1 00:00:05,008 --> 00:00:06,643 GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE. 2 00:00:06,643 --> 00:00:07,911 WELCOME TO NIH COUNCIL OF 3 00:00:07,911 --> 00:00:12,749 COUNCILS. THIS MEETING IS NOW IN 4 00:00:12,749 --> 00:00:17,720 SESSION. I AM NICOLE 5 00:00:17,720 --> 00:00:21,124 KLEINSTREUER, THE ACTING NOOIF 6 00:00:21,124 --> 00:00:24,961 DIRECTOR OF COUNCIL OF COUNCILS. 7 00:00:24,961 --> 00:00:28,464 I'M JOINED BY DR. FRANZISKA 8 00:00:28,464 --> 00:00:30,800 GRIEDER IN THE DIRECTOR OF 9 00:00:30,800 --> 00:00:31,634 OFFICE OF RESEARCH 10 00:00:31,634 --> 00:00:32,769 INFRASTRUCTURE PROGRAMS. 11 00:00:32,769 --> 00:00:34,304 ADDITIONALLY I WOULD LIKE TO 12 00:00:34,304 --> 00:00:36,906 RECOGNIZE MY COLLEAGUES IN THE 13 00:00:36,906 --> 00:00:39,309 ROOM, ROBIN K., DEPUTY DIRECTOR 14 00:00:39,309 --> 00:00:45,014 OF DPCPSI, TAYLOR G., SENIOR 15 00:00:45,014 --> 00:00:46,516 ADVISOR, TINA, PROGRAM ANALYST 16 00:00:46,516 --> 00:00:50,019 AND COUNCIL COORDINATOR AND 17 00:00:50,019 --> 00:00:51,988 GRACE M., HEALTH POLICY ANALYST. 18 00:00:51,988 --> 00:00:54,090 I WOULD LIKE TO THANK THE 19 00:00:54,090 --> 00:00:56,025 COUNCIL TEAM MEMBERS IN SUPPORT 20 00:00:56,025 --> 00:00:58,361 OF ALL THEIR WORK OF THE COUNCIL 21 00:00:58,361 --> 00:01:00,430 ACTIVITIES AND RECOGNIZE THE 22 00:01:00,430 --> 00:01:01,397 LOGISTICS CONTRACTOR FOR COUNCIL 23 00:01:01,397 --> 00:01:04,267 OF COUNCILS, THE CONSULTING 24 00:01:04,267 --> 00:01:06,636 GROUP, OR SCG. BEFORE WE REALLY 25 00:01:06,636 --> 00:01:09,138 GET GOING, LET ME TURN IT OVER 26 00:01:09,138 --> 00:01:10,607 TO FRANZISKA TO REMIND YOU OF A 27 00:01:10,607 --> 00:01:14,844 FEW PROCEDURES BEFORE TAKING 28 00:01:14,844 --> 00:01:17,614 ROLL CALL TO ENSURE THE MEETING 29 00:01:17,614 --> 00:01:21,284 MOVES SMOOTHLY. FRANZISKA THANK 30 00:01:21,284 --> 00:01:26,256 YOU, NICOLE. GOOD MORNING, BOTH 31 00:01:26,256 --> 00:01:27,790 COASTS AND EVERYBODY IN BETWEEN. 32 00:01:27,790 --> 00:01:31,327 WE WILL REMIND YOU OF SOME OF 33 00:01:31,327 --> 00:01:34,030 THE RULES, WHICH WILL HELP TO 34 00:01:34,030 --> 00:01:35,164 ENSURE ALL ARE ABLE TO 35 00:01:35,164 --> 00:01:36,633 CONTRIBUTE. WE ASK YOU REMAIN 36 00:01:36,633 --> 00:01:40,570 MUTED WHEN YOU ARE NOT ACTIVELY 37 00:01:40,570 --> 00:01:42,572 SPEAKING TO THE GROUP. IF YOU 38 00:01:42,572 --> 00:01:43,973 WOULD LIKE TO MAKE A COMMENT OR 39 00:01:43,973 --> 00:01:46,075 ASK A QUESTION, PLEASE USE THE 40 00:01:46,075 --> 00:01:48,544 RAISED HAND FEATURE OR ENTER 41 00:01:48,544 --> 00:01:51,648 YOUR COMMENT OR QUESTION 42 00:01:51,648 --> 00:01:54,617 DIRECTLY INTO THE CHAT BOX. ONE 43 00:01:54,617 --> 00:02:00,089 OF US WILL CALL ON YOU UNMUTE, 44 00:02:00,089 --> 00:02:01,924 IN ORDER WE SEE HANDS RAISED 45 00:02:01,924 --> 00:02:03,593 BEFORE MOVING TO THE CHAT. IF 46 00:02:03,593 --> 00:02:05,795 YOU HAVE TECHNICAL DIFFICULTIES, 47 00:02:05,795 --> 00:02:10,466 PLEASE CONTACT DANIEL OR ALISON 48 00:02:10,466 --> 00:02:14,103 OR ECBC, CONTACT BETINA VIA THE 49 00:02:14,103 --> 00:02:15,805 CHAT BOX. EMAILS ALSO WORK. YOU 50 00:02:15,805 --> 00:02:19,642 SEE EMAILS ON THE SCREEN RIGHT 51 00:02:19,642 --> 00:02:23,613 NOW. WE WILL NOW HAVE 52 00:02:23,613 --> 00:02:24,947 COUNCILMEMBERS INTRODUCE 53 00:02:24,947 --> 00:02:25,915 THEMSELVES, TELLING US YOUR 54 00:02:25,915 --> 00:02:27,850 NAME, YOUR INSTITUTIONAL 55 00:02:27,850 --> 00:02:31,688 AFFILIATION AND INDICATE IF YOU 56 00:02:31,688 --> 00:02:35,224 HAVE SERVED OR SERVING ON AN NIH 57 00:02:35,224 --> 00:02:37,627 OR CENTER -- NIH INSTITUTE OR 58 00:02:37,627 --> 00:02:39,262 CENTER COUNCIL AND WHICH YOU ARE 59 00:02:39,262 --> 00:02:41,230 SERVING ON. I WILL CALL YOUR 60 00:02:41,230 --> 00:02:44,500 NAMES IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER, BY 61 00:02:44,500 --> 00:02:47,837 YOUR LAST NAME. AT THAT TIME 62 00:02:47,837 --> 00:02:49,305 UNMUTE YOURSELF AND SHARE WITH 63 00:02:49,305 --> 00:02:51,274 US THE INFORMATION I JUST 64 00:02:51,274 --> 00:02:56,779 QUOTED. SO LET'S GO. DR. 65 00:02:56,779 --> 00:03:02,318 MONICA G., YOU ARE UP FIRST. 66 00:03:02,318 --> 00:03:06,956 >> SORRY, DR. MONICA GANDGANDHI 67 00:03:06,956 --> 00:03:07,857 PROFESSOR OF MEDICINE IN 68 00:03:07,857 --> 00:03:10,193 DIVISION OF H.I.V., INFECTIOUS 69 00:03:10,193 --> 00:03:12,562 DISEASE AND GLOBAL MEDICINE AT 70 00:03:12,562 --> 00:03:16,566 UCSF. I WAS ON THE O-RACK 71 00:03:16,566 --> 00:03:21,671 ADVISORY COMMITTEE, 2014-2018. 72 00:03:21,671 --> 00:03:27,844 THEN FROM 2019 TO 2030 I WAS ON 73 00:03:27,844 --> 00:03:30,913 NIAD ADVISORY COUNCIL. 74 00:03:30,913 --> 00:03:35,184 >> DR. IRIZARRY. 75 00:03:35,184 --> 00:03:37,553 >> I'M DR. IRIZARRY DEPARTMENT 76 00:03:37,553 --> 00:03:40,590 OF SCIENCE AND PROFESSOR OF 77 00:03:40,590 --> 00:03:41,791 BIOSTATISTICS AT HARVARD SCHOOL 78 00:03:41,791 --> 00:03:42,592 OF HEALTH. 79 00:03:42,592 --> 00:03:43,159 >> THANK YOU. 80 00:03:43,159 --> 00:03:47,797 >> SERVED ON THE NHGR COUNCIL 81 00:03:47,797 --> 00:03:50,199 UNTIL 2019, I THINK. THANK YOU. 82 00:03:50,199 --> 00:03:52,368 >> GREAT, THANK YOU. SORRY, I 83 00:03:52,368 --> 00:03:58,341 JUMPED THE GUN. DR. BARBARA 84 00:03:58,341 --> 00:03:58,608 JOHNSON. 85 00:03:58,608 --> 00:04:07,016 >> SORRY, I CAN'T EVEN READ. 86 00:04:07,016 --> 00:04:07,250 KAREN. 87 00:04:07,250 --> 00:04:10,853 >> MY APOLOGIES. I'M KAREN 88 00:04:10,853 --> 00:04:12,588 JOHNSTON, I'M A PROFESSOR AT THE 89 00:04:12,588 --> 00:04:15,591 UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA. I HAVE 90 00:04:15,591 --> 00:04:17,760 PREVIOUSLY BEEN ON NINDS 91 00:04:17,760 --> 00:04:20,096 COUNCIL, THANK YOU. 92 00:04:20,096 --> 00:04:23,166 >> THANK YOU, KAREN. I MIXED THE 93 00:04:23,166 --> 00:04:27,336 NEXT NAME UP WITH YOURS, KAREN. 94 00:04:27,336 --> 00:04:30,673 BARBARA KELLY. I'M GETTING A 95 00:04:30,673 --> 00:04:32,442 SIGNAL BARBARA IS NOT ON YET. 96 00:04:32,442 --> 00:04:36,112 I'M GOING TO GO TO JEAN KING. 97 00:04:36,112 --> 00:04:38,147 >> HI. MY NAME IS JEAN KING, 98 00:04:38,147 --> 00:04:41,350 DEAN OF ARTS AND SCIENCE, 99 00:04:41,350 --> 00:04:44,954 PROFESSOR OF NEUROSCIENCE, 100 00:04:44,954 --> 00:04:51,694 BIOLOGY AND TECHNOLOGY AT 101 00:04:51,694 --> 00:04:53,062 WORCESTER AND SERVED PRIOR TO 102 00:04:53,062 --> 00:04:55,198 THIS COUNCIL. 103 00:04:55,198 --> 00:04:59,402 >> THANK YOU. DR. DICK CRUMAN. 104 00:04:59,402 --> 00:05:04,006 >> I'M DICK CRUMAN, 105 00:05:04,006 --> 00:05:06,943 DISTINGUISHED PROFESSOR OF 106 00:05:06,943 --> 00:05:09,779 PEDIATRICS, COLORADO SCHOOL OF 107 00:05:09,779 --> 00:05:11,547 MEDICINE, PREVIOUSLY ON THE 108 00:05:11,547 --> 00:05:14,350 COUNCIL FROM 2015-2019. IN MY 109 00:05:14,350 --> 00:05:16,319 SIXTH YEAR ON THIS COUNCIL. 110 00:05:16,319 --> 00:05:18,588 >> THANK YOU, DICK. HI THAT YOUR 111 00:05:18,588 --> 00:05:22,458 DOG. I HEARD HIM. DR. KENT 112 00:05:22,458 --> 00:05:22,692 LLOYD. 113 00:05:22,692 --> 00:05:24,327 >> HI, GOOD MORNING EVERYONE. 114 00:05:24,327 --> 00:05:27,563 KENT LLOYD. I'M A PROFESSOR OF 115 00:05:27,563 --> 00:05:29,499 SURGERY, SCHOOL OF MEDICINE. 116 00:05:29,499 --> 00:05:31,367 CALIFORNIA DAVIS. I SERVED ON 117 00:05:31,367 --> 00:05:33,636 THIS COUNCIL NOW ALMOST A DECADE 118 00:05:33,636 --> 00:05:36,472 AGO, SO THEY BROUGHT ME BACK. 119 00:05:36,472 --> 00:05:36,973 THANKS. 120 00:05:36,973 --> 00:05:39,909 >> THANK YOU, KEN. DR. JENNIFER 121 00:05:39,909 --> 00:05:40,343 MANLEY. 122 00:05:40,343 --> 00:05:42,078 >> GOOD MORNING, EVERYONE. I'M 123 00:05:42,078 --> 00:05:45,014 JENNIFER MANLEY. I'M A PROFESSOR 124 00:05:45,014 --> 00:05:48,017 OF NEUROPSYCHOLOGY IN THE 125 00:05:48,017 --> 00:05:51,854 NEUROLOGY DEPARTMENT AT COLUMBIA 126 00:05:51,854 --> 00:05:55,491 UNIVERSITY. I SERVED ON THE NIA, 127 00:05:55,491 --> 00:05:57,260 NATIONAL INSTITUTES ON AGING 128 00:05:57,260 --> 00:06:00,162 COUNCIL. I THINK IT IS MY SECOND 129 00:06:00,162 --> 00:06:02,565 OR THIRD YEAR ON COUNCIL OF 130 00:06:02,565 --> 00:06:03,199 COUNCILS. 131 00:06:03,199 --> 00:06:11,741 >> THANK YOU, JENNIFER. 132 00:06:11,741 --> 00:06:14,710 >> -- NOT SERVED ON ANY OTHER 133 00:06:14,710 --> 00:06:16,345 COUNCILS. I'M HAVING A LITTLE 134 00:06:16,345 --> 00:06:17,847 PROBLEM ON MY VIDEO THIS MORNING 135 00:06:17,847 --> 00:06:20,583 SO I WILL PROBABLY LOG BACK IN 136 00:06:20,583 --> 00:06:21,684 AFTER. THIS ANYTHING ELSE I NEED 137 00:06:21,684 --> 00:06:22,752 TO ADDRESS? 138 00:06:22,752 --> 00:06:24,020 >> I THINK WE ARE GOOD. THANK 139 00:06:24,020 --> 00:06:24,220 YOU. 140 00:06:24,220 --> 00:06:26,322 >> THANK YOU. 141 00:06:26,322 --> 00:06:31,794 >> DR. RUS VAN GIVEELDER. 142 00:06:31,794 --> 00:06:33,996 >> PROFESSOR AND CHAIR IN 143 00:06:33,996 --> 00:06:35,231 WASHINGTON, SEATTLE. I SERVED ON 144 00:06:35,231 --> 00:06:37,633 THE NEI COUNCIL. THIS IS MY 145 00:06:37,633 --> 00:06:39,802 SIXTH YEAR ON COUNCIL AT 146 00:06:39,802 --> 00:06:43,973 COUNCILS AND SERVED A HOCK ON 147 00:06:43,973 --> 00:06:45,241 ADVISORY COUNCIL TO THE 148 00:06:45,241 --> 00:06:45,775 DIRECTOR. 149 00:06:45,775 --> 00:06:47,376 >> BARBARA IS STILL NOT HERE. WE 150 00:06:47,376 --> 00:06:49,545 WILL INTRODUCE HER LATER ON. A 151 00:06:49,545 --> 00:06:52,048 FEW ADDITIONAL ANNOUNCEMENTS. 152 00:06:52,048 --> 00:06:54,283 MEETING MATERIALS WERE SENT TO 153 00:06:54,283 --> 00:06:57,086 YOU MAY 27TH VIA EMAIL FOR 154 00:06:57,086 --> 00:06:59,121 TODAY'S VIRTUAL MEETING. AS 155 00:06:59,121 --> 00:07:00,623 MEMBERS OF THIS COUNCIL OF 156 00:07:00,623 --> 00:07:01,424 COUNCILS, YOU HAVE BEEN TOLD 157 00:07:01,424 --> 00:07:06,295 MANY TIMES YOU ARE SPECIAL 158 00:07:06,295 --> 00:07:06,829 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES AND 159 00:07:06,829 --> 00:07:07,763 THEREFORE SUBJECT TO RULES OF 160 00:07:07,763 --> 00:07:10,499 CONDUCT THAT APPLY TO FEDERAL 161 00:07:10,499 --> 00:07:12,768 EMPLOYEES. THESE RULES AND 162 00:07:12,768 --> 00:07:15,171 REGULATIONS ARE EXPLAINED IN A 163 00:07:15,171 --> 00:07:17,306 REPORT ENTITLED STANDARDS OF 164 00:07:17,306 --> 00:07:19,675 ETHICAL CONDUCT FOR EMPLOYEES OF 165 00:07:19,675 --> 00:07:21,444 THE EXECUTIVE BRANCH. YOU 166 00:07:21,444 --> 00:07:23,145 RECEIVED A COPY OF THAT REPORT 167 00:07:23,145 --> 00:07:25,381 WHEN YOU WERE FIRST APPOINTED TO 168 00:07:25,381 --> 00:07:27,783 THE COUNCIL. AT EVERY MEETING, 169 00:07:27,783 --> 00:07:29,852 IN AT DECISION TO REMINDING YOU 170 00:07:29,852 --> 00:07:32,655 ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE OF 171 00:07:32,655 --> 00:07:34,256 FOLLOWING ETHICALS, WE ALSO LIKE 172 00:07:34,256 --> 00:07:37,326 TO REVIEW THE STEPS THAT WE TAKE 173 00:07:37,326 --> 00:07:41,764 AND ASK YOU TO TAKE TO ENSURE 174 00:07:41,764 --> 00:07:43,332 THAT ANY CONFLICT OF INTEREST 175 00:07:43,332 --> 00:07:45,368 BETWEEN YOUR PUBLIC 176 00:07:45,368 --> 00:07:46,268 RESPONSIBILITIES AND YOUR 177 00:07:46,268 --> 00:07:50,339 PRIVATE INTERESTS AND ACTIVITIES 178 00:07:50,339 --> 00:07:51,974 ARE IDENTIFIED AND ADDRESSED. 179 00:07:51,974 --> 00:07:53,809 THREE TIMES A YEAR YOU PROVIDE 180 00:07:53,809 --> 00:07:55,811 US WITH INFORMATION ABOUT YOUR 181 00:07:55,811 --> 00:07:57,580 PERSONAL, PROFESSIONAL AND 182 00:07:57,580 --> 00:07:59,949 FINANCIAL INTERESTS. WE USE THIS 183 00:07:59,949 --> 00:08:02,852 INFORMATION AS THE BASIS FOR 184 00:08:02,852 --> 00:08:05,955 ASSESSING WHETHER YOU HAVE ANY 185 00:08:05,955 --> 00:08:08,524 REAL POTENTIAL OR APPARENT 186 00:08:08,524 --> 00:08:10,259 CONFLICT OF INTEREST THAT COULD 187 00:08:10,259 --> 00:08:12,328 COMPROMISE YOUR ABILITY TO BE 188 00:08:12,328 --> 00:08:13,663 OBJECTIVE IN GIVING ADVICE 189 00:08:13,663 --> 00:08:19,802 DURING THE COUNCIL MEETINGS. IF 190 00:08:19,802 --> 00:08:22,371 SUCH CONFLICTS ARE IDENTIFIED WE 191 00:08:22,371 --> 00:08:24,173 EITHER ISSUE A WAIVER OR RECUSE 192 00:08:24,173 --> 00:08:27,109 YOU FROM A PARTICULAR PORTION OF 193 00:08:27,109 --> 00:08:29,612 THE MEETING. WE ALSO RELY, TO A 194 00:08:29,612 --> 00:08:33,516 GREAT DEGREE, ON YOU TO BE 195 00:08:33,516 --> 00:08:36,252 ATTENTIVE DURING OUR MEETINGS TO 196 00:08:36,252 --> 00:08:38,688 THE POSSIBILITY IF AN ISSUE 197 00:08:38,688 --> 00:08:42,124 ARISES THAT COULD AFFECT OR 198 00:08:42,124 --> 00:08:43,592 APPEAR TO AFFECT YOUR INTERESTS 199 00:08:43,592 --> 00:08:45,561 IN SPECIFIC WAY. IF THAT 200 00:08:45,561 --> 00:08:48,130 HAPPENS, WE ASK YOU RECUSE 201 00:08:48,130 --> 00:08:49,365 YOURSELF FROM THE DISCUSSION. 202 00:08:49,365 --> 00:08:51,300 YOU WOULD DO SO BY USING THE 203 00:08:51,300 --> 00:08:53,869 CHAT FEATURE. THEN WE WOULD MOVE 204 00:08:53,869 --> 00:08:57,173 YOU INTO THE WAITING ROOM. IF 205 00:08:57,173 --> 00:09:00,342 YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS ABOUT THE 206 00:09:00,342 --> 00:09:05,047 RULES OF CONDUCT OR CONFLICT OF 207 00:09:05,047 --> 00:09:07,016 INTERESTS, OUR COMMITTEE 208 00:09:07,016 --> 00:09:10,553 MANAGEMENT SPECIALISTS OR I WILL 209 00:09:10,553 --> 00:09:12,955 BE HAPPY TO ADDRESS THOSE 210 00:09:12,955 --> 00:09:14,356 QUESTIONS. FACE USUALLY CONTACTS 211 00:09:14,356 --> 00:09:18,194 YOU ABOUT THE FINANCIAL 212 00:09:18,194 --> 00:09:19,862 INTERESTS, SO YOU ARE FAMILIAR 213 00:09:19,862 --> 00:09:23,799 WITH HER. A FEW MORE ITEMS. TIME 214 00:09:23,799 --> 00:09:25,501 IS ALLOTTED IN EACH HOUR FOR 215 00:09:25,501 --> 00:09:26,869 DISCUSSION BY COUNCIL FOLLOWING 216 00:09:26,869 --> 00:09:28,938 EACH PRESENTATION. UNFORTUNATELY 217 00:09:28,938 --> 00:09:30,339 THERE IS LIMITED TIME FOR ANY 218 00:09:30,339 --> 00:09:33,676 COMMENTS FROM OTHER ATTENDEES. 219 00:09:33,676 --> 00:09:35,611 THE PUBLIC IS WELCOME TO PUB 220 00:09:35,611 --> 00:09:37,613 MITT COMMENTS IN WRITING AFTER 221 00:09:37,613 --> 00:09:41,784 THE MEETING. INSTRUCTIONS IN HOW 222 00:09:41,784 --> 00:09:43,753 TO DO SUBMIT SUCH COMMENTS YOU 223 00:09:43,753 --> 00:09:46,021 CAN FIND IN THE FEDERAL 224 00:09:46,021 --> 00:09:47,356 REGISTER, WHICH WAS PUBLISHED 225 00:09:47,356 --> 00:09:51,260 FOR THIS MEETING ON MARCH 25TH. 226 00:09:51,260 --> 00:09:52,728 APPROVE MINUTES FOR THIS MEETING 227 00:09:52,728 --> 00:09:55,798 WILL BE POSTED ON THE DPCPSI 228 00:09:55,798 --> 00:09:58,467 WEBSITE. AS A REMINDER OF FUTURE 229 00:09:58,467 --> 00:10:01,871 MEETING, DATES ARE ALSO POSTED 230 00:10:01,871 --> 00:10:04,273 ON THE DPCPSI WEBSITE. THERE IS 231 00:10:04,273 --> 00:10:10,980 ONLY ONE MEETING LEFT IN THIS 232 00:10:10,980 --> 00:10:14,383 THAT WE CAN HAVE IT IN PERSON 233 00:10:14,383 --> 00:10:18,487 FOR SEPTEMBER 12TH -- 11 AND 12. 234 00:10:18,487 --> 00:10:20,756 A REMINDER, THE MEETING IS 235 00:10:20,756 --> 00:10:22,291 RECORDED AND WILL BE 236 00:10:22,291 --> 00:10:23,826 TRANSCRIBED. PLEASE UNMUTE 237 00:10:23,826 --> 00:10:25,494 YOURSELF IF YOU SPEAK AND 238 00:10:25,494 --> 00:10:28,063 IDENTIFY YOURSELF. THAT REALLY 239 00:10:28,063 --> 00:10:28,898 HELPS. ALSO PLEASE MUTE YOURSELF 240 00:10:28,898 --> 00:10:33,202 AFTER YOU HAVE FINISHED SO 241 00:10:33,202 --> 00:10:35,905 OTHERS CAN TURN ON THEIR 242 00:10:35,905 --> 00:10:38,307 MICROPHONE. NOTE THE HOST CAN 243 00:10:38,307 --> 00:10:40,276 CONTROL YOUR MICROPHONE IN CASE 244 00:10:40,276 --> 00:10:45,981 YOU TURN IT OFF. A REMIAR REMIN 245 00:10:45,981 --> 00:10:47,683 TURN ON YOUR VIDEO CAMERA WHEN 246 00:10:47,683 --> 00:10:54,557 SPEAKING .ENTER /* IF YOU NEED 247 00:10:54,557 --> 00:10:55,791 ASSISTANCE USE THE CHAT FEATURE 248 00:10:55,791 --> 00:10:58,194 ON TEAMS. THE CLOSED SESSION 249 00:10:58,194 --> 00:11:02,932 WILL BE HELD FROM 12:15 TO 1:15 250 00:11:02,932 --> 00:11:05,100 TO CONDUCT SECOND-LEVEL REVIEW 251 00:11:05,100 --> 00:11:07,369 FOR GRANT APPLICATIONS. IN 252 00:11:07,369 --> 00:11:09,605 ACCORDANCE WITH NIH AND FEDERAL 253 00:11:09,605 --> 00:11:11,807 POLICY ATTENDANCE IS RESTRICTED 254 00:11:11,807 --> 00:11:14,910 TO COUNCILMEMBERS AND RELEVANT 255 00:11:14,910 --> 00:11:17,379 NIH STAFF. THE OPEN SESSION WILL 256 00:11:17,379 --> 00:11:21,317 RESTART AT 1:15. ARE THERE ANY 257 00:11:21,317 --> 00:11:22,751 QUESTIONS AT THIS POINT. NOT 258 00:11:22,751 --> 00:11:26,589 SEEING ANY, I WILL TURN THE 259 00:11:26,589 --> 00:11:27,923 MICROPHONE OVER TO YOU. 260 00:11:27,923 --> 00:11:30,392 >> THANK YOU, FRANCESCA. SO I 261 00:11:30,392 --> 00:11:32,928 WOULD LIKE TO REPEAT THAT WE ARE 262 00:11:32,928 --> 00:11:34,697 IN THE OPEN SESSION OF TODAY'S 263 00:11:34,697 --> 00:11:37,733 MEETING, WHICH MEANS OPEN TO THE 264 00:11:37,733 --> 00:11:40,836 PUBLIC, INCLUDING MEMBERS OF THE 265 00:11:40,836 --> 00:11:43,806 PRESS. WE ARE VIDEO CASTING SO 266 00:11:43,806 --> 00:11:45,674 ALL INTERESTED PARTYIES CAN 267 00:11:45,674 --> 00:11:48,210 LISTEN IN. LET'S KICK THINGS 268 00:11:48,210 --> 00:11:51,814 OFF. AFTER I PROVIDE NIH AND 269 00:11:51,814 --> 00:11:53,215 DPCPSI UPDATES OUR AGENDA WILL 270 00:11:53,215 --> 00:11:54,650 INCLUDE FINAL REPORTS ON TWO 271 00:11:54,650 --> 00:11:59,655 COUNCIL OF COUNCIL'S WORKING 272 00:11:59,655 --> 00:11:59,922 GROUPS . 273 00:11:59,922 --> 00:12:08,631 THE GENERAL REPOSITORY AND THE 274 00:12:08,631 --> 00:12:11,500 OFFICE OF NUTRITION AND DIETARY 275 00:12:11,500 --> 00:12:13,702 SUPPLEMENTS FOLLOWED BY ODS ON 276 00:12:13,702 --> 00:12:15,804 STRENGTHENING, RIGOR AND 277 00:12:15,804 --> 00:12:19,808 REPRODUCIBILITY OF DIETARY 278 00:12:19,808 --> 00:12:21,944 SUPPLEMENTS. SO, AS YOU KNOW, 279 00:12:21,944 --> 00:12:24,079 THE DIRECTORS OF EACH OF THE 280 00:12:24,079 --> 00:12:27,616 DPCPSI PROGRAM OFFICES SERVE AS 281 00:12:27,616 --> 00:12:28,350 NON-VOTING LIAISONS TO THE 282 00:12:28,350 --> 00:12:29,985 COUNCIL. THEY ARE LISTED WITH 283 00:12:29,985 --> 00:12:31,921 THEIR PHOTOS ON THE SLIDE. THEY 284 00:12:31,921 --> 00:12:33,923 ARE ALL ON THE CALL AND 285 00:12:33,923 --> 00:12:35,925 AVAILABLE FOR INPUT OR COMMENTS, 286 00:12:35,925 --> 00:12:39,228 IF NEEDED. OKAY. SO STARTING 287 00:12:39,228 --> 00:12:41,797 WITH THE DPCPSI UPDATES, I WANT 288 00:12:41,797 --> 00:12:46,368 TO ANNOUNCE SOME LEADERSHIP 289 00:12:46,368 --> 00:12:46,802 CHA 290 00:12:46,802 --> 00:12:47,303 CHAN 291 00:12:47,303 --> 00:12:48,804 CHANGES. SO WE CAN MOVE TO THE 292 00:12:48,804 --> 00:12:53,976 NEXT SLIDE. DR. COURTNEY ANY 293 00:12:53,976 --> 00:12:56,612 ACKLAND IS DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL 294 00:12:56,612 --> 00:12:58,013 INSTITUTE OF NURSING RESEARCH, 295 00:12:58,013 --> 00:13:01,617 WHERE SHE HAS SERVED AS DEPUTY 296 00:13:01,617 --> 00:13:04,520 DIRECTOR SINCE 20 # 23 AND 297 00:13:04,520 --> 00:13:06,255 PREVIOUSLY SERVED AT NIH AND 298 00:13:06,255 --> 00:13:08,557 BEFORE THAT SENIOR ADVISOR 299 00:13:08,557 --> 00:13:11,126 WITHIN THE NIH DIRECTOR. SHE HAS 300 00:13:11,126 --> 00:13:13,963 OVER 15 YEARS AT NIH WHERE SHE'S 301 00:13:13,963 --> 00:13:17,032 LEAD ALIGNMENT AND COMPLEX 302 00:13:17,032 --> 00:13:18,567 CHALLENGES IN SUPPORT OF NIH'S 303 00:13:18,567 --> 00:13:22,338 MISSION. DR. ALISON C. IS THE 304 00:13:22,338 --> 00:13:24,873 ACTING DIRECTOR OF EUNICE 305 00:13:24,873 --> 00:13:26,809 SHRIVER CHILD HELP AND HUMAN 306 00:13:26,809 --> 00:13:28,911 DEVELOPMENT, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR 307 00:13:28,911 --> 00:13:31,013 SINCE 2019 AND PREVIOUSLY SERVED 308 00:13:31,013 --> 00:13:34,083 AS DIRECTOR OF THE NATIONAL 309 00:13:34,083 --> 00:13:35,884 CENTER FOR MEDICAL 310 00:13:35,884 --> 00:13:38,187 REHABILITATION AND IS A NAGS 311 00:13:38,187 --> 00:13:41,323 LEADER IN REHABILITATION 312 00:13:41,323 --> 00:13:42,124 MEDICINE TO COORDINATE AND 313 00:13:42,124 --> 00:13:43,525 RESEARCH RESOURCES IN THIS 314 00:13:43,525 --> 00:13:46,128 FIELD. DR. MONICA WEB-HOOPER IS 315 00:13:46,128 --> 00:13:48,530 NOW SERVING AS ACTING DIRECTOR 316 00:13:48,530 --> 00:13:50,599 OF NATIONAL INSTITUTE ON 317 00:13:50,599 --> 00:13:53,268 MINORITY DISPARITIES, THE DEPUTY 318 00:13:53,268 --> 00:13:58,540 DIRECTOR SINCE 2024. DR. 319 00:13:58,540 --> 00:14:00,009 WEBB-HOOPER CAME FROM CASE 320 00:14:00,009 --> 00:14:01,744 WESTERN, WHERE SHE WAS PROFESSOR 321 00:14:01,744 --> 00:14:05,647 OF ONCOLOGY, FAMILY MEDICINE AND 322 00:14:05,647 --> 00:14:13,522 HEALTH AND SCIENCES. SHE HAS 323 00:14:13,522 --> 00:14:16,225 SEARCHED AT NCI AND CASE 324 00:14:16,225 --> 00:14:17,693 COMPREHENSIVE CANCER CENTER. DR. 325 00:14:17,693 --> 00:14:18,994 ANDREA IS THE ACTING DIRECTOR OF 326 00:14:18,994 --> 00:14:20,896 THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF MENTAL 327 00:14:20,896 --> 00:14:22,831 HEALTH, THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF 328 00:14:22,831 --> 00:14:26,135 THE BRAIN RESEARCH THROUGH 329 00:14:26,135 --> 00:14:27,536 ADVANCING INNOVATIVE 330 00:14:27,536 --> 00:14:29,071 TECHNOLOGIES OR THE BRAIN 331 00:14:29,071 --> 00:14:30,305 INITIATIVES. SHE PREVIOUSLY HELD 332 00:14:30,305 --> 00:14:32,541 DIRECTOR POSITIONS AT OFFICE FOR 333 00:14:32,541 --> 00:14:35,144 DISPARITIES AND WORKFORCE 334 00:14:35,144 --> 00:14:36,945 DIVERSITY, RURAL MENTAL HEALTH 335 00:14:36,945 --> 00:14:39,715 RESEARCH AND FUNCTIONAL 336 00:14:39,715 --> 00:14:44,219 NEUROGENOMICS IN BASIC BEHAVIOR. 337 00:14:44,219 --> 00:14:46,622 OVER SEEING LARGE PROGRAMS AND 338 00:14:46,622 --> 00:14:47,589 COLLABORATIVE PROGRAMS AT NIH 339 00:14:47,589 --> 00:14:54,496 DURING HER TIME THERE. DR. JE 340 00:14:54,496 --> 00:14:55,064 JEJE 341 00:14:55,064 --> 00:14:57,032 JEFF T. IS AT THE INSTITUTE OF 342 00:14:57,032 --> 00:15:02,871 ALLEY GIS AND CHIEF SINCE 2006 343 00:15:02,871 --> 00:15:05,407 AND PRIOR TO THAT, MOLECULAR 344 00:15:05,407 --> 00:15:10,179 PATHOLOGY AT THE ARMED INSTITUTE 345 00:15:10,179 --> 00:15:15,384 OF PATHOLOGY SINCE 1994. VIRAL 346 00:15:15,384 --> 00:15:21,023 SURVEILLANCE, VIROLOGY AND 347 00:15:21,023 --> 00:15:22,624 BACTERIALOLOGY AND CLINICAL 348 00:15:22,624 --> 00:15:23,525 RESEARCH. LASTLY OUR OWN 349 00:15:23,525 --> 00:15:26,929 DIRECTOR OF OFFICE OF STRATEGIC 350 00:15:26,929 --> 00:15:29,364 COORDINATION OR COMMON FUND AT 351 00:15:29,364 --> 00:15:30,766 DPCPSI, DR. CAROLYN HEADER IS 352 00:15:30,766 --> 00:15:33,469 THE ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL 353 00:15:33,469 --> 00:15:35,938 HUMAN GENOME INSTITUTE. BEFORE 354 00:15:35,938 --> 00:15:38,340 COMING TO DPCPSI DR. HEADER WAS 355 00:15:38,340 --> 00:15:41,510 AT NHGRI, THE DIRECTOR OF GENOME 356 00:15:41,510 --> 00:15:42,311 SCIENCES AND AS PROGRAM 357 00:15:42,311 --> 00:15:45,848 DIRECTOR, SERVING AS THE NHDR 358 00:15:45,848 --> 00:15:47,416 TEAM LEAD FOR THE ATLAS AND 359 00:15:47,416 --> 00:15:48,750 BRINGS MORE THAN 20 YEARS OF 360 00:15:48,750 --> 00:15:51,053 EXPERIENCE IN GENETICS AND 361 00:15:51,053 --> 00:15:52,488 EPIDEMIOLOGY AS WELL AS MANAGING 362 00:15:52,488 --> 00:15:55,958 LARGE RESEARCH COLLABORATIONS. 363 00:15:55,958 --> 00:15:59,428 WHILE CAROLYN IS AT NHGRI DR. 364 00:15:59,428 --> 00:16:02,131 VIVIAN WANG, DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF 365 00:16:02,131 --> 00:16:03,832 OFFICE RESEARCH ON WOMEN'S 366 00:16:03,832 --> 00:16:07,136 HEALTH WILL SERVE AS ACTING OSC 367 00:16:07,136 --> 00:16:09,104 DIRECTOR. PRIOR WAS AT THE 368 00:16:09,104 --> 00:16:11,773 OFFICE OF DATA SCIENCE STRATEGY 369 00:16:11,773 --> 00:16:13,308 AND SERVED AS INAUGURAL DEPUTY 370 00:16:13,308 --> 00:16:14,776 DIRECTOR OF OFFICE OF DATA 371 00:16:14,776 --> 00:16:18,046 SHARING AT CENTER FOR BIOMEDICAL 372 00:16:18,046 --> 00:16:19,214 INFORMATICS AND TECHNOLOGY AT 373 00:16:19,214 --> 00:16:21,517 THE NCI. SHE WAS THE PROGRAM 374 00:16:21,517 --> 00:16:23,819 DIRECTOR FOR DATA ACCESS AND 375 00:16:23,819 --> 00:16:26,955 SHARING ETHICAL AND LEGAL SOCIAL 376 00:16:26,955 --> 00:16:29,958 IMPLICATIONS RESEARCH PROGRAM AT 377 00:16:29,958 --> 00:16:32,728 NHGRI. WHILE VIVIAN IS AT OSC, 378 00:16:32,728 --> 00:16:34,863 CINDY KAUFMAN, DIRECTOR OF 379 00:16:34,863 --> 00:16:36,465 STRATEGIC ENGAGEMENT AT 380 00:16:36,465 --> 00:16:38,700 PORTFOLIO ANALYSIS WILL SERVE AS 381 00:16:38,700 --> 00:16:41,069 ACTING DIRECTOR OF ORWH. 382 00:16:41,069 --> 00:16:42,604 PREVIOUSLY SHE SERVED AS DEPUTY 383 00:16:42,604 --> 00:16:44,439 DIRECTOR IN OFFICE OF SCIENCE, 384 00:16:44,439 --> 00:16:45,741 POLICY, EDUCATION AND 385 00:16:45,741 --> 00:16:48,043 COMMUNICATIONS AT NHLBI AND 386 00:16:48,043 --> 00:16:49,711 BRANCH CHIEF OF SCIENTIFIC 387 00:16:49,711 --> 00:16:52,814 PLANNING, POLICY AND ANALYSIS 388 00:16:52,814 --> 00:16:55,350 BRANCH IN NIAMS. I THINK THAT IS 389 00:16:55,350 --> 00:16:58,887 ALL THE DOMINOS THAT HAVE BEEN 390 00:16:58,887 --> 00:17:01,557 PUT IN PLACE TO REALLY FILL OUT 391 00:17:01,557 --> 00:17:03,192 OUR LEADERSHIP TEAM IN A VERY 392 00:17:03,192 --> 00:17:08,797 ROBUST WAY. I WOULD LIKE TO 393 00:17:08,797 --> 00:17:10,666 EXTEND MY GRATITUDE TO THE 394 00:17:10,666 --> 00:17:11,433 LEADERSHIP AND APPRECIATION TO 395 00:17:11,433 --> 00:17:12,935 THE DPCPSI COLLEAGUES FOR THEIR 396 00:17:12,935 --> 00:17:14,436 FLEXIBILITY. THE COMMITMENT 397 00:17:14,436 --> 00:17:16,905 THAT'S BEING DEMONSTRATED TO 398 00:17:16,905 --> 00:17:17,673 EXCELLENCE AND RESILIENCE IS 399 00:17:17,673 --> 00:17:19,708 VERY DEEPLY APPRECIATED, 400 00:17:19,708 --> 00:17:20,576 ESPECIALLY DURING TIMES THAT 401 00:17:20,576 --> 00:17:23,612 HAVE TESTED OUR COLLECTIVE 402 00:17:23,612 --> 00:17:25,747 ADAPTABILITY. I THINK IT IS 403 00:17:25,747 --> 00:17:27,382 IMPORTANT TO NOTE WHILE 404 00:17:27,382 --> 00:17:29,351 TRANSITIONS OBVIOUSLY BRING 405 00:17:29,351 --> 00:17:31,787 CHALLENGES THEY ALSO OFFER 406 00:17:31,787 --> 00:17:32,921 OPPORTUNITIES FOR RENEWED 407 00:17:32,921 --> 00:17:36,325 PURPOSE SO I'M REALLY EXCITED TO 408 00:17:36,325 --> 00:17:41,897 MOVE FORWARD UNDER THESE -- THIS 409 00:17:41,897 --> 00:17:48,804 LEADERSHIP. SPEAKING OF WHICH, 410 00:17:48,804 --> 00:17:52,808 NIH IS CENTRALIZING PEER REVIEW 411 00:17:52,808 --> 00:17:55,277 AND EXPERIENCED A WIDE RANGE OF 412 00:17:55,277 --> 00:17:56,478 MECHANISMS BUT AS THEY THE TAKE 413 00:17:56,478 --> 00:17:57,879 ON ALL REVIEW THE LEADER S HAVE 414 00:17:57,879 --> 00:18:01,250 REACHED OUT TO COUNTERPARTS AT 415 00:18:01,250 --> 00:18:03,819 ICs TO LEARN MORE ABOUT PEER 416 00:18:03,819 --> 00:18:13,095 REVIEW PROCESSES UNIQUE TO EACH 417 00:18:13,095 --> 00:18:16,798 ONE. NIH IS AWARE THE IRG AND 418 00:18:16,798 --> 00:18:18,367 SEPs MUST COMPLETE WORK FOR MAY 419 00:18:18,367 --> 00:18:19,968 COUNCIL ROUND BEFORE 420 00:18:19,968 --> 00:18:20,902 TERMINATION. EXACT TERMINATION 421 00:18:20,902 --> 00:18:22,738 DATE IS NOT AVAILABLE. MOST 422 00:18:22,738 --> 00:18:25,440 LIKELY, THE END OF JUNE. MEMBERS 423 00:18:25,440 --> 00:18:27,442 OF STANDING COMMITTEES THAT WILL 424 00:18:27,442 --> 00:18:30,545 BE TERMINATED AND GRANTED 425 00:18:30,545 --> 00:18:32,914 CONTINUOUS -- MEMBERS OF THE 426 00:18:32,914 --> 00:18:34,516 COMMITTEE THAT WILL BE TERMINATE 427 00:18:34,516 --> 00:18:36,385 WILLED BE GRANTED PRIVILEGES 428 00:18:36,385 --> 00:18:40,455 THROUGH AUGUST 10, 2026. THEIR 429 00:18:40,455 --> 00:18:43,091 THEIR SERVICE IS VERY MUCH 430 00:18:43,091 --> 00:18:45,861 APPRECIATED AND CSR RECOGNIZES 431 00:18:45,861 --> 00:18:47,496 THE EXPERTISE AND ARE LIKELY TO 432 00:18:47,496 --> 00:18:49,931 REACH OUT AND INVITE THEM TO 433 00:18:49,931 --> 00:18:53,435 SERVE ON CSR PANELS MOVING 434 00:18:53,435 --> 00:18:54,069 FORWARD. APPLICATIONS THAT WOULD 435 00:18:54,069 --> 00:18:56,471 HAVE BEEN REVIEWED WILL BE 436 00:18:56,471 --> 00:18:59,374 REVIEWED AND WILL BE REVIEWED IN 437 00:18:59,374 --> 00:19:04,713 A TIMELY FASHION BY CSR. ON 438 00:19:04,713 --> 00:19:07,816 APRIL 29TH, NIH ANNOUNCED ITS 439 00:19:07,816 --> 00:19:09,518 COMMIT TO DEVELOPING, VALIDATING 440 00:19:09,518 --> 00:19:12,754 AND SCALING NEW APPROACH 441 00:19:12,754 --> 00:19:17,259 METHODOLOGIES OR NAMS ACROSS THE 442 00:19:17,259 --> 00:19:18,827 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH PORTFOLIO, 443 00:19:18,827 --> 00:19:20,462 TECHNIQUES DESIGNED TO MODEL 444 00:19:20,462 --> 00:19:25,500 HUMAN BIOLOGY AND COMPLEMENT 445 00:19:25,500 --> 00:19:25,867 TR 446 00:19:25,867 --> 00:19:27,803 TRADITIONAL ANIMAL STUDIES. IN 447 00:19:27,803 --> 00:19:30,572 SOME CASE, SERVING AS 448 00:19:30,572 --> 00:19:32,107 ALTERNATIVES. WE KNOW THE ANIMAL 449 00:19:32,107 --> 00:19:33,875 MODELS DON'T BE IMPORTANT TO 450 00:19:33,875 --> 00:19:34,776 ADVANCING OUR SCIENTIFIC 451 00:19:34,776 --> 00:19:38,380 KNOWLEDGE BUT WE ALSO RECOGNIZE 452 00:19:38,380 --> 00:19:40,015 NAMS OFFER STRENGTHS THAT WHEN 453 00:19:40,015 --> 00:19:41,817 UTILIZED CORRECTLY OR IN 454 00:19:41,817 --> 00:19:42,751 COMBINATION CAN EXPAND THE TOOL 455 00:19:42,751 --> 00:19:44,953 BOX FOR RESEARCHERS TO ANSWER 456 00:19:44,953 --> 00:19:46,822 PREVIOUSLY DIFFICULT OR 457 00:19:46,822 --> 00:19:48,623 UNANSWERABLE BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH 458 00:19:48,623 --> 00:19:50,192 QUESTIONS. THIS IS NOT 459 00:19:50,192 --> 00:19:51,593 BRAND-NEW. THERE ARE LOTS OF 460 00:19:51,593 --> 00:19:55,564 NAMS ACTIVITIES GOING ON ACROSS 461 00:19:55,564 --> 00:19:57,432 THE ICOs AND AGENCY INVESTMENT 462 00:19:57,432 --> 00:19:59,668 HAS BEEN INCREASING OVER TIME. 463 00:19:59,668 --> 00:20:01,169 SO THE INTENTION HERE IS TO 464 00:20:01,169 --> 00:20:03,805 BUILD ON THOSE EXISTING EFFORTS, 465 00:20:03,805 --> 00:20:06,141 INCLUDING THE VALIDATION WORK OF 466 00:20:06,141 --> 00:20:08,877 THE INTERAGENCY COMMITTEE, 467 00:20:08,877 --> 00:20:11,213 ICVAM, MY FORMER HOME. PROGRAMS 468 00:20:11,213 --> 00:20:15,150 LIKE THE NCAT PROGRAM, THE 3D 469 00:20:15,150 --> 00:20:16,818 TISSUE BIOPRINTING PROGRAM, WORK 470 00:20:16,818 --> 00:20:19,321 OF THE COMMON FUNDS 471 00:20:19,321 --> 00:20:21,022 COMPLEMENTARY RI PROGRAM SO 472 00:20:21,022 --> 00:20:23,058 COMPLEMENTING ANIMAL RESEARCH 473 00:20:23,058 --> 00:20:24,693 AND EXPERIMENTATION. TO BRING 474 00:20:24,693 --> 00:20:26,862 ALL THOSE TOGETHER IN A 475 00:20:26,862 --> 00:20:29,598 COORDINATED FASHION AND TO WORK 476 00:20:29,598 --> 00:20:30,832 ACROSS THOSE EFFORTS AND DEVELOP 477 00:20:30,832 --> 00:20:34,169 AND INTEGRATE NAMS MORE 478 00:20:34,169 --> 00:20:36,037 COMPREHENSIVELY INTO THE 479 00:20:36,037 --> 00:20:36,705 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH PORTFOLIO. 480 00:20:36,705 --> 00:20:38,740 JUST LAST MONTH THE 481 00:20:38,740 --> 00:20:41,176 COMPLEMENTARY RI PROGRAM 482 00:20:41,176 --> 00:20:43,745 PARTNER ED WITH THE FOUNDATION 483 00:20:43,745 --> 00:20:47,115 -- FOUNDATION FOR NIH, FNIH TO 484 00:20:47,115 --> 00:20:49,117 ENHANCE ADOPTION AND USE THROUGH 485 00:20:49,117 --> 00:20:51,052 ESTABLISHMENT OF EVALUATION AND 486 00:20:51,052 --> 00:20:52,320 QUALIFICATION SO THE VQN IS 487 00:20:52,320 --> 00:20:55,357 GOING TO BE WORKING WITH THAT 488 00:20:55,357 --> 00:20:58,226 PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP AND 489 00:20:58,226 --> 00:20:59,428 REGULATORY COLLEAGUES TO ENSURE 490 00:20:59,428 --> 00:21:01,830 THAT ANY NAMS DEVELOPED THAT 491 00:21:01,830 --> 00:21:03,765 SHOW PROMISE WILL BE RIGOROUSLY 492 00:21:03,765 --> 00:21:07,035 AND ROBUSTLY EVALUATED AND 493 00:21:07,035 --> 00:21:09,171 VALIDATED FOR POTENTIAL USE IN 494 00:21:09,171 --> 00:21:10,505 REGULATORY DECISION MAKING. SO 495 00:21:10,505 --> 00:21:16,411 WE ARE ALL VERY EXCITED ABOUT 496 00:21:16,411 --> 00:21:17,646 INF 497 00:21:17,646 --> 00:21:19,714 NIH'S COMMITMENT TO EXPAND THESE 498 00:21:19,714 --> 00:21:21,917 TECHNOLOGIES. LED BY ODSS NIH 499 00:21:21,917 --> 00:21:23,452 RELEASED PLAN FOR DATA SCIENCE 500 00:21:23,452 --> 00:21:26,188 FOR 2025 TO 2030 ON 501 00:21:26,188 --> 00:21:28,256 JANUARY 17TH. THIS PLAN PREPARES 502 00:21:28,256 --> 00:21:30,592 NIH TO NAVIGATE EVOLVING 503 00:21:30,592 --> 00:21:33,161 TECHNOLOGY LANDSCAPE, ADDRESS 504 00:21:33,161 --> 00:21:34,996 RAPID RISE IN QUANTITY AND 505 00:21:34,996 --> 00:21:37,566 DIVERSITY AND BRIDGE NEW DATA TO 506 00:21:37,566 --> 00:21:39,301 EXISTING KNOWLEDGE. SO NIH'S 507 00:21:39,301 --> 00:21:41,436 GOALS TO ACHIEVE THIS VISION ARE 508 00:21:41,436 --> 00:21:42,904 TO SUPPORT DATA MANAGEMENT AND 509 00:21:42,904 --> 00:21:45,974 FED RATED RESOURCES, ENHANCE 510 00:21:45,974 --> 00:21:49,110 HUMAN-DERIVED DATA FOR RESEARCH, 511 00:21:49,110 --> 00:21:51,179 CREATE NEW OPPORTUNITIES IN 512 00:21:51,179 --> 00:21:54,115 SOFTWARE, COMPUTATION AND AI AND 513 00:21:54,115 --> 00:21:58,787 STRENGTHEN THE DATA SCIENCE 514 00:21:58,787 --> 00:22:00,121 COMMUNITY. THEN IN FEBRUARY AND 515 00:22:00,121 --> 00:22:02,491 APRIL THE TRIBAL HEALTH RESEARCH 516 00:22:02,491 --> 00:22:07,362 OFFICE, OR THRO LED NIH'S 517 00:22:07,362 --> 00:22:13,301 PARTICIPATION IN CONSULTATION 518 00:22:13,301 --> 00:22:17,772 MEETINGS HELD AT HSSS 519 00:22:17,772 --> 00:22:18,306 HEADQUARTERS. SECRETARY 520 00:22:18,306 --> 00:22:21,209 ROBERT F. KENNEDY , JR. AND 521 00:22:21,209 --> 00:22:23,612 OTHERS MET WITH STAFF AND DR. B. 522 00:22:23,612 --> 00:22:24,846 WAS INTRODUCED TO TRIBAL LEADERS 523 00:22:24,846 --> 00:22:27,415 AND PART OF A PANEL ON CHRONIC 524 00:22:27,415 --> 00:22:29,050 DISEASE DURING THE ATVC, 525 00:22:29,050 --> 00:22:31,887 FOLLOWED BY AN UPDATE AND Q&A 526 00:22:31,887 --> 00:22:33,288 WITH STAT. TRIBAL LEADERS 527 00:22:33,288 --> 00:22:36,124 STRONGLY ADVOCATED DURING THESE 528 00:22:36,124 --> 00:22:37,759 MEETINGS FOR ONGOING HEALTH 529 00:22:37,759 --> 00:22:40,061 INITIATIVES AND EXPANDED 530 00:22:40,061 --> 00:22:41,363 WORKFORCE DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS 531 00:22:41,363 --> 00:22:44,132 IN INDIAN COUNTRY. NEXT NIH 532 00:22:44,132 --> 00:22:45,467 OFFICE OF RESEARCH ON WOMEN'S 533 00:22:45,467 --> 00:22:47,102 HEALTH RECOGNIZES THE NATIONAL 534 00:22:47,102 --> 00:22:51,306 WOMEN'S HEALTH WEEK EACH YEAR . 