE TO THINK MORE 2407 02:19:26,288 --> 02:19:26,588 BROADLY. 2408 02:19:26,588 --> 02:19:27,990 SO THE HEALTH CARE SECTOR, OF 2409 02:19:27,990 --> 02:19:30,526 COURSE, IS IMPORTANT. 2410 02:19:30,526 --> 02:19:34,062 BUT ALL OF THESE OTHER SECTORS 2411 02:19:34,062 --> 02:19:35,964 GIVEN WHAT WE DISCUSSED ABOUT 2412 02:19:35,964 --> 02:19:41,169 THE SDOH DOMAINS THAT BRINGING 2413 02:19:41,169 --> 02:19:44,373 IN COMMERCE, ECONOMIC AND URBAN 2414 02:19:44,373 --> 02:19:46,008 DEVELOPMENT, TRANSPORTATION, 2415 02:19:46,008 --> 02:19:48,076 EDUCATION, HOUSING, JUSTICE 2416 02:19:48,076 --> 02:19:50,412 THEY'RE ALL RELEVANT DEPENDING 2417 02:19:50,412 --> 02:19:52,614 ON THE RESEARCH AND QUESTION YOU 2418 02:19:52,614 --> 02:19:53,882 ARE PROPOSING. 2419 02:19:53,882 --> 02:19:56,852 CENTRAL TO ANY EFFORT TO ADDRESS 2420 02:19:56,852 --> 02:20:00,255 HEALTH AND AT THE STRUCTURAL AND 2421 02:20:00,255 --> 02:20:01,790 SOCIAL LEVEL NEEDS TO INVOLVE 2422 02:20:01,790 --> 02:20:02,791 THE COMMUNITY AND I'LL TALK A 2423 02:20:02,791 --> 02:20:08,297 LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHY THAT IS. 2424 02:20:08,297 --> 02:20:10,299 SO THE CDC PROVIDES FRAMEWORK 2425 02:20:10,299 --> 02:20:11,500 FOR MEANINGFUL ENGAGEMENT WE 2426 02:20:11,500 --> 02:20:12,534 LEVERAGE FOR THE DISCUSSION 2427 02:20:12,534 --> 02:20:12,834 HERE. 2428 02:20:12,834 --> 02:20:14,703 I ENCOURAGE YOU TO TAKE A LOOK, 2429 02:20:14,703 --> 02:20:21,577 TYPE IN PRINCIPLES OF COMMUNITY 2430 02:20:21,577 --> 02:20:21,944 ENGAGEMENT/CDC. 2431 02:20:21,944 --> 02:20:26,548 MEANINGFUL COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 2432 02:20:26,548 --> 02:20:29,251 IS A COLLABORATE PROCESSES WHICH 2433 02:20:29,251 --> 02:20:32,287 MAXIMIZES ISSUES THAT AFFECT A 2434 02:20:32,287 --> 02:20:33,889 SPECIFIC POPULATION DEFINED BY 2435 02:20:33,889 --> 02:20:36,959 RACE, ETHNICITY, GEOGRAPHY AND 2436 02:20:36,959 --> 02:20:37,960 THE LIKE. 2437 02:20:37,960 --> 02:20:39,728 AUTHENTIC COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 2438 02:20:39,728 --> 02:20:41,797 CAN HELP MOBILIZE RESOURCES AND 2439 02:20:41,797 --> 02:20:43,265 RESOURCES AND FACILITATE CHANGE 2440 02:20:43,265 --> 02:20:44,800 AND SYSTEMS, POLICIES AND 2441 02:20:44,800 --> 02:20:45,867 PROGRAMS. 2442 02:20:45,867 --> 02:20:48,971 IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT TO NOTE THAT 2443 02:20:48,971 --> 02:20:50,305 WORKING WITH COMMUNITY OFTEN 2444 02:20:50,305 --> 02:20:52,007 TAKES A DIFFERENT PERFORM THAN 2445 02:20:52,007 --> 02:20:53,408 WORKING WITH TRADITIONAL 2446 02:20:53,408 --> 02:20:54,409 ACADEMIC PARTNERS. 2447 02:20:54,409 --> 02:20:55,677 YOU'RE PRIORITIES OR THE HEALTH 2448 02:20:55,677 --> 02:21:00,015 ISSUES YOU MAY WANT TO FOCUS ON 2449 02:21:00,015 --> 02:21:00,816 MAY NOT ALIGN WITH THE 2450 02:21:00,816 --> 02:21:01,717 PRIORITIES OF THE COMMUNITY. 2451 02:21:01,717 --> 02:21:05,153 IT TAKES A COLLABORATIVE PROCESS 2452 02:21:05,153 --> 02:21:08,390 TO MAKE THE COLLABORATION WORK 2453 02:21:08,390 --> 02:21:11,326 AND WORK WELL. 2454 02:21:11,326 --> 02:21:12,628 I'LL TALK ABOUT SOME PRINCIPLES 2455 02:21:12,628 --> 02:21:14,296 OF COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT. 2456 02:21:14,296 --> 02:21:15,464 SO THE FIRST PRINCIPLE OF 2457 02:21:15,464 --> 02:21:17,165 COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT THAT I WANT 2458 02:21:17,165 --> 02:21:21,069 TO HIGHLIGHT TODAY AND I WON'T 2459 02:21:21,069 --> 02:21:21,870 GO THROUGH THE LIST IN WHOLE 2460 02:21:21,870 --> 02:21:22,237 TRUST. 2461 02:21:22,237 --> 02:21:24,539 BUILDING TRUST BEFORE YOU GO TO 2462 02:21:24,539 --> 02:21:25,674 COMMUNITY TO ASK FOR SOMETHING, 2463 02:21:25,674 --> 02:21:27,943 TO ASK FOR THEM TO BE INVOLVED 2464 02:21:27,943 --> 02:21:30,312 IN THE RESEARCH PROJECT OR TO 2465 02:21:30,312 --> 02:21:32,814 ASK FOR RESOURCE THEY MAY HAVE 2466 02:21:32,814 --> 02:21:34,783 ACCESS, TO POPULATIONS, ETCETERA 2467 02:21:34,783 --> 02:21:35,717 IS REALLY IMPORTANT YOU BUILD 2468 02:21:35,717 --> 02:21:37,886 TRUST WITH THE COMMUNITY TO MAKE 2469 02:21:37,886 --> 02:21:41,890 THE PARTNERSHIP SUSTAINABLE AND 2470 02:21:41,890 --> 02:21:45,861 EFFECTIVE OVER TIME. 2471 02:21:45,861 --> 02:21:47,896 ANOTHER ONE IS BI-DIRECTIONAL 2472 02:21:47,896 --> 02:21:48,163 LEARNING. 2473 02:21:48,163 --> 02:21:49,765 UNDERSTANDING COMMUNITY HAS 2474 02:21:49,765 --> 02:21:50,799 UNIQUE PERSPECTIVES AND 2475 02:21:50,799 --> 02:21:51,700 EXPERIENCE THAT BRINGS 2476 02:21:51,700 --> 02:21:54,670 TREMENDOUS VALUE TO THE 2477 02:21:54,670 --> 02:21:55,404 PARTNERSHIP. 2478 02:21:55,404 --> 02:21:56,004 SO YOU ARE LEARNING FROM 2479 02:21:56,004 --> 02:21:56,938 COMMUNITY AND COMMUNITY IS 2480 02:21:56,938 --> 02:21:57,873 LEARNING FROM YOU. 2481 02:21:57,873 --> 02:21:58,807 SO KEEPING AT THE FOREFRONT IS 2482 02:21:58,807 --> 02:22:02,411 IMPORTANT. 2483 02:22:02,411 --> 02:22:02,844 SHARED GOVERNANCE. 2484 02:22:02,844 --> 02:22:05,147 SHARED DECISION MAKING. 2485 02:22:05,147 --> 02:22:06,848 AGAIN, IF IT IS A COLLABORATION 2486 02:22:06,848 --> 02:22:08,950 AND AN AUTHENTIC COLLABORATION 2487 02:22:08,950 --> 02:22:09,918 IT'S IMPORTANT THAT COMMUNITY 2488 02:22:09,918 --> 02:22:11,119 HAS A VOICE AT THE TABLE AS 2489 02:22:11,119 --> 02:22:14,289 WELL. 2490 02:22:14,289 --> 02:22:17,392 SO CO-CREATED, CO-EQUAL IS 2491 02:22:17,392 --> 02:22:21,129 CENTRALLY IMPORTANT TO 2492 02:22:21,129 --> 02:22:22,764 COMMUNITY-ENGAGED RESEARCH. 2493 02:22:22,764 --> 02:22:25,834 SO, I WENT THROUGH THAT QUICKLY 2494 02:22:25,834 --> 02:22:28,303 IN THE INTEREST OF TIME. 2495 02:22:28,303 --> 02:22:29,438 NOW HOPEFULLY THAT GIVES YOU AN 2496 02:22:29,438 --> 02:22:30,472 INDICATION OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF 2497 02:22:30,472 --> 02:22:33,809 THE COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIP TO 2498 02:22:33,809 --> 02:22:36,978 ADVANCE SCIENCE FOR SOCIETY. 2499 02:22:36,978 --> 02:22:38,146 THE COMPASS PROGRAM. 2500 02:22:38,146 --> 02:22:39,915 I WANT TO ACKNOWLEDGE OUR 2501 02:22:39,915 --> 02:22:41,083 CO-CHAIRS THAT HAVE BEEN 2502 02:22:41,083 --> 02:22:42,017 VISIONARIES IN CREATING AND 2503 02:22:42,017 --> 02:22:43,819 BUILDING OUT THE PROGRAM. 2504 02:22:43,819 --> 02:22:45,654 THEY ARE ACROSS FOUR DIFFERENT 2505 02:22:45,654 --> 02:22:46,521 NIH INSTITUTES. 2506 02:22:46,521 --> 02:22:50,058 BUT THE WHOLE OF THE WORKING 2507 02:22:50,058 --> 02:22:52,794 GROUP IS FAR LARGER SO EXPANDS 2508 02:22:52,794 --> 02:22:53,895 MOST OF NIH. 2509 02:22:53,895 --> 02:22:56,298 IT'S BEEN A COLLABORATIVE 2510 02:22:56,298 --> 02:22:57,899 PROCESS TO THINK THROUGH WHAT 2511 02:22:57,899 --> 02:22:59,868 THE REQUIREMENT SHOULD BE FOR A 2512 02:22:59,868 --> 02:23:01,737 TYPE OF PROGRAM UNIQUE AND 2513 02:23:01,737 --> 02:23:08,276 INNOVATIVE FOR THE NIH. 2514 02:23:08,276 --> 02:23:13,014 SO THIS IS SUPPORTED BY THE 2515 02:23:13,014 --> 02:23:14,783 COMMON FUND AND COMMUNITY LED. 2516 02:23:14,783 --> 02:23:15,817 AND IT'S QUITE DIFFERENT THAN 2517 02:23:15,817 --> 02:23:19,888 WHAT YOU PROBABLY ARE USED TO. 2518 02:23:19,888 --> 02:23:21,389 COMMUNITY INVOLVED PROJECTS BUT 2519 02:23:21,389 --> 02:23:23,525 THESE PROJECTS THE COMMUNITY, 2520 02:23:23,525 --> 02:23:25,127 COMMUNITY ORGANIZATION ARE 2521 02:23:25,127 --> 02:23:26,294 LEADING EFFORTS HERE TO LEVERAGE 2522 02:23:26,294 --> 02:23:28,330 STRUCTURAL INTERVENTIONS TO 2523 02:23:28,330 --> 02:23:30,298 ADDRESS HEALTH, REDUCE HEALTH 2524 02:23:30,298 --> 02:23:30,932 DISPARITIES AND ADVANCE HEALTH 2525 02:23:30,932 --> 02:23:35,604 EQUITY. 2526 02:23:35,604 --> 02:23:38,707 THE OVER ALL GOALS ARE TWOFOLD. 2527 02:23:38,707 --> 02:23:42,144 TO CATALYZE, DEPLOY AND EVALUATE 2528 02:23:42,144 --> 02:23:44,246 COMMUNITY-LED STRUCTURAL 2529 02:23:44,246 --> 02:23:45,580 INTERVENTIONS AND DEVELOP A NEW 2530 02:23:45,580 --> 02:23:47,582 MODEL OF HEALTH EQUITY 2531 02:23:47,582 --> 02:23:48,250 STRUCTURAL INTERVENTIONS THAT 2532 02:23:48,250 --> 02:23:49,217 THE NIH CAN LEVERAGE AND USE 2533 02:23:49,217 --> 02:23:53,421 MOVING FORWARD. 2534 02:23:53,421 --> 02:23:55,090 THERE ARE THREE INTERCONNECTED 2535 02:23:55,090 --> 02:23:55,590 PROGRAMS. 2536 02:23:55,590 --> 02:23:58,527 ONE THE COMMUNITY-LED HEALTH 2537 02:23:58,527 --> 02:24:00,295 EQUITY STRUCTURAL INTERVENTION. 2538 02:24:00,295 --> 02:24:02,063 WE'LL FUND UP TO 25 AWARDS FOR 2539 02:24:02,063 --> 02:24:04,833 THIS AND THESE ARE LED BY 2540 02:24:04,833 --> 02:24:06,668 COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS NOT BY 2541 02:24:06,668 --> 02:24:08,069 RESEARCH ORGANIZATIONS. 2542 02:24:08,069 --> 02:24:09,137 THE HEALTH EQUITY RESEARCH HUBS, 2543 02:24:09,137 --> 02:24:11,406 UP TO FIVE AWARDS, AND THE 2544 02:24:11,406 --> 02:24:12,040 COORDINATION CENTER WHICH IS ONE 2545 02:24:12,040 --> 02:24:16,011 AWARD. 2546 02:24:16,011 --> 02:24:17,879 THE STRUCTURAL INTERVENTIONS 2547 02:24:17,879 --> 02:24:20,515 COMPONENT IS CHARGED WITH 2548 02:24:20,515 --> 02:24:21,750 DEVELOPING IMPLEMENTING, 2549 02:24:21,750 --> 02:24:22,617 ASSESSING AND DISSEMINATING 2550 02:24:22,617 --> 02:24:24,452 THESE TYPES OF INTERVENTIONS 2551 02:24:24,452 --> 02:24:25,921 BASED ON THEIR HEALTH PRIORITIES 2552 02:24:25,921 --> 02:24:31,026 AND THEIR POPULATIONS OF NEED. 2553 02:24:31,026 --> 02:24:32,294 THE HEALTH EQUITY RESEARCH HUBS 2554 02:24:32,294 --> 02:24:34,596 WILL BE CENTERED IN PROVIDING 2555 02:24:34,596 --> 02:24:37,866 TECHNICAL AND SCIENTIFIC SUPPORT 2556 02:24:37,866 --> 02:24:40,168 TO THE COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS. 2557 02:24:40,168 --> 02:24:41,837 IN COLLABORATION WITH THE 2558 02:24:41,837 --> 02:24:43,772 COORDINATION CENTER AND THE 2559 02:24:43,772 --> 02:24:45,874 COORDINATION IS THE GLUE TO THE 2560 02:24:45,874 --> 02:24:47,375 PROGRAM AND WILL BE IN CHARGE OF 2561 02:24:47,375 --> 02:24:50,278 MANAGING THE OVER ALL PROGRAM 2562 02:24:50,278 --> 02:24:51,646 AND COORDINATION OF 2563 02:24:51,646 --> 02:24:53,882 ADMINISTRATIVE DATA CAPACITY, 2564 02:24:53,882 --> 02:24:54,516 BUILDING, TRAINING ACTIVITIES, 2565 02:24:54,516 --> 02:25:04,693 ETCETERA. 2566 02:25:14,703 --> 02:25:17,305 NOW I'LL TURN IT OVER TO TALK 2567 02:25:17,305 --> 02:25:21,376 ABOUT THE INTERVENTIONS. 2568 02:25:21,376 --> 02:25:25,881 >> I'M YVONNE OWEN FERGUSON AND 2569 02:25:25,881 --> 02:25:28,917 SERVE AS THE LEAD OF PROGRAM 2570 02:25:28,917 --> 02:25:31,453 LEAD FOR THE COMPASS PROGRAM. 2571 02:25:31,453 --> 02:25:33,288 IN TERMS OF CHALLENGE AND 2572 02:25:33,288 --> 02:25:34,189 OPPORTUNITIES, WE REALLY WANTED 2573 02:25:34,189 --> 02:25:36,858 TO SPEAK TO YOU AS AN AUDIENCE 2574 02:25:36,858 --> 02:25:40,996 TO THINK ABOUT LEVERAGING THE 2575 02:25:40,996 --> 02:25:42,931 RESOURCES AND EXPERTISE OF THE 2576 02:25:42,931 --> 02:25:43,932 MULTISCALE MODELING COMMUNITY 2577 02:25:43,932 --> 02:25:45,834 AND HOW IT WILL BE IMPORTANT TO 2578 02:25:45,834 --> 02:25:47,602 THE SUCCESS OF CAMPUS. 2579 02:25:47,602 --> 02:25:49,871 I'LL SPEND A COUPLE SLIDES 2580 02:25:49,871 --> 02:25:51,373 TALKING ABOUT THIS. 2581 02:25:51,373 --> 02:25:53,008 SO WHAT ARE SOME OF THE 2582 02:25:53,008 --> 02:25:54,809 CHALLENGES AND WHAT ARE SOME OF 2583 02:25:54,809 --> 02:25:57,212 THE OPPORTUNITIES FOR 2584 02:25:57,212 --> 02:25:57,846 INTEGRATING SOCIAL AND 2585 02:25:57,846 --> 02:26:00,482 STRUCTURAL DETERMINATES OF 2586 02:26:00,482 --> 02:26:00,982 HEALTH? 2587 02:26:00,982 --> 02:26:04,486 I WANT TO RECOGNIZE OUR 2588 02:26:04,486 --> 02:26:06,321 COLLEAGUE FROM NIMHD DR. LAURIE 2589 02:26:06,321 --> 02:26:08,089 SCOTT SHELDON FOR HER THINKING 2590 02:26:08,089 --> 02:26:09,224 AROUND THIS. 2591 02:26:09,224 --> 02:26:11,159 FOR THE CHALLENGES THERE ARE A 2592 02:26:11,159 --> 02:26:12,627 LACK OF DATA STANDARDIZATIONS 2593 02:26:12,627 --> 02:26:14,095 ACROSS THE PROJECTS AND DATA 2594 02:26:14,095 --> 02:26:19,301 SETS THUS FAR. 2595 02:26:19,301 --> 02:26:21,169 WE'RE CALLING FOR PROJECTS TO 2596 02:26:21,169 --> 02:26:23,371 BRAIN STORM ABOUT COMMON DATA 2597 02:26:23,371 --> 02:26:24,906 ELEMENTS. 2598 02:26:24,906 --> 02:26:27,943 ALSO BARRIERS TO DATA DESPITE 2599 02:26:27,943 --> 02:26:29,544 NIH'S NEW POLICY FOR DATA 2600 02:26:29,544 --> 02:26:30,445 MANAGEMENT AND SHARING. 2601 02:26:30,445 --> 02:26:33,214 THERE'S STILL GOING TO BE 2602 02:26:33,214 --> 02:26:33,949 BARRIERS FROM THE COMMUNITY 2603 02:26:33,949 --> 02:26:37,886 ABOUT SHARING THEIR DATA. 2604 02:26:37,886 --> 02:26:39,621 THERE'S ALSO A LACK OF 2605 02:26:39,621 --> 02:26:40,455 REPRESENTATIVENESS IN OUR 2606 02:26:40,455 --> 02:26:43,491 CURRENT DATA SETS. 2607 02:26:43,491 --> 02:26:45,760 FOR EXAMPLE, UNDER REPRESENTED 2608 02:26:45,760 --> 02:26:47,729 COMMUNITIES ARE NOT WELL 2609 02:26:47,729 --> 02:26:48,296 REPRESENTED AND SOMETIMES 2610 02:26:48,296 --> 02:26:51,466 EXCLUDED FROM THE DATA SETS. 2611 02:26:51,466 --> 02:26:54,536 ANOTHER CHALLENGE THE FOCUS THAT 2612 02:26:54,536 --> 02:26:56,304 MOST INTERVENTIONS THAT INCLUDE 2613 02:26:56,304 --> 02:26:59,007 SOCIAL DETERMINATES OF HEALTH 2614 02:26:59,007 --> 02:26:59,941 FOCUS ON INDIVIDUAL LEVEL 2615 02:26:59,941 --> 02:27:01,876 OUTCOMES WITH LIMITED ATTENTION 2616 02:27:01,876 --> 02:27:04,145 TO THE COMMUNITY OR STRUCTURAL 2617 02:27:04,145 --> 02:27:05,880 LEVEL OF SOCIAL DETERMINATES OF 2618 02:27:05,880 --> 02:27:06,681 HEALTH. 2619 02:27:06,681 --> 02:27:08,083 AND FINALLY THERE'S A CHALLENGE 2620 02:27:08,083 --> 02:27:14,255 IN TERMS OF THE LACK OF TRAINING 2621 02:27:14,255 --> 02:27:16,491 OUT IN THE EXTRAMURAL COMMUNITY 2622 02:27:16,491 --> 02:27:17,892 OF MULTI-LEVEL AND SOCIAL 2623 02:27:17,892 --> 02:27:19,094 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH DATA. 2624 02:27:19,094 --> 02:27:21,129 WHAT ARE THE OPPORTUNITIES? 2625 02:27:21,129 --> 02:27:21,863 THERE ARE SOME OPPORTUNITIES. 2626 02:27:21,863 --> 02:27:23,631 THERE'S NOT AN OPPORTUNITY TO 2627 02:27:23,631 --> 02:27:25,633 UNDERSTAND THE IMPACT OF SOCIAL 2628 02:27:25,633 --> 02:27:29,004 AND STRUCTURAL DETERMINATES OF 2629 02:27:29,004 --> 02:27:31,773 HEALTH ACROSS HEALTH CONDITIONS 2630 02:27:31,773 --> 02:27:33,875 AND DOMAINS AND THERE'S ALSO 2631 02:27:33,875 --> 02:27:36,745 OPPORTUNITIES TO BUILD 2632 02:27:36,745 --> 02:27:37,212 STRUCTURAL AND SOCIAL 2633 02:27:37,212 --> 02:27:47,722 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH MODELS. 2634 02:27:53,495 --> 02:27:56,064 WE LOOKING AT DATA ON 2635 02:27:56,064 --> 02:27:56,664 GEOGRAPHICAL AREA DATA. 2636 02:27:56,664 --> 02:28:00,468 IT CAN BE LINKED TO 2637 02:28:00,468 --> 02:28:01,336 INDIVIDUAL-LEVEL PARTICIPANT 2638 02:28:01,336 --> 02:28:03,104 DATA USING THE PARTICIPANT'S 2639 02:28:03,104 --> 02:28:05,206 ADDRESSES AND ZIP CODES AND SO 2640 02:28:05,206 --> 02:28:08,009 BY USING POPULATION-LEVEL DATA 2641 02:28:08,009 --> 02:28:09,677 IN THAT WAY THAT'S ONE EXAMPLE 2642 02:28:09,677 --> 02:28:12,947 AND ONE WAY TO EXTEND THE DATA 2643 02:28:12,947 --> 02:28:15,283 SET BEYOND IT'S ORIGINAL INTENT 2644 02:28:15,283 --> 02:28:16,518 TO ANSWER NEW QUESTIONS OR 2645 02:28:16,518 --> 02:28:17,886 PROVIDE NEW INSIGHTS ABOUT 2646 02:28:17,886 --> 02:28:22,057 FINDINGS. 2647 02:28:22,057 --> 02:28:24,993 SO THIS SLIDE SHOWS YOU THE MANY 2648 02:28:24,993 --> 02:28:27,195 PUBLIC DATA SETS THAT ARE USED 2649 02:28:27,195 --> 02:28:29,864 TO UNDERSTAND THE IMPACT OF 2650 02:28:29,864 --> 02:28:30,799 SOCIAL AND STRUCTURAL 2651 02:28:30,799 --> 02:28:32,834 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH. 2652 02:28:32,834 --> 02:28:35,770 WE HAVE THE U.S. CENSUS BUREAU 2653 02:28:35,770 --> 02:28:38,306 WHICH INCLUDES OTHER DATA SETS 2654 02:28:38,306 --> 02:28:40,875 THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY SURVEY, 2655 02:28:40,875 --> 02:28:42,177 THE AMERICAN HOUSING SURVEY. 2656 02:28:42,177 --> 02:28:45,947 WE HAVE THE HEALTH RESOURCES AND 2657 02:28:45,947 --> 02:28:49,417 SERVICES ADMINISTRATION OR HRSA 2658 02:28:49,417 --> 02:28:50,785 AREA HEALTH RESOURCES FILES. 2659 02:28:50,785 --> 02:28:52,554 CDC HAS SEVERAL DATA SETS SUCH 2660 02:28:52,554 --> 02:28:56,991 AS PLACES AND THE ENVIRONMENTAL 2661 02:28:56,991 --> 02:28:59,260 JUSTICE INDEX. 2662 02:28:59,260 --> 02:29:02,163 ALSO ALL OF US AN NIH PROGRAM 2663 02:29:02,163 --> 02:29:05,133 HAS A VERY LARGE DIVERSE SAMPLE 2664 02:29:05,133 --> 02:29:07,469 OF PATIENTS DIAGNOSED WITH 2665 02:29:07,469 --> 02:29:08,503 CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE, 2666 02:29:08,503 --> 02:29:09,904 DIABETES, CANCER, HIV AND OTHER 2667 02:29:09,904 --> 02:29:15,443 HEALTH CONDITIONS. 2668 02:29:15,443 --> 02:29:17,045 THE COMPASS PROGRAM EMPHASIZES 2669 02:29:17,045 --> 02:29:18,379 THE COLLECTION OF COMMON DATA 2670 02:29:18,379 --> 02:29:20,115 ELEMENTS AMONG INDIVIDUAL 2671 02:29:20,115 --> 02:29:25,587 AWARDEES AND ACROSS AWARDAWARDE. 2672 02:29:25,587 --> 02:29:28,490 WHY ARE WE EMPHASIZING COMMON 2673 02:29:28,490 --> 02:29:29,557 DATA ELEMENTS? 2674 02:29:29,557 --> 02:29:31,993 NOT ONLY IS IT THE VISION OF OUR 2675 02:29:31,993 --> 02:29:33,661 CO-CHAIRS BUT MAINLY IT PROVIDES 2676 02:29:33,661 --> 02:29:37,432 A WAY FOR STANDARDIZATION ACROSS 2677 02:29:37,432 --> 02:29:40,535 THE COLLECTION OF THE PROGRAMS. 2678 02:29:40,535 --> 02:29:43,204 IT PROVIDES FOR A SYSTEMATIC WAY 2679 02:29:43,204 --> 02:29:45,840 ACROSS THE DIFFERENT SITES AND 2680 02:29:45,840 --> 02:29:48,109 STUDIES THAT IS CONSISTENT. 2681 02:29:48,109 --> 02:29:50,278 IT PROMOTES DATA SHARING, DATA 2682 02:29:50,278 --> 02:29:51,880 HARMONIZATION AND CONTRIBUTES TO 2683 02:29:51,880 --> 02:29:54,048 THE LARGE DATA SET AND THIS 2684 02:29:54,048 --> 02:29:57,619 AFFECT THE POWER. 2685 02:29:57,619 --> 02:29:59,420 BY COMPASS EMPHASIZING THE 2686 02:29:59,420 --> 02:30:00,321 COLLECTION OF COMMON ELEMENT WE 2687 02:30:00,321 --> 02:30:02,290 HOPE TO PROVIDE FOR A GREATER 2688 02:30:02,290 --> 02:30:05,160 UNDERSTANDING OF HOW INTERVENING 2689 02:30:05,160 --> 02:30:07,395 ON STRUCTURAL FACTORS REDUCES 2690 02:30:07,395 --> 02:30:09,864 DISPARITIES AND HEALTH OUTCOMES 2691 02:30:09,864 --> 02:30:12,634 AMONG VARIOUS PRIORITY 2692 02:30:12,634 --> 02:30:13,434 POPULATIONS, NEIGHBORHOODS, 2693 02:30:13,434 --> 02:30:14,435 COMMUNITIES, COUNTIES, STATES, 2694 02:30:14,435 --> 02:30:16,704 ETCETERA. 2695 02:30:16,704 --> 02:30:18,940 AS THE FOUNDATION OF OUR 2696 02:30:18,940 --> 02:30:21,509 THINKING, THE PROGRAM TEAM LOOKS 2697 02:30:21,509 --> 02:30:25,213 TOWARDS THE PHOENIX X TOOL KIT, 2698 02:30:25,213 --> 02:30:25,880 SOCIAL DETERMINATES OF HEALTH 2699 02:30:25,880 --> 02:30:28,316 COLLECTION LAUNCHED IN 2020 AND 2700 02:30:28,316 --> 02:30:31,319 IS EXPANDING WITH THE ADDITION 2701 02:30:31,319 --> 02:30:32,320 OF MANY SOCIAL DETERMINATES OF 2702 02:30:32,320 --> 02:30:35,690 HEALTH PROTOCOLS. 2703 02:30:35,690 --> 02:30:39,460 SO THE PHOENIX X TOOL KIT 2704 02:30:39,460 --> 02:30:41,329 CONTAINS CONSENSUS MEASURES FOR 2705 02:30:41,329 --> 02:30:43,932 PHENOTYPES AND EXPOSURES AND 2706 02:30:43,932 --> 02:30:45,800 PROVIDES RECOMMENDED STANDARD 2707 02:30:45,800 --> 02:30:46,367 DATA COLLECTION PROTOCOL 2708 02:30:46,367 --> 02:30:50,338 MEASURES AND IS SUPPORTED BY 2709 02:30:50,338 --> 02:30:53,875 VARIOUS NIH CENTERS, INSTITUTES 2710 02:30:53,875 --> 02:30:55,743 AND OFFICES. 2711 02:30:55,743 --> 02:30:57,612 THERE ARE INDIVIDUAL AND 2712 02:30:57,612 --> 02:30:58,246 STRUCTURAL SOCIAL DETERMINATES 2713 02:30:58,246 --> 02:31:01,716 OF HEALTH PROTOCOLS HOUSED IN 2714 02:31:01,716 --> 02:31:04,352 THE PHOENIX X SDOH COLLECTION. 2715 02:31:04,352 --> 02:31:09,090 HERE'S A LIST OF THOSE PROTOCOLS 2716 02:31:09,090 --> 02:31:10,892 RELEVANT TO COMPASS AND MAY BE 2717 02:31:10,892 --> 02:31:12,293 OTHER RELEVANT PROTOCOLS BUT 2718 02:31:12,293 --> 02:31:14,896 THESE ARE A FEW. 2719 02:31:14,896 --> 02:31:18,266 AGAIN, AIR QUALITY INDEX IS ONE, 2720 02:31:18,266 --> 02:31:20,068 CONCENTRATED POVERTY, 2721 02:31:20,068 --> 02:31:23,738 ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE, FOOD 2722 02:31:23,738 --> 02:31:26,741 SWAMPS, RACE AND ETHNIC 2723 02:31:26,741 --> 02:31:28,443 RESIDENTIAL SEGREGATION, SOCIAL 2724 02:31:28,443 --> 02:31:31,079 VULNERABILITY, WATER, ACCESS AND 2725 02:31:31,079 --> 02:31:32,580 SANITATION SO THAT'S JUST AN 2726 02:31:32,580 --> 02:31:33,848 EXAMPLE OF SOME OF THOSE 2727 02:31:33,848 --> 02:31:38,286 PROTOCOLS THAT MIGHT BE RELEVANT 2728 02:31:38,286 --> 02:31:39,320 TO COMPASS. 2729 02:31:39,320 --> 02:31:41,122 SO GEOGRAPHIC IDENTIFIERS USED 2730 02:31:41,122 --> 02:31:42,824 TO LINK DATA SETS FROM DIFFERENT 2731 02:31:42,824 --> 02:31:44,626 SOURCES IS WHAT YOU'RE SEEING ON 2732 02:31:44,626 --> 02:31:45,593 THIS SLIDE. 2733 02:31:45,593 --> 02:31:47,962 AND THIS JUST GIVES ANOTHER 2734 02:31:47,962 --> 02:31:50,732 OPPORTUNITY AND EXAMPLE OF HOW 2735 02:31:50,732 --> 02:31:55,136 YOU CAN UTILIZE ZIP CODE 2736 02:31:55,136 --> 02:31:59,274 TABULATION AREAS OR ZTAs WHICH 2737 02:31:59,274 --> 02:32:01,876 ARE A MORE GENERALIZED AREA OF 2738 02:32:01,876 --> 02:32:02,610 ZIP CODE SERVICE AREAS. 2739 02:32:02,610 --> 02:32:07,048 THIS PROVIDES AN EXAMPLE. 2740 02:32:07,048 --> 02:32:08,783 AND IN THE INTEREST OF TIME, 2741 02:32:08,783 --> 02:32:10,318 THIS IS THE LAST SLIDE. 2742 02:32:10,318 --> 02:32:12,520 I WANTED TO PROVIDE ANOTHER 2743 02:32:12,520 --> 02:32:14,956 EXAMPLE OF A WAY OUR COMMON FUND 2744 02:32:14,956 --> 02:32:19,560 DATA ECO SYSTEM WHICH INVOLVED 2745 02:32:19,560 --> 02:32:23,298 MANY OF OUR COMMON FUND PROGRAM 2746 02:32:23,298 --> 02:32:24,532 INCLUDES OUR KIDS FIRST PROGRAM. 2747 02:32:24,532 --> 02:32:27,201 A RESEARCH QUESTION WAS ASKED 2748 02:32:27,201 --> 02:32:30,138 ABOUT IS HOUSING INSECURITY 2749 02:32:30,138 --> 02:32:32,307 ASSOCIATED WITH CHILDHOOD CANCER 2750 02:32:32,307 --> 02:32:32,573 SURVIVAL. 2751 02:32:32,573 --> 02:32:34,208 THE FOUR DIFFERENT LEVELS IN 2752 02:32:34,208 --> 02:32:37,879 WHICH THE ANSWER CAN BE ANAL 2753 02:32:37,879 --> 02:32:39,547 ANALYZED. 2754 02:32:39,547 --> 02:32:40,715 IT PROVIDES AN EXAMPLE. 2755 02:32:40,715 --> 02:32:42,550 THESE ARE FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES 2756 02:32:42,550 --> 02:32:45,153 YOU CAN EXPLORE IN TERMS OF 2757 02:32:45,153 --> 02:32:46,321 LOOKING AT SOCIAL DETERMINATES 2758 02:32:46,321 --> 02:32:48,956 OF HEALTH AND THE WAY THAT YOU 2759 02:32:48,956 --> 02:32:51,092 CAN APPLY YOUR RESEARCH TO 2760 02:32:51,092 --> 02:32:51,993 INTEGRATE INTO THOSE FUNDING 2761 02:32:51,993 --> 02:32:52,660 OPPORTUNITIES THAT ARE ACTIVE AT 2762 02:32:52,660 --> 02:32:55,029 THIS TIME. 2763 02:32:55,029 --> 02:32:55,830 AND WE WANT TO THANK YOU FOR 2764 02:32:55,830 --> 02:33:01,869 YOUR ATTENTION. 2765 02:33:01,869 --> 02:33:11,112 [APPLAUSE] 2766 02:33:11,112 --> 02:33:13,481 >> THANK YOU. 2767 02:33:13,481 --> 02:33:15,316 IF THERE'S QUESTIONS WE CAN 2768 02:33:15,316 --> 02:33:17,218 ENTERTAIN THEM NOW EITHER COME 2769 02:33:17,218 --> 02:33:19,354 TO THE MICROPHONE OR INVITE YOU 2770 02:33:19,354 --> 02:33:25,693 TO ENTER YOUR QUESTION IN THE 2771 02:33:25,693 --> 02:33:25,893 WIKI. 2772 02:33:25,893 --> 02:33:27,862 >> THERE'S A QUESTION IN WIKI, 2773 02:33:27,862 --> 02:33:29,897 I'M PARAPHRASING, WHAT DO YOU 2774 02:33:29,897 --> 02:33:32,300 SEE AS THE ROLE OF TECHNOLOGY 2775 02:33:32,300 --> 02:33:35,036 LIKE WEARABLE DEVICES OR 2776 02:33:35,036 --> 02:33:36,304 AFFORDABLE BLOOD PRESSURE 2777 02:33:36,304 --> 02:33:36,904 MEASUREMENTS IN THE COMMUNITY 2778 02:33:36,904 --> 02:33:39,273 INTERVENTIONS? 2779 02:33:39,273 --> 02:33:42,076 >> THAT'S A GOOD QUESTION. 2780 02:33:42,076 --> 02:33:45,880 WE DO HAVE SOME PROJECTS THAT 2781 02:33:45,880 --> 02:33:48,649 ARE PROPOSING THOSE TYPES OF 2782 02:33:48,649 --> 02:33:48,950 INSTRUMENTS. 2783 02:33:48,950 --> 02:33:53,121 AND WE SEE THEM AS VERY CRITICAL 2784 02:33:53,121 --> 02:33:54,722 IN THAT THEY CAN HAVE WEARABLE 2785 02:33:54,722 --> 02:33:58,826 DEVICES AS A DATA COLLECTION AS 2786 02:33:58,826 --> 02:34:00,561 A WAY TO COLLECT 2787 02:34:00,561 --> 02:34:02,296 INDIVIDUAL-LEVEL DATA IN TERMS 2788 02:34:02,296 --> 02:34:04,065 OF OUTCOMES BUT WE'RE ALSO 2789 02:34:04,065 --> 02:34:05,933 EMPHASIZING SINCE THIS IS A 2790 02:34:05,933 --> 02:34:07,702 MULTI-LEVEL TYPE OF 2791 02:34:07,702 --> 02:34:08,569 INTERVENTION, STRUCTURAL 2792 02:34:08,569 --> 02:34:11,839 INTERVENTION THAT THEY INCLUDE 2793 02:34:11,839 --> 02:34:12,874 OTHER MEASURES AS WELL ON A 2794 02:34:12,874 --> 02:34:13,908 COMMUNITY LEVEL AND MORE 2795 02:34:13,908 --> 02:34:16,811 STRUCTURAL LEVEL IN ADDITION TO, 2796 02:34:16,811 --> 02:34:17,879 FOR EXAMPLE, WEARABLE 2797 02:34:17,879 --> 02:34:18,579 TECHNOLOGIES AND SUCH. 2798 02:34:18,579 --> 02:34:21,883 BUT WE DO HAVE SOME PROGRAMS, 2799 02:34:21,883 --> 02:34:23,317 SOME PROJECTS THAT ARE PROPOSING 2800 02:34:23,317 --> 02:34:29,757 DATA IN THAT WAY. 2801 02:34:29,757 --> 02:34:30,925 >> THANK YOU FOR THE WONDERFUL 2802 02:34:30,925 --> 02:34:31,926 PRESENTATION. 2803 02:34:31,926 --> 02:34:33,861 I DON'T WORK IN THIS AREA BUT 2804 02:34:33,861 --> 02:34:36,998 I'VE HAD THE GOOD FORTUNE OF 2805 02:34:36,998 --> 02:34:38,533 WORKING WITH A START UP COMPANY 2806 02:34:38,533 --> 02:34:39,534 IN NORTH PHILADELPHIA WHICH 2807 02:34:39,534 --> 02:34:42,637 FOCUSES ON SDOH. 2808 02:34:42,637 --> 02:34:48,009 I FIND THE CONTEXT IN WHICH YOU 2809 02:34:48,009 --> 02:34:49,610 PRESENTED VERY INTERESTING. 2810 02:34:49,610 --> 02:34:51,179 THE QUESTION I HAVE FOR YOU IN 2811 02:34:51,179 --> 02:34:52,747 MY LIMITED UNDERSTANDING A LOT 2812 02:34:52,747 --> 02:35:01,823 OF THE SDOH RELATE D DATA EXIST 2813 02:35:01,823 --> 02:35:05,493 IN STATE OWNED DATA AND THE 2814 02:35:05,493 --> 02:35:06,594 MEDICAL DATA STILL RESIDES WITH 2815 02:35:06,594 --> 02:35:07,028 THE HOSPITALS. 2816 02:35:07,028 --> 02:35:09,530 FOR A COMMUNITY LIKE US WHERE 2817 02:35:09,530 --> 02:35:11,165 WE'RE INTERESTED IN MAKING 2818 02:35:11,165 --> 02:35:15,603 PREDICTIONS AT AN INDIVIDUAL 2819 02:35:15,603 --> 02:35:17,238 LEVEL, PATIENT LEVEL, IT WOULD 2820 02:35:17,238 --> 02:35:23,744 BE NICE TO ST HAVE THE DATA 2821 02:35:23,744 --> 02:35:28,416 MEASURES AND THEY MAY HAVE 2822 02:35:28,416 --> 02:35:29,884 COMORBIDITIES SOCIAL BARRIERS IT 2823 02:35:29,884 --> 02:35:35,523 WOULD BE NICE TO HAVE THE SAME 2824 02:35:35,523 --> 02:35:38,059 DATA THE MEDICAL AND DATA FOR 2825 02:35:38,059 --> 02:35:43,998 THE SAME PATIENT AMON MISED OF 2826 02:35:43,998 --> 02:35:46,133 COURSE -- ANONYMIZED OF COURSE 2827 02:35:46,133 --> 02:35:48,102 AND HOW DO YOU SEE THIS EVOLVING 2828 02:35:48,102 --> 02:35:49,871 IN THE FUTURE AND ARE THERE 2829 02:35:49,871 --> 02:35:50,171 INITIATIVES? 2830 02:35:50,171 --> 02:35:59,380 >> THAT'S A GOOD QUESTION. 2831 02:35:59,380 --> 02:36:02,016 THERE'S AN EFFORT FROM THE WHITE 2832 02:36:02,016 --> 02:36:03,985 HOUSE THAT IS DEVELOPING A PLAY 2833 02:36:03,985 --> 02:36:05,887 BOOK AND ONE OF THE PILLARS OF 2834 02:36:05,887 --> 02:36:08,756 THE PLAY BOOK IS DATA LINKAGE. 2835 02:36:08,756 --> 02:36:10,725 IT'S FOCUSSED ON SDOH 2836 02:36:10,725 --> 02:36:11,058 SPECIFICALLY. 2837 02:36:11,058 --> 02:36:12,493 WE UNDERSTAND IT'S HARD TO MAKE 2838 02:36:12,493 --> 02:36:14,095 PREDICTIONS AND IT'S HARD TO 2839 02:36:14,095 --> 02:36:17,231 BUILD A CASE FOR INTERVENTION 2840 02:36:17,231 --> 02:36:17,932 DEVELOPMENT OR PROGRAM 2841 02:36:17,932 --> 02:36:18,866 DEVELOPMENT OR POLICY WHEN YOU 2842 02:36:18,866 --> 02:36:20,935 DON'T HAVE DATA. 2843 02:36:20,935 --> 02:36:22,103 SO WE UNDERSTAND AND RECOGNIZE 2844 02:36:22,103 --> 02:36:24,739 DATA IS CRITICAL TO MOVING THIS 2845 02:36:24,739 --> 02:36:25,873 WORK FORWARD AND IT IS A 2846 02:36:25,873 --> 02:36:29,377 CHALLENGE BUT AT THE FEDERAL 2847 02:36:29,377 --> 02:36:30,211 GOVERNMENT LEVEL WE ARE WORKING 2848 02:36:30,211 --> 02:36:31,913 ON IT AND HOPEFULLY IN THE 2849 02:36:31,913 --> 02:36:33,514 NEXT -- IT'S NOT GOING TO BE 2850 02:36:33,514 --> 02:36:35,650 QUICK, RIGHT, SO IT'S A 2851 02:36:35,650 --> 02:36:40,421 CHALLENGE TRYING TO INTEGRATE 2852 02:36:40,421 --> 02:36:41,822 DIFFERENT DATA SOURCES FROM 2853 02:36:41,822 --> 02:36:42,657 DIFFERENT SECTORS AND FROM 2854 02:36:42,657 --> 02:36:44,325 DIFFERENT PARTNERS, ETCETERA. 2855 02:36:44,325 --> 02:36:47,128 IT IS A CHALLENGE THAT WE 2856 02:36:47,128 --> 02:36:47,962 UNDERSTAND AND RECOGNIZE AND ARE 2857 02:36:47,962 --> 02:36:50,665 TRYING TO MOVE ON. 2858 02:36:50,665 --> 02:36:51,832 >> OKAY. 2859 02:36:51,832 --> 02:36:53,501 WE HAVE SOME OTHER QUESTIONS 2860 02:36:53,501 --> 02:36:56,571 THAT HAVE BEEN POSTED TO WIKI 2861 02:36:56,571 --> 02:36:58,839 BUT MORE OF A GENERAL NATURE. 2862 02:36:58,839 --> 02:37:00,341 IN THE INTEREST OF TIME WE'LL 2863 02:37:00,341 --> 02:37:05,046 MOVE ON TO THE NEXT SPEAKER. 2864 02:37:05,046 --> 02:37:08,816 >> SO, I'M THE CHIEF OF THE 2865 02:37:08,816 --> 02:37:14,322 REVIEW OFFICE AT NIBIB AND WOULD 2866 02:37:14,322 --> 02:37:18,326 LIKE TO ADD ONE MORE INITIATIVE 2867 02:37:18,326 --> 02:37:19,427 IT'S A TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT TO 2868 02:37:19,427 --> 02:37:23,698 REDUCE HEALTH DISPARITIES. 2869 02:37:23,698 --> 02:37:27,868 IT'S CURRENTLY RUNNING SO THE 2870 02:37:27,868 --> 02:37:30,271 NEXT DATE IS JANUARY 26 AND WE 2871 02:37:30,271 --> 02:37:36,077 WOULD LIKE TO SEE MORE 2872 02:37:36,077 --> 02:37:36,577 APPLICATIONS. 2873 02:37:36,577 --> 02:37:39,580 IT DIDN'T HAVE PARTICULAR 2874 02:37:39,580 --> 02:37:42,149 MULTI-SCALE MODELLING BUT IT'S 2875 02:37:42,149 --> 02:37:44,318 OPEN TO ANY TECHNOLOGY 2876 02:37:44,318 --> 02:37:45,386 DEVELOPMENT. 2877 02:37:45,386 --> 02:37:45,653 THANK YOU. 2878 02:37:45,653 --> 02:37:47,254 >> WOULD YOU PLEASE POST THE 2879 02:37:47,254 --> 02:37:48,155 INFORMATION IN THE WIKI? 2880 02:37:48,155 --> 02:37:48,789 THAT WOULD BE GREAT. 2881 02:37:48,789 --> 02:37:57,131 AT THIS TIME I'D LIKE TO 2882 02:37:57,131 --> 02:37:58,466 INTRODUCE THE NEXT SPEAKER. 2883 02:37:58,466 --> 02:38:01,702 >> I'D LIKE TO INTRODUCE ALLISON 2884 02:38:01,702 --> 02:38:04,772 RILEY TO INTRODUCE HER WORK AND 2885 02:38:04,772 --> 02:38:07,174 ALL HER METHODS SHOULD SEEM 2886 02:38:07,174 --> 02:38:08,142 FAMILIAR AND HAS EXPERIENCE 2887 02:38:08,142 --> 02:38:09,910 ADDRESSING HEALTH DISPARITIES 2888 02:38:09,910 --> 02:38:11,245 THROUGH THINGS LIKE THE BUILT 2889 02:38:11,245 --> 02:38:12,847 ENVIRONMENT WE JUST HEARD ABOUT 2890 02:38:12,847 --> 02:38:15,282 AND ALSO THINGS I THINK ARE 2891 02:38:15,282 --> 02:38:16,717 EXCITING IS HAS A LOT OF 2892 02:38:16,717 --> 02:38:17,451 EXPERIENCE WORKING WITH POLICY 2893 02:38:17,451 --> 02:38:19,353 MAKERS AND SO THINKING HOW DO WE 2894 02:38:19,353 --> 02:38:20,454 USE OUR MODELS AND COMMUNICATE 2895 02:38:20,454 --> 02:38:23,491 OUR MODELS AND HOW DO WE BUILD 2896 02:38:23,491 --> 02:38:25,126 THEM IN A ROBUST AND RELIABLE 2897 02:38:25,126 --> 02:38:26,494 WAY TO HAVE IMPACT. 