1 00:00:06,224 --> 00:00:08,059 >> GOOD AFTERNOON OR MORNING, 2 00:00:08,059 --> 00:00:09,060 EVERYBODY, DEPENDING WHERE YOU 3 00:00:09,060 --> 00:00:09,460 ARE LOCATED. 4 00:00:09,460 --> 00:00:11,863 I WOULD LIKE TO WELCOME YOU TO 5 00:00:11,863 --> 00:00:14,365 THIS OPEN SESSION OF THE 6 00:00:14,365 --> 00:00:16,768 NATIONAL ADVISORY COUNCIL FOR 7 00:00:16,768 --> 00:00:17,368 HUMAN GENOME RESEARCH, 8 00:00:17,368 --> 00:00:18,670 INCLUDING THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE 9 00:00:18,670 --> 00:00:21,539 HERE IN PERSON, WE HAVE MEMBERS 10 00:00:21,539 --> 00:00:23,441 OF OUR NHGRI STAFF HERE IN THE 11 00:00:23,441 --> 00:00:23,675 ROOM. 12 00:00:23,675 --> 00:00:25,376 WITH ME. 13 00:00:25,376 --> 00:00:27,512 AS WELL AS OUR COUNCILMEMBER 14 00:00:27,512 --> 00:00:28,813 WHO'S ARE ATTENDING VIRTUALLY 15 00:00:28,813 --> 00:00:31,549 AND ANYONE WHO IS JOINING US 16 00:00:31,549 --> 00:00:33,785 OVER THE LIVE STREAM. 17 00:00:33,785 --> 00:00:35,386 I AM OFFICIALLY GAVELING US TO 18 00:00:35,386 --> 00:00:37,822 A START. 19 00:00:37,822 --> 00:00:39,590 THEY ACTUALLY GIVE YOU A GAVEL 20 00:00:39,590 --> 00:00:41,926 AND TURNING IT OVER TO OUR 21 00:00:41,926 --> 00:00:45,830 EXECUTIVE SECRETARY FOR THE 22 00:00:45,830 --> 00:00:46,964 COUNCIL, JEN TROYER. 23 00:00:46,964 --> 00:00:50,568 >> I WOULD LIKE TO JOIN CAROLYN 24 00:00:50,568 --> 00:00:51,035 IN INVITING EVERYBODY. 25 00:00:51,035 --> 00:00:52,470 BEFORE WE GET STARTED, WE HAVE 26 00:00:52,470 --> 00:00:53,771 A COUPLE OF BUSINESS ITEMS TO 27 00:00:53,771 --> 00:01:01,713 ATTEND TO. 28 00:01:01,713 --> 00:01:05,883 ONE OF THESE, I'M SUPPOSED TO 29 00:01:05,883 --> 00:01:07,518 INTRODUCE OUR NEW 30 00:01:07,518 --> 00:01:08,219 COUNCILMEMBERS, NHGRI STAFF, 31 00:01:08,219 --> 00:01:09,354 LIAISONS AND GUESTS. 32 00:01:09,354 --> 00:01:10,788 WE DON'T HAVE ANY NEW 33 00:01:10,788 --> 00:01:12,256 COUNCILMEMBERS TO INTRODUCE. 34 00:01:12,256 --> 00:01:13,858 AND CAROLYN HAS A FEW SLIDES 35 00:01:13,858 --> 00:01:15,026 FOR STAFF MEMBERS. 36 00:01:15,026 --> 00:01:18,029 BUT I WILL SAY THAT NHGRI IS 37 00:01:18,029 --> 00:01:19,163 DELIGHTED TO WELCOME BACK 38 00:01:19,163 --> 00:01:20,264 CAROLYN HUTTER AS OUR NEW 39 00:01:20,264 --> 00:01:23,201 ACTING DIRECTOR. 40 00:01:23,201 --> 00:01:29,173 AND THEN I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO 41 00:01:29,173 --> 00:01:31,309 INVITE, ACKNOWLEDGE OUR 42 00:01:31,309 --> 00:01:32,844 LIAISONS. 43 00:01:32,844 --> 00:01:35,213 GEORGIA FROM GENETIC ALLIANCE. 44 00:01:35,213 --> 00:01:36,614 ALLEN FROM THE INTERNATIONAL 45 00:01:36,614 --> 00:01:38,516 SOCIETY OF NURSES AND GENETICS, 46 00:01:38,516 --> 00:01:45,890 LILAH JAMAL FROM THE NATIONAL 47 00:01:45,890 --> 00:01:48,726 SOCIETY OF GENETIC COUNSELORS 48 00:01:48,726 --> 00:01:50,395 AND WELCOME ANY NIH COLLEAGUES 49 00:01:50,395 --> 00:01:51,262 JOINING US FOR THIS OPEN 50 00:01:51,262 --> 00:01:52,196 SESSION, AS WELL AS ALL OF YOU 51 00:01:52,196 --> 00:01:54,799 WATCHING. 52 00:01:54,799 --> 00:01:56,868 SO THE FIRST ORDER OF BUSINESS 53 00:01:56,868 --> 00:01:58,669 FOR TODAY IS BECAUSE WE HAVE 54 00:01:58,669 --> 00:02:01,506 NOT HAD AN OPEN SESSION SINCE 55 00:02:01,506 --> 00:02:03,808 SEPTEMBER, WE NEED TO APPROVE 56 00:02:03,808 --> 00:02:07,011 THE MINUTES FROM OUR SEPTEMBER 57 00:02:07,011 --> 00:02:07,245 MEETING. 58 00:02:07,245 --> 00:02:08,446 THESE HAVE BEEN PROVIDED AS A 59 00:02:08,446 --> 00:02:10,381 DOCUMENT TO COUNCIL AND ONCE 60 00:02:10,381 --> 00:02:12,316 THEY ARE APPROVED WILL ALSO BE 61 00:02:12,316 --> 00:02:13,684 AVAILABLE TO ANYONE ONLINE. 62 00:02:13,684 --> 00:02:17,455 SO I AM GOING TO ASK OUR 63 00:02:17,455 --> 00:02:19,524 COUNCILMEMBERS FOR THE FIRST 64 00:02:19,524 --> 00:02:21,125 TIME VOTING ELECTRONICALLY, AS 65 00:02:21,125 --> 00:02:23,327 WELL AS BY RAISING HANDS. 66 00:02:23,327 --> 00:02:28,666 SO FIRST OF ALL, I'M GOING TO 67 00:02:28,666 --> 00:02:30,268 ASK YOU IN THE OPEN SESSION 68 00:02:30,268 --> 00:02:34,305 AGENDA TAB THERE'S A VOTE TO 69 00:02:34,305 --> 00:02:36,874 APPROVE THE NHGRI COUNCIL 70 00:02:36,874 --> 00:02:38,443 MEETING MINUTES FROM SEPTEMBER 71 00:02:38,443 --> 00:02:38,643 2024. 72 00:02:38,643 --> 00:02:41,045 IF YOU CAN GO INTO THAT, AND 73 00:02:41,045 --> 00:02:42,447 EITHER APPROVE OR DISAPPROVE, 74 00:02:42,447 --> 00:02:47,318 OR ABSTAIN, IF WERE NOT PRESENT 75 00:02:47,318 --> 00:02:54,492 THEN, YOU CAN ABSTAIN. 76 00:02:54,492 --> 00:02:56,494 >> DON'T WE HAVE TO HAVE A 77 00:02:56,494 --> 00:02:59,630 MOTION AND SECOND TO VOTE? 78 00:02:59,630 --> 00:03:01,966 >> YES, SO CAN WE HAVE A MOTION 79 00:03:01,966 --> 00:03:03,401 TO APPROVE THOSE MINUTES BY 80 00:03:03,401 --> 00:03:03,601 HAND. 81 00:03:03,601 --> 00:03:03,968 WE WILL DO THAT. 82 00:03:03,968 --> 00:03:04,302 >> MOTION. 83 00:03:04,302 --> 00:03:05,970 >> GREAT. 84 00:03:05,970 --> 00:03:07,772 AND IT LOOKS LIKE THERE ARE 85 00:03:07,772 --> 00:03:09,440 SECONDS AND THIRDS, SO WE ARE 86 00:03:09,440 --> 00:03:10,007 ALL SET THERE. 87 00:03:10,007 --> 00:03:11,375 NOW I'M GOING TO ASK YOU TO DO 88 00:03:11,375 --> 00:03:13,010 THE HAND RAISING. 89 00:03:13,010 --> 00:03:13,811 SO ALL APPROVE, PLEASE RAISE 90 00:03:13,811 --> 00:03:17,081 YOUR HAND. 91 00:03:17,081 --> 00:03:20,518 EXCELLENT. 92 00:03:20,518 --> 00:03:22,386 ANY DISAPPROVE? 93 00:03:22,386 --> 00:03:25,590 NANCY, I ASSUME THAT WAS AN 94 00:03:25,590 --> 00:03:25,823 APPROVE. 95 00:03:25,823 --> 00:03:27,325 AND THEN NOBODY ABSTAINING, SO 96 00:03:27,325 --> 00:03:27,692 WE ARE ALL SET. 97 00:03:27,692 --> 00:03:28,726 SO THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 98 00:03:28,726 --> 00:03:32,597 THAT ORDER OF BUSINESS IS DONE. 99 00:03:32,597 --> 00:03:34,599 THE SECOND IS ONTO OUR CONFLICT 100 00:03:34,599 --> 00:03:35,766 OF INTEREST STATEMENT. 101 00:03:35,766 --> 00:03:38,202 WE HAD OUR CLOSED SESSION OF 102 00:03:38,202 --> 00:03:38,603 COUNCIL YESTERDAY. 103 00:03:38,603 --> 00:03:39,971 SO THIS REFERS TO ALL OF THE 104 00:03:39,971 --> 00:03:40,905 APPLICATIONS THAT WERE 105 00:03:40,905 --> 00:03:42,406 DISCUSSED BY COUNCIL AT THE 106 00:03:42,406 --> 00:03:42,907 CLOSED SESSION MEETING 107 00:03:42,907 --> 00:03:46,210 YESTERDAY. 108 00:03:46,210 --> 00:03:47,578 COUNCILMEMBERS ARE REQUIRED TO 109 00:03:47,578 --> 00:03:50,147 LEAVE THE MEETING ROOM WHEN 110 00:03:50,147 --> 00:03:51,816 APPLICATIONS SUBMITTED BY THEIR 111 00:03:51,816 --> 00:03:53,084 OWN ORGANIZATION ARE BEING 112 00:03:53,084 --> 00:03:55,019 INDIVIDUALLY DISCUSSED. 113 00:03:55,019 --> 00:03:56,854 IN THE CASE OF STATE HIGHER 114 00:03:56,854 --> 00:04:01,092 EDUCATION OR OTHER SYSTEMS WITH 115 00:04:01,092 --> 00:04:04,395 MULTIPLE CAMPUS THAT'S ARE 116 00:04:04,395 --> 00:04:05,496 GEOGRAPHICALLY SEPARATED YOUR 117 00:04:05,496 --> 00:04:07,365 OWN ORGANIZATION MEANS THE 118 00:04:07,365 --> 00:04:09,033 ENTIRE SYSTEM EXCEPT WHERE A 119 00:04:09,033 --> 00:04:12,270 DETERMINATION HAS BEEN MADE THE 120 00:04:12,270 --> 00:04:13,170 COMPONENTS ARE SEPARATE 121 00:04:13,170 --> 00:04:14,205 ORGANIZATIONS FOR PURPOSES OF 122 00:04:14,205 --> 00:04:15,506 DETERMINING CONFLICT OF 123 00:04:15,506 --> 00:04:15,940 INTEREST. 124 00:04:15,940 --> 00:04:17,642 ALL PEOPLE PRESENT SHOULD AVOID 125 00:04:17,642 --> 00:04:18,976 SITUATIONS THAT COULD GIVE RISE 126 00:04:18,976 --> 00:04:20,845 TO CHARGES OF CONFLICT OF 127 00:04:20,845 --> 00:04:21,646 INTEREST, WHETHER REAL OR 128 00:04:21,646 --> 00:04:24,482 APPARENT. 129 00:04:24,482 --> 00:04:25,650 FOR EXAMPLE, NO ONE 130 00:04:25,650 --> 00:04:26,350 PARTICIPATES IN THE 131 00:04:26,350 --> 00:04:28,886 DELIBERATIONS AND ACTIONS ON 132 00:04:28,886 --> 00:04:31,422 ANY APPLICATION FROM OR 133 00:04:31,422 --> 00:04:32,623 INVOLVING THEIR SPOUSE, 134 00:04:32,623 --> 00:04:34,458 PARTNER, CHILD, A RECENT 135 00:04:34,458 --> 00:04:36,794 STUDENT, A RECENT TEACHER, A 136 00:04:36,794 --> 00:04:37,695 PROFESSIONAL COLLABORATOR WITH 137 00:04:37,695 --> 00:04:39,430 WHOM THEY HAVE WORKED CLOSELY. 138 00:04:39,430 --> 00:04:42,133 A CLOSE FRIEND, OR A SCIENTIST 139 00:04:42,133 --> 00:04:44,835 WITH WHOM THEY HAVE HAD LONG 140 00:04:44,835 --> 00:04:45,736 STANDING SCIENTIFIC OR PERSONAL 141 00:04:45,736 --> 00:04:55,212 DIFFERENCES. 142 00:04:55,212 --> 00:04:57,748 THE NHGRI STAFF HAVE INSTRUCTED 143 00:04:57,748 --> 00:04:59,717 COUNCILMEMBERS ACCORDINGLY. 144 00:04:59,717 --> 00:05:01,352 IN COUNCIL ACTIONS IN WHICH 145 00:05:01,352 --> 00:05:04,121 COUNCILMEMBERS VOTE ON A BLOCK 146 00:05:04,121 --> 00:05:05,089 OF APPLICATIONS WITHOUT 147 00:05:05,089 --> 00:05:07,391 DISCUSSING ANY INDIVIDUAL ONE, 148 00:05:07,391 --> 00:05:09,961 FOR EXAMPLE, THE ON BLOCK 149 00:05:09,961 --> 00:05:11,462 ACTION, THEIR VOTE DIDN'T APPLY 150 00:05:11,462 --> 00:05:13,264 TO ANY APPLICATIONS FROM ANY 151 00:05:13,264 --> 00:05:15,299 INSTITUTIONS OR INDIVIDUALS 152 00:05:15,299 --> 00:05:24,809 FULFILLING THE CRITERIA ABOVE. 153 00:05:24,809 --> 00:05:26,477 ALL RIGHT, THAT BEING SAID, WE 154 00:05:26,477 --> 00:05:29,280 CAN MOVE ONTO AN UPDATE FROM 155 00:05:29,280 --> 00:05:31,482 OUR ACTING DIRECTOR, CAROLYN, 156 00:05:31,482 --> 00:05:32,783 OVER TO YOU. 157 00:05:32,783 --> 00:05:34,452 >> EXCELLENT, THANK YOU SO MUCH. 158 00:05:34,452 --> 00:05:35,886 CAN WE PLEASE PULL UP MY SLIDES? 159 00:05:35,886 --> 00:05:40,358 EXCELLENT. 160 00:05:40,358 --> 00:05:42,627 AGAIN, MY NAME IS CAROLYN 161 00:05:42,627 --> 00:05:44,729 HUTTER, THE ACTING DIRECTOR OF 162 00:05:44,729 --> 00:05:45,963 NHGRI, I TOOK THIS POSITION ON 163 00:05:45,963 --> 00:05:46,831 MAY 5th. 164 00:05:46,831 --> 00:05:50,501 I WILL DISCUSS A LITTLE BIT 165 00:05:50,501 --> 00:05:52,937 MORE WHEN I DO NHGRI UPDATES AS 166 00:05:52,937 --> 00:05:54,972 TO WHY I'M IN THIS ROLE. 167 00:05:54,972 --> 00:06:00,578 BUT AS BACKGROUND, I HAVE 168 00:06:00,578 --> 00:06:02,179 TRAINING IN EPIDEMIOLOGY, 169 00:06:02,179 --> 00:06:03,381 BIOSTATISTICS AND GENETICS, AND 170 00:06:03,381 --> 00:06:06,584 I'VE BEEN AT THE NIH SINCE 2012. 171 00:06:06,584 --> 00:06:11,789 I WAS A PROGRAM DIRECTOR AND 172 00:06:11,789 --> 00:06:12,790 THEN DIVISION DIRECTOR AT 173 00:06:12,790 --> 00:06:15,026 NHCBI, I LEFT THE OFFICE OF 174 00:06:15,026 --> 00:06:16,227 STRATEGIC COORDINATION WHICH 175 00:06:16,227 --> 00:06:17,595 OVERSEES THE COMMON FUND BUT 176 00:06:17,595 --> 00:06:19,530 WAS THEN ASKED TO COME BACK 177 00:06:19,530 --> 00:06:22,066 INTO THIS ROLE WITH THE 178 00:06:22,066 --> 00:06:27,438 DEPARTURE OF ERIC GREEN AND BEN 179 00:06:27,438 --> 00:06:29,106 SPOTTAM. 180 00:06:29,106 --> 00:06:32,443 THIS WON'T BE IF YOU ARE A 181 00:06:32,443 --> 00:06:34,078 REGULAR WATCHER OF THE NHGRI 182 00:06:34,078 --> 00:06:35,579 COUNCIL, THIS WON'T BE LIKE A 183 00:06:35,579 --> 00:06:36,847 REGULAR DIRECTOR'S REPORT. 184 00:06:36,847 --> 00:06:38,916 I AM GOING TO GIVE SOME UPDATES 185 00:06:38,916 --> 00:06:41,018 BOTH FIRST AT THE NIH LEVEL, 186 00:06:41,018 --> 00:06:43,421 AND THEN MOVING TO INSTITUTE OR 187 00:06:43,421 --> 00:06:47,958 NHGRI LEVEL UPDATES. 188 00:06:47,958 --> 00:06:50,327 SO, MY FIRST UPDATE AT THE NIH 189 00:06:50,327 --> 00:06:55,266 LEVEL IS THAT WE DO HAVE A NEW 190 00:06:55,266 --> 00:06:55,599 NIH DIRECTOR. 191 00:06:55,599 --> 00:07:01,505 HE STARTED IN EARLY APRIL. 192 00:07:01,505 --> 00:07:01,939 DR. JAYANTA OR JAY, 193 00:07:01,939 --> 00:07:02,940 BHATTACHARYA. 194 00:07:02,940 --> 00:07:05,276 HE HAS COME TO US FROM STANFORD 195 00:07:05,276 --> 00:07:07,111 WHERE HE DID BOTH HIS TRAINING 196 00:07:07,111 --> 00:07:09,914 AND HAD A FACULTY POSITION. 197 00:07:09,914 --> 00:07:12,950 HE HAS GIVEN SEVERAL PUBLIC 198 00:07:12,950 --> 00:07:13,517 TALKS OUTLINING HIS VISION. 199 00:07:13,517 --> 00:07:14,185 I PARTICULARLY RECOMMEND IF YOU 200 00:07:14,185 --> 00:07:16,454 WANT TO SEE MORE OF WHAT HE IS 201 00:07:16,454 --> 00:07:19,223 INTERESTED FROM HIS OWN WORDS, 202 00:07:19,223 --> 00:07:21,158 THE NINDS COUNCIL, WHICH IS 203 00:07:21,158 --> 00:07:22,560 SIMILAR TO THIS COUNCIL, 204 00:07:22,560 --> 00:07:23,527 AVAILABLE ON THE NIH VIDEOCAST, 205 00:07:23,527 --> 00:07:26,430 YOU CAN GO BACK TO PRIOR EVENTS. 206 00:07:26,430 --> 00:07:29,233 IF YOU GO TO THAT ALMOST 207 00:07:29,233 --> 00:07:31,302 EXACTLY THE 30 MINUTE MARK, HE 208 00:07:31,302 --> 00:07:41,645 BEGINS HIS REMARKS. 209 00:07:54,992 --> 00:07:55,493 MAKE AMERICA HEALTHY AGAIN 210 00:07:55,493 --> 00:07:56,727 AGENDA. 211 00:07:56,727 --> 00:08:00,164 HE ALSO HAS A REALLY STRONG 212 00:08:00,164 --> 00:08:00,965 PASSION AROUND ENSURING 213 00:08:00,965 --> 00:08:02,500 RELIABLE RESULTS AND THIS 214 00:08:02,500 --> 00:08:04,168 INCLUDES A FOCUS ON REPLICATION 215 00:08:04,168 --> 00:08:08,639 AND WAYS TO MAKE SCIENCE 216 00:08:08,639 --> 00:08:09,774 REPLICAABLE, REPRODUCIBLE AND 217 00:08:09,774 --> 00:08:12,777 GENERALIZABLE. 218 00:08:12,777 --> 00:08:14,945 HE EMPHASIZES MAKING BIG 219 00:08:14,945 --> 00:08:16,580 ADVANCES WITH NIH RECONNECTING 220 00:08:16,580 --> 00:08:19,483 TO OUR CORE MISSION FINDING THE 221 00:08:19,483 --> 00:08:20,251 MOST INNOVATIVE BIOMEDICAL 222 00:08:20,251 --> 00:08:22,153 RESEARCH TO MOVE FORWARD. 223 00:08:22,153 --> 00:08:24,588 AN INTEREST IN MAINTAINING 224 00:08:24,588 --> 00:08:26,991 SAFETY AND TRANSPARENCY THROUGH 225 00:08:26,991 --> 00:08:27,625 APPROPRIATE REGULATION, POLICY, 226 00:08:27,625 --> 00:08:30,327 ET CETERA. 227 00:08:30,327 --> 00:08:31,629 AND ENCOURAGING ACADEMIC 228 00:08:31,629 --> 00:08:34,098 FREEDOM, INCLUDING ALLOWING THE 229 00:08:34,098 --> 00:08:35,733 EXPRESSION OF DISAGREEMENT AND 230 00:08:35,733 --> 00:08:39,003 QUESTIONING OF SCIENTIFIC DOGMA. 231 00:08:39,003 --> 00:08:39,904 SO AGAIN, THERE ARE PUBLIC 232 00:08:39,904 --> 00:08:41,305 PLACES WHERE YOU CAN SEE MORE 233 00:08:41,305 --> 00:08:47,044 AND I THINK HE HAS PLANS TO PUT 234 00:08:47,044 --> 00:08:49,313 FORWARD SOME ADDITIONAL 235 00:08:49,313 --> 00:08:51,081 INFORMATION HIGHLIGHTING HIS 236 00:08:51,081 --> 00:08:51,315 AGENDA. 237 00:08:51,315 --> 00:08:53,150 IN ADDITION TO A NEW NIH 238 00:08:53,150 --> 00:08:54,351 DIRECTOR WE HAVE HAD CRITICAL 239 00:08:54,351 --> 00:08:55,753 CHANGES AT THE LEADERSHIP LEVEL. 240 00:08:55,753 --> 00:08:57,721 I'M NOT REPRESENTING ALL OF 241 00:08:57,721 --> 00:08:58,055 THEM. 242 00:08:58,055 --> 00:09:00,858 BUT THERE WERE SOME KEY NIH 243 00:09:00,858 --> 00:09:02,526 LEADERSHIP RETIREMENTS THAT 244 00:09:02,526 --> 00:09:08,365 HAVE HAPPENED SINCE JANUARY, 245 00:09:08,365 --> 00:09:09,733 INCLUDING DR. TABAK, NIH 246 00:09:09,733 --> 00:09:13,370 PRINCIPAL DEPUTY DIRECTOR. 247 00:09:13,370 --> 00:09:18,576 DR. LAUER, AND JOHN BURKLOW, 248 00:09:18,576 --> 00:09:18,943 CHIEF OF STAFF. 249 00:09:18,943 --> 00:09:21,378 IN TERMS OF NEW COMING IN, 250 00:09:21,378 --> 00:09:25,850 MATTHEW MEMOLI, WHO WAS AN 251 00:09:25,850 --> 00:09:27,518 INTRAMURAL INVESTIGATOR, WAS 252 00:09:27,518 --> 00:09:29,453 THE FIRST ACTING NIH DIRECTOR 253 00:09:29,453 --> 00:09:31,522 AND NOW ROLE OF PRINCIPAL 254 00:09:31,522 --> 00:09:32,923 DEPUTY DIRECTOR. 255 00:09:32,923 --> 00:09:36,694 JOHN LORSCH, THE LONG TERM 256 00:09:36,694 --> 00:09:38,829 NIHGMS DIRECTOR IS SERVING AS 257 00:09:38,829 --> 00:09:43,300 AT ACTING DEPUTY IT DRENGTOR 258 00:09:43,300 --> 00:09:46,537 FOR EXTRAMURAL RESEARCH. 259 00:09:46,537 --> 00:09:48,906 NICOLE KLEINSTREUER HAS COME IN 260 00:09:48,906 --> 00:09:55,379 TO BE DEPUTY DIRECTOR FOR 261 00:09:55,379 --> 00:09:57,815 POUGHKEEPSIE. 262 00:09:57,815 --> 00:10:03,520 SEANA CRANSTON IS NIH CHIEF OF 263 00:10:03,520 --> 00:10:06,223 STAFF, AND ERIC SCHNABEL IS NIH 264 00:10:06,223 --> 00:10:07,858 CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER THAT 265 00:10:07,858 --> 00:10:08,425 STARLTED UNDER THE CURRENT 266 00:10:08,425 --> 00:10:09,260 ADMINISTRATION. 267 00:10:09,260 --> 00:10:11,528 I AM NOT ALONE IN MY ACTING 268 00:10:11,528 --> 00:10:12,630 ROLE. 269 00:10:12,630 --> 00:10:14,498 IN JANUARY THERE WERE ALREADY 270 00:10:14,498 --> 00:10:18,602 TWO ACTING DIRECTORS AT NIH AND 271 00:10:18,602 --> 00:10:26,210 BECAUSE OF THE LEAVING OF 272 00:10:26,210 --> 00:10:30,414 SHANNON, DEANA, ALLISTER RA, 273 00:10:30,414 --> 00:10:36,520 ERIC GREEN, SHELLY AND JANEEN 274 00:10:36,520 --> 00:10:38,389 MARAZIO, WE HAVE NEW ACTING 275 00:10:38,389 --> 00:10:48,232 DIRECTORS, YOU CAN SEE THEM, 276 00:10:48,232 --> 00:10:55,306 NINR, NICHD, NIMHD, NHGRI, 277 00:10:55,306 --> 00:11:03,614 NIMH, NIAID. 278 00:11:03,614 --> 00:11:04,782 COURTNEY, ALLISON, MONICA, 279 00:11:04,782 --> 00:11:11,889 CAROLYN, ANDREA, JEFF. 280 00:11:11,889 --> 00:11:13,958 THE FISCAL YEAR 2025 ENACTED 281 00:11:13,958 --> 00:11:16,961 BUDGET IS BASED ON THE 282 00:11:16,961 --> 00:11:18,128 CONTINUATION OF THE FY 2024 283 00:11:18,128 --> 00:11:19,730 ENACTED APPROPRIATION. 284 00:11:19,730 --> 00:11:20,331 THE NIH BUDGET WENT DOWN 285 00:11:20,331 --> 00:11:22,533 SLIGHTLY. 286 00:11:22,533 --> 00:11:25,636 MOSTLY BECAUSE OF 21st CENTURY 287 00:11:25,636 --> 00:11:27,071 CURES, CUTS THAT IMPACTED ALL 288 00:11:27,071 --> 00:11:30,040 OF US PROGRAM AND BRAIN 289 00:11:30,040 --> 00:11:34,778 INITIATIVE, BUT THE 47.3 TO 47 290 00:11:34,778 --> 00:11:36,613 BILLION, AND NHGRI STAYED 291 00:11:36,613 --> 00:11:38,949 STEADY AT JUST OVER 660 MILLION 292 00:11:38,949 --> 00:11:39,183 DOLLARS. 293 00:11:39,183 --> 00:11:41,785 IF YOU LOOK FORWARD TO FY '26 294 00:11:41,785 --> 00:11:43,153 WE DON'T KNOW WHAT THE BUDGET 295 00:11:43,153 --> 00:11:46,657 IS GOING TO BE YET, BUT THE 296 00:11:46,657 --> 00:11:50,094 PRESIDENT PUT OUT THE FY '26 297 00:11:50,094 --> 00:11:52,663 PRESIDENT'S BUDGET THAT CUTS 298 00:11:52,663 --> 00:11:55,165 THE NIH BUDGET FROM 47 BILLION 299 00:11:55,165 --> 00:11:56,867 DOWN TO JUST UNDER $28 BILLION, 300 00:11:56,867 --> 00:11:59,303 WHICH IS ABOUT A 40% DECREASE 301 00:11:59,303 --> 00:12:01,905 TO THE BUDGET. 302 00:12:01,905 --> 00:12:03,574 FOR NHGRI, I DON'T HAVE A 303 00:12:03,574 --> 00:12:05,676 NUMBER IN THAT CELL FOR A 304 00:12:05,676 --> 00:12:08,545 REASON, BECAUSE UNDER THE 305 00:12:08,545 --> 00:12:09,246 PRESIDENT'S PROPOSED BUDGET, 306 00:12:09,246 --> 00:12:11,415 NHGRI MOVES INTO A NEW 307 00:12:11,415 --> 00:12:13,350 REORGANIZATION. 308 00:12:13,350 --> 00:12:15,919 SO IN ADDITION TO PROPOSING A 309 00:12:15,919 --> 00:12:18,055 40% CUT, THE PRESIDENT'S BUDGET 310 00:12:18,055 --> 00:12:19,490 HAS ADDITIONAL ACTIVITIES 311 00:12:19,490 --> 00:12:20,624 AROUND INDIRECT COSTS, SALARY 312 00:12:20,624 --> 00:12:23,727 CAPS, SOME OTHER THINGS 313 00:12:23,727 --> 00:12:26,030 MULTI-YEAR FUNDING ET CETERA. 314 00:12:26,030 --> 00:12:28,065 AND PROPOSES A REORGANIZATION 315 00:12:28,065 --> 00:12:30,067 FROM 27 INSTITUTES DOWN TO 11. 316 00:12:30,067 --> 00:12:31,301 SO THIS INCLUDES, I'M NOT GOING 317 00:12:31,301 --> 00:12:33,470 TO READ THROUGH ALL THIS, BUT 318 00:12:33,470 --> 00:12:35,372 THE NATIONAL HEART LUNG AND 319 00:12:35,372 --> 00:12:36,774 BLOOD INSTITUTE. 320 00:12:36,774 --> 00:12:38,375 NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF ARTHRITIS 321 00:12:38,375 --> 00:12:40,210 AND MOUSSE LO SKELETAL AND SKIN 322 00:12:40,210 --> 00:12:42,846 DISEASE AND NATIONAL INSTITUTE 323 00:12:42,846 --> 00:12:44,882 OF DIABETES AND DIGESTIVE AND 324 00:12:44,882 --> 00:12:46,283 KIDNEY DISEASES MOVING INTO 325 00:12:46,283 --> 00:12:46,850 NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF BODY 326 00:12:46,850 --> 00:12:48,452 SYSTEMS. 327 00:12:48,452 --> 00:12:56,627 NHGRI COMES IN HERE JOINING 328 00:12:56,627 --> 00:13:02,566 NIGMS, NLM AND NATIONAL 329 00:13:02,566 --> 00:13:06,470 INSTITUTE. 330 00:13:06,470 --> 00:13:09,440 NIAID STAY THE SAME. 331 00:13:09,440 --> 00:13:10,607 NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR 332 00:13:10,607 --> 00:13:12,309 BIOMEDICAL SCIENCES MOVES OUT 333 00:13:12,309 --> 00:13:14,878 OF NIH TO A NEWLY FORMED 334 00:13:14,878 --> 00:13:16,080 ADMINISTRATION FOR HEALTHY 335 00:13:16,080 --> 00:13:18,115 AMERICA WITHIN HHS AND THIS 336 00:13:18,115 --> 00:13:19,516 BUDGET PROPOSES AN ELIMINATION 337 00:13:19,516 --> 00:13:21,885 OF THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE FOR 338 00:13:21,885 --> 00:13:24,655 NURSING RESEARCH, NATIONAL 339 00:13:24,655 --> 00:13:27,491 CENTER FOR COMPLIMENTARY AND 340 00:13:27,491 --> 00:13:27,958 INTEGRATIVE HEALTH, 341 00:13:27,958 --> 00:13:29,159 PHARMACOGENOMICKERITY AND 342 00:13:29,159 --> 00:13:29,726 MINORITY HEALTH AND HEALTH 343 00:13:29,726 --> 00:13:30,294 DISPARITIES. 344 00:13:30,294 --> 00:13:34,598 IF YOU LOOK AT THIS 345 00:13:34,598 --> 00:13:35,699 NEWLY-FORMED NIMGS, IT'S BUDGET 346 00:13:35,699 --> 00:13:37,568 OF THE NEW INSTITUTE IS ABOUT 347 00:13:37,568 --> 00:13:39,303 40% OF WHAT YOU GET IF YOU 348 00:13:39,303 --> 00:13:40,871 ADDED THE CURRENT BUDGETS OF 349 00:13:40,871 --> 00:13:43,340 THE FIVE INSTITUTES BEING PUT 350 00:13:43,340 --> 00:13:43,607 TOGETHER. 351 00:13:43,607 --> 00:13:46,076 AND THAT'S GENERALLY TRUE 352 00:13:46,076 --> 00:13:48,212 ACROSS-THE-BOARD. 353 00:13:48,212 --> 00:13:49,613 THAT 40% DECREASE IS GENERALLY 354 00:13:49,613 --> 00:13:51,281 HOW THEY APPLIED IT 355 00:13:51,281 --> 00:13:51,815 ACROSS-THE-BOARD FOR THIS 356 00:13:51,815 --> 00:13:52,683 PROPOSED BUDGET. 357 00:13:52,683 --> 00:13:54,518 I WILL ALSO REMIND EVERYBODY 358 00:13:54,518 --> 00:13:55,953 THOUGH THAT THE PRESIDENT'S 359 00:13:55,953 --> 00:13:58,989 BUDGET IS JUST ONE STEP IN HOW 360 00:13:58,989 --> 00:14:01,058 YOU CREATE A U.S. FEDERAL 361 00:14:01,058 --> 00:14:01,291 BUDGET. 362 00:14:01,291 --> 00:14:02,893 SO THIS OUTLINE, THIS IS FROM A 363 00:14:02,893 --> 00:14:04,528 WEBSITE, HOW DO WE MAKE THE 364 00:14:04,528 --> 00:14:06,964 BUDGET AND THERE'S MORE TO IT 365 00:14:06,964 --> 00:14:07,231 THAN THIS. 366 00:14:07,231 --> 00:14:08,398 THE PRESIDENT'S BUDGET IS SORT 367 00:14:08,398 --> 00:14:10,567 OF STEP THREE, AND WHERE WE ARE 368 00:14:10,567 --> 00:14:13,470 NOW IS IN STEP FOUR WHERE THE 369 00:14:13,470 --> 00:14:16,406 BUDGET IS BEING CONSIDERED AT 370 00:14:16,406 --> 00:14:18,275 THE HOUSE AND SENATE LEVEL, 371 00:14:18,275 --> 00:14:20,377 SORT OF BEING EVALUATED BY 372 00:14:20,377 --> 00:14:22,079 SUBCOMMITTEES WHO ARE HOLDING 373 00:14:22,079 --> 00:14:22,346 HEARINGS. 374 00:14:22,346 --> 00:14:23,914 AND ACTUALLY, JUST LAST WEEK, 375 00:14:23,914 --> 00:14:25,816 THE SENATE LABOR, HEALTH AND 376 00:14:25,816 --> 00:14:27,184 HUMAN SERVICES EDUCATION AND 377 00:14:27,184 --> 00:14:27,918 RELATED AGENCIES SUBCOMMITTEE 378 00:14:27,918 --> 00:14:32,289 HELD A HER HEARING FOR THE 379 00:14:32,289 --> 00:14:34,224 PRESIDENT'S FISCAL YEAR '26 380 00:14:34,224 --> 00:14:37,227 BUDGET, REQUEST FOR NATIONAL 381 00:14:37,227 --> 00:14:38,729 INSTITUTE OF HEALTH, DR. 382 00:14:38,729 --> 00:14:39,396 BHATTACHARYA WAS AVAILABLE FOR 383 00:14:39,396 --> 00:14:43,467 THAT AND YOU CAN FIND THAT 384 00:14:43,467 --> 00:14:46,370 ONLINE. 385 00:14:46,370 --> 00:14:48,906 I WANT TO NOTE IN ADDITION TO 386 00:14:48,906 --> 00:14:51,441 BUDGET CHANGES THERE'S BEEN A 387 00:14:51,441 --> 00:14:53,177 NUMBER OF OF POLICY UPDATES. 388 00:14:53,177 --> 00:14:55,612 THESE ARE TWO WEBSITES. 389 00:14:55,612 --> 00:14:58,215 ON EACH OF THESE SLIDES, WHERE 390 00:14:58,215 --> 00:14:58,916 THERE'S THESE QR CODES THESE 391 00:14:58,916 --> 00:14:59,883 WILL TAKE YOU TO THE 392 00:14:59,883 --> 00:15:01,385 APPROPRIATE WEBSITE. 393 00:15:01,385 --> 00:15:03,387 WE HAVE, THESE ARE WEBSITES YOU 394 00:15:03,387 --> 00:15:06,356 CAN GO TO TO FIND SOME UPDATED 395 00:15:06,356 --> 00:15:07,524 INFORMATION ABOUT POLICY 396 00:15:07,524 --> 00:15:09,960 UPDATES. 397 00:15:09,960 --> 00:15:11,795 THE NEXT TWO SLIDES GO OVER KEY 398 00:15:11,795 --> 00:15:12,729 POLICY UPDATES. 399 00:15:12,729 --> 00:15:14,565 I WILL GO THROUGH THIS QUITE 400 00:15:14,565 --> 00:15:16,200 QUICKLY BUT I STILL THINK IT'S 401 00:15:16,200 --> 00:15:18,135 IMPORTANT TO THE EXTENT THERE'S 402 00:15:18,135 --> 00:15:19,503 MEMBERS OF THE EXTRAMURAL 403 00:15:19,503 --> 00:15:20,871 COMMUNITY TO BE WATCHING THESE 404 00:15:20,871 --> 00:15:22,105 TO BE AWARE OF THESE. 405 00:15:22,105 --> 00:15:23,874 I SORT OF GROUPED THEM INTO 406 00:15:23,874 --> 00:15:25,175 SOME KEY AREAS. 407 00:15:25,175 --> 00:15:27,477 THE FIRST IS AROUND TRAINING 408 00:15:27,477 --> 00:15:29,112 AND EARLY CAREER. 409 00:15:29,112 --> 00:15:30,480 SO MENTORED CAREER, DEVELOPMENT 410 00:15:30,480 --> 00:15:32,082 AWARD ELIGIBILITY WAS EXTENDED 411 00:15:32,082 --> 00:15:33,317 FOR INDIVIDUALS WHOSE AWARDS 412 00:15:33,317 --> 00:15:34,484 WERE TERMINATED EARLY. 413 00:15:34,484 --> 00:15:38,455 THERE WAS ALSO AN EXTENSION OF 414 00:15:38,455 --> 00:15:40,591 E.S.I. STATUS FOR PEOPLE WHOSE 415 00:15:40,591 --> 00:15:41,925 E.S.I.'S STATUS WAS GOING TO 416 00:15:41,925 --> 00:15:43,293 HAVE EXPIRED BETWEEN OCTOBER OF 417 00:15:43,293 --> 00:15:47,764 2024 AND JULY OF 2025. 418 00:15:47,764 --> 00:15:49,199 THIS NEXT BULLET, THERE'S 419 00:15:49,199 --> 00:15:51,335 ACTUALLY, THERE WAS AN EARLY 420 00:15:51,335 --> 00:15:54,671 EXPIRATION DATE TO THE PARENT 421 00:15:54,671 --> 00:15:56,206 FELLOWSHIP NOFO'S BUT THOSE GOT 422 00:15:56,206 --> 00:15:57,207 RELEASED EITHER FRIDAY AND 423 00:15:57,207 --> 00:15:59,509 MONDAY, SO BETWEEN WHEN I 424 00:15:59,509 --> 00:16:00,077 FINALIZED THESE SLIDES AND 425 00:16:00,077 --> 00:16:02,246 TODAY. 426 00:16:02,246 --> 00:16:05,082 IF YOU GO, AND THERE'S SOME 427 00:16:05,082 --> 00:16:05,849 CHANGES TO LATEST FOREIGN 428 00:16:05,849 --> 00:16:08,585 PACKAGE BUT IF YOU LOOK AT THE 429 00:16:08,585 --> 00:16:10,554 NEW NOFO'S FOR THOSE, NOTICE OF 430 00:16:10,554 --> 00:16:11,488 FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES, YOU CAN 431 00:16:11,488 --> 00:16:12,789 FIND OUT ABOUT THAT. 432 00:16:12,789 --> 00:16:14,458 AND THERE WAS SOME CHANGES TO 433 00:16:14,458 --> 00:16:19,296 THE CHILD CARE COSTS IN THE 434 00:16:19,296 --> 00:16:19,930 INSTITUTIONAL RESEARCH TRAINING 435 00:16:19,930 --> 00:16:23,667 AWARDS. 436 00:16:23,667 --> 00:16:25,102 FOR FOREIGN SUBAWARDS AND 437 00:16:25,102 --> 00:16:26,503 COLLABORATIONS, NIH IS NO 438 00:16:26,503 --> 00:16:28,405 LONGER ISSUING AWARDS TO 439 00:16:28,405 --> 00:16:29,773 DOMESTIC OR FOREIGN ENTITIES 440 00:16:29,773 --> 00:16:33,543 THAT INCLUDE SUBAWARDS. 441 00:16:33,543 --> 00:16:34,778 THIS CAME OUT IN NOT-OD-25-104. 442 00:16:34,778 --> 00:16:36,813 THERE WILL BE A NEW AWARD 443 00:16:36,813 --> 00:16:38,949 STRUCTURE IN THE INTERIM 444 00:16:38,949 --> 00:16:40,817 INSTITUTIONS CAN RENEGOTIATE OR 445 00:16:40,817 --> 00:16:42,452 TO TRANSFER THE WORK TO EITHER 446 00:16:42,452 --> 00:16:44,521 THE PRIME OR TO A DIFFERENT 447 00:16:44,521 --> 00:16:45,889 DOMESTIC SUB RECIPIENT. 448 00:16:45,889 --> 00:16:48,058 AND THEN THERE WAS ALSO A 449 00:16:48,058 --> 00:16:50,360 NOTICE REMINDING PEOPLE THAT IF 450 00:16:50,360 --> 00:16:53,130 YOU HAVE AN INDICATION OF 451 00:16:53,130 --> 00:16:55,465 FOREIGN ACTIVITIES OR 452 00:16:55,465 --> 00:16:56,133 INTERNATIONAL COLLABORATIONS IN 453 00:16:56,133 --> 00:16:59,303 YOUR AWARDS YOU NEED TO INCLUDE 454 00:16:59,303 --> 00:17:00,404 A FOREIGN JUSTIFICATION. 455 00:17:00,404 --> 00:17:02,572 THAT USED TO BE SOMETHING THAT 456 00:17:02,572 --> 00:17:03,707 COULD SOMETIMES BE HANDLED IN 457 00:17:03,707 --> 00:17:05,142 THE JUST IN TIME PROCESS. 458 00:17:05,142 --> 00:17:07,678 THAT'S NO LONGER THE CASE, IF 459 00:17:07,678 --> 00:17:08,879 THAT'S NOT AVAILABLE, THE 460 00:17:08,879 --> 00:17:10,681 AWARDS WILL BE WITHDRAWN. 461 00:17:10,681 --> 00:17:13,784 THAT WAS A NOTICE OF INCREASED 462 00:17:13,784 --> 00:17:14,351 ENFORCEMENT OF AN EXISTING 463 00:17:14,351 --> 00:17:16,119 POLICY. 464 00:17:16,119 --> 00:17:18,021 OTHER AREAS WHERE THERE'S SOME 465 00:17:18,021 --> 00:17:18,955 KEY POLICIES, THE FIRST ONE 466 00:17:18,955 --> 00:17:20,824 THAT CAME OUT WAS A CHANGE TO 467 00:17:20,824 --> 00:17:22,259 THE INDIRECT COST RATE, THAT 468 00:17:22,259 --> 00:17:23,827 ONE IS CURRENTLY ON HOLD. 469 00:17:23,827 --> 00:17:25,962 A MAJOR CHANGE IS THAT ALL 470 00:17:25,962 --> 00:17:28,465 REQUESTS FOR NO COST EXTENSIONS 471 00:17:28,465 --> 00:17:30,067 NOW MUST BE SUBMITTED AS A 472 00:17:30,067 --> 00:17:31,535 PRIOR APPROVAL REQUEST. 473 00:17:31,535 --> 00:17:33,370 THERE'S BEEN SOME BACK AND 474 00:17:33,370 --> 00:17:35,205 FORTH ABOUT A NEW CIVIL RIGHTS 475 00:17:35,205 --> 00:17:36,206 TERM THAT WAS ADDED. 476 00:17:36,206 --> 00:17:38,175 AND THEN ON HOLD. 477 00:17:38,175 --> 00:17:39,309 THERE'S AN UPDATED NOTICE 478 00:17:39,309 --> 00:17:40,644 AROUND THAT. 479 00:17:40,644 --> 00:17:42,512 THE NIH PUBLIC ACCESS POLICY, 480 00:17:42,512 --> 00:17:44,414 WHICH HAD ALWAYS BEEN IN WORKS, 481 00:17:44,414 --> 00:17:46,116 THE EFFECTIVE DATE FOR THAT GOT 482 00:17:46,116 --> 00:17:49,986 MOVED FORWARD, SO IT ACTUALLY 483 00:17:49,986 --> 00:17:51,054 WILL START JULY 1st OR 484 00:17:51,054 --> 00:17:52,122 BEGINNING OF NEXT MONTH. 485 00:17:52,122 --> 00:17:53,790 NRZ BEEN A COUPLE THINGS I 486 00:17:53,790 --> 00:17:56,193 COULD HAVE GROUPED TOGETHER 487 00:17:56,193 --> 00:17:58,328 SORT OF AROUND SOME OF THAT 488 00:17:58,328 --> 00:18:00,864 SAFETY AND TRANSPARENCY SPACE. 489 00:18:00,864 --> 00:18:06,103 SO SOME INFORMATION ABOUT GAIN 490 00:18:06,103 --> 00:18:07,504 OF FUNCTION RESEARCH, ONE 491 00:18:07,504 --> 00:18:13,844 ADDRESSING IN A RELATIONSHIP TO 492 00:18:13,844 --> 00:18:15,278 RECOMBINANT OR SYNTHETIC 493 00:18:15,278 --> 00:18:20,217 NUCLEIC ACID MOLECULES THAT'S 494 00:18:20,217 --> 00:18:22,018 THE TITLE, PUBLICLY POST 495 00:18:22,018 --> 00:18:23,854 INSTITUTIONAL BIO SAFETY 496 00:18:23,854 --> 00:18:24,921 COMMITTEE ROSTERS AND POSTING 497 00:18:24,921 --> 00:18:27,324 MEETING MINUTES GOING FORWARD. 498 00:18:27,324 --> 00:18:29,059 FINALLY, THIS IS RELEVANT TO 499 00:18:29,059 --> 00:18:32,162 OUR COMMUNITY IN THE GDS SPACE, 500 00:18:32,162 --> 00:18:34,531 THERE WAS NOTICE PUT OUT ABOUT 501 00:18:34,531 --> 00:18:35,665 GENERATIVE AI AND CONTROLLED 502 00:18:35,665 --> 00:18:37,601 ACCESS TO GENOMIC DATA. 503 00:18:37,601 --> 00:18:39,736 SO APPROVED USERS MAY DEVELOP 504 00:18:39,736 --> 00:18:40,837 AI MODELS USING CONTROLLED 505 00:18:40,837 --> 00:18:42,739 ACCESS DATA BUT THEY CAN ONLY 506 00:18:42,739 --> 00:18:44,141 SHARE THOSE WITH APPROVED 507 00:18:44,141 --> 00:18:45,776 COLLABORATORS AND MAY NOT 508 00:18:45,776 --> 00:18:46,743 RETAIN THE MODELS OR PARAMETERS 509 00:18:46,743 --> 00:18:48,879 AFTER CLOSE OUT OF THE PROJECT. 510 00:18:48,879 --> 00:18:53,350 NOW I WILL NOTE, IN THIS 511 00:18:53,350 --> 00:18:55,018 SPECIFIC AREA, THERE'S 512 00:18:55,018 --> 00:18:56,186 RELATEDLY AN R.F.I. ON 513 00:18:56,186 --> 00:18:58,088 RESPONSIBLE DEVELOPMENT AND 514 00:18:58,088 --> 00:19:03,293 SHARING OF GENERATIVE A.I. 515 00:19:03,293 --> 00:19:05,862 TOOLS USING ACCESS DATA. 516 00:19:05,862 --> 00:19:08,231 THE PURPOSE IS GAIN INPUT ON 517 00:19:08,231 --> 00:19:11,501 STRATEGIES TO PREVENT LEAKAGE 518 00:19:11,501 --> 00:19:15,305 OF SENSITIVE HUMAN GENOMIC DATA 519 00:19:15,305 --> 00:19:16,139 WHEN SHARING MODELS. 520 00:19:16,139 --> 00:19:18,475 LOOKING TO STRIKE A BALANCE 521 00:19:18,475 --> 00:19:20,043 BETWEEN DATA SECURITY WHILE 522 00:19:20,043 --> 00:19:21,878 ALSO FOSTERING BROAD INNOVATION 523 00:19:21,878 --> 00:19:22,712 IN THIS SPACE. 524 00:19:22,712 --> 00:19:24,314 SO WE ARE SEEKING PUBLIC 525 00:19:24,314 --> 00:19:26,216 FEEDBACK ON THE TYPES AND 526 00:19:26,216 --> 00:19:28,318 DEGREES OF RISKS ASSOCIATED 527 00:19:28,318 --> 00:19:30,921 WITH GENERATIVE AI MODELS USING 528 00:19:30,921 --> 00:19:32,622 CONTROLLED ACCESS DATA AS 529 00:19:32,622 --> 00:19:33,256 PRACTICAL STRATEGIES AND 530 00:19:33,256 --> 00:19:35,192 TECHNOLOGIES THAT COULD BE USED 531 00:19:35,192 --> 00:19:37,961 TO MITIGATE THESE RISKS. 532 00:19:37,961 --> 00:19:39,596 HERE IS INFORMATION ELECTRONIC 533 00:19:39,596 --> 00:19:41,498 COMMENTS WILL BE ACCEPTED 534 00:19:41,498 --> 00:19:41,898 THROUGH JULY 16th. 535 00:19:41,898 --> 00:19:45,702 IF YOU WANT TO KNOW MORE YOU 536 00:19:45,702 --> 00:19:46,903 CAN FOLLOW THIS NOT-OD-25-118 537 00:19:46,903 --> 00:19:47,637 TO GET THE INFORMATION 538 00:19:47,637 --> 00:19:55,912 INCLUDING HOW TO RESPOND. 539 00:19:55,912 --> 00:19:58,215 SO WE ALSO CONTINUE TO HAVE 540 00:19:58,215 --> 00:20:00,350 FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES AVAILABLE 541 00:20:00,350 --> 00:20:03,086 FROM THE NIH FUNDING 542 00:20:03,086 --> 00:20:05,222 OPPORTUNITIES, THE NIH GUIDE 543 00:20:05,222 --> 00:20:05,922 FOR CONTRACTS, THAT'S THE 544 00:20:05,922 --> 00:20:07,424 STANDARD PAGE YOU HAVE ALWAYS 545 00:20:07,424 --> 00:20:07,858 GONE TO. 546 00:20:07,858 --> 00:20:09,259 THERE ACTUALLY HAVE BEEN IN THE 547 00:20:09,259 --> 00:20:14,097 LAST SEVERAL DAYS A NUMBER OF 548 00:20:14,097 --> 00:20:15,065 NOTICE OF FUNDING 549 00:20:15,065 --> 00:20:15,899 OPPORTUNITIES, THERE HAVEN'T 550 00:20:15,899 --> 00:20:17,901 BEEN ANY FOR A WHILE BUT THERE 551 00:20:17,901 --> 00:20:18,802 HAVE NOW BEEN, SORRY, MY WATCH 552 00:20:18,802 --> 00:20:21,304 IS BUZZING. 553 00:20:21,304 --> 00:20:22,973 THERE'S NOW BEEN SOME UP THERE, 554 00:20:22,973 --> 00:20:24,875 SO I ENCOURAGE YOU TO CONTINUE 555 00:20:24,875 --> 00:20:26,910 TO LOOK AT THE NIH GUIDE. 556 00:20:26,910 --> 00:20:28,378 BUT IN ADDITION THERE'S BEEN 557 00:20:28,378 --> 00:20:30,947 SOME CHANGES TO OUR PROCESS AND 558 00:20:30,947 --> 00:20:32,382 SO, BEFORE THINGS GO TO THE 559 00:20:32,382 --> 00:20:34,384 GUIDE, THERE'S GOING TO BE 560 00:20:34,384 --> 00:20:36,152 THESE FEDERAL-WIDE FORECASTS. 561 00:20:36,152 --> 00:20:39,623 SO YOU CAN GO TO THIS PAGE TO 562 00:20:39,623 --> 00:20:41,224 FIND WHAT IS HAPPENING IN THE 563 00:20:41,224 --> 00:20:42,192 FORECAST SPACE. 564 00:20:42,192 --> 00:20:45,929 IF YOU WANT TO FIND INITIATIVES 565 00:20:45,929 --> 00:20:46,596 FORECASTED SPECIFICALLY 566 00:20:46,596 --> 00:20:47,497 SUPPORTED BY NHGRI, WE SHOULD 567 00:20:47,497 --> 00:20:49,232 WORK IN THE FUTURE TO MAKE SURE 568 00:20:49,232 --> 00:20:50,834 WE HAVE NHGRI IN THERE WELL 569 00:20:50,834 --> 00:20:52,068 ENOUGH IT SHOWS UP AS A SEARCH 570 00:20:52,068 --> 00:20:52,903 TERM. 571 00:20:52,903 --> 00:20:54,337 BUT IF YOU REALLY WANT TO MAKE 572 00:20:54,337 --> 00:20:56,406 SURE YOU GET EVERYTHING YOU 573 00:20:56,406 --> 00:20:59,309 SEARCH FOR OUR SYSTEM'S 574 00:20:59,309 --> 00:21:00,410 LISTING, SEARCH FOR 93.172. 575 00:21:00,410 --> 00:21:03,780 THIS IS WHERE THINGS WILL BE 576 00:21:03,780 --> 00:21:04,681 COMING FORWARD AHEAD OF THEM 577 00:21:04,681 --> 00:21:07,117 WINDING UP IN THE GUIDE. 578 00:21:07,117 --> 00:21:08,385 WE ENCOURAGE PEOPLE TO USE THIS. 579 00:21:08,385 --> 00:21:09,653 IT'S NOT EXACTLY THE SAME AS 580 00:21:09,653 --> 00:21:11,922 WHEN WE HAD A NOTICE OF INTENT 581 00:21:11,922 --> 00:21:13,757 TO PUBLISH BUT IT WILL GIVE YOU 582 00:21:13,757 --> 00:21:15,392 AN IDEA OF WHEN THINGS COME 583 00:21:15,392 --> 00:21:16,126 FORWARD OR MAY COME FORWARD IN 584 00:21:16,126 --> 00:21:17,460 THE FUTURE. 