535 00:22:51,306 --> 00:22:53,942 WITH THE VIVIAN PIN SYMPOSIUM, 536 00:22:53,942 --> 00:22:57,779 HONORING THE FIRST FULL-TIME 537 00:22:57,779 --> 00:23:00,081 DIRECTOR, VIVIAN W. PIN. THIS 538 00:23:00,081 --> 00:23:02,350 YEAR'S SEMINARY, ADVANCING FOR 539 00:23:02,350 --> 00:23:04,219 THE HEALTH OF WOMEN FOCUSED ON 540 00:23:04,219 --> 00:23:06,555 SKILLS, RESOURCES TRAINING CAN 541 00:23:06,555 --> 00:23:08,456 BUILD CAPACITY FOR 542 00:23:08,456 --> 00:23:15,297 INTERDISCIPLINARY DATA ANALYSES. 543 00:23:15,297 --> 00:23:16,698 THE SIMIYMPOSIUM FOCUSED AROUND 544 00:23:16,698 --> 00:23:17,899 REAL WORLD SCIENCE AND DATA 545 00:23:17,899 --> 00:23:20,101 PRIVACY . IF YOU WERE UNABLE TO 546 00:23:20,101 --> 00:23:23,538 ATTEND, YOU ARE IN LUCK. THE 547 00:23:23,538 --> 00:23:24,940 SYMPOSIUM WAS RECORDED AND CAN 548 00:23:24,940 --> 00:23:28,777 BE VIEWED ON NIH VIDEOCAST OR 549 00:23:28,777 --> 00:23:30,745 SCANNING THE QR CODE ON THE 550 00:23:30,745 --> 00:23:33,381 SLIDE. FOR OUR LAST UPDATE, 551 00:23:33,381 --> 00:23:35,984 SCIENTISTS WORKING ON THE GENE 552 00:23:35,984 --> 00:23:38,253 DISRUPTION PROJECT AND 553 00:23:38,253 --> 00:23:39,287 TRANSGENIC PROJECT HAVE BEEN 554 00:23:39,287 --> 00:23:42,857 HONOR ED WITH RECEIVING THE 2025 555 00:23:42,857 --> 00:23:45,827 COMMUNITY AWARD FOR OUTSTANDING 556 00:23:45,827 --> 00:23:46,995 CONTRIBUTIONS TO TECHNOLOGY AND 557 00:23:46,995 --> 00:23:48,496 RESOURCES THAT HAVE BENEFITTED 558 00:23:48,496 --> 00:23:51,800 ALL OF THESE RESEARCHERS. THESE 559 00:23:51,800 --> 00:23:55,737 PROJECT, PRIMARILY FUNDED BY 560 00:23:55,737 --> 00:23:59,040 GROUP, HAVE GENERATED OVER 561 00:23:59,040 --> 00:24:00,175 34,000 STOCKS TO THE CENTER. 562 00:24:00,175 --> 00:24:02,611 THIS CENTER PARTLY SUPPORTED BY 563 00:24:02,611 --> 00:24:06,381 OREP, NIGMS AND NINDS HAS 564 00:24:06,381 --> 00:24:07,582 DISTRIBUTED OVER A MILLION 565 00:24:07,582 --> 00:24:09,384 SAMPLES FROM THESE TWO TO THE 566 00:24:09,384 --> 00:24:11,786 RESEARCH COMMUNITY IN THE PAST 567 00:24:11,786 --> 00:24:13,922 20 YEARS. THESE RESOURCES HAVE 568 00:24:13,922 --> 00:24:15,991 HAVE ENABLE ABLED A BROAD RANGE 569 00:24:15,991 --> 00:24:18,259 OF ALMOST EVERY GENE ON THE FLY 570 00:24:18,259 --> 00:24:20,261 AND PROVIDED INSIGHT TO 571 00:24:20,261 --> 00:24:22,330 MECHANISMS, DIAGNOSIS AND 572 00:24:22,330 --> 00:24:24,099 TREATMENT OF A WIDE RANGE OF 573 00:24:24,099 --> 00:24:28,203 HUMAN DISEASE. OKAY. THAT 574 00:24:28,203 --> 00:24:33,174 CONCLUDES THE NIH DPCPSI 575 00:24:33,174 --> 00:24:35,477 UPDATES. 576 00:24:35,477 --> 00:24:38,713 WE DO HAVE TIME FOR 577 00:24:38,713 --> 00:24:40,548 QUESTIONS SO I CAN OPEN UP THE 578 00:24:40,548 --> 00:24:46,554 FLOOR TO QUESTIONS FROM 579 00:24:46,554 --> 00:24:47,656 COUNCILMEMBERS. 580 00:24:47,656 --> 00:24:47,822 581 00:24:47,822 --> 00:24:49,724 >> I HAVE A QUESTION. 582 00:24:49,724 --> 00:24:52,727 >> DR. MANLEY, PLEASE GO AHEAD. 583 00:24:52,727 --> 00:24:55,263 >> THANK YOU. THANK YOU SO MUCH 584 00:24:55,263 --> 00:25:00,101 FOR THAT UPDATE. MY QUESTION IS 585 00:25:00,101 --> 00:25:04,506 ABOUT THE HIGH-RISK, HIGH-REWARD 586 00:25:04,506 --> 00:25:06,608 PROGRAMS. COUNCIL OF COUNCILS IS 587 00:25:06,608 --> 00:25:10,245 IN CHARGE -- PART OF OUR CHARGE 588 00:25:10,245 --> 00:25:14,416 IS TO ADVISE THE NIH DIRECTOR ON 589 00:25:14,416 --> 00:25:16,718 NIH-WIDE INITIATIVES, LIKE THE 590 00:25:16,718 --> 00:25:19,788 COMMON FUND, HIGH-RISK, 591 00:25:19,788 --> 00:25:23,491 HIGH-REWARD PROGRAMS, WE 592 00:25:23,491 --> 00:25:24,359 ENTHUSIASTICALLY APPROVED THESE 593 00:25:24,359 --> 00:25:26,461 CONCEPTS IN APRIL. WE ARE ALSO 594 00:25:26,461 --> 00:25:27,362 CHARGED WITH PERFORMING THE 595 00:25:27,362 --> 00:25:29,831 SECOND LEVEL OF REVIEW FOR 596 00:25:29,831 --> 00:25:31,099 HIGH-RISK, HIGH-REWARD PROGRAMS 597 00:25:31,099 --> 00:25:33,702 AND ASSESSING THE FIRST LEVEL OF 598 00:25:33,702 --> 00:25:35,704 REVIEW FOR FAIRNESS AND 599 00:25:35,704 --> 00:25:38,106 UNIFORMITY IN THE APPLICATION OF 600 00:25:38,106 --> 00:25:40,742 REVIEW CRITERIA. AT OUR APRIL 601 00:25:40,742 --> 00:25:43,378 COUNCIL MEETING, AS I MENTIONED, 602 00:25:43,378 --> 00:25:46,347 WE ENTHUSIASTICALLY APPROVED 603 00:25:46,347 --> 00:25:47,649 CONSENTS FOR THESE HIGHLY 604 00:25:47,649 --> 00:25:49,284 SELECTED PROGRAMS THAT FOSTER 605 00:25:49,284 --> 00:25:52,554 SCIENTIFIC LEAPS, ENCOURAGE 606 00:25:52,554 --> 00:25:54,122 CREATIVITY AND INNOVATION AND 607 00:25:54,122 --> 00:25:54,756 EMPHASIZED THE DEVELOPMENT OF 608 00:25:54,756 --> 00:25:59,627 THE NEXT GENERATION OF 609 00:25:59,627 --> 00:26:01,362 SCIENTISTS. AT THESE, 610 00:26:01,362 --> 00:26:02,931 APPLICATIONS ARE AVAILABLE TO 611 00:26:02,931 --> 00:26:04,499 PEOPLE ACROSS SCIENTIFIC AREAS 612 00:26:04,499 --> 00:26:07,702 AND INVESTIGATORS ACROSS NIH 613 00:26:07,702 --> 00:26:10,405 INSTITUTES. SO ARE UNIQUE IN 614 00:26:10,405 --> 00:26:14,142 THAT WAY. THE N. O. T. OR NOTICE 615 00:26:14,142 --> 00:26:15,643 OF INTENT TO POST FUNDING 616 00:26:15,643 --> 00:26:18,146 ANNOUNCEMENT FOR THE DP1 617 00:26:18,146 --> 00:26:23,785 PROGRAM, WHICH IS PIONEER'S 618 00:26:23,785 --> 00:26:26,988 AWARD DP2, INNOVATORS, THESE ARE 619 00:26:26,988 --> 00:26:31,092 BEEN POSTED ONLINE BUT THE DP5 620 00:26:31,092 --> 00:26:32,660 OR EARLY INDEPENDENCE IS NOT 621 00:26:32,660 --> 00:26:33,995 THERE. NORMALLY THE 622 00:26:33,995 --> 00:26:35,630 ANNOUNCEMENTS ARE ISSUED EVERY 623 00:26:35,630 --> 00:26:39,334 YEAR IN MARCH. IF THESE ARE 624 00:26:39,334 --> 00:26:41,402 POST ED IN JUNE, AS ESTIMATED, 625 00:26:41,402 --> 00:26:43,838 THE TURNAROUND TIME APPLICANTS 626 00:26:43,838 --> 00:26:46,875 WILL HAVE WILL BE SEVERELY 627 00:26:46,875 --> 00:26:48,343 CONSTRICTED. DUE DATES ARE 628 00:26:48,343 --> 00:26:50,111 NORMALLY SEPTEMBER BUT THE NEW 629 00:26:50,111 --> 00:26:53,948 DP2 DUE DATE IS ESTIMATED TO BE 630 00:26:53,948 --> 00:26:55,116 AUGUST 19, 2025, LEAVING ONLY 631 00:26:55,116 --> 00:26:57,919 TWO MONTHS TO RESPOND. IN THE 632 00:26:57,919 --> 00:27:00,188 NOTICE OF INTENT FOR THE DP2 633 00:27:00,188 --> 00:27:01,823 AWARD, THE NUMBER OF AWARDS HAS 634 00:27:01,823 --> 00:27:05,693 BEEN REDUCED FROM 35 TO 30. THE 635 00:27:05,693 --> 00:27:08,296 PROGRAM -- OR THE FUNDING FOR 636 00:27:08,296 --> 00:27:15,804 THE PROGRAM IS REDUCED FROM 44 637 00:27:15,804 --> 00:27:16,571 MILLION TO 37.7 MILLION. AT 638 00:27:16,571 --> 00:27:19,808 LEAST SIX HIGH-RISK, HIGH-REWARD 639 00:27:19,808 --> 00:27:23,812 PROGRAMS HAVE BEEN CANCELLED 640 00:27:23,812 --> 00:27:26,247 SINCE JANUARY 2025. THESE ARE 641 00:27:26,247 --> 00:27:27,615 ALREADY FUNDED PROGRAMS, ALREADY 642 00:27:27,615 --> 00:27:31,786 REVIEWED PROGRAMS. THERE'S FOUR 643 00:27:31,786 --> 00:27:33,955 DP2s AND TWO DP5s. SO MY 644 00:27:33,955 --> 00:27:35,023 QUESTIONS ARE, I WILL PUT THESE 645 00:27:35,023 --> 00:27:37,826 IN THE CHAT, WHEN DO YOU EXPECT 646 00:27:37,826 --> 00:27:41,362 DP5 MECHANISM TO BE POSTED IF I 647 00:27:41,362 --> 00:27:43,398 WON'T BE, WHY WON'T IT BE. WHAT 648 00:27:43,398 --> 00:27:46,968 IS THE RATIONALE FOR REDUCTION 649 00:27:46,968 --> 00:27:48,336 IN SUPPORT FOR THE DP TOOL OR 650 00:27:48,336 --> 00:27:51,806 NEW INVESTIGATOR AWARDS -- 651 00:27:51,806 --> 00:27:54,142 SORRY, NEW INNOVATOR AWARDS, 652 00:27:54,142 --> 00:27:58,446 GIVEN THE WILD SUCCESS OF THESE 653 00:27:58,446 --> 00:28:03,418 GRANTS IN THE PAST. AND A WINDOW 654 00:28:03,418 --> 00:28:06,187 BETWEEN POSTING OF THE RFAs AND 655 00:28:06,187 --> 00:28:11,726 DUE DATES, ESPECIALLY FOR THE 656 00:28:11,726 --> 00:28:13,528 DP2 PROGRAM AND YOU CLARIFY 657 00:28:13,528 --> 00:28:16,865 COUNCIL COUNCIL'S ROLE IN 658 00:28:16,865 --> 00:28:18,166 ASSESSING FAIRNESS UNITED 659 00:28:18,166 --> 00:28:20,101 NATIONS FORMTY OF VIEW OF 660 00:28:20,101 --> 00:28:22,370 HIGH-RISK AND IE-REWARD NOW THAT 661 00:28:22,370 --> 00:28:24,305 STOP WORK ORDER S HAVE BEEN 662 00:28:24,305 --> 00:28:25,940 ISSUED TO AT LEAST SIX GRANTS IN 663 00:28:25,940 --> 00:28:27,008 THIS PROGRAM THAT WERE 664 00:28:27,008 --> 00:28:30,545 PREVIOUSLY REVIEWED AND APPROVED 665 00:28:30,545 --> 00:28:38,052 BY COUNCIL, THANK YOU. 666 00:28:38,052 --> 00:28:41,055 >> THANK YOU, DR. MANLEY. I DO 667 00:28:41,055 --> 00:28:42,190 APPRECIATE YOU PUTTING THOSE 668 00:28:42,190 --> 00:28:43,591 QUESTIONS IN THE CHAT WHENEVER 669 00:28:43,591 --> 00:28:49,264 YOU HAVE A MOM MOMENT TO ENSURE 670 00:28:49,264 --> 00:28:51,532 DON'T MISS THEM. I CANNOT SPEAK 671 00:28:51,532 --> 00:28:53,601 -- I CAN NOT PROVIDE A 672 00:28:53,601 --> 00:28:54,903 COMPREHENSIVE ANSWER TO EVERY 673 00:28:54,903 --> 00:28:55,970 QUESTION YOU HAVE ASKED. I WILL 674 00:28:55,970 --> 00:28:58,072 TURN -- I DO NOT ACTUALLY SEE 675 00:28:58,072 --> 00:29:02,710 ANY OF MY OSC COLLEAGUES ONLINE 676 00:29:02,710 --> 00:29:04,312 AT THE MOMENT, BUT IF ANY OF 677 00:29:04,312 --> 00:29:05,947 THEM ARE THERE AND WOULD LIKE TO 678 00:29:05,947 --> 00:29:07,415 WEIGH IN ON THAT, I WILL 679 00:29:07,415 --> 00:29:10,485 OBVIOUSLY OPEN UP THE FLOOR TO 680 00:29:10,485 --> 00:29:13,721 THEM. BUT I CAN PROVIDE AS MUCH 681 00:29:13,721 --> 00:29:14,789 INFORMATION AS I HAVE AVAILABLE 682 00:29:14,789 --> 00:29:16,891 AT THIS TIME. LOOKING 683 00:29:16,891 --> 00:29:19,794 SPECIFICALLY FIRST AT THE EARLY 684 00:29:19,794 --> 00:29:21,562 INDEPENDENCE AWARD WE DID 685 00:29:21,562 --> 00:29:23,364 RECEIVE INITIAL FEEDBACK THROUGH 686 00:29:23,364 --> 00:29:27,502 THE INTERNAL REVIEW PROCESS AND 687 00:29:27,502 --> 00:29:29,470 LOOKING AT FURTHER OPTIONS AND 688 00:29:29,470 --> 00:29:32,373 TIMING FOR REISSUING THE NOFO AS 689 00:29:32,373 --> 00:29:35,443 SOON AS POSSIBLE SO WE ARE AWARE 690 00:29:35,443 --> 00:29:40,448 AND ADDRESSING IT. THE RATIONALE 691 00:29:40,448 --> 00:29:49,057 FOR REDICT AND SUPPORT FOR THE, 692 00:29:49,057 --> 00:29:50,692 AGAIN, I WOULD PASS THAT 693 00:29:50,692 --> 00:29:54,696 QUESTION TO MY OSC COLLEAGUES, 694 00:29:54,696 --> 00:29:56,064 WHO I DON'T SEE ONLINE BUT WE 695 00:29:56,064 --> 00:29:57,298 CAN TAKE THAT QUESTION BACK TO 696 00:29:57,298 --> 00:30:00,501 THEM AND COME BACK TO YOU. BUT 697 00:30:00,501 --> 00:30:05,540 MY ASSUMPTION IS THIS IS DUE TO 698 00:30:05,540 --> 00:30:07,141 BUDGET CONSTRAINTS. HOW WILL WE 699 00:30:07,141 --> 00:30:09,077 REDUCE THE NEGATIVE IMPACT OF 700 00:30:09,077 --> 00:30:11,813 THE CONSTRICTED WINDOW BETWEEN 701 00:30:11,813 --> 00:30:14,015 POSTING AND DUE DATES, WE WILL 702 00:30:14,015 --> 00:30:16,017 REVIEW ALL OF THE APPLICATIONS 703 00:30:16,017 --> 00:30:18,453 RECEIVED IN A TIMELY PROCESS AND 704 00:30:18,453 --> 00:30:24,525 ENSURE AWARDS ARE MADE AS 705 00:30:24,525 --> 00:30:28,997 EXPEDIENTLY AS POSSIBLE. CAN I 706 00:30:28,997 --> 00:30:32,900 CLARIFY COUNSEL'S ROLE IN 707 00:30:32,900 --> 00:30:34,202 PROGRAM NOW THAT STOP WORK 708 00:30:34,202 --> 00:30:36,304 ORDERS HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO AT 709 00:30:36,304 --> 00:30:38,272 LEAST SIX GRANTS REVIEWED AND 710 00:30:38,272 --> 00:30:42,844 APPROVED BY COC. THE STOP WORK 711 00:30:42,844 --> 00:30:44,579 ORDERS, I PRESUME, WERE ISSUED 712 00:30:44,579 --> 00:30:51,986 DURING THE REVIEW PROCESS, THE 713 00:30:51,986 --> 00:30:54,122 DOGE REVIEW, TO ENSURE CONSIST 714 00:30:54,122 --> 00:30:57,358 TENSE WITH EXECUTIVE ORDERS WE 715 00:30:57,358 --> 00:31:00,962 HAVE RECEIVED. THAT DOES NOT 716 00:31:00,962 --> 00:31:03,398 CHANGE COUNCIL'S ROLE IN 717 00:31:03,398 --> 00:31:06,834 ASSESSING THE HRHR PROGRAM 718 00:31:06,834 --> 00:31:09,971 MOVING FORWARD. COUNCIL STILL 719 00:31:09,971 --> 00:31:10,571 RETAINS THAT ROLE. 720 00:31:10,571 --> 00:31:14,042 >> LET ME JUST REQUEST, MAYBE BY 721 00:31:14,042 --> 00:31:16,444 THE END OF THE DAY, YOU KNOW, IN 722 00:31:16,444 --> 00:31:18,646 ANOTHER PORTION OF OUR SESSION 723 00:31:18,646 --> 00:31:22,417 WE CAN GET THE ANSWER FROM -- 724 00:31:22,417 --> 00:31:25,186 THAT YOU WERE SEEKING ABOUT THE 725 00:31:25,186 --> 00:31:28,423 REDUCTION IN SUPPORT FOR THE 726 00:31:28,423 --> 00:31:33,227 DP2s. THAT WOULD BE WONDERFUL. I 727 00:31:33,227 --> 00:31:37,098 WILL QUICKLY ASK THE 728 00:31:37,098 --> 00:31:39,500 INFORMATIONAL WEBINARS FOR 729 00:31:39,500 --> 00:31:42,236 APPLICANTS NORMALLY TAKE PLACE 730 00:31:42,236 --> 00:31:44,272 IN LATE JUNE. THAT IS A KEY PART 731 00:31:44,272 --> 00:31:47,942 OF ORIENTING THE SCIENTIFIC 732 00:31:47,942 --> 00:31:53,448 COMMUNITY ABOUT HOW TO APPLY. 733 00:31:53,448 --> 00:31:55,583 THERE IS A RESTRICTED TIME WHEN 734 00:31:55,583 --> 00:32:03,791 THE RFA COMES OUT AND WHEN 735 00:32:03,791 --> 00:32:11,232 APPLICATIONS ARE DUE AND ROLL 736 00:32:11,232 --> 00:32:12,400 OUT FOR APPLICANTS. 737 00:32:12,400 --> 00:32:15,803 >> THANK YOU. I WILL GO BACK TO 738 00:32:15,803 --> 00:32:17,839 MY COLLEAGUES. MY PRESUMPTION IS 739 00:32:17,839 --> 00:32:19,774 THEY ARE CONTINUING TO HOLD THEM 740 00:32:19,774 --> 00:32:22,043 IN LATE JUNE, AS PLANNED. WE 741 00:32:22,043 --> 00:32:24,112 WILL CONFIRM THAT WITH THEM AND 742 00:32:24,112 --> 00:32:30,284 GET BACK TO YOU, THANK YOU. DR. 743 00:32:30,284 --> 00:32:31,018 GANDHI. 744 00:32:31,018 --> 00:32:31,819 >> THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY 745 00:32:31,819 --> 00:32:34,422 BE ON THIS COUNCIL. ONE QUESTION 746 00:32:34,422 --> 00:32:36,190 I HAD WAS THE SIGNIFICANT 747 00:32:36,190 --> 00:32:38,059 RESTRIKE AGRICULTURING OF THE 748 00:32:38,059 --> 00:32:40,528 INSTITUTES PROPOSED BY THE 749 00:32:40,528 --> 00:32:43,097 PASS-BACK BUDGET THAT WAS 750 00:32:43,097 --> 00:32:44,565 REVEALED TO -- I THINK 751 00:32:44,565 --> 00:32:49,303 WASHINGTON POST REVEALED IT 752 00:32:49,303 --> 00:32:51,839 APRIL 16TH. THE CONSOLIDATED 753 00:32:51,839 --> 00:32:52,874 INSTITUTES WERE REALLY 754 00:32:52,874 --> 00:32:57,512 DIFFERENT. FOR EXAMPLE, NIMH, 755 00:32:57,512 --> 00:32:59,247 NIDA, NIAA WOULD GO UNDER 756 00:32:59,247 --> 00:33:01,048 SOMETHING LIKE NATIONAL 757 00:33:01,048 --> 00:33:02,416 INSTITUTES OF BEHAVIORAL HEALTH 758 00:33:02,416 --> 00:33:05,319 SO SEEMED LIKE A MASSIVE 759 00:33:05,319 --> 00:33:06,487 RESTRUCTURING. WHEN WE LOOKED AT 760 00:33:06,487 --> 00:33:08,422 THE CHARTER OF COUNCIL OF 761 00:33:08,422 --> 00:33:09,690 COUNCILS, IT SEEMED LIKE 762 00:33:09,690 --> 00:33:11,359 ANYTHING THAT WOULD INFLUENCE 763 00:33:11,359 --> 00:33:12,994 REORGANIZATION AND STRATEGIC 764 00:33:12,994 --> 00:33:14,128 COORDINATION AND PLANNING WOULD 765 00:33:14,128 --> 00:33:16,864 BE WITHIN THE CHARTER OF THE 766 00:33:16,864 --> 00:33:19,700 COUNCIL OF COUNCIL'S ABILITY TO 767 00:33:19,700 --> 00:33:23,538 ADVISE SO WANTED TO ASK ABOUT IS 768 00:33:23,538 --> 00:33:25,273 OUR CHARTER STILL THE SAME FOR 769 00:33:25,273 --> 00:33:29,944 COUNCIL OF COUNCILS TO ADVISE 770 00:33:29,944 --> 00:33:32,213 SOMETHING AND ADVICE SOMETHING 771 00:33:32,213 --> 00:33:34,982 LIKE RESTRIKE AGRICULTURE. AND 772 00:33:34,982 --> 00:33:36,284 THAT WOULD RELATE TWO OTHER 773 00:33:36,284 --> 00:33:46,294 MAJOR RELATE TO. ONE IS SHORT IS 774 00:33:46,294 --> 00:33:48,996 SUPPOSED TO BE 27 MEMBERS, NOW 775 00:33:48,996 --> 00:33:49,597 CURRENTLY 10, THOUGH OTHER S 776 00:33:49,597 --> 00:33:51,933 HAVE BEEN APPROVED. ALSO, FOR 777 00:33:51,933 --> 00:33:52,733 EXAMPLE, SOMETHING LIKE THE 778 00:33:52,733 --> 00:33:59,807 FOREIGN SUB AWARD, NOTOD, 25104 779 00:33:59,807 --> 00:34:00,641 MAY 1ST WHICH SIGNIFICANTLY 780 00:34:00,641 --> 00:34:03,277 CHANGES FUNDING STRUCTURE OF NIH 781 00:34:03,277 --> 00:34:06,113 AND HALTED AT THIS MOMENT GLOBAL 782 00:34:06,113 --> 00:34:08,182 RESEARCH AT THE NIH. SO IT IS 783 00:34:08,182 --> 00:34:09,884 REALLY MORE OF A PHILOSOPHICAL 784 00:34:09,884 --> 00:34:12,253 QUESTION ABOUT IS OUR CHARTER 785 00:34:12,253 --> 00:34:14,655 STILL THERE. HAS IT CHANGED AND 786 00:34:14,655 --> 00:34:18,326 COULD WE ADVISE ON THESE TOPIC, 787 00:34:18,326 --> 00:34:20,228 RESTRUCTURING FOREIGN SUB AWARDS 788 00:34:20,228 --> 00:34:22,663 AND MEMBERSHIP -- IF THIS 789 00:34:22,663 --> 00:34:27,802 MEMBERSHIP NUMBER REMAINS THE 790 00:34:27,802 --> 00:34:28,035 SAME. 791 00:34:28,035 --> 00:34:30,438 >> THANK YOU DR. GANDHI. THE 792 00:34:30,438 --> 00:34:32,540 CHARTER OF COUNCIL OF COUNCILS 793 00:34:32,540 --> 00:34:35,443 HAS NOT CHANGED. WE CAN DISCUSS 794 00:34:35,443 --> 00:34:37,144 WHETHER OR NOT RESTRICT PROPOSED 795 00:34:37,144 --> 00:34:38,079 RESTRUCTURING IS SOMETHING THAT 796 00:34:38,079 --> 00:34:40,681 WOULD BE AN AGENDA ITEM FOR 797 00:34:40,681 --> 00:34:46,821 DISCUSSION AND ADVICE IN FUTURE 798 00:34:46,821 --> 00:34:49,257 COUNCIL MEETINGS. WE ARE AWARD 799 00:34:49,257 --> 00:34:52,260 TO CONSOLIDATE THE 27 INSTITUTES 800 00:34:52,260 --> 00:34:54,061 AND CENTERS. THIS PROPOSAL 801 00:34:54,061 --> 00:34:56,030 OUTLINES RESTRUCTURING TO 802 00:34:56,030 --> 00:34:57,331 RETAINING THE NATIONAL CANCER 803 00:34:57,331 --> 00:34:59,433 INSTITUTE, NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF 804 00:34:59,433 --> 00:35:01,936 ALLERGY AND INFECTIOUS DISEASES 805 00:35:01,936 --> 00:35:03,537 AND NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF AGING 806 00:35:03,537 --> 00:35:07,141 AND CONSOLIDATE THE REMAINING 807 00:35:07,141 --> 00:35:09,410 INTO FIVE NEW ONES, NATIONAL 808 00:35:09,410 --> 00:35:12,046 INSTITUTE ON BODY RESEARCH, 809 00:35:12,046 --> 00:35:15,483 BRAIN, GENERAL SCIENCES, 810 00:35:15,483 --> 00:35:17,051 DISABILITY-RELATE AND BEHAVIORAL 811 00:35:17,051 --> 00:35:19,153 HEALTH. THAT IS THE PROPOSAL 812 00:35:19,153 --> 00:35:22,089 THAT IS PART OF THE OMB BUDGET 813 00:35:22,089 --> 00:35:26,560 IN THE PRESIDENT'S BUDGET. 814 00:35:26,560 --> 00:35:29,397 REGARDING THE NIH POLICY ON 815 00:35:29,397 --> 00:35:31,232 FOREIGN SUB AWARDS I THINK 816 00:35:31,232 --> 00:35:32,566 PROBABLY MANY OF YOU HAVE READ 817 00:35:32,566 --> 00:35:34,869 THE POLICY AND ARE AWARE THAT WE 818 00:35:34,869 --> 00:35:38,339 ARE WORKING VERY HARD TO 819 00:35:38,339 --> 00:35:39,974 ESTABLISH A NEW AWARD STRUCTURE 820 00:35:39,974 --> 00:35:44,679 BY THE END OF SEPTEMBER SO BY 821 00:35:44,679 --> 00:35:45,513 SEPTEMBER 30TH, 2025, THAT 822 00:35:45,513 --> 00:35:46,714 PROHIBITS FOREIGN SUB AWARDS 823 00:35:46,714 --> 00:35:50,151 FROM BEING NESTED UNDER THE 824 00:35:50,151 --> 00:35:51,585 PARENT GRANT BUT IMPLEMENTS A 825 00:35:51,585 --> 00:35:53,854 NEW AWARD STRUCTURE THAT 826 00:35:53,854 --> 00:35:57,358 INCLUDES A PRIME WITH 827 00:35:57,358 --> 00:36:07,268 INDEPENDENT AWARDS TO MORE TRACK 828 00:36:07,268 --> 00:36:09,070 INDIVIDUALLY WHILE SCIENTIFIC 829 00:36:09,070 --> 00:36:10,838 PROGRESS COLLECTED BY THE 830 00:36:10,838 --> 00:36:12,373 PRIMARY INSTITUTION. UNTIL THAT 831 00:36:12,373 --> 00:36:14,675 IS IN PLACE NIH WILL NOT ISSUE 832 00:36:14,675 --> 00:36:18,179 AWARDS THAT INCLUDE A FOREIGN 833 00:36:18,179 --> 00:36:22,016 SUB AWARD. THIS IS A TEMPORARY 834 00:36:22,016 --> 00:36:23,951 PAUSE WHILE NIH FINALIZES 835 00:36:23,951 --> 00:36:25,052 IMPLEMENTATION OF STRUCTURE 836 00:36:25,052 --> 00:36:28,322 WHICH IS EXPECTED NO LATER THAN 837 00:36:28,322 --> 00:36:29,690 SEPTEMBER. THE INTENTION HERE IS 838 00:36:29,690 --> 00:36:32,026 TO HAVE A CLEARER STRUCTURE AND 839 00:36:32,026 --> 00:36:35,363 SAFEGUARDS TO ENHANCE 840 00:36:35,363 --> 00:36:37,398 TRANSPARENCY, TRACKABILITY AND 841 00:36:37,398 --> 00:36:38,666 PROTECT NATIONAL SECURITY IN 842 00:36:38,666 --> 00:36:42,403 AREAS OF MONETARY AND 843 00:36:42,403 --> 00:36:43,604 NON-MONETARY FOREIGN 844 00:36:43,604 --> 00:36:46,741 COLLABORA 845 00:36:46,741 --> 00:36:47,775 COLLABORATION. I THINK I 846 00:36:47,775 --> 00:36:49,043 ADDRESSED ALL THE POINTS. 847 00:36:49,043 --> 00:36:51,011 >>> I THINK THE LAST WAS 848 00:36:51,011 --> 00:36:53,114 27-MEMBER COMMITTEE AND WE KNOW 849 00:36:53,114 --> 00:36:54,749 OUR COLLEAGUES HAD BEEN 850 00:36:54,749 --> 00:36:58,252 APPROVED. NOW IT IS CURRENTLY 851 00:36:58,252 --> 00:36:58,452 TEN. 852 00:36:58,452 --> 00:37:01,389 >> CORRECT. WE -- SO THE 853 00:37:01,389 --> 00:37:03,023 APPROVAL PROCESS IS STILL 854 00:37:03,023 --> 00:37:04,191 UNDERWAY. WE HAVE PENDING 855 00:37:04,191 --> 00:37:06,227 MEMBERS THAT HAVE BEEN NOMINATED 856 00:37:06,227 --> 00:37:09,130 OVER THE PAST TWO YEARS. WE ARE 857 00:37:09,130 --> 00:37:10,831 CURRENTLY GOING THROUGH, 858 00:37:10,831 --> 00:37:12,500 NOMINATING PEOPLE FOR 2025 859 00:37:12,500 --> 00:37:14,135 VACANCIES. HOWEVER, WITH THE 860 00:37:14,135 --> 00:37:15,269 HIRING FREEZE IT IS ACTUALLY NOT 861 00:37:15,269 --> 00:37:16,937 POSSIBLE FOR US TO APPOINT NEW 862 00:37:16,937 --> 00:37:18,806 MEMBERS AT THIS TIME. BUT WE ARE 863 00:37:18,806 --> 00:37:21,675 WORKING ON CLEARING THIS BACKLOG 864 00:37:21,675 --> 00:37:22,443 AS SOON AS -- 865 00:37:22,443 --> 00:37:28,315 >> OKAY, THANK YOU. THANK YOU. 866 00:37:28,315 --> 00:37:31,419 >> THERE LLOYD I THINK WAS NEXT. 867 00:37:31,419 --> 00:37:33,120 >> HI, GOOD MORNING DR. 868 00:37:33,120 --> 00:37:34,622 KLEINSTREUER. JUST FOLLOWING UP 869 00:37:34,622 --> 00:37:37,525 ON MONICA'S COMMENTS, YOU KNOW, 870 00:37:37,525 --> 00:37:39,326 JUST TO BE FRANK, I THINK A LOT 871 00:37:39,326 --> 00:37:41,695 OF US ARE SKEPTICAL THAT THIS 872 00:37:41,695 --> 00:37:44,632 PLAN FOR RESTRUCTURING AT NIH IS 873 00:37:44,632 --> 00:37:46,434 GOING TO LEAD TO THE 874 00:37:46,434 --> 00:37:47,468 ADMINISTRATION'S EFFORT TO MAKE 875 00:37:47,468 --> 00:37:49,737 AMERICA HEALTHY AGAIN. 876 00:37:49,737 --> 00:37:52,273 ESPECIALLY IN LIGHT OF THE 877 00:37:52,273 --> 00:37:54,475 PROPOSED SIGNIFICANT PROPOSED 878 00:37:54,475 --> 00:37:55,843 REDUCTION AND BUDGET TO THE NIH 879 00:37:55,843 --> 00:37:59,480 SO REMAINS KIND OF QUESTIONABLE. 880 00:37:59,480 --> 00:38:01,182 MY QUESTION IS REGARDING YOUR -- 881 00:38:01,182 --> 00:38:03,818 THANKS FOR THIS PRESENTATION YOU 882 00:38:03,818 --> 00:38:05,920 MADE ABOUT PRIORITIZING 883 00:38:05,920 --> 00:38:07,087 HUMAN-BASED RESEARCH 884 00:38:07,087 --> 00:38:09,790 TECHNOLOGIES. I DON'T THINK YOU 885 00:38:09,790 --> 00:38:11,826 MENTIONED THIS ANNOUNCEMENT THAT 886 00:38:11,826 --> 00:38:14,595 CAME OUT AT THE SAME TIME AS 887 00:38:14,595 --> 00:38:17,164 APRIL 29TH, EIGHT DAYS AFTER OUR 888 00:38:17,164 --> 00:38:21,268 LAST COUNCIL MEETING. THIS 889 00:38:21,268 --> 00:38:22,837 CREATION OF OFFICE RESEARCH AND 890 00:38:22,837 --> 00:38:25,506 VALIDATION FOR RIVA P SO 891 00:38:25,506 --> 00:38:26,941 WONDER ING IF YOU COULD MAYBE 892 00:38:26,941 --> 00:38:28,275 COMMENT ABOUT THAT. WHAT EXACTLY 893 00:38:28,275 --> 00:38:30,177 THAT WILL BE DOING. I NOTICED, 894 00:38:30,177 --> 00:38:33,781 AND YOU ARE VERY CAREFUL AND I 895 00:38:33,781 --> 00:38:34,949 APPRECIATE THAT OF MENTIONING 896 00:38:34,949 --> 00:38:37,818 HOW NOVEL ALTERNATIVE METHODS, 897 00:38:37,818 --> 00:38:39,820 WHICH I THINK ARE FANTASTIC. 898 00:38:39,820 --> 00:38:42,990 THEY ARE TO COMPLEMENT 899 00:38:42,990 --> 00:38:44,225 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH AND 900 00:38:44,225 --> 00:38:45,526 COMPLEMENT ANIMAL NOD DELL USE 901 00:38:45,526 --> 00:38:47,828 AND NOT TO REPLACE THEM SO I'M 902 00:38:47,828 --> 00:38:49,163 REALLY HAPPY TO HEAR YOU SAID 903 00:38:49,163 --> 00:38:50,831 THAT. THERE STILL REMAINS A LOT 904 00:38:50,831 --> 00:38:54,435 OF CONCERN OUT HERE IN THE 905 00:38:54,435 --> 00:38:55,636 SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY THAT -- 906 00:38:55,636 --> 00:38:57,071 WITH OTHERS THAT ARE SPEAKING 907 00:38:57,071 --> 00:38:58,772 THAT THERE REALLY IS AN EFFORT 908 00:38:58,772 --> 00:39:00,441 TO ELIMINATE SUPPORT FOR ANIMAL 909 00:39:00,441 --> 00:39:02,443 RESEARCH. YOU KNOW, WE HAVE SEEN 910 00:39:02,443 --> 00:39:05,813 JUST OVER THE LAST WEEK THIS 911 00:39:05,813 --> 00:39:07,147 FANTASTIC NUMBER OF PAPERS 912 00:39:07,147 --> 00:39:09,250 COMING OUT IN REPORTS IN FACT, 913 00:39:09,250 --> 00:39:12,753 OF HOW ANIMAL-BASED RESEARCH HAS 914 00:39:12,753 --> 00:39:15,489 BEEN ABSOLUTELY INCREDIBLE AND 915 00:39:15,489 --> 00:39:17,324 INCREDIBLY IMPORTANT FOR HUMAN 916 00:39:17,324 --> 00:39:18,425 HEALTH RESEARCH. I WILL JUST 917 00:39:18,425 --> 00:39:20,528 GIVE THE EXAMPLE THAT CPS1 918 00:39:20,528 --> 00:39:23,664 TREATMENT BY THIS PERSONIZED 919 00:39:23,664 --> 00:39:25,633 CRISPR BASED PRIME EDITING AT 920 00:39:25,633 --> 00:39:29,436 CHOP, YOU KNOW, IT IS CITED IN 921 00:39:29,436 --> 00:39:30,504 THE ANNOUNCEMENT AND PAPER THEIR 922 00:39:30,504 --> 00:39:34,041 NECESSITY FOR MOUSE MODELS TO 923 00:39:34,041 --> 00:39:35,943 VALIDATE THE TECHNIQUE AND 924 00:39:35,943 --> 00:39:37,511 NON-HUMAN PRIMATES TO TEST IT. 925 00:39:37,511 --> 00:39:40,881 JUST WONDER ING IF YOU COULD 926 00:39:40,881 --> 00:39:43,484 COMMENT ABOUT OR RIVA WHAT YOUR 927 00:39:43,484 --> 00:39:45,619 PLANS OR I IMAGINE OFFICE AS 928 00:39:45,619 --> 00:39:48,455 OFFICE OR DIRECTOR OR DPCPSI AND 929 00:39:48,455 --> 00:39:52,526 YOUR THOUGHTS ABOUT ALL THAT, 930 00:39:52,526 --> 00:39:52,793 THANKS. 931 00:39:52,793 --> 00:40:00,534 >> THANK YOU, DR. LLOYD. YES. SO 932 00:40:00,534 --> 00:40:05,739 THE -- I LIKE TO PRONOUNCE IT 933 00:40:05,739 --> 00:40:09,643 ORIVA, BUT TO EACH HIS OWN. THIS 934 00:40:09,643 --> 00:40:12,246 INTENT IS PART OF A PROPOSAL 935 00:40:12,246 --> 00:40:14,882 THAT WILL NEED TO BE APPROVED BY 936 00:40:14,882 --> 00:40:16,884 HHS AND, YOU KNOW, CONGRESS WILL 937 00:40:16,884 --> 00:40:19,820 NEED TO BE NOTIFIED. SO THAT 938 00:40:19,820 --> 00:40:21,221 ISN'T FINALIZED YET BUT THE 939 00:40:21,221 --> 00:40:24,458 INTENT OF ORIVA IS ACTUALLY TO 940 00:40:24,458 --> 00:40:25,359 FUNCTION MUCH IN THE SAME WAY 941 00:40:25,359 --> 00:40:30,130 THAT MANY OF THE OTHER DPCPSI 942 00:40:30,130 --> 00:40:36,437 OFFICES FUNCTION. IF YOU TAKE 943 00:40:36,437 --> 00:40:39,273 OWRH OR OTHERS THESE ARE 944 00:40:39,273 --> 00:40:41,475 CROSS-CUTTING THEMES. MANY OF 945 00:40:41,475 --> 00:40:43,577 ALL THE NIH INSTITUTES AND 946 00:40:43,577 --> 00:40:45,646 CENTERS HAVE VERY ROBUST 947 00:40:45,646 --> 00:40:48,482 PROGRAMS IN. NAMS HAS REALLY 948 00:40:48,482 --> 00:40:51,819 OVER THE LAST SEVERAL DECADES 949 00:40:51,819 --> 00:40:55,856 RISEN TO THE LEVEL OF NEEDING A 950 00:40:55,856 --> 00:40:59,593 COORDINATING OFFICE TO ENSURE 951 00:40:59,593 --> 00:41:01,362 THE NIH-WIDE EFFORTS TO DEVELOP, 952 00:41:01,362 --> 00:41:05,532 VALIDATE AND SCALE THE USE OF 953 00:41:05,532 --> 00:41:07,935 NEW APPROACH METHODOLOGIES ARE 954 00:41:07,935 --> 00:41:10,037 WORKING EFFECTIVELY TOGETHER. SO 955 00:41:10,037 --> 00:41:12,039 THAT WE CAN REALLY COORDINATE 956 00:41:12,039 --> 00:41:15,709 ACROSS THE AGENCIES BIOMEDICAL 957 00:41:15,709 --> 00:41:17,544 RESEARCH PORTFOLIO TO SERVE AS 958 00:41:17,544 --> 00:41:19,346 HUB FOR ENTER AGENCY 959 00:41:19,346 --> 00:41:21,115 COORDINATION, TO ENSURE THESE 960 00:41:21,115 --> 00:41:23,717 NAMS DEVELOPED TO BE AS RELEVANT 961 00:41:23,717 --> 00:41:26,854 AND TRANSLATIONAL AS POSSIBLE TO 962 00:41:26,854 --> 00:41:28,822 HUMAN HEALTH ARE BEING DEVELOPED 963 00:41:28,822 --> 00:41:31,692 ROBUSTLY AND EVALUATED AND 964 00:41:31,692 --> 00:41:34,762 VALIDATED TO ENSURE THEIR 965 00:41:34,762 --> 00:41:35,763 SUITABILITY AND CONVERSATION AND 966 00:41:35,763 --> 00:41:38,732 THEIR USE FOR ARING TOIR 967 00:41:38,732 --> 00:41:40,634 DECISION MAKING AND BIOMEDICAL 968 00:41:40,634 --> 00:41:43,203 RESEARCH INSIGHTS AND 969 00:41:43,203 --> 00:41:44,938 DISCOVERIES. SO THAT IS OUR 970 00:41:44,938 --> 00:41:48,709 VISION FOR ORIVA'S FUNCTION. WE 971 00:41:48,709 --> 00:41:50,978 ALSO ENVISIONED EXPANDING TO, 972 00:41:50,978 --> 00:41:54,214 AGAIN, MUCH LIKE ANY OF THE 973 00:41:54,214 --> 00:41:55,816 OTHER DPCPSI OFFICES, HAVING 974 00:41:55,816 --> 00:41:57,818 CO -FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES IN 975 00:41:57,818 --> 00:41:59,420 PARTNERSHIP WITH OTHER ICs 976 00:41:59,420 --> 00:42:01,321 WORKING IN THE SPACE, EXPANDING 977 00:42:01,321 --> 00:42:04,625 TRAINING IN NON-ANIMAL 978 00:42:04,625 --> 00:42:06,126 APPROACHES, DEVELOPING BETTER 979 00:42:06,126 --> 00:42:09,430 EVALUATION CRITERIA TO ASSESS 980 00:42:09,430 --> 00:42:10,898 THOSE METHODS BASED ON THEIR 981 00:42:10,898 --> 00:42:15,169 SUITABILITY, CONTEXT OF USE, 982 00:42:15,169 --> 00:42:16,303 TRANSLATIONAL RELEVANCE, ET 983 00:42:16,303 --> 00:42:18,505 CETERA. WORKING WITH GREAT 984 00:42:18,505 --> 00:42:22,543 REVIEW STAFF TO BETTER INTEGRATE 985 00:42:22,543 --> 00:42:24,078 EXPERTS ON NAMS INTO VARIOUS 986 00:42:24,078 --> 00:42:34,121 STUDY SECTIONS SO THOSE ARE 987 00:42:34,121 --> 00:42:36,190 IDEA S IF INCLUDED FOR INCLUSION 988 00:42:36,190 --> 00:42:36,724 IN DPCPSI. 989 00:42:36,724 --> 00:42:39,359 >> I THINK THAT IS ALL VERY 990 00:42:39,359 --> 00:42:40,194 INTRIGUING AND APPRECIATE THAT 991 00:42:40,194 --> 00:42:41,862 FURTHER EXPLANATION. I THINK IT 992 00:42:41,862 --> 00:42:43,230 IS IMPORTANT -- YOU KEEP USING 993 00:42:43,230 --> 00:42:45,232 THE WORD VALIDATION. I THINK 994 00:42:45,232 --> 00:42:50,404 VALIDATION INCLUDES VALIDATING 995 00:42:50,404 --> 00:42:51,805 INVIVO COMPLEX SYSTEMS LIKE A 996 00:42:51,805 --> 00:42:55,042 MOUSE OR NON-HUMAN PRIMATE, YOU 997 00:42:55,042 --> 00:42:56,844 MENTIONED THE AWARD. SO IT IS 998 00:42:56,844 --> 00:42:58,112 REALLY IMPORTANT WE PROTECT THE 999 00:42:58,112 --> 00:42:59,913 STOCK CENTERS THAT ARE OUT 1000 00:42:59,913 --> 00:43:02,149 THERE, PROVIDING THOSE ANIMAL 1001 00:43:02,149 --> 00:43:05,285 MODELS FOR PEOPLE TO USE AND, 1002 00:43:05,285 --> 00:43:08,222 IMPORTANTLY, FOG BEING ABLE TO 1003 00:43:08,222 --> 00:43:10,824 VALIDATE THESE NAMS AND THEY 1004 00:43:10,824 --> 00:43:11,859 COME ONLINE. 1005 00:43:11,859 --> 00:43:15,829 >> THANK YOU FOR YOUR FEEDBACK. 1006 00:43:15,829 --> 00:43:19,333 NOTE THOSE FOR THE ORO RESEARCH 1007 00:43:19,333 --> 00:43:22,035 CENTERS ARE CONTINUING AND , IN 1008 00:43:22,035 --> 00:43:24,071 FACT, HAVE WE HAVE BEEN WORKING 1009 00:43:24,071 --> 00:43:27,007 RECENTLY TO EXPAND THEM AND 1010 00:43:27,007 --> 00:43:29,309 INCLUDE MENTION OF EMPHASIS ON 1011 00:43:29,309 --> 00:43:33,847 NAMS AS COMPLEMENTARY RI 1012 00:43:33,847 --> 00:43:37,217 ACTIVITIES TO THE ANIMAL MODELS 1013 00:43:37,217 --> 00:43:40,554 SUPPORTED BY THOSE RESOURCE 1014 00:43:40,554 --> 00:43:44,191 CENTERS. DR. VAN GELTER THEN WE 1015 00:43:44,191 --> 00:43:45,492 HAVE TO MOVE ON SO WE HAVE TO 1016 00:43:45,492 --> 00:43:47,127 KEEP TO OUR AGENDA. WE WILL HAVE 1017 00:43:47,127 --> 00:43:49,830 TIME POTENTIALLY LATER IN THE 1018 00:43:49,830 --> 00:43:51,498 MEETING TO REVISIT SOME OF YOUR 1019 00:43:51,498 --> 00:43:53,200 QUESTIONS, ASSUMING WE CAN STAY 1020 00:43:53,200 --> 00:43:55,836 ON TRACK AS FAR AS THE AGENDA 1021 00:43:55,836 --> 00:44:05,746 GOES. PLEASE GO AHEAD, RUSS. 1022 00:44:05,746 --> 00:44:07,514 >> -- CURRENTLY AND COMING BACK 1023 00:44:07,514 --> 00:44:10,617 TO THE NIH ISSUE, WE DISCUSSED 1024 00:44:10,617 --> 00:44:12,085 THIS AT THE LAST COUNCIL OF 1025 00:44:12,085 --> 00:44:13,887 COUNCIL MEETING IN 2024 UNDER 1026 00:44:13,887 --> 00:44:16,423 YOUR PREDECESSOR AND I BELIEVE 1027 00:44:16,423 --> 00:44:17,925 BROUGHT UP TO ADVISORY MEETING 1028 00:44:17,925 --> 00:44:22,396 TO THE DIRECTOR, THERE IS A CON 1029 00:44:22,396 --> 00:44:23,831 ARE CONGRESSLY MANDATED PROCESS 1030 00:44:23,831 --> 00:44:26,466 FOR COORDINATION OF NIH, UNDER 1031 00:44:26,466 --> 00:44:28,836 THE REFORM ACTIVE 2006, WHICH 1032 00:44:28,836 --> 00:44:30,470 STARTS WITH THE SECRETARY OF 1033 00:44:30,470 --> 00:44:33,106 HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES, 1034 00:44:33,106 --> 00:44:36,543 GIVING 180 DAYS NOTICE FOR 1035 00:44:36,543 --> 00:44:37,678 POSSIBLE REORGANIZATION. THEN A 1036 00:44:37,678 --> 00:44:41,348 PROCESS IN WHICH THE SCIENTIFIC 1037 00:44:41,348 --> 00:44:42,149 MANAGEMENT REVIEW BOARD COMMENTS 1038 00:44:42,149 --> 00:44:46,019 ON THE POTENTIAL REORGANIZATION. 1039 00:44:46,019 --> 00:44:48,522 FOLLOWED BY THEN PUBLIC HEARINGS 1040 00:44:48,522 --> 00:44:50,424 AND ULTIMATELY CONGRESSIONAL 1041 00:44:50,424 --> 00:44:52,059 LEVEL APPROVAL, OR AT LEAST 1042 00:44:52,059 --> 00:44:53,227 CONGRESSIONAL NOTIFICATION. WE 1043 00:44:53,227 --> 00:44:57,664 WERE TOLD IN THE FALL THE SMRB, 1044 00:44:57,664 --> 00:44:59,233 THE SCIENTIFIC MANAGEMENT REVIEW 1045 00:44:59,233 --> 00:45:01,401 BOARD, HAD BEEN RECHARTERED. 1046 00:45:01,401 --> 00:45:02,870 DORMANT FOR A NUMBER OF YEARS. 1047 00:45:02,870 --> 00:45:04,738 IT IS ONLY REQUIRED TO MEET 1048 00:45:04,738 --> 00:45:07,274 EVERY SEVEN YEARS. IT WAS 1049 00:45:07,274 --> 00:45:08,842 BEGINNING A PROCESS TOWARDS 1050 00:45:08,842 --> 00:45:12,546 LOOKING AT REORGANIZATION. IT 1051 00:45:12,546 --> 00:45:13,780 APPEARS THE CURRENT 1052 00:45:13,780 --> 00:45:15,082 RECOMMENDATION, AT LEAST FROM 1053 00:45:15,082 --> 00:45:16,984 THE PRESIDENT'S BUDGET, BYPASS 1054 00:45:16,984 --> 00:45:18,719 THIS AND ASSUME REORGANIZATION 1055 00:45:18,719 --> 00:45:20,187 INTO A SMALLER NUMBER OF 1056 00:45:20,187 --> 00:45:23,023 INSTITUTES AND CENTERS, WHICH 1057 00:45:23,023 --> 00:45:25,492 WILL OBVIOUSLY HAVE TREMENDOUS 1058 00:45:25,492 --> 00:45:26,426 REPERCUSSIONS UNDER THE 1059 00:45:26,426 --> 00:45:31,531 PORTFOLIO THAT HAPPENS UNDER NIH 1060 00:45:31,531 --> 00:45:33,166 AND AFFECT MANY PROPOSALALS FROM 1061 00:45:33,166 --> 00:45:34,768 THE COMMENT FUND. CAN YOU GIVE 1062 00:45:34,768 --> 00:45:36,270 AN UPDATE ON THAT PROCESS. IN 1063 00:45:36,270 --> 00:45:38,238 PARTICULAR, WHAT THE SMRB STATUS 1064 00:45:38,238 --> 00:45:40,140 IS, WHETHER THEY HAVE MET YET OR 1065 00:45:40,140 --> 00:45:42,342 WHETHER THEY HAVE A MEETING 1066 00:45:42,342 --> 00:45:46,413 PLANNED, AND IF THAT WILL BE 1067 00:45:46,413 --> 00:45:46,647 PUBLIC. 