2898 02:38:26,494 --> 02:38:26,761 ALL YOURS. 2899 02:38:26,761 --> 02:38:29,864 THANK YOU. 2900 02:38:29,864 --> 02:38:31,065 >> HI, THANKS. 2901 02:38:31,065 --> 02:38:36,504 I'M ALLISON RILEY AN ASSISTANT 2902 02:38:36,504 --> 02:38:39,173 SOON TO BE PROFESSOR AT MARYLAND 2903 02:38:39,173 --> 02:38:43,911 COLLEGE PARK DOWN THE ROAD. 2904 02:38:43,911 --> 02:38:46,580 I'LL ADMIT I WAS SURPRISED WHEN 2905 02:38:46,580 --> 02:38:48,549 I WAS ASKED TO BE A SPEAKER -- 2906 02:38:48,549 --> 02:38:50,951 SORRY, THERE'S AN ECHO I'M 2907 02:38:50,951 --> 02:38:52,820 TRYING TO GET USED TO. 2908 02:38:52,820 --> 02:38:55,656 I'M TRYING TO FOCUS ON THE BUILT 2909 02:38:55,656 --> 02:38:57,391 ENVIRONMENT AND WHAT IS IT ABOUT 2910 02:38:57,391 --> 02:39:01,095 THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT THAT ARE 2911 02:39:01,095 --> 02:39:02,963 CAUSING THESE HEALTH OUTCOMES 2912 02:39:02,963 --> 02:39:07,635 THAT ARE NEGATIVE AND REALLY 2913 02:39:07,635 --> 02:39:10,037 STRADDLE THE SOCIO ECONOMIC 2914 02:39:10,037 --> 02:39:10,438 DIVIDE. 2915 02:39:10,438 --> 02:39:13,074 SO THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT IS A 2916 02:39:13,074 --> 02:39:14,909 KEY DETERMINATE OF HEALTH. 2917 02:39:14,909 --> 02:39:16,811 THANK YOU FOR -- WHEN YOU WENT 2918 02:39:16,811 --> 02:39:17,912 THROUGH YOUR PRESENTATION, ONE 2919 02:39:17,912 --> 02:39:20,481 OF THE AREAS OF THAT BIG CIRCLE 2920 02:39:20,481 --> 02:39:28,489 IS IS THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT. 2921 02:39:28,489 --> 02:39:30,825 I'M NOT GOING TO GO INTO TOO 2922 02:39:30,825 --> 02:39:33,127 MUCH OF WHAT PEOPLE ALREADY KNOW 2923 02:39:33,127 --> 02:39:33,327 ABOUT. 2924 02:39:33,327 --> 02:39:34,762 AIR POLLUTION TENDS TO BE WORSE 2925 02:39:34,762 --> 02:39:37,798 IN AREAS THAT WERE HISTORICALLY 2926 02:39:37,798 --> 02:39:39,166 RED LINES. 2927 02:39:39,166 --> 02:39:46,440 AREAS DENIED FEDERAL MORTGAGES 2928 02:39:46,440 --> 02:39:48,509 BECAUSE THEY HAD AT LEAST ONE 2929 02:39:48,509 --> 02:39:51,512 PERSON OF COLOR AND IF YOU GO TO 2930 02:39:51,512 --> 02:39:56,917 AREAS A WHERE YOU COULD GET A 2931 02:39:56,917 --> 02:39:58,953 MORTGAGE AT A GOOD RATE AND 2932 02:39:58,953 --> 02:40:00,020 THERE'S HEAT DISPARITIES IN 2933 02:40:00,020 --> 02:40:01,222 AREAS RED LINED. 2934 02:40:01,222 --> 02:40:03,624 THOSE TEND TO BE HOTTER IN URBAN 2935 02:40:03,624 --> 02:40:09,864 AREAS AND AREAS THAT WERE DEEMED 2936 02:40:09,864 --> 02:40:12,666 HIGH-QUALITY INVESTMENTS ARE 2937 02:40:12,666 --> 02:40:14,301 COOLER. 2938 02:40:14,301 --> 02:40:17,872 PORTLAND, OREGON THE AVERAGE 2939 02:40:17,872 --> 02:40:19,473 DIFFERENCE IS ABOUT 12 DEGREES. 2940 02:40:19,473 --> 02:40:22,676 THAT'S HUGE, RIGHT. 2941 02:40:22,676 --> 02:40:24,311 WHY IS THIS -- WHAT IS CAUSING 2942 02:40:24,311 --> 02:40:25,479 AIR POLLUTION AND HEAT? 2943 02:40:25,479 --> 02:40:26,313 LET'S LOOK AT BALTIMORE. 2944 02:40:26,313 --> 02:40:32,086 I LIVED IN BALTIMORE MANY MANY 2945 02:40:32,086 --> 02:40:32,319 YEARS. 2946 02:40:32,319 --> 02:40:34,955 THERE'S FEWER TREES, WHAT DOES 2947 02:40:34,955 --> 02:40:35,489 THAT MEAN? 2948 02:40:35,489 --> 02:40:37,491 IN AREAS HISTORICALLY RED LINED 2949 02:40:37,491 --> 02:40:40,528 IT MEANS IT'S HOTTER. 2950 02:40:40,528 --> 02:40:44,265 MORE POLLUTION, MORE ABILITY TO 2951 02:40:44,265 --> 02:40:47,401 COLLECT NOX AND LONG BEACH, 2952 02:40:47,401 --> 02:40:48,702 ASTHMA ALLEY. 2953 02:40:48,702 --> 02:40:52,807 IT'S NO COINCIDENCE BECAUSE THE 2954 02:40:52,807 --> 02:40:55,476 PORT IS RIGHT THERE. 2955 02:40:55,476 --> 02:40:58,813 THERE'S SHIPS AND NOT ONLY 2956 02:40:58,813 --> 02:41:01,649 HIGHWAY AND TRAINING BUT THEY 2957 02:41:01,649 --> 02:41:02,283 BURN BUNKER FUEL. 2958 02:41:02,283 --> 02:41:04,485 IT'S THE WORSE FUEL TO BREATHE 2959 02:41:04,485 --> 02:41:09,190 FILLED WITH NOX AND SOX HAVE 2960 02:41:09,190 --> 02:41:14,295 SHIPS AND PORTS BURNING THIS 2961 02:41:14,295 --> 02:41:14,695 OIL. 2962 02:41:14,695 --> 02:41:16,764 WE SEE WITH THE INCOME DIVIDE 2963 02:41:16,764 --> 02:41:19,066 WITH AREAS WITH HIGHER INCOME IN 2964 02:41:19,066 --> 02:41:21,902 BALTIMORE, MORE TREES, LESS AIR 2965 02:41:21,902 --> 02:41:25,072 POLLUTION, LOWERING ON THE WEST 2966 02:41:25,072 --> 02:41:26,407 SIDE MUCH LOWER INCOME, HIGHER 2967 02:41:26,407 --> 02:41:36,650 POLLUTION, HOTTER. 2968 02:41:36,650 --> 02:41:42,323 I LOOK AT WHAT IS THE EXTREME 2969 02:41:42,323 --> 02:41:45,092 ENVIRONMENT IN EXTREME EVENTS 2970 02:41:45,092 --> 02:41:46,994 CAUSING INFRASTRUCTURE TO BE AN 2971 02:41:46,994 --> 02:41:48,295 AMPLIFIER OF THESE NEGATIVE 2972 02:41:48,295 --> 02:41:49,463 OUTCOMES. 2973 02:41:49,463 --> 02:41:53,267 SO IF WE LOOK AT FLOODS OR 2974 02:41:53,267 --> 02:41:54,368 HURRICANES, THEY HAVE 2975 02:41:54,368 --> 02:41:55,102 SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON 2976 02:41:55,102 --> 02:41:56,337 INDIVIDUALS AND COMMUNITIES AS 2977 02:41:56,337 --> 02:41:56,971 YOU CAN IMAGINE. 2978 02:41:56,971 --> 02:41:59,773 BUT THE IMPACT IS NOT USUALLY 2979 02:41:59,773 --> 02:42:00,541 FELT EVENLY. 2980 02:42:00,541 --> 02:42:04,645 IT CAN DISRUPT LIVES. 2981 02:42:04,645 --> 02:42:07,014 LOSS OF INCOME AND YOU MAY LOSE 2982 02:42:07,014 --> 02:42:08,682 YOUR JOB IMMEDIATELY OR HOME. 2983 02:42:08,682 --> 02:42:11,318 THE LIKELIHOOD OF LOSING HOME 2984 02:42:11,318 --> 02:42:15,022 VARIES DRAMATICALLY ACROSS THE 2985 02:42:15,022 --> 02:42:17,024 SOCIO ECONOMIC DIVIDE AND WE'LL 2986 02:42:17,024 --> 02:42:18,826 TALK ABOUT THAT. 2987 02:42:18,826 --> 02:42:20,861 THERE'S INCREASINGLY FORCED 2988 02:42:20,861 --> 02:42:22,363 MIGRATION THAT OCCURS AFTER A 2989 02:42:22,363 --> 02:42:24,365 DISASTER NOT ONLY IN HURRICANE 2990 02:42:24,365 --> 02:42:30,304 KATRINA BUT IN SMALLER EVENTS 2991 02:42:30,304 --> 02:42:33,274 WHERE PEOPLE ARE FORCED TO 2992 02:42:33,274 --> 02:42:33,908 RELOCATE SEEKING ECONOMIC 2993 02:42:33,908 --> 02:42:35,109 OPPORTUNITIES AND THIS IS A 2994 02:42:35,109 --> 02:42:41,649 MAJOR STRESSOR FOR INDIVIDUALS. 2995 02:42:41,649 --> 02:42:42,516 THERE'S MAJOR HEALTH EFFECTS 2996 02:42:42,516 --> 02:42:43,484 CAUSED BY A LACK OF 2997 02:42:43,484 --> 02:42:43,851 INFRASTRUCTURE. 2998 02:42:43,851 --> 02:42:45,819 THERE'S A LACK OF MEDICATION 2999 02:42:45,819 --> 02:42:48,956 THAT CAN OCCUR. 3000 02:42:48,956 --> 02:42:50,291 SO WE SEE THE HEALTH CARE 3001 02:42:50,291 --> 02:42:52,726 NONPROFIT THAT IS OPERATED IN 3002 02:42:52,726 --> 02:42:55,129 BALTIMORE BUT DEPLOYED AFTER 3003 02:42:55,129 --> 02:42:56,964 MOST DISASTERS IN THE UNITED 3004 02:42:56,964 --> 02:42:57,665 STATES FOUND THAT THE AVERAGE 3005 02:42:57,665 --> 02:43:01,568 PERSON OVER THE AGE OF ABOUT 45 3006 02:43:01,568 --> 02:43:05,139 IN THE GULF COAST STATE IS ON 12 3007 02:43:05,139 --> 02:43:05,439 MEDICATION. 3008 02:43:05,439 --> 02:43:06,040 IF YOU ALL OF A SUDDEN LOSE 3009 02:43:06,040 --> 02:43:07,207 ACCESS TO A PHARMACY BECAUSE 3010 02:43:07,207 --> 02:43:09,143 THEY ALL CLOSE, YOU DON'T HAVE 3011 02:43:09,143 --> 02:43:11,578 ACCESS EASILY TO MEDICATIONS AND 3012 02:43:11,578 --> 02:43:12,613 HOPEFULLY THEY'RE ALL WRITTEN 3013 02:43:12,613 --> 02:43:13,747 DOWN WITH THE DOSAGE. 3014 02:43:13,747 --> 02:43:17,885 LACK OF ACCESS TO MEDICAL CARE. 3015 02:43:17,885 --> 02:43:22,356 WE'LL TALK ABOUT THAT. 3016 02:43:22,356 --> 02:43:25,092 ROADS BECOME DESTROYED AND AFTER 3017 02:43:25,092 --> 02:43:27,127 HURRICANE HARVEY THE 9-1-1 3018 02:43:27,127 --> 02:43:29,330 SYSTEM WAS STILL ON ANALOG IN 3019 02:43:29,330 --> 02:43:30,597 MOST THE AREA AND COULD NOT CALL 3020 02:43:30,597 --> 02:43:32,433 FOR HELP BECAUSE OF THE OUTDATED 3021 02:43:32,433 --> 02:43:32,900 SYSTEM. 3022 02:43:32,900 --> 02:43:37,204 THERE'S MENTAL HEALTH 3023 02:43:37,204 --> 02:43:37,538 IMPLICATIONS. 3024 02:43:37,538 --> 02:43:39,707 ALSO AFTER DISASTERS YOU HAVE 3025 02:43:39,707 --> 02:43:40,841 UNRELIABLE POWER WHICH WE'LL 3026 02:43:40,841 --> 02:43:44,345 TALK ABOUT WHICH IS UNRELIABLE, 3027 02:43:44,345 --> 02:43:45,045 UNEVENLY. 3028 02:43:45,045 --> 02:43:47,781 YOU HAVE UNRELIABLE WATER AND 3029 02:43:47,781 --> 02:43:51,752 UNRELIABLE UNEVENLY AND WASTE 3030 02:43:51,752 --> 02:43:53,954 WATER SERVICES ARE UNRELIABLE 3031 02:43:53,954 --> 02:43:57,858 AND UNRELIABLE UNEVENLY. 3032 02:43:57,858 --> 02:43:58,726 I'LL TALK ABOUT THE ROLE 3033 02:43:58,726 --> 02:43:59,293 INFRASTRUCTURE PLAYS IN THE 3034 02:43:59,293 --> 02:44:04,264 IMPACTS. 3035 02:44:04,264 --> 02:44:08,602 I'LL GO THROUGH EXAMPLES IN MY 3036 02:44:08,602 --> 02:44:08,869 RESEARCH. 3037 02:44:08,869 --> 02:44:10,871 SO THIS IS THIS IS IN A LOT OF 3038 02:44:10,871 --> 02:44:11,672 WAYS BY DESIGN. 3039 02:44:11,672 --> 02:44:14,975 THE PICTURE ON THE NORTH IS A 3040 02:44:14,975 --> 02:44:16,777 PICTURE FROM WEST HOUSTON. 3041 02:44:16,777 --> 02:44:18,712 SO HURRICANE HARVEY, 30 TO 40 3042 02:44:18,712 --> 02:44:21,315 INCHES OF RAIN IN TWO DAYS. 3043 02:44:21,315 --> 02:44:22,883 MASSIVE FLOODING. 3044 02:44:22,883 --> 02:44:26,920 WAS NOT TIME TO EVACUATE. 3045 02:44:26,920 --> 02:44:27,588 SHELTER IN PLACE. 3046 02:44:27,588 --> 02:44:31,258 ANOTHER AND EAST OF HOUSTON HAD 3047 02:44:31,258 --> 02:44:33,494 WORSE DAMAGE AND WEST HAD HOMES 3048 02:44:33,494 --> 02:44:37,531 FLOOD, DAMAGE WAS NOT AS SEVERE. 3049 02:44:37,531 --> 02:44:39,366 THE REASON IS IS HOW THE LAND 3050 02:44:39,366 --> 02:44:40,401 WAS DESIGN. 3051 02:44:40,401 --> 02:44:44,004 ON THE WEST, IT TENDS TO BE MORE 3052 02:44:44,004 --> 02:44:47,041 GREEN SPACE AND SPONGES TO 3053 02:44:47,041 --> 02:44:49,209 ABSORB THE WATER. 3054 02:44:49,209 --> 02:44:53,847 ON THE WEST YOU HAVE CONCRETE 3055 02:44:53,847 --> 02:44:54,748 DRAINAGE DITCHES. 3056 02:44:54,748 --> 02:44:57,084 THESE ARE NOT GREAT FOR DAY TO 3057 02:44:57,084 --> 02:44:58,852 DAY HUMAN HEALTH. 3058 02:44:58,852 --> 02:45:02,489 THEY BREED BUGS AND NOT GOOD 3059 02:45:02,489 --> 02:45:05,826 THINGS BUT THEY ALSO CAN GET 3060 02:45:05,826 --> 02:45:10,497 EASILY OVERLOADED WITH WATER IN 3061 02:45:10,497 --> 02:45:13,000 HEAVY RAIN EVENTS AND THERE'S NO 3062 02:45:13,000 --> 02:45:15,169 WAY FOR THE WATER TO GET 3063 02:45:15,169 --> 02:45:16,570 EVACUATED BECAUSE IT'S CONCRETE 3064 02:45:16,570 --> 02:45:20,340 AND IT SIT THERE AND THERE'S 3065 02:45:20,340 --> 02:45:26,346 NOWHERE TO GO IT FLOODS 3066 02:45:26,346 --> 02:45:27,214 WHEREVER. 3067 02:45:27,214 --> 02:45:28,816 THE INFRASTRUCTURE MADE IT WORSE 3068 02:45:28,816 --> 02:45:30,184 IN HOUSTON AFTER HURRICANE 3069 02:45:30,184 --> 02:45:35,289 HARVEY. 3070 02:45:35,289 --> 02:45:37,324 AND LEADS TO SLOWER RECOVER RIS 3071 02:45:37,324 --> 02:45:38,559 AND WORSE OUTCOMES IN THE OVER 3072 02:45:38,559 --> 02:45:40,094 BURDENED POPULATIONS. 3073 02:45:40,094 --> 02:45:41,862 I'M GOING TO START TO WALK 3074 02:45:41,862 --> 02:45:45,866 THROUGH SOME OF THESE. 3075 02:45:45,866 --> 02:45:49,503 AND HISTORICALLY MARGINALIZED 3076 02:45:49,503 --> 02:45:53,107 GROUPS HAVE FACED HIGHER 3077 02:45:53,107 --> 02:45:53,941 EXPOSURE TO CLIMATE CHANGE AND 3078 02:45:53,941 --> 02:45:57,111 EVEN BEFORE RED LINING. 3079 02:45:57,111 --> 02:45:59,012 POST CIVIL WAR, LAND HAS SET 3080 02:45:59,012 --> 02:46:03,283 ASIDE FOR ENSLAVED PEOPLE, 3081 02:46:03,283 --> 02:46:06,787 FORMERLY ENSLAVED PEOPLE AND 3082 02:46:06,787 --> 02:46:08,355 BLACK VETERANS IN AREAS THAT 3083 02:46:08,355 --> 02:46:09,790 WERE FLOOD-PRONE. 3084 02:46:09,790 --> 02:46:15,562 SO IF YOU LOOK AT NORTH RED WOOD 3085 02:46:15,562 --> 02:46:21,735 ABOUT FIVE MILES AWAY IS 3086 02:46:21,735 --> 02:46:22,369 TRADITIONALLY AFRICAN AMERICAN 3087 02:46:22,369 --> 02:46:24,004 AND IT'S FLOOD-PRONE LAND AND 3088 02:46:24,004 --> 02:46:25,105 LAND THE U.S. GOVERNMENT DID NOT 3089 02:46:25,105 --> 02:46:30,777 WANT SO IT WAS GIVEN TO FORMERLY 3090 02:46:30,777 --> 02:46:31,445 ENSLAVED INDIVIDUALS. 3091 02:46:31,445 --> 02:46:34,581 THEN WE GET TO RED LINING WHICH 3092 02:46:34,581 --> 02:46:37,117 FURTHER EXACERBATED THESE 3093 02:46:37,117 --> 02:46:39,586 DISPARITIES AND EVEN AFTER RED 3094 02:46:39,586 --> 02:46:46,160 LINING ENDED IN THE 1970s WE 3095 02:46:46,160 --> 02:46:48,462 CONTINUE WITH POLICIES LIKE 3096 02:46:48,462 --> 02:46:49,163 EXCLUSIONARY ZONING WHICH 3097 02:46:49,163 --> 02:46:50,264 PREVENT LOWER INCOME INDIVIDUALS 3098 02:46:50,264 --> 02:46:51,031 FROM MOVING TO AREAS THAT ARE 3099 02:46:51,031 --> 02:46:53,100 SAFER. 3100 02:46:53,100 --> 02:46:58,605 SO WE HAVE -- THERE IS BY DESIGN 3101 02:46:58,605 --> 02:46:59,907 SEGREGATION AND DIFFERENTIAL 3102 02:46:59,907 --> 02:47:02,609 EXPOSURE TO HAZARDS AND ALSO 3103 02:47:02,609 --> 02:47:04,211 CLIMATE CHANGE SO HEAT, SEA 3104 02:47:04,211 --> 02:47:05,012 LEVEL RISE. 3105 02:47:05,012 --> 02:47:07,981 WE ALSO HAVE HISTORICAL AND 3106 02:47:07,981 --> 02:47:09,883 CURRENT UNDER INVESTMENT IN 3107 02:47:09,883 --> 02:47:11,418 HISTORICALLY MARGINALIZED 3108 02:47:11,418 --> 02:47:11,718 COMMUNITIES. 3109 02:47:11,718 --> 02:47:13,887 A LOT OF IT IS BECAUSE LIKE AS 3110 02:47:13,887 --> 02:47:17,791 OF RIGHT NOW WE DON'T HAVE 3111 02:47:17,791 --> 02:47:19,893 THERE'S THE COST BENEFIT RATIO. 3112 02:47:19,893 --> 02:47:21,862 IF YOU LOOK AT JACKSON, 3113 02:47:21,862 --> 02:47:25,866 MISSISSIPPI IN 2012, THE WATER 3114 02:47:25,866 --> 02:47:30,571 BOARD WENT IN FRONT OF THE 3115 02:47:30,571 --> 02:47:32,239 MISSISSIPPI BONDS GROUP THE 3116 02:47:32,239 --> 02:47:33,440 REGULATORY BOND TO GET BONDS TO 3117 02:47:33,440 --> 02:47:35,275 INVEST IN THEIR WATER SYSTEM. 3118 02:47:35,275 --> 02:47:37,010 IT WAS DEEMED TOO RISKY OF AN 3119 02:47:37,010 --> 02:47:37,377 INVESTMENT. 3120 02:47:37,377 --> 02:47:39,179 THEY WOULDN'T GET THEIR MONEY 3121 02:47:39,179 --> 02:47:39,446 BACK. 3122 02:47:39,446 --> 02:47:42,883 THEY WERE UNABLE TO GET BONDS. 3123 02:47:42,883 --> 02:47:44,718 IT GUARANTEED A FAILURE OF THE 3124 02:47:44,718 --> 02:47:49,323 WATER SYSTEM IN JACKSON, 3125 02:47:49,323 --> 02:47:49,890 MISSISSIPPI LAST YEAR. 3126 02:47:49,890 --> 02:47:51,792 BECAUSE THEY'RE UNABLE TO GET 3127 02:47:51,792 --> 02:47:52,059 CAPITAL. 3128 02:47:52,059 --> 02:47:53,894 THIS HAPPENS OVER AND OVER AND 3129 02:47:53,894 --> 02:47:55,629 OVER AGAIN. 3130 02:47:55,629 --> 02:47:59,366 WE KNOW THAT THIS LEADS TO HOMES 3131 02:47:59,366 --> 02:48:01,034 THAT IN UNDER INVESTED AREAS 3132 02:48:01,034 --> 02:48:03,203 TEND TO BE OLDER, BUILT TO 3133 02:48:03,203 --> 02:48:06,273 POORER OR OLDER BUILDING CODES 3134 02:48:06,273 --> 02:48:11,612 IF THEY'RE BUILT TO BUILDING 3135 02:48:11,612 --> 02:48:16,116 CODES AT ALL. 3136 02:48:16,116 --> 02:48:17,618 AND OVER BURDENED COMMUNITIES 3137 02:48:17,618 --> 02:48:20,354 HAVE LESS ABILITY TO ADAPT. 3138 02:48:20,354 --> 02:48:21,688 LESS LIKELY TO HAVE INSURANCE IF 3139 02:48:21,688 --> 02:48:25,259 THEIR HOME WERE TO BE DAMAGED. 3140 02:48:25,259 --> 02:48:29,296 LESS LIKELY TO -- LESS ACCESS TO 3141 02:48:29,296 --> 02:48:30,097 FEDERAL RESOURCES AND AID AFTER 3142 02:48:30,097 --> 02:48:32,032 FEDERAL DISASTERS BECAUSE IF 3143 02:48:32,032 --> 02:48:34,434 YOU'RE A RENTER -- IF YOU'RE A 3144 02:48:34,434 --> 02:48:35,102 HOMEOWNER HAVE YOU ACCESS TO 3145 02:48:35,102 --> 02:48:36,236 CERTAIN PROGRAMS, IF YOU'RE A 3146 02:48:36,236 --> 02:48:45,679 RENTER YOU DON'T HAVE ACCESS. 3147 02:48:45,679 --> 02:48:49,049 IF YOU HAVE TO EVACUATE FOR A 3148 02:48:49,049 --> 02:48:50,350 FEW DAYS OR MONTHS HOW MUCH WILL 3149 02:48:50,350 --> 02:48:52,119 THAT COST? 3150 02:48:52,119 --> 02:48:53,754 WE SEE SOMETIMES PEOPLE STAY 3151 02:48:53,754 --> 02:48:54,688 BEHIND UNDER EXPOSED BECAUSE 3152 02:48:54,688 --> 02:48:56,757 THEY DON'T HAVE THE FEW HUNDRED 3153 02:48:56,757 --> 02:48:57,424 DOLLARS IN ORDER TO GO SOMEWHERE 3154 02:48:57,424 --> 02:49:00,861 ELSE. 3155 02:49:00,861 --> 02:49:01,662 AND A LOT OF THIS IS STILL 3156 02:49:01,662 --> 02:49:03,397 CODIFIED BY LAW. 3157 02:49:03,397 --> 02:49:05,866 SO WE LOOK AT COST BENEFIT 3158 02:49:05,866 --> 02:49:06,867 ANALYSIS. 3159 02:49:06,867 --> 02:49:07,734 IT SEEMS REASONABLE. 3160 02:49:07,734 --> 02:49:12,839 THE BENEFITS HAVE TO OUTWEIGH 3161 02:49:12,839 --> 02:49:15,108 THE COST WHEN WE USE FEDERAL 3162 02:49:15,108 --> 02:49:17,644 FUNDS AND FEMA AND ARMY CORPS 3163 02:49:17,644 --> 02:49:20,047 ARE BOUND BY THIS RULE. 3164 02:49:20,047 --> 02:49:21,448 IT KIND OF ON THE SURFACE MAKES 3165 02:49:21,448 --> 02:49:23,183 SENSE BUT HOW DO WE IMPLEMENT 3166 02:49:23,183 --> 02:49:23,717 THIS? 3167 02:49:23,717 --> 02:49:26,787 WE LOOK AT HOW MUCH VALUE THE 3168 02:49:26,787 --> 02:49:29,389 PROPERTY VALUE OF WHAT IS THAT 3169 02:49:29,389 --> 02:49:31,358 INVESTMENT IS GOING TO HAVE. 3170 02:49:31,358 --> 02:49:33,660 SO IF YOU LOOK AT A LEVEE OR 3171 02:49:33,660 --> 02:49:35,796 SOME DIKE YOU MAY MAKE A MASSIVE 3172 02:49:35,796 --> 02:49:37,864 INVESTMENT IN YOU LOOK AT THE 3173 02:49:37,864 --> 02:49:43,303 PROPERTY OF THE LAND BEHIND IT. 3174 02:49:43,303 --> 02:49:45,038 WHAT IS THE RISK REDUCTION THE 3175 02:49:45,038 --> 02:49:51,645 PROPERTY LOSS THAT COMES BY THAT 3176 02:49:51,645 --> 02:49:52,079 INVESTMENT? 3177 02:49:52,079 --> 02:49:53,213 WE PROTECT WEALTHY HOMES AND 3178 02:49:53,213 --> 02:49:54,881 DON'T PROTECT POORER COMMUNITIES 3179 02:49:54,881 --> 02:49:57,884 WITH LEVIES OR OTHER FLOOD 3180 02:49:57,884 --> 02:49:59,119 BARRIERS BECAUSE WE CAN'T MAKE 3181 02:49:59,119 --> 02:50:02,122 THE COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS WORK. 3182 02:50:02,122 --> 02:50:07,527 YOU'LL SEE RIGHT NOW IF YOU LOOK 3183 02:50:07,527 --> 02:50:12,132 AT NEW YORK CITY PLAN POST 3184 02:50:12,132 --> 02:50:13,500 HURRICANE HARVEY STORM SURGE 3185 02:50:13,500 --> 02:50:17,003 PLAN THE PLAN IS TO INVEST AND 3186 02:50:17,003 --> 02:50:18,805 PUT MASSIVE BARRIERS IN 3187 02:50:18,805 --> 02:50:21,575 MANHATTAN AND HIGH-VALUE AREAS 3188 02:50:21,575 --> 02:50:25,812 AND HARLEM AND SOUTH BRONX WILL 3189 02:50:25,812 --> 02:50:27,347 STILL BE EXPOSED TO SEA LEVEL 3190 02:50:27,347 --> 02:50:29,316 RISE AND STORM SURGE AND THERE'S 3191 02:50:29,316 --> 02:50:39,926 NO INVESTMENTS RIGHT NOW. 3192 02:50:39,926 --> 02:50:42,162 THE STAFFORD ACT IS BASED ON 3193 02:50:42,162 --> 02:50:42,362 VALUE. 3194 02:50:42,362 --> 02:50:43,330 HOW MUCH WAS DAMAGED. 3195 02:50:43,330 --> 02:50:45,298 SO WHILE YOU MIGHT HAVE MORE 3196 02:50:45,298 --> 02:50:47,968 DAMAGE OR MORE LIKELIHOOD OF 3197 02:50:47,968 --> 02:50:49,870 DAMAGE IN POORER AREAS, IT 3198 02:50:49,870 --> 02:50:53,340 DOESN'T ALWAYS GET TO THAT 3199 02:50:53,340 --> 02:50:56,309 THRESHOLD WHEREAS IN WEALTHIER 3200 02:50:56,309 --> 02:50:57,911 COMMUNITIES YOU'RE MORE LIKELY 3201 02:50:57,911 --> 02:51:00,414 TO GET A LOT OF FEDERAL AID. 3202 02:51:00,414 --> 02:51:03,016 FEDERAL AID COMES WITH A 75% 3203 02:51:03,016 --> 02:51:05,719 GUARANTEED REIMBURSEMENT UP TO 3204 02:51:05,719 --> 02:51:09,856 90% REIMBURSEMENT FOR 3205 02:51:09,856 --> 02:51:10,257 INFRASTRUCTURE. 3206 02:51:10,257 --> 02:51:11,925 SO IT'S ONE OF THE EASIEST WAYS 3207 02:51:11,925 --> 02:51:16,430 FOR WEALTHY COMMUNITY TO MAKE 3208 02:51:16,430 --> 02:51:17,164 INVESTMENT IN THEIR 3209 02:51:17,164 --> 02:51:19,900 INFRASTRUCTURE IS TO MAKE THEY 3210 02:51:19,900 --> 02:51:21,868 GET THE FEDERAL DOLLARS. 3211 02:51:21,868 --> 02:51:24,004 WE SEE POORER COMMUNITIES 3212 02:51:24,004 --> 02:51:26,673 GETTING DISASTER AID BUT NOT 3213 02:51:26,673 --> 02:51:28,208 HAVING THE 25% COST SHARE AND 3214 02:51:28,208 --> 02:51:29,309 NOT BEING ABLE TO AFFORD IT AND 3215 02:51:29,309 --> 02:51:39,619 ACCESS THE FUNDS. 3216 02:51:41,455 --> 02:51:44,357 2018, AND LOOKING AT THE 3217 02:51:44,357 --> 02:51:49,329 WEALTHIER COMMUNITY WAS ABLE TO 3218 02:51:49,329 --> 02:51:53,667 GET THE DISASTER MITIGATION AND 3219 02:51:53,667 --> 02:51:54,968 OTHERS DOES NOT GET A 3220 02:51:54,968 --> 02:51:56,336 DECLARATION BECAUSE THEY DIDN'T 3221 02:51:56,336 --> 02:51:58,405 GET TO THE DAMAGE THRESHOLD 3222 02:51:58,405 --> 02:52:02,075 BECAUSE THE PROPERTY VALUES WERE 3223 02:52:02,075 --> 02:52:07,113 LESS. 3224 02:52:07,113 --> 02:52:08,381 >> I'LL GO THROUGH THE EXAMPLES 3225 02:52:08,381 --> 02:52:10,183 WE LOOK AT WITHIN THE RESEARCH 3226 02:52:10,183 --> 02:52:12,586 GROUP. 3227 02:52:12,586 --> 02:52:17,123 ONE IS HURRICANES AND RENTERS 3228 02:52:17,123 --> 02:52:19,926 ARE UNIQUELY VULNERABLE TO 3229 02:52:19,926 --> 02:52:20,627 DISASTERS BECAUSE OF INCREASED 3230 02:52:20,627 --> 02:52:24,764 HAZARD EXPOSURE. 3231 02:52:24,764 --> 02:52:29,870 I BELIEVE IT'S 10% OF PUBLIC 3232 02:52:29,870 --> 02:52:31,004 HOUSING IN THE FLOODPLAIN. 3233 02:52:31,004 --> 02:52:33,874 MOST PUBLIC HOUSING IS NOT UP TO 3234 02:52:33,874 --> 02:52:41,281 CURRENT HURRICANE CODES. 3235 02:52:41,281 --> 02:52:44,184 THERE'S STORM SHUTTERS AND 3236 02:52:44,184 --> 02:52:44,951 THINGS LIKE THAT AND 3237 02:52:44,951 --> 02:52:46,653 INTERSECTION 8 HOUSING WE LOOK 3238 02:52:46,653 --> 02:52:48,788 AT ALL REN TERS WHEN WE LOOK AT 3239 02:52:48,788 --> 02:52:49,055 THIS. 3240 02:52:49,055 --> 02:52:50,357 HIGHER VULNERABILITY. 3241 02:52:50,357 --> 02:52:54,094 NOT UP TO CODE AND SOCIO 3242 02:52:54,094 --> 02:53:01,868 ECONOMIC DISADVANTAGE. 3243 02:53:01,868 --> 02:53:02,302 DEF 3244 02:53:04,671 --> 02:53:07,374 >> RENTERS HAVE LESS ABLE TO GET 3245 02:53:07,374 --> 02:53:09,876 FUNDING AND HOMEOWNERS UP ARE TO 3246 02:53:09,876 --> 02:53:15,682 ABOUT $36,000. 3247 02:53:15,682 --> 02:53:17,918 WE THINK DISASTERS CAUSE SHOCKS 3248 02:53:17,918 --> 02:53:20,186 IN THE RENTAL MARKET BUT NOBODY 3249 02:53:20,186 --> 02:53:21,788 LOOKED AT IT UNTIL WE DID AND 3250 02:53:21,788 --> 02:53:22,822 MOSTLY LOOKED AT THE HOUSING 3251 02:53:22,822 --> 02:53:24,858 MARKET IS WHAT RESEARCH LOOKED 3252 02:53:24,858 --> 02:53:25,091 AT. 3253 02:53:25,091 --> 02:53:29,829 WHAT'S IT DO FOR HOMEOWNERS AND 3254 02:53:29,829 --> 02:53:31,431 HOW DO REPETITIVE LOSSES AFFECT 3255 02:53:31,431 --> 02:53:32,365 HOMEOWNERS. 3256 02:53:32,365 --> 02:53:34,801 HOW DOES IT AFFECT RENT AND 3257 02:53:34,801 --> 02:53:36,603 AFFORDABILITY OF HOUSING AND WE 3258 02:53:36,603 --> 02:53:40,540 LOOKED AT 19 STATES OVER 10 3259 02:53:40,540 --> 02:53:42,676 STATES IN THE EAST COAST AND 3260 02:53:42,676 --> 02:53:44,177 GULF COAST LOOKING AT SOCIO 3261 02:53:44,177 --> 02:53:45,879 ECONOMIC AND HOUSING DATA. 3262 02:53:45,879 --> 02:53:48,214 AS HURRICANE INTENSITY INCREASED 3263 02:53:48,214 --> 02:53:51,885 A REDUCE HOUSING AVAILABILITY 3264 02:53:51,885 --> 02:53:53,853 NOT SURPRISING BECAUSE 3265 02:53:53,853 --> 02:53:57,290 HURRICANES DAMAGED HOMES. 3266 02:53:57,290 --> 02:53:58,358 THERE'S AN INTERESTING FINDING 3267 02:53:58,358 --> 02:54:04,331 AS AVAILABILITY DECREASED, IT 3268 02:54:04,331 --> 02:54:07,567 INCREASED RENT SO THAT'S AS 3269 02:54:07,567 --> 02:54:07,901 EXPECTED. 3270 02:54:07,901 --> 02:54:12,606 HAVE YOU LESS HOUSING, 3271 02:54:12,606 --> 02:54:13,139 INCREASES, DEMAND OF RENT. 3272 02:54:13,139 --> 02:54:16,676 IT ALSO INCREASED THE 3273 02:54:16,676 --> 02:54:17,877 AFFORDABILITY. 3274 02:54:17,877 --> 02:54:22,983 THAT DOESN'T MAKES SENSE. 3275 02:54:22,983 --> 02:54:24,084 YOU HAVE LESS HOUSING BUT 3276 02:54:24,084 --> 02:54:24,884 INCREASE THE AFFORDABILITY OF 3277 02:54:24,884 --> 02:54:25,218 THE HOUSING. 3278 02:54:25,218 --> 02:54:29,856 SO WHAT'S GOING ON? 3279 02:54:29,856 --> 02:54:31,891 WITH FOUND RENTERS ARE BEING 3280 02:54:31,891 --> 02:54:32,359 DISPLACED. 3281 02:54:32,359 --> 02:54:33,827 THERE'S A FORCED MIGRATION GOING 3282 02:54:33,827 --> 02:54:35,962 ON CONSISTENTLY SO PEOPLE ABLE 3283 02:54:35,962 --> 02:54:38,965 TO MOVE MOVE AND SO WE FIND THAT 3284 02:54:38,965 --> 02:54:40,266 THE AFFORDABILITY APPEARS TO 3285 02:54:40,266 --> 02:54:41,868 INCREASE BECAUSE THE AREA IS 3286 02:54:41,868 --> 02:54:46,573 BECOMING WEALTHIER. 3287 02:54:46,573 --> 02:54:50,677 THERE'S A FORCED MIGRATION GOING 3288 02:54:50,677 --> 02:54:51,044 ON. 3289 02:54:51,044 --> 02:54:53,046 HIGHER RENTS CORRESPOND ALSO 3290 02:54:53,046 --> 02:54:54,914 WITH HIGHER INCOME, MORE RENTERS 3291 02:54:54,914 --> 02:54:57,884 BUT THE LACK OF AFFORDABILITY 3292 02:54:57,884 --> 02:54:58,985 CORRESPONDS MORE WITH NON-WHITE 3293 02:54:58,985 --> 02:55:02,856 POPULATIONS AND MORE RENTERS. 3294 02:55:02,856 --> 02:55:03,923 RIGHT NOW THERE'S NO REAL 3295 02:55:03,923 --> 02:55:06,326 FEDERAL RESTRICTIONS AFTER 3296 02:55:06,326 --> 02:55:06,693 DISASTERS. 3297 02:55:06,693 --> 02:55:08,161 SO IF YOU GET A DISASTER 3298 02:55:08,161 --> 02:55:09,663 DECLARATION YOU GET ALL THE 3299 02:55:09,663 --> 02:55:11,631 FEDERAL AID. 3300 02:55:11,631 --> 02:55:13,967 IT'S NOT TIED TO RENTER 3301 02:55:13,967 --> 02:55:16,403 PROTECTION THERE'S NO RENTER 3302 02:55:16,403 --> 02:55:17,037 EVICTION MORATORIUMS OR OTHER 3303 02:55:17,037 --> 02:55:21,174 SUPPORT FOR RENTERS AND SO THIS 3304 02:55:21,174 --> 02:55:24,744 IS AN EXAMPLE ABOUT HOW WE ARE 3305 02:55:24,744 --> 02:55:26,446 NOT REALLY PROTECTING RENTERS. 3306 02:55:26,446 --> 02:55:28,181 A WHOLE SUBSET OF THE POPULATION 3307 02:55:28,181 --> 02:55:32,118 DURING THE EXTREME EVENTS. 3308 02:55:32,118 --> 02:55:33,853 ANOTHER EXAMPLE WE LOOK AT IS 3309 02:55:33,853 --> 02:55:36,189 HURRICANES AND ELECTRIC POWER 3310 02:55:36,189 --> 02:55:37,290 RELIABILITY. 3311 02:55:37,290 --> 02:55:39,559 THE NUMBER OF MAJOR POWER LOSS 3312 02:55:39,559 --> 02:55:41,861 EVENTS FROM WEATHER HAS RISEN 3313 02:55:41,861 --> 02:55:43,596 BETWEEN DEPENDING ON THE YEAR, 3314 02:55:43,596 --> 02:55:49,069 FOUR AND EIGHTFOLD SINCE 2000 3315 02:55:49,069 --> 02:55:50,837 AND EXPECT THAT TO INCREASE 3316 02:55:50,837 --> 02:55:52,872 RAPIDLY WITH CLIMATE CHANGE. 3317 02:55:52,872 --> 02:55:54,741 THAT'S OUTAGES, LONG DURATION 3318 02:55:54,741 --> 02:55:57,477 OUTAGES WITH MORE THAN 50,000 3319 02:55:57,477 --> 02:55:59,412 CUSTOMERS WITHOUT POWER. 3320 02:55:59,412 --> 02:56:00,013 LAST YEAR WAS OVER 120,000 I 3321 02:56:00,013 --> 02:56:05,251 BELIEVE. 3322 02:56:05,251 --> 02:56:07,153 THE DEMAND IN REQUIREMENTS FOR 3323 02:56:07,153 --> 02:56:09,155 ELECTRIC POWER IS NOT UNIFORM 3324 02:56:09,155 --> 02:56:11,157 ACROSS DEMOGRAPHICS. 3325 02:56:11,157 --> 02:56:12,659 WE THINK EVERYBODY NEEDS POWER 3326 02:56:12,659 --> 02:56:16,229 EQUALLY BUT IT'S NOT TRUE. 3327 02:56:16,229 --> 02:56:18,631 HEAT ISLANDS REQUIRE MORE SPACE 3328 02:56:18,631 --> 02:56:18,965 CONDITIONING. 3329 02:56:18,965 --> 02:56:21,501 WE NEED TO WARM OR COOL SOME 3330 02:56:21,501 --> 02:56:22,368 AREAS MORE. 3331 02:56:22,368 --> 02:56:24,104 MEDICALLY FRAGILE INDIVIDUALS 3332 02:56:24,104 --> 02:56:28,007 MAY NEED ELECTRIC POWER FOR 3333 02:56:28,007 --> 02:56:29,476 SUPPLEMENTAL OXYGEN AND TO KEEP 3334 02:56:29,476 --> 02:56:30,443 MEDICATIONS COOL. 3335 02:56:30,443 --> 02:56:36,149 THERE'S DIFFERENTIAL ABILITY TO 3336 02:56:36,149 --> 02:56:36,449 RELOCATE. 3337 02:56:36,449 --> 02:56:39,652 AFTER 2012 IN D.C. MANY PEOPLE 3338 02:56:39,652 --> 02:56:41,421 LOST POWER FOR A WEEK OR MORE. 3339 02:56:41,421 --> 02:56:43,690 THERE WERE A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO 3340 02:56:43,690 --> 02:56:45,859 LEFT D.C. WHEN IT WAS OVER 100 3341 02:56:45,859 --> 02:56:47,360 DEGREES BUT NOT EVERYONE IS ABLE 3342 02:56:47,360 --> 02:56:48,461 TO JUST LEAVE WHEN THEY DON'T 3343 02:56:48,461 --> 02:56:49,863 HAVE POWER FOR A WEEK OR WEEK 3344 02:56:49,863 --> 02:56:53,867 AND A HALF. 3345 02:56:53,867 --> 02:56:59,239 SO WE LOOKED AT WHO IS LOSING 3346 02:56:59,239 --> 02:57:00,573 POWER AT WHAT RATES AND WHAT'S 3347 02:57:00,573 --> 02:57:03,843 THE POWER RELIABILITY ACROSS 3348 02:57:03,843 --> 02:57:04,878 DEMOGRAPHICS AND HOW LONG DOES 3349 02:57:04,878 --> 02:57:09,048 IT TAKE TO GET POWER BACK ON. 3350 02:57:09,048 --> 02:57:11,050 WE LOOKED AT HURRICANE ISAAC 3351 02:57:11,050 --> 02:57:13,853 AND, LOUISIANA, I BELIEVE 2017 3352 02:57:13,853 --> 02:57:17,090 BUT I MAY BE WRONG ABOUT THAT 3353 02:57:17,090 --> 02:57:22,295 AND HOW STORM SEVERITY, INCOME 3354 02:57:22,295 --> 02:57:25,165 AND RACE PLAY INTO RECOVERY 3355 02:57:25,165 --> 02:57:25,365 TIMES. 3356 02:57:25,365 --> 02:57:28,368 THE MORE OUTAGES YOU HAVE THE 3357 02:57:28,368 --> 02:57:29,969 LONGER RECOVERY TIME BUT THE 3358 02:57:29,969 --> 02:57:32,138 HIGHER INCOME YOU HAVE THE LOWER 3359 02:57:32,138 --> 02:57:33,406 RECOVERY TIME. 3360 02:57:33,406 --> 02:57:37,043 IT TAKES LESS TIME TO GET YOUR 3361 02:57:37,043 --> 02:57:47,554 POWER BACK ON THEN IF YOU'RE 3362 02:57:57,931 --> 02:58:00,733 RICH AND YOU'RE SUPPOSED TO 3363 02:58:00,733 --> 02:58:02,368 PRIORITIZE DENSE AREAS FIRST SO 3364 02:58:02,368 --> 02:58:05,872 THIS UTILITY IS PRIORITIZING THE 3365 02:58:05,872 --> 02:58:06,239 OUTSKIRTS FIRST. 3366 02:58:06,239 --> 02:58:06,840 WHICH IS ACTUALLY VERY 3367 02:58:06,840 --> 02:58:09,876 CONCERNING. 3368 02:58:09,876 --> 02:58:11,578 IT'S MIXED WITH RACE. 3369 02:58:11,578 --> 02:58:14,781 WE FOUND IF YOU'RE SURROUNDED BY 3370 02:58:14,781 --> 02:58:16,349 WHITE POPULATION OR COMMUNITIES 3371 02:58:16,349 --> 02:58:20,353 YOU'RE LIKELY TO HAVE POWER 3372 02:58:20,353 --> 02:58:24,757 RESTORED SOONER THAN IF YOU ARE 3373 02:58:24,757 --> 02:58:26,392 NOT SURROUNDED BY WHITE 3374 02:58:26,392 --> 02:58:28,428 COMMUNITIES AND MAKING SURE YOU 3375 02:58:28,428 --> 02:58:30,797 HAVE WHITE NEIGHBORS IS A BIG 3376 02:58:30,797 --> 02:58:34,200 DETERMINATE OF WHEN HAVE YOU 3377 02:58:34,200 --> 02:58:37,303 POWER BACK ON. 3378 02:58:37,303 --> 02:58:39,505 MIXED FINDINGS WE FOUND POWER IS 3379 02:58:39,505 --> 02:58:42,876 NOT CONSISTENTLY RESTORED FAST 3380 02:58:42,876 --> 02:58:44,944 OR QUICK TO POLICE STATIONS OR 3381 02:58:44,944 --> 02:58:46,179 HOSPITALS AND THIS IS ACTUALLY 3382 02:58:46,179 --> 02:58:49,883 CONSISTENT WITH INTERVIEWS WE'VE 3383 02:58:49,883 --> 02:58:52,452 HAD WITH UTILITIES. 3384 02:58:52,452 --> 02:58:53,620 THEY BELIEVE THERE SHOULD BE 3385 02:58:53,620 --> 02:58:55,722 SUFFICIENT BACK UP GENERATION AT 3386 02:58:55,722 --> 02:58:56,289 THE FACILITIES. 3387 02:58:56,289 --> 02:58:59,092 THEY DO NOT ALWAYS PRIORITIZE 3388 02:58:59,092 --> 02:59:09,302 THOSE AREAS. 3389 02:59:09,936 --> 02:59:11,371 ANOTHER PROJECT WE LOOK AT IS 3390 02:59:11,371 --> 02:59:13,773 SEA LEVEL RISE AND THE IMPACTS 3391 02:59:13,773 --> 02:59:14,440 ON INFRASTRUCTURE. 3392 02:59:14,440 --> 02:59:17,343 IT WILL NOT BE FELT EVENLY. 3393 02:59:17,343 --> 02:59:18,912 POORER AREAS ARE MORE EXPOSED TO 3394 02:59:18,912 --> 02:59:20,380 SEA LEVEL RISE. 3395 02:59:20,380 --> 02:59:21,648 A LOT OF WORK I DO IS ON THE 3396 02:59:21,648 --> 02:59:23,816 EASTERN SHORE OF MARYLAND AND 3397 02:59:23,816 --> 02:59:26,219 ONE AREA IS SEPTIC SYSTEMS. 