585 00:21:17,460 --> 00:21:18,862 THERE'S NO GUARANTY THAT THINGS 586 00:21:18,862 --> 00:21:19,696 THAT ARE FORECASTED WILL MAKE 587 00:21:19,696 --> 00:21:22,265 IT ALL THE WAY TO BEING A NOFO, 588 00:21:22,265 --> 00:21:23,700 BUT IT COULD GIVE YOU AN IDEA 589 00:21:23,700 --> 00:21:25,068 WHAT COULD BE COMING IN THE 590 00:21:25,068 --> 00:21:26,703 PIPELINE AND THINGS YOU MIGHT 591 00:21:26,703 --> 00:21:28,438 BE LOOKING AT OR INTERESTED IN. 592 00:21:28,438 --> 00:21:29,739 SO FOR EXAMPLE, THE THINGS THAT 593 00:21:29,739 --> 00:21:31,174 WE ARE PRESENTING IN COUNCIL 594 00:21:31,174 --> 00:21:32,842 TODAY, IF THEY CONTINUE TO MOVE 595 00:21:32,842 --> 00:21:34,311 FORWARD, IF THEY GET COUNCIL 596 00:21:34,311 --> 00:21:35,679 APPROVAL AND WE CONTINUE TO 597 00:21:35,679 --> 00:21:38,214 MOVE FORWARD, THEY WILL APPEAR 598 00:21:38,214 --> 00:21:39,316 FIRST IN THIS FEDERAL-WIDE 599 00:21:39,316 --> 00:21:41,685 FORECAST SPACE BEFORE THEY 600 00:21:41,685 --> 00:21:42,619 POTENTIALLY GO ONTO BECOMING 601 00:21:42,619 --> 00:21:47,691 ACTUAL FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES. 602 00:21:47,691 --> 00:21:50,026 ANOTHER MAJOR CHANGE, I'M SORT 603 00:21:50,026 --> 00:21:51,861 OF WORKING US FROM POLICY, THAT 604 00:21:51,861 --> 00:21:53,296 IS THE UPSTREAM POLICY OF 605 00:21:53,296 --> 00:21:54,664 THINGS YOU NEED TO KNOW, NOTICE 606 00:21:54,664 --> 00:21:56,533 OF FUNDING AWARDS. 607 00:21:56,533 --> 00:21:58,435 MOVING INTO THE REVIEW SPACE. 608 00:21:58,435 --> 00:22:01,037 A MAJOR CHANGE THAT'S HAPPENED 609 00:22:01,037 --> 00:22:03,373 AT NIH IS SCIENTIFIC REVIEW HAS 610 00:22:03,373 --> 00:22:06,676 BEEN CONSOLIDATED. 611 00:22:06,676 --> 00:22:09,646 SO PREVIOUSLY SCIENTIFIC REVIEW 612 00:22:09,646 --> 00:22:11,715 WAS HANDLED THROUGH SCIENTIFIC 613 00:22:11,715 --> 00:22:15,919 REVIEW AT CSR, WHICH FOCUSED 614 00:22:15,919 --> 00:22:19,422 PRIMARILY ON INVESTIGATIVE WORK 615 00:22:19,422 --> 00:22:21,291 THROUGH THE PARENT NOFO'S, AS 616 00:22:21,291 --> 00:22:22,759 WELL AS COLLABORATIVE 617 00:22:22,759 --> 00:22:25,395 INITIATIVES AND THEN THERE WERE 618 00:22:25,395 --> 00:22:27,030 SCIENTIFIC REVIEW OFFICERS OR 619 00:22:27,030 --> 00:22:28,198 SRO'S AT INDIVIDUAL INSTITUTES 620 00:22:28,198 --> 00:22:31,401 AND CENTERS WHO ORGANIZED THEIR 621 00:22:31,401 --> 00:22:32,802 OWN REVIEWS. 622 00:22:32,802 --> 00:22:34,037 FOCUSING TYPICALLY ON COMPLEX 623 00:22:34,037 --> 00:22:37,040 MECHANISMS, ON THINGS THAT CAME 624 00:22:37,040 --> 00:22:40,610 IN UNDER SPECIFIC NOFO'S FOR 625 00:22:40,610 --> 00:22:42,479 INITIATIVES AS WELL AS SOME OF 626 00:22:42,479 --> 00:22:44,948 OUR TRAINING PORTFOLIO. 627 00:22:44,948 --> 00:22:46,149 SO NOW, STARTING WITH 628 00:22:46,149 --> 00:22:47,317 APPLICATIONS GOING TO OCTOBER 629 00:22:47,317 --> 00:22:48,485 COUNCIL AND BEYOND, SO STARTING 630 00:22:48,485 --> 00:22:49,919 WITH THE REVIEW THAT IS 631 00:22:49,919 --> 00:22:51,988 HAPPENING THIS SUMMER, ALL OF 632 00:22:51,988 --> 00:22:54,257 THIS HAS BEEN CONSOLIDATED INTO 633 00:22:54,257 --> 00:22:55,525 THE CSR. 634 00:22:55,525 --> 00:22:58,495 THIS IS GOING TO BE A MAJOR 635 00:22:58,495 --> 00:22:59,362 CHANGE ACROSS NIH. 636 00:22:59,362 --> 00:23:03,299 WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT IT FROM A 637 00:23:03,299 --> 00:23:04,768 NHGRI PERSPECTIVE. 638 00:23:04,768 --> 00:23:08,004 JUST ABOUT HALF OF OUR FUNDED 639 00:23:08,004 --> 00:23:11,374 APPLICATIONS HAVE TRADITIONALLY 640 00:23:11,374 --> 00:23:12,809 GONE THROUGH OUR NHGRI-SPECIFIC 641 00:23:12,809 --> 00:23:13,043 REVIEW. 642 00:23:13,043 --> 00:23:14,911 AND SO THAT'S GOING TO BE SORT 643 00:23:14,911 --> 00:23:17,013 OF A CHANGE IN HOW THE REVIEW 644 00:23:17,013 --> 00:23:18,648 IS DONE, HOW WE INTERACT WITH 645 00:23:18,648 --> 00:23:20,116 REVIEW AND A LITTLE BIT IN 646 00:23:20,116 --> 00:23:21,551 TERMS OF WHAT WE EXPECT IN 647 00:23:21,551 --> 00:23:24,320 TERMS OF THE TYPES OF REVIEWS 648 00:23:24,320 --> 00:23:26,089 WE GET, PARTICULARLY DURING 649 00:23:26,089 --> 00:23:27,590 THIS INITIAL TRANSITION PROCESS. 650 00:23:27,590 --> 00:23:28,758 SO THAT'S SOMETHING WE ARE 651 00:23:28,758 --> 00:23:30,627 GOING TO BE WATCHING AND 652 00:23:30,627 --> 00:23:32,028 MONITORING AND MAYBE HAVING 653 00:23:32,028 --> 00:23:32,696 DISCUSSIONS WITH COUNCIL WITH 654 00:23:32,696 --> 00:23:35,532 AS WE SORT OF LOOK AT HOW THE 655 00:23:35,532 --> 00:23:37,867 CSR REVIEW GOES FOR SOME OF OUR 656 00:23:37,867 --> 00:23:39,302 INITIAL INITIATIVES COMING 657 00:23:39,302 --> 00:23:40,036 THROUGH THAT PROCESS. 658 00:23:40,036 --> 00:23:42,539 I WANT TO TAKE A MOMENT TO GIVE 659 00:23:42,539 --> 00:23:46,209 MANY THANKS TO THE FORMER NHGRI 660 00:23:46,209 --> 00:23:47,544 SCIENTIFIC REVIEW BRANCH 661 00:23:47,544 --> 00:23:47,977 MEMBERS. 662 00:23:47,977 --> 00:23:49,979 A NUMBER OF THEM HAVE RETIRED. 663 00:23:49,979 --> 00:23:52,148 A COUPLE OF THEM MOVED TO CSR 664 00:23:52,148 --> 00:23:53,983 AND A COUPLE PEOPLE FROM THAT 665 00:23:53,983 --> 00:23:55,885 BRANCH HAVE TAKEN NEW ROLES AT 666 00:23:55,885 --> 00:23:58,188 NHGRI BUT THEY HAVE ALL BEEN 667 00:23:58,188 --> 00:23:59,823 MAJOR CONTRIBUTORS TO OUR WORK 668 00:23:59,823 --> 00:24:02,258 AND OUR SUCCESS AND OUR 669 00:24:02,258 --> 00:24:02,692 EXTRAMURAL PROGRAM. 670 00:24:02,692 --> 00:24:05,895 I ALSO WANT TO GIVE MANY THANKS 671 00:24:05,895 --> 00:24:07,130 TO THE GENOME G-STANDING 672 00:24:07,130 --> 00:24:07,697 SECTION MEMBERS WHO ARE OUT 673 00:24:07,697 --> 00:24:08,431 THERE. 674 00:24:08,431 --> 00:24:11,534 I GUESS THEY ARE ALL PASSED 675 00:24:11,534 --> 00:24:13,002 NOW, BUT RECENT PASSED, AS WELL 676 00:24:13,002 --> 00:24:16,806 AS PEOPLE WHO PARTICIPATED IN 677 00:24:16,806 --> 00:24:19,275 THE COUNTLESS SAPS SPECIAL 678 00:24:19,275 --> 00:24:21,878 EMPHASIS PANELS THAT NHGRI HAS 679 00:24:21,878 --> 00:24:22,378 PUT TOGETHER FOR REVIEW. 680 00:24:22,378 --> 00:24:23,313 AND OF COURSE THANK YOU TO 681 00:24:23,313 --> 00:24:24,481 EVERYONE WHO HAS SERVED AND 682 00:24:24,481 --> 00:24:26,649 WILL CONTINUE TO SERVE IN THE 683 00:24:26,649 --> 00:24:31,955 FUTURE ON CSR PANELS. 684 00:24:31,955 --> 00:24:33,389 ANOTHER THING TO NOTE, AND I'M 685 00:24:33,389 --> 00:24:34,958 NOT GOING TO BE ABLE TO TALK 686 00:24:34,958 --> 00:24:37,093 ABOUT THIS VERY MUCH BECAUSE 687 00:24:37,093 --> 00:24:37,794 THERE'S ACTIVE LITIGATION, BUT 688 00:24:37,794 --> 00:24:42,265 THERE HAVE BEEN A NUMBER OF 689 00:24:42,265 --> 00:24:42,799 AWARDS TERMINATED BY NIH. 690 00:24:42,799 --> 00:24:46,503 AND YOU CAN GO TO THIS WEBSITE, 691 00:24:46,503 --> 00:24:47,737 THIS TAGGS WEBSITE TO FIND OUT 692 00:24:47,737 --> 00:24:50,340 ABOUT SOME OF THIS. 693 00:24:50,340 --> 00:24:52,909 IF YOU FOLLOW THE LINK THAT 694 00:24:52,909 --> 00:24:55,745 WILL BRING YOU TO A PDF THAT 695 00:24:55,745 --> 00:24:58,181 GETS UPDATED OF ALL TERMINATED 696 00:24:58,181 --> 00:24:58,848 HHS GRANTS. 697 00:24:58,848 --> 00:25:00,216 JUST WANTING PEOPLE TO BE AWARE 698 00:25:00,216 --> 00:25:02,385 OF THAT AS SOMETHING THAT IS 699 00:25:02,385 --> 00:25:04,587 SORT OF HAPPENING IN THE 700 00:25:04,587 --> 00:25:08,057 EXTRAMURAL COMMUNITY THESE DAYS. 701 00:25:08,057 --> 00:25:18,601 SO MOVING FROM NIH TO NHGRI WE 702 00:25:19,602 --> 00:25:20,503 HAVE HAD LEADERSHIP CHANGES, 703 00:25:20,503 --> 00:25:22,739 ERIC GREEN DID NOT HAVE HIS 704 00:25:22,739 --> 00:25:26,476 APPOINTMENT, HE DID NOT GET 705 00:25:26,476 --> 00:25:28,278 REAPPOINTED FOR HIS IC DIRECTOR 706 00:25:28,278 --> 00:25:31,514 TERM YEAR, HE WAS UP FOR 707 00:25:31,514 --> 00:25:34,984 REAPPOINTED AND THE DIDN'T GET 708 00:25:34,984 --> 00:25:36,786 REAPPOINTED AND BONHAM HAS BEEN 709 00:25:36,786 --> 00:25:39,055 MOVED OUT OF HIS LEADERSHIP 710 00:25:39,055 --> 00:25:39,889 POSITION LEADING TO ME BEING IN 711 00:25:39,889 --> 00:25:43,126 THIS ROLE. 712 00:25:43,126 --> 00:25:44,594 WE HAVE SOME GOOD NEWS 713 00:25:44,594 --> 00:25:46,095 LEADERSHIP CHANGES IN OUR 714 00:25:46,095 --> 00:25:46,896 EXTRAMURAL PROGRAM. 715 00:25:46,896 --> 00:25:49,432 SOME OF THIS, ALL OF THIS 716 00:25:49,432 --> 00:25:51,067 HAPPENED PRIOR TO THE HIRING 717 00:25:51,067 --> 00:25:52,135 FREEZE, BUT SINCE OUR LAST 718 00:25:52,135 --> 00:26:00,610 COUNCIL. 719 00:26:00,610 --> 00:26:03,146 SO ERIN RAMOS THE POSITION I 720 00:26:03,146 --> 00:26:05,014 USED TO HOLD, LISA CHADWICK AS 721 00:26:05,014 --> 00:26:09,219 HER DEPUTY. 722 00:26:09,219 --> 00:26:12,989 SIMONA VOLPI FOR DIVISION OF 723 00:26:12,989 --> 00:26:15,058 GENOMIC MEDICINE AND HEATHER 724 00:26:15,058 --> 00:26:17,427 COLLEY PROGRAM DIRECTOR OFFICE 725 00:26:17,427 --> 00:26:18,528 OF DIRECTOR. 726 00:26:18,528 --> 00:26:20,263 I WANT TO THANK THEM FOR 727 00:26:20,263 --> 00:26:21,798 HELPING TO CONTRIBUTE TO THE 728 00:26:21,798 --> 00:26:23,199 LEADERSHIP NEEDED IN THIS TIME 729 00:26:23,199 --> 00:26:24,667 OF SORT OF GREAT CHANGE. 730 00:26:24,667 --> 00:26:28,338 I WILL ALSO TAKE A MOMENT HERE, 731 00:26:28,338 --> 00:26:29,372 THOUGH THEY AREN'T IN 732 00:26:29,372 --> 00:26:30,473 EXTRAMURAL LEADERSHIP TO GIVE A 733 00:26:30,473 --> 00:26:35,445 HUGE THANK YOU TO ELLEN AND JOE 734 00:26:35,445 --> 00:26:37,080 HANKY IN OUR EXECUTIVE OFFICER 735 00:26:37,080 --> 00:26:39,415 AND TEP TI EXECUTIVE OFFICER 736 00:26:39,415 --> 00:26:40,617 WHO HAVE REALLY BEEN CRITICAL 737 00:26:40,617 --> 00:26:42,919 WITH ALL OF OUR STAFF IN 738 00:26:42,919 --> 00:26:45,989 GUIDING US THROUGH THIS TIME. 739 00:26:45,989 --> 00:26:48,057 WE HAVE SOME, ADDITIONALLY WE 740 00:26:48,057 --> 00:26:53,229 HAVE TWO NEW PROGRAM DIRECTORS. 741 00:26:53,229 --> 00:26:55,832 ELENA HERNANDEZ-RAMON IN OFFICE 742 00:26:55,832 --> 00:26:58,034 OF DIRECTOR AND LI ZHANG IN 743 00:26:58,034 --> 00:26:59,869 DIVISION OF GENOMIC MEDICINE. 744 00:26:59,869 --> 00:27:03,406 WE ARE GLAD TO HAVE THEM ON OUR 745 00:27:03,406 --> 00:27:04,874 TEAM AND CONTRIBUTING TO OUR 746 00:27:04,874 --> 00:27:07,443 PROGRAM STAFF AT NHGRI. 747 00:27:07,443 --> 00:27:10,246 WE HAVE ALSO HAD SIGNIFICANT 748 00:27:10,246 --> 00:27:10,580 STAFF LOSSES. 749 00:27:10,580 --> 00:27:13,116 THE EXACT NUMBERS OF THIS, I 750 00:27:13,116 --> 00:27:14,884 CAN'T, ARE TBD. 751 00:27:14,884 --> 00:27:18,988 SOME OF THIS IS ALSO UNDER 752 00:27:18,988 --> 00:27:19,389 ACTIVE LITIGATION. 753 00:27:19,389 --> 00:27:23,159 BUT IF THINGS MOVE FORWARD WITH 754 00:27:23,159 --> 00:27:24,294 THE INTENDED REDUCTIONS IN 755 00:27:24,294 --> 00:27:25,795 FORCE, ALONG WITH OTHER THING 756 00:27:25,795 --> 00:27:28,431 THAT'S HAVE HAPPENED WE EXPECT 757 00:27:28,431 --> 00:27:30,800 TO HAVE 90 FEWER FEDERAL 758 00:27:30,800 --> 00:27:32,201 EMPLOYEES AT NHGRI BY SEPTEMBER. 759 00:27:32,201 --> 00:27:33,836 TO GIVE THAT NUMBER 760 00:27:33,836 --> 00:27:35,071 PERSPECTIVE, THAT'S A LITTLE 761 00:27:35,071 --> 00:27:36,139 OVER 20% REDUCTION IN OUR TOTAL 762 00:27:36,139 --> 00:27:38,775 STAFF. 763 00:27:38,775 --> 00:27:39,442 THAT DOESN'T INCLUDE 764 00:27:39,442 --> 00:27:40,677 CONTRACTORS. 765 00:27:40,677 --> 00:27:43,279 AND WE HAVE ALSO HAD 766 00:27:43,279 --> 00:27:45,682 SIGNIFICANT CONTRACTOR LOSSES. 767 00:27:45,682 --> 00:27:51,120 THE IMPACTED AREAS FOR NHGRI 768 00:27:51,120 --> 00:27:52,188 OUR ENTIRE COMMUNICATIONS GROUP 769 00:27:52,188 --> 00:27:53,790 HAS BEEN, WAS PART OF THE 770 00:27:53,790 --> 00:27:55,625 REDUCTION AND FORCE EFFORT. 771 00:27:55,625 --> 00:27:58,027 SO THAT MAY BE WHY YOU ARE 772 00:27:58,027 --> 00:27:58,695 NOTICING THERE'S SOME CHANGES. 773 00:27:58,695 --> 00:28:00,263 THEY ARE DOING A GREAT JOB WITH 774 00:28:00,263 --> 00:28:02,899 THE VIDEO HERE, BUT IF IT LOOKS 775 00:28:02,899 --> 00:28:04,233 DIFFERENT THAN DIFFERENT 776 00:28:04,233 --> 00:28:05,201 COUNCILS AND OBVIOUSLY 777 00:28:05,201 --> 00:28:06,102 EVERYTHING OUR AMAZING 778 00:28:06,102 --> 00:28:07,370 COMMUNICATION TEAM HAS DONE HAS 779 00:28:07,370 --> 00:28:09,906 BEEN IMPACTED BY THIS. 780 00:28:09,906 --> 00:28:11,374 SIMILARLY, OUR EDUCATION AND 781 00:28:11,374 --> 00:28:12,241 COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT BRANCH. 782 00:28:12,241 --> 00:28:15,578 OUR POLICY AND PROGRAM ANALYSIS 783 00:28:15,578 --> 00:28:15,812 BRANCH. 784 00:28:15,812 --> 00:28:17,246 ACQUISITIONS AND LOGISTICS AND 785 00:28:17,246 --> 00:28:19,515 OUR MANAGEMENT ANALYSIS AND 786 00:28:19,515 --> 00:28:19,983 WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT. 787 00:28:19,983 --> 00:28:21,317 BRANCHES WERE ALL IMPACTED BY 788 00:28:21,317 --> 00:28:23,586 THE REDUCTION IN FORCE. 789 00:28:23,586 --> 00:28:26,122 SO I WANT TO THANK EVERYBODY 790 00:28:26,122 --> 00:28:29,392 FROM THOSE GROUPS FOR THE 791 00:28:29,392 --> 00:28:30,760 AMAZING CONTRIBUTIONS THAT THEY 792 00:28:30,760 --> 00:28:32,395 HAVE DONE FOR NHGRI AND IT 793 00:28:32,395 --> 00:28:35,198 SEEMS JUST LIKE EVERY DAY WE 794 00:28:35,198 --> 00:28:37,033 RECOGNIZE SOMETHING THAT USED 795 00:28:37,033 --> 00:28:38,468 TO JUST HAPPEN WITHOUT OUR 796 00:28:38,468 --> 00:28:39,869 THINKING ABOUT IT THAT ISN'T 797 00:28:39,869 --> 00:28:42,939 HAPPENING THE WAY WE EXPECTED 798 00:28:42,939 --> 00:28:43,906 BECAUSE OF THESE LOSSES. 799 00:28:43,906 --> 00:28:45,541 AND WE ARE WORKING. 800 00:28:45,541 --> 00:28:47,210 SO JUST HUGE THANK YOU TO 801 00:28:47,210 --> 00:28:48,578 EVERYBODY FROM THOSE GROUPS FOR 802 00:28:48,578 --> 00:28:50,079 EVERYTHING YOU HAVE DONE FOR 803 00:28:50,079 --> 00:28:52,315 NHGRI OVER YOUR TIME. 804 00:28:52,315 --> 00:28:55,385 WE ALSO WERE HIGHLY IMPACTED IN 805 00:28:55,385 --> 00:28:56,052 GRANTS MANAGEMENT. 806 00:28:56,052 --> 00:29:00,723 THIS WAS STARRED OUT BECAUSE IT 807 00:29:00,723 --> 00:29:01,891 WASN'T AN AREA TARGETED AND 808 00:29:01,891 --> 00:29:04,293 MORE IMPACTED BY SOME OF THE 809 00:29:04,293 --> 00:29:04,894 VOLUNTARY RETIREMENT OFFERS 810 00:29:04,894 --> 00:29:07,997 THAT WERE PUT FORWARD. 811 00:29:07,997 --> 00:29:10,133 AND SO, BUT WE FEEL THAT VERY 812 00:29:10,133 --> 00:29:12,001 ACUTELY, SIMILAR TO THE LOSS WE 813 00:29:12,001 --> 00:29:13,569 FEEL IN THESE OTHER IMPACTED 814 00:29:13,569 --> 00:29:15,304 AREAS, SO I WANTED TO CALL THAT 815 00:29:15,304 --> 00:29:17,073 OUT. 816 00:29:17,073 --> 00:29:19,709 DESPITE THIS, YOU KNOW, WE 817 00:29:19,709 --> 00:29:21,944 STILL HAVE AN EYE ON THE NHGRI 818 00:29:21,944 --> 00:29:23,479 STRATEGIC VISION. 819 00:29:23,479 --> 00:29:25,782 WE HAVE TO UPDATE SOME ASPECTS 820 00:29:25,782 --> 00:29:27,650 OF OUR IMPLEMENTATION OF THIS 821 00:29:27,650 --> 00:29:30,953 TO ENSURE ALIGNMENT WITH NEW 822 00:29:30,953 --> 00:29:32,688 HHS AND NIH PRIORITIES BUT THE 823 00:29:32,688 --> 00:29:34,490 UNDERLYING MISSION IS THE SAME. 824 00:29:34,490 --> 00:29:35,892 NAMELY AS LEADING AUTHORITY IN 825 00:29:35,892 --> 00:29:37,760 THE FIELD OF GENOMICS OUR 826 00:29:37,760 --> 00:29:39,595 MISSION IS TO ACCELERATE 827 00:29:39,595 --> 00:29:40,763 SCIENTIFIC AND MEDICAL BREAK 828 00:29:40,763 --> 00:29:42,231 THREWS THAT IMPROVE HUMAN 829 00:29:42,231 --> 00:29:42,465 HEALTH. 830 00:29:42,465 --> 00:29:44,067 WE WILL CONTINUE TO DO THIS BY 831 00:29:44,067 --> 00:29:45,701 DRIVING CUTTING EDGE RESEARCH, 832 00:29:45,701 --> 00:29:47,203 DEVELOPING NEW TECHNOLOGIES AND 833 00:29:47,203 --> 00:29:47,904 STUDYING THE IMPACT OF GENOMICS 834 00:29:47,904 --> 00:29:50,239 ON SOCIETY. 835 00:29:50,239 --> 00:29:52,208 WE WANT TO COLLABORATE AND WORK 836 00:29:52,208 --> 00:29:54,310 WITH THE LARGER SCIENTIFIC AND 837 00:29:54,310 --> 00:29:56,446 MEDICAL COMMUNITIES TO ENHANCE 838 00:29:56,446 --> 00:29:57,580 GENOMIC TECHNOLOGIES THAT 839 00:29:57,580 --> 00:29:59,916 ACCELERATE BREAK THREWS AND 840 00:29:59,916 --> 00:30:03,352 IMPROVE LIVES AND ADVANCE THE 841 00:30:03,352 --> 00:30:03,820 FOREFRONT OF GENOMICS. 842 00:30:03,820 --> 00:30:05,688 I'M JUST GOING TO GIVE A COUPLE 843 00:30:05,688 --> 00:30:07,256 HIGHLIGHTS TO SHOW SOME OF THE 844 00:30:07,256 --> 00:30:08,357 ACTIVITY WE HAVE BEEN DOING 845 00:30:08,357 --> 00:30:10,059 SINCE LAST COUNCIL. 846 00:30:10,059 --> 00:30:11,861 SO IN THE EXTRA MURAL RESEARCH 847 00:30:11,861 --> 00:30:14,897 SIDE, OUR OFFICE OF GENOMIC 848 00:30:14,897 --> 00:30:19,402 DATA SCIENCE HOSTED A WORKSHOP 849 00:30:19,402 --> 00:30:20,803 IMPROVING THE FAIRNESS AND 850 00:30:20,803 --> 00:30:22,038 SUSTAINABILITY OF THE NHGRI 851 00:30:22,038 --> 00:30:23,606 RESOURCES ECOSYSTEM IN MARCH. 852 00:30:23,606 --> 00:30:26,442 THE GOALS OF THE WORKSHOP WERE 853 00:30:26,442 --> 00:30:27,410 DEVELOPED ACTUAL 854 00:30:27,410 --> 00:30:29,011 RECOMMENDATIONS AT THE NHGRI 855 00:30:29,011 --> 00:30:30,179 FUNDED RESOURCE COMMUNITY CAN 856 00:30:30,179 --> 00:30:33,249 ADOPT TO IMPROVE THE FAIRNESS 857 00:30:33,249 --> 00:30:35,618 AND SUSTAINABILITY OF OUR 858 00:30:35,618 --> 00:30:36,452 RESOURCES, ENHANCING THEIR 859 00:30:36,452 --> 00:30:37,086 DISCOVERABILITY, ACCESSIBILITY, 860 00:30:37,086 --> 00:30:39,755 QUALITY AND UTILITY. 861 00:30:39,755 --> 00:30:40,490 WORKSHOP TOPICS WERE 862 00:30:40,490 --> 00:30:43,726 PRIORITIZED BASED ON RESULTS OF 863 00:30:43,726 --> 00:30:44,560 THE SELF-ASSESSMENT PERFORMED, 864 00:30:44,560 --> 00:30:46,562 WE PERFORMED WHICH FOCUSED ON 865 00:30:46,562 --> 00:30:48,364 THE RESOURCES ONGOING PRACTICES 866 00:30:48,364 --> 00:30:50,266 TO IMPLEMENT THE FAIR 867 00:30:50,266 --> 00:30:50,900 PRINCIPLES AND THEIR EFFECTIVE 868 00:30:50,900 --> 00:30:53,536 IMPROVEMENT PLANS. 869 00:30:53,536 --> 00:30:55,905 THESE ARE BEING COMPILED INTO A 870 00:30:55,905 --> 00:30:58,274 REPORT THAT WILL BE RELEASED IN 871 00:30:58,274 --> 00:31:01,777 ZENOTO. 872 00:31:01,777 --> 00:31:03,679 SIMILARLY, THE MOLECULAR 873 00:31:03,679 --> 00:31:06,949 PHENOTYPES ANALYSIS OF CELLS OR 874 00:31:06,949 --> 00:31:09,519 MORPHIC CONSORTIUM IS 875 00:31:09,519 --> 00:31:11,420 DEVELOPING AN EXTENSIVE CATALOG 876 00:31:11,420 --> 00:31:13,289 OF MOLECULAR AND PHENOTYPE A 877 00:31:13,289 --> 00:31:16,826 LILLES OF EVERY HUMAN GENOME, 878 00:31:16,826 --> 00:31:17,960 CONSORTIUM'S MARKER PAPER WAS 879 00:31:17,960 --> 00:31:18,561 PUBLISHED IN NATURE THIS PAST 880 00:31:18,561 --> 00:31:19,862 FEBRUARY. 881 00:31:19,862 --> 00:31:20,930 AND IT ALSO CORRESPONDED WITH 882 00:31:20,930 --> 00:31:23,599 THE FIRST RELEASE OF THE DATA 883 00:31:23,599 --> 00:31:25,635 CATALOG WHICH COULD BE ACCESSED 884 00:31:25,635 --> 00:31:26,169 THROUGH THE CONSORTIUM'S 885 00:31:26,169 --> 00:31:27,537 WEBSITE. 886 00:31:27,537 --> 00:31:30,306 AND FINALLY, I WILL HIGHLIGHT 887 00:31:30,306 --> 00:31:31,941 THIS PAST DECEMBER, NHGRI'S 888 00:31:31,941 --> 00:31:35,378 GENOMIC MEDICINE WORKING GROUP 889 00:31:35,378 --> 00:31:38,281 JOINED WITH NIAID TO HOLD A 890 00:31:38,281 --> 00:31:41,751 16th GENOMIC MEDICINE WITH HOST 891 00:31:41,751 --> 00:31:43,553 GENOMICS AND INFECTIOUS 892 00:31:43,553 --> 00:31:44,187 DISEASES. 893 00:31:44,187 --> 00:31:45,788 SCIENTISTS CONVENED TO REVIEW 894 00:31:45,788 --> 00:31:46,989 RESEARCH OPPORTUNITIES FOR 895 00:31:46,989 --> 00:31:48,124 INCREASING USE OF GENOMIC DATA 896 00:31:48,124 --> 00:31:49,792 IN THE CLINICAL CARE OF INFECK 897 00:31:49,792 --> 00:31:53,029 SHUSING DISEASES. 898 00:31:53,029 --> 00:31:54,197 GENOMIC APPROACHES FOR 899 00:31:54,197 --> 00:31:55,898 IMPROVING IDENTIFICATIONS OF 900 00:31:55,898 --> 00:31:57,633 INDIVIDUALS WITH AIRBORNE 901 00:31:57,633 --> 00:31:59,936 IMMUNITY AND INFECTIOUS DISEASE 902 00:31:59,936 --> 00:32:03,573 COMPONENTS INTO CONSORTIA. 903 00:32:03,573 --> 00:32:05,308 OBVIOUSLY I COULD IDENTIFY 904 00:32:05,308 --> 00:32:06,509 ADDITIONAL WORK THROUGH OUR 905 00:32:06,509 --> 00:32:07,877 CONSORTIA AND ACTIVITIES BUT 906 00:32:07,877 --> 00:32:09,545 WITH OUR LIMITED STAFF, YOU ARE 907 00:32:09,545 --> 00:32:11,013 GOING TO GET MORE LIMITED 908 00:32:11,013 --> 00:32:12,515 HIGHLIGHTS IN TERMS OF THE 909 00:32:12,515 --> 00:32:15,718 ACTIVITIES THAT WE ARE DOING. 910 00:32:15,718 --> 00:32:17,587 I WILL ALSO CALL OUT AND I HAVE 911 00:32:17,587 --> 00:32:19,689 THIS READY BECAUSE THIS WAS 912 00:32:19,689 --> 00:32:21,624 GOING TO BE PREPARED, THIS WAS 913 00:32:21,624 --> 00:32:25,127 PREPARED FOR THE FEBRUARY 914 00:32:25,127 --> 00:32:26,062 COUNCIL, SOME 915 00:32:26,062 --> 00:32:26,562 INVESTIGATOR-INITIATED 916 00:32:26,562 --> 00:32:28,364 HIGHLIGHTS OF WORK FROM OUR 917 00:32:28,364 --> 00:32:29,799 EXTRAMURAL FUNDED INVESTIGATORS. 918 00:32:29,799 --> 00:32:35,638 SO FIRST WE HAVE A PUBLICATION 919 00:32:35,638 --> 00:32:45,381 BY BEI LIU AND COLLEAGUES, 920 00:32:45,381 --> 00:32:49,018 SNORNA FACILITATED PROTEIN 921 00:32:49,018 --> 00:32:53,489 SECRETION REVEAL BID TRANSCRIPT 922 00:32:53,489 --> 00:32:55,324 TOME WIDE SNORNA TARGET 923 00:32:55,324 --> 00:33:00,162 IDENTIFICATION. 924 00:33:00,162 --> 00:33:03,666 GU AND COLLEAGUES WITH A CRISPR 925 00:33:03,666 --> 00:33:06,702 SCREENING METHOD READ OUT IN 926 00:33:06,702 --> 00:33:10,706 CELL TYPES AND CONTEXT ELUSIVE 927 00:33:10,706 --> 00:33:13,676 IN OPTICAL SCREENING. 928 00:33:13,676 --> 00:33:16,245 THEY DEMONSTRATED OPTICAL 929 00:33:16,245 --> 00:33:18,614 PHENOTYPE PINPOINTS LIKELY 930 00:33:18,614 --> 00:33:19,982 PATHOGENIC DERIVED MUTATIONS, 931 00:33:19,982 --> 00:33:21,150 PREVIOUSLY CLASSIFIED OF 932 00:33:21,150 --> 00:33:23,519 UNKNOWN CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE. 933 00:33:23,519 --> 00:33:25,755 LASTLY IN THIS PAPER BY WANG 934 00:33:25,755 --> 00:33:29,759 AND COLLEAGUE RESEARCHERS 935 00:33:29,759 --> 00:33:31,460 DESCRIBED A NEW METHOD 936 00:33:31,460 --> 00:33:33,296 PROGRESSION SCORE BY 937 00:33:33,296 --> 00:33:35,631 INTEGRATING DATA FROM EHR BASED 938 00:33:35,631 --> 00:33:37,700 BIO BANKS AND CONTROL STUDIES 939 00:33:37,700 --> 00:33:39,101 ABLE TO DERIVE RELIABLE RISK 940 00:33:39,101 --> 00:33:41,704 SCORES FOR THE PROGRESSION OF 941 00:33:41,704 --> 00:33:43,939 RHEUMATOID ARTHRITIS AND LUPUS. 942 00:33:43,939 --> 00:33:45,608 AGAIN, JUST A SMALL SUBSET OF 943 00:33:45,608 --> 00:33:46,309 HIGHLIGHTS OF THE IMPORTANT 944 00:33:46,309 --> 00:33:48,711 WORK THAT ALL OF OUR EXTRAMURAL 945 00:33:48,711 --> 00:33:52,481 RESEARCHERS ARE DOING. 946 00:33:52,481 --> 00:33:54,150 THE INTRAMURAL SIDE WE ALSO 947 00:33:54,150 --> 00:33:56,319 CONTINUE TO HAVE SOME 948 00:33:56,319 --> 00:33:59,822 CHALLENGES UNIQUE TO BEING IN 949 00:33:59,822 --> 00:34:00,890 AN INTRAMURAL RESEARCH PROGRAM 950 00:34:00,890 --> 00:34:02,124 AT NIH THESE DAYS BUT ALSO 951 00:34:02,124 --> 00:34:04,226 CONTINUE TO MOVE FORWARD WITH 952 00:34:04,226 --> 00:34:06,962 SOME EXCITING RESEARCH. 953 00:34:06,962 --> 00:34:08,197 CHARLES PUBLISHED A PAPER 954 00:34:08,197 --> 00:34:11,200 WITHIN THE LAST COUPLE WEEKS 955 00:34:11,200 --> 00:34:12,435 FOCUSED ON SUB CONTINENTAL 956 00:34:12,435 --> 00:34:14,036 GENETIC VARIATION IN THE ALL OF 957 00:34:14,036 --> 00:34:16,138 US RESEARCH PROGRAM AND FOUND 958 00:34:16,138 --> 00:34:18,674 THAT SELF-IDENTIFIED RACE AND 959 00:34:18,674 --> 00:34:21,243 ETHNICITY CATEGORIES DO NOT 960 00:34:21,243 --> 00:34:27,416 ALIGN NEATLY WITH GENETIC 961 00:34:27,416 --> 00:34:28,284 VARIATION. 962 00:34:28,284 --> 00:34:29,985 THEY NOTED THAT THESE 963 00:34:29,985 --> 00:34:30,886 DISTINCTIONS IMPACT TRAITS LIKE 964 00:34:30,886 --> 00:34:33,222 BMI AND HEIGHT WHICH ARE 965 00:34:33,222 --> 00:34:33,689 CRUCIAL FOR REDUCING 966 00:34:33,689 --> 00:34:35,624 CONFOUNDING GENETIC ASSOCIATION. 967 00:34:35,624 --> 00:34:37,927 THIS REALLY IS STRONG ALIGNMENT 968 00:34:37,927 --> 00:34:39,829 WITH THE NATIONAL ACADEMIES 969 00:34:39,829 --> 00:34:46,202 REPORT CALL FOR MORE PRECISE 970 00:34:46,202 --> 00:34:46,669 AND CONTEXT SPECIFIC 971 00:34:46,669 --> 00:34:47,470 DESCRIPTORS PREVIOUSLY PRESENT 972 00:34:47,470 --> 00:34:57,813 TODAY THIS COUNCIL. 973 00:34:59,148 --> 00:35:00,716 PHIL PRESENTED COMPARATIVE 974 00:35:00,716 --> 00:35:05,488 ANALYSIS FOR SIX APE SPECIES, 975 00:35:05,488 --> 00:35:06,021 HIGHLY REPETITIVE GENOMIC 976 00:35:06,021 --> 00:35:08,391 REGIONS. 977 00:35:08,391 --> 00:35:10,226 AND ENABLING BETTER COMPARISONS 978 00:35:10,226 --> 00:35:10,593 ACROSS SPECIES. 979 00:35:10,593 --> 00:35:12,328 THIS WAS ABLE TO SHED NEW LIGHT 980 00:35:12,328 --> 00:35:14,897 ON APE GENOME EVOLUTION AND 981 00:35:14,897 --> 00:35:16,599 PROVIDE FOUNDATIONAL RESOURCE 982 00:35:16,599 --> 00:35:19,402 FOR UNDERSTANDING HUMAN 983 00:35:19,402 --> 00:35:28,210 EVOLUTIONARY HISTORY. 984 00:35:28,210 --> 00:35:31,647 MEHRU FOUND CAN MUTATE WITHOUT 985 00:35:31,647 --> 00:35:34,950 HINDERING PRODUCTION. 986 00:35:34,950 --> 00:35:36,085 EMPHASIZING THE IMPORTANT 987 00:35:36,085 --> 00:35:38,654 THINGS THAT COULD BE FOUND 988 00:35:38,654 --> 00:35:39,522 THROUGH DESIGN OF SYNTHETIC 989 00:35:39,522 --> 00:35:41,490 PROTEINS. 990 00:35:41,490 --> 00:35:43,359 AND FINALLY JULIE SEGRE AND 991 00:35:43,359 --> 00:35:46,829 COLLEAGUES FOUND THE SKIN 992 00:35:46,829 --> 00:35:49,632 SERVES AS KEY RESERVOIR FOR 993 00:35:49,632 --> 00:35:51,200 BACTERIA IN NURSING HOMES AND 994 00:35:51,200 --> 00:35:53,068 CONTRIBUTES TO THE SPREAD 995 00:35:53,068 --> 00:35:54,069 WITHIN FACILITIES SO THIS 996 00:35:54,069 --> 00:35:56,539 HIGHLIGHTS THE IMPORTANCE OF 997 00:35:56,539 --> 00:35:59,575 CONSIDERING THE SKIN RESERVOIR 998 00:35:59,575 --> 00:36:05,481 WHEN CONSIDERING BOTH TRACKING 999 00:36:05,481 --> 00:36:06,348 AND ADDRESSING POTENTIAL 1000 00:36:06,348 --> 00:36:07,349 INFECTION PREVENTION METHODS IN 1001 00:36:07,349 --> 00:36:09,185 THOSE SETTINGS. 1002 00:36:09,185 --> 00:36:11,086 SO AGAIN, MANY MORE HIGHLIGHTS 1003 00:36:11,086 --> 00:36:12,922 COULD HAVE BEEN BROUGHT FORWARD 1004 00:36:12,922 --> 00:36:14,824 FROM OUR INTRA AND EXTRAMURAL 1005 00:36:14,824 --> 00:36:17,359 PROGRAMS BUT I WANT TO SHOW 1006 00:36:17,359 --> 00:36:18,794 THIS TO SHOW HOW SCIENCE IS 1007 00:36:18,794 --> 00:36:20,796 CONTINUING TO MOVE FORWARD IN 1008 00:36:20,796 --> 00:36:21,096 THESE TIMES. 1009 00:36:21,096 --> 00:36:23,098 I WILL JUST SAY THERE'S A LOT 1010 00:36:23,098 --> 00:36:24,700 HAPPENING AT NHGRI TODAY. 1011 00:36:24,700 --> 00:36:27,269 AT ONE POINT I WAS SUPPOSED TO 1012 00:36:27,269 --> 00:36:29,305 BE THREE PLACES AT ONCE. 1013 00:36:29,305 --> 00:36:31,407 OUR CLINICAL FELLOWS ARE HAVING 1014 00:36:31,407 --> 00:36:31,807 THEIR GRADUATION. 1015 00:36:31,807 --> 00:36:33,042 I WAS ABLE TO PROVIDE TAPED 1016 00:36:33,042 --> 00:36:35,644 REMARKS FOR THEM AND SOME 1017 00:36:35,644 --> 00:36:37,313 EXCITING ACTIVITIES AND I JUST 1018 00:36:37,313 --> 00:36:43,352 WANT TO SAY CONGRATULATIONS TO 1019 00:36:43,352 --> 00:36:43,719 THOSE GRADUATES. 1020 00:36:43,719 --> 00:36:51,494 WE ARE SAVING OUR QUADRENNIAL 1021 00:36:51,494 --> 00:36:55,030 REVIEW SITE VISIT. 1022 00:36:55,030 --> 00:36:56,932 THEY UNDERGO A REVIEW FROM THE 1023 00:36:56,932 --> 00:36:58,100 PREVIOUS FOUR YEARS AS WELL AS 1024 00:36:58,100 --> 00:37:00,202 PLANS FOR THE NEXT FOUR YEARS 1025 00:37:00,202 --> 00:37:02,137 THIS IS VITAL FOR MAINTAINING 1026 00:37:02,137 --> 00:37:03,706 HIGH STANDARDS OF EXCELLENCE IN 1027 00:37:03,706 --> 00:37:05,341 THE PROGRAM AND MAKING 1028 00:37:05,341 --> 00:37:07,543 DECISIONS ABOUT FUTURE RESEARCH 1029 00:37:07,543 --> 00:37:07,843 ALLOCATIONS. 1030 00:37:07,843 --> 00:37:09,578 SO I WANT TO THANK, I THANK 1031 00:37:09,578 --> 00:37:10,846 THEM IN PERSON BUT THAT'S WHERE 1032 00:37:10,846 --> 00:37:14,850 I WAS THIS MORNING TO THE 1033 00:37:14,850 --> 00:37:16,352 PEOPLE PARTICIPATING IN THAT 1034 00:37:16,352 --> 00:37:18,120 QUADRENNIAL REVIEW. 1035 00:37:18,120 --> 00:37:19,455 I'M GOING TO JUST HIGHLIGHT 1036 00:37:19,455 --> 00:37:20,689 THAT WE HAVE A REALLY GREAT 1037 00:37:20,689 --> 00:37:22,725 OPEN SESSION. 1038 00:37:22,725 --> 00:37:26,729 WE WILL HAVE A T32 EVALUATION 1039 00:37:26,729 --> 00:37:27,596 REPORT, THREE CRITICAL CONCEPT 1040 00:37:27,596 --> 00:37:28,631 CLEARANCES. 1041 00:37:28,631 --> 00:37:30,199 THERE WILL BE SOME REPORTS READ 1042 00:37:30,199 --> 00:37:35,237 INTO THE MINUTES AS WELL AS 1043 00:37:35,237 --> 00:37:36,438 COUNCIL BUSINESS THAT JEN 1044 00:37:36,438 --> 00:37:38,374 TROYER WILL HANDLE AT THE END. 1045 00:37:38,374 --> 00:37:41,377 I WANT TO GIVE A HUGE THANK 1046 00:37:41,377 --> 00:37:44,246 YOU, CALLING OUT PARTICULARLY 1047 00:37:44,246 --> 00:37:47,750 OUR COUNCIL EXECUTIVE JEN 1048 00:37:47,750 --> 00:37:49,852 TROYER, OUR COUNCIL 1049 00:37:49,852 --> 00:37:53,289 COORDINATOR, ISSEL LIM, COMFORT 1050 00:37:53,289 --> 00:37:57,159 BROWN, OUR COUNCIL CONFLICT OF 1051 00:37:57,159 --> 00:37:58,961 INTEREST MANAGER, NICK NGUYEN. 1052 00:37:58,961 --> 00:38:01,764 AS WELL AS IT SUPPORT STAFF, 1053 00:38:01,764 --> 00:38:02,865 NIH VIDEO SUPPORT STAFF ARE 1054 00:38:02,865 --> 00:38:05,034 HAVING AND ALL OF THE PEOPLE 1055 00:38:05,034 --> 00:38:05,968 LISTED HERE WHO HAVE 1056 00:38:05,968 --> 00:38:06,969 CONTRIBUTED EITHER TO MAKING 1057 00:38:06,969 --> 00:38:09,204 THIS DAY A SUCCESS OR MAKING MY 1058 00:38:09,204 --> 00:38:14,143 SLIDE PRESENTATION. 1059 00:38:14,143 --> 00:38:16,712 SO WITH THAT, I WILL STOP AND 1060 00:38:16,712 --> 00:38:18,581 TURN IT OVER TO SEE IF THERE 1061 00:38:18,581 --> 00:38:28,891 ARE ANY QUESTIONS. 1062 00:38:32,928 --> 00:38:34,797 I'M GIVING COUNCILMEMBERS A FEW 1063 00:38:34,797 --> 00:38:36,365 SECONDS TO RAISE THEIR HANDS IF 1064 00:38:36,365 --> 00:38:44,673 THEY WANT TO ASK ANYTHING. 1065 00:38:44,673 --> 00:38:49,144 OKAY, I THINK WE ARE MOVING 1066 00:38:49,144 --> 00:38:49,578 ONTO CHRIS GUNTER'S 1067 00:38:49,578 --> 00:38:50,613 PRESENTATION. 1068 00:38:50,613 --> 00:38:53,015 THIS WAS ALSO PLANNED FOR OUR 1069 00:38:53,015 --> 00:38:54,350 FEBRUARY COUNCIL WHICH WE HAD 1070 00:38:54,350 --> 00:38:57,086 TO CANCEL. 1071 00:38:57,086 --> 00:38:58,153 WELCOME CHRIS AND LOOK FORWARD 1072 00:38:58,153 --> 00:38:59,321 TO YOUR PRESENTATION. 1073 00:38:59,321 --> 00:39:01,123 >> MAKING SURE I CAN TURN THAT 1074 00:39:01,123 --> 00:39:01,290 ON. 1075 00:39:01,290 --> 00:39:02,825 THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR HAVING ME 1076 00:39:02,825 --> 00:39:03,025 HERE. 1077 00:39:03,025 --> 00:39:06,362 I WILL WALK YOU THROUGH OUR 1078 00:39:06,362 --> 00:39:07,062 EVALUATION, FIRST ABOUT WHY WE 1079 00:39:07,062 --> 00:39:09,465 DID IT AND TELL YOU WHAT WE DID. 1080 00:39:09,465 --> 00:39:11,333 IN PARTICULAR WE LOOKED AT THIS 1081 00:39:11,333 --> 00:39:14,637 GRANT WITH A VERY LONG NAME 1082 00:39:14,637 --> 00:39:18,641 THAT RUTH, A FORMER DIRECTOR OF 1083 00:39:18,641 --> 00:39:20,275 NIH, HER NRSA INSTITUTIONAL 1084 00:39:20,275 --> 00:39:21,443 TRAINING GRANTS, THE T32 IS 1085 00:39:21,443 --> 00:39:22,845 WHAT WE CALL IT FOR SHORT SO 1086 00:39:22,845 --> 00:39:25,481 THAT'S WHAT I WILL CALL IT 1087 00:39:25,481 --> 00:39:26,081 THROUGHOUT THIS PRESENTATION. 1088 00:39:26,081 --> 00:39:27,783 THIS WAS ONLY POSSIBLE WITH THE 1089 00:39:27,783 --> 00:39:29,284 HELP OF MY COLLEAGUE MOLLY BIRD 1090 00:39:29,284 --> 00:39:30,653 WHO IS TUNING IN AND ABLE TO 1091 00:39:30,653 --> 00:39:31,420 ANSWER QUESTIONS AS WELL. 1092 00:39:31,420 --> 00:39:32,688 THANK YOU VERY MUCH. 1093 00:39:32,688 --> 00:39:35,858 AND WE ALSO WORKED WITH A 1094 00:39:35,858 --> 00:39:37,126 NUMBER OF TRAINING STAFF AS I 1095 00:39:37,126 --> 00:39:38,460 WILL TELL YOU THROUGHOUT, SO 1096 00:39:38,460 --> 00:39:39,828 THANK YOU TO THEM AS WELL. 1097 00:39:39,828 --> 00:39:42,264 I WILL TELL YOU ABOUT OUR 1098 00:39:42,264 --> 00:39:42,798 EVALUATION QUESTIONS AND 1099 00:39:42,798 --> 00:39:44,099 METHODS AND TELL YOU OUR 1100 00:39:44,099 --> 00:39:45,601 FINDINGS THROUGH A NUMBER OF 1101 00:39:45,601 --> 00:39:46,368 DIFFERENT METHODS AND HOW WE 1102 00:39:46,368 --> 00:39:48,170 DID THOSE. 1103 00:39:48,170 --> 00:39:50,472 BUT FIRST YOU MIGHT BE ASKING 1104 00:39:50,472 --> 00:39:53,475 YOURSELF WHY ARE WE DOING THIS? 1105 00:39:53,475 --> 00:39:55,244 WHY WE ESTABLISHED THIS FORMER 1106 00:39:55,244 --> 00:39:56,512 EVALUATION CAPABILITY AT NHGRI. 1107 00:39:56,512 --> 00:39:58,147 AS PART OF THE U.S. GOVERNMENT 1108 00:39:58,147 --> 00:39:59,314 WE ARE REQUIRED BY SOMETHING 1109 00:39:59,314 --> 00:40:00,949 CALLED THE EVIDENCE ACT OF 2018 1110 00:40:00,949 --> 00:40:02,618 TO ACTUALLY SHOW THE EVIDENCE 1111 00:40:02,618 --> 00:40:03,285 FOR OUR DECISION MAKING 1112 00:40:03,285 --> 00:40:04,053 PROCESSES. 1113 00:40:04,053 --> 00:40:06,622 AND THE WAY THE NIH AND ITS 1114 00:40:06,622 --> 00:40:07,589 PARENT AGENCY, HHS HAVE 1115 00:40:07,589 --> 00:40:09,625 DEVELOPED A RESPONSE TO THAT IS 1116 00:40:09,625 --> 00:40:12,895 TO DEVELOP FRAMEWORKS LIKE THIS 1117 00:40:12,895 --> 00:40:14,096 FOR EVALUATION AND TRANSPARENCY 1118 00:40:14,096 --> 00:40:15,497 AND INNOVATION AND RESPONSE. 1119 00:40:15,497 --> 00:40:16,899 AND THAT INCLUDES A REQUEST 1120 00:40:16,899 --> 00:40:19,068 THAT WE ALL RECEIVED AT OUR 1121 00:40:19,068 --> 00:40:21,370 INSTITUTES TO CARRY OUT MORE 1122 00:40:21,370 --> 00:40:22,171 IN-DEPTH EVALUATIONS AND SHARE 1123 00:40:22,171 --> 00:40:24,139 THE DATA FROM THOSE. 1124 00:40:24,139 --> 00:40:25,474 YOU MIGHT REMEMBER THAT WE CAME 1125 00:40:25,474 --> 00:40:26,909 TO THIS COUNCIL LAST YEAR IN 1126 00:40:26,909 --> 00:40:28,777 FEBRUARY AND TALKED TO YOU 1127 00:40:28,777 --> 00:40:29,745 ABOUT OUR FIRST LARGE 1128 00:40:29,745 --> 00:40:31,146 EVALUATION WHICH WAS THE 1129 00:40:31,146 --> 00:40:33,248 CENTERS OF EXCELLENCE IN 1130 00:40:33,248 --> 00:40:34,817 GENOMIC SCIENCES OR CEGS, THAT 1131 00:40:34,817 --> 00:40:37,286 IS AVAILABLE ON OUR WEBSITE NOW. 1132 00:40:37,286 --> 00:40:39,354 WE THEN WANTED TO TURN IT TO 1133 00:40:39,354 --> 00:40:40,956 TRAINING WHICH HAS BEEN A 1134 00:40:40,956 --> 00:40:42,391 PRIORITY FOR NHGRI BUT ALSO FOR 1135 00:40:42,391 --> 00:40:43,926 THIS COUNCIL IN PARTICULAR. 1136 00:40:43,926 --> 00:40:50,232 SO WE DECIDED TO LOOK AT THIS 1137 00:40:50,232 --> 00:40:51,700 INSTITUTIONAL AWARD INSTEAD OF 1138 00:40:51,700 --> 00:40:54,303 INDIVIDUAL AWARDS AS A PROGRAM. 1139 00:40:54,303 --> 00:40:56,038 THE NHGRI NOW FUNDS T32'S IN 1140 00:40:56,038 --> 00:40:56,872 THREE DIFFERENT SUBJECT AREAS. 1141 00:40:56,872 --> 00:40:59,308 IF YOU HAVE BEEN A LONG TERM 1142 00:40:59,308 --> 00:41:01,076 WATCHER OF COUNCIL YOU WILL BE 1143 00:41:01,076 --> 00:41:04,346 FAMILIAR, THE FIRST IS ETHICAL, 1144 00:41:04,346 --> 00:41:06,215 LEGAL AND SOCIAL IMPLICATIONS 1145 00:41:06,215 --> 00:41:07,282 OR ELSI. 1146 00:41:07,282 --> 00:41:10,853 THESE ARE 2024 MAPS OF THE U.S. 1147 00:41:10,853 --> 00:41:12,755 ALSO SIX PROGRAM FOR GENOMIC 1148 00:41:12,755 --> 00:41:14,123 MEDICINE AND 12 FOR GENOMIC 1149 00:41:14,123 --> 00:41:15,257 SCIENCE AS OF THIS YEAR. 1150 00:41:15,257 --> 00:41:18,727 SINCE THE PROJECT STARTED WE 1151 00:41:18,727 --> 00:41:21,530 HAVE OVER 2,000 PREDOCTORAL AND 1152 00:41:21,530 --> 00:41:22,731 POSTDOCTORAL TRAINEES AND 23 1153 00:41:22,731 --> 00:41:24,600 GRANTS TO 17 INSTITUTIONS. 1154 00:41:24,600 --> 00:41:27,803 THIS IS NOT A SMALL COMMITMENT 1155 00:41:27,803 --> 00:41:32,040 ON BEHALF OF NHGRI OR NHL. 1156 00:41:32,040 --> 00:41:34,276 LOOKING AT OUR EVALUATION 1157 00:41:34,276 --> 00:41:35,677 METHODS AND QUESTIONS. 1158 00:41:35,677 --> 00:41:37,112 A MODEL, THE IMPORTANT PARTS 1159 00:41:37,112 --> 00:41:38,947 ARE IN THE COLORED SECTIONS. 1160 00:41:38,947 --> 00:41:41,350 SO THE PURPLE HERE IS THE 1161 00:41:41,350 --> 00:41:43,385 INPUTS, WE CHARACTERIZE WHAT WE 1162 00:41:43,385 --> 00:41:44,520 AND OUR PARTNERS ACTUALLY 1163 00:41:44,520 --> 00:41:45,788 INVESTED IN THESE PROGRAMS. 