1068 00:45:46,647 --> 00:45:48,548 >> THANK YOU FOR THE COMMENTS, 1069 00:45:48,548 --> 00:45:55,055 DR. VAN GELDER. YOUR COMMENTS 1070 00:45:55,055 --> 00:45:57,257 SUMMARIZED EFFECTIVELY THE 1071 00:45:57,257 --> 00:46:01,895 STATUS OF THIS PARTICULAR ISSUE 1072 00:46:01,895 --> 00:46:05,766 SO AS YOU NOTED SMRB WAS 1073 00:46:05,766 --> 00:46:06,767 RECONSTITUTED, RECHARTERED. THEY 1074 00:46:06,767 --> 00:46:09,970 HAVE NOT MET YET. I AM NOT AWARE 1075 00:46:09,970 --> 00:46:13,607 OF A PLANNED MEETING SO THAT -- 1076 00:46:13,607 --> 00:46:15,709 I GUESS THAT IS NOT THE MOST 1077 00:46:15,709 --> 00:46:17,411 SATISFACTORY ANSWER BUT ALL THE 1078 00:46:17,411 --> 00:46:20,647 INFORMATION I HAVE AVAILABLE AT 1079 00:46:20,647 --> 00:46:22,416 THIS TIME, THANK YOU. 1080 00:46:22,416 --> 00:46:25,118 >> MAY I INTERRUPT. IF WE ARE 1081 00:46:25,118 --> 00:46:28,021 MOVING ON, LET ME ASK BARBARA 1082 00:46:28,021 --> 00:46:28,855 KELLY TO INTRODUCE HERSELF 1083 00:46:28,855 --> 00:46:32,192 BECAUSE I SEE SHE IS ON NOW. 1084 00:46:32,192 --> 00:46:34,828 BARBARA, WOULD YOU LIKE TO 1085 00:46:34,828 --> 00:46:36,430 INTRODUCE YOURSELF. NAME YOUR 1086 00:46:36,430 --> 00:46:37,431 AFFILIATION, IF YOU HAVE SERVED 1087 00:46:37,431 --> 00:46:38,999 ON A PREVIOUS COUNCIL. 1088 00:46:38,999 --> 00:46:40,801 >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. BARBARA 1089 00:46:40,801 --> 00:46:42,569 KELLY, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE 1090 00:46:42,569 --> 00:46:43,971 HEARING LOSS ASSOCIATION OF 1091 00:46:43,971 --> 00:46:45,572 AMERICA. I PREVIOUSLY SERVED ON 1092 00:46:45,572 --> 00:46:47,641 THE NATIONAL INSTITUTE ON 1093 00:46:47,641 --> 00:46:50,010 DEAFNESS AND OTHER COMMUNICATION 1094 00:46:50,010 --> 00:46:51,578 DISORDERS COUNCIL, THANK YOU. 1095 00:46:51,578 --> 00:46:53,347 >> GREAT, THANK YOU, BARBARA. 1096 00:46:53,347 --> 00:46:56,750 NOW BACK TO YOU, NICOLE. 1097 00:46:56,750 --> 00:47:00,620 >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. OKAY. SO 1098 00:47:00,620 --> 00:47:03,690 NEXT WE ARE MOVING TO WORKING 1099 00:47:03,690 --> 00:47:05,959 GROUP RECOMMENDATION REPORTS. 1100 00:47:05,959 --> 00:47:11,965 FIRST WE HAVE THE NIH GENERALIST 1101 00:47:11,965 --> 00:47:12,632 REPOSITORY ECOSYSTEM INITIATIVE, 1102 00:47:12,632 --> 00:47:13,433 COUNCIL OF COUNCIL 1103 00:47:13,433 --> 00:47:16,003 RECOMMENDATION WORKING REPORTS. 1104 00:47:16,003 --> 00:47:18,472 PRESENTED BY DR. SUSAN 1105 00:47:18,472 --> 00:47:20,073 GREGURICK, AND COUNCIL OF 1106 00:47:20,073 --> 00:47:26,680 COUNCIL MEMBER DR. RAFAEL 1107 00:47:26,680 --> 00:47:30,017 IRIZARRY AT HARVARD. I WILL TURN 1108 00:47:30,017 --> 00:47:31,818 IT OVER TO SUSAN AND RAFAEL. 1109 00:47:31,818 --> 00:47:34,021 >> THANK YOU SO MUCH, NICOLE. 1110 00:47:34,021 --> 00:47:39,026 REALLY BIG THANKS TO MY 1111 00:47:39,026 --> 00:47:45,665 CO-CHAIR, DR. RAFAEL IRIZARRY 1112 00:47:45,665 --> 00:47:47,267 FOR THE WORKING REPORT WE WILL 1113 00:47:47,267 --> 00:47:48,735 PRESENT FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION. 1114 00:47:48,735 --> 00:47:52,339 NEXT SLIDE -- I WANT TO SET THE 1115 00:47:52,339 --> 00:47:54,474 STAGE BRIEFLY. OUR GENERALIST 1116 00:47:54,474 --> 00:47:55,008 INITIATIVE, THIS PROGRAM 1117 00:47:55,008 --> 00:47:57,577 SUPPORTS OUR GOALS TO ENHANCE 1118 00:47:57,577 --> 00:47:59,579 RESEARCHER'S ABILITY TO SHARE 1119 00:47:59,579 --> 00:48:01,114 DATASETS THAT UNDERLIE THEIR 1120 00:48:01,114 --> 00:48:02,516 RESEARCH AND THEIR PUBLICATIONS 1121 00:48:02,516 --> 00:48:05,352 AND ALIGNS WITH OUR GOALS TO 1122 00:48:05,352 --> 00:48:07,587 SUPPORT THE NIH FINAL DATA 1123 00:48:07,587 --> 00:48:10,057 MANAGEMENT AND SHARING POLICY. 1124 00:48:10,057 --> 00:48:12,225 SO THE NEXT SLIDE IS JUST A 1125 00:48:12,225 --> 00:48:13,560 LITTLE HISTORY ABOUT THIS 1126 00:48:13,560 --> 00:48:16,029 PROGRAM. SO THIS PROGRAM WAS THE 1127 00:48:16,029 --> 00:48:17,798 GENESIS OF A GROUND-BREAKING 1128 00:48:17,798 --> 00:48:19,199 WORKSHOP WE HELD IN 2020 THAT 1129 00:48:19,199 --> 00:48:24,805 WAS CO -CHAIREDED BY DR. MARION 1130 00:48:24,805 --> 00:48:27,607 MATONE AND DR. SHELLY STALL. WE 1131 00:48:27,607 --> 00:48:28,875 CONDUCT ED A PILOT ON THIS 1132 00:48:28,875 --> 00:48:31,812 CONCEPT OF THE GRAY REPOSITORY 1133 00:48:31,812 --> 00:48:35,215 INITIATIVE. THAT GROUND BREAKING 1134 00:48:35,215 --> 00:48:36,650 WORKSHOP LAID OUT CONCEPTS THAT 1135 00:48:36,650 --> 00:48:38,418 UNDERLIE THIS PROGRAM. FIRST AND 1136 00:48:38,418 --> 00:48:41,855 FOREMOST IS COMPETITION, WHERE A 1137 00:48:41,855 --> 00:48:43,290 VIBRANT REPOSITORY COMMUNITY 1138 00:48:43,290 --> 00:48:44,991 INCLUDING PARTICIPANTS FROM 1139 00:48:44,991 --> 00:48:46,259 INDUSTRY, ACADEMIA AND 1140 00:48:46,259 --> 00:48:48,261 GOVERNMENT CAN APPLY CONCEPTS OF 1141 00:48:48,261 --> 00:48:50,397 DETERMINING WHERE TO COMPETE AND 1142 00:48:50,397 --> 00:48:52,499 WHERE TO COLLABORATE. PUT THE 1143 00:48:52,499 --> 00:48:54,067 RESEARCHER AT CENTER, IMPORTANCE 1144 00:48:54,067 --> 00:48:56,002 OF RESEARCH ENGAGEMENT AND 1145 00:48:56,002 --> 00:48:57,170 NON-RESEARCHERS WOULD BENEFIT 1146 00:48:57,170 --> 00:48:58,472 FROM SHARING OF DATA AND 1147 00:48:58,472 --> 00:49:02,142 SERVICES ARE PART OF THIS DESIGN 1148 00:49:02,142 --> 00:49:03,043 OF THIS PROGRAM. FINALLY 1149 00:49:03,043 --> 00:49:05,078 SOFTWARES OF CONTEXT THAT NEEDS 1150 00:49:05,078 --> 00:49:07,814 TO INCENTIVISE METRICS AND 1151 00:49:07,814 --> 00:49:09,015 ENCOURAGE BEHAVIORAL CHANGE 1152 00:49:09,015 --> 00:49:11,918 AROUND DATA AND SOFTWARE SHARING 1153 00:49:11,918 --> 00:49:14,754 THAT PROVIDES TRANSPARENCY, 1154 00:49:14,754 --> 00:49:16,556 REUSABILITY AND REUSE. NEXT 1155 00:49:16,556 --> 00:49:19,092 SLIDE IS AN OVERVIEW OF GOALS 1156 00:49:19,092 --> 00:49:19,860 AND OBJECTIVE . 1157 00:49:19,860 --> 00:49:24,231 THE GOAL IS TO ENHANCE DATA 1158 00:49:24,231 --> 00:49:26,633 SHARING, ENHANCE GREATER 1159 00:49:26,633 --> 00:49:29,236 DISCOVABILITY AND SUPPORT 1160 00:49:29,236 --> 00:49:35,008 REPRODUCIBILITY AND PROVIDE A 1161 00:49:35,008 --> 00:49:35,809 LEARNING OPPORTUNITY . SO WE 1162 00:49:35,809 --> 00:49:41,748 (?) MODEL FOR BEST PRACTICES AND 1163 00:49:41,748 --> 00:49:43,183 ENSTANCIATED DATA ACROSS 1164 00:49:43,183 --> 00:49:44,584 REPOSITORIES LISTED, YOU SEE 1165 00:49:44,584 --> 00:49:51,825 THEM AT BOTTOM, STARTING WITH 1166 00:49:51,825 --> 00:49:55,829 (?) REPOSITORY ECOSYSTEM AND 1167 00:49:55,829 --> 00:49:56,897 PROVIDED LEARNING OPPORTUNITIES. 1168 00:49:56,897 --> 00:50:00,667 SO THE NEXT SLIDE IS A FEW OF 1169 00:50:00,667 --> 00:50:04,704 OUR NOTABLE OUTCOMES, INCLUDING 1170 00:50:04,704 --> 00:50:12,345 THE COMMENT IN META DATA FILES 1171 00:50:12,345 --> 00:50:14,881 AND METRICS IMPORTANT FOR BOTH 1172 00:50:14,881 --> 00:50:16,983 INSTITUTIONS AND FOR FUNDERS. WE 1173 00:50:16,983 --> 00:50:21,388 ARE ENSTANCIATING IDENTIFIERS 1174 00:50:21,388 --> 00:50:23,590 FOR RESEARCHERS AND OUTPUT AND 1175 00:50:23,590 --> 00:50:24,624 PRODUCE ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF 1176 00:50:24,624 --> 00:50:28,828 LEARNING MATERIALS YOU CAN SEE 1177 00:50:28,828 --> 00:50:31,731 CATALOGED HERE. THE NEXT SLIDE 1178 00:50:31,731 --> 00:50:32,866 INDICATES THE WORKING GROUP 1179 00:50:32,866 --> 00:50:35,101 CHARGE. COMPLETION OF THIS FIRST 1180 00:50:35,101 --> 00:50:36,603 INITIATIVE OF THIS PROGRAM WITH 1181 00:50:36,603 --> 00:50:38,872 THREE YEARS. WE CHARGE THE 1182 00:50:38,872 --> 00:50:40,006 WORKING GROUP GRAY COUNCIL 1183 00:50:40,006 --> 00:50:42,375 WORKING GROUPS TO PROVIDE AN 1184 00:50:42,375 --> 00:50:43,610 ASSESSMENT OF PROGRESS THAT HAS 1185 00:50:43,610 --> 00:50:46,746 BEEN DONE, TO DATE. FUTURE 1186 00:50:46,746 --> 00:50:49,616 RECOMMENDATIONS IF SO DESIRED 1187 00:50:49,616 --> 00:50:52,485 FOR THIS PROGRAM SO THEY 1188 00:50:52,485 --> 00:50:53,520 REVIEWED THE CURRENT SCOPE AND 1189 00:50:53,520 --> 00:50:55,822 GOALS AND LOOKED AT ALL THE 1190 00:50:55,822 --> 00:50:57,691 WORK, GRAY REPOSITORIES IN SOME 1191 00:50:57,691 --> 00:50:59,459 OF THE COMMUNITY, PROVIDED 1192 00:50:59,459 --> 00:51:00,627 RECOMMENDATIONS ON FUTURE OF 1193 00:51:00,627 --> 00:51:02,629 THIS INITIATIVE INCLUDING FUTURE 1194 00:51:02,629 --> 00:51:05,232 GOALS THAT WOULD BE BASED ON 1195 00:51:05,232 --> 00:51:07,834 PROGRESS THAT IS IMPORTANT FOR 1196 00:51:07,834 --> 00:51:09,002 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH COMMUNITY'S 1197 00:51:09,002 --> 00:51:10,637 NEEDS. FINALLY, WE ASK THEM TO 1198 00:51:10,637 --> 00:51:12,539 GIVE US INDICATIONS OF WHAT 1199 00:51:12,539 --> 00:51:14,007 SUCCESS WOULD LOOK LIKE FOR THIS 1200 00:51:14,007 --> 00:51:16,009 INITIATIVE IN THE NEXT THREE 1201 00:51:16,009 --> 00:51:18,311 YEARS. THE NEXT SLIDE IS JUST A 1202 00:51:18,311 --> 00:51:19,746 HIGHLIGHT OF THE CHARGE. I WANT 1203 00:51:19,746 --> 00:51:22,215 TO THANK EACH AND EVERY ONE OF 1204 00:51:22,215 --> 00:51:25,518 OUR MEMBERS AND DR. IRIZARRY, 1205 00:51:25,518 --> 00:51:30,223 THANKS TO CASPER, RICK, CARLY, 1206 00:51:30,223 --> 00:51:33,793 JASON AND ALSO AMANDA WHO HELPED 1207 00:51:33,793 --> 00:51:36,396 ORGANIZE US, RUN MEETINGS AND 1208 00:51:36,396 --> 00:51:37,330 HELP ED WITH THE INITIAL DRAFT 1209 00:51:37,330 --> 00:51:40,934 OF THE REPORT. THE NEXT SLIDE IS 1210 00:51:40,934 --> 00:51:43,803 JUST HOW WE CONDUCTED OURSELVES. 1211 00:51:43,803 --> 00:51:45,939 WITH YOU WILL SEE WE HAD TEN 1212 00:51:45,939 --> 00:51:49,209 SESSIONS AND FOCUSED ON THE 1213 00:51:49,209 --> 00:51:50,910 THEMES, STARTING WITH COMMUNITY 1214 00:51:50,910 --> 00:51:53,013 ENGAGEMENT, META DATA METRICS 1215 00:51:53,013 --> 00:51:54,748 AND RESEARCH STORIES, PUTTING 1216 00:51:54,748 --> 00:51:55,782 RESEARCHERS AT THE FRONT. YOU 1217 00:51:55,782 --> 00:51:58,318 WILL HEAR THIS IN 1218 00:51:58,318 --> 00:51:59,552 RECOMMENDATIONS. WE SPENT A 1219 00:51:59,552 --> 00:52:00,987 NUMBER OF MOMENTS WRITING 1220 00:52:00,987 --> 00:52:03,423 REPORT. WITH THAT AND NEXTED 1221 00:52:03,423 --> 00:52:05,025 SLIDE I PASS OVER TO DR. 1222 00:52:05,025 --> 00:52:06,726 IRIZARRY, WHO WILL PROVIDE YOU 1223 00:52:06,726 --> 00:52:09,062 WITH THE REPORT, FINDING AND 1224 00:52:09,062 --> 00:52:09,829 RECOMMENDATIONS. THANK YOU, DR. 1225 00:52:09,829 --> 00:52:11,665 IRIZARRY, FOR YOUR WORK HERE. 1226 00:52:11,665 --> 00:52:14,901 >> THANK YOU, SUSAN. THANK YOU 1227 00:52:14,901 --> 00:52:17,637 FOR LISTENING AND ALL THE 1228 00:52:17,637 --> 00:52:21,441 MEMBERS THAT MADE WRITING THIS 1229 00:52:21,441 --> 00:52:24,477 REPORT FUN AND NOT THAT MUCH 1230 00:52:24,477 --> 00:52:26,379 WORK FOR ME. I WANT TO START BY 1231 00:52:26,379 --> 00:52:32,152 -- YOU CAN GO TO THE NEXT SLIDE. 1232 00:52:32,152 --> 00:52:33,987 I WANT TO START BY SUMMARIZING A 1233 00:52:33,987 --> 00:52:36,323 BIT OF WHAT SUSAN SAID, SO 1234 00:52:36,323 --> 00:52:38,658 EVERYBODY GETS AN IDEA HOW 1235 00:52:38,658 --> 00:52:40,360 IMPORTANT AND COST-EFFECTIVE 1236 00:52:40,360 --> 00:52:43,630 THIS WHOLE PROJECT IS. SO WHEN 1237 00:52:43,630 --> 00:52:46,399 THOSE OF YOU WHO WORK IN AREAS, 1238 00:52:46,399 --> 00:52:49,469 ME FOR EXAMPLE IN GENOMICS, WE 1239 00:52:49,469 --> 00:52:50,570 ARE USED TO HAVING THESE WHERE 1240 00:52:50,570 --> 00:52:54,174 WE CAN PUT OUR DATA AND ALL 1241 00:52:54,174 --> 00:52:55,608 FIGURED OUT AND YOU KNOW WHAT TO 1242 00:52:55,608 --> 00:52:58,545 DO, REQUIRED TO PUBLISH. BUT 1243 00:52:58,545 --> 00:53:02,515 THERE'S MANY OTHER AREAS OF 1244 00:53:02,515 --> 00:53:06,386 BIOMEDICAL THAT DON'T HAVE SUCH 1245 00:53:06,386 --> 00:53:07,821 REPOSITORIES. THE IDEA IS TO 1246 00:53:07,821 --> 00:53:11,024 OFFER A PLACE FOR PEOPLE TO BE 1247 00:53:11,024 --> 00:53:12,359 ABLE TO SHARE THEIR DATA. NOW IT 1248 00:53:12,359 --> 00:53:16,596 IS REQUIRED BY THE NIH, WHEN 1249 00:53:16,596 --> 00:53:20,500 THERE AREN'T ALREADY SPECIALIZED 1250 00:53:20,500 --> 00:53:22,268 REPOSITORIES. SO THAT IS NOT -- 1251 00:53:22,268 --> 00:53:24,404 THAT IS JUST AN INTRODUCTION TO 1252 00:53:24,404 --> 00:53:27,407 MOTIVATION FOR THIS. BUT THEN 1253 00:53:27,407 --> 00:53:29,709 WHAT THE IDEA OF THIS GRAY 1254 00:53:29,709 --> 00:53:32,312 INITIATIVE IS TO MAKE IT SO THAT 1255 00:53:32,312 --> 00:53:34,080 WHEN PEOPLE SUBMIT DATA, IT 1256 00:53:34,080 --> 00:53:36,750 MAKES IT -- THERE IS SOME 1257 00:53:36,750 --> 00:53:38,585 SYSTEMATIC ORGANIZATION. IT IS 1258 00:53:38,585 --> 00:53:40,987 NOT JUST THROWING STUFF UP AND 1259 00:53:40,987 --> 00:53:43,556 JUST TO SATISFY SOME 1260 00:53:43,556 --> 00:53:45,125 REQUIREMENTS. SO IN PARTICULAR, 1261 00:53:45,125 --> 00:53:52,098 IF WE LATER WANT TO REUSE THE 1262 00:53:52,098 --> 00:53:56,536 DATA -- THAT IN PART WHAT THIS 1263 00:53:56,536 --> 00:53:59,372 COMMITTEE IS -- THIS INITIATIVE 1264 00:53:59,372 --> 00:54:02,342 IS ABOUT. YOU WANT PEOPLE TO 1265 00:54:02,342 --> 00:54:04,144 SHARE DATA AS REQUIRED. ONE OF 1266 00:54:04,144 --> 00:54:06,179 THE REASONS WE DO THAT, IN THE 1267 00:54:06,179 --> 00:54:08,047 OPINION OF THE COMMITTEE, THIS 1268 00:54:08,047 --> 00:54:11,818 IS THE MAIN RECOMMENDATION, 1269 00:54:11,818 --> 00:54:14,187 INSTEAD OF ALL MOTIVATIONS, THE 1270 00:54:14,187 --> 00:54:15,722 MAIN ONE AND WE SHOULD BE 1271 00:54:15,722 --> 00:54:18,191 FOCUSED ON IS THIS FACILITATING 1272 00:54:18,191 --> 00:54:20,126 DATA REUSE SO WE SPEND LOT OF 1273 00:54:20,126 --> 00:54:21,494 MONEY ON THESE DATA SETS. 1274 00:54:21,494 --> 00:54:23,029 THERE'S PROBABLY A LOT MORE 1275 00:54:23,029 --> 00:54:24,731 INFORMATION THAT WAS PUBLISHED 1276 00:54:24,731 --> 00:54:26,466 BY THE ORIGINAL GENERATORS. YOU 1277 00:54:26,466 --> 00:54:30,036 CAN COMBINE DATA SETS TO 1278 00:54:30,036 --> 00:54:31,805 GENERATE NEW INSIGHTS. BUT THAT 1279 00:54:31,805 --> 00:54:34,607 IS NOT EASY TO FIND DATA AND PUT 1280 00:54:34,607 --> 00:54:37,610 IT ALL TOGETHER. THAT IS WHAT WE 1281 00:54:37,610 --> 00:54:39,546 -- PART OF WHAT THIS INITIATIVE 1282 00:54:39,546 --> 00:54:41,381 IS ABOUT. THAT IS WHAT WE WANT 1283 00:54:41,381 --> 00:54:45,885 TO FOCUS ON. WHAT WE WANT THE 1284 00:54:45,885 --> 00:54:50,023 NEXT VERSION OF THIS INITIATIVE 1285 00:54:50,023 --> 00:54:54,360 TO MAKE THE MAIN PRIORITY, MAKE 1286 00:54:54,360 --> 00:54:59,065 DATA REUSE EASIER AND DOABLE. SO 1287 00:54:59,065 --> 00:55:01,835 THAT -- THERE IS ALSO -- THERE'S 1288 00:55:01,835 --> 00:55:05,672 OTHER IMPORTANT ASPECTS THAT 1289 00:55:05,672 --> 00:55:11,077 ALSO SHOULD BE -- CONTINUE TO BE 1290 00:55:11,077 --> 00:55:14,180 PRIORITIZED. QUANTIFYING IMPACT. 1291 00:55:14,180 --> 00:55:24,824 WE WANT THIS (AUDIO DIFFICULTY) 1292 00:56:04,364 --> 00:56:07,834 REDONE SO WE WANT THAT TO BE 1293 00:56:07,834 --> 00:56:12,138 MORE OF A PRIORITY. THEN THE 1294 00:56:12,138 --> 00:56:14,107 OTHER -- MAIN RECOMMENDATION IS 1295 00:56:14,107 --> 00:56:18,111 THE FIRST CYCLE OF THIS, THERE 1296 00:56:18,111 --> 00:56:21,414 WAS A LOT OF THOUGHT THAT WAS 1297 00:56:21,414 --> 00:56:22,782 PERHAPS MORE THEORETICAL AND 1298 00:56:22,782 --> 00:56:26,586 THINKING OF PRINCIPLES AND 1299 00:56:26,586 --> 00:56:31,090 GETTING THINGS STARTED. ONE OF 1300 00:56:31,090 --> 00:56:35,728 THE THINGS WE FOUND IS THERE 1301 00:56:35,728 --> 00:56:37,530 DOESN'T SEEM TO BE THAT MUCH 1302 00:56:37,530 --> 00:56:39,465 ENGAGEMENT IN USING DATA. WE 1303 00:56:39,465 --> 00:56:42,936 WANT MORE. THAT IS ANOTHER MAIN 1304 00:56:42,936 --> 00:56:45,805 RECOMMENDATION. THE NEXT SLIDE. 1305 00:56:45,805 --> 00:56:47,073 YEAH, O THIS IS WHAT I 1306 00:56:47,073 --> 00:56:49,142 DISCUSSED, THE FOCUS, THE MAIN 1307 00:56:49,142 --> 00:56:53,279 FOCUS WOULD BE REUSE OF FOCUS SO 1308 00:56:53,279 --> 00:56:56,349 THAT MAKING THE DATA EASY TO 1309 00:56:56,349 --> 00:56:58,718 FIND AND MAKE IT -- THINK HARD 1310 00:56:58,718 --> 00:57:01,154 ABOUT THE CAPABILITIES FOR 1311 00:57:01,154 --> 00:57:02,755 SEARCHING. THIS IS IN THE REPORT 1312 00:57:02,755 --> 00:57:04,557 WE TALK A LOT ABOUT THIS. IF YOU 1313 00:57:04,557 --> 00:57:07,827 WANT TO LEARN MORE. BUT THIS IS 1314 00:57:07,827 --> 00:57:10,964 ACTUALLY QUITE A COMPLEX 1315 00:57:10,964 --> 00:57:14,367 CHALLENGE. HOW DO YOU MAKE DATA 1316 00:57:14,367 --> 00:57:17,370 FINDABLE AND MAKING IT SO THAT 1317 00:57:17,370 --> 00:57:19,806 PEOPLE LOOKING FOR DATA THAT 1318 00:57:19,806 --> 00:57:22,508 THEY MIGHT NOT KNOW ARE 1319 00:57:22,508 --> 00:57:24,277 AVAILABLE, HOW DO YOU DO THAT? 1320 00:57:24,277 --> 00:57:27,080 WHAT TOOLS CAN THEY DEVELOP TO 1321 00:57:27,080 --> 00:57:29,349 MAKE IT EASY TO FIND. SAY ALL 1322 00:57:29,349 --> 00:57:32,251 THE DATA SETS RELATED TO THE 1323 00:57:32,251 --> 00:57:35,922 SPECIFIC TOPIC YOU ARE 1324 00:57:35,922 --> 00:57:41,394 INTERESTED IN STUDY. NEXT SLIDE. 1325 00:57:41,394 --> 00:57:43,730 SO SOME OF THE OTHER 1326 00:57:43,730 --> 00:57:45,531 RECOMMENDATIONS WITH EXPANDING 1327 00:57:45,531 --> 00:57:52,372 ENGAGEMENT WITH THE BIOMEDICAL, 1328 00:57:52,372 --> 00:57:54,240 THESE ARE THINGS ARE LOOKING 1329 00:57:54,240 --> 00:57:58,077 FOR. MAKE IT MUCH MORE 1330 00:57:58,077 --> 00:58:01,180 PRACTICAL. ALSO TO ENGAGE WITH 1331 00:58:01,180 --> 00:58:05,918 OTHER REPOSITORIES, THERE IS A 1332 00:58:05,918 --> 00:58:08,388 LOT OUT THERE. AND SOME WERE 1333 00:58:08,388 --> 00:58:09,389 CONCERNED THERE WASN'T ENOUGH 1334 00:58:09,389 --> 00:58:12,225 COMMUNICATION WITH WHAT IS 1335 00:58:12,225 --> 00:58:15,294 ALREADY WORKING WITH THE MORE 1336 00:58:15,294 --> 00:58:17,030 MATURE REPOSITORIES, 1337 00:58:17,030 --> 00:58:20,967 DOMAIN-SPECIFIC REPOSITORIES 1338 00:58:20,967 --> 00:58:22,435 THEN TO CONTRIBUTE TO FAIR 1339 00:58:22,435 --> 00:58:24,003 METHODS AND APPROACHES, 1340 00:58:24,003 --> 00:58:25,405 ESTABLISH A STEERING COMMITTEE 1341 00:58:25,405 --> 00:58:26,305 FROM THE COMMUNITY, FROM THE 1342 00:58:26,305 --> 00:58:30,810 PEOPLE THAT ARE GOING TO USE 1343 00:58:30,810 --> 00:58:37,717 THIS. NEXT SLIDE. SO AGAIN, THE 1344 00:58:37,717 --> 00:58:40,920 METRICS FOR QUANTIFYING IMPACT 1345 00:58:40,920 --> 00:58:44,991 ON BIOMEDICAL DATA, WE WANT THEM 1346 00:58:44,991 --> 00:58:47,660 TO FOCUS, IMPACT IN CASE 1347 00:58:47,660 --> 00:58:50,263 STUDIES. WE -- THERE WERE SOME 1348 00:58:50,263 --> 00:58:54,801 CASE STUDIES BUT I THINK IN THE 1349 00:58:54,801 --> 00:58:58,438 NEXT GENERATION THERE SHOULD BE 1350 00:58:58,438 --> 00:59:01,574 MANY MORE SUCCESS STORIES OF 1351 00:59:01,574 --> 00:59:03,676 PAPERS BY OBTAINING DATA FROM 1352 00:59:03,676 --> 00:59:09,682 THESE GENERALIST REPOSITORIES. 1353 00:59:09,682 --> 00:59:12,351 THEN ALSO THE FOCUS ON THE 1354 00:59:12,351 --> 00:59:14,654 UNIVERSAL ADOPTION OF DATA 1355 00:59:14,654 --> 00:59:15,755 CITATION AND LINKING TO 1356 00:59:15,755 --> 00:59:17,623 PUBLICATIONS. THIS RELATES TO MY 1357 00:59:17,623 --> 00:59:20,493 EARLIER COMMENTS ABOUT 1358 00:59:20,493 --> 00:59:21,661 INCENTIVISING THE SHARING OF 1359 00:59:21,661 --> 00:59:22,862 DATA. THIS IS SOMETHING THAT A 1360 00:59:22,862 --> 00:59:24,664 LOT OF -- IT IS NOT JUST THIS 1361 00:59:24,664 --> 00:59:25,965 GROUP THAT IS THINKING ABOUT IT 1362 00:59:25,965 --> 00:59:27,900 SO WE ARE RECOMMENDING THEY 1363 00:59:27,900 --> 00:59:29,902 IDENTIFY PARTNERS TO DEVELOP 1364 00:59:29,902 --> 00:59:32,672 METRICS WITH. IT SHOULDN'T JUST 1365 00:59:32,672 --> 00:59:35,808 BE THIS SMALL ISH GROUP. THIS IS 1366 00:59:35,808 --> 00:59:37,176 A BIGGER CHALLENGE THAT I THINK 1367 00:59:37,176 --> 00:59:40,880 A LOT OF PEOPLE ACROSS THE NIH 1368 00:59:40,880 --> 00:59:45,118 ARE WORKING ON. THE NEXT SLIDE. 1369 00:59:45,118 --> 00:59:47,820 SO BEFORE I TURN IT OVER TO Q & 1370 00:59:47,820 --> 00:59:52,058 A, ONE OF THE THINGS I LEARN BY 1371 00:59:52,058 --> 00:59:55,027 WORKING ON THIS REPORT IS THAT 1372 00:59:55,027 --> 00:59:58,264 THIS IS -- AS YOU HEARD ME SAY, 1373 00:59:58,264 --> 00:59:59,832 SOMETHING I THINK IS VERY 1374 00:59:59,832 --> 01:00:00,666 IMPORTANT TO HAVE THIS 1375 01:00:00,666 --> 01:00:01,968 CAPABILITY OF NOT JUST A PLACE 1376 01:00:01,968 --> 01:00:04,604 FOR PEOPLE TO SHARE DATA BUT 1377 01:00:04,604 --> 01:00:07,907 MAKE IT SO THAT IT IS REUSABLE. 1378 01:00:07,907 --> 01:00:11,511 OTHERS CAN FIND IT AND USE IT. 1379 01:00:11,511 --> 01:00:13,813 THIS PARTICULAR INITIATIVE IS 1380 01:00:13,813 --> 01:00:15,715 ACTUALLY PRETTY SMALL, THE 1381 01:00:15,715 --> 01:00:18,317 FUNDING IS SMALL SO THAT I ENDED 1382 01:00:18,317 --> 01:00:20,686 UP BEING CONVINCED THE RETURN ON 1383 01:00:20,686 --> 01:00:23,356 INVESTMENT IS GOING TO BE -- CAN 1384 01:00:23,356 --> 01:00:24,490 BE QUITE LARGE. ALL RIGHT. THAT 1385 01:00:24,490 --> 01:00:30,129 IS ALL I HAVE TO SAY. WE ARE 1386 01:00:30,129 --> 01:00:32,198 HAPPY TO TAKE QUESTIONS. 1387 01:00:32,198 --> 01:00:34,433 >> THANKS SO MUCH. BEFORE WE 1388 01:00:34,433 --> 01:00:37,403 START WITH QUESTIONS, I WANT TO 1389 01:00:37,403 --> 01:00:39,405 REMIND MEMBERS OF OUR PROCESS 1390 01:00:39,405 --> 01:00:41,174 FOR WORK GROUP REPORTS. SO THE 1391 01:00:41,174 --> 01:00:43,042 COUNCIL DOES NOT EDIT THE REPORT 1392 01:00:43,042 --> 01:00:45,178 AND ITS RECOMMENDATIONS. WE ARE 1393 01:00:45,178 --> 01:00:47,780 ASKING FOR YOUR YES OR NO VOTE 1394 01:00:47,780 --> 01:00:48,481 ABOUT WHETHER YOU CONSIDER THE 1395 01:00:48,481 --> 01:00:50,483 WORK GROUPS, WORK PROCESS, WHAT 1396 01:00:50,483 --> 01:00:52,785 IS ADEQUATE AND RECOMMENDATIONS 1397 01:00:52,785 --> 01:00:55,855 ARE SOUND. YOU CERTAINLY CAN 1398 01:00:55,855 --> 01:00:57,990 ELECT TO CONVEY ADDITIONAL VIEWS 1399 01:00:57,990 --> 01:01:00,960 FROM COUNCIL IN A MEMO THAT I 1400 01:01:00,960 --> 01:01:06,699 WILL WRITE REPRESENTING YOU TO 1401 01:01:06,699 --> 01:01:08,601 DR. B. AS HE CONSIDERS TO 1402 01:01:08,601 --> 01:01:11,137 RESPOND SO A REMINDER. I SEE 1403 01:01:11,137 --> 01:01:12,672 QUESTIONS AND FOLKS RAISING 1404 01:01:12,672 --> 01:01:16,209 THEIR HANDS SO I WILL TURN IT 1405 01:01:16,209 --> 01:01:20,880 OVER TO FRANZISKA TO GO THROUGH 1406 01:01:20,880 --> 01:01:22,949 AND ASK FOLKS TO UNMUTE. 1407 01:01:22,949 --> 01:01:25,318 >> I SEE ROSS YOU HAVE RAISED 1408 01:01:25,318 --> 01:01:26,786 YOUR HAND FIRST. GO AHEAD. 1409 01:01:26,786 --> 01:01:28,921 >> I WANT TO THANK RAFAEL AND 1410 01:01:28,921 --> 01:01:30,389 SUSAN FOR PUTTING THIS TOGETHER. 1411 01:01:30,389 --> 01:01:31,991 SO IMPORTANT, SO TIMELY. A 1412 01:01:31,991 --> 01:01:34,994 QUESTION IN THE COMMENT. THE 1413 01:01:34,994 --> 01:01:37,597 QUESTION IS IN THINKING ABOUT 1414 01:01:37,597 --> 01:01:40,433 WHAT IS A LARGE SHAREHOLDER 1415 01:01:40,433 --> 01:01:41,801 DATASET WAS THERE CONSIDERATION 1416 01:01:41,801 --> 01:01:43,369 GIVEN TO REGISTRATION PROCESS 1417 01:01:43,369 --> 01:01:47,273 FORMALIZED BY THE NIH SIMILAR TO 1418 01:01:47,273 --> 01:01:55,581 CLINICAL TRIALS.GOV, TO ALLOW AT 1419 01:01:55,581 --> 01:01:59,685 LEAST CATALOGING WHAT CREATES A 1420 01:01:59,685 --> 01:02:01,187 DATA SET AND REPOSITORY FOR 1421 01:02:01,187 --> 01:02:03,823 PEOPLE TO FIND THESE DATA SETS? 1422 01:02:03,823 --> 01:02:07,360 >> I CAN TAKE A STAB AT THAT, IF 1423 01:02:07,360 --> 01:02:12,465 YOU LIKE, AND OTHERS. I THINK 1424 01:02:12,465 --> 01:02:14,300 THAT IS AN EXCELLENT CONCEPT AND 1425 01:02:14,300 --> 01:02:15,234 QUESTION. WHAT IS HAPPENING AT 1426 01:02:15,234 --> 01:02:16,969 THE NATIONAL LIBRARY OF 1427 01:02:16,969 --> 01:02:19,171 MEDICINE, WHICH I THINK WE CAN 1428 01:02:19,171 --> 01:02:20,907 EXPAND ON AND REPOSITORIES 1429 01:02:20,907 --> 01:02:22,508 PARTICIPATE, WHICH IS 1430 01:02:22,508 --> 01:02:26,779 ESSENTIALLY A META DATA 1431 01:02:26,779 --> 01:02:28,114 REGISTRATION AND CATALOG SUCH 1432 01:02:28,114 --> 01:02:31,918 THAT ALL FUNDED BY NIH, OR MAYBE 1433 01:02:31,918 --> 01:02:35,554 JUST BIOMEDICAL DATA SETS ARE 1434 01:02:35,554 --> 01:02:38,591 CATALOGED THROUGH META DATA AND 1435 01:02:38,591 --> 01:02:40,059 LINKED OUT THROUGH THE 1436 01:02:40,059 --> 01:02:41,294 REPOSITORY, THIS PROVIDES 1437 01:02:41,294 --> 01:02:43,195 OPPORTUNITY FOR THE NLM TO 1438 01:02:43,195 --> 01:02:46,365 DISCOVER DATA AND GO TO 1439 01:02:46,365 --> 01:02:47,700 REPOSITORY WHERE THEY CAN OBTAIN 1440 01:02:47,700 --> 01:02:49,635 THE DATA. IT IS A COST-EFFECTIVE 1441 01:02:49,635 --> 01:02:51,804 WAY OF SEARCHING, DISCOVERING 1442 01:02:51,804 --> 01:02:54,674 AND SHARING DATA IN THAT THESE 1443 01:02:54,674 --> 01:02:56,442 REPOSITORIES ARE EITHER FUNDED 1444 01:02:56,442 --> 01:02:59,445 BY NIH OR OTHER ENTITIES. THE 1445 01:02:59,445 --> 01:03:00,913 GRAY INITIATIVE REPOSITORIES ARE 1446 01:03:00,913 --> 01:03:04,951 NOT FUNDED BY NIH BUT THE 1447 01:03:04,951 --> 01:03:06,585 COLLABORATION AND COOPERATION 1448 01:03:06,585 --> 01:03:08,387 CONCEPTS IS WHAT WE FUND. SO 1449 01:03:08,387 --> 01:03:10,790 THAT IS THE MODEL. I THINK WE 1450 01:03:10,790 --> 01:03:12,591 COULD BUILD OUT ON THAT. I LOVE 1451 01:03:12,591 --> 01:03:13,659 THE CONCEPT AND WOULD LIKE TO 1452 01:03:13,659 --> 01:03:16,996 SEE THAT ENSTANCIATED AT SCALE. 1453 01:03:16,996 --> 01:03:19,031 >> THAT IS PART OF WHAT WE ARE 1454 01:03:19,031 --> 01:03:21,667 LOOKING FOR WHEN WE RECOMMEND WE 1455 01:03:21,667 --> 01:03:23,235 GET MORE FEEDBACK FROM THE 1456 01:03:23,235 --> 01:03:24,904 COMMUNITY. AS SUSAN EXPLAINED 1457 01:03:24,904 --> 01:03:27,340 YOU CAN DEPOSIT A DATA SET ON 1458 01:03:27,340 --> 01:03:29,342 ANY OF THESE. NIH HAS NOTHING TO 1459 01:03:29,342 --> 01:03:31,143 DO WITH THAT. THAT IS SOMETHING 1460 01:03:31,143 --> 01:03:34,313 YOU CAN DO. SOME ARE FREE. 1461 01:03:34,313 --> 01:03:36,916 DEPOSIT PRETTY BIG STUFF WITHOUT 1462 01:03:36,916 --> 01:03:39,385 PAYING. BUT ONCE YOU DO THAT, 1463 01:03:39,385 --> 01:03:43,889 HOW PEOPLE FIND IT. IT IS 1464 01:03:43,889 --> 01:03:45,024 IMPOSSIBLE UNLESS THEY GO TO 1465 01:03:45,024 --> 01:03:46,859 YOUR PAPER AND SEE THE LINK. 1466 01:03:46,859 --> 01:03:48,728 OTHERWISE IT IS HARD. ONE OF THE 1467 01:03:48,728 --> 01:03:51,163 POINT S IS TO HAVE META DATA TO 1468 01:03:51,163 --> 01:03:55,101 MAKE IT FINDABLE. WHAT WE HAVE 1469 01:03:55,101 --> 01:03:59,438 FOUND IS THAT LIKE I SAID 1470 01:03:59,438 --> 01:04:01,707 EARLIER, THERE IS SOME WORK AND 1471 01:04:01,707 --> 01:04:03,676 ADAPTATION OF IDEAS PUT OUT TO 1472 01:04:03,676 --> 01:04:07,113 MAKE THINGS FINDABLE BUT WE WANT 1473 01:04:07,113 --> 01:04:12,184 TO SEE MORE PRACTICAL SOLUTIONS 1474 01:04:12,184 --> 01:04:14,286 TO ANSWER QUESTIONS JUST LIKE 1475 01:04:14,286 --> 01:04:14,653 YOURS. 1476 01:04:14,653 --> 01:04:17,289 >> GREAT. I'M GLAD THIS IS BEING 1477 01:04:17,289 --> 01:04:20,726 CONSIDERED. I WOULD REALLY URGE 1478 01:04:20,726 --> 01:04:23,829 THE GROUP, ESPECIALLY THE VLM 1479 01:04:23,829 --> 01:04:25,664 GROUP TO COME UP WITH CRITERIA 1480 01:04:25,664 --> 01:04:27,266 FOR WHAT CONSTITUTES A DATA 1481 01:04:27,266 --> 01:04:29,168 SOURCE OR DATA SET AND ENFORCE 1482 01:04:29,168 --> 01:04:30,903 THAT SIMILAR TO WHAT'S HAPPENED 1483 01:04:30,903 --> 01:04:33,672 WITH CLINICAL TRIALS IN CLINICAL 1484 01:04:33,672 --> 01:04:35,441 TRIAL.GOV SHOWING YOU HAVE TO 1485 01:04:35,441 --> 01:04:38,577 MEET CERTAIN CRITERIA, LIKE IRB 1486 01:04:38,577 --> 01:04:40,312 APPROVAL TO HAVE A STUDY. THE 1487 01:04:40,312 --> 01:04:42,882 COMMENT IS, JUST TO MAKE THE 1488 01:04:42,882 --> 01:04:45,918 LARGER COMMUNITY AWARE OF A 1489 01:04:45,918 --> 01:04:48,220 CHALLENGE THAT ORIGINATE ED FROM 1490 01:04:48,220 --> 01:04:50,056 THE EYE INSTITUTE AND MIKE 1491 01:04:50,056 --> 01:04:51,924 CHANG, THE DIRECTOR, THE S. 1492 01:04:51,924 --> 01:04:54,460 INDEX CHALLENGE. THIS IS OPEN. 1493 01:04:54,460 --> 01:04:56,996 NOW IT IS ACTUALLY CLOSING VERY 1494 01:04:56,996 --> 01:04:58,697 SHORTLY I THINK THE END OF THIS 1495 01:04:58,697 --> 01:05:01,400 WEEK. I WILL PUT THE LINK IN THE 1496 01:05:01,400 --> 01:05:03,502 COMMENTS TO REED FROM THE 1497 01:05:03,502 --> 01:05:04,637 ANNOUNCEMENT. THIS IS A 1498 01:05:04,637 --> 01:05:06,072 CHALLENGE TO INCENTIVISE AND 1499 01:05:06,072 --> 01:05:08,040 REWARD DATA SHARING BY PROMOTING 1500 01:05:08,040 --> 01:05:09,608 A NEW METRIC THAT WILL ASSESS 1501 01:05:09,608 --> 01:05:11,510 HOW EFFECTIVELY RESEARCHERS 1502 01:05:11,510 --> 01:05:15,247 SHARE DATA. IT WILL INCLUDE THE 1503 01:05:15,247 --> 01:05:17,616 VALUE OF SHARE DATA INCLUDING 1504 01:05:17,616 --> 01:05:20,352 COMPLIANCE WITH FAIR PRINCIPLE, 1505 01:05:20,352 --> 01:05:22,621 TIMELINESS WITH WHICH DATA IS 1506 01:05:22,621 --> 01:05:24,690 SHARED, COMPLETE LESS OF META 1507 01:05:24,690 --> 01:05:25,991 DATA, FREQUENCY WHICH SHARED 1508 01:05:25,991 --> 01:05:27,893 DATA IS U UTILIZED AS WELL AS 1509 01:05:27,893 --> 01:05:31,230 INFLUENCE OF SHARED DATA ON 1510 01:05:31,230 --> 01:05:33,432 SHARED PUBLICATION AND PATENTS. 1511 01:05:33,432 --> 01:05:35,468 I ENCOURAGE THE GROUP TO 1512 01:05:35,468 --> 01:05:37,603 COORDINATE WITH NEI IN EFFORTS 1513 01:05:37,603 --> 01:05:39,705 TO TRY TO DEVELOP A METRIC FOR 1514 01:05:39,705 --> 01:05:40,906 IMPACT COMPARABLE TO WHAT YOU 1515 01:05:40,906 --> 01:05:43,876 ARE DISCUSSING, RAFAEL, TO 1516 01:05:43,876 --> 01:05:47,546 DETERMINE HOW EFFECTIVE A DATA 1517 01:05:47,546 --> 01:05:53,519 SET IS. 1518 01:05:53,519 --> 01:05:55,654 >> ANYTHING TO WORK WITH OTHERS 1519 01:05:55,654 --> 01:05:57,957 AND IMPLEMENT WHAT ARE -- IF 1520 01:05:57,957 --> 01:06:01,994 THERE ARE -- THINGS THAT ARE 1521 01:06:01,994 --> 01:06:04,864 IMPLEMENTED TO USE THAT. 1522 01:06:04,864 --> 01:06:06,499 >> THANK YOU FOR THAT QUESTION. 1523 01:06:06,499 --> 01:06:08,667 WE ALSO SAW SUSAN'S COMMENT IN 1524 01:06:08,667 --> 01:06:10,302 THE CHAT AS WELL. THANK YOU, 1525 01:06:10,302 --> 01:06:12,838 RAFAEL, AND SUSAN FOR THE 1526 01:06:12,838 --> 01:06:15,808 RESPONSE. YOU HAVE THE NEXT 1527 01:06:15,808 --> 01:06:16,275 QUESTION. 1528 01:06:16,275 --> 01:06:17,676 >> SO THANKS VERY MUCH. GREAT 1529 01:06:17,676 --> 01:06:21,013 WORK TO THE WORKING GROUP. I DO 1530 01:06:21,013 --> 01:06:23,549 HAVE TWO QUESTIONS REGARDING IF 1531 01:06:23,549 --> 01:06:24,517 THE WORKING GROUP ACTUALLY 1532 01:06:24,517 --> 01:06:27,219 DISCUSSED THESE TWO THINGS. I'M 1533 01:06:27,219 --> 01:06:28,587 ASKING BECAUSE, YOU KNOW, WE 1534 01:06:28,587 --> 01:06:30,623 HAVE BEEN ASKED TO SHARE DATA 1535 01:06:30,623 --> 01:06:33,159 FOR MANY, MANY YEARS. THERE HAVE 1536 01:06:33,159 --> 01:06:34,426 BEEN MANY POLICIES FROM NIH 1537 01:06:34,426 --> 01:06:37,329 SAYING HOW TO SHARE DATA AND ALL 1538 01:06:37,329 --> 01:06:40,266 THAT. YET WHAT I FIND LACKING IS 1539 01:06:40,266 --> 01:06:42,701 NOT SO MUCH THE SHARING OF DATA, 1540 01:06:42,701 --> 01:06:44,203 OR YES, WE COULD ALWAYS DO 1541 01:06:44,203 --> 01:06:46,038 BETTER. BUT ON THE OTHER END. 1542 01:06:46,038 --> 01:06:48,007 THE PERSON WHO IS THEN GOING TO 1543 01:06:48,007 --> 01:06:51,810 USE THAT DATA THAT WAS SHARED BY 1544 01:06:51,810 --> 01:06:53,646 SOMEONE ELSE. SO MY QUESTIONS 1545 01:06:53,646 --> 01:06:55,514 THEN ARE DID THE WORKING GROUP 1546 01:06:55,514 --> 01:06:56,782 TAKE UNDER CONSIDERATION THE 1547 01:06:56,782 --> 01:06:59,451 FACT THAT THERE IS A NEED FOR 1548 01:06:59,451 --> 01:07:01,020 CURATION OF DATA COMING FROM 1549 01:07:01,020 --> 01:07:04,056 MULTIPLE SOURCES THAT, YOU KNOW, 1550 01:07:04,056 --> 01:07:05,591 EVEN SOMETHING AS SIMPLE AND 1551 01:07:05,591 --> 01:07:08,427 DOWN TO THE LEVEL OF IT IS IN 1552 01:07:08,427 --> 01:07:11,030 MILLIGRAMS OR MIL EQUIVALENTS IN 1553 01:07:11,030 --> 01:07:11,430 TERM OS TESTIFY 1554 01:07:11,430 --> 01:07:12,331 REPORT .ENTERIF YOU DON'T HAVE 1555 01:07:12,331 --> 01:07:14,900 THAT CURATED IT IS IMPOSSIBLE AS 1556 01:07:14,900 --> 01:07:16,402 USERS TO ACTUALLY USE THAT DATA. 1557 01:07:16,402 --> 01:07:19,738 DID YOU ADDRESS CURATION, NUMBER 1558 01:07:19,738 --> 01:07:23,175 ONE. NUMBER TWO, DR. IRIZARRY, 1559 01:07:23,175 --> 01:07:24,743 YOU SAID THERE WILL BE A GREAT 1560 01:07:24,743 --> 01:07:26,912 RETURN ON INVESTMENT IN THIS. SO 1561 01:07:26,912 --> 01:07:28,581 WITH REGARD TO THAT AND WITH 1562 01:07:28,581 --> 01:07:32,384 REGARD TO THE DEVASTATING 1563 01:07:32,384 --> 01:07:34,119 SHRINKING OF THE NIH BUDGET, 1564 01:07:34,119 --> 01:07:35,287 WHAT DID THE GROUP TALK ABOUT, 1565 01:07:35,287 --> 01:07:36,956 WHAT INVESTMENT WILL BE NEEDED. 1566 01:07:36,956 --> 01:07:40,926 BECAUSE OF THE REDUCED NIH 1567 01:07:40,926 --> 01:07:42,528 BUDGET PROPOSED, WHAT YOU 1568 01:07:42,528 --> 01:07:44,096 BELIEVE IS WORTH GIVING UP IN 1569 01:07:44,096 --> 01:07:45,764 ORDER TO PAY FOR THIS EFFORT. 1570 01:07:45,764 --> 01:07:47,199 THANKS VERY MUCH. 1571 01:07:47,199 --> 01:07:49,435 >> SO TO ANSWER YOUR FIRST 1572 01:07:49,435 --> 01:07:51,804 QUESTION, THAT WAS PERHAPS THE 1573 01:07:51,804 --> 01:07:54,940 THING WE DISCUSSED THE MOST 1574 01:07:54,940 --> 01:07:57,109 EXACTLY. YOUR EXAMPLE IS VERY 1575 01:07:57,109 --> 01:07:59,612 SIMILAR TO ONE THAT WE WERE 1576 01:07:59,612 --> 01:08:00,980 GOING TO DISCUSS MANY OTHERS. 