3398 02:59:26,219 --> 02:59:28,588 20% OF HOMES IN THE U.S. ARE ON 3399 02:59:28,588 --> 02:59:30,089 SEPTIC BUT IT'S A HUGE MAJOR 3400 02:59:30,089 --> 02:59:30,556 HEALTH PROBLEM. 3401 02:59:30,556 --> 02:59:33,226 YOU HAVE SEPTIC, YOU HAVE SEA 3402 02:59:33,226 --> 02:59:37,864 LEVEL RISE, INTERACTING WITH 3403 02:59:37,864 --> 02:59:39,666 SEPTIC YOU DEGRADE WASTE WATER 3404 02:59:39,666 --> 02:59:42,201 AND THIS IS A MAJOR HEALTH 3405 02:59:42,201 --> 02:59:47,774 PROBLEM AND CAUSES 3406 02:59:47,774 --> 02:59:49,642 GASTROENTERITIS AND WE EXPECT 3407 02:59:49,642 --> 02:59:50,276 HOOK WORK. 3408 02:59:50,276 --> 02:59:52,946 57% OF CHILDREN SAMPLES IN A 3409 02:59:52,946 --> 02:59:55,348 COUNTY IN ALABAMA WERE FOUND TO 3410 02:59:55,348 --> 02:59:57,250 HAVE HOOK WORM BECAUSE OF THE 3411 02:59:57,250 --> 02:59:57,951 FAILING SEPTIC SYSTEM. 3412 02:59:57,951 --> 02:59:58,818 WE'RE LOOKING AT WHAT TO DO 3413 02:59:58,818 --> 03:00:02,522 ABOUT THIS. 3414 03:00:02,522 --> 03:00:04,357 NOW THERE'S A COMPOUNDED 3415 03:00:04,357 --> 03:00:04,691 VULNERABILITY. 3416 03:00:04,691 --> 03:00:05,858 YOU LOOK AT INFRASTRUCTURE 3417 03:00:05,858 --> 03:00:07,360 INVESTMENTS IN BLACK COMMUNITIES 3418 03:00:07,360 --> 03:00:07,894 VERSUS WHITE. 3419 03:00:07,894 --> 03:00:10,096 WHITE COMMUNITIES ARE FAR MORE 3420 03:00:10,096 --> 03:00:12,732 LIKELY TO BE ON SEWER THAN ON 3421 03:00:12,732 --> 03:00:13,733 SEPTIC BECAUSE OF BELIEFS OVER 3422 03:00:13,733 --> 03:00:17,603 ABILITY TO PAY. 3423 03:00:17,603 --> 03:00:19,439 WE SEE THIS EVEN TODAY. 3424 03:00:19,439 --> 03:00:21,774 WE WORK WITH A HISTORICALLY 3425 03:00:21,774 --> 03:00:22,375 AFRICAN AMERICAN COMMUNITY ON 3426 03:00:22,375 --> 03:00:23,676 THE EASTERN SHORE WHO WANT TO BE 3427 03:00:23,676 --> 03:00:27,747 ON SEWER SYSTEMS BUT CAN'T GET 3428 03:00:27,747 --> 03:00:30,550 ACCESS TO A SEWER WASTE WATER 3429 03:00:30,550 --> 03:00:31,718 TREATMENT PLANT BECAUSE EVEN 3430 03:00:31,718 --> 03:00:33,286 TODAY THERE'S A BELIEF THEY WILL 3431 03:00:33,286 --> 03:00:36,522 NOT BE ABLE TO PAY THE BILLS. 3432 03:00:36,522 --> 03:00:40,259 IF YOU'RE ON SEPTIC YOU'RE 3433 03:00:40,259 --> 03:00:43,963 INELIGIBLE FOR PUBLIC AID IF 3434 03:00:43,963 --> 03:00:49,702 YOU'RE ON SEWER YOU CAN GET AID 3435 03:00:49,702 --> 03:00:51,838 SO WHO WILL BE EXPOSED TO SEPTIC 3436 03:00:51,838 --> 03:00:53,873 SYSTEMS AND CLIMATE CHANGE? 3437 03:00:53,873 --> 03:00:55,541 WHAT'S THIS MEAN FOR HEALTH? 3438 03:00:55,541 --> 03:00:57,243 MARYLAND IS AN INTERESTING STATE 3439 03:00:57,243 --> 03:00:57,844 BECAUSE IF YOU COME TO THE 3440 03:00:57,844 --> 03:01:02,648 HOSPITAL OR YOUR DOCTOR WITH 3441 03:01:02,648 --> 03:01:04,484 GASTROENTERITIS AND THEY ASK YOU 3442 03:01:04,484 --> 03:01:06,886 AND WE HAVE MEDICAL DATA ARE YOU 3443 03:01:06,886 --> 03:01:08,221 ON SEPTIC OR WELL WATER? 3444 03:01:08,221 --> 03:01:10,523 WE KNOW WHO AND WHAT WE CAN 3445 03:01:10,523 --> 03:01:12,291 CORRELATE THAT WITH THE TIDES 3446 03:01:12,291 --> 03:01:18,998 AND LOOK AT PRECIPITATION IT 3447 03:01:18,998 --> 03:01:20,033 KNOW WHEN SOME OF THE CAUSES OF 3448 03:01:20,033 --> 03:01:21,868 THE ILLNESSES. 3449 03:01:21,868 --> 03:01:24,170 WE'RE WORKING ON HOW TO USE 3450 03:01:24,170 --> 03:01:25,638 GREEN BANKING AND OTHER 3451 03:01:25,638 --> 03:01:27,273 INNOVATIVE FINANCIAL MECHANISMS 3452 03:01:27,273 --> 03:01:30,910 TO HOMEOWNERS CAN IMPROVE THEIR 3453 03:01:30,910 --> 03:01:32,378 SEPTIC SYSTEMS OR LOOK AT 3454 03:01:32,378 --> 03:01:34,147 ALTERNATIVE TECHNOLOGIES TO 3455 03:01:34,147 --> 03:01:35,648 REDUCE THE RISK. 3456 03:01:35,648 --> 03:01:42,789 I WILL END THERE. 3457 03:01:42,789 --> 03:01:43,890 I'LL REMIND EVERYONE, 3458 03:01:43,890 --> 03:01:47,193 INFRASTRUCTURE CAN BE A HAZARD 3459 03:01:47,193 --> 03:01:47,627 AMPLIFIER. 3460 03:01:47,627 --> 03:01:50,196 THERE'S A REASON WHY WE THINK 3461 03:01:50,196 --> 03:01:52,065 THAT -- THERE'S NOT ONLY DO WE 3462 03:01:52,065 --> 03:01:54,033 TALK ABOUT THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT 3463 03:01:54,033 --> 03:01:56,269 BEING PROBLEMATIC BUT THERE'S A 3464 03:01:56,269 --> 03:01:56,836 REAL REASON. 3465 03:01:56,836 --> 03:01:58,004 A LOT OF IT IS BY DESIGN. 3466 03:01:58,004 --> 03:02:01,174 I WANT TO THANK MY FUNDERS, EPA, 3467 03:02:01,174 --> 03:02:01,874 NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION AND 3468 03:02:01,874 --> 03:02:05,878 THE NATIONAL ACADEMIES AND HAPPY 3469 03:02:05,878 --> 03:02:16,422 TO ANSWER ANY QUESTIONS ON WIKI. 3470 03:02:20,426 --> 03:02:23,096 >> THERE'S ONE QUESTION SAYING 3471 03:02:23,096 --> 03:02:25,865 USING ZIP CODE OR AIS IS TO 3472 03:02:25,865 --> 03:02:28,634 LARGE OF A BLOCK TO SEE WHAT'S 3473 03:02:28,634 --> 03:02:29,602 HAPPENING. 3474 03:02:29,602 --> 03:02:31,404 >> FOR OUTAGES? 3475 03:02:31,404 --> 03:02:37,877 >> IS THERE ANYTHING PEOPLE CAN 3476 03:02:37,877 --> 03:02:40,012 DO TO GET HIGHER SPATIAL 3477 03:02:40,012 --> 03:02:40,313 INFORMATION? 3478 03:02:40,313 --> 03:02:42,849 >> OUTAGES SO UTILITIES ARE 3479 03:02:42,849 --> 03:02:44,917 PRIVATELY OWNED SO IT'S 3480 03:02:44,917 --> 03:02:45,852 EXTREMELY CHALLENGING TO GET MUE 3481 03:02:45,852 --> 03:02:49,856 TILT DATA. 3482 03:02:49,856 --> 03:02:51,157 -- UTILITY DATA AND NO UTILITY 3483 03:02:51,157 --> 03:02:53,059 WOULD EVER GIVE YOU DATA TO DO 3484 03:02:53,059 --> 03:02:53,860 THIS. 3485 03:02:53,860 --> 03:02:54,660 THAT'S NOT GOING TO HAPPEN 3486 03:02:54,660 --> 03:03:00,266 UNLESS THEY'RE FORCED BY A 3487 03:03:00,266 --> 03:03:01,434 REGULATOR. 3488 03:03:01,434 --> 03:03:02,969 AND IF YOU HAVE A SMART METER IN 3489 03:03:02,969 --> 03:03:04,437 YOUR HOUSE YOU KNOW THE MOMENT 3490 03:03:04,437 --> 03:03:06,105 THE HOUSE LOSES POWER AND GOES 3491 03:03:06,105 --> 03:03:07,773 BACK ON. 3492 03:03:07,773 --> 03:03:10,676 THAT DATA IS VERY CHALLENGING TO 3493 03:03:10,676 --> 03:03:13,913 GET BUT THEY REALLY CONTROL WHY 3494 03:03:13,913 --> 03:03:17,016 THAT DATA -- THEY'RE REQUIRED BY 3495 03:03:17,016 --> 03:03:19,352 LAW TO POST EVERY 15 MINUTES AT 3496 03:03:19,352 --> 03:03:20,720 THE ZIP CODE AND THEN THEY 3497 03:03:20,720 --> 03:03:23,356 DELETE THE DATA SO YOU HAVE TO 3498 03:03:23,356 --> 03:03:25,591 CONTINUOUSLY SCRAPE TO GET THAT 3499 03:03:25,591 --> 03:03:25,858 DATA. 3500 03:03:25,858 --> 03:03:31,697 IT'S NOT DATA THAT THEY WANT YOU 3501 03:03:31,697 --> 03:03:37,803 TO HAVE BECAUSE IT'S A PRIVATE 3502 03:03:37,803 --> 03:03:38,037 COMPANY. 3503 03:03:38,037 --> 03:03:41,741 THEY DON'T WANT -- THEY'RE ALSO 3504 03:03:41,741 --> 03:03:45,178 NOT INTERESTINGLY REGULATED ONCE 3505 03:03:45,178 --> 03:03:47,046 YOU GET A MAJOR POWER EVENT THE 3506 03:03:47,046 --> 03:03:48,381 REGULATIONS DON'T APPLY ANY MORE 3507 03:03:48,381 --> 03:03:49,882 YOU DON'T HAVE THE RELIABILITY 3508 03:03:49,882 --> 03:03:52,852 STANDARDS THEY HAVE TO ADHERED 3509 03:03:52,852 --> 03:03:55,021 TO BECAUSE IT'S CONSIDERED FORCE 3510 03:03:55,021 --> 03:04:01,594 MAYOR TO APPLY SO IT WOULD BE 3511 03:04:01,594 --> 03:04:05,798 GREAT TO GET THIS DATA BUT NOT 3512 03:04:05,798 --> 03:04:06,399 IN THE CARDS FOR THIS TYPE OF 3513 03:04:06,399 --> 03:04:16,576 RESEARCH. 3514 03:04:17,109 --> 03:04:26,385 -- 3515 03:04:26,385 --> 03:04:28,754 >> THERE'S A LOT OF QUESTIONS ON 3516 03:04:28,754 --> 03:04:32,191 THE WIKI AND SURE THE PRESENTERS 3517 03:04:32,191 --> 03:04:34,126 WILL BE HAPPY TO ANSWER ON THE 3518 03:04:34,126 --> 03:04:34,527 WIKI. 3519 03:04:34,527 --> 03:04:38,598 >> AS WE PULL UP THE THIRD 3520 03:04:38,598 --> 03:04:40,433 PRESENTATION, I'M DELIGHTED TO 3521 03:04:40,433 --> 03:04:45,871 INTRODUCE OUR THIRD SPEAKER, 3522 03:04:45,871 --> 03:04:49,442 JASMINE KLINEAS FROM EMORY 3523 03:04:49,442 --> 03:04:51,944 UNIVERSITY AND A K-99 RECIPIENT 3524 03:04:51,944 --> 03:04:56,983 FROM THE NCI AND THE REASON WE 3525 03:04:56,983 --> 03:04:59,752 INVITED HER IS SUMMARIZED WELL 3526 03:04:59,752 --> 03:05:01,520 IN THE GOAL ON THE RESEARCH ON 3527 03:05:01,520 --> 03:05:07,727 THE WIKI TO UNDERSTAND HOW 3528 03:05:07,727 --> 03:05:09,762 SOCIAL STRUCTURAL INFLUENCES OF 3529 03:05:09,762 --> 03:05:11,964 HEALTH DRIVE CANCER DISPARITIES. 3530 03:05:11,964 --> 03:05:12,965 I HOPE WE CAN LEARN A LOT FROM 3531 03:05:12,965 --> 03:05:14,900 HER TODAY AND IN THE BREAKOUT 3532 03:05:14,900 --> 03:05:15,968 SESSION WE'RE HOPING TO DISCUSS 3533 03:05:15,968 --> 03:05:20,006 THIS FURTHER IN TERMS OF HOW CAN 3534 03:05:20,006 --> 03:05:20,539 WE INTEGRATE THIS IN THE 3535 03:05:20,539 --> 03:05:27,179 MULTISCALE MODELING WE DO. 3536 03:05:27,179 --> 03:05:29,982 >> THANK YOU FOR INVITING ME TO 3537 03:05:29,982 --> 03:05:31,183 YOUR GUYS' SPACE. 3538 03:05:31,183 --> 03:05:32,952 I'VE NEVER BEEN TO THIS 3539 03:05:32,952 --> 03:05:34,854 SYMPOSIUM AND LEARNED A LOT. 3540 03:05:34,854 --> 03:05:37,123 I TRIED TO INCORPORATE A FEW 3541 03:05:37,123 --> 03:05:38,357 THINGS FROM THE DIFFERENT TALKS 3542 03:05:38,357 --> 03:05:39,558 TOWARDS THE END BUT WE'LL SEE 3543 03:05:39,558 --> 03:05:40,393 HOW THAT GOES. 3544 03:05:40,393 --> 03:05:43,095 THIS IS THE TITLE I USUALLY GIVE 3545 03:05:43,095 --> 03:05:46,065 FOR MY TALKS, BUT I'LL ALSO BE 3546 03:05:46,065 --> 03:05:48,100 PROVIDING SOME FRAMEWORK AND 3547 03:05:48,100 --> 03:05:49,835 GUIDING PRINCIPLES THAT ALLOW ME 3548 03:05:49,835 --> 03:05:50,870 TO APPROACH THE WORK I DO 3549 03:05:50,870 --> 03:05:51,671 BECAUSE I THINK THAT MAY BE 3550 03:05:51,671 --> 03:05:58,210 HELPFUL FOR YOU ALL. 3551 03:05:58,210 --> 03:05:59,545 ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS I LIKE 3552 03:05:59,545 --> 03:06:01,347 TO SHOW PEOPLE IS WHO I AM. 3553 03:06:01,347 --> 03:06:03,649 I THINK ALL OF US BRING WHO WE 3554 03:06:03,649 --> 03:06:04,884 ARE INTO OUR WORK AND HELPS US 3555 03:06:04,884 --> 03:06:08,454 THINK ABOUT THE QUESTIONS WE 3556 03:06:08,454 --> 03:06:09,588 COME UP WITH AND HELPS THINK 3557 03:06:09,588 --> 03:06:12,658 ABOUT WHAT DRIVES THE RESEARCH. 3558 03:06:12,658 --> 03:06:14,627 FOR ME, AND I ALWAYS HAD A MASK 3559 03:06:14,627 --> 03:06:16,262 ON SO I WAS LIKE THIS IS WHAT I 3560 03:06:16,262 --> 03:06:18,464 LOOK LIKE. 3561 03:06:18,464 --> 03:06:20,800 YOU CAN SEE THAT. 3562 03:06:20,800 --> 03:06:22,835 I'M A BREAST CANCER RESEARCHER 3563 03:06:22,835 --> 03:06:26,405 AND TRAINED CANCER BIOLOGIST AND 3564 03:06:26,405 --> 03:06:30,343 HAS BEEN WORKING IN THE 3565 03:06:30,343 --> 03:06:31,744 MOLECULAR EPIDEMIOLOGY FIELD AND 3566 03:06:31,744 --> 03:06:33,879 AM A MOTHER AND WIFE AND DO A 3567 03:06:33,879 --> 03:06:35,548 LOT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT 3568 03:06:35,548 --> 03:06:35,748 WORK. 3569 03:06:35,748 --> 03:06:38,384 ALL THESE ASPECTS OF MY LIFE 3570 03:06:38,384 --> 03:06:39,952 SHAPE MY RESEARCH QUESTIONS AND 3571 03:06:39,952 --> 03:06:44,890 WHAT I DO AND WHY I DO IT. 3572 03:06:44,890 --> 03:06:45,758 ONE OF THE THINGS THAT'S 3573 03:06:45,758 --> 03:06:49,362 IMPORTANT IS TO SHARE SOME OF MY 3574 03:06:49,362 --> 03:06:50,396 WORKING DEFINITIONS I USE. 3575 03:06:50,396 --> 03:06:52,198 THESE ARE MOSTLY FROM THE CDC. 3576 03:06:52,198 --> 03:06:53,866 WHEN WE THINK ABOUT HEALTH 3577 03:06:53,866 --> 03:06:55,935 EQUITY IT'S THE STATE IN WHICH 3578 03:06:55,935 --> 03:06:56,869 EVERYONE HAS A FAIR AND JUST 3579 03:06:56,869 --> 03:06:58,137 OPPORTUNITY TO ATTAIN THEIR 3580 03:06:58,137 --> 03:07:00,740 HIGHEST LEVEL OF HEALTH. 3581 03:07:00,740 --> 03:07:02,808 SO THERE'S DIFFERENT THINGS THAT 3582 03:07:02,808 --> 03:07:04,377 NEED TO BE ADDRESSED IN ORDER TO 3583 03:07:04,377 --> 03:07:07,146 ACHIEVE HEALTH EQUITY. 3584 03:07:07,146 --> 03:07:10,249 SOME ARE HISTORICAL AND 3585 03:07:10,249 --> 03:07:13,652 TEMPORARYIN JUSTICES AND THERE'S 3586 03:07:13,652 --> 03:07:15,888 OTHER -- TEMPORARY INJUSTICES 3587 03:07:15,888 --> 03:07:19,759 AND PREVENTIBLE HEALTH 3588 03:07:19,759 --> 03:07:20,059 DISPARITIES. 3589 03:07:20,059 --> 03:07:21,994 THIS GRAPHIC IS HELPFUL. 3590 03:07:21,994 --> 03:07:25,865 WHEN WE THINK OF EQUALITY THAT'S 3591 03:07:25,865 --> 03:07:27,500 EVERYBODY GETTING EVERYTHING 3592 03:07:27,500 --> 03:07:28,901 EQUALLY AND THAT'S NOT WHAT 3593 03:07:28,901 --> 03:07:30,436 HELPS ACHIEVE EQUITY WHICH IS 3594 03:07:30,436 --> 03:07:32,405 EVERYBODY GETTING WHAT THEY NEED 3595 03:07:32,405 --> 03:07:36,475 TO BE HEALTHY. 3596 03:07:36,475 --> 03:07:39,779 THE DEFINITION I USED IS THEY'RE 3597 03:07:39,779 --> 03:07:40,546 PREVENTIBLE DIFFERENCES IN THE 3598 03:07:40,546 --> 03:07:48,888 BURDEN OF DISEASE, VIOLENCE, 3599 03:07:48,888 --> 03:07:49,889 EXPERIENCED BY SOCIALLY 3600 03:07:49,889 --> 03:07:50,890 DISADVANTAGED POPULATIONS. 3601 03:07:50,890 --> 03:07:53,025 WHAT CAN WE IDENTIFY THAT'S 3602 03:07:53,025 --> 03:07:54,193 PREVENTIBLE WE CAN INTERVENE ON 3603 03:07:54,193 --> 03:07:56,395 THAT HELP US TO ELIMINATE THESE 3604 03:07:56,395 --> 03:08:01,834 DISPARITIES? 3605 03:08:01,834 --> 03:08:02,701 THE DEFINITION I THOUGHT WOULD 3606 03:08:02,701 --> 03:08:05,471 BE HELPFUL AND I LOOK AT RACIAL 3607 03:08:05,471 --> 03:08:07,006 HEALTH DISPARITIES AND WHAT IS 3608 03:08:07,006 --> 03:08:07,273 RACE. 3609 03:08:07,273 --> 03:08:10,309 IT'S A HOT TOPIC AND PEOPLE LIKE 3610 03:08:10,309 --> 03:08:11,811 TO INCORPORATE RACE INTO THEIR 3611 03:08:11,811 --> 03:08:13,646 RESEARCH BUT IT'S ULTIMATELY A 3612 03:08:13,646 --> 03:08:14,480 SOCIAL CONSTRUCT AND IT'S WHAT 3613 03:08:14,480 --> 03:08:16,415 WE USE TO GROUP PEOPLE AND 3614 03:08:16,415 --> 03:08:18,384 TYPICALLY WE USED IT AS A 3615 03:08:18,384 --> 03:08:18,984 HIERARCHICAL SYSTEM TO GROUP 3616 03:08:18,984 --> 03:08:25,658 PEOPLE. 3617 03:08:25,658 --> 03:08:27,893 BASED MOSTLY ON COLOR OF SKIN 3618 03:08:27,893 --> 03:08:29,628 AND COULD HAVE BEEN HEIGHT BUT 3619 03:08:29,628 --> 03:08:31,063 WE CHOSE SKIN FOR SOME REASON 3620 03:08:31,063 --> 03:08:33,999 IT'S NOT A BIOLOGICAL CONSTRUCT 3621 03:08:33,999 --> 03:08:34,467 AS MUCH AS SOCIAL. 3622 03:08:34,467 --> 03:08:37,002 BECAUSE WE LIVE IN A SOCIAL 3623 03:08:37,002 --> 03:08:39,405 SOCIETY IT STILL HAS 3624 03:08:39,405 --> 03:08:41,207 IMPLICATIONS FOR OUR HEALTH AND 3625 03:08:41,207 --> 03:08:43,375 SHOULD BE MINDFUL OF RACE AND 3626 03:08:43,375 --> 03:08:43,609 THOUGHT. 3627 03:08:43,609 --> 03:08:47,112 IN HOW AND WHY WE DO IT. 3628 03:08:47,112 --> 03:08:49,882 SO MY FRAMEWORK I USE FOR 3629 03:08:49,882 --> 03:08:51,617 STUDYING HEALTH DISPARITIES 3630 03:08:51,617 --> 03:08:52,785 SCALES FROM THE POPULATION ALL 3631 03:08:52,785 --> 03:08:55,955 THE WAY DOWN TO THE CELL. 3632 03:08:55,955 --> 03:08:58,190 SO I LOOK AT HOW POPULATIONS ARE 3633 03:08:58,190 --> 03:08:58,858 EXPOSED TO DIFFERENT 3634 03:08:58,858 --> 03:09:01,627 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH AND HOW 3635 03:09:01,627 --> 03:09:03,696 IT IMPACTS THEIR OUTCOMES AND 3636 03:09:03,696 --> 03:09:08,400 HOW THAT IMPACTS BIOLOGY. 3637 03:09:08,400 --> 03:09:10,703 SOME OF MY GUIDING PRINCIPLES IN 3638 03:09:10,703 --> 03:09:12,171 THIS FIELD, ONE THE FIRST 3639 03:09:12,171 --> 03:09:15,174 QUESTION IS ARE THERE HEALTH 3640 03:09:15,174 --> 03:09:17,476 DISPARITIES IN THE MODELS OF 3641 03:09:17,476 --> 03:09:18,978 DISEASE I STUDY, WHICH THERE ARE 3642 03:09:18,978 --> 03:09:21,080 BUT THESE ARE QUESTIONS YOU CAN 3643 03:09:21,080 --> 03:09:21,680 ASK YOURSELF. 3644 03:09:21,680 --> 03:09:23,883 THERE'S TYPICALLY A LOT OF 3645 03:09:23,883 --> 03:09:25,951 RESEARCH DONE MAYBE IN OTHER 3646 03:09:25,951 --> 03:09:26,385 FIELDS. 3647 03:09:26,385 --> 03:09:28,254 IT'S IMPORTANT TO LOOK AT THE 3648 03:09:28,254 --> 03:09:29,855 PRIOR LITERATURE AND ADVANCES IN 3649 03:09:29,855 --> 03:09:34,560 THESE FIELDS THAT MAY HELP ME 3650 03:09:34,560 --> 03:09:35,995 DETERMINE WHETHER HEALTH 3651 03:09:35,995 --> 03:09:37,930 EQUITIES RESEARCH IS SOMETHING I 3652 03:09:37,930 --> 03:09:42,301 CAN INCORPORATE AND ARE THERE 3653 03:09:42,301 --> 03:09:44,703 STRUCTURAL OR SOCIAL 3654 03:09:44,703 --> 03:09:46,639 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH AND I 3655 03:09:46,639 --> 03:09:47,706 APPRECIATE THE PRESENTATION ON 3656 03:09:47,706 --> 03:09:48,874 THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT AND HOW IT 3657 03:09:48,874 --> 03:09:51,577 HAS AN IMPACT ON SO MANY THINGS. 3658 03:09:51,577 --> 03:09:53,512 MAYBE THERE'S OTHER DETERMINATES 3659 03:09:53,512 --> 03:09:55,247 OF HEALTH THAT IMPACT OUR MODELS 3660 03:09:55,247 --> 03:09:57,182 OR DISEASES THAT WE COULD BE 3661 03:09:57,182 --> 03:09:58,517 MORE THOUGHTFUL ABOUT. 3662 03:09:58,517 --> 03:10:00,653 THE THIRD QUESTION IS HOW CAN WE 3663 03:10:00,653 --> 03:10:03,322 DESIGN OUR CITIES TO CONTRIBUTE 3664 03:10:03,322 --> 03:10:05,024 TOWARDS HEALTH EQUITY. 3665 03:10:05,024 --> 03:10:06,258 WHO HAS CONTRIBUTED TO DESIGNING 3666 03:10:06,258 --> 03:10:07,426 THE MODEL OR THE QUESTION AND 3667 03:10:07,426 --> 03:10:10,829 WHAT ARE SOME OF THE POTENTIAL 3668 03:10:10,829 --> 03:10:12,698 BIASES THAT CAN ARISE BASED ON 3669 03:10:12,698 --> 03:10:19,038 WHO IS CONTRIBUTING OR NOT 3670 03:10:19,038 --> 03:10:19,438 CONTRIBUTING. 3671 03:10:19,438 --> 03:10:21,106 SO WHAT ARE OTHER PEOPLE I CAN 3672 03:10:21,106 --> 03:10:23,676 BRING IN IF THAT'S HELPFUL. 3673 03:10:23,676 --> 03:10:26,278 WHAT ARE OTHER SPACES I COULD 3674 03:10:26,278 --> 03:10:27,446 TOUCH ON TO BETTER HELP INFORM 3675 03:10:27,446 --> 03:10:30,149 THE QUESTION OR DESIGN OF MY 3676 03:10:30,149 --> 03:10:32,384 STUDY AND HOW IS THE MODEL BEING 3677 03:10:32,384 --> 03:10:33,686 TRAINED AND WHAT'S THE INPUT AND 3678 03:10:33,686 --> 03:10:35,321 IS IT REPRESENTATIVE OF THE 3679 03:10:35,321 --> 03:10:36,088 POPULATION OF INTEREST. 3680 03:10:36,088 --> 03:10:37,856 THAT'S ONE OF THE LIMITATIONS I 3681 03:10:37,856 --> 03:10:39,558 WAS MENTIONING IN THE EARLIER 3682 03:10:39,558 --> 03:10:39,758 STUDY. 3683 03:10:39,758 --> 03:10:41,827 A LOT OF WORK ESPECIALLY IN THE 3684 03:10:41,827 --> 03:10:43,796 BIO LOGIC FIELD IS LIMITED TO 3685 03:10:43,796 --> 03:10:47,499 CERTAIN POPULATIONS AND DOESN'T 3686 03:10:47,499 --> 03:10:49,668 ALWAYS SCALE TO OTHER 3687 03:10:49,668 --> 03:10:53,539 POPULATIONS OR REPRESENTATIVE OF 3688 03:10:53,539 --> 03:10:53,772 ANYONE. 3689 03:10:53,772 --> 03:10:56,742 THE FOURTH QUESTION IS WHY AM I 3690 03:10:56,742 --> 03:10:58,577 DOING HEALTH EQUITY RESEARCH AND 3691 03:10:58,577 --> 03:11:01,146 A FRIEND BROUGHT THIS UP 3692 03:11:01,146 --> 03:11:03,682 YESTERDAY, IT'S A HOT TOPIC AND 3693 03:11:03,682 --> 03:11:04,783 THERE'S SO MANY FUNDING 3694 03:11:04,783 --> 03:11:06,819 OPPORTUNITIES BUT WE WANT TO 3695 03:11:06,819 --> 03:11:08,153 AVOID HEALTH EQUITY TOURISM AND 3696 03:11:08,153 --> 03:11:10,589 THAT COULD BE DAMAGING IF WE'RE 3697 03:11:10,589 --> 03:11:11,924 NOT CONSCIOUS AND THOUGHTFUL 3698 03:11:11,924 --> 03:11:13,559 ABOUT WHY WE'RE DOING IT AND 3699 03:11:13,559 --> 03:11:15,961 THINKING WITH THE BIASES AND 3700 03:11:15,961 --> 03:11:17,863 THINKING ABOUT HOW WE WANT TO 3701 03:11:17,863 --> 03:11:24,136 DEVELOP OUR QUESTION. 3702 03:11:24,136 --> 03:11:25,204 I'LL GIVE THE EXAMPLE IN BREAST 3703 03:11:25,204 --> 03:11:27,373 CANCER THE WORK I DO. 3704 03:11:27,373 --> 03:11:30,342 MANY ARE PROBABLY FAMILIAR THAT 3705 03:11:30,342 --> 03:11:31,644 ONE IN EIGHT WOMEN WILL DEVELOP 3706 03:11:31,644 --> 03:11:33,312 AN INVASIVE BREAST CANCER DURING 3707 03:11:33,312 --> 03:11:34,313 HER LIFE TIME. 3708 03:11:34,313 --> 03:11:36,749 FOR MOST OF US IT'S MAYBE NOT A 3709 03:11:36,749 --> 03:11:37,016 STATISTIC. 3710 03:11:37,016 --> 03:11:39,284 MAYBE WE KNOW SOMEBODY, A 3711 03:11:39,284 --> 03:11:43,922 SISTER, FRIENDS, PARENT FOR ME 3712 03:11:43,922 --> 03:11:45,691 IT'S MY GRANDMOTHER SHE WAS 3713 03:11:45,691 --> 03:11:49,762 DIAGNOSED AT THE AGE OF 49 AND I 3714 03:11:49,762 --> 03:11:52,431 WAS AROUND 7 YEARS AND I THOUGHT 3715 03:11:52,431 --> 03:11:55,467 I'M GOING TO CURE BREAST CANCER 3716 03:11:55,467 --> 03:11:56,769 AND AS MANY CONFIDENT YOUNG 3717 03:11:56,769 --> 03:11:58,070 PEOPLE SAY. 3718 03:11:58,070 --> 03:11:59,972 I DID NOT BUT I'M MAKING AN 3719 03:11:59,972 --> 03:12:00,839 EFFORT TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE 3720 03:12:00,839 --> 03:12:03,442 FIELD AND KEPT MY PROMISE TO 3721 03:12:03,442 --> 03:12:03,609 HER. 3722 03:12:03,609 --> 03:12:05,878 WHY FOR ME IT'S AN EXAMPLE OF 3723 03:12:05,878 --> 03:12:06,545 HEALTH DISPARITIES? 3724 03:12:06,545 --> 03:12:09,381 ONE, THERE ARE RACIAL 3725 03:12:09,381 --> 03:12:10,683 DISPARITIES IN BREAST CANCER 3726 03:12:10,683 --> 03:12:13,018 MORTALITY IF YOU LOOK AT THE 3727 03:12:13,018 --> 03:12:14,687 GRAPH FROM THE AMERICAN BREAST 3728 03:12:14,687 --> 03:12:17,856 CANCER SOCIETY WE FOCUS ON THE 3729 03:12:17,856 --> 03:12:20,025 TWO BARS ON THE LEFT AND 3730 03:12:20,025 --> 03:12:22,027 NON-HISPANIC WHITE WOMEN HAVE A 3731 03:12:22,027 --> 03:12:23,729 HIGHER INCIDENT THAN 3732 03:12:23,729 --> 03:12:27,933 NON-HISPANIC BLACK WOMEN BUT NOT 3733 03:12:27,933 --> 03:12:29,668 NON-HISPANIC BLACK WOMEN IN THE 3734 03:12:29,668 --> 03:12:31,704 40% MORE LIKELY TO DIE OF THEIR 3735 03:12:31,704 --> 03:12:33,005 BREAST CANCER. 3736 03:12:33,005 --> 03:12:35,274 WHY THIS IS THE CASE THE WIDEST 3737 03:12:35,274 --> 03:12:43,749 GAP IS NOT WELL KNOWN. 3738 03:12:43,749 --> 03:12:45,184 AND THERE'S SOME ARE AT THE 3739 03:12:45,184 --> 03:12:48,187 TUMOR LEVEL, TREATMENT, QUALITY 3740 03:12:48,187 --> 03:12:50,355 OF TREATMENT AND NOW THE 3741 03:12:50,355 --> 03:12:52,624 STRUCTURAL DETERMINATES OF 3742 03:12:52,624 --> 03:12:53,859 HEALTH. 3743 03:12:53,859 --> 03:12:55,427 NATIONALLY 40% OF BLACK WOMEN 3744 03:12:55,427 --> 03:12:57,496 ARE LIKELY TO DIE THAN WHITE BUT 3745 03:12:57,496 --> 03:13:00,299 IN ATLANTA WHERE I DIE, BLACK 3746 03:13:00,299 --> 03:13:01,967 WOMEN ARE TWICE AS LIKELY TO DIE 3747 03:13:01,967 --> 03:13:02,768 SO IT'S IMPORTANT FOR THE 3748 03:13:02,768 --> 03:13:06,038 POPULATION I STUDY IN 3749 03:13:06,038 --> 03:13:11,310 PARTICULAR. 3750 03:13:11,310 --> 03:13:14,213 AS A CANCER BIOLOGIST I TRY TO 3751 03:13:14,213 --> 03:13:16,915 UNDERSTAND HOW THAT MIGHT 3752 03:13:16,915 --> 03:13:17,416 CONTRIBUTE. 3753 03:13:17,416 --> 03:13:21,253 SO WHY TUMOR CARE IS IMPORTANT. 3754 03:13:21,253 --> 03:13:22,688 FOR BREAST CANCER THERE'S 3755 03:13:22,688 --> 03:13:24,857 DIFFERENT SUB TYPES AND FOUR 3756 03:13:24,857 --> 03:13:26,058 TYPICALLY IN THE CLINIC AND 3757 03:13:26,058 --> 03:13:29,528 TYPED BY DIFFERENT RECEPTOR 3758 03:13:29,528 --> 03:13:30,596 STATUS AND DIFFERENT POSITIVE 3759 03:13:30,596 --> 03:13:31,497 RECEPTORS THAT HAVE A 3760 03:13:31,497 --> 03:13:32,197 COMBINATION OF ONE OF THESE 3761 03:13:32,197 --> 03:13:34,299 THREE RECEPTORS AND THEY TEND TO 3762 03:13:34,299 --> 03:13:37,136 BENEFIT FROM TARGETED THERAPY. 3763 03:13:37,136 --> 03:13:39,238 AND HAVE A BETTER PROGNOSIS THAN 3764 03:13:39,238 --> 03:13:42,374 WOMEN THAT HAVE TRIPLE-NEGATIVE 3765 03:13:42,374 --> 03:13:43,642 BREAST CANCER WHICH DON'T 3766 03:13:43,642 --> 03:13:45,511 EXPRESS ANY OF THE RECEPTORS AN 3767 03:13:45,511 --> 03:13:46,845 THEREFORE DON'T BENEFIT FROM 3768 03:13:46,845 --> 03:13:49,014 TARGET THERAPIES ONLY TYPICALLY 3769 03:13:49,014 --> 03:13:50,616 GET TREATED WITH CHEMOTHERAPY 3770 03:13:50,616 --> 03:13:52,818 AND UNFORTUNATELY ABOUT 50% OF 3771 03:13:52,818 --> 03:13:56,288 THESE PATIENTS ARE RESISTANT TO 3772 03:13:56,288 --> 03:13:57,456 CHEMOTHERAPY SO THEY'RE 3773 03:13:57,456 --> 03:13:57,823 NON-RESPONDERS. 3774 03:13:57,823 --> 03:13:59,925 IT'S IMPORTANT TO THINK ABOUT 3775 03:13:59,925 --> 03:14:05,130 THIS WITH THE DISPARITIES 3776 03:14:05,130 --> 03:14:06,799 BECAUSE BLACK WOMEN ARE MORE 3777 03:14:06,799 --> 03:14:09,334 LIKELY TO BE DIAGNOSED WITH 3778 03:14:09,334 --> 03:14:12,037 TRIPLE NEGATIVE BREAST CANCER 3779 03:14:12,037 --> 03:14:14,406 COMPARED TO THEIR WHITE COUNTER 3780 03:14:14,406 --> 03:14:17,709 PARTS AND SO THERE'S SUBTYPES TO 3781 03:14:17,709 --> 03:14:19,044 NOTE AS WELL. 3782 03:14:19,044 --> 03:14:20,479 I DIDN'T SHOW MY DISSERTATION 3783 03:14:20,479 --> 03:14:23,015 WORK IN NANO THERAPEUTICS AND 3784 03:14:23,015 --> 03:14:24,750 DETERMINING DRUG RESISTANT 3785 03:14:24,750 --> 03:14:26,418 PATHWAYS BUT ONCE I COMPLETED 3786 03:14:26,418 --> 03:14:29,855 THAT FIVE YEARS OR SO OF WORK 3787 03:14:29,855 --> 03:14:31,790 THE QUESTION STILL LINGERED WHY 3788 03:14:31,790 --> 03:14:33,625 ARE BLACK WOMEN MORE LIKELY TO 3789 03:14:33,625 --> 03:14:40,532 GET TRIPLE NEGATIVE BREAST 3790 03:14:40,532 --> 03:14:40,766 CANCER? 3791 03:14:40,766 --> 03:14:42,367 DOING PRELIMINARY RESEARCH I SAW 3792 03:14:42,367 --> 03:14:47,673 THERE WERE INDIVIDUAL-LEVEL 3793 03:14:47,673 --> 03:14:48,473 CHARACTER 3794 03:14:48,473 --> 03:14:51,109 CHARACTERISTICS AND LOOKING AT 3795 03:14:51,109 --> 03:14:55,747 GENETIC OR LIFESTYLE OR OBESITY 3796 03:14:55,747 --> 03:15:01,854 AND PREGNANCY FACTORS AND NONE 3797 03:15:01,854 --> 03:15:06,425 ROSE TO THE REASON AND WHILE WE 3798 03:15:06,425 --> 03:15:08,760 PRIMARILY HAVE FOCUSSED ON 3799 03:15:08,760 --> 03:15:11,597 INDIVIDUAL-LEVEL RISK FACTORS WE 3800 03:15:11,597 --> 03:15:15,334 UP TO THIS POINT WE NEED TO KNOW 3801 03:15:15,334 --> 03:15:16,768 WHAT'S HAPPENING ABOVE THE SKIN 3802 03:15:16,768 --> 03:15:19,805 AND LOOKING AT STRUCTURAL 3803 03:15:19,805 --> 03:15:22,174 INEQUITIES AND INJUSTICES THAT 3804 03:15:22,174 --> 03:15:23,075 DRIVE LIVED ENVIRONMENTS AND CAN 3805 03:15:23,075 --> 03:15:24,142 HAVE IMPLICATIONS FOR BELOW THE 3806 03:15:24,142 --> 03:15:29,014 SKIN. 3807 03:15:29,014 --> 03:15:30,782 ADDRESSING DISEASE WILL REQUIRE 3808 03:15:30,782 --> 03:15:32,417 HOW STRUCTURAL INEQUITIES IMPACT 3809 03:15:32,417 --> 03:15:35,053 HEALTH. 3810 03:15:35,053 --> 03:15:36,755 SO I TALK ABOUT STRUCTURAL 3811 03:15:36,755 --> 03:15:39,725 RACISM AND IN 2021 THE CDC 3812 03:15:39,725 --> 03:15:41,860 DECLARED RACISM AS A PUBLIC 3813 03:15:41,860 --> 03:15:44,263 HEALTH ISSUE. 3814 03:15:44,263 --> 03:15:50,068 AND STRUCTURAL RACISM IS DEFINE 3815 03:15:50,068 --> 03:15:57,242 AS IDEOLOGIES THAT GENERATE AND 3816 03:15:57,242 --> 03:15:59,344 PERPETUATE INEQUITIES BETWEEN 3817 03:15:59,344 --> 03:15:59,544 RACES. 3818 03:15:59,544 --> 03:16:02,981 I USE RED LINING AS A VARIABLE 3819 03:16:02,981 --> 03:16:07,586 THAT'S UPSTREAM OF BIOLOGICAL 3820 03:16:07,586 --> 03:16:08,553 FACTORS TO DETERMINE AND THIS IS 3821 03:16:08,553 --> 03:16:09,755 A MAP OF ATLANTA. 3822 03:16:09,755 --> 03:16:12,324 A FOLK MAP FROM THE 1930s. 3823 03:16:12,324 --> 03:16:18,430 AS MENTIONED BEFORE, RED LINING 3824 03:16:18,430 --> 03:16:20,132 HAS BEEN OUTLAWED SINCE THE 3825 03:16:20,132 --> 03:16:22,801 1960s BUT THERE'S A PRESENT DAY 3826 03:16:22,801 --> 03:16:32,444 SYSTEM OF DENIAL OF MORTGAGES 3827 03:16:32,444 --> 03:16:37,916 BASED ON PLACE AND IT IMPACTING, 3828 03:16:37,916 --> 03:16:39,718 HOUSING, HEALTH CARE, NUTRITION, 3829 03:16:39,718 --> 03:16:41,219 GREEN SPACE ALL THE THINGS WE 3830 03:16:41,219 --> 03:16:42,587 TALKED ABOUT ALREADY EVEN THE 3831 03:16:42,587 --> 03:16:44,423 TEMPERATURE OF A PLACE. 3832 03:16:44,423 --> 03:16:46,391 SO IT'S AN INDICATOR I LIKE TO 3833 03:16:46,391 --> 03:16:50,696 USE BECAUSE IT'S SO FAR UPSTREAM 3834 03:16:50,696 --> 03:16:52,998 AND WE CAN START UNPACKING THE 3835 03:16:52,998 --> 03:16:55,567 DOWN STREAM AFFECTS. 3836 03:16:55,567 --> 03:16:57,269 THE QUESTION DOES STRUCTURAL 3837 03:16:57,269 --> 03:16:59,271 RACISM IMPACT HEALTH OUTCOMES? 3838 03:16:59,271 --> 03:17:00,939 IN OUR GROUP WE LOOKED AT 3839 03:17:00,939 --> 03:17:02,374 CONTEMPORARY RED LINING WITHIN 3840 03:17:02,374 --> 03:17:04,142 THE METRO AREA USING FIVE 3841 03:17:04,142 --> 03:17:06,611 COUNTIES AND SAW LIVING IN A 3842 03:17:06,611 --> 03:17:08,046 CONTEMPORARY RED LINE AREA WAS 3843 03:17:08,046 --> 03:17:09,848 ASSOCIATED WITH A 60% INCREASE 3844 03:17:09,848 --> 03:17:10,882 IN BREAST CANCER MORTALITY. 3845 03:17:10,882 --> 03:17:13,418 THIS IS WHEN WE ADJUSTED FOR AGE 3846 03:17:13,418 --> 03:17:14,319 AND RACE. 3847 03:17:14,319 --> 03:17:16,521 AND 80% OF NON-HISPANIC BLACK 3848 03:17:16,521 --> 03:17:19,358 WOMEN VERSUS 20% OF NON-HISPANIC 3849 03:17:19,358 --> 03:17:20,792 BLACK WOMEN LIVED IN THE RED 3850 03:17:20,792 --> 03:17:22,260 LINE DISTRICTS AND LIVING IN A 3851 03:17:22,260 --> 03:17:24,129 RED LINE AREA YOU'RE MORE LIKELY 3852 03:17:24,129 --> 03:17:26,932 TO BE DIAGNOSED WITH TRIPLE 3853 03:17:26,932 --> 03:17:29,868 NEGATIVE BREAST CANCER OR HAVE 3854 03:17:29,868 --> 03:17:31,503 ED STAGE DISEASE. 3855 03:17:31,503 --> 03:17:37,943 AS A TRAINED CANCER BIO 3856 03:17:37,943 --> 03:17:40,445 BIOLOGIST WHAT'S THE SOCIAL 3857 03:17:40,445 --> 03:17:41,713 STRUCTURAL DETERMINATE OF HEALTH 3858 03:17:41,713 --> 03:17:46,385 LIKE RED LINING IN THE HEALTH 3859 03:17:46,385 --> 03:17:47,886 OUTCOMES? 3860 03:17:47,886 --> 03:17:49,855 ONE TOOL IS LOOKING AT THE 3861 03:17:49,855 --> 03:17:51,823 EPIGENOME MEDIATOR AT THE 3862 03:17:51,823 --> 03:17:53,859 BIOLOGICAL LEVEL. 3863 03:17:53,859 --> 03:17:56,728 THE EPIGENOME IS A GREAT TOOL 3864 03:17:56,728 --> 03:17:57,796 BECAUSE IT DOESN'T CHANGE TO THE 3865 03:17:57,796 --> 03:17:59,498 SEQUENCE BUT LOOKING AN TOP OF 3866 03:17:59,498 --> 03:18:01,900 THE DNA THAT CHANGE THE GENE'S 3867 03:18:01,900 --> 03:18:02,834 ABILITY TO BE EXPRESSED. 3868 03:18:02,834 --> 03:18:06,972 SO DNA METHYLATION, MODIFICATION 3869 03:18:06,972 --> 03:18:13,045 TO THE HISTONE AND THINGS 3870 03:18:13,045 --> 03:18:13,912 INFLUENCED BY SOCIAL 3871 03:18:13,912 --> 03:18:17,482 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH, DIET, 3872 03:18:17,482 --> 03:18:20,085 PHYSICAL ACTIVITY, STRESS THAT 3873 03:18:20,085 --> 03:18:22,587 CAN CHANGE EPIGENETIC 3874 03:18:22,587 --> 03:18:24,523 MODIFICATIONS AND POTENTIALLY 3875 03:18:24,523 --> 03:18:25,123 CHANGING OUTCOMES FOR BREAST 3876 03:18:25,123 --> 03:18:30,629 CANCER PATIENTS. 3877 03:18:30,629 --> 03:18:32,864 I CAN CALL EPIGENOME WIDE 3878 03:18:32,864 --> 03:18:37,869 ASSOCIATION STUDIES THEY CAN 3879 03:18:37,869 --> 03:18:41,039 MEASURE GENOME WIDE MARKS AND 3880 03:18:41,039 --> 03:18:43,208 DNA METHYLATION MARK ON 8,000 3881 03:18:43,208 --> 03:18:45,844 SITES CALLED CPG SITES AND LOOK 3882 03:18:45,844 --> 03:18:47,946 AT CASES AND CONTROLS COMPARING 3883 03:18:47,946 --> 03:18:49,614 PEOPLE IN RED LINED AREAS 3884 03:18:49,614 --> 03:18:52,350 COMPARING THOSE WHO DO NOT AND 3885 03:18:52,350 --> 03:18:56,421 MEASURE METHYLATION. 3886 03:18:56,421 --> 03:18:59,291 REGRESSING METHYLATION VALUES ON 3887 03:18:59,291 --> 03:19:00,625 THESE CPG SITES. 