1164 00:41:45,788 --> 00:41:48,624 THE BLUE SECTIONS ARE THE 1165 00:41:48,624 --> 00:41:49,525 OUTPUTS WHAT ACTIVITIES AND 1166 00:41:49,525 --> 00:41:51,193 WHAT MEASURES ARE WE GOING TO 1167 00:41:51,193 --> 00:41:53,529 USE TO LOOK AT THOSE BUT MORE 1168 00:41:53,529 --> 00:41:54,997 SPECIFICALLY WE WILL FOCUS ON 1169 00:41:54,997 --> 00:41:59,635 THE GREEN SECTIONS, OUTCOMES. 1170 00:41:59,635 --> 00:42:00,803 THE SHORT-TERM, DURING 1171 00:42:00,803 --> 00:42:02,004 TRAINING, MEDIUM AFTER TRAINING 1172 00:42:02,004 --> 00:42:03,105 AND LONG TERM IMPACT OR LEGACY 1173 00:42:03,105 --> 00:42:05,507 OF THIS PROGRAM. 1174 00:42:05,507 --> 00:42:07,376 WE BOIL THOSE DOWN INTO THREE 1175 00:42:07,376 --> 00:42:09,244 EVALUATION QUESTIONS. 1176 00:42:09,244 --> 00:42:10,679 SO THE FIRST ONE WHAT HAS BEEN 1177 00:42:10,679 --> 00:42:12,815 THE IMPACT OF THE FUNDING. 1178 00:42:12,815 --> 00:42:14,917 BASICALLY WHAT DID WE GET FOR 1179 00:42:14,917 --> 00:42:17,286 OUR MONEY IN TRAINING OUTCOMES. 1180 00:42:17,286 --> 00:42:20,989 HAS THIS FUNDED AND ACCELERATED 1181 00:42:20,989 --> 00:42:22,658 AREAS CENTRAL TO THE STRATEGIC 1182 00:42:22,658 --> 00:42:23,258 VISION AND PRIORITY AREAS OF 1183 00:42:23,258 --> 00:42:24,059 NHGRI. 1184 00:42:24,059 --> 00:42:26,228 AND THIRD WHAT ARE THE 1185 00:42:26,228 --> 00:42:27,129 COMMUNITY'S PERCEPTIONS OF THE 1186 00:42:27,129 --> 00:42:28,430 PROGRAM AND DO THEY HAVE 1187 00:42:28,430 --> 00:42:30,799 SUGGESTIONS FOR IMPROVEMENT? 1188 00:42:30,799 --> 00:42:32,267 WE ARE COMMITTED TO MAKING SURE 1189 00:42:32,267 --> 00:42:34,837 WE CAN DO THIS AS BEST WE CAN. 1190 00:42:34,837 --> 00:42:35,637 WE CHOSE THREE DIFFERENT 1191 00:42:35,637 --> 00:42:36,405 METHODS. 1192 00:42:36,405 --> 00:42:37,573 WE DID TRACKING OF TRAINEES. 1193 00:42:37,573 --> 00:42:39,441 I WILL WALK YOU THROUGH THAT. 1194 00:42:39,441 --> 00:42:42,044 A SURVEY OF TRAINEES WE ASKED 1195 00:42:42,044 --> 00:42:42,578 THEM AND DID QUALITATIVE 1196 00:42:42,578 --> 00:42:44,146 INTERVIEWING. 1197 00:42:44,146 --> 00:42:47,683 AND THAT BASICALLY GIVES US A 1198 00:42:47,683 --> 00:42:48,684 DIAGRAM OF CONCENTRIC CIRCLES 1199 00:42:48,684 --> 00:42:50,452 HOW WE REACHED OUT TO CURRENT 1200 00:42:50,452 --> 00:42:52,154 AND FORMER TRAINEES. 1201 00:42:52,154 --> 00:42:55,123 TO WALK THROUGH THOSE FIRST 1202 00:42:55,123 --> 00:42:57,693 WHEN WE LOOKED AT TRACKING 1203 00:42:57,693 --> 00:42:58,594 DATA, RIPPLE EFFECT, SO THANK 1204 00:42:58,594 --> 00:43:00,796 YOU TO THEM. 1205 00:43:00,796 --> 00:43:03,298 SINCE OUR FIRST TRAINING GRANT 1206 00:43:03,298 --> 00:43:04,066 IN 1990. 1207 00:43:04,066 --> 00:43:05,934 WE WENT THROUGH DEMOGRAPHICS, 1208 00:43:05,934 --> 00:43:07,169 LOOKED AT PUBLICATIONS 1209 00:43:07,169 --> 00:43:09,271 ACKNOWLEDGING THE T32 GRANT AND 1210 00:43:09,271 --> 00:43:10,873 PUBLICATIONS THAT WERE PRODUCED 1211 00:43:10,873 --> 00:43:11,607 DURING AND AFTER TRAINEES 1212 00:43:11,607 --> 00:43:13,976 WORKED ON THE PROGRAM AND 1213 00:43:13,976 --> 00:43:14,910 SUBSEQUENT NIH GRANT 1214 00:43:14,910 --> 00:43:15,477 SUBMISSIONS AND AWARDS FOR 1215 00:43:15,477 --> 00:43:17,980 THOSE. 1216 00:43:17,980 --> 00:43:19,548 SECOND, WE THEN DECIDED TO ASK 1217 00:43:19,548 --> 00:43:20,816 THE TRAINEES THEMSELVES. 1218 00:43:20,816 --> 00:43:22,317 SO WE DID A SURVEY. 1219 00:43:22,317 --> 00:43:25,520 WE BOILED THIS DOWN TO 1220 00:43:25,520 --> 00:43:26,154 CONCENTRIC CIRCLES, THIS 1221 00:43:26,154 --> 00:43:29,658 REPRESENTS A LOT OF WORK OF 1222 00:43:29,658 --> 00:43:30,659 AMBER JACKSON AND MOLLY BIRD SO 1223 00:43:30,659 --> 00:43:32,227 THANK YOU TO THEM. 1224 00:43:32,227 --> 00:43:33,462 WE LOOKED AT PROGRESS REPORTS 1225 00:43:33,462 --> 00:43:36,932 AND TRIED TO FIND AS MANY EMAIL 1226 00:43:36,932 --> 00:43:40,269 ADDRESSES WE ENDED UP WITH SET 1227 00:43:40,269 --> 00:43:40,969 OF 1,283 FOR TRAINEES. 1228 00:43:40,969 --> 00:43:46,275 WE SENT AN EMAIL, WE FOUND ONLY 1229 00:43:46,275 --> 00:43:46,675 1,045 WERE VALID. 1230 00:43:46,675 --> 00:43:48,911 AND WE GOT BACK 447 RESPONSES. 1231 00:43:48,911 --> 00:43:51,280 A GOOD RESPONSE RATE OF 40% OF 1232 00:43:51,280 --> 00:43:51,480 THAT. 1233 00:43:51,480 --> 00:43:53,916 ON OUR SURVEY WE ASKED 1234 00:43:53,916 --> 00:43:54,716 QUANTITATIVE AND OPEN-ENDED 1235 00:43:54,716 --> 00:43:55,884 ITEMS WE DEVELOPED WITH THE 1236 00:43:55,884 --> 00:43:57,586 P.I.'S IN ADVANCE. 1237 00:43:57,586 --> 00:43:59,087 THEY WANTED US TO ASK ARE YOU 1238 00:43:59,087 --> 00:44:01,123 HAPPY AND ARE YOU USING WHAT 1239 00:44:01,123 --> 00:44:03,392 YOU LEARNED IN YOUR T32 TIME? 1240 00:44:03,392 --> 00:44:04,693 SO WE INCORPORATED BOTH OF 1241 00:44:04,693 --> 00:44:05,827 THOSE. 1242 00:44:05,827 --> 00:44:06,728 WE ALSO HAD DEMOGRAPHIC 1243 00:44:06,728 --> 00:44:07,930 INFORMATION, ABOUT THAT I WILL 1244 00:44:07,930 --> 00:44:10,632 SAY THE TWO FINAL SETS WERE 1245 00:44:10,632 --> 00:44:12,801 PRETTY SIMILAR IN DEMOGRAPHICS. 1246 00:44:12,801 --> 00:44:14,303 AND FINALLY WE DID QUALITATIVE 1247 00:44:14,303 --> 00:44:15,237 INTERVIEWS. 1248 00:44:15,237 --> 00:44:19,107 WE CO CREATED AN INTERVIEW 1249 00:44:19,107 --> 00:44:22,010 GUIDE WITH THE TRAINING TEAM 1250 00:44:22,010 --> 00:44:24,112 AND SEMI STRUCTURED INTERVIEWS 1251 00:44:24,112 --> 00:44:26,415 WITH 34 P.I.'S, TWO REVIEWERS 1252 00:44:26,415 --> 00:44:27,783 OFFERED MULTIPLE ROUNDS AND 1253 00:44:27,783 --> 00:44:28,450 GREAT SUGGESTIONS AND SEVERAL 1254 00:44:28,450 --> 00:44:31,119 STAFF MEMBERS. 1255 00:44:31,119 --> 00:44:32,154 WE CODED FOR IMPORTANT THEMES 1256 00:44:32,154 --> 00:44:34,356 AND WE DID A LOT OF FEEDBACK 1257 00:44:34,356 --> 00:44:35,691 ROUNDS. 1258 00:44:35,691 --> 00:44:38,961 THIS IS THE LAST FEEDBACK ROUND 1259 00:44:38,961 --> 00:44:40,128 FOR COUNCIL, WE WILL WELCOME 1260 00:44:40,128 --> 00:44:41,730 YOU COULD FIND ME ON THE 1261 00:44:41,730 --> 00:44:43,398 WEBSITE AND THEN TALK TO A 1262 00:44:43,398 --> 00:44:45,133 NUMBER OF PEOPLE AND THAT WAS 1263 00:44:45,133 --> 00:44:46,368 VERY VALUABLE HELPING US TO THE 1264 00:44:46,368 --> 00:44:50,272 FINAL PRODUCT. 1265 00:44:50,272 --> 00:44:51,506 WHERE DID OUR TRAINEES GO AND 1266 00:44:51,506 --> 00:44:52,874 WHERE ARE THEY NOW? 1267 00:44:52,874 --> 00:44:54,476 IF YOU LOOK AT THE LARGER POOL 1268 00:44:54,476 --> 00:44:56,144 ON THE RIGHT, YOU COULD SEE 1269 00:44:56,144 --> 00:44:57,179 THOSE ARE ALL TRAINEES AND THE 1270 00:44:57,179 --> 00:44:59,381 COLUMN ON THE LEFT IS THE 1271 00:44:59,381 --> 00:44:59,815 SURVEY RESPONDENTS. 1272 00:44:59,815 --> 00:45:03,919 SO WE FOUND THAT A NUMBER OF, 1273 00:45:03,919 --> 00:45:05,587 THIS IS PREDOCTORAL VERSUS 1274 00:45:05,587 --> 00:45:10,892 POSTDOCTORAL, THE FIRST NUMBER. 1275 00:45:10,892 --> 00:45:11,493 THE GENOMIC SCIENCES 1276 00:45:11,493 --> 00:45:12,794 REPRESENTED SLIGHTLY, THANK YOU 1277 00:45:12,794 --> 00:45:13,562 TO THOSE WHO ANSWERED THE 1278 00:45:13,562 --> 00:45:15,998 SURVEY A LITTLE MORE. 1279 00:45:15,998 --> 00:45:17,933 AND RECENCY BIAS WHICH IS 1280 00:45:17,933 --> 00:45:20,202 FAIRLY COMMON WITH SURVEYS. 1281 00:45:20,202 --> 00:45:21,570 THOSE WHO ANSWERED WERE MORE 1282 00:45:21,570 --> 00:45:22,471 RECENT THAN THOSE WHO HAD BEEN 1283 00:45:22,471 --> 00:45:25,307 IN THE PAST. 1284 00:45:25,307 --> 00:45:27,175 THIS MAP IS SHOWING THE 1285 00:45:27,175 --> 00:45:28,577 LOCATIONS OF THE T32 TRAINING 1286 00:45:28,577 --> 00:45:28,810 SITES. 1287 00:45:28,810 --> 00:45:30,245 THOSE ARE THE BLUE DOTS. 1288 00:45:30,245 --> 00:45:31,580 THAT'S WHERE OUR TRAINING SITES 1289 00:45:31,580 --> 00:45:32,180 ARE. 1290 00:45:32,180 --> 00:45:33,382 AND WE ASKED THE TRAINEES WHERE 1291 00:45:33,382 --> 00:45:34,716 THEY WERE AFTER THE GRANT. 1292 00:45:34,716 --> 00:45:39,287 AND YOU COULD SEE WE FEEL THIS 1293 00:45:39,287 --> 00:45:41,356 IS MEETING THEIR RUTH GRANT, OR 1294 00:45:41,356 --> 00:45:43,759 STATEMENT LISTED IN THEREOF 1295 00:45:43,759 --> 00:45:45,327 SUPPLYING A TRAINED BIOMEDICAL 1296 00:45:45,327 --> 00:45:46,962 WORKFORCE ACROSS THE ENTIRE U.S. 1297 00:45:46,962 --> 00:45:48,230 WE HAVE TRAINEES IN ALMOST 1298 00:45:48,230 --> 00:45:52,334 EVERY STATE IN THE COUNTRY. 1299 00:45:52,334 --> 00:45:55,704 LOOKING AT OUR TRACKING DATA. 1300 00:45:55,704 --> 00:45:59,508 WE FOUND OUR TRAINEES AUTHORED 1301 00:45:59,508 --> 00:45:59,941 3,303 PUBLICATIONS 1302 00:45:59,941 --> 00:46:00,842 ACKNOWLEDGING THE GRANTS. 1303 00:46:00,842 --> 00:46:02,811 THIS IS A CHANCE TO GIVE A 1304 00:46:02,811 --> 00:46:04,212 PLEA, PLEASE MAKE SURE YOU 1305 00:46:04,212 --> 00:46:06,381 ACKNOWLEDGE YOUR GRANT IN YOUR 1306 00:46:06,381 --> 00:46:08,250 PUBLICATION BECAUSE THAT'S HOW 1307 00:46:08,250 --> 00:46:10,419 WE PRODUCE GRAPHS LIKE THIS. 1308 00:46:10,419 --> 00:46:11,787 THANK YOU VERY MUCH TO THEM. 1309 00:46:11,787 --> 00:46:14,823 WHEN WE LOOKED AT CITATIONS WE 1310 00:46:14,823 --> 00:46:15,924 FOUND THE PUBLICATION THAT 1311 00:46:15,924 --> 00:46:18,827 ACKNOWLEDGE WERE HIGHLY CITED. 1312 00:46:18,827 --> 00:46:19,861 BOTTOM LEFT IS MEASURE R.C.R. 1313 00:46:19,861 --> 00:46:21,930 DEVELOPED BY THE NIH. 1314 00:46:21,930 --> 00:46:22,597 NORMALIZES THE RELATIVE 1315 00:46:22,597 --> 00:46:23,765 CITATIONS IN THE FIELD, THE 1316 00:46:23,765 --> 00:46:25,567 AVERAGE WOULD BE ONE. 1317 00:46:25,567 --> 00:46:27,536 THE MEAN IN THESE PUBLICATIONS 1318 00:46:27,536 --> 00:46:29,171 IS 3.7. 1319 00:46:29,171 --> 00:46:30,672 THAT MEANS 3.7 MORE HIGHLY 1320 00:46:30,672 --> 00:46:32,474 CITED THAN THE AVERAGE. 1321 00:46:32,474 --> 00:46:34,076 TWO CITED MORE THAN 5,000 TIMES 1322 00:46:34,076 --> 00:46:36,645 SO THEY ARE BEING CITED. 1323 00:46:36,645 --> 00:46:39,448 ALSO THE TRAINEES PRODUCED 1324 00:46:39,448 --> 00:46:40,382 HIGHLY INFLUENTIAL PAPERS AFTER 1325 00:46:40,382 --> 00:46:42,717 THEIR TIME IN THE PROGRAM. 1326 00:46:42,717 --> 00:46:45,153 EACH CITED OVER 11,000 TIMES. 1327 00:46:45,153 --> 00:46:50,725 YOU COULD SEE THE HIGHEST, 1328 00:46:50,725 --> 00:46:52,160 CYTOSCAPE OVER 40,000 TIMES. 1329 00:46:52,160 --> 00:46:54,162 I WILL SHOW YOU TWO DIFFERENT 1330 00:46:54,162 --> 00:46:55,564 WAYS TO LOOK AT GRANTS. 1331 00:46:55,564 --> 00:46:57,365 FIRST IS FROM THE APPLICATION 1332 00:46:57,365 --> 00:46:57,666 PERSPECTIVE. 1333 00:46:57,666 --> 00:47:00,669 THAT IS THAT THE T32 TRAINEES 1334 00:47:00,669 --> 00:47:03,171 SUB SY QUENT APPLICATIONS HAD A 1335 00:47:03,171 --> 00:47:06,875 24% AWARD RATE FOR ANY TYPE ONE 1336 00:47:06,875 --> 00:47:09,244 ACROSS NIH AND 17% FOR R01. 1337 00:47:09,244 --> 00:47:11,246 THIS IS THEIR APPLICATIONS. 1338 00:47:11,246 --> 00:47:13,381 AS CAROLYN MENTIONED ONE OF THE 1339 00:47:13,381 --> 00:47:14,583 THINGS NHGRI HAS IN ITS 1340 00:47:14,583 --> 00:47:17,853 STRATEGIC VISION WE ARE IN THE 1341 00:47:17,853 --> 00:47:19,254 FOREFRONT OF GENOMICS, WE 1342 00:47:19,254 --> 00:47:19,955 DEVELOP TECHNOLOGY AND 1343 00:47:19,955 --> 00:47:21,189 INNOVATIONS AND WITH WANT THAT 1344 00:47:21,189 --> 00:47:23,325 SPREAD OUT ACROSS THE REST OF 1345 00:47:23,325 --> 00:47:24,392 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH AND WE SEE 1346 00:47:24,392 --> 00:47:26,795 THAT SUPPORTED IN THE DATA. 1347 00:47:26,795 --> 00:47:28,396 THE SUBSEQUENT FUNDING IS BEING 1348 00:47:28,396 --> 00:47:30,599 SPREAD OUT ACROSS MULTIPLE 1349 00:47:30,599 --> 00:47:35,103 INSTITUTE AND CENTERS FOR NIH. 1350 00:47:35,103 --> 00:47:37,005 WE SWITCHED THE PEOPLE 1351 00:47:37,005 --> 00:47:38,673 PERSPECTIVE OF THE ALMOST 600 1352 00:47:38,673 --> 00:47:43,445 TRAINEES THAT APPLY FOR TYPE 1 1353 00:47:43,445 --> 00:47:43,678 FUNDING. 1354 00:47:43,678 --> 00:47:45,814 62% FUNDING RATE. 1355 00:47:45,814 --> 00:47:49,784 WE SAW SIMILAR FUNDING RATES 1356 00:47:49,784 --> 00:47:50,785 WHETHER PREDOCTORAL OR 1357 00:47:50,785 --> 00:47:51,253 POSTDOCTORAL TRAINEE. 1358 00:47:51,253 --> 00:47:52,254 AROUND THE SAME THING. 1359 00:47:52,254 --> 00:47:53,421 AND TURNING TO OUR SURVEY. 1360 00:47:53,421 --> 00:47:55,590 WE SAW THAT THE TRAINEES WHO 1361 00:47:55,590 --> 00:47:58,793 RESPONDED TO THE SURVEY WERE 1362 00:47:58,793 --> 00:48:00,362 LARGELY IN RESEARCH ROLES IN 1363 00:48:00,362 --> 00:48:03,265 ACADEMIA OR INDUSTRY. 1364 00:48:03,265 --> 00:48:05,934 MORE LIKELY IN T32'S AND ASKED 1365 00:48:05,934 --> 00:48:07,435 THE QUESTION PI'S WANTED US TO 1366 00:48:07,435 --> 00:48:09,204 ASK, ARE YOU HAPPY? 1367 00:48:09,204 --> 00:48:13,408 IF THEY WERE SATISFIED WITH 1368 00:48:13,408 --> 00:48:13,909 THEIR CAREER TRAJECTORY. 1369 00:48:13,909 --> 00:48:14,910 VERY SATISFIED THAT WAS THE 1370 00:48:14,910 --> 00:48:15,544 MAJORITY OF TRAINEES WHO SAID 1371 00:48:15,544 --> 00:48:17,379 THAT. 1372 00:48:17,379 --> 00:48:18,813 ASKED THEM IF THEY WOULD USE 1373 00:48:18,813 --> 00:48:20,715 THE SKILL ORZ KNOWLEDGE OR WERE 1374 00:48:20,715 --> 00:48:23,285 USING THE SKILLS OR KNOWLEDGE 1375 00:48:23,285 --> 00:48:23,818 THEY GAINED DURING THEIR 1376 00:48:23,818 --> 00:48:24,953 EXPERIENCE. 1377 00:48:24,953 --> 00:48:26,488 ONLY 3% SAID NO. 1378 00:48:26,488 --> 00:48:27,522 EVERYONE ELSE SAID YES. 1379 00:48:27,522 --> 00:48:29,391 THIS IS A QUOTE FROM ONE, THEY 1380 00:48:29,391 --> 00:48:31,293 DIDN'T HAVE SKILLS AND NOW THEY 1381 00:48:31,293 --> 00:48:32,961 ARE USING THEM EVERY DAY. 1382 00:48:32,961 --> 00:48:34,162 WE SPECIFICALLY ASKED THEM HOW 1383 00:48:34,162 --> 00:48:35,430 THEY WERE PREPARED FOR THEIR 1384 00:48:35,430 --> 00:48:37,132 CURRENT OR FUTURE ROLE. 1385 00:48:37,132 --> 00:48:38,099 MOST SAID SKILLS DEVELOPMENT. 1386 00:48:38,099 --> 00:48:40,202 ON THE RIGHT YOU COULD SEE SOME 1387 00:48:40,202 --> 00:48:41,903 OF THE SPECIFIC SKILLS THEY 1388 00:48:41,903 --> 00:48:42,170 MENTIONED. 1389 00:48:42,170 --> 00:48:43,838 ALL THE THINGS YOU WOULD EXPECT 1390 00:48:43,838 --> 00:48:45,340 FOR A SCIENTIFIC CAREER. 1391 00:48:45,340 --> 00:48:47,676 AND FINALLY WE ASKED THEM FOR 1392 00:48:47,676 --> 00:48:48,643 SUGGESTIONS OF IMPROVEMENT, 1393 00:48:48,643 --> 00:48:50,478 WHAT DO THE TRAINEES THINK WE 1394 00:48:50,478 --> 00:48:52,347 COULD BE DOING BETTER THEY 1395 00:48:52,347 --> 00:48:55,684 SUGGESTED MORE EXPOSURE TO NON 1396 00:48:55,684 --> 00:48:56,585 TRADITIONAL CAREERS, ELSI 1397 00:48:56,585 --> 00:48:58,653 PROGRAMS AND AI AND MACHINE 1398 00:48:58,653 --> 00:48:58,920 LEARNING. 1399 00:48:58,920 --> 00:49:00,121 THOSE ARE THINGS YOU PROBABLY 1400 00:49:00,121 --> 00:49:01,189 COULD HAVE PREDICTED IN ADVANCE. 1401 00:49:01,189 --> 00:49:03,558 I WILL END WITH A QUALITATIVE 1402 00:49:03,558 --> 00:49:04,793 DATA SUMMARY. 1403 00:49:04,793 --> 00:49:06,161 WE INTERVIEWED ALL 34 P.I.'S 1404 00:49:06,161 --> 00:49:07,629 AND TWO REVIEWERS. 1405 00:49:07,629 --> 00:49:11,499 WE DIDN'T ASK QUESTIONS OF THE 1406 00:49:11,499 --> 00:49:14,169 BUDGET AND THAT CAME UP IN 1407 00:49:14,169 --> 00:49:15,303 EVERY INTERVIEW AS YOU COULD 1408 00:49:15,303 --> 00:49:16,271 IMAGINE. 1409 00:49:16,271 --> 00:49:18,640 WE ASKED WHAT DO YOU SEE AS 1410 00:49:18,640 --> 00:49:19,975 YOUR TOP SUCCESSFUL OUTCOME. 1411 00:49:19,975 --> 00:49:22,077 WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT. 1412 00:49:22,077 --> 00:49:23,011 SECOND COMMUNITY, BUILDING 1413 00:49:23,011 --> 00:49:25,313 COMMUNITY AND THIRD WAS ADVANCE 1414 00:49:25,313 --> 00:49:27,082 ISING NHGRI STRATEGIC VISION. 1415 00:49:27,082 --> 00:49:28,750 THEN ASKED THEM HOW THIS GRANT 1416 00:49:28,750 --> 00:49:30,619 ALLOWED YOU TO PROVIDE TRAINING 1417 00:49:30,619 --> 00:49:31,219 THAT WOULDN'T HAVE OTHERWISE 1418 00:49:31,219 --> 00:49:32,854 BEEN POSSIBLE. 1419 00:49:32,854 --> 00:49:34,022 THE TWO TOP THEMES WERE 1420 00:49:34,022 --> 00:49:35,490 STRUCTURE AND RESOURCES. 1421 00:49:35,490 --> 00:49:37,626 YOU COULD SEE QUOTES FROM PI'S 1422 00:49:37,626 --> 00:49:38,994 GIVING EXAMPLES HOW THEY WERE 1423 00:49:38,994 --> 00:49:39,995 ABLE TO DEVELOP OTHER PROGRAMS 1424 00:49:39,995 --> 00:49:41,363 OR OTHER COURSES. 1425 00:49:41,363 --> 00:49:43,198 AND THE SECOND WAS ATTRACTING 1426 00:49:43,198 --> 00:49:45,367 TOP TALENT PARTICULARLY FOR 1427 00:49:45,367 --> 00:49:45,567 MD'S. 1428 00:49:45,567 --> 00:49:47,435 THAT WAS THE MOST IMPORTANT FOR 1429 00:49:47,435 --> 00:49:49,537 US IS TO ATTRACT MD'S AND ALLOW 1430 00:49:49,537 --> 00:49:51,006 THEM TO PAUSE THEIR CLINICAL 1431 00:49:51,006 --> 00:49:52,641 CAREERS TO DO THIS RESEARCH, 1432 00:49:52,641 --> 00:49:54,442 THIS CLINICAL RESEARCH. 1433 00:49:54,442 --> 00:49:55,777 SO TWO THEMES WE DIDN'T ASK 1434 00:49:55,777 --> 00:49:57,746 THAT CAME UP. 1435 00:49:57,746 --> 00:49:59,014 I SHOULD POINT OUT BOTH, NUMBER 1436 00:49:59,014 --> 00:50:01,182 OF THESE ARE AT THE NIH LEVEL 1437 00:50:01,182 --> 00:50:03,084 AND NOT THE NHGRI LEVEL. 1438 00:50:03,084 --> 00:50:05,387 THE FIRST ONE WAS SALARY 1439 00:50:05,387 --> 00:50:06,354 DISCREPANCIES BETWEEN TRAINEES 1440 00:50:06,354 --> 00:50:07,789 AND UNIVERSITY REQUIREMENTS ARE 1441 00:50:07,789 --> 00:50:09,724 A PROBLEM AND THAT AFFECTS 1442 00:50:09,724 --> 00:50:10,058 PARTICIPATION. 1443 00:50:10,058 --> 00:50:12,494 THAT WAS BROKEN INTO TWO AREAS 1444 00:50:12,494 --> 00:50:13,695 FOR TRAINEES NOT BEING ABLE TO 1445 00:50:13,695 --> 00:50:15,597 BE ON THE GRANT AND FACULTY NOT 1446 00:50:15,597 --> 00:50:17,098 HAVING TRAINEES ON THE GRANT 1447 00:50:17,098 --> 00:50:18,667 BECAUSE THEY COULDN'T MAKE UP 1448 00:50:18,667 --> 00:50:19,367 THE DIFFERENCE WHAT WAS 1449 00:50:19,367 --> 00:50:22,437 SUPPLIED BY THE GRANT AND WHAT 1450 00:50:22,437 --> 00:50:23,071 INSTITUTIONAL REQUIREMENTS WERE. 1451 00:50:23,071 --> 00:50:23,672 THAT'S SOMETHING AT THE NIH 1452 00:50:23,672 --> 00:50:24,606 LEVEL. 1453 00:50:24,606 --> 00:50:27,175 THE SECOND THEME WAS PROGRAM 1454 00:50:27,175 --> 00:50:28,310 ADMINISTRATOR AND MANAGERS ARE 1455 00:50:28,310 --> 00:50:30,945 IMPORTANT TO THESE GRANTS BUT 1456 00:50:30,945 --> 00:50:31,346 NEED MORE SUPPORT. 1457 00:50:31,346 --> 00:50:32,781 THAT BROKE UP INTO THREE AREAS 1458 00:50:32,781 --> 00:50:34,749 PEOPLE OVER LOADED AND STRESSED 1459 00:50:34,749 --> 00:50:36,351 WE CAN PROBABLY ALL RELATE TO, 1460 00:50:36,351 --> 00:50:39,454 NOTEN VIETED OR COVERED BY THE 1461 00:50:39,454 --> 00:50:41,256 INDO MEETING OR NOT 1462 00:50:41,256 --> 00:50:42,190 SUFFICIENTLY SUPPORTED BY 1463 00:50:42,190 --> 00:50:43,858 FUNDS, A THE NIH LEVEL. 1464 00:50:43,858 --> 00:50:45,760 AND I WILL END WITH SOME QUOTE 1465 00:50:45,760 --> 00:50:47,362 THAT'S SPEAK FOR THEMSELVES 1466 00:50:47,362 --> 00:50:50,298 THIS WAS ABOUT THE TRAINEE 1467 00:50:50,298 --> 00:50:50,665 TRACKING TABLES. 1468 00:50:50,665 --> 00:50:51,533 ONE TOLD US, THEY WENT FROM A 1469 00:50:51,533 --> 00:50:53,168 POINT YOU WANT TO RIP YOUR EYES 1470 00:50:53,168 --> 00:50:55,337 OUT AND JUMP OUT A WINDOW TO 1471 00:50:55,337 --> 00:50:56,471 JUST WANTING TO STAB YOURSELF 1472 00:50:56,471 --> 00:50:58,573 IN THE HEAD WITH AN ICE PICK. 1473 00:50:58,573 --> 00:51:00,575 I HAVE TO NOTE NIH PUT 1474 00:51:00,575 --> 00:51:02,110 SIGNIFICANT CHANGES TO THIS 1475 00:51:02,110 --> 00:51:05,447 APPLICATION REVIEW AND 1476 00:51:05,447 --> 00:51:07,482 REPORTING PROCESS IN PLACE IN 1477 00:51:07,482 --> 00:51:08,616 JANUARY 2025, WE HAVEN'T GONE 1478 00:51:08,616 --> 00:51:10,919 BACK AND ASKED FOR ANOTHER 1479 00:51:10,919 --> 00:51:11,886 ANALOGY YET BUT HOPEFULLY IT'S 1480 00:51:11,886 --> 00:51:13,021 BETTER FOR THEM. 1481 00:51:13,021 --> 00:51:14,923 JUST TO SUM UP, OUR EVALUATION 1482 00:51:14,923 --> 00:51:17,992 QUESTIONS WE ASKED WHAT THE 1483 00:51:17,992 --> 00:51:19,594 IMPACT WAS ON OUTCOMES, THEY 1484 00:51:19,594 --> 00:51:21,062 ARE SATISFIED WITH THEIR 1485 00:51:21,062 --> 00:51:21,596 CAREERS USING SKILLS THEY 1486 00:51:21,596 --> 00:51:23,431 LEARNED. 1487 00:51:23,431 --> 00:51:26,401 THEY PUBLISHED HILI CITED 1488 00:51:26,401 --> 00:51:31,306 PAPERS, RECEIVED GRANTS AND NOW 1489 00:51:31,306 --> 00:51:32,607 STRUCTURE T32 PI. 1490 00:51:32,607 --> 00:51:36,378 WE ASKED HAS THIS SUPPORTED 1491 00:51:36,378 --> 00:51:37,011 ACCELERATED AREA CENTRAL TO OUR 1492 00:51:37,011 --> 00:51:38,546 VISION? 1493 00:51:38,546 --> 00:51:41,282 WE HAVE SEEN PAPERS, GRANTS AND 1494 00:51:41,282 --> 00:51:41,983 AWARDS, SPREAD ACROSS OTHER 1495 00:51:41,983 --> 00:51:44,119 IC'S WHICH IS PART OF OUR 1496 00:51:44,119 --> 00:51:45,587 VISION, WE SAW THE TRAINEES 1497 00:51:45,587 --> 00:51:46,988 SPREAD ACROSS THE U.S. ONE 1498 00:51:46,988 --> 00:51:49,491 QUESTION I DIDN'T COVER, WE 1499 00:51:49,491 --> 00:51:52,794 ASKED ALL PI'S DID YOU FEEL 1500 00:51:52,794 --> 00:51:53,962 THIS GRANT FOSTERED 1501 00:51:53,962 --> 00:51:55,697 INTERDISCIPLINE AIRITY AND 1502 00:51:55,697 --> 00:51:57,766 EVERY SINGLE PI ANSWERED YES TO 1503 00:51:57,766 --> 00:51:58,099 THAT QUESTION. 1504 00:51:58,099 --> 00:51:58,767 FINALLY WE ASKED WHAT DO YOU 1505 00:51:58,767 --> 00:52:00,301 ALL THINK ABOUT THIS? 1506 00:52:00,301 --> 00:52:02,670 DO YOU HAVE SUGGESTIONS FOR 1507 00:52:02,670 --> 00:52:04,272 IMPROVEMENT, WE GOT QUITE A FEW. 1508 00:52:04,272 --> 00:52:07,108 THEY SAID THE PROGRAM WAS A 1509 00:52:07,108 --> 00:52:08,276 SUCCESS, PARTICULARLY NUMBER 1510 00:52:08,276 --> 00:52:09,778 TALKED ABOUT OUR ANNUAL MEETING 1511 00:52:09,778 --> 00:52:10,512 BEING AN IMPORTANT PART OF THE 1512 00:52:10,512 --> 00:52:11,780 PROGRAM. 1513 00:52:11,780 --> 00:52:13,214 THEY HAVE ONGOING CONCERNS 1514 00:52:13,214 --> 00:52:14,115 ABOUT THE APPLICATION, BUDGET 1515 00:52:14,115 --> 00:52:17,185 STRUCTURE, MANY OF THOSE AT THE 1516 00:52:17,185 --> 00:52:19,754 NIH LEVEL, NOT THE NHRI LEVEL. 1517 00:52:19,754 --> 00:52:21,823 BUT PLAN GOING FORWARD LIKE FOR 1518 00:52:21,823 --> 00:52:25,693 CEGS PUBLISH THIS ON A REPORT 1519 00:52:25,693 --> 00:52:27,395 WHICH WILL LOOK LESS NICE 1520 00:52:27,395 --> 00:52:28,830 BECAUSE WE DON'T HAVE THE COMMS 1521 00:52:28,830 --> 00:52:30,698 TEAM BUT WE PLAN TO PUT IT ON 1522 00:52:30,698 --> 00:52:31,833 THE WEBSITE AND PUBLICATION. 1523 00:52:31,833 --> 00:52:34,836 THANK YOU TO THE RIPPLE EFFECT 1524 00:52:34,836 --> 00:52:35,036 TEAM. 1525 00:52:35,036 --> 00:52:35,804 MOLLIE BIRD WAS A CRUCIAL PART 1526 00:52:35,804 --> 00:52:37,639 AND DID A LOT OF THE WORK. 1527 00:52:37,639 --> 00:52:38,440 EVERYONE WHO PARTICIPATED AND I 1528 00:52:38,440 --> 00:52:48,850 WILL TAKE ANY QUESTIONS. 1529 00:53:01,062 --> 00:53:02,197 P BRUCE? 1530 00:53:02,197 --> 00:53:03,798 >> THANK YOU. 1531 00:53:03,798 --> 00:53:06,634 ONE THING THAT STRIKES ME THE 1532 00:53:06,634 --> 00:53:08,303 WORLD THE TRAINEES ARE ENTERING 1533 00:53:08,303 --> 00:53:09,437 INTO IS ALREADY QUITE DIFFERENT 1534 00:53:09,437 --> 00:53:11,005 FROM THE ONE THAT EXISTED EVEN 1535 00:53:11,005 --> 00:53:16,578 A FEW MONTHS AGO. 1536 00:53:16,578 --> 00:53:18,646 AND I WONDER, IT'S PROBABLY TOO 1537 00:53:18,646 --> 00:53:19,814 RECENT TO SHOW UP ON THE DATA 1538 00:53:19,814 --> 00:53:20,982 COLLECTION. 1539 00:53:20,982 --> 00:53:23,518 BUT I WONDER IF THERE'S SOME 1540 00:53:23,518 --> 00:53:26,821 WAY OF TRACKING WHETHER THERE'S 1541 00:53:26,821 --> 00:53:28,323 BEEN AN IMPACT OF RECRUITMENT 1542 00:53:28,323 --> 00:53:30,358 OF TRAINEES TO THE PROGRAMS ON 1543 00:53:30,358 --> 00:53:31,659 ONE HAND OR OUTCOMES IN TERMS 1544 00:53:31,659 --> 00:53:33,661 OF A ABILITY TO FIND RESEARCH 1545 00:53:33,661 --> 00:53:34,796 POSITIONS GIVEN THE CHANGES WE 1546 00:53:34,796 --> 00:53:39,300 HEARD ABOUT EARLIER IN TERMS OF 1547 00:53:39,300 --> 00:53:40,468 FUNDING. 1548 00:53:40,468 --> 00:53:43,571 >> I THINK THAT'S A GREAT 1549 00:53:43,571 --> 00:53:43,838 QUESTION. 1550 00:53:43,838 --> 00:53:44,472 I THINK WE ALL EXPECT WE WOULD 1551 00:53:44,472 --> 00:53:45,940 SEE THAT. 1552 00:53:45,940 --> 00:53:49,177 I ALSO RUN AN INTRAMURAL LAB 1553 00:53:49,177 --> 00:53:51,412 WHICH IS HOW WE WERE ABLE TO DO 1554 00:53:51,412 --> 00:53:51,980 THIS STUDY. 1555 00:53:51,980 --> 00:53:53,781 I'M LOOKING FOR POST VAKS IF 1556 00:53:53,781 --> 00:53:56,184 ANYONE WOULD LIKE TO JOIN, WHO 1557 00:53:56,184 --> 00:53:57,385 IS WATCHING, AND CHART THOSE I 1558 00:53:57,385 --> 00:53:58,620 WOULD BE HAPPY TO HAVE YOU IN 1559 00:53:58,620 --> 00:54:02,724 THE LAB. 1560 00:54:02,724 --> 00:54:05,059 I THINK WE ARE ALL INTERESTED 1561 00:54:05,059 --> 00:54:06,728 IN THE ANSWERS TOO. 1562 00:54:06,728 --> 00:54:09,030 >> I KNOW WHAT ERIC WAS WANTING 1563 00:54:09,030 --> 00:54:11,399 AND HIS VISION, WHICH I WILL 1564 00:54:11,399 --> 00:54:12,767 CERTAINLY KEEP MOVING FORWARD 1565 00:54:12,767 --> 00:54:14,168 AND HOPEFULLY WHOEVER COMES ON 1566 00:54:14,168 --> 00:54:16,037 AS THE NEXT PERMANENT ONE IS 1567 00:54:16,037 --> 00:54:19,974 HAVING SOME OF THESE DIFFERENT 1568 00:54:19,974 --> 00:54:22,043 THINGS THAT CHRIS IS DOING CAN 1569 00:54:22,043 --> 00:54:23,945 ALSO SERVE AS BENCHMARKS, RIGHT? 1570 00:54:23,945 --> 00:54:25,780 IT'S ACTUALLY KIND OF USEFUL TO 1571 00:54:25,780 --> 00:54:30,518 THINK WE HAVE THE TIMING THAT 1572 00:54:30,518 --> 00:54:33,121 WE HAVE 2024, WHICH IS WHEN 1573 00:54:33,121 --> 00:54:34,022 THIS WAS PRIMARILY DONE, 1574 00:54:34,022 --> 00:54:34,722 BENCHMARK AND HAVING THAT 1575 00:54:34,722 --> 00:54:38,593 ABILITY TO DO SOME OF THAT 1576 00:54:38,593 --> 00:54:39,561 FOLLOW-UP WILL BE UNAIDED BY 1577 00:54:39,561 --> 00:54:42,130 HAVING HAD THIS. 1578 00:54:42,130 --> 00:54:43,064 THIS ALL PREDATED THAT IN TERMS 1579 00:54:43,064 --> 00:54:44,265 OF TIMING. 1580 00:54:44,265 --> 00:54:46,134 THIS WAS SUPPOSED TO HAVE BEEN 1581 00:54:46,134 --> 00:54:46,701 A PRESENTATION AT FEBRUARY 1582 00:54:46,701 --> 00:54:47,502 COUNCIL. 1583 00:54:47,502 --> 00:54:51,272 BUT I THINK IT WILL SERVE AS 1584 00:54:51,272 --> 00:54:53,107 HELPFUL TO UNDERSTAND IS SOME 1585 00:54:53,107 --> 00:54:54,309 OF THOSE THINGS AND HOW WE 1586 00:54:54,309 --> 00:54:59,447 MIGHT ADDRESS THEM. 1587 00:54:59,447 --> 00:55:00,815 >> I SAW JUDY'S HAND UP AND 1588 00:55:00,815 --> 00:55:02,083 THEN KELLY. 1589 00:55:02,083 --> 00:55:04,986 >> OKAY, I WILL GO FIRST THEN. 1590 00:55:04,986 --> 00:55:06,621 I WANT TO JUST AMPLIFY ON TWO 1591 00:55:06,621 --> 00:55:08,022 POINTS THAT YOU MADE THAT I 1592 00:55:08,022 --> 00:55:10,658 COULDN'T AGREE WITH MORE. 1593 00:55:10,658 --> 00:55:15,263 ONE WAS THE VALUE TO LATE 1594 00:55:15,263 --> 00:55:15,730 BLOOMERS LIKE MYSELF. 1595 00:55:15,730 --> 00:55:17,131 WHO BASICALLY DIDN'T DECIDE 1596 00:55:17,131 --> 00:55:18,533 UNTIL AFTER INTERNAL MEDICINE 1597 00:55:18,533 --> 00:55:19,367 RESIDENCY I WANTED TO DO 1598 00:55:19,367 --> 00:55:19,934 RESEARCH. 1599 00:55:19,934 --> 00:55:23,004 SO I DO THINK THIS IS 1600 00:55:23,004 --> 00:55:27,175 ABSOLUTELY ESSENTIAL, THAT NOT 1601 00:55:27,175 --> 00:55:32,180 ALL MD RESEARCHERS OR MD 1602 00:55:32,180 --> 00:55:34,015 Ph.D.'S ARE ESSENTIAL TO MAKING 1603 00:55:34,015 --> 00:55:34,916 LATE BLOOMING PHYSICIAN 1604 00:55:34,916 --> 00:55:35,917 SCIENTISTS HAVE A VIABLE CAREER 1605 00:55:35,917 --> 00:55:37,318 IN RESEARCH. 1606 00:55:37,318 --> 00:55:39,187 KUDOS TO THAT AND I REALLY 1607 00:55:39,187 --> 00:55:40,121 AMPLIFY THAT POINT. 1608 00:55:40,121 --> 00:55:41,789 THE SECOND ONE IS THAT FINAL, 1609 00:55:41,789 --> 00:55:44,826 IT'S A SMALL POINT ABOUT THE 1610 00:55:44,826 --> 00:55:47,428 ORCHID THING. 1611 00:55:47,428 --> 00:55:48,296 INCREASINGLY JOURNALS ARE USING 1612 00:55:48,296 --> 00:55:51,232 ORCHID AND NOW FOR ALL MY PAPER 1613 00:55:51,232 --> 00:55:52,066 SUBMISSIONS AND REVIEWS, THE 1614 00:55:52,066 --> 00:55:54,569 ORCHID IS THE WAY TO GO. 1615 00:55:54,569 --> 00:55:57,071 SO SOME OF THE CHANGES WITH 1616 00:55:57,071 --> 00:55:59,340 RESPECT TO WOMEN WITH THEIR 1617 00:55:59,340 --> 00:56:01,643 MAIDEN NAME AND MARRIED NAME. 1618 00:56:01,643 --> 00:56:03,544 I DO THINK ORCHID IS YOUR 1619 00:56:03,544 --> 00:56:04,879 SCIENTIFIC SOCIAL SECURITY 1620 00:56:04,879 --> 00:56:05,113 NUMBER. 1621 00:56:05,113 --> 00:56:05,713 I WOULD ENCOURAGE USE OF THAT 1622 00:56:05,713 --> 00:56:10,018 THROUGHOUT. 1623 00:56:10,018 --> 00:56:11,152 >> GREAT POINT, WE PRESENTED 1624 00:56:11,152 --> 00:56:13,287 THIS WORK TO THE EVALUATION 1625 00:56:13,287 --> 00:56:15,423 ACROSS THE NIH AND THEY ALSO 1626 00:56:15,423 --> 00:56:15,823 AGREED WITH THAT. 1627 00:56:15,823 --> 00:56:16,624 WE WILL KEEP TRYING TO WORK 1628 00:56:16,624 --> 00:56:18,793 WITH ALL OF THEM TO MAKE THAT, 1629 00:56:18,793 --> 00:56:22,697 GO TO THE RIGHT PLACE, THAT 1630 00:56:22,697 --> 00:56:28,202 SUGGESTION. 1631 00:56:28,202 --> 00:56:33,274 >> CAROLYN: KELLY, GO AHEAD. 1632 00:56:33,274 --> 00:56:34,909 >> KELLY: SO ONE OF THE POINTS 1633 00:56:34,909 --> 00:56:38,980 YOU HAD IS THAT THE TRAINEES 1634 00:56:38,980 --> 00:56:44,519 THEMSELVES HAD REQUESTED 1635 00:56:44,519 --> 00:56:44,952 GREATER EXPOSURE TO 1636 00:56:44,952 --> 00:56:53,094 NON-TRADITIONAL CAREER PATHS. 1637 00:56:53,094 --> 00:56:59,233 I WOULD ALMOST SAY THAT THAT'S 1638 00:56:59,233 --> 00:57:01,102 A CODE WORD FOR INDUSTRY. 1639 00:57:01,102 --> 00:57:04,605 I THINK THE MAJORITY OF OUR 1640 00:57:04,605 --> 00:57:06,274 TRAINEES ARE GOING TO INDUSTRY 1641 00:57:06,274 --> 00:57:07,642 AND THAT'S BECAUSE THERE'S MORE 1642 00:57:07,642 --> 00:57:09,477 JOBS IN INDUSTRY THAN THERE ARE 1643 00:57:09,477 --> 00:57:12,480 IN ACADEMICS. 1644 00:57:12,480 --> 00:57:20,054 AND I ACTUALLY THINK THAT 1645 00:57:20,054 --> 00:57:21,289 HAVING MODIFYING THE 1646 00:57:21,289 --> 00:57:23,324 REQUIREMENTS BE ACCEPTED INTO 1647 00:57:23,324 --> 00:57:26,661 THE T32 PROGRAM AS WELL AS 1648 00:57:26,661 --> 00:57:29,197 F31'S AS WELL AS WHAT ARE SOME 1649 00:57:29,197 --> 00:57:31,032 OF THE TRAINING SO THAT WHEN 1650 00:57:31,032 --> 00:57:32,900 THEY ACTUALLY HIT THE INDUSTRY 1651 00:57:32,900 --> 00:57:38,773 THAT THEY HAVE AN EDGE UP WOULD 1652 00:57:38,773 --> 00:57:43,978 BE BENEFICIAL FOR THE TRAINEES, 1653 00:57:43,978 --> 00:57:45,780 AS WELL AS FOR, I ACTUALLY 1654 00:57:45,780 --> 00:57:47,315 THINK IT WOULD BE BENEFICIAL 1655 00:57:47,315 --> 00:57:49,083 FOR ACADEMICS TOO. 1656 00:57:49,083 --> 00:57:50,451 SOMETIMES THE TRAINEES, THEY 1657 00:57:50,451 --> 00:57:53,254 LOOK AT THE ACADEMICS AND THEY 1658 00:57:53,254 --> 00:57:57,391 GO, OH WOW. 1659 00:57:57,391 --> 00:57:59,527 THERE'S A LOT OF DIFFICULTIES 1660 00:57:59,527 --> 00:58:01,162 IN ACADEMICS. 1661 00:58:01,162 --> 00:58:02,363 BUT THERE'S ALSO DIFFICULTIES 1662 00:58:02,363 --> 00:58:08,236 IN ANY POSITION IN INDUSTRY. 1663 00:58:08,236 --> 00:58:10,905 SO GIVING THEM SOME EXPOSURE TO 1664 00:58:10,905 --> 00:58:12,406 INDUSTRY WE MAY END UP 1665 00:58:12,406 --> 00:58:13,574 RECRUITING MORE INTO THE 1666 00:58:13,574 --> 00:58:15,743 ACADEMIC REALM. 1667 00:58:15,743 --> 00:58:17,879 I WOULD ENCOURAGE THE PEOPLE 1668 00:58:17,879 --> 00:58:19,046 THAT PUT TOGETHER THESE 1669 00:58:19,046 --> 00:58:21,182 TRAINING PROGRAMS TO TRY TO 1670 00:58:21,182 --> 00:58:24,152 FIGURE OUT HOW TO GIVE THE 1671 00:58:24,152 --> 00:58:25,987 GRADUATE STUDENTS THE EXPOSURE 1672 00:58:25,987 --> 00:58:28,356 TO INDUSTRY THAT THEY WANT IN 1673 00:58:28,356 --> 00:58:30,191 THEIR TRAINING PROGRAMS, SO 1674 00:58:30,191 --> 00:58:33,227 THAT THEY CAN MAKE INFORMED 1675 00:58:33,227 --> 00:58:34,395 DECISIONS AT THAT JUNCTURE OF 1676 00:58:34,395 --> 00:58:39,400 WHAT THEY ARE GOING TO DO AFTER 1677 00:58:39,400 --> 00:58:40,535 THEIR TRAINING. 1678 00:58:40,535 --> 00:58:42,270 >> CHRIS: YEAH, THANK YOU. 1679 00:58:42,270 --> 00:58:42,770 I THINK THAT'S VALUABLE 1680 00:58:42,770 --> 00:58:43,805 FEEDBACK. 1681 00:58:43,805 --> 00:58:49,110 I CAN'T NAME ANY NAMES BECAUSE 1682 00:58:49,110 --> 00:58:50,745 WE CAN'T IDENTIFY THE P.I.'S 1683 00:58:50,745 --> 00:58:53,281 BUT WE SAW WIDE RANGE. 1684 00:58:53,281 --> 00:58:54,248 SO THAT'S ANOTHER ARGUMENT FOR 1685 00:58:54,248 --> 00:58:55,883 A NUMBER OF PEOPLE SAID THEY 1686 00:58:55,883 --> 00:58:57,151 REALLY LIKE THE ANNUAL MEETING 1687 00:58:57,151 --> 00:58:58,953 BECAUSE OF THE EXPOSURE TO THE 1688 00:58:58,953 --> 00:59:00,421 PI'S FROM OTHER PROGRAMS AND 1689 00:59:00,421 --> 00:59:01,122 BEING ABLE TO EXCHANGE 1690 00:59:01,122 --> 00:59:02,990 INFORMATION LIKE THAT. 1691 00:59:02,990 --> 00:59:06,661 SO TO ME THAT'S A VENUE THIS 1692 00:59:06,661 --> 00:59:08,062 CAN TAKE PLACE AS WELL, THOSE 1693 00:59:08,062 --> 00:59:10,731 DISCUSSIONS AND SHARING 1694 00:59:10,731 --> 00:59:13,768 INFORMATION. 1695 00:59:13,768 --> 00:59:24,245 >> CAROLYN: CASEY, GO AHEAD. 1696 00:59:29,116 --> 00:59:30,551 >> CASEY: EXCELLENT DATA. 1697 00:59:30,551 --> 00:59:32,086 WE ALWAYS LIKE TO SEE MORE. 1698 00:59:32,086 --> 00:59:33,588 I WAS WONDERING IF THERE ARE 1699 00:59:33,588 --> 00:59:35,423 PLANS TO FOLLOW THIS GROUP OVER 1700 00:59:35,423 --> 00:59:38,292 TIME TO DO A SIMILAR TYPE OF 1701 00:59:38,292 --> 00:59:40,161 SURVEY IN LIKE A FEW YEARS 1702 00:59:40,161 --> 00:59:43,564 LATER TO SEE IF THINGS HAVE 1703 00:59:43,564 --> 00:59:43,798 CHANGED. 1704 00:59:43,798 --> 00:59:45,032 AND IF YOU ALL ARE THINKING 1705 00:59:45,032 --> 00:59:48,035 ABOUT THAT? 1706 00:59:48,035 --> 00:59:49,937 >> CHRIS: YEAH, GREAT QUESTION, 1707 00:59:49,937 --> 00:59:50,938 WE HADN'T PLANNED THAT YET. 1708 00:59:50,938 --> 00:59:53,140 I THINK WE HAVE TO SEE WHAT THE 1709 00:59:53,140 --> 00:59:53,875 FUNDING ENVIRONMENT HOLDS ON 1710 00:59:53,875 --> 00:59:55,076 OUR END TO SEE IF THAT'S MONEY 1711 00:59:55,076 --> 00:59:56,177 THAT WE HAVE. 1712 00:59:56,177 --> 00:59:58,112 BUT YEAH, ABSOLUTELY. 1713 00:59:58,112 --> 01:00:00,181 >> CASEY: ONE THING I WOULD BE 1714 01:00:00,181 --> 01:00:01,649 INTERESTED IN SEEING ALSO, 1715 01:00:01,649 --> 01:00:03,551 WHICH COMMUNITIES THE GRADUATES 1716 01:00:03,551 --> 01:00:07,688 ARE A PART OF, IF THAT'S A 1717 01:00:07,688 --> 01:00:09,156 QUESTION THAT YOU DIDN'T ANSWER 1718 01:00:09,156 --> 01:00:11,259 THIS TIME AROUND, MAYBE NEXT 1719 01:00:11,259 --> 01:00:13,561 TIME AROUND IT WOULD BE GOOD TO 1720 01:00:13,561 --> 01:00:15,663 SEE WHERE, IN ADDITION TO 1721 01:00:15,663 --> 01:00:16,364 GEOGRAPHICALLY, WHICH 1722 01:00:16,364 --> 01:00:17,131 COMMUNITIES THEY ARE ALSO PART 1723 01:00:17,131 --> 01:00:19,133 OF. 1724 01:00:19,133 --> 01:00:21,235 >> CHRIS: YES, THOSE ARE DATA 1725 01:00:21,235 --> 01:00:22,703 WE HAVE, WE JUST DIDN'T SHOW 1726 01:00:22,703 --> 01:00:23,004 THEM TODAY. 1727 01:00:23,004 --> 01:00:26,374 BUT YEAH. 1728 01:00:26,374 --> 01:00:29,176 >> CAROLYN: BRUCE, GO AHEAD. 1729 01:00:29,176 --> 01:00:31,512 >> BRUCE: YEAH, I WOULD BROADEN 1730 01:00:31,512 --> 01:00:34,282 THE CONCEPT OF WHAT ARE BEING 1731 01:00:34,282 --> 01:00:35,449 CALLED NON-TRADITIONAL CAREER 1732 01:00:35,449 --> 01:00:37,618 PATHS BEYOND INDUSTRY TO 1733 01:00:37,618 --> 01:00:38,786 INCLUDE SCIENTIFIC 1734 01:00:38,786 --> 01:00:39,387 COMMUNICATIONS, FOR EXAMPLE, 1735 01:00:39,387 --> 01:00:40,021 SCIENTIFIC PUBLISHING. 1736 01:00:40,021 --> 01:00:41,622 YOU COULD GO ON AND ON, I 1737 01:00:41,622 --> 01:00:42,990 THINK, WITH MANY THINGS. 1738 01:00:42,990 --> 01:00:46,260 IT STRIKES ME THAT IT WILL BE 1739 01:00:46,260 --> 01:00:47,295 INCREASINGLY IMPORTANT TO 1740 01:00:47,295 --> 01:00:50,031 EXPOSE TRAINEES, NOT JUST TO 1741 01:00:50,031 --> 01:00:53,034 THESE ALTERNATIVE CAREER PATHS, 1742 01:00:53,034 --> 01:00:54,402 BUT ALSO SOMEWHERE ALONG THE 1743 01:00:54,402 --> 01:00:57,638 WAY IT MAY BE HELPFUL TO 1744 01:00:57,638 --> 01:00:59,006 PROVIDE EDUCATION, I GUESS YOU 1745 01:00:59,006 --> 01:01:00,641 COULD SAY IN HOW SCIENCE WORKS. 1746 01:01:00,641 --> 01:01:04,879 AND WHAT I MEAN BY THAT IS, HOW 1747 01:01:04,879 --> 01:01:06,847 THIS FUNDING ACTUALLY WORKS. 