1577 01:08:00,980 --> 01:08:04,183 THAT IS PART OF THE 1578 01:08:04,183 --> 01:08:08,187 RECOMMENDATION IS TO FOCUS ON 1579 01:08:08,187 --> 01:08:10,723 PRACTICALITY AS YOU DESCRIBED. A 1580 01:08:10,723 --> 01:08:12,224 RE-USER CAN ACTUALLY DO 1581 01:08:12,224 --> 01:08:15,995 SOMETHING WITH THIS. THAT IS ONE 1582 01:08:15,995 --> 01:08:18,764 THING I LEARNED FROM LISTENING 1583 01:08:18,764 --> 01:08:19,832 TO THE PEOPLE CURRENTLY INVOLVED 1584 01:08:19,832 --> 01:08:21,600 IN INITIATIVE THAT THAT IS A 1585 01:08:21,600 --> 01:08:23,002 PRETTY HARD PROBLEM WHEN YOU 1586 01:08:23,002 --> 01:08:25,638 HAVE A GENERALIST REPOSITORY, 1587 01:08:25,638 --> 01:08:29,508 ACTUALLY QUITE HARD. UNLIKE THE 1588 01:08:29,508 --> 01:08:30,709 DOMAIN-SPECIFIC ONES WHERE YOU 1589 01:08:30,709 --> 01:08:31,710 CAN BE VERY SPECIFIC ABOUT WHAT 1590 01:08:31,710 --> 01:08:33,479 YOU NEED TO INCLUDE, HERE IT IS 1591 01:08:33,479 --> 01:08:38,651 A LITTLE BIT -- A LITTLE HARDER. 1592 01:08:38,651 --> 01:08:39,818 BECAUSE THERE'S MANY DIFFERENT 1593 01:08:39,818 --> 01:08:43,055 DATA SETS FROM DIFFERENT AREAS 1594 01:08:43,055 --> 01:08:45,424 OF BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH. THAT WAS 1595 01:08:45,424 --> 01:08:46,292 ATTENTION WHEN WE DISCUSS ED IN 1596 01:08:46,292 --> 01:08:48,560 THE COMMITTEE. THERE WAS SOME 1597 01:08:48,560 --> 01:08:49,695 THAT THOUGHT THERE SHOULD FOCUS 1598 01:08:49,695 --> 01:08:52,598 MORE ON MAKING IT -- FOCUSING ON 1599 01:08:52,598 --> 01:08:55,034 MAYBE THE 80% THAT CAN BE MADE 1600 01:08:55,034 --> 01:08:57,269 SPECIFIC. OTHERS THAT THOUGHT 1601 01:08:57,269 --> 01:08:58,971 NO, THIS IS A GENERAL 1602 01:08:58,971 --> 01:09:00,406 REPOSITORY, THE WHOLE POINT IS 1603 01:09:00,406 --> 01:09:02,107 KEEP IT GENERAL. BUT IT IS IN 1604 01:09:02,107 --> 01:09:03,242 THERE, IN THE REPORT. YOU CAN 1605 01:09:03,242 --> 01:09:05,277 SEE THAT RELATES TO THE FIRST 1606 01:09:05,277 --> 01:09:09,315 RECOMMENDATION. IS THAT FOCUS ON 1607 01:09:09,315 --> 01:09:11,216 MAKING THE DATA -- MAKING IT 1608 01:09:11,216 --> 01:09:13,052 REUSABLE. THAT SHOULD BE THE 1609 01:09:13,052 --> 01:09:15,854 VERY PRACTICAL FOCUS AND IN 1610 01:09:15,854 --> 01:09:18,157 PARTICULAR USABLE BY THE 1611 01:09:18,157 --> 01:09:19,558 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH COMMUNITY. 1612 01:09:19,558 --> 01:09:21,360 TO YOUR SECOND QUESTION, MAYBE 1613 01:09:21,360 --> 01:09:22,795 SUSAN, YOU CAN SAY MORE ABOUT 1614 01:09:22,795 --> 01:09:26,565 THIS BUT WE WEREN'T CHARGED WITH 1615 01:09:26,565 --> 01:09:29,134 DISCUSSING BUDGETS. WE WERE 1616 01:09:29,134 --> 01:09:31,704 CHARGED WITH DISCUSSING 1617 01:09:31,704 --> 01:09:32,438 RECOMMENDATIONS BASED ON WHAT 1618 01:09:32,438 --> 01:09:35,374 THE MISSION OF THE INITIATIVE 1619 01:09:35,374 --> 01:09:35,674 IS. 1620 01:09:35,674 --> 01:09:37,409 >> YEAH, THAT IS CORRECT. WE DID 1621 01:09:37,409 --> 01:09:39,645 NOT CHARGE THEM TO RECOMMEND A 1622 01:09:39,645 --> 01:09:40,612 PARTICULAR BUDGET LEVEL BECAUSE 1623 01:09:40,612 --> 01:09:42,581 THERE ARE MANY PRIORITIES OF THE 1624 01:09:42,581 --> 01:09:44,583 NIH AND NIH DIRECTOR THAT WOULD 1625 01:09:44,583 --> 01:09:48,187 BE TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION. THE 1626 01:09:48,187 --> 01:09:50,389 STRATEGIC PLAN FOR DATA SCIENCE 1627 01:09:50,389 --> 01:09:51,824 AND REISSUE , THE NUMBER ONE 1628 01:09:51,824 --> 01:09:53,625 ACTIVITY WE HEARD FROM THE 1629 01:09:53,625 --> 01:09:55,227 COMMUNITY AND FROM OUR NIH 1630 01:09:55,227 --> 01:09:57,062 LEADERSHIP WAS TO FOCUS AND 1631 01:09:57,062 --> 01:09:58,130 SUPPORT THE NIH DATA MANAGEMENT 1632 01:09:58,130 --> 01:10:01,800 AND SHARING POLICY WITH REAL (?) 1633 01:10:01,800 --> 01:10:03,569 AND WORK THAT WOULD ENABLE THE 1634 01:10:03,569 --> 01:10:06,705 COMMUNITY TO CREATE AND USE DATA 1635 01:10:06,705 --> 01:10:08,307 SO THAT RESEARCH IS 1636 01:10:08,307 --> 01:10:09,842 REPRODUCIBLE. I SEE THAT ECHOING 1637 01:10:09,842 --> 01:10:11,610 AS A STRONG PRIORITY, GOING 1638 01:10:11,610 --> 01:10:12,711 FORWARD. I THINK WE WILL TAKE 1639 01:10:12,711 --> 01:10:14,113 THIS UNDER CONSIDERATION AS WE 1640 01:10:14,113 --> 01:10:17,816 PLAN FOR PROGRAMS IN FY26. 1641 01:10:17,816 --> 01:10:19,651 >> THANKS. I HOPE YOU WILL BRING 1642 01:10:19,651 --> 01:10:23,055 BACK MAYBE IN A YEAR TO US HOW 1643 01:10:23,055 --> 01:10:27,626 YOUR EFFORTS HAVE PROGRESSED AND 1644 01:10:27,626 --> 01:10:29,228 WHAT CHALLENGES YOU ARE FINDING 1645 01:10:29,228 --> 01:10:31,797 AND MAYBE PROVIDE SUGGESTIONS, 1646 01:10:31,797 --> 01:10:32,064 THANKS. 1647 01:10:32,064 --> 01:10:33,165 >> WOULD LOVE TO DO THAT. 1648 01:10:33,165 --> 01:10:34,700 >> GREAT. 1649 01:10:34,700 --> 01:10:37,236 >> SO I DON'T SEE ANYMORE 1650 01:10:37,236 --> 01:10:38,404 QUESTIONS. I'M SEEING WE CAN GO 1651 01:10:38,404 --> 01:10:41,507 TO THE VOTE, IN THAT CASE. YOU 1652 01:10:41,507 --> 01:10:44,443 REMEMBER FROM THE LAST MEETING 1653 01:10:44,443 --> 01:10:48,747 WE WILL DO THE RAISED HAND 1654 01:10:48,747 --> 01:10:50,149 VOTES. PLEASE REMEMBER ONLY 1655 01:10:50,149 --> 01:10:51,650 COUNCILMEMBERS CAN VOTE. I WILL 1656 01:10:51,650 --> 01:10:53,752 ASK FOR A MOTION AND SECOND TO 1657 01:10:53,752 --> 01:10:56,922 BE ENTERED INTO THE CHAT BY TWO 1658 01:10:56,922 --> 01:10:59,324 COUNCILMEMBERS. THEN I WILL ASK 1659 01:10:59,324 --> 01:11:00,159 FOR DISCUSSION AND THEN ASK FOR 1660 01:11:00,159 --> 01:11:05,664 A VOTE. SO LET ME START. MAY I 1661 01:11:05,664 --> 01:11:10,035 HAVE A MOTION TO ACCEPT, AS 1662 01:11:10,035 --> 01:11:13,705 WRITTEN, THE REPORT -- THE 1663 01:11:13,705 --> 01:11:20,012 GENERALIST NESH TIF -- 1664 01:11:20,012 --> 01:11:23,081 INITIATIVE OR WORKING GROUP OF 1665 01:11:23,081 --> 01:11:26,151 COUNCIL OF COUNCILS. I HAVE TO 1666 01:11:26,151 --> 01:11:28,020 SWITCH OVER. I SEE SO MOVED AND 1667 01:11:28,020 --> 01:11:29,588 ALSO SEE SECONDED. THANK YOU 1668 01:11:29,588 --> 01:11:33,692 VERY MUCH. IS THERE ANY 1669 01:11:33,692 --> 01:11:43,101 ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION ON THIS 1670 01:11:43,101 --> 01:11:47,806 MOTION? 1671 01:11:47,806 --> 01:11:49,641 1672 01:11:49,641 --> 01:11:54,112 >> THANK YOU, DOCTOR. THIS IS TO 1673 01:11:54,112 --> 01:11:56,014 ACCEPT AS WRITTEN REPORT OF 1674 01:11:56,014 --> 01:11:59,852 GENERALIST REPOSITORY ECOSYSTEM 1675 01:11:59,852 --> 01:12:00,686 INITIATIVE GRAY WORKING GROUP OF 1676 01:12:00,686 --> 01:12:03,222 THE COUNCIL OF COUNCIL. AS 1677 01:12:03,222 --> 01:12:03,856 REMINDER ONLY COUNCILMEMBERS 1678 01:12:03,856 --> 01:12:06,124 SHOULD PARTICIPATE. PLEASE RAISE 1679 01:12:06,124 --> 01:12:16,468 YOUR HAND TO VOTE AYE. THANK 1680 01:12:16,468 --> 01:12:26,512 YOU. I SEE NINE HANDS. PLEASE 1681 01:12:26,512 --> 01:12:31,650 LOWER ALL HANDS. THANK YOU SO 1682 01:12:31,650 --> 01:12:34,686 MUCH. PLEASE RAISE YOUR HAND TO 1683 01:12:34,686 --> 01:12:42,895 VOTE NAY. NOT SEEING ANY HANDS. 1684 01:12:42,895 --> 01:12:46,298 MOVING ALONG. PLEASE RAISE YOUR 1685 01:12:46,298 --> 01:12:56,975 HAND TO VOTE ABSTENTION. NOT 1686 01:12:56,975 --> 01:12:58,844 SEEING ANY HANDS. THIS CONCLUDES 1687 01:12:58,844 --> 01:13:02,614 THE VOTE. THE MOTION, AS STATED, 1688 01:13:02,614 --> 01:13:03,715 HAS PASSED. 1689 01:13:03,715 --> 01:13:06,018 >> THANK YOU, CHRISTINA AND 1690 01:13:06,018 --> 01:13:08,020 STAFF. WE ARE ALMOST PERFECTLY 1691 01:13:08,020 --> 01:13:09,588 ON TIME. BACK TO YOU. 1692 01:13:09,588 --> 01:13:11,423 >> I DO JUST WANT TO FOLLOW UP 1693 01:13:11,423 --> 01:13:13,959 AND ASK IF THERE ARE ANY 1694 01:13:13,959 --> 01:13:14,927 ADDITIONAL VIEWS THAT COUNCIL 1695 01:13:14,927 --> 01:13:20,198 WOULD LIKE TO CONVEY WITH THE 1696 01:13:20,198 --> 01:13:21,867 REPORT. I WOULD ASK IF THERE 1697 01:13:21,867 --> 01:13:23,302 ARE, IF YOU COULD PUT THEM IN 1698 01:13:23,302 --> 01:13:27,873 THE CHAT, THAT WOULD BE VERY 1699 01:13:27,873 --> 01:13:30,108 HELPFUL. I WILL ALSO NOTE THAT 1700 01:13:30,108 --> 01:13:32,611 WE ARE WORKING ON DRAFTING 1701 01:13:32,611 --> 01:13:34,313 RESPONSES TO SOME OF THE 1702 01:13:34,313 --> 01:13:35,747 QUESTIONS THAT WERE RAISED 1703 01:13:35,747 --> 01:13:37,149 DURING THE PREVIOUS SESSION FROM 1704 01:13:37,149 --> 01:13:39,751 DR. MANLEY AND OTHERS REGARDING 1705 01:13:39,751 --> 01:13:46,425 SOME OF THE AWARDS AND COUNCIL 1706 01:13:46,425 --> 01:13:47,793 MEMBERSHIP. WE WILL FOLLOW UP 1707 01:13:47,793 --> 01:13:49,661 LATER WITH ADDITIONAL 1708 01:13:49,661 --> 01:13:51,597 INFORMATION TO ADDRESS THOSE 1709 01:13:51,597 --> 01:13:55,100 QUESTIONS. OKAY. MOVING TO OUR 1710 01:13:55,100 --> 01:13:59,905 NEXT AGENDA ITEM, THIS IS THE 1711 01:13:59,905 --> 01:14:04,876 NIH AIM-AHEAD PROGRAM COUNCIL OF 1712 01:14:04,876 --> 01:14:07,312 COUNCIL'S REPORT. PRESENTED BY 1713 01:14:07,312 --> 01:14:08,947 SUSAN. AGAIN, THANK YOU, SUSAN. 1714 01:14:08,947 --> 01:14:12,551 YOU HAVE LOTS OF WORK. COUNCIL 1715 01:14:12,551 --> 01:14:13,819 OF COUNCIL'S MEMBER DR. KAREN 1716 01:14:13,819 --> 01:14:17,122 JOHNSTON, THE DISTINGUISHED 1717 01:14:17,122 --> 01:14:19,091 PROFESSOR OF NEUROLOGY AND 1718 01:14:19,091 --> 01:14:20,626 CLINICAL RESEARCH AT UNIVERSITY 1719 01:14:20,626 --> 01:14:21,827 OF VIRGINIA SCHOOL OF MEDICINE 1720 01:14:21,827 --> 01:14:23,829 AND DR. JEAN KING, DEAN OF ARTS 1721 01:14:23,829 --> 01:14:27,265 AND SCIENCES AND PROFESSOR OF 1722 01:14:27,265 --> 01:14:27,833 NEUROSCIENCE, BIOLOGY AND 1723 01:14:27,833 --> 01:14:35,807 BIOTECHNOLOGY AT WORCESTER 1724 01:14:35,807 --> 01:14:38,276 POLYTECNIC INSTITUTE. 1725 01:14:38,276 --> 01:14:40,746 >> I WILL KICK OFF. IT WAS A 1726 01:14:40,746 --> 01:14:41,980 WONDERFUL YEAR WORKING WITH BOTH 1727 01:14:41,980 --> 01:14:43,215 GROUPS. NOW THE AIM-AHEAD AND 1728 01:14:43,215 --> 01:14:46,084 YOU WILL HEAR OUR WORKING GROUP 1729 01:14:46,084 --> 01:14:47,986 REPORT. I WANT TO THANK KAREN 1730 01:14:47,986 --> 01:14:49,488 AND JEAN FOR DEDICATED HARD WORK 1731 01:14:49,488 --> 01:14:52,224 ON THIS REPORT. IT WAS A DELIGHT 1732 01:14:52,224 --> 01:14:54,092 TO WORK TOGETHER. THE NEXT SLIDE 1733 01:14:54,092 --> 01:14:56,361 IS JUST A LITTLE BIT OF AN 1734 01:14:56,361 --> 01:14:59,831 OVERVIEW OF THE PROGRAM. SO THE 1735 01:14:59,831 --> 01:15:00,599 AIM-AHEAD PROGRAM INITIATED BY 1736 01:15:00,599 --> 01:15:05,804 NIH AIMS TO ENHANCE THE USE OF 1737 01:15:05,804 --> 01:15:06,405 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND 1738 01:15:06,405 --> 01:15:07,673 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH IN CLINICAL 1739 01:15:07,673 --> 01:15:11,243 SETTINGS BY BUILDING 1740 01:15:11,243 --> 01:15:11,843 PARTNERSHIPS THAT SUPPORT 1741 01:15:11,843 --> 01:15:13,645 INFRASTRUCTURE AND RESEARCH AND 1742 01:15:13,645 --> 01:15:15,814 MENTORSHIP AND TRAINING. 1743 01:15:15,814 --> 01:15:19,217 PRIMARILY IN UNDERRESOURCED 1744 01:15:19,217 --> 01:15:20,419 COMMUNITIES. THIS HAD A 1745 01:15:20,419 --> 01:15:21,486 WHIRLWIND TOUR, A FUNDING 1746 01:15:21,486 --> 01:15:23,188 ANNOUNCEMENT IN JULY OF 2021 AND 1747 01:15:23,188 --> 01:15:26,825 MADE THE FINAL AWARDS 1748 01:15:26,825 --> 01:15:29,961 SEPTEMBER 17TH OF 2021 SO QUITE, 1749 01:15:29,961 --> 01:15:34,499 QUITE FAST. THE MAIN IS DR. V., 1750 01:15:34,499 --> 01:15:37,703 PROFESSOR AT UNIVERSITY OF NORTH 1751 01:15:37,703 --> 01:15:41,907 TEXAS HEALTH SCIENCE CENTER IN 1752 01:15:41,907 --> 01:15:46,244 FORT WORTH, TEXAS. THE ENTIRE 1753 01:15:46,244 --> 01:15:47,546 PROGRAM AND GOVERNANCE, I DON'T 1754 01:15:47,546 --> 01:15:49,381 WANT TO GO THROUGH THE WHOLE 1755 01:15:49,381 --> 01:15:50,315 FIGURE BUT HIGHLIGHT A FEW 1756 01:15:50,315 --> 01:15:51,483 IMPORTANT FACTS YOU REALLY NEED 1757 01:15:51,483 --> 01:15:52,384 TO KNOW . 1758 01:15:52,384 --> 01:15:55,620 THE FIRST IS FUNDING MECHANISM 1759 01:15:55,620 --> 01:15:57,122 IS OTHER TRANSACTIONAL 1760 01:15:57,122 --> 01:15:58,623 AUTHORITY, NEITHER A CONTRACT OR 1761 01:15:58,623 --> 01:16:00,292 GRANT BUT SORT OF PARTNERSHIP 1762 01:16:00,292 --> 01:16:05,097 BETWEEN AWARDEE AND NIH. IT IS 1763 01:16:05,097 --> 01:16:05,897 BROKEN INTO ADMINISTRATIVE, 1764 01:16:05,897 --> 01:16:07,599 INFRASTRUCTURE, DATA AND 1765 01:16:07,599 --> 01:16:09,101 TRAINING COURSE. THOSE ARE 1766 01:16:09,101 --> 01:16:11,203 FUNDED THROUGH THE SUBAWARDS OF 1767 01:16:11,203 --> 01:16:18,643 THE MAIN OTA TO (?). THE AWARD 1768 01:16:18,643 --> 01:16:19,978 INCLUDES IDENTIFYING FOUR NORTH 1769 01:16:19,978 --> 01:16:22,347 STARSLY IDENTIFY AND HELP FOCUS 1770 01:16:22,347 --> 01:16:23,815 ENTIRE PROGRAM AND ALL SO WE ARE 1771 01:16:23,815 --> 01:16:26,952 ALL MARCHING TOGETHER. AND 1772 01:16:26,952 --> 01:16:28,153 IMPORTANTLY THIS PROGRAM IS 1773 01:16:28,153 --> 01:16:29,788 NATIONWIDE AND STRUCTURED WITH 1774 01:16:29,788 --> 01:16:32,858 SEVEN HUBS. THAT HELPS US PUT 1775 01:16:32,858 --> 01:16:35,660 PROGRAMS AND INITIATIVES AND 1776 01:16:35,660 --> 01:16:36,661 COLLABORATIONS ACROSS THE 1777 01:16:36,661 --> 01:16:38,263 COUNTRY. THOSE ARE INITIATED 1778 01:16:38,263 --> 01:16:39,731 THROUGH THE HUB STRUCTURE. SO 1779 01:16:39,731 --> 01:16:43,668 THE NEXT SLIDE, JUST REALLY 1780 01:16:43,668 --> 01:16:45,470 ILLUSTRATES THE GOALS AND NORTH 1781 01:16:45,470 --> 01:16:47,472 STAR. THE GOALS ARE 1782 01:16:47,472 --> 01:16:50,642 PARTICIPATION OF RESEARCHERS AND 1783 01:16:50,642 --> 01:16:52,878 COMMUNITIES AND STAKEHOLDERS AND 1784 01:16:52,878 --> 01:16:55,080 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE AND 1785 01:16:55,080 --> 01:16:56,314 PARTICIPATION BY THOSE THAT MAY 1786 01:16:56,314 --> 01:16:57,516 NOT NECESSARILY BE FIRST THOUGHT 1787 01:16:57,516 --> 01:16:59,818 IN DEVELOPING AND USING AI. 1788 01:16:59,818 --> 01:17:03,221 FOCUSING ON HEALTH CHALLENGES 1789 01:17:03,221 --> 01:17:05,857 AND DISPARITIES AND BEHAVIORAL, 1790 01:17:05,857 --> 01:17:08,426 MENTAL, METABOLIC, CARDIO, 1791 01:17:08,426 --> 01:17:10,829 RESEARCH AND OUTCOMES USING 1792 01:17:10,829 --> 01:17:12,197 INTELLIGENCE, MACHINE LEARNING 1793 01:17:12,197 --> 01:17:15,667 AND, IMPORTANTLY, TO BRING THE 1794 01:17:15,667 --> 01:17:16,568 CAPACITY THAT ARTIFICIAL 1795 01:17:16,568 --> 01:17:19,204 INTELLIGENCE OFFERS THROUGH THIS 1796 01:17:19,204 --> 01:17:21,573 ENABLING TECHNOLOGY ACROSS 1797 01:17:21,573 --> 01:17:23,809 UNITED STATES. THE FOUR NORTH 1798 01:17:23,809 --> 01:17:25,076 STARS THAT DRIVE THIS PROGRAM 1799 01:17:25,076 --> 01:17:27,379 ARE TO DEVELOP A BROAD TALENT 1800 01:17:27,379 --> 01:17:30,749 SET OF NEW AI AND WORKFORCE, TO 1801 01:17:30,749 --> 01:17:31,783 INCREASE KNOWLEDGE AND AWARENESS 1802 01:17:31,783 --> 01:17:35,854 OF THIS AT A NATIONAL SCALE BY 1803 01:17:35,854 --> 01:17:37,956 ENGAGING EMPOWERMENT IN 1804 01:17:37,956 --> 01:17:39,257 ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, TO USE 1805 01:17:39,257 --> 01:17:41,760 THAT TO IMPROVE HEALTH AND WE 1806 01:17:41,760 --> 01:17:46,665 HAD A PARTICULAR FOCUS ON CARDIO 1807 01:17:46,665 --> 01:17:47,399 METABOLIC CANCER COMMUNITIES 1808 01:17:47,399 --> 01:17:48,266 BECAUSE THIS IS WHAT THE 1809 01:17:48,266 --> 01:17:50,302 COMMUNITIES TOLD US THEY WANTED 1810 01:17:50,302 --> 01:17:52,070 US TO WORK ON. TO BUILD THAT 1811 01:17:52,070 --> 01:17:53,205 INFRASTRUCTURE AND CAPACITY TO 1812 01:17:53,205 --> 01:17:54,039 WORK WITH COMMUNITIES, MEET 1813 01:17:54,039 --> 01:17:55,740 WHERE THEY ARE AND HELP DEVELOP 1814 01:17:55,740 --> 01:17:56,775 THAT INFRASTRUCTURE. BECAUSE 1815 01:17:56,775 --> 01:17:59,711 THERE IS NO ONE-SIZE-FITS ALL 1816 01:17:59,711 --> 01:18:00,979 THAT WILL WORK ACROSS OUR 1817 01:18:00,979 --> 01:18:03,949 NATION. SO WE DID MEET WITH THE 1818 01:18:03,949 --> 01:18:06,818 COMMUNITIES TO HELP DEVELOP THE 1819 01:18:06,818 --> 01:18:08,787 INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THEM. THE 1820 01:18:08,787 --> 01:18:11,256 NEXT SLIDE IS GOING TO BE THE 1821 01:18:11,256 --> 01:18:12,290 HIGHLIGHTS. I CAN'T POSSIBLY 1822 01:18:12,290 --> 01:18:14,426 DISCUSS ALL. I WILL HIGHLIGHT A 1823 01:18:14,426 --> 01:18:15,994 FEW. JUST THE NOMENCLATURE WHEN 1824 01:18:15,994 --> 01:18:19,397 YOU SEE NS1, THAT MEANS NORTH 1825 01:18:19,397 --> 01:18:22,067 STAR ONE SO NS4 WOULD BE NORTH 1826 01:18:22,067 --> 01:18:23,969 STAR FOUR. SOME OF THE 1827 01:18:23,969 --> 01:18:26,071 HIGHLIGHTS. FOR EXAMPLE THIS 1828 01:18:26,071 --> 01:18:27,772 ENGAGES OVER 650 RESEARCHERS AND 1829 01:18:27,772 --> 01:18:30,308 I THINK ALMOST A THOUSAND 1830 01:18:30,308 --> 01:18:32,510 INSTITUTIONS ACROSS THE COUNTRY. 1831 01:18:32,510 --> 01:18:34,946 WE ALSO LEVERAGE EXISTING 1832 01:18:34,946 --> 01:18:37,115 PROGRAMS AT NIH TO HELP WITH OUR 1833 01:18:37,115 --> 01:18:39,317 TRAINING, OUR DATA AND 1834 01:18:39,317 --> 01:18:41,686 CAPACITY-BUILDING. SO, FOR 1835 01:18:41,686 --> 01:18:42,854 EXAMPLE, WE HAVE STRONG 1836 01:18:42,854 --> 01:18:43,889 COLLABORATIONS WITH THE ALL OF 1837 01:18:43,889 --> 01:18:48,026 US, NCADS COVID CLINICAL COHORT 1838 01:18:48,026 --> 01:18:49,761 COLLABORATIVE, WITH BRIDGE TO AI 1839 01:18:49,761 --> 01:18:55,166 AND SHARED PLATFORM SUPPORTED BY 1840 01:18:55,166 --> 01:18:56,635 NIMHD. WE SUBSTANTIATE 1841 01:18:56,635 --> 01:19:00,005 PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS, 1842 01:19:00,005 --> 01:19:02,941 OCHEN AND MEDSTAR. I WANT TO 1843 01:19:02,941 --> 01:19:04,209 HIGHLIGHT ONE PARTNERSHIP FOR 1844 01:19:04,209 --> 01:19:05,577 ME, IN PARTICULAR, IS 1845 01:19:05,577 --> 01:19:07,812 PARTNERSHIP WITH AMERICAN INDIAN 1846 01:19:07,812 --> 01:19:10,649 HIGHER EDUCATIONAL CONSORTIUM TO 1847 01:19:10,649 --> 01:19:13,351 DEVELOP AI CURRICULUM WITH 22 1848 01:19:13,351 --> 01:19:15,553 TRIBAL COLLEGES AND 1849 01:19:15,553 --> 01:19:16,354 UNIVERSITIES. THIS IS A SNAPSHOT 1850 01:19:16,354 --> 01:19:18,757 OF SOME OF THE IMPACTS OF THIS 1851 01:19:18,757 --> 01:19:20,959 PROGRAM. THE NEXT SLIDE IS THE 1852 01:19:20,959 --> 01:19:22,160 CHARGE.LY READ THE CHARGE AND 1853 01:19:22,160 --> 01:19:23,962 HAND OFF TO MY COLLEAGUE, KAREN. 1854 01:19:23,962 --> 01:19:27,365 SO WE CHARGE THIS GROUP IN APRIL 1855 01:19:27,365 --> 01:19:29,401 OF 2024 TO REVIEW THE CURRENT 1856 01:19:29,401 --> 01:19:33,705 SCOPE AND GOALS OF THE AIM-AHEAD 1857 01:19:33,705 --> 01:19:35,607 PROGRAM, ASSES THE PROGRESS TO 1858 01:19:35,607 --> 01:19:39,778 DATE. BASED ON THIS, TO MAKE 1859 01:19:39,778 --> 01:19:43,381 RECOMMEND 1860 01:19:43,381 --> 01:19:45,083 RECOMMENDATIONS, LIKE THE OTHER 1861 01:19:45,083 --> 01:19:46,918 WORKING GROUP, TELL US WHAT YOU 1862 01:19:46,918 --> 01:19:48,386 THINK SUCCESS OF THIS PROGRAM 1863 01:19:48,386 --> 01:19:50,622 WOULD MEAN SO WE CAN MEET YOUR 1864 01:19:50,622 --> 01:19:53,158 DESIRED GOALS. WITH THAT, I'M 1865 01:19:53,158 --> 01:19:54,926 GOING TO HAND OVER TO KAREN SO 1866 01:19:54,926 --> 01:19:57,629 WE CAN MOVE FORWARD ON THE 1867 01:19:57,629 --> 01:19:58,129 PROCESS. 1868 01:19:58,129 --> 01:20:00,665 >> GREAT. THANK YOU, SUSAN. SO I 1869 01:20:00,665 --> 01:20:02,534 JUST WANTED TO MAKE SURE THE 1870 01:20:02,534 --> 01:20:03,969 COUNCIL HAD A LITTLE SENSE OF 1871 01:20:03,969 --> 01:20:06,972 THE PROCESS THAT WE USED. WE 1872 01:20:06,972 --> 01:20:09,207 STARTED BY IDENTIFYING EXPERTS 1873 01:20:09,207 --> 01:20:12,444 ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND BRINGING 1874 01:20:12,444 --> 01:20:19,150 THEM TOGETHER, MEET MONTHS AGOLY 1875 01:20:19,150 --> 01:20:21,653 SINCE OCTOBER OF 2024. WE SPENT 1876 01:20:21,653 --> 01:20:23,188 MOST TIME MEETING WITH MEMBERS 1877 01:20:23,188 --> 01:20:26,758 OF THE AIM-AHEAD TEAM SO MET 1878 01:20:26,758 --> 01:20:30,662 WITH LEADERSHIP, TRAINEE, AWARD 1879 01:20:30,662 --> 01:20:34,766 DEE, STAKEHOLDERS AND PANEL 1880 01:20:34,766 --> 01:20:37,869 MEMBERS. IN EACH OF THESE 1881 01:20:37,869 --> 01:20:39,471 MEETI 1882 01:20:39,471 --> 01:20:40,939 MEETINGS, WE TALKED WITH TEAM 1883 01:20:40,939 --> 01:20:42,307 MEMBERS ABOUT THEIR PERCEPTION 1884 01:20:42,307 --> 01:20:43,708 OF KEY SUCCESSES WERE, WHAT 1885 01:20:43,708 --> 01:20:45,310 THEIR CHALLENGES WERE, WHAT 1886 01:20:45,310 --> 01:20:47,846 THEIR RECOMMENDATIONS WOULD BE 1887 01:20:47,846 --> 01:20:52,017 IN TERMS OF THE FUTURE OF 1888 01:20:52,017 --> 01:20:52,951 AIM-AHEAD. ALL THAT INFORMATION 1889 01:20:52,951 --> 01:20:57,088 WE USED TO DEVELOP THE DETAILED 1890 01:20:57,088 --> 01:20:59,424 REPORT, WHICH YOU HAVE AND OUR 1891 01:20:59,424 --> 01:21:02,060 HOPES THIS WILL INFORM THE NEXT 1892 01:21:02,060 --> 01:21:04,863 ITERATION OF AIM-AHEAD. NEXT 1893 01:21:04,863 --> 01:21:07,332 SLIDE, PLEASE. SO THIS IS OUR 1894 01:21:07,332 --> 01:21:10,468 EXPERT TEAM. WE ARE INCREDIBLY 1895 01:21:10,468 --> 01:21:12,537 GRATEFUL TO EACH FOR THEIR 1896 01:21:12,537 --> 01:21:15,874 INSIGHTS AND THEIR TIME. NEXT 1897 01:21:15,874 --> 01:21:18,243 SLIDE, PLEASE. SO WE WANTED TO 1898 01:21:18,243 --> 01:21:20,478 MAKE SURE THE COUNCIL HAS A 1899 01:21:20,478 --> 01:21:26,317 SENSE OF THE DREAD -- BREADTH OF 1900 01:21:26,317 --> 01:21:27,952 THE NETWORK. THIS IS A MAP 1901 01:21:27,952 --> 01:21:29,554 ACROSS THE COUNTRY. YOU CAN SEE 1902 01:21:29,554 --> 01:21:30,789 ON THE MAP THE DIFFERENT COLORS 1903 01:21:30,789 --> 01:21:33,291 IN THE STATES. THOSE REPRESENT 1904 01:21:33,291 --> 01:21:35,994 THE SEVEN REGIONAL HUBS. THEN 1905 01:21:35,994 --> 01:21:38,963 THE RED DOTS ARE MENTEES AND 1906 01:21:38,963 --> 01:21:40,865 BLUE ARE MENTORS. YOU CAN SEE 1907 01:21:40,865 --> 01:21:42,267 HOW WELL DISTRIBUTED THEY ARE 1908 01:21:42,267 --> 01:21:46,604 ACROSS THE HUBS AND ACROSS THE 1909 01:21:46,604 --> 01:21:48,640 NATION. WE ALSO LOOK AT 1910 01:21:48,640 --> 01:21:54,279 COMMUNITY STAKEHOLDER MAPS AND 1911 01:21:54,279 --> 01:21:55,713 AWARDEE MAPS AND THOSE ARE 1912 01:21:55,713 --> 01:21:58,616 DISTRIBUTED ACROSS HUBS AND 1913 01:21:58,616 --> 01:22:00,218 COUNTRY. NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. SO 1914 01:22:00,218 --> 01:22:01,853 WE WANTED TO GIVE THE COUNCIL A 1915 01:22:01,853 --> 01:22:04,422 LITTLE BIT OF A HIGH-LEVEL SENSE 1916 01:22:04,422 --> 01:22:06,024 OF WHAT OUR MAJOR FINDING WERE. 1917 01:22:06,024 --> 01:22:09,227 I WILL TELL YOU THAT WE WERE ALL 1918 01:22:09,227 --> 01:22:11,529 VERY MUCH IMPRESSED WITH THE 1919 01:22:11,529 --> 01:22:14,632 FACT THAT AIM-AHEAD HAD BUILT A 1920 01:22:14,632 --> 01:22:16,701 NATIONAL AI MACHINE LEARNING 1921 01:22:16,701 --> 01:22:18,103 HEALTH RESEARCH ECOSYSTEM. YOU 1922 01:22:18,103 --> 01:22:19,704 CAN SEE IN THAT IMPACT BOX ON 1923 01:22:19,704 --> 01:22:23,341 THE SLIDE THAT THERE WERE OVER 1924 01:22:23,341 --> 01:22:31,282 7,000 MEMBERS, OVER 4,000 MEANT 1925 01:22:31,282 --> 01:22:33,685 MENTEES, 2,000 MENTORS AND 2,000 1926 01:22:33,685 --> 01:22:34,819 INSTITUTIONS INVOLVED THAT WAS 1927 01:22:34,819 --> 01:22:36,788 BUILDING COLLABORATION. WE ALSO 1928 01:22:36,788 --> 01:22:38,189 IDENTIFIED THERE WAS A -- THEY 1929 01:22:38,189 --> 01:22:41,025 HAD BUILT A PROFESSIONAL 1930 01:22:41,025 --> 01:22:43,094 DEVELOPMENT ECOSYSTEM. THEY USED 1931 01:22:43,094 --> 01:22:46,764 A TOOL CALLED AIM-AHEAD CONNECT, 1932 01:22:46,764 --> 01:22:50,602 WHICH HOUSES ALL OF THE TRAINING 1933 01:22:50,602 --> 01:22:53,571 MATERIALS AND CONFERENCES, 1934 01:22:53,571 --> 01:22:54,239 SYMPOSIUM MATERIALS THAT ARE NOT 1935 01:22:54,239 --> 01:22:57,408 ONLY AVAILABLE TO THE AIM-AHEAD 1936 01:22:57,408 --> 01:22:59,043 PARTICIPANTS BUT HAD MADE IT 1937 01:22:59,043 --> 01:23:02,180 AVAILABLE BY REGISTRATION FOR 1938 01:23:02,180 --> 01:23:05,817 ANYONE WHO WANTS TO REGISTER AND 1939 01:23:05,817 --> 01:23:16,194 VIEW THOSE MATERIALS 1940 01:23:19,063 --> 01:23:20,431 ASYNCROUNUSLY AND TO NETWORK. 1941 01:23:20,431 --> 01:23:22,100 THEY HAVE DEVELOPED 1942 01:23:22,100 --> 01:23:24,202 APPROXIMATELY 400 AI-READY 1943 01:23:24,202 --> 01:23:27,005 RESEARCH WORK FORCE MEMBERS WE 1944 01:23:27,005 --> 01:23:27,739 STRONGLY BELIEVE WILL SUPPORT 1945 01:23:27,739 --> 01:23:29,507 THE SUSTAINABILITY OF THE IMPACT 1946 01:23:29,507 --> 01:23:33,645 THEY CAN HAVE. NEXT SLIDE, 1947 01:23:33,645 --> 01:23:36,080 PLEASE. SO ONE OF THE THINGS WE 1948 01:23:36,080 --> 01:23:42,554 TALK ABOUT IN EVERY SINGLE ONE, 1949 01:23:42,554 --> 01:23:45,557 A COUPLE OF THE COMPONENTS THAT 1950 01:23:45,557 --> 01:23:48,193 WE FELT WERE REALLY IMPACTFUL IN 1951 01:23:48,193 --> 01:23:51,529 TERMS OF CREATING A SUSTAINABLE 1952 01:23:51,529 --> 01:23:53,998 INFRASTRUCTURE. THE FIRST WAS 1953 01:23:53,998 --> 01:23:55,400 THEY DEVELOPED A FED RATED 1954 01:23:55,400 --> 01:23:57,268 NETWORK, WHICH ALLOWED FOR 1955 01:23:57,268 --> 01:24:00,605 COLLABORATIVE DATA ANALYSIS 1956 01:24:00,605 --> 01:24:04,509 WITHOUT THE INSTITUTIONS OR 1957 01:24:04,509 --> 01:24:07,278 ORGANIZATIONS HAVING TO SHARE 1958 01:24:07,278 --> 01:24:09,314 THEIR PATIENT-LEVEL DATA OUTSIDE 1959 01:24:09,314 --> 01:24:11,816 OF THEIR OWN FIREWALL. THEY 1960 01:24:11,816 --> 01:24:14,519 CREATED A REGULATORY COMPLIANCE 1961 01:24:14,519 --> 01:24:16,287 OFFICE, WHICH FUNCTIONED ALMOST 1962 01:24:16,287 --> 01:24:20,291 LIKE A REGULATORY CONCIERGE TO 1963 01:24:20,291 --> 01:24:21,759 HELP MEMBERS GET THROUGH THOSE 1964 01:24:21,759 --> 01:24:23,094 REGULATORY PIECES MORE QUICKLY 1965 01:24:23,094 --> 01:24:24,562 AND EFFICIENTLY SO THEY COULD 1966 01:24:24,562 --> 01:24:27,699 GET TO THEIR RESEARCH PROJECTS. 1967 01:24:27,699 --> 01:24:31,236 THEY WERE VERY INTENTIONED ABOUT 1968 01:24:31,236 --> 01:24:33,404 BUILDING CAPACITY IN THE TRIBAL 1969 01:24:33,404 --> 01:24:35,306 COMMUNITY SAFETY NET HOSPITALS 1970 01:24:35,306 --> 01:24:38,443 COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTERS. 1971 01:24:38,443 --> 01:24:40,078 FINALLY, THEY DEVELOPED A 1972 01:24:40,078 --> 01:24:44,582 DURABLE REAL-WORLD DATA AI 1973 01:24:44,582 --> 01:24:45,183 TRAINING CURRICULUM ALREADY 1974 01:24:45,183 --> 01:24:47,085 BEING SHARED WITH ALL OF US, 1975 01:24:47,085 --> 01:24:50,421 WITH NCATS AND BRIDGE TO AI. 1976 01:24:50,421 --> 01:24:52,457 EACH OF THESE COMPONENTS ARE 1977 01:24:52,457 --> 01:24:54,826 ONLY SOME BUT THINGS WE THOUGHT 1978 01:24:54,826 --> 01:24:56,461 REALLY SUPPORTED THE 1979 01:24:56,461 --> 01:24:58,062 SUSTAINABILITY OF THE PROGRAM. 1980 01:24:58,062 --> 01:24:59,631 WITH THAT I'LL PASS IT AHEAD TO 1981 01:24:59,631 --> 01:25:03,268 DR. KING TO TALK ABOUT OUR 1982 01:25:03,268 --> 01:25:03,668 RECOMMENDATIONS. 1983 01:25:03,668 --> 01:25:04,669 >> THANK YOU VERY MUCH. THANKS 1984 01:25:04,669 --> 01:25:06,638 TO THIS GROUP. IT WAS A 1985 01:25:06,638 --> 01:25:10,108 WONDERFUL GROUP TO WORK WITH. 1986 01:25:10,108 --> 01:25:12,677 NEXT SLIDE, PLEASE. SO AS IN 1987 01:25:12,677 --> 01:25:14,712 EVERY ORGANIZATION AND EVERY 1988 01:25:14,712 --> 01:25:15,847 GREAT PROJECT LIKE THIS ONE, 1989 01:25:15,847 --> 01:25:18,783 THERE ARE CHALLENGES. THEREFORE 1990 01:25:18,783 --> 01:25:21,753 WE HAVE USED THAT FRAMEWORK FOR 1991 01:25:21,753 --> 01:25:22,553 RECOMMENDATIONS. I HOPE YOU 1992 01:25:22,553 --> 01:25:23,821 UNDERSTAND FROM ALL THE THINGS 1993 01:25:23,821 --> 01:25:25,590 WE HAVE SHOWN YOU SO FAR IN THE 1994 01:25:25,590 --> 01:25:28,259 LAST TEN SLIDES THAT AIM-AHEAD 1995 01:25:28,259 --> 01:25:30,928 HAS BEEN SIGNIFICANT, 1996 01:25:30,928 --> 01:25:32,063 TRANSFORMATIVE AND VERY LARGE 1997 01:25:32,063 --> 01:25:35,199 ECOSYSTEM. IN THAT CONNECTIVITY, 1998 01:25:35,199 --> 01:25:37,735 THE AREAS WE THINK COULD BE 1999 01:25:37,735 --> 01:25:39,804 STRENGTHENED BY THE FOLLOWING 2000 01:25:39,804 --> 01:25:41,439 RECOMMENDATIONS. SO ONE OF THE 2001 01:25:41,439 --> 01:25:43,308 CHALLENGES THAT CAME UP EVERY 2002 01:25:43,308 --> 01:25:45,143 SINGLE TIME WAS THE SHORT TIME 2003 01:25:45,143 --> 01:25:45,343 LINE . 2004 01:25:45,343 --> 01:25:46,811 THE ONE YEAR WAS TOO SHORT AND 2005 01:25:46,811 --> 01:25:49,113 IMPACTED WHAT I CALLED MORE LIKE 2006 01:25:49,113 --> 01:25:52,483 A PRI, THE PREPARATION, THE 2007 01:25:52,483 --> 01:25:53,651 REGULATORY COMPLIANCES. YOU HAVE 2008 01:25:53,651 --> 01:25:55,787 TO KNOW IN SOME OF THESE 2009 01:25:55,787 --> 01:25:57,255 ORGANIZATIONS THERE'S NOT A LOT 2010 01:25:57,255 --> 01:25:59,457 OF ROBUSTNESS IN TERMS OF I HAVE 2011 01:25:59,457 --> 01:26:02,894 RB AND (?) SO A LOT OF LEARNING 2012 01:26:02,894 --> 01:26:04,595 HAD TO HAPPEN IN ORDER TO 2013 01:26:04,595 --> 01:26:06,364 IMPLEMENT. THAT CHALLENGE WAS 2014 01:26:06,364 --> 01:26:07,799 ONE THAT WAS SIGNIFICANT IN 2015 01:26:07,799 --> 01:26:09,567 TERMS OF MAKING THIS AS 2016 01:26:09,567 --> 01:26:11,536 SIGNIFICANT AS WE'D LIKE BECAUSE 2017 01:26:11,536 --> 01:26:13,771 TIMING WAS NOT EXACTLY ON POINT. 2018 01:26:13,771 --> 01:26:15,073 WE WOULD REALLY LIKE 2019 01:26:15,073 --> 01:26:16,541 RECOMMENDATION ONE TO BE TO 2020 01:26:16,541 --> 01:26:18,609 EXTEND THE TIME LINE OF THE OTA 2021 01:26:18,609 --> 01:26:22,680 TO AT LEAST THREE YEARS, WHICH 2022 01:26:22,680 --> 01:26:24,115 REASSURANCES IN A TIMELY MANNER 2023 01:26:24,115 --> 01:26:25,616 SO PEOPLE COULD HAVE TIME FOR 2024 01:26:25,616 --> 01:26:27,819 THE PREPARATION AND GET IN ALL 2025 01:26:27,819 --> 01:26:29,854 THE DOCUMENTS IN LINE. CHALLENGE 2026 01:26:29,854 --> 01:26:33,558 TWO IS SIMILAR BECAUSE IT IS 2027 01:26:33,558 --> 01:26:36,060 ABOUT TIMING. BUT SHORTER 2028 01:26:36,060 --> 01:26:37,662 PERIODS MADE IT DIFFICULT FOR 2029 01:26:37,662 --> 01:26:38,896 COLLABORATIONS TO HAPPEN IN 2030 01:26:38,896 --> 01:26:40,631 TERMS OF MEANINGFUL 2031 01:26:40,631 --> 01:26:42,100 RELATIONSHIPS. AS WE KNOW, ONE 2032 01:26:42,100 --> 01:26:44,268 OF THE CURRENCIES OF 2033 01:26:44,268 --> 01:26:46,938 COLLABORATION, ESPECIALLY WITH 2034 01:26:46,938 --> 01:26:49,674 COMMUNITIES, IS TIME. TRUST 2035 01:26:49,674 --> 01:26:51,042 BUILDS WITH TIME. THIS LED TO 2036 01:26:51,042 --> 01:26:53,077 PEOPLE USING ALL COLLABORATION, 2037 01:26:53,077 --> 01:26:54,545 ALREADY READY, AND WE WOULD LOVE 2038 01:26:54,545 --> 01:26:56,781 TO SEE THIS EXTEND TO OTHER 2039 01:26:56,781 --> 01:26:58,282 COLLABORATIONS THAT ARE NOT AS 2040 01:26:58,282 --> 01:26:59,350 TIMELY AND THEREFORE COULD 2041 01:26:59,350 --> 01:27:01,152 ACTUALLY BE EXPANSIVE IN THAT 2042 01:27:01,152 --> 01:27:03,087 AMOUNT OF TIME. SO WE ARE 2043 01:27:03,087 --> 01:27:05,690 THINKING ABOUT A SIX-MONTH 2044 01:27:05,690 --> 01:27:07,325 REAWARD STAGE WHERE ALL THIS 2045 01:27:07,325 --> 01:27:09,394 COULD HAPPEN AND ESTABLISHMENT 2046 01:27:09,394 --> 01:27:11,796 OF COMMUNITY AMBASSADORS TO MAKE 2047 01:27:11,796 --> 01:27:13,898 SURE STRENGTH AND TRUST OF THOSE 2048 01:27:13,898 --> 01:27:15,633 INTERACTIONS NOT JUST HAPPEN BUT 2049 01:27:15,633 --> 01:27:17,869 BECOME ROBUST. THE THIRD 2050 01:27:17,869 --> 01:27:21,506 CHALLENGE WE HEARD A LOT OF WAS 2051 01:27:21,506 --> 01:27:23,107 MENTOR SHIP ALTHOUGH STRONG 2052 01:27:23,107 --> 01:27:26,878 LACKED CONSISTENCY. SOME MENTOR 2053 01:27:26,878 --> 01:27:28,679 MENTEE PEERS WERE NOT SIMILAR TO 2054 01:27:28,679 --> 01:27:29,981 OTHER S SO WE THINK WE COULD 2055 01:27:29,981 --> 01:27:31,182 ENHANCE THE SUCCESS OF THIS 2056 01:27:31,182 --> 01:27:35,553 RELATIONSHIP BY BUILDING IN MORE 2057 01:27:35,553 --> 01:27:38,489 RELIANCE ON WHAT THIS 2058 01:27:38,489 --> 01:27:43,327 RELATIONSHIP WOULD BE LIKE. I 2059 01:27:43,327 --> 01:27:45,596 THINK THERE ARE LOTS OF NEW 2060 01:27:45,596 --> 01:27:47,799 PROGRAMS REALLY LOOKING AT THESE 2061 01:27:47,799 --> 01:27:49,700 INDEPTH AND I THINK WE COULD 2062 01:27:49,700 --> 01:27:55,807 BRING SCIENCE OF MENTOR 2063 01:27:55,807 --> 01:27:56,808 MENTEEING INTO THIS. OUR FINAL 2064 01:27:56,808 --> 01:27:59,477 SLIDE IS RARELY TO ENHANCE AND 2065 01:27:59,477 --> 01:28:01,179 IMPLEMENT NOVEL EVALUATION 2066 01:28:01,179 --> 01:28:02,713 REPORT. WE TALKED ABOUT THAT IN 2067 01:28:02,713 --> 01:28:05,383 THE OTHER REPORT. WHERE WE 2068 01:28:05,383 --> 01:28:08,052 REALLY WANTED TO MAKE SURE THE 2069 01:28:08,052 --> 01:28:09,754 SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY AND 2070 01:28:09,754 --> 01:28:11,756 AIM-AHEAD ECOSYSTEM UNITED 2071 01:28:11,756 --> 01:28:13,057 STATES HOW TRANSFORMATIVE WE 2072 01:28:13,057 --> 01:28:15,960 THINK THIS HAS BEEN IN SO MANY 2073 01:28:15,960 --> 01:28:18,563 WAYS BY CAPTURING MOVE OF THIS 2074 01:28:18,563 --> 01:28:20,264 INFORMATION. SO THEY HAVE 2075 01:28:20,264 --> 01:28:22,033 ESTABLISHED A PROCESS BUT THERE 2076 01:28:22,033 --> 01:28:23,801 ARE OPPORTUNITIES TO CAPTURE AND 2077 01:28:23,801 --> 01:28:26,003 IMPACT OUTCOMES SO WE WANTED TO 2078 01:28:26,003 --> 01:28:28,172 IMPACT OUTCOMES TO BE VALIDATED 2079 01:28:28,172 --> 01:28:30,641 IN WAYS THAT MADE SENSE, 2080 01:28:30,641 --> 01:28:32,643 MEASURED BASELINE DATA, 2081 01:28:32,643 --> 01:28:34,145 PROGRESS, QUANTIFY THE ROIs. 2082 01:28:34,145 --> 01:28:36,147 THERE ARE SO MANY WAYS WE THINK 2083 01:28:36,147 --> 01:28:38,382 WE COULD BE MORE EXPANSIVE. IT 2084 01:28:38,382 --> 01:28:39,250 WAS HAPPENING BUT NOT TRACK ED 2085 01:28:39,250 --> 01:28:41,986 IN A WAY WE THINK COULD REALLY 2086 01:28:41,986 --> 01:28:42,954 CHANGE THE SCIENTIFIC COMMUNITY 2087 01:28:42,954 --> 01:28:45,756 THE WAYS WE UNDERSTAND THE ROI 2088 01:28:45,756 --> 01:28:47,792 ON THIS INVESTMENT. LAST BUT NOT 2089 01:28:47,792 --> 01:28:49,994 LEAST, WE TALKED A LOT ABOUT 2090 01:28:49,994 --> 01:28:51,796 SUSTAINABILITY AS YOU HEARD FROM 2091 01:28:51,796 --> 01:28:54,165 MY PARTNERS AND COLLEAGUES 2092 01:28:54,165 --> 01:28:56,901 PRESENTED BEFORE ME. AIM-AHEAD 2093 01:28:56,901 --> 01:28:58,169 NURTURED SUSTAINABILITY THROUGH 2094 01:28:58,169 --> 01:29:00,371 LOTS OF CAPACITY BUILDING, 2095 01:29:00,371 --> 01:29:02,340 CONCIERGE SERVICES, LONG-TERM 2096 01:29:02,340 --> 01:29:04,842 SUSTAINABILITY IS KEY. WITHOUT 2097 01:29:04,842 --> 01:29:06,711 THAT WE WILL REALLY NOT BE AS 2098 01:29:06,711 --> 01:29:07,979 RELIANT ON GROUPS WE HAVE 2099 01:29:07,979 --> 01:29:09,747 ALREADY FORMED. THEY ARE SO 2100 01:29:09,747 --> 01:29:11,782 STRONG. WE REALLY WANT TO MAKE 2101 01:29:11,782 --> 01:29:12,683 SURE THIS CONTINUES WHETHER OR 2102 01:29:12,683 --> 01:29:14,519 NOT THERE IS FEDERAL FUNDING. 