3888 03:19:00,625 --> 03:19:03,195 SO WE CAN LOOK AT DIFFERENTIAL 3889 03:19:03,195 --> 03:19:04,796 METHYLATION AND LOOK AT 3890 03:19:04,796 --> 03:19:07,599 DIFFERENCES IN EPIGENETIC AGE 3891 03:19:07,599 --> 03:19:10,769 WHICH IS USING COMPOSITES OF THE 3892 03:19:10,769 --> 03:19:11,803 METHYLATION MARKS AND SEEING 3893 03:19:11,803 --> 03:19:13,071 WHETHER THERE'S DIFFERENCE IN 3894 03:19:13,071 --> 03:19:17,876 BIOLOGICAL AGE, WHICH IS THE 3895 03:19:17,876 --> 03:19:19,211 EPIGENIC AGE AND CHRONOLOGICAL 3896 03:19:19,211 --> 03:19:21,680 AGE IN AGE ACCELERATION. 3897 03:19:21,680 --> 03:19:25,083 LIVING IN A CONTEMPORARY RED 3898 03:19:25,083 --> 03:19:29,855 LINE NEIGHBORHOOD AND LOOKING AT 3899 03:19:29,855 --> 03:19:35,660 PLACE BASED STRUCTURAL RACISM 3900 03:19:35,660 --> 03:19:38,296 AND LOOKING AT A GENOME WIDE 3901 03:19:38,296 --> 03:19:41,566 ASSOCIATION STUDY AND A PILOT 3902 03:19:41,566 --> 03:19:46,838 STUDY AND 80 WOMEN AND 3903 03:19:46,838 --> 03:19:50,876 DIFFERENTIAL METHYLATION AND RED 3904 03:19:50,876 --> 03:19:51,109 LINING. 3905 03:19:51,109 --> 03:19:53,879 WE CONTEMPORARY RED LINING IS 3906 03:19:53,879 --> 03:19:55,447 ASSOCIATED WITH METHYLATION WITH 3907 03:19:55,447 --> 03:19:56,648 BREAST CANCER AND SITES WERE 3908 03:19:56,648 --> 03:19:57,849 ASSOCIATED. 3909 03:19:57,849 --> 03:20:00,051 THIS IS A VOLCANO PLOT. 3910 03:20:00,051 --> 03:20:02,654 THIS IS AFFECT SIZE ON THE X 3911 03:20:02,654 --> 03:20:03,054 AXIS. 3912 03:20:03,054 --> 03:20:05,857 ALL THESE ARE HAVE A POSITIVE 3913 03:20:05,857 --> 03:20:08,960 EFFECT SIZE MEANING THEY WERE 3914 03:20:08,960 --> 03:20:09,594 HYPERMETHYLATED OR HAD AN 3915 03:20:09,594 --> 03:20:11,997 INCREASE IN METHYLATION AND ALL 3916 03:20:11,997 --> 03:20:12,597 IN THE BOX ARE STATISTICALLY 3917 03:20:12,597 --> 03:20:21,373 SIGNIFICANT. 3918 03:20:21,373 --> 03:20:23,808 AND LOOKING AT DEVELOPMENT 3919 03:20:23,808 --> 03:20:25,243 PROCESSES AND ONCOGENIC 3920 03:20:25,243 --> 03:20:27,979 SIGNALLING AND ALL THE THINGS 3921 03:20:27,979 --> 03:20:29,481 THAT WOULD SUPPORT THAT THESE 3922 03:20:29,481 --> 03:20:30,081 WOULD ENHANCE BREAST CANCER 3923 03:20:30,081 --> 03:20:36,755 OUTCOMES. 3924 03:20:36,755 --> 03:20:38,924 WE ALSO LOOKED AT INTERACTION 3925 03:20:38,924 --> 03:20:41,860 BY E.R. STATUS AND DIDN'T SEE 3926 03:20:41,860 --> 03:20:44,162 ANYTHING STATISTICALLY 3927 03:20:44,162 --> 03:20:44,462 SIGNIFICANT. 3928 03:20:44,462 --> 03:20:53,338 WE SAW INTERESTING TRENDS WHERE 3929 03:20:53,338 --> 03:20:56,074 IF YHERE ON THIS AXIS IT 3930 03:20:56,074 --> 03:20:58,977 INCREASED BY ALL 36 SITES VERSUS 3931 03:20:58,977 --> 03:21:02,013 IF YOU HAD NO E .R. RECEPTOR YOU 3932 03:21:02,013 --> 03:21:06,551 HAD HIGH METHYLATION ACROSS THE 3933 03:21:06,551 --> 03:21:06,751 BOARD. 3934 03:21:06,751 --> 03:21:09,854 QUITE INTERESTING. 3935 03:21:09,854 --> 03:21:14,226 IN LOOKING AT EPIDEMIC AGE WAS 3936 03:21:14,226 --> 03:21:15,493 ASSOCIATED WITH BREAST CANCER 3937 03:21:15,493 --> 03:21:17,329 AND ADJUSTING FOR AGE LIVING IN 3938 03:21:17,329 --> 03:21:19,564 A RED LINE AREAS YOU'D BE FIVE 3939 03:21:19,564 --> 03:21:22,334 YEARS OR SO OLDER BIOLOGICAL 3940 03:21:22,334 --> 03:21:24,569 THAN THOSE IN RED LINE AND 3941 03:21:24,569 --> 03:21:26,438 ADJUSTING FOR AGE AND RACE IT 3942 03:21:26,438 --> 03:21:27,639 INCREASE THE ASSOCIATION TO 6.6 3943 03:21:27,639 --> 03:21:37,816 YEARS OLDER. 3944 03:21:37,816 --> 03:21:39,117 AND LOOKING AT BREAST CANCER 3945 03:21:39,117 --> 03:21:40,452 MORTALITY AND LOOKING AT THE 3946 03:21:40,452 --> 03:21:42,387 HAZARD RATIOS. 3947 03:21:42,387 --> 03:21:45,523 THERE'S ACTUALLY A 5% DECREASE 3948 03:21:45,523 --> 03:21:46,891 IN MORTALITY WITH ONE OF THE 3949 03:21:46,891 --> 03:21:52,063 PLOTS WHICH IS INTERESTING BUT 3950 03:21:52,063 --> 03:21:53,331 ALSO THERE'S REASONS I WON'T GET 3951 03:21:53,331 --> 03:21:55,467 INTO BECAUSE OF TIME. 3952 03:21:55,467 --> 03:21:57,168 SO THERE'S LIMITATIONS TO THIS. 3953 03:21:57,168 --> 03:22:00,105 WE HAD A SMALL SAMPLE SIZE AND 3954 03:22:00,105 --> 03:22:03,008 FOCUSSED ON THE DNA METHYLOME 3955 03:22:03,008 --> 03:22:05,210 AND LOOKING AT DOWN STREAM 3956 03:22:05,210 --> 03:22:07,145 IMPACTS OF GREEN EXPRESSION. 3957 03:22:07,145 --> 03:22:08,780 WE DID IDENTIFY NOVEL 3958 03:22:08,780 --> 03:22:11,416 ASSOCIATION BETWEEN RED LINING 3959 03:22:11,416 --> 03:22:13,285 AND THE BREAST TUMOR DNA 3960 03:22:13,285 --> 03:22:14,552 METHYLOME AND THE DATA ARE THE 3961 03:22:14,552 --> 03:22:17,856 FIRST TO SHOW CONTEMPORARY 3962 03:22:17,856 --> 03:22:20,425 RACISM POLICIES IMPACT THE 3963 03:22:20,425 --> 03:22:23,628 BREAST TUMOR GENOME. 3964 03:22:23,628 --> 03:22:28,166 AND STRUCTURAL EQUITIES HAVE 3965 03:22:28,166 --> 03:22:29,801 INEQUITIES AND THERE'S PERTURB 3966 03:22:29,801 --> 03:22:33,471 BASES ON BREAST CANCER OUTCOMES. 3967 03:22:33,471 --> 03:22:35,307 ALL THE WORK WENT INTO 3968 03:22:35,307 --> 03:22:39,377 DEVELOPING MY K-99 NOW MY 3969 03:22:39,377 --> 03:22:41,313 CURRENT RESEARCH INVESTIGATING 3970 03:22:41,313 --> 03:22:44,382 THE SOCIAL AND STRUCTURAL 3971 03:22:44,382 --> 03:22:45,984 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH TO 3972 03:22:45,984 --> 03:22:47,419 UNDERSTAND THE ETIOLOGY IN 3973 03:22:47,419 --> 03:22:48,720 BREAST CANCER. 3974 03:22:48,720 --> 03:22:49,321 I'VE PRIMARILY TALKED ABOUT 3975 03:22:49,321 --> 03:22:51,056 BREAST CANCER MORTALITY BUT IF 3976 03:22:51,056 --> 03:22:53,091 WE THINK OF THE CANCER CARE 3977 03:22:53,091 --> 03:22:55,193 CONTINUUM IT HAS MANY 3978 03:22:55,193 --> 03:22:57,062 COMPONENTS, ETIOLOGY IN WHY 3979 03:22:57,062 --> 03:22:58,229 PEOPLE DEVELOP BREAST CANCER IS 3980 03:22:58,229 --> 03:23:00,332 WHAT I'M FOCUSSING ON NOW. 3981 03:23:00,332 --> 03:23:02,667 LOOKING AT RED LINING, PRIMARILY 3982 03:23:02,667 --> 03:23:04,502 HISTORIC RED LINING AND HOW IT 3983 03:23:04,502 --> 03:23:05,970 IMPACTS THE DEVELOPMENT OF 3984 03:23:05,970 --> 03:23:09,774 TRIPLE NEGATIVE BREAST CANCER 3985 03:23:09,774 --> 03:23:13,912 AND LOOKING AT ONO GENIC 3986 03:23:13,912 --> 03:23:18,850 SIGNAL -- ONCOGENIC SIGNALLING 3987 03:23:18,850 --> 03:23:21,286 ACTIVATION AND I'LL SUBMIT FOR 3988 03:23:21,286 --> 03:23:22,387 PUBLICATION BUT LIVING IN A RED 3989 03:23:22,387 --> 03:23:24,022 LINE AREA WAS ASSOCIATED WITH 3990 03:23:24,022 --> 03:23:26,324 AGE INCREASE OF DEVELOPING 3991 03:23:26,324 --> 03:23:29,094 TRIPLE NEGATIVE BREAST CANCER. 3992 03:23:29,094 --> 03:23:33,865 NOW WE'RE MOVING INTO THIS AIM 2 3993 03:23:33,865 --> 03:23:36,868 AND AGAIN LOOKING AT DIFFERENT 3994 03:23:36,868 --> 03:23:39,003 METHYLATION AND AGE METHYLATION 3995 03:23:39,003 --> 03:23:41,439 AND OTHER DOWN STREAM FUNCTIONAL 3996 03:23:41,439 --> 03:23:43,408 ASSAYS TO BE ABLE TO DETERMINE 3997 03:23:43,408 --> 03:23:45,243 WHETHER WE SEE SOME FUNCTIONAL 3998 03:23:45,243 --> 03:23:49,814 IMPLICATIONS TO SOME OF THESE 3999 03:23:49,814 --> 03:23:53,852 EPIGENETIC CHANGES. 4000 03:23:53,852 --> 03:23:58,490 RED LINING IS ASSOCIATED WITH 4001 03:23:58,490 --> 03:24:00,258 BIOLOGICAL MECHANISMS UNDER TE 4002 03:24:00,258 --> 03:24:01,860 SKIN AND FURTHER WORK IS NEEDED 4003 03:24:01,860 --> 03:24:04,362 TO ELUCIDATE MECHANISMS AND 4004 03:24:04,362 --> 03:24:05,997 INSIGHTS GOVERNING BREAST CANCER 4005 03:24:05,997 --> 03:24:07,766 DISPARITIES. 4006 03:24:07,766 --> 03:24:10,135 THIS IS WHERE I TRY TO 4007 03:24:10,135 --> 03:24:11,803 INCORPORATE SOMETHING I SAW 4008 03:24:11,803 --> 03:24:13,371 YESTERDAY AND I SAW THE 10 4009 03:24:13,371 --> 03:24:17,075 SIMPLE RULES FOR CREDIBILITY IN 4010 03:24:17,075 --> 03:24:17,742 MODELS. 4011 03:24:17,742 --> 03:24:20,845 BUT SOME ARE HELPFUL IF WE'RE 4012 03:24:20,845 --> 03:24:21,846 THINKING ABOUT HEALTH EQUITY AND 4013 03:24:21,846 --> 03:24:26,418 IN THE MODELS WE MIGHT BE USING. 4014 03:24:26,418 --> 03:24:29,087 AND FIRST DEFINE THE CONTEXT 4015 03:24:29,087 --> 03:24:29,320 CLEARLY. 4016 03:24:29,320 --> 03:24:32,724 IN WHAT CONTEXT AM I ABLE TO USE 4017 03:24:32,724 --> 03:24:33,591 HEALTH EQUITY? 4018 03:24:33,591 --> 03:24:36,227 WHAT AM I TRYING TO INCORPORATE 4019 03:24:36,227 --> 03:24:38,463 AND WHAT DOES IT MAKE SENSE FOR 4020 03:24:38,463 --> 03:24:41,166 MY MODEL AND DISEASE AND AM I 4021 03:24:41,166 --> 03:24:42,934 USING THE APPROPRIATE DATA IS MY 4022 03:24:42,934 --> 03:24:45,804 GROUP INCORPORATING BOTH GROUPS 4023 03:24:45,804 --> 03:24:51,376 AND HOW WELL ARE THEY 4024 03:24:51,376 --> 03:24:53,611 REPRESENTED. 4025 03:24:53,611 --> 03:25:01,653 WHEN WE SHARE AND PUBLISHING WE 4026 03:25:01,653 --> 03:25:03,455 ONLY USE EUROPEAN ANCESTRY WE 4027 03:25:03,455 --> 03:25:05,223 SHOULD STATE THAT CLEARLY SO 4028 03:25:05,223 --> 03:25:06,925 PEOPLE KNOW THERE'S LIMITED 4029 03:25:06,925 --> 03:25:08,460 UTILITY IF WE'RE TRYING TO 4030 03:25:08,460 --> 03:25:11,496 EXPAND IT TO MORE GROUPS. 4031 03:25:11,496 --> 03:25:12,664 DOCUMENTING ADEQUATELY. 4032 03:25:12,664 --> 03:25:14,399 SOME OF THE DISPARITIES HAPPEN 4033 03:25:14,399 --> 03:25:15,400 NOT JUST IN THE MODELS 4034 03:25:15,400 --> 03:25:18,670 THEMSELVES BUT HOW WE SHARE WHAT 4035 03:25:18,670 --> 03:25:20,371 WE'RE DOING SO OTHER PEOPLE IN 4036 03:25:20,371 --> 03:25:22,307 SPACES WE'RE IN AND OTHER 4037 03:25:22,307 --> 03:25:23,741 COMMUNITIES AND COUNTRIES CAN 4038 03:25:23,741 --> 03:25:25,877 ALSO UTILIZE WHAT WE'RE DOING. 4039 03:25:25,877 --> 03:25:26,744 I THINK BEING ABLE TO DOCUMENT 4040 03:25:26,744 --> 03:25:33,852 WELL. 4041 03:25:33,852 --> 03:25:35,753 AND WE DISSEMINATE WELL IN OUR 4042 03:25:35,753 --> 03:25:36,521 OWN CONFERENCES AND JOURNALS BUT 4043 03:25:36,521 --> 03:25:39,023 WHEN IT COMES TO THE COMMUNITY 4044 03:25:39,023 --> 03:25:41,059 PARTNERSHIPS AND PEOPLE IMPACTED 4045 03:25:41,059 --> 03:25:42,627 BY THE HEALTH CONDITIONS WE 4046 03:25:42,627 --> 03:25:43,895 DON'T REALLY SHARE AS MUCH AS 4047 03:25:43,895 --> 03:25:45,163 WITH THEM AND IT'S HELPFUL I 4048 03:25:45,163 --> 03:25:46,531 THINK NOT ONLY FOR THEM BUT FOR 4049 03:25:46,531 --> 03:25:48,466 US TO BE ABLE TO SHAPE OUR 4050 03:25:48,466 --> 03:25:49,400 QUESTIONS BETTER WHEN WE 4051 03:25:49,400 --> 03:25:51,236 DISSEMINATE WHAT WE'RE TRYING TO 4052 03:25:51,236 --> 03:25:52,136 DO AND WHAT WE'RE LEARNING 4053 03:25:52,136 --> 03:26:00,411 BROADLY AND WITH OTHERS. 4054 03:26:00,411 --> 03:26:04,716 AND THERE ARE LIMITATIONS THAT I 4055 03:26:04,716 --> 03:26:07,185 SHOULD MENTION I HAD TO GO ON A 4056 03:26:07,185 --> 03:26:08,820 FOUR-YEAR POSTDOC TO BE TRAINED 4057 03:26:08,820 --> 03:26:09,854 ENOUGH TO UNDERSTAND WHAT 4058 03:26:09,854 --> 03:26:11,789 POPULATION SCIENTISTS WERE 4059 03:26:11,789 --> 03:26:15,093 SAYING SO I CAN INCORPORATE IT 4060 03:26:15,093 --> 03:26:17,662 INTO MY MOLECULAR RESEARCH. 4061 03:26:17,662 --> 03:26:18,863 TRYING TO UNDERSTAND OR TO LEARN 4062 03:26:18,863 --> 03:26:22,367 EACH OTHER'S LANGUAGE IS ENOUGH 4063 03:26:22,367 --> 03:26:23,935 SO WE CAN COLLABORATE IF WE 4064 03:26:23,935 --> 03:26:25,069 CAN'T DO OUR RESEARCH OURSELVES 4065 03:26:25,069 --> 03:26:26,170 AT LEAST HAVE COLLABORATORS TO 4066 03:26:26,170 --> 03:26:28,640 HELP GUIDE US SO WE CAN 4067 03:26:28,640 --> 03:26:29,574 INCORPORATE THIS REALLY 4068 03:26:29,574 --> 03:26:30,241 IMPORTANT TYPE OF WORK INTO WHAT 4069 03:26:30,241 --> 03:26:37,715 WE'RE DOING. 4070 03:26:37,715 --> 03:26:38,850 I'D LIKE TO ACKNOWLEDGE MY 4071 03:26:38,850 --> 03:26:41,853 COLLABORATORS AND MENTEES AND 4072 03:26:41,853 --> 03:26:52,163 THANK YOU SO MUCH. 4073 03:26:54,399 --> 03:26:56,334 >> SO HOW DO WE TALK TO THE 4074 03:26:56,334 --> 03:26:57,669 DIFFERENT RESEARCH COMMUNITIES 4075 03:26:57,669 --> 03:26:59,804 AND BUILD COLLABORATIONS. 4076 03:26:59,804 --> 03:27:02,707 ONE QUESTION THAT'S COME UP FOR 4077 03:27:02,707 --> 03:27:08,212 EVERYBODY AND WHAT KIND OF 4078 03:27:08,212 --> 03:27:09,847 COLLABORATIONS DO YOU THINK THE 4079 03:27:09,847 --> 03:27:10,481 MULTISCALE MODELING COMMUNITY 4080 03:27:10,481 --> 03:27:11,849 WOULD BENEFIT FROM TO START TO 4081 03:27:11,849 --> 03:27:13,818 BUILD THOSE CONNECTIONS? 4082 03:27:13,818 --> 03:27:15,253 >> THAT'S A GOOD QUESTION. 4083 03:27:15,253 --> 03:27:20,224 I THINK HAVING SOMEONE LIKE 4084 03:27:20,224 --> 03:27:22,694 MYSELF NOT IN THE SPACE AND I 4085 03:27:22,694 --> 03:27:24,796 COULD SEE HOW MY WORK COULD 4086 03:27:24,796 --> 03:27:26,831 INFORM YOUR WORK AND YOUR WORK 4087 03:27:26,831 --> 03:27:27,799 IS INFORMING MINE. 4088 03:27:27,799 --> 03:27:30,435 REACHING OUT TO MORE PEOPLE THAT 4089 03:27:30,435 --> 03:27:31,636 MAYBE TANGENTIALLY ARE RELATED 4090 03:27:31,636 --> 03:27:33,338 BUT NOT PART OF YOUR COMMUNITY 4091 03:27:33,338 --> 03:27:33,938 WOULD HELP PUSH YOUR SCIENCE 4092 03:27:33,938 --> 03:27:37,208 FORWARD. 4093 03:27:37,208 --> 03:27:39,110 I THINK THAT'S A FIRST STEP AND 4094 03:27:39,110 --> 03:27:41,379 ALWAYS LOOKING FOR 4095 03:27:41,379 --> 03:27:41,713 OPPORTUNITIES. 4096 03:27:41,713 --> 03:27:43,848 THIS MORNING AT THE HOTEL I GOT 4097 03:27:43,848 --> 03:27:45,383 SAT DOWN AT A RANDOM TABLE WITH 4098 03:27:45,383 --> 03:27:48,286 A NICE LADY AND WE STARTED 4099 03:27:48,286 --> 03:27:48,519 TALKING. 4100 03:27:48,519 --> 03:27:50,655 SHE DOES ALZHEIMER'S RESEARCH 4101 03:27:50,655 --> 03:28:00,465 AND WE DO CANCER PATRDISPARITIED 4102 03:28:00,465 --> 03:28:01,866 HAD TOUCH POINTS TO PUSH OUR 4103 03:28:01,866 --> 03:28:12,410 SCIENCES FORWARD IS HELPFUL TOO. 4104 03:28:17,382 --> 03:28:19,117 WE'RE INVOLVING THE COMMUNITY 4105 03:28:19,117 --> 03:28:20,985 BECAUSE WE DO NEED ASSISTANCE 4106 03:28:20,985 --> 03:28:26,357 AND YOUR THINKING AROUND HOW WE 4107 03:28:26,357 --> 03:28:28,126 WOULD MEASURE MODELS IN TERMS OF 4108 03:28:28,126 --> 03:28:30,428 CAMPUS AND STRUCTURAL 4109 03:28:30,428 --> 03:28:31,596 INTERVENTIONS AND SOCIAL 4110 03:28:31,596 --> 03:28:32,463 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH. 4111 03:28:32,463 --> 03:28:35,266 SO I DO WANT TO PUBLICLY THANK 4112 03:28:35,266 --> 03:28:40,471 GRACE PENG WHO IS A KEY PERSON 4113 03:28:40,471 --> 03:28:43,374 AND SERVING AS A PROJECT 4114 03:28:43,374 --> 03:28:45,576 SCIENTIST ON COMPASS AND THE 4115 03:28:45,576 --> 03:28:46,778 INVITATION AND THOUGHT PROCESS 4116 03:28:46,778 --> 03:28:47,378 TO INCLUDE US TO BE IN 4117 03:28:47,378 --> 03:28:54,852 DISCUSSION WITH YOUR COMMUNITY. 4118 03:28:54,852 --> 03:28:56,754 >> THE COMPASS GROUP IS AN 4119 03:28:56,754 --> 03:28:58,189 AMAZING GROUP TO WORK WITH AND 4120 03:28:58,189 --> 03:28:59,857 YOU'RE THE MOST ORGANIZED PEOPLE 4121 03:28:59,857 --> 03:29:10,234 I'VE EVER WORKED WITH. 4122 03:29:17,108 --> 03:29:20,011 >> ONE OF OUR BREAKOUT SESSIONS 4123 03:29:20,011 --> 03:29:21,846 WILL BE A COMBINATION OF SOCIAL 4124 03:29:21,846 --> 03:29:22,647 BEHAVIORAL MODELLING AND SOCIAL 4125 03:29:22,647 --> 03:29:29,854 DETERMINATES. 4126 03:29:29,854 --> 03:29:31,723 AND COME UP WITH CONCRETE ACTION 4127 03:29:31,723 --> 03:29:37,328 ITEMS AND NEXT STEPS IN TERMS OF 4128 03:29:37,328 --> 03:29:39,530 FURTHERING THESE EFFORTS IN 4129 03:29:39,530 --> 03:29:41,065 TERMS OF BETTER UNDERSTANDING 4130 03:29:41,065 --> 03:29:41,699 SOCIAL DETERMINATES. 4131 03:29:41,699 --> 03:29:42,834 I WANT TO THANK THE PANEL AND 4132 03:29:42,834 --> 03:29:44,368 THANK THE SESSION AND SO LET'S 4133 03:29:44,368 --> 03:29:45,870 GIVE EVERYONE A ROUND OF 4134 03:29:45,870 --> 03:29:54,779 APPLAUSE. 4135 03:29:54,779 --> 03:29:56,748 LET'S SEGUE TO THE NEXT MINI 4136 03:29:56,748 --> 03:30:02,386 SESSION WHICH IS WHERE WE'RE 4137 03:30:02,386 --> 03:30:05,523 GOING TO REVIEW OUR IMAG MSM 4138 03:30:05,523 --> 03:30:16,033 MISSION STATEMENT AND VISION. 4139 03:30:17,335 --> 03:30:18,569 ONCE WE GO THROUGH THE VISION 4140 03:30:18,569 --> 03:30:20,271 AND VISION STATEMENT WE'LL HAVE 4141 03:30:20,271 --> 03:30:24,242 EACH OF THE BREAKOUT LEADS HAVE 4142 03:30:24,242 --> 03:30:26,010 A ONE-MINUTE PITCH FOR THEIR 4143 03:30:26,010 --> 03:30:29,680 BREAKOUT SESSION AND AFTER THAT 4144 03:30:29,680 --> 03:30:32,116 DISPEND TO BREAK FOR LUNCH AND 4145 03:30:32,116 --> 03:30:33,751 START BREAKOUT SESSIONS. 4146 03:30:33,751 --> 03:30:39,123 LET'S START WITH THE VISION. 4147 03:30:39,123 --> 03:30:45,630 BASICALLY, WE DECIDED TO REVISIT 4148 03:30:45,630 --> 03:30:51,669 OUR ILAG -- IMAG MISSION WHICH 4149 03:30:51,669 --> 03:30:58,976 WAS CRAFTED A DECADE AGO. 4150 03:30:58,976 --> 03:31:00,745 WANTED TO PRESENT THIS TO THE 4151 03:31:00,745 --> 03:31:05,383 WHOLE CONSORTIUM TO GET YOUR 4152 03:31:05,383 --> 03:31:05,683 FEEDBACK. 4153 03:31:05,683 --> 03:31:07,618 THE VISION IS LISTED HERE 4154 03:31:07,618 --> 03:31:09,253 INSIGHTFUL APPLICATION OF EVER 4155 03:31:09,253 --> 03:31:11,956 INCREASING ADVANCES IN 4156 03:31:11,956 --> 03:31:14,325 COMPUTATIONAL MODEL OF 4157 03:31:14,325 --> 03:31:16,327 BIOLOGICAL AND BIOMEDICAL 4158 03:31:16,327 --> 03:31:18,429 SYSTEMS ACROSS WIDE RANGES OF 4159 03:31:18,429 --> 03:31:20,331 SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL SCALES. 4160 03:31:20,331 --> 03:31:23,134 HAS THE POWER TO PROVIDE A 4161 03:31:23,134 --> 03:31:23,634 RIGOROUS FRAMEWORK FOR 4162 03:31:23,634 --> 03:31:24,168 SCIENTIFIC DISCOVERY AND 4163 03:31:24,168 --> 03:31:26,037 TRANSLATION. 4164 03:31:26,037 --> 03:31:29,073 THE MISSION IS TO GROW AND 4165 03:31:29,073 --> 03:31:30,908 EXPAND THE FIELD OF MULTI-SCALE 4166 03:31:30,908 --> 03:31:31,609 MODELLING THROUGH DEVELOPMENT 4167 03:31:31,609 --> 03:31:35,413 AND APPLICATION OF MECHANISTIC 4168 03:31:35,413 --> 03:31:36,447 MATHEMATICAL AND COMPUTATIONAL 4169 03:31:36,447 --> 03:31:38,482 MODELS OVER WIDE RANGES OF 4170 03:31:38,482 --> 03:31:41,519 SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL SCALES AND 4171 03:31:41,519 --> 03:31:42,687 MULTIPLE LEVELS OF INVESTIGATION 4172 03:31:42,687 --> 03:31:49,861 THAT INCLUDE AN TOM CAG CAL -- 4173 03:31:49,861 --> 03:31:52,096 ANATOMIC AND PHYSIOLOGICAL 4174 03:31:52,096 --> 03:31:54,398 FIELDS AND INTERDISCIPLINARY 4175 03:31:54,398 --> 03:31:57,568 COLLABORATIONS AN BUILD DIVERSE 4176 03:31:57,568 --> 03:32:01,105 COMMUNITY OF SCIENTISTS, 4177 03:32:01,105 --> 03:32:02,506 EXPERIMENTALISTS, CLINICIANS, 4178 03:32:02,506 --> 03:32:07,011 PUBLIC HEALTH EXPERTS AND OTHER 4179 03:32:07,011 --> 03:32:07,912 STAKEHOLDERS FROM DIFFERENT 4180 03:32:07,912 --> 03:32:09,180 MODELLING TECHNIQUES. 4181 03:32:09,180 --> 03:32:16,854 SECOND BULLET POINT IS 4182 03:32:16,854 --> 03:32:20,324 MECHANISM-BASED MODELLING AND 4183 03:32:20,324 --> 03:32:21,792 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE 4184 03:32:21,792 --> 03:32:24,662 PROPREDICTING REPRODUCIBLE 4185 03:32:24,662 --> 03:32:24,929 OUTCOMES. 4186 03:32:24,929 --> 03:32:26,964 THIRD, ENSURING THE 4187 03:32:26,964 --> 03:32:27,865 IMPLEMENTATION FOR CREDIBLE 4188 03:32:27,865 --> 03:32:29,767 PRACTICE FOR MODELLING AND FAIR 4189 03:32:29,767 --> 03:32:30,968 PRINCIPLES FOR SCIENTIFIC DATA 4190 03:32:30,968 --> 03:32:32,737 MANAGE TOWARDS INTEGRATING MODEL 4191 03:32:32,737 --> 03:32:35,439 DEVELOPMENT, DOCUMENTATION, 4192 03:32:35,439 --> 03:32:38,476 BENCHMARKING, SHARING AND REUSE. 4193 03:32:38,476 --> 03:32:40,144 FOUR, FACILITATING THE 4194 03:32:40,144 --> 03:32:41,746 DISSEMINATION OF MODELS AND 4195 03:32:41,746 --> 03:32:45,850 MODELLING INSIGHTS WITHIN THE 4196 03:32:45,850 --> 03:32:46,984 BIOMEDICAL, BEHAVIORAL AND OTHER 4197 03:32:46,984 --> 03:32:48,986 RELEVANT COMMUNITIES AND 4198 03:32:48,986 --> 03:32:49,620 ADOPTION BY STAKEHOLDER 4199 03:32:49,620 --> 03:32:51,555 COMMUNITIES AND FIVE, 4200 03:32:51,555 --> 03:32:52,290 ENCOURAGING MENTORING AND 4201 03:32:52,290 --> 03:32:56,460 PROVIDING ACCESS TO FUTURE 4202 03:32:56,460 --> 03:32:59,196 GENERATIONS OF MULTISCALE 4203 03:32:59,196 --> 03:32:59,463 MODELERS. 4204 03:32:59,463 --> 03:33:04,535 WE DEFINE THE DEFINITION OF MSM, 4205 03:33:04,535 --> 03:33:08,306 MULTISCALE MODELING AND MSM MOLT 4206 03:33:08,306 --> 03:33:08,606 MOTIVATION. 4207 03:33:08,606 --> 03:33:09,874 WE WANTED TO ENCOURAGE EVERYONE 4208 03:33:09,874 --> 03:33:12,810 TO GO TO THE WIKI TO OFFER 4209 03:33:12,810 --> 03:33:14,045 THOUGHTS AND TO GIVE EVERYONE AN 4210 03:33:14,045 --> 03:33:19,650 OPPORTUNITY TO SEE IF THERE'S 4211 03:33:19,650 --> 03:33:28,726 INITIAL REACTION AND SEE WHAT 4212 03:33:28,726 --> 03:33:33,731 THE CONSORTIUM AS A WHOLE AND A 4213 03:33:33,731 --> 03:33:34,298 TWO-MINUTE OPPORTUNITY FOR 4214 03:33:34,298 --> 03:33:35,066 ANYONE TO OFFER QUESTIONS OR 4215 03:33:35,066 --> 03:33:45,276 SUGGESTIONS. 4216 03:33:55,853 --> 03:33:57,855 >> IF THEY'RE INCLUSIVE DATA 4217 03:33:57,855 --> 03:33:59,123 ANALYSIS SO WE'RE MAKING IT UP 4218 03:33:59,123 --> 03:34:01,826 FRONT WE'RE ACKNOWLEDGING DATA 4219 03:34:01,826 --> 03:34:06,998 AND MAKING AN EFFORT TO BE 4220 03:34:06,998 --> 03:34:08,332 ADDRESSING THE ENTIRETY OF THE 4221 03:34:08,332 --> 03:34:09,667 U.S. POPULATION AND ALL THE DATA 4222 03:34:09,667 --> 03:34:10,034 COMING IN. 4223 03:34:10,034 --> 03:34:12,470 IF THERE'S A WAY TO WORD THAT IN 4224 03:34:12,470 --> 03:34:13,671 IN MEASURE LEARNING AND DATA 4225 03:34:13,671 --> 03:34:17,108 SCIENCE ASPECT. 4226 03:34:17,108 --> 03:34:18,642 >> I'M SORRY. 4227 03:34:18,642 --> 03:34:20,478 >> INCLUSIVE DATA ANALYSIS. 4228 03:34:20,478 --> 03:34:21,545 UNDERSTANDING IT'S GOING TO 4229 03:34:21,545 --> 03:34:23,848 BE -- IT'S AN EFFORT TO GET THAT 4230 03:34:23,848 --> 03:34:25,716 DATA AND ACKNOWLEDGE THE BIASES 4231 03:34:25,716 --> 03:34:27,918 AND THE DATA AVAILABILITY IF 4232 03:34:27,918 --> 03:34:28,586 THAT MAKES SENSE. 4233 03:34:28,586 --> 03:34:29,854 >> NOTED. 4234 03:34:29,854 --> 03:34:40,131 EXCELLENT POINT. 4235 03:34:40,531 --> 03:34:42,566 >> THERE'S MARK UP LANGUAGE 4236 03:34:42,566 --> 03:34:45,536 SINCE I SAW TALKS ON MARK UP 4237 03:34:45,536 --> 03:34:48,272 LANGUAGE AND IT'S CALLED THE 4238 03:34:48,272 --> 03:34:49,306 MARK UP STRATEGY LANGUAGE AND I 4239 03:34:49,306 --> 03:34:52,843 WAS ON THE COMMITTEE WITH AMBER 4240 03:34:52,843 --> 03:34:53,944 YEARS AGO AND IT WAS DEVELOPED 4241 03:34:53,944 --> 03:34:59,083 IN ORDER TO HELP THE UNFUNDED 4242 03:34:59,083 --> 03:35:00,017 MANDATE TO MAKE THE INTENTION 4243 03:35:00,017 --> 03:35:03,854 STAKEHOLDERS AND THE RESULTS OF 4244 03:35:03,854 --> 03:35:06,223 ANYBODY MACHINE READABLE SO 4245 03:35:06,223 --> 03:35:06,857 PEOPLE CAN DISCOVER JUST THOSE 4246 03:35:06,857 --> 03:35:12,363 THINGS ABOUT YOU. 4247 03:35:12,363 --> 03:35:17,868 IT'S AN ISO STANDARD AND 4248 03:35:17,868 --> 03:35:19,537 SUPPORTED BY AIM AN INFORMATION 4249 03:35:19,537 --> 03:35:20,638 GROUP AND STRATEGY MARK UP 4250 03:35:20,638 --> 03:35:22,606 LANGUAGE YOU CAN FIND QUICKLY ON 4251 03:35:22,606 --> 03:35:22,873 GOOGLE. 4252 03:35:22,873 --> 03:35:25,843 >> THANK YOU. 4253 03:35:25,843 --> 03:35:30,981 FOR THE INPUT. 4254 03:35:30,981 --> 03:35:32,116 >> IF THERE'S NO OTHER QUESTIONS 4255 03:35:32,116 --> 03:35:34,185 OR COMMENTS WE'LL MOVE ON TO THE 4256 03:35:34,185 --> 03:35:35,152 INTRODUCTION OF THE DIFFERENT 4257 03:35:35,152 --> 03:35:39,657 BREAKOUT SESSIONS. 4258 03:35:39,657 --> 03:35:44,061 WE HAVE FIVE DIFFERENT BREAKOUT 4259 03:35:44,061 --> 03:35:50,935 SESSION AND THE LEADS. 4260 03:35:50,935 --> 03:35:52,503 WE'LL PUT UP SLIDES FOR EACH OF 4261 03:35:52,503 --> 03:35:58,109 THE BREAKOUT SESSIONS. 4262 03:35:58,109 --> 03:36:08,652 LET'S START OUT WITH WE'LL GIVE 4263 03:36:13,991 --> 03:36:16,160 EACH OF OUR BREAKOUT SESSION 4264 03:36:16,160 --> 03:36:17,728 LEADERS A MINUTE. 4265 03:36:17,728 --> 03:36:19,563 STARTING WITH BREAK OUT SESSION 4266 03:36:19,563 --> 03:36:22,733 NUMBER 1, MEDICAL DIGITAL TWINS, 4267 03:36:22,733 --> 03:36:24,168 GARY AND LIZ. 4268 03:36:24,168 --> 03:36:27,004 >> I'LL START BY SAYING I HATE 4269 03:36:27,004 --> 03:36:28,572 THIS PARTICULAR PHRASE AND ONE 4270 03:36:28,572 --> 03:36:30,007 OF THE REASONS I HATE THIS 4271 03:36:30,007 --> 03:36:31,142 PARTICULAR PHRASE IS WHEN PEOPLE 4272 03:36:31,142 --> 03:36:33,210 TALK ABOUT MEDICAL DIGITAL TWINS 4273 03:36:33,210 --> 03:36:37,848 THEY SHOW A PICTURE OF AN 4274 03:36:37,848 --> 03:36:39,583 AIRPLANE ENGINE AND ITS DIGITAL 4275 03:36:39,583 --> 03:36:42,753 TO TWIN AND HAVE NOTHING TO DO 4276 03:36:42,753 --> 03:36:44,221 WITH WHAT THEY SUBSEQUENTLY CALL 4277 03:36:44,221 --> 03:36:50,461 A MEDICAL DIGITAL TWIN. 4278 03:36:50,461 --> 03:36:53,130 EVERY INDUSTRY TWIN THERE'S A 4279 03:36:53,130 --> 03:36:56,133 PLACE FOR MSM IN ACHIEVING THE 4280 03:36:56,133 --> 03:36:57,401 ASPIRATIONAL GOAL OF WHAT 4281 03:36:57,401 --> 03:36:59,570 DIGITAL TWINS SHOULD BE ABLE TO 4282 03:36:59,570 --> 03:36:59,803 DECIDE. 4283 03:36:59,803 --> 03:37:01,605 TO PREVIEW WHAT THE CONTENT OF 4284 03:37:01,605 --> 03:37:03,240 THIS BREAKOUT SESSION IS GOING 4285 03:37:03,240 --> 03:37:04,808 TO BE, WE'RE NOT GOING TO 4286 03:37:04,808 --> 03:37:05,876 RELITIGATE WHAT THE DEFINITION 4287 03:37:05,876 --> 03:37:09,847 OF A DIGITAL TWIN IS GOING TO 4288 03:37:09,847 --> 03:37:10,614 BE. 4289 03:37:10,614 --> 03:37:14,485 I PUT ALL THAT INFORMATION BASED 4290 03:37:14,485 --> 03:37:16,253 ON EXTENSIVE PRIOR MEMBERS THIS 4291 03:37:16,253 --> 03:37:18,055 PARTICULAR GROUP ON THE WIKI AND 4292 03:37:18,055 --> 03:37:19,757 BREAKOUT PAGE. 4293 03:37:19,757 --> 03:37:21,292 WE'RE DOING TO FOCUS HOW TO MOVE 4294 03:37:21,292 --> 03:37:25,563 FORWARD IN ACHIEVING THIS 4295 03:37:25,563 --> 03:37:29,867 ASPIRATIONAL GOAL OF TRYING TO 4296 03:37:29,867 --> 03:37:30,801 PARADOXICALLY IDENTIFY 4297 03:37:30,801 --> 03:37:32,136 INTERMEDIATE STEPS TO PROVIDE 4298 03:37:32,136 --> 03:37:34,138 BENEFITS WHILE WE'RE MOVING 4299 03:37:34,138 --> 03:37:37,875 TOWARDS THIS ASPIRATIONAL GOAL. 4300 03:37:37,875 --> 03:37:39,276 THANK YOU. 4301 03:37:39,276 --> 03:37:41,412 >> ALWAYS GREAT TO START OFF 4302 03:37:41,412 --> 03:37:50,487 WITH A STRONG STATEMENT. 4303 03:37:50,487 --> 03:37:55,559 >> AND SESSION TWO, NEW 4304 03:37:55,559 --> 03:37:57,895 MECHANISTIC ML METHODS WITH 4305 03:37:57,895 --> 03:38:00,497 GEORGE AND ILANA. 4306 03:38:00,497 --> 03:38:02,466 >> THERE'S TIME TO SOLUTION AND 4307 03:38:02,466 --> 03:38:05,502 INTERPRETATION AND DELIVERY OF 4308 03:38:05,502 --> 03:38:05,869 RESULTS. 4309 03:38:05,869 --> 03:38:08,105 WE DISCUSS HOW THE NEW METHODS 4310 03:38:08,105 --> 03:38:09,640 PHYSICS INFORM THE NETWORK. 4311 03:38:09,640 --> 03:38:14,411 AND NETWORKS TRANSFORM AND YOU 4312 03:38:14,411 --> 03:38:18,949 SAW THIS MORNING A VERY NICE 4313 03:38:18,949 --> 03:38:20,150 INTERPRETATION OF BOND GRAPHS 4314 03:38:20,150 --> 03:38:22,620 AND HOW THIS COULD HELP 4315 03:38:22,620 --> 03:38:26,090 MECHANISTIC MODELLING AND IN THE 4316 03:38:26,090 --> 03:38:29,493 FIRST HALF WE'LL DISCUSS VARIOUS 4317 03:38:29,493 --> 03:38:32,062 METHODS AND IN THE SECOND HALF, 4318 03:38:32,062 --> 03:38:33,430 THE LAST 45 MINUTES COME UP WITH 4319 03:38:33,430 --> 03:38:34,632 CONCRETE ACCOMMODATIONS. 4320 03:38:34,632 --> 03:38:34,865 >> OKAY. 4321 03:38:34,865 --> 03:38:41,372 THANK YOU. 4322 03:38:41,372 --> 03:38:43,407 THIS WILL BE IN NACHER ROOM D 4323 03:38:43,407 --> 03:38:46,410 AND ONE IN NATCHER ROOM A/B AND 4324 03:38:46,410 --> 03:38:48,445 THE THIRD BREAKOUT SESSION IS 4325 03:38:48,445 --> 03:38:49,546 SOCIAL BEHAVIORAL AND SOCIAL 4326 03:38:49,546 --> 03:38:54,518 DETERMINES OF HEALTH MODELS, 4327 03:38:54,518 --> 03:38:57,855 NETWORKS, PROBABILISTIC AND 4328 03:38:57,855 --> 03:39:00,791 STOCHASTIC MODELS. 4329 03:39:00,791 --> 03:39:04,395 WE HAVE JULIA BERZHANSKAYA AND 4330 03:39:04,395 --> 03:39:06,830 MYSELF. 4331 03:39:06,830 --> 03:39:09,867 >> WE'RE HOPING WE HAVE THE 4332 03:39:09,867 --> 03:39:12,970 BENEFIT OF THE PLENARY SESSION 4333 03:39:12,970 --> 03:39:13,937 AND WOULD LIKE TO SYNTHESIZE 4334 03:39:13,937 --> 03:39:15,606 WHAT WE LEARN FROM THE SESSION 4335 03:39:15,606 --> 03:39:19,343 AND BRING TO THE COMMUNITY AND 4336 03:39:19,343 --> 03:39:20,711 WHAT WE CAN DO AS MULTISCALE 4337 03:39:20,711 --> 03:39:23,147 MODELERS AND WHAT IS THE LOW 4338 03:39:23,147 --> 03:39:25,849 HANGING FRUIT TO TAKE ADVANTAGE 4339 03:39:25,849 --> 03:39:28,519 AND CONCRETE STEPS TO START 4340 03:39:28,519 --> 03:39:30,654 ADDRESSING HEALTH EQUITIES IN 4341 03:39:30,654 --> 03:39:35,492 OUR MULTISCALE MODELLING 4342 03:39:35,492 --> 03:39:37,861 COMMUNITY. 4343 03:39:37,861 --> 03:39:41,532 >> I'M SUVRANU AND I JOINED 4344 03:39:41,532 --> 03:39:43,834 BETWEEN FLORIDA A&M AND FLORIDA 4345 03:39:43,834 --> 03:39:45,169 STATE UNIVERSITY. 4346 03:39:45,169 --> 03:39:45,869 SO QUANTUM -- 4347 03:39:45,869 --> 03:39:49,707 >> NEXT SLIDE. 4348 03:39:49,707 --> 03:39:50,040 >> SORRY. 4349 03:39:50,040 --> 03:39:51,642 THIS IS THE DISCUSSION I'LL HAVE 4350 03:39:51,642 --> 03:39:53,677 BUT I WANTED TO MAKE IT CLEAR 4351 03:39:53,677 --> 03:39:56,980 THAT QUANTUM COMPUTING IS NOT 4352 03:39:56,980 --> 03:39:59,149 JUST AN EVOLUTION AND NOT TO GET 4353 03:39:59,149 --> 03:40:00,484 THINGS DONE FASTER THAN 4354 03:40:00,484 --> 03:40:01,685 CLASSICAL COMPUTERS. 4355 03:40:01,685 --> 03:40:03,020 IT'S A FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT 4356 03:40:03,020 --> 03:40:04,488 WAYS OF COMPUTING. 4357 03:40:04,488 --> 03:40:09,460 WHY DO I SAY SO? 4358 03:40:09,460 --> 03:40:12,863 IF I HAVE M BITS IN SPACE BUT IF 4359 03:40:12,863 --> 03:40:16,467 I HAVE A SINGLE CUBIC IT'S NOT 4360 03:40:16,467 --> 03:40:19,903 JUST ONE OR ZERO IT'S A SUPER 4361 03:40:19,903 --> 03:40:21,438 POSITION OF TWO STATES. 4362 03:40:21,438 --> 03:40:25,542 IF I HAVE A QUANTUM RATIO THAT 4363 03:40:25,542 --> 03:40:28,879 RESIDES IN A SPACE WHICH MEANS 4364 03:40:28,879 --> 03:40:33,050 IF I ADD ONE MORE IT DOUBLE THE 4365 03:40:33,050 --> 03:40:35,386 SIZE OF THE HYPER SPACE. 4366 03:40:35,386 --> 03:40:36,854 THAT'S OUTSTANDING? 4367 03:40:36,854 --> 03:40:37,855 WHY. 4368 03:40:37,855 --> 03:40:45,863 THE ENTIRE HUMAN GENOME HAS 3 4369 03:40:45,863 --> 03:40:47,030 BILLION BASE PAIRS. 4370 03:40:47,030 --> 03:40:52,603 THAT'S REALLY 34 CUBINS. 4371 03:40:52,603 --> 03:40:55,139 68 CUBETTS WILL HOLD THE 4372 03:40:55,139 --> 03:40:57,207 INFORMATION OF ALL HUMAN BEINGS 4373 03:40:57,207 --> 03:40:57,408 ALIVE. 4374 03:40:57,408 --> 03:41:03,147 I HOPE I GOT YOUR ATTENTION 4375 03:41:03,147 --> 03:41:09,787 WHICH MEANS WE CAN DO QUANTUM 4376 03:41:09,787 --> 03:41:10,454 MECHANICAL CALCULATIONS AT A 4377 03:41:10,454 --> 03:41:13,924 LEVEL WE COULD NEVER DO IN THE 4378 03:41:13,924 --> 03:41:24,034 PAST. 4379 03:41:27,638 --> 03:41:31,041 AND YOU'RE ALL IN THE CYCLE. 4380 03:41:31,041 --> 03:41:34,111 SO THE GOOD NEWS IS NOT ONLY ARE 4381 03:41:34,111 --> 03:41:36,547 THE START UPS COMING UP BUT THE 4382 03:41:36,547 --> 03:41:43,387 BIG BOYS, IBM, GOOGLE, MICROSOFT 4383 03:41:43,387 --> 03:41:52,863 ARE ALL JUMPING IN WITH A QUBIT. 4384 03:41:52,863 --> 03:41:59,603 EACH NEEDS HUNDRED LOGICAL QUBIT 4385 03:41:59,603 --> 03:42:02,105 IT MEANS A BILLION SYSTEM 4386 03:42:02,105 --> 03:42:03,373 WITH-2030. 