1748 01:01:06,847 --> 01:01:08,316 UNFORTUNATELY PEOPLE ARE 1749 01:01:08,316 --> 01:01:09,917 GETTING A PRETTY HARD LESSON, 1750 01:01:09,917 --> 01:01:15,323 LIKE FOR EXAMPLE, WHAT ARE 1751 01:01:15,323 --> 01:01:15,856 INDIRECT COSTS RIGHT NOW. 1752 01:01:15,856 --> 01:01:16,791 IT WOULD PROBABLY BEHOOVE 1753 01:01:16,791 --> 01:01:19,794 PEOPLE TO HAVE BEEN EDUCATED 1754 01:01:19,794 --> 01:01:23,631 ABOUT THE OVERALL KIND OF 1755 01:01:23,631 --> 01:01:25,032 SCIENTIFIC INFRASTRUCTURE THAT 1756 01:01:25,032 --> 01:01:27,868 EXISTS AND ENCOMPASSES AN 1757 01:01:27,868 --> 01:01:30,171 ENTIRE ECOSYSTEM OF ACADEMIC 1758 01:01:30,171 --> 01:01:32,406 AND INDUSTRY AND PROFESSIONAL 1759 01:01:32,406 --> 01:01:33,741 SOCIETY AND SO FORTH. 1760 01:01:33,741 --> 01:01:36,210 KIND OF AVENUES. 1761 01:01:36,210 --> 01:01:38,045 SO THAT THEY ACTUALLY 1762 01:01:38,045 --> 01:01:39,213 UNDERSTAND THE COMPLEX WORLD 1763 01:01:39,213 --> 01:01:42,350 THEY ARE MOVING INTO, AND IT 1764 01:01:42,350 --> 01:01:43,951 GOES WAY BEYOND JUST THE 1765 01:01:43,951 --> 01:01:45,386 INDIVIDUAL LAB, MAYBE, THAT 1766 01:01:45,386 --> 01:01:49,657 THEY ARE WORKING. 1767 01:01:49,657 --> 01:01:51,292 >> CHRIS: YEAH, I THINK THAT'S 1768 01:01:51,292 --> 01:01:51,692 A GREAT POINT. 1769 01:01:51,692 --> 01:01:53,494 I CAN SPEAK TO MY OWN 1770 01:01:53,494 --> 01:01:55,429 EXPERIENCE, WHEN I WAS IN 1771 01:01:55,429 --> 01:01:56,297 GRADUATE SCHOOL, LIKE KELLY 1772 01:01:56,297 --> 01:01:58,366 SAID, I LOOKED AT MY P.I.'S AND 1773 01:01:58,366 --> 01:02:00,034 THOUGHT I'M NOT GOING INTO THAT. 1774 01:02:00,034 --> 01:02:02,937 THAT LOOKS HARD, I SAW PEOPLE 1775 01:02:02,937 --> 01:02:04,271 PUTTING OUT 80-90 APPLICATIONS 1776 01:02:04,271 --> 01:02:06,173 THIS IS WHEN DINOSAURS WERE 1777 01:02:06,173 --> 01:02:07,174 WALKING OUTSIDE OUR BUILDINGS 1778 01:02:07,174 --> 01:02:08,709 AND NOT GETTING JOBS AND I'M 1779 01:02:08,709 --> 01:02:10,411 NOT SURE IT'S ANY BETTER. 1780 01:02:10,411 --> 01:02:12,780 SPEAKING AS SOMEONE WHO IS NOW 1781 01:02:12,780 --> 01:02:15,149 A P.I., NO ONE IS MORE SHOCKED 1782 01:02:15,149 --> 01:02:16,450 THAN ME TO FIGURE THAT OUT, I 1783 01:02:16,450 --> 01:02:17,284 AGREE. 1784 01:02:17,284 --> 01:02:19,487 I THINK MORE PLACES ARE DOING 1785 01:02:19,487 --> 01:02:19,820 THAT NOW. 1786 01:02:19,820 --> 01:02:21,455 I AGREE WITH KELLY'S STATEMENT 1787 01:02:21,455 --> 01:02:22,690 THAT ACADEMIA IS THE 1788 01:02:22,690 --> 01:02:23,190 ALTERNATIVE CAREER NOW, 1789 01:02:23,190 --> 01:02:24,959 BASICALLY. 1790 01:02:24,959 --> 01:02:27,028 BUT IT SOUNDS LIKE OUR TRAINEES 1791 01:02:27,028 --> 01:02:28,629 THAT IS A PERENNIAL THING THEY 1792 01:02:28,629 --> 01:02:29,830 ARE STILL ASKING FOR EXPOSURE 1793 01:02:29,830 --> 01:02:38,339 TO WHAT ALL IS OUT THERE. 1794 01:02:38,339 --> 01:02:39,473 >> CAROLYN: ANY OTHER QUESTIONS 1795 01:02:39,473 --> 01:02:47,415 FOR CHRIS? 1796 01:02:47,415 --> 01:02:49,750 OR COMMENTS FROM ALL OF US, 1797 01:02:49,750 --> 01:02:51,385 WHAT'S GOING ON IN TRAINING IN 1798 01:02:51,385 --> 01:02:55,990 YOUR WORLD? 1799 01:02:55,990 --> 01:03:00,227 ALL RIGHT, THANK YOU, CHRIS. 1800 01:03:00,227 --> 01:03:01,862 SO YOU MAY HAVE NOTICED, IF YOU 1801 01:03:01,862 --> 01:03:02,897 HAVE BEEN FOLLOWING ALONG THAT 1802 01:03:02,897 --> 01:03:04,999 WE ARE QUITE A BIT AHEAD IN OUR 1803 01:03:04,999 --> 01:03:05,833 AGENDA. 1804 01:03:05,833 --> 01:03:10,104 AND SO WE ARE GOING TO, IF IT'S 1805 01:03:10,104 --> 01:03:11,338 ALL RIGHT WITH OUR 1806 01:03:11,338 --> 01:03:15,309 COUNCILMEMBERS, PLOW RIGHT INTO 1807 01:03:15,309 --> 01:03:15,943 OUR CONCEPT CLEARANCES. 1808 01:03:15,943 --> 01:03:17,578 AND KNOWING THAT WE MAY LOSE 1809 01:03:17,578 --> 01:03:19,046 BRUCE FOR A LITTLE BIT OF TIME, 1810 01:03:19,046 --> 01:03:20,648 WE ARE GOING TO GO AHEAD AND 1811 01:03:20,648 --> 01:03:23,217 START WITH THE ONE WHERE HE IS 1812 01:03:23,217 --> 01:03:26,387 LEADING OFF DISCUSSION, THE 1813 01:03:26,387 --> 01:03:27,321 CLINICAL DATA ECOSYSTEM FOR 1814 01:03:27,321 --> 01:03:28,889 GENOMICS AND TERI MANOLIO WILL 1815 01:03:28,889 --> 01:03:35,830 BE PRESENTING. 1816 01:03:35,830 --> 01:03:37,932 >> TERI: GREAT, THANKS, JEN AND 1817 01:03:37,932 --> 01:03:39,633 THANK YOU FOR BEING FLEXIBLE TO 1818 01:03:39,633 --> 01:03:40,568 WE CAN LET CHRIS GET TO HIS 1819 01:03:40,568 --> 01:03:41,869 CALL. 1820 01:03:41,869 --> 01:03:44,505 I'M PRESENTING THIS CONCEPT FOR 1821 01:03:44,505 --> 01:03:45,873 CLINICAL DATA ECOSYSTEM FOR 1822 01:03:45,873 --> 01:03:49,910 GENOMICS, THIS IS ENTIRELY THE 1823 01:03:49,910 --> 01:03:52,480 WORK OF NEPHI WALTON, A 1824 01:03:52,480 --> 01:03:53,414 PROBATIONARY EMPLOYEE WHO WAS 1825 01:03:53,414 --> 01:03:54,648 SEPARATED IN EARLY FEBRUARY. 1826 01:03:54,648 --> 01:03:56,650 WE MISS HIM AND ALL OF OUR 1827 01:03:56,650 --> 01:04:00,454 SEPARATED EMPLOYEES GREATLY. 1828 01:04:00,454 --> 01:04:02,056 THE BACKGROUND OF THIS ACTUALLY 1829 01:04:02,056 --> 01:04:04,358 STARTED WITH A WORKSHOP THAT 1830 01:04:04,358 --> 01:04:06,760 NEPHI ORGANIZED BACK IN APRIL 1831 01:04:06,760 --> 01:04:09,530 OF 2024, LOOKING AT HOW WE 1832 01:04:09,530 --> 01:04:11,632 COULD BETTER INTEGRATE GENOMIC 1833 01:04:11,632 --> 01:04:13,467 DATA INTO MEDICAL RECORDS AND 1834 01:04:13,467 --> 01:04:15,336 CLINICAL DECISION SUPPORT TO 1835 01:04:15,336 --> 01:04:16,103 MAKE THEM AVAILABLE FOR 1836 01:04:16,103 --> 01:04:18,639 CLINICIANS TO BE ABLE TO USE IN 1837 01:04:18,639 --> 01:04:19,740 CLINICAL CARE, AND A KEY 1838 01:04:19,740 --> 01:04:21,175 RECOMMENDATION FROM THAT GROUP 1839 01:04:21,175 --> 01:04:24,211 IS TO ESTABLISH A NETWORK THAT 1840 01:04:24,211 --> 01:04:26,080 WOULD BASICALLY PILOT AND TEST 1841 01:04:26,080 --> 01:04:27,982 WAYS TO ADDRESS CHALLENGES OF 1842 01:04:27,982 --> 01:04:30,384 INTEGRATING THESE DATA AND 1843 01:04:30,384 --> 01:04:32,019 ALLOWING THEIR LONGITUDINAL USE 1844 01:04:32,019 --> 01:04:33,821 IN MULTIPLE SETTINGS IN 1845 01:04:33,821 --> 01:04:34,588 CLINICAL CARE, INCLUDING MOST 1846 01:04:34,588 --> 01:04:37,158 IMPORTANTLY TO ME AS A PRIMARY 1847 01:04:37,158 --> 01:04:40,161 CARE CLINICIAN IN PRIMARY CARE. 1848 01:04:40,161 --> 01:04:41,662 SO THE OBJECTIVES OF THE 1849 01:04:41,662 --> 01:04:43,164 PROGRAM THAT WE ARE BRINGING TO 1850 01:04:43,164 --> 01:04:45,299 YOU TODAY, THE CONCEPT ARE TO 1851 01:04:45,299 --> 01:04:46,767 ESTABLISH A PILOT DATA 1852 01:04:46,767 --> 01:04:48,369 ECOSYSTEM THAT WOULD ENABLE THE 1853 01:04:48,369 --> 01:04:50,204 SHARING AND SORT OF TEST 1854 01:04:50,204 --> 01:04:52,306 DIFFERENT MODELS OF DOING THIS 1855 01:04:52,306 --> 01:04:54,241 OF GENOMIC STRUCTURED DATA 1856 01:04:54,241 --> 01:04:55,409 ACROSS DIFFERENT HEALTHCARE 1857 01:04:55,409 --> 01:04:58,245 SETTINGS INCLUDING PRIMARY 1858 01:04:58,245 --> 01:04:59,680 CARE, CREATE STANDARDIZED 1859 01:04:59,680 --> 01:05:00,347 APPLICATION PROGRAMMING 1860 01:05:00,347 --> 01:05:01,649 INTERFACES OR API'S TO SUPPORT 1861 01:05:01,649 --> 01:05:04,318 ACCESS TO THESE DATA. 1862 01:05:04,318 --> 01:05:05,252 DEVELOP OPEN-SOURCE CLINICAL 1863 01:05:05,252 --> 01:05:06,654 SOFTWARE APPLICATIONS AND 1864 01:05:06,654 --> 01:05:07,288 DATABASES TO UTILIZE THESE 1865 01:05:07,288 --> 01:05:09,256 API'S. 1866 01:05:09,256 --> 01:05:12,026 DEMONSTRATE HOW THIS ECOSYSTEM 1867 01:05:12,026 --> 01:05:13,661 CAN SUPPORT ACCESS TO PATIENT'S 1868 01:05:13,661 --> 01:05:15,996 GENOMIC DATA AND LINK THAT TO 1869 01:05:15,996 --> 01:05:18,165 THEIR CLINICAL DATA, AS THEY 1870 01:05:18,165 --> 01:05:19,066 TRAVEL ACROSS DIFFERENT 1871 01:05:19,066 --> 01:05:19,934 HEALTHCARE SYSTEMS THROUGHOUT 1872 01:05:19,934 --> 01:05:21,368 THEIR LIVES, POTENTIALLY. 1873 01:05:21,368 --> 01:05:23,537 AND THEN REFINE AND DEVELOP 1874 01:05:23,537 --> 01:05:24,004 THESE PRACTICES INTO 1875 01:05:24,004 --> 01:05:25,439 IMPLEMENTATION RESOURCES THAT 1876 01:05:25,439 --> 01:05:26,540 COULD BE WIDELY SHARED AND 1877 01:05:26,540 --> 01:05:28,509 ADOPTED. 1878 01:05:28,509 --> 01:05:31,679 WE KNOW THAT THE ROLE OF 1879 01:05:31,679 --> 01:05:33,547 GENOMIC DATA IN HEALTHCARE IS 1880 01:05:33,547 --> 01:05:34,848 GROWING AND HAS GROWN IN 1881 01:05:34,848 --> 01:05:38,919 SEVERAL DIFFERENT DOMAINS. 1882 01:05:38,919 --> 01:05:39,386 CANCER SCREENING, 1883 01:05:39,386 --> 01:05:40,020 PHARMACOGENOMICS RARE DISEASES, 1884 01:05:40,020 --> 01:05:41,488 ET CETERA. 1885 01:05:41,488 --> 01:05:43,424 HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS SHOULD BE 1886 01:05:43,424 --> 01:05:47,795 ABLE TO ACCESS THESE DATA 1887 01:05:47,795 --> 01:05:48,929 LONGITUDINAL AND ASSESS RESULTS 1888 01:05:48,929 --> 01:05:49,997 OR SOMEONE SHOULD DO IT AND 1889 01:05:49,997 --> 01:05:52,032 PROVIDE IT TO THEM TO ADAPT THE 1890 01:05:52,032 --> 01:05:54,168 CARE BASED ON NEW DISCOVERIES 1891 01:05:54,168 --> 01:05:55,803 OR APPLICATIONS AND GSD OR 1892 01:05:55,803 --> 01:05:57,438 GENOMIC STRUCTURED DATA SHOULD 1893 01:05:57,438 --> 01:05:59,540 BE INTEGRATED INTO A PATIENT'S 1894 01:05:59,540 --> 01:06:01,141 PRIMARY SOURCE OF CARE WHILE 1895 01:06:01,141 --> 01:06:02,810 ENABLING EXCHANGE OF RESULTS 1896 01:06:02,810 --> 01:06:03,978 FROM DIFFERENT PROVIDERS FROM 1897 01:06:03,978 --> 01:06:06,814 WHOM THEY MAY BE RECEIVING CARE. 1898 01:06:06,814 --> 01:06:11,018 OUR CURRENT STATE IS FAR FROM 1899 01:06:11,018 --> 01:06:11,352 THAT, HOWEVER. 1900 01:06:11,352 --> 01:06:13,354 SEQUENCING DATA ARE TYPICALLY 1901 01:06:13,354 --> 01:06:16,156 TRANSMITTED STILL IN SOME 1902 01:06:16,156 --> 01:06:19,493 INSTANCES, THERE ARE SOME 1903 01:06:19,493 --> 01:06:20,828 EXCEPTIONS AS NON COMPUTABLE 1904 01:06:20,828 --> 01:06:22,663 PDF'S, THERE'S A VAST AMOUNT, 1905 01:06:22,663 --> 01:06:24,331 SOMETIMES THE ENTIRE GENOME 1906 01:06:24,331 --> 01:06:25,532 SEQUENCE DATA THAT ARE RETAINED 1907 01:06:25,532 --> 01:06:28,335 AT THE LAB, OR MAY NOT EVEN BE 1908 01:06:28,335 --> 01:06:29,470 RETAINED BUT OFTEN RETAINED 1909 01:06:29,470 --> 01:06:31,405 THERE THAT ARE NOT REPORTED AND 1910 01:06:31,405 --> 01:06:34,975 THEY COULD BE VERY VALUABLE IN 1911 01:06:34,975 --> 01:06:35,309 PATIENT CARE. 1912 01:06:35,309 --> 01:06:37,478 ALSO, EACH EXCHANGE OF GENETIC 1913 01:06:37,478 --> 01:06:39,780 DATA BETWEEN LAB AND CLINICAL 1914 01:06:39,780 --> 01:06:42,349 SETTING, OR BETWEEN LABS OR 1915 01:06:42,349 --> 01:06:45,452 WHATEVER TEND TO REQUIRE A 1916 01:06:45,452 --> 01:06:45,853 CUSTOM INTERFACE. 1917 01:06:45,853 --> 01:06:46,787 SO THIS IS NOT SCALABLE IN ANY 1918 01:06:46,787 --> 01:06:49,490 WAY. 1919 01:06:49,490 --> 01:06:52,326 AND NEEDS TO BE MUCH MORE 1920 01:06:52,326 --> 01:06:55,562 STREAMLINED AND SYSTEMATIC 1921 01:06:55,562 --> 01:06:55,963 APPROACH TO THAT. 1922 01:06:55,963 --> 01:06:57,264 GENETIC DATA FOR EACH PATIENT 1923 01:06:57,264 --> 01:06:58,899 ARE TYPICALLY STORED AS 1924 01:06:58,899 --> 01:07:00,301 INDIVIDUAL FILES FOR EACH 1925 01:07:00,301 --> 01:07:02,670 PATIENT AND DATA STANDARDS ARE 1926 01:07:02,670 --> 01:07:04,238 CURRENTLY NOT TOTALLY ADEQUATE. 1927 01:07:04,238 --> 01:07:06,807 THEY ARE IMPROVING BUT NOT 1928 01:07:06,807 --> 01:07:08,475 ADEQUATE FOR FACILITATING 1929 01:07:08,475 --> 01:07:11,345 EXCHANGE OF GSD ACROSS SETTINGS. 1930 01:07:11,345 --> 01:07:14,248 HAS THIS BEEN USED? 1931 01:07:14,248 --> 01:07:16,717 OKAY, EVEN IF IT HAS. 1932 01:07:16,717 --> 01:07:19,053 SUPER. 1933 01:07:19,053 --> 01:07:20,988 SO SOME EARLY SUCCESSES THAT WE 1934 01:07:20,988 --> 01:07:24,958 HAVE SEEN OUT IN THE RESEARCH, 1935 01:07:24,958 --> 01:07:26,327 PARTICULARLY IN TERTIARY CARE 1936 01:07:26,327 --> 01:07:27,861 SETTINGS THERE'S BEEN LIMITED 1937 01:07:27,861 --> 01:07:29,063 INTEGRATION OF STRUCTURED 1938 01:07:29,063 --> 01:07:29,997 GENOME RESULTS INTO THEENSINGER 1939 01:07:29,997 --> 01:07:32,099 HR AND THAT'S NOW BEEN ACHIEVED 1940 01:07:32,099 --> 01:07:34,668 BY OVER 20 SYSTEMS IN THE U.S. 1941 01:07:34,668 --> 01:07:35,369 A VERY NICE DEMONSTRATION 1942 01:07:35,369 --> 01:07:40,774 PROJECT OF THIS WAS THE GENETIC 1943 01:07:40,774 --> 01:07:41,408 CANCER RISK DETECTOR OR GARDE 1944 01:07:41,408 --> 01:07:48,215 PROGRAM. 1945 01:07:48,215 --> 01:07:51,285 FIRST DEPLOYMENT OF A 1946 01:07:51,285 --> 01:07:52,219 GENERALIZABLE HL7 1947 01:07:52,219 --> 01:07:53,654 STANDARDS-BASED METHOD FOR 1948 01:07:53,654 --> 01:07:55,556 POPULATION LEVEL CDS FOR 1949 01:07:55,556 --> 01:07:56,957 GENOMICS. 1950 01:07:56,957 --> 01:07:59,259 IMPLEMENTED STANDARDS BASED AND 1951 01:07:59,259 --> 01:08:00,694 WAS SUCCESSFULLY DEPLOYED 1952 01:08:00,694 --> 01:08:01,495 ACROSS THREE HEALTHCARE SYSTEMS 1953 01:08:01,495 --> 01:08:02,930 ACROSS THE COUNTRY. 1954 01:08:02,930 --> 01:08:04,932 SO REALLY A VERY NICE 1955 01:08:04,932 --> 01:08:06,066 PROTOTYPE, AN EARLY ONE. 1956 01:08:06,066 --> 01:08:08,669 AND EXPANSION OF THESE KINDS OF 1957 01:08:08,669 --> 01:08:10,804 EARLY SUCCESSES COULD ENABLE, 1958 01:08:10,804 --> 01:08:13,307 WE WOULD EXPECT, INTEGRATION OF 1959 01:08:13,307 --> 01:08:14,541 GENOMIC DATA INTO HEALTH 1960 01:08:14,541 --> 01:08:15,909 INFORMATION EXCHANGES THAT ARE 1961 01:08:15,909 --> 01:08:19,580 SORT OF CLUSTERS OF SOMETIMES 1962 01:08:19,580 --> 01:08:20,581 STATEWIDE, SOMETIMES REGION 1963 01:08:20,581 --> 01:08:22,683 WIDE OF CARE RECORDS THAT CAN 1964 01:08:22,683 --> 01:08:26,153 BE USED IN FOLLOWING A PATIENT 1965 01:08:26,153 --> 01:08:27,054 FROM HEALTHCARE SETTING TO 1966 01:08:27,054 --> 01:08:29,189 HEALTHCARE SETTING THAT MAKES 1967 01:08:29,189 --> 01:08:31,024 THE DATA AVAILABLE ACROSS 1968 01:08:31,024 --> 01:08:32,459 MULTIPLE PROVIDERS, ACROSS 1969 01:08:32,459 --> 01:08:34,128 CLINICAL FACILITIES AND WITH 1970 01:08:34,128 --> 01:08:35,028 PATIENTS TO COORDINATE AND 1971 01:08:35,028 --> 01:08:36,697 IMPROVE THEIR CARE. 1972 01:08:36,697 --> 01:08:38,098 SO OUR DESIRED STATE AND WHAT 1973 01:08:38,098 --> 01:08:41,135 WE WOULD LIKE TO PILOT IN THIS 1974 01:08:41,135 --> 01:08:42,803 PROGRAM ARE SEQUENCING DATA 1975 01:08:42,803 --> 01:08:44,705 WOULD BE READILY AVAILABLE AS 1976 01:08:44,705 --> 01:08:46,306 STRUCTURED DATA IN A 1977 01:08:46,306 --> 01:08:48,976 STANDARDIZED COMPUTABLE FORMAT 1978 01:08:48,976 --> 01:08:49,443 THAT DOESN'T REQUIRE 1979 01:08:49,443 --> 01:08:50,310 INDIVIDUALIZED INTERFACES. 1980 01:08:50,310 --> 01:08:51,645 THAT THEY ARE AVAILABLE TO 1981 01:08:51,645 --> 01:08:54,481 EVERY MEMBER OF WHATEVER 1982 01:08:54,481 --> 01:08:57,017 NETWORK IS ESTABLISHED AND 1983 01:08:57,017 --> 01:08:58,352 OBVIOUSLY WITH APPROPRIATE 1984 01:08:58,352 --> 01:08:59,253 CONFIDENTIALITY AND PRIVACY 1985 01:08:59,253 --> 01:08:59,620 PROTECTIONS. 1986 01:08:59,620 --> 01:09:01,488 THAT THEY ARE ACCESSIBLE IN ALL 1987 01:09:01,488 --> 01:09:04,391 THE SETTING WHERE'S PATIENTS 1988 01:09:04,391 --> 01:09:07,294 WOULD RECEIVE HEALTHCARE AND 1989 01:09:07,294 --> 01:09:08,629 EVEN POTENTIALLY TO PATIENTS. 1990 01:09:08,629 --> 01:09:10,764 ABLE TO PROVIDE INFORMATICS AND 1991 01:09:10,764 --> 01:09:12,433 DATA GOVERNANCE, SUCH AS ACCESS 1992 01:09:12,433 --> 01:09:15,002 CONTROL AND AUTHENTICATION TO 1993 01:09:15,002 --> 01:09:17,304 FACILITATE EASY EXCHANGE AND 1994 01:09:17,304 --> 01:09:19,206 THE NETWORK WOULD DEMONSTRATE 1995 01:09:19,206 --> 01:09:21,041 THESE CAPABILITIES ACROSS 1996 01:09:21,041 --> 01:09:22,409 MULTIPLE DISTINCT BUT 1997 01:09:22,409 --> 01:09:23,143 INTEROPERABLE HEALTHCARE 1998 01:09:23,143 --> 01:09:25,245 SYSTEMS AND COLLABORATE TO 1999 01:09:25,245 --> 01:09:26,046 DEMONSTRATE THE EFFECTIVENESS, 2000 01:09:26,046 --> 01:09:28,282 MODIFY AND IMPROVE IT. 2001 01:09:28,282 --> 01:09:29,983 THIS LITTLE CARTOON IS SHOWING 2002 01:09:29,983 --> 01:09:33,120 US THE SORT OF LIFE SPAN OF A 2003 01:09:33,120 --> 01:09:34,321 GIVEN INDIVIDUAL AND HOW 2004 01:09:34,321 --> 01:09:35,522 GENOMIC DATA MIGHT BE USED 2005 01:09:35,522 --> 01:09:38,058 ACROSS THAT. 2006 01:09:38,058 --> 01:09:40,861 OBVIOUSLY WHERE THERE'S NEWBORN 2007 01:09:40,861 --> 01:09:41,795 SEQUENCING OR EVEN PRENATAL 2008 01:09:41,795 --> 01:09:43,464 GENETIC TESTING THEY WOULD BE 2009 01:09:43,464 --> 01:09:45,799 USED IN THAT SETTING AND COULD 2010 01:09:45,799 --> 01:09:46,533 POTENTIALLY HAVE AN IMPACT 2011 01:09:46,533 --> 01:09:49,336 LATER IN LIFE AS WELL. 2012 01:09:49,336 --> 01:09:50,971 GENETIC DIAGNOSIS COULD BE MADE 2013 01:09:50,971 --> 01:09:52,139 AT MULTIPLE TIME POINTS 2014 01:09:52,139 --> 01:09:56,610 THROUGHOUT THE LIFE SPAN. 2015 01:09:56,610 --> 01:09:57,811 OPPORTUNITIES FOR RESEARCH, 2016 01:09:57,811 --> 01:09:58,445 PHARMACOGENETICS, PARTICULARLY 2017 01:09:58,445 --> 01:10:00,647 INCREASING AS ONE GETS A LITTLE 2018 01:10:00,647 --> 01:10:05,085 BIT OLDER AND ACCUMULATES BOTH 2019 01:10:05,085 --> 01:10:10,691 CO-EXISTING ILLNESSES AND DRUGS. 2020 01:10:10,691 --> 01:10:11,925 AND POLYGENIC RISK SCORE COULD 2021 01:10:11,925 --> 01:10:14,561 BE PRODUCED. 2022 01:10:14,561 --> 01:10:16,930 AND AI ALGORITHMS COULD BE 2023 01:10:16,930 --> 01:10:17,498 PRODUCED ACROSS THESE TIME 2024 01:10:17,498 --> 01:10:19,233 POINTS TOO. 2025 01:10:19,233 --> 01:10:21,502 ALL OF THESE ARE POSSIBILITIES 2026 01:10:21,502 --> 01:10:22,469 FOR GENETIC DATA REPOSITORY WE 2027 01:10:22,469 --> 01:10:25,272 WOULD LIKE TO TRY TO FACILITATE. 2028 01:10:25,272 --> 01:10:27,674 TYPES OF OPERATIONS THIS COULD 2029 01:10:27,674 --> 01:10:29,309 ENABLE WOULD INCLUDE, JUST 2030 01:10:29,309 --> 01:10:32,880 THINKING OF GS DATA SIT IN A 2031 01:10:32,880 --> 01:10:34,014 GENETIC REPOSITORY WOULD LIKELY 2032 01:10:34,014 --> 01:10:37,351 BE AT A LAB, BUT COULD 2033 01:10:37,351 --> 01:10:38,719 CONCEIVABLY BE AT ANOTHER 2034 01:10:38,719 --> 01:10:39,419 HEALTHCARE SYSTEM THAT 2035 01:10:39,419 --> 01:10:41,522 GENERATED THOSE DATA AND THE 2036 01:10:41,522 --> 01:10:42,556 API'S COULD BE DEVELOPED THAT 2037 01:10:42,556 --> 01:10:43,790 WOULD RECEIVE THE DATA REQUEST 2038 01:10:43,790 --> 01:10:45,659 AND PASS BACK RESPONSES. 2039 01:10:45,659 --> 01:10:46,693 THREE EXAMPLES, THERE ARE MANY. 2040 01:10:46,693 --> 01:10:49,096 BUT ONE MIGHT BE A SPECIFIC 2041 01:10:49,096 --> 01:10:52,533 DATA REQUEST FROM A CLINICIAN, 2042 01:10:52,533 --> 01:10:56,069 A BREAST SURGEON WHO WANTS TO 2043 01:10:56,069 --> 01:10:59,339 KNOW ALL THE RARE YANTS IN THE 2044 01:10:59,339 --> 01:11:02,142 PATIENT'S BRCA1. 2045 01:11:02,142 --> 01:11:04,511 REQUESTER RECEIVES FW, SD FROM 2046 01:11:04,511 --> 01:11:06,947 REPOSITORY AND PERFORMS 2047 01:11:06,947 --> 01:11:08,782 OPERATION ON DATA TO DETERMINE, 2048 01:11:08,782 --> 01:11:11,184 AND WOULD PROVIDE THE CARE TO 2049 01:11:11,184 --> 01:11:11,885 THE PATIENT FOR THAT. 2050 01:11:11,885 --> 01:11:14,354 OR REQUEST THE FULL DATA. 2051 01:11:14,354 --> 01:11:15,822 MIGHT ASK FOR THE PATIENT'S 2052 01:11:15,822 --> 01:11:19,326 ENTIRE GENOME BE GIVEN A 2053 01:11:19,326 --> 01:11:19,626 GENOMIC VCF. 2054 01:11:19,626 --> 01:11:21,862 THEY COULD SEARCH IF THEY ARE 2055 01:11:21,862 --> 01:11:23,964 CAPABLE THEREOF AND INTERESTED 2056 01:11:23,964 --> 01:11:27,334 FOR PATIENT RELEVANT PATH 2057 01:11:27,334 --> 01:11:28,969 AGAINIC OR LIKELY PATHOGENIC 2058 01:11:28,969 --> 01:11:30,404 VARIANTS IN OTHER GENES AND 2059 01:11:30,404 --> 01:11:31,939 PROVIDE CARE FOR THE PATIENT. 2060 01:11:31,939 --> 01:11:33,507 OR COULD BE A NO TOUCH REQUEST, 2061 01:11:33,507 --> 01:11:34,808 WHICH WOULD BE THE SORT OF 2062 01:11:34,808 --> 01:11:37,311 THING I WOULD DO WITH SAY THEY 2063 01:11:37,311 --> 01:11:42,849 ARE LOOKING FOR A PATIENT'S 2064 01:11:42,849 --> 01:11:43,984 POLYGENIC RISK SCORE FOR 2065 01:11:43,984 --> 01:11:48,422 CORONARY DISEASE. 2066 01:11:48,422 --> 01:11:50,524 DOES ADDRESS CERTAIN CONCERNS 2067 01:11:50,524 --> 01:11:52,426 RELATED TO CONFIDENTIALITY, 2068 01:11:52,426 --> 01:11:54,995 THEY ASK TO PERFORM OPERATION 2069 01:11:54,995 --> 01:11:56,897 ON THE DATA SO CALCULATE THIS 2070 01:11:56,897 --> 01:11:59,132 PARTICULAR POLYGENIC RISK SCORE 2071 01:11:59,132 --> 01:12:00,834 OR ALL FOR CORONARY DISEASE, 2072 01:12:00,834 --> 01:12:03,570 WHICH THERE ARE MANY, SEND THE 2073 01:12:03,570 --> 01:12:05,105 RESULT. 2074 01:12:05,105 --> 01:12:06,406 BUT THE REQUESTER NEVER TOUCHES 2075 01:12:06,406 --> 01:12:12,245 THE GENOME INC DATA DIRECTLY. 2076 01:12:12,245 --> 01:12:14,648 THIS COULD BE SHOWN 2077 01:12:14,648 --> 01:12:16,049 SCHEMATICKLY IN THESE DIAGRAMS 2078 01:12:16,049 --> 01:12:17,284 THE DATA PEOPLE LOVE AND I HAVE 2079 01:12:17,284 --> 01:12:18,885 TROUBLE NAVIGATING. 2080 01:12:18,885 --> 01:12:20,487 BUT THIS SHOWS THE GENOMIC 2081 01:12:20,487 --> 01:12:23,323 SEQUENCE DATA IN THE LIGHT BLUE 2082 01:12:23,323 --> 01:12:26,093 BARREL THING ON THE UPPER LEFT 2083 01:12:26,093 --> 01:12:26,393 HAND CORNER. 2084 01:12:26,393 --> 01:12:31,064 THE API IS THIS SORT OF ROYAL 2085 01:12:31,064 --> 01:12:31,698 BLUE WIDGET THAT IS IT THIS 2086 01:12:31,698 --> 01:12:33,300 CALCULATION. 2087 01:12:33,300 --> 01:12:35,836 SPECIFIC DATA REQUEST IS SENT, 2088 01:12:35,836 --> 01:12:38,572 IT GOES TO THE GENERAL 2089 01:12:38,572 --> 01:12:41,208 REPOSITORY, IT SPITS OUT THE 2090 01:12:41,208 --> 01:12:41,575 SUBJECT'S DATA. 2091 01:12:41,575 --> 01:12:43,777 THERE'S A PROCESS THE REQUESTER 2092 01:12:43,777 --> 01:12:48,281 WOULD USE TO FIGURE OUT ARE 2093 01:12:48,281 --> 01:12:49,016 THERE PATHOGENIC VARIANTS, THEY 2094 01:12:49,016 --> 01:12:51,284 GET THE RESULT AND GO ONTO CARE 2095 01:12:51,284 --> 01:12:55,522 FOR THE PATIENT. 2096 01:12:55,522 --> 01:12:57,691 REPOSITORY SENDS COMPRISING ALL 2097 01:12:57,691 --> 01:12:59,393 THE THE CHD PRS. 2098 01:12:59,393 --> 01:13:01,328 IN A SECOND EXAMPLE, YOU COULD 2099 01:13:01,328 --> 01:13:03,630 GET, HAVE A FULL DATA REQUEST. 2100 01:13:03,630 --> 01:13:07,067 AGAIN, THAT REQUEST IS SENT TO 2101 01:13:07,067 --> 01:13:09,369 THE API, THE DATA ARE SENT OUT, 2102 01:13:09,369 --> 01:13:12,005 AGAIN A PROCESSING STEP AND THE 2103 01:13:12,005 --> 01:13:14,541 RESULT SO THE REQUESTER THEN 2104 01:13:14,541 --> 01:13:16,176 MODELS FOR EXAMPLE, MULTIPLE 2105 01:13:16,176 --> 01:13:17,744 CHD SCORES OR COULD BE SCORES 2106 01:13:17,744 --> 01:13:21,348 FOR MULTIPLE DISEASES. 2107 01:13:21,348 --> 01:13:23,417 AND IN AN NO-TOUCH APPROACH, 2108 01:13:23,417 --> 01:13:24,751 THIS IS SLIGHTLY DIFFERENT 2109 01:13:24,751 --> 01:13:25,819 REQUEST, SO THEY CONCEIVE OF 2110 01:13:25,819 --> 01:13:28,555 THE REQUEST BUT THEY SEND THE 2111 01:13:28,555 --> 01:13:30,023 REQUEST THROUGH THE API, THAT 2112 01:13:30,023 --> 01:13:31,391 IS IT THE DATA PROCESSING ON 2113 01:13:31,391 --> 01:13:32,759 THE DATA, SENDS BACK THE RESULT 2114 01:13:32,759 --> 01:13:33,560 AND THEN THEY CARE FOR THE 2115 01:13:33,560 --> 01:13:36,296 PATIENT. 2116 01:13:36,296 --> 01:13:37,264 WHAT DID I DO? 2117 01:13:37,264 --> 01:13:40,867 SOMETHING BAD. 2118 01:13:40,867 --> 01:13:50,177 CAN YOU RESCUE ME, PLEASE? 2119 01:13:50,177 --> 01:13:51,812 THERE WE GO, I WILL TAKE IT 2120 01:13:51,812 --> 01:13:53,613 FROM HERE, I APPRECIATE IT. 2121 01:13:53,613 --> 01:13:55,315 SO WHAT WE ARE PROPOSING -- 2122 01:13:55,315 --> 01:13:56,249 OH, IT'S NOT SHOWING? 2123 01:13:56,249 --> 01:13:57,284 OH, OKAY. 2124 01:13:57,284 --> 01:14:07,394 SORRY. 2125 01:14:18,772 --> 01:14:20,140 WE ARE PROPOSING 1-3 RFA'S, 2126 01:14:20,140 --> 01:14:21,341 CAROLYN MENTION DOLLARS THERE'S 2127 01:14:21,341 --> 01:14:23,143 A MOVE OF LIMITING AND 2128 01:14:23,143 --> 01:14:27,080 REDEUCING THE NUMBER OF 2129 01:14:27,080 --> 01:14:28,849 SOLICITATIONS OR NOFO'S WE SEND 2130 01:14:28,849 --> 01:14:29,015 OUT. 2131 01:14:29,015 --> 01:14:30,117 ONE WAY TO APPROACH AND 2132 01:14:30,117 --> 01:14:31,551 SIMPLIFY WOULD BE TO PUT THE 2133 01:14:31,551 --> 01:14:34,354 REQUEST FOR ALL THREE TYPES OF 2134 01:14:34,354 --> 01:14:35,789 CENTERS, LABORATORY, CLINICAL 2135 01:14:35,789 --> 01:14:36,990 SITES AND COORDINATING CENTER 2136 01:14:36,990 --> 01:14:39,292 INTO A SINGLE REQUEST FOR 2137 01:14:39,292 --> 01:14:43,663 APPLICATIONS OR NOFO. 2138 01:14:43,663 --> 01:14:44,898 AND HONESTLY, WHEN WE WRITE 2139 01:14:44,898 --> 01:14:47,400 THESE THINGS WE TEND TO PUT 80% 2140 01:14:47,400 --> 01:14:48,602 OF THE INFORMATION IS IN EACH 2141 01:14:48,602 --> 01:14:50,303 OF THEM, THEY HAVE TO KNOW WHAT 2142 01:14:50,303 --> 01:14:51,571 EACH OTHER IS DOING IN ORDER TO 2143 01:14:51,571 --> 01:14:53,073 WRITE THEIR APPLICATION. 2144 01:14:53,073 --> 01:14:54,040 WE COULD SAY SOMETHING LIKE, 2145 01:14:54,040 --> 01:14:57,144 ALL RIGHT, IF YOU ARE APPLYING 2146 01:14:57,144 --> 01:14:58,311 FOR THE COORDINATING CENTER 2147 01:14:58,311 --> 01:14:59,646 MAKE SURE YOU ADDRESS THESE 2148 01:14:59,646 --> 01:15:01,581 TASKS, IF APPLYING FOR THE 2149 01:15:01,581 --> 01:15:03,650 CLINICAL TASKS ADDRESS THESE. 2150 01:15:03,650 --> 01:15:05,952 IT'S NOT CLEAR YET WHERE IT'S 2151 01:15:05,952 --> 01:15:07,621 GOING, THAT'S AN INNOVATION WE 2152 01:15:07,621 --> 01:15:09,322 HAVE YET TO SEE IMPLEMENTED. 2153 01:15:09,322 --> 01:15:13,693 IT COULD BE ONE TO THREE. 2154 01:15:13,693 --> 01:15:15,262 WE ARE LOOKING A DATABASE THAT 2155 01:15:15,262 --> 01:15:17,330 WOULD SERVE UP GENOME INC TATE 2156 01:15:17,330 --> 01:15:19,733 TA. 2157 01:15:19,733 --> 01:15:21,535 WE ARE PROPOSING SIMULATED 2158 01:15:21,535 --> 01:15:24,371 RATHER THAN ACTUAL PATIENT DATA 2159 01:15:24,371 --> 01:15:27,007 TO AVOID NECESSITIES FOR 2160 01:15:27,007 --> 01:15:27,607 OBVIOUSLY CONSENT AND IRB, ET 2161 01:15:27,607 --> 01:15:28,408 CETERA. 2162 01:15:28,408 --> 01:15:30,677 AND THE FACT THAT WE REALLY 2163 01:15:30,677 --> 01:15:32,312 DON'T, FOR THIS PILOT PROJECT, 2164 01:15:32,312 --> 01:15:34,648 WE REALLY DON'T NEED ACTUAL 2165 01:15:34,648 --> 01:15:35,949 PATIENT DATA, SO SIMULATED DATA 2166 01:15:35,949 --> 01:15:37,717 WILL WORK JUST FINE. 2167 01:15:37,717 --> 01:15:39,486 AND DEVELOP GENOMIC OPERATIONS 2168 01:15:39,486 --> 01:15:42,589 FOR THE API'S THAT THEY DEVELOP. 2169 01:15:42,589 --> 01:15:43,990 CLINICAL SITES SIMILARLY WOULD 2170 01:15:43,990 --> 01:15:45,592 DEVELOP AND DEPLOY APPLICATIONS 2171 01:15:45,592 --> 01:15:47,093 THAT UTILIZE THE GENOMIC DATA 2172 01:15:47,093 --> 01:15:50,597 IN CLINICAL CARE AND THEY WOULD 2173 01:15:50,597 --> 01:15:51,198 DEVELOP ASSIMILATED DATASET 2174 01:15:51,198 --> 01:15:53,200 THAT COINCIDES WITH THE GENOMIC 2175 01:15:53,200 --> 01:15:54,801 TATE TA SETS AND COORDINATING 2176 01:15:54,801 --> 01:15:57,304 CENTER WOULD KEEP ALL OF THIS 2177 01:15:57,304 --> 01:15:58,972 HUM TOGETHER, COORDINATING, 2178 01:15:58,972 --> 01:15:59,940 SHARING AND IMPLEMENTATION 2179 01:15:59,940 --> 01:16:01,541 EFFORTS AMONG THOSE SITES 2180 01:16:01,541 --> 01:16:03,176 THROUGH IN-PERSON MEETINGS ET 2181 01:16:03,176 --> 01:16:04,878 CETERA BUT ALSO COMPILE 2182 01:16:04,878 --> 01:16:07,180 ORGANIZED BEST PRACTICES, THE 2183 01:16:07,180 --> 01:16:08,215 API'S AND VARIOUS OPEN SOURCE 2184 01:16:08,215 --> 01:16:09,249 PROGRAMMING ET CETERA. 2185 01:16:09,249 --> 01:16:11,351 BROAD DISTRIBUTION. 2186 01:16:11,351 --> 01:16:13,620 AND FACILITATE ENGAGEMENT WHICH 2187 01:16:13,620 --> 01:16:14,754 WILL BE IMPORTANT FOR 2188 01:16:14,754 --> 01:16:15,922 STANDARDIZATION AND LATER 2189 01:16:15,922 --> 01:16:16,790 ACCEPTANCE, WITH STANDARDS 2190 01:16:16,790 --> 01:16:17,357 ORGANIZATIONS AND INDUSTRY 2191 01:16:17,357 --> 01:16:20,961 PARTNERS. 2192 01:16:20,961 --> 01:16:22,629 SO THE PROPOSED SCOPE, SORRY, 2193 01:16:22,629 --> 01:16:24,931 AND CONTINUING ON THE PROPOSED 2194 01:16:24,931 --> 01:16:26,600 SCOPE, METRICS TO ASSESS THE 2195 01:16:26,600 --> 01:16:28,902 SUCCESS AND SCAPABILITY OF THE 2196 01:16:28,902 --> 01:16:30,270 IMPLEMENTATION COULD INCLUDE 2197 01:16:30,270 --> 01:16:32,205 THINGS LIKE EASE OF 2198 01:16:32,205 --> 01:16:34,307 IMPLEMENTATION, PORTABILITY OF 2199 01:16:34,307 --> 01:16:36,109 THE APPLICATIONS, CUSTOMIZATION 2200 01:16:36,109 --> 01:16:37,744 REQUIREMENTS, DATA 2201 01:16:37,744 --> 01:16:38,245 AVAILABILITY, ET CETERA. 2202 01:16:38,245 --> 01:16:38,845 THERE COULD BE TECHNICAL 2203 01:16:38,845 --> 01:16:39,846 METRICS SUCH AS RESPONSE TIME 2204 01:16:39,846 --> 01:16:43,183 OR ERROR RATE, ET CETERA. 2205 01:16:43,183 --> 01:16:44,551 QUALITATIVE ASSESSMENTS BY END 2206 01:16:44,551 --> 01:16:45,986 USERS, HOW EASY WAS THIS TO 2207 01:16:45,986 --> 01:16:47,087 USE, HOW WOULD YOU SUGGEST WE 2208 01:16:47,087 --> 01:16:48,989 IMPROVE IT, ET CETERA. 2209 01:16:48,989 --> 01:16:50,457 AND SUSTAINABILITY AGAIN, 2210 01:16:50,457 --> 01:16:52,626 ASSESS THROUGH EVALUATION AND 2211 01:16:52,626 --> 01:16:53,994 PROPOSED ADOPTIONS BY STANDARDS 2212 01:16:53,994 --> 01:16:59,499 BODIES SUCH AS THE GENOMIC 2213 01:16:59,499 --> 01:17:02,402 GLOBAL ALLIANCE, OR HL7. 2214 01:17:02,402 --> 01:17:04,938 AND AGAIN, MECHANISMS OF 2215 01:17:04,938 --> 01:17:06,773 SUPPORT WOULD BE U01 2216 01:17:06,773 --> 01:17:08,008 COOPERATIVE AGREEMENTS FOR ONE 2217 01:17:08,008 --> 01:17:09,409 COORDINATING CENTER, A COUPLE 2218 01:17:09,409 --> 01:17:11,378 OF CLINICAL SITES, A COUPLE OF 2219 01:17:11,378 --> 01:17:11,945 LABORATORY SITES. 2220 01:17:11,945 --> 01:17:13,380 WE PREFER MORE THAN ONE BECAUSE 2221 01:17:13,380 --> 01:17:16,116 WE WANT TO BE SURE IT'S 2222 01:17:16,116 --> 01:17:16,650 WORKABLE ACROSS MULTIPLE 2223 01:17:16,650 --> 01:17:19,085 SETTINGS. 2224 01:17:19,085 --> 01:17:20,287 ESTIMATED $6 MILLION PER YEAR 2225 01:17:20,287 --> 01:17:22,155 FOR TOTAL OF FIVE YEARS AND WE 2226 01:17:22,155 --> 01:17:23,890 MAY SEEK FUNDS FROM OTHER IC'S 2227 01:17:23,890 --> 01:17:25,825 TO INCREASE THE NUMBER OF SITES 2228 01:17:25,825 --> 01:17:27,527 OR SOFTWARE APPLICATIONS. 2229 01:17:27,527 --> 01:17:29,663 SO THAT'S ALL I HAVE TO SAY. 2230 01:17:29,663 --> 01:17:32,699 I WILL STOP THERE AND TURN TO 2231 01:17:32,699 --> 01:17:35,535 BRUCE KORF AS THE FIRST 2232 01:17:35,535 --> 01:17:36,036 DISCUSSANT. 2233 01:17:36,036 --> 01:17:40,840 >> BRUCE: THANKS, TERI AND 2234 01:17:40,840 --> 01:17:42,242 THANKS FOR ACCOMMODATING MY 2235 01:17:42,242 --> 01:17:44,144 SCHEDULE, I HAVE TO JUMP OFF AT 2236 01:17:44,144 --> 01:17:46,346 2:00 FOR JUST A LITTLE WHILE. 2237 01:17:46,346 --> 01:17:47,814 AS A STARTING POINT, I'M REALLY 2238 01:17:47,814 --> 01:17:50,850 EXCITED TO SEE THIS. 2239 01:17:50,850 --> 01:17:52,018 THE ABILITY TO INTEGRATE 2240 01:17:52,018 --> 01:17:53,420 GENOMIC DATA INTO THE 2241 01:17:53,420 --> 01:17:54,487 MAINSTREAM OF HEALTHCARE IS 2242 01:17:54,487 --> 01:17:56,856 GOING IT BE CRITICAL, IF WE ARE 2243 01:17:56,856 --> 01:17:59,693 GOING TO SEE THE POTENTIAL OF 2244 01:17:59,693 --> 01:18:01,027 GENOMIC MEDICINE BE REALIZED ON 2245 01:18:01,027 --> 01:18:03,363 A ROUTINE BASIS. 2246 01:18:03,363 --> 01:18:05,699 SO GETTING AWAY FROM THE PDF 2247 01:18:05,699 --> 01:18:07,467 ERA IS GOING TO BE ABSOLUTELY 2248 01:18:07,467 --> 01:18:10,503 CRITICAL. 2249 01:18:10,503 --> 01:18:12,872 A FEW THINGS JUST OCCURRED TO 2250 01:18:12,872 --> 01:18:15,875 ME IN WHICH MAY OR MAY NOT FIT 2251 01:18:15,875 --> 01:18:19,679 INTO THE SCOPE OF THIS, I'LL 2252 01:18:19,679 --> 01:18:21,348 JUST MENTION A FEW POINTS THAT 2253 01:18:21,348 --> 01:18:23,083 I THINK MIGHT BE RELEVANT. 2254 01:18:23,083 --> 01:18:24,150 IT'S GOING TO BE IMPORTANT, I 2255 01:18:24,150 --> 01:18:27,354 THINK, ALONG THE WAY TO DEVELOP 2256 01:18:27,354 --> 01:18:27,620 USE CASES. 2257 01:18:27,620 --> 01:18:28,621 THE WORST THAT COULD HAPPEN IS 2258 01:18:28,621 --> 01:18:30,757 THE DATA DOESN'T GET INTO THE 2259 01:18:30,757 --> 01:18:31,324 MEDICAL RECORD SO IT'S NOT 2260 01:18:31,324 --> 01:18:34,060 THERE. 2261 01:18:34,060 --> 01:18:35,695 THE SECOND WORST IS IT IS 2262 01:18:35,695 --> 01:18:37,797 BURIED THERE IN A WAY NO ONE 2263 01:18:37,797 --> 01:18:39,599 KNOWS HOW TO ACCESS OR USE IT. 2264 01:18:39,599 --> 01:18:45,305 THERE WILL BE THE NEED NOT JUST 2265 01:18:45,305 --> 01:18:46,439 FOR AFICIONADOS TO ACCESS IT 2266 01:18:46,439 --> 01:18:48,308 BUT TO FIND ITS WAY INTO THE 2267 01:18:48,308 --> 01:18:50,443 HANDS OF PEOPLE WHO AREN'T 2268 01:18:50,443 --> 01:18:51,811 REALLY VERY FAMILIAR WITH 2269 01:18:51,811 --> 01:18:55,315 GENOMICS BUT WILL STILL FIND IT 2270 01:18:55,315 --> 01:18:56,750 VALUABLE FOR THEIR CARE. 2271 01:18:56,750 --> 01:18:58,385 SO ULTIMATELY, I THINK, WHETHER 2272 01:18:58,385 --> 01:18:59,319 IMMEDIATELY OR NOT, THERE'S 2273 01:18:59,319 --> 01:19:03,490 GOING TO NEED TO BE INTERFACES 2274 01:19:03,490 --> 01:19:05,258 INTO CLINICIANS WHO ARE 2275 01:19:05,258 --> 01:19:07,160 UNFAMILIAR WITH GENOMICS, AS 2276 01:19:07,160 --> 01:19:10,263 WELL AS EDUCATION ABOUT THE USE. 2277 01:19:10,263 --> 01:19:12,866 AND THAT MAY APPLY NOT ONLY TO 2278 01:19:12,866 --> 01:19:14,667 THE CLINICIANS BUT ALSO TO 2279 01:19:14,667 --> 01:19:14,934 PATIENTS. 2280 01:19:14,934 --> 01:19:17,203 ONE THING THAT I THINK MAY 2281 01:19:17,203 --> 01:19:18,605 EVOLVE OVER TIME IS AN INTEREST 2282 01:19:18,605 --> 01:19:21,474 ON THE PART OF AT LEAST SOME 2283 01:19:21,474 --> 01:19:22,675 PEOPLE, TO HAVE DIRECT ACCESS 2284 01:19:22,675 --> 01:19:28,648 TO THEIR OWN GENOMIC DATA, NOT 2285 01:19:28,648 --> 01:19:29,916 NECESSARILY ONLY THROUGH A 2286 01:19:29,916 --> 01:19:31,518 CLINICIAN BUT TO EXPLORE ON 2287 01:19:31,518 --> 01:19:31,785 THEIR OWN. 2288 01:19:31,785 --> 01:19:34,320 THE ABILITY TO HAVE SOME 2289 01:19:34,320 --> 01:19:35,789 CONTROL OF THAT COULD BECOME 2290 01:19:35,789 --> 01:19:36,956 SOMETHING SOME PEOPLE WILL AT 2291 01:19:36,956 --> 01:19:39,192 LEAST BE INTERESTED IN. 2292 01:19:39,192 --> 01:19:40,827 AND HAVING SOME CONSUMER INPUT 2293 01:19:40,827 --> 01:19:43,263 INTO THIS PROCESS MIGHT 2294 01:19:43,263 --> 01:19:43,730 ACTUALLY BE VALUABLE. 2295 01:19:43,730 --> 01:19:44,798 EVEN FROM AN EARLY STAGE. 2296 01:19:44,798 --> 01:19:48,835 THERE ARE GOING TO BE ISSUES OF 2297 01:19:48,835 --> 01:19:50,737 TRUST WITH ALL OF THESE DATA, 2298 01:19:50,737 --> 01:19:52,639 FOR EXAMPLE, I THINK ARE GOING 2299 01:19:52,639 --> 01:19:55,642 TO NEED TO BE ADDRESSED OVER 2300 01:19:55,642 --> 01:19:58,178 TIME. 2301 01:19:58,178 --> 01:19:59,813 THERE'S ALSO, THE POTENTIAL, IF 2302 01:19:59,813 --> 01:20:01,681 YOU THINK ABOUT IT, YOU MADE 2303 01:20:01,681 --> 01:20:05,685 THE POINT THAT A SURGEON COULD 2304 01:20:05,685 --> 01:20:07,754 ASK ABOUT A BRCA GENE CHANGE 2305 01:20:07,754 --> 01:20:09,055 AND THAT CERTAINLY IS EASY TO 2306 01:20:09,055 --> 01:20:11,391 MATHISEN NAIR YO. 2307 01:20:11,391 --> 01:20:12,725 SCENARIO. 2308 01:20:12,725 --> 01:20:14,794 BUT THE OTHER SIDE IS SOMEONE 2309 01:20:14,794 --> 01:20:16,162 DEVELOPS BREAST CANCER AND THEN 2310 01:20:16,162 --> 01:20:17,597 AFTER THE FACT GOES AND 2311 01:20:17,597 --> 01:20:19,232 DISCOVERS THAT IT WAS KNOWN ALL 2312 01:20:19,232 --> 01:20:23,203 ALONG THAT THERE WAS A BRCA-1 2313 01:20:23,203 --> 01:20:25,138 VARIANT THAT NO ONE PAID ANY 2314 01:20:25,138 --> 01:20:25,472 ATTENTION TO. 2315 01:20:25,472 --> 01:20:28,842 AND HOW TO NAVIGATE THAT, WHAT 2316 01:20:28,842 --> 01:20:30,877 COULD ACTUALLY BE A MEDICAL 2317 01:20:30,877 --> 01:20:34,547 LEGAL SET OF ISSUES. 2318 01:20:34,547 --> 01:20:36,749 IF THE INFORMATION IS 2319 01:20:36,749 --> 01:20:37,917 ACCESSIBLE, THERE'S MAYBE, 2320 01:20:37,917 --> 01:20:39,085 POTENTIALLY ANYWAY AN 2321 01:20:39,085 --> 01:20:40,487 EXPECTATION IT WILL BE ACCESSED 2322 01:20:40,487 --> 01:20:42,655 TO THE BENEFIT OF A PATIENT. 