2103 01:29:14,519 --> 01:29:17,421 HOW DO WE DO THAT? HOW DO WE 2104 01:29:17,421 --> 01:29:19,357 INCENTIVISE A SUSTAINABLE 2105 01:29:19,357 --> 01:29:20,591 NETWORK THAT WE HAVE BUILT IN 2106 01:29:20,591 --> 01:29:22,627 ORDER TO GET THE DATA WE NEED, 2107 01:29:22,627 --> 01:29:24,896 IN ORDER TO GET THE RESULTS WE 2108 01:29:24,896 --> 01:29:27,198 NEED. SO IN BUILDING TOOLS, 2109 01:29:27,198 --> 01:29:33,271 TECHNOLOGY AND TALENT, WHILE WE 2110 01:29:33,271 --> 01:29:34,839 BUILD WE NEED TO INTEGRATE THEM 2111 01:29:34,839 --> 01:29:37,041 BETTER, MAKE CONNECTIVITY WORK 2112 01:29:37,041 --> 01:29:39,810 SO WE COULD SUSTAIN THESE REALLY 2113 01:29:39,810 --> 01:29:41,512 GREAT INTERACTIONS AND ALL 2114 01:29:41,512 --> 01:29:42,613 SUSTAINABLE AND TRANSFORMATIVE 2115 01:29:42,613 --> 01:29:43,881 THINGS THAT HAVE HAPPENED SO WE 2116 01:29:43,881 --> 01:29:45,917 ARE LOOKING FORWARD TO FIGURING 2117 01:29:45,917 --> 01:29:49,020 HOW TO ADOPT TRADE-IN AND 2118 01:29:49,020 --> 01:29:50,955 TRADE-OUT MODELS, SUPPORT 2119 01:29:50,955 --> 01:29:51,989 UNDERRESOURCED COMMUNITIES. I 2120 01:29:51,989 --> 01:29:53,190 THINK ABOUT THIS WHEN I LISTEN 2121 01:29:53,190 --> 01:29:55,493 TO ALL THE INFORMATION WE GOT AS 2122 01:29:55,493 --> 01:29:57,361 AI FOR ALL. AS YOU COULD TELL 2123 01:29:57,361 --> 01:30:00,631 FROM THE MAP, WE REALLY DID 2124 01:30:00,631 --> 01:30:01,966 INFILTRATE ALMOST EVERY SINGLE 2125 01:30:01,966 --> 01:30:03,434 STATE IN THE UNITED STATES. WE 2126 01:30:03,434 --> 01:30:06,604 REALLY NEED TO DO A BETTER JOB 2127 01:30:06,604 --> 01:30:07,939 OF MAKING SURE NOT ONLY HAVE WE 2128 01:30:07,939 --> 01:30:10,241 DONE WHAT WE HAVE DONE RIGHT NOW 2129 01:30:10,241 --> 01:30:11,676 BUT CONTINUE THIS MODEL AND 2130 01:30:11,676 --> 01:30:12,777 HOPEFULLY DO IT AGAIN AND MAKE 2131 01:30:12,777 --> 01:30:18,149 SURE IT IS SUSTAINABLE. NEXT 2132 01:30:18,149 --> 01:30:23,487 SLIDE, PLEASE. I THINK THAT IS 2133 01:30:23,487 --> 01:30:24,789 THE LAST SLIDE. ALL RIGHT. OPEN 2134 01:30:24,789 --> 01:30:26,490 FOR DISCUSSION, THANK YOU VERY 2135 01:30:26,490 --> 01:30:26,724 MUCH. 2136 01:30:26,724 --> 01:30:29,594 >> THANK YOU SO MUCH, SUSAN, 2137 01:30:29,594 --> 01:30:32,029 KAREN AND JEAN. AS WITH THE 2138 01:30:32,029 --> 01:30:33,798 PREVIOUS WORK GROUP REPORT WE 2139 01:30:33,798 --> 01:30:35,433 WILL TAKE A VOTE ON WHETHER 2140 01:30:35,433 --> 01:30:36,901 COUNCIL ACCEPTS REPORT BUT FIRST 2141 01:30:36,901 --> 01:30:38,502 WE WANT TO OPEN IT TO QUESTIONS. 2142 01:30:38,502 --> 01:30:40,438 IF THERE ARE QUESTIONS, PLEASE 2143 01:30:40,438 --> 01:30:43,074 RAISE YOUR HAND. YOU WILL BE 2144 01:30:43,074 --> 01:30:44,241 RECOGNIZED BY FRANZISKA AND 2145 01:30:44,241 --> 01:30:45,376 ASKED TO UNMUTE YOURSELF. 2146 01:30:45,376 --> 01:30:48,179 >> THANK YOU, NICOLE. I SEE 2147 01:30:48,179 --> 01:30:52,984 LAUREN, YOU HAVE YOUR HANDS UP. 2148 01:30:52,984 --> 01:30:54,652 GOES TO YOU. 2149 01:30:54,652 --> 01:30:55,820 >> THANK YOU. APPRECIATE THE 2150 01:30:55,820 --> 01:30:57,021 EFFORT TOWARDS REGULATORY 2151 01:30:57,021 --> 01:30:58,522 COMPLIANCE AND PROCESS YOU HAVE 2152 01:30:58,522 --> 01:31:00,358 FOR CENTRALIZING THAT. THAT 2153 01:31:00,358 --> 01:31:01,959 SOUNDS GREAT. I'M JUST WONDERING 2154 01:31:01,959 --> 01:31:04,061 HOW YOU THINK ABOUT KEEPING UP 2155 01:31:04,061 --> 01:31:08,466 TO DATE WITH, YOU KNOW, POLICY, 2156 01:31:08,466 --> 01:31:09,367 REGULATORY SORT OF ASSURANCE 2157 01:31:09,367 --> 01:31:11,569 LAB. THERE'S A LOT OF DISCUSSION 2158 01:31:11,569 --> 01:31:13,504 HERE ABOUT BEST PRACTICES IN 2159 01:31:13,504 --> 01:31:15,806 HEALTH CARE, THE NATIONAL 2160 01:31:15,806 --> 01:31:16,774 ACADEMIES ISSUED A REPORT. SO 2161 01:31:16,774 --> 01:31:19,143 THAT SORT OF SOFT OR NOT PURE 2162 01:31:19,143 --> 01:31:20,711 COMPLIANCE BUT EXPECTATION OF 2163 01:31:20,711 --> 01:31:22,413 BEST PRACTICES AND EVOLVING 2164 01:31:22,413 --> 01:31:28,686 PATROL S POLICY /* /* -- POLICY 2165 01:31:28,686 --> 01:31:30,321 AND HOW YOU ARE INCORPORATING 2166 01:31:30,321 --> 01:31:31,288 THAT SO PEOPLE ARE THINKING 2167 01:31:31,288 --> 01:31:32,390 ABOUT IN IT THAT SPACE. 2168 01:31:32,390 --> 01:31:34,158 >> I'M HAPPY TO START ON THAT 2169 01:31:34,158 --> 01:31:35,926 AND MAYBE MY COLLEAGUES CAN 2170 01:31:35,926 --> 01:31:37,662 COMMENT FURTHER. ONE OF THE 2171 01:31:37,662 --> 01:31:38,863 RECOMMENDATIONS WE MADE IS THEY 2172 01:31:38,863 --> 01:31:40,831 CAN CONTINUE TO CENTRALIZE SOME 2173 01:31:40,831 --> 01:31:44,635 OF THESE RESOURCES SO THAT THE 2174 01:31:44,635 --> 01:31:47,805 REGULATORY TEAM COULD 2175 01:31:47,805 --> 01:31:49,840 POTENTIALLY BE CHARGED WITH 2176 01:31:49,840 --> 01:31:51,509 REALLY WORKING HARD TO MAKE SURE 2177 01:31:51,509 --> 01:31:53,678 THEY ARE UP TO DATE AND GETTING 2178 01:31:53,678 --> 01:31:56,447 THOSE UP-TO-DATE REGULATIONS 2179 01:31:56,447 --> 01:31:59,050 IMMEDIATELY OUT TO THE HEAD 2180 01:31:59,050 --> 01:32:00,017 AWARDEES, ESPECIALLY FOLKS GOING 2181 01:32:00,017 --> 01:32:01,152 THROUGH THE REGULATORY PROCESS 2182 01:32:01,152 --> 01:32:04,288 AT THAT TIME. SO WE TOTALLY 2183 01:32:04,288 --> 01:32:06,123 AGREE WITH YOU THAT THAT IS A 2184 01:32:06,123 --> 01:32:08,592 BIG LIFT TO KEEP UP WITH THE 2185 01:32:08,592 --> 01:32:09,860 REGULATORY REQUIREMENTS, SO OUR 2186 01:32:09,860 --> 01:32:12,797 HOPE IS BY CENTRALIZING IT AND 2187 01:32:12,797 --> 01:32:14,498 CONTINUING TO OFFER THIS 2188 01:32:14,498 --> 01:32:16,167 CONCIERGE-LIKE SERVICE THAT WE 2189 01:32:16,167 --> 01:32:17,768 WOULD BE ABLE TO SUPPORT THE 2190 01:32:17,768 --> 01:32:24,075 AIM-AHEAD TEAM MEMBERS THAT WAY. 2191 01:32:24,075 --> 01:32:27,244 >> I JUST WANT TO ADD TO THAT, 2192 01:32:27,244 --> 01:32:29,046 EXACTLY RIGHT. I THINK THAT SO 2193 01:32:29,046 --> 01:32:31,015 MUCH IS CHANGING SO QUICKLY, IT 2194 01:32:31,015 --> 01:32:32,983 IS REALLY DIFFICULT FOR YOU TO 2195 01:32:32,983 --> 01:32:34,719 GET WIT ON THE GROUND, 2196 01:32:34,719 --> 01:32:36,187 ESPECIALLY FOR THESE COMMUNITY 2197 01:32:36,187 --> 01:32:37,621 ORGANIZATIONS AND ORGANIZATIONS 2198 01:32:37,621 --> 01:32:39,890 THAT NOT AS TIGHTLY LINKED TO 2199 01:32:39,890 --> 01:32:42,159 THE WHOLE ECOSYSTEM. SO HAVING 2200 01:32:42,159 --> 01:32:45,463 SOME PLACE WHERE THE EXPERTISE 2201 01:32:45,463 --> 01:32:47,531 RESIDE AND THEN USING THAT AS 2202 01:32:47,531 --> 01:32:51,001 CORE TO FIND OUT TO ALL OF THE 2203 01:32:51,001 --> 01:32:51,736 COMMUNITY MEMBERS MAYBE THE BEST 2204 01:32:51,736 --> 01:32:55,372 WAY TO DO THAT. WE HAVE A CORE 2205 01:32:55,372 --> 01:32:56,807 WHOSE JOB IS TO FIGURE IT OUT 2206 01:32:56,807 --> 01:32:59,310 AND THEIR JOB IS TO GET IT OUT 2207 01:32:59,310 --> 01:33:00,911 TO OTHERS, SO THAT THE PEOPLE 2208 01:33:00,911 --> 01:33:02,580 WHO UNDERSTAND IT THE BEST 2209 01:33:02,580 --> 01:33:03,547 ACTUALLY SPENDING TIME 2210 01:33:03,547 --> 01:33:04,982 UNDERSTANDING ALL OF THE NEW 2211 01:33:04,982 --> 01:33:06,717 GUIDELINES THAT WILL BE COMING 2212 01:33:06,717 --> 01:33:08,152 DOWN AND NEW LEARN ING THAT IS 2213 01:33:08,152 --> 01:33:11,422 HAPPENING AS WE DO MORE AND MORE 2214 01:33:11,422 --> 01:33:16,660 OF THIS KIND OF RESEARCH. 2215 01:33:16,660 --> 01:33:20,397 >> GREAT, THANK YOU FOR 2216 01:33:20,397 --> 01:33:23,801 QUESTION. I ASSUME THAT ADDRESS 2217 01:33:23,801 --> 01:33:26,237 YOUR COMMENTS, RIGHT? 2218 01:33:26,237 --> 01:33:26,704 >> YES. 2219 01:33:26,704 --> 01:33:29,406 >> DR. LLOYD, YOU HAVE THE NEXT 2220 01:33:29,406 --> 01:33:29,774 QUESTION. 2221 01:33:29,774 --> 01:33:32,576 >> YEAH, SO DR. JOHNSON, DR. 2222 01:33:32,576 --> 01:33:35,146 KING, I ASK THIS QUESTION BUT IN 2223 01:33:35,146 --> 01:33:37,748 THE CONTEXT OF BEING A CHAIR OF 2224 01:33:37,748 --> 01:33:42,920 THER WORKING GROUPS -- OTHER 2225 01:33:42,920 --> 01:33:45,122 WORKING GROUPS, I KNOW HOW 2226 01:33:45,122 --> 01:33:46,257 DIFFICULT SO PLEASE TAKE THIS IN 2227 01:33:46,257 --> 01:33:47,958 A POSITIVE WAY. I READ YOUR 2228 01:33:47,958 --> 01:33:49,693 REPORT AND LISTENED CAREFULLY. I 2229 01:33:49,693 --> 01:33:51,328 JUST GO BACK TO THE FIRST 2230 01:33:51,328 --> 01:33:52,596 SENTENCE OF THE EXECUTIVE 2231 01:33:52,596 --> 01:33:59,470 SUMMARY. SAYS LAUNCH ED IN 2021, 2232 01:33:59,470 --> 01:34:01,839 AIM-AHEAD. TO IMPROVE HEALTH OF 2233 01:34:01,839 --> 01:34:03,574 ALL AMERICANS. BUT I DIDN'T HEAR 2234 01:34:03,574 --> 01:34:05,075 ANYTHING ABOUT THAT. WHAT I 2235 01:34:05,075 --> 01:34:08,646 HEARD IN THE FIRST PRESENTATION, 2236 01:34:08,646 --> 01:34:10,414 DR. JOHNSON YOU TALKED ABOUT 2237 01:34:10,414 --> 01:34:14,718 THOSE BUT YOU ARE GREAT. MEMBER, 2238 01:34:14,718 --> 01:34:16,887 INSTITUTIONS, EXTREMELY 2239 01:34:16,887 --> 01:34:18,556 IMPRESSIVE BUT METRICS AREN'T 2240 01:34:18,556 --> 01:34:20,691 IMPACTS. DR. KING I WAS 2241 01:34:20,691 --> 01:34:22,626 LISTENING TO YOUR 2242 01:34:22,626 --> 01:34:24,495 RECOMMENDATIONS BUT THOSE SEEM 2243 01:34:24,495 --> 01:34:25,529 MOSTLY ABOUT PROCESS, NOT ABOUT 2244 01:34:25,529 --> 01:34:30,000 HOW ARE WE EVALUATING THE -- 2245 01:34:30,000 --> 01:34:32,803 AGAIN, THE ROI ON QUOTE, 2246 01:34:32,803 --> 01:34:35,673 UNQUOTE, IMPROVING HEALTH OF ALL 2247 01:34:35,673 --> 01:34:37,708 AMERICANS. INTERPRET THAT AS YOU 2248 01:34:37,708 --> 01:34:39,476 WILL. MY QUESTION IS DID THE 2249 01:34:39,476 --> 01:34:42,046 WORKING GROUP GET INPUT FROM ALL 2250 01:34:42,046 --> 01:34:44,081 THE PERSONS YOU SPOKE TO ABOUT 2251 01:34:44,081 --> 01:34:46,750 WHAT HAS THE IMPACT OF THIS 2252 01:34:46,750 --> 01:34:51,822 PROGRAM BEEN ON, YOU KNOW, 2253 01:34:51,822 --> 01:34:55,159 REDUCING HEALTH DISPARITIES, 2254 01:34:55,159 --> 01:34:58,262 REDUCING CANCER INCIDENTS, 2255 01:34:58,262 --> 01:34:59,563 IMPROVING ACCESS TO HEALTH CARE. 2256 01:34:59,563 --> 01:35:01,832 WHATEVER THE REAL HUMAN HEALTH 2257 01:35:01,832 --> 01:35:05,536 IMPACTS ARE. DID YOU TALK TO AND 2258 01:35:05,536 --> 01:35:07,037 INTERVIEW PEOPLE TO GET FEEDBACK 2259 01:35:07,037 --> 01:35:09,940 ON THAT? DO YOU THINK THERE 2260 01:35:09,940 --> 01:35:11,175 SHOULD BE RECOMMENDATIONS ABOUT 2261 01:35:11,175 --> 01:35:13,978 HOW TO IMPROVE THAT TYPE OF 2262 01:35:13,978 --> 01:35:14,945 REPORTING, THANKS. 2263 01:35:14,945 --> 01:35:17,414 >> YEAH, I'M HAPPY TO START THIS 2264 01:35:17,414 --> 01:35:19,516 ONE TOO. THEN MY COLLEAGUES CAN 2265 01:35:19,516 --> 01:35:22,119 JUMP IN. SO I THINK YOU ARE 2266 01:35:22,119 --> 01:35:23,520 SPOT-ON WITH THAT QUESTION. THAT 2267 01:35:23,520 --> 01:35:25,923 IS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT WE 2268 01:35:25,923 --> 01:35:29,393 TALKED A LOT ABOUT. AS YOU KNOW, 2269 01:35:29,393 --> 01:35:31,161 EARLY IN A PROGRAM OFTEN WE WILL 2270 01:35:31,161 --> 01:35:33,664 MEASURE THE PROCESS PIECES AND 2271 01:35:33,664 --> 01:35:35,699 THE TOUCHES. THEN LATER IN A 2272 01:35:35,699 --> 01:35:37,835 PROGRAM WE TEND TO MEASURE THE 2273 01:35:37,835 --> 01:35:40,571 ACTUAL IMPACT. SO IT IS A LITTLE 2274 01:35:40,571 --> 01:35:42,873 EARLY TO REALLY CAPTURE IMPACT. 2275 01:35:42,873 --> 01:35:44,575 AND TO ADDRESS YOUR QUESTION 2276 01:35:44,575 --> 01:35:46,176 ABOUT WHETHER WE TALK TO FOLKS 2277 01:35:46,176 --> 01:35:48,746 ABOUT THAT, WE DID. BUT WE HEARD 2278 01:35:48,746 --> 01:35:50,881 MORE ANECDOTAL STORIES ABOUT THE 2279 01:35:50,881 --> 01:35:53,884 IMPACT ON THEM AS INDIVIDUALS. 2280 01:35:53,884 --> 01:35:56,020 EITHER COMMUNITY STAKEHOLDERS OR 2281 01:35:56,020 --> 01:35:58,088 AWARDEES OR TRAINEES. THEY WOULD 2282 01:35:58,088 --> 01:36:01,091 TALK ABOUT HOW IMPACTFUL THE 2283 01:36:01,091 --> 01:36:03,360 PROGRAM WAS FOR THEIR INDIVIDUAL 2284 01:36:03,360 --> 01:36:05,796 ENGAGEMENT IN THIS TYPE OF WORK. 2285 01:36:05,796 --> 01:36:10,834 LESS SO ABOUT THE IMPACT ON 2286 01:36:10,834 --> 01:36:12,336 LARGER POPULATIONS. SO AS YOU 2287 01:36:12,336 --> 01:36:15,472 HEARD FROM DR. KING, ONE OF OUR 2288 01:36:15,472 --> 01:36:17,374 RECOMMENDATIONS WAS FOR THE 2289 01:36:17,374 --> 01:36:19,176 AIM-AHEAD TEAM TO START TO GET 2290 01:36:19,176 --> 01:36:23,814 MORE 2291 01:36:23,814 --> 01:36:27,584 MORE -- CREATIVE AND KNOW 2292 01:36:27,584 --> 01:36:29,820 INVESTIGATIVE METRICS TO CAPTURE 2293 01:36:29,820 --> 01:36:31,755 THE TRUE IMPACT ON PEOPLE AND 2294 01:36:31,755 --> 01:36:33,757 POPULATION HEALTH THAT. IS MY 2295 01:36:33,757 --> 01:36:35,693 PERSPECTIVE. DR. KING, I DON'T 2296 01:36:35,693 --> 01:36:36,627 KNOW IF YOU WANT TO COMMENT ON 2297 01:36:36,627 --> 01:36:36,927 THAT. 2298 01:36:36,927 --> 01:36:38,495 >> THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION. 2299 01:36:38,495 --> 01:36:40,064 THANK YOU FOR ASKING. TO REALLY 2300 01:36:40,064 --> 01:36:41,498 TALK ABOUT WHAT DR. JOHNSON JUST 2301 01:36:41,498 --> 01:36:42,833 SAID, THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT 2302 01:36:42,833 --> 01:36:44,501 HAPPENED. WE STARTED WHERE 2303 01:36:44,501 --> 01:36:46,804 PEOPLE SAID THESE ARE CHALLENGE, 2304 01:36:46,804 --> 01:36:47,805 THESE RECOMMENDATION ALSO MAKE 2305 01:36:47,805 --> 01:36:50,107 IT BETTER. WHAT WE DIDN'T FIND 2306 01:36:50,107 --> 01:36:52,476 AS MUCH, WHICH IS WHY SUCCESS 2307 01:36:52,476 --> 01:36:53,711 METRIC S IS WHAT I FOCUSED ON 2308 01:36:53,711 --> 01:36:58,082 NUMBER FOUR, IS WE NEED TO TELL 2309 01:36:58,082 --> 01:37:00,084 YOU WHAT ARE SUCCESS METRICS WE 2310 01:37:00,084 --> 01:37:02,953 CAN ACTUALLY TALK ABOUT MORE. TO 2311 01:37:02,953 --> 01:37:03,988 SUZANNE'S POINT, THEY REALLY DID 2312 01:37:03,988 --> 01:37:05,489 TALK AND KAREN, THEY TALKED 2313 01:37:05,489 --> 01:37:07,725 ABOUT THE INDIVIDUAL BASIS. NOW 2314 01:37:07,725 --> 01:37:09,326 WHAT WE DID FIND OUT IS THERE 2315 01:37:09,326 --> 01:37:11,996 ARE LOTS OF GRANTS THEY HAVE 2316 01:37:11,996 --> 01:37:13,530 SUBMITTED THAT WAS, YOU KNOW, 2317 01:37:13,530 --> 01:37:15,165 SORT OF BECAUSE OF THIS, THEY 2318 01:37:15,165 --> 01:37:18,068 WERE ABLE TO LEVERAGE THIS 2319 01:37:18,068 --> 01:37:19,036 OPPORTUNITY TO WRITE MORE 2320 01:37:19,036 --> 01:37:20,971 GRANTS. THE GRANTS THEY WERE 2321 01:37:20,971 --> 01:37:22,272 WRITING WERE REALLY MUCH MORE 2322 01:37:22,272 --> 01:37:23,807 INCLUSIVE SO A LOT OF THE IMPACT 2323 01:37:23,807 --> 01:37:26,543 WILL COME. WHAT I THINK HAS BEEN 2324 01:37:26,543 --> 01:37:30,547 THE BIGGEST IMPACT, FROM MY 2325 01:37:30,547 --> 01:37:36,553 PERSPECTIVE, IS THOW DO WE 2326 01:37:36,553 --> 01:37:38,222 SUSTAIN THIS BECAUSE THE IMPACT 2327 01:37:38,222 --> 01:37:40,591 IS YET TO COME. IT WAS VERY 2328 01:37:40,591 --> 01:37:41,825 QUICK. EVERYTHING GOT TOGETHER. 2329 01:37:41,825 --> 01:37:43,327 THEY FINALLY JUST GOT THE STUDY 2330 01:37:43,327 --> 01:37:50,834 DONE. LOTS OF PAPERIN S AGO. LO 2331 01:37:50,834 --> 01:37:52,569 OF PRESENTATIONS. WE ARE JUST 2332 01:37:52,569 --> 01:37:53,737 THERE SO THIS FORWARD THINK ING 2333 01:37:53,737 --> 01:37:56,373 IS WHAT WE BROUGHT. YOU NEED TO 2334 01:37:56,373 --> 01:37:58,208 TELL US MORE BUT SUCCESS 2335 01:37:58,208 --> 01:37:59,643 MEASURES IN TERMS OF WIDER 2336 01:37:59,643 --> 01:38:01,578 ECOSYSTEM AND TELL US HOW YOU 2337 01:38:01,578 --> 01:38:02,813 ARE GOING TO SUSTAIN THIS SINCE 2338 01:38:02,813 --> 01:38:04,014 YOU HAVE DONE THE WORK. FELT 2339 01:38:04,014 --> 01:38:06,683 LIKE THEY HAD THE TOOLS. OF 2340 01:38:06,683 --> 01:38:09,286 COURSE TOOL, TECHNOLOGY AND 2341 01:38:09,286 --> 01:38:10,554 TALENT. ALL THOSE THREE CAME 2342 01:38:10,554 --> 01:38:12,589 TOGETHER. NOW TO USE THOSE TO 2343 01:38:12,589 --> 01:38:13,657 IMPLEMENT THE KIND OF IMPACT YOU 2344 01:38:13,657 --> 01:38:15,225 ARE LOOKING FOR, I THINK IT IS 2345 01:38:15,225 --> 01:38:17,728 ALREADY THERE, WE HAVE TO HAVE 2346 01:38:17,728 --> 01:38:18,929 BETTER SUCCESS MEASURES OTHER 2347 01:38:18,929 --> 01:38:20,497 THAN HOW MANY PRESENTATIONS, HOW 2348 01:38:20,497 --> 01:38:27,704 GOOD WAS THE MENTOR AND MENTEE 2349 01:38:27,704 --> 01:38:28,806 RELATIONSHIP. 2350 01:38:28,806 --> 01:38:32,176 >> RIGHT, THANK YOU. DR. KING, 2351 01:38:32,176 --> 01:38:33,777 WE MISSED THE LAST PART OF WHAT 2352 01:38:33,777 --> 01:38:35,646 YOU WERE SAYING BECAUSE -- 2353 01:38:35,646 --> 01:38:37,514 >> SORRY ABOUT THAT. SOMEHOW MY 2354 01:38:37,514 --> 01:38:39,716 HAND HIT THAT. WHAT I THINK WE 2355 01:38:39,716 --> 01:38:43,387 ARE RIGHT NOW, QUICKLY REPEAT 2356 01:38:43,387 --> 01:38:45,556 IT, WE HAVE TALENT, TECHNOLOGY 2357 01:38:45,556 --> 01:38:47,491 AND TOOLS. ALL THOSE THINGS CAME 2358 01:38:47,491 --> 01:38:49,393 TOGETHER. SO IT IS NOW TO USE 2359 01:38:49,393 --> 01:38:51,895 ALL THOSE TO THE IMPACT THAT WE 2360 01:38:51,895 --> 01:38:53,664 WOULD LOVE TO SEE IS HAPPENING 2361 01:38:53,664 --> 01:38:55,466 BUT JUST NOW. WE ARE THERE RIGHT 2362 01:38:55,466 --> 01:38:57,534 NOW AND WHAT WE TALK ABOUT A LOT 2363 01:38:57,534 --> 01:38:59,002 IS HAVING SUCCESS MEASURES WE 2364 01:38:59,002 --> 01:39:01,138 COULD TALK ABOUT ALL THE THINGS 2365 01:39:01,138 --> 01:39:04,274 WE JUST TALKED ABOUT. WHAT 2366 01:39:04,274 --> 01:39:05,742 CHANGE ED?ENTER WE SAW A LOT 2367 01:39:05,742 --> 01:39:06,743 CHANGE BECAUSE LOTS OF PAPERS 2368 01:39:06,743 --> 01:39:08,479 AND GRANTS WENT IN. ALL THAT 2369 01:39:08,479 --> 01:39:10,981 HAPPENED BUT WASN'T AS COHESIVE 2370 01:39:10,981 --> 01:39:13,217 SUCCESS MEASURES AS WE'D LIKE TO 2371 01:39:13,217 --> 01:39:15,018 PRESENT. THE INDIAN SITE FOR 2372 01:39:15,018 --> 01:39:16,386 EXAMPLE, THEY TALKED ABOUT HOW 2373 01:39:16,386 --> 01:39:19,256 THAT CHANGED ALL THE 2374 01:39:19,256 --> 01:39:20,190 INTERACTIONS. THE COMMITMENT TO 2375 01:39:20,190 --> 01:39:22,793 NEW COMMUNITY MEMBERS COMING IN 2376 01:39:22,793 --> 01:39:24,761 TO AI. SO IT FELT LIKE AI FOR 2377 01:39:24,761 --> 01:39:27,030 ALL. NOW WE HAVE TO USE IT TO DO 2378 01:39:27,030 --> 01:39:29,099 THE IMPACT PIECE. WHICH HAPPENED 2379 01:39:29,099 --> 01:39:30,667 BUT IT WASN'T AS CLEAR AS WE 2380 01:39:30,667 --> 01:39:34,471 WOULD HAVE LIKED IT TO BE, 2381 01:39:34,471 --> 01:39:36,039 HENCE WHY MUCH OF OUR 2382 01:39:36,039 --> 01:39:37,307 RECOMMENDATIONS HOW TO MAKE IT 2383 01:39:37,307 --> 01:39:41,145 STRONGER AND HOW TO HAVE BETTER 2384 01:39:41,145 --> 01:39:46,483 SUCCESS MEASURES GOING FORWARD. 2385 01:39:46,483 --> 01:39:48,051 SUSAN, ANYTHING ELSE YOU WANT TO 2386 01:39:48,051 --> 01:39:48,252 ADD? 2387 01:39:48,252 --> 01:39:50,320 >> I COMPLETELY CONCUR. WHAT YOU 2388 01:39:50,320 --> 01:39:52,356 SAID RESONATES WITH ME QUITE A 2389 01:39:52,356 --> 01:39:54,625 BIT. NOW LOOKING FOR THE LARGER 2390 01:39:54,625 --> 01:39:57,794 IMPACT, IF WE GO FORWARD, WOULD 2391 01:39:57,794 --> 01:40:01,532 BE REALLY KEEN OUTCOME FOR THE 2392 01:40:01,532 --> 01:40:05,369 NEXT PHASE. 2393 01:40:05,369 --> 01:40:09,973 >> GREAT. SO THANK YOU ALL FOR 2394 01:40:09,973 --> 01:40:11,808 ANSWERING THE QUESTIONS. I SEE 2395 01:40:11,808 --> 01:40:16,480 NO OTHER QUESTIONS. I SAW 2396 01:40:16,480 --> 01:40:19,816 MONICA'S CAMERA CAME ON BUT I 2397 01:40:19,816 --> 01:40:22,986 ASSUME THAT CAMERA CAME ON NOT 2398 01:40:22,986 --> 01:40:25,589 WANTING TO ASK A QUESTION. IF 2399 01:40:25,589 --> 01:40:27,791 THAT IS CORRECT, THEN CAN MOVE 2400 01:40:27,791 --> 01:40:30,427 ON TO THE VOTE. BECAUSE YOU JUST 2401 01:40:30,427 --> 01:40:33,096 VOTED, YOU ARE ALL EXPERTS IN 2402 01:40:33,096 --> 01:40:35,799 VOTING. DO NOT NEED TO REPEAT 2403 01:40:35,799 --> 01:40:41,405 THE INSTRUCTIONS. I WILL ASK FOR 2404 01:40:41,405 --> 01:40:43,807 A MOTION AND WAIT FOR THE SO 2405 01:40:43,807 --> 01:40:47,144 MOVED AND SECOND. MAY I HAVE A 2406 01:40:47,144 --> 01:40:49,713 MOTION TO ACCEPT AS WRITTEN THE 2407 01:40:49,713 --> 01:40:53,250 REPORT OF THE AIM-AHEAD WORKING 2408 01:40:53,250 --> 01:40:56,653 GROUP OF THE COUNCIL OF 2409 01:40:56,653 --> 01:41:01,458 COUNCILS. I SEE. SO MOVED. DO I 2410 01:41:01,458 --> 01:41:05,629 GET A SECOND? I SEE THE SECOND. 2411 01:41:05,629 --> 01:41:07,798 THAT WILL ALLOW ME TO ASK IS 2412 01:41:07,798 --> 01:41:10,000 THERE ANY ADDITIONAL DISCUSSION 2413 01:41:10,000 --> 01:41:10,734 AT THIS POINT? 2414 01:41:10,734 --> 01:41:14,905 >> FRANZISKA -- GOOD, NEVERMIND. 2415 01:41:14,905 --> 01:41:16,907 >> I KIND OF SAW THE SECOND OF 2416 01:41:16,907 --> 01:41:19,076 THE SO MOVED, I GET IT. ANY 2417 01:41:19,076 --> 01:41:21,111 DISCUSSION AT THIS POINT, IN 2418 01:41:21,111 --> 01:41:27,784 ADDITION TO WHAT WE ALREADY 2419 01:41:27,784 --> 01:41:37,094 HEARD? I DON'T SEE RAISED HANDS. 2420 01:41:37,094 --> 01:41:45,802 >> THANK YOU, DOCTOR. THIS IS A 2421 01:41:45,802 --> 01:41:47,404 VOTE ON MOTION TO ACCEPT AS 2422 01:41:47,404 --> 01:41:49,139 WRITTEN THE WORKING GROUP OF 2423 01:41:49,139 --> 01:41:51,842 COUNCIL OF COUNCILS. AS REMINDER 2424 01:41:51,842 --> 01:41:53,977 ONLINE COUNCILMEMBERS SHOULD 2425 01:41:53,977 --> 01:41:57,614 PARTICIPATE. PLEASE RAISE YOUR 2426 01:41:57,614 --> 01:42:05,022 HANDS TO VOTE AYE. THANK YOU, I 2427 01:42:05,022 --> 01:42:10,227 SEE THE HANDS RAISING. I SEE 2428 01:42:10,227 --> 01:42:12,696 EIGHT HANDS. ALL RIGHT. PLEASE 2429 01:42:12,696 --> 01:42:16,933 LOWER YOUR HANDS -- WAIT, I SEE 2430 01:42:16,933 --> 01:42:23,640 ANOTHER HAND. 2431 01:42:23,640 --> 01:42:29,713 I'M SEEING HANDS COMING UP. 2432 01:42:29,713 --> 01:42:33,650 THIS IS A VOTE FOR AYE. IF YOUR 2433 01:42:33,650 --> 01:42:38,822 HANDS ARE RAISED. OKAY. I'M 2434 01:42:38,822 --> 01:42:42,726 SEEING HANDS COME BACK UP. WANT 2435 01:42:42,726 --> 01:42:45,262 TO LEAVE IT UP A LITTLE LONGER 2436 01:42:45,262 --> 01:42:53,403 FOR FOLKS TO VOTE AYE. OKAY. WE 2437 01:42:53,403 --> 01:42:55,806 ARE GOING TO MOVE ALONG SO 2438 01:42:55,806 --> 01:42:58,942 PLEASE LOWER YOUR HANDS. THANK 2439 01:42:58,942 --> 01:43:01,778 YOU. PLEASE RAISE YOUR HAND IF 2440 01:43:01,778 --> 01:43:10,954 YOU ARE VOTING NAY. IF YOU WOULD 2441 01:43:10,954 --> 01:43:13,323 LIKE TO VOTE NAY, PLEASE RAISE 2442 01:43:13,323 --> 01:43:16,026 YOUR HAND AT THIS TIME. NOT 2443 01:43:16,026 --> 01:43:17,461 SEEING ANY HANDS. PLEASE RAISE 2444 01:43:17,461 --> 01:43:27,971 YOUR HAND TO VOTE ABSTENTION. 2445 01:43:30,073 --> 01:43:32,809 NOT SEEING ANY HANDS. THIS 2446 01:43:32,809 --> 01:43:35,178 CONCLUDES THE VOTE. THE MOTION, 2447 01:43:35,178 --> 01:43:36,380 AS STATED, AS PASSED. 2448 01:43:36,380 --> 01:43:38,815 >> THANK YOU, CHRISTINA. I 2449 01:43:38,815 --> 01:43:40,150 CLEARLY SEE THAT THE MEMBERS WHO 2450 01:43:40,150 --> 01:43:42,185 ARE ON THE WORKING GROUPS ARE 2451 01:43:42,185 --> 01:43:44,388 NOT VOTING, SO THAT IS WHY WE 2452 01:43:44,388 --> 01:43:46,523 HAD EIGHT VOTES ON THE SECOND 2453 01:43:46,523 --> 01:43:48,725 AND NINE AT THE FIRST ONE. 2454 01:43:48,725 --> 01:43:50,627 MEMBERS WHO CONTRIBUTED TO 2455 01:43:50,627 --> 01:43:52,429 WORKING GROUP DID NOT 2456 01:43:52,429 --> 01:43:54,398 PARTICIPATE. SO THANK YOU ALL. 2457 01:43:54,398 --> 01:43:56,032 ONE QUICK COMMENT. WE WERE 2458 01:43:56,032 --> 01:43:58,468 LOOKING INTO LIKE NOT DOING THE 2459 01:43:58,468 --> 01:43:59,803 HAND-RAISING AND HAVING 2460 01:43:59,803 --> 01:44:01,505 DIFFERENT METHODS. MAYBE UNTIL 2461 01:44:01,505 --> 01:44:03,306 THE NEXT TIME WE HAVE SOMETHING 2462 01:44:03,306 --> 01:44:05,075 MORE SUCCESSFUL IF WE ARE 2463 01:44:05,075 --> 01:44:06,343 IN-PERSON. THEN ANYHOW IT WILL 2464 01:44:06,343 --> 01:44:10,814 BE EASIER. BACK TO YOU, NICOLE. 2465 01:44:10,814 --> 01:44:12,682 >> THANK YOU. SO ONCE AGAIN, AS 2466 01:44:12,682 --> 01:44:14,384 SIMILAR TO HOW WE HANDLE THIS 2467 01:44:14,384 --> 01:44:16,853 FOR THE GRI REPORT, IF THERE ARE 2468 01:44:16,853 --> 01:44:18,588 ADDITIONAL VIEWS THAT THE 2469 01:44:18,588 --> 01:44:22,259 COUNCIL WOULD LIKE TO CONVEY 2470 01:44:22,259 --> 01:44:25,562 WITH THE REPORT, PLEASE TYPE 2471 01:44:25,562 --> 01:44:28,331 THOSE IN THE CHAT. SO BEFORE WE 2472 01:44:28,331 --> 01:44:30,634 BREAK FOR LUNCH, I WOULD JUST 2473 01:44:30,634 --> 01:44:31,368 LIKE TO CONGRATULATE EVERYONE 2474 01:44:31,368 --> 01:44:34,004 FOR BEING SO PERFECTLY ON TIME, 2475 01:44:34,004 --> 01:44:35,806 BUT BEFORE WE BREAK FOR LUNCH I 2476 01:44:35,806 --> 01:44:38,175 DID WANT TO FOLLOW UP ON SEVERAL 2477 01:44:38,175 --> 01:44:42,279 OF THE QUESTIONS THAT WERE 2478 01:44:42,279 --> 01:44:45,248 RAISED IN ONE OF THE EARLIER 2479 01:44:45,248 --> 01:44:49,119 SESSIONS. I HAVE PUT IN THE CHAT 2480 01:44:49,119 --> 01:44:53,056 RESPONSES FROM OUR OSC 2481 01:44:53,056 --> 01:44:55,325 COLLEAGUES IN RESPONSE TO DR. 2482 01:44:55,325 --> 01:44:57,894 MANLEY'S QUESTIONS, RECOGNIZING 2483 01:44:57,894 --> 01:44:59,262 THOSE VIEWING THE WEBCAST DO NOT 2484 01:44:59,262 --> 01:45:01,398 HAVE ACCESS TO THE CHAT, I WILL 2485 01:45:01,398 --> 01:45:03,200 READ THE RESPONSES FOR THE 2486 01:45:03,200 --> 01:45:05,168 BENEFIT OF THOSE VIEWERS THEN WE 2487 01:45:05,168 --> 01:45:07,170 WILL BREAK FOR LUNCH. SO THE 2488 01:45:07,170 --> 01:45:09,239 FIRST QUESTION, WHEN DO YOU 2489 01:45:09,239 --> 01:45:10,707 EXPECT DP5 MECHANISM TO BE 2490 01:45:10,707 --> 01:45:12,275 POSTED. IF IT WILL NOT BE, WHY. 2491 01:45:12,275 --> 01:45:14,044 THE RESPONSE, THE INITIAL DRAFT 2492 01:45:14,044 --> 01:45:19,983 OF FY2026DP5NOFO WAS PAUSED BY 2493 01:45:19,983 --> 01:45:21,751 NIH LEADERSHIP BUT MOVE FORWARD 2494 01:45:21,751 --> 01:45:24,254 AFTER COMPARISON BETWEEN DP5s 2495 01:45:24,254 --> 01:45:25,989 AND EARLY EARLY STAGE 2496 01:45:25,989 --> 01:45:27,657 INITIATIVES ACROSS NIH. THERE 2497 01:45:27,657 --> 01:45:31,795 WAS A FULL EVALUATION REPORT ED 2498 01:45:31,795 --> 01:45:38,368 IN REPORT FOR DP2s, NEW 2499 01:45:38,368 --> 01:45:39,803 INNOVATOR AWARDS GIVEN WILD 2500 01:45:39,803 --> 01:45:40,871 SUCCESS IN THE PAST. NEW 2501 01:45:40,871 --> 01:45:42,839 RESPONSE, THIS REDUCTION WAS 2502 01:45:42,839 --> 01:45:45,542 DRIVEN BY BUDGET RESTRICTIONS 2503 01:45:45,542 --> 01:45:48,378 AND CHANGE IN MYF POLICIES 2504 01:45:48,378 --> 01:45:50,614 ACROSS HHS. AS ANY FISCAL YEAR 2505 01:45:50,614 --> 01:45:52,482 UNFOLDS AND BUDGET AND SPENDING 2506 01:45:52,482 --> 01:45:53,583 BECOMES CLEARER THE NUMBER OF 2507 01:45:53,583 --> 01:45:55,452 AWARDS WE ARE ABLE TO FUND MAY 2508 01:45:55,452 --> 01:45:58,321 BE SLIGHTLY HIGHER OR LOWER THAN 2509 01:45:58,321 --> 01:46:00,190 ANTICIPATED. THIS FLUCTUATION 2510 01:46:00,190 --> 01:46:02,259 DOES NOT REFLECT PROGRAMMATIC 2511 01:46:02,259 --> 01:46:04,060 INTENTION. WE ARE TRYING TO FUND 2512 01:46:04,060 --> 01:46:06,263 AT LEAST 30 NEW INNOVATORS EACH 2513 01:46:06,263 --> 01:46:08,198 YEAR. THIRD QUESTION, HOW WILL 2514 01:46:08,198 --> 01:46:10,133 DPCPSI STAFF REDUCE NEGATIVE 2515 01:46:10,133 --> 01:46:13,503 IMPACT OF CONSTRICTED WINDOW 2516 01:46:13,503 --> 01:46:15,005 BETWEEN POSTING AND DUE DATE 2517 01:46:15,005 --> 01:46:17,607 ESPECIALLY FOR THE 2. STAFF WILL 2518 01:46:17,607 --> 01:46:20,944 PRO OR ADVERTISE POTENTIAL 2519 01:46:20,944 --> 01:46:21,978 APPLICANTS IN RESPONDING DURING 2520 01:46:21,978 --> 01:46:23,780 POSTING DATES. DETAILED 2521 01:46:23,780 --> 01:46:24,614 APPLICATION GUIDES ARE AVAILABLE 2522 01:46:24,614 --> 01:46:26,416 ON THE WEBSITE. TECHNICAL 2523 01:46:26,416 --> 01:46:27,784 ASSISTANCE WEBINAR ALSO BE 2524 01:46:27,784 --> 01:46:30,453 POSTED AS SOON AS NOFOs ARE 2525 01:46:30,453 --> 01:46:33,290 PUBLISHED. MAJOR CHANGES ARE NOT 2526 01:46:33,290 --> 01:46:37,260 ANTICIPATED FOR DPs 1, 2 AND 5. 2527 01:46:37,260 --> 01:46:38,628 FOURTH QUESTION, YOU CLARIFY 2528 01:46:38,628 --> 01:46:40,096 COUNCIL'S ROLE IN ASSESSING 2529 01:46:40,096 --> 01:46:41,431 UNIFORMITY AND REVIEW OF THE 2530 01:46:41,431 --> 01:46:42,399 PROGRAM NOW THAT STOP WORK 2531 01:46:42,399 --> 01:46:45,302 ORDER S HAVE BEEN ISSUED TO SIX 2532 01:46:45,302 --> 01:46:47,604 HRHR GRANTS PREVIOUSLY APPROVED 2533 01:46:47,604 --> 01:46:50,006 BY COC. RESPONSE, COUNCIL'S ROLE 2534 01:46:50,006 --> 01:46:52,542 IS ASSESS FAIRNESS REVIEW BUT 2535 01:46:52,542 --> 01:46:53,843 FUNDING DECISIONS ARE LEFT TO 2536 01:46:53,843 --> 01:46:56,146 THE ICO. PROGRAM STAFF ARE 2537 01:46:56,146 --> 01:46:58,615 FOLLOWING POLICIES APPROVED BY 2538 01:46:58,615 --> 01:47:02,152 HHS, AND NIH AND CONSULTING WITH 2539 01:47:02,152 --> 01:47:04,554 ADMINISTERING ACs IN 2540 01:47:04,554 --> 01:47:06,623 CATEGORIZING AWARDS, SO THANKS 2541 01:47:06,623 --> 01:47:08,792 TO COLLEAGUES FOR PROVIDING 2542 01:47:08,792 --> 01:47:10,594 THOROUGH RESPONSES TO THESE 2543 01:47:10,594 --> 01:47:13,496 QUESTIONS. NOW WE WILL GO AHEAD 2544 01:47:13,496 --> 01:47:16,399 AND HAVE A SHORT BREAK. EXCUSE 2545 01:47:16,399 --> 01:47:18,134 ME. BEFORE WE TRANSITION TO THE 2546 01:47:18,134 --> 01:47:19,436 CLOSED SESSION OF TODAY'S 2547 01:47:19,436 --> 01:47:21,538 MEETING SO I WOULD ASK ALL OUR 2548 01:47:21,538 --> 01:47:23,006 MEMBERS PLEASE REMAIN LOGGED IN 2549 01:47:23,006 --> 01:47:26,042 AND MUTED. WE WILL SEE EVERYONE 2550 01:47:26,042 --> 01:47:29,779 BACK IN THIRTY MINUTES, BY 2551 01:47:29,779 --> 01:47:30,447 12:15. THIS IS ONLINE 2552 01:47:30,447 --> 01:47:31,381 COUNCILMEMBERS AND STAFF WITH 2553 01:47:31,381 --> 01:47:32,816 NEED TO KNOW WILL BE 2554 01:47:32,816 --> 01:47:34,317 PARTICIPATING IN THE CLOSED 2555 01:47:34,317 --> 01:47:34,584 SESSION . 2556 01:47:34,584 --> 01:47:37,253 THE OPEN WILL RESUME AT 2557 01:47:37,253 --> 01:47:39,237 1:15 P.M. THANK YOU ALL. 2558 01:47:39,237 --> 01:47:41,907 ALL RIGHT, SO NEXT ON OUR AGENDA 2559 01:47:41,907 --> 01:47:44,376 IS A PRESENTATION OF THE OFFICE 2560 01:47:44,376 --> 01:47:45,844 OF NUTRITION RESEARCH STRATEGIC 2561 01:47:45,844 --> 01:47:50,482 PLAN AND UPDATE ON THE UPDATE OF 2562 01:47:50,482 --> 01:47:52,517 DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS STRATEGIC 2563 01:47:52,517 --> 01:47:57,489 PLAN. 2564 01:47:57,489 --> 01:47:59,057 DR. BREMER DIRECTOR WILL 2565 01:47:59,057 --> 01:47:59,993 PRESENT. 2566 01:47:59,993 --> 01:48:02,529 >> THANK YOU, NICOLE AND THANK 2567 01:48:02,529 --> 01:48:06,600 YOU EVERYONE FOR TODAY AND THE 2568 01:48:06,600 --> 01:48:08,368 COUNCIL MEMBERS AND JUST WHAT 2569 01:48:08,368 --> 01:48:10,170 EVERYONE WANTS TO TALK ABOUT 2570 01:48:10,170 --> 01:48:13,407 AVENUE TRIGS -- AFTER LUNCH IS 2571 01:48:13,407 --> 01:48:14,675 NUTRITION AND DIET. 2572 01:48:14,675 --> 01:48:15,843 I CAN'T WAIT. 2573 01:48:15,843 --> 01:48:17,878 AM I COMING IN TOO LOUD OR IS 2574 01:48:17,878 --> 01:48:20,514 ALL GOOD ON THAT END. 2575 01:48:20,514 --> 01:48:21,762 >> YOU SOUND, GREAT, DREW. 2576 01:48:21,762 --> 01:48:22,676 >> FANTASTIC. 2577 01:48:22,676 --> 01:48:24,311 I'LL START BY SAYING I HAVE THE 2578 01:48:24,311 --> 01:48:25,379 PRIVILEGE AND HONOR TO BE 2579 01:48:25,379 --> 01:48:26,913 WORKING IN TWO OFFICES. 2580 01:48:26,913 --> 01:48:30,283 THE OFFICE OF NUTRITION RESEARCH 2581 01:48:30,283 --> 01:48:33,420 AND DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS. 2582 01:48:33,420 --> 01:48:35,322 I HAVE BOTH TEAMS IN THE OFFICE 2583 01:48:35,322 --> 01:48:38,158 WITH ME AND IT'S TRULY A 2584 01:48:38,158 --> 01:48:38,425 PRIVILEGE. 2585 01:48:38,425 --> 01:48:40,260 AND THANK YOU TO THE COUNCIL 2586 01:48:40,260 --> 01:48:41,895 MEMBERS FOR TAKING TIME TO 2587 01:48:41,895 --> 01:48:44,564 LISTEN TO ME AND GIVING ME A 2588 01:48:44,564 --> 01:48:46,233 CHANCE TO GIVE A HIGH-LEVEL 2589 01:48:46,233 --> 01:48:48,301 OVERVIEW OF THE PLANS FOR BOTH 2590 01:48:48,301 --> 01:48:48,769 OFFICES. 2591 01:48:48,769 --> 01:48:51,672 AND I'LL START BY SAYING THAT 2592 01:48:51,672 --> 01:48:56,910 THE O & R PLAN OF TUESDAY IS 2593 01:48:56,910 --> 01:48:57,577 OFFICIALLY APPROVED AND GETTING 2594 01:48:57,577 --> 01:49:00,947 READY TO BE LAUNCHED TO PUBLIC. 2595 01:49:00,947 --> 01:49:03,050 I'D LIKE TO THANK THE CONSULTING 2596 01:49:03,050 --> 01:49:04,751 GROUP FOR MAKING IT LOOK SO 2597 01:49:04,751 --> 01:49:08,221 PRETTY AND I THINK YOU HAVE 2598 01:49:08,221 --> 01:49:10,190 COPIES IN THE ROOM AND WE'VE HAD 2599 01:49:10,190 --> 01:49:12,192 A CHANCE TO PRESENT ON THE 2600 01:49:12,192 --> 01:49:13,593 OFFICE OF DIETARY SUPPLEMENT 2601 01:49:13,593 --> 01:49:15,662 PLAN LAST YEAR AND GIVE YOU AN 2602 01:49:15,662 --> 01:49:18,298 UPDATE HOW THINGS HAVE GONE IN 2603 01:49:18,298 --> 01:49:21,268 THE PAST 12 MONTHS. 2604 01:49:21,268 --> 01:49:24,304 I'D LIKE TO START MY TALKS WITH 2605 01:49:24,304 --> 01:49:25,439 THE GRATITUDE AND ACKNOWLEDGING 2606 01:49:25,439 --> 01:49:26,907 THOSE WHO DO THE WORK. 2607 01:49:26,907 --> 01:49:27,808 I HAVE THE EXTRAORDINARY 2608 01:49:27,808 --> 01:49:29,710 PRIVILEGE OF WORKING WITH 2609 01:49:29,710 --> 01:49:32,212 AMAZING INDIVIDUALS. 2610 01:49:32,212 --> 01:49:33,880 AND I'LL TRY TO GET BACK TIME AT 2611 01:49:33,880 --> 01:49:35,082 THE END BECAUSE I KNOW THERE'S 2612 01:49:35,082 --> 01:49:37,451 SOME QUESTIONS WE WANT TO HAVE A 2613 01:49:37,451 --> 01:49:38,351 CHANCE TO ADDRESS BEFORE COUNCIL 2614 01:49:38,351 --> 01:49:40,053 CLOSES SO I'LL BE STREAMLINED 2615 01:49:40,053 --> 01:49:41,388 BUT I DON'T WANT TO MISS 2616 01:49:41,388 --> 01:49:42,723 ANYTHING IMPORTANT AND 2617 01:49:42,723 --> 01:49:43,356 ACKNOWLEDGING THE INDIVIDUALS 2618 01:49:43,356 --> 01:49:48,295 WHO DO THE WORK IS SUPER 2619 01:49:48,295 --> 01:49:48,929 IMPORTANT. 2620 01:49:48,929 --> 01:49:56,136 FOR THE O&R AND ODR TEAM MEMBERS 2621 01:49:56,136 --> 01:49:57,938 AND PAST I WANT TO SAY THANKS 2622 01:49:57,938 --> 01:50:00,140 AND TO THOSE ON THE ZOOM AND 2623 01:50:00,140 --> 01:50:05,178 TEAMS WE WORKED WITH AND FEDERAL 2624 01:50:05,178 --> 01:50:10,117 COLLEAGUES AND CERTAINLY OUR 2625 01:50:10,117 --> 01:50:11,718 EXTRA MURAL COLLEAGUES AND TEAM 2626 01:50:11,718 --> 01:50:12,352 WORK MAKES THE DREAM WORK AS I 2627 01:50:12,352 --> 01:50:18,291 SAY. 2628 01:50:18,291 --> 01:50:21,128 AS YOU'VE HEARD ABOUT TODAY IS 2629 01:50:21,128 --> 01:50:23,597 THE OFFICES IN DPCPSI SERVE A 2630 01:50:23,597 --> 01:50:25,098 ROLE TO COORDINATE, PROVIDE 2631 01:50:25,098 --> 01:50:27,300 SUPPORT AND SERVICE TO THE NIH 2632 01:50:27,300 --> 01:50:28,835 AS A WHOLE. 