4387 03:42:03,373 --> 03:42:05,642 THAT'S THE TIME FRAME COMING UP. 4388 03:42:05,642 --> 03:42:09,847 IN THE NEAR TERM IT'S A PRETTY 4389 03:42:09,847 --> 03:42:13,717 HI LEVEL BUT IN THE LONGER TERM 4390 03:42:13,717 --> 03:42:18,989 IT'S NOWHERE TO WHERE TO WHERE 4391 03:42:18,989 --> 03:42:20,724 REALITIES GOING TO BE. 4392 03:42:20,724 --> 03:42:27,097 >> THAT IN NATCHER 2 AND THE 4393 03:42:27,097 --> 03:42:28,932 LAST BUT NOT LEAST BREAKOUT 4394 03:42:28,932 --> 03:42:32,469 SESSION FIVE TRANSLATION AND 4395 03:42:32,469 --> 03:42:35,072 INCENTIVIZATION IN NATCHER ROOMS 4396 03:42:35,072 --> 03:42:38,242 F1 AND F2. 4397 03:42:38,242 --> 03:42:42,412 AND THAT'S FEILIM AND ELENA. 4398 03:42:42,412 --> 03:42:46,383 >> I'M ELENA A STAFF FELLOW IN 4399 03:42:46,383 --> 03:42:48,352 THE FOOD AND DRUG ADMINISTRATION 4400 03:42:48,352 --> 03:42:50,888 OF SCIENCE AND ENGINEERING LABS 4401 03:42:50,888 --> 03:42:54,625 AND WE'RE INTERESTED IN THINKING 4402 03:42:54,625 --> 03:42:57,661 AND HOW TO BRAIN STORM MSM TOOLS 4403 03:42:57,661 --> 03:43:00,797 IN PRACTICE AND HOW THEY CAN BE 4404 03:43:00,797 --> 03:43:02,299 TRANSLATED FOR OTHER 4405 03:43:02,299 --> 03:43:02,866 APPLICATIONS. 4406 03:43:02,866 --> 03:43:04,668 THE THINGS WE'LL DISCUSS IS WHAT 4407 03:43:04,668 --> 03:43:07,871 ARE THE CURRENT AND EXISTING MSM 4408 03:43:07,871 --> 03:43:10,741 TOOLS, WHO DEVELOPS THEM AND HOW 4409 03:43:10,741 --> 03:43:12,776 ARE THEY USED IN PRACTICE NOW? 4410 03:43:12,776 --> 03:43:19,283 WHAT ARE THE SPECIFIC DOMAINS AS 4411 03:43:19,283 --> 03:43:19,683 DIFFERENT SCALES. 4412 03:43:19,683 --> 03:43:23,687 WHAT ARE THE HURDLES AND THE 4413 03:43:23,687 --> 03:43:25,289 OPPORTUNITIES FOR DEVELOPING 4414 03:43:25,289 --> 03:43:26,456 THEM FURTHER. 4415 03:43:26,456 --> 03:43:29,726 WE'LL ALSO TALK ABOUT HOW TO 4416 03:43:29,726 --> 03:43:32,796 DEVELOP TRUSTWORTHY FOR CREDIBLE 4417 03:43:32,796 --> 03:43:37,467 TOOLS AND COMBINE TOOLS 4418 03:43:37,467 --> 03:43:37,868 TOGETHER. 4419 03:43:37,868 --> 03:43:38,869 VERY INTERESTED IN WHO IS IN 4420 03:43:38,869 --> 03:43:40,804 CHARGE OF THAT AND WHO CAN MAKE 4421 03:43:40,804 --> 03:43:43,140 STANDARDS AND WHAT ARE THE 4422 03:43:43,140 --> 03:43:44,474 STANDARDS WE CAN MAKE THERE? 4423 03:43:44,474 --> 03:43:46,009 AND FINALLY HOW CAN WE 4424 03:43:46,009 --> 03:43:49,846 DISSEMINATE THE TOOLS INTO 4425 03:43:49,846 --> 03:43:52,149 PRACTICE SO THAT THE COMMUNITIES 4426 03:43:52,149 --> 03:43:53,584 IN SMALL BUSINESS AND ACADEMIA 4427 03:43:53,584 --> 03:43:56,453 AND SMALL BUSINESS CAN USE THEM. 4428 03:43:56,453 --> 03:43:57,854 >> OKAY. 4429 03:43:57,854 --> 03:43:59,389 THANK YOU. 4430 03:43:59,389 --> 03:44:01,858 SO THESE NEXT BREAKOUT SESSIONS 4431 03:44:01,858 --> 03:44:04,928 WILL BE DIVIDED INTO TWO ROUNDS. 4432 03:44:04,928 --> 03:44:05,929 BASICALLY THE FIRST ROUND WILL 4433 03:44:05,929 --> 03:44:07,698 BE SOME GENERAL BRAIN STORMING 4434 03:44:07,698 --> 03:44:11,168 AND TRYING TO COME UP WITH 4435 03:44:11,168 --> 03:44:12,936 CONCRETE ACTION ITEMS, THINGS 4436 03:44:12,936 --> 03:44:15,105 YOU WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE MSM 4437 03:44:15,105 --> 03:44:17,941 CONSORTIUM DO OVER THE COMING 4438 03:44:17,941 --> 03:44:20,844 YEAR AND IN THE SECOND WILL BE 4439 03:44:20,844 --> 03:44:22,546 REFINING THESE AND SOLIDIFYING 4440 03:44:22,546 --> 03:44:23,180 THESE. 4441 03:44:23,180 --> 03:44:24,247 YOU DO HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO 4442 03:44:24,247 --> 03:44:26,750 SWITCH BREAKOUT SESSIONS IF YOU 4443 03:44:26,750 --> 03:44:29,119 WANT BETWEEN ROOMS 1 AND 2 4444 03:44:29,119 --> 03:44:32,456 BETWEEN ROUNDS 1 AND 2 AND WE'LL 4445 03:44:32,456 --> 03:44:35,125 ASK EACH BREAKOUT SESSION TO 4446 03:44:35,125 --> 03:44:38,128 COMPILE NOTES SO WE ALREADY HAVE 4447 03:44:38,128 --> 03:44:39,997 TEMPLATES TO BE PLACED ON THE 4448 03:44:39,997 --> 03:44:44,134 WIKI AND WE RECONVENE LATER THIS 4449 03:44:44,134 --> 03:44:44,768 AFTERNOON WE'LL HAVE REPORTS 4450 03:44:44,768 --> 03:44:46,570 FROM THE BREAKOUTS. 4451 03:44:46,570 --> 03:44:48,505 THE EMPHASIS IS WE CAN CONCRETE 4452 03:44:48,505 --> 03:44:49,740 IDEAS AND THINGS TO TAKE ACTION 4453 03:44:49,740 --> 03:44:50,641 ON OVER THE NEXT YEAR. 4454 03:44:50,641 --> 03:44:53,877 WITH THAT, GRACE, DO YOU HAVE 4455 03:44:53,877 --> 03:44:54,678 ANYTHING TO ADD? 4456 03:44:54,678 --> 03:44:55,946 >> THANK YOU ALL FOR DESCRIBING 4457 03:44:55,946 --> 03:44:59,449 YOUR BREAKOUT SESSIONS SO 4458 03:44:59,449 --> 03:44:59,750 WONDERFULLY. 4459 03:44:59,750 --> 03:45:00,851 WE ARE ABOUT 15 MINUTES BEHIND 4460 03:45:00,851 --> 03:45:03,620 SCHEDULE BUT THE PLAN IS TO GO 4461 03:45:03,620 --> 03:45:04,521 OUTSIDE, PICK UP YOUR LUNCH 4462 03:45:04,521 --> 03:45:06,957 BOXES AND GO TO THE RESPECTIVE 4463 03:45:06,957 --> 03:45:07,524 BREAKOUT ROOMS. 4464 03:45:07,524 --> 03:45:11,461 AS WE SAID, THERE'S TWO ROUNDS. 4465 03:45:11,461 --> 03:45:13,930 SO YOU'RE WELCOME TO GO TO TWO 4466 03:45:13,930 --> 03:45:17,434 BREAKOUTS OR ONE MORE BUT THE 4467 03:45:17,434 --> 03:45:19,069 IDEA IS ROUND TWO WILL BUILD ON 4468 03:45:19,069 --> 03:45:20,237 DISCUSSIONS OF ROUND ONE AND 4469 03:45:20,237 --> 03:45:25,175 WE'LL IS THE LEADS TO RECAP WHAT 4470 03:45:25,175 --> 03:45:27,277 WAS SYNTHESIZED IN ROUND ONE TO 4471 03:45:27,277 --> 03:45:29,212 HAVE FURTHER BUILD UP IN ROUND 4472 03:45:29,212 --> 03:45:32,849 TWO AND GO TO TO THE ATRIUM FOR 4473 03:45:32,849 --> 03:45:35,852 A SNACK BREAK COURTESY OF THE 4474 03:45:35,852 --> 03:45:37,087 SOCIETY FOR MATHEMATICAL BIOLOGY 4475 03:45:37,087 --> 03:45:39,089 AND WE'LL STAY THERE AND GO TO 4476 03:45:39,089 --> 03:45:41,191 THE POSTER SESSION AND THE IMAG 4477 03:45:41,191 --> 03:45:43,360 FOLKS WILL BE AT THE IMAG TABLE 4478 03:45:43,360 --> 03:45:45,729 TO ANSWER ANY GRANT QUESTIONS 4479 03:45:45,729 --> 03:45:47,864 YOU MIGHT HAVE AND THEN WE'LL 4480 03:45:47,864 --> 03:45:50,801 ALL RECONVENE HERE AT 3:15 TO 4481 03:45:50,801 --> 03:45:54,204 HERE THE SUMMARY OF THE BREAKOUT 4482 03:45:54,204 --> 03:45:56,373 SESSIONS AND THEN CLOSE WITH 4483 03:45:56,373 --> 03:45:57,541 FUTURE DIRECTIONS. 4484 03:45:57,541 --> 03:46:03,213 NOW, YOU SAW THE BREAKOUT SLIDES 4485 03:46:03,213 --> 03:46:04,214 ACTUALLY IN THE BREAKOUT SESSION 4486 03:46:04,214 --> 03:46:05,749 SO PLEASE GO TO THE BREAKOUT 4487 03:46:05,749 --> 03:46:07,851 SESSION PAGES TO SEE THE 4488 03:46:07,851 --> 03:46:08,185 DESCRIPTOR. 4489 03:46:08,185 --> 03:46:10,253 EACH BREAKOUT SESSION HAS ITS 4490 03:46:10,253 --> 03:46:11,588 OWN PAGE AND QUESTIONS AND 4491 03:46:11,588 --> 03:46:13,957 RESOURCES AND PLACES FOR YOU TO 4492 03:46:13,957 --> 03:46:15,659 POST COMMENTS THERE. 4493 03:46:15,659 --> 03:46:18,328 AS WELL IF YOU GO TO THE 4494 03:46:18,328 --> 03:46:19,162 BREAKOUT SESSION PAGE YOU'LL 4495 03:46:19,162 --> 03:46:21,364 FIND THE SLIDE DECK WE JUST 4496 03:46:21,364 --> 03:46:22,165 PRESENTED FROM. 4497 03:46:22,165 --> 03:46:24,468 THE NOTE TAKERS IN THE ROOM 4498 03:46:24,468 --> 03:46:25,635 DEPENDING ON HOW MANY PEOPLE 4499 03:46:25,635 --> 03:46:27,104 WILL BE IN THE ROOM COULD BE 4500 03:46:27,104 --> 03:46:29,139 SPLIT UP AND IF YOU REALLY 4501 03:46:29,139 --> 03:46:30,741 DIDN'T HAVE TIME TO ATTEND THE 4502 03:46:30,741 --> 03:46:32,476 BREAKOUT AND REALLY WANTED TO 4503 03:46:32,476 --> 03:46:33,877 ADD SOME THOUGHTS, FEEL FREE TO 4504 03:46:33,877 --> 03:46:35,512 GO AHEAD AND ADD A SLIDE IN 4505 03:46:35,512 --> 03:46:37,781 THERE AND PUT YOUR THOUGHTS IN 4506 03:46:37,781 --> 03:46:39,449 THERE TO MAKE SURE THE SCRIBES 4507 03:46:39,449 --> 03:46:41,118 CATCH YOUR THOUGHTS ABOUT IT OR 4508 03:46:41,118 --> 03:46:43,854 PUT IT IN THE COMMENTS IN THE 4509 03:46:43,854 --> 03:46:45,455 WIKI BUT THESE ARE THE SLIDES 4510 03:46:45,455 --> 03:46:50,393 THAT DESCRIBE AND THE MODERATORS 4511 03:46:50,393 --> 03:46:51,561 WILL BE USING TO COMPILE TO MAKE 4512 03:46:51,561 --> 03:46:58,034 THE SUMMARY SLIDES BY END OF THE 4513 03:46:58,034 --> 03:47:01,872 DAY AND TOMORROW WILL BE 4514 03:47:01,872 --> 03:47:08,078 AVAILABLE FOR YOU TO USE. 4515 03:47:08,078 --> 03:47:09,312 WE'LL ALL CONVENE BACK HERE AT 4516 03:47:09,312 --> 03:47:13,984 3:15. 4517 03:47:13,984 --> 03:47:19,189 WE'LL ALL CONVENE BACK HERE AT 4518 03:47:19,189 --> 03:47:19,389 3:15. 4519 03:47:19,389 --> 03:47:20,957 LIZ WAS SUGGESTING THE SNACK AND 4520 03:47:20,957 --> 03:47:22,292 POSTERS WILL HAPPEN AT THE 4521 03:47:22,292 --> 03:47:24,327 STATEMENT TIME ANY WAY. 4522 03:47:24,327 --> 03:47:25,295 ENJOY YOUR NEXT FEW HOURS AND 4523 03:47:25,295 --> 03:47:26,700 SEE YOU IN THREE HOURS. 4524 03:47:28,882 --> 03:47:30,017 BASICALLY THIS SESSION WE'LL GO 4525 03:47:30,017 --> 03:47:35,122 THROUGH EACH OF THE BREAKOUT 4526 03:47:35,122 --> 03:47:37,824 LEADERS. 4527 03:47:37,824 --> 03:47:40,894 THEY'RE GOING TO GO OVER THEIR 4528 03:47:40,894 --> 03:47:42,062 ACTION ITEMS AND REPORT OUT 4529 03:47:42,062 --> 03:47:46,833 SLIDES AND NEXT STEPS FOR THE 4530 03:47:46,833 --> 03:47:47,167 CONSORTIUM. 4531 03:47:47,167 --> 03:47:52,306 WE'LL START WITH DIGITAL TWINS 4532 03:47:52,306 --> 03:47:55,409 WHICH IS GARY AND -- WE'RE LIVE. 4533 03:47:55,409 --> 03:47:58,745 >> WE HAD A SPIRITED DISCUSSION 4534 03:47:58,745 --> 03:47:59,913 ABOUT DIGITAL TWINS. 4535 03:47:59,913 --> 03:48:02,516 ONE OF THE THING THAT CAME OUT 4536 03:48:02,516 --> 03:48:04,251 WHENEVER WE HAVE THE 4537 03:48:04,251 --> 03:48:06,853 CONVERSATION IN THE CONTEXT OF 4538 03:48:06,853 --> 03:48:10,157 MSM WE WANT TO DESCRIBE DIGITAL 4539 03:48:10,157 --> 03:48:16,730 TWINS THAT REQUIRE MSMs AND 4540 03:48:16,730 --> 03:48:17,864 MULTISCALE MECHANISM DIGITAL 4541 03:48:17,864 --> 03:48:19,833 MODEL TWINS AS YOU IF YOU WANT 4542 03:48:19,833 --> 03:48:21,702 TO TEST NOVEL DRUGS, NEW 4543 03:48:21,702 --> 03:48:23,437 INTERVENTIONS IN A BIOLOGICAL 4544 03:48:23,437 --> 03:48:25,205 CONTEXT IN WHICH THEY OTHERWISE 4545 03:48:25,205 --> 03:48:27,708 HAVEN'T BEEN TRIED YOU NEED THE 4546 03:48:27,708 --> 03:48:30,811 CAPABILITY FROM THE MECHANISTIC 4547 03:48:30,811 --> 03:48:31,044 MODEL. 4548 03:48:31,044 --> 03:48:33,947 THAT'S WHAT SEPARATES MSM OR 4549 03:48:33,947 --> 03:48:36,883 ORIENTED DTs FROM THE OTHER SET 4550 03:48:36,883 --> 03:48:37,985 OF THINGS PEOPLE ARE CALLING 4551 03:48:37,985 --> 03:48:39,586 DIGITAL TWINS. 4552 03:48:39,586 --> 03:48:45,192 THE OTHER THING THAT WAS A 4553 03:48:45,192 --> 03:48:47,260 RECOGNITION THAT WAS IMPORTANT 4554 03:48:47,260 --> 03:48:48,295 THAT SEPARATED THE COMPONENT 4555 03:48:48,295 --> 03:48:51,898 FROM A DIGITAL TWIN FROM A 4556 03:48:51,898 --> 03:48:52,933 REGULAR MODEL IS EXPLICIT 4557 03:48:52,933 --> 03:48:56,269 ATTENTION TO HOW YOU UPDATE THE 4558 03:48:56,269 --> 03:48:59,740 MODEL FROM AN NDT FROM DATA FROM 4559 03:48:59,740 --> 03:49:00,007 PATIENTS. 4560 03:49:00,007 --> 03:49:06,913 SO DATA ACCESSIBILITY IN A 4561 03:49:06,913 --> 03:49:09,082 LONGITUDINAL FASHION IS A 4562 03:49:09,082 --> 03:49:10,717 NECESSARY COMPONENT IN TERMS OF 4563 03:49:10,717 --> 03:49:13,587 DEFINING WHAT A DIGITAL TWIN 4564 03:49:13,587 --> 03:49:14,554 WOULD BE. 4565 03:49:14,554 --> 03:49:16,590 SO FROM THOSE PARTICULAR KIND OF 4566 03:49:16,590 --> 03:49:17,858 VERY HIGH LEVEL SUMMARIES, WE 4567 03:49:17,858 --> 03:49:19,860 CAME UP WITH A COUPLE OF THE 4568 03:49:19,860 --> 03:49:22,229 NEXT STEPS. 4569 03:49:22,229 --> 03:49:25,098 THE FIRST ONE WAS WHAT I REALLY 4570 03:49:25,098 --> 03:49:27,467 DIDN'T WANT TO HAVE TO BUT ENDED 4571 03:49:27,467 --> 03:49:28,869 UP ARRIVING AT WAS MAYBE A 4572 03:49:28,869 --> 03:49:32,039 COUPLE PAPERS. 4573 03:49:32,039 --> 03:49:37,477 ONE, ESSENTIALLY ACROSS DOMAIN 4574 03:49:37,477 --> 03:49:41,148 SERVE OF LARGE AMBITIOUS DIGITAL 4575 03:49:41,148 --> 03:49:44,918 TWIN PROJECTS NOT FROM INDUSTRY. 4576 03:49:44,918 --> 03:49:46,186 REINHARDT SUGGESTED A VIRTUAL 4577 03:49:46,186 --> 03:49:51,525 CITY OR EARTH AND THESE TYPES OF 4578 03:49:51,525 --> 03:49:52,159 AMBITIOUS PROJECTS MEET THE 4579 03:49:52,159 --> 03:49:53,860 SCOPE OF WHAT WE'RE LOOKING FOR 4580 03:49:53,860 --> 03:49:57,631 IN TERMS OF OUR ASPIRATIONAL 4581 03:49:57,631 --> 03:49:57,964 DIGITAL TWIN. 4582 03:49:57,964 --> 03:50:01,501 AGAIN, ANOTHER PAPER WOULD BE TO 4583 03:50:01,501 --> 03:50:06,740 STRONGLY CIRCUMSCRIBE A DEFINED 4584 03:50:06,740 --> 03:50:07,374 MULTISCALE MODELING DIGITAL 4585 03:50:07,374 --> 03:50:08,775 TWINS HOW THEY'RE SEPARATE FROM 4586 03:50:08,775 --> 03:50:10,277 OTHER TYPES OF DIGITAL TWINS 4587 03:50:10,277 --> 03:50:11,878 MORE IN KEEPING WITH THE 4588 03:50:11,878 --> 03:50:12,879 INDUSTRIAL PARADIGM AN WHAT IS 4589 03:50:12,879 --> 03:50:16,283 NEEDED TO GET TO THAT PARTICULAR 4590 03:50:16,283 --> 03:50:17,250 POINT. 4591 03:50:17,250 --> 03:50:20,287 WE ALSO RECOGNIZE THAT THE RANGE 4592 03:50:20,287 --> 03:50:23,824 OF METHODS AND EXPERTISE 4593 03:50:23,824 --> 03:50:28,662 REQUIRED TO DEVELOP MSM, MDT 4594 03:50:28,662 --> 03:50:29,996 WOULD CROSS MULTIPLE EXPERTISE 4595 03:50:29,996 --> 03:50:31,665 AND MULTIPLE DISCIPLINES AND 4596 03:50:31,665 --> 03:50:35,268 THAT DOING SUCH A PROJECT WOULD 4597 03:50:35,268 --> 03:50:40,307 REQUIRE A LARGE CONSORTIA 4598 03:50:40,307 --> 03:50:40,841 APPROACH. 4599 03:50:40,841 --> 03:50:42,609 ALSO KEEPING WITH THE IDEA OF 4600 03:50:42,609 --> 03:50:45,345 THE TWIN AS A TWIN OF AN ENTIRE 4601 03:50:45,345 --> 03:50:47,581 PERSON, IF WE WANT TO STUDY 4602 03:50:47,581 --> 03:50:49,549 INDIVIDUAL DISEASES, WE NEED TO 4603 03:50:49,549 --> 03:50:51,518 AT LEAST PLACE THOSE DISEASES 4604 03:50:51,518 --> 03:50:54,755 WITHIN THE CONTEXT OF THE ENTIRE 4605 03:50:54,755 --> 03:50:56,356 PERSON EVEN IF YOU DON'T HAVE 4606 03:50:56,356 --> 03:50:57,991 THE SAME GRANULARITY OF 4607 03:50:57,991 --> 03:51:02,229 REPRESENTATION THAT ALLOWS US 4608 03:51:02,229 --> 03:51:04,364 BOTH TO FOCUS MODELLING ON AREAS 4609 03:51:04,364 --> 03:51:07,367 OF INTEREST BUT ALSO PROVIDE AN 4610 03:51:07,367 --> 03:51:09,069 OPPORTUNITY FOR INTERFACING WITH 4611 03:51:09,069 --> 03:51:12,339 OVER THE SKIN ENDEAVORS SUCH AS 4612 03:51:12,339 --> 03:51:13,039 THE ENVIRONMENTAL AND SOCIAL 4613 03:51:13,039 --> 03:51:18,612 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH. 4614 03:51:18,612 --> 03:51:21,882 IT ALSO BECAME CLEAR THAT AT OUR 4615 03:51:21,882 --> 03:51:25,685 CURRENT LEVEL OF DEVELOPMENT, 4616 03:51:25,685 --> 03:51:29,489 MDTs WOULD REQUIRE SOME SORT OF 4617 03:51:29,489 --> 03:51:31,625 FORMALIZED DESCRIPTION OF THEIR 4618 03:51:31,625 --> 03:51:33,960 FIT FOR PURPOSE JUST FAKES FOR 4619 03:51:33,960 --> 03:51:39,933 WHAT DATA YOU'LL USE AND 4620 03:51:39,933 --> 03:51:43,470 SOMETHING TO A VARIANT OF THE 10 4621 03:51:43,470 --> 03:51:44,070 CREDIBLE RULES IS SOMETHING 4622 03:51:44,070 --> 03:51:54,614 WE'LL POTENTIALLY WORK ON AND AN 4623 03:51:56,583 --> 03:51:57,517 INTERMEDIATE POINT TO 4624 03:51:57,517 --> 03:52:00,854 DEMONSTRATE WHETHER THEY CAN 4625 03:52:00,854 --> 03:52:08,261 AUGMENT THE PERFORMANCE OF A.I. 4626 03:52:08,261 --> 03:52:10,664 AND M.L. ALGORITHMS AND OTHER 4627 03:52:10,664 --> 03:52:12,265 MATURE A.I. APPLICATIONS AND I 4628 03:52:12,265 --> 03:52:13,767 THINK IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO 4629 03:52:13,767 --> 03:52:15,268 PROVIDE SOME TRUSTWORTHINESS IN 4630 03:52:15,268 --> 03:52:20,507 THE UNDERLYING MODELS IF THEY'RE 4631 03:52:20,507 --> 03:52:30,750 SUCCESSFUL IN INCREASING THE 4632 03:52:30,750 --> 03:52:33,019 GENERALIZABILITY AND ADDRESS THE 4633 03:52:33,019 --> 03:52:35,388 INEQUITIES IN DATA THAT MAY BE 4634 03:52:35,388 --> 03:52:37,557 PRESENT FOR OTHER M.L./A.I. 4635 03:52:37,557 --> 03:52:37,891 APPLICATIONS. 4636 03:52:37,891 --> 03:52:42,295 THAT'S IT. 4637 03:52:42,295 --> 03:52:44,264 >> THANKS, GARY. 4638 03:52:44,264 --> 03:52:47,234 LIZ, ANYTHING TO ADD? 4639 03:52:47,234 --> 03:52:50,437 >> I THINK AS ALWAYS HAPPENS IN 4640 03:52:50,437 --> 03:52:52,105 THESE SESSIONS PEOPLE MENTION 4641 03:52:52,105 --> 03:52:54,507 THE FUNDING THING, WHICH WE 4642 03:52:54,507 --> 03:52:55,775 CAN'T DEAL WITH IN THE BREAKOUTS 4643 03:52:55,775 --> 03:53:00,780 BUT I THINK IT WAS GOOD WE HAD A 4644 03:53:00,780 --> 03:53:01,882 LOT OF DIVERSITY OF DIFFERENT 4645 03:53:01,882 --> 03:53:05,252 IMAG STAFF IN THERE SO WE 4646 03:53:05,252 --> 03:53:06,486 DEFINITELY UNDERSTAND THE 4647 03:53:06,486 --> 03:53:07,687 COMPLEXITY OF THESE KINDS OF 4648 03:53:07,687 --> 03:53:10,257 DIGITAL TWIN APPLICATIONS. 4649 03:53:10,257 --> 03:53:12,292 SO IF EVERYONE WANTS TO HEAR THE 4650 03:53:12,292 --> 03:53:13,927 FUNDING MECHANISMS JUST KNOW 4651 03:53:13,927 --> 03:53:16,263 WE'RE LISTENING IN THE 4652 03:53:16,263 --> 03:53:16,663 BREAKOUTS. 4653 03:53:16,663 --> 03:53:17,497 THAT'S ALL WE CAN REALLY ADD TO 4654 03:53:17,497 --> 03:53:20,267 THAT DISCUSSION. 4655 03:53:20,267 --> 03:53:22,002 >> OKAY. 4656 03:53:22,002 --> 03:53:24,271 THANKS, GARY, THANKS, LIZ. 4657 03:53:24,271 --> 03:53:26,439 ANY COMMENTS OR QUESTIONS FROM 4658 03:53:26,439 --> 03:53:28,275 ANYONE ABOUT WHAT GARY AND LIZ 4659 03:53:28,275 --> 03:53:34,214 JUST MENTIONED? 4660 03:53:34,214 --> 03:53:34,414 OKAY. 4661 03:53:34,414 --> 03:53:36,516 DON'T SEE ANY COMMENTS OR 4662 03:53:36,516 --> 03:53:36,917 QUESTIONS. 4663 03:53:36,917 --> 03:53:40,887 OKAY, MOVING RIGHT ALONG TO 4664 03:53:40,887 --> 03:53:44,291 BREAKOUT SESSION 2, NEW 4665 03:53:44,291 --> 03:53:45,525 MECHANISTIC AND M.L. METHODS AND 4666 03:53:45,525 --> 03:53:48,161 SEE IF I CAN FIND THE ACTUAL -- 4667 03:53:48,161 --> 03:53:56,269 SUMMARY BREAKOUT SESSION 2. 4668 03:53:56,269 --> 03:53:58,838 >> I'M GEORGE KARNIADAKIS. 4669 03:53:58,838 --> 03:54:00,273 WE HAD THE LIVELY DISCUSSION. 4670 03:54:00,273 --> 03:54:03,343 I DIDN'T EXPECT IT ACTUALLY BUT 4671 03:54:03,343 --> 03:54:05,111 LOTS OF PEOPLE WITH DIFFERENT 4672 03:54:05,111 --> 03:54:08,281 OPINIONS WHICH TURNED OUT TO BE 4673 03:54:08,281 --> 03:54:08,715 REALLY GOOD. 4674 03:54:08,715 --> 03:54:14,421 SO WHAT WE'VE DONE HERE, WELL, I 4675 03:54:14,421 --> 03:54:17,757 HAVE DIVIDED THE DISCUSSION TO 4676 03:54:17,757 --> 03:54:19,326 TWO DIFFERENT TOPICS. 4677 03:54:19,326 --> 03:54:25,265 THE FIRST ONE IS EXPLAINABLE 4678 03:54:25,265 --> 03:54:27,667 A.I. 4679 03:54:27,667 --> 03:54:30,470 AND IT WAS ALSO A POINT OF 4680 03:54:30,470 --> 03:54:33,506 AGREEMENT BECAUSE IT'S ALL CLEAR 4681 03:54:33,506 --> 03:54:37,310 WHAT THE EXPLAINING OF A.I. IS 4682 03:54:37,310 --> 03:54:39,913 IN THIS COMMUNITY. 4683 03:54:39,913 --> 03:54:43,283 IT'S EVEN DIFFICULT TO DEFINE 4684 03:54:43,283 --> 03:54:45,018 A.I. IN THE PURE SCIENCE 4685 03:54:45,018 --> 03:54:46,920 COMMUNITY BUT AT THE END I THINK 4686 03:54:46,920 --> 03:54:49,823 WE REACHED SOME SORT OF 4687 03:54:49,823 --> 03:54:52,058 CONSENSUS WE THE BIO MECHANISTIC 4688 03:54:52,058 --> 03:54:55,462 MODELS BUT WE NEED CORRELATIONS 4689 03:54:55,462 --> 03:54:56,696 AND NEED CAUSALITY. 4690 03:54:56,696 --> 03:55:00,300 THE FIRST BULLET TALKS ABOUT 4691 03:55:00,300 --> 03:55:01,868 CAUSALALITY AND INFERENCE AND 4692 03:55:01,868 --> 03:55:04,704 MECHANISTIC MODELS CAN LEAD TO 4693 03:55:04,704 --> 03:55:05,338 EXPLAINABLE A.I. FOR DIFFERENT 4694 03:55:05,338 --> 03:55:09,776 APPLICATIONS. 4695 03:55:09,776 --> 03:55:11,511 OUR CAUSALITY IS A HOT TOPIC IN 4696 03:55:11,511 --> 03:55:16,883 COMPUTER SCIENCE AND THAT IS 4697 03:55:16,883 --> 03:55:23,256 IMPLEMENTED IN REAL LIFE USINGC 4698 03:55:23,256 --> 03:55:24,457 LIFE USING SO THIS CAUSALITY A 4699 03:55:24,457 --> 03:55:32,265 HOT TOPIC THAT COULD BE LEVERAGE 4700 03:55:32,265 --> 03:55:38,038 S AND CAUSALITY CAUSALITY 4701 03:55:38,038 --> 03:55:40,840 DIFFERENT THAN CORRELATION. 4702 03:55:40,840 --> 03:55:42,609 THERE WAS DISCUSSION IN DON'T 4703 03:55:42,609 --> 03:55:47,280 STICK TO THE TERM NIFTIC WAY OF 4704 03:55:47,280 --> 03:55:49,049 MODELLING AND WE KNOW 4705 03:55:49,049 --> 03:55:51,051 PROBABILISTIC MODELLING LAWS YOU 4706 03:55:51,051 --> 03:55:52,352 TO LOOK AT OTHER STATES THAT ARE 4707 03:55:52,352 --> 03:55:55,789 CLOSE TO THE STATE YOU'RE 4708 03:55:55,789 --> 03:56:00,260 CONSIDERING. 4709 03:56:00,260 --> 03:56:07,033 FOR PROBABILISTIC CONDITIONS AND 4710 03:56:07,033 --> 03:56:10,170 LOOK AT INPUTS AND OUTPUTS. 4711 03:56:10,170 --> 03:56:12,405 THERE'S ALWAYS THE QUESTION OF 4712 03:56:12,405 --> 03:56:12,739 EXTRAPOLATION. 4713 03:56:12,739 --> 03:56:16,109 YOU DEAL WITH NEURAL NETWORKS 4714 03:56:16,109 --> 03:56:17,911 AND MACHINE LEARNING AND DOING 4715 03:56:17,911 --> 03:56:20,647 WELL INSIDE THE DISTRIBUTION BUT 4716 03:56:20,647 --> 03:56:22,849 OUTSIDE THE DISTRIBUTION WOULD 4717 03:56:22,849 --> 03:56:28,288 REQUIRE MORE DATA KNOWLEDGE AND 4718 03:56:28,288 --> 03:56:28,521 PHYSICS. 4719 03:56:28,521 --> 03:56:33,927 TO THAT EFFECT PROCESSES COULD 4720 03:56:33,927 --> 03:56:35,261 BE INFORMED FROM HISTORICAL DATA 4721 03:56:35,261 --> 03:56:38,832 AND OTHER SIMILAR CASES BUT MORE 4722 03:56:38,832 --> 03:56:40,266 INFORMATIVE PRIORS LEADING TO 4723 03:56:40,266 --> 03:56:44,003 MORE ACCURATE RESULTS. 4724 03:56:44,003 --> 03:56:48,208 BRINGING THE PHYSICS INTO 4725 03:56:48,208 --> 03:56:48,942 MACHINE LEARNING USING FOR 4726 03:56:48,942 --> 03:56:51,010 EXAMPLE PHYSICS AND FORMULA 4727 03:56:51,010 --> 03:56:53,513 NETWORKS OR OTHER PROCESSES. 4728 03:56:53,513 --> 03:56:55,281 IT'S VERY IMPORTANT BECAUSE WHEN 4729 03:56:55,281 --> 03:56:59,619 YOU HAVE ABRUPT CHANGES IN THE 4730 03:56:59,619 --> 03:57:09,762 PHYSICS AND BY -- BIFURCATIONS 4731 03:57:09,762 --> 03:57:10,263 CAUSALITY DIFFERENT FOR 4732 03:57:10,263 --> 03:57:11,965 INTERPRETING INSIDE THE 4733 03:57:11,965 --> 03:57:14,100 DISTRIBUTION AND THE CATEGORY 4734 03:57:14,100 --> 03:57:17,737 THIS CAUSALITY NOT IN 4735 03:57:17,737 --> 03:57:20,106 CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER BUT I LUMPED 4736 03:57:20,106 --> 03:57:24,277 THEM INTO THE X A.I. CAN WE 4737 03:57:24,277 --> 03:57:27,046 INTEGRATE MECHANISTIC MODELS. 4738 03:57:27,046 --> 03:57:28,615 IT SEEMS THEY'RE SEPARATE OR 4739 03:57:28,615 --> 03:57:32,285 WORK IN PARALLEL BUT INTEGRATION 4740 03:57:32,285 --> 03:57:36,356 WOULD BRING HUGE BENEFITS. 4741 03:57:36,356 --> 03:57:39,859 HOW TO DO THAT CAUSALITY NOT 4742 03:57:39,859 --> 03:57:41,961 EXACTLY CLEAR AND THAT WOULD BE 4743 03:57:41,961 --> 03:57:43,329 PROBABLY A RESEARCH TOPIC NIH 4744 03:57:43,329 --> 03:57:51,070 COULD LOOK INTO. 4745 03:57:51,070 --> 03:57:53,239 THIS MORNING -- THE NEXT ONE 4746 03:57:53,239 --> 03:57:58,545 CAUSALITY IMPERFECT DATA AND WE 4747 03:57:58,545 --> 03:57:59,879 START THE DISCUSSION THIS 4748 03:57:59,879 --> 03:58:00,580 MORNING WE TALKED ABOUT 4749 03:58:00,580 --> 03:58:02,348 IMPERFECT DATA. 4750 03:58:02,348 --> 03:58:05,218 I TALKED ABOUT DATA IMBALANCE. 4751 03:58:05,218 --> 03:58:07,854 THE DATA CAUSALITY NEVER 4752 03:58:07,854 --> 03:58:08,087 PERFECT. 4753 03:58:08,087 --> 03:58:13,126 SO IN FACT FOR THE SAME 4754 03:58:13,126 --> 03:58:13,793 EXPERIMENT, DIFFERENT LIVES HAVE 4755 03:58:13,793 --> 03:58:15,862 DIFFERENT RESULTS. 4756 03:58:15,862 --> 03:58:18,865 WE KNOW THAT'S NOT A NEW THING 4757 03:58:18,865 --> 03:58:22,802 BUT NOW BECAUSE IT'S TIMELY TO 4758 03:58:22,802 --> 03:58:24,571 SET THE STANDARDS AND REPORT 4759 03:58:24,571 --> 03:58:26,072 CONDITIONS AND TRANSPARENCY AND 4760 03:58:26,072 --> 03:58:27,207 COMPLETE REPORTING. 4761 03:58:27,207 --> 03:58:29,609 THAT'S ONE WAY TO START ON THIS. 4762 03:58:29,609 --> 03:58:32,545 THERE WAS A DISCUSSION ON 4763 03:58:32,545 --> 03:58:33,913 STANDARDIZING PROTOCOLS AND DATA 4764 03:58:33,913 --> 03:58:37,850 AND NORMALIZING FROM DIFFERENT 4765 03:58:37,850 --> 03:58:39,018 SOURCES BECAUSE WE'LL ALWAYS 4766 03:58:39,018 --> 03:58:41,254 HAVE DIFFERENT MODALITIES AND 4767 03:58:41,254 --> 03:58:42,855 DIFFERENT RESOLUTIONS FROM 4768 03:58:42,855 --> 03:58:45,225 DIFFERENT SOURCES AND DIFFERENT 4769 03:58:45,225 --> 03:58:47,260 INVESTIGATORS AND DIFFERENT 4770 03:58:47,260 --> 03:58:47,760 PRACTICES. 4771 03:58:47,760 --> 03:58:49,596 AS YOU KNOW EVERYBODY HAS A LOG 4772 03:58:49,596 --> 03:58:53,466 BOOK AND HAVE DIFFERENT 4773 03:58:53,466 --> 03:58:56,736 PRACTICES IN EVERY LAB AND I 4774 03:58:56,736 --> 03:58:59,239 KEEP THE LOG BOOK SAFE. 4775 03:58:59,239 --> 03:59:01,608 BUT HOW DO YOU FUSE ALL THE DATA 4776 03:59:01,608 --> 03:59:04,010 IF YOU WERE TO TRAIN YOUR 4777 03:59:04,010 --> 03:59:04,911 NETWORKS? 4778 03:59:04,911 --> 03:59:05,545 YOU HAVE TO BE VERY CAREFUL WITH 4779 03:59:05,545 --> 03:59:07,146 THAT. 4780 03:59:07,146 --> 03:59:11,150 MORE BROADLY, THAT WAS A 4781 03:59:11,150 --> 03:59:13,353 QUESTION THAT WAS OPPOSED NOT IN 4782 03:59:13,353 --> 03:59:16,756 THE ORIGINAL BULLETS OF 4783 03:59:16,756 --> 03:59:23,263 QUESTIONS BUT HOW THE TRAINING, 4784 03:59:23,263 --> 03:59:29,936 THE MULTIMODAL TRAINING COULD 4785 03:59:29,936 --> 03:59:32,272 CREATE BIAS DUE TO FACTORS AND 4786 03:59:32,272 --> 03:59:34,374 IN A POOR AREA COULD BE 4787 03:59:34,374 --> 03:59:39,545 DIFFERENT THAN IMAGES YOU 4788 03:59:39,545 --> 03:59:42,749 ACQUIRE IN A RICHER AREA, LET'S 4789 03:59:42,749 --> 03:59:46,319 SAY IN DEMOGRAPHICS AND WE HEARD 4790 03:59:46,319 --> 03:59:48,721 EARLIER EXCELLENT TALKS ABOUT 4791 03:59:48,721 --> 03:59:51,491 THE TOPIC ABOUT RED LINING AND 4792 03:59:51,491 --> 03:59:53,760 THIS COULD CREATE GAPS IN 4793 03:59:53,760 --> 03:59:54,127 METADATA. 4794 03:59:54,127 --> 03:59:57,163 THIS ITSELF PRESENTS AN 4795 03:59:57,163 --> 04:00:02,335 OPPORTUNITY FOR CREATIVE 4796 04:00:02,335 --> 04:00:03,970 MATHEMATICS FOR EXAMPLE FROM AIR 4797 04:00:03,970 --> 04:00:06,205 FORCE AND SUGGESTED WE CAN LOOK 4798 04:00:06,205 --> 04:00:08,274 AT METADATA AND CATEGORY COULD 4799 04:00:08,274 --> 04:00:10,610 BE USED BUT OTHER METHODS 4800 04:00:10,610 --> 04:00:14,514 CAUSALITY SOMETHING I DON'T 4801 04:00:14,514 --> 04:00:17,050 THINK PEOPLE HAVE DONE BEFORE 4802 04:00:17,050 --> 04:00:21,788 AND THERE WAS DESIGNING IN DARPA 4803 04:00:21,788 --> 04:00:23,856 AND METADATA COULD BE A GREAT 4804 04:00:23,856 --> 04:00:25,591 NEW DIRECTION AND FUNDING 4805 04:00:25,591 --> 04:00:29,862 MECHANISM COULD BE INITIATED AND 4806 04:00:29,862 --> 04:00:31,998 I KNOW THE PROGRAM MANAGER FROM 4807 04:00:31,998 --> 04:00:34,334 NSF WAS ALSO INTERESTED IN 4808 04:00:34,334 --> 04:00:35,735 CARRYING OUT MATHEMATICAL TOPICS 4809 04:00:35,735 --> 04:00:40,273 THAT COULD BE FUNDED FROM NSF. 4810 04:00:40,273 --> 04:00:45,645 I THINK BOTH THE TOPICS AND GAPS 4811 04:00:45,645 --> 04:00:51,918 IN METADATA AND PROBABILISTIC 4812 04:00:51,918 --> 04:00:57,990 THINKING COULD BE A DISCUSSION 4813 04:00:57,990 --> 04:01:01,894 AND THERE WAS TOPIC OF 4814 04:01:01,894 --> 04:01:03,663 DEVELOPING THE MODEL IN THE LAB 4815 04:01:03,663 --> 04:01:08,267 AND HOW DO YOU GUARANTEE IT WILL 4816 04:01:08,267 --> 04:01:18,010 BE USEFUL FOR ANOTHER LAB. 4817 04:01:18,010 --> 04:01:19,545 IF THERE'S UNCERTAINTY 4818 04:01:19,545 --> 04:01:22,482 ASSOCIATED WITH THE NEURAL 4819 04:01:22,482 --> 04:01:24,350 NETWORKS AND EMPIRICAL 4820 04:01:24,350 --> 04:01:26,986 OPTIMIZATION AND THE BIAS OF THE 4821 04:01:26,986 --> 04:01:29,255 DATA IN THE PARTICULAR LAB THAT 4822 04:01:29,255 --> 04:01:35,094 DEVELOPED THE NEURAL NETWORK 4823 04:01:35,094 --> 04:01:35,294 MODEL. 4824 04:01:35,294 --> 04:01:36,496 THERE ARE TECHNIQUES WITH 4825 04:01:36,496 --> 04:01:39,565 LEARNING AND SIMILAR MODELS AND 4826 04:01:39,565 --> 04:01:41,267 DOMAIN ADAPTATION THAT ARE 4827 04:01:41,267 --> 04:01:46,439 STANDARD METHODS THAT ARE USED 4828 04:01:46,439 --> 04:01:48,074 IN COMPUTER SCIENCE AND SO ON. 4829 04:01:48,074 --> 04:01:52,011 THEY COULD ALSO BE USED HERE 4830 04:01:52,011 --> 04:01:54,614 TOWARDS A UNIVERSALITY OF MODELS 4831 04:01:54,614 --> 04:01:57,517 THAT APPLY ACROSS DIFFERENT 4832 04:01:57,517 --> 04:01:57,850 LABORATORIES. 4833 04:01:57,850 --> 04:01:59,252 THERE WAS SOME OTHER DISCUSSION 4834 04:01:59,252 --> 04:02:02,755 WHERE WE CAPTURE EVERYTHING BUT 4835 04:02:02,755 --> 04:02:06,159 WE WERE IN THE MECHANISTIC MODEL 4836 04:02:06,159 --> 04:02:09,962 SESSION SO SOMEONE POINTED OUT 4837 04:02:09,962 --> 04:02:15,201 RIGHT FLY SO THAT DATA COULD BE 4838 04:02:15,201 --> 04:02:19,238 GENERATED ALSO USING ACCURATE 4839 04:02:19,238 --> 04:02:21,741 DATA MECHANISTIC MODELS OFFLINE 4840 04:02:21,741 --> 04:02:23,443 AND THEN THOSE SYNTHETIC DATA 4841 04:02:23,443 --> 04:02:25,978 COULD BE USED FOR TRAINING 4842 04:02:25,978 --> 04:02:30,183 NEURAL NETWORKS AND THEN 4843 04:02:30,183 --> 04:02:31,417 INFERENCE USING THESE NETWORKS 4844 04:02:31,417 --> 04:02:33,719 COULD BE EXTREMELY FAST AND 4845 04:02:33,719 --> 04:02:36,255 THINK OF THE MODELS AS 4846 04:02:36,255 --> 04:02:37,723 SURROGATES OR IN QUANTIFICATION 4847 04:02:37,723 --> 04:02:41,961 WHERE YOU NEED TO RUN MULTIPLE 4848 04:02:41,961 --> 04:02:42,662 SIMULATIONS. 4849 04:02:42,662 --> 04:02:44,263 THESE WERE SOME OF THE TOPICS. 4850 04:02:44,263 --> 04:02:50,970 I MAY HAVE MISSED A FEW BUT AT 4851 04:02:50,970 --> 04:02:53,906 THE END I THINK WE HAD 4852 04:02:53,906 --> 04:02:55,775 MEANINGFUL DISCUSSIONS AND 4853 04:02:55,775 --> 04:02:57,009 DOESN'T WANT TO QUIT FOR THE 4854 04:02:57,009 --> 04:03:01,013 BREAK SO THAT WAS A GOOD SIGN. 4855 04:03:01,013 --> 04:03:01,614 >> SOUNDS GREAT. 4856 04:03:01,614 --> 04:03:03,516 THAT'S ALWAYS A GOOD TIME IF YOU 4857 04:03:03,516 --> 04:03:05,985 HAVE TOO LITTLE TIME TO DISCUSS 4858 04:03:05,985 --> 04:03:07,787 TOO LITTLE THINGS. 4859 04:03:07,787 --> 04:03:11,257 ANY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, 4860 04:03:11,257 --> 04:03:21,467 SUGGESTIONS? 4861 04:03:27,273 --> 04:03:29,242 >> THERE ARE MANY TOPICS WE 4862 04:03:29,242 --> 04:03:32,278 DISCUSSED AND ONE CAUGHT ME BY 4863 04:03:32,278 --> 04:03:33,913 SURPRISE AND FRED SAID SOME OF 4864 04:03:33,913 --> 04:03:36,182 THE MLs WE TALKED ABOUT LIKE IN 4865 04:03:36,182 --> 04:03:40,486 THIS EXPERIENCE MAY BE NEED TO 4866 04:03:40,486 --> 04:03:43,089 BE TRAINED OR USED IN SITUATIONS 4867 04:03:43,089 --> 04:03:45,858 AND WE DON'T HAVE THE COMPUTING 4868 04:03:45,858 --> 04:03:46,125 POWER. 4869 04:03:46,125 --> 04:03:47,260 THIS CAUSALITY SOMETHING THAT 4870 04:03:47,260 --> 04:03:48,995 CAUGHT MY ATTENTION BUT THIS MAY 4871 04:03:48,995 --> 04:03:50,429 BE SOMETHING YOU MAY WANT TO 4872 04:03:50,429 --> 04:03:52,832 THINK ABOUT ALL OF US BECAUSE 4873 04:03:52,832 --> 04:03:55,468 WE'RE TALKING ABOUT M.L. MODEL 4874 04:03:55,468 --> 04:03:58,571 NEEDS COMPUTING POWER BUT THE 4875 04:03:58,571 --> 04:04:00,273 ENVIRONMENT WOULD NEED TO APPLY 4876 04:04:00,273 --> 04:04:02,341 THEM DOESN'T HAVE COMPUTING 4877 04:04:02,341 --> 04:04:02,542 POWER. 