2323 01:20:42,655 --> 01:20:44,524 OF COURSE IT GETS EVEN MORE 2324 01:20:44,524 --> 01:20:46,359 COMPLICATED WHEN YOU REALIZE 2325 01:20:46,359 --> 01:20:49,095 THERE WILL BE VUS'S OR OTHER 2326 01:20:49,095 --> 01:20:51,297 THINGS THAT ARE PRONE TO 2327 01:20:51,297 --> 01:20:52,132 MISINTERPRETATION. 2328 01:20:52,132 --> 01:20:53,299 I THINK PUTTING THIS 2329 01:20:53,299 --> 01:20:55,135 INFORMATION AT THE HANDS OF 2330 01:20:55,135 --> 01:20:56,503 CLINICIANS IS A FANTASTIC AND 2331 01:20:56,503 --> 01:20:57,904 IMPORTANT STEP FORWARD. 2332 01:20:57,904 --> 01:21:01,474 BUT IT RAISES A LOT OF SORT OF 2333 01:21:01,474 --> 01:21:02,876 LOGISTICAL ISSUES, IN TERMS OF 2334 01:21:02,876 --> 01:21:06,246 HOW IT WILL BE USED, HOW PEOPLE 2335 01:21:06,246 --> 01:21:08,548 WILL KNOW THAT IT'S THERE, AND 2336 01:21:08,548 --> 01:21:10,917 KNOW THAT THEY SHOULD QUERY IT. 2337 01:21:10,917 --> 01:21:13,586 THERE WILL ALSO BE QUESTIONS OF 2338 01:21:13,586 --> 01:21:15,688 HOW INFORMATION IS UPDATED. 2339 01:21:15,688 --> 01:21:17,157 THE SEQUENCE AND ITS 2340 01:21:17,157 --> 01:21:18,558 INTERPRETATION TODAY, NOT ONLY 2341 01:21:18,558 --> 01:21:21,094 WILL CHANGE WITH THE EVOLUTION 2342 01:21:21,094 --> 01:21:23,696 OF A PATIENT'S MEDICAL HISTORY, 2343 01:21:23,696 --> 01:21:28,268 BUT ALSO AS MORE KNOWLEDGE IS 2344 01:21:28,268 --> 01:21:30,603 GAINED AND HOW THAT INFORMATION 2345 01:21:30,603 --> 01:21:32,472 IS MAINTAINED IN AN UP-TO-DATE 2346 01:21:32,472 --> 01:21:34,140 SORT OF CURATED MANNER IS, I 2347 01:21:34,140 --> 01:21:35,508 THINK, ALSO GOING TO BE 2348 01:21:35,508 --> 01:21:36,242 IMPORTANT. 2349 01:21:36,242 --> 01:21:38,845 I GUESS IN SUMMARY, I GUESS 2350 01:21:38,845 --> 01:21:41,481 IT'S A TERRIFIC STEP THAT IS 2351 01:21:41,481 --> 01:21:43,349 VERY, VERY MUCH NEEDED AND 2352 01:21:43,349 --> 01:21:44,717 REALLY WOULD LOOK FORWARD TO 2353 01:21:44,717 --> 01:21:47,820 THE KIND OF PROGRESS THAT THIS 2354 01:21:47,820 --> 01:21:49,122 WILL GENERATE. 2355 01:21:49,122 --> 01:21:50,990 AND I THINK IT'S GOING TO RAISE 2356 01:21:50,990 --> 01:21:51,524 ANY NUMBER OF ADDITIONAL 2357 01:21:51,524 --> 01:21:52,492 QUESTIONS. 2358 01:21:52,492 --> 01:21:53,693 SOME OF WHICH MAY BE POSSIBLE 2359 01:21:53,693 --> 01:21:55,528 TO EMBED IN THE WAY THIS IS PUT 2360 01:21:55,528 --> 01:21:56,496 TOGETHER. 2361 01:21:56,496 --> 01:21:58,498 AND SOME OF WHICH MAY BE NEXT 2362 01:21:58,498 --> 01:22:01,901 STEPS THAT WOULD HAPPEN ONCE 2363 01:22:01,901 --> 01:22:03,503 THE INFORMATION IS POTENTIALLY 2364 01:22:03,503 --> 01:22:03,736 AT HAND. 2365 01:22:03,736 --> 01:22:05,205 I WILL PAUSE AT THAT POINT, BUT 2366 01:22:05,205 --> 01:22:06,873 THOSE ARE SOME OF THE THINGS 2367 01:22:06,873 --> 01:22:12,412 THAT HAVE OCCURRED TO ME. 2368 01:22:12,412 --> 01:22:14,747 >> TERI: GREAT, SUPER. 2369 01:22:14,747 --> 01:22:15,281 THOSE WERE GREAT COMMENTS. 2370 01:22:15,281 --> 01:22:16,816 THANK YOU. 2371 01:22:16,816 --> 01:22:18,418 I BELIEVE THE OTHER DISCUSSANT 2372 01:22:18,418 --> 01:22:20,153 WAS CASEY. 2373 01:22:20,153 --> 01:22:24,157 >> KELLY: IT'S KELLY. 2374 01:22:24,157 --> 01:22:26,226 >> JEN: KELLY, GO AHEAD AND 2375 01:22:26,226 --> 01:22:27,627 THEN WE WILL WELCOME COMMENTS 2376 01:22:27,627 --> 01:22:30,830 FROM CASEY AND EVERYONE ELSE. 2377 01:22:30,830 --> 01:22:35,435 >> KELLY: I WANT TO SECOND 2378 01:22:35,435 --> 01:22:36,269 THOSE COMMENTS. 2379 01:22:36,269 --> 01:22:37,637 YOU TOUCHED UPON IT IN YOUR 2380 01:22:37,637 --> 01:22:40,873 SLIDE OF ALL THE POTENTIAL WAYS 2381 01:22:40,873 --> 01:22:46,246 SUCH DATA COULD BE USED. 2382 01:22:46,246 --> 01:22:48,414 I THINK REALLY ANTICIPATING THE 2383 01:22:48,414 --> 01:22:57,090 VALUE THAT 2384 01:22:57,090 --> 01:22:59,859 THIS TYPE OF DATABASE WOULD 2385 01:22:59,859 --> 01:23:02,895 PROVIDE FOR RESEARCH, AND THE 2386 01:23:02,895 --> 01:23:07,000 ABILITY TO ACTUALLY, NOT ONLY 2387 01:23:07,000 --> 01:23:08,401 PUT INFORMATION INTO, TO 2388 01:23:08,401 --> 01:23:11,704 AUGMENT THAT RESOURCE BASED ON 2389 01:23:11,704 --> 01:23:14,574 EXTERNAL RESEARCH BUT THE VALUE 2390 01:23:14,574 --> 01:23:16,442 OF THIS INFORMATION FOR 2391 01:23:16,442 --> 01:23:17,744 RESEARCHERS THEMSELVES TO GAIN 2392 01:23:17,744 --> 01:23:20,280 NEW INFORMATION. 2393 01:23:20,280 --> 01:23:24,083 I WANT TO REALLY EMPHASIZE THE 2394 01:23:24,083 --> 01:23:25,885 IMPORTANCE OF THINKING OF THAT 2395 01:23:25,885 --> 01:23:30,189 UP FRONT AND WHAT TYPE OF 2396 01:23:30,189 --> 01:23:31,557 CONSENSUS, WHAT TYPE OF OTHER 2397 01:23:31,557 --> 01:23:35,561 INFORMATION, HOW DOES THE BACK 2398 01:23:35,561 --> 01:23:37,530 END NEED TO BE DEVELOPED? 2399 01:23:37,530 --> 01:23:39,098 AND WOULD THE DATA BE SILOED 2400 01:23:39,098 --> 01:23:40,600 AND WOULD PEOPLE HAVE TO BE 2401 01:23:40,600 --> 01:23:45,505 ABLE TO ACCESS IT THROUGH A 2402 01:23:45,505 --> 01:23:47,307 SILOED EVENT, I THINK THAT'S 2403 01:23:47,307 --> 01:23:47,607 KEY. 2404 01:23:47,607 --> 01:23:51,511 SO BUILDING THAT INTO THE 2405 01:23:51,511 --> 01:23:58,551 PROGRAM. 2406 01:23:58,551 --> 01:24:00,653 >> TERI: THANKS, KELLY. 2407 01:24:00,653 --> 01:24:01,821 THAT'S VERY IMPORTANT, AND 2408 01:24:01,821 --> 01:24:02,989 THAT'S WHY INVESTIGATORS WHEN 2409 01:24:02,989 --> 01:24:03,790 THEY COME ON BOARD MAY CHANGE 2410 01:24:03,790 --> 01:24:05,325 THIS. 2411 01:24:05,325 --> 01:24:06,492 BUT WE ARE PROPOSING SIMULATED 2412 01:24:06,492 --> 01:24:08,594 DATA SO WE CAN GET THE SYSTEM 2413 01:24:08,594 --> 01:24:10,496 DOWN, GET THE CHANGES IN 2414 01:24:10,496 --> 01:24:11,464 INFRASTRUCTURE UNDERSTOOD AND 2415 01:24:11,464 --> 01:24:14,334 SORT OF PLAYED WITH AND KICKED 2416 01:24:14,334 --> 01:24:15,835 AROUND WITHOUT HAVING TO 2417 01:24:15,835 --> 01:24:17,637 ADDRESS THESE KINDS OF CONCERNS. 2418 01:24:17,637 --> 01:24:19,272 AND THEN HOPEFULLY, AS WE ARE 2419 01:24:19,272 --> 01:24:22,041 BUILDING IT OUT FOR SOMETHING 2420 01:24:22,041 --> 01:24:23,976 THAT COULD BE DISSEMINATED, 2421 01:24:23,976 --> 01:24:26,546 REALLY TRY TO TACKLE THOSE 2422 01:24:26,546 --> 01:24:27,814 ISSUES IN PREPARATION FOR USING 2423 01:24:27,814 --> 01:24:33,319 REAL PATIENT DATA. 2424 01:24:33,319 --> 01:24:43,596 OTHER COMMENTS? 2425 01:24:44,130 --> 01:24:46,099 >> CASEY: I HAVE A COMMENT. 2426 01:24:46,099 --> 01:24:48,234 ALONG THE LINE WITH WHAT BRUCE 2427 01:24:48,234 --> 01:24:49,669 WAS SAYING EARLIER, THERE'S 2428 01:24:49,669 --> 01:24:51,371 SOME SIMULATED DATA THAT IS 2429 01:24:51,371 --> 01:24:52,038 BEING USED. 2430 01:24:52,038 --> 01:24:54,407 BUT THERE'S A NEW USE CASE 2431 01:24:54,407 --> 01:24:56,309 WHERE PATIENTS WILL BE GETTING 2432 01:24:56,309 --> 01:24:57,910 THE RESULTS, LIKE UPON ORDERING 2433 01:24:57,910 --> 01:25:00,046 A TEST, THEY COULD BE GETTING 2434 01:25:00,046 --> 01:25:02,582 THE RESULTS BEFORE THE 2435 01:25:02,582 --> 01:25:02,849 CLINICIAN. 2436 01:25:02,849 --> 01:25:04,317 AND SO THAT IS SOMETHING THAT 2437 01:25:04,317 --> 01:25:05,651 WILL BE GREAT TO EXPLORE 2438 01:25:05,651 --> 01:25:07,353 FURTHER. 2439 01:25:07,353 --> 01:25:09,989 JUST RIGHT NOW WITH PDF'S IT'S 2440 01:25:09,989 --> 01:25:13,326 STILL, THERE'S KIND OF A STOP 2441 01:25:13,326 --> 01:25:14,560 BEFORE A CLINICIAN CAN 2442 01:25:14,560 --> 01:25:16,195 INTERVENE BEFORE THE PATIENT 2443 01:25:16,195 --> 01:25:18,297 GETS ACCESS TO THEIR RESULTS. 2444 01:25:18,297 --> 01:25:19,565 SO THAT'S AN INTERESTING USE 2445 01:25:19,565 --> 01:25:20,199 CASE. 2446 01:25:20,199 --> 01:25:26,572 AND THEN THE OTHER ASPECT IS, 2447 01:25:26,572 --> 01:25:28,674 WHAT IS BEING PROPOSED IS 2448 01:25:28,674 --> 01:25:30,343 MAKING DATA AVAILABLE AT 2449 01:25:30,343 --> 01:25:31,944 MULTIPLE POINTS OVER THE LIFE, 2450 01:25:31,944 --> 01:25:34,380 OVER THE COURSE OF LIFE. 2451 01:25:34,380 --> 01:25:37,650 AND SO, SOME OF THOSE SCENARIOS 2452 01:25:37,650 --> 01:25:39,318 MAY NOT HAVE BEEN EXPLORED IN 2453 01:25:39,318 --> 01:25:42,355 OTHER NETWORKS. 2454 01:25:42,355 --> 01:25:45,491 AND SO JUST THINKING ABOUT, IF 2455 01:25:45,491 --> 01:25:50,663 THEY ARE ONES THAT COULD BE 2456 01:25:50,663 --> 01:25:51,898 EXPLORED IN SOME WAY, IN THE 2457 01:25:51,898 --> 01:25:57,937 LINE, LIKE I DON'T KNOW FOR THE 2458 01:25:57,937 --> 01:25:59,439 COMING UP LIKE E-CONSULT 2459 01:25:59,439 --> 01:26:01,274 NETWORK FOR EXAMPLE, MAYBE 2460 01:26:01,274 --> 01:26:05,845 THERE'S WAYS TO THINK ABOUT 2461 01:26:05,845 --> 01:26:06,512 CONSULTATION ON THOSE DIFFERENT 2462 01:26:06,512 --> 01:26:07,814 POINTS IN TIME. 2463 01:26:07,814 --> 01:26:09,615 SO ANYWAY, I JUST WANTED TO 2464 01:26:09,615 --> 01:26:13,419 KIND OF AGREE WITH THE POINT 2465 01:26:13,419 --> 01:26:14,954 ABOUT EXPLORING THESE USE CASES 2466 01:26:14,954 --> 01:26:16,055 OF THESE DIFFERENT POINTS IN 2467 01:26:16,055 --> 01:26:17,890 TIME AND HOW THEY ARE DIFFERENT 2468 01:26:17,890 --> 01:26:22,495 WHEN THE DATA IS COMPLETELY 2469 01:26:22,495 --> 01:26:23,696 COMPUTABLE AND CONNECTED WITH 2470 01:26:23,696 --> 01:26:26,365 CLINICAL DATA IS CONNECTED. 2471 01:26:26,365 --> 01:26:28,768 BUT VERY EXCITED TO HEAR THIS. 2472 01:26:28,768 --> 01:26:29,469 >> TERI: SUPER, THANK YOU, 2473 01:26:29,469 --> 01:26:30,703 CASEY. 2474 01:26:30,703 --> 01:26:32,271 ONE COULD EVEN IMAGINE ONE OF 2475 01:26:32,271 --> 01:26:33,739 THE ADVANTAGES OF USING 2476 01:26:33,739 --> 01:26:35,374 SIMULATED DATA IS YOU COULD AGE 2477 01:26:35,374 --> 01:26:36,909 YOUR PATIENT. 2478 01:26:36,909 --> 01:26:39,245 SAY TOMORROW WE DECIDE THAT 2479 01:26:39,245 --> 01:26:41,581 JOHN INSTEAD OF BEING 25 HE IS 2480 01:26:41,581 --> 01:26:44,817 NOW 45 OR 65 OR 85. 2481 01:26:44,817 --> 01:26:46,719 OR HE HAS SUDDENLY GONE TO I A 2482 01:26:46,719 --> 01:26:47,420 DIFFERENT STATE AND BEING CARED 2483 01:26:47,420 --> 01:26:49,288 FOR THERE. 2484 01:26:49,288 --> 01:26:51,424 YEAH, THOSE ARE GREAT IDEAS, 2485 01:26:51,424 --> 01:26:53,292 THANK YOU. 2486 01:26:53,292 --> 01:26:58,531 >> JEN: NANCY? 2487 01:26:58,531 --> 01:27:06,339 >> NANCY: I JUST WANTED TO 2488 01:27:06,339 --> 01:27:06,873 AGREE VEHEMENTLY WITH OUR 2489 01:27:06,873 --> 01:27:07,974 EXPERTS. 2490 01:27:07,974 --> 01:27:09,175 AND I ESPECIALLY WANTED TO 2491 01:27:09,175 --> 01:27:10,076 CIRCLE BACK TO ONE OF THE 2492 01:27:10,076 --> 01:27:11,477 THINGS KELLY SAID. 2493 01:27:11,477 --> 01:27:13,446 I DON'T THINK PEOPLE APPRECIATE 2494 01:27:13,446 --> 01:27:15,581 HOW MUCH GENOME DATA ARE 2495 01:27:15,581 --> 01:27:21,687 ACTUALLY AVAILABLE AND CAN BE 2496 01:27:21,687 --> 01:27:22,221 HUGELY VALUABLE EVEN NOW. 2497 01:27:22,221 --> 01:27:24,924 WE UNDERTOOK, I SHOULD SAY, ONE 2498 01:27:24,924 --> 01:27:28,394 OF MY COLLEAGUES UNDERTOOK, 2499 01:27:28,394 --> 01:27:30,830 LITERALLY A YEARS LONG EFFORT 2500 01:27:30,830 --> 01:27:32,665 TO DO THIS AT VANDERBILT. 2501 01:27:32,665 --> 01:27:34,467 IT DID TAKE YEARS BUT IT TURNED 2502 01:27:34,467 --> 01:27:38,204 OUT WE HAD DATA ON MORE THAN 2503 01:27:38,204 --> 01:27:39,472 100,000 PEOPLE WITH CLINICAL 2504 01:27:39,472 --> 01:27:44,143 GENETIC INFORMATION. 2505 01:27:44,143 --> 01:27:47,213 AND THE VALUE OF THAT, IT HAS 2506 01:27:47,213 --> 01:27:51,117 JUST BEEN INCREDIBLE ALREADY, 2507 01:27:51,117 --> 01:27:54,186 IN TERMS OF HOW USEFUL AN 2508 01:27:54,186 --> 01:27:55,588 AUXILIARY DATABASE IT IS FOR 2509 01:27:55,588 --> 01:27:57,723 SEARCHING IN THE CONTEXT OF 2510 01:27:57,723 --> 01:28:03,262 UDN-TYPE QUESTIONS. 2511 01:28:03,262 --> 01:28:05,565 BUT ALSO OTHER TYPES OF 2512 01:28:05,565 --> 01:28:06,699 QUESTIONS. 2513 01:28:06,699 --> 01:28:09,035 I THINK THIS IS OVERDUE BUT 2514 01:28:09,035 --> 01:28:10,903 PART OF THE CHALLENGE HAS 2515 01:28:10,903 --> 01:28:11,804 HISTORICALLY BEEN WHEN IS THE 2516 01:28:11,804 --> 01:28:14,840 RIGHT TIME TO MAKE THIS 2517 01:28:14,840 --> 01:28:15,141 INVESTMENT? 2518 01:28:15,141 --> 01:28:19,278 AND I THINK IT'S OVERDUE. 2519 01:28:19,278 --> 01:28:23,249 SO THIS WILL BE A VERY TIMELY 2520 01:28:23,249 --> 01:28:23,783 AND IMPORTANT INVESTMENT. 2521 01:28:23,783 --> 01:28:26,118 BECAUSE I'M SURE THAT OTHER 2522 01:28:26,118 --> 01:28:27,219 MEDICAL CENTERS HAVE ALREADY 2523 01:28:27,219 --> 01:28:30,089 GOT DATA ON HUNDREDS OF 2524 01:28:30,089 --> 01:28:32,358 THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE THAT CAN 2525 01:28:32,358 --> 01:28:35,494 IMMEDIATELY COME INTO THESE 2526 01:28:35,494 --> 01:28:35,962 SYSTEMS. 2527 01:28:35,962 --> 01:28:38,097 SO KUDOS FOR GETTING THIS 2528 01:28:38,097 --> 01:28:38,364 TOGETHER. 2529 01:28:38,364 --> 01:28:41,200 THIS HAD TO HAVE BEEN A MONSTER 2530 01:28:41,200 --> 01:28:43,436 TO JUST GET THE ARMS WRAPPED 2531 01:28:43,436 --> 01:28:44,236 AROUND. 2532 01:28:44,236 --> 01:28:45,605 SO THANKS TO NHGRI FOR TAKING 2533 01:28:45,605 --> 01:28:48,507 THE LEADERSHIP ON THIS. 2534 01:28:48,507 --> 01:28:50,643 >> TERI: THANK YOU, NANCY. 2535 01:28:50,643 --> 01:28:53,179 REALLY THE THANKS NEED TO GO TO 2536 01:28:53,179 --> 01:28:54,580 MY COLLEAGUE NEPHI WHO WAS THE 2537 01:28:54,580 --> 01:28:56,682 LEADER IN THIS AND DID A 2538 01:28:56,682 --> 01:28:58,584 FABULOUS JOB DEVELOPING IT, WE 2539 01:28:58,584 --> 01:29:00,186 HOPE TO ATTRACT HIM BACK WHEN 2540 01:29:00,186 --> 01:29:02,455 GRASS IS A LITTLE GREENER. 2541 01:29:02,455 --> 01:29:03,456 >> JEN: TIM, I THINK YOU HAD A 2542 01:29:03,456 --> 01:29:03,990 QUESTION? 2543 01:29:03,990 --> 01:29:05,758 >> TIM: YEP. 2544 01:29:05,758 --> 01:29:09,128 I AGREE WITH ALL THESE COMMENTS. 2545 01:29:09,128 --> 01:29:10,463 IT'S IMPRESSIVE AND I REALLY 2546 01:29:10,463 --> 01:29:11,030 APPRECIATE THE PRESENTATION 2547 01:29:11,030 --> 01:29:13,132 TODAY. 2548 01:29:13,132 --> 01:29:16,969 ONE CONCERN I DO HAVE IS HOW 2549 01:29:16,969 --> 01:29:19,071 MOVING REVIEW TO CSR WILL 2550 01:29:19,071 --> 01:29:21,540 IMPACT SOMETHING LIKE THIS 2551 01:29:21,540 --> 01:29:22,942 WHERE FOR EXAMPLE, SECURITY IS 2552 01:29:22,942 --> 01:29:24,577 GOING TO BE A HUGE 2553 01:29:24,577 --> 01:29:26,612 CONSIDERATION AND THAT'S NOT 2554 01:29:26,612 --> 01:29:28,948 SOMETHING THAT I THINK THE 2555 01:29:28,948 --> 01:29:31,450 STANDARD CSR PANEL IS GOING TO 2556 01:29:31,450 --> 01:29:35,287 BE CAPABLE OF EVALUATING AND 2557 01:29:35,287 --> 01:29:36,188 REVIEWING PLANS FOR. 2558 01:29:36,188 --> 01:29:37,556 I DON'T, IT'S MORE OF A 2559 01:29:37,556 --> 01:29:39,025 COMMENT, I GUESS THAN A 2560 01:29:39,025 --> 01:29:40,726 QUESTION, BUT JUST WANT TO FLAG 2561 01:29:40,726 --> 01:29:42,094 THAT, THAT'S SOMETHING THAT, I 2562 01:29:42,094 --> 01:29:44,930 THINK, I HAVE CONCERNS THAT THE 2563 01:29:44,930 --> 01:29:46,966 STANDARD CSR PANEL MAY NOT DO 2564 01:29:46,966 --> 01:29:53,572 SERVICE TO AN RFA LIKE THIS. 2565 01:29:53,572 --> 01:29:55,741 >> TERI: LET ME ASK BEFORE YOU 2566 01:29:55,741 --> 01:29:57,209 COMMENT, THE SECURITY CONCERN 2567 01:29:57,209 --> 01:29:59,011 WOULD BE ABOUT ACTUAL PATIENT 2568 01:29:59,011 --> 01:30:03,282 DATA OR ABOUT SIMULATED DATA? 2569 01:30:03,282 --> 01:30:05,084 >> TIM: IT SEEMS IF YOU ARE 2570 01:30:05,084 --> 01:30:07,420 GOING TO SERVE UP PATIENT DATA, 2571 01:30:07,420 --> 01:30:08,320 THE SECURITY CONCERNS BECOME 2572 01:30:08,320 --> 01:30:10,489 QUITE STRONG AND IT WOULD BE, 2573 01:30:10,489 --> 01:30:12,091 YOU KNOW, PRUDENT TO EVALUATE 2574 01:30:12,091 --> 01:30:14,226 THAT ON SIMULATED DATA. 2575 01:30:14,226 --> 01:30:14,660 >> TERI: EXCELLENT. 2576 01:30:14,660 --> 01:30:15,161 YES. 2577 01:30:15,161 --> 01:30:17,496 GO AHEAD. 2578 01:30:17,496 --> 01:30:20,332 >> JEN: YES, I JUST WANTED TO 2579 01:30:20,332 --> 01:30:23,736 STEP IN, SORRY, DIDN'T MEAN TO 2580 01:30:23,736 --> 01:30:25,638 INTERRUPT YOU, THAT MOVING TO 2581 01:30:25,638 --> 01:30:27,139 CSR DOES NOT MEAN THAT IT WILL 2582 01:30:27,139 --> 01:30:30,543 NOT GET SPECIAL EMPHASIS PANELS. 2583 01:30:30,543 --> 01:30:32,178 SO THEY WILL CONDUCT SPECIAL 2584 01:30:32,178 --> 01:30:34,046 EMPHASIS PANELS. 2585 01:30:34,046 --> 01:30:36,182 AND IN FACT, THEY, YOU KNOW, 2586 01:30:36,182 --> 01:30:37,383 REMAINS TO BE SEEN EXACTLY HOW 2587 01:30:37,383 --> 01:30:39,618 IT ALL WORKS TOGETHER. 2588 01:30:39,618 --> 01:30:42,054 BUT THEY WILL CONSULT WITH US 2589 01:30:42,054 --> 01:30:44,390 ON, YOU KNOW, WHAT TYPE OF 2590 01:30:44,390 --> 01:30:45,057 EXPERTISE IS NEEDED FOR REVIEWS 2591 01:30:45,057 --> 01:30:46,492 AND SO FORTH. 2592 01:30:46,492 --> 01:30:50,262 SO NOT EVERYTHING WILL BE GOING 2593 01:30:50,262 --> 01:30:50,696 TO STANDING PANELS. 2594 01:30:50,696 --> 01:31:01,173 I JUST WANT TO CLARIFY THAT. 2595 01:31:02,174 --> 01:31:04,944 >> I WAS GOING TO SAY THAT, I 2596 01:31:04,944 --> 01:31:06,779 ELUDED TO THAT IN MY 2597 01:31:06,779 --> 01:31:07,513 PRESENTATION, IT WILL BE 2598 01:31:07,513 --> 01:31:09,181 IMPORTANT FOR US TO FIGURE OUT 2599 01:31:09,181 --> 01:31:11,050 HOW TO WORK WITH CSR AS A 2600 01:31:11,050 --> 01:31:13,819 PARTNER TO MOVE THESE TYPES OF 2601 01:31:13,819 --> 01:31:14,353 INITIATIVES FORWARD 2602 01:31:14,353 --> 01:31:18,057 PARTICULARLY WHEN WE ARE 2603 01:31:18,057 --> 01:31:19,492 PUSHING INTO THESE NICHE AREAS. 2604 01:31:19,492 --> 01:31:21,060 WE AREN'T ALONE IN THIS, IT 2605 01:31:21,060 --> 01:31:23,362 WILL HAVE TO BE DONE AT THE 2606 01:31:23,362 --> 01:31:24,396 NIH-WIDE LEVEL. 2607 01:31:24,396 --> 01:31:26,098 I THINK THAT'S GOING TO BE 2608 01:31:26,098 --> 01:31:27,733 SOMETHING AND AGAIN, I SORT OF 2609 01:31:27,733 --> 01:31:29,168 ELUDED TO FOR COUNCIL TO WORK 2610 01:31:29,168 --> 01:31:30,903 WITH AS WE START TO COME BACK 2611 01:31:30,903 --> 01:31:35,274 WITH SOME OF THE FIRST NOFO'S, 2612 01:31:35,274 --> 01:31:36,342 FIRST FUNDING PLANS COMING OUT 2613 01:31:36,342 --> 01:31:38,444 OF SOME OF THIS NEW MODEL. 2614 01:31:38,444 --> 01:31:41,881 I THINK WE WILL GET THERE, I DO 2615 01:31:41,881 --> 01:31:44,116 WANT TO STRESS JEN'S POINT IT'S 2616 01:31:44,116 --> 01:31:46,652 NOT GOING TO BE LIKE THEY ARE 2617 01:31:46,652 --> 01:31:48,087 ALL GOING TO STANDING STUDY 2618 01:31:48,087 --> 01:31:50,489 SECTIONS BUT IT'S ALSO GOING TO 2619 01:31:50,489 --> 01:31:51,423 BE IMPORTANT FOR US INTERNALLY 2620 01:31:51,423 --> 01:31:52,992 AND THEN ALSO IN PARTNERSHIP 2621 01:31:52,992 --> 01:31:54,894 WITH COUNCIL WHICH IS WHY I'M 2622 01:31:54,894 --> 01:31:56,228 STRESSING IT NOW TO WORK 2623 01:31:56,228 --> 01:31:58,831 THROUGH HOW DO WE WORK THROUGH 2624 01:31:58,831 --> 01:32:01,600 THIS PLACE AND GET CSR TO THAT 2625 01:32:01,600 --> 01:32:03,202 POINT, BECAUSE I THINK THEY ARE 2626 01:32:03,202 --> 01:32:04,703 DEDICATED TO DOING IT BUT IT'S 2627 01:32:04,703 --> 01:32:07,072 NOT LIKE THEY ARE GOING TO 2628 01:32:07,072 --> 01:32:08,908 INSTANTANEOUSLY BE ABLE TO 2629 01:32:08,908 --> 01:32:12,011 ABSORB THE EXPERTISE OF 27 2630 01:32:12,011 --> 01:32:15,147 INSTITUTES SORT OF APPROACHES. 2631 01:32:15,147 --> 01:32:16,582 SO LONG TERM, WE WILL GET THERE. 2632 01:32:16,582 --> 01:32:17,850 BUT IN THE SHORT-TERM IT WILL 2633 01:32:17,850 --> 01:32:19,118 BE SOMETHING WE HAVE TO PUSH ON 2634 01:32:19,118 --> 01:32:22,721 AND WE WILL BE WORKING WITH 2635 01:32:22,721 --> 01:32:24,590 COUNCIL TO MAKE SURE WE ARE 2636 01:32:24,590 --> 01:32:26,725 STILL GETTING WHAT WE WANT OUT 2637 01:32:26,725 --> 01:32:27,760 OF THESE KEY INITIATIVES WE ARE 2638 01:32:27,760 --> 01:32:29,061 PUTTING FORWARD. 2639 01:32:29,061 --> 01:32:33,432 >> TIM: THANK YOU. 2640 01:32:33,432 --> 01:32:34,867 >> TERI: ARE THERE OTHER 2641 01:32:34,867 --> 01:32:38,437 COMMENTS FROM COUNCILMEMBERS? 2642 01:32:38,437 --> 01:32:41,207 IF NOT, I THINK I TURN IT BACK 2643 01:32:41,207 --> 01:32:41,440 TO YOU. 2644 01:32:41,440 --> 01:32:43,275 >> JEN: YEAH, I THEY WE NEED A 2645 01:32:43,275 --> 01:32:47,746 MOTION TO APPROVE. 2646 01:32:47,746 --> 01:32:49,949 GOT ONE FROM BRUCE, AND SECOND, 2647 01:32:49,949 --> 01:32:51,050 LOOKS LIKE WE GOT A COUPLE 2648 01:32:51,050 --> 01:32:52,184 SECONDS. 2649 01:32:52,184 --> 01:32:53,085 WE WILL DO HANDS FIRST. 2650 01:32:53,085 --> 01:32:53,853 ALL IN FAVOR? 2651 01:32:53,853 --> 01:32:57,223 THANK YOU. 2652 01:32:57,223 --> 01:32:58,757 SO NOBODY AGAINST, AND NOBODY 2653 01:32:58,757 --> 01:33:00,726 ABSTAINING, YOU ARE ALL SET. 2654 01:33:00,726 --> 01:33:01,327 AND THEN COUNCILMEMBERS, I'M 2655 01:33:01,327 --> 01:33:05,297 GOING TO ASK YOU TO CLICK BACK 2656 01:33:05,297 --> 01:33:08,367 INTO ECB IN THE OPEN SESSION 2657 01:33:08,367 --> 01:33:13,873 AGENDA AND SCROLL DOWN TO THE 2658 01:33:13,873 --> 01:33:16,208 CLINICAL DATA ECOSYSTEM FOR 2659 01:33:16,208 --> 01:33:17,776 GENOMICS AND REGISTER YOUR VOTE 2660 01:33:17,776 --> 01:33:21,380 IN THE SYSTEM. 2661 01:33:21,380 --> 01:33:23,249 AND WHILE THEY ARE DOING THAT, 2662 01:33:23,249 --> 01:33:26,118 I'M GOING TO INVITE ROB UP TO 2663 01:33:26,118 --> 01:33:28,687 TALK ABOUT THE NEXT CLEARANCE, 2664 01:33:28,687 --> 01:33:29,588 THE GENOMIC RESEARCH CAPACITY 2665 01:33:29,588 --> 01:33:39,899 BUILDING CENTERS. 2666 01:33:49,041 --> 01:33:50,476 >> ROB: THANK YOU FOR ALLOWING 2667 01:33:50,476 --> 01:33:53,679 ME TO SPEAK TO YOU ABOUT THIS 2668 01:33:53,679 --> 01:33:54,013 NEXT CONCEPT. 2669 01:33:54,013 --> 01:33:59,285 I WANT TO SAY THANK YOU TO 2670 01:33:59,285 --> 01:34:00,786 LAINEY AND WAYNE. 2671 01:34:00,786 --> 01:34:02,621 AND SHOUT OUT TO MY PARENTS. 2672 01:34:02,621 --> 01:34:03,789 WE CHANGED THE TIME. 2673 01:34:03,789 --> 01:34:05,858 I DON'T KNOW IF THEY WILL BE 2674 01:34:05,858 --> 01:34:07,626 WATCHING ME, IF THEY WATCH ME 2675 01:34:07,626 --> 01:34:10,129 IN A FUTURE VIDEOCAST, SHOUT 2676 01:34:10,129 --> 01:34:15,801 OUT TO MY FAMILY IN PERU. 2677 01:34:15,801 --> 01:34:18,671 [KIM JACOBI MYERS] 2678 01:34:18,671 --> 01:34:22,775 >> I HAD A SUDDEN REALIZATION, 2679 01:34:22,775 --> 01:34:24,643 I DIDN'T DO THIS AND COULD HAVE 2680 01:34:24,643 --> 01:34:26,712 CALLED MY MOM AND ME TALKING 2681 01:34:26,712 --> 01:34:28,814 FOR 30 MINUTES. 2682 01:34:28,814 --> 01:34:30,916 >> ROB: WE ARE FEDERAL 2683 01:34:30,916 --> 01:34:32,251 OFFICIALS BUT WE ARE PEOPLE, 2684 01:34:32,251 --> 01:34:34,153 THE PEOPLE BEHIND US THEY CARE 2685 01:34:34,153 --> 01:34:35,487 THAT THE SCIENCE BEHIND THIS 2686 01:34:35,487 --> 01:34:36,322 MOVES FORWARD. 2687 01:34:36,322 --> 01:34:37,556 THAT'S PART AND PARCEL WHAT 2688 01:34:37,556 --> 01:34:38,891 THIS CONCEPT IS ABOUT. 2689 01:34:38,891 --> 01:34:41,160 HOW DO WE ENSURE WE ARE AT THE 2690 01:34:41,160 --> 01:34:43,062 FOREFRONT OF GENOMICS AND 2691 01:34:43,062 --> 01:34:44,496 EVERYONE ACROSS THIS 2692 01:34:44,496 --> 01:34:45,097 INSTITUTION AND INSTITUTION 2693 01:34:45,097 --> 01:34:47,299 TYPES COULD BE PART AND PARCEL 2694 01:34:47,299 --> 01:34:52,237 OF THAT PATH FORWARD. 2695 01:34:52,237 --> 01:34:53,672 IT'S THE GENOMICS RESEARCH 2696 01:34:53,672 --> 01:34:54,940 CAPACITY BUILDING. 2697 01:34:54,940 --> 01:34:57,109 DRIVING OPPORTUNITIES FOR THE 2698 01:34:57,109 --> 01:34:58,043 DEVELOPMENT OF INNOVATIVE 2699 01:34:58,043 --> 01:34:59,478 RESEARCH, EXPANDING TRAINING 2700 01:34:59,478 --> 01:35:00,646 OPPORTUNITIES AND THEN 2701 01:35:00,646 --> 01:35:01,580 STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS AND 2702 01:35:01,580 --> 01:35:02,481 ALLIANCES, NOT ONLY WITH 2703 01:35:02,481 --> 01:35:05,684 INSTITUTIONS BUT ALSO WITH 2704 01:35:05,684 --> 01:35:06,552 COMMUNITY MEMBERS AND GROUPS. 2705 01:35:06,552 --> 01:35:08,420 WHAT'S THE CONCEPT IN GENERAL? 2706 01:35:08,420 --> 01:35:11,256 OUR FWOEL IS TO ENHANCE 2707 01:35:11,256 --> 01:35:11,890 GENOMICS RESEARCH AND RESEARCH 2708 01:35:11,890 --> 01:35:12,825 CAPACITY. 2709 01:35:12,825 --> 01:35:14,660 SO WE ARE TRYING TO ENSURE 2710 01:35:14,660 --> 01:35:17,730 INSTITUTIONS THAT HAVE LESS 2711 01:35:17,730 --> 01:35:20,065 THAN $50 MILLION PER FISCAL 2712 01:35:20,065 --> 01:35:22,801 YEAR, LESS THAN $25 MILLION PER 2713 01:35:22,801 --> 01:35:24,903 YEAR IN TOTAL COST RO1 FUNDING 2714 01:35:24,903 --> 01:35:26,905 HAVE OPPORTUNITIES TO GET LARGE 2715 01:35:26,905 --> 01:35:28,273 SCALE GENOMICS RESEARCH FUNDING 2716 01:35:28,273 --> 01:35:30,075 TO EXPAND THE RESEARCH THEY ARE 2717 01:35:30,075 --> 01:35:31,677 DOING AND ALSO TRAIN NEXT 2718 01:35:31,677 --> 01:35:35,014 GENERATION OF RESEARCHERS. 2719 01:35:35,014 --> 01:35:37,316 THE MECHANISMS IN RM1, 2720 01:35:37,316 --> 01:35:38,751 COLLABORATIVE PROGRAM GRANT FOR 2721 01:35:38,751 --> 01:35:39,451 MULTI-DISCIPLINARY TEAMS WITH 2722 01:35:39,451 --> 01:35:41,787 THE IDEA THERE WILL BE ONE 2723 01:35:41,787 --> 01:35:42,955 SCIENTIFIC IDEA ACROSS THE 2724 01:35:42,955 --> 01:35:44,390 ENTIRE CENTER WITH DIFFERENT 2725 01:35:44,390 --> 01:35:45,557 INVESTIGATORS THAT ARE WORKING 2726 01:35:45,557 --> 01:35:49,995 TOGETHER TO MOVE THINGS FORWARD. 2727 01:35:49,995 --> 01:35:51,096 THESE CENTERS WILL HAVE FOUR 2728 01:35:51,096 --> 01:35:52,965 SPECIFIC COMPONENTS. 2729 01:35:52,965 --> 01:35:56,235 THE BASE OF IT WILL BE THE 2730 01:35:56,235 --> 01:35:58,103 PRIMARY RESEARCH PROJECT WHICH 2731 01:35:58,103 --> 01:35:59,772 COULD BE 2-3 PROJECTS PER TEAM 2732 01:35:59,772 --> 01:36:02,174 A DIRECTION THE ONE OVERARCHING 2733 01:36:02,174 --> 01:36:02,441 QUESTION. 2734 01:36:02,441 --> 01:36:03,709 AND WE ARE BEING FAIRLY OPEN 2735 01:36:03,709 --> 01:36:05,344 ABOUT WHAT THAT QUESTION COULD 2736 01:36:05,344 --> 01:36:06,512 BE AN THE APPROACHES THEY WOULD 2737 01:36:06,512 --> 01:36:08,380 LIKE TO TAKE WITH IT. 2738 01:36:08,380 --> 01:36:10,716 ADDITIONALLY, WE WANT TO ENSURE 2739 01:36:10,716 --> 01:36:11,650 THERE'S A COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT 2740 01:36:11,650 --> 01:36:11,884 CORE. 2741 01:36:11,884 --> 01:36:13,285 AT THE HEART OF IT WE WANT TO 2742 01:36:13,285 --> 01:36:15,154 MAKE SURE THAT THE WORK BEING 2743 01:36:15,154 --> 01:36:17,022 DONE COMES BACK AND TOUCHES THE 2744 01:36:17,022 --> 01:36:17,289 COMMUNITY. 2745 01:36:17,289 --> 01:36:18,457 AND ALSO THAT THE COMMUNITY IS 2746 01:36:18,457 --> 01:36:19,758 AWARE OF WHAT'S HAPPENING IN 2747 01:36:19,758 --> 01:36:23,162 THAT IVORY TOWER. 2748 01:36:23,162 --> 01:36:26,098 LIKEWISE, THERE NEEDS TO BE A 2749 01:36:26,098 --> 01:36:27,699 TRAINING CORE BECAUSE THIS IS A 2750 01:36:27,699 --> 01:36:29,168 PATHWAY TO SEE OPPORTUNITIES IN 2751 01:36:29,168 --> 01:36:30,736 SCIENCE AND RESEARCH. 2752 01:36:30,736 --> 01:36:32,337 LASTLY, SINCE IT'S A FAIRLY 2753 01:36:32,337 --> 01:36:33,739 LARGE CENTER PROGRAM THERE 2754 01:36:33,739 --> 01:36:34,540 SHOULD BE COLLABORATION CORE 2755 01:36:34,540 --> 01:36:39,078 WITHIN THAT CENTER. 2756 01:36:39,078 --> 01:36:40,212 SO, THE POTENTIAL CENTER 2757 01:36:40,212 --> 01:36:41,713 FORMATION COULD GO A NUMBER OF 2758 01:36:41,713 --> 01:36:42,147 WAYS. 2759 01:36:42,147 --> 01:36:43,449 THIS IS ONE VERSION OF WHAT A 2760 01:36:43,449 --> 01:36:45,484 CENTER COULD LOOK LIKE. 2761 01:36:45,484 --> 01:36:47,352 YOU COULD BE A SOUTHEASTERN 2762 01:36:47,352 --> 01:36:49,455 GENOMICS CAPACITY CENTER WHERE 2763 01:36:49,455 --> 01:36:50,422 THERE'S THREE DISTINCT 2764 01:36:50,422 --> 01:36:52,057 INSTITUTIONS WORKING TOGETHER 2765 01:36:52,057 --> 01:36:53,892 WITH PI'S AT THREE DISTINCT 2766 01:36:53,892 --> 01:36:54,126 PLACES. 2767 01:36:54,126 --> 01:36:57,129 BUT STILL THAT ONE OVERARCHING 2768 01:36:57,129 --> 01:36:59,198 TYING TOGETHER SCIENTIFIC GOAL. 2769 01:36:59,198 --> 01:37:01,900 OR YOU COULD HAVE CENTER WHERE 2770 01:37:01,900 --> 01:37:03,035 IT'S TWO INSTITUTIONS BUT TWO 2771 01:37:03,035 --> 01:37:05,070 OF THE INVESTIGATORS ARE FROM 2772 01:37:05,070 --> 01:37:06,805 THE SAME INSTITUTION. 2773 01:37:06,805 --> 01:37:09,408 THE IDEA PRIMARILY HERE IS THAT 2774 01:37:09,408 --> 01:37:10,976 THE INSTITUTION TYPES ARE 2775 01:37:10,976 --> 01:37:12,177 INSTITUTIONS THAT HAVE 2776 01:37:12,177 --> 01:37:13,112 HISTORICALLY NOT BEEN HEAVILY 2777 01:37:13,112 --> 01:37:14,713 FUNDED BY NIH BUT THIS IS A 2778 01:37:14,713 --> 01:37:17,783 CHANCE FOR THEM TO BE PART OF 2779 01:37:17,783 --> 01:37:18,484 THE GENOMICS COMMUNITY. 2780 01:37:18,484 --> 01:37:19,184 ESSENTIALLY THE CAPACITY 2781 01:37:19,184 --> 01:37:21,854 CENTERS WILL SERVE AS A NEXUS 2782 01:37:21,854 --> 01:37:24,556 POINT TO ENSURE THAT RESEARCH 2783 01:37:24,556 --> 01:37:26,458 THAT'S HAPPENING ACROSS NHGRI 2784 01:37:26,458 --> 01:37:28,627 CAN BE DISSEMINATED TO MORE AND 2785 01:37:28,627 --> 01:37:29,728 MORE INSTITUTIONS AND ALSO 2786 01:37:29,728 --> 01:37:34,166 PROVIDE TRAINING OPPORTUNITIES. 2787 01:37:34,166 --> 01:37:36,535 NHGRI INTENDS TO COMMIT UP TO 2788 01:37:36,535 --> 01:37:41,373 $45 MILLION IN TOTAL COSTS FROM 2789 01:37:41,373 --> 01:37:44,209 2026-2031 AND FUND UP TO THREE 2790 01:37:44,209 --> 01:37:45,144 CAPACITY BUILDING CENTERS, 2791 01:37:45,144 --> 01:37:47,513 DEPENDING ON THE AVAILABILITY 2792 01:37:47,513 --> 01:37:49,448 OF FUNDS. 2793 01:37:49,448 --> 01:37:51,316 I GRANT, THIS IS MUCH VAGUER 2794 01:37:51,316 --> 01:37:52,284 THAN THE PREVIOUS PROPOSAL 2795 01:37:52,284 --> 01:37:53,385 BECAUSE WE ARE STILL WORKING 2796 01:37:53,385 --> 01:37:54,653 THROUGH ALL THE DETAILS. 2797 01:37:54,653 --> 01:37:56,321 SO WE WOULD REALLY LIKE TO HEAR 2798 01:37:56,321 --> 01:37:57,489 YOUR COMMENTS OR THOUGHTS YOU 2799 01:37:57,489 --> 01:37:59,558 MIGHT HAVE ABOUT HOW WE CAN 2800 01:37:59,558 --> 01:38:00,159 ENSURE THIS PROGRAM MEETS ITS 2801 01:38:00,159 --> 01:38:01,460 GOAL. 2802 01:38:01,460 --> 01:38:03,529 THAT GOAL IS ENSURING THAT 2803 01:38:03,529 --> 01:38:04,763 REGARDLESS OF THE ZIP CODE, 2804 01:38:04,763 --> 01:38:07,099 INDIVIDUALS CAN BE PART OF THE 2805 01:38:07,099 --> 01:38:10,802 REVOLUTION OF GENOMICS AND 2806 01:38:10,802 --> 01:38:11,436 ENSURING INCREASED LIVELIHOODS. 2807 01:38:11,436 --> 01:38:13,672 SO WITH THAT, I'M GOING TO PASS 2808 01:38:13,672 --> 01:38:16,141 THE MIC TO OUR AMAZING JEN 2809 01:38:16,141 --> 01:38:18,911 TROYER WHO IS GOING TO ASK YOU 2810 01:38:18,911 --> 01:38:21,680 ALL FOR COMMENTS AND QUESTIONS. 2811 01:38:21,680 --> 01:38:23,081 >> JEN: OKAY, WOULD SOMEBODY 2812 01:38:23,081 --> 01:38:28,086 LIKE TO START US OFF? 2813 01:38:28,086 --> 01:38:29,721 -- CASEY, WOULD YOU LIKE TO 2814 01:38:29,721 --> 01:38:30,789 START US OFF? 2815 01:38:30,789 --> 01:38:34,059 >> CASEY: YES. 2816 01:38:34,059 --> 01:38:37,996 I JUST HAD TO COME OFF MUTE. 2817 01:38:37,996 --> 01:38:40,899 I'M REALLY EXCITED TO SEE THIS 2818 01:38:40,899 --> 01:38:43,635 CONCEPT BEING PUT FORWARD. 2819 01:38:43,635 --> 01:38:48,740 I HAD A COUPLE OF THOUGHTS. 2820 01:38:48,740 --> 01:38:50,175 AND I LIKE THE FLEXIBILITY OF 2821 01:38:50,175 --> 01:38:53,912 IT, JUST TO START OUT WITH. 2822 01:38:53,912 --> 01:38:58,150 I LIKE THE FLEXIBILITY OF 2823 01:38:58,150 --> 01:38:58,584 HAVING ONE TO THREE 2824 01:38:58,584 --> 01:39:00,018 INSTITUTIONS. 2825 01:39:00,018 --> 01:39:01,887 IT COULD BE ONE INSTITUTION 2826 01:39:01,887 --> 01:39:03,121 VERSUS THREE INSTITUTIONS THAT 2827 01:39:03,121 --> 01:39:05,557 ARE PART OF A REGION, FOR EXER 2828 01:39:05,557 --> 01:39:05,724 EX. 2829 01:39:05,724 --> 01:39:06,792 EXAMPLE. 2830 01:39:06,792 --> 01:39:12,731 AND YOU ARE KIND OF BUILDING 2831 01:39:12,731 --> 01:39:14,633 SUB COMMUTITY WITHIN THE 2832 01:39:14,633 --> 01:39:15,100 GENOMICS ENVIRONMENT. 2833 01:39:15,100 --> 01:39:18,203 I DID HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT HOW 2834 01:39:18,203 --> 01:39:19,705 THE LOW-RESOURCE DEFINITION 2835 01:39:19,705 --> 01:39:26,345 WAS, HOW THAT WAS DEFINED? 2836 01:39:26,345 --> 01:39:28,480 LIKE IS THERE A FLOOR FOR HOW 2837 01:39:28,480 --> 01:39:31,283 IT IS BEING DEFINED FOR PEOPLE 2838 01:39:31,283 --> 01:39:32,985 TO BEEL NL? 2839 01:39:32,985 --> 01:39:43,262 -- BE ELIGIBLE? 2840 01:39:46,665 --> 01:39:53,071 IS THERE A KIND OF CLEAR LACK 2841 01:39:53,071 --> 01:39:53,605 OF MEMBERSHIP WITHIN THE 2842 01:39:53,605 --> 01:39:55,741 GENOMICS QUESTION? 2843 01:39:55,741 --> 01:39:58,710 >> ROB: THAT'S A GREAT QUESTION. 2844 01:39:58,710 --> 01:40:00,545 WE ARE WORKING ABOUT WHO IS 2845 01:40:00,545 --> 01:40:03,048 TAKING PART IN LARGE RESEARCH 2846 01:40:03,048 --> 01:40:06,118 FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES BOTH 2847 01:40:06,118 --> 01:40:08,420 NHGRI AND NHGMS, SO THAT'S THE 2848 01:40:08,420 --> 01:40:10,022 RATIONALE OF HAVING A $50 2849 01:40:10,022 --> 01:40:11,923 MILLION CAP IN TOTAL COSTS FROM 2850 01:40:11,923 --> 01:40:16,428 NIH OVER THREE YEARS AND $25 2851 01:40:16,428 --> 01:40:18,730 MILLION IN TOTAL COSTS R01 OVER 2852 01:40:18,730 --> 01:40:22,567 THE THREE FISCAL YEARS. 2853 01:40:22,567 --> 01:40:24,236 WE WANT TO ENSURE THE FUNDSES 2854 01:40:24,236 --> 01:40:25,837 ARE GOING TO NOT THE SAME 2855 01:40:25,837 --> 01:40:27,472 INSTITUTIONS OVER AND OVER. 2856 01:40:27,472 --> 01:40:30,142 AND THAT ALL THE PARTICIPATING 2857 01:40:30,142 --> 01:40:34,112 COMPONENTS ARE INSTITUTIONS OF 2858 01:40:34,112 --> 01:40:34,379 THAT TYPE. 2859 01:40:34,379 --> 01:40:38,116 SO IN PREVIOUS PROGRAMMING 2860 01:40:38,116 --> 01:40:39,551 SOMETIMES THERE'S BEEN THIS 2861 01:40:39,551 --> 01:40:40,185 ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENT BUT 2862 01:40:40,185 --> 01:40:42,287 THEN THERE WOULD BE 2863 01:40:42,287 --> 01:40:43,488 SUBCONTRACTS OF VERY LARGE 2864 01:40:43,488 --> 01:40:45,557 INSTITUTIONS. 2865 01:40:45,557 --> 01:40:46,525 WHICH, SORT OF DEFEATS SOME OF 2866 01:40:46,525 --> 01:40:48,660 THE PURPOSE OF TRYING TO ENSURE 2867 01:40:48,660 --> 01:40:49,428 THAT INVESTMENTS HAPPEN AT 2868 01:40:49,428 --> 01:40:59,805 SMALLER INSTITUTIONS. 2869 01:41:00,839 --> 01:41:02,674 >> CASEY: I SEE. 2870 01:41:02,674 --> 01:41:04,876 THANK YOU FOR CLARIFYING THAT. 2871 01:41:04,876 --> 01:41:05,811 FOR THE CAPACITY-BUILDING 2872 01:41:05,811 --> 01:41:07,145 ASPECT, THE FUNDS ARE WHAT'S 2873 01:41:07,145 --> 01:41:09,247 GOING TO FUEL THE CAPACITY 2874 01:41:09,247 --> 01:41:11,316 BUILDING AND THEN THERE'S 2875 01:41:11,316 --> 01:41:13,852 MECHANISMS WITHIN THE STRUCTURE 2876 01:41:13,852 --> 01:41:17,989 FOR ENABLING COMMUNITY 2877 01:41:17,989 --> 01:41:19,658 ENGAGEMENT, AS WELL AS 2878 01:41:19,658 --> 01:41:20,258 BROADENING CHANGE THROUGHOUT 2879 01:41:20,258 --> 01:41:21,793 THE INSTITUTION. 2880 01:41:21,793 --> 01:41:22,928 I'M ASSUMING ALSO THAT TRAINING 2881 01:41:22,928 --> 01:41:24,296 WOULD BE ALIGNED WITH THE 2882 01:41:24,296 --> 01:41:25,964 RESEARCH PROJECTS THAT ARE 2883 01:41:25,964 --> 01:41:28,266 BEING SUPPORTED BY IT AS WELL. 2884 01:41:28,266 --> 01:41:30,035 IT SEEMS LIKE THE STRUCTURE 2885 01:41:30,035 --> 01:41:31,837 MAKES SENSE. 2886 01:41:31,837 --> 01:41:33,705 I DID SEE THERE WAS SOME 2887 01:41:33,705 --> 01:41:35,273 EXISTING PROGRAMS ALSO THAT 2888 01:41:35,273 --> 01:41:36,641 WERE LISTED. 2889 01:41:36,641 --> 01:41:38,043 AND I WASN'T SURE IF THERE'S A 2890 01:41:38,043 --> 01:41:40,679 VISION FOR HOW IT WOULD ALIGN 2891 01:41:40,679 --> 01:41:51,123 WITH AN EXISTING PROGRAMS. 2892 01:41:53,325 --> 01:41:59,464 I WASN'T IS THERE HOW IT WOULD 2893 01:41:59,464 --> 01:42:00,132 ALIGN. 2894 01:42:00,132 --> 01:42:02,734 >> ROB: THE PLACE OF GREATER 2895 01:42:02,734 --> 01:42:03,835 INCORPORATION OF THE TWO 2896 01:42:03,835 --> 01:42:05,971 DIFFERENT GROUPS IS THROUGH 2897 01:42:05,971 --> 01:42:06,338 ANNUAL MEETINGS. 2898 01:42:06,338 --> 01:42:07,572 AND ALSO ENSURING THAT THERE'S 2899 01:42:07,572 --> 01:42:09,674 JUST GREATER DIALOGUE. 