2633 01:50:28,835 --> 01:50:29,903 THAT'S ONE OF THE STRATEGIC 2634 01:50:29,903 --> 01:50:30,570 LOCATIONS OF BEING IN THE OFFICE 2635 01:50:30,570 --> 01:50:34,374 OF THE DIRECTOR IS THAT WE HAVE 2636 01:50:34,374 --> 01:50:36,276 THAT ACCESSIBILITY TO OTHER 2637 01:50:36,276 --> 01:50:38,378 INSTITUTES AND CENTERS. 2638 01:50:38,378 --> 01:50:40,180 BUT OUR REACH GOES WELL BEYOND 2639 01:50:40,180 --> 01:50:43,717 THAT, WE ALSO WORK CLOSELY WITH 2640 01:50:43,717 --> 01:50:44,651 A LOT OF OUR FEDERAL PARTNERS 2641 01:50:44,651 --> 01:50:47,087 AND THAT MAKES THE OFFICES NOT 2642 01:50:47,087 --> 01:50:49,222 JUST AN NIH OFFICE BUT REALLY A 2643 01:50:49,222 --> 01:50:52,125 U.S. GOVERNMENT OFFICE AND 2644 01:50:52,125 --> 01:51:00,300 RANGES FROM THE USDA, NHANES, 2645 01:51:00,300 --> 01:51:02,569 NIST WE HAVE FINGERS IN LOTS OF 2646 01:51:02,569 --> 01:51:04,037 POTS AND BRING OUR EXPERTISE AND 2647 01:51:04,037 --> 01:51:04,871 SKILL SET TO ADVANCE THE 2648 01:51:04,871 --> 01:51:09,309 MISSIONS OF THE OTHER AGENCIES. 2649 01:51:09,309 --> 01:51:11,545 BEYOND THAT WE ALSO REACH BEYOND 2650 01:51:11,545 --> 01:51:12,412 THE U.S. GOVERNMENT. 2651 01:51:12,412 --> 01:51:15,882 I LISTED TWO HERE AS 2652 01:51:15,882 --> 01:51:17,651 ILLUSTRATIVE EXAMPLES OF THE 2653 01:51:17,651 --> 01:51:20,187 GATES FOUNDATION AND NATIONAL 2654 01:51:20,187 --> 01:51:24,891 COLLABORATIVE OF CHILDHOOD 2655 01:51:24,891 --> 01:51:27,260 RESEARCHES AND BOTH OFFICES ARE 2656 01:51:27,260 --> 01:51:30,530 IN COLLABORATION AND IT'S MEANT 2657 01:51:30,530 --> 01:51:33,667 TO BE AN EXPANSIVE LIFT TO MOVE 2658 01:51:33,667 --> 01:51:37,437 THE FIELD FORWARD. 2659 01:51:37,437 --> 01:51:40,640 SO WHAT'S OUR VALUE ADD? 2660 01:51:40,640 --> 01:51:43,810 WHEN I JOINED DPCPSI SEPTEMBER 2661 01:51:43,810 --> 01:51:45,445 2023 I CHALLENGED OUR TEAMS TO 2662 01:51:45,445 --> 01:51:46,880 THINK ABOUT WHY WE'RE HERE AND 2663 01:51:46,880 --> 01:51:49,583 WHAT WOULD GO AWAY IF WE WEREN'T 2664 01:51:49,583 --> 01:51:53,286 HERE AND WE REALLY NARROWED IT 2665 01:51:53,286 --> 01:51:56,823 DOWN TO THREE PARTS OF A TRY 2666 01:51:56,823 --> 01:51:59,759 ANGLE AND WE BRING OUR SUBJECT 2667 01:51:59,759 --> 01:52:01,995 MATTER EXPERTISE AND WE'RE 2668 01:52:01,995 --> 01:52:03,830 SCIENTIFIC LEADERS AND WE COME 2669 01:52:03,830 --> 01:52:08,501 FROM VARIOUS BACKGROUNDS AND ALL 2670 01:52:08,501 --> 01:52:10,237 THAT REALLY EMBODIES THE WHOLE 2671 01:52:10,237 --> 01:52:12,706 IS MORE THAN THE SUM OF ITS 2672 01:52:12,706 --> 01:52:12,906 PARTS. 2673 01:52:12,906 --> 01:52:13,773 WE PROVIDE SERVICE, TECHNICAL 2674 01:52:13,773 --> 01:52:16,109 SUPPORT AND COORDINATE. 2675 01:52:16,109 --> 01:52:21,348 THAT'S WHAT DIFFERENTIATES OUR 2676 01:52:21,348 --> 01:52:22,949 OFFICES FROM MAYBE TOPIC SIMILAR 2677 01:52:22,949 --> 01:52:24,317 OFFICES IN THE INSTITUTES AND 2678 01:52:24,317 --> 01:52:28,989 CENTERS. 2679 01:52:28,989 --> 01:52:30,123 AGAIN, I HAD THE PRIVILEGE OF 2680 01:52:30,123 --> 01:52:32,225 JOINING THE OFFICE OF RESEARCH 2681 01:52:32,225 --> 01:52:34,361 IN SEPTEMBER '23. 2682 01:52:34,361 --> 01:52:35,762 IT'S BEEN A WONDERFUL 2683 01:52:35,762 --> 01:52:36,796 OPPORTUNITY AND TREMENDOUS JOY. 2684 01:52:36,796 --> 01:52:38,131 I LOVE COMING TO WORK EVERY DAY. 2685 01:52:38,131 --> 01:52:42,369 IF YOU THINK I'M EXCITED NOW 2686 01:52:42,369 --> 01:52:46,773 WAIT UNTIL I GET TO THE OTHER 2687 01:52:46,773 --> 01:52:47,040 SUBJECTS. 2688 01:52:47,040 --> 01:52:49,743 I WANT TO HONE IN ON OUR GUIDING 2689 01:52:49,743 --> 01:52:50,343 PRINCIPLES. 2690 01:52:50,343 --> 01:52:52,679 WHEN YOU TALK OR HEAR ABOUT 2691 01:52:52,679 --> 01:52:53,647 NUTRITION IT MEANS DIFFERENT 2692 01:52:53,647 --> 01:52:56,883 THINGS TO DIFFERENT PEOPLE. 2693 01:52:56,883 --> 01:53:07,427 IF YOU ASK 20 NUTRITIONISTS WHAT 2694 01:53:12,432 --> 01:53:15,735 IS NUTRITION YOU'LL GET TO 2695 01:53:15,735 --> 01:53:16,636 ANSWERS AND NUTRITION IS CULTURE 2696 01:53:16,636 --> 01:53:19,239 AND FAMILY AND MEMORY BUT 2697 01:53:19,239 --> 01:53:21,741 NUTRITION IS MORE THAN FOOD. 2698 01:53:21,741 --> 01:53:24,711 FOOD IS THE DELIVERING MECHANISM 2699 01:53:24,711 --> 01:53:27,180 BUT THE NUTRITION IS ALL THE 2700 01:53:27,180 --> 01:53:29,382 COOL BIOLOGY THAT HAPPENS WHEN 2701 01:53:29,382 --> 01:53:31,685 YOU INGEST SOMETHING. 2702 01:53:31,685 --> 01:53:34,354 IT GOES TO THE SECOND POINT. 2703 01:53:34,354 --> 01:53:36,256 IT'S AN EXPANSIVE BIOLOGY THAT 2704 01:53:36,256 --> 01:53:38,892 GOES FROM THE FOOD INGESTED TO 2705 01:53:38,892 --> 01:53:42,362 METABOLISM TO IMPACT ON CELLULAR 2706 01:53:42,362 --> 01:53:44,130 FUNCTION. 2707 01:53:44,130 --> 01:53:46,099 FOOD IS THE LINK AND NUTRITION 2708 01:53:46,099 --> 01:53:48,702 SCIENCE IS THE LINK BETWEEN THE 2709 01:53:48,702 --> 01:53:50,470 FOOD WE EAT AND OUR OVER ALL 2710 01:53:50,470 --> 01:53:52,772 HEALTH PHYSICAL AND MENTAL. 2711 01:53:52,772 --> 01:53:54,207 THOSE WHO HEARD ME BEFORE, HEARD 2712 01:53:54,207 --> 01:53:56,176 ME SAY THE BIOLOGY OF NUTRITION 2713 01:53:56,176 --> 01:53:58,378 TOUCHES EVERY TELL OF EVERY 2714 01:53:58,378 --> 01:54:00,647 SYSTEM IN OUR BODIES IN EVERY 2715 01:54:00,647 --> 01:54:03,516 STAGE AND AGE ACROSS THE LIFE 2716 01:54:03,516 --> 01:54:05,652 SPAN AND LINKED TO HEALTH AND 2717 01:54:05,652 --> 01:54:05,919 DISEASE. 2718 01:54:05,919 --> 01:54:09,923 I HAD THE PRIVILEGE OF BEING AN 2719 01:54:09,923 --> 01:54:12,225 INTERNAL MEDICINE PEDIATRICS 2720 01:54:12,225 --> 01:54:13,226 PHYSICIAN AND IN TEACHING 2721 01:54:13,226 --> 01:54:15,862 MEDICAL STUDENTS AND RESIDENTS I 2722 01:54:15,862 --> 01:54:18,498 CHALLENGED THEM TO THINK ABOUT 2723 01:54:18,498 --> 01:54:20,467 SOMETHING THAT ISN'T IMPACTED BY 2724 01:54:20,467 --> 01:54:24,371 NUTRITION OR IMPACTED BY 2725 01:54:24,371 --> 01:54:25,105 NUTRITION. 2726 01:54:25,105 --> 01:54:28,375 NUTRITIONAL STATUS IS A 2727 01:54:28,375 --> 01:54:30,076 FUNDAMENTAL BIOLOGICAL VARIABLE 2728 01:54:30,076 --> 01:54:33,113 LIKE AGE AND SEX. 2729 01:54:33,113 --> 01:54:39,519 IT'S GOT AN INEXTRICABLE ROLE IN 2730 01:54:39,519 --> 01:54:46,926 HEALTH AND DISEASE AND MEDICAL 2731 01:54:46,926 --> 01:54:49,763 THERAPIES AND EXPOSURES CAN 2732 01:54:49,763 --> 01:54:51,798 OFTEN IMPACT THE NUTRITIONAL 2733 01:54:51,798 --> 01:54:54,634 STATUS OF THE PERSON THEREAFTER. 2734 01:54:54,634 --> 01:54:57,270 SO IT'S UNLIKE AGE AND SEX WHERE 2735 01:54:57,270 --> 01:55:03,009 AGE GOES CRHRONOLOGICALLY AND SX 2736 01:55:03,009 --> 01:55:05,278 IS DETERMINED BY CHROMOSOMES. 2737 01:55:05,278 --> 01:55:06,746 NUTRITIONAL STATUS IS VERY 2738 01:55:06,746 --> 01:55:07,547 FLUID. 2739 01:55:07,547 --> 01:55:10,216 AND THE LAST POINT IT'S DISEASE 2740 01:55:10,216 --> 01:55:11,618 AGNOSTIC WHICH IT TOUCHES AND 2741 01:55:11,618 --> 01:55:14,921 I'LL TOUCH OB IN A SECOND AT 24 2742 01:55:14,921 --> 01:55:17,190 INSTITUTES AND CENTERS AS WELL 2743 01:55:17,190 --> 01:55:18,658 AS THE OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR 2744 01:55:18,658 --> 01:55:24,230 AND NUTRITION SCIENCES. 2745 01:55:24,230 --> 01:55:25,932 SO WHY DO I LOVE TALKING ABOUT 2746 01:55:25,932 --> 01:55:27,500 THIS AND WHY DO I CARE SO MUCH 2747 01:55:27,500 --> 01:55:29,669 AND LOVE COMING TO WORK EVERY 2748 01:55:29,669 --> 01:55:30,070 DAY? 2749 01:55:30,070 --> 01:55:31,538 THIS IS NOT NEWS TO YOU BUT IT 2750 01:55:31,538 --> 01:55:33,606 IS LEVEL SETTING I THINK. 2751 01:55:33,606 --> 01:55:37,544 WE'RE ESPECIALLY IN THE NEWS 2752 01:55:37,544 --> 01:55:40,914 THESE DAYS WITH MAHA WE'RE 2753 01:55:40,914 --> 01:55:42,348 FACING AN URGENT NUTRITION 2754 01:55:42,348 --> 01:55:44,150 RELATED HEALTH CRISIS. 2755 01:55:44,150 --> 01:55:46,386 AT A GLOBAL LEVEL BOWEL 2756 01:55:46,386 --> 01:55:50,356 NUTRITION IS THE LEADING CAUSE 2757 01:55:50,356 --> 01:55:53,760 OF MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY AND 2758 01:55:53,760 --> 01:55:55,762 IN THE U.S. SUB NUTRITION IS 2759 01:55:55,762 --> 01:55:58,364 THREATENING OUR PUBLIC HEALTH, 2760 01:55:58,364 --> 01:56:01,134 WE HEAR ABOUT EVERY DAY AND 2761 01:56:01,134 --> 01:56:04,771 AFFECTS OUR ECONOMY AND NATIONAL 2762 01:56:04,771 --> 01:56:05,038 SECURITY. 2763 01:56:05,038 --> 01:56:07,640 NEARLY 8 OF 10 U.S. YOUNG ADULTS 2764 01:56:07,640 --> 01:56:09,442 CANNOT QUALIFY FOR THE MILITARY 2765 01:56:09,442 --> 01:56:12,879 DUE TO A DIET RELATED CONDITION 2766 01:56:12,879 --> 01:56:14,547 INCLUDING OBESITY, NEARLY 8 IN 2767 01:56:14,547 --> 01:56:14,714 10. 2768 01:56:14,714 --> 01:56:18,284 IT'S SUPER IMPORTANT. 2769 01:56:18,284 --> 01:56:21,921 AND CHRONIC RELATED DISEASES 2770 01:56:21,921 --> 01:56:24,924 IT'S ESTIMATED TO LEAD TO THE 2771 01:56:24,924 --> 01:56:28,261 DEATH OF 16,000 AMERICANS EACH 2772 01:56:28,261 --> 01:56:29,796 WEEK AND 1500 NEW CASES OF 2773 01:56:29,796 --> 01:56:31,331 CANCER PER WEEK IS THE EXTENT OF 2774 01:56:31,331 --> 01:56:32,031 THE PROBLEM. 2775 01:56:32,031 --> 01:56:35,168 I MENTIONED THE COST EXCEEDING 2776 01:56:35,168 --> 01:56:38,371 $1.1 TRILLION PER YEAR. 2777 01:56:38,371 --> 01:56:42,375 AGAIN, IT'S SUBOPTIMAL DIETS AND 2778 01:56:42,375 --> 01:56:50,383 KILL MORE THAN TOBACCO SMOKING 2779 01:56:50,383 --> 01:56:57,223 AND OTHERS AND IT'S THE LEADING 2780 01:56:57,223 --> 01:56:59,425 REASON AND MORE AMERICANS HAVE 2781 01:56:59,425 --> 01:57:02,362 DIED FROM DIABETES MORE THAN THE 2782 01:57:02,362 --> 01:57:06,366 ENTIRE CIVIL AND WORLD WAR. 2783 01:57:06,366 --> 01:57:07,333 THAT'S HUGE. 2784 01:57:07,333 --> 01:57:13,840 SO WHEN I CAME TO O&R WE THOUGHT 2785 01:57:13,840 --> 01:57:15,575 ABOUT WHERE SHOULD WE GO. 2786 01:57:15,575 --> 01:57:18,044 WE ASSESSED WHERE WE WERE AND WE 2787 01:57:18,044 --> 01:57:20,980 ENGAGED EACH OTHER AND ENGAGED 2788 01:57:20,980 --> 01:57:22,315 LOCAL PARTNERS AND EXTRAMURAL 2789 01:57:22,315 --> 01:57:25,218 PARTNERS AND DID A LOT OF 2790 01:57:25,218 --> 01:57:25,585 REFLECTION. 2791 01:57:25,585 --> 01:57:27,620 THOSE WHO KNOW ME KNOW I LIKE TO 2792 01:57:27,620 --> 01:57:29,556 THINK ABOUT THINGS AND REFINE 2793 01:57:29,556 --> 01:57:30,423 BASED ON ASSESSMENT AND FEEDBACK 2794 01:57:30,423 --> 01:57:33,760 AND I ALSO WANTED TO HAVE AN 2795 01:57:33,760 --> 01:57:36,462 OFFICE PLAN JUST LIKE THE OFFICE 2796 01:57:36,462 --> 01:57:38,364 OF DIETARY SUPPLEMENT THAT WAS 2797 01:57:38,364 --> 01:57:39,098 ACTIONABLE. 2798 01:57:39,098 --> 01:57:40,767 WE DIDN'T JUST WANT TO 2799 01:57:40,767 --> 01:57:41,067 PONTIFICATE. 2800 01:57:41,067 --> 01:57:42,335 WE WANTED TO TAKE THE THOUGHTS 2801 01:57:42,335 --> 01:57:44,938 AND MOVE THEM INTO ACTION. 2802 01:57:44,938 --> 01:57:49,175 JUST ON TUESDAY WE HAVE NOW A 2803 01:57:49,175 --> 01:57:50,777 CODIFIED PLAN FOR THE NEXT 2804 01:57:50,777 --> 01:57:54,347 SEVERAL FISCAL YEARS FOR THE 2805 01:57:54,347 --> 01:57:57,183 OFFICE. 2806 01:57:57,183 --> 01:58:02,322 SO O & R AND FOR THOSE ON THE 2807 01:58:02,322 --> 01:58:03,756 COUNCIL OF COUNCILS WHO HASN'T 2808 01:58:03,756 --> 01:58:04,724 HEARD ABOUT THE OFFICE YET. 2809 01:58:04,724 --> 01:58:07,160 WE ENFORCE THE ROLE OF NUTRITION 2810 01:58:07,160 --> 01:58:08,828 IN ALL ASPECTS OF HUMAN BIOLOGY, 2811 01:58:08,828 --> 01:58:11,831 I SAID BEFORE. 2812 01:58:11,831 --> 01:58:13,199 WE COORDINATE RESEARCH ACROSS 2813 01:58:13,199 --> 01:58:15,168 THE NIH AND BEYOND. 2814 01:58:15,168 --> 01:58:16,936 WE ADVISE HHS LEADERSHIP AND 2815 01:58:16,936 --> 01:58:19,372 ANYONE WHO WILL LISTEN, FOR THAT 2816 01:58:19,372 --> 01:58:21,174 MATTER, ON ANYTHING NUTRITION 2817 01:58:21,174 --> 01:58:24,444 AND NUTRITION RELATED. 2818 01:58:24,444 --> 01:58:25,378 WE LEAD COMMITTEES. 2819 01:58:25,378 --> 01:58:26,613 IT'S NOT JUST TO BE ON 2820 01:58:26,613 --> 01:58:28,648 COMMITTEES BUT STILL LEAD. 2821 01:58:28,648 --> 01:58:31,150 THERE'S A BIG DISTINCTION THERE 2822 01:58:31,150 --> 01:58:34,354 AND THE LAST SEVERAL YEARS HAS 2823 01:58:34,354 --> 01:58:36,289 BEEN EXTREMELY INSTRUMENTAL IN 2824 01:58:36,289 --> 01:58:47,033 HIS TEAM IN PRODUCING A N A BIAL 2825 01:58:48,534 --> 01:58:55,575 NUTRITION AND REPORT. 2826 01:58:55,575 --> 01:58:58,344 AND WE HAVE SIX. 2827 01:58:58,344 --> 01:59:01,180 24 OF THE INSTITUTES AND CENTERS 2828 01:59:01,180 --> 01:59:03,416 AS WELL AS THE OD HAVE A 2829 01:59:03,416 --> 01:59:05,118 NUTRITION PORTFOLIO. 2830 01:59:05,118 --> 01:59:07,754 HIGH LEVEL CONTEXT OF THE SPACE 2831 01:59:07,754 --> 01:59:09,689 APPROXIMATELY $2 BILLION PER 2832 01:59:09,689 --> 01:59:13,059 YEAR SPENT ON NUTRITION RELATED 2833 01:59:13,059 --> 01:59:14,394 SCIENCE PART OF THE NIH 2834 01:59:14,394 --> 01:59:14,694 OBLIGATIONS. 2835 01:59:14,694 --> 01:59:18,064 WE HAVE A BROAD REACH AND OUR 2836 01:59:18,064 --> 01:59:19,666 PURPOSE IS TO OPTIMIZE WHOLE 2837 01:59:19,666 --> 01:59:20,867 PERSON HEALTH AND REALIZING HOW 2838 01:59:20,867 --> 01:59:22,368 IMPORTANT THE ROLE OF NUTRITION 2839 01:59:22,368 --> 01:59:27,807 IS. 2840 01:59:27,807 --> 01:59:28,775 SO MISSION AND VISION. 2841 01:59:28,775 --> 01:59:31,210 THIS WAS SUPER IMPORTANT TO ME 2842 01:59:31,210 --> 01:59:34,347 TO CODIFY THESE AND I'M NOT 2843 01:59:34,347 --> 01:59:38,184 GOING TO READ THESE WORD BY WORD 2844 01:59:38,184 --> 01:59:39,719 BUT AT A SUPER HIGH LEVEL OUR 2845 01:59:39,719 --> 01:59:42,488 VISION IS TO THINK ABOUT 2846 01:59:42,488 --> 01:59:43,790 IMPACTING HEALTH NOW BUT ALSO 2847 01:59:43,790 --> 01:59:47,560 IMPACTING HEALTH IN THE FUTURE. 2848 01:59:47,560 --> 01:59:49,929 AND FROM A MISSION STANDPOINT TO 2849 01:59:49,929 --> 01:59:51,364 EMBRACE THE COMPLEXITIES OF 2850 01:59:51,364 --> 01:59:53,633 DOING NUTRITION SCIENCE. 2851 01:59:53,633 --> 01:59:55,335 THIS IS A FIELD THAT'S 2852 01:59:55,335 --> 01:59:57,136 EXTRAORDINARILY DIFFICULT TO DO 2853 01:59:57,136 --> 02:00:00,473 BECAUSE OF ALL THE VARIABLES 2854 02:00:00,473 --> 02:00:02,375 INVOLVED. 2855 02:00:02,375 --> 02:00:04,811 BUT THINKING ABOUT NUTRITION IN 2856 02:00:04,811 --> 02:00:06,846 AN ECOLOGICAL FRAMEWORK CAN WE 2857 02:00:06,846 --> 02:00:08,214 HOPE TO MOVE THE FIELD FORWARD. 2858 02:00:08,214 --> 02:00:11,884 PART OF THE GOALS IS TO IMPROVE 2859 02:00:11,884 --> 02:00:16,289 PRECISION AND IN THE ASSESSMENT 2860 02:00:16,289 --> 02:00:22,362 OF NUTRITIONAL STATUS AND INFORM 2861 02:00:22,362 --> 02:00:23,663 PRACTICES AND POLICIES. 2862 02:00:23,663 --> 02:00:25,698 I'LL TALK ABOUT GENERATING 2863 02:00:25,698 --> 02:00:27,066 EVIDENCE IN A LITTLE BIT. 2864 02:00:27,066 --> 02:00:28,601 AS FAR AS OUR STRATEGY GOES YOU 2865 02:00:28,601 --> 02:00:30,503 HEARD ME MENTION IT'S REALLY 2866 02:00:30,503 --> 02:00:33,673 SERVICE, TECHNICAL SUPPORT AND 2867 02:00:33,673 --> 02:00:34,674 ASSISTANCE AND COORDINATION AND 2868 02:00:34,674 --> 02:00:38,144 THEN AS FAR AS VALUES, ALL THOSE 2869 02:00:38,144 --> 02:00:42,815 ARE IMPORTANT BUT INTEGRITY AND 2870 02:00:42,815 --> 02:00:46,352 CURIOSITY AND TRANSPARENCY RISE. 2871 02:00:46,352 --> 02:00:48,020 THINKING OF HARD PROBLEMS WITH 2872 02:00:48,020 --> 02:00:50,623 NEW LENSES IN NEW WAYS TO 2873 02:00:50,623 --> 02:00:54,360 SUPPORT RESEARCH THAT'S SOLUTION 2874 02:00:54,360 --> 02:00:57,997 FOCUSSED AND ACTIONABLE. 2875 02:00:57,997 --> 02:01:02,168 SO HERE'S OUR STRATEGIC PLAN 2876 02:01:02,168 --> 02:01:02,435 FRAMEWORK. 2877 02:01:02,435 --> 02:01:03,703 IT HAS FOUR MAJOR GOALS AS WELL 2878 02:01:03,703 --> 02:01:06,139 AS TWO CROSS-CUTTING PRIORITIES. 2879 02:01:06,139 --> 02:01:08,007 ON THE NEXT TWO SLIDES I'LL GO 2880 02:01:08,007 --> 02:01:09,642 MORE INTO DETAILS WITH THESE 2881 02:01:09,642 --> 02:01:12,445 GOALS BUT THEY'RE REALLY TO 2882 02:01:12,445 --> 02:01:13,513 ADVANCE SCIENCE. 2883 02:01:13,513 --> 02:01:15,648 THAT'S WHY WE'RE HERE TO ADVANCE 2884 02:01:15,648 --> 02:01:15,915 SCIENCE. 2885 02:01:15,915 --> 02:01:16,816 TO GENERATE EVIDENCE. 2886 02:01:16,816 --> 02:01:18,384 WE'LL TALK ABOUT GENERATING 2887 02:01:18,384 --> 02:01:19,852 EVIDENCE TO HELP IN CLINICAL 2888 02:01:19,852 --> 02:01:21,421 PRACTICE AND GENERATING EVIDENCE 2889 02:01:21,421 --> 02:01:22,822 TO HELP IN THE REGULATORY SPACE 2890 02:01:22,822 --> 02:01:25,358 BUT GENERATING EVIDENCE TO 2891 02:01:25,358 --> 02:01:28,561 INFORM DECISION MAKERS AS THEY 2892 02:01:28,561 --> 02:01:31,230 MAKE THEIR DECISIONS BUILDING 2893 02:01:31,230 --> 02:01:31,798 CAPACITY. 2894 02:01:31,798 --> 02:01:33,232 TRAINING AND EXPANDING THE 2895 02:01:33,232 --> 02:01:35,435 CAPACITY OF THE CURRENT 2896 02:01:35,435 --> 02:01:36,936 NUTRITIONAL WORKFORCE TO DEAL 2897 02:01:36,936 --> 02:01:38,371 WITH A LOT OF THE SERIOUS ISSUES 2898 02:01:38,371 --> 02:01:42,442 THAT ARE RIGHT AT HAND AND THEN 2899 02:01:42,442 --> 02:01:47,380 FOSTERING STEWARDSHIP. 2900 02:01:47,380 --> 02:01:53,586 HOI DO WE COMMUNICATE AND IMPART 2901 02:01:53,586 --> 02:01:55,354 OUR KNOWLEDGE TO IMPACT MENTAL 2902 02:01:55,354 --> 02:01:56,689 HEALTH AND END BY SHOWING HOW 2903 02:01:56,689 --> 02:01:58,991 WE'RE WORKING TO EXPAND 2904 02:01:58,991 --> 02:01:59,992 NUTRITION SCIENCE OUTSIDE THE 2905 02:01:59,992 --> 02:02:01,994 NIH AND INTERNALLY. 2906 02:02:01,994 --> 02:02:04,697 THEN OUR CROSS-CUTTING 2907 02:02:04,697 --> 02:02:05,932 PRIORITIES FOCUS ON TRAINING AND 2908 02:02:05,932 --> 02:02:08,167 OPTIMIZING NUTRITION ACROSS THE 2909 02:02:08,167 --> 02:02:10,336 LIFE SPAN RECOGNIZING THERE ARE 2910 02:02:10,336 --> 02:02:11,604 CRITICAL PERIODS AND SENSITIVE 2911 02:02:11,604 --> 02:02:13,906 PERIODS ACROSS THE LIFE SPAN 2912 02:02:13,906 --> 02:02:16,175 WHERE NUTRITIONAL NEEDS COULD BE 2913 02:02:16,175 --> 02:02:17,810 DIFFERENT AND UNDERSTANDING THE 2914 02:02:17,810 --> 02:02:19,479 NEEDS THROUGHOUT THE LIFE SPAN 2915 02:02:19,479 --> 02:02:21,581 AFFECT THE ABILITY TO BE MORE 2916 02:02:21,581 --> 02:02:22,381 PRECISE IN DIETARY 2917 02:02:22,381 --> 02:02:24,250 RECOMMENDATIONS. 2918 02:02:24,250 --> 02:02:28,120 SO TO GET A BIT MORE IN DEPTH ON 2919 02:02:28,120 --> 02:02:31,524 THE GOALS, GOAL ONE ADVANCING 2920 02:02:31,524 --> 02:02:31,791 SCIENCE. 2921 02:02:31,791 --> 02:02:34,360 AGAIN, I'M NOT GOING TO READ ALL 2922 02:02:34,360 --> 02:02:39,031 THESE VERBATIM BUT OUR FIRST 2923 02:02:39,031 --> 02:02:40,466 OBJECTIVE IS TO IMPROVE RIGOR 2924 02:02:40,466 --> 02:02:48,007 AND REPROABILDUCIBILITY AND YOU 2925 02:02:48,007 --> 02:02:49,976 HEAR ABOUT OUR EMPHASIS ON THIS 2926 02:02:49,976 --> 02:02:51,711 AND ONLY BY DOING THAT CAN WE 2927 02:02:51,711 --> 02:02:53,913 HOPE TO ADVANCE THE FUNDAMENTAL 2928 02:02:53,913 --> 02:02:55,081 UNDERSTANDING OF NUTRITION IN 2929 02:02:55,081 --> 02:02:58,017 ALL BIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS. 2930 02:02:58,017 --> 02:03:00,653 RESEARCH OBJECTIVE TWO IS TO 2931 02:03:00,653 --> 02:03:03,923 ENHANCE THE PRECISION OF 2932 02:03:03,923 --> 02:03:07,026 PRECISION SCIENCE. 2933 02:03:07,026 --> 02:03:09,795 IT'S POWERED BY THE ALL OF US 2934 02:03:09,795 --> 02:03:11,097 RESEARCH ACTIVITY ONGOING AND 2935 02:03:11,097 --> 02:03:13,633 WANT TO HARNESS WHAT'S GOING ON 2936 02:03:13,633 --> 02:03:14,500 IN THE ACTIVITY AND INITIATIVE 2937 02:03:14,500 --> 02:03:18,404 TO MOVE THE FIELD FORWARD. 2938 02:03:18,404 --> 02:03:22,208 AND THE THIRD IS UNDERSTANDING 2939 02:03:22,208 --> 02:03:24,143 ALL THE CHANGES THAT ARE 2940 02:03:24,143 --> 02:03:26,245 HAPPENING IN THE ENVIRONMENT AND 2941 02:03:26,245 --> 02:03:29,215 ACROSS THE WORLD AND IN FOOD 2942 02:03:29,215 --> 02:03:32,251 SYSTEMS HOW DO WE ENSURE THAT 2943 02:03:32,251 --> 02:03:33,519 THERE'S ADEQUATE NUTRITIONAL 2944 02:03:33,519 --> 02:03:36,355 SUPPORT TO PROMOTE GROWTH AND 2945 02:03:36,355 --> 02:03:36,656 DEVELOPMENT. 2946 02:03:36,656 --> 02:03:38,791 MOVING ON TO GOAL 2, SUPPORTING 2947 02:03:38,791 --> 02:03:40,426 THE GENERATION OF EVIDENCE. 2948 02:03:40,426 --> 02:03:44,163 THE FIRST OBJECTIVE REALLY IS TO 2949 02:03:44,163 --> 02:03:48,534 HONE IN ON THE APPROACHES TO 2950 02:03:48,534 --> 02:03:55,207 ASSESS NUTRITIONAL STATUS TO 2951 02:03:55,207 --> 02:03:57,109 IDENTIFY WHEN AN INDIVIDUAL IS 2952 02:03:57,109 --> 02:03:58,277 MALNOURISHED. 2953 02:03:58,277 --> 02:03:59,278 MALNUTRITION BELIEVE IT OR NOT 2954 02:03:59,278 --> 02:04:01,614 IN 2025 THERE'S NO UNIFIED 2955 02:04:01,614 --> 02:04:03,349 DEFINITION OF WHAT IT MEANS TO 2956 02:04:03,349 --> 02:04:06,552 BE MALNOURISHED AND NO UNIFIED 2957 02:04:06,552 --> 02:04:08,020 APPROACH TO ASSESSING 2958 02:04:08,020 --> 02:04:10,690 NUTRITIONAL STATUS OR MAKING 2959 02:04:10,690 --> 02:04:14,360 ATTRIBUTIONS TO ONE'S 2960 02:04:14,360 --> 02:04:18,230 NUTRITIONAL STATUS. 2961 02:04:18,230 --> 02:04:19,966 THERE'S A PROJECT WHERE WE'RE 2962 02:04:19,966 --> 02:04:23,069 FOCUSSING ON HOW DOES ONE DEFINE 2963 02:04:23,069 --> 02:04:24,503 NUTRITIONAL STATUS IN 2964 02:04:24,503 --> 02:04:26,906 MALNUTRITION BECAUSE THAT REALLY 2965 02:04:26,906 --> 02:04:29,809 IMPACTS FOOD AS MEDICINE 2966 02:04:29,809 --> 02:04:31,777 ACTIVITIES AND INFORMS PRECISION 2967 02:04:31,777 --> 02:04:34,213 NUTRITION AND ALL OTHER 2968 02:04:34,213 --> 02:04:34,513 ACTIVITIES. 2969 02:04:34,513 --> 02:04:36,449 AND THE SECOND OBJECTIVE IS 2970 02:04:36,449 --> 02:04:38,184 SUPPORTING THE SCIENCES THAT CAN 2971 02:04:38,184 --> 02:04:40,786 INFORM REGULATORY DECISION 2972 02:04:40,786 --> 02:04:41,020 MAKERS. 2973 02:04:41,020 --> 02:04:42,989 BACK ON MAY 9 THERE WAS AN 2974 02:04:42,989 --> 02:04:44,156 ANNOUNCEMENT OF A JOINT PROGRAM 2975 02:04:44,156 --> 02:04:46,359 BETWEEN THE NIH AND FDA FOCUSSED 2976 02:04:46,359 --> 02:04:48,227 ON NUTRITION REGULATORY SCIENCE 2977 02:04:48,227 --> 02:04:51,797 AND THAT REALLY STEMMED FROM AN 2978 02:04:51,797 --> 02:04:53,833 OBSERVATION AND RECOGNITION THAT 2979 02:04:53,833 --> 02:04:58,137 THERE IS A PAUCITY OF RIGOROUS 2980 02:04:58,137 --> 02:04:59,405 DATA THAT CAN HELP INFORM 2981 02:04:59,405 --> 02:05:01,207 DECISION MAKERS IN THIS SPACE SO 2982 02:05:01,207 --> 02:05:04,176 THAT'S WHAT WE HOPE TO LEVERAGE 2983 02:05:04,176 --> 02:05:05,778 AT THE NIH INFRASTRUCTURE AND 2984 02:05:05,778 --> 02:05:08,047 SYSTEMS TO REALLY SUPPORT THE 2985 02:05:08,047 --> 02:05:10,349 SCIENCE TO INFORM OUR OTHER 2986 02:05:10,349 --> 02:05:15,888 FEDERAL PARTNERS. 2987 02:05:15,888 --> 02:05:21,293 GOING ON TO GOAL THREE IS 2988 02:05:21,293 --> 02:05:26,365 BUILDING CAPACITY AND STRENGTHEN 2989 02:05:26,365 --> 02:05:30,136 SCIENCE. 2990 02:05:30,136 --> 02:05:33,939 THIS GOES BACK TO THE NOTION OF 2991 02:05:33,939 --> 02:05:36,008 NUTRITIONAL STATUS AS BEING A 2992 02:05:36,008 --> 02:05:39,078 FUNDAMENTAL BIOLOGICAL VARIABLE 2993 02:05:39,078 --> 02:05:42,848 IN ALL BIOMEDICAL SCIENCES AND 2994 02:05:42,848 --> 02:05:44,483 ENHANCE CAPACITY AND ENHANCEMENT 2995 02:05:44,483 --> 02:05:47,653 ACROSS THE WORKFORCE IN 2996 02:05:47,653 --> 02:05:51,290 NUTRITION SCIENCE WORKFORCE AS 2997 02:05:51,290 --> 02:05:52,158 WELL AS A WORKFORCE THAT TAKES 2998 02:05:52,158 --> 02:05:54,193 IT FROM THE CLINIC TO THE PUBLIC 2999 02:05:54,193 --> 02:05:56,395 AND THOSE ARE THE REGISTERED 3000 02:05:56,395 --> 02:05:58,330 DIETITIANS WHICH I HAVE THE 3001 02:05:58,330 --> 02:06:00,266 UTMOST PROFOUND RESPECT FOR 3002 02:06:00,266 --> 02:06:01,233 BECAUSE THAT COMMUNITY TAKES ALL 3003 02:06:01,233 --> 02:06:02,201 THE INFORMATION AND MAKES IT 3004 02:06:02,201 --> 02:06:06,372 REAL TO INDIVIDUALS AT THE 3005 02:06:06,372 --> 02:06:07,039 BEDSIDE AND IN THE HOME. 3006 02:06:07,039 --> 02:06:10,376 THEN TO CLOSE OUT WITH OUR 3007 02:06:10,376 --> 02:06:12,278 FOURTH GOAL AS FAR AS 3008 02:06:12,278 --> 02:06:13,345 STEWARDSHIP AND COLLABORATION 3009 02:06:13,345 --> 02:06:16,549 AND TRANSPARENCY AND 3010 02:06:16,549 --> 02:06:19,285 ACCOUNTABILITY IS BE THAT 3011 02:06:19,285 --> 02:06:22,822 SYNERGISTIC HUB TO FACILITATE 3012 02:06:22,822 --> 02:06:24,790 AND LEAD EFFORTS ACROSS THE 3013 02:06:24,790 --> 02:06:26,158 GOVERNMENTS AND ACROSS NON 3014 02:06:26,158 --> 02:06:29,261 GOVERNMENT PARTNERS. 3015 02:06:29,261 --> 02:06:30,529 TO REALLY INCREASE KNOWLEDGE AND 3016 02:06:30,529 --> 02:06:33,265 GENERATE INTEREST IN NUTRITION 3017 02:06:33,265 --> 02:06:33,499 SCIENCE. 3018 02:06:33,499 --> 02:06:35,201 IN A LARGE PART IT'S DONE BY HOW 3019 02:06:35,201 --> 02:06:37,002 WE COMMUNICATE NUTRITION AND THE 3020 02:06:37,002 --> 02:06:38,404 RESULT OF STUDIES TO THE GENERAL 3021 02:06:38,404 --> 02:06:38,637 PUBLIC. 3022 02:06:38,637 --> 02:06:40,239 AND THEN THE FOURTH OBJECTIVE 3023 02:06:40,239 --> 02:06:41,507 BEING TO EXPAND THE IMPACT OF 3024 02:06:41,507 --> 02:06:44,276 OUR ACTIVITIES OF PROGRAMS AND 3025 02:06:44,276 --> 02:06:44,610 CAPABILITIES. 3026 02:06:44,610 --> 02:06:54,053 I'LL TOUCH ON THAT AT THE END. 3027 02:06:54,053 --> 02:06:58,357 AND IN 2020 UNDER CHRIS LYNCH'S 3028 02:06:58,357 --> 02:07:04,230 LEADERSHIP THERE WAS A 2020-2030 3029 02:07:04,230 --> 02:07:07,633 STRATEGIC PLAN FOR NUTRITION 3030 02:07:07,633 --> 02:07:09,902 RESEARCH. 3031 02:07:09,902 --> 02:07:13,139 OUR GOAL WAS TO BE SYNERGISTIC 3032 02:07:13,139 --> 02:07:14,340 AND COMPLEMENT THE NIH WIDE 3033 02:07:14,340 --> 02:07:16,375 STRATEGIC PLAN AND HOW CAN OUR 3034 02:07:16,375 --> 02:07:20,179 OFFICE ACTIVITIES IMPACT AND 3035 02:07:20,179 --> 02:07:22,448 IMPLEMENT THE OVER ALL NIH WIDE 3036 02:07:22,448 --> 02:07:32,725 NUTRITION PLAN. 3037 02:07:34,426 --> 02:07:36,695 AND DEMONSTRATE HOW OUR PLAN 3038 02:07:36,695 --> 02:07:38,864 MAPS WITH THE NIH OVER ALL PLAN 3039 02:07:38,864 --> 02:07:41,534 AND UNIFYING THE THEME OF THE 3040 02:07:41,534 --> 02:07:49,642 PLAN BEING PRECISION NUTRITION. 3041 02:07:49,642 --> 02:07:51,043 AND NOT ONLY TO SUPPORT THE 3042 02:07:51,043 --> 02:07:53,746 SCIENCE AND DO THE WRITING AND 3043 02:07:53,746 --> 02:07:57,183 BE ON THE MEETINGS, LEAD THE 3044 02:07:57,183 --> 02:08:00,619 INITIATIVES AND SPEAK OFF CAMPUS 3045 02:08:00,619 --> 02:08:09,295 TO HELP OUR EXTRAMURAL COMMUNITY 3046 02:08:09,295 --> 02:08:14,200 BUT AM A FIRM BELIEVER IN DOING 3047 02:08:14,200 --> 02:08:17,269 SOMETHING IN OUR OWN BACK YARD 3048 02:08:17,269 --> 02:08:18,904 AND WE HAD A TEACHING KITCHEN 3049 02:08:18,904 --> 02:08:20,439 PROGRAM ON CAMPUS. 3050 02:08:20,439 --> 02:08:24,243 IT'S ONE THING TO BE WRITING 3051 02:08:24,243 --> 02:08:25,911 ABOUT HOW TO IMPROVE NUTRITION 3052 02:08:25,911 --> 02:08:29,782 AND WHAT DIETARY PATTERNS MAY BE 3053 02:08:29,782 --> 02:08:34,386 BENEFICIAL TO SOMEONE'S HEALTH 3054 02:08:34,386 --> 02:08:36,522 BUT IT'S ALSO IMPORTANT TO SHOW 3055 02:08:36,522 --> 02:08:39,091 PEOPLE HOW TO TAKE THE 3056 02:08:39,091 --> 02:08:42,261 INFORMATION AND WE WENT TO THE 3057 02:08:42,261 --> 02:08:43,896 CHILDREN'S INN AND TALK ABOUT 3058 02:08:43,896 --> 02:08:47,199 DIET AND NUTRITION AND TEACH 3059 02:08:47,199 --> 02:08:54,273 SKILLS AND HAVE EXPERIENTIAL 3060 02:08:54,273 --> 02:08:56,308 LEARNING AND WE TEACH KNEW 3061 02:08:56,308 --> 02:08:57,643 TRYING AND SHOW PEOPLE HOW TO 3062 02:08:57,643 --> 02:08:59,245 TAKE IT BACK TO THE KITCHEN AND 3063 02:08:59,245 --> 02:09:02,348 MAKE A MEAL THAT'S HEALTHY. 3064 02:09:02,348 --> 02:09:03,849 THAT'S BEEN ONE OF THE 3065 02:09:03,849 --> 02:09:06,352 HIGHLIGHTS OF THE PAST MANY 3066 02:09:06,352 --> 02:09:08,454 MONTHS HERE IN OUR OFFICE. 3067 02:09:08,454 --> 02:09:10,356 AND WITH THAT I'M GOING TO PIVOT 3068 02:09:10,356 --> 02:09:12,057 TO THE OFFICE OF DIETARY 3069 02:09:12,057 --> 02:09:15,094 SUPPLEMENTS WHO IS CELEBRATING A 3070 02:09:15,094 --> 02:09:17,096 BIG BIRTHDAY THIS YEAR IN 30 3071 02:09:17,096 --> 02:09:18,631 YEARS, LET'S HEAR IT, 3072 02:09:18,631 --> 02:09:19,231 UNBELIEVABLE? 3073 02:09:19,231 --> 02:09:20,466 I LIKE THE CLAPPING. 3074 02:09:20,466 --> 02:09:25,337 YEAH, SO BACK IN APRIL I AGAIN 3075 02:09:25,337 --> 02:09:27,406 EXTRAORDINARY PRIVILEGE OF 3076 02:09:27,406 --> 02:09:30,242 JOINING THE OFFICE OF DIETARY 3077 02:09:30,242 --> 02:09:30,542 SUPPLEMENTS. 3078 02:09:30,542 --> 02:09:36,181 NOT NEW TO THEM AT ALL AS YOU'LL 3079 02:09:36,181 --> 02:09:38,450 HEAR THERE'S LOTS OF SYNERGIES. 3080 02:09:38,450 --> 02:09:44,256 I HAD THE PRIVILEGE OF 3081 02:09:44,256 --> 02:09:52,598 INTERACTING WITH THE OFFICE. 3082 02:09:52,598 --> 02:09:56,435 BEING INVOLVED IN THE OFFICE AND 3083 02:09:56,435 --> 02:09:58,804 BEING ENGAGED SHOWCASED HOW 3084 02:09:58,804 --> 02:09:59,605 EXTRAORDINARY THEY ARE. 3085 02:09:59,605 --> 02:10:00,306 HAPPY BIRTHDAY. 3086 02:10:00,306 --> 02:10:05,444 SO THE CHARGE OF THE OFFICE OF 3087 02:10:05,444 --> 02:10:06,278 DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS IS A BIT 3088 02:10:06,278 --> 02:10:07,546 DIFFERENT. 3089 02:10:07,546 --> 02:10:09,615 WHEN I TALKED ABOUT NUTRITION 3090 02:10:09,615 --> 02:10:11,650 AND HOW ENVISION NUTRITION IS 3091 02:10:11,650 --> 02:10:12,952 THE BIOLOGY OF WHAT HAPPENS 3092 02:10:12,952 --> 02:10:14,987 AFTER YOU INGEST SOMETHING TO 3093 02:10:14,987 --> 02:10:17,623 WHAT HAPPENS AT THE CELLULAR 3094 02:10:17,623 --> 02:10:20,659 LEVEL AND FOR A HEALTH OUTCOME. 3095 02:10:20,659 --> 02:10:24,363 THE OFFICE IS FOCUSSED ON THE 3096 02:10:24,363 --> 02:10:25,898 SUPPLEMENT OR THE NUTRIENT OR 3097 02:10:25,898 --> 02:10:27,499 THE INPUT, IF YOU WILL, OF 3098 02:10:27,499 --> 02:10:30,169 WHAT'S BEING INGESTED. 3099 02:10:30,169 --> 02:10:33,138 SO THE OFFICE THE DIETARY 3100 02:10:33,138 --> 02:10:34,273 SUPPLEMENT HEALTH AND EDUCATION 3101 02:10:34,273 --> 02:10:36,608 ACT WAS PASSED IN '94 BUT THE 3102 02:10:36,608 --> 02:10:40,612 OFFICE ITSELF WAS ESTABLISHED IN 3103 02:10:40,612 --> 02:10:40,779 '95. 3104 02:10:40,779 --> 02:10:43,482 AND THE LEGISLATIVE PURPOSE OF 3105 02:10:43,482 --> 02:10:51,957 THE OFFICE IS TO EXPLORE THIS TO 3106 02:10:51,957 --> 02:10:53,459 IMPROVE HEALTH CARE AND I'LL 3107 02:10:53,459 --> 02:10:54,994 SHOW YOU IN THE NEXT SLIDE IT'S 3108 02:10:54,994 --> 02:10:56,061 A BIG BUSINESS. 3109 02:10:56,061 --> 02:10:59,365 AND FROM WHAT THE SCIENTIFIC 3110 02:10:59,365 --> 02:11:05,437 STUDY OF BENEFITS IN IMPROVING 3111 02:11:05,437 --> 02:11:06,905 HEALTH AND PREVENTING DISEASE 3112 02:11:06,905 --> 02:11:09,641 AND THEY'RE SIMILAR TO THE 3113 02:11:09,641 --> 02:11:10,943 OFFICE OF NUTRITION SUPPORT TO 3114 02:11:10,943 --> 02:11:13,479 SUPPORT THE SCIENCE IN A DIETARY 3115 02:11:13,479 --> 02:11:14,480 SUPPLEMENT SPACE THAT'S GOING TO 3116 02:11:14,480 --> 02:11:17,383 MOVE THE NEEDAL FORWARD AND TO 3117 02:11:17,383 --> 02:11:20,352 BE ADVISORS TO KEY LEADERS IN 3118 02:11:20,352 --> 02:11:22,354 THIS SPACE RECOGNIZING THAT 3119 02:11:22,354 --> 02:11:25,991 DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS IS A BIG 3120 02:11:25,991 --> 02:11:28,193 COMPONENT OF THE AMERICAN DIET. 3121 02:11:28,193 --> 02:11:29,828 JUST SOME HOUSEKEEPING HIGH 3122 02:11:29,828 --> 02:11:31,764 LEVEL FACT TO THE RIGHT THE 3123 02:11:31,764 --> 02:11:34,800 OPERATING BUDGET IS $28.5 3124 02:11:34,800 --> 02:11:35,300 MILLION. 3125 02:11:35,300 --> 02:11:36,602 THE CURRENT STAFF IN THE OFFICE 3126 02:11:36,602 --> 02:11:40,739 IS 22. 3127 02:11:40,739 --> 02:11:41,707 THE OFFICE HAS BEEN VERY BROAD 3128 02:11:41,707 --> 02:11:45,144 IN THEIR REACH AND THEY SUPPORT 3129 02:11:45,144 --> 02:11:46,345 A DIETARY SUPPLEMENT RESEARCH IN 3130 02:11:46,345 --> 02:11:48,647 20 INSTITUTES AND CENTERS OVER 3131 02:11:48,647 --> 02:11:49,948 THE PAST 10 YEARS. 3132 02:11:49,948 --> 02:11:51,817 JUST TO PUT CONTEXT TO THE 3133 02:11:51,817 --> 02:11:54,186 ENGAGEMENT OF THE OFFICE AND THE 3134 02:11:54,186 --> 02:11:59,024 SUPPORT OF THE OFFICE ABOUT $300 3135 02:11:59,024 --> 02:12:00,492 MILLION SPENT ON DIETARY 3136 02:12:00,492 --> 02:12:01,627 SUPPLEMENT RELATED RESEARCH AND 3137 02:12:01,627 --> 02:12:04,096 THE OFFICE DIRECTLY CO-FUNDS 3138 02:12:04,096 --> 02:12:06,365 APPROXIMATELY 50 AWARDS A YEAR 3139 02:12:06,365 --> 02:12:08,467 GOING TO $8.5 MILLION PER YEAR. 3140 02:12:08,467 --> 02:12:10,169 JUST LIKE THE OFFICE OF 3141 02:12:10,169 --> 02:12:11,770 NUTRITION RESEARCH THE OFFICE OF 3142 02:12:11,770 --> 02:12:13,972 DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS HAS AN 3143 02:12:13,972 --> 02:12:15,274 EXTREMELY BROAD REACH WHICH IS 3144 02:12:15,274 --> 02:12:17,976 NOT SURPRISING GIVEN THE EXTENT 3145 02:12:17,976 --> 02:12:19,044 DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS ARE USED IN 3146 02:12:19,044 --> 02:12:23,816 THE U.S. AND BEYOND AND REALLY 3147 02:12:23,816 --> 02:12:25,350 THEY'RE MAJOR FOCUS IS TO 3148 02:12:25,350 --> 02:12:27,753 ELUCIDATE THE ROLE OF DIETARY 3149 02:12:27,753 --> 02:12:30,389 SUPPLEMENTS IN OPTIMIZING 3150 02:12:30,389 --> 02:12:34,526 HEALTH. 3151 02:12:34,526 --> 02:12:36,095 THIS IS MORE FOR YOUR RECORDS 3152 02:12:36,095 --> 02:12:37,162 AND I PROMISE I WILL NOT WALK 3153 02:12:37,162 --> 02:12:40,466 YOU THROUGH EVERYTHING. 3154 02:12:40,466 --> 02:12:42,367 THE OFFICE HAS HAD EXTRAORDINARY 3155 02:12:42,367 --> 02:12:44,269 ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN THE PAST 30 3156 02:12:44,269 --> 02:12:44,536 YEARS. 3157 02:12:44,536 --> 02:12:49,441 IT'S TRULY A PRIVILEGE TO BE A 3158 02:12:49,441 --> 02:12:53,245 PART OF IT AND I WANTED TO CALL 3159 02:12:53,245 --> 02:12:56,515 OUT AND HIGHLIGHT THE RECENT 3160 02:12:56,515 --> 02:12:59,885 DIRECTOR WHO SPENT WELL OVER AU 3161 02:12:59,885 --> 02:13:02,588 YEAR THINKING ABOUT HOW THE 3162 02:13:02,588 --> 02:13:05,624 OFFICE COULD MOVE FORWARD IN A 3163 02:13:05,624 --> 02:13:06,391 WAY THAT HAD TREMENDOUS 3164 02:13:06,391 --> 02:13:07,493 SCIENTIFIC IMPACT. 