4878 04:04:02,542 --> 04:04:05,244 IT'S A POINT THAT SEEMED 4879 04:04:05,244 --> 04:04:07,880 IMPORTANT TO ME. 4880 04:04:07,880 --> 04:04:11,250 >> JACOB WAS RIGHT WE DISCUSSED 4881 04:04:11,250 --> 04:04:21,794 HOW MUCH COMPUTING CAUSALITY -- 4882 04:04:40,379 --> 04:04:50,756 THE COMPUTING WAS NEEDED. 4883 04:05:13,245 --> 04:05:14,580 THERE'S A MEMORY FOOTPRINT. 4884 04:05:14,580 --> 04:05:16,015 >> ANY OTHER QUESTIONS, 4885 04:05:16,015 --> 04:05:16,282 COMMENTS? 4886 04:05:16,282 --> 04:05:21,520 GEORGE. 4887 04:05:21,520 --> 04:05:23,656 SO I AM THE REPORT OUT PERSON 4888 04:05:23,656 --> 04:05:26,092 FOR BREAKOUT NUMBER 3 WHICH IS 4889 04:05:26,092 --> 04:05:28,194 SOCIAL BEHAVIORAL AND SOCIAL 4890 04:05:28,194 --> 04:05:33,933 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH AND 4891 04:05:33,933 --> 04:05:42,141 PROBABILISTIC AND MECHANISTIC 4892 04:05:42,141 --> 04:05:45,378 MODELLING AND YOU CAN ADDRESS 4893 04:05:45,378 --> 04:05:47,279 BEHAVIORAL ISSUES IN SOCIAL 4894 04:05:47,279 --> 04:05:49,482 DETERMINATES OF HEALTH. 4895 04:05:49,482 --> 04:05:53,285 IT WAS AGREED THERE ARE OTHER 4896 04:05:53,285 --> 04:05:58,090 EFFORTS OUT MANY YEARS. 4897 04:05:58,090 --> 04:06:00,192 AND CONNECT UP WITH THE EFFORTS 4898 04:06:00,192 --> 04:06:01,627 RATHER THAN REINVENT THE WHEEL. 4899 04:06:01,627 --> 04:06:04,363 YOU HEARD FROM THE SESSION 4900 04:06:04,363 --> 04:06:05,865 EARLIER TODAY ABOUT COMPASS AND 4901 04:06:05,865 --> 04:06:08,300 SOME OTHER INITIATIVES EFFORTS 4902 04:06:08,300 --> 04:06:11,604 OUT THERE SO PART OF THE 4903 04:06:11,604 --> 04:06:12,872 CONVERSATION WAS PEOPLE 4904 04:06:12,872 --> 04:06:15,608 MENTIONING SOME OF THESE OTHER 4905 04:06:15,608 --> 04:06:17,109 EFFORTS OR OTHER GROUPS, 4906 04:06:17,109 --> 04:06:17,643 INITIATIVES THAT WILL BE 4907 04:06:17,643 --> 04:06:21,414 IMPORTANT TO CONNECT TO. 4908 04:06:21,414 --> 04:06:24,383 AND CONNECT TO FOR A VARIETY OF 4909 04:06:24,383 --> 04:06:24,684 REASONS. 4910 04:06:24,684 --> 04:06:30,089 ONE IS TO UNDERSTAND WHAT'S BEEN 4911 04:06:30,089 --> 04:06:30,923 DONE WITH MULTISCALE MODELING 4912 04:06:30,923 --> 04:06:31,824 AND WHAT'S THE SCALE OF 4913 04:06:31,824 --> 04:06:33,192 MULTISCALE MODELING AND MAKING 4914 04:06:33,192 --> 04:06:34,360 SURE DIFFERENT GROUPS AND 4915 04:06:34,360 --> 04:06:35,194 INITIATIVES UNDERSTAND THE 4916 04:06:35,194 --> 04:06:37,730 POTENTIAL OF MULTISCALE MODELING 4917 04:06:37,730 --> 04:06:40,199 AND ON THE FLIP SIDE CONNECTING 4918 04:06:40,199 --> 04:06:42,435 MULTISCALE MODELING WITH THE 4919 04:06:42,435 --> 04:06:43,402 ACTUAL QUESTIONS, WITH THE 4920 04:06:43,402 --> 04:06:45,071 ACTUAL COMMUNITIES AND PEOPLE ON 4921 04:06:45,071 --> 04:06:46,872 THE GROUND WHO UNDERSTAND WHAT 4922 04:06:46,872 --> 04:06:51,577 THE REAL ISSUES ARE SO WE'RE NOT 4923 04:06:51,577 --> 04:06:53,279 MULTISCALE MODELERS AREN'T 4924 04:06:53,279 --> 04:06:54,613 DEVELOPING IN PURE ABSTRACT 4925 04:06:54,613 --> 04:06:55,014 SPACE. 4926 04:06:55,014 --> 04:07:00,319 A BIG PART WAS DRAWING THE 4927 04:07:00,319 --> 04:07:00,619 CONNECTIONS. 4928 04:07:00,619 --> 04:07:03,055 ALSO HAVING MULTISCALE MODELING 4929 04:07:03,055 --> 04:07:06,392 DOING OTHER THINGS SUCH AS SHAPE 4930 04:07:06,392 --> 04:07:08,794 WHAT DATA NEEDS TO BE COLLECTED 4931 04:07:08,794 --> 04:07:12,298 AND WHAT SUB GROUPS COULD BE 4932 04:07:12,298 --> 04:07:14,533 CONNECTED SO TO THAT END WE CAME 4933 04:07:14,533 --> 04:07:16,836 UP WITH SEVERAL CONCRETE STEPS. 4934 04:07:16,836 --> 04:07:20,406 SO ONE WAS ACTUALLY PILE A LIST 4935 04:07:20,406 --> 04:07:25,478 OF AND I WOULDN'T SAY IMAG 4936 04:07:25,478 --> 04:07:26,846 INITIATIVES AND ACROSS THE 4937 04:07:26,846 --> 04:07:30,049 COUNTRY AND MAYBE GLOBALLY 4938 04:07:30,049 --> 04:07:35,287 WORKING ON EQUITY ISSUES AND 4939 04:07:35,287 --> 04:07:36,288 SOCIAL DETERMINATES ISSUES AND 4940 04:07:36,288 --> 04:07:38,390 THIS COULD BE A GLOSSARY OR LIST 4941 04:07:38,390 --> 04:07:40,659 THAT CAN HELP IDENTIFY WHICH 4942 04:07:40,659 --> 04:07:45,297 TYPES OF INITIATIVES THAT OUR 4943 04:07:45,297 --> 04:07:48,801 CONSORTIUM CAN CONNECT WITH AND 4944 04:07:48,801 --> 04:07:49,902 CONNECT WITH MEANING ATTEND OR 4945 04:07:49,902 --> 04:07:53,172 BE INVOLVED IN SOME OF THEIR 4946 04:07:53,172 --> 04:07:54,840 FUTURE MEETINGS OR FUTURE 4947 04:07:54,840 --> 04:07:56,308 WORKSHOPS OR SOME OF THEIR 4948 04:07:56,308 --> 04:08:02,414 FUTURE INITIATIVES. 4949 04:08:02,414 --> 04:08:04,350 ONE THING WE'D LIKE TO DO IS SET 4950 04:08:04,350 --> 04:08:06,652 UP A SYSTEM WHERE EVERYONE, IF 4951 04:08:06,652 --> 04:08:08,187 YOU CAN THINK OF AN INITIATIVE 4952 04:08:08,187 --> 04:08:09,889 THAT IS RELEVANT, JUST THROW IT 4953 04:08:09,889 --> 04:08:11,924 OUT THERE, ADD IT TO THIS LIST 4954 04:08:11,924 --> 04:08:13,926 AND WE CAN COMPILE A REALLY LONG 4955 04:08:13,926 --> 04:08:15,461 LIST AND ONCE WE HAVE THAT LIST 4956 04:08:15,461 --> 04:08:18,230 WE CAN DECIDE HOW WE MIGHT WANT 4957 04:08:18,230 --> 04:08:19,431 TO ENGAGE WITH THESE DIFFERENT 4958 04:08:19,431 --> 04:08:21,433 TYPES OF GROUPS. 4959 04:08:21,433 --> 04:08:23,169 NUMBER TWO IS I'D ANYTHING AND 4960 04:08:23,169 --> 04:08:27,940 CLARIFYING GOOD USE CASES THAT 4961 04:08:27,940 --> 04:08:29,642 DEMONSTRATE IMPACT OF MULTISCALE 4962 04:08:29,642 --> 04:08:31,710 MODELING. 4963 04:08:31,710 --> 04:08:32,545 WE SHOULD REMEMBER THERE'S 4964 04:08:32,545 --> 04:08:33,946 EXAMPLES OF MULTISCALE MODELING 4965 04:08:33,946 --> 04:08:35,347 OUT THERE THAT HAVE HAD A LOT OF 4966 04:08:35,347 --> 04:08:37,216 IMPACT WHEN IT COMES TO POLICY 4967 04:08:37,216 --> 04:08:38,984 AND CHANGING BEHAVIOR AND THINGS 4968 04:08:38,984 --> 04:08:40,319 LIKE THAT. 4969 04:08:40,319 --> 04:08:41,287 ONE OF THE FIRST THINGS WE 4970 04:08:41,287 --> 04:08:43,222 THOUGHT WAS TO MAKE A CALL AND 4971 04:08:43,222 --> 04:08:45,157 SAY IF YOU HAVE IDEAS OF WORK 4972 04:08:45,157 --> 04:08:47,159 YOU'VE DONE YOURSELF OR WORK YOU 4973 04:08:47,159 --> 04:08:48,961 ARE AWARE OF, SEND THAT IN AND 4974 04:08:48,961 --> 04:08:49,562 WE CAN COMPILE A LONG LIST OF 4975 04:08:49,562 --> 04:08:53,065 THIS. 4976 04:08:53,065 --> 04:08:54,567 THIS LIST CAN SERVE SEVERAL 4977 04:08:54,567 --> 04:08:54,834 PURPOSES. 4978 04:08:54,834 --> 04:08:58,737 ONE IS IF WE WANT TO GIVE 4979 04:08:58,737 --> 04:09:01,006 EXAMPLES TO DIFFERENT IMAG 4980 04:09:01,006 --> 04:09:03,709 INITIATIVES AND COMMUNITY GROUPS 4981 04:09:03,709 --> 04:09:04,777 OF HOW MULTISCALE MODELING CAN 4982 04:09:04,777 --> 04:09:05,411 BE USED. 4983 04:09:05,411 --> 04:09:07,346 THESE ARE CONCRETE EXAMPLES OUT 4984 04:09:07,346 --> 04:09:08,480 THERE THAT ARE EXPLAINING 4985 04:09:08,480 --> 04:09:14,987 SOMETHING IN ABSTRACT, WE CAN DO 4986 04:09:14,987 --> 04:09:17,089 X, Y AND Z AND HERE'S THE 4987 04:09:17,089 --> 04:09:19,124 PUBLICATION OR AN EXAMPLE OF 4988 04:09:19,124 --> 04:09:20,192 SOMETHING THAT WORKED VERY WELL. 4989 04:09:20,192 --> 04:09:22,161 AND NUMBER TWO, THAT CAN ALSO 4990 04:09:22,161 --> 04:09:23,762 IDENTIFY THE GAPS. 4991 04:09:23,762 --> 04:09:26,465 SO WE TALKED ABOUT EXISTING USE 4992 04:09:26,465 --> 04:09:28,133 CASES AND POTENTIAL FUTURE TEST 4993 04:09:28,133 --> 04:09:28,734 CASES. 4994 04:09:28,734 --> 04:09:31,670 SO THERE MAY BE PARTICULAR AREAS 4995 04:09:31,670 --> 04:09:34,106 THAT ARE MORE WELL SUBSCRIBED 4996 04:09:34,106 --> 04:09:36,308 WHEN IT COMES TO MULTISCALE 4997 04:09:36,308 --> 04:09:39,144 MODELING AND MORE AREAS THAT ARE 4998 04:09:39,144 --> 04:09:39,411 DEFICIENT. 4999 04:09:39,411 --> 04:09:40,779 IF WE HAVE THE LIST OF USE CASES 5000 04:09:40,779 --> 04:09:45,551 WE CAN ALSO IDENTIFY FUTURE TEST 5001 04:09:45,551 --> 04:09:47,286 CASES AND WE'VE LISTED HERE 5002 04:09:47,286 --> 04:09:50,923 EXAMPLES OF DIFFERENT AREAS THAT 5003 04:09:50,923 --> 04:09:52,858 PEOPLE THINK THAT NEED TO BE 5004 04:09:52,858 --> 04:09:55,361 ADDRESSED, DIFFERENT CANCER 5005 04:09:55,361 --> 04:09:58,764 AREAS, MATERNAL HEALTH, SHOWCASE 5006 04:09:58,764 --> 04:10:00,299 MSM APPLICATIONS TO SEX 5007 04:10:00,299 --> 04:10:02,768 DIFFERENCES, SOURCE OPTIONS FROM 5008 04:10:02,768 --> 04:10:03,302 THE COMMUNITY. 5009 04:10:03,302 --> 04:10:05,004 AGAIN WE MENTION THE LIBRARY OF 5010 04:10:05,004 --> 04:10:06,639 POTENTIAL USE CASES. 5011 04:10:06,639 --> 04:10:08,007 WE TALKED ABOUT POTENTIALLY 5012 04:10:08,007 --> 04:10:13,312 TURNING THIS INTO A COMMENTARY 5013 04:10:13,312 --> 04:10:15,614 SHOWING HOW MULTISCALE MODELING 5014 04:10:15,614 --> 04:10:17,283 CAN BE USED TO ADDRESS SOCIAL 5015 04:10:17,283 --> 04:10:18,651 DETERMINATES AND BEHAVIORAL 5016 04:10:18,651 --> 04:10:18,984 ISSUES. 5017 04:10:18,984 --> 04:10:20,552 SO THAT'S ANOTHER CONCRETE NEXT 5018 04:10:20,552 --> 04:10:24,390 STEP THAT WE'D LIKE TO PURSUE. 5019 04:10:24,390 --> 04:10:28,327 THE THIRD CONCRETE NEXT STEP IS 5020 04:10:28,327 --> 04:10:31,163 TO INTEGRATE EQUITY INTO MANY OR 5021 04:10:31,163 --> 04:10:35,501 MOST OF OUR EXISTING MODEL 5022 04:10:35,501 --> 04:10:36,702 CREDIBILITY 10 SIMPLE RULES AND 5023 04:10:36,702 --> 04:10:38,404 OTHER TYPES OF INITIATIVES. 5024 04:10:38,404 --> 04:10:40,873 IT FIRST CAME OUT LIKE WE SHOULD 5025 04:10:40,873 --> 04:10:43,609 MAYBE ADD A CREDIBILITY CRITERIA 5026 04:10:43,609 --> 04:10:46,879 AT THE END THAT ADDRESSES 5027 04:10:46,879 --> 04:10:48,113 EQUITY, DIVERSITY INCLUSION. 5028 04:10:48,113 --> 04:10:49,848 BUT THEN IT CAME OUT LATER 5029 04:10:49,848 --> 04:10:51,850 SAYING SHOULD THIS BE A SEPARATE 5030 04:10:51,850 --> 04:10:53,752 ITEM OR SHOULD THIS BE 5031 04:10:53,752 --> 04:10:56,622 INTEGRATED INTO ALL OF OUR MODEL 5032 04:10:56,622 --> 04:10:57,056 CREDIBILITY POINTS? 5033 04:10:57,056 --> 04:10:59,258 WE FELT IT'S ACTUALLY BETTER THE 5034 04:10:59,258 --> 04:11:01,760 LATTER IS BETTER BECAUSE THIS IS 5035 04:11:01,760 --> 04:11:05,864 INHERENT IF YOU ARE ACTUALLY 5036 04:11:05,864 --> 04:11:07,066 GOING TO BE CREDIBLY MODEL 5037 04:11:07,066 --> 04:11:09,435 SOMETHING THEN YOU HAVE TO TAKE 5038 04:11:09,435 --> 04:11:10,636 INTO ACCOUNT ALL THE DIFFERENT 5039 04:11:10,636 --> 04:11:13,539 FORCES OR TAKE INTO ACCOUNT YOU 5040 04:11:13,539 --> 04:11:15,240 MAY HAVE HETEROGENEOUS AFFECT ON 5041 04:11:15,240 --> 04:11:16,308 DIFFERENT PEOPLE. 5042 04:11:16,308 --> 04:11:18,610 WE THOUGHT IT WOULD BE BETTER TO 5043 04:11:18,610 --> 04:11:19,778 INTEGRATE EQUITY INTO THESE 5044 04:11:19,778 --> 04:11:21,680 THINGS AND NOT JUST THE 10 5045 04:11:21,680 --> 04:11:22,915 SIMPLE RULES BUT EVERYTHING WE 5046 04:11:22,915 --> 04:11:23,882 DO GOING FORWARD. 5047 04:11:23,882 --> 04:11:27,419 ONE OF THE DANGERS IS THAT 5048 04:11:27,419 --> 04:11:29,088 SOCIAL DETERMINATES, EQUITY, 5049 04:11:29,088 --> 04:11:30,289 DIVERSITY, INCLUSION CAN BE 5050 04:11:30,289 --> 04:11:32,157 VIEWED AS A QUOTE, UNQUOTE, 5051 04:11:32,157 --> 04:11:34,226 CHECK MARK OR ADDITIONAL THING 5052 04:11:34,226 --> 04:11:35,361 TO DO WHEN IT'S ACTUALLY 5053 04:11:35,361 --> 04:11:37,830 INTEGRAL TO THE SCIENCE. 5054 04:11:37,830 --> 04:11:39,498 THAT WAS A THIRD DISCUSSION. 5055 04:11:39,498 --> 04:11:42,968 THE FOURTH POINT IS A DUPLICATE 5056 04:11:42,968 --> 04:11:45,137 OF THE SECOND POINT WE'D LIKE TO 5057 04:11:45,137 --> 04:11:46,638 PROCEED WITH A COMMENTARY 5058 04:11:46,638 --> 04:11:48,307 ADDRESSING HOW MULTISCALE 5059 04:11:48,307 --> 04:11:49,441 MODELING CAN ADDRESS THESE 5060 04:11:49,441 --> 04:11:50,042 DIFFERENT SOCIAL DETERMINATES 5061 04:11:50,042 --> 04:11:51,977 AND SOCIAL ISSUES. 5062 04:11:51,977 --> 04:11:55,080 SO THAT'S WHAT OUR BREAKOUT 5063 04:11:55,080 --> 04:11:58,984 THREE SESSION CAME UP IN WITH. 5064 04:11:58,984 --> 04:12:01,887 JULIA, I WANTED TO GIVE YOU AN 5065 04:12:01,887 --> 04:12:03,522 OPPORTUNITY TO ADD ANYTHING TO 5066 04:12:03,522 --> 04:12:03,722 THAT. 5067 04:12:03,722 --> 04:12:04,623 >> THANKS, BRUCE. 5068 04:12:04,623 --> 04:12:05,657 GREAT SUMMARY. 5069 04:12:05,657 --> 04:12:12,031 THE ONLY THINGS I WANTED TO ADD 5070 04:12:12,031 --> 04:12:18,137 IS THAT I SAW WE WERE TALKING 5071 04:12:18,137 --> 04:12:24,710 ABOUT WHAT IT MEANS TO BUILD A 5072 04:12:24,710 --> 04:12:26,278 MULTISCALE MODEL AND I HEAR 5073 04:12:26,278 --> 04:12:27,246 ABOUT BUILDING CITIES AND WHAT'S 5074 04:12:27,246 --> 04:12:30,716 A BETTER WAY TO INTEGRATE AND 5075 04:12:30,716 --> 04:12:33,352 EXPLORE THE CROSS TOPICS AND 5076 04:12:33,352 --> 04:12:40,192 SAME EXPLAINABILITY AND THE 5077 04:12:40,192 --> 04:12:44,263 SOCIAL DETERMINATES OF HEALTH. 5078 04:12:44,263 --> 04:12:46,398 I THINK THE POINT OF IDENTIFYING 5079 04:12:46,398 --> 04:12:51,670 BIOLOGICAL MODELS THAT CAN BE 5080 04:12:51,670 --> 04:13:02,214 USED IN THE TOPICS, THEY NEED TO 5081 04:13:12,357 --> 04:13:18,030 AND THERE'S A MANDATE COMING IN 5082 04:13:18,030 --> 04:13:23,302 2024 AND THERE'S A COUPLE 5083 04:13:23,302 --> 04:13:25,003 EXAMPLES ON THE SCREEN. 5084 04:13:25,003 --> 04:13:27,706 YOU DON'T NEED TO GENERATE THE 5085 04:13:27,706 --> 04:13:30,242 DATA FROM THE GROUND LEVEL. 5086 04:13:30,242 --> 04:13:33,779 ONE OF THE LAST THINGS I THINK 5087 04:13:33,779 --> 04:13:37,716 WERE MENTIONED IN THE SESSION 5088 04:13:37,716 --> 04:13:39,318 WAS THE TRAINING ENGAGEMENT. 5089 04:13:39,318 --> 04:13:40,619 I DON'T KNOW IF YOU MENTIONED 5090 04:13:40,619 --> 04:13:44,289 THEM, I MAY HAVE MISSED. 5091 04:13:44,289 --> 04:13:46,792 AND RESPECT TO TRAINING THE 5092 04:13:46,792 --> 04:13:48,994 QUESTION WAS ASKED WHETHER THERE 5093 04:13:48,994 --> 04:13:59,304 IS THE ABILITY TO CROSS 5094 04:13:59,304 --> 04:14:06,612 POLLINATE AND YOU CAN INCREASE 5095 04:14:06,612 --> 04:14:09,081 MORE GROUPS OF TRAINEES AND WITH 5096 04:14:09,081 --> 04:14:11,783 ENGAGEMENT OF COMMUNITY I THINK 5097 04:14:11,783 --> 04:14:14,119 YOU MENTIONED THAT I THINK IN 5098 04:14:14,119 --> 04:14:20,292 DEVICE DEVELOPMENT TO WHERE I 5099 04:14:20,292 --> 04:14:24,296 LIVE IT'S NOT RESEARCH NOTHING 5100 04:14:24,296 --> 04:14:26,899 ABOUT US WITHOUT US AND IN MY 5101 04:14:26,899 --> 04:14:29,301 INSTITUTE WE HAVE SEVERAL 5102 04:14:29,301 --> 04:14:31,503 ENGAGEMENT CENTER AND SOMETHING 5103 04:14:31,503 --> 04:14:35,307 NIH IS DOING AND CAN ALSO BUILD. 5104 04:14:35,307 --> 04:14:35,607 THAT'S ALL. 5105 04:14:35,607 --> 04:14:37,976 THANK YOU. 5106 04:14:37,976 --> 04:14:39,278 >> THANKS, JULIA. 5107 04:14:39,278 --> 04:14:41,446 ANY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, 5108 04:14:41,446 --> 04:14:51,990 SUGGESTIONS FROM EVERYONE ELSE? 5109 04:14:52,357 --> 04:14:55,928 >> ORLANDO LOPEZ FROM NHCR. 5110 04:14:55,928 --> 04:14:59,231 THERE'S EMERGING FRAMEWORK AND 5111 04:14:59,231 --> 04:15:00,599 ACTIVITIES AROUND ENGAGEMENTING 5112 04:15:00,599 --> 04:15:04,336 COMMUNITIES TO CAPTURE DATA LIKE 5113 04:15:04,336 --> 04:15:07,573 REAL WORLD DATA, REAL WORLD 5114 04:15:07,573 --> 04:15:09,041 EVIDENCE, LIKE VIRTUAL CLINICAL 5115 04:15:09,041 --> 04:15:11,310 TRIALS AND THROUGH WEARABLES AND 5116 04:15:11,310 --> 04:15:12,311 DIFFERENT TECHNOLOGIES. 5117 04:15:12,311 --> 04:15:15,247 WOULD IT BE TIMELY TO THINK 5118 04:15:15,247 --> 04:15:17,149 ABOUT HOW WE CAN LEVERAGE THOSE 5119 04:15:17,149 --> 04:15:19,318 OPPORTUNITIES AND THAT EMERGING 5120 04:15:19,318 --> 04:15:21,186 STREAM OF DATA LIKE BRING YOUR 5121 04:15:21,186 --> 04:15:24,990 OWN DATA, BRING YOUR OWN DEVICE 5122 04:15:24,990 --> 04:15:27,526 TYPE OF SET UP AND TO BE TO 5123 04:15:27,526 --> 04:15:29,294 REALLY TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE 5124 04:15:29,294 --> 04:15:30,862 EMERGING CAPABILITIES ON 5125 04:15:30,862 --> 04:15:33,198 GENERATING DATA AND POSSIBLY 5126 04:15:33,198 --> 04:15:35,534 REAL TIME OR SEMI PSEUDO REAL 5127 04:15:35,534 --> 04:15:36,301 TIME COMPUTING POWER. 5128 04:15:36,301 --> 04:15:40,305 THANK YOU. 5129 04:15:40,305 --> 04:15:41,173 >> YEAH, THAT'S AN EXCELLENT 5130 04:15:41,173 --> 04:15:41,940 SUGGESTION AND ONE OF THOSE 5131 04:15:41,940 --> 04:15:44,910 THINGS WE WANT TO ENCOURAGE WHEN 5132 04:15:44,910 --> 04:15:49,248 WE DO SEND OUT MESSAGES ASKING 5133 04:15:49,248 --> 04:15:51,516 THROW OUT ANY INITIATIVE US FEEL 5134 04:15:51,516 --> 04:15:53,418 WOULD BE RELEVANT, JUST ADD THAT 5135 04:15:53,418 --> 04:15:54,553 TO THE LIST. 5136 04:15:54,553 --> 04:15:57,656 WE FEEL THIS WOULD BE HELPFUL 5137 04:15:57,656 --> 04:16:01,526 FOR THE WHOLE COMMUNITY TO HAVE 5138 04:16:01,526 --> 04:16:05,030 THIS GLOSSARY OR INDEX OF 5139 04:16:05,030 --> 04:16:06,064 DIFFERENT POSSIBILITIES AND 5140 04:16:06,064 --> 04:16:08,467 AFTER THAT THINK OF HOW TO 5141 04:16:08,467 --> 04:16:08,700 ENGAGE. 5142 04:16:08,700 --> 04:16:13,572 ONE OF OUR GOALS AS A BREAKOUT 5143 04:16:13,572 --> 04:16:14,706 SESSION WAS TO ESTABLISH THINGS 5144 04:16:14,706 --> 04:16:17,309 THAT ARE LOW -HANGING FRUIT THAT 5145 04:16:17,309 --> 04:16:19,211 ARE REACHABLE WE KNOW FOR SURE 5146 04:16:19,211 --> 04:16:20,912 COME NEXT YEAR WE CAN SAY WE 5147 04:16:20,912 --> 04:16:22,881 HAVE DONE THIS AND FEEL IT WOULD 5148 04:16:22,881 --> 04:16:24,249 BE BENEFICIAL TO THE CONSORTIUM 5149 04:16:24,249 --> 04:16:25,217 AND ALSO INDIVIDUALLY BECAUSE 5150 04:16:25,217 --> 04:16:28,520 THEN YOU'LL BE ABLE TO SAY, OH, 5151 04:16:28,520 --> 04:16:29,187 THIS INITIATIVE IS DOING 5152 04:16:29,187 --> 04:16:30,689 COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT. 5153 04:16:30,689 --> 04:16:31,923 THIS INITIATIVE IS DOING SUCH 5154 04:16:31,923 --> 04:16:35,827 AND SUCH AND SO WE FEEL IT WILL 5155 04:16:35,827 --> 04:16:36,728 BE BENEFICIAL TO HAVE INDIVIDUAL 5156 04:16:36,728 --> 04:16:39,765 INVESTIGATORS AS WELL. 5157 04:16:39,765 --> 04:16:40,399 ANY OTHER QUESTIONS OR 5158 04:16:40,399 --> 04:16:44,970 SUGGESTIONS? 5159 04:16:44,970 --> 04:16:45,170 OKAY. 5160 04:16:45,170 --> 04:16:48,307 WITH THAT THAT WAS BREAKOUT 5161 04:16:48,307 --> 04:16:49,374 SESSION 3. 5162 04:16:49,374 --> 04:16:56,281 LET'S MOVE TO BREAKOUT SESSION 5163 04:16:56,281 --> 04:16:58,650 4. 5164 04:16:58,650 --> 04:16:59,885 >> GOOD AFTERNOON. 5165 04:16:59,885 --> 04:17:10,429 I'M SUR SUVRANU DE AND WE TALKED 5166 04:17:10,629 --> 04:17:12,831 LESS ABOUT QUANTUM SENSING BUT 5167 04:17:12,831 --> 04:17:14,499 ALL ABOUT THE EXCITING FIELD OF 5168 04:17:14,499 --> 04:17:15,634 QUANTUM TECHNOLOGIES. 5169 04:17:15,634 --> 04:17:16,501 THE INTERESTING THING ABOUT THE 5170 04:17:16,501 --> 04:17:18,737 FIELD IS THE PHYSICS OF THIS IS 5171 04:17:18,737 --> 04:17:22,174 KNOWN FOR MANY YEARS. 5172 04:17:22,174 --> 04:17:24,376 IT'S NOT THE PHYSICS THAT'S THE 5173 04:17:24,376 --> 04:17:27,212 QUESTION BUT WHETHER WE CAN 5174 04:17:27,212 --> 04:17:29,381 DEVELOP DEVICES TO DELIVER 5175 04:17:29,381 --> 04:17:30,949 COMPUTING AT SCALE OR DEVELOP 5176 04:17:30,949 --> 04:17:32,884 DEVICES THAT SENSE WHAT WE WANT 5177 04:17:32,884 --> 04:17:34,486 TO SENSE WITH THE KIND OF 5178 04:17:34,486 --> 04:17:36,054 RESOLUTION WE WANT. 5179 04:17:36,054 --> 04:17:39,157 ESSENTIALLY COMING TO THE POINT 5180 04:17:39,157 --> 04:17:42,127 IS IT REALLY A GPT, A GENERAL 5181 04:17:42,127 --> 04:17:44,062 PURPOSE TECHNOLOGY TAKING OFF. 5182 04:17:44,062 --> 04:17:46,498 THINK OF WHEN EDISON AND THE 5183 04:17:46,498 --> 04:17:48,867 OTHERS WERE TRYING TO EXPERIMENT 5184 04:17:48,867 --> 04:17:50,102 WITH TECHNOLOGY TO DETERMINE IF 5185 04:17:50,102 --> 04:17:51,803 LIGHT BULBS WOULD WORK. 5186 04:17:51,803 --> 04:17:53,305 WE'RE AT THAT STAGE IN THE 5187 04:17:53,305 --> 04:17:55,507 DEVELOPMENT OF TECHNOLOGY. 5188 04:17:55,507 --> 04:17:59,311 IF YOU'RE ONE OF THE NAYSAYERS 5189 04:17:59,311 --> 04:18:04,316 THINKING THE LIGHT FOR FIVE 5190 04:18:04,316 --> 04:18:06,151 MINUTES SO WE'RE NOT GOING TO 5191 04:18:06,151 --> 04:18:09,521 HAVE A LIGHT BULB EVER YOU'LL BE 5192 04:18:09,521 --> 04:18:10,789 LEFT IN THE DARK LITERALLY. 5193 04:18:10,789 --> 04:18:13,091 SO THIS IS WHERE WE ARE. 5194 04:18:13,091 --> 04:18:18,363 THIS IS THE DILEMMA OF BEING IN 5195 04:18:18,363 --> 04:18:28,907 THE FIELD YOU DON'T HAVE -- NO 5196 04:18:33,578 --> 04:18:33,812 QUANTUM FIX. 5197 04:18:33,812 --> 04:18:37,149 GOING BACK TO MY POINT. 5198 04:18:37,149 --> 04:18:39,317 BASICALLY THIS TECHNOLOGY ARE 5199 04:18:39,317 --> 04:18:40,085 EVOLVING AND WE'RE JUST 5200 04:18:40,085 --> 04:18:40,419 FOLLOWING. 5201 04:18:40,419 --> 04:18:43,789 WE'RE GOING WITH THE TECHNOLOGY 5202 04:18:43,789 --> 04:18:44,089 DEVELOPMENT. 5203 04:18:44,089 --> 04:18:45,123 THIS IS VERY DIFFERENT FROM THE 5204 04:18:45,123 --> 04:18:46,525 OTHER SESSIONS YOU HEARD WHERE 5205 04:18:46,525 --> 04:18:48,493 WE HAVE THE COMPUTING 5206 04:18:48,493 --> 04:18:50,695 CAPACITIES, IT'S JUST THE 5207 04:18:50,695 --> 04:18:52,931 ALGORITHMS AND THE THINGS 5208 04:18:52,931 --> 04:18:55,367 RELATED TO DATA SO ON, SO FORTH. 5209 04:18:55,367 --> 04:18:58,069 HERE WE DON'T HAVE YET THE 5210 04:18:58,069 --> 04:18:59,304 COMPUTATION INFRASTRUCTURE IN 5211 04:18:59,304 --> 04:18:59,738 PLACE. 5212 04:18:59,738 --> 04:19:00,705 THAT'S ALL THE MORE IMPORTANT 5213 04:19:00,705 --> 04:19:01,740 WE'RE FOCUSSED ON WHAT WE HAVE 5214 04:19:01,740 --> 04:19:05,277 AND WHAT THE POTENTIALS ARE 5215 04:19:05,277 --> 04:19:07,946 KNOWING WE CAN TRUST THE PHYSICS 5216 04:19:07,946 --> 04:19:09,848 THAT IS EMBEDDED ALMOST 100 5217 04:19:09,848 --> 04:19:10,749 YEARS NOW. 5218 04:19:10,749 --> 04:19:11,850 WHAT IS THE TECHNOLOGY RIGHT NOW 5219 04:19:11,850 --> 04:19:14,653 WE'RE WORKING ON? 5220 04:19:14,653 --> 04:19:17,322 SO THE BASIC TYPES OF QUANTUM 5221 04:19:17,322 --> 04:19:18,657 COMPUTERS IN EXISTENCE RIGHT NOW 5222 04:19:18,657 --> 04:19:20,859 THAT ARE IN RESEARCH AND PEOPLE 5223 04:19:20,859 --> 04:19:23,662 ARE TRYING TO BRING THEM TO 5224 04:19:23,662 --> 04:19:23,895 MARKET? 5225 04:19:23,895 --> 04:19:27,332 ONE IS QUANTUM ENABLING. 5226 04:19:27,332 --> 04:19:29,301 THAT WORKS ON SPECIALIZED 5227 04:19:29,301 --> 04:19:33,238 OPTIMIZE AGENCY PROBLEMS KNOWN 5228 04:19:33,238 --> 04:19:38,844 AS HAMILTONIAN YOU'RE LOOKING AT 5229 04:19:38,844 --> 04:19:41,546 THE MINIMUM OF THIS AND IF YOU 5230 04:19:41,546 --> 04:19:43,515 CAN CAST YOUR PROBLEM AND IF 5231 04:19:43,515 --> 04:19:45,851 YOU'RE TRYING TO SOLVE A BUNCH 5232 04:19:45,851 --> 04:19:48,220 OF EQUATIONS, X EQUALS B YOU CAN 5233 04:19:48,220 --> 04:19:55,894 CAST THAT AS A MODIFIED ICING 5234 04:19:55,894 --> 04:19:59,397 HAMILTONIAN AND UNLIKE WHAT DOES 5235 04:19:59,397 --> 04:20:02,601 ITERATIONS IT EVOLVES THE QUBITS 5236 04:20:02,601 --> 04:20:04,836 ALL THE TIME OVER A FINITE TIME. 5237 04:20:04,836 --> 04:20:07,405 THIS IS A THEOREM OF QUANTUM 5238 04:20:07,405 --> 04:20:08,440 MECHANICS AND GIVES YOU THE 5239 04:20:08,440 --> 04:20:11,009 ANSWER IN ONE SHOT. 5240 04:20:11,009 --> 04:20:12,043 AGAIN, REMEMBER THIS IS 5241 04:20:12,043 --> 04:20:13,912 SPECIALIZED AND WHAT IS IT GOOD 5242 04:20:13,912 --> 04:20:14,446 FOR? 5243 04:20:14,446 --> 04:20:19,017 FOR EXAMPLE, PROTEIN FORMING 5244 04:20:19,017 --> 04:20:19,284 PROBLEMS? 5245 04:20:19,284 --> 04:20:21,887 DRUG DESIGN AND MACHINE LEARNING 5246 04:20:21,887 --> 04:20:23,889 AT THE HEART OF MACHINE LEARNING 5247 04:20:23,889 --> 04:20:27,993 IS AN OPTIMIZATION PROCESS. 5248 04:20:27,993 --> 04:20:29,895 ABOUT 5,000 QUBITS ARE AVAILABLE 5249 04:20:29,895 --> 04:20:34,933 RIGHT NOW IN THE SYSTEM THAT IS 5250 04:20:34,933 --> 04:20:35,834 BEING DEVELOPED. 5251 04:20:35,834 --> 04:20:43,308 THE OTHER CLASS ARE GATE-BASED 5252 04:20:43,308 --> 04:20:44,009 QUANTUM COMPUTERS. 5253 04:20:44,009 --> 04:20:46,845 >> IN YOU HAVE QUBITS THAT GIVE 5254 04:20:46,845 --> 04:20:49,848 END QUBITS THAT FORM A QUANTUM 5255 04:20:49,848 --> 04:20:55,353 REGISTER AND THEN APPLY 5256 04:20:55,353 --> 04:21:04,095 OPERATIONS ON THOSE. 5257 04:21:04,095 --> 04:21:07,799 AND IF HAVE THEM TOGETHER IT'S 5258 04:21:07,799 --> 04:21:10,535 NOTHING BUT A SEQUENCE OF 5259 04:21:10,535 --> 04:21:11,870 OPERATIONS APPLIED TO THE 5260 04:21:11,870 --> 04:21:15,707 QUANTUM STATE OF A QUANTUM 5261 04:21:15,707 --> 04:21:15,974 REGISTER. 5262 04:21:15,974 --> 04:21:23,348 THEN BOTH OF THESE QUANTUM 5263 04:21:23,348 --> 04:21:28,286 COMPUTERS ARE VERY DIFFERENT 5264 04:21:28,286 --> 04:21:30,322 SUPERCOMPUTERS YOU'RE USED TO. 5265 04:21:30,322 --> 04:21:32,924 YOU HAVE A SAMPLE BUT RUN IT ONE 5266 04:21:32,924 --> 04:21:34,392 TIME. 5267 04:21:34,392 --> 04:21:38,663 YOU HAVE TO BE ABLE TO EXTRACT 5268 04:21:38,663 --> 04:21:39,431 STATISTICAL INFORMATION FROM THE 5269 04:21:39,431 --> 04:21:40,966 ANSWER YOU'RE GETTING TO RUN IT 5270 04:21:40,966 --> 04:21:43,301 MULTIPLE TIME AND OBSERVING THE 5271 04:21:43,301 --> 04:21:43,535 RESULTS. 5272 04:21:43,535 --> 04:21:44,302 THEY'RE VERY DIFFERENT FROM THE 5273 04:21:44,302 --> 04:21:47,339 KINDS OF THINGS WE'RE LOOKING 5274 04:21:47,339 --> 04:21:47,572 AT. 5275 04:21:47,572 --> 04:21:49,074 SO AT ONE LEVEL OF DETAIL, 5276 04:21:49,074 --> 04:21:51,142 PEOPLE ARE TRYING TO COME UP 5277 04:21:51,142 --> 04:21:51,943 WITH THE TECHNOLOGY AND THE 5278 04:21:51,943 --> 04:21:55,213 HARDWARE THAT RUNS THIS. 5279 04:21:55,213 --> 04:21:56,481 BUT WE FROM THE PERSPECTIVE OF 5280 04:21:56,481 --> 04:21:59,618 NIH OR THE ONES THAT ARE WORKING 5281 04:21:59,618 --> 04:22:01,286 IN DOMAINS CARE ABOUT USING THE 5282 04:22:01,286 --> 04:22:03,755 TECHNOLOGIES TO SOLVE A PROBLEM. 5283 04:22:03,755 --> 04:22:05,690 SO ESSENTIALLY WE HAVE TO HAVE A 5284 04:22:05,690 --> 04:22:08,293 LANGUAGE THAT IS AGNOSTIC TO THE 5285 04:22:08,293 --> 04:22:08,760 HARDWARE. 5286 04:22:08,760 --> 04:22:11,896 AND THANKS TO ALL THE COMPANIES 5287 04:22:11,896 --> 04:22:13,999 LIKE GOOGLE, MICROSOFT AND 5288 04:22:13,999 --> 04:22:16,001 AMAZON, THEY'RE ALL COMING 5289 04:22:16,001 --> 04:22:17,369 TOGETHER, CREATING CLOUD-BASED 5290 04:22:17,369 --> 04:22:19,070 PLATFORMS TO GIVE YOU THAT 5291 04:22:19,070 --> 04:22:21,306 LANGUAGE, IBM, FOR EXAMPLE, GIVE 5292 04:22:21,306 --> 04:22:23,241 YOU THE LANGUAGE YOU CAN USE TO 5293 04:22:23,241 --> 04:22:24,309 PROGRAM THE COMPUTERS WITHOUT 5294 04:22:24,309 --> 04:22:27,412 ACTUALLY GOING TO THE QUANTUM 5295 04:22:27,412 --> 04:22:29,047 MECHANICS OR THE SPECIFIC 5296 04:22:29,047 --> 04:22:29,614 HARDWARE TECHNOLOGIES BEING 5297 04:22:29,614 --> 04:22:31,816 DEVELOPED TO DO THAT. 5298 04:22:31,816 --> 04:22:35,320 SO THE HARDWARE IS EVOLVING IN 5299 04:22:35,320 --> 04:22:35,520 STEPS. 5300 04:22:35,520 --> 04:22:38,857 RIGHT NOW THE LARGEST QUANTUM 5301 04:22:38,857 --> 04:22:42,794 COMPUTER HAS 433 PHYSICAL 5302 04:22:42,794 --> 04:22:43,028 QUBITS. 5303 04:22:43,028 --> 04:22:45,697 REMEMBER, ABOUT 100 PHYSICAL 5304 04:22:45,697 --> 04:22:46,665 QUBITS ARE REQUIRED FOR ERROR 5305 04:22:46,665 --> 04:22:48,233 CORRECTION TO GIVE YOU ONE 5306 04:22:48,233 --> 04:22:49,167 LOGICAL QUBIT. 5307 04:22:49,167 --> 04:22:50,135 THAT'S A LARGE QUBIT YOU HAVE 5308 04:22:50,135 --> 04:22:53,338 AFTER A CORRECTION. 5309 04:22:53,338 --> 04:22:57,108 AND THAT'S THE IBM OFFSPRING. 5310 04:22:57,108 --> 04:23:00,412 AND THEN THE NEXT STAGE IS GOING 5311 04:23:00,412 --> 04:23:04,516 TO HAVE 1,000 QUBITS AND THEN 5312 04:23:04,516 --> 04:23:08,086 THE 2,000 QUBITS AND SO ON WITH 5313 04:23:08,086 --> 04:23:10,455 THE AIM OF HAVING 100 LOGICAL 5314 04:23:10,455 --> 04:23:15,527 QUBITS BY 2030. 5315 04:23:15,527 --> 04:23:19,497 WE'LL BE EXPOSED TO 5316 04:23:19,497 --> 04:23:20,899 EXPONENTIEXPONEN 5317 04:23:20,899 --> 04:23:22,600 EXPONENTIALLY BETTER HARDWARE IN 5318 04:23:22,600 --> 04:23:26,671 THE YEARS TO COME AND THE PLAN 5319 04:23:26,671 --> 04:23:29,240 INCLUDES EVOLVING TECHNOLOGY AND 5320 04:23:29,240 --> 04:23:31,743 WE CAN'T WRITE THE PROPOSAL TO 5321 04:23:31,743 --> 04:23:33,845 RUN MASSIVE SIMULATIONS. 5322 04:23:33,845 --> 04:23:37,182 THIS IS DIFFERENT FROM A.I. AND 5323 04:23:37,182 --> 04:23:38,116 DIGITAL TWINS AND SO ON. 5324 04:23:38,116 --> 04:23:40,285 WE HAVE TO MAKE SURE THE FIRST 5325 04:23:40,285 --> 04:23:44,923 ITEM IS BRING THE COMMUNITY 5326 04:23:44,923 --> 04:23:47,459 TOGETHER THERE'S NO DOUBT THIS 5327 04:23:47,459 --> 04:23:48,993 TECHNOLOGY WILL BE ONLINE. 5328 04:23:48,993 --> 04:23:50,228 THERE'S NO DOUBT WE NEED PEOPLE 5329 04:23:50,228 --> 04:23:51,196 TRAINED IN THIS. 5330 04:23:51,196 --> 04:23:58,436 THERE'S NO DOUBT WE NEED THE 5331 04:23:58,436 --> 04:23:59,971 ACADEMIC BUILT AROUND IT. 5332 04:23:59,971 --> 04:24:05,276 WHEN A.I. CAME INTO EXISTENCE WE 5333 04:24:05,276 --> 04:24:08,847 KNEW ABOUT NEURO MORPHIC AND 5334 04:24:08,847 --> 04:24:13,118 ACADEMICS WERE SCRAMBLING TO 5335 04:24:13,118 --> 04:24:16,254 HIRE PEOPLE BECAUSE THEY WERE 5336 04:24:16,254 --> 04:24:17,555 SNAPPED LIKE CRAZY AND WHAT DO 5337 04:24:17,555 --> 04:24:19,157 WE DO TO DELIVER THE COMMUNITY 5338 04:24:19,157 --> 04:24:21,659 AROUND QUANTUM COMPUTING. 5339 04:24:21,659 --> 04:24:23,361 THANKS TO IMAG WE HAVE A 5340 04:24:23,361 --> 04:24:25,263 COMMUNITY AND WE NEED TO BRING 5341 04:24:25,263 --> 04:24:28,299 QUANTUM COMPUTING AND QUANTUM 5342 04:24:28,299 --> 04:24:29,334 SENSING AS A SEPARATE GROUP 5343 04:24:29,334 --> 04:24:33,104 WITHIN MSM. 5344 04:24:33,104 --> 04:24:34,973 DELIVERED ABOUT THE MISSION OF 5345 04:24:34,973 --> 04:24:36,574 WHERE WE WANT TO BE AND OUR 5346 04:24:36,574 --> 04:24:39,444 GOALS OVER HOW WE WANT TO REACH 5347 04:24:39,444 --> 04:24:40,311 THE GOALS. 5348 04:24:40,311 --> 04:24:42,547 OBJECTIVES. 5349 04:24:42,547 --> 04:24:44,916 WE ALSO HAVE TO MAKE A CLEAR 5350 04:24:44,916 --> 04:24:46,151 DISTINCTION BETWEEN QUANTUM 5351 04:24:46,151 --> 04:24:47,619 COMPUTING AND QUANTUM SENSING. 5352 04:24:47,619 --> 04:24:48,219 THOSE ARE EXTREMELY IMPORTANT 5353 04:24:48,219 --> 04:24:51,089 THINGS. 5354 04:24:51,089 --> 04:24:52,390 THERE'S POTENTIAL OVERLAP BUT 5355 04:24:52,390 --> 04:24:54,793 DIFFERENT TECHNOLOGIES. 5356 04:24:54,793 --> 04:24:56,561 AND THEY'RE DIFFERENT IN TERMS 5357 04:24:56,561 --> 04:24:58,897 OF THE BARRIERS TO ENTRY. 5358 04:24:58,897 --> 04:25:02,600 QUANTUM COMPUTING CAN BE 5359 04:25:02,600 --> 04:25:03,468 ACCESSED BY PEOPLE TRAINED IN 5360 04:25:03,468 --> 04:25:08,306 CLASSICAL COMPUTING. 5361 04:25:08,306 --> 04:25:09,774 ON THE OTHER HAND QUANTUM 5362 04:25:09,774 --> 04:25:12,310 SENSING IS MORE IN THE REALM OF 5363 04:25:12,310 --> 04:25:12,544 PHYSICS. 5364 04:25:12,544 --> 04:25:15,647 SOMEBODY WOULD HAVE TO GET TO 5365 04:25:15,647 --> 04:25:16,848 THE NITTY-GRITTY OF QUANTUM 5366 04:25:16,848 --> 04:25:18,850 MECHANICS AND BE ABLE TO 5367 04:25:18,850 --> 04:25:21,019 GENERATE DEVICES THOUGH THEY'RE 5368 04:25:21,019 --> 04:25:23,922 ALSO GOING TO BE EXTENSIVELY 5369 04:25:23,922 --> 04:25:26,424 USED IN FOR EXAMPLE MEDICAL 5370 04:25:26,424 --> 04:25:27,859 IMAGING AND SENSING AND 5371 04:25:27,859 --> 04:25:30,228 BIOLOGICAL SENSING. 5372 04:25:30,228 --> 04:25:31,863 THE KIND OF RESOLUTION THEY'LL 5373 04:25:31,863 --> 04:25:34,732 BRING TO THE FIELDS WILL BE 5374 04:25:34,732 --> 04:25:35,967 UNPARALLELED BUT THERE'S TWO 5375 04:25:35,967 --> 04:25:38,636 KINDS OF TECHNOLOGIES WE NEED TO 5376 04:25:38,636 --> 04:25:39,871 BE CAREFUL NOT TO CONFLATE. 