2900 01:42:09,674 --> 01:42:13,678 SO EVEN IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF 2901 01:42:13,678 --> 01:42:15,080 THIS NOTICE OF FUNDING 2902 01:42:15,080 --> 01:42:15,781 OPPORTUNITY, GREATER 2903 01:42:15,781 --> 01:42:16,748 INTERACTION WITH OTHER 2904 01:42:16,748 --> 01:42:18,150 DIVISIONS TO ENSURE AS WE 2905 01:42:18,150 --> 01:42:19,384 DEVELOP THIS FUNDING 2906 01:42:19,384 --> 01:42:20,719 OPPORTUNITY THAT THERE'S WIDE 2907 01:42:20,719 --> 01:42:22,154 UNDERSTANDING OF WHAT'S GOING 2908 01:42:22,154 --> 01:42:24,055 ON THAT DISSEMINATES TO ALREADY 2909 01:42:24,055 --> 01:42:24,723 FUNDED RESEARCH INVESTIGATORS 2910 01:42:24,723 --> 01:42:26,458 IN THOSE DIFFERENT DIVISIONS. 2911 01:42:26,458 --> 01:42:28,693 SO WE WANT TO ENSURE THIS 2912 01:42:28,693 --> 01:42:29,828 DOESN'T STANDOFF ON ITS OWN, OH 2913 01:42:29,828 --> 01:42:33,298 YEAH THIS IS THE CAPACITY 2914 01:42:33,298 --> 01:42:34,332 BUILDING WITHOUT INTERSECTIONS 2915 01:42:34,332 --> 01:42:36,802 FROM ELSI CENTERS OR FROM THE 2916 01:42:36,802 --> 01:42:43,408 CEGS BUT SHOULD BE PART AND 2917 01:42:43,408 --> 01:42:45,510 PARCEL 1HG OR 1IH APPROACH. 2918 01:42:45,510 --> 01:42:47,813 >> CASEY: THANK YOU, THAT'S THE 2919 01:42:47,813 --> 01:42:49,448 VIEW TO HAVE THIS PLAN FOR 2920 01:42:49,448 --> 01:42:51,883 DIFFERENT GROUPS TO GET 2921 01:42:51,883 --> 01:42:52,717 TOGETHER AND SHARE KNOWLEDGE, 2922 01:42:52,717 --> 01:42:54,219 KNOWLEDGE TRANSFER. 2923 01:42:54,219 --> 01:42:56,087 THANK YOU. 2924 01:42:56,087 --> 01:43:04,996 I THINK I WILL PASS IT TO NANCY. 2925 01:43:04,996 --> 01:43:07,332 >> NANCY: I JUST WANTED TO MAKE 2926 01:43:07,332 --> 01:43:08,934 SURE THAT YOU MIGHT LINK IN 2927 01:43:08,934 --> 01:43:14,172 WITH SOME OF THE RECENT AI 2928 01:43:14,172 --> 01:43:15,574 INITIATIVES THAT NHGRI, IN 2929 01:43:15,574 --> 01:43:20,979 PARTICULAR, HAS PUT FORWARD. 2930 01:43:20,979 --> 01:43:25,450 I THINK ONE OF THE THINGS THAT 2931 01:43:25,450 --> 01:43:28,553 NEEDS TO HAPPEN AS GENETICS 2932 01:43:28,553 --> 01:43:32,457 GETS BETTER DISTRIBUTED IS A 2933 01:43:32,457 --> 01:43:34,159 REMINDER THAT 50% OF PRACTICING 2934 01:43:34,159 --> 01:43:36,127 PHYSICIANS IN THE UNITED STATES 2935 01:43:36,127 --> 01:43:38,997 OF AMERICA HAVE NEVER HAD A 2936 01:43:38,997 --> 01:43:42,701 COURSE IN GENETICS, NOT AS 2937 01:43:42,701 --> 01:43:45,570 MEDICAL STUDENTS, NOT EVER. 2938 01:43:45,570 --> 01:43:48,573 SO THE UNDERSTANDING OF HOW TO 2939 01:43:48,573 --> 01:43:53,778 ORDER GENETIC TESTS, FOR 2940 01:43:53,778 --> 01:43:54,179 EXAMPLE, IS POOR. 2941 01:43:54,179 --> 01:43:58,049 AND WHEN PHYSICIANS BECOME 2942 01:43:58,049 --> 01:43:59,217 ENCOURAGED TO START DOING THESE 2943 01:43:59,217 --> 01:44:03,255 THINGS, THEY MAKE A LOT OF 2944 01:44:03,255 --> 01:44:03,522 MISTAKES. 2945 01:44:03,522 --> 01:44:05,957 AND WE HAD EMPLOYED A GENETIC 2946 01:44:05,957 --> 01:44:07,759 COUNSELOR FOR EXAMPLE, TO LOOK 2947 01:44:07,759 --> 01:44:09,628 OVERALL OF THE MEDICAL TESTS 2948 01:44:09,628 --> 01:44:11,062 ORDERED AT BUMC. 2949 01:44:11,062 --> 01:44:14,966 AND IT SAVED US JUST TONS OF 2950 01:44:14,966 --> 01:44:16,668 MONEY BECAUSE THE PHYSICIANS 2951 01:44:16,668 --> 01:44:17,836 WERE ORDERING THE WRONG TESTS, 2952 01:44:17,836 --> 01:44:19,504 A LOT OF THE TIME. 2953 01:44:19,504 --> 01:44:21,506 AND ORDERING WHAT WERE IN 2954 01:44:21,506 --> 01:44:23,141 EFFECT DUPLICATE TESTS THAT 2955 01:44:23,141 --> 01:44:24,576 THEY DIDN'T REALIZE WERE 2956 01:44:24,576 --> 01:44:25,644 DUPLICATE TESTS AND ALL KINDS 2957 01:44:25,644 --> 01:44:26,444 OF THINGS LIKE THAT. 2958 01:44:26,444 --> 01:44:29,214 I KNOW SOME OF THE AI EFFORTS 2959 01:44:29,214 --> 01:44:33,818 UNDER WAY ARE ACTUALLY DESIGNED 2960 01:44:33,818 --> 01:44:37,822 TO HELP DO THINGS LIKE THAT, 2961 01:44:37,822 --> 01:44:39,190 THAT COULD BE REALLY GREAT FOR 2962 01:44:39,190 --> 01:44:40,926 THESE GROUPS TO BE ABLE TO TAP 2963 01:44:40,926 --> 01:44:46,031 INTO FROM THE BEGINNING. 2964 01:44:46,031 --> 01:44:51,036 SO IT WAS A SPECIFIC SUGGESTION 2965 01:44:51,036 --> 01:44:53,805 THAT THE AMONG THE WAYS YOU 2966 01:44:53,805 --> 01:44:56,341 LOOK TO PARTNER WITH EXISTING 2967 01:44:56,341 --> 01:44:59,344 FUNDING IS ALSO IN THE AI 2968 01:44:59,344 --> 01:45:03,181 INITIATIVE. 2969 01:45:03,181 --> 01:45:05,951 BECAUSE I THINK THEY ARE SOME 2970 01:45:05,951 --> 01:45:07,018 FOSI? 2971 01:45:07,018 --> 01:45:09,120 (?) THINGS THAT WOULD BE AT 2972 01:45:09,120 --> 01:45:14,225 INSTITUTIONAL LEVELS THAT COULD 2973 01:45:14,225 --> 01:45:16,761 REALLY HELP IN THIS PARTICULAR 2974 01:45:16,761 --> 01:45:18,196 SET OF INSTITUTIONS THAT ARE 2975 01:45:18,196 --> 01:45:23,535 GOING TO BE A LOT MORE 2976 01:45:23,535 --> 01:45:25,604 COMMUNITY-BASED, IN SOME SENSE, 2977 01:45:25,604 --> 01:45:28,073 RATHER THAN UNIVERSITY RESEARCH 2978 01:45:28,073 --> 01:45:35,313 EXCLUSIVE KINDS OF INSTITUTIONS. 2979 01:45:35,313 --> 01:45:36,548 THAT MAY BENEFIT ESPECIALLY 2980 01:45:36,548 --> 01:45:38,483 FROM THE AI MATERIALS BEING 2981 01:45:38,483 --> 01:45:39,551 DEVELOPED FOR HEALTHCARE 2982 01:45:39,551 --> 01:45:40,485 CENTERS. 2983 01:45:40,485 --> 01:45:42,520 >> ROB: I THINK THAT'S AN 2984 01:45:42,520 --> 01:45:43,722 EXCELLENT POINT, NANCY. 2985 01:45:43,722 --> 01:45:46,791 ALSO I LIKE THE IDEA OF 2986 01:45:46,791 --> 01:45:48,393 FOCUSING ON PROVIDERS WHO MIGHT 2987 01:45:48,393 --> 01:45:49,828 NOT HAVE THAT GENOMIC TRAINING. 2988 01:45:49,828 --> 01:45:51,229 AND IF THAT COULD BE 2989 01:45:51,229 --> 01:45:52,063 POTENTIALLY PART OF THE 2990 01:45:52,063 --> 01:45:54,466 COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT CORE. 2991 01:45:54,466 --> 01:45:56,368 SOMETIMES WE DON'T ALWAYS VIEW 2992 01:45:56,368 --> 01:45:58,670 THE PHYSICIAN CLASS -- 2993 01:45:58,670 --> 01:46:00,305 >> NANCY: EXACTLY. 2994 01:46:00,305 --> 01:46:03,008 THE PHYSICIANS ARE A PART OF 2995 01:46:03,008 --> 01:46:03,375 THAT COMMUNITY. 2996 01:46:03,375 --> 01:46:05,243 THAT YOU WANT TO HEAR FROM. 2997 01:46:05,243 --> 01:46:07,312 AND GET INPUT FROM, BUT ALSO 2998 01:46:07,312 --> 01:46:10,448 THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO BE ABLE 2999 01:46:10,448 --> 01:46:13,852 TO HELP WITH AUTOMATED TOOLS. 3000 01:46:13,852 --> 01:46:20,925 THANK YOU. 3001 01:46:20,925 --> 01:46:22,460 >> CASEY: I THINK TIM WAS THE 3002 01:46:22,460 --> 01:46:24,796 OTHER DISCUSSANT. 3003 01:46:24,796 --> 01:46:27,265 >> TIM: THIS IS WONDERFUL TO 3004 01:46:27,265 --> 01:46:27,632 SEE. 3005 01:46:27,632 --> 01:46:30,235 I ESPECIALLY LIKED SOME OF YOUR 3006 01:46:30,235 --> 01:46:31,970 COMMENTS ABOUT CONNECTING THIS 3007 01:46:31,970 --> 01:46:33,238 WITH EXISTING PROGRAMS. 3008 01:46:33,238 --> 01:46:36,107 I THINK IT WOULD BE VERY 3009 01:46:36,107 --> 01:46:37,709 NATURAL FOR THE CEGS MEETING TO 3010 01:46:37,709 --> 01:46:39,811 INCLUDE THESE AWARDS AS WELL 3011 01:46:39,811 --> 01:46:40,845 FOR EXAMPLE, OR SOMETHING ALONG 3012 01:46:40,845 --> 01:46:42,180 THOSE LINES. 3013 01:46:42,180 --> 01:46:44,749 THAT MAKES IT A PART OF THE 3014 01:46:44,749 --> 01:46:46,418 BROADER ECOSYSTEM AND I COULD 3015 01:46:46,418 --> 01:46:47,786 ENCOURAGE YOU TO THINK STRONGLY 3016 01:46:47,786 --> 01:46:53,491 ABOUT DOING THAT AND MAKING 3017 01:46:53,491 --> 01:46:55,427 THAT QUITE SEAMLESS AND QUITE 3018 01:46:55,427 --> 01:46:57,162 TRANSPARENT. 3019 01:46:57,162 --> 01:47:01,166 ALSO IN THE WRITTEN DOCUMENT 3020 01:47:01,166 --> 01:47:03,134 THERE'S SOME COMMENTS AROUND 3021 01:47:03,134 --> 01:47:04,269 BUILDING, MAKING THIS 3022 01:47:04,269 --> 01:47:05,403 RECRUITIVE AND BRING IN NEW 3023 01:47:05,403 --> 01:47:10,775 FACULTY HIRES. 3024 01:47:10,775 --> 01:47:12,010 ONE CONSIDERATION IS A 3025 01:47:12,010 --> 01:47:13,611 FIVE-YEAR TIMEFRAME ENOUGH FOR 3026 01:47:13,611 --> 01:47:15,213 THAT TYPE OF ACTIVITY GIVEN HOW 3027 01:47:15,213 --> 01:47:18,717 LONG IT COULD OFTEN TAKE TO 3028 01:47:18,717 --> 01:47:20,218 IDENTIFY ADVERTISE, FIND AND 3029 01:47:20,218 --> 01:47:22,287 SUPPORT NEW FACULTY MEMBERS. 3030 01:47:22,287 --> 01:47:24,122 YOU KNOW, I DON'T KNOW IF 3031 01:47:24,122 --> 01:47:25,356 THERE'S EVER POTENTIAL TO GO 3032 01:47:25,356 --> 01:47:27,292 PAST OR LONGER THAN FIVE YEARS 3033 01:47:27,292 --> 01:47:28,626 BUT YOU MIGHT THINK ARE THERE 3034 01:47:28,626 --> 01:47:33,231 WAYS TO SET THIS UP TO MAKE 3035 01:47:33,231 --> 01:47:35,567 THAT FACULTY OR RECRUITED AS 3036 01:47:35,567 --> 01:47:38,169 PART OF THIS, CAN BE MULTIPLE 3037 01:47:38,169 --> 01:47:42,073 YEARS OF SUPPORT OUT OF IT. 3038 01:47:42,073 --> 01:47:43,274 >> ROB: THAT'S AN EXCELLENT 3039 01:47:43,274 --> 01:47:43,708 POINT, TIM. 3040 01:47:43,708 --> 01:47:45,610 I WISH I HAD A MAGIC WAND FOR 3041 01:47:45,610 --> 01:47:46,711 FUNDING AND WE COULD DO IT FOR 3042 01:47:46,711 --> 01:47:49,114 TEN YEARS. 3043 01:47:49,114 --> 01:47:52,383 I KNOW IN THE RM1, IT'S OFTEN 3044 01:47:52,383 --> 01:47:54,686 THINKING THE 5-10 YEAR WINDOW, 3045 01:47:54,686 --> 01:47:55,653 PENDING THE SUCCESS HOW THIS 3046 01:47:55,653 --> 01:47:57,355 GOES THERE WOULD BE POSSIBILITY. 3047 01:47:57,355 --> 01:47:59,457 >> TIM: I THINK WHERE I'M GOING 3048 01:47:59,457 --> 01:48:01,059 IS ENCOURAGING WHAT DOES A 3049 01:48:01,059 --> 01:48:02,227 RENEWAL LOOK LIKE FOR THESE FOR 3050 01:48:02,227 --> 01:48:03,862 A SECOND SET OF FIVE YEARS, 3051 01:48:03,862 --> 01:48:05,530 WHAT WOULD SUCCESS LOOK LIKE 3052 01:48:05,530 --> 01:48:06,164 AND WHAT WOULD RENEWAL LOOK 3053 01:48:06,164 --> 01:48:07,198 LIKE? 3054 01:48:07,198 --> 01:48:08,900 I THINK IT'S THOSE SORT OF 3055 01:48:08,900 --> 01:48:10,268 RENEWED PROJECTS I THINK YOU 3056 01:48:10,268 --> 01:48:16,775 COULD HAVE OUT SIZED IMPACT. 3057 01:48:16,775 --> 01:48:19,344 >> JEN: BRUCE, I THINK YOU HAD 3058 01:48:19,344 --> 01:48:19,677 YOUR HAND UP? 3059 01:48:19,677 --> 01:48:20,812 >> BRUCE: YEAH, THANKS. 3060 01:48:20,812 --> 01:48:22,781 TWO THINGS. 3061 01:48:22,781 --> 01:48:24,516 ONE IS, IT STRIKES ME THAT 3062 01:48:24,516 --> 01:48:26,718 THERE COULD BE OPPORTUNITIES 3063 01:48:26,718 --> 01:48:28,086 HERE FOR PARTNERSHIPS WITH THE 3064 01:48:28,086 --> 01:48:29,954 ALL OF US RESEARCH PROGRAM. 3065 01:48:29,954 --> 01:48:31,422 WHICH I KNOW HAS STRONG 3066 01:48:31,422 --> 01:48:35,426 INTEREST IN SEEING USE OF THE 3067 01:48:35,426 --> 01:48:37,061 DATASETS BY INVESTIGATORS AS 3068 01:48:37,061 --> 01:48:38,530 WIDELY DISTRIBUTED AS POSSIBLE. 3069 01:48:38,530 --> 01:48:40,431 THE ADVANTAGE THERE IS THE COST 3070 01:48:40,431 --> 01:48:41,866 OF SEQUENCING IS ZERO FOR 3071 01:48:41,866 --> 01:48:43,401 PEOPLE THAT MIGHT WANT TO 3072 01:48:43,401 --> 01:48:45,170 ANALYZE THE DATA. 3073 01:48:45,170 --> 01:48:48,139 AND ONE COULD IMAGINE THAT 3074 01:48:48,139 --> 01:48:49,808 WOULD BE, ONE OF UNDOUBTEDLY 3075 01:48:49,808 --> 01:48:51,442 MANY RESOURCES THAT COULD BE 3076 01:48:51,442 --> 01:48:53,745 USED TO KIND OF HELP JUMP START 3077 01:48:53,745 --> 01:48:56,147 SOME OF THESE RESEARCH EFFORTS. 3078 01:48:56,147 --> 01:48:57,749 THE OTHER THING UNRELATED TO 3079 01:48:57,749 --> 01:49:00,185 THIS IS, I GUESS I COULD 3080 01:49:00,185 --> 01:49:03,655 IMAGINE THAT PART OF THIS COULD 3081 01:49:03,655 --> 01:49:05,256 INCLUDE WAYS OF TRAINING 3082 01:49:05,256 --> 01:49:06,891 INVESTIGATORS TO ACQUIRE SKILLS 3083 01:49:06,891 --> 01:49:08,993 THAT THEY MIGHT NOT CURRENTLY 3084 01:49:08,993 --> 01:49:12,130 HAVE BUT COULD ACQUIRE AND THEN 3085 01:49:12,130 --> 01:49:14,365 BECOME PLAYERS. 3086 01:49:14,365 --> 01:49:19,103 IMAGINE DEVELOPING ALMOST LIKE 3087 01:49:19,103 --> 01:49:20,238 CERTIFICATES OF COMPETENCY 3088 01:49:20,238 --> 01:49:22,373 PROGRAMS IN PARTICULAR AREAS OF 3089 01:49:22,373 --> 01:49:24,709 DATA ANALYSIS, FOR EXAMPLE, 3090 01:49:24,709 --> 01:49:26,578 THAT WOULD HELP PEOPLE REACH A 3091 01:49:26,578 --> 01:49:28,546 POINT WHERE THEY ACTUALLY COULD 3092 01:49:28,546 --> 01:49:29,881 BECOME INDEPENDENT BUT TO HELP 3093 01:49:29,881 --> 01:49:31,416 MENTOR THEM ALONG THE WAY TO 3094 01:49:31,416 --> 01:49:37,255 ACTUALLY ACHIEVE THAT. 3095 01:49:37,255 --> 01:49:45,496 >> ROB: I CONCUR. 3096 01:49:45,496 --> 01:49:47,799 >> CASEY: I HAD ANOTHER COMMENT 3097 01:49:47,799 --> 01:49:49,701 WHAT NANCY AND BRUCE BROUGHT 3098 01:49:49,701 --> 01:49:51,336 UP, LEVERAGING EXISTING 3099 01:49:51,336 --> 01:49:51,703 INFRASTRUCTURE. 3100 01:49:51,703 --> 01:49:55,006 I THINK ANOTHER PROGRAM TO 3101 01:49:55,006 --> 01:49:57,242 CONSIDER IS THE ABLE HEAD? 3102 01:49:57,242 --> 01:49:59,377 (?) PROGRAM, THEY HAVE SOME 3103 01:49:59,377 --> 01:50:03,448 INTERESTING MODELS TO 3104 01:50:03,448 --> 01:50:05,250 FACILITATE ONBOARDING WITH NEW 3105 01:50:05,250 --> 01:50:12,790 INFRASTRUCTURE AND THINGS LIKE 3106 01:50:12,790 --> 01:50:14,192 THAT, CONCIATORS PROVIDING 3107 01:50:14,192 --> 01:50:17,862 GUIDANCE AND GETTING ONBOARDED 3108 01:50:17,862 --> 01:50:19,063 IN EXISTING INFRASTRUCTURE. 3109 01:50:19,063 --> 01:50:22,934 I THINK SIMILAR STRATEGIES 3110 01:50:22,934 --> 01:50:23,334 EXIST WITH ANVIL. 3111 01:50:23,334 --> 01:50:26,070 IF THERE WERE WAYS TO DIRECTLY 3112 01:50:26,070 --> 01:50:27,705 CONNECT THESE CENTERS WITH 3113 01:50:27,705 --> 01:50:30,041 THESE KINDS OF PROGRAMS AND 3114 01:50:30,041 --> 01:50:31,442 SUPPORT OPTIONS ALSO IT WOULD 3115 01:50:31,442 --> 01:50:33,745 BE GREAT. 3116 01:50:33,745 --> 01:50:35,079 >> ROB: I CONCUR. 3117 01:50:35,079 --> 01:50:37,248 I THINK THE WAY THIS IS 3118 01:50:37,248 --> 01:50:38,716 SUCCESSFUL IS IF IT CONNECTS 3119 01:50:38,716 --> 01:50:40,551 FULLY TO THE ENTIRE GENOME 3120 01:50:40,551 --> 01:50:42,654 UNIVERSE, AS WELL AS ALL 3121 01:50:42,654 --> 01:50:44,255 OPPORTUNITIES ACROSS NIH LARGER. 3122 01:50:44,255 --> 01:50:47,292 SO WE HOPE TO MOVE FORWARD WITH 3123 01:50:47,292 --> 01:50:47,759 IT, WITH YOUR CONSENT. 3124 01:50:47,759 --> 01:50:49,661 BUT ALSO COME BACK AT REGULAR 3125 01:50:49,661 --> 01:50:51,062 INTERVALS AND GIVE YOU UPDATES 3126 01:50:51,062 --> 01:50:53,965 ABOUT HEY, THIS IS HOW WE ARE 3127 01:50:53,965 --> 01:50:54,232 DOING IT. 3128 01:50:54,232 --> 01:50:56,601 AND ALSO HOW COULD WE DO IT 3129 01:50:56,601 --> 01:50:57,435 POTENTIALLY BETTER, BECAUSE 3130 01:50:57,435 --> 01:51:03,942 IT'S AN EXPERIMENT, RIGHT? 3131 01:51:03,942 --> 01:51:07,078 >> JEN: GO AHEAD, JANE. 3132 01:51:07,078 --> 01:51:09,414 >> JANE: I THINK THE ONLY 3133 01:51:09,414 --> 01:51:11,082 PERSON WITH THE RAISE-HAND 3134 01:51:11,082 --> 01:51:12,116 FUNCTION IS NANCY, WHICH I 3135 01:51:12,116 --> 01:51:13,685 THINK IS PROBABLY APPROPRIATE. 3136 01:51:13,685 --> 01:51:15,053 JUST A COMMENT ABOUT FOLLOWING 3137 01:51:15,053 --> 01:51:19,290 UP ON KIND OF CONNECTING IT TO 3138 01:51:19,290 --> 01:51:29,734 OTHER GENOME INITIATIVES. 3139 01:51:34,872 --> 01:51:36,674 MAJOR COMMENT ABOUT FOLLOWING 3140 01:51:36,674 --> 01:51:39,711 UP ON CONNECTING IT TO ANOTHER 3141 01:51:39,711 --> 01:51:40,445 GENOME INITIATIVES, I DON'T 3142 01:51:40,445 --> 01:51:42,280 KNOW ABOUT THE REST OF THE 3143 01:51:42,280 --> 01:51:43,781 GROUP THAT TRAVELS BANG, IT'S 3144 01:51:43,781 --> 01:51:46,484 VERY BUSY BETWEEN SEPTEMBER AND 3145 01:51:46,484 --> 01:51:46,684 JUNE. 3146 01:51:46,684 --> 01:51:48,119 I WOULD ENCOURAGE YOU FOR 3147 01:51:48,119 --> 01:51:48,753 CAPACITY BUILDING AND EDUCATION 3148 01:51:48,753 --> 01:51:49,954 PURPOSES. 3149 01:51:49,954 --> 01:51:51,622 PEOPLE ARE BUSY DURING THE 3150 01:51:51,622 --> 01:51:53,124 SUMMERS, AT LEAST I AM, I THINK 3151 01:51:53,124 --> 01:51:55,493 IT'S TRUE FOR THE OTHER PEOPLE. 3152 01:51:55,493 --> 01:51:59,297 I THINK IT'S AN OPPORTUNITY TO 3153 01:51:59,297 --> 01:52:01,132 HAVE COURSES AND CONNECTIVITY. 3154 01:52:01,132 --> 01:52:04,836 >> ROB: THANK YOU. 3155 01:52:04,836 --> 01:52:07,171 >> JEN: ANY OTHER COMMENTS, 3156 01:52:07,171 --> 01:52:07,772 QUESTIONS OR SUGGESTIONS FROM 3157 01:52:07,772 --> 01:52:15,313 COUNCILMEMBERS? 3158 01:52:15,313 --> 01:52:16,314 ALL RIGHT, COULD I HAVE A 3159 01:52:16,314 --> 01:52:18,049 MOTION TO APPROVE? 3160 01:52:18,049 --> 01:52:19,584 GOT ONE. 3161 01:52:19,584 --> 01:52:20,284 AND THE SECOND, ALL RIGHT. 3162 01:52:20,284 --> 01:52:24,789 ALL IN FAVOR? 3163 01:52:24,789 --> 01:52:27,125 HOLD YOUR HANDS UP FOR A MINUTE. 3164 01:52:27,125 --> 01:52:28,126 ALL RIGHT, GOOD, THANK YOU. 3165 01:52:28,126 --> 01:52:32,330 LOOKS UNITED KINGDOM. 3166 01:52:32,330 --> 01:52:34,198 -- UNANIMOUS, WE WILL MOVE 3167 01:52:34,198 --> 01:52:43,307 ONTO VOTING IN ECB, FOR THE 3168 01:52:43,307 --> 01:52:43,841 GENOMIC RESEARCH CAPACITY 3169 01:52:43,841 --> 01:52:44,409 BUILDING. 3170 01:52:44,409 --> 01:52:45,309 IF YOU CAN REGISTER YOUR VOTE 3171 01:52:45,309 --> 01:52:46,711 THERE. 3172 01:52:46,711 --> 01:52:47,912 WHILE THEY ARE DOING THAT, I 3173 01:52:47,912 --> 01:52:50,214 THINK WHAT WE WILL DO NOW IS 3174 01:52:50,214 --> 01:52:51,416 TAKE A BREAK UNTIL 2:15 AND 3175 01:52:51,416 --> 01:52:53,918 THEN WE WILL COME BACK WITH THE 3176 01:52:53,918 --> 01:52:54,919 LAST CONCEPT CLEARANCE. 3177 01:52:54,919 --> 01:52:58,923 SO EVERYBODY STRETCH YOUR LEGS, 3178 01:52:58,923 --> 01:52:59,424 GET SOMETHING TO DRINK. 3179 01:52:59,424 --> 01:53:03,361 WE WILL SEE YOU IN WHAT IS IT 3180 01:53:03,361 --> 01:53:04,262 20 MINUTES? 3181 01:53:04,262 --> 01:53:06,613 A LITTLE OVER 20 MINUTES. 3182 01:53:11,554 --> 01:53:13,355 I'M CHECKING TO SEE IF JUDY AND 3183 01:53:13,355 --> 01:53:14,423 CASEY ARE BACK. 3184 01:53:14,423 --> 01:53:15,858 I KNOW BRUCE IS STILL ON HIS 3185 01:53:15,858 --> 01:53:16,292 OTHER CALL. 3186 01:53:16,292 --> 01:53:26,469 HI, CASEY. 3187 01:53:28,337 --> 01:53:30,372 WHILE WE ARE WAITING FOR JUDY 3188 01:53:30,372 --> 01:53:31,874 AND BRUCE TO GET BACK, WE WILL 3189 01:53:31,874 --> 01:53:33,642 TAKE CARE OF SOME OF THE 3190 01:53:33,642 --> 01:53:36,045 NON-VOTING BUSINESS WE ARE 3191 01:53:36,045 --> 01:53:37,813 REQUIRED TO DO DURING THESE 3192 01:53:37,813 --> 01:53:39,615 COUNCILS. 3193 01:53:39,615 --> 01:53:41,350 SO FIRST OF ALL, I'M GOING TO 3194 01:53:41,350 --> 01:53:42,151 -- OH, EVERYBODY IS HERE. 3195 01:53:42,151 --> 01:53:43,252 WONDERFUL. 3196 01:53:43,252 --> 01:53:46,922 I THINK WE WILL GO BACK TO THE 3197 01:53:46,922 --> 01:53:49,692 NON-VOTING THINGS LATER THEN, 3198 01:53:49,692 --> 01:53:52,695 IF ALEXANDER, IF YOU ARE READY. 3199 01:53:52,695 --> 01:53:54,697 WE WILL HAVE ZANDER COME UP. 3200 01:53:54,697 --> 01:53:56,365 ARE YOUR PARENTS READY? 3201 01:53:56,365 --> 01:54:06,542 [LAUGHTER] 3202 01:54:07,376 --> 01:54:08,077 ANCIENT DNA FOR MODERN 3203 01:54:08,077 --> 01:54:10,513 GENOMICS, TAKE IT AWAY. 3204 01:54:10,513 --> 01:54:12,782 >> ALEXANDER: THANKS, JEN. 3205 01:54:12,782 --> 01:54:19,388 HAPPY TO PRESENT THIS IDEA. 3206 01:54:19,388 --> 01:54:24,226 ANCIENT DNA FOR MODERN 3207 01:54:24,226 --> 01:54:26,428 GENOMICS, WITH JYOTI DAYA, DAVE 3208 01:54:26,428 --> 01:54:28,164 KAUFMAN AND ISMAIL SAFI. 3209 01:54:28,164 --> 01:54:30,065 IF YOU HAVE BEEN PAYING 3210 01:54:30,065 --> 01:54:32,401 ATTENTION TO THE OTHER NEWS, 3211 01:54:32,401 --> 01:54:34,937 THE DIRE WOLFE HAS BEEN 3212 01:54:34,937 --> 01:54:36,839 RESURRECTED FROM EXTINCTION, OR 3213 01:54:36,839 --> 01:54:39,642 SO CLAIMED. 3214 01:54:39,642 --> 01:54:43,813 ANCIENT DNA FOR A 3215 01:54:43,813 --> 01:54:45,981 40,000-YEAR-OLD SKULL -- 3216 01:54:45,981 --> 01:54:48,250 >> CAROLYN: ALL RIGHT, EVERYONE 3217 01:54:48,250 --> 01:54:48,517 SIT TIGHT. 3218 01:54:48,517 --> 01:54:50,653 WE LOST POWER. 3219 01:54:50,653 --> 01:54:52,955 COUNCILMEMBERS CAN YOU HEAR US? 3220 01:54:52,955 --> 01:54:54,790 >> YES, WE CAN STILL HEAR YOU. 3221 01:54:54,790 --> 01:54:55,691 >> CAROLYN: OKAY, THEY CAN 3222 01:54:55,691 --> 01:54:58,060 STILL HEAR US. 3223 01:54:58,060 --> 01:55:00,529 >> WE ALSO SEE THE DIRE WOLFE. 3224 01:55:00,529 --> 01:55:01,831 >> CAROLYN: OBVIOUSLY WE HAVE 3225 01:55:01,831 --> 01:55:02,765 GENERATOR POWER. 3226 01:55:02,765 --> 01:55:04,600 BUT THERE WAS A HUGE SOUND OF 3227 01:55:04,600 --> 01:55:05,267 EVERYTHING TURNING OFF IN THE 3228 01:55:05,267 --> 01:55:15,377 ROOM. 3229 01:55:19,348 --> 01:55:21,884 GIVE US A SECOND TO REGROUP. 3230 01:55:21,884 --> 01:55:24,420 WE DO HAVE POWER RAINS AND 3231 01:55:24,420 --> 01:55:24,887 THUNDERSTORMS OUTSIDE. 3232 01:55:24,887 --> 01:55:26,755 THAT COULD BE CONTRIBUTING. 3233 01:55:26,755 --> 01:55:32,161 >> I JOKED EARLIER WOULD BE 3234 01:55:32,161 --> 01:55:32,795 STRUCK DOWN DURING THIS 3235 01:55:32,795 --> 01:55:43,038 PRESENTATION. 3236 01:56:17,706 --> 01:56:19,508 >> CAROLYN: IT SEEMS WE ARE 3237 01:56:19,508 --> 01:56:20,776 ABLE TO RESUME, THE VIDEOCAST 3238 01:56:20,776 --> 01:56:22,511 IS STILL GOING. 3239 01:56:22,511 --> 01:56:24,380 WE CAN ALL SEE. 3240 01:56:24,380 --> 01:56:26,815 IT'S GOING TO GET HOT IN HERE 3241 01:56:26,815 --> 01:56:27,950 IF THE AIR CONDITIONER DOESN'T 3242 01:56:27,950 --> 01:56:33,722 COME BACK ON, BUT WE WILL DEAL. 3243 01:56:33,722 --> 01:56:36,759 GO AHEAD, ZANDER, YOU CAN 3244 01:56:36,759 --> 01:56:46,936 CONTINUE. 3245 01:56:49,104 --> 01:56:52,408 OKAY, ALEXANDER, TAKE IT AWAY. 3246 01:56:52,408 --> 01:56:54,043 >> ALEXANDER: EXCITING. 3247 01:56:54,043 --> 01:56:57,813 AS I WAS SAYING, ANCIENT DNA 3248 01:56:57,813 --> 01:56:59,815 FROM A 40,000-YEAR-OLD SKULL 3249 01:56:59,815 --> 01:57:00,816 AND 10,000-YEAR-OLD TOOTH FROM 3250 01:57:00,816 --> 01:57:04,853 A DIRE WOLF WAS USED TO 3251 01:57:04,853 --> 01:57:06,488 INTRODUCE VARIANTS IN THE WOLF 3252 01:57:06,488 --> 01:57:07,356 GENOME RESULTING IN TWO PUPS 3253 01:57:07,356 --> 01:57:09,658 BEING BORN. 3254 01:57:09,658 --> 01:57:11,527 ALTHOUGH THESE PUPS ARE NOT 3255 01:57:11,527 --> 01:57:12,728 DIRE WOLFS IT DOES DEMONSTRATE 3256 01:57:12,728 --> 01:57:14,563 WE ARE NOW IN THE POSITION TO 3257 01:57:14,563 --> 01:57:17,132 UNDERSTAND THE E FENGTS OF 3258 01:57:17,132 --> 01:57:19,234 ANCIENT DNA VARIANTS ON THE 3259 01:57:19,234 --> 01:57:22,137 FUNCTION AND BIOLOGY OF 3260 01:57:22,137 --> 01:57:24,773 GENOMES, NOT ONLY IN VITRO BUT 3261 01:57:24,773 --> 01:57:26,275 ALSO IN VIVO. 3262 01:57:26,275 --> 01:57:29,545 NOW WHEN IT COMES TO ANCIENT 3263 01:57:29,545 --> 01:57:31,647 HUMAN DNA AND FOR OUR PURPOSES, 3264 01:57:31,647 --> 01:57:34,683 WE ARE CALLING ANYTHING OLDER 3265 01:57:34,683 --> 01:57:36,151 THAN 500 YEARS, ANCIENT, THE 3266 01:57:36,151 --> 01:57:37,119 "NEW YORK TIMES" ASKED LAST 3267 01:57:37,119 --> 01:57:41,123 YEAR IF THE FUTURE OF MEDICINE 3268 01:57:41,123 --> 01:57:43,125 IS HIDDEN IN ANCIENT DNA. 3269 01:57:43,125 --> 01:57:45,861 THIS WAS SPURRED BY A SERIES OF 3270 01:57:45,861 --> 01:57:48,630 PAPERS THAT SHOWED THAT 3271 01:57:48,630 --> 01:57:49,999 MIGRATING POPULATIONS IN REGION 3272 01:57:49,999 --> 01:57:51,767 WHEN THEY BRING IN NEW GENETIC 3273 01:57:51,767 --> 01:57:53,302 VARIANTS THEY CAN BE SUBJECT TO 3274 01:57:53,302 --> 01:57:55,938 SELECTION BASED ON CHANGES AND 3275 01:57:55,938 --> 01:57:56,572 DIET AND LIFESTYLE. 3276 01:57:56,572 --> 01:57:58,173 WHICH UNDER CURRENT CONDITIONS 3277 01:57:58,173 --> 01:58:00,776 CAN LEAD TO INCREASED DISEASE 3278 01:58:00,776 --> 01:58:01,710 RISK. 3279 01:58:01,710 --> 01:58:09,051 SO FOR EXAMPLE, ONE HYPOTHESIS 3280 01:58:09,051 --> 01:58:12,087 IS IN EURO ASIA, THEY STARTED 3281 01:58:12,087 --> 01:58:15,157 CONSUMING LARGE AMOUNTS OF RAW 3282 01:58:15,157 --> 01:58:19,695 DAIRY PRODUCTS WHICH NOT 3283 01:58:19,695 --> 01:58:21,096 SURPRISINGLY LED TO IMMUNE 3284 01:58:21,096 --> 01:58:24,833 FUNCTION FOR INCREASED RISK FOR 3285 01:58:24,833 --> 01:58:25,267 AUTOIMMUNE DISEASE. 3286 01:58:25,267 --> 01:58:26,435 ANCIENT DNA CAN POTENTIALLY 3287 01:58:26,435 --> 01:58:27,536 TELL US SOMETHING ABOUT MODERN 3288 01:58:27,536 --> 01:58:30,506 DISEASE BIOLOGY. 3289 01:58:30,506 --> 01:58:32,875 NOW WE ALL KNOW HOW IMPORTANT 3290 01:58:32,875 --> 01:58:36,345 IT IS TO SAMPLE BROADLY GENETIC 3291 01:58:36,345 --> 01:58:36,912 VARIATION FROM ACROSS 3292 01:58:36,912 --> 01:58:38,313 POPULATIONS AND THIS IS 3293 01:58:38,313 --> 01:58:39,848 SOMETHING WE OUTLINED IN OUR 3294 01:58:39,848 --> 01:58:43,986 2020 STRATEGIC VISION. 3295 01:58:43,986 --> 01:58:46,088 NAZ BECAUSE GENETIC EFFECTS 3296 01:58:46,088 --> 01:58:47,456 FOUND IN ONE POPULATION DON'T 3297 01:58:47,456 --> 01:58:49,291 NECESSARILY CARRY OVER TO OTHER 3298 01:58:49,291 --> 01:58:55,397 POPULATIONS, THIS COULD BE DUE 3299 01:58:55,397 --> 01:58:58,000 TO DIFFERENCES IN ALLELE 3300 01:58:58,000 --> 01:59:00,769 FREQUENCY AND LOCAL AND 3301 01:59:00,769 --> 01:59:01,336 DEMOGRAPHIC FACTORS. 3302 01:59:01,336 --> 01:59:04,940 WE CAN HARNESS THE EFFECTS OF 3303 01:59:04,940 --> 01:59:06,775 EVOLUTION TO GIVE US BETTER 3304 01:59:06,775 --> 01:59:08,243 INSIGHTS IN GENOME BIOLOGY. 3305 01:59:08,243 --> 01:59:10,679 ALTHOUGH WE CAN LEARN A LOT 3306 01:59:10,679 --> 01:59:11,980 FROM EXISTING POPULATIONS AND 3307 01:59:11,980 --> 01:59:13,615 SPECIES, THERE IS STILL MORE WE 3308 01:59:13,615 --> 01:59:15,250 CAN LEARN FROM POPULATIONS THAT 3309 01:59:15,250 --> 01:59:16,652 NO LONGER EXIST AND FROM 3310 01:59:16,652 --> 01:59:18,153 SPECIES THAT ARE MORE CLOSELY 3311 01:59:18,153 --> 01:59:26,962 RELATED TO HUMANS LIKE SOME OF 3312 01:59:26,962 --> 01:59:29,932 OUR EXTINCT HOMINANT COUSINS. 3313 01:59:29,932 --> 01:59:31,934 WE THINK IT'S IMPORTANT TO 3314 01:59:31,934 --> 01:59:34,203 RESEARCH ESPECIALLY IF IT HAS 3315 01:59:34,203 --> 01:59:35,838 IMPLICATIONS FOR UNDERSTANDING 3316 01:59:35,838 --> 01:59:36,972 MODERN GENOMES AND CONTEMPORARY 3317 01:59:36,972 --> 01:59:40,142 HUMAN DISEASES. 3318 01:59:40,142 --> 01:59:43,879 BUT JUST LIKE DNA FROM MODERN 3319 01:59:43,879 --> 01:59:45,547 HUMAN POPULATIONS, DNA FROM 3320 01:59:45,547 --> 01:59:48,851 ANCIENT HUMAN SOURCES IS 3321 01:59:48,851 --> 01:59:49,518 GEOGRAPHICALLY BIASED. 3322 01:59:49,518 --> 01:59:52,054 MOST EXISTING DNA DATA THAT'S 3323 01:59:52,054 --> 01:59:54,690 BEEN PUBLISHED COMES FROM 3324 01:59:54,690 --> 01:59:58,160 WESTERN EURO ASIA, BY THE ALLEN 3325 01:59:58,160 --> 01:59:59,828 ANCIENT DNA RESOURCE SHOWING 3326 01:59:59,828 --> 02:00:01,797 MOST, ABOUT 79% OF IT COMES 3327 02:00:01,797 --> 02:00:03,532 FROM EUROPE AND RUSSIA. 3328 02:00:03,532 --> 02:00:05,234 AND IMPORTANTLY, THIS IS NOT 3329 02:00:05,234 --> 02:00:08,370 BECAUSE OF THE AVAILABILITY OF 3330 02:00:08,370 --> 02:00:09,838 SAMPLES, THERE ARE THOUSANDS OF 3331 02:00:09,838 --> 02:00:11,807 SAMPLES SITTING IN COLLECTIONS 3332 02:00:11,807 --> 02:00:13,942 IN MUSEUMS AROUND THE WORLD, 3333 02:00:13,942 --> 02:00:15,811 REALLY DUE TO DISTRIBUTION AND 3334 02:00:15,811 --> 02:00:16,745 DEPLOYMENT OF RESOURCES, WHERE 3335 02:00:16,745 --> 02:00:22,851 WE PUT OUR MONEY AND OUR EFFORT. 3336 02:00:22,851 --> 02:00:23,552 THIS MEANS ANY RELEVANT 3337 02:00:23,552 --> 02:00:25,654 INSIGHTS YOU GET INTO THE 3338 02:00:25,654 --> 02:00:27,689 BIOLOGY OF DISEASES OR OTHER 3339 02:00:27,689 --> 02:00:29,558 TRAITS COMING FROM ANCIENT DNA 3340 02:00:29,558 --> 02:00:31,994 DATA MAY BE APPLICABLE ONLY TO 3341 02:00:31,994 --> 02:00:33,295 SOME POPULATIONS. 3342 02:00:33,295 --> 02:00:34,463 ADDITIONALLY MOST OF THE 3343 02:00:34,463 --> 02:00:37,533 PUBLISHED DATA SO FAR HAS BEEN 3344 02:00:37,533 --> 02:00:41,703 GENERATED BY TARGETING ABOUT 3345 02:00:41,703 --> 02:00:42,771 ONE MILLION NON RANDOM SNPS IN 3346 02:00:42,771 --> 02:00:44,540 THE GENOME. 3347 02:00:44,540 --> 02:00:45,941 THIS IS THE ANALOGY AND 3348 02:00:45,941 --> 02:00:48,510 INFERENCES YOU CAN DO ABOUT 3349 02:00:48,510 --> 02:00:49,945 THINGS LIKE SELECTION OR 3350 02:00:49,945 --> 02:00:50,479 INTERFWRETION INTO HUMAN 3351 02:00:50,479 --> 02:00:51,446 GENOMES. 3352 02:00:51,446 --> 02:00:54,016 AND TODAY HAS REALLY BEEN THE 3353 02:00:54,016 --> 02:00:59,521 SEQUENCING COSTS THAT HAVE BEEN 3354 02:00:59,521 --> 02:01:04,426 LIMITING IN THIS EFFECT, 3355 02:01:04,426 --> 02:01:05,093 ESPECIALLY WITH CONTAMINATION, 3356 02:01:05,093 --> 02:01:07,262 BUT THIS IS NO LONGER A BARRIER. 3357 02:01:07,262 --> 02:01:11,166 WHAT WE DO NEED IS A WAY TO 3358 02:01:11,166 --> 02:01:14,303 OVERCOME BOTH THE GEOGRAPHIC 3359 02:01:14,303 --> 02:01:18,907 SAMPLING BIAS AND GENOME 3360 02:01:18,907 --> 02:01:20,542 COVERAGE BIAS FOR ANCIENT DNA 3361 02:01:20,542 --> 02:01:24,246 DATA AND MAKE IT AVAILABLE TO 3362 02:01:24,246 --> 02:01:24,746 THE RESEARCH COMMUNITY. 3363 02:01:24,746 --> 02:01:27,482 LAST OCTOBER WE PUT TOGETHER A 3364 02:01:27,482 --> 02:01:28,917 WEBINAR ON ANCIENT GENETIC 3365 02:01:28,917 --> 02:01:30,319 CLUES INTO MODERN HUMAN DISEASE. 3366 02:01:30,319 --> 02:01:36,625 WE BROUGHT TOGETHER A GROUP OF 3367 02:01:36,625 --> 02:01:37,292 ANTHROPOLOGISTS, POPULATION 3368 02:01:37,292 --> 02:01:37,893 EVOLUTIONARY MEDICINISTS TO 3369 02:01:37,893 --> 02:01:39,661 DISCUSS THE STATE OF THE FIELD. 3370 02:01:39,661 --> 02:01:42,030 SOME KEY TAKE AWAYS AND HIGH 3371 02:01:42,030 --> 02:01:44,099 LEVEL RECOMMENDATIONS FROM THE 3372 02:01:44,099 --> 02:01:45,033 PANELISTS INCLUDED THAT 3373 02:01:45,033 --> 02:01:46,268 RESEARCHERS SHOULD ENGAGE WITH 3374 02:01:46,268 --> 02:01:48,203 LOCAL COMMUNITIES EARLY ON IN A 3375 02:01:48,203 --> 02:01:49,972 PROJECT TO DETERMINE COMMUNITY 3376 02:01:49,972 --> 02:01:50,939 RESEARCH INTERESTS AND THEIR 3377 02:01:50,939 --> 02:01:52,074 PRIORITIES AND WHETHER THEY 3378 02:01:52,074 --> 02:01:55,944 ALIGN WITH THOSE OF 3379 02:01:55,944 --> 02:01:56,478 INVESTIGATORS AND FUNDERS. 3380 02:01:56,478 --> 02:01:57,779 AND THAT INVESTIGATORS IN THE 3381 02:01:57,779 --> 02:02:00,749 GLOBAL SOUTH AND LOW AND MIDDLE 3382 02:02:00,749 --> 02:02:02,484 INCOME COUNTRIES MAY LACK THE 3383 02:02:02,484 --> 02:02:05,020 NECESSARY RESOURCES TO BE EQUAL 3384 02:02:05,020 --> 02:02:06,622 PARTNERS IN IDEALLY FUTURE 3385 02:02:06,622 --> 02:02:08,290 PROJECTS WOULD INVOLVE CAPACITY 3386 02:02:08,290 --> 02:02:09,558 BUILDING FOCUSING ON 3387 02:02:09,558 --> 02:02:10,125 INFRASTRUCTURE OR WORKFORCE 3388 02:02:10,125 --> 02:02:11,727 DEVELOPMENT. 3389 02:02:11,727 --> 02:02:13,161 AND THAT STEPS SHOULD BE TAKEN 3390 02:02:13,161 --> 02:02:16,565 TO PREVENT THE GAP IN THE 3391 02:02:16,565 --> 02:02:18,200 REPRESENTATION OF ANCIENT DNA 3392 02:02:18,200 --> 02:02:20,335 FROM GLOBAL POPULATIONS FROM 3393 02:02:20,335 --> 02:02:26,942 WIDENING FURTHER THAT MAY 3394 02:02:26,942 --> 02:02:29,144 EXACERBATE DISPARITIES THAT MAY 3395 02:02:29,144 --> 02:02:30,312 EXIST AND POTENTIAL BENEFITS 3396 02:02:30,312 --> 02:02:31,713 AND APPLICATIONS SHOULD BE 3397 02:02:31,713 --> 02:02:33,815 PRESENTED IN A MEASURED AND 3398 02:02:33,815 --> 02:02:34,316 RESPONSIBLE MANNER TO 3399 02:02:34,316 --> 02:02:34,916 PARTICIPATING COMMUNITIES AND 3400 02:02:34,916 --> 02:02:35,651 THE PUBLIC. 3401 02:02:35,651 --> 02:02:37,986 THERE'S A LOT OF INTEREST AND 3402 02:02:37,986 --> 02:02:40,122 ATTENTION IN DNA RESEARCH AND 3403 02:02:40,122 --> 02:02:42,157 IT'S SENSATIONALIZED SO WE HAVE 3404 02:02:42,157 --> 02:02:44,059 A DUTY TO PRESENT THIS RESEARCH 3405 02:02:44,059 --> 02:02:47,129 IN A RESPONSIBLE MANNER. 3406 02:02:47,129 --> 02:02:51,066 NOW GIVEN ALL THAT WE PROPOSE A 3407 02:02:51,066 --> 02:02:53,935 PROGRAM ANCIENT DNA FOR MODERN 3408 02:02:53,935 --> 02:02:56,071 GENOMICS WHOSE BROAD GOALS 3409 02:02:56,071 --> 02:02:58,640 INCLUDE TO SURVEY AND IDENTIFY 3410 02:02:58,640 --> 02:03:01,443 SOURCES OF DNA FROM ACROSS THE 3411 02:03:01,443 --> 02:03:02,844 GLOBE, ENGAGING AND PARTNERING 3412 02:03:02,844 --> 02:03:04,780 WITH LOCAL INVESTIGATORS AND 3413 02:03:04,780 --> 02:03:07,316 COMMUNITIES. 3414 02:03:07,316 --> 02:03:08,817 ESTABLISHING ETHICAL AND 3415 02:03:08,817 --> 02:03:10,152 REGULATORY FRAMEWORK FOR 3416 02:03:10,152 --> 02:03:10,819 COLLECTING SAMPLES GENERATING 3417 02:03:10,819 --> 02:03:13,655 SEQUENCES AND SHARING DATA. 3418 02:03:13,655 --> 02:03:17,259 GENERATE HARMONIZE HIGH QUALITY 3419 02:03:17,259 --> 02:03:19,027 WHOLE GENOME ANCIENT DNA DATA 3420 02:03:19,027 --> 02:03:21,830 FROM NEW AND EXISTING SOURCES 3421 02:03:21,830 --> 02:03:23,699 SAMPLING GLOBAL GENETIC 3422 02:03:23,699 --> 02:03:24,866 DIVERSITY, CREATE CENTRALIZED 3423 02:03:24,866 --> 02:03:26,068 FEDERATED DATA RESOURCE AND 3424 02:03:26,068 --> 02:03:28,136 SUPPORT INDIVIDUAL RESEARCH TO 3425 02:03:28,136 --> 02:03:29,104 ADDRESS THE BIOLOGY, 3426 02:03:29,104 --> 02:03:31,073 EPIDEMIOLOGY OR EVOLUTION OF 3427 02:03:31,073 --> 02:03:31,640 DISEASE AND HEALTH-RELATED 3428 02:03:31,640 --> 02:03:33,875 TRAITS. 3429 02:03:33,875 --> 02:03:35,544 THE STRUCTURE OF THIS PROGRAM 3430 02:03:35,544 --> 02:03:38,880 WOULD INVOLVE THREE COMPONENTS. 3431 02:03:38,880 --> 02:03:41,149 A COORDINATION CENTER, UM1 DATA 3432 02:03:41,149 --> 02:03:44,186 PRODUCTION, U24 AND SERIES OF 3433 02:03:44,186 --> 02:03:46,254 RESEARCH PROJECTS, U01'S THAT 3434 02:03:46,254 --> 02:03:47,422 WOULD ADDRESS SPECIFIC 3435 02:03:47,422 --> 02:03:48,323 SCIENTIFIC QUESTIONS USING THE 3436 02:03:48,323 --> 02:03:49,991 ANCIENT DNA RESOURCE. 3437 02:03:49,991 --> 02:03:51,960 TODAY WE ARE ONLY SEEKING 3438 02:03:51,960 --> 02:03:55,864 CLEARANCE FOR THE FIRST TWO 3439 02:03:55,864 --> 02:03:56,398 COMPONENTS OF THE PROGRAM. 3440 02:03:56,398 --> 02:03:56,998 COORDINATION CENTER AND DATA 3441 02:03:56,998 --> 02:03:57,966 PRODUCTION CENTER. 3442 02:03:57,966 --> 02:03:58,967 THE INDIVIDUAL RESEARCH 3443 02:03:58,967 --> 02:04:00,335 PROJECTS WOULD COME TO COUNCIL 3444 02:04:00,335 --> 02:04:02,237 AT A LATER DATE FOR CLEARANCE 3445 02:04:02,237 --> 02:04:03,839 AND HOPEFULLY BY IT THAT TIME 3446 02:04:03,839 --> 02:04:11,413 THAT WOULD ALSO INVOLVE THE 3447 02:04:11,413 --> 02:04:11,980 PARTICIPATION OF OTHER NIH 3448 02:04:11,980 --> 02:04:13,682 INSTITUTES. 3449 02:04:13,682 --> 02:04:15,050 THE FIRST COMPONENT COMMUNITY 3450 02:04:15,050 --> 02:04:16,418 ENGAGEMENT AND COORDINATION 3451 02:04:16,418 --> 02:04:17,486 CENTER WOULD BE RESPONSIBLE 3452 02:04:17,486 --> 02:04:18,987 WORKING WITH LOCAL COMMUNITIES 3453 02:04:18,987 --> 02:04:21,223 TO IDENTIFY EXISTING AND NEW 3454 02:04:21,223 --> 02:04:23,358 SOURCES OF ANCIENT DNA THAT 3455 02:04:23,358 --> 02:04:24,292 MEET ESTABLISHED ETHICAL 3456 02:04:24,292 --> 02:04:26,361 FRAMEWORK FOR DATA SHARING AND 3457 02:04:26,361 --> 02:04:27,329 SOVEREIGNTY. 3458 02:04:27,329 --> 02:04:29,030 PROVIDE OVERALL OVERSIGHT AND 3459 02:04:29,030 --> 02:04:30,065 COORDINATION OF PROGRAM 3460 02:04:30,065 --> 02:04:32,234 ACTIVITIES ACROSS ALL 3461 02:04:32,234 --> 02:04:32,534 COMPONENTS. 3462 02:04:32,534 --> 02:04:34,169 DO THIS BY COORDINATE OUTREACH 3463 02:04:34,169 --> 02:04:35,570 TO INTERNATIONAL PARTNERS, 3464 02:04:35,570 --> 02:04:36,271 RESEARCH COLLABORATORS AND 3465 02:04:36,271 --> 02:04:37,005 PARTICIPANT COMMUNITIES WITH 3466 02:04:37,005 --> 02:04:39,841 THE LARGER GOAL OF CREATING A 3467 02:04:39,841 --> 02:04:40,842 GLOBALLY INCLUSIVE AND 3468 02:04:40,842 --> 02:04:42,310 REPRESENTATIVE ANCIENT DNA 3469 02:04:42,310 --> 02:04:42,577 RESOURCE. 3470 02:04:42,577 --> 02:04:43,545 THEY WOULD DETERMINE THE 3471 02:04:43,545 --> 02:04:44,479 INTEREST AND PRIORITIES OF 3472 02:04:44,479 --> 02:04:46,815 LOCAL COMMUNITIES WITH RESPECT 3473 02:04:46,815 --> 02:04:49,618 TO GENERATION OF SHARING OF 3474 02:04:49,618 --> 02:04:51,486 ANCIENT AND HISTORICAL DNA AND 3475 02:04:51,486 --> 02:04:52,821 DESIGN AND IMPLEMENT TRAINING 3476 02:04:52,821 --> 02:04:54,122 FOR LOCAL RESEARCHERS IN THE 3477 02:04:54,122 --> 02:04:56,191 GENERATION AND USE OF ANCIENT 3478 02:04:56,191 --> 02:04:56,691 DNA DATA. 3479 02:04:56,691 --> 02:05:02,230 OVERALL WE WANT TO BE ABLE TO 3480 02:05:02,230 --> 02:05:03,265 IDENTIFY SAMPLES OLD AND NEW 3481 02:05:03,265 --> 02:05:05,867 FROM THE AROUND THE WORLD AND 3482 02:05:05,867 --> 02:05:09,638 FILL IN GAPS AND DO THIS IN AN 3483 02:05:09,638 --> 02:05:10,205 ETHICAL AND NON EXTRACTIVE 3484 02:05:10,205 --> 02:05:11,840 MANNER. 