3165 02:13:07,493 --> 02:13:11,530 SO I HAD THE PRIVILEGE OF 3166 02:13:11,530 --> 02:13:14,800 SPEAKING TODAY BUT STEPHANIE 3167 02:13:14,800 --> 02:13:16,435 GEORGE THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR AND 3168 02:13:16,435 --> 02:13:17,369 ALL THE MEMBERS OF THE OFFICE 3169 02:13:17,369 --> 02:13:19,037 ALL THE CREDIT GOES TO THEM. 3170 02:13:19,037 --> 02:13:21,940 I GET THE PRIVILEGE OF BEING THE 3171 02:13:21,940 --> 02:13:30,682 VOICE BUT THEY DID ALL THE WORK. 3172 02:13:30,682 --> 02:13:34,520 AS I ITERATED DIETARY 3173 02:13:34,520 --> 02:13:38,357 SUPPLEMENTS ARE A LARGE PART OF 3174 02:13:38,357 --> 02:13:39,057 THE U.S. DIET. 3175 02:13:39,057 --> 02:13:41,326 ALMOST TWO-THIRDS OF ADULTS AND 3176 02:13:41,326 --> 02:13:42,661 A THIRD OF CHILDREN IN THE 3177 02:13:42,661 --> 02:13:43,795 U.S. USE DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS. 3178 02:13:43,795 --> 02:13:45,731 IF YOU LOOK AT THE GROWTH OF 3179 02:13:45,731 --> 02:13:50,602 THEIR USE IN SALES OVER THE PAST 3180 02:13:50,602 --> 02:13:55,574 30 YEARS THERE'S ABOUT 4,000 3181 02:13:55,574 --> 02:13:57,342 PRODUCTS ON THE MARKET AND NOW 3182 02:13:57,342 --> 02:13:58,377 THERE'S OVER 90,000 PRODUCTS ON 3183 02:13:58,377 --> 02:14:06,985 THE MARKET. 3184 02:14:06,985 --> 02:14:09,087 THE SCIENCE THE OFFICE DOES IS 3185 02:14:09,087 --> 02:14:12,357 NOT CHARGED THE OFFICE IS NOT 3186 02:14:12,357 --> 02:14:13,492 CHARGED WITH REGULATORY 3187 02:14:13,492 --> 02:14:15,761 DECISIONS REGARDING DIETARY 3188 02:14:15,761 --> 02:14:17,196 SUPPLEMENTS BUT RATHER THE 3189 02:14:17,196 --> 02:14:20,365 OPPORTUNITY THE OFFICE HAS IS TO 3190 02:14:20,365 --> 02:14:23,502 ENHANCE THE SCIENCE AND SUPPORT 3191 02:14:23,502 --> 02:14:24,870 AND THEN INFORM DECISION MAKERS 3192 02:14:24,870 --> 02:14:27,873 WHEN THEY'RE ASKED TO MAKE 3193 02:14:27,873 --> 02:14:28,140 DECISIONS. 3194 02:14:28,140 --> 02:14:31,310 YOU CAN SEE JUST THE EXPONENTIAL 3195 02:14:31,310 --> 02:14:32,244 INCREASE IN THE AMOUNT OF OUT 3196 02:14:32,244 --> 02:14:34,346 PRODUCTS AND SALES OF PRODUCTS 3197 02:14:34,346 --> 02:14:41,954 OVER THE PAST 30 YEARS. 3198 02:14:41,954 --> 02:14:44,856 S MUCH LIKE THE OFFICE OF 3199 02:14:44,856 --> 02:14:46,758 NUTRITION RESEARCH ODS IS 3200 02:14:46,758 --> 02:14:48,260 MISSION DRIVEN. 3201 02:14:48,260 --> 02:14:51,163 THERE'S THREE MAJOR GOALS OF THE 3202 02:14:51,163 --> 02:14:56,501 OFFICE TO ADVANCE DIETARY 3203 02:14:56,501 --> 02:14:57,769 SUPPLEMENT SCIENCE AND ENHANCING 3204 02:14:57,769 --> 02:14:58,837 THE SCIENCE WILL MAKE A 3205 02:14:58,837 --> 02:15:01,473 DIFFERENCE AND MOVE THE NEEDAL 3206 02:15:01,473 --> 02:15:02,374 FORWARD. 3207 02:15:02,374 --> 02:15:04,943 EXPANDING CAPACITY AND REALLY TO 3208 02:15:04,943 --> 02:15:06,245 STRENGTHEN THE FIELD OF SCIENCE 3209 02:15:06,245 --> 02:15:09,081 AND ADDRESS EMERGING PUBLIC 3210 02:15:09,081 --> 02:15:11,116 HEALTH CONCERNS AND AGAIN WHAT 3211 02:15:11,116 --> 02:15:14,353 IS THE ROLE OF DIETARY 3212 02:15:14,353 --> 02:15:18,357 SUPPLEMENTS BUT TO HELP MAKE 3213 02:15:18,357 --> 02:15:21,627 AMERICA HEALTHIER AGAIN AND 3214 02:15:21,627 --> 02:15:22,861 FOSTER STEWARDSHIP AND 3215 02:15:22,861 --> 02:15:24,196 COLLABORATION AND YOU SEE 3216 02:15:24,196 --> 02:15:25,264 ALIGNMENTS BETWEEN THE TWO 3217 02:15:25,264 --> 02:15:28,667 OFFICES WITH WHAT WE ARE TRYING 3218 02:15:28,667 --> 02:15:39,211 TO DO INTERNALLY AT THE NIH WITH 3219 02:15:45,651 --> 02:15:47,185 OFFICES. 3220 02:15:47,185 --> 02:15:51,890 I FLUSHED OUT WHAT THE GOALS ARE 3221 02:15:51,890 --> 02:15:53,358 FOR ODS. 3222 02:15:53,358 --> 02:15:55,627 FIRST LIKE ONR IS RESEARCH. 3223 02:15:55,627 --> 02:15:57,529 ADVANCING THE STUDY OF THE 3224 02:15:57,529 --> 02:15:59,464 BIOLOGICAL EFFECTS OF DIETARY 3225 02:15:59,464 --> 02:15:59,765 SUPPLEMENTS. 3226 02:15:59,765 --> 02:16:02,301 HERE'S WHERE IT'S NUANCED. 3227 02:16:02,301 --> 02:16:03,001 ON RESILIENCE AND HEALTH ACROSS 3228 02:16:03,001 --> 02:16:04,670 THE LIFE SPAN. 3229 02:16:04,670 --> 02:16:07,072 HOW CAN DIETARY SUPPLEMENT USE 3230 02:16:07,072 --> 02:16:09,308 FACILITATE RESILIENCE AND THE 3231 02:16:09,308 --> 02:16:12,344 ABILITY TO MAINTAIN HEALTH 3232 02:16:12,344 --> 02:16:15,614 ACROSS THE LIFE SPAN THAT'S ADD 3233 02:16:15,614 --> 02:16:19,084 AN INDIVIDUAL AND POPULATION 3234 02:16:19,084 --> 02:16:19,351 LEVEL. 3235 02:16:19,351 --> 02:16:20,919 WITH ALMOST TWO-THIRDS OF ADULT 3236 02:16:20,919 --> 02:16:23,055 AND A THIRD OF CHILDREN TAKING 3237 02:16:23,055 --> 02:16:24,556 DIETARY SUPPLEMENT IT'S NOT AN 3238 02:16:24,556 --> 02:16:25,190 INDIVIDUAL ISSUE BUT POPULATION 3239 02:16:25,190 --> 02:16:30,395 ISSUE. 3240 02:16:30,395 --> 02:16:32,764 THEN ADVANCING THE SCIENCE ON 3241 02:16:32,764 --> 02:16:35,000 THE STABILITY, EFFICACY AND 3242 02:16:35,000 --> 02:16:37,636 SAFETY OF DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS IS 3243 02:16:37,636 --> 02:16:39,371 SOMETHING EXTREMELY IMPORTANT 3244 02:16:39,371 --> 02:16:42,407 AND THE OFFICE HAS BEEN ENGAGED 3245 02:16:42,407 --> 02:16:48,113 IN IS THE ANALYTICS OF DIETARY 3246 02:16:48,113 --> 02:16:48,413 SUPPLEMENTS. 3247 02:16:48,413 --> 02:16:50,716 AS FAR AS RESEARCH CAPACITY 3248 02:16:50,716 --> 02:16:52,617 YOU'LL HEAR MORE FROM ADAM ABOUT 3249 02:16:52,617 --> 02:16:53,652 ALL THE EFFORTS AND NOVEL 3250 02:16:53,652 --> 02:16:54,386 EFFORTS THE OFFICE IS PUTTING 3251 02:16:54,386 --> 02:16:57,322 FORWARD. 3252 02:16:57,322 --> 02:16:59,391 REALLY TRYING TO STRENGTHEN AND 3253 02:16:59,391 --> 02:17:00,992 HARMONIZE METHODOLOGICAL 3254 02:17:00,992 --> 02:17:02,394 APPROACHES TO PROMOTE SCIENTIFIC 3255 02:17:02,394 --> 02:17:04,029 BEST PRACTICES. 3256 02:17:04,029 --> 02:17:05,997 WE WANT TO ACHIEVE THAT GOLD 3257 02:17:05,997 --> 02:17:08,700 STANDARD OF SCIENTIFIC RIGOR AND 3258 02:17:08,700 --> 02:17:12,738 REPRODUCIBILITY IN THE NUTRITION 3259 02:17:12,738 --> 02:17:22,381 SCIENCES AND DIETARY SUPPLEMENT 3260 02:17:22,381 --> 02:17:26,118 OFFICES AND KUDOS FOR THOSE 3261 02:17:26,118 --> 02:17:31,523 INVOLVED USING THE DATABASES AND 3262 02:17:31,523 --> 02:17:33,592 PREPARING FACT SHEETS. 3263 02:17:33,592 --> 02:17:36,661 WHAT THE OFFICE SUPPORTS ARE A 3264 02:17:36,661 --> 02:17:38,163 TREMENDOUS NATIONAL RESEARCH 3265 02:17:38,163 --> 02:17:45,437 THAT ARE INVALUABLE. 3266 02:17:45,437 --> 02:17:50,375 AS FAR AS STEWARDSHIP MAKING 3267 02:17:50,375 --> 02:17:51,777 SURE IT'S TRANSLATABLE AND 3268 02:17:51,777 --> 02:17:54,212 ACCESSIBLE TO THE PUBLIC. 3269 02:17:54,212 --> 02:17:56,848 THE FACT SHEETS ARE ACCESSED 3270 02:17:56,848 --> 02:17:59,785 THOUSANDS OF TIMES A DAY. 3271 02:17:59,785 --> 02:18:02,287 AND IS THE MOST ACCESSED PART OF 3272 02:18:02,287 --> 02:18:12,531 THE ODS WEBSITES BUT THOSE ARE 3273 02:18:12,531 --> 02:18:14,199 FIRST OF ALL UPDATED BY A TEAM 3274 02:18:14,199 --> 02:18:16,034 AND USED BY PRACTITIONERS AND BY 3275 02:18:16,034 --> 02:18:18,804 THE GENERAL PUBLIC. 3276 02:18:18,804 --> 02:18:22,407 THEY SERVE A MYRIAD OF REASONS 3277 02:18:22,407 --> 02:18:24,776 AND WRITTEN AT THE APPROPRIATE 3278 02:18:24,776 --> 02:18:27,813 LEVEL THEY CAN BE ACTIONABLE AND 3279 02:18:27,813 --> 02:18:30,182 TRANSLATABLE TO A GIVEN 3280 02:18:30,182 --> 02:18:30,449 AUDIENCE. 3281 02:18:30,449 --> 02:18:31,983 AND ALSO ROUNDING OUT THE LAST 3282 02:18:31,983 --> 02:18:35,086 BULLET, COORDINATING AND 3283 02:18:35,086 --> 02:18:38,657 SUPPORTING WORKFORCE AND 3284 02:18:38,657 --> 02:18:43,261 PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT. 3285 02:18:43,261 --> 02:18:44,763 A THEME IN THE OFFICE IS HOW TO 3286 02:18:44,763 --> 02:18:46,998 TRAIN INDIVIDUALS TO DO RIGOROUS 3287 02:18:46,998 --> 02:18:48,166 SCIENCE IN THE SPACE AND MAKE 3288 02:18:48,166 --> 02:18:48,633 THEM TRANSLATABLE AND 3289 02:18:48,633 --> 02:18:58,844 ACTIONABLE. 3290 02:19:04,349 --> 02:19:06,985 AND ONE IS HEALTHY AMERICANS AND 3291 02:19:06,985 --> 02:19:10,355 ALL OF US WANT TO MAKE AMERICANS 3292 02:19:10,355 --> 02:19:12,657 HEALTHY AND WHAT IS THE ROLE OF 3293 02:19:12,657 --> 02:19:14,593 DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS IN THAT 3294 02:19:14,593 --> 02:19:16,761 SPACE AND WE WANT AMERICANS 3295 02:19:16,761 --> 02:19:17,896 HEALTHY THROUGHOUT THE ENTIRE 3296 02:19:17,896 --> 02:19:18,830 LIFE SPAN. 3297 02:19:18,830 --> 02:19:21,233 SO YOU HEAR ME TALK ABOUT 3298 02:19:21,233 --> 02:19:22,400 NUTRITION THROUGHOUT THE LIFE 3299 02:19:22,400 --> 02:19:24,035 SPAN BUT WHAT ARE THE ROLE OF 3300 02:19:24,035 --> 02:19:26,938 DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS IN ADDITION 3301 02:19:26,938 --> 02:19:28,740 TO PATTERNS TO OPTIMIZE HEALTH 3302 02:19:28,740 --> 02:19:31,743 IN CRITICAL PERIODS OF LIFE 3303 02:19:31,743 --> 02:19:33,879 WHERE NEEDS COULD BE DIFFERENT 3304 02:19:33,879 --> 02:19:37,949 WHETHER THE NICU OR THE 3305 02:19:37,949 --> 02:19:42,888 2-YEAR-OLD OR 7-YEAR-OLD OR 3306 02:19:42,888 --> 02:19:45,624 PUBERTAL BOY OR PREGNANT WOMAN 3307 02:19:45,624 --> 02:19:47,259 OR 85-YEAR-OLD WITH OTHER HEALTH 3308 02:19:47,259 --> 02:19:47,692 ISSUES. 3309 02:19:47,692 --> 02:19:54,799 ALL THE OPTIONS HAVE NUANCE D S 3310 02:19:54,799 --> 02:19:58,803 AND WHAT IS THE ROLE OF DIETARY 3311 02:19:58,803 --> 02:20:00,972 SUPPLEMENTS AND HOW CAN THEY BE 3312 02:20:00,972 --> 02:20:04,409 USED TO OPTIMIZE HEALTH AND FACE 3313 02:20:04,409 --> 02:20:04,943 RESILIENCE IN THE FACE OF 3314 02:20:04,943 --> 02:20:13,919 STRESSORS. 3315 02:20:13,919 --> 02:20:15,654 HE CAN TALK FOR WEEKS IT'S 3316 02:20:15,654 --> 02:20:17,789 AMAZING AND HE'S CAFFEINATED. 3317 02:20:17,789 --> 02:20:19,391 WATCH OUT. 3318 02:20:19,391 --> 02:20:20,725 ODS HAS HAD LONG STANDING 3319 02:20:20,725 --> 02:20:22,494 SUPPORT OF OTHER PROGRAMS THAT 3320 02:20:22,494 --> 02:20:24,696 HITS WHERE WE ARE TODAY IN 3321 02:20:24,696 --> 02:20:26,631 ENHANCING RIGOR AND 3322 02:20:26,631 --> 02:20:27,098 REPRODUCIBILITY AND 3323 02:20:27,098 --> 02:20:30,869 METHODOLOGIES. 3324 02:20:30,869 --> 02:20:33,605 I'D LIKE TO DO A SHOUT OUT TO 3325 02:20:33,605 --> 02:20:35,473 THE GROUP FOR BEING AHEAD IN 3326 02:20:35,473 --> 02:20:39,411 THESE SPACES BECAUSE I'LL CALL 3327 02:20:39,411 --> 02:20:41,313 OUT THE ANALYTICAL METHODS AND 3328 02:20:41,313 --> 02:20:47,152 THE CARBON PROGRAM AS BEING 3329 02:20:47,152 --> 02:20:48,086 THINKING ABOUT THESE SPACES NOT 3330 02:20:48,086 --> 02:20:55,260 JUST NOW BUT FOR THE PAST 10 3331 02:20:55,260 --> 02:20:56,494 PLUS YEARS. 3332 02:20:56,494 --> 02:20:57,462 MANY PROGRAMS FOCUS ON 3333 02:20:57,462 --> 02:20:59,030 TRANSLATABILITY AND HOW CAN THE 3334 02:20:59,030 --> 02:21:01,366 SCIENCE BE DONE IN A RIGOROUS 3335 02:21:01,366 --> 02:21:03,101 AND REPRODUCIBLE FASHION AND HOW 3336 02:21:03,101 --> 02:21:08,907 CAN THAT BE TRANSLATABLE TO 3337 02:21:08,907 --> 02:21:10,709 IMPACT PUBLIC HEALTH IN A 3338 02:21:10,709 --> 02:21:13,945 BENEFICIAL MANNER HAS BEEN AN 3339 02:21:13,945 --> 02:21:18,316 OVER ARCHING THEME SINCE THE 3340 02:21:18,316 --> 02:21:18,783 OFFICE'S EXISTENCE. 3341 02:21:18,783 --> 02:21:25,924 AND I WAS CHATTING WITH ADAM AND 3342 02:21:25,924 --> 02:21:26,691 BORROWED THIS QUOTE FROM HIM 3343 02:21:26,691 --> 02:21:28,259 YOU'LL HEAR FROM NEXT AND JUST 3344 02:21:28,259 --> 02:21:30,762 LIKE WE GUIDE PRINCIPLES FOR THE 3345 02:21:30,762 --> 02:21:31,596 OFFICE OF NUTRITION RESEARCH I 3346 02:21:31,596 --> 02:21:37,569 WAS THINKING WHAT'S A GREAT 3347 02:21:37,569 --> 02:21:39,004 PRINCIPLE FOR DIETARY SUPPLEMENT 3348 02:21:39,004 --> 02:21:41,373 AND THE TRANSLATION FROM STUDIES 3349 02:21:41,373 --> 02:21:44,709 STUDYING THE MECHANISTIC HEALTH 3350 02:21:44,709 --> 02:21:45,410 EFFECTS OF SUPPLEMENT TO INFORM 3351 02:21:45,410 --> 02:21:48,013 HEALTH CARE PRACTICES TO MAKE 3352 02:21:48,013 --> 02:21:49,247 THIS ACTIONABLE TO INFORM 3353 02:21:49,247 --> 02:21:50,215 PRACTICES IN INDIVIDUAL'S 3354 02:21:50,215 --> 02:21:54,386 DECISIONS TO USE OR AVOID 3355 02:21:54,386 --> 02:21:56,688 SUPPLEMENTS REQUIRES RIGOROUS 3356 02:21:56,688 --> 02:21:59,624 EVIDENCE BASE THAT'S IN THE PEER 3357 02:21:59,624 --> 02:22:00,825 REVIEWED LITERATURE AND THAT'S 3358 02:22:00,825 --> 02:22:02,761 WHAT WE STRIVE FOR TO SUPPORT 3359 02:22:02,761 --> 02:22:04,896 THE SCIENCE TO GENERATE THE DATA 3360 02:22:04,896 --> 02:22:06,331 TO INFORM THE DECISION MAKERS 3361 02:22:06,331 --> 02:22:10,602 WHETHER IT BE REGULATORY OR THE 3362 02:22:10,602 --> 02:22:12,270 PHYSICIAN FOR THE INDIVIDUAL 3363 02:22:12,270 --> 02:22:14,372 DECIDING WHETHER OR NOT TO TAKE 3364 02:22:14,372 --> 02:22:15,106 A DIETARY SUPPLEMENT. 3365 02:22:15,106 --> 02:22:25,650 AND WITH THAT IT'S A PLEASURE TO 3366 02:22:27,085 --> 02:22:28,920 INTRODUCE ADAM FOR DIETARY 3367 02:22:28,920 --> 02:22:29,220 SUPPLEMENTS. 3368 02:22:29,220 --> 02:22:30,822 IN THE GOVERNMENT IF YOU'RE 3369 02:22:30,822 --> 02:22:32,791 GOING TO HAVE THE INITIATIVE YOU 3370 02:22:32,791 --> 02:22:36,895 HAVE TO HAVE A COOL ACRONYM AND 3371 02:22:36,895 --> 02:22:39,764 HE DID A SPECTACULAR JOB WITH 3372 02:22:39,764 --> 02:22:42,534 RIGOR BECAUSE THAT'S WHAT WE'RE 3373 02:22:42,534 --> 02:22:46,304 ABOUT, RIGOR, REPRODUCIBILITY 3374 02:22:46,304 --> 02:22:48,139 AND I KNOW I SPOKE FOR 35 3375 02:22:48,139 --> 02:22:50,508 MINUTES STRAIGHT BUT I WANTED TO 3376 02:22:50,508 --> 02:23:00,852 GIVE YOU TIME BACK. 3377 02:23:02,454 --> 02:23:05,924 1 3378 02:23:05,924 --> 02:23:08,626 >> THANK YOU FOR ACCELERATING TO 3379 02:23:08,626 --> 02:23:19,070 ALLOW TIME FOR AT THE END. 3380 02:23:20,271 --> 02:23:21,740 >> I'LL ASK TO YOU COMMENT ON 3381 02:23:21,740 --> 02:23:24,909 THE SCIENTIFIC REASONS FOR 3382 02:23:24,909 --> 02:23:30,315 TREATING SUPPLEMENT AL 3383 02:23:30,315 --> 02:23:32,083 SUPPLEMENTS FROM OTHER COMPOUNDS 3384 02:23:32,083 --> 02:23:33,585 AND DRUGS AND I'VE BEEN 3385 02:23:33,585 --> 02:23:34,853 CONCERNED THEY DO MORE HARM THAN 3386 02:23:34,853 --> 02:23:37,222 GOOD AND THERE'S NO REQUIREMENTS 3387 02:23:37,222 --> 02:23:39,557 TO PROVE SAFETY BEFORE YOU SELL 3388 02:23:39,557 --> 02:23:40,325 THEM IS A DANGEROUS REALITY. 3389 02:23:40,325 --> 02:23:43,862 I WANT TO HEAR ABOUT THE REASONS 3390 02:23:43,862 --> 02:23:48,767 WHY THE NIH TREATS THEM 3391 02:23:48,767 --> 02:23:49,067 SEPARATELY. 3392 02:23:49,067 --> 02:23:50,068 WHY AREN'T THEY TREATED LIKE ANY 3393 02:23:50,068 --> 02:24:00,478 OTHER DRUG OR COMPOUND? 3394 02:24:10,455 --> 02:24:13,825 >> I'LL TALK ABOUT THE NIH 3395 02:24:13,825 --> 02:24:17,695 VERSUS THE FDA THE HIGH LEVEL IS 3396 02:24:17,695 --> 02:24:21,800 FOOD IS MORE IN THE FOOD THAN 3397 02:24:21,800 --> 02:24:24,536 DRUG CATEGORY AND HAVE DIFFERENT 3398 02:24:24,536 --> 02:24:24,903 PATHWAYS. 3399 02:24:24,903 --> 02:24:26,404 THE OFFICE SINCE ITS INCEPTION 3400 02:24:26,404 --> 02:24:29,440 HAS BEEN CHARGED TO SUPPORT THE 3401 02:24:29,440 --> 02:24:32,744 SCIENCE TO THEN INFORM DECISION 3402 02:24:32,744 --> 02:24:33,912 MAKERS AND WHERE I THINK YOU'RE 3403 02:24:33,912 --> 02:24:36,815 GOING IS WITH REGULATION AND 3404 02:24:36,815 --> 02:24:38,049 THAT FALLS UNDER THE PURVIEW OF 3405 02:24:38,049 --> 02:24:40,618 THE FDA. 3406 02:24:40,618 --> 02:24:46,391 ONE OF OUR GOALS IS TO ENHANCE 3407 02:24:46,391 --> 02:24:48,927 THE SCIENCE TO ENHANCE OUR 3408 02:24:48,927 --> 02:24:59,304 COLLEAGUES AT THE FDA. 3409 02:25:00,471 --> 02:25:03,308 >> THANK YOU FOR THE OVERVIEW 3410 02:25:03,308 --> 02:25:05,543 AND IF YOU SELL BOTTLES OF YOUR 3411 02:25:05,543 --> 02:25:08,947 ENTHUSIASM SIGN ME UP. 3412 02:25:08,947 --> 02:25:10,381 >> THIS IS NOTHING. 3413 02:25:10,381 --> 02:25:12,917 WAIT UNTIL LATER. 3414 02:25:12,917 --> 02:25:15,587 >> I'M A CLINICIAN AND 3415 02:25:15,587 --> 02:25:17,789 OPHTHALMOLOGIST, WE HAD THE 3416 02:25:17,789 --> 02:25:21,259 BENEFIT OF THE ARAD STUDIES 40 3417 02:25:21,259 --> 02:25:23,061 OR 50 OF THEM WHICH I KNOW YOUR 3418 02:25:23,061 --> 02:25:24,596 OFFICE HELPED SUPPORT OVER THE 3419 02:25:24,596 --> 02:25:24,796 YEARS. 3420 02:25:24,796 --> 02:25:27,232 WHEN I SIT WITH THE PATIENT AND 3421 02:25:27,232 --> 02:25:29,500 ADVISE THEM THEY SHOULD BE 3422 02:25:29,500 --> 02:25:30,902 TAKING A COMBINATION OF VIT 3423 02:25:30,902 --> 02:25:37,709 MAYBES A, E, ZINC AND COPPER I 3424 02:25:37,709 --> 02:25:48,186 HAVE PHENOMENAL DATA UND 3425 02:25:48,186 --> 02:25:50,655 UNDERGIRDING THAT DISCUSSION AND 3426 02:25:50,655 --> 02:25:53,458 PROSPECTIVE RANDOMIZED CONTROL 3427 02:25:53,458 --> 02:25:54,926 TRIALS WITH CLEAR END POINTS AND 3428 02:25:54,926 --> 02:25:58,863 FROM A REPRODUCIBILITY END POINT 3429 02:25:58,863 --> 02:25:59,731 YOU JUST CAN'T GET MUCH BETTER 3430 02:25:59,731 --> 02:26:03,468 THAN THAT IN THE SPACE. 3431 02:26:03,468 --> 02:26:04,002 IN LOOKING THROUGH YOUR 3432 02:26:04,002 --> 02:26:05,803 STRATEGIC PLAN I ONLY SEE THE 3433 02:26:05,803 --> 02:26:09,641 WORDS CLINICAL TRIAL MENTIONED 3434 02:26:09,641 --> 02:26:19,984 FOUR OR FIVE TIMES. 3435 02:26:20,818 --> 02:26:23,254 NHANES IS INHERENT CHALLENGES IN 3436 02:26:23,254 --> 02:26:26,891 THAT AS A DATA RESOURCE. 3437 02:26:26,891 --> 02:26:29,560 IT WILL BE DIFFICULT FOR THE 3438 02:26:29,560 --> 02:26:30,595 PUBLIC AND IT'S DIFFICULT FOR 3439 02:26:30,595 --> 02:26:31,696 PHYSICIANS TO MAKE SENSE OF 3440 02:26:31,696 --> 02:26:32,096 THAT. 3441 02:26:32,096 --> 02:26:35,800 CAN YOU GIVE ME A SENSE OF WHERE 3442 02:26:35,800 --> 02:26:37,969 IN THE PRIORITY CHAIN SUPPORTING 3443 02:26:37,969 --> 02:26:39,971 ADDITIONAL RANDOMIZED CONTROL 3444 02:26:39,971 --> 02:26:43,441 TRIALS OF SUPPLEMENTS AND/OR 3445 02:26:43,441 --> 02:26:44,709 NUTRITIONAL ROUTES SITS WITHIN 3446 02:26:44,709 --> 02:26:47,412 THE OFFICE WHEN YOU PRIORITIZE 3447 02:26:47,412 --> 02:26:57,588 YOUR PROGRAMATIC OPTIONS? 3448 02:26:57,588 --> 02:27:00,925 >> THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION. 3449 02:27:00,925 --> 02:27:09,434 AND ARAD IS A GREAT EXAMPLE OF 3450 02:27:09,434 --> 02:27:12,437 AND THEN INFORM CLINICAL IMPACT 3451 02:27:12,437 --> 02:27:15,974 AND TO YOUR POINT AND HAVE A 3452 02:27:15,974 --> 02:27:20,511 CLINICIAN BE CONFIDENT IN THE 3453 02:27:20,511 --> 02:27:31,055 RECOMMENDATIONS THEY'RE MAKING. 3454 02:27:37,061 --> 02:27:39,197 I LOOK AT THE END POINTS AND 3455 02:27:39,197 --> 02:27:41,032 WHAT THE ANTICIPATED OUTCOMES 3456 02:27:41,032 --> 02:27:51,542 AND WHAT THE METRICS WOULD BE 3457 02:27:54,912 --> 02:27:56,180 SOMETIMES I DON'T LIKE THE WORD 3458 02:27:56,180 --> 02:27:58,082 ONE OFF BUT THINKING ABOUT THE 3459 02:27:58,082 --> 02:28:02,387 BIG TRIALS THAT NEED TO BE DONE 3460 02:28:02,387 --> 02:28:06,991 TO INFORM THE PATIENT 3461 02:28:06,991 --> 02:28:07,291 POPULATION. 3462 02:28:07,291 --> 02:28:09,227 >> WE SPENT THE MORNING TALKING 3463 02:28:09,227 --> 02:28:10,395 ABOUT BIG DATA AND WAYS OF 3464 02:28:10,395 --> 02:28:11,829 MANAGING LARGE DATA SETS. 3465 02:28:11,829 --> 02:28:13,431 THE CHALLENGE WITH THOSE DATA 3466 02:28:13,431 --> 02:28:20,071 SETS IS WITH 90,000 SUPPLEMENS 3467 02:28:20,071 --> 02:28:22,573 AND SO MANY END POINTS THEY'RE 3468 02:28:22,573 --> 02:28:22,907 UNACCOUNTABLE. 3469 02:28:22,907 --> 02:28:24,942 THE FALSE DISCOVERY RATE IS 3470 02:28:24,942 --> 02:28:29,113 TREMENDOUSLY HIGH AND THAT 3471 02:28:29,113 --> 02:28:39,624 INTRINSICALLY LOWERS AND GOLD 3472 02:28:56,808 --> 02:28:57,909 STANDARD SCIENCE IS GOLD 3473 02:28:57,909 --> 02:28:58,376 STANDARD SCIENCE. 3474 02:28:58,376 --> 02:29:01,012 >> THANK YOU FOR THE COMMENT, 3475 02:29:01,012 --> 02:29:05,516 RUSS. 3476 02:29:05,516 --> 02:29:06,417 >> DEFINITE IN THE INTEREST OF 3477 02:29:06,417 --> 02:29:08,052 TIME WE SHOULD MOVE ON. 3478 02:29:08,052 --> 02:29:11,322 WE'RE NOW MOVING TO AN ODS 3479 02:29:11,322 --> 02:29:14,759 PROGRAM UPDATE ON IMPROVING THE 3480 02:29:14,759 --> 02:29:25,269 RIGOR AND REPRODUCIBILITY OF 3481 02:29:27,872 --> 02:29:30,408 DIETARY SUPPLEMENT RESEARCH BY 3482 02:29:30,408 --> 02:29:33,144 ADAM KUSZAK. 3483 02:29:33,144 --> 02:29:34,178 >> THANK YOU FOR THE OPPORTUNITY 3484 02:29:34,178 --> 02:29:34,679 TO UPDATE THE PROGRAM 3485 02:29:34,679 --> 02:29:38,182 ACTIVITIES. 3486 02:29:38,182 --> 02:29:39,217 THE PRIOR CONVERSATION COULDN'T 3487 02:29:39,217 --> 02:29:49,760 HAVE TEED ME UP BETTER ON THIS. 3488 02:29:51,429 --> 02:29:54,565 I'LL HAVE A SYNOPSIS OF THE 3489 02:29:54,565 --> 02:29:58,402 APPROACHES WE'RE ESTABLISHING TO 3490 02:29:58,402 --> 02:29:59,670 FOSTER GREATER KNOWLEDGE OF 3491 02:29:59,670 --> 02:30:00,204 DIETARY SUPPLEMENT HEALTH 3492 02:30:00,204 --> 02:30:05,042 EFFECTS. 3493 02:30:05,042 --> 02:30:06,244 >> I'VE GIVEN YOU PERMISSION TO 3494 02:30:06,244 --> 02:30:16,621 MOVE YOUR OWN SLIDES. 3495 02:30:21,192 --> 02:30:24,228 THE CURRENT LANDSCAPE OF THE 3496 02:30:24,228 --> 02:30:25,830 DIETARY SUPPLEMENT RESEARCH 3497 02:30:25,830 --> 02:30:27,165 INCLUDES A BREADTH OF NIH 3498 02:30:27,165 --> 02:30:28,332 INVESTMENT, A NUMBER OF GOOD 3499 02:30:28,332 --> 02:30:32,003 PRACTICE GUIDELINES WITH VARY 3500 02:30:32,003 --> 02:30:34,105 AND APPLICABILITY TO DIETARY 3501 02:30:34,105 --> 02:30:36,908 SUPPLEMENTS AND HISTORY OF ODS 3502 02:30:36,908 --> 02:30:38,309 AND BROADER NIH RESEARCH 3503 02:30:38,309 --> 02:30:40,545 SUPPORTING RIGOR AND 3504 02:30:40,545 --> 02:30:41,179 REPRODUCIBILITY. 3505 02:30:41,179 --> 02:30:44,849 EVEN SO, INHERENT CHALLENGES IN 3506 02:30:44,849 --> 02:30:45,950 CONDUCTING TRANSLATABLE 3507 02:30:45,950 --> 02:30:47,885 INTERVENTION RESEARCH ALONG WITH 3508 02:30:47,885 --> 02:30:48,953 THE CHEMICALLY COMPLEX 3509 02:30:48,953 --> 02:30:52,023 FORMULATION ARE DIETARY 3510 02:30:52,023 --> 02:30:54,192 SUPPLEMENTS HAS YIELDED AN 3511 02:30:54,192 --> 02:30:58,396 EVIDENCE BASE THAT CAN BE JUDGED 3512 02:30:58,396 --> 02:30:59,330 AS HETEROGENEOUS AND DIFFICULT 3513 02:30:59,330 --> 02:31:01,165 TO GENERALIZE TO PUBLIC HEALTH 3514 02:31:01,165 --> 02:31:01,766 OUTCOMES. 3515 02:31:01,766 --> 02:31:03,367 ODS IS ADDRESSING THE STATE OF 3516 02:31:03,367 --> 02:31:05,136 THE SCIENCE AS AN OPPORTUNITY 3517 02:31:05,136 --> 02:31:07,638 FOR EXPANDED PROGRAM ACTIVITIES 3518 02:31:07,638 --> 02:31:11,042 DEVELOPING REPRODUCIBILITY AND 3519 02:31:11,042 --> 02:31:13,878 INTEGRITY GUIDANCE TO OPTIMIZE 3520 02:31:13,878 --> 02:31:15,980 RESEARCH FOR DIETARY GUIDANCE. 3521 02:31:15,980 --> 02:31:20,985 I'LL INTRODUCE ACTIVITIES 3522 02:31:20,985 --> 02:31:22,787 GUIDANCE AND PORTFOLIO ANALYSES 3523 02:31:22,787 --> 02:31:24,622 WITH THE GOALS OF IDENTIFYING 3524 02:31:24,622 --> 02:31:26,390 AND PRIORITIZING RESEARCH AND 3525 02:31:26,390 --> 02:31:32,363 RESOURCE NEEDS. 3526 02:31:32,363 --> 02:31:33,698 THESE ACTIVITIES WILL DRIVE NEW 3527 02:31:33,698 --> 02:31:38,035 SERVICES TO STIMULATE RIGOR AND 3528 02:31:38,035 --> 02:31:39,670 COMPARABILITY AND REPLICABILITY 3529 02:31:39,670 --> 02:31:46,377 TOWARD A VISION OF A MORE ROBUST 3530 02:31:46,377 --> 02:31:47,678 EVIDENCE BASE. 3531 02:31:47,678 --> 02:31:54,385 I APPRECIATE DR. BREM ER'S 3532 02:31:54,385 --> 02:31:57,355 UPDATE EARLIER. 3533 02:31:57,355 --> 02:31:58,522 WITH PARTNERS AND COLLEAGUES 3534 02:31:58,522 --> 02:32:04,295 ACROSS NIH WE HAVE TRANSLATION 3535 02:32:04,295 --> 02:32:05,529 TO CATALYZE RESEARCH AND SUPPORT 3536 02:32:05,529 --> 02:32:06,163 CAPACITY BUILDING. 3537 02:32:06,163 --> 02:32:08,332 ABOUT A YEAR AGO NOW IN THINKING 3538 02:32:08,332 --> 02:32:09,267 ABOUT THE RESEARCH PORTFOLIO AND 3539 02:32:09,267 --> 02:32:12,169 WHERE TO AMPLIFY OUR PROGRAM 3540 02:32:12,169 --> 02:32:13,571 EFFORTS, WE ASKED WHAT MORE 3541 02:32:13,571 --> 02:32:16,307 COULD ODS TO INCREASE THE 3542 02:32:16,307 --> 02:32:17,308 STRENGTH AND RELIABILITY OF 3543 02:32:17,308 --> 02:32:23,447 DIETARY SUPPLEMENT SCIENCE. 3544 02:32:23,447 --> 02:32:24,782 THE NIH'S RESEARCH PORTFOLIO 3545 02:32:24,782 --> 02:32:26,117 RELEVANT TO UNDERSTANDING THE 3546 02:32:26,117 --> 02:32:28,586 HEALTH EFFECTS COVERS A LARGE 3547 02:32:28,586 --> 02:32:31,922 BREATH OF PHYSIOLOGICAL SYSTEMS 3548 02:32:31,922 --> 02:32:38,396 AND HEALTH CONDITIONS. 3549 02:32:38,396 --> 02:32:40,831 WITH MECHANISMS OF ACTION AND 3550 02:32:40,831 --> 02:32:42,400 SUPPLEMENTS IN DISEASE STATE 3551 02:32:42,400 --> 02:32:51,275 OUTCOMES. 3552 02:32:51,275 --> 02:32:53,210 AND TRANSLATION OF THE 3553 02:32:53,210 --> 02:32:55,513 MECHANISTIC AND HEALTH OUTCOMES 3554 02:32:55,513 --> 02:32:56,814 RESEARCH TO INFORM HEALTH CARE 3555 02:32:56,814 --> 02:32:57,982 PRACTICES AT THE INDIVIDUAL 3556 02:32:57,982 --> 02:32:59,617 LEVEL TO USE OR AVOID 3557 02:32:59,617 --> 02:33:01,052 SUPPLEMENTS AND AT THE 3558 02:33:01,052 --> 02:33:03,554 POPULATION LEVEL FOR CLINICAL 3559 02:33:03,554 --> 02:33:08,259 PRACTICE REQUIRES THAT RIGOROUS 3560 02:33:08,259 --> 02:33:10,394 EVIDENCE BASE THAT'S 3561 02:33:10,394 --> 02:33:11,629 REPRODUCIBLE AND ACCURATELY 3562 02:33:11,629 --> 02:33:11,896 REPORTED. 3563 02:33:11,896 --> 02:33:14,398 I COULDN'T HAVE SET UP THE 3564 02:33:14,398 --> 02:33:15,399 CONVERSATION BETTER IN THE PRIOR 3565 02:33:15,399 --> 02:33:16,167 CONVERSATION. 3566 02:33:16,167 --> 02:33:17,968 THERE'S SEVERAL EXAMPLES OF 3567 02:33:17,968 --> 02:33:20,538 WHERE A ROBUST EVIDENCE BASE FOR 3568 02:33:20,538 --> 02:33:21,572 DIETARY SUPPLEMENT HEALTH 3569 02:33:21,572 --> 02:33:22,640 AFFECTS WILL BE ESTABLISHED AND 3570 02:33:22,640 --> 02:33:24,608 ONE GOOD EXAMPLE IS THE 3571 02:33:24,608 --> 02:33:25,876 AGE-RELATED EYE DISEASE STUDIES 3572 02:33:25,876 --> 02:33:27,645 LED BY THE NATIONAL EYE 3573 02:33:27,645 --> 02:33:31,982 INSTITUTE WHERE A WELL DEFINED 3574 02:33:31,982 --> 02:33:34,285 DIETARY INGREDIENT FORMULATION 3575 02:33:34,285 --> 02:33:37,355 WERE THOROUGHLY TESTED AND 3576 02:33:37,355 --> 02:33:42,393 REFINED THROUGH RTCs AND STUDIES 3577 02:33:42,393 --> 02:33:43,794 HAVE CONFIRMED BENEFICIAL 3578 02:33:43,794 --> 02:33:47,131 EFFECTS ON SLOWING MACULAR 3579 02:33:47,131 --> 02:33:47,898 DEGENERATION AND ADDITIONAL 3580 02:33:47,898 --> 02:33:54,004 BENEFITS AND STAGES OF MACULAR 3581 02:33:54,004 --> 02:33:54,372 DEGENERATION. 3582 02:33:54,372 --> 02:33:58,109 SIGNIFICANT FINDINGS, METHOD 3583 02:33:58,109 --> 02:34:01,045 LOGICALLY EXPANDED UPON THROUGH 3584 02:34:01,045 --> 02:34:05,149 APPROACH AND RIGOROUS STUDY 3585 02:34:05,149 --> 02:34:08,753 DESIGN AND TRUSTWORTHY SCIENCE 3586 02:34:08,753 --> 02:34:12,890 CONFIDENTLY COMMUNICATED TO THE 3587 02:34:12,890 --> 02:34:13,124 PUBLIC. 3588 02:34:13,124 --> 02:34:15,493 AT THE SAME TIME THERE'S 3589 02:34:15,493 --> 02:34:16,994 CHALLENGES TO DIETARY SUPPLEMENT 3590 02:34:16,994 --> 02:34:17,261 RESEARCH. 3591 02:34:17,261 --> 02:34:19,964 STUDIES THAT ARE EXCLUDED FROM 3592 02:34:19,964 --> 02:34:23,067 SYSTEMIC REVIEWS AND 3593 02:34:23,067 --> 02:34:25,202 META-ANALYSES ARE OFTEN TELLING 3594 02:34:25,202 --> 02:34:30,207 THE LIMITATIONS ARE COMMONLY 3595 02:34:30,207 --> 02:34:31,375 CITED SUCH AS RANDOMIZATION OR 3596 02:34:31,375 --> 02:34:35,045 NO BLINDING, LACK OF VALIDATED 3597 02:34:35,045 --> 02:34:37,148 BIOMARKERS OR IRRELEVANT HEALTH 3598 02:34:37,148 --> 02:34:39,150 OUTCOME MEASURES AND DURATION OR 3599 02:34:39,150 --> 02:34:41,318 NO FOLLOW-UP UNDERMINING 3600 02:34:41,318 --> 02:34:42,386 RESEARCH COMPARABILITY. 3601 02:34:42,386 --> 02:34:44,755 IN ADDITION TO THESE BROADER 3602 02:34:44,755 --> 02:34:47,291 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH CHALLENGES, 3603 02:34:47,291 --> 02:34:48,926 DIETARY SUPPLEMENT STUDIES MUST 3604 02:34:48,926 --> 02:34:50,728 ALSO CONTEND WITH CHALLENGES IN 3605 02:34:50,728 --> 02:34:53,731 ASSESSING INTAKE AND STATUS AS 3606 02:34:53,731 --> 02:34:55,299 WELL AS DIFFICULTIES IN 3607 02:34:55,299 --> 02:34:57,668 INTERPRETING AND COMPARE RESULTS 3608 02:34:57,668 --> 02:34:59,270 ACROSS NUMEROUS INGREDIENT 3609 02:34:59,270 --> 02:35:00,604 FORMULATIONS THAT CAN BE 3610 02:35:00,604 --> 02:35:02,006 THOROUGHLY OR MINIMALLY 3611 02:35:02,006 --> 02:35:02,606 CHARACTERIZED OR ANYWHERE IN 3612 02:35:02,606 --> 02:35:09,547 BETWEEN. 3613 02:35:09,547 --> 02:35:15,453 ODS ASKS HOW TO IMPROVE EFFORTS 3614 02:35:15,453 --> 02:35:16,187 OF RELATED NUTRITIONAL RESEARCH 3615 02:35:16,187 --> 02:35:19,957 AND HOW CAN ODS PROMOTE 3616 02:35:19,957 --> 02:35:21,792 COMPARABILITY AN GREATER 3617 02:35:21,792 --> 02:35:22,426 REPRODUCIBILITY AND WHAT ARE 3618 02:35:22,426 --> 02:35:23,761 ADDITIONAL APPROACHES TO 3619 02:35:23,761 --> 02:35:26,130 IDENTIFY AND PRIORITIZE NEEDS 3620 02:35:26,130 --> 02:35:27,565 AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR ADVANCING 3621 02:35:27,565 --> 02:35:28,432 ANALYTICAL SCIENCES AND 3622 02:35:28,432 --> 02:35:39,109 INCREASING RESEARCH CAPACITY. 3623 02:35:39,109 --> 02:35:41,011 AND PROMOTE FURTHER PROGRESS IN 3624 02:35:41,011 --> 02:35:42,179 THE RIGOR WITH WHICH DIETARY 3625 02:35:42,179 --> 02:35:44,381 SUPPLEMENT STUDIES ARE DESIGN, 3626 02:35:44,381 --> 02:35:44,915 CONDUCTED, EVALUATED AND 3627 02:35:44,915 --> 02:35:50,387 REPORTED. 3628 02:35:50,387 --> 02:35:53,190 AND INTEGRITY GUIDANCE TO 3629 02:35:53,190 --> 02:35:53,824 OPTIMIZE RESEARCH FOR DIETARY 3630 02:35:53,824 --> 02:35:58,429 SCIENCE OR RIGOR. 3631 02:35:58,429 --> 02:35:59,897 RIGOR INCLUDES A FEW INITIATED 3632 02:35:59,897 --> 02:36:05,336 AND PLANNED ACTIVITIES. 3633 02:36:05,336 --> 02:36:06,770 ODS WILL ENGAGE WITH THE 3634 02:36:06,770 --> 02:36:08,405 RESEARCH COMMUNITY TO CLARIFY, 3635 02:36:08,405 --> 02:36:10,374 ELABORATE AND UPDATE 3636 02:36:10,374 --> 02:36:12,076 RECOMMENDATIONS FOR CHEMICALLY 3637 02:36:12,076 --> 02:36:12,710 CHARACTERIZING DIETARY 3638 02:36:12,710 --> 02:36:14,378 SUPPLEMENT INGREDIENTS AND 3639 02:36:14,378 --> 02:36:15,713 PRODUCTS USED AS EXPERIMENTAL 3640 02:36:15,713 --> 02:36:26,190 AND CLINICAL INTERVENTIONS. 3641 02:36:30,394 --> 02:36:32,963 AROUND TO BETTER UNDERSTAND HOW 3642 02:36:32,963 --> 02:36:34,498 NIH CAN PROMOTE WELL FORMULATE 3643 02:36:34,498 --> 02:36:36,600 AND COMPARABLE ACROSS THE FIELD. 3644 02:36:36,600 --> 02:36:39,770 AND ODS IS LEADING A 3645 02:36:39,770 --> 02:36:40,304 CHARACTERIZATION OF THE 3646 02:36:40,304 --> 02:36:43,674 PORTFOLIO OF NIH SUPPLEMENT 3647 02:36:43,674 --> 02:36:46,977 RESEARCH AS A FIRST STEP TOWARDS 3648 02:36:46,977 --> 02:36:48,212 IDENTIFYING CAPACITY BUILDING 3649 02:36:48,212 --> 02:36:49,947 NEEDS WHERE NEW RESOURCES CAN 3650 02:36:49,947 --> 02:36:52,116 FURTHER ENCOURAGE WELL 3651 02:36:52,116 --> 02:36:53,350 CONTROLLED DESIGNS THAT FOR 3652 02:36:53,350 --> 02:36:55,219 EXAMPLE REDUCE MEASUREMENT BIAS 3653 02:36:55,219 --> 02:36:58,088 OR FACILITATE THE DEVELOPMENT OF 3654 02:36:58,088 --> 02:36:58,722 VALIDATED BIOMARKERS AND OUTCOME 3655 02:36:58,722 --> 02:37:08,899 MEASURES. 3656 02:37:12,670 --> 02:37:14,538 IT HOLDS TRUE WHEN THEY'RE DONE 3657 02:37:14,538 --> 02:37:17,641 WITH BOTANICALS AND NATURAL 3658 02:37:17,641 --> 02:37:20,644 PRODUCTS AND OTHER DIETARY 3659 02:37:20,644 --> 02:37:22,379 INTERVENTIONS THE DATA WILL BE 3660 02:37:22,379 --> 02:37:26,383 IRREPRODUCIBLE AND DIFFICULT TO 3661 02:37:26,383 --> 02:37:26,650 INTERPRET. 3662 02:37:26,650 --> 02:37:28,886 FOLLOWING STEPS FROM COLLEAGUES, 3663 02:37:28,886 --> 02:37:30,554 ODS HAS IMPLEMENTED NATURAL 3664 02:37:30,554 --> 02:37:32,323 PRODUCT AND DIETARY SUPPLEMENT 3665 02:37:32,323 --> 02:37:34,191 INTEGRITY GUIDANCE TO AID IN THE 3666 02:37:34,191 --> 02:37:34,725 DESIGN AND EVALUATION OF 3667 02:37:34,725 --> 02:37:37,361 RESEARCH. 3668 02:37:37,361 --> 02:37:39,863 THESE GUIDELINES EMPHASIZE THE 3669 02:37:39,863 --> 02:37:42,166 IMPORTANCE OF CHARACTERIZING THE 3670 02:37:42,166 --> 02:37:43,400 SUPPLEMENT UNDER INVESTIGATION 3671 02:37:43,400 --> 02:37:45,703 FOR ITS CHEMICAL COMPOSITION, 3672 02:37:45,703 --> 02:37:48,138 IDENTITY AND AUTHENTICITY AND 3673 02:37:48,138 --> 02:37:50,975 STABILITY AND ALL FOR A 3674 02:37:50,975 --> 02:37:51,575 REPRODUCIBLE PREPARATION. 3675 02:37:51,575 --> 02:37:53,611 WE ALSO FOUND IN THAT TIME THE 3676 02:37:53,611 --> 02:37:55,112 GUIDELINES HAVE NOT ALWAYS BEEN 3677 02:37:55,112 --> 02:37:56,714 CONSISTENTLY COMMUNICATED IN A 3678 02:37:56,714 --> 02:37:59,016 CLEAR AND ACTIONABLE MANNER. 3679 02:37:59,016 --> 02:38:02,119 AS SUCH WE WILL NOT ONLY UPDATE 3680 02:38:02,119 --> 02:38:03,887 THE GUIDANCE TO INCLUDE 3681 02:38:03,887 --> 02:38:04,788 TECHNICAL ADVANCES AND 3682 02:38:04,788 --> 02:38:07,124 CONSIDERATIONS OF METABOLISM AND 3683 02:38:07,124 --> 02:38:09,193 BIO AVAILABILITY BUT ODS WILL 3684 02:38:09,193 --> 02:38:11,562 WORK WITH PARTNER I.C.s TO 3685 02:38:11,562 --> 02:38:12,196 DEVELOP APPROACHES TO DEVELOP 3686 02:38:12,196 --> 02:38:14,632 THE GUIDELINES ARE MORE 3687 02:38:14,632 --> 02:38:18,702 APPLICABLE AND USEFUL TO THE 3688 02:38:18,702 --> 02:38:19,670 BROADER RESEARCH COMMUNITY. 3689 02:38:19,670 --> 02:38:21,705 IN THE INITIATING PORTFOLIO 3690 02:38:21,705 --> 02:38:24,408 ANALYSIS ACTIVITIES WE ARE 3691 02:38:24,408 --> 02:38:25,342 PARTNERING WITH COLLEAGUES 3692 02:38:25,342 --> 02:38:28,345 ACROSS THE DIVISION AND ASKING 3693 02:38:28,345 --> 02:38:31,081 TO WHAT EXTENSION IT'S FOCUSSED 3694 02:38:31,081 --> 02:38:32,082 ON HEALTH OPTIMIZATION, 3695 02:38:32,082 --> 02:38:33,717 RESILIENCE AND THE PREVENTION OF 3696 02:38:33,717 --> 02:38:37,121 CHRONIC DISEASES COMPARED TO 3697 02:38:37,121 --> 02:38:38,389 MECHANISMS, METABOLISM OR 3698 02:38:38,389 --> 02:38:42,393 DISEASE MANAGEMENT TOPICS AS 3699 02:38:42,393 --> 02:38:43,694 EXEMPLIFIED WITH THE SCOPING 3700 02:38:43,694 --> 02:38:46,096 ESTIMATES FOR A SMALL COHORT OF 3701 02:38:46,096 --> 02:38:49,099 CLINICAL TRIAL STUDIES. 