5377 04:25:39,871 --> 04:25:43,041 WHAT IS DISCUSSED IS YES, 5378 04:25:43,041 --> 04:25:44,309 QUANTUM SENSING WOULD GIVE RISE 5379 04:25:44,309 --> 04:25:46,744 TO LOTS OF DATA AND BECAUSE 5380 04:25:46,744 --> 04:25:48,646 QUANTUM DATA WOULD BE ABLE TO 5381 04:25:48,646 --> 04:25:51,349 DEAL WITH MASSIVE AMOUNT OF DATA 5382 04:25:51,349 --> 04:25:52,684 THE TWO OVERLAP. 5383 04:25:52,684 --> 04:25:54,619 WE ALSO HAVE TO THINK ABOUT THE 5384 04:25:54,619 --> 04:25:56,287 SECURITY OF THE DATA. 5385 04:25:56,287 --> 04:25:59,257 DATA SECURITY IS PARAMOUNT. 5386 04:25:59,257 --> 04:26:01,359 AS WE KNOW ONE OF THE CURSE OF 5387 04:26:01,359 --> 04:26:04,295 QUANTUM COMPUTING IS IT'S GOING 5388 04:26:04,295 --> 04:26:07,899 TO BE ABLE TO BREACH RSA. 5389 04:26:07,899 --> 04:26:11,336 AND SO WE HAVE TO THINK ABOUT 5390 04:26:11,336 --> 04:26:13,705 QUANTUM SECURITY PARTICULARLY 5391 04:26:13,705 --> 04:26:14,372 FOR BIOLOGICAL AND BIOMEDICAL 5392 04:26:14,372 --> 04:26:22,247 AND BEHAVIORAL DATA. 5393 04:26:22,247 --> 04:26:24,983 WHEN WE DISCUSSED INVOLVING THE 5394 04:26:24,983 --> 04:26:26,251 PROCESS ACROSS ALL DOMAINS IS 5395 04:26:26,251 --> 04:26:27,018 WONDERFUL BECAUSE WE HAVE 5396 04:26:27,018 --> 04:26:29,254 COMPUTER SCIENTISTS AND 5397 04:26:29,254 --> 04:26:30,221 MATHEMATICIANS AN ENGINEERING 5398 04:26:30,221 --> 04:26:33,358 WORK TOGETHER TO SOLVE PROBLEMS 5399 04:26:33,358 --> 04:26:34,492 AND THE DEVELOPING A WORKFORCE 5400 04:26:34,492 --> 04:26:36,294 IS GOING TO BE CRITICAL FOR ALL 5401 04:26:36,294 --> 04:26:39,564 OF US AND THAT IS TO BE 5402 04:26:39,564 --> 04:26:41,733 SUPPORTED BY BOTH THE P.I.s THAT 5403 04:26:41,733 --> 04:26:48,306 IS US, TALKING TO STUDENTS AND 5404 04:26:48,306 --> 04:26:51,643 TALKING ABOUT THE FUNDING 5405 04:26:51,643 --> 04:26:53,077 AGENCIES WILLING TO DELIVER THE 5406 04:26:53,077 --> 04:26:57,181 WORK AND WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT. 5407 04:26:57,181 --> 04:27:03,054 >> YOU HAVE A MINUTE. 5408 04:27:03,054 --> 04:27:05,757 >> SO BASICALLY THE OTHER THING 5409 04:27:05,757 --> 04:27:07,325 WE TALKED ABOUT IS BARRIER TO 5410 04:27:07,325 --> 04:27:09,027 ENTRY WHICH IS CRITICAL FOR US 5411 04:27:09,027 --> 04:27:10,261 TO UNDERSTAND WHAT IS THE 5412 04:27:10,261 --> 04:27:10,962 BARRIER TO ENTRY AND THERE ARE 5413 04:27:10,962 --> 04:27:13,665 QUITE A FEW. 5414 04:27:13,665 --> 04:27:14,499 FOR QUANTUM COMPUTING THE 5415 04:27:14,499 --> 04:27:16,801 BARRIER TO ENTRY IS NOT HUGE. 5416 04:27:16,801 --> 04:27:21,606 IT'S JUST THAT WE HAVE TO WRITE 5417 04:27:21,606 --> 04:27:22,907 ARTICLES AND I'M WORKING ON ONE 5418 04:27:22,907 --> 04:27:24,442 OF THOSE ARTICLES TO MAKE SURE 5419 04:27:24,442 --> 04:27:25,810 PEOPLE CAN UNDERSTAND HOW THEY 5420 04:27:25,810 --> 04:27:28,313 CAN USE LANGUAGES THEY KNOW. 5421 04:27:28,313 --> 04:27:30,748 THE OTHER THING I'D LIKE TO 5422 04:27:30,748 --> 04:27:32,283 PROPOSE IS WE COME UP WITH A 5423 04:27:32,283 --> 04:27:37,155 SPECIAL ISSUE AS WE DID FOR 5424 04:27:37,155 --> 04:27:37,755 MULTISCALE MODELING BRINGING 5425 04:27:37,755 --> 04:27:39,090 TOGETHER VARIOUS VIEW POINTS OF 5426 04:27:39,090 --> 04:27:41,326 RESULTS WE'RE GETTING AND WHAT 5427 04:27:41,326 --> 04:27:43,194 ARE THE QUESTIONS IN THE NEXT 5428 04:27:43,194 --> 04:27:45,697 FIVE TO 10 YEARS THAT DOES A LOT 5429 04:27:45,697 --> 04:27:47,665 OF GOOD THAT BRINGS THE 5430 04:27:47,665 --> 04:27:48,666 DIVERSITY OF THE COMMUNITY 5431 04:27:48,666 --> 04:27:48,933 TOGETHER. 5432 04:27:48,933 --> 04:27:52,303 THIS I THINK IS A SUMMARY OF 5433 04:27:52,303 --> 04:27:56,207 TONS OF DISCUSSIONS WE ALSO HAD 5434 04:27:56,207 --> 04:27:57,809 AT THE BREAK AND IN THE SESSION. 5435 04:27:57,809 --> 04:27:58,576 >> THANK YOU. 5436 04:27:58,576 --> 04:28:00,712 LOOKS LIKE YOU GUYS TALKED ABOUT 5437 04:28:00,712 --> 04:28:02,113 A LOT OF STUFF. 5438 04:28:02,113 --> 04:28:05,049 ANY QUICK COMMENTS? 5439 04:28:05,049 --> 04:28:05,316 QUESTIONS? 5440 04:28:05,316 --> 04:28:07,618 >> QUICK COMMENT, I WISH I COULD 5441 04:28:07,618 --> 04:28:10,021 BE IN THIS MEETING BUT I WAS IN 5442 04:28:10,021 --> 04:28:12,290 THE MACHINE LEARNING ONE. 5443 04:28:12,290 --> 04:28:13,491 THERE'S AN OVERLAP BETWEEN 5444 04:28:13,491 --> 04:28:15,660 MACHINE LEARNING AND QUANTUM 5445 04:28:15,660 --> 04:28:17,362 COMPUTING AND WHAT YOU SAID IS 5446 04:28:17,362 --> 04:28:21,199 GOING TO HAPPEN IS ALREADY 5447 04:28:21,199 --> 04:28:27,105 HAPPENING AND LAST WEEK SOMEONE 5448 04:28:27,105 --> 04:28:28,406 PRESENTED THE COMBINATION OF 5449 04:28:28,406 --> 04:28:29,340 THOSE TWO. 5450 04:28:29,340 --> 04:28:31,209 PEOPLE ARE ALREADY WORKING IN 5451 04:28:31,209 --> 04:28:32,977 INDUSTRY AND PROMOTING THIS AND 5452 04:28:32,977 --> 04:28:34,946 YOU CAN SIMULATE THINGS ON THE 5453 04:28:34,946 --> 04:28:35,880 COMPUTER TODAY. 5454 04:28:35,880 --> 04:28:36,214 QUICK COMMENT. 5455 04:28:36,214 --> 04:28:38,850 >> THANKS FOR THE COMMENT. 5456 04:28:38,850 --> 04:28:39,117 EXCELLENT. 5457 04:28:39,117 --> 04:28:41,052 IN THE INTEREST OF TIME LET'S 5458 04:28:41,052 --> 04:28:46,090 MOVE ON TO BREAKOUT SESSION 5. 5459 04:28:46,090 --> 04:28:51,829 WE HAVE ABOUT FIVE MINUTES TO 5460 04:28:51,829 --> 04:28:53,264 WRAP THAT UP. 5461 04:28:53,264 --> 04:28:55,099 >> THANK YOU. 5462 04:28:55,099 --> 04:28:58,436 OUR SESSION WAS TRANSLATION AND 5463 04:28:58,436 --> 04:29:03,574 INCENTIVIZATION AND THE TALKS 5464 04:29:03,574 --> 04:29:04,342 PARALLELED THE OTHER BREAKOUT 5465 04:29:04,342 --> 04:29:08,679 DISCUSSIONS. 5466 04:29:08,679 --> 04:29:09,981 WE DISCUSSED MANY DIFFERENT 5467 04:29:09,981 --> 04:29:11,749 APPLICATIONS FOR MEDICAL DEVICES 5468 04:29:11,749 --> 04:29:20,291 AND FOR PHARMACOLOGY AND IMAGING 5469 04:29:20,291 --> 04:29:23,461 AND WE HAD TOOLS TO TEST BLACK 5470 04:29:23,461 --> 04:29:26,597 BOX A.I. DEVICES. 5471 04:29:26,597 --> 04:29:27,865 SPECIFICALLY MSM TOOLS ARE 5472 04:29:27,865 --> 04:29:30,301 REUSABLE BY OTHER MODELERS AND 5473 04:29:30,301 --> 04:29:33,771 CAN GENERATE NEW TOOLS AND WE 5474 04:29:33,771 --> 04:29:35,239 GET TO MODEL THE PHYSIOLOGY AT 5475 04:29:35,239 --> 04:29:40,278 DIFFERENT SCALES. 5476 04:29:40,278 --> 04:29:41,879 MSM TOOLS CAN BE USED BY 5477 04:29:41,879 --> 04:29:46,684 DIFFERENT STAKEHOLDERS IN 5478 04:29:46,684 --> 04:29:48,019 ACADEMIA AND GOVERNMENT AND 5479 04:29:48,019 --> 04:29:52,290 NATIONAL LABS AND MSM TOOLS CAN 5480 04:29:52,290 --> 04:29:54,625 BE USED TO GENERATE SYNTHETIC 5481 04:29:54,625 --> 04:29:56,294 DATA AS OTHER DISCUSSIONS HAVE 5482 04:29:56,294 --> 04:29:56,561 DISCUSSED. 5483 04:29:56,561 --> 04:29:59,664 OUR COMMON GOAL IS WE WANT TO 5484 04:29:59,664 --> 04:30:02,200 MAKE TOOLS SUSTAINABLE AND LONG 5485 04:30:02,200 --> 04:30:03,601 LIVED AND CAN BE USED FROM YEAR 5486 04:30:03,601 --> 04:30:10,241 TO YEAR AND CAN BE VALIDATED. 5487 04:30:10,241 --> 04:30:12,143 THEY'LL CONTINUE ON AND ON IN 5488 04:30:12,143 --> 04:30:13,044 OUR CHANGING WORLD. 5489 04:30:13,044 --> 04:30:15,079 ONE NEXT STEP WE THOUGHT WOULD 5490 04:30:15,079 --> 04:30:17,381 BE USEFUL IS TO CREATE A 5491 04:30:17,381 --> 04:30:19,617 REPOSITORY AT DIFFERENT SCALES 5492 04:30:19,617 --> 04:30:21,552 TO INCORPORATE MANY OF THE 5493 04:30:21,552 --> 04:30:22,653 TOPICS THAT WERE COVERED IN THE 5494 04:30:22,653 --> 04:30:23,754 WORKSHOP AND BREAKOUT SESSIONS 5495 04:30:23,754 --> 04:30:28,126 SO THE TOOLS ARE STANDARDIZED, 5496 04:30:28,126 --> 04:30:29,360 THE PROCESS WILL FACILITATE THE 5497 04:30:29,360 --> 04:30:31,129 FACT THAT WE CAN TRANSLATE THE 5498 04:30:31,129 --> 04:30:31,929 TOOLS, WE CAN VALIDATE THEM AND 5499 04:30:31,929 --> 04:30:35,433 REUSE THEM. 5500 04:30:35,433 --> 04:30:37,835 APART FROM WHAT WOULD HELP US 5501 04:30:37,835 --> 04:30:41,105 MAKE TOOLS THAT ARE NOT LANGUAGE 5502 04:30:41,105 --> 04:30:42,440 DEPENDENT AND USE THEM ACROSS 5503 04:30:42,440 --> 04:30:43,774 PYTHON AND WHATEVER LANGUAGE 5504 04:30:43,774 --> 04:30:46,110 TYPE YOU USE TO WRITE AND CAN 5505 04:30:46,110 --> 04:30:47,278 INCORPORATE NEW DATA AND 5506 04:30:47,278 --> 04:30:51,149 VALIDATION BY A COMMUNITY. 5507 04:30:51,149 --> 04:30:53,351 AND THIS WOULD FACILITATE MAKING 5508 04:30:53,351 --> 04:30:57,755 TOOLS THAT ARE ADAPTABLE. 5509 04:30:57,755 --> 04:30:59,157 THERE WERE A COUPLE CONCLUSIONS. 5510 04:30:59,157 --> 04:31:01,292 WE WANT TO HAVE STANDARDS AND 5511 04:31:01,292 --> 04:31:02,827 DESIGNS DRIVEN BY THE COMMUNITY. 5512 04:31:02,827 --> 04:31:05,730 SO WE WANT TO BRING TOGETHER 5513 04:31:05,730 --> 04:31:07,498 DIFFERENT ATTENDEES FROM IMAGO 5514 04:31:07,498 --> 04:31:09,800 AND MSM AND HELP US CREATE 5515 04:31:09,800 --> 04:31:12,303 SOMETHING THAT CAN BE USED BY 5516 04:31:12,303 --> 04:31:13,437 MANY DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES 5517 04:31:13,437 --> 04:31:14,005 TOGETHER. 5518 04:31:14,005 --> 04:31:19,110 AND FINALLY, IT WOULD BE 5519 04:31:19,110 --> 04:31:22,613 IMPORTANT TO SEE THIS PLATFORM 5520 04:31:22,613 --> 04:31:23,948 WILL HELP ME UNDERSTAND WHAT I'M 5521 04:31:23,948 --> 04:31:25,716 DOING AND WHAT ARE YOU DOING? 5522 04:31:25,716 --> 04:31:28,686 WHAT SHOULD I WORK ON NEXT TO 5523 04:31:28,686 --> 04:31:33,090 FACILITATE PROGRESS SO WE'RE NOT 5524 04:31:33,090 --> 04:31:34,959 ALL WORKING ON THE SAME THING. 5525 04:31:34,959 --> 04:31:36,928 >> THAT'S A GREAT SUMMARY. 5526 04:31:36,928 --> 04:31:38,629 I WAS TRYING TO THINK ANYTHING 5527 04:31:38,629 --> 04:31:39,797 ELSE THAT CAME UP. 5528 04:31:39,797 --> 04:31:44,735 MAYBE GO BACK TO THE EQUITY 5529 04:31:44,735 --> 04:31:45,803 POINT AND EARLIER THAT WAS ONE 5530 04:31:45,803 --> 04:31:47,338 THING WE TALKED ABOUT ALSO IN 5531 04:31:47,338 --> 04:31:49,340 CONNECTION WITH MAKING SURE THE 5532 04:31:49,340 --> 04:31:50,708 MODELS AND TOOLS ARE LONG LIVED 5533 04:31:50,708 --> 04:31:53,344 AND REUSED. 5534 04:31:53,344 --> 04:31:55,313 MAKING SURE THAT IT'S POSSIBLE 5535 04:31:55,313 --> 04:31:56,214 SAYING IF THEY'RE ORIGINALLY 5536 04:31:56,214 --> 04:31:58,149 CREATED WITH THE SET OF DATA 5537 04:31:58,149 --> 04:31:59,250 RESTRICTED TO ONE GROUP OF 5538 04:31:59,250 --> 04:32:00,284 PEOPLE, IT'S POSSIBLE TO BRING 5539 04:32:00,284 --> 04:32:02,253 IN NEW DATA AND POPULATIONS AND 5540 04:32:02,253 --> 04:32:03,054 ALL THOSE THINGS. 5541 04:32:03,054 --> 04:32:06,290 IT'S VERY MUCH IN THE STRUCTURE. 5542 04:32:06,290 --> 04:32:08,292 >> GREAT. 5543 04:32:08,292 --> 04:32:11,629 THANK YOU FOR THE SUMMARY. 5544 04:32:11,629 --> 04:32:12,296 QUESTIONS, COMMENTS? 5545 04:32:12,296 --> 04:32:13,464 >> I HAVE A QUESTION. 5546 04:32:13,464 --> 04:32:15,333 SO WHAT WOULD BE THE PLAN FOR 5547 04:32:15,333 --> 04:32:20,304 CREATING THIS REPOSITORY GIVEN 5548 04:32:20,304 --> 04:32:22,206 THERE ARE THOUSANDS AND MODELS 5549 04:32:22,206 --> 04:32:23,841 AND TOOLS AN DATABASES THOUGHT. 5550 04:32:23,841 --> 04:32:27,378 HOW WOULD YOU VET AND DECIDE HOW 5551 04:32:27,378 --> 04:32:29,347 TO PUT THE WHATEVER STAMP YOU 5552 04:32:29,347 --> 04:32:31,582 THINK YOU WANT TO PUT ON? 5553 04:32:31,582 --> 04:32:33,551 >> SO THIS IS SOMETHING THAT WE 5554 04:32:33,551 --> 04:32:33,918 DISCUSSED. 5555 04:32:33,918 --> 04:32:36,721 I THINK IT COULD BE A 5556 04:32:36,721 --> 04:32:38,556 POTENTIALLY MODULAR FRAMEWORK. 5557 04:32:38,556 --> 04:32:40,291 WE TALKED ABOUT CREDIBILITY AND 5558 04:32:40,291 --> 04:32:42,927 LANGUAGES THAT CAN BE USED TO 5559 04:32:42,927 --> 04:32:44,262 CULL DIFFERENT TOOLS TOGETHER 5560 04:32:44,262 --> 04:32:47,131 INTO A COMMON FORMAT. 5561 04:32:47,131 --> 04:32:48,633 THERE ARE CREDIBILITY PRACTICES 5562 04:32:48,633 --> 04:32:52,236 THAT WE CAN INCORPORATE AND AS A 5563 04:32:52,236 --> 04:32:53,771 COUNT WE CAN COME UP WITH A WAY 5564 04:32:53,771 --> 04:32:55,740 TO CREATE ONE STANDARD 5565 04:32:55,740 --> 04:32:57,575 REPOSITORY THAT IS MANAGED BUT 5566 04:32:57,575 --> 04:33:01,545 THE FEEDBACK ON HOW TO CREATE IT 5567 04:33:01,545 --> 04:33:02,280 WOULD COME FROM MEETINGS LIKE 5568 04:33:02,280 --> 04:33:07,151 THIS. 5569 04:33:07,151 --> 04:33:08,286 >> ONE MORE QUESTION? 5570 04:33:08,286 --> 04:33:10,388 >> I THINK THIS IS GREAT AND YOU 5571 04:33:10,388 --> 04:33:11,956 PROBABLY DISCUSSED THIS TOO BUT 5572 04:33:11,956 --> 04:33:13,090 WANTED TO SEE IF YOU CAN SPEAK 5573 04:33:13,090 --> 04:33:14,425 ON WHETHER YOU TALKED ABOUT THE 5574 04:33:14,425 --> 04:33:16,861 ROLE OF UNCERTAINTY IN 5575 04:33:16,861 --> 04:33:18,362 DEVELOPING THE TRANSLATIONAL 5576 04:33:18,362 --> 04:33:21,098 TOOLS TO UNDERSTAND WHAT ARE THE 5577 04:33:21,098 --> 04:33:22,700 UNCERTAINTIES IN THE INPUT IN 5578 04:33:22,700 --> 04:33:23,934 DATA AND AS WE DEVELOP TOOLS 5579 04:33:23,934 --> 04:33:26,037 WHAT'S THE UNCERTAINTY IN OUR 5580 04:33:26,037 --> 04:33:28,072 PREDICTIVE CAPABILITIES AND 5581 04:33:28,072 --> 04:33:32,276 UNCERTAINTIES IN OUR OUTPUTS? 5582 04:33:32,276 --> 04:33:35,780 >> I WILL TRY TO REPEAT THE 5583 04:33:35,780 --> 04:33:37,315 QUESTION, I'M NOT SURE I 5584 04:33:37,315 --> 04:33:38,749 UNDERSTOOD IT BUT IS THE 5585 04:33:38,749 --> 04:33:40,251 QUESTION HOW TO MODEL 5586 04:33:40,251 --> 04:33:40,551 UNCERTAINTY? 5587 04:33:40,551 --> 04:33:44,588 AND TO WHAT -- 5588 04:33:44,588 --> 04:33:46,691 >> AND TO WHAT EXTENT YOU NEED 5589 04:33:46,691 --> 04:33:49,060 TO ACCOUNT FOR IT WHEN BUILDING 5590 04:33:49,060 --> 04:33:49,827 A TRANSLATIONAL TOOLS. 5591 04:33:49,827 --> 04:33:51,829 >> WE TALKED ABOUT HOW TO 5592 04:33:51,829 --> 04:33:56,934 VALIDATE TOOLS AND MAKE IT CAN 5593 04:33:56,934 --> 04:34:01,706 BE CAPABILITY AND FOR OTHERS WE 5594 04:34:01,706 --> 04:34:04,141 DO NOT AND GIVE JON WE CAN 5595 04:34:04,141 --> 04:34:05,242 RELEASE AND SHARE TOOLS 5596 04:34:05,242 --> 04:34:08,546 EVERYBODY CAN USE WE CAN ALSO 5597 04:34:08,546 --> 04:34:12,583 SHARE THE VALIDATION PIPELINES 5598 04:34:12,583 --> 04:34:14,251 AND SEE HOW THE COMMUNITY HELPS 5599 04:34:14,251 --> 04:34:18,222 VALIDATE SOME OF THESE THINGS. 5600 04:34:18,222 --> 04:34:19,857 >> GREAT. 5601 04:34:19,857 --> 04:34:23,094 GARY, ONE MORE COMMENT. 5602 04:34:23,094 --> 04:34:30,000 >> HOW IS THIS DIFFERENT THAN 5603 04:34:30,000 --> 04:34:31,702 THE THING DR. SAURO'S DOING AND 5604 04:34:31,702 --> 04:34:33,838 DR. HUNTER IS DOING, THE 5605 04:34:33,838 --> 04:34:36,307 MULTIPLE MODEL REPOSITORIES. 5606 04:34:36,307 --> 04:34:39,110 ALL THESE TYPES OF THINGS. 5607 04:34:39,110 --> 04:34:39,944 HOW IS THIS DIFFERENT OR 5608 04:34:39,944 --> 04:34:42,513 DIFFERENT FROM THAT? 5609 04:34:42,513 --> 04:34:43,814 >> IT IS VERY SIMILAR AND BASED 5610 04:34:43,814 --> 04:34:44,949 ON THOSE EFFORTS BUT WHAT WE 5611 04:34:44,949 --> 04:34:46,584 NEED IS SOMETHING BIGGER. 5612 04:34:46,584 --> 04:34:51,655 WE CANNOT -- WE WANT TO MAKE IT 5613 04:34:51,655 --> 04:34:53,391 AT DIFFERENT LEVELS, ORGAN LEVEL 5614 04:34:53,391 --> 04:34:56,727 AND BODY LEVEL AND STARTING AT 5615 04:34:56,727 --> 04:34:57,728 THE CELLULAR LEVEL START FROM 5616 04:34:57,728 --> 04:34:58,929 THE BOTTOM UP TO THE FULL 5617 04:34:58,929 --> 04:35:00,297 PICTURE. 5618 04:35:00,297 --> 04:35:03,901 >> OKAY. 5619 04:35:03,901 --> 04:35:04,602 >> OKAY. 5620 04:35:04,602 --> 04:35:10,174 WE'RE BACK ON SCHEDULE. 5621 04:35:10,174 --> 04:35:16,747 SO THE LAST 15 MINUTES, 4:15 TO 5622 04:35:16,747 --> 04:35:20,117 4:30 WE'RE SCHEDULED FOR NEXT 5623 04:35:20,117 --> 04:35:21,552 STEPS AND WRAP-UP AND THANK YOU 5624 04:35:21,552 --> 04:35:23,387 THE SESSION LEADS FOR LEADING 5625 04:35:23,387 --> 04:35:27,591 YOUR BREAKOUT SESSIONS. 5626 04:35:27,591 --> 04:35:29,894 I WANTED TO INSIGHT BACK UP ALL 5627 04:35:29,894 --> 04:35:32,296 THE PLANNING COMMITTEE MEMBERS 5628 04:35:32,296 --> 04:35:42,540 AND CO-CHAIRS. 5629 04:35:43,641 --> 04:35:44,175 WE'RE WELCOME TO STAY HERE IF 5630 04:35:44,175 --> 04:35:46,377 YOU WANT. 5631 04:35:46,377 --> 04:35:50,247 >> WE'RE BLIND ED 5632 04:35:51,182 --> 04:35:51,182 5633 04:35:59,089 --> 04:35:59,857 >> THE LAST SESSION. 5634 04:35:59,857 --> 04:36:00,491 THANK YOU ALL FOR STICKING TO 5635 04:36:00,491 --> 04:36:03,961 THE END. 5636 04:36:03,961 --> 04:36:05,396 THIS IS TO THE MOST EXCITING 5637 04:36:05,396 --> 04:36:05,729 SESSION. 5638 04:36:05,729 --> 04:36:09,600 WHAT DO WE WANT TO DO NEXT? 5639 04:36:09,600 --> 04:36:12,303 SO DID WE EVER GET ANYWHERE WITH 5640 04:36:12,303 --> 04:36:13,904 THAT WORD CLOUD, HERBERT? 5641 04:36:13,904 --> 04:36:17,374 >> NO. 5642 04:36:17,374 --> 04:36:20,311 LAST TIME I LOOKED I HAVE NINE 5643 04:36:20,311 --> 04:36:23,214 ENTRIES. 5644 04:36:23,214 --> 04:36:25,349 NOT MUCH OF A CLOUD WITH NINE 5645 04:36:25,349 --> 04:36:25,850 ENTRIES. 5646 04:36:25,850 --> 04:36:36,360 >> MUST HAVE BEEN A WILDFIRE. 5647 04:36:39,096 --> 04:36:42,533 >> LET'S LOOK AT IT. 5648 04:36:42,533 --> 04:36:47,004 IT WAS INTENTIONAL FOR YOU IT 5649 04:36:47,004 --> 04:36:47,938 LOOK AT THE WIKI. 5650 04:36:47,938 --> 04:36:48,606 DID YOU WANT TO COMMENT. 5651 04:36:48,606 --> 04:36:50,608 THERE'S MORE THAN NINE. 5652 04:36:50,608 --> 04:36:53,043 >> YOU'RE RIGHT, ONE, TWO, 5653 04:36:53,043 --> 04:36:57,181 THREE, FOUR, FIVE, SIX, SEVEN, 5654 04:36:57,181 --> 04:36:58,382 EIGHT -- WE HAVE TEN. 5655 04:36:58,382 --> 04:37:07,525 WE HAVE A RANGE OF RESPONSES. 5656 04:37:07,525 --> 04:37:10,227 I'M NOT SURE WHAT ELSE TO SAY 5657 04:37:10,227 --> 04:37:11,095 ABOUT IT. 5658 04:37:11,095 --> 04:37:15,366 >> IS IT REFLECTIVE? 5659 04:37:15,366 --> 04:37:18,269 >> IT'S NOTHING ABOUT A.I. 5660 04:37:18,269 --> 04:37:19,169 THERE SHOULD BE MORE MACHINE 5661 04:37:19,169 --> 04:37:20,304 LEARNING HERE. 5662 04:37:20,304 --> 04:37:30,514 I'M JOKING. 5663 04:37:39,723 --> 04:37:41,392 >> WHAT ABOUT THE APPLICATIONS. 5664 04:37:41,392 --> 04:37:42,560 >> BROAD RANGE. 5665 04:37:42,560 --> 04:37:46,096 >> DISEASE MODELLING IS PRETTY 5666 04:37:46,096 --> 04:37:46,330 GENERAL. 5667 04:37:46,330 --> 04:37:49,033 >> ONE OF THE STRENGTHS OF THIS 5668 04:37:49,033 --> 04:37:49,500 COMMUNITY I THINK. 5669 04:37:49,500 --> 04:37:52,303 >> AND THE PICTURES? 5670 04:37:52,303 --> 04:37:59,877 ALL RIGHT. 5671 04:37:59,877 --> 04:38:00,110 OKAY. 5672 04:38:00,110 --> 04:38:01,245 WELL, THANK YOU FOR THAT. 5673 04:38:01,245 --> 04:38:03,547 AND SO LET'S GO TO THE FINAL 5674 04:38:03,547 --> 04:38:04,281 SESSION. 5675 04:38:04,281 --> 04:38:07,718 IF YOU ALL CAN SIT AT THE TABLE. 5676 04:38:07,718 --> 04:38:11,388 IT WOULD BE GREAT IF WE CAN HASH 5677 04:38:11,388 --> 04:38:18,996 OUT THE FINAL THOUGHTS. 5678 04:38:18,996 --> 04:38:23,367 AM I SPEAKING IN THE WRONG MIC? 5679 04:38:23,367 --> 04:38:24,702 CAN YOU ALL HEAR ME? 5680 04:38:24,702 --> 04:38:25,402 SORRY ABOUT THAT. 5681 04:38:25,402 --> 04:38:27,671 FOR THOSE ON VIDEOCAST WE WERE 5682 04:38:27,671 --> 04:38:29,373 JUST LOOKING AT A COMPILATION OF 5683 04:38:29,373 --> 04:38:31,342 FAVORITE METHODS AND 5684 04:38:31,342 --> 04:38:33,510 APPLICATIONS AND OUR PAST 5685 04:38:33,510 --> 04:38:35,813 PICTURES AND WE'RE THINKING OF 5686 04:38:35,813 --> 04:38:36,747 EVERYBODY WHO ORGANIZED THIS 5687 04:38:36,747 --> 04:38:38,782 MEETING AND WE ARE NOW AT THE 5688 04:38:38,782 --> 04:38:41,852 VERY LAST SESSION WHERE WE'RE 5689 04:38:41,852 --> 04:38:43,287 TALKING ABOUT FUTURE DIRECTIONS. 5690 04:38:43,287 --> 04:38:46,090 AND SO WHEN I OPENED UP THE 5691 04:38:46,090 --> 04:38:48,025 MEETING I ASKED EVERYBODY TO 5692 04:38:48,025 --> 04:38:49,226 THINK ABOUT WHEN YOU'RE SITTING 5693 04:38:49,226 --> 04:38:51,862 IN THIS MEETING FOR THESE TWO 5694 04:38:51,862 --> 04:38:53,931 DAYS, WHAT ARE SOME ACTIONABLE 5695 04:38:53,931 --> 04:38:57,534 NEXT STEPS AND WE USED THE FIRST 5696 04:38:57,534 --> 04:39:00,304 DAY TO RECAP WHAT WONDERFUL 5697 04:39:00,304 --> 04:39:03,474 THINGS IN THE LAST 20 YEARS AND 5698 04:39:03,474 --> 04:39:04,642 LESSONED LEARNED AND THINKING 5699 04:39:04,642 --> 04:39:06,777 ABOUT THE CURRENT PROJECTS AND 5700 04:39:06,777 --> 04:39:07,911 NEW INVESTIGATORS AND EARLY 5701 04:39:07,911 --> 04:39:09,546 CAREER INVESTIGATORS THAT WERE 5702 04:39:09,546 --> 04:39:11,348 HIGHLIGHTED IN THIS MEETING AND 5703 04:39:11,348 --> 04:39:16,320 HOW THEY CAN PREPARE US FOR THE 5704 04:39:16,320 --> 04:39:18,355 FUTURE OF THE MULTISCALE 5705 04:39:18,355 --> 04:39:18,822 MODELING INITIATIVE. 5706 04:39:18,822 --> 04:39:19,890 TODAY WE THOUGHT ABOUT OUR 5707 04:39:19,890 --> 04:39:22,326 MISSION STATEMENT AND OUR 5708 04:39:22,326 --> 04:39:23,627 BREAKOUTS ALSO CONSIDERED THE 5709 04:39:23,627 --> 04:39:24,495 MISSION STATEMENT WITHIN THE 5710 04:39:24,495 --> 04:39:27,498 FIVE TOPICS WE JUST TALKED ABOUT 5711 04:39:27,498 --> 04:39:29,800 AND MADE SOME ACTIONABLE PLANS 5712 04:39:29,800 --> 04:39:33,137 BUT I WOULD LIKE TO SAY NOW WHAT 5713 04:39:33,137 --> 04:39:35,806 DO WE WANT TO DO IN TERMS OF ANY 5714 04:39:35,806 --> 04:39:40,110 CHANGES WE WANT TO MAKE TO THE 5715 04:39:40,110 --> 04:39:40,744 MULTISCALE MODELING CONSORTIUM 5716 04:39:40,744 --> 04:39:45,516 IN GENERAL IN OUR ACTIVITIES AND 5717 04:39:45,516 --> 04:39:46,884 THEN WHETHER OR NOT OR NOT WE 5718 04:39:46,884 --> 04:39:48,018 WANT A MEETING NEXT YEAR. 5719 04:39:48,018 --> 04:39:52,489 I'LL STOP HERE AND LET FOLKS 5720 04:39:52,489 --> 04:39:53,590 CHIME IN. 5721 04:39:53,590 --> 04:40:00,130 THERE ARE SOME POSTS ACTUALLY. 5722 04:40:00,130 --> 04:40:01,165 POSTER SESSION NEEDS RENOVATION 5723 04:40:01,165 --> 04:40:11,408 TOWARDS INTERACTIVE POSTERS. 5724 04:40:11,408 --> 04:40:12,076 ANYTHING ELSE? 5725 04:40:12,076 --> 04:40:13,577 GARY. 5726 04:40:13,577 --> 04:40:15,479 >> I THINK WE SHOULD HAVE A 5727 04:40:15,479 --> 04:40:17,381 MEETING NEXT YEAR AND I THINK IT 5728 04:40:17,381 --> 04:40:19,850 WOULD BE VERY NICE IF THE 5729 04:40:19,850 --> 04:40:21,151 MEETING WAS STRUCTURED AROUND 5730 04:40:21,151 --> 04:40:22,653 THE TOPICS THAT WERE JUST 5731 04:40:22,653 --> 04:40:25,789 PRESENTED AT THE BREAKOUT. 5732 04:40:25,789 --> 04:40:27,091 SEEMS LIKE THERE'S CLEARLY A LOT 5733 04:40:27,091 --> 04:40:28,392 OF DISCUSSION AND DEVELOPMENT 5734 04:40:28,392 --> 04:40:31,361 THAT'S RELATED ALONG THOSE TYPES 5735 04:40:31,361 --> 04:40:35,499 THEMES AND IT WOULD ALSO GIVE US 5736 04:40:35,499 --> 04:40:37,668 AN OPPORTUNITY TO EXPLORE 5737 04:40:37,668 --> 04:40:38,469 SYNERGIES ACROSS THOSE 5738 04:40:38,469 --> 04:40:48,946 PARTICULAR BREAKOUT TOPICS. 5739 04:40:53,550 --> 04:40:54,651 >> OKAY. 5740 04:40:54,651 --> 04:40:56,220 ANY VOLUNTEERS TO HELP ORGANIZE 5741 04:40:56,220 --> 04:40:57,121 THIS MEETING? 5742 04:40:57,121 --> 04:41:07,231 >> NO. 5743 04:41:08,365 --> 04:41:08,799 MAYBE. 5744 04:41:08,799 --> 04:41:16,306 >> CAN YOU STATE YOUR NAME? 5745 04:41:16,306 --> 04:41:26,550 >> JOHN RICE. 5746 04:41:30,354 --> 04:41:31,455 >> JOHN DID ATTEMPT DURING THE 5747 04:41:31,455 --> 04:41:31,722 PANDEMIC. 5748 04:41:31,722 --> 04:41:41,665 I CAN VOUCH FOR THAT. 5749 04:41:41,665 --> 04:41:41,932 ALL RIGHT. 5750 04:41:41,932 --> 04:41:46,069 ANY OTHER COMMENTS? 5751 04:41:46,069 --> 04:41:48,939 I THOUGHT YOU WERE VOLUNTEERING, 5752 04:41:48,939 --> 04:41:49,206 HERBERT. 5753 04:41:49,206 --> 04:41:50,574 ALL RIGHT. 5754 04:41:50,574 --> 04:41:51,408 NEXT TOPIC. 5755 04:41:51,408 --> 04:41:54,745 >> I ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO 5756 04:41:54,745 --> 04:41:55,546 CONSIDER CO-CHAIRING THE 5757 04:41:55,546 --> 04:41:55,913 MEETING. 5758 04:41:55,913 --> 04:42:01,952 ALL JOKING ASIDE IT'S WAS GREAT 5759 04:42:01,952 --> 04:42:02,519 WORKING WITH THE WHOLE 5760 04:42:02,519 --> 04:42:04,254 ORGANIZING COMMITTEE AND IT'S A 5761 04:42:04,254 --> 04:42:08,725 GREAT OPPORTUNITY TO MEET 5762 04:42:08,725 --> 04:42:10,260 DIFFERENT PEOPLE, LEARN 5763 04:42:10,260 --> 04:42:12,296 DIFFERENT THINGS AND MEET 5764 04:42:12,296 --> 04:42:14,765 DIFFERENT SECTORS OF THE IMAG 5765 04:42:14,765 --> 04:42:16,700 CONSORTIUM YOU MAY NOT BE AWARE 5766 04:42:16,700 --> 04:42:17,367 OF. 5767 04:42:17,367 --> 04:42:20,103 I WANT TO ENCOURAGE EVERYONE TO 5768 04:42:20,103 --> 04:42:21,338 DO THIS. 5769 04:42:21,338 --> 04:42:22,439 IT'S MY SECOND TIME AROUND 5770 04:42:22,439 --> 04:42:23,540 CO-CHAIRING THE MEETING. 5771 04:42:23,540 --> 04:42:25,142 IF YOU DO IT ONCE YOU'RE 5772 04:42:25,142 --> 04:42:26,243 INTERESTED A SECOND TIME. 5773 04:42:26,243 --> 04:42:28,278 >> THIS IS BRUCE'S SECOND TIME 5774 04:42:28,278 --> 04:42:32,182 FOR SURE. 5775 04:42:32,182 --> 04:42:37,321 >> ONE THING I COULD ADD FOR THE 5776 04:42:37,321 --> 04:42:37,554 FUTURE. 5777 04:42:37,554 --> 04:42:39,223 MANY TRAINEES WE DON'T HAVE 5778 04:42:39,223 --> 04:42:41,191 ANYTHING FOR TRAINEES, Ph.D. 5779 04:42:41,191 --> 04:42:41,458 STUDENTS. 5780 04:42:41,458 --> 04:42:48,732 IT WOULD BE NICE IF WE HAD SOME 5781 04:42:48,732 --> 04:42:50,701 SPECIAL TIME FOR THEM BECAUSE 5782 04:42:50,701 --> 04:42:52,302 THEY'RE OUR FUTURE ALONG WITH 5783 04:42:52,302 --> 04:42:53,203 THE POSTDOCS AS WELL. 5784 04:42:53,203 --> 04:42:56,306 AND I KNOW THERE'S A COUPLE 5785 04:42:56,306 --> 04:43:01,411 TRAINEES HERE THIS WEEK. 5786 04:43:01,411 --> 04:43:03,647 >> WHAT ABOUT DIVERSITY IN OUR 5787 04:43:03,647 --> 04:43:03,914 AUDIENCE? 5788 04:43:03,914 --> 04:43:08,385 >> I WAS GOING TO ADD UNDER 5789 04:43:08,385 --> 04:43:11,154 REPRESENTS GROUPS IS SOMETHING 5790 04:43:11,154 --> 04:43:12,389 FOR THAT AS WELL ALONG WITH WHAT 5791 04:43:12,389 --> 04:43:22,633 HERBERT SAID. 5792 04:43:25,636 --> 04:43:28,305 >> ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT 5793 04:43:28,305 --> 04:43:29,006 INVITING TO THE CONSORTIUM IN 5794 04:43:29,006 --> 04:43:39,449 GENERAL OR TO THE MEETING? 5795 04:43:41,451 --> 04:43:44,955 >> I'VE ALSO RUN INTO A LOT OF 5796 04:43:44,955 --> 04:43:46,757 PEOPLE WHO ARE IN FACT AT 5797 04:43:46,757 --> 04:43:47,758 VARIOUS TRAINING LEVELS AND 5798 04:43:47,758 --> 04:43:48,892 FRUSTRATED BY THE FACT THAT THEY 5799 04:43:48,892 --> 04:43:52,062 HAVE TO FOCUS ON ONE SPECIFIC 5800 04:43:52,062 --> 04:43:52,262 AREA. 5801 04:43:52,262 --> 04:43:54,932 WHEN I TELL THEM ABOUT 5802 04:43:54,932 --> 04:43:56,066 MULTISCALE MODELING THEY GET 5803 04:43:56,066 --> 04:43:57,434 EXTREMELY INTRIGUED. 5804 04:43:57,434 --> 04:44:00,170 I THINK THERE'S A HUGE UNPACKED 5805 04:44:00,170 --> 04:44:02,773 POPULATION OUT THERE OF PEOPLE 5806 04:44:02,773 --> 04:44:05,976 WHO WOULD INHERENTLY LIKE TO BE 5807 04:44:05,976 --> 04:44:08,011 MULTISCALE MODELERS BUT THE 5808 04:44:08,011 --> 04:44:09,813 TRAINING SYSTEM, THE EDUCATION 5809 04:44:09,813 --> 04:44:11,114 SYSTEM DOES NOT ENCOURAGE THAT. 5810 04:44:11,114 --> 04:44:14,051 SO WE MIGHT WANT TO THINK ABOUT 5811 04:44:14,051 --> 04:44:18,355 HOW TO ENGAGE THOSE INDIVIDUALS 5812 04:44:18,355 --> 04:44:22,192 BECAUSE CERTAINLY WE HAVE PEOPLE 5813 04:44:22,192 --> 04:44:24,861 ALREADY IN LABS OF 5814 04:44:24,861 --> 04:44:25,762 SELF-IDENTIFIED MULTISCALE 5815 04:44:25,762 --> 04:44:26,663 MODELERS BUT WE'RE LIMITING 5816 04:44:26,663 --> 04:44:28,098 OURSELVES I THINK. 5817 04:44:28,098 --> 04:44:32,369 >> YOU'RE SAYING THE NATURE OF 5818 04:44:32,369 --> 04:44:33,236 MULTISCALE MODELING IS SO 5819 04:44:33,236 --> 04:44:34,338 FOCUSSED IT'S NARROW. 5820 04:44:34,338 --> 04:44:35,238 >> OPPOSITE. 5821 04:44:35,238 --> 04:44:36,740 PEOPLE ARE FRUSTRATED BY THE 5822 04:44:36,740 --> 04:44:39,009 FACT THEY FEEL THEY HAVE TO 5823 04:44:39,009 --> 04:44:40,978 FOCUS ON ONE SPECIFIC AREA AP 5824 04:44:40,978 --> 04:44:41,878 WOULD RATHER CROSS SCALES BUT 5825 04:44:41,878 --> 04:44:43,981 THEY'RE NOT AWARE OF THIS 5826 04:44:43,981 --> 04:44:45,182 CONSORTIUM. 5827 04:44:45,182 --> 04:44:46,850 THEY'RE NOT AWARE OF MULTISCALE 5828 04:44:46,850 --> 04:44:47,217 MODELING. 5829 04:44:47,217 --> 04:44:50,921 I THINK IT'S A GREAT WAY FOR US 5830 04:44:50,921 --> 04:44:54,324 TO GROW OUR CONSORTIUM. 5831 04:44:54,324 --> 04:44:55,659 SO THE QUESTION IS HOW DO YOU 5832 04:44:55,659 --> 04:44:59,429 REACH OUT TO THOSE FOLKS WHO 5833 04:44:59,429 --> 04:45:04,334 DON'T ALREADY IDENTIFY AS 5834 04:45:04,334 --> 04:45:06,703 MULTISCALE MODELERS. 5835 04:45:06,703 --> 04:45:09,072 THERE'S PEOPLE WHO CROSS 5836 04:45:09,072 --> 04:45:10,240 SCIENCES ARE MULTISCALE 5837 04:45:10,240 --> 04:45:10,640 MODELERS. 5838 04:45:10,640 --> 04:45:12,609 THEY JUST DON'T CALL THEMSELVES 5839 04:45:12,609 --> 04:45:13,410 THAT. 5840 04:45:13,410 --> 04:45:17,147 IT'S QUITE MAGICAL WHEN YOU TELL 5841 04:45:17,147 --> 04:45:19,916 THEM, YOU'RE A MULTISCALE 5842 04:45:19,916 --> 04:45:24,054 MODELER AND THEY THINK I JUST 5843 04:45:24,054 --> 04:45:34,364 FOUND AN IDENTITY. 5844 04:45:42,873 --> 04:45:49,346 >> HAVE WE HAD ANY SESSIONS OR 5845 04:45:49,346 --> 04:45:52,315 ACTIVITY THAT FOCUSES ON THE 5846 04:45:52,315 --> 04:45:55,852 SUCCESSFUL OF IMPLEMENTATION OF 5847 04:45:55,852 --> 04:45:56,553 MULTISCALE MODELING OUTSIDE OF 5848 04:45:56,553 --> 04:45:58,488 WHAT IT WAS INTENDED FOR. 5849 04:45:58,488 --> 04:46:02,559 >> SO HERE WE ARE ON THE WIKI. 5850 04:46:02,559 --> 04:46:04,227 IN THE SCOURING OF OUR MEETINGS 5851 04:46:04,227 --> 04:46:08,031 GO TO NEWS AND EVENTS AND 5852 04:46:08,031 --> 04:46:11,234 IMAG-HOSTED EVENTS AND YOU'LL 5853 04:46:11,234 --> 04:46:13,270 SEE ALL OUR MEETINGS ARCHIVED 5854 04:46:13,270 --> 04:46:15,806 FROM 2006 AND THE WIKI HERE WITH 5855 04:46:15,806 --> 04:46:18,508 ALL THE AGENDAS. 5856 04:46:18,508 --> 04:46:21,511 INVARIABLY I FOUND AT LEAST FIVE 5857 04:46:21,511 --> 04:46:24,281 OR SIX THAT HAD SUCCESS STORIES, 5858 04:46:24,281 --> 04:46:26,483 LESSONED LEARNED FROM THE CLINIC 5859 04:46:26,483 --> 04:46:27,050 AND DIFFERENT AREAS. 5860 04:46:27,050 --> 04:46:30,387 I'M NOT SAYING IT'S NOT A GOOD 5861 04:46:30,387 --> 04:46:32,255 THING BUT PERHAPS -- WHAT DID 5862 04:46:32,255 --> 04:46:39,763 YOU WANT TO DO WITH THAT? 5863 04:46:39,763 --> 04:46:41,765 SO WE'LL CONTINUE TO DO THAT, 5864 04:46:41,765 --> 04:46:42,132 YOU'RE SAYING. 5865 04:46:42,132 --> 04:46:52,476 CONTINUE TO DO THAT? 5866 04:46:56,279 --> 04:46:59,483 >> KIND OF PICKING UP FROM A 5867 04:46:59,483 --> 04:47:04,354 COUPLE YEARS AGO THE OUTREACH 5868 04:47:04,354 --> 04:47:08,291 EFFORT TO GET OTHER PEOPLE HERE 5869 04:47:08,291 --> 04:47:18,835 EXPLORE EXPLICITLY WORKING WITH 5870 04:47:20,470 --> 04:47:23,206 PEOPLE AND THE ORGANIZATION AND 5871 04:47:23,206 --> 04:47:25,342 LEVERAGING THAT TO MEETING CAN 5872 04:47:25,342 --> 04:47:27,444 ALSO HAVE THE REMOTE COMPONENT 5873 04:47:27,444 --> 04:47:33,116 AND MAYBE A SEGMENT WHERE WE GET 5874 04:47:33,116 --> 04:47:34,451 THEM TO PARTICIPATE AND SHARE 5875 04:47:34,451 --> 04:47:39,623 WITH US SOME OF WHAT THEY'RE 5876 04:47:39,623 --> 04:47:42,459 DOING IN THE EUROPEAN UNION AND 5877 04:47:42,459 --> 04:47:45,095 THE IDEA OF BRING A FRIEND. 