3485 02:05:11,840 --> 02:05:13,408 THE SECOND COMPONENT OF DATA 3486 02:05:13,408 --> 02:05:14,643 GENERATION AND RESOURCE CENTER 3487 02:05:14,643 --> 02:05:16,211 WOULD BE RESPONSIBLE FOR 3488 02:05:16,211 --> 02:05:17,379 PRODUCING THE HIGH-QUALITY 3489 02:05:17,379 --> 02:05:19,247 GENOMES FROM A PROVED ANCIENT 3490 02:05:19,247 --> 02:05:20,916 DNA SOURCES AND HARMONIZE THAT 3491 02:05:20,916 --> 02:05:22,984 WITH EXISTING DATA TO CREATE A 3492 02:05:22,984 --> 02:05:24,419 CENTRALIZED DATA PORTAL. 3493 02:05:24,419 --> 02:05:27,055 WE WOULD DO THIS BY SEQUENCING 3494 02:05:27,055 --> 02:05:30,625 UP TO AT LEAST 10,000 DIPLOID 3495 02:05:30,625 --> 02:05:32,160 GENOMES REPRESENTING ANCIENT 3496 02:05:32,160 --> 02:05:32,627 AND HISTORICAL GLOBAL 3497 02:05:32,627 --> 02:05:34,830 POPULATIONS. 3498 02:05:34,830 --> 02:05:36,731 CREATE A CENTRALIZED HARMONIZED 3499 02:05:36,731 --> 02:05:38,133 DATA RESOURCE COMPATIBLE WITH 3500 02:05:38,133 --> 02:05:39,768 FEDERATED SYSTEM OF MIXED DATA 3501 02:05:39,768 --> 02:05:41,436 STORAGE AND USE LIMITATIONS AND 3502 02:05:41,436 --> 02:05:43,138 IMPORTANTLY NO MORE THAN 25 3503 02:05:43,138 --> 02:05:45,006 PERCENT OF THE NEW GENOME 3504 02:05:45,006 --> 02:05:48,343 SEQUENCE WOULD COME FROM 3505 02:05:48,343 --> 02:05:51,513 ANCIENT AND HISTORICAL WESTERN 3506 02:05:51,513 --> 02:05:52,747 EURASIAN POPULATIONS. 3507 02:05:52,747 --> 02:05:55,550 WE HOPE FOR THE COVERAGE THAT 3508 02:05:55,550 --> 02:05:56,485 CURRENTLY EXISTS FOR ANCIENT 3509 02:05:56,485 --> 02:05:58,787 DNA DATA AND DO THIS IN A WAY 3510 02:05:58,787 --> 02:06:01,189 THAT TAKES INTO ACCOUNT THE 3511 02:06:01,189 --> 02:06:02,824 GEOGRAPHY AND CHRONOLOGY OF 3512 02:06:02,824 --> 02:06:04,392 DIVERSITY THAT EXISTS TODAY AND 3513 02:06:04,392 --> 02:06:07,796 THAT HAS EXISTED IN THE PAST. 3514 02:06:07,796 --> 02:06:09,664 FUNDING AND TIMING. 3515 02:06:09,664 --> 02:06:12,968 WE ARE LOOKING TO START IN FY 3516 02:06:12,968 --> 02:06:14,302 '27. 3517 02:06:14,302 --> 02:06:16,638 A COORDINATION CENTER UM1 IN 3518 02:06:16,638 --> 02:06:17,806 THE DATA PRODUCTION CENTER U24 3519 02:06:17,806 --> 02:06:19,508 WILL START AT THE SAME TIME. 3520 02:06:19,508 --> 02:06:21,576 THEY WILL WORK TOGETHER TO 3521 02:06:21,576 --> 02:06:23,612 IDENTIFY EXISTING AND NEW 3522 02:06:23,612 --> 02:06:26,715 SOURCES OF ANCIENT DNA AND DATA 3523 02:06:26,715 --> 02:06:28,316 PRODUCTION WILL RAMP UP ACROSS 3524 02:06:28,316 --> 02:06:30,952 THE YEARS AS NEW SAMPLES ARE 3525 02:06:30,952 --> 02:06:31,253 IDENTIFIED. 3526 02:06:31,253 --> 02:06:31,887 THE INDIVIDUAL RESEARCH PROJECT 3527 02:06:31,887 --> 02:06:35,056 WOULD START IN THE SUBSEQUENT 3528 02:06:35,056 --> 02:06:35,357 FISCAL YEAR. 3529 02:06:35,357 --> 02:06:36,758 BUT IN ALL, IN TOTAL ACROSS ALL 3530 02:06:36,758 --> 02:06:38,627 FIVE YEARS AND ACROSS ALL THREE 3531 02:06:38,627 --> 02:06:40,729 COMPONENTS AND IF THE STARS 3532 02:06:40,729 --> 02:06:43,565 ALIGN, WE HOPE TO INVEST AROUND 3533 02:06:43,565 --> 02:06:46,668 $25 MILLION IN THE PROGRAM. 3534 02:06:46,668 --> 02:06:49,271 THAT IS IT. 3535 02:06:49,271 --> 02:06:58,747 AND I'M HAPPY TO TAKE QUESTIONS. 3536 02:06:58,747 --> 02:07:00,081 >> CAROLYN: JUDY, YOU WANT TO 3537 02:07:00,081 --> 02:07:01,349 LEAD US OFF? 3538 02:07:01,349 --> 02:07:03,251 >> SURE, I THOUGHT IT WAS ME 3539 02:07:03,251 --> 02:07:05,053 AND BRUCE, BUT I'M GETTING 3540 02:07:05,053 --> 02:07:05,820 CONFUSED. 3541 02:07:05,820 --> 02:07:07,522 I THINK THE FUNDAMENTAL 3542 02:07:07,522 --> 02:07:08,223 RATIONALE FOR THIS INITIATIVE 3543 02:07:08,223 --> 02:07:10,025 IS OUTSTANDING. 3544 02:07:10,025 --> 02:07:11,860 I'VE ALWAYS BEEN A BIG BELIEVER 3545 02:07:11,860 --> 02:07:14,496 OF SOMEONE WHO STUDIES THE 3546 02:07:14,496 --> 02:07:15,063 GENETICS OF CHRONIC 3547 02:07:15,063 --> 02:07:16,331 INFLAMMATORY DISEASES THAT SOME 3548 02:07:16,331 --> 02:07:17,732 OF THE DIFFERENCES IN DISEASE 3549 02:07:17,732 --> 02:07:20,135 PREVALENCE THAT WE SEE IN 3550 02:07:20,135 --> 02:07:22,203 DIFFERENT POPULATIONS. 3551 02:07:22,203 --> 02:07:23,772 SO MODERN DAY DISEASES CLEARLY 3552 02:07:23,772 --> 02:07:26,608 HAVE THEIR ROOTS, I GUESS I 3553 02:07:26,608 --> 02:07:29,444 AGREE WITH THE "NEW YORK TIMES" 3554 02:07:29,444 --> 02:07:31,780 HEADLINES THAT SELECTION FACTOR 3555 02:07:31,780 --> 02:07:33,181 TO HISTORICALLY SIGNIFICANT 3556 02:07:33,181 --> 02:07:35,016 PATHOGENS PROBABLY PLAY A KEY 3557 02:07:35,016 --> 02:07:36,284 ROLE IN DRIVING MODERN DAY 3558 02:07:36,284 --> 02:07:38,086 CHRONIC DISEASES. 3559 02:07:38,086 --> 02:07:39,020 I THINK THE SCIENTIFIC 3560 02:07:39,020 --> 02:07:40,922 RATIONALE FOR THIS IS CLEARLY 3561 02:07:40,922 --> 02:07:44,125 OUTSTANDING. 3562 02:07:44,125 --> 02:07:46,595 AGAIN, I DID NOT LISTEN TO THE 3563 02:07:46,595 --> 02:07:47,462 WEBINAR FROM THE LAST OCTOBER 3564 02:07:47,462 --> 02:07:49,331 BUT I DID LOOK AT THE AGENDA. 3565 02:07:49,331 --> 02:07:52,767 AND I LOOKED AT THE FOLKS THAT 3566 02:07:52,767 --> 02:07:53,568 WERE INVOLVED IN THIS. 3567 02:07:53,568 --> 02:07:54,970 CLEARLY EPIDEMIOLOGY AND 3568 02:07:54,970 --> 02:07:56,871 UNDERSTANDING OF HISTORICAL 3569 02:07:56,871 --> 02:07:58,106 PATTERNS OF DISEASE, I THINK, 3570 02:07:58,106 --> 02:08:01,576 SHOULD INFORM SOME OF THIS. 3571 02:08:01,576 --> 02:08:03,178 AND SO, I THINK THAT'S PROBABLY 3572 02:08:03,178 --> 02:08:05,714 GOING TO BE WEIGHTED TO THE 3573 02:08:05,714 --> 02:08:08,450 COORDINATING CENTER TOGETHER 3574 02:08:08,450 --> 02:08:10,452 WITH THE SEQUENCING CENTER 3575 02:08:10,452 --> 02:08:10,986 WORKING TOGETHER ON THIS. 3576 02:08:10,986 --> 02:08:12,654 BECAUSE THIS IS LIKE TRYING TO 3577 02:08:12,654 --> 02:08:15,490 BOIL AN OCEAN A LITTLE BIT. 3578 02:08:15,490 --> 02:08:17,525 BEING STRATEGIC ABOUT THIS AND 3579 02:08:17,525 --> 02:08:22,063 REALLY BEING ONBOARD SO THAT 3580 02:08:22,063 --> 02:08:23,231 SAMPLE ACQUISITION CAN PROCEED 3581 02:08:23,231 --> 02:08:25,600 A PACE IN AN EFFICIENT WAY AND 3582 02:08:25,600 --> 02:08:26,735 MAKE SURE THE SEQUENCING CAN BE 3583 02:08:26,735 --> 02:08:28,903 DONE IN A TIMELY AND EFFICIENT 3584 02:08:28,903 --> 02:08:30,538 MANNER WILL BE ESSENTIAL. 3585 02:08:30,538 --> 02:08:32,674 I DID HAVE A QUESTION, KIND OF 3586 02:08:32,674 --> 02:08:34,509 GIVEN THE NEW POLICIES 3587 02:08:34,509 --> 02:08:35,010 REGARDING INTERNATIONAL 3588 02:08:35,010 --> 02:08:39,247 SUBCONTRACTS. 3589 02:08:39,247 --> 02:08:43,418 AND THAT MIGHT POTENTIALLY BE A 3590 02:08:43,418 --> 02:08:44,919 CHALLENGE FOR THE COORDINATING 3591 02:08:44,919 --> 02:08:46,354 CENTER OR THE SEQUENCING 3592 02:08:46,354 --> 02:08:48,757 CENTERS PRESUMING THEY ARE 3593 02:08:48,757 --> 02:08:50,091 PRIMARILY U.S. INVESTIGATORS. 3594 02:08:50,091 --> 02:08:53,762 THERE'S CLEARLY GOING TO BE A 3595 02:08:53,762 --> 02:08:55,196 KEY ROLE FOR ACQUISITION, AS 3596 02:08:55,196 --> 02:08:57,365 YOU SAID, THE RFA SAYS YOU 3597 02:08:57,365 --> 02:09:02,137 CAN'T BE MORE THAN 25% OF A 3598 02:09:02,137 --> 02:09:02,671 ALREADY WELL REPRESENTED 3599 02:09:02,671 --> 02:09:03,905 COHORTS. 3600 02:09:03,905 --> 02:09:04,839 CLEARLY AFRICA WILL BE 3601 02:09:04,839 --> 02:09:05,840 IMPORTANT. 3602 02:09:05,840 --> 02:09:07,676 I'M NOT REALLY AN EXPERT ON 3603 02:09:07,676 --> 02:09:10,645 NORTH AMERICA AND THE BERING 3604 02:09:10,645 --> 02:09:12,113 STRAIT SO CLEARLY THERE'S 3605 02:09:12,113 --> 02:09:13,314 PRESUMABLY THIS WAS ALL 3606 02:09:13,314 --> 02:09:14,449 DISCUSSED AT THE WEBINAR LAST 3607 02:09:14,449 --> 02:09:15,350 FALL. 3608 02:09:15,350 --> 02:09:16,518 AND THEN FINALLY, JUST 3609 02:09:16,518 --> 02:09:19,821 SOMETHING FOR DISCUSSION WITH 3610 02:09:19,821 --> 02:09:21,723 THE GROUP IS KIND OF THE 3611 02:09:21,723 --> 02:09:24,359 QUESTION PART WOULD NOT START 3612 02:09:24,359 --> 02:09:26,127 INTO FISCAL YEAR '28. 3613 02:09:26,127 --> 02:09:27,996 I JUST WONDER AND OBVIOUSLY THE 3614 02:09:27,996 --> 02:09:29,464 COORDINATING CENTER WILL BE 3615 02:09:29,464 --> 02:09:31,066 EXPERT ON THIS AND SEQUENCING 3616 02:09:31,066 --> 02:09:32,233 CENTER WILL BE EXPERT ON THIS. 3617 02:09:32,233 --> 02:09:33,601 BUT I THINK ASKING THE 3618 02:09:33,601 --> 02:09:36,204 QUESTIONS AND KIND OF 3619 02:09:36,204 --> 02:09:37,305 ANTICIPATING PROBABLY ANALYSES 3620 02:09:37,305 --> 02:09:38,339 SHOULD BE DONE SOONER RATHER 3621 02:09:38,339 --> 02:09:39,140 THAN LATER. 3622 02:09:39,140 --> 02:09:41,943 I UNDERSTAND KIND OF THE 3623 02:09:41,943 --> 02:09:42,977 OPERATIONAL REASONS WHY IT'S 3624 02:09:42,977 --> 02:09:44,245 BEING PROPOSED AND DONE THAT 3625 02:09:44,245 --> 02:09:46,815 WAY. 3626 02:09:46,815 --> 02:09:48,016 BUT IT DOES, IT'S SOMETHING 3627 02:09:48,016 --> 02:09:48,883 THAT SHOULD BE AT LEAST 3628 02:09:48,883 --> 02:09:50,552 CONSIDERED AND DISCUSSED. 3629 02:09:50,552 --> 02:09:51,653 SO THOSE ARE MY MAJOR THOUGHTS 3630 02:09:51,653 --> 02:09:59,527 WHEN I READ THIS. 3631 02:09:59,527 --> 02:10:00,462 >> ALEXANDER: QUICK COMPONENT, 3632 02:10:00,462 --> 02:10:01,896 WE HOPE BY THE TIME THIS COMES 3633 02:10:01,896 --> 02:10:04,766 OUT THAT WILL BE A NEW 3634 02:10:04,766 --> 02:10:06,367 MECHANISM IN PLACE FOR THE 3635 02:10:06,367 --> 02:10:08,103 PARTICIPATION OF OUR 3636 02:10:08,103 --> 02:10:08,703 INSTITUTIONS IN NIH-SUPPORTED 3637 02:10:08,703 --> 02:10:12,607 RESEARCH. 3638 02:10:12,607 --> 02:10:15,210 >> JEN: YEAH, SO IT IS 3639 02:10:15,210 --> 02:10:17,579 ANTICIPATED PERHAPS AS EARLY AS 3640 02:10:17,579 --> 02:10:18,246 SEPTEMBER, APPLICATIONS COMING 3641 02:10:18,246 --> 02:10:20,915 IN AFTER SEPTEMBER WILL HAVE A 3642 02:10:20,915 --> 02:10:25,320 MECHANISM BY WHICH WHAT WILL 3643 02:10:25,320 --> 02:10:27,222 HAPPEN, THERE WILL BE COMPANION. 3644 02:10:27,222 --> 02:10:29,924 SO IT WOULD COME IN AS ONE 3645 02:10:29,924 --> 02:10:31,793 APPLICATION BUT THE AWARDS GO 3646 02:10:31,793 --> 02:10:32,427 INDIVIDUALLY TO THE DIFFERENT 3647 02:10:32,427 --> 02:10:33,695 INSTITUTIONS. 3648 02:10:33,695 --> 02:10:34,596 EVENTUALLY THIS IS ACTUALLY 3649 02:10:34,596 --> 02:10:36,231 PROBABLY GOING TO ROLL OUT FOR 3650 02:10:36,231 --> 02:10:39,000 ALL THINGS THAT USED TO BE 3651 02:10:39,000 --> 02:10:40,335 SUBS, BUT IT'S STARTING WITH 3652 02:10:40,335 --> 02:10:42,103 FOREIGN. 3653 02:10:42,103 --> 02:10:43,438 WE DON'T ANTICIPATE THAT ALONE 3654 02:10:43,438 --> 02:10:45,340 WILL BE A PROBLEM NOW IF THERE 3655 02:10:45,340 --> 02:10:46,541 WERE COLLECTION OF COUNTRIES OF 3656 02:10:46,541 --> 02:10:48,209 CONCERN WHERE WE ARE NOT 3657 02:10:48,209 --> 02:10:49,344 ALLOWED TO PROVIDE FUNDING, 3658 02:10:49,344 --> 02:10:51,746 THAT WOULD BE DIFFERENT. 3659 02:10:51,746 --> 02:10:53,815 BUT FOR FOREIGN COMPONENTS WE 3660 02:10:53,815 --> 02:10:56,384 EXPECT THAT PROBLEM TO BE 3661 02:10:56,384 --> 02:10:58,686 SOLVED. 3662 02:10:58,686 --> 02:11:01,623 >> ALEXANDER: IN TERMS OF 3663 02:11:01,623 --> 02:11:02,857 IDENTIFYING SAMPLES TO 3664 02:11:02,857 --> 02:11:04,726 SEQUENCE, WE HOPE THERE'S A 3665 02:11:04,726 --> 02:11:06,161 CONVERSATION WITH THE 3666 02:11:06,161 --> 02:11:07,128 COORDINATING AND SEQUENCING 3667 02:11:07,128 --> 02:11:09,430 CENTERS WHICH SAMPLES WOULD BE 3668 02:11:09,430 --> 02:11:10,632 MOST VALUABLE, DEPENDING WHAT 3669 02:11:10,632 --> 02:11:12,734 KINDS OF QUESTIONS WE WANT 3670 02:11:12,734 --> 02:11:13,101 ANSWERED, RIGHT? 3671 02:11:13,101 --> 02:11:14,836 SO, I DON'T THINK THE LIMITING 3672 02:11:14,836 --> 02:11:16,004 FACTOR WILL BE THE SAMPLES, 3673 02:11:16,004 --> 02:11:18,439 IT'S HOW MUCH MONEY WE COULD 3674 02:11:18,439 --> 02:11:19,073 PUT TOWARDS SEQUENCING THE 3675 02:11:19,073 --> 02:11:23,578 SAMPLES AND THERE WILL HAVE TO 3676 02:11:23,578 --> 02:11:24,813 BE SOME DISCUSSION AND 3677 02:11:24,813 --> 02:11:26,681 TRADE-OFFS IN TERMS OF BREADTH 3678 02:11:26,681 --> 02:11:28,049 AND DEPTH OF THE SAMPLES AND 3679 02:11:28,049 --> 02:11:29,217 WHEN AND WHERE YOU GET THE 3680 02:11:29,217 --> 02:11:32,053 SAMPLES FROM. 3681 02:11:32,053 --> 02:11:34,923 >> JUDY: OKAY, THAT ALWAYS IS 3682 02:11:34,923 --> 02:11:35,190 AN ISSUE. 3683 02:11:35,190 --> 02:11:36,724 I WAS A LITTLE LESS CONCERNED 3684 02:11:36,724 --> 02:11:42,463 WHEN I SAW YOUR SLIDE, KIND OF 3685 02:11:42,463 --> 02:11:44,532 ON THE SEQUENCING CENTER BUDGET 3686 02:11:44,532 --> 02:11:45,300 BEING SUBSTANTIALLY LESS THAN 3687 02:11:45,300 --> 02:11:47,602 THE OUT YEARS BUT IT'S NOT A 3688 02:11:47,602 --> 02:11:48,903 TRIVIAL THING TO GET THE 3689 02:11:48,903 --> 02:11:49,971 SAMPLES. 3690 02:11:49,971 --> 02:11:54,075 >> ALEXANDER: I AGREE. 3691 02:11:54,075 --> 02:11:55,743 >> JEN: NANCY, DO YOU WANT TO 3692 02:11:55,743 --> 02:11:57,645 GO AHEAD? 3693 02:11:57,645 --> 02:11:59,814 >> NANCY: YEAH, SO I JUST HAD A 3694 02:11:59,814 --> 02:12:00,782 COUPLE OF OTHER THOUGHTS AND 3695 02:12:00,782 --> 02:12:01,850 COMMENTS. 3696 02:12:01,850 --> 02:12:06,154 ONE IS THAT, WHILE I CERTAINLY 3697 02:12:06,154 --> 02:12:08,289 AGREE THAT HAVING THE 3698 02:12:08,289 --> 02:12:11,192 COORDINATING CENTER, THE 3699 02:12:11,192 --> 02:12:13,261 COMMUNITY AND COORDINATING 3700 02:12:13,261 --> 02:12:14,162 CENTER AND SEQUENCING CENTER 3701 02:12:14,162 --> 02:12:15,396 GET STARTED FIRST, IT'S GOING 3702 02:12:15,396 --> 02:12:17,498 TO BE IMPORTANT TO HAVE A REAL 3703 02:12:17,498 --> 02:12:19,601 DIALOGUE WITH THE FULL 3704 02:12:19,601 --> 02:12:23,271 COMMUNITY OF SCIENTISTS WHO 3705 02:12:23,271 --> 02:12:26,975 ANTICIPATE USING THE DATA FOR 3706 02:12:26,975 --> 02:12:29,344 THINGS LIKE HOW YOU, THE FINAL 3707 02:12:29,344 --> 02:12:30,879 DECISIONS MADE ON HOW THE DATA 3708 02:12:30,879 --> 02:12:38,720 WILL BE REPRESENTED. 3709 02:12:38,720 --> 02:12:40,889 LIKE WHAT THE POSSIBILITY OF 3710 02:12:40,889 --> 02:12:47,629 STRUCTURAL VARIATION IS AN 3711 02:12:47,629 --> 02:12:50,298 IMPORTANT PART OF EVOLUTION AND 3712 02:12:50,298 --> 02:12:53,167 ADAPTATION. 3713 02:12:53,167 --> 02:12:57,372 IS MEANINGFUL AND REAL. 3714 02:12:57,372 --> 02:13:01,676 SO HOW WE CHOOSE TO REPRESENT 3715 02:13:01,676 --> 02:13:02,577 SEQUENCE VARIATION THESE DAYS 3716 02:13:02,577 --> 02:13:09,284 IS MORE COMPLEX. 3717 02:13:09,284 --> 02:13:13,821 THE SORT OF MORE GRAPHICAL 3718 02:13:13,821 --> 02:13:15,657 SORTS OF INTERFACES ALLOW US TO 3719 02:13:15,657 --> 02:13:18,393 PRESERVE MORE OF THAT 3720 02:13:18,393 --> 02:13:20,428 POTENTIALLY STRUCTURAL 3721 02:13:20,428 --> 02:13:20,695 VARIATION. 3722 02:13:20,695 --> 02:13:23,231 IT COULD TURN OUT TO BE 3723 02:13:23,231 --> 02:13:24,999 IMPORTANT FROM AN EVOLUTIONARY 3724 02:13:24,999 --> 02:13:28,903 PERSPECTIVE. 3725 02:13:28,903 --> 02:13:32,874 SO JUST A HEAD'S UP THAT THERE 3726 02:13:32,874 --> 02:13:37,912 ARE LIKELY TO BE AT LEAST A 3727 02:13:37,912 --> 02:13:42,283 SUBGROUP OF PEOPLE SEEKING A 3728 02:13:42,283 --> 02:13:43,685 MORE COMPLEX ORIENTATION THAN 3729 02:13:43,685 --> 02:13:44,485 MIGHT HAVE ORIGINALLY BEEN 3730 02:13:44,485 --> 02:13:49,991 CONSIDERED. 3731 02:13:49,991 --> 02:13:52,327 I WOULD PREDICT THIS DATABASE 3732 02:13:52,327 --> 02:14:02,770 WOULD GET VERY HEAVY USE. 3733 02:14:03,171 --> 02:14:04,939 HOW THE DATA GETS REPRESENTED 3734 02:14:04,939 --> 02:14:07,575 IS OF EXTREME INTEREST TO THE 3735 02:14:07,575 --> 02:14:08,476 SCIENTISTS DEVELOPING THE 3736 02:14:08,476 --> 02:14:09,377 ANALYTIC TECHNOLOGIES FOR 3737 02:14:09,377 --> 02:14:13,815 LOOKING AT THESE POPULATIONS 3738 02:14:13,815 --> 02:14:15,216 AND TRYING TO UNDERSTAND 3739 02:14:15,216 --> 02:14:16,884 ORIGINS AND ADAPTATIONS AND SO 3740 02:14:16,884 --> 02:14:17,085 FORTH. 3741 02:14:17,085 --> 02:14:20,989 SO I JUST THINK THERE HAS TO BE 3742 02:14:20,989 --> 02:14:22,557 A LOT OF COMMUNICATION AS THE 3743 02:14:22,557 --> 02:14:26,227 DATA START TO BE STORED. 3744 02:14:26,227 --> 02:14:29,263 BECAUSE YOU DON'T WANT 3745 02:14:29,263 --> 02:14:31,232 DECISIONS THAT CAN'T BE 3746 02:14:31,232 --> 02:14:32,400 READDRESSED WITHOUT GREAT 3747 02:14:32,400 --> 02:14:33,267 EXPENSE LATER, AS PEOPLE YOU 3748 02:14:33,267 --> 02:14:35,870 KNOW, TRY TO DO ANALYSES. 3749 02:14:35,870 --> 02:14:36,471 AND THE RELEVANT DATA AREN'T 3750 02:14:36,471 --> 02:14:39,407 THERE. 3751 02:14:39,407 --> 02:14:43,111 SO THAT'S ONE THING. 3752 02:14:43,111 --> 02:14:46,714 THE OTHER THING, THE OTHER 3753 02:14:46,714 --> 02:14:50,818 WORRISOME THING IS STARTING TO 3754 02:14:50,818 --> 02:14:55,623 HAPPEN IN SOME PLACES IS THE 3755 02:14:55,623 --> 02:14:57,025 LOCAL COMMUNITIES ARE NOT 3756 02:14:57,025 --> 02:15:00,895 ALWAYS IN AGREEMENT ABOUT WHO 3757 02:15:00,895 --> 02:15:04,399 HAS, WHO SHOULD HAVE THE SAY IN 3758 02:15:04,399 --> 02:15:05,867 WHAT HAPPENS TO LOCAL ANCIENT 3759 02:15:05,867 --> 02:15:10,838 DNA SAMPLES. 3760 02:15:10,838 --> 02:15:12,206 SO I THINK THAT WOULDN'T COME 3761 02:15:12,206 --> 02:15:13,908 AS A SURPRISE TO ANYBODY WHO 3762 02:15:13,908 --> 02:15:14,409 HAS DONE THIS COMMUNITY 3763 02:15:14,409 --> 02:15:15,243 RESEARCH. 3764 02:15:15,243 --> 02:15:19,047 BUT I THINK IT DOES ADD AN 3765 02:15:19,047 --> 02:15:23,618 ELEMENT OF POTENTIALLY OF TIME 3766 02:15:23,618 --> 02:15:26,254 TO THE COLLECTION OF OF 3767 02:15:26,254 --> 02:15:30,491 SPECIMENS BECAUSE THERE HAVE TO 3768 02:15:30,491 --> 02:15:31,959 BE ADJUDICATIONS ABOUT WHO ALL 3769 02:15:31,959 --> 02:15:36,964 HAS A SAY IN HOW THINGS GET 3770 02:15:36,964 --> 02:15:42,303 DECIDED. 3771 02:15:42,303 --> 02:15:43,271 I THINK AN AGGRESSIVE TIMELINE 3772 02:15:43,271 --> 02:15:48,709 IS A GOOD THING TO PURSUE. 3773 02:15:48,709 --> 02:15:52,647 BUT I THINK THERE'S, IT IS IN 3774 02:15:52,647 --> 02:15:59,554 SOME AREAS GOING TO BE 3775 02:15:59,554 --> 02:16:00,521 COMPLICATED ABOUT DECISION 3776 02:16:00,521 --> 02:16:06,994 MAKING ABOUT WHO GETS TO SAY, 3777 02:16:06,994 --> 02:16:10,465 WHO GETS THESE FINAL 3778 02:16:10,465 --> 02:16:12,767 SUGGESTIONS FOR HOW DNA COULD 3779 02:16:12,767 --> 02:16:14,135 BE USED. 3780 02:16:14,135 --> 02:16:15,536 I DON'T THINK THIS IS SOMETHING 3781 02:16:15,536 --> 02:16:17,705 THAT WOULDN'T HAVE COME UP IN 3782 02:16:17,705 --> 02:16:21,476 SOME OF THESE DISCUSSIONS. 3783 02:16:21,476 --> 02:16:29,750 IT'S JUST REMINDING EVERYBODY 3784 02:16:29,750 --> 02:16:31,919 THAT THE TIMELINES CAN GET 3785 02:16:31,919 --> 02:16:33,721 COMPLICATED FOR CERTAIN AREAS. 3786 02:16:33,721 --> 02:16:34,655 I'M SO GRATEFUL SOMEONE HAS 3787 02:16:34,655 --> 02:16:38,192 TAKEN THIS ON. 3788 02:16:38,192 --> 02:16:40,561 IT'S A HEAVY LIFT AND TAKES 3789 02:16:40,561 --> 02:16:41,963 EXPERTISE TO EVEN DEVELOP THE 3790 02:16:41,963 --> 02:16:43,798 CONCEPT FOR A PROPOSAL SO MY 3791 02:16:43,798 --> 02:16:44,999 HAT'S REALLY OFF TO THE GROUP. 3792 02:16:44,999 --> 02:16:49,003 I THINK IT IS LONG OVERDUE 3793 02:16:49,003 --> 02:16:52,206 BECAUSE PEOPLE HAVE BEEN 3794 02:16:52,206 --> 02:16:53,040 DESPERATE FOR THESE DATA FOR 3795 02:16:53,040 --> 02:16:54,542 SOME TIME. 3796 02:16:54,542 --> 02:16:57,245 I'M REALLY GLAD THAT NHGRI IS 3797 02:16:57,245 --> 02:16:58,646 TRYING TO TAKE A LEADERSHIP 3798 02:16:58,646 --> 02:16:59,680 ROLE HERE, I THINK IT'S A 3799 02:16:59,680 --> 02:17:00,314 REALLY GOOD THING. 3800 02:17:00,314 --> 02:17:02,116 THANKS. 3801 02:17:02,116 --> 02:17:02,950 >> ALEXANDER: A COUPLE THINGS 3802 02:17:02,950 --> 02:17:04,519 TO THINK ABOUT IT. 3803 02:17:04,519 --> 02:17:08,689 DURING THE FIRST YEAR, THE 3804 02:17:08,689 --> 02:17:09,190 COORDINATION AND DATA 3805 02:17:09,190 --> 02:17:11,292 PRODUCTION CENTER CAN DO SOME 3806 02:17:11,292 --> 02:17:12,527 OUTREACH TO THE RESEARCH 3807 02:17:12,527 --> 02:17:14,128 COMMUNITY ASKING THEM WHAT 3808 02:17:14,128 --> 02:17:14,929 THEIR INTERESTS AND PRIORITIES 3809 02:17:14,929 --> 02:17:17,431 ARE IN TERMS OF THE DATA SO THE 3810 02:17:17,431 --> 02:17:18,966 DECISION MAKING IS NOT INTERNAL 3811 02:17:18,966 --> 02:17:20,801 TO THE NETWORK ITSELF. 3812 02:17:20,801 --> 02:17:21,402 IT DOES INVOLVE THE LARGER 3813 02:17:21,402 --> 02:17:22,336 COMMUNITY. 3814 02:17:22,336 --> 02:17:24,839 SO THAT'S A GOOD THING TO 3815 02:17:24,839 --> 02:17:26,174 INCORPORATE EARLY ON. 3816 02:17:26,174 --> 02:17:26,807 SO THAT'S A BROADER 3817 02:17:26,807 --> 02:17:30,211 CONVERSATION. 3818 02:17:30,211 --> 02:17:34,148 IN TERMS OF ESTABLISHING NEW 3819 02:17:34,148 --> 02:17:34,882 RELATIONSHIPS AND WITH 3820 02:17:34,882 --> 02:17:36,050 DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES, I THINK 3821 02:17:36,050 --> 02:17:37,051 GIVEN THE SHORT TIMELINE WHAT 3822 02:17:37,051 --> 02:17:38,886 WE WOULD LIKE TO DO FOR THE 3823 02:17:38,886 --> 02:17:42,590 COORDINATION CENTER IS REALLY 3824 02:17:42,590 --> 02:17:44,225 LOOK FOR INVESTIGATORS THAT 3825 02:17:44,225 --> 02:17:45,626 HAVE ALREADY ESTABLISHED 3826 02:17:45,626 --> 02:17:46,460 RELATIONSHIPS AND NETWORKS WITH 3827 02:17:46,460 --> 02:17:47,261 DIFFERENT COMMUNITIES. 3828 02:17:47,261 --> 02:17:48,930 THEY HAVE THAT TRUST ALREADY. 3829 02:17:48,930 --> 02:17:51,532 SO WE CAN SORT OF HIT THE 3830 02:17:51,532 --> 02:17:52,767 GROUND RUNNING WITH THOSE 3831 02:17:52,767 --> 02:17:57,471 RELATIONSHIPS ALREADY THERE. 3832 02:17:57,471 --> 02:18:00,241 BUT IT MIGHT BE THE CASE THERE 3833 02:18:00,241 --> 02:18:05,313 MIGHT BE SOME REGIONS OR AGES 3834 02:18:05,313 --> 02:18:06,681 THAT THE RESEARCHERS IDENTIFY 3835 02:18:06,681 --> 02:18:08,683 AS CRITICAL AND THEY WILL NEED 3836 02:18:08,683 --> 02:18:09,884 TO ESTABLISH NEW RELATIONSHIPS 3837 02:18:09,884 --> 02:18:11,185 AND NEW NETWORKS. 3838 02:18:11,185 --> 02:18:14,155 THAT'S SOMETHING, ONCE THEY ARE 3839 02:18:14,155 --> 02:18:15,022 THERE, FUTURE PROGRAMS CAN THEN 3840 02:18:15,022 --> 02:18:17,191 WORK WITH THEM. 3841 02:18:17,191 --> 02:18:18,859 BUT I THINK USING ESTABLISHED 3842 02:18:18,859 --> 02:18:19,794 RELATIONSHIPS AND BUILDING NEW 3843 02:18:19,794 --> 02:18:21,963 ONES, I THINK WOULD BE VERY 3844 02:18:21,963 --> 02:18:24,832 HELPFUL FOR FUTURE PROJECTS AS 3845 02:18:24,832 --> 02:18:29,770 WELL. 3846 02:18:29,770 --> 02:18:31,839 >> JEN: GO AHEAD, BRUCE. 3847 02:18:31,839 --> 02:18:34,242 >> BRUCE: I THINK THIS IS A 3848 02:18:34,242 --> 02:18:35,209 REALLY FASCINATING AREA, AND 3849 02:18:35,209 --> 02:18:36,043 IT'S ONE I DON'T KNOW VERY MUCH 3850 02:18:36,043 --> 02:18:37,278 ABOUT. 3851 02:18:37,278 --> 02:18:38,813 SOME OF THESE POINTS MAY BE A 3852 02:18:38,813 --> 02:18:40,314 LITTLE BIT NAIVE. 3853 02:18:40,314 --> 02:18:42,683 FIRST OF ALL, IT STRIKES ME IN 3854 02:18:42,683 --> 02:18:43,818 A WAY YOU COULD CONCEPTUALIZE 3855 02:18:43,818 --> 02:18:45,319 THIS AS LOOKING AT THE PAN 3856 02:18:45,319 --> 02:18:48,422 GENOME IN THE FOURTH DIMENSION. 3857 02:18:48,422 --> 02:18:51,158 NAMELY A DIMENSION OF TIME. 3858 02:18:51,158 --> 02:18:55,162 AND I WONDER IN THE COURSE OF 3859 02:18:55,162 --> 02:18:56,897 WHERE SAMPLES ARE OBTAINED FROM 3860 02:18:56,897 --> 02:19:00,167 NOT ONLY IS IT IMPORTANT TO 3861 02:19:00,167 --> 02:19:03,504 LOOK AT GEOGRAPHICAL DIVERSITY, 3862 02:19:03,504 --> 02:19:14,048 BUT ALSO, THERE MUST BE 3863 02:19:14,048 --> 02:19:15,583 CLIMACTIC EVENTS, ICE AGE IS 3864 02:19:15,583 --> 02:19:17,451 ONE ONE WOULD WANT TO BE 3865 02:19:17,451 --> 02:19:19,687 LOOKING AT IN CONTEXT OF HUMAN 3866 02:19:19,687 --> 02:19:19,954 EVOLUTION. 3867 02:19:19,954 --> 02:19:21,822 I DON'T KNOW HOW FEASIBLE THIS 3868 02:19:21,822 --> 02:19:24,058 IS, THIS IS WHERE MY NAIVITY 3869 02:19:24,058 --> 02:19:26,360 WILL SHOW. 3870 02:19:26,360 --> 02:19:30,531 I THINK HUMANS HAVE CO-EVOLVED 3871 02:19:30,531 --> 02:19:30,965 WITH MICROORGANISMS. 3872 02:19:30,965 --> 02:19:32,967 I AM WONDERING IF THERE ARE 3873 02:19:32,967 --> 02:19:34,302 WAYS OF PARALLELING SOME OF THE 3874 02:19:34,302 --> 02:19:37,071 FINDINGS OF WAYS OF LOOKING AT 3875 02:19:37,071 --> 02:19:37,938 EVOLUTION OF MICROORGANISMS 3876 02:19:37,938 --> 02:19:39,840 THAT WOULD HAVE PROBABLY HAD A 3877 02:19:39,840 --> 02:19:41,509 BIG IMPACT ON HUMAN HEALTH OVER 3878 02:19:41,509 --> 02:19:45,346 THE COURSE OF THE AGES. 3879 02:19:45,346 --> 02:19:46,213 >> ALEXANDER: YEAH, SO ONE, 3880 02:19:46,213 --> 02:19:49,717 REASON WHY MOST OF THE 3881 02:19:49,717 --> 02:19:53,554 SEQUENCING HAS BEEN TARGETED IS 3882 02:19:53,554 --> 02:20:00,761 MUCH OF THE ANCIENT DNA HAVE 3883 02:20:00,761 --> 02:20:02,029 CONTAMINATION, MOSTLY MICROBIAL. 3884 02:20:02,029 --> 02:20:03,731 WE WILL SEQUENCE THAT WE WON'T 3885 02:20:03,731 --> 02:20:07,101 THROW AWAY BUT WILL BE THERE TO 3886 02:20:07,101 --> 02:20:09,503 ANALYZE IN TANDEM WITH THE 3887 02:20:09,503 --> 02:20:10,604 ANCIENT HUMAN DNA THAT'S A 3888 02:20:10,604 --> 02:20:12,840 RESOURCE WE CAN PRESENT TO THE 3889 02:20:12,840 --> 02:20:19,847 COMMUNITY. 3890 02:20:19,847 --> 02:20:22,883 >> JEN: KELLY? 3891 02:20:22,883 --> 02:20:24,518 >> KELLY: FOLLOWING A LITTLE 3892 02:20:24,518 --> 02:20:26,153 BIT UP ON WHAT BRUCE SAID AND 3893 02:20:26,153 --> 02:20:28,089 ALSO THE COMMENT ABOUT THE 3894 02:20:28,089 --> 02:20:29,890 DEFINITION OF ANCIENT GENOMES 3895 02:20:29,890 --> 02:20:32,259 BEING MORE THAN 500 YEARS, I'M 3896 02:20:32,259 --> 02:20:33,894 WONDERING IF IT WOULD MAKE 3897 02:20:33,894 --> 02:20:36,230 SENSE TO EVEN PULL THAT 3898 02:20:36,230 --> 02:20:38,566 TIMELINE IN, OR IF THAT'S A 3899 02:20:38,566 --> 02:20:40,768 HARD TIMELINE CUT-OFF FOR THE 3900 02:20:40,768 --> 02:20:41,335 RFA. 3901 02:20:41,335 --> 02:20:42,269 BECAUSE I THINK THERE'S 3902 02:20:42,269 --> 02:20:49,610 PROBABLY BEEN A LOT OF 3903 02:20:49,610 --> 02:20:51,212 EVOLUTIONARY PRESSURE OVER THE 3904 02:20:51,212 --> 02:20:53,514 LAST 400 YEARS AS POPULATIONS 3905 02:20:53,514 --> 02:20:54,915 HAVE MADE MAJOR MIGRATIONS 3906 02:20:54,915 --> 02:20:56,917 AROUND THE WORLD AND IMPACTED 3907 02:20:56,917 --> 02:21:02,990 OTHER POPULATIONS. 3908 02:21:02,990 --> 02:21:07,495 TO ACTUALLY BE ABLE TO GET A 3909 02:21:07,495 --> 02:21:09,830 TIME LINE OF WHEN THE SELECTION 3910 02:21:09,830 --> 02:21:11,265 PRESSURES OCCURRED, IT MIGHT BE 3911 02:21:11,265 --> 02:21:13,100 IMPORTANT TO PULL THAT TIMELINE 3912 02:21:13,100 --> 02:21:16,103 INTO MAYBE 200 YEARS. 3913 02:21:16,103 --> 02:21:18,105 ALTHOUGH WE OBVIOUSLY DON'T 3914 02:21:18,105 --> 02:21:19,340 WANT TO BE SEQUENCING. 3915 02:21:19,340 --> 02:21:21,675 YOU DON'T WANT TO SPEND YOUR 3916 02:21:21,675 --> 02:21:24,745 ENTIRE BUDGET SEQUENCING PEOPLE 3917 02:21:24,745 --> 02:21:25,179 FROM 200 YEARS AGO. 3918 02:21:25,179 --> 02:21:26,313 BUT I'M WONDERING IF PULLING 3919 02:21:26,313 --> 02:21:29,784 THAT IN A LITTLE BIT WOULD HELP 3920 02:21:29,784 --> 02:21:33,954 RESOLVE SOME OF THE QUESTIONS. 3921 02:21:33,954 --> 02:21:35,623 >> ALEXANDER: YOU MIGHT HAVE 3922 02:21:35,623 --> 02:21:38,859 NOTICED I SAID ANCIENT AND 3923 02:21:38,859 --> 02:21:40,060 HISTORICAL DNA. 3924 02:21:40,060 --> 02:21:41,662 WE CONSIDER HISTORICAL DNA 3925 02:21:41,662 --> 02:21:43,230 ANYTHING YOUNGER THAN 500 YEARS 3926 02:21:43,230 --> 02:21:44,965 SO THAT WOULD ALSO BE A TARGET. 3927 02:21:44,965 --> 02:21:46,167 THEN IT WOULD BE UP TO THE 3928 02:21:46,167 --> 02:21:47,501 NETWORK TO DETERMINE THE 3929 02:21:47,501 --> 02:21:49,870 BALANCE OF HOW MUCH HISTORICAL, 3930 02:21:49,870 --> 02:21:51,071 VERSUS HOW MUCH ANCIENT AND HOW 3931 02:21:51,071 --> 02:21:54,809 FAR BACK TO GO. 3932 02:21:54,809 --> 02:21:55,943 WITH THE HISTORICAL DNA, IT'S 3933 02:21:55,943 --> 02:21:57,812 MUCH EASIER TO SORT OF 3934 02:21:57,812 --> 02:21:58,479 COMMUNICATE WITH LOCAL 3935 02:21:58,479 --> 02:22:00,581 COMMUNITIES AND SORT OF 3936 02:22:00,581 --> 02:22:03,150 DETERMINE WHO HAS SORT OF 3937 02:22:03,150 --> 02:22:04,652 SOVEREIGNTY AND CLAIM OVER DATA. 3938 02:22:04,652 --> 02:22:05,886 ONCE YOU START GOING FURTHER 3939 02:22:05,886 --> 02:22:06,487 BACK IT BECOMES MUCH MORE 3940 02:22:06,487 --> 02:22:07,721 DIFFICULT. 3941 02:22:07,721 --> 02:22:10,090 IN SOME CASES THERE WILL BE 3942 02:22:10,090 --> 02:22:11,058 POPULATIONS THAT NO LONGER 3943 02:22:11,058 --> 02:22:12,893 EXIST, SO WHO IS SPEAKING FOR 3944 02:22:12,893 --> 02:22:14,161 THOSE POPULATIONS THAT HAVE 3945 02:22:14,161 --> 02:22:15,996 SORT OF MERGED AND MIXED AND 3946 02:22:15,996 --> 02:22:16,764 NOW EXIST IN A COMPLETELY 3947 02:22:16,764 --> 02:22:17,832 DIFFERENT FORM. 3948 02:22:17,832 --> 02:22:19,233 SO THOSE ARE THE TYPE OF 3949 02:22:19,233 --> 02:22:20,901 QUESTIONS THEY WILL HAVE TO 3950 02:22:20,901 --> 02:22:31,045 ADDRESS. 3951 02:22:31,579 --> 02:22:36,817 >> JEN: ANYONE ELSE WANT TO SAY 3952 02:22:36,817 --> 02:22:38,118 ANYTHING? 3953 02:22:38,118 --> 02:22:41,255 >> I WILL MAKE A SIDE COMMENT I 3954 02:22:41,255 --> 02:22:49,497 MADE AT MY OPENING REMARKS I 3955 02:22:49,497 --> 02:22:50,898 WAS AT A QUADRENNIAL GROUP, AND 3956 02:22:50,898 --> 02:22:51,966 THEY WERE LOOKING AT THE NATIVE 3957 02:22:51,966 --> 02:22:53,300 DOG. 3958 02:22:53,300 --> 02:22:54,935 THAT WOULDN'T BE PART OF THIS 3959 02:22:54,935 --> 02:22:56,637 PROJECT BUT I TOLD HER I WOULD 3960 02:22:56,637 --> 02:22:57,972 CONNECT WITH YOU, BECAUSE I 3961 02:22:57,972 --> 02:23:00,774 THINK IT WOULD BE INTERESTING 3962 02:23:00,774 --> 02:23:11,051 OUTSIDE THE NIH. 3963 02:23:12,853 --> 02:23:14,088 THINKING OF HAVING A LINKING OF 3964 02:23:14,088 --> 02:23:16,757 SOME OF THAT WOULD BE 3965 02:23:16,757 --> 02:23:18,993 INTERESTING. 3966 02:23:18,993 --> 02:23:19,860 >> ALEXANDER: HOST PATHOGEN 3967 02:23:19,860 --> 02:23:21,595 EVOLUTION, YOU COULD LOOK AT 3968 02:23:21,595 --> 02:23:23,531 EVOLUTION OF DOGS AND HUMANS, 3969 02:23:23,531 --> 02:23:24,899 DOGS AND CATS, TYPES OF 3970 02:23:24,899 --> 02:23:26,867 QUESTIONS I'M SURE INTEREST A 3971 02:23:26,867 --> 02:23:33,073 LOT OF PEOPLE. 3972 02:23:33,073 --> 02:23:34,208 >> JEN: ALL RIGHT. 3973 02:23:34,208 --> 02:23:36,043 MOTION TO APPROVE? 3974 02:23:36,043 --> 02:23:37,344 >> APPROVE. 3975 02:23:37,344 --> 02:23:39,480 >> JEN: AND SECONDED. 3976 02:23:39,480 --> 02:23:41,048 OKAY, ALL IN FAVOR, RAISE YOUR 3977 02:23:41,048 --> 02:23:48,355 HAND? 3978 02:23:48,355 --> 02:23:50,424 GREAT, LOOKS UNANIMOUS. 3979 02:23:50,424 --> 02:23:53,193 AND INTO ECB, IT'S THE ANCIENT 3980 02:23:53,193 --> 02:23:54,128 DNA FOR MODERN GENETICS CONCEPT. 3981 02:23:54,128 --> 02:23:55,596 THE SECOND ONE. 3982 02:23:55,596 --> 02:23:56,764 IF YOU COULD VOTE IN THERE AS 3983 02:23:56,764 --> 02:23:58,599 WELL. 3984 02:23:58,599 --> 02:24:00,968 THANK YOU, ZANDER. 3985 02:24:00,968 --> 02:24:03,270 >> ALEXANDER: THANK YOU, 3986 02:24:03,270 --> 02:24:08,776 EVERYONE. 3987 02:24:08,776 --> 02:24:10,177 >> JEN: I KNOW CAROLYN HAD A 3988 02:24:10,177 --> 02:24:11,946 SLIDE ABOUT ALL THE PEOPLE THAT 3989 02:24:11,946 --> 02:24:12,846 HELPED COUNCIL AT THIS MOMENT 3990 02:24:12,846 --> 02:24:13,881 BECAUSE I HAVE BEEN WATCHING 3991 02:24:13,881 --> 02:24:15,583 HIM, I WANT TO GIVE A SPECIAL 3992 02:24:15,583 --> 02:24:17,952 SHOUT OUT FOR BEN FOR TAKING 3993 02:24:17,952 --> 02:24:18,686 FANTASTIC NOTES FOR OUR MINUTES 3994 02:24:18,686 --> 02:24:20,621 FOR ALL OF THIS. 3995 02:24:20,621 --> 02:24:21,989 I THINK HIS FINGERS ARE MOVING 3996 02:24:21,989 --> 02:24:23,924 FASTER THAN THE SPEED OF LIGHT. 3997 02:24:23,924 --> 02:24:24,758 I THINK HE HAS CAPTURED 3998 02:24:24,758 --> 02:24:27,061 EVERYTHING THAT YOU GUYS HAVE 3999 02:24:27,061 --> 02:24:33,467 SAID. 4000 02:24:33,467 --> 02:24:35,135 >> [OFF MIC] 4001 02:24:35,135 --> 02:24:36,770 >> JEN: FOR YOUR PARENTS TO 4002 02:24:36,770 --> 02:24:37,471 WATCH, YES. 4003 02:24:37,471 --> 02:24:39,873 >> THANK YOU, AND MOM AND DAD, 4004 02:24:39,873 --> 02:24:41,976 IF YOU ARE WATCHING, I DID IT. 4005 02:24:41,976 --> 02:24:44,111 [LAUGHTER] 4006 02:24:44,111 --> 02:24:46,480 >> JEN: ALL RIGHT. 4007 02:24:46,480 --> 02:24:48,816 SO ONTO THE LAST BITS OF 4008 02:24:48,816 --> 02:24:50,451 BUSINESS. 4009 02:24:50,451 --> 02:24:52,319 FIRST OF ALL, OUR WORKING 4010 02:24:52,319 --> 02:24:54,521 GROUPS OF COUNCIL ARE REQUIRED 4011 02:24:54,521 --> 02:24:56,957 TO REPORT TO YOU ONCE A YEAR. 4012 02:24:56,957 --> 02:24:59,193 SO IN YOUR ECB YOU WILL FIND 4013 02:24:59,193 --> 02:25:01,161 REPORTS FROM TWO WORKING GROUPS 4014 02:25:01,161 --> 02:25:02,062 OF COUNCIL, THE GENOMIC 4015 02:25:02,062 --> 02:25:04,465 MEDICINE WORKING GROUP AND THE 4016 02:25:04,465 --> 02:25:05,099 GENOMICS AND SOCIETY WORKING 4017 02:25:05,099 --> 02:25:06,967 GROUP. 4018 02:25:06,967 --> 02:25:08,535 THESE ARE WRITTEN REPORTS THAT 4019 02:25:08,535 --> 02:25:11,805 YOU CAN READ AT YOUR LEISURE 4020 02:25:11,805 --> 02:25:14,141 AND THERE'S NO NEED TO VOTE. 4021 02:25:14,141 --> 02:25:15,442 HOWEVER, TERI AND NICOLE ARE 4022 02:25:15,442 --> 02:25:17,444 AVAILABLE IF YOU HAVE ANY 4023 02:25:17,444 --> 02:25:21,048 QUESTIONS FOR THEM ABOUT THESE 4024 02:25:21,048 --> 02:25:23,617 REPORTS. 4025 02:25:23,617 --> 02:25:25,486 ALL RIGHT. 4026 02:25:25,486 --> 02:25:27,321 FIVE SECONDS WITH NO QUESTIONS. 4027 02:25:27,321 --> 02:25:31,358 WE ARE GOING TO MOVE ON. 4028 02:25:31,358 --> 02:25:32,793 WE DO, WE ARE REQUIRED TO GET A 4029 02:25:32,793 --> 02:25:36,397 VOTE FROM YOU THAT YOU HAVE 4030 02:25:36,397 --> 02:25:41,135 SEEN AND REVIEWED THE TRIENNIAL 4031 02:25:41,135 --> 02:25:44,905 INCLUSION REPORT FOR FY 4032 02:25:44,905 --> 02:25:45,172 2022-2024. 4033 02:25:45,172 --> 02:25:47,274 WE HAVE COME TO COUNCIL EVERY 4034 02:25:47,274 --> 02:25:50,611 THREE YEARS WITH THIS REPORT TO 4035 02:25:50,611 --> 02:25:54,715 DOCUMENT THAT ALL THE STUDIES 4036 02:25:54,715 --> 02:25:57,484 THAT WE HAVE CONDUCTED HAVE 4037 02:25:57,484 --> 02:25:59,787 APPROPRIATE INCLUSION OF STUDY 4038 02:25:59,787 --> 02:26:00,054 SUBJECTS. 4039 02:26:00,054 --> 02:26:03,557 AND SO, I'M GOING TO ASK FOR A 4040 02:26:03,557 --> 02:26:04,658 MOTION TO APPROVE THE TRIENNIAL 4041 02:26:04,658 --> 02:26:08,162 INCLUSION REPORT. 4042 02:26:08,162 --> 02:26:12,866 AND I WANT TO GIVE A SHOUT OUT 4043 02:26:12,866 --> 02:26:14,968 TO JAMAL SCOTT, WHO IS, DO YOU 4044 02:26:14,968 --> 02:26:19,740 WANT TO- 4045 02:26:19,740 --> 02:26:24,278 >> JAMAL SCOTT, CHRISTINA CHANG 4046 02:26:24,278 --> 02:26:25,045 AND PEDIMINA, ARE THE ONE WHO'S 4047 02:26:25,045 --> 02:26:25,846 DID IT. 4048 02:26:25,846 --> 02:26:28,215 >> JEN: WE PUT IT IN THE 4049 02:26:28,215 --> 02:26:29,817 COUNCIL BOOK BUT THEY PULLED IT 4050 02:26:29,817 --> 02:26:31,051 ALL TOGETHER AND DID QUITE A 4051 02:26:31,051 --> 02:26:33,587 BIT OF WORK ON THAT. 4052 02:26:33,587 --> 02:26:36,090 CAN I HAVE A MOTION TO INCLUDE 4053 02:26:36,090 --> 02:26:38,859 THE INCLUSION REPORT. 4054 02:26:38,859 --> 02:26:40,260 FROM NANCY AND SECOND. 4055 02:26:40,260 --> 02:26:40,561 ALL APPROVE? 4056 02:26:40,561 --> 02:26:42,396 THANK YOU. 4057 02:26:42,396 --> 02:26:50,370 THAT'S UNITED KINGDOM AGAIN. 4058 02:26:50,370 --> 02:26:54,007 ALSO DO THAT IN COUNCIL BOOK. 4059 02:26:54,007 --> 02:26:56,744 WE WILL THEN MOVE ON TO THE 4060 02:26:56,744 --> 02:26:57,711 MOST EXCITING PART. 4061 02:26:57,711 --> 02:27:00,047 OUR ANNUAL REVIEW OF THE 4062 02:27:00,047 --> 02:27:01,749 STATEMENT OF UNDERSTANDING 4063 02:27:01,749 --> 02:27:06,186 BETWEEN COUNCIL AND NHGRI. 4064 02:27:06,186 --> 02:27:07,554 SO AGAIN, THIS COMES TO YOU ALL 4065 02:27:07,554 --> 02:27:09,456 ONCE A YEAR TO MAKE SURE THAT 4066 02:27:09,456 --> 02:27:12,459 WE ARE ALL IN AGREEMENT ON OUR 4067 02:27:12,459 --> 02:27:15,028 TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF WHAT 4068 02:27:15,028 --> 02:27:16,930 THE COUNCIL WILL APPROVE. 