3702 02:38:49,099 --> 02:38:50,801 WE'RE ALSO IMPROVING OUR OWN 3703 02:38:50,801 --> 02:38:52,670 TOOL KIT IN COLLABORATION WITH 3704 02:38:52,670 --> 02:38:54,438 THE OFFICE OF PORTFOLIO ANALYSIS 3705 02:38:54,438 --> 02:38:56,607 TO BETTER CHARACTERIZE WHICH 3706 02:38:56,607 --> 02:38:58,108 INGREDIENTS AND IMPORTANTLY WHAT 3707 02:38:58,108 --> 02:39:00,678 COMBINATIONS OF INGREDIENTS AND 3708 02:39:00,678 --> 02:39:02,579 DOSES ARE BEING STUDIED FOR 3709 02:39:02,579 --> 02:39:04,548 EFFICACY OR EFFECTIVENESS FOR 3710 02:39:04,548 --> 02:39:07,718 DIFFERENT HEALTH CONDITIONS AND 3711 02:39:07,718 --> 02:39:09,119 POPULATIONS AND FROM THIS WILL 3712 02:39:09,119 --> 02:39:10,988 ENHANCE OUR ABILITY TO IDENTIFY 3713 02:39:10,988 --> 02:39:14,391 EMERGING OPPORTUNITY AREAS. 3714 02:39:14,391 --> 02:39:15,259 IN THE LOWER RIGHT PRELIMINARY 3715 02:39:15,259 --> 02:39:18,228 EXAMPLE HERE WE'RE LOOKING NOT 3716 02:39:18,228 --> 02:39:19,830 ONLY AT WHERE CERTAIN VITAMINS 3717 02:39:19,830 --> 02:39:24,101 OR PHYTO CHEMICALS ARE BEING 3718 02:39:24,101 --> 02:39:27,171 STUDIED BUT WHERE THEY'RE BEING 3719 02:39:27,171 --> 02:39:37,114 STUDIED IN COMBINATION. 3720 02:39:37,114 --> 02:39:39,016 AND LOOK AT WHERE THEY'VE IN 3721 02:39:39,016 --> 02:39:39,683 CERTAIN POPULATIONS AND ASSESS 3722 02:39:39,683 --> 02:39:42,352 THE STATE OF SCIENCE WHERE 3723 02:39:42,352 --> 02:39:43,120 REPRODUCIBILITY AND 3724 02:39:43,120 --> 02:39:45,089 TRANSLATABILITY FROM THE 3725 02:39:45,089 --> 02:39:46,623 PERSPECTIVE OF EXPERIMENTAL 3726 02:39:46,623 --> 02:39:49,093 MODELS AND DURATION AND OUTCOME 3727 02:39:49,093 --> 02:39:49,893 MEASURES. 3728 02:39:49,893 --> 02:39:52,162 FOR EXAMPLE, WE CAN CONSIDER 3729 02:39:52,162 --> 02:39:52,963 WHERE MEANINGFUL OUTCOME 3730 02:39:52,963 --> 02:39:55,099 MEASURES MAY BE LACKING AND 3731 02:39:55,099 --> 02:39:56,200 LIMITING THE GENERALIZABILITY OF 3732 02:39:56,200 --> 02:40:05,375 DIETARY SUPPLEMENT RESEARCH. 3733 02:40:05,375 --> 02:40:07,111 COLLECTIVELY THEY'LL STAND UP 3734 02:40:07,111 --> 02:40:08,679 IMPACTFUL APPROACHES TO PROMOTE 3735 02:40:08,679 --> 02:40:13,117 THE STUDY OF MORE REPLICABLE 3736 02:40:13,117 --> 02:40:14,551 DIETARY INTERVENTIONS AND 3737 02:40:14,551 --> 02:40:18,388 ADDRESS METHODOLOGICAL 3738 02:40:18,388 --> 02:40:20,124 CHALLENGES. 3739 02:40:20,124 --> 02:40:24,094 IN THE LONGER TERM RIGOR AIMS TO 3740 02:40:24,094 --> 02:40:25,095 CONSOLIDATE RESEARCH BEST 3741 02:40:25,095 --> 02:40:26,196 PRACTICES. 3742 02:40:26,196 --> 02:40:29,166 STIMULATE REPRODUCIBLE DIETARY 3743 02:40:29,166 --> 02:40:31,902 SUPPLEMENT RESEARCH MORE READILY 3744 02:40:31,902 --> 02:40:33,036 TRANSLATABLE TO UNDERSTAND 3745 02:40:33,036 --> 02:40:33,971 SAFETY, EFFICACY AND 3746 02:40:33,971 --> 02:40:37,207 EFFECTIVENESS AND PROMOTE AN 3747 02:40:37,207 --> 02:40:38,809 INCREASINGLY ROBUST EVIDENCE 3748 02:40:38,809 --> 02:40:41,812 BASE THAT'S MORE INFORMATIVE AND 3749 02:40:41,812 --> 02:40:43,013 ACTIONABLE TO HEALTH CARE 3750 02:40:43,013 --> 02:40:43,514 DECISIONS AND CLINICAL 3751 02:40:43,514 --> 02:40:47,217 PRACTICES. 3752 02:40:47,217 --> 02:40:48,218 I'M VERY GRATEFUL FOR THE 3753 02:40:48,218 --> 02:40:50,554 SUPPORT AND CONTRIBUTIONS OF 3754 02:40:50,554 --> 02:40:52,489 MANY COLLEAGUES, ODS LEADERSHIP 3755 02:40:52,489 --> 02:40:55,092 AND THE ENTIRE ODS TEAM AS WELL 3756 02:40:55,092 --> 02:40:56,460 AS PARTNERSHIP WITH COLLEAGUES 3757 02:40:56,460 --> 02:41:02,132 FROM NCCIH, ODP, OBSSR AND OPA 3758 02:41:02,132 --> 02:41:02,966 AND THANK YOU THE COUNCIL FOR 3759 02:41:02,966 --> 02:41:03,734 YOUR TIME. 3760 02:41:03,734 --> 02:41:05,169 I APPRECIATE BEING ABLE TO HEAR 3761 02:41:05,169 --> 02:41:06,370 YOUR FEEDBACK AND ANSWER YOUR 3762 02:41:06,370 --> 02:41:16,547 QUESTIONS. 3763 02:41:16,880 --> 02:41:18,382 >> THANK YOU, ADAM. 3764 02:41:18,382 --> 02:41:19,683 IF COUNCIL MEMBERS HAVE 3765 02:41:19,683 --> 02:41:22,586 QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS, PLEASE 3766 02:41:22,586 --> 02:41:24,655 RAISE YOUR HAND. 3767 02:41:24,655 --> 02:41:27,691 I APPRECIATE BOTH THE 3768 02:41:27,691 --> 02:41:31,094 PRESENTATIONS. 3769 02:41:31,094 --> 02:41:35,766 ARE YOU FOCUSSING PRIMARILY ON 3770 02:41:35,766 --> 02:41:42,372 DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS THAT ARE 3771 02:41:42,372 --> 02:41:43,574 AVAILABLE FROM YOUR DOCTOR OR 3772 02:41:43,574 --> 02:41:46,376 OVER THE COUNTER AND I HAVE A 3773 02:41:46,376 --> 02:41:48,045 FOLLOW-UP AFTER THAT. 3774 02:41:48,045 --> 02:41:49,847 >> FOR THE OFFICE OF DIETARY 3775 02:41:49,847 --> 02:41:53,483 SUPPLEMENTS IT'S NOT LIMITED TO 3776 02:41:53,483 --> 02:41:54,351 THOSE CATEGORIES. 3777 02:41:54,351 --> 02:41:56,053 MAYBE FOR EXAMPLE WHETHER YOUR 3778 02:41:56,053 --> 02:42:04,561 DOCTOR PRESCRIBES A PRENATAL 3779 02:42:04,561 --> 02:42:05,596 SUPPLEMENT OR CHOOSE TO PURCHASE 3780 02:42:05,596 --> 02:42:06,797 ONE FROM THE PHARMACY. 3781 02:42:06,797 --> 02:42:08,265 THERE'S NOT A FOCUS ON ONE 3782 02:42:08,265 --> 02:42:09,399 CATEGORY OR APPROACH THERE. 3783 02:42:09,399 --> 02:42:11,768 >> OKAY. 3784 02:42:11,768 --> 02:42:15,672 IN THAT REGARD, UNLESS I MISSED 3785 02:42:15,672 --> 02:42:22,145 IT OR YOU DIDN'T SAY IT, I THINK 3786 02:42:22,145 --> 02:42:23,513 YOU'RE MAYBE MISSING AN 3787 02:42:23,513 --> 02:42:24,815 OPPORTUNITY HERE BECAUSE DIETARY 3788 02:42:24,815 --> 02:42:26,049 SUPPLEMENTS THEN PEOPLE CAN GET 3789 02:42:26,049 --> 02:42:27,718 THEM FOR SELF-MEDICATION. 3790 02:42:27,718 --> 02:42:29,186 SO IF YOU'RE CONDUCTING THE 3791 02:42:29,186 --> 02:42:33,390 RESEARCH AND THEN PUBLISHING IT 3792 02:42:33,390 --> 02:42:36,927 IN THE SCIENTIFIC REALM, THAT 3793 02:42:36,927 --> 02:42:38,695 DOESN'T GET TO THE GENERAL 3794 02:42:38,695 --> 02:42:39,196 PUBLIC. 3795 02:42:39,196 --> 02:42:40,697 I THINK YOU MIGHT TO CONSIDER 3796 02:42:40,697 --> 02:42:42,366 WAYS TO GET WHAT YOU DO OUT TO 3797 02:42:42,366 --> 02:42:43,767 THE GENERAL PUBLIC. 3798 02:42:43,767 --> 02:42:45,702 AS YOU KNOW, NOT ONLY THERE'S 3799 02:42:45,702 --> 02:42:49,907 BENEFITS TO SOME DIETARY 3800 02:42:49,907 --> 02:42:56,013 SUPPLEMENTS BUT SOME CLAIMS IN 3801 02:42:56,013 --> 02:43:02,052 WHICH THEY'RE RECOMMENDED BUT IF 3802 02:43:02,052 --> 02:43:03,954 THEY'RE NOT FROM THEY WON'T BE 3803 02:43:03,954 --> 02:43:04,655 SEEN BY THE PUBLIC. 3804 02:43:04,655 --> 02:43:07,958 >> IT'S TRUE. 3805 02:43:07,958 --> 02:43:11,728 WE'RE ALWAYS LOOKING LOOKING TO 3806 02:43:11,728 --> 02:43:12,496 GET PEOPLE THE INFORMATION THEY 3807 02:43:12,496 --> 02:43:23,040 WANT AND NEED IN WAYS THEY CAN 3808 02:43:29,947 --> 02:43:30,948 WE'RE TRYING TO EXPAND AND 3809 02:43:30,948 --> 02:43:34,551 DIGEST THE TOTALITY OF THE 3810 02:43:34,551 --> 02:43:36,853 BIOMEDICAL LITERATURE AND BE 3811 02:43:36,853 --> 02:43:38,655 ABLE TO SUMMARIZE IT IN A CLEAR 3812 02:43:38,655 --> 02:43:41,858 MANNER THAT IF YOU HAVE A 3813 02:43:41,858 --> 02:43:43,427 QUESTION, IS THIS INGREDIENT 3814 02:43:43,427 --> 02:43:45,696 GOING TO GIVE ME SOME HEALTH 3815 02:43:45,696 --> 02:43:47,564 BENEFIT OR IS THERE SOME 3816 02:43:47,564 --> 02:43:48,298 POTENTIAL CONCERN FOR A 3817 02:43:48,298 --> 02:43:48,765 PARTICULAR CONDITION. 3818 02:43:48,765 --> 02:43:51,735 WE REALLY TRY TO RELAY THAT 3819 02:43:51,735 --> 02:43:54,905 INFORMATION BEST AS WE CAN AND 3820 02:43:54,905 --> 02:43:57,441 IT'S ALSO A PLACE WHERE AS 3821 02:43:57,441 --> 02:44:00,911 RESEARCHERS CAN TAKE A LOOK AND 3822 02:44:00,911 --> 02:44:04,648 ALSO SEE WHERE THERE'S FURTHER 3823 02:44:04,648 --> 02:44:05,916 RESEARCH TO SHED MORE LIGHT ON 3824 02:44:05,916 --> 02:44:06,917 THE TOPIC. 3825 02:44:06,917 --> 02:44:09,219 FOR EXAMPLE, IN OUR FACT SHEETS 3826 02:44:09,219 --> 02:44:12,756 WE DO TALK ABOUT WHERE A FEW 3827 02:44:12,756 --> 02:44:14,491 STUDIES NOT VERY LARGE SAMPLE 3828 02:44:14,491 --> 02:44:17,394 SIZE VERY DIFFERENT DOSES OR 3829 02:44:17,394 --> 02:44:19,262 FORMULATIONS LOOKED AT AND SO 3830 02:44:19,262 --> 02:44:29,773 FURTHER INVESTIGATION NEEDED. 3831 02:44:32,509 --> 02:44:34,311 >> PLEASE GO AHEAD. 3832 02:44:34,311 --> 02:44:35,579 >> THIS MAY BE MORE OF A 3833 02:44:35,579 --> 02:44:37,447 QUESTION FOR DR. BREMER AGAIN 3834 02:44:37,447 --> 02:44:41,318 BUT AS DR. BREMER IS CURRENTLY 3835 02:44:41,318 --> 02:44:46,056 THE ACTING DIRECTOR AND DIRECTOR 3836 02:44:46,056 --> 02:44:47,657 OF ODS IN THIS APPARENT SEASON 3837 02:44:47,657 --> 02:44:50,394 OF LOOKING FOR OPPORTUNITIES TO 3838 02:44:50,394 --> 02:44:55,499 CONSOLIDATE AND SYNERGIZE I'D BE 3839 02:44:55,499 --> 02:44:57,701 CURIOUS ON THOUGHTS OF STRENGTHS 3840 02:44:57,701 --> 02:45:01,805 AND WEAKNESSES OF HAVING TWO 3841 02:45:01,805 --> 02:45:04,274 OFFICES WITHIN DPCPSI THAT HAVE 3842 02:45:04,274 --> 02:45:05,375 FAIRLY OVERLAPPING INTERESTS AS 3843 02:45:05,375 --> 02:45:15,852 WE'VE DISCUSSED HERE TODAY. 3844 02:45:18,388 --> 02:45:19,256 >> THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTION. 3845 02:45:19,256 --> 02:45:25,195 I SEE THE OFFICE AS A SPECTRUM. 3846 02:45:25,195 --> 02:45:26,763 AND IS THE OFFICE OF DIETARY 3847 02:45:26,763 --> 02:45:30,434 SUPPLEMENT AND ONR WORK HAND IN 3848 02:45:30,434 --> 02:45:33,303 HAND AND THE TEAM HAVE SPENT A 3849 02:45:33,303 --> 02:45:34,938 NUMBER OF YEARS FOCUSSED ON THE 3850 02:45:34,938 --> 02:45:38,241 INPUT OF THE DIETARY 3851 02:45:38,241 --> 02:45:46,349 SUPPLEMENTS. 3852 02:45:46,349 --> 02:45:47,451 THE NUTRITION RESEARCH OFFICE 3853 02:45:47,451 --> 02:45:54,391 OUR GOAL IS TO FOCUS ON THE 3854 02:45:54,391 --> 02:45:55,425 BIOLOGY. 3855 02:45:55,425 --> 02:45:57,994 WHAT INTEREST THE TECHNOLOGICAL 3856 02:45:57,994 --> 02:45:59,129 FACTORS AN WHAT HAPPENS AFTER 3857 02:45:59,129 --> 02:46:04,768 THE SUPPLEMENT ISS INGESTED GOIG 3858 02:46:04,768 --> 02:46:09,539 FROM A FOOD MATRIX TO METABOLIC 3859 02:46:09,539 --> 02:46:10,874 MATRIX AND HOW IT'S AFFECTING 3860 02:46:10,874 --> 02:46:11,541 CELLULAR FUNCTION AND IMPACTING 3861 02:46:11,541 --> 02:46:15,779 HEALTH. 3862 02:46:15,779 --> 02:46:17,581 THE DIETARY SUPPLEMENT ASPECT IS 3863 02:46:17,581 --> 02:46:21,885 A PART OF THAT CONTINUUM AND 3864 02:46:21,885 --> 02:46:24,821 IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND WHAT ARE 3865 02:46:24,821 --> 02:46:25,922 THE CONSTITUENTS AND INGREDIENTS 3866 02:46:25,922 --> 02:46:28,258 AND ABOUT WHAT IS THE FUNCTION 3867 02:46:28,258 --> 02:46:30,327 OF WHAT'S GOING IN THE MOUTH AND 3868 02:46:30,327 --> 02:46:31,628 HOW DOES THAT TRANSLATE. 3869 02:46:31,628 --> 02:46:37,234 HOW DO YOU GO FROM FOOD TO 3870 02:46:37,234 --> 02:46:39,669 HEALTH THAT'S THE LINK BETWEEN 3871 02:46:39,669 --> 02:46:40,704 WHAT GOES INTO OUR MOUTH AND 3872 02:46:40,704 --> 02:46:46,643 WHAT THE HEALTH OUTCOMES ARE TO 3873 02:46:46,643 --> 02:46:47,511 DIFFERENTIATE. 3874 02:46:47,511 --> 02:46:58,054 IT'S A CONTINUUM BUT A PACKAGE. 3875 02:47:00,423 --> 02:47:00,690 >> THANK YOU. 3876 02:47:00,690 --> 02:47:05,962 DO ANY OTHER COUNCIL MEMBERS 3877 02:47:05,962 --> 02:47:10,400 HAVE QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS 3878 02:47:10,400 --> 02:47:13,203 BEFORE WE MOVE TO ANOTHER 3879 02:47:13,203 --> 02:47:15,071 DISCUSSION SESSION FOR OUR LAST 3880 02:47:15,071 --> 02:47:17,274 15 MINUTES? 3881 02:47:17,274 --> 02:47:17,774 OKAY. 3882 02:47:17,774 --> 02:47:21,178 SO MOVING BACK TO SOME 3883 02:47:21,178 --> 02:47:25,215 ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS THAT WERE 3884 02:47:25,215 --> 02:47:28,718 RAISED FOLLOWING THE NIH AND 3885 02:47:28,718 --> 02:47:32,088 DPCPSI UPDATES, COUNCIL MEMBERS 3886 02:47:32,088 --> 02:47:33,857 HAVE ASKED FOR ADDITIONAL TIME 3887 02:47:33,857 --> 02:47:35,559 TO BRING UP OTHER CONCERNS AND 3888 02:47:35,559 --> 02:47:37,127 QUESTIONS AND SO WE WILL TAKE 3889 02:47:37,127 --> 02:47:43,500 THE NEXT 15 MINUTES TO DO THAT 3890 02:47:43,500 --> 02:47:44,534 RECOGNIZING WE'LL LIKELY NOT BE 3891 02:47:44,534 --> 02:47:46,369 ABLE TO ADDRESS ALL THE 3892 02:47:46,369 --> 02:47:48,872 QUESTIONS COUNCIL MEMBERS HAVE 3893 02:47:48,872 --> 02:47:51,741 AND HAVE ASKED THEM TO SUBMIT 3894 02:47:51,741 --> 02:47:54,411 THEM IN WRITING THROUGH THE CHAT 3895 02:47:54,411 --> 02:47:58,381 FUNCTION AND TO ENSURE THAT WE 3896 02:47:58,381 --> 02:48:00,450 PROVIDE THOUGHTFUL AND DETAILED 3897 02:48:00,450 --> 02:48:02,919 RESPONSE TO YOUR QUESTIONS. 3898 02:48:02,919 --> 02:48:06,323 WE WILL CONSULT WITH THE VARIOUS 3899 02:48:06,323 --> 02:48:09,759 OFFICES WITHIN DPCPSI AND OFFICE 3900 02:48:09,759 --> 02:48:11,795 OF THE DIRECTOR TO PROVIDE THAT 3901 02:48:11,795 --> 02:48:13,196 FEEDBACK AND TO ENSURE IT'S 3902 02:48:13,196 --> 02:48:15,465 TRANSPARENT AND PUBLICALLY 3903 02:48:15,465 --> 02:48:18,368 ACCESSIBLE WE WILL PROVIDE THE 3904 02:48:18,368 --> 02:48:19,669 QUESTIONS AND WRITTEN RESPONSES 3905 02:48:19,669 --> 02:48:21,438 AS AN ADDENDUM TO THE MEETING 3906 02:48:21,438 --> 02:48:22,472 MINUTES AND THOSE WILL BE POSTED 3907 02:48:22,472 --> 02:48:23,039 ONCE THEY'RE REVIEWED AND 3908 02:48:23,039 --> 02:48:28,612 APPROVED. 3909 02:48:28,612 --> 02:48:30,413 DOES THAT SOUND LIKE AN 3910 02:48:30,413 --> 02:48:35,285 ACCEPTABLE WAY FORWARD FOR 3911 02:48:35,285 --> 02:48:35,919 COUNCIL MEMBERS. 3912 02:48:35,919 --> 02:48:37,187 I SEE NODDING HEADS. 3913 02:48:37,187 --> 02:48:37,921 THANK YOU. 3914 02:48:37,921 --> 02:48:41,625 SO FIRST, TO START OFF THERE WAS 3915 02:48:41,625 --> 02:48:46,396 A QUESTION FROM EARLIER ABOUT 3916 02:48:46,396 --> 02:48:51,668 COUNCIL MEMBERSHIP. 3917 02:48:51,668 --> 02:48:54,371 TO FOLLOW-UP ON THE MEMBERSHIP 3918 02:48:54,371 --> 02:48:56,940 REDUCTIONS IN STAFF MADE IT 3919 02:48:56,940 --> 02:48:59,042 DIFFICULT AND OUR CHARTER SHOWS 3920 02:48:59,042 --> 02:49:00,677 IT MAY SERVE AFTER THE 3921 02:49:00,677 --> 02:49:04,914 EXPIRATION OF THE MEMBER'S TERM 3922 02:49:04,914 --> 02:49:12,422 UNTIL A SUCCESSOR HAS LEFT 3923 02:49:12,422 --> 02:49:12,656 OFFICE. 3924 02:49:12,656 --> 02:49:15,225 GIVEN THE DELAYS IN APPOINTING 3925 02:49:15,225 --> 02:49:15,825 REPLACEMENT MEMBERS TO THE 3926 02:49:15,825 --> 02:49:19,929 COUNCIL OF COUNCILS WE ASKED 3927 02:49:19,929 --> 02:49:20,997 COUNCIL MEMBERS TO EXTEND THEIR 3928 02:49:20,997 --> 02:49:24,701 TERMS BY SIX MONTHS. 3929 02:49:24,701 --> 02:49:27,937 THESE ADMINISTRATE IIVE PLACEME 3930 02:49:27,937 --> 02:49:29,706 HAVE BEEN PROCESSED. 3931 02:49:29,706 --> 02:49:34,377 WE'VE NOT HAD AN OPTION TO 3932 02:49:34,377 --> 02:49:38,081 EXTEND A MEMBER UNTIL THEY HAVE 3933 02:49:38,081 --> 02:49:40,050 A REPLACEMENT AND WE'LL ASK FOR 3934 02:49:40,050 --> 02:49:41,117 CLARIFICATION TO DETERMINE WHY 3935 02:49:41,117 --> 02:49:42,385 THAT'S NOT BEEN AN OPTION IN THE 3936 02:49:42,385 --> 02:49:43,019 PAST. 3937 02:49:43,019 --> 02:49:44,454 WE'LL REPORT BACK AT THE NEXT 3938 02:49:44,454 --> 02:49:46,389 MEETING THE OUTCOME OF OUR 3939 02:49:46,389 --> 02:49:54,931 REQUEST. 3940 02:49:54,931 --> 02:49:55,965 IS THERE A FOLLOW-UP QUESTION TO 3941 02:49:55,965 --> 02:49:59,135 THAT OR CAN WE MOVE TO THE NEXT 3942 02:49:59,135 --> 02:49:59,402 QUESTION? 3943 02:49:59,402 --> 02:49:59,769 >> WE CAN MOVE. 3944 02:49:59,769 --> 02:50:09,946 >> GREAT. 3945 02:50:13,616 --> 02:50:16,820 >> ANY QUESTION IS HAVING JUST 3946 02:50:16,820 --> 02:50:19,122 HEARD PEOPLE WERE ASKED THERE 3947 02:50:19,122 --> 02:50:20,957 ARE TWO OF US WHOSE TERMS EXPIRE 3948 02:50:20,957 --> 02:50:21,825 THIS YEAR AND I DON'T REMEMBER 3949 02:50:21,825 --> 02:50:28,932 BEING ASKED. 3950 02:50:28,932 --> 02:50:31,067 WE CAN DO IT LATER IF YOU WANT 3951 02:50:31,067 --> 02:50:33,103 OR YOU CAN DECIDE NOT TO ASK ME 3952 02:50:33,103 --> 02:50:34,604 BUT EITHER ARE FINE. 3953 02:50:34,604 --> 02:50:37,474 >> TYPICALLY WE MAKE THOSE 3954 02:50:37,474 --> 02:50:39,242 CLOSER TO THE EXPIRATION OF THE 3955 02:50:39,242 --> 02:50:39,743 TERM DATE. 3956 02:50:39,743 --> 02:50:42,379 >> ALL RIGHT. 3957 02:50:42,379 --> 02:50:45,715 I'LL BE PATIENT. 3958 02:50:45,715 --> 02:50:47,417 >> THANK YOU. 3959 02:50:47,417 --> 02:50:48,585 >> QUESTION NUMBER ONE, IS THAT 3960 02:50:48,585 --> 02:50:48,785 OKAY? 3961 02:50:48,785 --> 02:50:53,556 >> PLEASE GO AHEAD. 3962 02:50:53,556 --> 02:50:56,059 >> SO EARLIER WE ASKED ABOUT 3963 02:50:56,059 --> 02:50:58,228 CANCELED GRANTS IN HOPE TO 3964 02:50:58,228 --> 02:51:00,196 CLARIFY OUR ROLE IN SECOND LEVEL 3965 02:51:00,196 --> 02:51:02,298 REVIEW FOR THE COMMON FUND 3966 02:51:02,298 --> 02:51:05,268 PROGRAMS AND YOU IMPLIED PROGRAM 3967 02:51:05,268 --> 02:51:07,237 STAFF ARE CONSULTING WITH 3968 02:51:07,237 --> 02:51:08,872 ADMINISTERING I.C.s AND 3969 02:51:08,872 --> 02:51:12,409 CATEGORIZING AWARDS FOR FUNDING 3970 02:51:12,409 --> 02:51:13,643 DECISIONS AND WE'D LIKE SOME 3971 02:51:13,643 --> 02:51:15,111 ADDITIONAL CLARIFICATION ABOUT 3972 02:51:15,111 --> 02:51:18,381 HOW THESE AWARDS ARE BEING 3973 02:51:18,381 --> 02:51:21,584 CATEGORIZED FOR CANCELLATION OR 3974 02:51:21,584 --> 02:51:24,354 RECEIPT OF STOP WORK ORDERS. 3975 02:51:24,354 --> 02:51:27,891 IN WHAT BASIS ARE THEY BEING 3976 02:51:27,891 --> 02:51:30,326 CATEGORIZED AND WHAT ENTITY 3977 02:51:30,326 --> 02:51:32,262 DOING THE CATEGORIZATION. 3978 02:51:32,262 --> 02:51:36,032 IS THE I.C.s IN COLLABORATION 3979 02:51:36,032 --> 02:51:46,276 WITH DOGE AND THERE'S AUTOMATED 3980 02:51:46,276 --> 02:51:46,509 PROCESS. 3981 02:51:46,509 --> 02:51:49,279 WHAT ASPECTS OF THE GRANT 3982 02:51:49,279 --> 02:51:52,582 APPLICATION ARE BEING REVIEWED? 3983 02:51:52,582 --> 02:51:54,951 IS IT THE BUDGET, AND HOW ARE 3984 02:51:54,951 --> 02:51:56,419 THE I.C. PROGRAM STAFF INVOLVED 3985 02:51:56,419 --> 02:52:00,690 IN THE FINAL DECISION MAKING OF 3986 02:52:00,690 --> 02:52:02,992 THE STOP WORK ORDERS. 3987 02:52:02,992 --> 02:52:05,361 >> THANK YOU FOR THE QUESTIONS. 3988 02:52:05,361 --> 02:52:06,129 I'LL PROVIDE A PRELIMINARY 3989 02:52:06,129 --> 02:52:07,697 RESPONSE AND THEN WE'LL 3990 02:52:07,697 --> 02:52:09,499 FOLLOW-UP IN WRITING WITH 3991 02:52:09,499 --> 02:52:13,803 ADDITIONAL FEEDBACK FROM OUR OER 3992 02:52:13,803 --> 02:52:14,437 OFFICE OF EXTRAMURAL RESEARCH 3993 02:52:14,437 --> 02:52:15,905 COLLEAGUES AS FAR AS THE FORMAL 3994 02:52:15,905 --> 02:52:17,574 PROCESS FOR REVIEW AND ALL THE 3995 02:52:17,574 --> 02:52:25,181 OTHER DETAILS BEING ASKED HERE. 3996 02:52:25,181 --> 02:52:26,883 FROM A HIGHER LEVEL THE GRANTS 3997 02:52:26,883 --> 02:52:31,654 ARE BEING REVIEWED BY DOGE. 3998 02:52:31,654 --> 02:52:34,190 THEY'VE GONE THROUGH THE BACKLOG 3999 02:52:34,190 --> 02:52:37,927 OF GRANTS CATEGORIZED THAT WERE 4000 02:52:37,927 --> 02:52:41,931 PAUSED OR FROZEN OR POTENTIALLY 4001 02:52:41,931 --> 02:52:42,866 CATEGORIZED FOR TERMINATION. 4002 02:52:42,866 --> 02:52:43,967 THEY'RE REVIEWING THEM FOR 4003 02:52:43,967 --> 02:52:47,570 COMPLIANCE WITH THE PRESIDENT'S 4004 02:52:47,570 --> 02:52:52,542 EXECUTIVE ORDERS. 4005 02:52:52,542 --> 02:52:53,610 THOSE GRANTS FLAGGED ARE SENT 4006 02:52:53,610 --> 02:52:56,045 BACK TO NIH AND SENT TO THE 4007 02:52:56,045 --> 02:52:59,983 PROGRAM STAFF AT THE 4008 02:52:59,983 --> 02:53:03,786 ADMINISTERING I.C.s TO REVIEW 4009 02:53:03,786 --> 02:53:06,222 THEM AND WORK WITH SUBMITTERS TO 4010 02:53:06,222 --> 02:53:09,526 REVISE THE LANGUAGE AS NEEDED 4011 02:53:09,526 --> 02:53:15,365 AND THEN THOSE GO BACK TO NIH 4012 02:53:15,365 --> 02:53:17,400 SENIOR LEADERSHIP TO MAKE THE 4013 02:53:17,400 --> 02:53:18,368 FINAL DECISION ON WHETHER TO 4014 02:53:18,368 --> 02:53:25,875 ISSUE STOP WORK ORDERS OR NOT. 4015 02:53:25,875 --> 02:53:28,845 >> HOW ARE THE GRANTS FLAGGED? 4016 02:53:28,845 --> 02:53:33,283 >> BY DOGE OF THE CONTENT WITHIN 4017 02:53:33,283 --> 02:53:39,522 TITLE, ABSTRACT SPECIFIC AIMS. 4018 02:53:39,522 --> 02:53:41,090 I'LL DOUBLE CHECK AND FOLLOW-UP 4019 02:53:41,090 --> 02:53:43,092 WITH OUR OER COLLEAGUES, 4020 02:53:43,092 --> 02:53:45,261 FEEDBACK FROM OUR OER 4021 02:53:45,261 --> 02:53:45,562 COLLEAGUES. 4022 02:53:45,562 --> 02:53:51,601 >> IS A LIST OF THE FLAG IGING 4023 02:53:51,601 --> 02:53:52,769 TERMS THAT CREATE THE FLAG 4024 02:53:52,769 --> 02:53:53,036 AVAILABLE? 4025 02:53:53,036 --> 02:53:57,073 >> I DO NOT BELIEVE SO BUT WE 4026 02:53:57,073 --> 02:53:59,008 WILL ASK THE QUESTION FROM OUR 4027 02:53:59,008 --> 02:54:01,311 EXTRAMURAL COLLEAGUES AND GET 4028 02:54:01,311 --> 02:54:04,581 THEIR FEEDBACK. 4029 02:54:04,581 --> 02:54:04,814 >> OKAY. 4030 02:54:04,814 --> 02:54:07,016 THANK YOU. 4031 02:54:07,016 --> 02:54:10,486 >> I THINK I HAVE THE SECOND 4032 02:54:10,486 --> 02:54:16,559 QUESTION I PUT IN THE CHAT TH TS 4033 02:54:16,559 --> 02:54:19,329 IS RELATED TO DR. MANLY'S 4034 02:54:19,329 --> 02:54:22,732 QUESTION BECAUSE THE NGA OR NEW 4035 02:54:22,732 --> 02:54:25,301 AWARDS AREN'T GOING OUT BECAUSE 4036 02:54:25,301 --> 02:54:29,806 OF THE PROCESS AND WHAT IS THE 4037 02:54:29,806 --> 02:54:31,407 IMPACT OF THESE FUNDING NOT 4038 02:54:31,407 --> 02:54:34,877 GOING OUT FROM THE NIH? 4039 02:54:34,877 --> 02:54:37,180 AND THREE CONCERNS AND WANTED TO 4040 02:54:37,180 --> 02:54:39,882 SEE HOW WE COULD HELP. 4041 02:54:39,882 --> 02:54:42,085 ONE WAS THE IMPACT ON CLINICAL 4042 02:54:42,085 --> 02:54:45,221 TRIAL PARTICIPANTS IF THERE'S A 4043 02:54:45,221 --> 02:54:47,690 CLINICAL TRIAL CLOSED BECAUSE 4044 02:54:47,690 --> 02:54:48,524 USUALLY CLINICAL TRIAL CLOSED 4045 02:54:48,524 --> 02:54:51,794 FOR DSMB REVIEW LOOKING AT THE 4046 02:54:51,794 --> 02:54:52,795 OUTCOME SAYING IT'S USEFUL OR 4047 02:54:52,795 --> 02:54:53,930 DANGEROUS AND WE NEED TO 4048 02:54:53,930 --> 02:54:56,966 TERMINATE THE TRIAL SO THIS IS 4049 02:54:56,966 --> 02:54:59,669 HIGHLY UNUSUAL IN TERMS OF OUR 4050 02:54:59,669 --> 02:55:02,372 ETHICAL OBLIGATIONS TO PATIENTS. 4051 02:55:02,372 --> 02:55:06,376 SECOND IS THE IMPACT ON TRIALS 4052 02:55:06,376 --> 02:55:10,613 BEING STOPPED AND INVESTIGATORS 4053 02:55:10,613 --> 02:55:12,882 IT'S IMPACT ON ACADEMIC 4054 02:55:12,882 --> 02:55:16,552 UNIVERSITIES AND WE HAVE A GREAT 4055 02:55:16,552 --> 02:55:17,920 CONCERN ABOUT THE BUDGETS 4056 02:55:17,920 --> 02:55:19,122 APPROPRIATION COMMITTEE WITH A 4057 02:55:19,122 --> 02:55:20,723 LARGE SURPLUS AT THE NIH BECAUSE 4058 02:55:20,723 --> 02:55:23,726 WE KNOW THE MAJORITY OF THE 4059 02:55:23,726 --> 02:55:25,161 AMERICAN PEOPLE AS WELL AS 4060 02:55:25,161 --> 02:55:26,129 INTRAMURAL AND EXTRAMURAL 4061 02:55:26,129 --> 02:55:28,564 INVESTIGATORS AND THE DIRECTOR 4062 02:55:28,564 --> 02:55:30,066 HAVE STATED WE WANT TO PRESERVE 4063 02:55:30,066 --> 02:55:33,202 THE NIH BUDGET IF WE CAN. 4064 02:55:33,202 --> 02:55:35,805 THE REAL MAIN QUESTION IS 4065 02:55:35,805 --> 02:55:37,106 BECAUSE IT SEEMS STRATEGIC THAT 4066 02:55:37,106 --> 02:55:41,110 TO DO WITH SCIENCE AND WHAT'S 4067 02:55:41,110 --> 02:55:43,713 FUNDED, IF THERE'S ANYTHING WE 4068 02:55:43,713 --> 02:55:45,148 CAN DO TO HELP OR UNDERSTANDING 4069 02:55:45,148 --> 02:55:47,383 WHY THE MONEY ISN'T GOING OUT, 4070 02:55:47,383 --> 02:55:51,688 IS IT ALL RELATED TO WHAT 4071 02:55:51,688 --> 02:56:02,198 DR. MANLY ASKED WAS THERE A 4072 02:56:03,099 --> 02:56:09,872 BOTTLENECK FOR APPROVED AWARDS. 4073 02:56:09,872 --> 02:56:14,377 >> WE ARE AWARE OF THE DELAYS IN 4074 02:56:14,377 --> 02:56:17,680 DISBURSEMENT OF FUNDS AND WE'RE 4075 02:56:17,680 --> 02:56:18,581 WORKING TO ADDRESS THESE DELAYS 4076 02:56:18,581 --> 02:56:20,516 AND MY UNDERSTANDING IS THERE'S 4077 02:56:20,516 --> 02:56:21,451 BEEN QUITE A BIT OF PROGRESS 4078 02:56:21,451 --> 02:56:23,453 MADE IN JUST THE LAST WEEK OR 4079 02:56:23,453 --> 02:56:27,757 TWO ON GETTING SOME OF THESE 4080 02:56:27,757 --> 02:56:29,325 GRANTS REISSUED AND GETTING SOME 4081 02:56:29,325 --> 02:56:31,661 PAUSES LIFTED AND GETTING FUNDS 4082 02:56:31,661 --> 02:56:33,996 OUT THE DOOR. 4083 02:56:33,996 --> 02:56:44,540 SO ONE THING I'LL NOTE ALL NOTE 4084 02:56:45,875 --> 02:56:47,410 CLINICAL TRIALS THAT MAY BE 4085 02:56:47,410 --> 02:56:50,947 AFFECTED BY THE STOP WORK ORDERS 4086 02:56:50,947 --> 02:56:52,482 OR AWARDS WE'RE PROVIDING FUNDS 4087 02:56:52,482 --> 02:56:55,485 AND ADEQUATE TIME LINES FOR SAFE 4088 02:56:55,485 --> 02:56:57,019 AND ORDERLY SHUT DOWNS ON THE 4089 02:56:57,019 --> 02:57:00,223 ORDER OF UP TO SIX MONTHS TO 4090 02:57:00,223 --> 02:57:01,324 MAINTAIN PARTICIPANT SAFETY AND 4091 02:57:01,324 --> 02:57:03,726 PRIVACY AND MAINTAIN ANIMAL 4092 02:57:03,726 --> 02:57:06,195 WELFARE WHERE IT'S APPLICABLE. 4093 02:57:06,195 --> 02:57:16,439 >> THANK YOU. 4094 02:57:21,277 --> 02:57:23,880 >> WITH REGARD TO THE NEW POLICY 4095 02:57:23,880 --> 02:57:24,614 WITH CONSIDERATION AND 4096 02:57:24,614 --> 02:57:25,882 SUBMISSION WITH FOREIGN 4097 02:57:25,882 --> 02:57:28,651 APPLICATIONS CAN YOU EXPLAIN THE 4098 02:57:28,651 --> 02:57:29,919 EXTENT TO WHICH OUR COUNCIL OR 4099 02:57:29,919 --> 02:57:34,056 PERHAPS EVEN BY EXTENSION OTHER 4100 02:57:34,056 --> 02:57:34,724 I.C. COUNCILS PART OF THE SECOND 4101 02:57:34,724 --> 02:57:39,162 LEVEL REVIEW PROCESS. 4102 02:57:39,162 --> 02:57:43,432 AND HOW THE FINDINGS OF THE 4103 02:57:43,432 --> 02:57:45,968 REVIEWS WILL BE TAKEN INTO 4104 02:57:45,968 --> 02:57:47,537 ACCOUNT FOR HIGHER LEVEL AWARDS 4105 02:57:47,537 --> 02:57:50,773 IT GOES TO THE DOGE ISSUE. 4106 02:57:50,773 --> 02:57:52,842 BECAUSE THE CONCERN BY THOSE WHO 4107 02:57:52,842 --> 02:57:54,343 HAVE SPOKEN TO ME AND ELSEWHERE 4108 02:57:54,343 --> 02:57:57,180 IS THE DUE PROCESS IS INTENDED 4109 02:57:57,180 --> 02:58:00,349 TO ELIMINATE MOST IF NOT ALL 4110 02:58:00,349 --> 02:58:02,552 FOREIGN AWARDS, WHICH IF THAT'S 4111 02:58:02,552 --> 02:58:04,787 THE CASE, IT WILL HAVE 4112 02:58:04,787 --> 02:58:07,023 DELETERIOUS IMPACT ON HUMAN 4113 02:58:07,023 --> 02:58:09,091 HEALTH RESEARCH AND CONTRIBUTE 4114 02:58:09,091 --> 02:58:10,993 TO WASTEFUL SPENDING ON PROJECTS 4115 02:58:10,993 --> 02:58:13,296 HALFWAY THERE AND THEN DROPPED 4116 02:58:13,296 --> 02:58:15,731 AND THAT MAKES PROCESSES MORE 4117 02:58:15,731 --> 02:58:17,967 INEFFICIENT AND I KNOW WE'RE ALL 4118 02:58:17,967 --> 02:58:20,603 WORKING TOWARDS GREATER 4119 02:58:20,603 --> 02:58:21,470 EFFICIENCY. 4120 02:58:21,470 --> 02:58:25,441 >> THANK YOU. 4121 02:58:25,441 --> 02:58:27,443 UNDERSTOOD AND APPRECIATE YOUR 4122 02:58:27,443 --> 02:58:27,777 COMMENTS. 4123 02:58:27,777 --> 02:58:31,447 NIH DOES REMAIN COMMITTED TO 4124 02:58:31,447 --> 02:58:31,981 SUPPORTING INTERNATIONAL 4125 02:58:31,981 --> 02:58:33,616 SCIENTIFIC COLLABORATION WITH 4126 02:58:33,616 --> 02:58:34,250 FOREIGN SCIENTISTS AS WELL AS 4127 02:58:34,250 --> 02:58:36,652 IT'S CONDUCTED IN A SECURE AND 4128 02:58:36,652 --> 02:58:39,789 JUSTIFIABLE AND RESPONSIBLE WAY. 4129 02:58:39,789 --> 02:58:42,391 THERE'S NO INTENTION TO IN ANY 4130 02:58:42,391 --> 02:58:49,465 WAY CEASE FUNDING OF FOREIGN 4131 02:58:49,465 --> 02:58:52,735 COMPONENTS THEY'RE STRUCTURED OF 4132 02:58:52,735 --> 02:58:53,669 INDEPENDENT SUB PROJECTS RATHER 4133 02:58:53,669 --> 02:58:54,804 THAN SUB AWARDS. 4134 02:58:54,804 --> 02:58:56,239 THAT'S THE GOAL OF ESTABLISHING 4135 02:58:56,239 --> 02:59:00,409 THIS NEW AWARD STRUCTURE BY THE 4136 02:59:00,409 --> 02:59:05,882 END OF SEPTEMBER SO THAT WE CAN 4137 02:59:05,882 --> 02:59:10,353 TRACK EACH OF THE PROJECT'S 4138 02:59:10,353 --> 02:59:14,290 FUNDS INDIVIDUALLY. 4139 02:59:14,290 --> 02:59:17,026 I THINK THAT'S EVERYTHING I CAN 4140 02:59:17,026 --> 02:59:18,461 SAY ABOUT THAT. 4141 02:59:18,461 --> 02:59:19,929 >> ONE LAST COMMENT KIND OF 4142 02:59:19,929 --> 02:59:21,030 QUESTION. 4143 02:59:21,030 --> 02:59:25,134 WE RECOGNIZE WE HAVE A HARD STOP 4144 02:59:25,134 --> 02:59:28,271 TODAY AND WONDERED IF FOR THE 4145 02:59:28,271 --> 02:59:30,139 COUNCIL AGENDA IN SEPTEMBER IF 4146 02:59:30,139 --> 02:59:31,841 WE CAN ADD SOME TIME MAYBE AT 4147 02:59:31,841 --> 02:59:35,544 LEAST 30 MINUTES JUST TO DISCUSS 4148 02:59:35,544 --> 02:59:40,616 THINGS THERE'S SO MANY NEW 4149 02:59:40,616 --> 02:59:41,984 PROCESSES AND PROCEDURES THAT 4150 02:59:41,984 --> 02:59:43,819 WOULD BE HELPFUL TO THE COUNCIL. 4151 02:59:43,819 --> 02:59:52,161 >> FULLY AGREE AND WE WILL ADAM 4152 02:59:52,161 --> 02:59:57,900 ADD AMPLE TIME IN SEPTEMBER TO 4153 02:59:57,900 --> 03:00:02,371 HAVE ROBUST DISCUSSION ON ALL 4154 03:00:02,371 --> 03:00:04,040 THESE ISSUES AND QUESTIONS. 4155 03:00:04,040 --> 03:00:06,242 THE LAST SET OF QUESTIONS I SEE 4156 03:00:06,242 --> 03:00:12,381 ON HERE IS FROM RAFA WHO I 4157 03:00:12,381 --> 03:00:13,983 BELIEVE HAD TO JUMP OFF AT 2:00 4158 03:00:13,983 --> 03:00:15,451 P.M. AND IT'S ABOUT LOOKING 4159 03:00:15,451 --> 03:00:16,919 AHEAD AND PLANNING AND 4160 03:00:16,919 --> 03:00:19,689 UNDERSTANDING HOW THE EVOLVING 4161 03:00:19,689 --> 03:00:22,358 FUNDING LANDSCAPE MAY AFFECT THE 4162 03:00:22,358 --> 03:00:24,627 RESEARCH COMMUNITY AS A WHOLE 4163 03:00:24,627 --> 03:00:27,363 AND CLARITY ON RESEARCH 4164 03:00:27,363 --> 03:00:27,997 PRIORITIES, WHICH SCIENTIFIC 4165 03:00:27,997 --> 03:00:30,132 AREAS THAT RECEIVED FUNDING IN 4166 03:00:30,132 --> 03:00:34,737 THE PAST ARE LIKELY TO BECOME 4167 03:00:34,737 --> 03:00:36,005 INGELABLE FOR SUPPORT AND WHICH 4168 03:00:36,005 --> 03:00:39,342 INSTITUTES AND CENTERS CAN 4169 03:00:39,342 --> 03:00:41,177 ANTICIPATE FUNDING RANGES OVER 4170 03:00:41,177 --> 03:00:42,345 THE COMING YEARS. 4171 03:00:42,345 --> 03:00:46,382 SO WHAT I WOULD SAY ABOUT THESE 4172 03:00:46,382 --> 03:00:48,884 IS FIRST TO ADDRESS THE CLARITY 4173 03:00:48,884 --> 03:00:50,987 ON RESEARCH PRIORITIES I REFER 4174 03:00:50,987 --> 03:00:56,525 YOU TO DR. BHATTACHARYA WHERE HE 4175 03:00:56,525 --> 03:00:58,361 OUTLINED WHAT HIS PRIORITIES ARE 4176 03:00:58,361 --> 03:01:01,197 AND REFER YOU TO THE RECENT MAHA 4177 03:01:01,197 --> 03:01:04,266 COMMISSION REPORT RELEASED I 4178 03:01:04,266 --> 03:01:06,969 THINK LAST NURSE OR THE THURSDAY 4179 03:01:06,969 --> 03:01:07,203 BEFORE. 4180 03:01:07,203 --> 03:01:09,472 TIME FLIES WHEN YOUR HAVING FUN 4181 03:01:09,472 --> 03:01:12,775 ADDRESSING THE CHILDHOOD CHRONIC 4182 03:01:12,775 --> 03:01:14,844 DISEASE CRISIS AND MANY OF THE 4183 03:01:14,844 --> 03:01:15,578 PRIORITIES AND SUBJECT AREAS 4184 03:01:15,578 --> 03:01:19,582 THAT WERE HIGHLIGHTED IN THAT 4185 03:01:19,582 --> 03:01:29,725 REPORT. 4186 03:01:30,259 --> 03:01:33,029 I WOULD DIRECT YOU TO THE 4187 03:01:33,029 --> 03:01:34,997 STANDARD SCIENCE AND THOSE ARE 4188 03:01:34,997 --> 03:01:37,533 AREAS THAT ARE PRIORITIES TO ARE 4189 03:01:37,533 --> 03:01:38,501 THE ADMINISTRATION AND HHS AND 4190 03:01:38,501 --> 03:01:44,807 NIH LEADERSHIP. 4191 03:01:44,807 --> 03:01:46,509 IN TERMS OF GUIDANCE THE NIH 4192 03:01:46,509 --> 03:01:47,877 POLICIES AROUND FUNDING ARE 4193 03:01:47,877 --> 03:01:49,645 CLEARLY AB ARTIC HATED IN ALL 4194 03:01:49,645 --> 03:01:51,080 THE NOTICE OF FUNDING 4195 03:01:51,080 --> 03:01:51,680 OPPORTUNITIES AND RESEARCH 4196 03:01:51,680 --> 03:01:53,015 OPPORTUNITY ANNOUNCEMENTS. 4197 03:01:53,015 --> 03:01:58,654 SO I WOULD DIRECT YOU TO THOSE 4198 03:01:58,654 --> 03:02:01,457 IN TERMS OF INSTITUTIONAL 4199 03:02:01,457 --> 03:02:02,258 GUIDANCE. 4200 03:02:02,258 --> 03:02:03,059 OUTCOME LEVELS IS DEPENDENT ON 4201 03:02:03,059 --> 03:02:05,428 THE BUDGET. 4202 03:02:05,428 --> 03:02:07,363 THE AMOUNT THE NIH WILL CONTINUE 4203 03:02:07,363 --> 03:02:11,300 TO BE THE PREMIER FUNDER OF 4204 03:02:11,300 --> 03:02:13,436 BIOMEDICAL RESEARCH IN THE 4205 03:02:13,436 --> 03:02:14,370 WORLD. 4206 03:02:14,370 --> 03:02:16,105 THE PRESIDENT HAS CLEARLY STATED 4207 03:02:16,105 --> 03:02:17,873 THAT AND THE NIH DIRECTOR AND 4208 03:02:17,873 --> 03:02:19,442 SECRETARY AND THE EXACT LEVEL OF 4209 03:02:19,442 --> 03:02:22,378 FUNDING THAT WILL BE ALLOCATED 4210 03:02:22,378 --> 03:02:22,978 TO SUPPORTING EXTRAMURAL 4211 03:02:22,978 --> 03:02:24,246 RESEARCH WILL BE DEPENDENT ON 4212 03:02:24,246 --> 03:02:27,316 THE NIH'S BUDGET IN THE COMING 4213 03:02:27,316 --> 03:02:28,050 FISCAL YEARS. 4214 03:02:28,050 --> 03:02:30,386 SO WITH THAT, I REALLY THANK YOU 4215 03:02:30,386 --> 03:02:32,488 ALL FOR YOUR THOUGHTFUL INPUT 4216 03:02:32,488 --> 03:02:33,689 AND DISCUSSION. 4217 03:02:33,689 --> 03:02:35,224 I PERSONALLY AM VERY MUCH 4218 03:02:35,224 --> 03:02:36,058 LOOKING FORWARD TO GETTING TO 4219 03:02:36,058 --> 03:02:38,627 KNOW ALL OF YOU BETTER AT THE 4220 03:02:38,627 --> 03:02:40,896 NEXT COUNCIL OF COUNCILS MEETING 4221 03:02:40,896 --> 03:02:42,965 IN PERSON IN SEPTEMBER I THINK 4222 03:02:42,965 --> 03:02:43,566 SEPTEMBER 11 AND 12. 4223 03:02:43,566 --> 03:02:45,034 WE LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING YOU IN 4224 03:02:45,034 --> 03:02:49,338 THE FALL AND AS I MENTIONED, WE 4225 03:02:49,338 --> 03:02:51,340 WILL ADDRESS THESE QUESTIONS IN 4226 03:02:51,340 --> 03:02:53,642 WRITING AS AN ADDENDUM TO THE 4227 03:02:53,642 --> 03:02:55,744 MEETING MINUTES AND MAKE SURE 4228 03:02:55,744 --> 03:02:59,615 THAT THAT GETS CIRCULATED AN 4229 03:02:59,615 --> 03:03:00,816 POSTED TO ENSURE FULL 4230 03:03:00,816 --> 03:03:02,318 TRANSPARENCY AND RIGOR IN 4231 03:03:02,318 --> 03:03:04,086 ADDRESSING THE THOUGHTFUL ISSUES 4232 03:03:04,086 --> 03:03:04,820 YOU'VE RAISED TODAY SO THANK YOU 4233 03:03:04,820 --> 03:03:05,888 ALL. 4234 03:03:05,888 --> 03:03:06,355 >> THANK YOU SO MUCH. 4235 03:03:06,355 --> 03:03:16,599 >> THANK YOU.