5878 04:47:45,095 --> 04:47:47,264 THOSE OF US THAT ARE HERE 5879 04:47:47,264 --> 04:47:50,267 PARTICULARLY HERE FROM THE 5880 04:47:50,267 --> 04:47:52,302 LARGER UNIVERSITIES, IF YOU KNOW 5881 04:47:52,302 --> 04:47:55,772 OF RESEARCHERS FROM THE SMALLER 5882 04:47:55,772 --> 04:47:56,907 SCHOOLS IN YOUR AREA DOING 5883 04:47:56,907 --> 04:48:00,443 LITTLE PARTS OF THIS KIND OF 5884 04:48:00,443 --> 04:48:02,913 STUFF, THE EFFORT TO TRY TO 5885 04:48:02,913 --> 04:48:04,214 CONTACT THEM AND MAKE SURE 5886 04:48:04,214 --> 04:48:09,653 THEY'RE PERSONALLY INVITED AND 5887 04:48:09,653 --> 04:48:13,023 KIND OF MENTOR THEM SO THEY 5888 04:48:13,023 --> 04:48:14,591 DON'T FEEL LIKE, YOU CAN'T COME 5889 04:48:14,591 --> 04:48:14,958 TO NIH. 5890 04:48:14,958 --> 04:48:19,796 YOU CAN COME TO NIH. 5891 04:48:19,796 --> 04:48:20,230 >> THANK YOU, JOHN. 5892 04:48:20,230 --> 04:48:26,036 >> I GUESS ALONG THOSE LINES, 5893 04:48:26,036 --> 04:48:32,642 MAYBE ENGAGE IING ENGAGING END 5894 04:48:32,642 --> 04:48:33,810 CLINICIANS AND INDUSTRY FOLKS 5895 04:48:33,810 --> 04:48:35,045 DOING INTERESTING WORK AND MAYBE 5896 04:48:35,045 --> 04:48:38,415 BEYOND SOME OF THE ACADEMIC WORK 5897 04:48:38,415 --> 04:48:39,316 BUT ENGAGING THE DIFFERENT TYPES 5898 04:48:39,316 --> 04:48:47,357 OF COMMUNITIES AND USERS. 5899 04:48:47,357 --> 04:48:50,160 >> ORLANDO, DON'T LEAVE. 5900 04:48:50,160 --> 04:48:51,695 WE HAD SIMILAR THINGS LIKE THAT 5901 04:48:51,695 --> 04:48:53,463 IN THE PAST AND IT WOULD BE NICE 5902 04:48:53,463 --> 04:48:56,700 TO HAVE CONCRETE IDEAS OF HOW. 5903 04:48:56,700 --> 04:48:58,401 I THINK IN THE TRANSLATION 5904 04:48:58,401 --> 04:48:59,302 BREAKOUT SESSION MAYBE SOME OF 5905 04:48:59,302 --> 04:49:01,538 THOSE ACTIVITIES THAT WERE 5906 04:49:01,538 --> 04:49:07,444 PROPOSED MAY BE USEFUL BUT IT 5907 04:49:07,444 --> 04:49:13,416 SORT OF REALLY GETS DIRECT -- 5908 04:49:13,416 --> 04:49:16,286 EVERYBODY DOES THINGS TO SERVE 5909 04:49:16,286 --> 04:49:18,488 THEIR OWN NEEDS SO IF INDUSTRY 5910 04:49:18,488 --> 04:49:19,923 FOLKS ATTENDING THIS MEETING 5911 04:49:19,923 --> 04:49:21,891 FEELING IT WOULD SERVE THEIR 5912 04:49:21,891 --> 04:49:23,460 NEED OR CLINICIANS ATTENDING 5913 04:49:23,460 --> 04:49:25,028 THIS MEETING SERVING THEIR NEEDS 5914 04:49:25,028 --> 04:49:26,529 IT WOULD BE HELPFUL TO BRAIN 5915 04:49:26,529 --> 04:49:29,466 STORM THAT KIND OF IDEA. 5916 04:49:29,466 --> 04:49:32,636 >> MEDICAL DEVICE INDUSTRY. 5917 04:49:32,636 --> 04:49:34,271 I THINK YOU MENTIONED SOMETHING 5918 04:49:34,271 --> 04:49:34,938 YESTERDAY OR THIS MORNING AROUND 5919 04:49:34,938 --> 04:49:45,048 THAT. 5920 04:49:47,250 --> 04:49:48,385 SPECIFIC PROGRAMS AND TRAINIES 5921 04:49:48,385 --> 04:49:53,056 TO HAVE ACCESS TO CUTTING EDGE 5922 04:49:53,056 --> 04:49:55,225 TECHNOLOGIES THAT ARE NOT NEFSLY 5923 04:49:55,225 --> 04:50:00,230 ACCESSIBLE UP ACADEMIA. 5924 04:50:00,230 --> 04:50:03,800 AND THEN WITH A DIFFERENT ITEM, 5925 04:50:03,800 --> 04:50:09,306 ON THE ASPECT OF DATA CAPTURE, 5926 04:50:09,306 --> 04:50:10,674 YOU KNOW, THERE'S WEARABLE 5927 04:50:10,674 --> 04:50:14,577 DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES GENERATING 5928 04:50:14,577 --> 04:50:16,279 A LOT OF DATA AND THERE'S 5929 04:50:16,279 --> 04:50:20,750 EMERGING FRAMEWORKS HOW TO 5930 04:50:20,750 --> 04:50:22,719 ENSURE ACCESSIBILITY OF THAT 5931 04:50:22,719 --> 04:50:24,087 DATA, DATA ENGINEERING COULD BE 5932 04:50:24,087 --> 04:50:25,055 A VERY IMPORTANT ASPECT TO THE 5933 04:50:25,055 --> 04:50:29,793 MODELLING. 5934 04:50:29,793 --> 04:50:31,928 WE TALKED ABOUT DIFFERENT 5935 04:50:31,928 --> 04:50:32,529 MODELLING ASPECTS BUT NOT SO 5936 04:50:32,529 --> 04:50:33,630 MUCH ABOUT THE DATA ENGINEERING 5937 04:50:33,630 --> 04:50:35,632 AND STRUCTURING WHICH IS 5938 04:50:35,632 --> 04:50:40,303 CRITICAL. 5939 04:50:40,303 --> 04:50:40,970 >> THANKS. 5940 04:50:40,970 --> 04:50:43,840 >> SIMILAR TO WHAT WE DISCUSSED 5941 04:50:43,840 --> 04:50:46,643 DURING THE BREAKOUT SESSION 3, 5942 04:50:46,643 --> 04:50:48,278 THE MORE WE CAN IDENTIFY 5943 04:50:48,278 --> 04:50:51,247 EXISTING NETWORKS, THE MORE WE 5944 04:50:51,247 --> 04:50:53,450 CAN IDENTIFY EXISTING EFFORTS TO 5945 04:50:53,450 --> 04:50:54,851 CAPTURE A LOT OF THESE FOLKS 5946 04:50:54,851 --> 04:50:55,785 COLLECTIVELY AND ENGAGE THEM SO 5947 04:50:55,785 --> 04:51:00,457 YOU HAVE A WHOLE GROUP OF 5948 04:51:00,457 --> 04:51:01,324 INDIVIDUAL ORGANIZATIONS WITHIN 5949 04:51:01,324 --> 04:51:05,462 THE SECTOR YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT 5950 04:51:05,462 --> 04:51:10,567 I THINK THE BETTER SO LIKE 5951 04:51:10,567 --> 04:51:11,267 MEDICAL DEVICES OPPOSED TO 5952 04:51:11,267 --> 04:51:21,277 INDIVIDUAL COMPANIES. 5953 04:51:21,277 --> 04:51:22,712 >> SPECIFIC NAMES ON CONSORTIUMS 5954 04:51:22,712 --> 04:51:25,248 AND THE MEDICAL DEVICE 5955 04:51:25,248 --> 04:51:26,349 CONSORTIUM MEET QUITE OFTEN. 5956 04:51:26,349 --> 04:51:29,953 ONE THING I NOTICED BECAUSE I'M 5957 04:51:29,953 --> 04:51:36,559 AN IEEE MEMBER THEIR GROUP 5958 04:51:36,559 --> 04:51:37,394 KICKED OFF A BIG INITIATIVE 5959 04:51:37,394 --> 04:51:41,931 DEALING WITH OPEN HEALTH. 5960 04:51:41,931 --> 04:51:43,767 SWEEPING UP SOME OF THE BODIES 5961 04:51:43,767 --> 04:51:44,868 FROM THE OPEN HEALTH INITIATIVE 5962 04:51:44,868 --> 04:51:47,837 THAT ADDRESS SOME OF THE ISSUES 5963 04:51:47,837 --> 04:51:51,808 AND THEY'RE PUTTING, IF YOU 5964 04:51:51,808 --> 04:51:52,942 WILL, THE CAPITAL WITH THEIR 5965 04:51:52,942 --> 04:52:01,551 MEMBERS AND SPONSORSHIPS TO PUT 5966 04:52:01,551 --> 04:52:08,258 BIGGER WRAPPERS AROUND WHAT YOU 5967 04:52:08,258 --> 04:52:09,692 DELINEATED AND I'LL GIVE A PLUG 5968 04:52:09,692 --> 04:52:10,760 FOR THE STRATEGY MARK-UP 5969 04:52:10,760 --> 04:52:12,495 LANGUAGE OUT IN THE WEB AND I 5970 04:52:12,495 --> 04:52:15,698 THINK THE TAGLINE IS A WORLD 5971 04:52:15,698 --> 04:52:18,101 WIDE WEB OF STAKEHOLDERS OF 5972 04:52:18,101 --> 04:52:21,371 INTENT AND ACTUAL RESULTS IN A 5973 04:52:21,371 --> 04:52:28,711 MACHINE READFEEDABLE FORMAT STOP 5974 04:52:28,711 --> 04:52:33,416 BY THE GUY WHO -- READABLE 5975 04:52:33,416 --> 04:52:37,654 FORMAT AND WOULD HELP MACHINE 5976 04:52:37,654 --> 04:52:41,458 READABLE DOCUMENTS TO FIND WHO 5977 04:52:41,458 --> 04:52:42,926 IS DOING WHAT AND USE TECHNOLOGY 5978 04:52:42,926 --> 04:52:45,495 TO FIND THAT QUICKLY VERSUS 5979 04:52:45,495 --> 04:52:47,730 SEARCHING FOR WEBSITES AND 5980 04:52:47,730 --> 04:52:50,567 OPENING UP PDFs. 5981 04:52:50,567 --> 04:52:52,902 >> YOU SAID STRATEGY MARK-UP 5982 04:52:52,902 --> 04:52:53,236 LANGUAGE? 5983 04:52:53,236 --> 04:52:55,371 >> YES, ISO STANDARD I THINK 5984 04:52:55,371 --> 04:53:03,379 1469. 5985 04:53:03,379 --> 04:53:04,914 -- 17469. 5986 04:53:04,914 --> 04:53:06,749 >> CAN YOU ADD IT TO THE WIKI? 5987 04:53:06,749 --> 04:53:07,851 >> HAVING CONCRETE SUGGESTIONS 5988 04:53:07,851 --> 04:53:10,854 LIKE THAT IS HELPFUL BECAUSE IT 5989 04:53:10,854 --> 04:53:11,754 GIVES CLEAR -- SO VERY MUCH 5990 04:53:11,754 --> 04:53:16,726 APPRECIATE IT. 5991 04:53:16,726 --> 04:53:17,627 >> OKAY. 5992 04:53:17,627 --> 04:53:18,328 ANY OTHER THOUGHTS? 5993 04:53:18,328 --> 04:53:24,300 SO I GUESS I DIDN'T GET THE 5994 04:53:24,300 --> 04:53:28,905 ANSWER FOR BEYOND THIS MEETING? 5995 04:53:28,905 --> 04:53:30,473 ARE WE FINE HAVING OUR 5996 04:53:30,473 --> 04:53:31,774 CONSORTIUM JUST PLAN YEARLY 5997 04:53:31,774 --> 04:53:33,042 MEETINGS AND NOT DO ANYTHING 5998 04:53:33,042 --> 04:53:33,376 ELSE? 5999 04:53:33,376 --> 04:53:38,081 >> ONE THING THAT CAME UP DURING 6000 04:53:38,081 --> 04:53:39,883 THE BREAKOUT SESSION IS ALONG 6001 04:53:39,883 --> 04:53:42,986 THE YEAR HOW CAN WE CONNECT WITH 6002 04:53:42,986 --> 04:53:47,457 OTHER MEETINGS, CONNECT WITH 6003 04:53:47,457 --> 04:53:49,826 OTHER INITIATIVES? 6004 04:53:49,826 --> 04:53:54,163 SAY FOR INSTANCE, THERE'S 6005 04:53:54,163 --> 04:53:55,999 ANOTHER INITIATIVE WE'LL USE 6006 04:53:55,999 --> 04:53:56,666 SOCIAL DETERMINATES OR SOCIAL 6007 04:53:56,666 --> 04:53:58,601 BEHAVIORAL ASPECTS, WOULD IT 6008 04:53:58,601 --> 04:54:02,939 MAKE SENSE TO HAVE LIKE AN IMAG 6009 04:54:02,939 --> 04:54:05,074 MSM SESSION THERE OR BE PART OF 6010 04:54:05,074 --> 04:54:06,442 THE WORKSHOP OR SOMETHING? 6011 04:54:06,442 --> 04:54:08,545 IT SEEMS LIKE DOING THE 6012 04:54:08,545 --> 04:54:09,379 OUTREACHES THROUGHOUT THE YEAR 6013 04:54:09,379 --> 04:54:11,247 WILL BE BENEFICIAL FOR THE 6014 04:54:11,247 --> 04:54:13,283 CONSORTIUM IN GENERAL BUT ALSO 6015 04:54:13,283 --> 04:54:15,451 BENEFICIAL FOR THE INVESTIGATORS 6016 04:54:15,451 --> 04:54:16,119 WHO PARTICIPATE BECAUSE THEY'LL 6017 04:54:16,119 --> 04:54:16,920 BE ABLE TO GET THEIR WORK OUT 6018 04:54:16,920 --> 04:54:18,688 THERE TOO. 6019 04:54:18,688 --> 04:54:22,692 THAT MIGHT BE A WAY OF 6020 04:54:22,692 --> 04:54:23,326 CONTINUING DIFFERENT THINGS 6021 04:54:23,326 --> 04:54:24,294 THROUGHOUT THE YEAR AND AT THE 6022 04:54:24,294 --> 04:54:27,230 SAME TIME WE DON'T HAVE TO BEAR 6023 04:54:27,230 --> 04:54:28,298 THE BULK OF THE PLANNING. 6024 04:54:28,298 --> 04:54:30,199 >> MAKE A CALL OUT TO THE 6025 04:54:30,199 --> 04:54:31,434 CONSORTIUM LIST TO SEE IF YOU'RE 6026 04:54:31,434 --> 04:54:33,603 INTERESTED IN BEING A REPRESENT 6027 04:54:33,603 --> 04:54:35,872 ON BEHALF OF IMAG MSM? 6028 04:54:35,872 --> 04:54:46,015 >> YEP. 6029 04:54:48,718 --> 04:54:50,353 >> JOHN. 6030 04:54:50,353 --> 04:54:51,554 >> ASSUMING THERE'LL BE 6031 04:54:51,554 --> 04:54:56,593 SOMETHING ON MODEL CREDIBILITY 6032 04:54:56,593 --> 04:54:58,494 NEXT YEAR LET'S LOOK AT GET THE 6033 04:54:58,494 --> 04:55:00,129 FDA TO TELL US WHAT WE DO WITH 6034 04:55:00,129 --> 04:55:04,334 THE STANDARDS AND GUIDELINES FOR 6035 04:55:04,334 --> 04:55:06,869 MEDICAL MODELLING CREDIBILITY. 6036 04:55:06,869 --> 04:55:10,740 THAT'S A REAL THING NOW IN THAT 6037 04:55:10,740 --> 04:55:14,611 WORLD AND SOMETHING TO TALK 6038 04:55:14,611 --> 04:55:14,811 ABOUT. 6039 04:55:14,811 --> 04:55:19,215 THEIR PERSPECTIVE AND DOCUMENT 6040 04:55:19,215 --> 04:55:21,884 TO BE BRIEFED OUT ON IT AND 6041 04:55:21,884 --> 04:55:23,286 WHERE IT CAME FROM CONTINUOUSLY 6042 04:55:23,286 --> 04:55:23,820 BE USEFUL. 6043 04:55:23,820 --> 04:55:27,357 AND I NOTICED THIS YEAR THERE 6044 04:55:27,357 --> 04:55:27,991 WAS SOMETHING IN THERE ABOUT 6045 04:55:27,991 --> 04:55:30,259 GETTING FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE TO 6046 04:55:30,259 --> 04:55:35,264 ATTEND, TRAVEL MONEY, I DON'T 6047 04:55:35,264 --> 04:55:36,766 UNDERSTAND WHAT THAT IS BUT YOU 6048 04:55:36,766 --> 04:55:44,273 MAY CONSIDER MAKING PART OF THAT 6049 04:55:44,273 --> 04:55:46,909 WE CAN USE TO HELP SMALLER 6050 04:55:46,909 --> 04:55:49,112 UNIVERSITIES AND A BLOCK OF 6051 04:55:49,112 --> 04:55:50,847 FUNDING FOR ATTENDANCESHIPS TO 6052 04:55:50,847 --> 04:55:52,615 IF YOU WANT TO BRING PEOPLE NOT 6053 04:55:52,615 --> 04:55:55,184 FUNDED IN THIS KIND OF WORK THEY 6054 04:55:55,184 --> 04:55:57,887 CAN APPLY SPECIFICALLY FOR THAT 6055 04:55:57,887 --> 04:55:59,489 KIND OF SUPPORT IF YOU CAN 6056 04:55:59,489 --> 04:56:09,799 AFFORD TO DO THAT. 6057 04:56:10,867 --> 04:56:11,300 >> THANKS. 6058 04:56:11,300 --> 04:56:13,603 ALONG THE SAME LINES I DON'T 6059 04:56:13,603 --> 04:56:15,838 FLOW IF THIS IS OUTREACH OR 6060 04:56:15,838 --> 04:56:18,541 ACTIVITIES BUT I THINK WE 6061 04:56:18,541 --> 04:56:20,276 TOUCHED ABOUT THIS IN HALLWAYS 6062 04:56:20,276 --> 04:56:21,744 AND WORKSHOPS. 6063 04:56:21,744 --> 04:56:22,945 I THINK EVERYBODY HERE IS WORK 6064 04:56:22,945 --> 04:56:27,850 ON DIFFERENT APPROACHES AND 6065 04:56:27,850 --> 04:56:29,919 METHODS AND SHOWING HOW TO USE 6066 04:56:29,919 --> 04:56:32,188 THE METHODS TO TRAINEES AND 6067 04:56:32,188 --> 04:56:34,023 STUDENTS SPECIFICALLY IS USEFUL. 6068 04:56:34,023 --> 04:56:37,126 I KNOW THERE'S A LOT OF PEOPLE 6069 04:56:37,126 --> 04:56:39,729 WHO WANT TO KNOW WHAT MULTISCALE 6070 04:56:39,729 --> 04:56:41,097 MODELING IS AND FOR US SOME OF 6071 04:56:41,097 --> 04:56:42,065 THOSE THINGS YOU KNOW IT WHEN 6072 04:56:42,065 --> 04:56:44,834 YOU SEE IT BUT I THINK THAT 6073 04:56:44,834 --> 04:56:47,570 DEFINING IT AND PUTTING SOME 6074 04:56:47,570 --> 04:56:49,605 STANDARDS, CALL OUT TO HERBERT 6075 04:56:49,605 --> 04:56:52,275 ON THAT ONE, WOULD BE REALLY 6076 04:56:52,275 --> 04:56:52,975 USEFUL. 6077 04:56:52,975 --> 04:56:55,311 THEY COULD BE WORKSHOPS IN THIS 6078 04:56:55,311 --> 04:57:01,217 MEETING OR TACKED ON TO LIKE MY 6079 04:57:01,217 --> 04:57:03,586 FIELD OR FOR PHYSICAL SOCIETIES. 6080 04:57:03,586 --> 04:57:05,288 THERE'S WAY TO WORK IT OUT. 6081 04:57:05,288 --> 04:57:09,692 >> ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT LIKE 6082 04:57:09,692 --> 04:57:12,895 HANDS ON CODING AND NOT JUST 6083 04:57:12,895 --> 04:57:13,963 DEMONSTRATION BUT ACTUALLY 6084 04:57:13,963 --> 04:57:17,500 LEARNING, TUTORIALS -- 6085 04:57:17,500 --> 04:57:20,269 >> SIMPLE THINGS LIKE I HAVE A 6086 04:57:20,269 --> 04:57:23,473 MULTISCALE QUESTION AND HOW DO I 6087 04:57:23,473 --> 04:57:25,541 TACKLE THAT AND WHERE DO I START 6088 04:57:25,541 --> 04:57:27,143 AND I'VE DONE THAT IN OTHER 6089 04:57:27,143 --> 04:57:32,415 MEETINGS AND IT'S VERY USEFUL. 6090 04:57:32,415 --> 04:57:34,350 >> THAT RAISES ANOTHER QUESTION, 6091 04:57:34,350 --> 04:57:36,119 IS THERE A ROLE FOR DOING 6092 04:57:36,119 --> 04:57:39,222 WEBINARS ON SOMETHING NOW AND 6093 04:57:39,222 --> 04:57:39,655 THEN? 6094 04:57:39,655 --> 04:57:43,726 ONE IS EXPLAINING TO PEOPLE WHAT 6095 04:57:43,726 --> 04:57:45,695 MULTISCALE MODELING IS. 6096 04:57:45,695 --> 04:57:49,799 THAT COULD BE A RELATIVELY LOW 6097 04:57:49,799 --> 04:57:52,201 EFFORT POTENTIALLY HIGH YIELD 6098 04:57:52,201 --> 04:57:52,401 THING. 6099 04:57:52,401 --> 04:57:55,471 >> THAT WAS A DISCUSSION MAYBE 6100 04:57:55,471 --> 04:58:01,344 FIVE YEARS BACK AND I THINK 6101 04:58:01,344 --> 04:58:08,184 ANDREW McCULLOUGH SHEPHERDED 6102 04:58:08,184 --> 04:58:11,554 THAT AND WE HAVE ONE, I THINK 6103 04:58:11,554 --> 04:58:16,659 PETER HUNTER'S BUT WHEN WE HAD 6104 04:58:16,659 --> 04:58:19,128 THE WORKING GROUPS AT ONE POINT 6105 04:58:19,128 --> 04:58:20,596 WE REQUIRED EVERY WORKING GROUP 6106 04:58:20,596 --> 04:58:21,764 TO PRESENT TWO PRESENTATIONS A 6107 04:58:21,764 --> 04:58:24,500 YEAR AND SO WE HAVE A TON OF 6108 04:58:24,500 --> 04:58:25,101 RECORDED PRESENTATIONS ON THE 6109 04:58:25,101 --> 04:58:29,472 WIKI. 6110 04:58:29,472 --> 04:58:31,107 THE STEERING COMMITTEE DECIDED 6111 04:58:31,107 --> 04:58:32,241 THAT IT'S FINE BUT PEOPLE DON'T 6112 04:58:32,241 --> 04:58:34,377 HAVE TIME TO WATCH IT. 6113 04:58:34,377 --> 04:58:37,947 AND NOW THAT WE HAVE SO MANY -- 6114 04:58:37,947 --> 04:58:41,117 SO, THEN ANDREW WAS SAYING WELL, 6115 04:58:41,117 --> 04:58:48,891 WHY DON'T WE MAKE DIDACTIC TUE 6116 04:58:48,891 --> 04:58:50,359 TO 6117 04:58:50,359 --> 04:58:51,627 -- TUTORIAL AND REALIZED IT 6118 04:58:51,627 --> 04:58:53,496 TAKES A LOT OF WORK TO DO THAT. 6119 04:58:53,496 --> 04:58:55,865 I THINK WE DID ONE TEST BED 6120 04:58:55,865 --> 04:58:59,502 TUTORIALS, RIGHT HERE. 6121 04:58:59,502 --> 04:59:00,570 WE HAVE MORE THAN ONE. 6122 04:59:00,570 --> 04:59:06,843 SO HERE'S A FEW. 6123 04:59:06,843 --> 04:59:09,111 WE HAVE A FEW HERE. 6124 04:59:09,111 --> 04:59:12,215 THANK YOU, NET MAPPERS AND BOND 6125 04:59:12,215 --> 04:59:16,018 GRAPHS LML AND THAT'S IT 6126 04:59:16,018 --> 04:59:16,285 ACTUALLY. 6127 04:59:16,285 --> 04:59:17,119 THE LAST ONE WAS JUST AN 6128 04:59:17,119 --> 04:59:21,023 ADVERTISEMENT. 6129 04:59:21,023 --> 04:59:22,725 IT TAKES WORK. 6130 04:59:22,725 --> 04:59:24,694 >> ALSO THE QUESTION IS THE 6131 04:59:24,694 --> 04:59:27,063 AUDIENCE -- SOME OF THESE THINGS 6132 04:59:27,063 --> 04:59:28,297 ARE VERY SPECIFIC. 6133 04:59:28,297 --> 04:59:31,400 AND SO THERE MIGHT BE A 6134 04:59:31,400 --> 04:59:33,502 DIFFERENT WEBINAR MORE ORIENTED 6135 04:59:33,502 --> 04:59:38,341 TOWARDS OTHER COMMUNITIES TO 6136 04:59:38,341 --> 04:59:40,276 HELP UNDERSTAND SPECIFICALLY TO 6137 04:59:40,276 --> 04:59:43,446 THE MSM COMMUNITY. 6138 04:59:43,446 --> 04:59:45,381 >> SO WE DO POST THINGS IN 6139 04:59:45,381 --> 04:59:48,651 GENERAL LIKE IF WE HAVE AN 6140 04:59:48,651 --> 04:59:49,385 INTERESTING PRESENTATION. 6141 04:59:49,385 --> 04:59:54,156 SO ALL GET THE MESSAGES AND THE 6142 04:59:54,156 --> 04:59:55,258 VIRAL PANDEMIC WORKING GROUP HAS 6143 04:59:55,258 --> 04:59:57,927 BEEN POSTING ALL THEIR WEBINARS 6144 04:59:57,927 --> 05:00:01,797 EVERY WEEK HERE TOO. 6145 05:00:01,797 --> 05:00:09,505 I RECENTLY HOST THE PIRACY X AND 6146 05:00:09,505 --> 05:00:11,507 PEOPLE ARE POSTING AND I DON'T 6147 05:00:11,507 --> 05:00:15,077 KNOW IF YOU ALL ARE LOOKING BUT 6148 05:00:15,077 --> 05:00:16,145 IT WOULD BE GREAT TO GET 6149 05:00:16,145 --> 05:00:22,985 FEEDBACK ON THESE. 6150 05:00:22,985 --> 05:00:25,354 OPEN SIM AND ALL THAT. 6151 05:00:25,354 --> 05:00:27,957 I DIDN'T MEAN TO SAY IT'S NOT A 6152 05:00:27,957 --> 05:00:29,492 GOOD IDEA OR YOU CAN CONTINUE TO 6153 05:00:29,492 --> 05:00:36,799 POST IF YOU'D LIKE. 6154 05:00:36,799 --> 05:00:41,470 >> IN ADDITION TO THE MSM IN 6155 05:00:41,470 --> 05:00:48,010 2019 WE ORG ANIZED THE 6156 05:00:48,010 --> 05:00:50,713 INTERSECTION OF MSM MODELLING 6157 05:00:50,713 --> 05:00:51,614 AND MACHINE LEARNING AND GAVE 6158 05:00:51,614 --> 05:00:54,050 RISE TO TWO PAPERS THE REVIEWED 6159 05:00:54,050 --> 05:00:55,217 THE STATE OF THE ART. 6160 05:00:55,217 --> 05:00:57,586 I THINK IT'S TIME AND I'M KIND 6161 05:00:57,586 --> 05:00:58,955 OF HESITANT TO BRING IT UP 6162 05:00:58,955 --> 05:01:03,492 BECAUSE I DON'T WANT TO 6163 05:01:03,492 --> 05:01:05,127 VOLUNTEER BUT I THINK IT'S TIME 6164 05:01:05,127 --> 05:01:06,963 TO LOOK AT THE MULTISCALE 6165 05:01:06,963 --> 05:01:08,297 MODELING, MACHINE LEARNING AND 6166 05:01:08,297 --> 05:01:09,031 QUANTUM COMPUTING BECAUSE THE 6167 05:01:09,031 --> 05:01:12,535 THREE ARE INTIMATELY GOING TO BE 6168 05:01:12,535 --> 05:01:12,802 CONNECTED. 6169 05:01:12,802 --> 05:01:14,070 MACHINE LEARNING FOR QUANTUM 6170 05:01:14,070 --> 05:01:18,641 COMPUTING AND QUANTUM COMPUTING 6171 05:01:18,641 --> 05:01:21,143 FOR MACHINE LEARNING. 6172 05:01:21,143 --> 05:01:26,882 THERE IS A LOT OF OFFICIAL FOR 6173 05:01:26,882 --> 05:01:27,883 GROWTH AND IF YOU WANT TO BUILD 6174 05:01:27,883 --> 05:01:29,385 THE FUTURE AROUND THE TECHNOLOGY 6175 05:01:29,385 --> 05:01:30,353 MAYBE NEXT YEAR OR THE FOLLOWING 6176 05:01:30,353 --> 05:01:33,022 YEAR BUT I'D LIKE TO PUT A PLUG 6177 05:01:33,022 --> 05:01:35,391 FOR A SEPARATE TWO-DAY MEETING 6178 05:01:35,391 --> 05:01:37,360 TO HAVE IN DEPTH DISCUSSIONS ON 6179 05:01:37,360 --> 05:01:39,128 WHAT THE TECHNOLOGIES ARE AND 6180 05:01:39,128 --> 05:01:40,830 QUESTIONS ARE. 6181 05:01:40,830 --> 05:01:44,100 MAYBE WE COME UP WITH A CONCEPT 6182 05:01:44,100 --> 05:01:45,901 FOR A MORE INCLUSIVE BOOK 6183 05:01:45,901 --> 05:01:49,405 SOMETHING THAT COMES OUT OF IT 6184 05:01:49,405 --> 05:01:51,140 THAT PROVIDES GUIDANCE TO THE 6185 05:01:51,140 --> 05:01:53,476 COMMUNITY AND HAVE A WORKSHOP TO 6186 05:01:53,476 --> 05:01:55,911 SHOW PEOPLE HOW TO WORK ON THE 6187 05:01:55,911 --> 05:02:02,852 MORE ADVANCED PLATFORMS 6188 05:02:02,852 --> 05:02:04,620 DEMYSTIFYING THIS. 6189 05:02:04,620 --> 05:02:06,622 >> IT'S MACHINE LEARNING AND 6190 05:02:06,622 --> 05:02:07,289 MULTISCALE MODELING AND QUANTUM 6191 05:02:07,289 --> 05:02:07,556 COMPUTING. 6192 05:02:07,556 --> 05:02:14,296 THE THREE COMING TOGETHER. 6193 05:02:14,296 --> 05:02:16,298 >> IT'S HANDS ON? 6194 05:02:16,298 --> 05:02:19,402 >> IT'S DEMYSTIFYING THE 6195 05:02:19,402 --> 05:02:20,369 TECHNOLOGY AND BRINGING IN 6196 05:02:20,369 --> 05:02:23,773 AUTHORITIES TO TALK ABOUT WHERE 6197 05:02:23,773 --> 05:02:29,011 WE ARE AND WHERE TO GO AND A 6198 05:02:29,011 --> 05:02:31,380 FEW HANDS ON BUT NOT A FULLY 6199 05:02:31,380 --> 05:02:32,581 HANDS ON BECAUSE THE 6200 05:02:32,581 --> 05:02:34,784 TECHNOLOGY'S EVOLVING. 6201 05:02:34,784 --> 05:02:37,086 THERE'S A LOT OF THEORETICAL 6202 05:02:37,086 --> 05:02:40,689 DISCUSSIONS GOING ON THAT NEEDS 6203 05:02:40,689 --> 05:02:42,558 TO BE BROUGHT TO THE FORE. 6204 05:02:42,558 --> 05:02:44,860 AT THE END WE WANT RIGOROUS 6205 05:02:44,860 --> 05:02:46,495 TECHNIQUE ARE NOT JUST 6206 05:02:46,495 --> 05:02:46,796 APPLICATION. 6207 05:02:46,796 --> 05:02:52,334 THE TECHNOLOGY IS EVOLVING. 6208 05:02:52,334 --> 05:02:54,136 WE TALK ABOUT TECHNOLOGY THE WAY 6209 05:02:54,136 --> 05:02:58,140 WE CAN AND THEN SHOW STUDENTS 6210 05:02:58,140 --> 05:02:59,475 AND OTHERS TO EASE INTO THE 6211 05:02:59,475 --> 05:03:02,578 PLATFORMS. 6212 05:03:02,578 --> 05:03:09,218 >> I'LL HAVE TO PUT NAMES DOWN 6213 05:03:09,218 --> 05:03:09,385 NOW. 6214 05:03:09,385 --> 05:03:15,391 >> SO I DON'T KNOW IF IT WOULD 6215 05:03:15,391 --> 05:03:17,093 BE MORE LOGISTICALLY FEASIBLE TO 6216 05:03:17,093 --> 05:03:19,595 DO THAT AS A DAY ADD ON TO OUR 6217 05:03:19,595 --> 05:03:21,063 MANUAL MEETING UNLESS YOU WANT 6218 05:03:21,063 --> 05:03:23,165 TO HAVE IT SEPARATE. 6219 05:03:23,165 --> 05:03:25,668 THAT'S SOMETHING THAT THERE 6220 05:03:25,668 --> 05:03:27,703 MIGHT BE A LOT OF INTEREST IN 6221 05:03:27,703 --> 05:03:30,573 GOING TO BUT MAY NOT HAVE TIME 6222 05:03:30,573 --> 05:03:32,108 TO COME TO A COMPLETELY SEPARATE 6223 05:03:32,108 --> 05:03:32,308 THING. 6224 05:03:32,308 --> 05:03:42,651 SOMETHING LIKE THAT. 6225 05:03:45,187 --> 05:03:46,021 I WANTED YOU AS PART OF THE 6226 05:03:46,021 --> 05:03:47,490 PROGRAM ANYWAY. 6227 05:03:47,490 --> 05:03:56,866 >> OKAY. 6228 05:03:56,866 --> 05:03:57,433 >> OKAY. 6229 05:03:57,433 --> 05:04:01,337 MAYBE AS AN ADD-ON TOPIC THE 6230 05:04:01,337 --> 05:04:02,138 CONVERGENCE OF THE MULTISCALE 6231 05:04:02,138 --> 05:04:06,108 MODELING AND OTHER TECHNIQUES 6232 05:04:06,108 --> 05:04:10,312 WITH ADDED TO MANUFACTURING AND 6233 05:04:10,312 --> 05:04:13,115 OTHER ACTUAL PHYSICAL TECHNIQUES 6234 05:04:13,115 --> 05:04:15,651 FOR PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT 6235 05:04:15,651 --> 05:04:15,985 MANUFACTURING. 6236 05:04:15,985 --> 05:04:19,488 >> WAIT, ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING? 6237 05:04:19,488 --> 05:04:27,830 >> LIKE 3-D PRINTING OR OTHER 6238 05:04:27,830 --> 05:04:29,498 FABRICATION APPROACHES LIKE 6239 05:04:29,498 --> 05:04:33,068 OTHER TYPES OF MANUFACTURING FOR 6240 05:04:33,068 --> 05:04:33,903 PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT, MEDICAL 6241 05:04:33,903 --> 05:04:44,280 DEVICE DEVELOPMENT. 6242 05:04:44,280 --> 05:04:49,151 THE SYNERGIES AND CONNECTION 6243 05:04:49,151 --> 05:04:51,387 POINTS WITH MULTISCALE MODELING. 6244 05:04:51,387 --> 05:04:52,388 >> GREAT, THANK YOU. 6245 05:04:52,388 --> 05:04:53,923 PLEASE ADD TO ANY OF THE 6246 05:04:53,923 --> 05:04:57,660 COMMENTS I WROTE TO CLARIFY. 6247 05:04:57,660 --> 05:04:59,495 OKAY. 6248 05:04:59,495 --> 05:05:01,931 I THINK WE'RE DONE. 6249 05:05:01,931 --> 05:05:02,932 ALL RIGHT. 6250 05:05:02,932 --> 05:05:07,236 WELL, SO HOW ABOUT SOME FINAL 6251 05:05:07,236 --> 05:05:09,939 THOUGHTS STARTING WITH HERBERT 6252 05:05:09,939 --> 05:05:12,208 AND THEN TO ME AND WE'LL END THE 6253 05:05:12,208 --> 05:05:12,708 MEETING. 6254 05:05:12,708 --> 05:05:13,809 >> FINAL THOUGHTS FROM LATE IN 6255 05:05:13,809 --> 05:05:16,312 THE DAY AFTER A HANGOVER FROM 6256 05:05:16,312 --> 05:05:19,014 LAST NIGHT IN THE PUB. 6257 05:05:19,014 --> 05:05:20,282 WELL, IT'S GREAT TO BE BACK IN 6258 05:05:20,282 --> 05:05:22,685 PERSON. 6259 05:05:22,685 --> 05:05:24,687 IT'S GREAT TO SEE EVERYBODY 6260 05:05:24,687 --> 05:05:25,554 AGAIN. 6261 05:05:25,554 --> 05:05:27,523 AND WE'VE COME UP WITH SOME 6262 05:05:27,523 --> 05:05:29,525 IDEAS TO COLLABORATE WHICH IS 6263 05:05:29,525 --> 05:05:30,593 GREAT SO IT'S BEEN A SUCCESSFUL 6264 05:05:30,593 --> 05:05:39,568 MEETING FOR ME. 6265 05:05:39,568 --> 05:05:42,171 >> IT SEEMS LIKE IN THIS AGE 6266 05:05:42,171 --> 05:05:46,508 THERE'S ALWAYS A BUZZWORD OR NEW 6267 05:05:46,508 --> 05:05:47,076 CATCHPHRASE BUT MULTISCALE 6268 05:05:47,076 --> 05:05:48,577 MODELING HAS PERSISTED ALL THESE 6269 05:05:48,577 --> 05:05:49,011 YEARS. 6270 05:05:49,011 --> 05:05:51,513 IN FACT IT SEEMS LIKE MORE AND 6271 05:05:51,513 --> 05:05:54,984 MORE IT IS ACTUALLY ONE OF THE 6272 05:05:54,984 --> 05:05:57,152 KEY METHODS TO ISSUES OR 6273 05:05:57,152 --> 05:05:59,121 QUESTIONS WE FACE SO IT SEEMS 6274 05:05:59,121 --> 05:06:01,657 LIKE A BIG PART OF WHAT WE 6275 05:06:01,657 --> 05:06:02,124 REA 6276 05:06:02,124 --> 05:06:06,328 REALLY NEED TO DO IS BROADEN 6277 05:06:06,328 --> 05:06:06,929 UNDERSTANDING. 6278 05:06:06,929 --> 05:06:07,529 BROADEN KNOWLEDGE OF WHAT WE 6279 05:06:07,529 --> 05:06:09,398 ACTUALLY DO. 6280 05:06:09,398 --> 05:06:12,701 SO I THINK IT'S REALLY IMPORTANT 6281 05:06:12,701 --> 05:06:14,403 TO HAVE THIS MEETING BECAUSE 6282 05:06:14,403 --> 05:06:15,671 THIS IS OUR OPPORTUNITY AFTER 6283 05:06:15,671 --> 05:06:18,707 SEVERAL YEARS TO FINALLY GET 6284 05:06:18,707 --> 05:06:19,808 BACK TOGETHER AND WE HAVE TO 6285 05:06:19,808 --> 05:06:24,880 KEEP THAT IN MIND. 6286 05:06:24,880 --> 05:06:29,618 THE MORE WE CAN PROPAGATE THE 6287 05:06:29,618 --> 05:06:30,486 BENEFITS OF MULTISCALE MODELING 6288 05:06:30,486 --> 05:06:36,125 THE MORE WE CAN GROW THIS FIELD. 6289 05:06:36,125 --> 05:06:40,296 >> IT WAS WONDERFUL TO SEE SO 6290 05:06:40,296 --> 05:06:42,965 MANY PEOPLE AFTER SO MANY YEARS 6291 05:06:42,965 --> 05:06:48,837 IT WAS LIKE A RIB VAN WINKLE 6292 05:06:48,837 --> 05:06:52,041 EPISODE AND THOUGH WE'RE HERE AT 6293 05:06:52,041 --> 05:06:56,278 THE NIH CAMPUS IT'S WONDERFUL TO 6294 05:06:56,278 --> 05:06:59,081 MEET COLLEAGUES FROM FDA AND 6295 05:06:59,081 --> 05:07:00,282 VARIOUS PARTS OF DEPARTMENT OF 6296 05:07:00,282 --> 05:07:02,685 DEFENSE RESEARCH AGENCIES. 6297 05:07:02,685 --> 05:07:04,353 FOR THAT I'M SUPER GRATEFUL 6298 05:07:04,353 --> 05:07:04,753 EVERYONE CAME OUT. 6299 05:07:04,753 --> 05:07:09,958 THANK YOU. 6300 05:07:09,958 --> 05:07:11,860 >> I'LL JUST ADD AN 6301 05:07:11,860 --> 05:07:15,931 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF FOLKS HERE 6302 05:07:15,931 --> 05:07:17,900 ESPECIALLY THE FOLKS AT NIH, 6303 05:07:17,900 --> 05:07:19,668 GRACE AND LIZ AND REED WERE 6304 05:07:19,668 --> 05:07:22,338 WONDERFUL TO WORK WITH AND 6305 05:07:22,338 --> 05:07:25,174 DENISE, WHO I GUESS HAD TO LEAVE 6306 05:07:25,174 --> 05:07:35,517 EARLY WAS A SHOT IN THE ARM FOR 6307 05:07:35,517 --> 05:07:35,851 US. 6308 05:07:35,851 --> 05:07:37,386 >> I WILL ECHO THAT. 6309 05:07:37,386 --> 05:07:39,188 I WANT TO THANK THE COMMITTEE 6310 05:07:39,188 --> 05:07:40,322 AND DENISE AND REED. 6311 05:07:40,322 --> 05:07:42,358 YOU GUYS MADE THIS HAPPEN. 6312 05:07:42,358 --> 05:07:43,859 AT ONE POINT I WAS THINKING I 6313 05:07:43,859 --> 05:07:46,028 DON'T KNOW WHAT'S GOING TO 6314 05:07:46,028 --> 05:07:48,831 HAPPEN WITH THE MSM AND IMAG. 6315 05:07:48,831 --> 05:07:51,467 IT SEEMS LIKE WE HAVE BEEN 6316 05:07:51,467 --> 05:07:52,801 REV 6317 05:07:52,801 --> 05:07:53,035 REVIVED. 6318 05:07:53,035 --> 05:07:58,073 THANK YOU ALL FOR COMING AND 6319 05:07:58,073 --> 05:08:00,376 BEING HERE AND INTERACTING WITH 6320 05:08:00,376 --> 05:08:02,044 EVERYONE AND EXCITING TO SEE 6321 05:08:02,044 --> 05:08:03,078 DISCUSSIONS STILL GROWING AND 6322 05:08:03,078 --> 05:08:05,180 PEOPLE ARE ENJOYING THIS 6323 05:08:05,180 --> 05:08:09,351 ACTIVITY AND FOR ME I FEEL LIKE 6324 05:08:09,351 --> 05:08:12,287 WE CAN MAKE A LOT OF IMPACT. 6325 05:08:12,287 --> 05:08:17,493 I FEEL LIKE THIS COMMUNITY IS 6326 05:08:17,493 --> 05:08:19,528 VERY UNIQUE IN THAT SENSE THAT 6327 05:08:19,528 --> 05:08:21,797 YOU ALL CAME ON YOUR OWN. 6328 05:08:21,797 --> 05:08:23,399 WE DIDN'T FORCE YOU TO COME AND 6329 05:08:23,399 --> 05:08:26,402 YOU WERE HERE TO SHARE IDEAS AS 6330 05:08:26,402 --> 05:08:31,640 YOU'VE ALWAYS DONE AND 6331 05:08:31,640 --> 05:08:34,576 REMEMBERING ALL THOSE WONDERFUL 6332 05:08:34,576 --> 05:08:35,144 REMEMBRANCE SESSIONS. 6333 05:08:35,144 --> 05:08:36,445 I THINK A LOT OF THOSE FOLKS 6334 05:08:36,445 --> 05:08:40,883 WOULD HAVE BEEN GRATEFUL TO HERE 6335 05:08:40,883 --> 05:08:42,351 THAT THEIR LEGACIES ARE LIVING 6336 05:08:42,351 --> 05:08:44,286 ON AND ESPECIALLY WITH THE FOCUS 6337 05:08:44,286 --> 05:08:48,857 ON THE EARLY CAREER 6338 05:08:48,857 --> 05:08:49,958 INVESTIGATORS, A SPECIAL THANKS 6339 05:08:49,958 --> 05:08:53,429 TO VICTOR AND THEIR TEAM AND 6340 05:08:53,429 --> 05:08:59,001 ELENA GOLDBERG AND LIZ AND JASON 6341 05:08:59,001 --> 05:09:00,002 TO REEL SAY THE HIGHLIGHT OF THE 6342 05:09:00,002 --> 05:09:02,738 FUTURE IS THE NEXT GENERATION. 6343 05:09:02,738 --> 05:09:04,673 I WILL SAY THANK YOU AGAIN AND 6344 05:09:04,673 --> 05:09:07,910 AGAIN IF YOU WANT TO BE PART OF 6345 05:09:07,910 --> 05:09:10,145 THESE ACTIVITIES WE JUST WROTE 6346 05:09:10,145 --> 05:09:11,814 DOWN PLEASE POST IT IN THE WIKI 6347 05:09:11,814 --> 05:09:14,616 SO WE CAN DOCUMENT AND SEND ANY 6348 05:09:14,616 --> 05:09:15,818 FEEDBACK YOU MIGHT HAVE IN THE 6349 05:09:15,818 --> 05:09:17,553 WIKI AND I WISH YOU SAFE TRAVELS 6350 05:09:17,553 --> 05:09:19,655 HOME AND UNTIL THE NEXT TIME WE 6351 05:09:19,655 --> 05:09:19,955 MEET. 6352 05:09:19,955 --> 05:09:22,324 >> CAN I ADD ONE QUICK THING, 6353 05:09:22,324 --> 05:09:24,193 NATURALLY I WANT TO ECHO WHAT 6354 05:09:24,193 --> 05:09:25,694 JASON SAID ABOUT THE WHOLE 6355 05:09:25,694 --> 05:09:27,529 COMMITTEE IT'S BEEN GREAT 6356 05:09:27,529 --> 05:09:29,131 WORKING WITH EVERYONE BUT I WANT 6357 05:09:29,131 --> 05:09:30,365 TO SPECIFICALLY HIGHLIGHT GRACE. 6358 05:09:30,365 --> 05:09:32,267 ALL THESE YEARS WHEN YOU THINK 6359 05:09:32,267 --> 05:09:33,101 OF MULTISCALE MODELING YOU THINK 6360 05:09:33,101 --> 05:09:38,607 OF GREAT -- GRACE AND BEING THE 6361 05:09:38,607 --> 05:09:40,742 LEADER, THE EVANGELIST THE FORCE 6362 05:09:40,742 --> 05:09:46,315 IN PUSHING MULTISCALE MODELING 6363 05:09:46,315 --> 05:09:50,285 HAS BEEN INVALUABLE IF YOU 6364 05:09:50,285 --> 05:09:52,221 HADN'T PUSHED THIS WOULD WE HAVE 6365 05:09:52,221 --> 05:09:54,490 THIS COMMUNITY SO YOU DESERVE 6366 05:09:54,490 --> 05:09:55,891 CREDIT FOR ALL THIS. 6367 05:09:55,891 --> 05:09:58,460 >> THANK YOU ALL. 6368 05:09:58,460 --> 05:10:01,430 YOU GUYS ARE THE WIND BENEATH MY 6369 05:10:01,430 --> 05:10:01,630 FEET. 6370 05:10:01,630 --> 05:10:03,098 IF IT WEREN'T FOR YOU ALL I 6371 05:10:03,098 --> 05:10:03,699 WOULDN'T BE DOING IT SO THANK 6372 05:10:03,699 --> 05:10:06,502 YOU. 6373 05:10:06,502 --> 05:10:06,768 ALL RIGHT. 6374 05:10:06,768 --> 05:10:07,402 THANK YOU AND WE'LL ADJOURN THE 6375 05:10:07,402 --> 05:10:17,402 MEETING.