4069 02:27:16,930 --> 02:27:18,065 AND THIS WOULD HAVE COME TO 4070 02:27:18,065 --> 02:27:19,199 FEBRUARY BUT WE DIDN'T HAVE AN 4071 02:27:19,199 --> 02:27:22,035 OPEN SESSION IN FEBRUARY. 4072 02:27:22,035 --> 02:27:24,171 SO, THE STATEMENT OF 4073 02:27:24,171 --> 02:27:25,305 UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN THE 4074 02:27:25,305 --> 02:27:27,040 NATIONAL ADVISORY COUNCIL FOR 4075 02:27:27,040 --> 02:27:28,909 HOME GENOME RESEARCH AND THE 4076 02:27:28,909 --> 02:27:32,780 STAFF OF THE NATIONAL HUMAN 4077 02:27:32,780 --> 02:27:33,914 GENOME RESEARCH INSTITUTE. 4078 02:27:33,914 --> 02:27:36,216 OUR UNDERSTANDING IS THAT ALL 4079 02:27:36,216 --> 02:27:38,285 APPLICATIONS THAT HAVE 4080 02:27:38,285 --> 02:27:39,686 UNDERGONE THE INITIAL PEER 4081 02:27:39,686 --> 02:27:40,754 REVIEW WILL ALSO BE REVIEWED BY 4082 02:27:40,754 --> 02:27:45,659 COUNCIL. 4083 02:27:45,659 --> 02:27:47,528 EXCEPTIONS ARE APPLICATIONS FOR 4084 02:27:47,528 --> 02:27:48,061 FELLOWSHIPS, INTRAMURAL 4085 02:27:48,061 --> 02:27:55,702 RESEARCH THAT GOES ON AT NHGRI, 4086 02:27:55,702 --> 02:27:57,404 INTERAND INTRA AGENCY CONTRACTS. 4087 02:27:57,404 --> 02:27:59,473 AND THAT APPLICATIONS THAT HAVE 4088 02:27:59,473 --> 02:28:02,309 NOT BEEN IDENTIFIED FOR 4089 02:28:02,309 --> 02:28:02,910 INDIVIDUAL CONSIDERATION ARE 4090 02:28:02,910 --> 02:28:07,247 REVIEWED ON BLOCK. 4091 02:28:07,247 --> 02:28:08,015 THE FOLLOWING TYPES OF 4092 02:28:08,015 --> 02:28:10,017 APPLICATIONS WILL NOT BE IN THE 4093 02:28:10,017 --> 02:28:11,385 ON BLOCK VOTE BUT WILL ALWAYS 4094 02:28:11,385 --> 02:28:12,953 BE BROUGHT BEFORE YOU. 4095 02:28:12,953 --> 02:28:14,955 FOR INSTANCE, THE THINGS THAT 4096 02:28:14,955 --> 02:28:17,157 WE BROUGHT YESTERDAY. 4097 02:28:17,157 --> 02:28:20,093 THESE ARE ALL APPLICATIONS FOR 4098 02:28:20,093 --> 02:28:22,229 PROGRAM CONTRACTS, CENTERS AND 4099 02:28:22,229 --> 02:28:24,798 THE COOPERATIVE AGREEMENT OR U 4100 02:28:24,798 --> 02:28:27,301 COUNTERPARTS. 4101 02:28:27,301 --> 02:28:29,903 TRAINING, THE T32'S, AND ANY 4102 02:28:29,903 --> 02:28:31,171 COOPERATIVE AGREEMENT ON WHICH 4103 02:28:31,171 --> 02:28:33,707 NHGRI IS THE PRIMARY INSTITUTE. 4104 02:28:33,707 --> 02:28:35,375 WHERE WE ARE SECONDARY, IT WILL 4105 02:28:35,375 --> 02:28:37,344 GO TO THE COUNCIL OF THE 4106 02:28:37,344 --> 02:28:42,716 INSTITUTION THAT IS PRIMARY. 4107 02:28:42,716 --> 02:28:44,384 ALL APPLICATIONS THAT ARE 4108 02:28:44,384 --> 02:28:45,752 IDENTIFIED BY EITHER COUNCIL OR 4109 02:28:45,752 --> 02:28:48,589 STAFF TO BE OF SPECIAL CONCERN 4110 02:28:48,589 --> 02:28:50,424 OR POSING SPECIAL POLICY ISSUES. 4111 02:28:50,424 --> 02:28:51,592 SO WE WILL SOMETIMES IDENTIFY 4112 02:28:51,592 --> 02:28:53,694 THINGS THAT WE WANT TO BRING TO 4113 02:28:53,694 --> 02:28:55,996 YOU, BUT COUNCIL ALWAYS HAS THE 4114 02:28:55,996 --> 02:28:58,699 RIGHT TO RAISE ANY APPLICATION 4115 02:28:58,699 --> 02:28:59,633 THAT IS BEING CONSIDERED FOR 4116 02:28:59,633 --> 02:29:01,501 DISCUSSION. 4117 02:29:01,501 --> 02:29:05,005 EVEN IF NHGRI STAFF HAS NOT 4118 02:29:05,005 --> 02:29:05,839 DECIDED TO BRING THEM IN FRONT 4119 02:29:05,839 --> 02:29:09,042 OF YOU. 4120 02:29:09,042 --> 02:29:11,178 IF ANY APPLICATION HAS 4121 02:29:11,178 --> 02:29:12,579 PREVIOUSLY BEEN DEFERRED BY 4122 02:29:12,579 --> 02:29:13,981 COUNCIL FOR ADDITIONAL 4123 02:29:13,981 --> 02:29:14,815 INFORMATION OR RE-REVIEW, THAT 4124 02:29:14,815 --> 02:29:17,718 WOULD COME TO YOU. 4125 02:29:17,718 --> 02:29:19,152 ANY APPLICATIONS IN WHICH 4126 02:29:19,152 --> 02:29:21,255 UNRESOLVED CONCERNS HAVE BEEN 4127 02:29:21,255 --> 02:29:22,222 IDENTIFIED BY THE INITIAL 4128 02:29:22,222 --> 02:29:25,292 REVIEW GROUP, WITH RESPECT TO 4129 02:29:25,292 --> 02:29:27,828 ANIMAL WELFARE, HUMAN SUBJECTS, 4130 02:29:27,828 --> 02:29:29,263 ETHICAL ISSUES, RECOMBINANT 4131 02:29:29,263 --> 02:29:31,398 DNA, POTENTIAL BIO HAZARD OR 4132 02:29:31,398 --> 02:29:34,368 INCLUSION OR LACK OF WOMEN, 4133 02:29:34,368 --> 02:29:35,002 MINORS, MINORITIES IN CLINICAL 4134 02:29:35,002 --> 02:29:36,236 RESEARCH. 4135 02:29:36,236 --> 02:29:38,338 ANY APPLICATION FROM A FOREIGN 4136 02:29:38,338 --> 02:29:40,040 INSTITUTION FOR WHICH AN AWARD 4137 02:29:40,040 --> 02:29:41,575 IS PLANNED NEEDS TO HAVE A 4138 02:29:41,575 --> 02:29:43,677 FOREIGN JUSTIFICATION. 4139 02:29:43,677 --> 02:29:46,780 ANY APPLICATION WHERE THE TOTAL 4140 02:29:46,780 --> 02:29:49,149 NIH SUPPORT FOR THE PRINCIPAL'S 4141 02:29:49,149 --> 02:29:50,951 INVESTIGATOR ACTIVE ELIGIBLE 4142 02:29:50,951 --> 02:29:52,352 GRANTS ALREADY EXCEEDS $2 4143 02:29:52,352 --> 02:29:54,688 MILLION TOTAL COST AND THIS IS 4144 02:29:54,688 --> 02:29:57,057 BEING CONSIDERED BY FUNDING, 4145 02:29:57,057 --> 02:29:58,825 THIS IS NIH SPECIAL COUNCIL 4146 02:29:58,825 --> 02:29:59,059 REVIEW. 4147 02:29:59,059 --> 02:30:00,861 I WILL NOTE FOR THE AUDIENCE 4148 02:30:00,861 --> 02:30:03,363 WATCHING THAT FOR THIS YEAR, 4149 02:30:03,363 --> 02:30:06,833 FY' 25, THE REQUIREMENT TO DO 4150 02:30:06,833 --> 02:30:10,170 SPECIAL COUNCIL REVIEW WAS 4151 02:30:10,170 --> 02:30:12,205 WAIVED BY O.E.R., OR THE OFFICE 4152 02:30:12,205 --> 02:30:17,477 OF EXTRAMURAL RESEARCH. 4153 02:30:17,477 --> 02:30:19,780 WE AT NHGRI CONSIDER THAT 4154 02:30:19,780 --> 02:30:26,586 SPECIAL COUNCIL REVIEW IS NOT 4155 02:30:26,586 --> 02:30:28,021 NECESSARY FOR SUBJECTS OF 4156 02:30:28,021 --> 02:30:29,690 APPLICANTS CE IS, THEY ARE 4157 02:30:29,690 --> 02:30:31,825 ALREADY REQUIRED TO BE HIGHLY 4158 02:30:31,825 --> 02:30:32,793 INNOVATIVE AND TRANSFORMATIVE 4159 02:30:32,793 --> 02:30:33,727 WHICH IS THE REQUIREMENT, THAT 4160 02:30:33,727 --> 02:30:36,063 THE BAR THAT NEEDS TO BE PASSED 4161 02:30:36,063 --> 02:30:37,698 FOR SOMETHING TO MERIT BEING 4162 02:30:37,698 --> 02:30:39,132 FUNDED DESPITE BEING MORE THAN 4163 02:30:39,132 --> 02:30:40,500 $2 MILLION. 4164 02:30:40,500 --> 02:30:44,404 SO THEY ALREADY MEET THE SCR 4165 02:30:44,404 --> 02:30:45,605 CRITERIA AS UNIQUE RESEARCH 4166 02:30:45,605 --> 02:30:46,573 OPPORTUNITIES THAT ARE DISTINCT 4167 02:30:46,573 --> 02:30:48,742 FROM ANY OTHER AWARDS THAT THE 4168 02:30:48,742 --> 02:30:53,013 P.I. HAS ALREADY RECEIVED. 4169 02:30:53,013 --> 02:30:58,585 WE ALSO AGREE THAT ACTIVE GRANT 4170 02:30:58,585 --> 02:31:01,188 AWARDS THAT HAVE PROJECT PERIOD 4171 02:31:01,188 --> 02:31:03,423 END DATES WITHIN 90 DAYS OF THE 4172 02:31:03,423 --> 02:31:05,125 COUNCIL MEETING DON'T NEED TO 4173 02:31:05,125 --> 02:31:06,493 BE INCLUDED BECAUSE THOSE 4174 02:31:06,493 --> 02:31:09,930 AWARDS WOULD BE OVER BEFORE THE 4175 02:31:09,930 --> 02:31:12,065 RENEWAL AWARD WOULD START. 4176 02:31:12,065 --> 02:31:14,801 ALL RIGHT, SO THE FOLLOWING 4177 02:31:14,801 --> 02:31:15,969 OPTIONS ARE ALWAYS AVAILABLE 4178 02:31:15,969 --> 02:31:17,371 FOR COUNCIL FOR APPLICATIONS 4179 02:31:17,371 --> 02:31:18,739 THAT WE HAVE DISCUSSED. 4180 02:31:18,739 --> 02:31:20,874 YOU CAN CONCUR WITH THE 4181 02:31:20,874 --> 02:31:23,243 RECOMMENDATION OF THE INITIAL 4182 02:31:23,243 --> 02:31:27,247 REVIEW GROUP, OR THE I.R.G. 4183 02:31:27,247 --> 02:31:28,849 AND WITH OR WITHOUT ANY 4184 02:31:28,849 --> 02:31:29,583 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR CHANGES OR 4185 02:31:29,583 --> 02:31:31,651 FUNDING AMOUNT. 4186 02:31:31,651 --> 02:31:33,954 YOU CAN DEFER THE APPLICATION 4187 02:31:33,954 --> 02:31:36,323 FOR RE-REVIEW BECAUSE YOU FEEL 4188 02:31:36,323 --> 02:31:39,092 THERE WAS AN INADEQUATE INITIAL 4189 02:31:39,092 --> 02:31:40,394 REVIEW. 4190 02:31:40,394 --> 02:31:42,295 IF ASKED BY NHGRI STAFF, YOU 4191 02:31:42,295 --> 02:31:45,298 CAN RECOMMEND FOR HIGH OR LOW 4192 02:31:45,298 --> 02:31:48,135 PROGRAM PRIORITY, IN TERMS OF 4193 02:31:48,135 --> 02:31:48,635 FUNDING CONSIDERATIONS. 4194 02:31:48,635 --> 02:31:51,238 OR YOU CAN DEFER YOUR DECISION 4195 02:31:51,238 --> 02:31:52,806 AND ASK FOR MORE INFORMATION AT 4196 02:31:52,806 --> 02:31:54,408 A FUTURE MEETING. 4197 02:31:54,408 --> 02:31:56,043 SO THOSE ARE YOUR OPTIONS FOR 4198 02:31:56,043 --> 02:31:59,646 ANY VOTE THAT WE TAKE. 4199 02:31:59,646 --> 02:32:06,686 I WANT TO BRING SPECIAL 4200 02:32:06,686 --> 02:32:09,056 ATTENTION TO EXPEDITED COUNCIL 4201 02:32:09,056 --> 02:32:10,223 CONCURRENCE, OR EXPEDITED 4202 02:32:10,223 --> 02:32:12,059 REVIEW PROCESS BECAUSE IT IS 4203 02:32:12,059 --> 02:32:13,226 SOMETHING THAT WE PROBABLY WILL 4204 02:32:13,226 --> 02:32:15,362 USE A LITTLE BIT MORE AND A 4205 02:32:15,362 --> 02:32:16,897 LITTLE BIT DIFFERENTLY IN THE 4206 02:32:16,897 --> 02:32:20,767 FUTURE. 4207 02:32:20,767 --> 02:32:22,936 SO, NIH HAS AUTHORIZED THE USE 4208 02:32:22,936 --> 02:32:24,371 OF EXPEDITED REVIEW PROCESSES 4209 02:32:24,371 --> 02:32:26,440 TO IMPROVE THE EFFICIENCY AND 4210 02:32:26,440 --> 02:32:27,040 TIMELINESS OF MAKING CERTAIN 4211 02:32:27,040 --> 02:32:29,042 AWARDS. 4212 02:32:29,042 --> 02:32:31,344 THIS IS CALLED EXPEDITED 4213 02:32:31,344 --> 02:32:33,180 COUNCIL CONCURRENCE, AND IS 4214 02:32:33,180 --> 02:32:35,549 EXPECTED TO OCCUR ONCE EACH 4215 02:32:35,549 --> 02:32:36,516 COUNCIL ROUND, APPROXIMATELY 4216 02:32:36,516 --> 02:32:37,217 FOUR WEEKS BEFORE THE SCHEDULED 4217 02:32:37,217 --> 02:32:41,021 MEETING. 4218 02:32:41,021 --> 02:32:43,190 SO GENERALLY, WE USE ECC FOR 4219 02:32:43,190 --> 02:32:45,092 THE FOLLOWING TYPES OF 4220 02:32:45,092 --> 02:32:50,797 APPLICATIONS. 4221 02:32:50,797 --> 02:32:51,765 UNSOLICITED ELSI EXCEPT T32 4222 02:32:51,765 --> 02:32:54,634 WHICH ARE REQUIRED TO COME TO 4223 02:32:54,634 --> 02:32:54,868 COUNCIL. 4224 02:32:54,868 --> 02:32:56,736 SBIR. 4225 02:32:56,736 --> 02:32:57,637 CONFERENCE APPLICATIONS BECAUSE 4226 02:32:57,637 --> 02:32:59,106 THOSE ARE, YOU KNOW, HAVE A 4227 02:32:59,106 --> 02:33:00,807 TIME LIMIT AND NEED TO GET OUT 4228 02:33:00,807 --> 02:33:02,075 QUICKLY. 4229 02:33:02,075 --> 02:33:04,911 CAREER DEVELOPMENT APPLICATIONS. 4230 02:33:04,911 --> 02:33:09,116 SO K'S AND F'S. 4231 02:33:09,116 --> 02:33:09,783 UNSOLICITED RESEARCH 4232 02:33:09,783 --> 02:33:12,152 APPLICATIONS AND IN THE PAST WE 4233 02:33:12,152 --> 02:33:20,527 HAVE USED THIS FOR RO3 AND R21 4234 02:33:20,527 --> 02:33:21,795 WE ADDED UNSOLICITED RO1 AS 4235 02:33:21,795 --> 02:33:32,139 THINGS WE CAN BRING. 4236 02:33:32,806 --> 02:33:34,841 UNSOLICITED R 25. 4237 02:33:34,841 --> 02:33:36,943 AND ANY APPLICATION 4238 02:33:36,943 --> 02:33:37,844 ACCIDENTALLY OR THROUGH 4239 02:33:37,844 --> 02:33:39,012 ADMINISTRATIVE ERROR LEFT OFF 4240 02:33:39,012 --> 02:33:41,348 OF A PRIOR COUNCIL ROUND. 4241 02:33:41,348 --> 02:33:42,082 OCCASIONALLY THINGS SLIP 4242 02:33:42,082 --> 02:33:43,917 THROUGH THE CRACKS AND WE DON'T 4243 02:33:43,917 --> 02:33:45,585 WANT TO MAKE THE APPLICANTS 4244 02:33:45,585 --> 02:33:47,220 WAIT FOR A LONG TIME. 4245 02:33:47,220 --> 02:33:55,228 SO WE WILL BRING THOSE TO YOU. 4246 02:33:55,228 --> 02:33:57,097 SO THE SUBCOMMITTEE CONSISTS OF 4247 02:33:57,097 --> 02:33:57,797 3-4 COUNCILMEMBERS AND THANK 4248 02:33:57,797 --> 02:34:01,234 YOU TO THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE ON 4249 02:34:01,234 --> 02:34:02,269 OUR E.C.C. SUBCOMMITTEE WITH 4250 02:34:02,269 --> 02:34:03,336 BROAD EXPERTISE. 4251 02:34:03,336 --> 02:34:10,477 I THINK WE HAVE THAT HERE. 4252 02:34:10,477 --> 02:34:11,611 AND EACH SEPTEMBER WE WILL 4253 02:34:11,611 --> 02:34:18,218 REVIEW THAT AND GET NEW MEMBERS. 4254 02:34:18,218 --> 02:34:20,086 SO, HERE IS WHERE I WANT TO 4255 02:34:20,086 --> 02:34:22,722 BRING ATTENTION TO WHERE WE 4256 02:34:22,722 --> 02:34:24,925 MIGHT WANT TO USE THIS SOMEWHAT 4257 02:34:24,925 --> 02:34:25,692 DIFFERENTLY. 4258 02:34:25,692 --> 02:34:28,828 NORMALLY WE DO THIS PRIOR TO 4259 02:34:28,828 --> 02:34:30,664 COUNCIL. 4260 02:34:30,664 --> 02:34:32,732 HOWEVER, OTHER IC'S HAVE USED 4261 02:34:32,732 --> 02:34:35,502 IT ALSO TO DO IT AFTER OR AT 4262 02:34:35,502 --> 02:34:36,870 OTHER TIMES IN BETWEEN COUNCILS 4263 02:34:36,870 --> 02:34:40,106 WHEN IT BECAME NECESSARY. 4264 02:34:40,106 --> 02:34:42,175 AND AS YOU WILL KNOW WE HAD 4265 02:34:42,175 --> 02:34:43,643 SITUATIONS WHEN WE COULDN'T 4266 02:34:43,643 --> 02:34:44,878 HOLD COUNCILS WHEN WE EXPECTED 4267 02:34:44,878 --> 02:34:46,846 TO AND HAVE THE ABILITY TO USE 4268 02:34:46,846 --> 02:34:49,849 ECC IN THAT TIME WOULD HAVE 4269 02:34:49,849 --> 02:34:50,317 EXPEDITED SOME OF OUR 4270 02:34:50,317 --> 02:34:51,484 GRANTMAKING. 4271 02:34:51,484 --> 02:34:53,620 SO WHILE IT IS TYPICALLY ONE 4272 02:34:53,620 --> 02:34:55,055 MONTH PRIOR TO THE FEBRUARY, 4273 02:34:55,055 --> 02:34:56,790 MAY OR SEPTEMBER COUNCILS IT IS 4274 02:34:56,790 --> 02:34:57,857 NOT ALWAYS THAT TIME. 4275 02:34:57,857 --> 02:35:00,193 SO I JUST WANT TO BRING THAT TO 4276 02:35:00,193 --> 02:35:02,062 YOUR ATTENTION THAT WE MIGHT 4277 02:35:02,062 --> 02:35:03,930 INVOKE THIS AT OTHER TIMES 4278 02:35:03,930 --> 02:35:05,098 DURING THE YEAR, DEPENDING ON 4279 02:35:05,098 --> 02:35:05,565 NECESSITY. 4280 02:35:05,565 --> 02:35:07,300 WE NEVER HAVE IN THE PAST. 4281 02:35:07,300 --> 02:35:11,104 WE MAY IN THE FUTURE. 4282 02:35:11,104 --> 02:35:14,374 SO, YOU WILL GET FOR E.C.C. 4283 02:35:14,374 --> 02:35:16,009 CONCURRENCE, THE APPLICATION 4284 02:35:16,009 --> 02:35:17,644 NUMBER, P.I., INSTITUTION NAME, 4285 02:35:17,644 --> 02:35:20,747 PROJECT TITLE, IMPACT SCORE AND 4286 02:35:20,747 --> 02:35:21,114 PERCENTILE RANK. 4287 02:35:21,114 --> 02:35:22,315 IN MOST CASES YOU WILL ALSO 4288 02:35:22,315 --> 02:35:22,882 HAVE ACCESS TO THE SUMMARY 4289 02:35:22,882 --> 02:35:23,917 STATEMENT. 4290 02:35:23,917 --> 02:35:26,953 AND YOU ARE EXPECTED TO RESPOND 4291 02:35:26,953 --> 02:35:28,355 WITHIN SEVEN DAYS, IF THE 4292 02:35:28,355 --> 02:35:30,991 E.C.C. MEMBER DOES NOT RESPOND 4293 02:35:30,991 --> 02:35:32,792 WITHIN SEVEN DAYS IT'S 4294 02:35:32,792 --> 02:35:34,427 CONSIDERED AN EXTENSION. 4295 02:35:34,427 --> 02:35:36,329 AND WE WILL BASE THE VOTE ON 4296 02:35:36,329 --> 02:35:36,963 THE MAJORITY OF THE VOTES 4297 02:35:36,963 --> 02:35:43,536 RECEIVED. 4298 02:35:43,536 --> 02:35:46,506 ANY E.C.C. MEMBER CAN PULL AN 4299 02:35:46,506 --> 02:35:47,907 APPLICATION OFF THE LIST THAT 4300 02:35:47,907 --> 02:35:50,710 WE HAVE SENT YOU AND SAY, I 4301 02:35:50,710 --> 02:35:52,112 THINK THIS REALLY NEEDS TO GO 4302 02:35:52,112 --> 02:35:52,979 TO FULL COUNCIL AND HAVE A 4303 02:35:52,979 --> 02:35:53,780 DISCUSSION. 4304 02:35:53,780 --> 02:35:55,315 AND THAT IS FINE, YOU ALWAYS 4305 02:35:55,315 --> 02:35:56,816 HAVE THAT RIGHT TO RAISE A 4306 02:35:56,816 --> 02:35:58,218 PARTICULAR APPLICATION. 4307 02:35:58,218 --> 02:35:59,886 AND THEN THESE RECOMMENDATIONS 4308 02:35:59,886 --> 02:36:01,921 ARE ALL DOCUMENTED AND WILL BE 4309 02:36:01,921 --> 02:36:02,889 PRESENTED AT THE NEXT FULL 4310 02:36:02,889 --> 02:36:10,463 COUNCIL MEETING. 4311 02:36:10,463 --> 02:36:11,865 WE ALSO HAVE SOME 4312 02:36:11,865 --> 02:36:12,766 ADMINISTRATIVE AUTHORITIES 4313 02:36:12,766 --> 02:36:14,234 GENERALLY TO PROVIDE 4314 02:36:14,234 --> 02:36:15,135 SUPPLEMENTS AND OTHER MONETARY 4315 02:36:15,135 --> 02:36:16,236 ACTIONS THAT DO NOT NEED TO 4316 02:36:16,236 --> 02:36:17,737 COME TO COUNCIL. 4317 02:36:17,737 --> 02:36:20,106 SO DURING THE COURSE OF A 4318 02:36:20,106 --> 02:36:21,508 RESEARCH PROJECT A PRINCIPLE 4319 02:36:21,508 --> 02:36:23,310 INVESTIGATOR MAY REQUEST 4320 02:36:23,310 --> 02:36:25,078 ADDITIONAL FUNDS THROUGH AN 4321 02:36:25,078 --> 02:36:26,212 ADMINISTRATIVE RESUPPLEMENT AS 4322 02:36:26,212 --> 02:36:27,280 LONG AS THE WORK PROPOSED 4323 02:36:27,280 --> 02:36:29,816 DOESN'T EXPAND THE SCOPE OF THE 4324 02:36:29,816 --> 02:36:32,152 PROJECT BEYOND THAT WHICH WAS 4325 02:36:32,152 --> 02:36:33,086 PEER REVIEWED AND APPROVED BY 4326 02:36:33,086 --> 02:36:35,221 COUNCIL. 4327 02:36:35,221 --> 02:36:37,123 STAFF OF THE NHGRI WILL ANALYZE 4328 02:36:37,123 --> 02:36:40,160 AND REVIEW THE BUDGETS OF ALL 4329 02:36:40,160 --> 02:36:40,727 ADMINISTRATIVE SUPPLEMENT 4330 02:36:40,727 --> 02:36:41,361 APPLICATIONS BEFORE ISSUING ANY 4331 02:36:41,361 --> 02:36:41,995 AWARD. 4332 02:36:41,995 --> 02:36:44,331 SPECIAL NOTE IS MADE OF ANY 4333 02:36:44,331 --> 02:36:45,565 ITEMS REQUIRING ADJUSTMENT OF 4334 02:36:45,565 --> 02:36:48,068 AMOUNTS OR OTHER TERMS AND 4335 02:36:48,068 --> 02:36:50,136 CONDITIONS, THEY WILL NEGOTIATE 4336 02:36:50,136 --> 02:36:51,304 APPROPRIATE ADJUSTMENTS FOR 4337 02:36:51,304 --> 02:36:54,541 SUCH THINGS AS OVERLAPPING OR 4338 02:36:54,541 --> 02:36:55,775 DUPLICATE SUPPORT, INACCURATE 4339 02:36:55,775 --> 02:36:58,845 COST ESTIMATES OR ADJUSTMENTS 4340 02:36:58,845 --> 02:37:00,313 NECESSITATED BY THE RECOVERY OF 4341 02:37:00,313 --> 02:37:01,881 INDIRECT COSTS. 4342 02:37:01,881 --> 02:37:04,484 STAFF WILL ALSO MAKE 4343 02:37:04,484 --> 02:37:05,485 ADJUSTMENTS TO RECONCILE 4344 02:37:05,485 --> 02:37:06,586 INCONSISTENCIES BETWEEN 4345 02:37:06,586 --> 02:37:07,087 RECOMMENDED BUDGETS AND 4346 02:37:07,087 --> 02:37:10,323 RECOMMENDED ACTIVITIES. 4347 02:37:10,323 --> 02:37:11,324 SUPPLEMENTS FOR INITIATIVES TO 4348 02:37:11,324 --> 02:37:12,926 NHGRI AWARD WITHIN THE SCOPE OF 4349 02:37:12,926 --> 02:37:14,561 THE AWARD BUT FUNDED BY 4350 02:37:14,561 --> 02:37:16,162 INSTITUTES OR AGENCIES OTHER 4351 02:37:16,162 --> 02:37:19,499 THAN NHGRI DO NOT NEED COUNCIL 4352 02:37:19,499 --> 02:37:19,766 APPROVAL. 4353 02:37:19,766 --> 02:37:20,367 THE SUPPLEMENT WILL BE 4354 02:37:20,367 --> 02:37:21,801 DOCUMENTED AND REPORTED TO 4355 02:37:21,801 --> 02:37:23,236 COUNCIL FOR ITS INFORMATION AT 4356 02:37:23,236 --> 02:37:23,703 THE FIRST APPROPRIATE 4357 02:37:23,703 --> 02:37:26,773 OPPORTUNITY. 4358 02:37:26,773 --> 02:37:28,908 NHGRI MAY PROVIDE SUPPLEMENTS 4359 02:37:28,908 --> 02:37:32,379 TO GRANT AWARDS FUNDED BY OTHER 4360 02:37:32,379 --> 02:37:33,113 NHGRI INSTITUTES OR HHS 4361 02:37:33,113 --> 02:37:35,382 AGENCIES AS LONG AS WE ARE 4362 02:37:35,382 --> 02:37:37,016 ASSIGNED DUAL IC AND THE GRANT 4363 02:37:37,016 --> 02:37:39,252 HAS BEEN APPROVED BY THEIR 4364 02:37:39,252 --> 02:37:40,520 COUNCIL. 4365 02:37:40,520 --> 02:37:42,255 SO STAFF MAY MAKE SUPPLEMENTAL 4366 02:37:42,255 --> 02:37:43,656 AWARDS THAT ARE ABOVE THE LEVEL 4367 02:37:43,656 --> 02:37:44,724 RECOMMENDED BY THE COUNCIL AT 4368 02:37:44,724 --> 02:37:46,426 THE TIME OF THE INITIAL AWARD 4369 02:37:46,426 --> 02:37:47,927 AS LONG AS THAT GRANT HAS BEEN 4370 02:37:47,927 --> 02:37:53,400 APPROVED BY COUNCIL. 4371 02:37:53,400 --> 02:37:54,834 THESE SUPPLEMENTS ARE GENERALLY 4372 02:37:54,834 --> 02:37:56,736 TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF UNEXPECTED 4373 02:37:56,736 --> 02:37:58,171 SCIENTIFIC OPPORTUNITIES THAT 4374 02:37:58,171 --> 02:37:59,305 HAVE THE POTENTIAL TO 4375 02:37:59,305 --> 02:38:01,641 ACCELERATE THE COMPLETION OF 4376 02:38:01,641 --> 02:38:04,878 SCIENTIFIC GOALS, OR TO PROVIDE 4377 02:38:04,878 --> 02:38:06,079 AN EXTENSION WITH FUNDS FROM 4378 02:38:06,079 --> 02:38:08,181 ONE YEAR. 4379 02:38:08,181 --> 02:38:10,583 IT SHALL NOT EXCEED THE CURRENT 4380 02:38:10,583 --> 02:38:11,785 LEVEL OF SUPPORT FOR THE 4381 02:38:11,785 --> 02:38:22,228 DURATION OF THE EXTENSION. 4382 02:38:22,996 --> 02:38:26,733 AN EXTENSION COULD BE MADE WITH 4383 02:38:26,733 --> 02:38:28,134 A COMPETING APPLICATION IS 4384 02:38:28,134 --> 02:38:33,640 REFERRED FOR RIO -- REVIEW, 4385 02:38:33,640 --> 02:38:34,974 WE DID A LOT OF THESE DURING 4386 02:38:34,974 --> 02:38:36,776 COVID. 4387 02:38:36,776 --> 02:38:40,013 EXCEPTIONAL SITUATION. 4388 02:38:40,013 --> 02:38:41,981 OR ANTICIPATION OF FUTURE 4389 02:38:41,981 --> 02:38:42,849 FUNDING WHEN CONTINUING FUNDING 4390 02:38:42,849 --> 02:38:45,285 APPLICATION WILL NOT BE PAID. 4391 02:38:45,285 --> 02:38:46,119 THOSE ARE THE SITUATIONS IN 4392 02:38:46,119 --> 02:38:49,222 WHICH WE DO THAT. 4393 02:38:49,222 --> 02:38:50,857 ALL SUPPLEMENT REQUESTS ARE 4394 02:38:50,857 --> 02:38:52,025 REVIEWED BY THE EXTRAMURAL 4395 02:38:52,025 --> 02:38:53,927 LEADERSHIP TEAM AND MUST BE 4396 02:38:53,927 --> 02:38:56,463 APPROVED BY THE E.L.T. BEFORE 4397 02:38:56,463 --> 02:38:58,364 AN AWARD MAY BE MADE AND 4398 02:38:58,364 --> 02:38:59,732 REGARDLESS OF THE AMOUNT WE 4399 02:38:59,732 --> 02:39:03,336 REPORT THESE TO YOU AT THE NEXT 4400 02:39:03,336 --> 02:39:04,904 POSSIBLE ADVISORY COUNCIL 4401 02:39:04,904 --> 02:39:09,576 MEETING. 4402 02:39:09,576 --> 02:39:11,945 THERE ARE OTHER SPECIAL 4403 02:39:11,945 --> 02:39:13,112 CATEGORIES OF SUPPLEMENTS STAFF 4404 02:39:13,112 --> 02:39:15,281 CAN MAKE, GENERALLY TO RESPOND 4405 02:39:15,281 --> 02:39:17,217 TO NIH-WIDE INITIATIVES. 4406 02:39:17,217 --> 02:39:22,055 THAT OCCUR. 4407 02:39:22,055 --> 02:39:24,791 SOME OF THOSE ARE CHANGING SO 4408 02:39:24,791 --> 02:39:27,227 I'M NOT READING THEM OUT ALL OF 4409 02:39:27,227 --> 02:39:28,328 THEM FOR YOU. 4410 02:39:28,328 --> 02:39:32,031 SO ALL OF THE ANY TIME THAT WE, 4411 02:39:32,031 --> 02:39:34,133 IN ANY OF THESE CIRCUMSTANCES 4412 02:39:34,133 --> 02:39:35,835 ARE SPECIAL FUNDING 4413 02:39:35,835 --> 02:39:36,703 OPPORTUNITIES WE PROVIDE 4414 02:39:36,703 --> 02:39:38,771 SUPPLEMENTAL FUNDING, WE WILL 4415 02:39:38,771 --> 02:39:39,772 BE DOCUMENTING AND PRESENTING 4416 02:39:39,772 --> 02:39:40,940 THESE TO YOU AT THE NEXT 4417 02:39:40,940 --> 02:39:45,178 COUNCIL MEETING. 4418 02:39:45,178 --> 02:39:47,814 NOW THERE ARE REQUESTS FOR 4419 02:39:47,814 --> 02:39:48,882 ADMINISTRATIVE INCREASES WHICH 4420 02:39:48,882 --> 02:39:51,217 EXCEED THE AMOUNTS OF THE 4421 02:39:51,217 --> 02:39:52,385 INITIAL AWARD. 4422 02:39:52,385 --> 02:39:54,921 AND IN THOSE CASES, WE WILL 4423 02:39:54,921 --> 02:39:56,890 COME TO COUNCIL FOR ADVICE AND 4424 02:39:56,890 --> 02:39:57,524 RECOMMENDATION BEFORE WE WOULD 4425 02:39:57,524 --> 02:40:00,193 FUND THEM. 4426 02:40:00,193 --> 02:40:05,298 BUT THOSE REQUESTS THAT DO NOT 4427 02:40:05,298 --> 02:40:05,965 EXCEED COUNCIL ADMINISTRATIVE 4428 02:40:05,965 --> 02:40:07,934 AMOUNTS ARE ONLY IF THEY MARK 4429 02:40:07,934 --> 02:40:09,636 EXPANSION OR SIGNIFICANT CHANGE 4430 02:40:09,636 --> 02:40:12,305 TO THE CONTENT OR IF STAFF 4431 02:40:12,305 --> 02:40:13,606 DETERMINES THEY INVOLVE ISSUES 4432 02:40:13,606 --> 02:40:14,974 ON WHICH COUNCIL SHOULD BE 4433 02:40:14,974 --> 02:40:19,546 CONSULTED. 4434 02:40:19,546 --> 02:40:22,181 SOMETIMES WE CAN DO THOSE 4435 02:40:22,181 --> 02:40:24,484 CONSULTATIONS BY EMAIL IF IT'S 4436 02:40:24,484 --> 02:40:26,085 AN ISSUE OF TIME SENSITIVITY. 4437 02:40:26,085 --> 02:40:28,721 SO THAT'S ANOTHER WAY IN WHICH 4438 02:40:28,721 --> 02:40:30,590 WE MAY OCCASIONALLY REACH OUT 4439 02:40:30,590 --> 02:40:31,724 TO YOU BETWEEN COUNCILS AND ASK 4440 02:40:31,724 --> 02:40:35,562 YOU TO WEIGH IN ON SOMETHING. 4441 02:40:35,562 --> 02:40:37,163 THERE ARE ALSO EXCEPTIONAL 4442 02:40:37,163 --> 02:40:41,100 SITUATIONS. 4443 02:40:41,100 --> 02:40:42,268 EXPEDITED COUNCIL REVIEW, 4444 02:40:42,268 --> 02:40:43,703 REQUESTS BETWEEN COUNCIL 4445 02:40:43,703 --> 02:40:45,605 MEETINGS MAY BE INITIATED UNDER 4446 02:40:45,605 --> 02:40:47,540 CERTAIN SITUATIONS MAY INCLUDE 4447 02:40:47,540 --> 02:40:48,207 TIME SENSITIVE REQUESTS, 4448 02:40:48,207 --> 02:40:49,175 APPLICATIONS RESPONDING TO 4449 02:40:49,175 --> 02:40:51,177 REQUEST FOR APPLICATIONS OR 4450 02:40:51,177 --> 02:40:53,813 LETTERS OF INVITATION, OR 4451 02:40:53,813 --> 02:40:54,480 UNSOLICITED GRANT APPLICATIONS 4452 02:40:54,480 --> 02:40:56,316 THAT ARE BELIEVED BY THE 4453 02:40:56,316 --> 02:40:59,118 DIRECTOR OF NHGRI, THE DIRECTOR 4454 02:40:59,118 --> 02:41:01,621 OF NIH OR DESIGNEE TO ADDRESS A 4455 02:41:01,621 --> 02:41:05,058 PUBLIC HEALTH EMERGENCY OR 4456 02:41:05,058 --> 02:41:05,692 REPRESENTING OPPORTUNITIES IN 4457 02:41:05,692 --> 02:41:07,126 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH THAT WOULD 4458 02:41:07,126 --> 02:41:08,661 HAVE A SIGNIFICANT PUBLIC 4459 02:41:08,661 --> 02:41:09,696 HEALTH OR TRANSNIH IMPACT. 4460 02:41:09,696 --> 02:41:13,433 IN THE CASE OF A CRISIS OR 4461 02:41:13,433 --> 02:41:15,301 STATE OF EMERGENCY, INCLUDING 4462 02:41:15,301 --> 02:41:16,102 PANDEMIC, TERRORISM, ACTS OF 4463 02:41:16,102 --> 02:41:18,605 NATURE, ET CETERA OR TO REDUCE 4464 02:41:18,605 --> 02:41:19,305 TRAVEL BURDEN FOR 4465 02:41:19,305 --> 02:41:20,239 COUNCILMEMBERS AND THIS IS NOW 4466 02:41:20,239 --> 02:41:24,544 SORT OF RUN OF THE MILL BUT 4467 02:41:24,544 --> 02:41:27,013 USED TO BE SOMETHING WE NEEDED 4468 02:41:27,013 --> 02:41:29,349 AN AGREEMENT, COUNCIL MEETINGS 4469 02:41:29,349 --> 02:41:32,752 COULD BE CONDUCTED VIRTUALLY 4470 02:41:32,752 --> 02:41:33,353 USING SECURED VIRTUAL MEETING 4471 02:41:33,353 --> 02:41:35,321 PLATFORMS. 4472 02:41:35,321 --> 02:41:38,758 THREE OR MORE COUNCILMEMBERS 4473 02:41:38,758 --> 02:41:41,561 WITH THE APPROPRIATE EXPERTISE 4474 02:41:41,561 --> 02:41:42,562 AND REPUTATION WILL SECONDARY 4475 02:41:42,562 --> 02:41:44,797 REVIEW FOR ON BLOCK OR 4476 02:41:44,797 --> 02:41:45,665 INDIVIDUAL CONSIDERATION. 4477 02:41:45,665 --> 02:41:47,233 ALL RIGHT, SO WE WOULD LIKE 4478 02:41:47,233 --> 02:41:49,002 YOUR APPROVAL ON THE STATEMENT 4479 02:41:49,002 --> 02:41:50,837 OF UNDERSTANDING. 4480 02:41:50,837 --> 02:41:53,339 DOES ANYBODY HAVE ANY QUESTIONS 4481 02:41:53,339 --> 02:42:02,749 BEFORE WE GO TO A VOTE? 4482 02:42:02,749 --> 02:42:04,651 ALL RIGHT, MOTION TO APPROVE? 4483 02:42:04,651 --> 02:42:05,385 ALL RIGHT, AND SECONDS. 4484 02:42:05,385 --> 02:42:06,686 ALL IN FAVOR? 4485 02:42:06,686 --> 02:42:08,621 RAISE YOUR HAND. 4486 02:42:08,621 --> 02:42:11,658 LOOKS UNITED KINGDOM. 4487 02:42:11,658 --> 02:42:14,494 -- UNANIMOUS. 4488 02:42:14,494 --> 02:42:16,963 NOW PLEASE ENTER YOUR VOTES IN 4489 02:42:16,963 --> 02:42:17,864 ECB. 4490 02:42:17,864 --> 02:42:20,400 AND THAT IS YOUR LAST NEED TO 4491 02:42:20,400 --> 02:42:21,601 USE ECB THIS COUNCIL ROUND. 4492 02:42:21,601 --> 02:42:23,703 YOU WILL BE HAPPY TO HEAR. 4493 02:42:23,703 --> 02:42:25,772 AND THE FINAL ORDER OF BUSINESS 4494 02:42:25,772 --> 02:42:29,509 IS JUST TO GO OVER WHAT WE HOPE 4495 02:42:29,509 --> 02:42:31,411 TO BE OUR FUTURE MEETING DATES. 4496 02:42:31,411 --> 02:42:33,279 I NO LONGER PREDICT WHEN OUR 4497 02:42:33,279 --> 02:42:35,682 MEETING DATES ARE BECAUSE THEY 4498 02:42:35,682 --> 02:42:36,115 HAVE CHANGED A LOT. 4499 02:42:36,115 --> 02:42:38,017 AND THANK YOU ALL, BY THE WAY, 4500 02:42:38,017 --> 02:42:38,985 FOR YOUR FLEXIBILITY IN 4501 02:42:38,985 --> 02:42:43,056 ADAPTING AND THEN TO MY AMAZING 4502 02:42:43,056 --> 02:42:44,924 TEAM, COUNCIL COORDINATORS, AND 4503 02:42:44,924 --> 02:42:47,894 ALL THE HELPERS AND OUR I.T. 4504 02:42:47,894 --> 02:42:50,663 TEAM WHO HAVE ALSO ADAPTED TO 4505 02:42:50,663 --> 02:42:51,931 THE CONSTANTLY CHANGING NEEDS 4506 02:42:51,931 --> 02:42:58,004 OF COUNCIL THIS YEAR. 4507 02:42:58,004 --> 02:43:00,606 THE NEXT COUNCIL THAT WE HOPE 4508 02:43:00,606 --> 02:43:04,777 TO HAVE IN PERSON IS SEPTEMBER 4509 02:43:04,777 --> 02:43:08,047 15th-16th, 2025. 4510 02:43:08,047 --> 02:43:11,984 AFTER THAT, FEBRUARY 9-10, 2026. 4511 02:43:11,984 --> 02:43:16,189 MAY 18-19, 2026 4512 02:43:16,189 --> 02:43:18,758 SEPTEMBER 28-29, 2026 AND 4513 02:43:18,758 --> 02:43:20,693 FEBRUARY 8-9, 2027. 4514 02:43:20,693 --> 02:43:21,427 AND WE HAVE NOT SCHEDULED 4515 02:43:21,427 --> 02:43:23,763 BEYOND THAT. 4516 02:43:23,763 --> 02:43:27,633 IF YOU DO NOT HAVE THEM ON YOUR 4517 02:43:27,633 --> 02:43:28,201 CALENDARS, CONTACT COMFORT 4518 02:43:28,201 --> 02:43:29,736 BROWN AND SHE WILL MAKE SURE 4519 02:43:29,736 --> 02:43:34,273 THAT THEY ARE THERE. 4520 02:43:34,273 --> 02:43:36,909 DO YOU WANT TO CLOSE US OUT, 4521 02:43:36,909 --> 02:43:38,611 CAROLYN? 4522 02:43:38,611 --> 02:43:42,081 GO AHEAD, JUDY. 4523 02:43:42,081 --> 02:43:43,683 >> JUDY: FOR FEBRUARY 2026 FOR 4524 02:43:43,683 --> 02:43:45,284 THE OUT GOING GROUP WILL THAT 4525 02:43:45,284 --> 02:43:47,420 BE IN PERSON OR VIRTUAL, OR 4526 02:43:47,420 --> 02:43:48,287 IT'S NOT SETTLED YET? 4527 02:43:48,287 --> 02:43:49,522 >> JEN: I THINK WE WILL 4528 02:43:49,522 --> 02:43:55,795 CONTINUE TO HAVE OUR FEBRUARY 4529 02:43:55,795 --> 02:43:56,229 VIRTUAL BECAUSE OF 4530 02:43:56,229 --> 02:43:56,562 UNCERTAINTIES. 4531 02:43:56,562 --> 02:43:57,163 >> JUDY: OKAY, THANKS. 4532 02:43:57,163 --> 02:44:01,968 >> JEN: THANKS FOR ASKING. 4533 02:44:01,968 --> 02:44:04,270 OH, SORRY, I'M TURNING IT OVER 4534 02:44:04,270 --> 02:44:06,906 TO CAROLYN TO CONDUCT COUNCIL 4535 02:44:06,906 --> 02:44:08,374 INITIATED DISCUSSION, IS WHAT 4536 02:44:08,374 --> 02:44:08,641 I'M DOING. 4537 02:44:08,641 --> 02:44:09,642 >> CAROLYN: HI, EVERYBODY. 4538 02:44:09,642 --> 02:44:13,279 THIS IS JUST TIME FOR 4539 02:44:13,279 --> 02:44:13,913 COUNCILMEMBERS, IF THERE'S ANY 4540 02:44:13,913 --> 02:44:15,548 ITEMS THAT YOU WOULD LIKE TO 4541 02:44:15,548 --> 02:44:17,350 RAISE FOR US THAT WE DIDN'T 4542 02:44:17,350 --> 02:44:19,218 COVER IN TODAY'S AGENDA. 4543 02:44:19,218 --> 02:44:21,654 THIS COULD JUST BE INPUT TO 4544 02:44:21,654 --> 02:44:22,889 NHGRI, REQUESTS FOR TOPICS OR 4545 02:44:22,889 --> 02:44:25,158 THINGS YOU WOULD LIKE US TO 4546 02:44:25,158 --> 02:44:27,560 BRING TO FUTURE COUNCIL 4547 02:44:27,560 --> 02:44:29,562 MEETINGS OR QUESTIONS YOU HAVE 4548 02:44:29,562 --> 02:44:39,972 FOR LEADERSHIP OR STAFF. 4549 02:44:45,411 --> 02:44:47,880 DOESN'T SEEM TO BE ANYTHING, 4550 02:44:47,880 --> 02:44:48,414 WHICH IS COMPLETELY FINE. 4551 02:44:48,414 --> 02:44:52,351 I WILL GIVE YOU ONE MORE SECOND. 4552 02:44:52,351 --> 02:44:54,053 SO, NOW -- 4553 02:44:54,053 --> 02:44:56,322 >> ACTUALLY, I WOULD SAY, ERICA 4554 02:44:56,322 --> 02:44:58,524 ALWAYS ASKS THIS, THERE'S NEW 4555 02:44:58,524 --> 02:44:59,692 LEADERSHIP, ARE THERE ANY 4556 02:44:59,692 --> 02:45:00,793 PEOPLE YOU WOULD BE INTERESTED, 4557 02:45:00,793 --> 02:45:02,829 TIM, GO AHEAD. 4558 02:45:02,829 --> 02:45:04,897 >> TIM: THANK YOU, I WANT TO GO 4559 02:45:04,897 --> 02:45:06,999 ON RECORD SAYING FUNDING IS 4560 02:45:06,999 --> 02:45:09,435 ABSOLUTELY CRITICAL AND ALL OF 4561 02:45:09,435 --> 02:45:10,736 THE TUMULT OVER THE PAST SIX 4562 02:45:10,736 --> 02:45:13,573 MONTHS TO A YEAR HAS BEEN 4563 02:45:13,573 --> 02:45:16,542 DEVASTATING TO NIH RESEARCH AND 4564 02:45:16,542 --> 02:45:18,344 I HOPE THAT THE NIH SEES A 4565 02:45:18,344 --> 02:45:21,547 CLEARER PATH IN THE FUTURE. 4566 02:45:21,547 --> 02:45:31,924 >> CAROLYN: THANK YOU. 4567 02:45:34,260 --> 02:45:35,761 JEN WAS PROMPTING A QUESTION 4568 02:45:35,761 --> 02:45:37,163 WHETHER THERE'S ANY MEMBERS 4569 02:45:37,163 --> 02:45:38,097 OUTSIDE OF NHGRI LEADERSHIP 4570 02:45:38,097 --> 02:45:40,466 THAT YOU WOULD LIKE US TO TRY 4571 02:45:40,466 --> 02:45:43,102 TO ARRANGE COME TO OUR COUNCIL. 4572 02:45:43,102 --> 02:45:45,671 I DID MENTION THAT DR. 4573 02:45:45,671 --> 02:45:46,939 BHATTACHARYA HAS SPOKEN AT A 4574 02:45:46,939 --> 02:45:48,774 COUPLE OF OTHER COUNCILS. 4575 02:45:48,774 --> 02:45:50,209 WE CAN REACH OUT, I DO THINK WE 4576 02:45:50,209 --> 02:45:54,180 WILL BE REACHING OUT TO HIM TO 4577 02:45:54,180 --> 02:45:56,682 GET ON TO THE AGENDA AND TRACK 4578 02:45:56,682 --> 02:45:56,949 FOR THAT. 4579 02:45:56,949 --> 02:45:59,051 I THINK WE DECIDED TO TRY TO 4580 02:45:59,051 --> 02:46:00,720 PREFERENCE THAT FOR A TIME WHEN 4581 02:46:00,720 --> 02:46:03,189 YOU ARE IN PERSON, RATHER THAN 4582 02:46:03,189 --> 02:46:03,422 VIRTUAL. 4583 02:46:03,422 --> 02:46:05,291 BUT IF THERE ARE OTHER PEOPLE 4584 02:46:05,291 --> 02:46:06,459 FROM NIH LEADERSHIP YOU WOULD 4585 02:46:06,459 --> 02:46:09,262 LIKE US TO TRY TO SCHEDULE OR 4586 02:46:09,262 --> 02:46:10,162 BRING TO FUTURE MEETINGS, 4587 02:46:10,162 --> 02:46:11,797 PLEASE LET US KNOW. 4588 02:46:11,797 --> 02:46:13,766 I THINK IN FEBRUARY WE HAD 4589 02:46:13,766 --> 02:46:15,601 JOANIE ON THE DOCKET. 4590 02:46:15,601 --> 02:46:17,970 SO WE MAY REVISIT ALSO WHO WE 4591 02:46:17,970 --> 02:46:20,439 HAD PREVIOUSLY HAD SCHEDULED 4592 02:46:20,439 --> 02:46:22,108 FOR THE COUNCILS THAT SORT OF 4593 02:46:22,108 --> 02:46:28,781 GOT CANCELLED. 4594 02:46:28,781 --> 02:46:30,349 YOU DID HAVE JOANIE? 4595 02:46:30,349 --> 02:46:32,518 I'M SORRY, I LEFT, SO. 4596 02:46:32,518 --> 02:46:33,686 >> YOU KNOW, GIVEN THE 4597 02:46:33,686 --> 02:46:34,620 QUESTIONS THAT PEOPLE HAVE HAD, 4598 02:46:34,620 --> 02:46:36,289 AND I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE RIGHT 4599 02:46:36,289 --> 02:46:38,190 TIMING IS FOR THIS, MAYBE WE 4600 02:46:38,190 --> 02:46:40,526 WAIT FOR MAY OR SEPTEMBER BUT 4601 02:46:40,526 --> 02:46:42,828 IT SEEMS LIKE LEADERSHIP FROM 4602 02:46:42,828 --> 02:46:44,730 CSR, FROM CENTER FOR SCIENTIFIC 4603 02:46:44,730 --> 02:46:45,698 REVIEW MIGHT BE HELPFUL AS THAT 4604 02:46:45,698 --> 02:46:49,936 IS MOVING FORWARD. 4605 02:46:49,936 --> 02:46:57,443 >> YEAH. 4606 02:46:57,443 --> 02:47:00,613 >> JUDY: I GUESS I HAVE A 4607 02:47:00,613 --> 02:47:03,416 QUESTION IF THE NLM, IF THAT 4608 02:47:03,416 --> 02:47:04,850 DIRECTOR, HAS ANYTHING MOVED ON 4609 02:47:04,850 --> 02:47:07,186 THAT? 4610 02:47:07,186 --> 02:47:09,455 >> CAROLYN: YEAH, SO I HAD SORT 4611 02:47:09,455 --> 02:47:11,357 OF ELUDED THAT THERE HAD BEEN 4612 02:47:11,357 --> 02:47:14,327 PEOPLE WHO WERE IN ACTING 4613 02:47:14,327 --> 02:47:16,896 POSITIONS PRIOR TO PREVIOUSLY 4614 02:47:16,896 --> 02:47:22,735 AND SO BOTH NLM AND MENTAL 4615 02:47:22,735 --> 02:47:24,637 HEALTH WERE IN ACTIVE JOB 4616 02:47:24,637 --> 02:47:25,771 SEARCHES AND THOSE GOT CAUGHT 4617 02:47:25,771 --> 02:47:27,306 UP IN THE HIRING FREEZE THAT 4618 02:47:27,306 --> 02:47:31,077 HAPPENED. 4619 02:47:31,077 --> 02:47:32,678 SO MY UNDERSTANDING IS IN 4620 02:47:32,678 --> 02:47:34,180 RESUMING THOSE THEY WON'T BE 4621 02:47:34,180 --> 02:47:35,114 STARTING FROM SCRATCH AND THEY 4622 02:47:35,114 --> 02:47:36,215 WILL BE COMING BACK TO SORT OF 4623 02:47:36,215 --> 02:47:46,492 PICKING THAT UP. 4624 02:47:47,560 --> 02:47:51,430 BUT THERE WAS A HIRING FREEZE. 4625 02:47:51,430 --> 02:47:54,433 SO STEVE SHERRY IS STILL IN THE 4626 02:47:54,433 --> 02:47:56,769 ACTING DIRECTOR POSITION FOR 4627 02:47:56,769 --> 02:48:06,846 NLM. 4628 02:48:07,813 --> 02:48:09,382 OKAY, THANK YOU ALL TO COUNCIL, 4629 02:48:09,382 --> 02:48:11,951 THANK YOU VERY MUCH TO ALL THE 4630 02:48:11,951 --> 02:48:13,452 NHGRI STAFF, BOTH IN FRONT OF 4631 02:48:13,452 --> 02:48:15,121 AND BEHIND THE SCENES WHO MADE 4632 02:48:15,121 --> 02:48:16,956 TODAY SUCH A SUCCESS. 4633 02:48:16,956 --> 02:48:21,961 THANK YOU TO MY LEADERSHIP TEAM. 4634 02:48:21,961 --> 02:48:24,764 THANK YOU TO BEN, ISSIL, NICK, 4635 02:48:24,764 --> 02:48:26,165 COMFORT AND JEN AND THANK YOU 4636 02:48:26,165 --> 02:48:29,035 TO ANYBODY WHO TUNED IN TO 4637 02:48:29,035 --> 02:48:29,602 WATCH, INCLUDING HOPEFULLY, 4638 02:48:29,602 --> 02:48:30,403 ROB'S PARENTS. 4639 02:48:30,403 --> 02:48:34,073 I HOPE EVERYBODY HAS A 4640 02:48:34,073 --> 02:48:37,043 WONDERFUL REST OF THE DAY. 4641 02:48:37,043 --> 02:48:38,411 ENJOY THE JUNETEENTH HOLIDAY 4642 02:48:38,411 --> 02:48:39,278 TOMORROW AND WE WILL REASSEMBLE 4643 02:48:39,278 --> 02:48:41,414 IN SEPTEMBER. 4644 02:48:41,414 --> 02:48:42,114 THANK YOU, ALL. 4645 02:48:42,114 --> 02:48:52,324 [ APPLAUSE ]